Latest / First Encounter—A Historical Romance Podcast / S1 E12—The Bride by Julie Garwood with Jen Prokop
Transcript
- Andie James: Hello everyone and welcome to First Encounter. I am Andie James, a historical romance enthusiast and author. And I'm very excited for today's episode because we have a very special guest. guest today is Jen Prokop, who many of you know is half of the dynamic duo behind Fated Mates. and she's I don't know, you've been I I know. jen: So funny. Well, I've been, you know, romance for a long time, Andie. Andie James: Yeah. Romance for a long time because I know you've well, I don't know if I guess reviewed for a long, long time. Yeah. jen: Well Well, yeah, I mean, I've been reviewing for a decade for sure. Like I was trying to think kinda think back on that. And then I started reviewing for the Book Queen, who's still on like Blue Sky and maybe threads. and then ⁓ but I mean I I mean, I've been reading long enough that this book probably I read when it was like new. ⁓ You know? So Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Like. yeah, yeah. No. Jen's been reading romance forever. If you listen to Fated Mates you know that. famously found, you know, grandma's stock of yeah, the bag of books. So ⁓ yeah. jen: Bag of books, man. You know, whatever comes after podcasts will be a bunch of young people being like, Yeah, I found them in the little free library, right? Andie James: Yeah. Yeah, yeah. No, totally, totally. And I think I mean, I personally am part of a group that I know I'm not alone in where it was really COVID for me because I just needed a happy escape and I started reading romance and then I never turned back. ⁓ I did. I did. But it wasn't like what I actively read. Like, I mean, I Yeah, yeah. It was like the occasional I mean, I was much more a jen: Yeah. So you didn't read romance at all before COVID? Yeah. Okay. Sure. It was just like part of your reading diet. Andie James: historical fiction, lit fic, occasional mystery type person. ⁓ and there'd be times where I just like kind of was like, ⁓ I really want a romance. And I did read few ⁓ and there in high school, you know, and they were very much kind of these old school historicals that I found in like a secondhand bookshop. ⁓ so it was fun reading this, ⁓ I haven't even said today. I mean I introduced this before, but everyone, what we're discussing today. jen: Mm-hmm. Right. Mm-hmm. Andie James: The Bride by Julie Garwood, which is a classic that I had never read. ⁓ I we rectified that. ⁓ ⁓ ⁓ think I looked it up and it said nineteen eighty nine. Does that sound right to you? Okay. Okay. ⁓ some reason Yeah. ⁓ some reason in my head, I had Julie Garwood because like, I mean, she is kind of a mother of the genre, you know, she's jen: Yeah. Yeah. What year did this come out? I meant to look it up. Did you look it up? Yeah, I was I was say that that sounds about right. I would have said like late eight like eighty nine, ninety one kind of in that era. Yeah. Yeah, one of the four J's a few so yeah. The yeah. Andie James: And I yeah, the Jays. I've heard you talk about that. And so I guess in my head I was thinking this was gonna be like seventies. And so I was like I was thinking it was older than that. I guess I was thinking more like Judith McNaught, you know? jen: Well, I mean, so it's interesting. So like everybody, the four J's were Judith McNaught, Julie Garwood, Devereux ⁓ ⁓ Joanna Lindsay. And were like four historical romance authors who basically were most of them writing, I would say like like in the eighties to nineties, ⁓ you kind of the Fabio years, ⁓ in some ways for some of those authors more than others. Andie James: ⁓ huh. Yes. Okay. Yes. Yeah. jen: And you know, this was a time of like I mean, there was like category romance, right? And then there were like the big standalone books were historical. and these would have been, you know, you bought at the grocery store and, you know, check you know, like that like the mass market paperback size. And, ⁓ know, and I would say like ⁓ take on this is that if you were reading back then and you reading historical. Andie James: Yes. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Right. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. jen: ⁓ you would probably have favorites among those. ⁓ like for me, I definitely read all of those authors. But I was definitely a Julie Gartwood girl, and I really also love Jude Devereux. ⁓ but it's funny Andie James: Mm-hmm. Mm. Which is Jude Devereaux is also Judith Ivory. Is that correct? No. She's Judy Cuevas and Judith Ivory. Okay, sorry. Sorry. Yeah. jen: No, ⁓ Judith Ivory is different. Yes, right, right, who is also a J, but didn't produce as much. I mean, I think Judith Ivory has a handful of books. I mean, Julie Garwood and I mean Judith McNaught, for sure, Joanna Lindsay were just like producing at a at a pretty, you know, probably a book a year or you know, at least or whatever, which would have been really fast at the time. so, you know, and for so yeah, I but it's funny because I don't Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Right. jen: reread a lot of the Jude Deveraux I reread still