Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / Managing the Employee Who Says I Need More Time
Transcript
- Lucas: So Luna, I had a conversation last week that reminded me of a pattern I see all the time in management: the employee who, on every single task, says, 'I need more time.' Luna: Oh, that's a classic. It's like they're not saying no, they're just perpetually asking for a later deadline. Lucas: Exactly. And it's a tricky one because sometimes they genuinely do need more time. But when it becomes a pattern, you have to ask: is this about the workload, the skill level, or something else entirely? Luna: Right, because if it's always 'I need more time,' you never actually get to the root cause. You're just in a loop of renegotiating deadlines. Lucas: So let's drill into that. I want to share a framework I've used and a real example from a friend who manages a small software team. Let's call the developer Alex. Luna: Okay, Alex. What's the story? Lucas: So Alex was a solid engineer, but every story he picked up would come back with a request for an extra day or two. Not huge asks, just enough to push everything back. And it was happening on almost every single ticket. Luna: That sounds exhausting for the manager and probably the whole team, since it affects everyone's planning. Lucas: Right. So the manager tried the obvious things first: clearer requirements, smaller tickets, more check-ins. Nothing really changed. That's when I suggested they try a simple diagnostic. Luna: What did you suggest? Lucas: I told them to ask Alex two questions the next time he asked for more time. First: 'What specifically is taking longer than you expected?' And second: 'What would you need to feel confident about the new deadline?' Luna: That's smart. It forces them to move from vague to specific. If they can't articulate what's taking longer, that tells you something. Lucas: Exactly. And when they asked Alex, they found out he was spending a lot of time on a particular part of the codebase he wasn't familiar with. He was trying to figure it out on his own instead of asking for help. Luna: So it was a skill issue, not a time issue. He didn't need more time; he needed support or training. Lucas: That's exactly right. And once they knew that, they could pair him with a senior dev for that specific area, and the 'I need more time' requests dropped off dramatically. Luna: That's a nice, concrete outcome. But I'm guessing not every case is that clean. Sometimes it's not about skill; it might be about motivation or even just a habit of overestimating. Lucas: No, you're right. And that's where the second part of the framework comes in. You have to look at the pattern over time. Is it across all tasks or just certain types? Is it always the same amount of extra time? That gives you clues. Luna: So if it's always exactly one extra day, that might be a habit rather than a genuine need. Lucas: Yes. One of the things I've found useful is to ask the employee to track their time for a week. Not as a punishment, but just to see where the time actually goes. That often reveals surprises. Luna: Time tracking can feel a bit Big Brother, though. How do you present it so it doesn't feel like a threat? Lucas: You frame it as a learning exercise. You say, 'I want to understand your workload better so I can help you prioritize. Would you be open to tracking your time for a week so we can look at it together?' It's a collaborative thing. Luna: That makes sense. And I imagine when you see the data, it might show that they're spending two hours a day on emails or something. Lucas: Exactly. Once you have the data, you can have an honest conversation about where time is going and what might be worth delegating or deprioritizing. Luna: Yeah, that's the ideal. And I think it's also worth acknowledging that sometimes 'I need more time' is a legitimate ask. The key is to distinguish between a genuine need and a default reflex. Lucas: That's the heart of it. And I think part of the manager's job is to create an environment where people feel they can ask for more time without judgment, but also where they understand the impact on the team. Luna: So how do you set that expectation without making people afraid to speak up? Lucas: You make it part of the initial planning conversation. When you assign a task, you say, 'Here's the deadline. If you think you'll need more time, let me know as early as possible, and we'll talk about it.' That way, it's not a surprise at the last minute. Luna: And that also gives you the chance to ask, 'What's driving the need for more time?' before it becomes a crisis. Lucas: Exactly. And you know, this is such a common issue that we've talked about a lot on this show. We've covered employees who overcommit, employees who say 'I'll get to it,' and today we're digging into the 'I need more time' pattern. Luna: And if you're finding these conversations helpful, we just want to remind you that we keep this show ad-free, and that's thanks to listeners who support us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a small way to help us keep doing this. Lucas: Yeah, we really appreciate that. It means we can focus on the content and not on selling you anything. So thanks for that, and let's get back to the 'I need more time' challenge. Lucas: So, one more tool that I've found effective is the '5 Whys' technique. It's from the lean manufacturing world, but it works well for this. You keep asking 'why' until you hit the root cause. Luna: Can you give an example? How would that play out with an employee who says they need more time? Lucas: Sure. So employee says, 'I need two more days on this report.' You ask, 'Why?' They say, 'Because the data from the sales team is incomplete.' You ask, 'Why is it incomplete?' And you keep going. Eventually, you might find that the sales team doesn't have a clear process for submitting data, which is the real issue. Luna: So instead of just granting the extension, you solve a systemic problem that might affect other projects too. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the thing: when 'I need more time' becomes a pattern, it's rarely just about one task. There's usually an underlying issue, whether it's a process gap, a skill gap, or a motivation issue. Luna: And I guess it's on the manager to be curious rather than annoyed. That's easier said than done, though, when you're under pressure. Lucas: Absolutely. And that's why having a framework helps. It gives you a script to follow, so you don't fall into the habit of just saying 'okay, fine, take the extra day' and then seething about it later. Luna: Right. And if you find that it's genuinely a motivation issue, what do you do then? Because that's a harder conversation. Lucas: It is. If you've ruled out workload and skill, and it seems like they're just not engaged, you need to have a direct conversation about performance. You can say, 'I've noticed you've been asking for more time on several tasks. I'm concerned about the impact on the team. Is there something going on that we should talk about?' Luna: That opens the door for them to share what's happening, whether it's burnout, personal issues, or a lack of interest in the work. Lucas: And sometimes it's a fit issue. They might be in a role that doesn't play to their strengths. In that case, you might work with them to find a better fit within the company, or if it's just not working, you have to manage that out. Luna: But that's the last resort, I hope. Most of the time, you can fix it with better communication and support. Lucas: Yes, and that's the takeaway. When an employee says 'I need more time,' don't just take it at face value. Use it as a signal to dig deeper, understand the root cause, and then address it together. Luna: And that's how you turn a recurring stress point into a productive conversation about resources, priorities, and growth. Lucas: So next time you hear those four words, remember: it's not a request, it's a clue. And you're the detective. Good luck out there.