Latest / Escape The Clock: How to Become Financially Free and Have the Option Not to Work / The Fiat Trap: Investing in a Distorted Reality with Paul Musson, Author of Capital Offense
Transcript
- 0:19Welcome to Escape the Clock. Today's episode
- 0:21is a little different than our usual format.
- 0:24Normally, we're focusing on specific tactics
- 0:27for escaping the clock. But today, we're taking
- 0:30a look at the operating system itself. Today,
- 0:33I'm joined by Paul Musson, and he wrote a fascinating
- 0:37book called Capital Offense. And look, I've read
- 0:40a lot of books for the podcast at this point,
- 0:42but I have to say, I really learned a lot from
- 0:45the book and from my conversation with Paul.
- 0:48Because of that, it went a bit longer than usual
- 0:51because we had to unpack some of the most fundamental
- 0:53misunderstandings in finance. He is an expert
- 0:57in this, and he really put himself out there
- 1:00to explore a lot of these critical differences
- 1:02like between money and capital and how the central
- 1:05banks work and how we live in a leverage -based
- 1:08system of debt and how it really hurts our ability
- 1:11to save and invest effectively. These are very
- 1:15important things to understand when it comes
- 1:17to achieving financial freedom and how to protect
- 1:20yourself from the massive wealth transfer that's
- 1:23happening right now. It can be a dense conversation,
- 1:26but it challenges a lot of the conventional wisdoms,
- 1:29and I promise you it is worth every minute. So
- 1:32here is my conversation with Paul Musson. Welcome
- 1:35back to Escape the Clock, the show where we highlight
- 1:37strategies and approaches for achieving financial
- 1:38freedom and having the option not to work. I'm
- 1:41your host, Daniel C. Rogers. If you're listening
- 1:43to this podcast, you're likely doing everything
- 1:46right. You're spending less than you earn, you're
- 1:48saving the difference, and you're delaying gratification
- 1:51today to buy your freedom tomorrow. But what
- 1:53if the measuring stick that you're using to track
- 1:55that freedom is broken? Consider this. Since
- 1:59the creation of the Federal Reserve, the US dollar
- 2:01has lost over 96 % of its purchasing power. But
- 2:04that's just the history. The reality today is
- 2:07even more urgent. We are living in an economic
- 2:10environment where saving is often punished and
- 2:13speculation is encouraged. We see stock markets
- 2:16at all -time highs and home prices that have
- 2:18doubled in a decade, and we're told that this
- 2:21is quote -unquote wealth creation. But my guest
- 2:24today argues that this is a dangerous illusion.
- 2:27He believes that we're witnessing a systematic
- 2:29wealth redistribution, a mechanism designed to
- 2:32transfer value from the prudent saver to the
- 2:34indebted state. He calls it a beggar -thy -children
- 2:37policy that keeps zombie companies alive, inflates
- 2:40asset bubbles, and fundamentally confuses money
- 2:42with actual capital. If you're basing your financial
- 2:45independence on a number in a bank account, you
- 2:48need to understand the forces actively working
- 2:50to erode that number. Think about it through
- 2:52the lens of a program manager. Imagine trying
- 2:55to execute a 30 -year program where your budget
- 2:57shrinks 3 % every single year regardless of how
- 3:00well you manage it. You could have the perfect
- 3:02plan, the perfect timeline, the perfect discipline.
- 3:06But if the unit of account, the money itself,
- 3:08is broken, the project fails. It's like trying
- 3:11to build a castle on a slow -moving sinkhole.
- 3:14We are told that inflation is necessary for growth,
- 3:17but in reality it is often just a transfer of
- 3:19wealth from your pocket to someone else's. It
- 3:21is a system of failure that redistributes rewards
- 3:23from those who produce to those who consume.
- 3:25So how do we engineer a portfolio that survives
- 3:28a currency that is designed to lose value? That
- 3:31is one of the questions we're going to look to
- 3:32answer today. And today's guest is here to help
- 3:35us figure it out. I am joined by Paul Musson,
- 3:37the author of Capital Offense, Why Some Benefit
- 3:40at Your Expense. Paul is a veteran investment
- 3:43professional with over 30 years of experience.
- 3:46He formerly led the Ivy Funds and McKinsey Investments.
- 3:49managing over $10 billion in assets. And today
- 3:52we're going to discuss why inflation is not a
- 3:54weather pattern, but a moral crime, why your
- 3:56net worth might be a vanity metric, and how to
- 3:58build a defense strategy that prioritizes true
- 4:01wealth over fake money. Paul, welcome to Escape
- 4:04the Clock. Well, thank you, Daniel. Great to
- 4:06be here. And that was one hell of an introduction,
- 4:08I must say. Well, Paul, I'm actually really excited
- 4:11for this conversation because I was reading your
- 4:13book. I was just learning so much about so many
- 4:17things. Really can't wait for the audience to
- 4:20start to get some of these insights. But before
- 4:22we jump into some of these things, you used to
- 4:25manage billions of dollars and you've seen the
- 4:28system from the inside at some of the highest
- 4:30levels. What was the tipping point that made
- 4:34you decide to stop playing that game and decide
- 4:36to write this book that exposes so much of it?
- 4:39I don't know that there was. A specific tipping
- 4:42point, I think it was an accumulation and a slow
- 4:45awakening on my own part about what was really
- 4:49going on. And I've always lived my, well, not
- 4:53always, but a great deal of my life I have led,
- 4:56I've lived with this face the music type attitude.
- 5:02Don't kid myself. Don't stick my head in the
- 5:05sand. Consider second or third order consequences.
- 5:09Because I was, realizing what the consequences
- 5:12of not living that way were. That you could get
- 5:15away with something in the short term, but then
- 5:17it would come back to bite you. And I didn't
- 5:19want it to come back to bite me. And so I started
- 5:22living my life that way long before I became
- 5:24an investor. It was like an intellectually honest
- 5:26approach to living my life. We could talk about
- 5:29that as well, but that's the real journey. That
- 5:31doesn't happen overnight either. It's an evolution
- 5:33over time. And then, in part, it was because
- 5:37the way... we invested, and my team still invests,
- 5:41that investing, as an investor, you play a very
- 5:45important role in helping to facilitate the efficient
- 5:52allocation of capital in the system, in the economy.
- 5:55So as an investor, like you just said, that our
- 5:59clients would earn some money, create capital,
- 6:02they'd consume some of it, but then they would
- 6:04save the rest for their future financial security.
- 6:07They would hand over or they would give their
- 6:10money that they saved to us. And our goal was
- 6:13to augment what they had already done, not get
- 6:17rich quick scheme or, you know, like, no, we're
- 6:20going to help you to grow that a little bit,
- 6:22protect your capital. And the way we would do
- 6:25it would be by allocating it to who we thought
- 6:28were some of the best businesses in the world.
- 6:31The best run businesses are going to put that
- 6:32capital to productive use to create more capital.
- 6:36This is the way the system is supposed to work.
- 6:39A free market capitalist system, you only benefit
- 6:43to the extent that you're benefiting somebody
- 6:46else. You create capital, you freely exchange
- 6:49that capital with the capital they produced.
- 6:51Increasingly, we are moving to a benefit at the
- 6:55expense of somebody else, which we'll talk about.
- 6:57And I'm getting around to answering your question.
- 6:59And so if everybody's doing that, If we're taking
- 7:02the capital, making the best assessment that
- 7:04we can, okay, that company is a basket case company.
- 7:08They're going to destroy and consume capital
- 7:10rather than create it. Well, guess what? You
- 7:11don't get any capital. So you starve these zombie
- 7:15basket case companies for capital, and eventually
- 7:17they go out of business or they fix their business
- 7:20model. They're incentivized to change. But if
- 7:23the central banks come in and bail out Wall Street
- 7:26from very bad decision making, then the system
- 7:30stops working. And it encourages more of the
- 7:34very same type of behavior. It encourages even
- 7:36more risky behavior and more leverage because
- 7:40they know that the Fed will come to the rescue
- 7:43with taxpayer dollars. And they do that by printing
- 7:46money. Yeah. And we can talk about the mechanism,
- 7:48actually, how that actually works. So that sort
- 7:51of got me angry. Then you saw productivity growth
- 7:53grinding lower. The more this happened, more
- 7:56people are suffering from this, but they don't
- 7:58even know that this is why they're suffering.