some Garwoods, like are really hardwired into me. Yeah. Andie James: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah. that ⁓ makes sense because I so when I ⁓ started the podcast, so you know, like six months ago. We're very new, but I reached out to Jen as one of the people saying, Hey, would you be willing to, you know, do an episode with me? And I was like, You we can d you can discuss whatever you want. ⁓ Whatever you Like I just would love to have you on because jen: Mm. No pressure. Andie James: I guess I don't know if I need to disclaimer this or not, but I have worked with Jen before as an editor. She helped me do some developmental editing on my first series. So that's how I got to know her. other than of course listening to her like weekly. So ⁓ I her, whether or not she knows me, but Yeah, but I reached out to Jen ⁓ 'cause I knew I wanted to have you be one of my guests if you were if you were able. And ⁓ jen: Ha ha. Andie James: You know, you were like, Well, who are you thinking? And I gave her a list and she was like, Ooh, Julie Garwood. Let's do that. But no, I loved it. This was, ⁓ think ⁓ was my first Garwood, but I don't know. Yeah, because the overwhelming feeling I got when reading this book, I guess I would say. first all, I loved it. I mean, ⁓ I jen: Yeah, like let's do it. Right. Well yeah, sure. I mean that's the other thing. You're like, Have I read this author before? Who knows? Right? Yeah. Yeah. I I would wor I mean, I would listen, I I would worry about you if you didn't, right? I mean there are definitely things about it we'll talk about that are different, right? I mean like, you know, kind of structurally, like narratively, whatever. But like it's a banger, you know. Andie James: If I didn't. Yeah. Yeah. No, it was we'll talk about it. Yeah. Yes. Yes. It's great. but it's ⁓ because ⁓ throw to the very intro episode if anyone listened to that, and maybe you can help me with this, Jen. But I was saying, you know, kind of how I did ⁓ read occasionally ⁓ read book like this, ⁓ back in high school. And There's one that has stuck with me, but I couldn't tell you the title. I couldn't tell you who wrote it. I couldn't tell you the main plot. But the there's this I know. I know. But there's this scene that has stuck with me. ⁓ it basically like I the reason bringing it up now, because as I was reading this, I was like, my god, maybe that book was a Garwood. Like, I don't I don't know. But like jen: Like every romance reader has their white whale for sure, right? Yeah, maybe. Andie James: It was similar set I I'm sure it was similar in terms of like setting time period. Maybe not time period, but it was very much kind of like the Scottish guy had taken the woman and brought him back and whatever, right? I don't think it was like a kidnapping situation, but it wasn't like a she to marry him kind of situation. ⁓ But had basically like sequestered her once they reached ⁓ his ⁓ because couldn't sleep with her until she bled. I mean, hello, we have to make sure, right, that she's not carrying a child, or if she is, it's his, right? I remember this, he like came to visit her in her room as she's like shut away, right? Nothing there. but he like ⁓ sharing a with her and he had her like sit on his lap and he was like feeding her and stuff. jen: Right. ⁓ yeah. Mm-hmm. Andie James: And then it was dessert and there was like these little candies. And he's like, which one's your favorite? And she was like, lemon. And he was like, ⁓ let's figure out which one's lemon, which obviously he knew. But he like put them in his mouth and then he kissed her so they could like share it and taste it together until they finally got to lemon. ⁓ that just like stuck with me. ⁓ ⁓ jen: Mm. Like stuck with you. Yeah. I don't you know what? I'm gonna tell you, I don't think that's Garwood. Only because like the first part of it. I feel like given I mean it could be anybody, right? Like the thing is is like that kind of thing could be anybody. But I would say like I feel like that's got like a little more Johanna Lindsay in it. ⁓ But, know. Andie James: Probably not. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Right. Maybe, maybe. But the reason I bring that up, right? a reason for my crazy ⁓ as I was reading this, ⁓ even though I've not read a ton of books from this era or are set kind of in that medieval Scotland, ⁓ like read some, but not a lot. Like it's not the main thing I read, but there was something that felt so familiar about this, right? ⁓ That that book could have fit. jen: Mm-hmm. Andie James: into this. And so it was kind of like, ⁓ you you can school me on this, but I don't know if this is something that Garwood helped create ⁓ kind of world, or she was just writing into it. But it strikes the way that we kind of write Regencies now a little bit, where it's kind of like just these standard conventions that you know this world. jen: ⁓ Yeah. I mean, I think like that's the thing about I mean, this is why, like like ⁓ read every iteration of it, and then you get back to like the OG one, and you're like, this is where it comes from, right? ⁓ And yeah, I mean, I don't know if I would I