Latest / Coffee and Crime with Mom / Uncle Bob Kidney | A Cautionary Tale of Trust and Betrayal
Transcript
- CoffeeandCrimewithMom: So conquest New York 1905. There's this old guy, right? Everyone calls him uncle Bob, 81 lives alone in a log cabin. He literally built himself, never married, no kids, barely talks to anyone. But here's the thing. Everybody knows he's sitting on a pile of cash, like buried in jars, stuffed in walls, hidden in the rafters kind of cash. And one night in March, someone decides They waited long enough. They don't break in, he lets them in. And they leave with his mother's iron cash box and an axe they didn't bring with them. Yeah, we're doing this one. Okay, so picture this, Cayuga County, 1905. This is farm country. Everyone knows everyone. Robert Kidney, Uncle Bob, he's been here his whole life. His parents were pioneers. He was born on this land, built his own cabin and never left. And somewhere along the way, probably after losing his savings in a couple bank failures, he just stops trusting banks completely, like entirely, starts hiding his money. Zalle: his whole life. parents were dying of cancer. He was born with a disability. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: everywhere. Neighbors borrow from him. He's basically the town secret bank. Zalle: That's crazy because what it reminds me of is if it's kind of giving ⁓ Mr. Krabs from Spongebob where he puts all his money in his mattress and how like hides everything So that that's crazy, but everybody knows it so that that kind of I think that in itself that makes it dangerous Everybody knows you're the secret bank CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Yeah. Yeah. you're the secret bank. Yeah, everyone knows it, which is kind of the problem, right? Because when you're 81 and alone and everyone knows you got cash buried in your walls, that's not a great combination. But here's what gets me about this case. It's not just that he was robbed. It's that he opened the door. Zalle: That's what I was thinking when we were reading the original because it has to mean that he knew them, right? Like if you're opening the doors for somebody, you know. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Right, he had to. The boat was on the inside, a heavy boat. He moved it himself. So whoever showed up that night, he wasn't scared of them. Maybe he expected them. Maybe it was someone he lent money to before, someone who'd been in that cabin. Zalle: That's the creepiest part is cause like it wasn't a stranger in the dark. It was someone who called him uncle Bob. And I'm not going to lie. I kind of, have like a love hate relationship with his name, Robert uncle Bob kidney is the kidney throws me off at the end because that's not what I expect the last name to be. I don't know. Like the vibe, it just doesn't fit kidney. Yeah. I don't know. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. It gives me so many emotions. It didn't all go together. Alright. Alright, so what are we drinking? Zalle: Um, well today I have one of your whipped coffees. got me one of your, um, what is it? The, I don't know the whip coffee with the cocoa touch. I don't, I don't know how you called it. The name you gave me. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Okay. Yeah, you got to have the oat milk and that gives it the little cocoa dazzle. Zalle: Yeah, the Coco dazzle. Yeah. ⁓ CoffeeandCrimewithMom: So since I made that for you, that is also what I'm having. It's like my new addiction. I drink this way too much. I probably should drink a lot more water. Zalle: Yeah, Coffee is kind of my water. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Yeah, so this case is buried under layers like this man had hiding spots inside hiding hiding spots, floorboards, wall plaster, barn rafters, buried jars, and the killer tore that place apart, but still left thousands behind. Zalle: So for me, that's kind of the confusing part because it's either like they got what they wanted or they didn't like know the full map. And also I feel like you kind of have to know like what he got going on that he doesn't know anybody. This couldn't be for somebody like an outside job. You had to have known because if it's hidden everywhere in the floorboards, it sounds like it's gonna take a while. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Right. I it just sounds like he, I don't know. Like he just made everything too open for everyone. And that tells me they knew some stuff, but not everything, which narrows the field. You know, it wasn't a random drifter. It was someone who'd been inside that cabin before someone who knew about the cash box, maybe knew about a couple hiding spots, but didn't know the deep cuts. Zalle: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Too trusting. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Okay, let's set the scene properly. Conquest, New York, tiny farm town in Cayuga County. The Kidney family were legit pioneers, like settled this land decades ago pioneers. Robert never married, never had kids. He just worked his land and kept to himself. But like I said, after a couple bank failures wiped out white people out, he went full Hermit miser mode. Stopped trusting anything institutional. became his own bank. Zalle: Where in him becoming like his own bank and like stop trusting the institutionalization of money or whatever, did it go to him lending money to people like now he's the banker? CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Yeah, yeah, I don't know. Local farmers would borrow from him. He was basically operating this underground lender, which means people were in his cabin. They saw things. They probably noticed the iron cash box. Not safe. Maybe caught glimpses of where stuff was hidden. And in a small town where it travels, everyone knew Uncle Bob had money. The question was always where. Zalle: That is not safe, not safe. Everybody should not know this 81 year old man that lives out in this camp and that he built himself has all of this money hidden everywhere Because he lives out in the cabin by himself that he built and he's 81 and he never got married and he never had any kids and he kind of It's giving very hermit very loner life like so, how do you trust all these people to live? CoffeeandCrimewithMom: And you would think he wouldn't be that trusting. Right. And he's 81. Mm-hmm. Like, crowd city, old man. Zalle: than money if this is the life that you're living is very contradictory-ish. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Yeah, let's see what we find out. So who was this guy really? On paper, 81 year old hermit, quiet, harmless, a bit eccentric, but underneath he was actually pretty savvy about his own vulnerability. That was a hard word to say. He knew people knew. That's why he spread his money around so many spots. That's why he bolted his door. He wasn't naive. He was cautious. Zalle: Okay, okay, I can see the caution, but I mean, that only works if you never open the door, not if you're the community bank. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Exactly. And he did for someone on a Friday night in March, which means whatever relationship he had with this person, it overrode his survival instincts, at least for a moment. Zalle: So sad, so sad. So, March 10th, 1905 Friday night, Uncle Bob's alone, doors open, he probably just was existing, whittling, whatever all her enemies do. There was not a CoffeeandCrimewithMom: So March 10th, 1905, Friday night, Uncle Bob's alone, doors bolted. He probably just was existing, reading, whittling, whatever old hermits do. There was a knock at the door. He gets up, moves that heavy bolt, lets them in. Zalle: Okay, and then what? CoffeeandCrimewithMom: and then it's fast and brutal. They hit him with an axe, probably his own or one they grabbed, crushed his skull. He goes down face first, blood everywhere, and then they go to work. Zalle: That is so horrible and so cold, like cold blooded. That's, yes. And then hitting somebody with the axe, unless you just like hit them with the super sharp point. But I mean, even still it's kind of like a hit or miss. Either they're going to die like on impact or there's going to be a horrible way for them to go out. This is just, yeah. And then what they just, ransacking of the place, cold it cold. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: This poor little 81-year-old man. lives. Yeah, it's pretty savage. Yeah, yeah, the place is destroyed. Floorboards ripped up and plaster dug out from between the logs. Chest smashed. The mother's iron box gone. Simply money bags scattered around. But like we said, thousands still hidden, untouched. Zalle: That and that's what I'm saying. That's the crazy part. This had to have taken forever because you dug out behind the logs, you smashed the chest. There was empty money bags scattered all over the place. So you got away with it. It sounds like you got away with quite a bit, but like you didn't know where this everything was like the nitty gritty stuff, like the real money. So were they looking for something in specific in specific or did they just get what they could get? CoffeeandCrimewithMom: That we're pulling this thing apart. Right. ⁓ huh. Zalle: Did they just get what they could get and then did they leave? So that's where I'm like, hmm. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: I don't know, maybe they just didn't have time or they got spooked or this is my theory. They were someone who owed him money. They knew about the active cash box who came to settle the debt by force. And once they had what they needed, they ran. They didn't know about the deeper boards. I'm sorry, the deeper hordes because they weren't that close. Zalle: Okay, that theory makes sense. I like that theory. I don't, mean, not that I like that theory, but like I'm seeing where you're getting. Yeah. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Yeah. It kind of connects. Yeah. So two days later on Sunday, neighbor's kid, 14 years old, looks through the window and sees him. don't know why somebody is looking through windows, but they look through the window and they see him face. Right. They see him face down in blood. Two days did no one had checked on him. No one had noticed in this tight community where everyone supposedly knows everything. Zalle: It's a kid. It's a kid. And that's horrible for the kid. Horrible. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Nobody noticed Uncle Bob was gone for two days. Zalle: That's heartbreaking, but I bet if somebody needed some money, they would have noticed. That is horrible. You only notice him when you need something. And that's so sad because I'm sure what it sounds like was he was like a big staple or like part of the community. So clearly some kind of importance. Yeah. And then for him. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Yeah, it really is. When you need something. Yes. It seems he had a heart. Yeah, even though he didn't trust the banks, he had a heart for his neighbors. Zalle: Yeah, and to be just left dead for two days before some before a little kid finds you ⁓ my heart CoffeeandCrimewithMom: unknown. And he was known by everyone, truly known by no one. And that loneliness is part of what made him such an easy target. Zalle: Yeah, I agree. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Sheriff Walker takes the case. They search everything, question neighbors, follow leads to Rochester, Syracuse, Binghamton, nothing. Syracuse Post Standard runs it front page. Hermit is slain for his gold. Big headline, lots of detail. Next day, no clue of the killer. They post a $250 reward, which I'm sure back then was big money. which was serious money back then and nobody bites. Zalle: Just silence. then to let you know, this, once again, this was during 1905. So all of the stuff that we could find really was just through the Syracuse Post. And I mean, they do have great, they have the actual like headlines and stuff like that. But other than that, it really is not any more information. And it's crazy that for $250, still in this community where everybody's supposed to know everybody and we're all tight-knit and nothing? CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Hmm. complete silence, which tells you something too. Either the killer was that good or the community was that protective or, and this is dark, maybe more people knew than we're saying. Zalle: Okay, so I have like a tingly feeling about about maybe it being like the community being protective is what I'm feeling because maybe it was like a young person who did owe him money in like CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Mm-hmm. Zalle: He was, he just happened to be one of those people. Everybody was like, yeah, we don't normally trust this guy, but the old man took a chance on him and then he did something. But it's like, ⁓ now he's like a young kid in our community and now we have to like guard him. That's the, yeah, maybe that's kind of the vibe. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: It could be, it could be. Or also maybe so many people owed Uncle Bob that it was advantageous that he not be there. I don't know, I was not there. Oh, you like my big words? Thank you. Yeah, the young people. I don't know what you are. Okay, so two years pass. Zalle: advantageous vocabulary yes and that's the young people do CoffeeandCrimewithMom: The case is basically frozen. And then in 1907, this guy, Eugene Curran lives three miles from the cabin, gets thyphoid, ⁓ wait, hold on. Zalle: sure again mom not typhoid CoffeeandCrimewithMom: It's not that for it. Yeah, I'm tired. He gets typhoid fever. It's very bad. He's delirious. And in his fever, he starts confessing tells everyone he killed Uncle Bob gives details sounds credible. Zalle: I mean, you got the details. He's telling everybody he's on his deathbed, which is when people tend to confess. So did they arrest him? I need to know. What? Of course. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: That's when they tend to tell us. No, because when he recovers, he takes it all back. Says it was the fever, a distorted mind, hallucinations, and without a solid confession, they can't hold them. But here's the awful part. His wife hears all this, believes it, the stress, the horror of thinking her husband is a murderer. It breaks her. Her mind gives way. and two weeks later, she's dead. Zalle: That is just horrible. Now I got to die, because you out here confessing, because you got the thyroid fever. You got thyroid fever hallucinating, telling people you were a murderer and shit, and now I'm dead. Just because I love you so much. Two weeks, 14 days later, boom. Now look, there's two people you didn't kill. That's horrible. And we don't know, because I guess he's going to take back that confession too, since he took back the first. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: because you out here telling people that for and fever that's what that for and fever do to you. See you there. Right, right. Well, whether Curran actually did it or not, that confession killed her. And we still don't know if he was guilty or just sick and rambling. The case stays cold either way. Zalle: I mean, unless you're being interrogated by the police or something, how often is it that people really commit to crimes that they didn't do? And that's a real question. I don't know. So maybe if y'all know, write in and let me know. Because I feel like normally when people confess and it's a false confession, it's because they were under some kind of duress or something like that from the police during an interrogation or something, not just out here false confessioning. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Right. confession, we are just full of wrong words tonight. We have all of the wrong words. We need wrong words. Come to coffee and grind your mom. Zalle: Yeah, well that's what I got for you. And we're gonna stick in beside them, okay. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Well, I think that there have been instances of people just coming forward. Like even in the Jambanee Ramsey case, that guy just came forward and said that he had killed her or told somebody, it was something weird. So sometimes it's just something, it has to be a mental issue that they have outside of the being interrogated, the people who just come forward who just get to confess and this stuff. Zalle: outside. But I mean, like the people who actually, like, let's say he really did not do it. You know what I'm saying? Like he didn't do it, but he said he'd do it. How often do people just do that and it's not under some kind of like, like some kind of duress other than like interrogation? Is that a thing that happens? Like people get sick and they do that? CoffeeandCrimewithMom: ⁓ huh. some kind of different other than their agent is that a thing? Yeah, that's what I'm saying. is. There are people come forward and they just start confessing to these crimes and the police have to be trained and have to know how to tell if someone's that that's why you'll hear in certain cases that they keep back this piece of information. So people just start confessing and they don't have that. Then they know that they didn't actually do it because people just want Zalle: have to be trained. Mmm, mm, mm, mm, mm, mm, mm, CoffeeandCrimewithMom: their 15 minutes of fame, you know, as thick as that is, that is something that happens. So let's just run through this real quick. Pre 1905, uncle Bob lives his whole life in that cabin. Bank failures turn him into a hoarder. He lends money to locals. Everyone knows he's loaded. March 10th, 1905, someone he knows knocks. He opens the door and acts to the school. Zalle: Got you, got you, got you. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: and the place is ransacked and the cash box is gone. March 12th, 1905, neighbor's kid finds him. He's been dead for two days. March 13th, 1905, Syracuse Post Standard breaks it wide open. Spring 1905 leads to Rochester, Syracuse, Binghamton, all dead ends. $250 reward is put up and there are no takers. April 28th, 1905, The DA says all evidence is circumstantial and there's no arrest. 1907 Eugene Kern confessed his during typhoid fever and recants after recovery and his wife dies two weeks later from the shock. 1905 to now still unsolved, still one of Cuyuga County's coldest cases. Zalle: Hey, before we move on, I just the part where it says all evidence is circumstantial. Circumstantial evidence is evidence is evidence. I'm sorry. know otherwise they wouldn't have named it. They wouldn't have said evidence after the circumstantial. It's evidence in some circumstantial evidence. Wrong. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: is evidence. It is evidence. If you get enough circumstantial evidence, they wouldn't have put the evidence card in there. That's true. Mm-hmm. ⁓ Zalle: good. I don't know. I don't know. They got to figure out a way to work with the circumstantial evidence better because some of it. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: I think today we deal with it a little bit better. Sometimes, you know, the problem is, right. It wasn't circumstance for in the problem is we're dealing with humans. And so you never quite know. Okay. So let's talk about what this case actually says, because it's not just a robbery. It's about trust and isolation and how vulnerable that combination makes you. Zalle: That's what I'm saying, it's hard, because because, depending on the circumstance, you know. Okay, so let's talk about what this case actually says. and to think that he was isolated by choice, mean, at least mostly. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Right, but isolation doesn't mean invisible. Everyone knew his business. They knew he had money. They knew he was alone. They knew he'd open the door for the right person. And someone used all of that against him. Zalle: And I feel like the killer had to be patient too. Like this was an impulsive, you kind of had to fill it out and like know the layout and his habits and who he would open the door for and who he wouldn't write. And if he was alone, you know, to know that he'd be there by himself that Friday night, this wasn't just a coincidence or a spur of the moment. Yeah, yeah. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. In the right time to go. Mm-hmm. Right, like he took advantage of a moment, right. Exactly. This was planned, maybe not perfectly. They left a lot of money behind, but they knew enough to get inside, literally and figuratively. And that unbolted door is everything. It tells us Uncle Bob had relationships, even if they were thin. Someone was close enough to him to be let in, close enough to kill him. Zalle: Someone was closing up the... and they just go home and live their lives like they didn't just come in and kill this poor 81 year old man. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Yes, and live their life for 120 years now, probably. If they had kids, those kids are gone. If they told anyone that person is gone, the secret died with them, most likely. Zalle: It's so heartbreaking for him and then he was by his own side. I can't even say for like his family that sucks to know that it is like people and situations like that where it is just like, okay, well when I'm gone, that's it for my family and that's it for my story. Like this is just it. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: and he would buy himself a drink. Are they vulnerable? That's it. And that's it for my story. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I keep thinking about that kid, the 14 year old who looked through the window, what he saw, what that did to him. And I think about how Uncle Bob was this fixture, this person who was just always there in the background, part of the landscape until he wasn't. Zalle: I know that's so sad. And why, why would he be at uncle Bob's house? Like why would the 14 year old go to uncle Bob's house if he was only the person that like the banker, it didn't sound like he had like this deep rooted like connection with the community and all these people. So that to me, I find odd. Why was he there? Why was a little boy there? Yeah. So did he go because somebody had mentioned it and you know, kids hear stuff and he peeped. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Great. ⁓ Relationship with these people, and looking through somebody's window. ⁓ Maybe you heard something. Zalle: and he was just going to listen. Maybe the kid knew more than he ever said. He was just scared. What if that was like his people? And he heard him say, yeah, we just went like off Uncle Bob. he thought, Mm hmm. Mm hmm. And he went to go see the dead body and found it. And then nobody checked on Uncle Bob for two days, which is once again, just heartbreaking. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: And then he thought he was gonna see a dead body we've seen all the movies about little boys and dead bodies they want to see Two days in a community where everyone knows everything. That loneliness is the real tragedy here. He built this fortune of hiding spots and bolted doors, but the thing that killed him was the one thing he couldn't fortify. The need to trust someone enough to open the door. Zalle: Do you think we'll ever know? you think they'll be able to like, I don't know, maybe science or AI or something will be able to figure it out? CoffeeandCrimewithMom: I don't like to say that there's no chance on cold cases because crazy stuff happens, but in this one, I don't really think so. The confession was unreliable. The evidence was circumstantial. The witnesses are all dead. The cabin is gone. Whatever money was left has been found or rotted or both. This one stays in the cold case files forever, but the story matters because it shows how isolation even shows an isolation. creates vulnerability and how the people we trust or think we trust can be the most dangerous. Zalle: And that happens way more often than you would think. And then I also wonder, once he did die, once he was murdered, for the people who knew what was up, did they go and ransack his house afterwards? Was it possible that during these two days where supposedly nobody went to go check on Uncle Bob? CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Yeah. I'll see you later. Mm-hmm. Oh, you know they did. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Right. Maybe. Mm-hmm. ⁓ Zalle: Did somebody come and see that somebody had already ransacked the house and he was dead. And then they went through the house and ransacked the house and found more because it sounds like the person had to have been there for a while. And if he was the local bank, then it is possible. And this probably could have happened more than once. Like maybe somebody came in the first day, saw it instead of saying anything, took their chance on trying to find it and something, cause it already looked bad. And then day two, somebody came. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Yeah. And somebody who didn't know about the extra money came and saw that the chest was gone. But hey, I know where this other money is. It would be interesting to know. Yeah. Zalle: right, where it was and was like, ooh, this my opportunity. Yeah. I wonder if that, see, it's too many. Yeah. See, yes. It really would be. It really would be. wish, I don't know what I wish, but I wish we could know. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Yeah, I would love to know. Well, guys, thanks for listening to Coffee and Crime with Mom. Zalle: We appreciate you guys spending your time with us, we really do. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: more than you know. If you like this episode, follow us, leave a review, tell a friend, share us. Zalle: Yes, please. And make sure that you, um, comment on any of our videos. We'll be putting posts out on all of our social medias. We do polls where you can vote for what's going next. Um, Ooh, and mom, next week's episode. This one is a doozy. Okay. Okay. Well, you know, you send me so much stuff frequently because we are both. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Mm-hmm. Yes. Okay. Tell us about it. have plenty to do. ⁓ Zalle: really true crime fanatics. have nothing else to do, but go through true crime. I know I'm always busy. I'd be so stressed. Don't, don't let me play. Yes. But you sent me one and I thought it was kind of interesting. So we're going to do next week is the broomstick killer. He was very interesting in this case or this particular person. feel like it's a lot of like onion too. It is very depthy. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: is the blue tape. He was very interesting. In this case, this particular person, I feel like it's a lot of un-me too. It's very different. OK. OK, I see you with your analogies over there. Very demure, very demure. I'm excited about Zalle: I think it's gonna be a good one. Mm-hmm. I'm excited about that one. So until next time you guys stay caffeinated. Bye. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: And stay safe crime beans, bye bye