- 8:01Because while central banks are driving stock
- 8:03markets and housing prices higher, isn't that
- 8:05good for the economy? No. Stock markets should
- 8:07only be going higher if the underlying businesses
- 8:10are producing more and more capital. More capital
- 8:14being produced pushes stock markets higher. The
- 8:17Federal Reserve decided to do the opposite and
- 8:20drive stock markets higher and try to pull up
- 8:23the economy with it and hope that the benefits
- 8:25would all trickle down to everybody else. It
- 8:28didn't work and it won't. The M2 money supply
- 8:30exploded by 40 % between the years of 2020 and
- 8:342022, where the Federal Reserve economic data
- 8:38then showed that productivity barely budged.
- 8:42Like almost no productivity increase yet. The
- 8:45supply increased almost 50%. That's a massive
- 8:48disparity. One thing that I noticed is before
- 8:51I really got into investing and digging in and
- 8:53understanding and educating myself, I was pretty
- 8:55naive. I assumed anything on the stock market
- 8:58was some productive company. Everything would
- 9:00provide capital and value. And the more I would
- 9:03research investments, the more I would learn.
- 9:05There are a lot of zombie companies out there,
- 9:07quite a lot of just these companies dragging
- 9:10along. And like you mentioned. So I want to get
- 9:13into this a little bit more, though, on the money
- 9:15versus capital piece, just to help the audience
- 9:17understand the nuance here. Because a lot of
- 9:20time, I think we do inflate these things together.
- 9:23For someone building a nest egg, why is focusing
- 9:26on the accumulation of currency itself actually
- 9:31a trap? And how should they start to shift their
- 9:34mindset to focusing on acquiring true capital
- 9:37instead? And maybe start with the difference
- 9:39between money and capital in your mind. Yeah,
- 9:41I think I'll start there because it makes it
- 9:43easier. So a lot of people conflate capital with
- 9:47money. They're two very different things. It's
- 9:49the creation of capital that makes the world
- 9:51go around, not money. Money is extremely important.
- 9:54But all that money is there for is to exchange
- 9:58all the capital that's being produced. So capital
- 10:02can be anything that you produce that somebody
- 10:05else values or you yourself value. Could be a
- 10:08good or a service, your podcast. You're creating
- 10:11capital and your listeners are consuming it.
- 10:13So the example I like to give is you make a bike.
- 10:16You just created capital. I make a suit. I just
- 10:20create a capital. And then we fairly exchange
- 10:23the bike for the suit. That's called direct exchange
- 10:26or barter system. Importantly, none of that came
- 10:30at anybody else's expense. There was no bike
- 10:34and suit in the economy. And then we both used
- 10:37our resources and our work ethic and we created
- 10:40that and exchanged it with each other. No one
- 10:43was coerced. But we don't do direct exchange.
- 10:45You can't have a large economy with barter. It
- 10:48just doesn't work. It's too complicated. You
- 10:50know, how many kitchen chairs does it cost to
- 10:52take a flight to Florida? You know, you can't
- 10:54work that way. So we use a medium of exchange
- 10:57called money. So it's indirect exchange. So you
- 11:01would make your bike. You would sell it for $1
- 11:03,000. Let's say it's a really nice bike. And
- 11:05then you would use your $1 ,000 to buy the suit
- 11:08from me. indirect exchange. So the difference
- 11:11between capital and money. You can have an economy
- 11:14with capital and no money. You cannot have an
- 11:18economy with money and no capital. If you've
- 11:21got money, you've got no capital to exchange.
- 11:23So let's say you make 10 bikes. You sell them
- 11:27for a thousand bucks each. You got 10 ,000 bucks.
- 11:29You put that in your bank account. You don't
- 11:31spend it right away. You're saving it because
- 11:34you might want to go on a nice vacation at the
- 11:36end of the year. But before you get a chance
- 11:38to spend your $10 ,000, the central bank doubles
- 11:41the money supply. Now, when the central bank
- 11:44doubles the money supply, what they do is they
- 11:46just create money out of thin air, either digitally
- 11:49or they print it, push a couple of buttons. They
- 11:52did not have to create any capital to obtain
- 11:55that new money. So that new money has no capital
- 11:58stored up in it. Your $10 ,000 that's in your
- 12:01bank account, effectively what that is, doing
- 12:05is storing those 10 bikes that you produced.
- 12:07That's what gives that money value, right? So
- 12:10now the central bank prints money out of thin
- 12:12air. There's no capital in it, but it obtains
- 12:16capital as soon as it enters the economy by extracting
- 12:19capital from the rest of the money already in
- 12:22existence. So as soon as that new money comes
- 12:24into circulation, it takes five of the bikes
- 12:27from your $10 ,000 and puts it into the newly
- 12:29printed money. So your bank statement says, oh,
- 12:32great, I still have $10 ,000 in the bank. Well,
- 12:34guess what? It's only storing five bucks instead
- 12:36of 10. So now your $10 ,000 will only buy half
- 12:40as much as it would have done before the central
- 12:42bank doubled the money supply. That's the difference
- 12:45between capital and money. When we were on the
- 12:47gold standard, we had a more, at least a harder
- 12:50to game system, right? We had an actual resource
- 12:53there that we could know was sitting there that
- 12:56we could exchange against and stuff. When we
- 12:58went to the fiat system, it seems like, at least
- 13:01in your book, I started to get this understanding
- 13:02that that's when the hole started to be really
- 13:04dug. And now that we can just kind of have the
- 13:07central banks printing money, they'll just keep
- 13:09doing this because their incentive is to keep
- 13:12showing growth at all costs, no matter what.
- 13:15In your mind, is moving to digital currency the
- 13:19next big step for them to dig even further at
- 13:23this point? Is that how we should look at that?
- 13:25Well, it depends on the structure. Like, I mean,
- 13:28they could move to a digital currency. And as
- 13:31long as they didn't increase the money supply
- 13:34at a rapid rate, that would be completely fine.
- 13:37The trouble is, is that I don't think they have
- 13:39any intention of doing that. And if they move
- 13:42to a digital currency, it could be an even greater
- 13:46invasion of your privacy and your property rights.
- 13:50Now, don't get me wrong. I don't think it's a
- 13:52conspiracy theory, and I don't think these people
- 13:55are evil. I really don't. I really think that
- 13:58they believe, or at least they've convinced themselves,
- 14:01that what they are doing is the right thing for
- 14:04the greater economy, for the greater good. It
- 14:06also makes them look good, right? That they can
- 14:08spend more money to be convinced by certain economists
- 14:11that deficits and debts don't matter. They do.
- 14:13They matter a lot. But it's easy to convince
- 14:16yourself that. taking the easy path is the right
- 14:19thing to do. And so unfortunately, unless something
- 14:23changes, either a broader understanding or a
- 14:27crisis, then moving to a digital currency could
- 14:30make things worse. A lot of people here, myself
- 14:34included, track net worth. If you're in the United
- 14:37States, you're tracking it in US dollars. Is
- 14:39that just tracking inflation? rather than our
- 14:42real purchasing power? And is nominal net worth
- 14:44just a lie? What metric should we be really thinking
- 14:47about using instead? Some kind of hard asset,
- 14:49something else? Well, you know, it depends, you
- 14:53know, so let me back up. So policymakers like
- 14:56to point to record household wealth in America,
- 15:00and that is driven largely via soaring stock
- 15:04markets and soaring house prices. But if stock
- 15:09markets are soaring because of interest rates
- 15:12being taken to zero or the central bank printing
- 15:15money and buying assets and just announced that
- 15:18they're going to be buying treasury bills again,
- 15:20then that's not real wealth creation. All it
- 15:22is, is the price you have to pay for that wealth
- 15:26has just gone up. There's no more capital in
- 15:29society. But if you are fortunate enough that
- 15:34you have assets, And the central bank drives
- 15:37the nominal value of those assets higher. And
- 15:40then you sell those assets for money. And then
- 15:42you could invest them in real assets or whatever
- 15:44and try and protect you. You've benefited at
- 15:47the expense of somebody else. You haven't done
- 15:48anything wrong. You haven't done anything illegal.