mean, now I would say like the thing about these old Scotland Highlander historicals, like there are plenty of people writing them. ⁓ I think one of the things I would say is like for me. ⁓ Andie James: Yeah. Right. Right. Yeah. Hm. Yes. Yes. jen: Garwood is outside, ⁓ when you like on the reread of what I would consider like the bodice ripper, right? Like ⁓ like you're you're not getting a lot of sense that like ⁓ Alec for you know, he's not forcing her or right. Like so ⁓ I think other thing about like sort of what's happening here is you're seeing like the evolution of like kind of when you read it, you're like, ⁓ yeah, I see how it's like old school, but also like the Andie James: Mm-hmm. Yes. Yeah. No, no, not at all. jen: seeds of what has become kind of contemporary like romance mores, right? The way that like the characters sort of interact with each other, like, you know, the power of you know, the importance of like love as being the thing that's gonna determine the HEA, like when they can say that to each other, right? Like things like that. ⁓ I think it's also like so some of that exists. I think the way that it's old school is, you know, sort of the reliance on like an outside external plot. Andie James: Yeah. Yes, yes. Well. Right. Right. jen: Right to sort of drive like a f a final crisis, right? Like you're like, what's keeping the tension up in this book in terms of right? They're super into each other from the beginning. And yet we keep reading. so I think like there's ways in which, like, yeah, that doesn't surprise me at all that you would read this and feel like, ⁓ this is familiar to me, right? So I don't know, you know, I think Garwood was like one of many people writing like sort of the Scottish Highlander. Andie James: Yeah. Uh-huh. Yeah. Right, right. Yeah. Right. Yeah. Yeah. jen: I think like the real thing that Garwood brings to the table though is humor. This is like a funny fucking book. You know? And I think like that's the part. Like it's truly like their banter, like sort of like, you know, like the the way like the the like running gag about how she's always in the like can't find her way out of a paper bag. You know what I mean? Like how bad she is with directions, right? And, you know, the thing about how she has a man's name. Andie James: Yes. Yeah, it is. It is. Yeah, yeah. Terrible sense of direction, always. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. jen: You know, that like she's kind of convinced everybody's putting her you know, him ⁓ her up you know, he's putting everybody up to like sort of joking with her about that. ⁓ I mean, I think like that's the other thing though is like for me, like these this is like an example of a like a really joyful ⁓ joyful, really fun book to read, right? Andie James: Yes. Jamie. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. jen: So one of the other big differences though, well, I mean, so like plot wise, if people haven't read it, right? I mean, I don't know, like kind of tip your typical structure, yeah. Yeah, I think this is you know, it's funny. I think like this is a book that's a very hard to discuss without like spoilers intent, because like to me it has like one of this has some really great super memorable scenes. Andie James: Yeah, we should recap a little. Spoilers ahead if you haven't read it. I mean, it goes without saying, but Yeah. jen: Right. Like you were talking at the beginning about like the candy, right? Like I think one of the things about like whether or not a book, you know, like kind of lives on is like how memorable can make it, you And I think like that's why like there's so many things in this book that I think of as being I think of as being like really super memorable outside of like the plot, which as you said is like pretty basic, right? Like, ⁓ you Jamie's father is of this like deadbeat, he hasn't paid his taxes. Andie James: Yeah. Right. Yeah. Yeah. Welling your kid, yeah. jen: And so to punish him, right, the king is like, you gotta marry off one of your daughters. know, and he's also punishing the Highlanders, you gotta marry some of these English ladies. I'm gonna like tie tie all you people together. And in comes Alec Kincade like right riding his horse, a giant a man, right? And ⁓ she the beautiful of these four, you daughters, but also. ⁓ You know, the thing is the way in which she's like a very old school heroine is even though she's very close to her sister, she's also this like loner, She's like really ⁓ like other girls kind of vibe, right? Like she works harder, she's prettier, she knows how you know how to do all these things, she's stubborn, she ⁓ have any fear, right? Like all of that stuff. ⁓ ⁓ exactly. And then I think like the part that's actually really funny to me ⁓ Andie James: Yeah. She's very different from her sisters. Yeah. Yeah. Yes. Yes. ⁓ huh. Mm-hmm. Yeah. The healer, like. jen: She has befriended like the stable master, this old Scottish man named Yeah, named Beak, who ⁓ taught her Gaelic ⁓ she does not tell ⁓ this, right? She doesn't tell Alec this. And so, like another really funny, like kind of running gag is that ⁓ can understand everything they're talking about all the time, right? ⁓ and you know, off they go. Off go to Scotland, right? Andie James: Yes, I was gonna talk about him. Peak. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. jen: Where you know, her job is just gonna be to like be his wife. what she does instead, of course, is disrupt his entire clan. And it's great. ⁓ when you were reading this, what I mean, how did you feel in terms of like like was that like for you? I've read it so many times. It's just like taking a bath for me. Andie James: Course. Yeah. It's wonderful. Yeah. I know. Yeah, I know. It's interesting. Well, you know, I had there there were we'll talk about it, but there were a couple moments where I'm like, yep, this was written in eighty nine. Mm-hmm. You know, and but it was it was fine. Like there was nothing that was like there was eyebrow raises. There was nothing like truly offensive. I will say that. jen: ⁓ yeah, sure. Yeah. That's not true by the way of all of Garwood's books, right? Like there are some that there's like one in particular where it's like really like demonizing a gay character or I can't exactly remember. Or like the you know what I mean? In a way that is like really offensive, you know? And so I think like this book does, I think, along with some of the other ones, like really, you know, thread the needle without it being, you know. Andie James: I'm sure it's not. Yeah. Yeah. Uh-huh. Mm, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah, but I enjoyed I mean, I think the setup for this was very much kind of the culture clash between them, right? How are these two gonna kind of find common ground, reconcile, come to understand each other? I it's funny because you mentioned, you know, how he's like the big huge man riding on his horse and she's the most beautiful and ⁓ one thing that ⁓ found that made me really appreciate just her jen: Mm-hmm. Sure. Andie James: writing prowess, right? Garwood's skill as a writer is, I mean, there are some really stereotypical characters in here, right? Like you have just total archetypes in Jamie and Alec, and also some of the side characters. Like her sister Mary is just kind of the like, ⁓ weepy, know, English woman who can't handle anything. And you know, so mean she very much leans into the stereotypes, ⁓ but never found it jen: Mm-hmm. Yes. ⁓ yeah. Andie James: Too much. I was never like going, ⁓ yeah, this is corny because it's so like she made it work, even though of course she's the most beautiful woman. And of course he's like this ⁓ giant who ⁓ is as the Kincaid because he's such a fierce warrior. And you know, like it's all ⁓ right? Everything you would expect, but it doesn't ever fall into anything jen: Right. Andie James: Like it's still a serious book and I was taking it seriously. and so yeah, I really enjoyed it. it took me a minute. You said we'll talk structural stuff, but like ⁓ it me a minute. I obviously have read books where they had ha head hop before. ⁓ but this one ⁓ was lot from the very beginning. And I just it just took me a moment to get into it. But I did, you know, it was fine. ⁓ yeah. jen: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah, so everybody like what that means is like, you know, we're really common, we're really used right now to like really like strong delineations when point of view switches. Right. It's if it's not chapter by chapter, if it's like kind of mid chapter, usually we'll get like sort of a set of, you know, like some sort of diar like some asterisks or whatever on the page, right? To like sort of indicate. Right. There is right, it's like a scene break. And in this book, it is completely fluid. Andie James: Yes, thank you. Yes. Yeah. Yeah. It is a scene break for me when I'm writing. Yeah. ⁓ huh. Very fluid. Mm-hmm. jen: Right. I mean, you could have s not even just like paragraph by paragraph, sentence by sentence, and even to the point where occasionally there's a drift into like the point of view of like a side character, right? So Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Yes. I was gonna say that was the thing, is it's not so much if it was just Alec and Jamie, like that like I get it. Like we we're just we've softened what we do today, right? like it goes in like it I think chapter one starts from her father's point of view, Baron Jamison. ⁓ then later in that chapter, you know, after we've you know, the sisters are freaking out because one of them's gonna have to marry Scott, you know. jen: Mm-hmm. Right, right. Mm-hmm. Andie James: ⁓ she goes to the stable, and we talked about this stable master, right? And it goes into Beak's head and then it goes into her sister's head sometimes. And like, you know, so it took me a second because it was so ⁓ and fluid, like you said, but it didn't bother me one. I it didn't bother me. Like I did have to adjust, but like a couple pages, I was like, okay. And yeah. jen: Uh-huh. Yeah. Yeah, it's interesting. I mean, I think like in terms of like what it achieves, right, is like there's no s I mean so like one of the things Sarah says all the time on the podcast, and something I often say now to like authors when I'm editing, like you're choosing if a scene isn't working, try switching the point of view, right, to the other character. But also that you like Andie James: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Right. jen: intuitively like sort of be steering towards like who's the character that has the most to lose in any given scene, right? So because you're really showing like the person who's carrying the most in the scene, right? Like thing that they have the most to lose, the most to worry about, whatever. I think like what headhopping, right? Which again, we like say it's bad, and I get that it's out of fashion, but like when you read this book, Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. jen: What it allows you to do is actually like sort of have moments where you're like, okay, at this moment they both have something to lose or gain, or right, or there is a secondary character who has an observation that cannot be made by one of the two characters about what is happening between them. And so it just allows you to really like it's and and I would also say like the other difference that I think that this has is Andie James: Yes. Yeah. jen: the point of view overall is not as close, right? And I think that's why, because you're gonna at a moment's notice be able to sort of drift out of it into someone else's point of view. So I think that also takes a little bit of getting used to, right? Sort of the like interiority that we sometimes expect in like a modern kind of romance now. ⁓ don't quite get the same amount of. Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah. I mean it's there, but it's yeah, it's not yeah, it's almost more of an overview like you're almost watching a film, ⁓ know? Like I mean, maybe that's not the same, but it's it's like ⁓ observing the story than feeling like you're in ⁓ ⁓ don't know if that makes sense. jen: ⁓ of course, of course. Well, I mean, I think listen, I would say this. I would say if you especially only read in first person, going to third is people say feels ⁓ you know, awkward or weird to them. And now we're like a little bit even more distant. I d I don't personally think that it is I I like see what you're saying, but what I would say is like there is no way Julie Garwood had any idea that anybody reading these books was like thinking, ⁓ yes, I am like Jamie. Andie James: I don't know. Yeah. Yeah. Mm-hmm. no, I wasn't trying to imply that. I wasn't trying to imply that. Yeah. Yeah. jen: Right? Like there and that I th no, no, I know, but I think some people do really like we talk a lot about like the self-insert reader. It is interesting. And I'm just saying, like, there's no expectation that that's what's happening. You are you are reading about these two people who lived a thousand years ago or whatever. Right. And so it isn't think that's part of like what that distance is there because there's no sense that ⁓ is trying to Andie James: Yeah, the self insert's interesting. I don't know. Mm-hmm. Right. Right. Yeah. Yes. Yeah. jen: the author, Garwood is not trying to get you to think like, yes, what would I do here? Right? Or I'm like Jamie, no, you're not. ⁓ is you know what I mean. ⁓ I think like I do think that you're right. It feels that way. And that's because it's not trying to do something that modern romance readers expect or d demand, maybe. Andie James: Right. Right. Yeah. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Right. Right. Right. Yeah. No, I well, it's funny though, because I I was trying to think, and maybe you have a better idea of this, of like when the transition into kind of sh point of view shifts kind of started to happen. Because I feel like you know, thinking about romance specifically because I there's ⁓ there's a couple series that I read that are still they're they're well, one's finished now, but they're like current. And they do this all the time. So I don't know if that's like ⁓ jen: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. When did this happen in romance? Yeah, I would say, listen, I would say guess is around the twenty ten ⁓ of it, right? I mean, I think like fifty shades of gray, my guess is probably had to do I mean, ⁓ I'm saying this only like I'm trying to like purse I don't have like a real hard and fast feeling, but like ⁓ you think about ⁓ of course, but I mean if you think about like Immortals After Dark, which is like what the whole first season of the podcast was. ⁓ Andie James: Wow. Yeah. Yeah. Well yeah. No. I mean I don't think it it didn't happen like this is when, you know, but yeah. Right. Right. jen: You would often get like lots of different points of view as you're advancing like sort of lots of stories at the same time. but then you get sort of the like fifty shades of it all. And I can't even remember, is that single point of view? Is that only Anastasia? ⁓ think it might be. I'm not sure. I don't Yeah, that's right. Cause then there's like, isn't there a book that's like Christian's point of view? And so then you get people sort of like really and like I think Andie James: Mm-hmm. I think it might be. I think it I think it might be. Yeah. jen: Often, listen, this is not a hard and fast it