- 15:51But there's no real wealth creation happening
- 15:54there. And there is a lot of real wealth creation
- 15:57still happening in the economy. Don't get me
- 15:59wrong. But another example I use is, let's say
- 16:02you've got a desert island and there's three
- 16:05houses on the island and they're all priced at
- 16:08$400 ,000 each. And then one person sells one
- 16:13house to the other for $500 ,000. And then the
- 16:16other sells that for $600 ,000. And they keep
- 16:19selling the houses to each other at higher and
- 16:21higher prices. Well, you had three houses at
- 16:25$400 ,000. Net worth on the island was $1 .2
- 16:28million. But now if they all sell the houses
- 16:30to each other for a million dollars, household
- 16:32wealth has just gone up to $3 million. Despite
- 16:35the fact that you still only have three houses,
- 16:37no capital was created. But this is what lowering
- 16:42interest rates does and printing money. It creates
- 16:45fake wealth in the economy, fake wealth creation,
- 16:49but real wealth redistribution. Yeah, I'm glad
- 16:53you brought that up because that was probably
- 16:55one of the hardest things to read in the book
- 16:57for me was, you know, like like yourself, you
- 17:00admit it in the book and myself did well with
- 17:03owning a home generationally bought in a lot
- 17:06of debt there, but really stuck with it. And
- 17:09home values have just continued to go up and
- 17:12up and up. And what incentive do you have to
- 17:14sell your home necessarily when a lot of people
- 17:18who haven't bought it yet are being able to maintain
- 17:20very low interest rates? They don't have a lot
- 17:22of incentive to go take a higher interest rate
- 17:25and lose this appreciating asset. And others
- 17:28who have just really benefited from this increase
- 17:30in wealth are doing next to nothing, really,
- 17:32just sitting on this thing. Now, I put some work
- 17:35into my house. I tried to improve it in certain
- 17:36ways. But your point really is you wouldn't really
- 17:39have to do anything. Just the way the market's
- 17:41designed right now, that real estate asset will
- 17:43appreciate and you will benefit from it. And
- 17:45what that's doing is locking out the next generation
- 17:47or immigrants or others from being able to have
- 17:50access to that wealth. That was fascinating,
- 17:52but also kind of hard to read. How do you see
- 17:55that situation? And is it just an interest rate
- 17:57issue? How can we stop blocking this housing
- 18:01crisis from continuing for the next generation?
- 18:04Yeah, so it started with interest rates, but
- 18:08then other parties piled on to make it even worse.
- 18:12So we'll go back to 2001. So the U .S. had just
- 18:18gone through the dot com. boom and bubble. And
- 18:21there was lots of great things happening, right?
- 18:23The internet .com is super exciting, new business
- 18:27models. A lot of them were basket cases, but
- 18:29a lot of them ended up being like real wealth
- 18:32generators, and there was real productivity growth
- 18:34going on. Everyone got carried away, as they
- 18:36usually do. Anyway, so that was creating a real
- 18:38wealth effect, or partially real wealth effect.
- 18:41Stock markets going higher. Greenspan used to
- 18:43talk about, yes, he was the head of the central
- 18:45bank at the time, the Federal Reserve, and how
- 18:48much The stock wealth effect was contributing
- 18:50to spending in the economy, and so GDP was growing
- 18:53higher because stock markets were growing higher.
- 18:55Then the whole thing crashed. And then you had
- 18:57people like Paul Krugman of the New York Times
- 19:00and Paul McCulley of PIMCO, commentators, well
- 19:04-known, suggesting that the U .S. Federal Reserve
- 19:07should create a new wealth effect in the housing
- 19:10market because more people own housing assets
- 19:13than stock assets, and this would have a greater
- 19:15impact on GDP. People would borrow on the rising
- 19:19value of their home and go spend it. GDP is a
- 19:22measure of all final spending or consumption
- 19:24for the most part. It is not the fount of economic
- 19:27prosperity, which we can talk about. So anyways,
- 19:30so they started driving housing prices higher
- 19:32with record low interest rates at the time. Greenspan
- 19:37took the Fed funds rate down to 1 % in an economy
- 19:40that was still growing. That would normally be
- 19:43in emergency levels like depression or war. But
- 19:48no, because they thought it was good for the
- 19:50economy. A house has no business increasing in
- 19:55price because a house is not producing stuff.
- 19:59So earlier we were talking about how you created
- 20:02a capital via suit and I created capital via
- 20:05a bike. My wife and I bought our home here in
- 20:08a suburb of Toronto in 2001, right when these
- 20:11policies started. And then the Bank of Canada
- 20:13followed suit and the Bank of England and the
- 20:15European Central Bank. So our house today is
- 20:19worth four times what we paid for it. It's in
- 20:22nominal terms. In real terms, it's like two and
- 20:24a half times or something. So if in a capitalist
- 20:27system, you're only supposed to benefit to the
- 20:30extent that you benefited somebody else, whatever
- 20:33real wealth you have is supposed to be a reflection
- 20:37cumulatively of the wealth that others out there
- 20:40have because of your efforts. And you fairly
- 20:43exchange through the medium of exchange called
- 20:45money. So if our house went up four times in
- 20:48value, what was our contribution to society?
- 20:52Who else out there is also four times better
- 20:54off? No one. In fact, they're four times less
- 20:57well off. Our house is not producing four times
- 21:01the amount of stuff that it produced back in
- 21:032001. It hasn't increased four times in size.
- 21:08It hasn't relocated to a glorious oceanfront
- 21:10view in Palm Beach or something like that. It's
- 21:13the same economic good. that a younger couple
- 21:16or a newcomer to our country is forced to pay
- 21:20four times more than we paid for it. When you
- 21:22look down on society, when we make four times
- 21:25on our home, there's not four more homes. There's
- 21:29just a redistribution of wealth from a younger
- 21:32couple's bank account into our bank account.
- 21:35That's it. And it's unfair. It's immoral. It
- 21:39wasn't the goal. It wasn't the intention to create
- 21:41a housing affordability crisis for the next generation.
- 21:44I don't believe that at all, but it is the result.
- 21:47And it was so predictable. Yeah. I think this
- 21:49is why that was hard to read for me. And maybe
- 21:51why others might have a hard time with this because
- 21:53a lot of us just have good intent here, right?
- 21:55We're thinking we're doing the right things.
- 21:57We're trying to buy a home. We're working hard
- 21:59for putting our hard earned income into that,
- 22:02trying to build equity, but, and directly we're
- 22:05contributing to a housing crisis. We're contributing
- 22:08to wealth prevention for another generation.
- 22:11That's tough. In the United States, since 2009,
- 22:15the U .S. house wealth has nearly tripled to
- 22:17$150 trillion, which has largely been driven
- 22:21by asset price inflation, not GDP growth. So
- 22:25this is a pretty significant number we're talking
- 22:28about now. So I guess to follow up on that, should
- 22:31I even think or should the listeners here even
- 22:34think of their primary residence as an investment?
- 22:37Or is it better to view it as a consumption expense
- 22:39and just be more honest about it? Well, if central
- 22:43banks continue with this policy, with attempting
- 22:47to drive housing prices higher and. taking actions
- 22:51to prevent them from falling in price, then I
- 22:54think you should continue to factor that into
- 22:57your wealth. I think, on the other hand, I think
- 23:01being aware of how we have obtained that wealth
- 23:04is very important because it could go away at
- 23:08any time. And now the reason I say that is because
- 23:12our current path is not sustainable. It's not
- 23:15sustainable when a whole generation is priced
- 23:18out of the standard of living that they deserve,
- 23:22that they played by all the rules. They're better
- 23:25educated than I am, that's for sure, willing
- 23:28to work just as hard. They can't dream of affording
- 23:31the same sort of lifestyle that I was able to
- 23:33afford. And so they will not put up with it and
- 23:36they will demand change. You're seeing this in
- 23:38New York City with a new socialist mayor. And
- 23:41that will continue across the country. And so
- 23:44we can either decide to change it ourselves and
- 23:48make it fairer, such that this won't be the first
- 23:51time in modern history that the next generation
- 23:53will be worse off than the one that preceded
- 23:55it. So we can change it, or they're going to
- 23:57change it for us. But again, you know, it's...