always works rule, but I would say, you know, as late as think there's like transitional points, but like sometimes if you think about like a really big book, you can either see that it is like reflecting a big change that has happened or causes the big change to happen afterwards. And ⁓ Andie James: All right. Right. Right. Yeah. jen: I could easily think of books in the early parts of the two thousands. It still had like sort of some head hop head hopping. ⁓ but my guess is by like twenty ten it was sort of it had sort of changed. Yeah. Andie James: Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I mean that that makes sense to me. I don't know. It's interesting. But yeah, I think ⁓ now, you know, at least in romance, it's it's not I'm not gonna say it's never done, but it's just not the thing. ⁓ But I know, which I don't think is true. Yeah. ⁓ Yeah. jen: No, I mean people think it's like a hallmark of bad writing. And I would also say, here's n well, of course not, right? I mean here's the thing I'd also say. I also think my feeling is it has to do with the rise of first person in romance, right? Which because you can't head hop if you're in first person. I mean that I mean, you know, welcome to the three faces of Eve, I guess. But, ⁓ you know, think that Andie James: Yeah. ⁓ for sure. Yeah. You can't, you know. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. jen: that's the other thing that happened. So I think like there were kind of movements and shifts happening and then right? Andie James: Yeah. Yeah, it's interesting because I obviously this this podcast is focused on historicals and that's what I write. And I feel like we're still main ⁓ of romance genre still fiercely holding on to third. jen: And and I love you for it. Andie James: Yeah yeah. ⁓ but yeah. jen: 'Cause I find I find I find first sometimes very tiring. Like I'm just like just tell me a story. I don't wanna be the story. I'm just not actually that interested in that. And so I find third soothing, right? I just find it I'm just like I wanna fall into someone else's story. ⁓ so yeah, I I also think you I think that also has to do with ⁓ we haven't talked about this book at all yet, I think it's fine. I think also has to do with It is, I think, much easier to write in third and sort of have a modern viewpoint while be telling the story in the past. But I think if you're gonna write in first person and you there's just things that you cannot do. I've tried reading a couple of books that are, you know, in first person historicals. And I think it's really hard to get that like tone right. Like you can sort of have a narrative voice that sounds more modern, but can you have Andie James: ⁓ yeah. Yeah. jen: a character voice that sounds more modern. That's a I think the cognitive dissonance of that is much harder for readers to get over, is my guess. Andie James: That's a really good point. Yeah. Yeah, that's a really good point because yeah, it's different because know, if I'm writing as this person that's going to have the and attitudes of the time, it's harder to Yeah, ⁓ huh. I can see that. Obviously. Yeah. It's the thing. Yeah. Yeah. Right. ⁓ Right. jen: Now, close third, obviously we are is like the the illusion, right? That like the narrative voice is the character voice. I get it. But there's there's it's different. It just is, right? Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. don't yeah, but again getting back to this book, sorry. ⁓ this is what we do. We just go where the conversation takes us. but as you I kind of appreciated it in some ways because you're seeing jen: Yeah. Andie James: you get that other perspective on the characters from the side characters, right? You get how other people are observing them and noticing things about them that they don't necessarily know about themselves. And I'm thinking here of Jamie how she really I don't know if I mistreated as the right word, but she really like her father really kind of just relied on her to run the whole took advantage of, I guess maybe is a better way of I don't know. And know, so ⁓ the beginning we get that perspective from Beak, from the the stable master, who he's like, he can see this. And he's like, ⁓ he you totally different from your other sisters. He works you to the bone. Like, and so he sees this as an opportunity ⁓ jen: Yeah. ⁓ Right. Andie James: To match her with Alec and get her out of there and kind of give her a chance at like a different life. her father ⁓ even gonna present her as an option ⁓ to It was gonna like, ⁓ here's my other daughters, ⁓ like, yeah, yeah. you know, and then Alec can see it when he finds out more about her and and learns about kind of how she operated with her father, when he sees the way that she interacts with and protects her sister, who is jen: Yeah, right. Here's my other daughters, right? Andie James: One of her sisters is married to his friend in the kind of same way. So, know, in that way, it's like Jamie's aware of this. And again, it's third, so like she doesn't necessarily need to be. Like, we can still get that info. But seeing ⁓ how people make these kind of helps inform us as the reader of kind of