- 24:00To your point, it is tough. You know, it is tough
- 24:03to acknowledge this. And I'm 63. And, you know,
- 24:07when I tell my friends and family this, you know,
- 24:10first they don't really like it, you know, but
- 24:13they get it. They get it. And they don't want
- 24:16their kids to suffer at their expense. Although
- 24:19every now and then I do run across somebody who
- 24:22not only doesn't like it. but refuses to see
- 24:25it because they don't want to see it. And I understand
- 24:28as well, because the whole life they've been
- 24:30living to get on the housing ladder and blah,
- 24:32blah, blah, just like my parents did. And yeah,
- 24:34you haven't done anything wrong. I'm not blaming
- 24:36anybody. Nobody's a villain here. It's just a
- 24:39bad system. And there's a saying by Upton Sinclair.
- 24:43He was more of a left -leaning politician back
- 24:46in the 1930s. And he said that if someone's income
- 24:51depends on them not understanding something,
- 24:53don't expect them to understand it. It's not
- 24:56that they can't, they don't want to. Yeah. The
- 24:59way I look at it is if we can't take the time
- 25:02to understand the system, how are we going to
- 25:04improve it? Exactly. So I do think this is where
- 25:06this starts is with these conversations. Let
- 25:09me ask you about the other. big hidden tax that
- 25:12you really touched on in the book. You described
- 25:15inflation not as this kind of natural pattern
- 25:20or weather pattern, if you will, but as a deliberate
- 25:23mechanism of confiscation that is essentially
- 25:26a hidden tax on people who are acting prudently,
- 25:29you know, the savers and everyone. And a lot
- 25:32of people here, we are savers. We are investors.
- 25:34We are doing what we can. to hit financial independence
- 25:38so that we can have the option to enjoy our lives
- 25:41to the best means that we possibly can. So because
- 25:44of this hidden tax to inflation, I'd love you
- 25:46to explain it more to the audience about how
- 25:48that works. And also, does that mean that the
- 25:51traditional path to financial independence, which
- 25:54is saving a portion of your income, is that in
- 25:57your mind broken by design? I don't think it's
- 26:00broken by design. I mean, an economy cannot function
- 26:04without saving and investment. It just can't.
- 26:07Yet, I guess it started with an economist called
- 26:10John Maynard Keynes back in the 1930s. And it
- 26:13was in the middle of the Great Depression where
- 26:15he convinced politicians that it was effective
- 26:19demand or consumption that is required for an
- 26:23economy to really function. Demand drives economic
- 26:28prosperity and consumption. No, it's not. It's
- 26:31saving and investment. And saving and investment,
- 26:34you have to do that first. Create capital. You
- 26:38create a suit. That suit then gives you the wherewithal
- 26:41to go out and buy my bike. But you have to create
- 26:45a suit first, right? But they've tried to turn
- 26:49that around and convince people, governments,
- 26:51that... that consumption comes first. And if
- 26:55they need to print money to give to people to
- 26:59consume before they produce, then that's what
- 27:01they will do. But what that does is it redistributes
- 27:05capital within the system. So it does take capital
- 27:08from your savings and gives it. So if you refuse
- 27:11to spend your savings on a new bike from me,
- 27:14and instead you want to save your capital to
- 27:16create more suits, then the government will print
- 27:19money and extract capital from from your money
- 27:23and give it to someone else so they can buy my
- 27:25bike. They've convinced people that if people
- 27:28aren't worried about higher prices in the future,
- 27:31that they will refuse to spend. It's complete
- 27:34and utter nonsense. They call it the paradox
- 27:37of thrift. So if prices are falling, let's say
- 27:41the price of my bike is going down 2 % per year.
- 27:46Policymakers will believe that you'll refuse
- 27:48to buy my bike because you're just going to wait
- 27:49a year and buy it. at 2 % lower price. No, it's
- 27:55not true. So the example I use in my book is
- 27:58if you want to buy a TV, you've already got a
- 28:00TV, you want another TV. So it's a real luxury
- 28:03for the basement for your teenage kids. So it's
- 28:05300 bucks and there's 2 % deflation. So central
- 28:09bankers believe that you would never buy that
- 28:10TV because you just wait 12 months to buy it
- 28:132 % less. So your choice is you can buy the TV
- 28:16now for 300 bucks or wait a whole year and save
- 28:19six bucks. and buy for $2 .94. Are you going
- 28:22to wait a whole year? No, you're not. You know,
- 28:24by that logic, people wouldn't have bought flat
- 28:27screen TVs because they've been declining in
- 28:28price for years, right? People just continue
- 28:31to buy them, buy more of them, and a falling
- 28:34price. It's called good deflation. This should
- 28:37be the natural order of things in an unhampered
- 28:41economy. So what happens is companies, oh, let's
- 28:45see, TV is a great example. So back when they
- 28:48first launched flat screen TVs in early 2000s,
- 28:51they were like $3 ,000 or something. Then the
- 28:53companies that are producing them, they reinvest
- 28:56product innovation, R &D. They're able now to
- 28:59produce those TVs cheaper. So it's still $3 ,000,
- 29:03but because they're producing it cheaper, the
- 29:05cost has gone down. They're making more money.
- 29:08That higher profitability attracts competition
- 29:10from other players. They enter the market and
- 29:14compete, and the price comes down. then they
- 29:17reinvest and learn how to make it cheaper, their
- 29:19profitability increases, more competition comes
- 29:22in, the price comes down again. So when you have
- 29:24innovation, productivity improvements, as well
- 29:28as competition, you need both, then prices continuously
- 29:32fall over time, as long as the money supply is
- 29:35not increasing, and the ultimate beneficiary
- 29:38is the consumer. So even if you are a flat wage,
- 29:41your wages don't increase, every year you're
- 29:44becoming wealthier in real terms, Because your
- 29:47flat wage is buying more and more stuff. The
- 29:50last 30 years of the 1800s in the US, that's
- 29:53what you had. It was such a productivity boom.
- 29:57The money supply was only increasing 4 .5 % or
- 30:00something per year. I mean, I don't think it
- 30:02should be even rising that fast, but that's fairly
- 30:05slow by historical standards. That the amount
- 30:07of stuff being produced in the economy was growing
- 30:09faster than the money supply. So there's more
- 30:12and more stuff and less and less money. the prices
- 30:17of the stuff had to come down. Naturally, yeah.
- 30:19You know, that's good deflation. That should
- 30:23be happening. But instead, we pay more and more
- 30:26for everything, not because stuff is more expensive
- 30:30to produce. No, companies get more efficient
- 30:32at it every year. But the government's increased
- 30:34the money supply at a rate faster than the economy
- 30:38can produce the amount of stuff. And that's why
- 30:40you're paying more for everything. It's not the
- 30:43natural state of things. The natural state or
- 30:45natural order is the opposite. People feel the
- 30:47economy. It's always a top issue. We see the
- 30:52pendulum of political parties in the United States
- 30:55swing back and forth because of the economy.
- 30:57People on some level feel this. They know that
- 31:01they're not able to buy as much when they're
- 31:04at least at the grocery store. But I don't think
- 31:06everyone understands. exactly what that means.
- 31:09I think a lot of people, if you ask them, well,
- 31:11how do you fix this? They're like, I need more
- 31:12money. Pay me more money. They don't think about
- 31:15their spending power from a point of deflation.
- 31:18How do you think just an average person who,
- 31:21at least in the United States, that gets no financial
- 31:23education will be able to come to terms with
- 31:27some of these things? Would this just take a
- 31:29systemic change at a government level enough?
- 31:32Or is this more just an education issue as well?