the broader context. I don't know. jen: Mm-hmm. Right. Yeah, I mean, I think like interesting. I think we're at a time too like this is a character who ⁓ people can see things about her that she can't see about herself. This very hard to communicate in first. It's not impossible, right? Skilled writers do it. ⁓ But think this is also why we get sort of, you know, kind of in contemporary right now, at least, right? Like a lot of characters who are like kind of perfectly formed. How are you gonna show a character, right, who is ⁓ Andie James: Yes. Yeah. Right. Right. Right. Yeah. jen: learning who she is. And I think like this is something that Third really excels at, right? And s and especially in this way. We get this Alec's of her, right? But also like Beak and her sisters and ⁓ and like a cultural difference in right once she's in this new place too. So I think that that is it is really interesting to see ⁓ to that evolve. Whereas like Andie James: Exactly. Yes. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. jen: This is something I think that is Really like right, the thing about her father, she's like not so in the book, the the the plot establishes this is not her real father. Her mother ⁓ him when she was pregnant, and but he was he adopted her and she does feel that he like loves her. ⁓ it's clear that he does and relies on her, but it also feels like, well, this is Jamie's way ⁓ her duties is how she's going to like earn her keep, like show her worth and her value. ⁓ Andie James: Yeah. Right. Mm-hmm. Yes. Yeah. Yeah. jen: So like a really funny kind of ongoing thing is how furious she is at Alec that he won't give her duties. Andie James: Yeah, no, I was gonna say that for sure. Like it's interesting because again, kinda going back to how this is pretty stereotypical, I would say, is very much the portrait of ⁓ just w not even having read a ton of these like Highland romances. ⁓ it just made sense to me, right, that he would be how he is portrayed, which is, you know, kind of the you know, he's obviously head of the clan. You know, this is eleven hundred, so this is very much still the strong clan system. This is before a lot had changed there. And you know. jen: Right. Yeah. It is hard as an American, I just want to say, like head of the clan. I really had a moment there, I was like, Not that clan, everybody. ⁓ His Highlander clan. Right. C clan. Yeah. He's the laird. There you go. Andie James: Not that clan. Sorry. Sorry. Yes. No. No. Sorry. Yeah, he's the Laird. He's the Laird. Sorry. I'll use that terminology for now on. We don't want to confuse there. yeah, but he so he's the laird and he's very has kind of it you know, now it feels kind of backwards, but it's not meant in a bad way, but very protective view of like her job is to just be the wife and she doesn't need to do anything. And yeah, yes, yes. you know, i in one sense Jamie is the complete opposite of what he thinks he wants and needs because she's so strong and independent and fierce and she speaks her mind and, you jen: Sure. I mean he says my job is to own her. She's property, right? Andie James: And she she tells him from the get go, like, I'm just gonna tell you things and I I'll talk back to you and it's gonna frustrate you. And he's like, Okay, great, like I'll be frustrated, but like I'll never actually ⁓ mad at you or anything. You know, he's very kinda like reassuring to her. and where was I going with this? I did have a point, but so they get, you know, they get ⁓ home, they to Scotland, they get to back to the clan and you know, he's very much like, Yeah, just, you know, relax, chill. You're my you're my wife. You have this place of honor because you're the Laird's wife. And she's like, No, no, no, no, no. I need to do something. I need to solve problems. I need to, ⁓ know, and in the end he comes to recognize that her being kind of like a helper is actually a good thing. And, ⁓ know, but it's like she's actually what he needs, you know, of course, because it's romance and it's what the other needs. But ⁓ jen: Yeah. Yeah. Worse. Andie James: ⁓ yeah, but she's just like, What do you mean I can't do anything? And there's a really funny kind of setup where he gives her permission to change things in the kitchen. Mm-hmm. ⁓ he thinks she's just gonna like maybe change the menu, move around pots and pans, whatever, right? Like who's in charge? I don't know. ⁓ she literally wants to physically move the kitchen building because ⁓ jen: Change the kitchens. Yeah, right. Right. Right, 'cause it's in a different like the servants are having to like walk across a snowy courtyard with the food. Yeah. Andie James: Yeah. Right. So one of the servants tells her this and ⁓ comes back from being away for I don't remember. Well, star she starts lots of fights. So he comes back from some expedition trying to calm things down just because she doesn't know again the different cultural understandings here. But so she starts kerfuffle and he's off trying to appease it. And in the meantime, she's like, yeah, he gave me the Laird gave me permission to change the kitchens. So he comes back and he's like, What is going on? 