- 31:38Education has to come before a systemic change
- 31:42can happen, because I believe the systemic change
- 31:45will only occur when the people demand it. Now,
- 31:48there's a saying that the people always get the
- 31:51government that they deserve. Like, you voted
- 31:54for them, so stop complaining. Well, no, it's
- 31:57only true if the people actually understand what's
- 32:00going on. If you don't understand what's happening,
- 32:02you can't demand the right things from your policymakers,
- 32:05from your leaders. And so for a few decades,
- 32:08we've been demanding the other thing. We want
- 32:11free stuff. As I said before, like in the economy,
- 32:14what you have is supposed to be a reflection
- 32:16of what you've produced. And so if you're taking
- 32:20more from the system than you're contributing,
- 32:23it's coming at somebody else's expense. There's
- 32:25no ifs, ands, or buts about this. You just can't
- 32:28see who that is. And so it's easy then to convince
- 32:31ourselves that we deserve it and all this kind
- 32:33of nonsense. And so once people... understand
- 32:36what's going on and the path that we're on is
- 32:39not sustainable and that we are benefiting at
- 32:42the expense of our kids, then we will demand
- 32:45different actions from our leaders, our politicians,
- 32:48and then they'll do it because they're good people.
- 32:51They want to do the right thing. But to do the
- 32:54right thing today would be political suicide
- 32:56because nobody thinks that you're doing the right
- 32:58thing. Hey, how come we don't get all this free
- 33:00stuff? Let's vote this guy out. And I do believe
- 33:04that. I do have great faith in people. Most people
- 33:07are good people. Most people want to do the right
- 33:10thing. I truly believe that. And they will want
- 33:13to do the right thing. And the thing I love about
- 33:15America is this can -do spirit where you guys
- 33:19rally to the cause. You know, it's amazing what
- 33:23Americans can do. But importantly, the people
- 33:28have to know that they're all in it together.
- 33:32And it's not just a few people who have to make
- 33:35the sacrifices and these other people over here
- 33:37are going to make off like bandits. No. They
- 33:39have to know that we're all in this together.
- 33:41Let's do this. Let's fix this. Let's do whatever
- 33:44it takes. Let's not stick our head in the sand
- 33:47anymore. And so I believe it can happen. It won't
- 33:51be fun. No, it never is. As you're talking about
- 33:55that, it reminded me of when Paul Wagner was
- 33:59doing his very unpopular decisions to end the
- 34:06great inflation that was happening in the early
- 34:0880s and how everyone just thought he was crazy
- 34:11for what he was trying to do. Yet history has
- 34:15shown that was exactly what the economy needed.
- 34:18And we need more Pauls. That is my conclusion
- 34:20here. Yeah, that's right. So I think you mentioned
- 34:25him in the book, too, at one point. Yeah, I think
- 34:27he was the greatest central banker of all time
- 34:32and willing to do the right but unpopular thing.
- 34:37And, you know, I mean, it's a long story, but
- 34:41he I mean, a previous head as well. Burns, I
- 34:45think his name was. He also increased interest
- 34:47rates, but not enough. And the trouble was, is
- 34:50that. No matter how high the increased interest
- 34:52rates, banks were still, or people were still
- 34:55borrowing because in real terms, the rate was
- 34:58still very low or even negative. And so Paul
- 35:01Volcker had, I think he pivoted course and targeted
- 35:03the money supply instead of interest rates. Anyways,
- 35:06in today's environment, there is way more debt
- 35:11outstanding than there was when Paul Volcker
- 35:14took the Fed funds rate all the way up to, I
- 35:16think, to 20%. Can you imagine? and mortgage
- 35:19rates were up in high teens, I think. If you
- 35:22did that today with the amount of debt outstanding,
- 35:25I don't know that you could do it. Maybe. But
- 35:28this is the problem. The problem is that policymakers
- 35:31have encouraged debt -fueled consumption on the
- 35:35part of consumers, but also government debt -fueled
- 35:40spending. And with the U .S. now at well over
- 35:42120 % debt to GDP, there are certain studies
- 35:46out there that will tell you that once debt to
- 35:49GDP gets over 90%, that future economic growth
- 35:53is permanently harmed, that you should expect
- 35:55slower economic growth because you've got this
- 35:57debt anchor on your back that is slowing the
- 36:01economy down. I mean, just like you with your
- 36:03clients and your listeners, you caution about
- 36:06the hazards of having too much debt. But the
- 36:09problem is policymakers and some economists will
- 36:12say, What's right for an individual is not what's
- 36:15right for the broader economy. It is, but they
- 36:19will tell you that it's not. the the real medicine
- 36:43to heal the patient would be procession like
- 36:47just an actual, natural, painful healing process.
- 36:51And instead, it's just easier for the government,
- 36:55maybe central banks, just to go to stimulus and
- 36:58just pump drugs in there and stimulate the patient
- 37:02and keep them kind of going along. Fascinating
- 37:05way to kind of point that out. But I mean, I
- 37:08can see why that's a hard sell, right? You want
- 37:10to go and say, look, we're just going to go.
- 37:13deliberately into a recession so that we can
- 37:15deflate so your purchasing power is where it
- 37:18properly should be again and we and we move away
- 37:21from a leverage -based debt system that's so
- 37:23bad for so many people but what's the alternative
- 37:26right now all i see is the amount of debt in
- 37:29the united states it's just staggering both the
- 37:32government because it can just kind of just continuously
- 37:34print money for itself and borrow without worry
- 37:38and just consumer debt. I mean, I think it should
- 37:41be criminal personally, the interest rates for
- 37:44borrowing and the ease of borrowing. I was at
- 37:48a retail store just buying something for my daughter.
- 37:51It was like a $70 purchase. And I was pushed
- 37:54for a good couple minutes to get a retail branded
- 37:58credit card to save a small percentage on that
- 38:02amount. And I tried to spend that time telling
- 38:05the cashier why that was wrong to push those
- 38:08cards. But their incentive is to push it. They're
- 38:10told you're going to get a commission for doing
- 38:12this. And their whole sell is you're going to
- 38:14save $10 today. Why wouldn't you do it? Your
- 38:17credit's probably bad. They'll deny you. So no
- 38:21harm done. You save $10, right? Well, yeah, but
- 38:24your credit was already run. You're not making
- 38:26it better by applying for more cards. So, you
- 38:29know, people peddle. this and it becomes very
- 38:31predatory in a way. So I'm just curious, like
- 38:33when the cure is so painful, how will we get
- 38:38out of the situation? Well, yeah, a couple of
- 38:41comments first on that, you know, policymakers
- 38:43think that people need to be encouraged to consume.
- 38:47Nobody needs to be encouraged to consume. If
- 38:49anything, we need to be encouraged to save more,
- 38:52right? The consumption is not the issue. It's
- 38:55too much consumption is the issue. And the other
- 38:58thing is. You know, recessions are necessary,
- 39:01but they're not, as some people claim, a punishment.
- 39:05Oh, why? Oh, you want to punish people because
- 39:08there was a bull market or there was a bubble?
- 39:10No, it's not about punishment. It's about fixing
- 39:13things. So the analogy that you alluded to in
- 39:16my book, you know, it's like if you have a tumor
- 39:18and you go to the doctor and the doctor says,
- 39:22look, I have to operate on you. and remove the
- 39:25tumor is going to result in 18 months of rehab.
- 39:29And so economically, it's going to be pretty
- 39:31rough for you the next 18 months. Is the doctor
- 39:34punishing you? No, he's trying to help you, trying
- 39:38to heal you. And so, you know, get that out of
- 39:40the way. In terms of, you know, because it will
- 39:44be painful, it will be more painful for some
- 39:48than others. Now, some people have benefited
- 39:51enormously from this situation. Fiat billionaire,
- 39:56some people refer them to. Now, these people,
- 39:59if your wealth goes from $50 billion down to
- 40:03$2 billion, are you really suffering? If you're
- 40:06worth $500 million and your wealth goes down
- 40:09to $200 million, are you really suffering? I
- 40:12don't think so. Might be embarrassed. Maybe they're
- 40:14embarrassed. I don't know. But it will impact
- 40:17other people, particularly people who recently
- 40:21bought their first home at near all -time highs.
- 40:25And if the real price intrinsic value of homes
- 40:28is half of what it is today, then these people
- 40:32are unfairly punished. It's not that the price
- 40:36shouldn't go down to the intrinsic value. They
- 40:38shouldn't have gone up to the bubble price in
- 40:40the first place. That is the issue. So it's not
- 40:44their fault. As a society, I think we're obligated
- 40:48to help those people. We're not going to help
- 40:50the fiat billionaire because they're only worth
- 40:52$2 billion now, but we're going to help the younger
- 40:55first -time homebuyers who just lost money in
- 40:57their home if they have to sell it due to no
- 40:59fault of their own. So people like me who have
- 41:02made a fortune, not fortune, but made good money
- 41:05on my home, got to be careful. And so, yeah,
- 41:09if we sell it, maybe part of the capital gain
- 41:12is taxable. where there's 10%, 15%, 20%, and
- 41:17it's only on capital gains above a certain amount.
- 41:20So for people who all their life have been believing
- 41:24or thinking that they can rely on the capital
- 41:26gain on their home to fund their retirement,
- 41:28you can't all of a sudden just take that away
- 41:30from them. Now, if the price comes down, you're
- 41:34not going to get all of it. But the alternative
- 41:36is to continue to punish the next generation.
- 41:39If you understand that, yes, I was counting on
- 41:43this all my life, but I didn't realize that it
- 41:46was coming at the expense of somebody else, then
- 41:48it makes it easier to take. A house is not supposed
- 41:51to be an investment vehicle. It is a savings
- 41:53piggy bank. It's like, as you know, it's like
- 41:56a method of forced saving. Yeah, a liquid savings.
- 41:59If you buy a home with a mortgage, you're forced
- 42:01to pay your mortgage off. Otherwise, you know,
- 42:04a bank might come and take your home. And so,
- 42:06yeah, and then when you're finished, you've got
- 42:08all this equity in your home. But this equity
- 42:11in your home is a reflection of all the bikes
- 42:14that you made throughout your career, and you
- 42:16sold those bikes and used the money to pay down
- 42:19the mortgage. So your house, the equity in your
- 42:22home, you've got all these bikes stored up in
- 42:24your home. But if the central bank drives the
- 42:26price up two, three, four times, you've got your
- 42:29bikes, plus you have nursing services from this
- 42:33young couple over there. Plus, you've got flight
- 42:36attendant services from this young person over
- 42:39here. You've got their capital stored up in your
- 42:41house as well, which they have to fork over money
- 42:44if they want to get that capital back. Yeah,
- 42:46we've all become pack rats for capitalism. Yeah,
- 42:50listen, no easy answers here. I'm not here to
- 42:53tell anybody that there are. I'm just here to
- 42:56try and explain to people what's been going on.
- 42:58And why and what I believe we need to do to fix
- 43:02it. And the understanding is step one. You do
- 43:05a wonderful job of it in your book, actually.
- 43:06And I actually could talk to you about this all
- 43:08day. Thank you. You do a very good job just outlining
- 43:12the problem and educating people on kind of how
- 43:15we got there. I mean, you're kind of blunt with
- 43:16some of it at times, but you had a pretty optimistic
- 43:18message at the end, which I liked. Yeah. But
- 43:21I want to get let's get into some of the practical
- 43:24stuff. And I know you're not going to have answers
- 43:25for everything here. But, you know, I would love
- 43:27to get. your thoughts on some of these issues,
- 43:30because these are probably on people's minds
- 43:32right now when they're understanding the problem
- 43:34a little bit clearer. For instance, my listeners
- 43:36might be thinking about withdrawals. We save
- 43:40so that we can live off of those savings in the
- 43:42future. And a lot of people live by this idea
- 43:46of a 4 % rule. This idea that they're going to
- 43:49withdraw 4 % inflation adjusted for the rest
- 43:53of their years, or at least long enough to get
- 43:54to some kind of retirement accounts. A safe withdrawal
- 43:58rate, considering that a lot of people look at
- 44:02CPI or just inflation numbers, how safe is it
- 44:06really when we calculate this burn rate based
- 44:10on this data, which is based on inflation, based
- 44:14on all these problems we talked about? Well,
- 44:16it depends on what happens. No, honestly, as
- 44:20a professional investor, we would always remind
- 44:25ourselves that We didn't know what was going
- 44:27to happen. And we also know that nobody else
- 44:31knows what's going to happen, even though there
- 44:33are lots of people out there with opinions with
- 44:35respect to what they think is going to happen.
- 44:38And there's a lot of smart people, a lot of smart
- 44:40experts. And it always sounds convincing. Then
- 44:44you can hear another person say the exact opposite.
- 44:46Oh, that sounds convincing too. Nobody knows.
- 44:48And so the way I've always approached my investing
- 44:53style and my savings and spending, is, you know,
- 44:57assuming that something bad could happen one
- 45:00day, but it might not. And so I'm going to strike
- 45:03that balance of probably not spending or withdrawing
- 45:08as much as I possibly could if things were rosy
- 45:11forever. But if things do get really bad, I'm
- 45:15still going to be okay. And if things are better
- 45:17than I expected, well, that's a bonus and I'll
- 45:19spend more in the future. I don't know any other
- 45:22way to approach it because I don't know what's
- 45:24going to happen. As you know, it all depends
- 45:27on your own risk tolerance. People are different.
- 45:32Could I share with you one story with your listeners?
- 45:35Please. It's somewhat related to this, but I
- 45:38just think you just triggered my memory. So my
- 45:41clients over the years were financial advisors.
- 45:44So stockbrokers, financial planners, lots of
- 45:47amazing people, like really providing a really
- 45:50amazing service for their clients. And as you
- 45:54know, as you said, you know, it's important to
- 45:57forego some consumption today, save some money
- 46:00so you can spend in the future. And so we're
- 46:03trying to get people to be disciplined to save
- 46:06and not consume all your money today. So this
- 46:08one advisor in London, Ontario, which is not
- 46:11too far, like an hour and a half from where I
- 46:12live. And it's a lower cost living area, you
- 46:15know, it's a nice area, but not like in a big
- 46:17city like Toronto. And so she said, let me tell
- 46:20you about this client of mine. He was an East
- 46:22European. I think he worked in a car, like an
- 46:25assembly factory, but an amazing saver. And he
- 46:29was in his 80s, passed away. His wife now is
- 46:32coming to see the advisor to see about the state
- 46:34of the finances. And she has no clue, right?
- 46:36Because he did everything. And she was so excited
- 46:40for the client to come because she was going
- 46:42to tell her all the good news, right? So client
- 46:45comes in. She says, okay, first of all, no mortgage.
- 46:49Your house is paid off. Second of all, you've
- 46:51got over a million dollars in the bank account.
- 46:54You're not going to have to worry about anything
- 46:55for the rest of your life. Her client starts
- 46:58crying and the advisor says, well, what's the
- 47:00matter? Why are you upset? I think I know why.
- 47:02I said, all I ever asked for was two weeks in
- 47:06Florida. Wouldn't spend the money. And so you
- 47:09got to strike that balance. My wife and I, one
- 47:12of our favorite sayings, and it's been, Brett,
- 47:15we've been married 33 years, is life is happening
- 47:18now. Awesome. Don't wait for a better life in
- 47:22the future, but make sure you're saving so you're
- 47:24going to have a good life in the future, too.
- 47:26You know, just striking that balance. Thank you
- 47:28for saying that. I think that's very important.
- 47:31I had to go through that journey myself. I realized
- 47:33at one point my optimization technique was frugality
- 47:36to the point where I wasn't enjoying my present.
- 47:39And luckily, I have a. very supportive spouse
- 47:41who kicked me in the line there and together
- 47:44we figured that out. But yeah, you're absolutely
- 47:46right. You can't sacrifice to the point that
- 47:48you're miserable. It's about smoothing out your
- 47:51life, enjoying your present and having the future
- 47:54you want. The next question I have for you is
- 47:57closer to investing because a lot of people will
- 48:01look at investing as that accelerant to being
- 48:04able to have enough money in the timeline that
- 48:07they want to have it. You had described in your
- 48:10book the economy as a functioning alcoholic dependent
- 48:14on cheap money that was just kind of keeping
- 48:17these zombie companies going. For a passive investor,
- 48:20I know a lot of passive investors. I've actually
- 48:22helped a lot of people get into investing and
- 48:24will say, okay, go into these index funds. But
- 48:27you surprised me. You made a point about, hey,
- 48:29look, when you're buying into these index funds,
- 48:32and again, for anyone who doesn't remember, I
- 48:35have a whole episode on this, but index funds
- 48:38are going to be buying into a broad set of stocks,
- 48:41more than one company. You're buying into many
- 48:44companies. But you're knowingly subsidizing some
- 48:47failing companies in this set, very likely, which
- 48:50is weighing down your returns. So that's really
- 48:53interesting. So in a way, you are contributing
- 48:55to keeping zombie companies alive through some
- 48:57of these index funds. Do you feel like people's
- 49:01investment strategies should shift? Or is that
- 49:04just part of the situation we're in? Well, I
- 49:07would say that start by saying there's nothing
- 49:09wrong with index funds and the whole idea and
- 49:12the concept. And in fact, there's for a lot of
- 49:15people, I think it's a very good vehicle. It's
- 49:18not a good vehicle if index funds start to overwhelm
- 49:22the capital allocation mechanism within the markets
- 49:26because you have their price indiscriminate.
- 49:30And so they're not looking around the world for
- 49:33who are the best allocators of capital. They
- 49:36just buy what's going up. Now, I mentioned Michael
- 49:39Green in my book. He talks about how the largest
- 49:42stocks in the index benefit inordinately from
- 49:46passive investing. And the reason is, so if you
- 49:50have 100 bucks goes into a passive fund and Microsoft
- 49:54is 5 % of the index, well, Microsoft gets 5%.
- 49:59of that $100 or $5. But the trouble is, is that
- 50:02the liquidity of the daily trading activity of
- 50:06Microsoft is what they call inelastic compared
- 50:09to the market cap. So the liquidity might not
- 50:12be five times what a stock that's priced at $1
- 50:16is. And so the impact on the share price is much
- 50:20greater when that $5 comes in to buy Microsoft.
- 50:22So anyways, but it doesn't mean people shouldn't
- 50:25buy index funds. I think people should just be
- 50:28aware that a lot of the stocks that they have
- 50:31that they're invested in are very expensive.
- 50:33Yes, they do hold basket case companies in their
- 50:37portfolio. But, you know, for the last 20 years,
- 50:40it hasn't mattered. And it may not matter for
- 50:44the next five or 10 years. If the central bank
- 50:47continues to come storming back by printing money
- 50:51to drive those asset prices higher, so they could
- 50:54continue to benefit from that. But these actions
- 50:57do inordinate harm to the functioning of the
- 51:01economy. It distorts the price discovery mechanism
- 51:04of markets, keeps those zombie companies alive.
- 51:07So companies like Microsoft, they're amazing
- 51:10companies. There's no question about this. It's
- 51:14just... the price that you have to pay for that
- 51:16amazing company keeps going higher and higher
- 51:18and higher. So there's no more, the price is
- 51:21not reflecting more and more capital that's being
- 51:23created. It's reflecting the fact that passive
- 51:26investing and central banks are driving those
- 51:28stock prices higher. Well, and just like the
- 51:30housing market, that's pricing a lot of people
- 51:31out too. No, exactly. Like, yeah, I know a lot
- 51:34of people that my son included finally got interested
- 51:36in investing in some of the stocks he was interested
- 51:38in and couldn't afford. So he felt like it was
- 51:41a barrier, which was kind of sad. In your book,
- 51:44you do outline solutions. You talk about, look,
- 51:47this is even how the system itself could be fixed.
- 51:50Now, of course, myself and listeners, we're not
- 51:52going to be able to fix the Fed, but all we can
- 51:55control is how we live our own lives. Now, of
- 51:58course, educating ourselves is important, but
- 52:00we also need to figure out what personal defense
- 52:02measures we need to put in place for our own
- 52:05financial security. So in a world of fake wealth
- 52:09and zombie companies, how do you see equality
- 52:12as as part of the strategy when it comes to the
- 52:15ultimate safety net. Kinds of things I have in
- 52:17my mind would be things like cash flow and looking
- 52:21for quote unquote, maybe honest money assets
- 52:24like gold. You mentioned gold quite often in
- 52:26the book. Do you look at that, for instance,
- 52:28as a safety net that someone should be putting
- 52:31in a financial freedom plan? So I have gold in
- 52:34my personal portfolio. It's a percentage. Call
- 52:37it my sort of central bank lunacy hedge. And
- 52:40like if they really go nuts, some policymakers
- 52:43will say that financial repression is the only
- 52:45way out of this, which is a really bad thing,
- 52:48by the way. And so you will be financially repressed
- 52:51and the governments will inflate their way out
- 52:54of the debt problem. And if they do that, then
- 52:58having gold would probably be a very good hedge.
- 53:01No guarantees. But... If they don't do that,
- 53:04if they actually try to fix the situation, price
- 53:06of gold could get cut in half very quickly. As
- 53:09part of the solution is what you're saying. Yeah.
- 53:12Well, yeah, because people won't feel that they
- 53:15need as a hedge anymore, that other foreign central
- 53:18banks won't feel that they need to hold gold
- 53:21if they can all of a sudden start trusting the
- 53:23US dollar again. That's the main issue. And so,
- 53:26but I don't know, like I said earlier, which
- 53:29one is going to be. It's not going to hold some
- 53:31gold. I'm not going to like have a whole pile
- 53:33of gold and tell everybody got it. And then,
- 53:35you know, if it doesn't work out that way, oh,
- 53:37you know. And so it's just striking a balance,
- 53:39having diversification, having some real assets,
- 53:42a house, property, have some gold. I've invested
- 53:46in the stock markets. I've got some cash and
- 53:48some high interest savings accounts and stuff
- 53:50like that. Like I'm very defensively postured
- 53:53and my equity investing is through my mutual
- 53:57funds that I used to run. So my team, old team,
- 54:00they're running it. And I know exactly what they're
- 54:03doing. Very high quality companies with strong
- 54:05balance sheets. And that's just me. You know,
- 54:08like I'm a worrywart. I am too. You know, a bit
- 54:12of a worrywart in part because I see what's going
- 54:14on out there. But, you know, you lose hair when
- 54:17you worry. So I used to joke with my clients
- 54:19that the name of our funds was Ivy. So my motto
- 54:23was at Ivy, we lose hair so you don't have to.
- 54:28Yeah, that was great to hear because I, have
- 54:31a very similar defensive posture i look at diversification
- 54:34sure but i also diversify my hedges right and
- 54:39i try to think about how do i imbalance some
- 54:41covariance on each side as far as possible so
- 54:44it's great and i think that's really helpful
- 54:46and useful for the listeners to think about because
- 54:49again can't really change the system outside
- 54:51of understanding the system pushing for and speaking
- 54:54up but doing those kinds of smart moves can help
- 54:57protect stuff. So despite the capital fence that
- 55:01you've outlined so clearly, you did, like I said,
- 55:04come off pretty optimistic. So if we are able
- 55:08as a global society to fix money, what does the
- 55:13future look like? How would we live in a system
- 55:15like that? Well, I think we would thrive. We
- 55:19would thrive if we had honest money, hard money.
- 55:24what you had was only at least a closer approximation
- 55:29of what your contributions were. So first of
- 55:33all, people would be happier because it would
- 55:35be a much fairer system. Wealth inequality would
- 55:38not be nearly as wide as it is today. There would
- 55:43still be wealth inequality as there should be
- 55:46because it's based on your efforts and your contributions.
- 55:50Your bike shop, you make 10 bikes a week and
- 55:53I decide, well, I only want to make one suit
- 55:55a week because I'd rather goof off or whatever,
- 55:57then you should have more wealth than me. But
- 56:00it's not coming at my expense, right? There would
- 56:03be much less debt. The price discovery mechanism
- 56:06of capital markets would no longer be distorted.
- 56:10And so you would have much more efficient allocation
- 56:13of capital. There would be way more stuff being
- 56:16produced, way more innovation. Companies would
- 56:19be encouraged. to invest in their businesses
- 56:22rather than their share price. Rather than taking
- 56:25on debt and buying back shares to drive the share
- 56:28price higher, they would use that capital more
- 56:31in their own business. And again, don't get me
- 56:33wrong, there's still lots of great things going
- 56:35on in corporate America, but there's a lot of
- 56:38bad things going on too, and a lot of bad incentives.
- 56:42I think Charlie Munger used to say, he was Warren
- 56:44Buffett's sidekick, you know, show me the incentive,
- 56:46I'll tell you the behavior, whatever. I got one
- 56:49quick story. And it's just an example of what
- 56:51it's all about. This is capitalism. This is like
- 56:54where all the constituents benefit. People think
- 56:58like success is just the senior executives and
- 57:01the shareholders benefiting. Well, if that's
- 57:03what's happening, that business model is not
- 57:04going to last very long. And that's what you
- 57:06see out there often. But there's a lot more of
- 57:09the other stuff going on. So Fastenal, they're
- 57:11based in Minnesota. They make fasteners, screws
- 57:13and stuff and distribute them and stuff to them.
- 57:14So not the most exciting business. We went to
- 57:17visit the plant. We had a tour of the plant.
- 57:20And they're so excited. The plant managers, check
- 57:22out these screws. Our clients love us. And what
- 57:24the hell's going on here, you know? And so I
- 57:27asked the guy, I said, why do you love the business
- 57:29so much? And he said, well, it's management,
- 57:31ownership. They treat us like partners. They
- 57:34ask for our opinions. And it's not just lip service.
- 57:37They implement a lot of our ideas. And importantly,
- 57:40they all share in the success of the business.
- 57:43The more profitable the business is, Everybody
- 57:46benefits. That's the way it's supposed to be.
- 57:48So then he said, oh, I forgot to tell you. There's
- 57:51a great example. So the CEO was the founder.
- 57:54He owned about a third of the company. His wife
- 57:56also had a good stake in the business. She'd
- 57:58passed away a few years earlier. After she passed
- 58:01away, the CEO took all of her shares and distributed
- 58:05them to all the employees in your company. Wow.
- 58:08That's what it's about, right? And founders are
- 58:11often this way because You know, he started the
- 58:14business from the ground up. So he did every
- 58:17job that everyone in that company is doing now.
- 58:19So he's got more empathy for what they may be
- 58:22going through. And, you know, versus you get
- 58:26these career executives, again, not bad people.
- 58:28And I've met some amazing career executives,
- 58:30but they're more financially driven. Right. They've
- 58:33never had to start a business. They don't know
- 58:35what it's like to be in the back, sweeping the
- 58:37floor and closing the shop up at the end of the
- 58:39night and committing your own capital and worry
- 58:42about it. But if you have honest money and you
- 58:46don't have the threat of central banks bailing
- 58:50out bad decisions, then you're going to have
- 58:53more companies like Fastenal sharing in the benefits.
- 58:57Yeah, I think it would just be amazing. Because
- 59:00then human spirit and kindness and empathy and
- 59:03ingenuity just takes care of the rest. You just
- 59:06have to provide the playing field. Imagine if
- 59:10the markets just rewarded those behaviors by
- 59:12default, the kind of world we'd be in, that'd
- 59:15be amazing. Yeah, no. Well, thank you so much,
- 59:18Paul. This has been a longer conversation, but
- 59:21every moment of it was really insightful. I appreciate
- 59:25you putting yourself out there and helping us
- 59:27understand some of these things in more detail.
- 59:30How can listeners connect with you and get your
- 59:32book, Capital Offense? Yeah, well, thank you,
- 59:35Daniel, for having me. Very good conversation.
- 59:38So my book is called Capital Offense, Why Some
- 59:41Benefit at Your Expense. And you can order online
- 59:45at Amazon, Barnes & Noble, Thrift Books. The
- 59:49odd store has it on the shelf, but not many.
- 59:52And there should be an audible version available
- 59:55very soon. We've already submitted it. So I'm
- 59:58hopeful that that will be out soon. And then
- 1:00:00my website, you can access it in two ways, Paddington
- 1:00:04Capital. MGMT .com or PaulLyticalEconomy. So
- 1:00:11my name, PaulLyticalEconomy .com. And there you
- 1:00:16can put your email in and subscribe to my free
- 1:00:21blog. It comes out usually on late in the day
- 1:00:23on Monday. And so I talk a lot about this stuff,
- 1:00:27talk about what's going on in the economy, try
- 1:00:29to keep it fun. And again, I use no financial
- 1:00:33fancy words and keep jargon and keep it simple.
- 1:00:37And so trying to democratize all of this so people
- 1:00:42who are not in the industry can participate and
- 1:00:44have a voice. We really appreciate that. And
- 1:00:47I'll make sure all of that's in the show notes
- 1:00:48for folks to find as well. Thanks again, Paul,
- 1:00:51for coming on Escape the Clock. Really appreciate
- 1:00:52it. Well, thanks, Daniel. It was great. In my
- 1:00:59conversation with Paul Musson, what jumped out
- 1:01:01to me was the fundamental distinction that he
- 1:01:04drew between money and capital. We tend to use
- 1:01:06these words interchangeably. Paul made it very
- 1:01:09clear that these things are distinct. Capital
- 1:01:11is the productive value that we create, the bikes
- 1:01:15that we build, the services we provide. While
- 1:01:18money is just the tool we use to exchange it,
- 1:01:20this distortion though, it happens when we print
- 1:01:23more money. Because without creating more capital,
- 1:01:26it creates an illusion of wealth. It is actually
- 1:01:28a hidden tax on our savings. That hidden tax,
- 1:01:31that really hurts our ability to achieve the
- 1:01:34freedom that we're working so hard for. This
- 1:01:36became most painfully clear when we discussed
- 1:01:38the housing market. We've all been conditioned
- 1:01:40to celebrate when our home values skyrocket.
- 1:01:43But as Paul pointed out with his example of his
- 1:01:45own home, that it went up 4x in value without
- 1:01:48doing any improvements, just by simply living
- 1:01:51in it. But there wasn't any wealth creation.
- 1:01:53That was wealth redistribution. and we're essentially
- 1:01:56locking in gains at the expense of the next generation,
- 1:02:00who are now priced out of the life that we ourselves
- 1:02:03have enjoyed. It is a heavy realization to accept
- 1:02:05that our good investment might actually be contributing
- 1:02:08to the very inequality that we worry about. We
- 1:02:11also touched on the paradox of thrift. The system
- 1:02:14is currently designed to punish prudence. If
- 1:02:16we choose to save, the central banks are incentivized
- 1:02:19to print money to force consumption, devaluing
- 1:02:22the labor we stored away. It feels like we're
- 1:02:24running on a treadmill, where the speed keeps
- 1:02:27increasing just to stay in place. Paul mentioned
- 1:02:30his personal defense against this, what he calls
- 1:02:33his central bank lunacy hedge. Allocating a percentage
- 1:02:37of his portfolio to gold, not to get rich, but
- 1:02:41to ensure against policy errors. Diversification.
- 1:02:44We talk about it a lot, but honestly, in the
- 1:02:47system we're in, you have to do it. Without protecting
- 1:02:50the wealth, there's no way. that we can be sure
- 1:02:54that we'll have any peace of mind. But perhaps
- 1:02:56the most critical insight that he shared was
- 1:02:59one that we've touched on many times on the show.
- 1:03:01He shared a story about a widow, and it was a
- 1:03:04stark reminder that while we're building all
- 1:03:07of this wealth and we're trying to protect it
- 1:03:09and always worried and obsessing over the future,
- 1:03:12we can't forget to live today. We have to strike
- 1:03:15a balance between preparing for the worst economic
- 1:03:17seasons and enjoying the best seasons of our
- 1:03:20lives. As always, I want to hear from you. Does
- 1:03:23the distinction between money and capital change
- 1:03:25how you view your own savings? And are you treating
- 1:03:29your home as an investment or a consumption expense?
- 1:03:32Leave your response where you listen or email
- 1:03:34me at contact at escape the clock dot com. Thanks
- 1:03:37as always for listening. Best of luck beating
- 1:03:39the system and escaping the clock. I'll catch
- 1:03:42you next week. Thanks for tuning in to this episode.
- 1:03:47Remember, while I'm not yet a financial planner,
- 1:03:49I am getting my degree in wealth management.
- 1:03:51You should take anything you've heard here as
- 1:03:53tips and advice to making your plan. To learn
- 1:03:56more, visit www .escapetheclock .com. There you
- 1:04:00can find the book, resources, including the planner,
- 1:04:03and you can even schedule time with me. Please
- 1:04:05remember to like and subscribe so you don't miss
- 1:04:07an episode. Thanks for tuning in and I'll catch
- 1:04:09you next time.