'Cause there's like this wall down and there's like it's so funny. It's great. jen: Mm-hmm. Right. Andie James: But I love them together. They are perfect for each other. Obviously. They don't realize it, but they are. They I thought that the way ⁓ jen: ⁓ yeah. Andie James: their first love scene when they come together after being married is very sweet. Like he jen: Well, it's also yeah, go ahead and talk about this, but then I wanna talk about this as like a pacing thing, which is really interesting. Andie James: Yes. Yeah. I well, I just I thought it was it's one of those things where had asked him at some point, she's like, basically, she's like, Well, we just met and I know we're married, but like, I don't know you. ⁓ can we hold off a little bit on consummating this marriage? Like ⁓ right. Right. She really know yet. jen: I mean, she doesn't even really know what she's asking for, right, by the way, either. Like she has no idea. She just knows something's gonna happen, right? Andie James: Yeah, she just knows doesn't yeah, and he's like, hmm, okay, mm-hmm. Yeah, but he has no intention, right? But I think is where I think you were saying it kind of differs maybe and feels a little more modern, where in his head when we see through his perspective that he's like, Yeah, we're not waiting. Like ⁓ you know. ⁓ is, because beautiful, right? And he thinks she's gorgeous and jen: Yeah, 'cause he's like super into her, right? Yeah. Yeah. Andie James: He's impressed with the way she's like stood up to some bandits and you know, whatever. so he kind of like pats her the head, appeases her, but he's like, ⁓ And so he just kind of starts kissing her and things just kind of start moving along and it feels good and she's okay with it. And he just kind of keeps taking it further and further. ⁓ And so, a way, it's like you could say that like he's very much pushing her boundaries, but it doesn't at all read as jen: Right. Yeah. Andie James: nonconsensual because she's like into it, you know, which again goes back to that conversation about how we wrote these in the old school when it's like the women are like, ⁓ no, no, no, I can't want it, but I want it and Yeah. jen: Right, yeah. Right. Right. Right. Well, I think like the part that's interesting to me too is I mean, this is like what eleven hundred. There's not a sense from Jamie that she would ever really like say no either. Right? Like there's like I mean this is it's can you consent when you don't even realize that's like a right you have, right? Yeah, right, this was Andie James: Yes. Right. Right, 'cause she is now his wife. She is his property. She is yes. Yeah. Yeah. Right. jen: How it goes and she's been raised a certain way. Now, I'm not saying that this is like part of her mental journey, but I think like we as readers are to understand that this is, you know, she understands that she's married now and this is what's gonna happen. I think the thing that's interesting to me in terms of the book is that like pacing wise, this happens at the thirty-three percent mark. I made a point of looking at this. ⁓ Andie James: Right. Right. Right. Right. Yeah. Yeah, it's ⁓ did you yeah, it's jen: Well, just cause I wanted to talk about this, because I think one of the things we're like sort of seeing now, there's sort of like a n a new wave of Puritanism happening in in romance, kind of across the board, that now what we're getting is like this is something that everybody is like waiting to do. And the delay is happening kind of like I said across the board and it's happening more and more. ⁓ Andie James: Yeah. Mm-hmm. jen: ⁓ you know, if you read Romancing the Beat, which is like Gwen Hayes' book about sort of like the plotting of a romance novel, which is about 10 years old, she suggests that like a good time for this to happen is like the 50% mark. now routinely, if I'm reading a book written now, I'm like, well, this isn't gonna happen until 75%, maybe, right? ⁓ this is in some ways to me frustrating and kind of silly. Because you this book, there is nothing is Andie James: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yep. ⁓ yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. jen: The point of a romance isn't for the people to have sex. The point of a romance is for people to fall in love. Right. And so this they don't have to necessarily have anything to do with each other. one of the like sort of arguments that I'd like kind of like to make is that back in the day in a lot of these books, ⁓ almost all of them, the heroine is if it's male, female, right? And for a really long time, that's all romance was, right? she's a virgin. Andie James: Yes. jen: She's definitely a virgin. one the things you were gonna kind of do is like get him they're getting married. Like she's not gonna be a virgin for long. And then was like I think a long run of time readers were kind of like, This is silly. Like people don't people aren't virgins anymore. know what I mean? Like this is like this we don't need to like sort of like preserve this as a kind of way of thinking about like Andie James: ⁓ yeah. jen: true love and romance or what else, else. ⁓ what to me ⁓ a a lot of these books is okay, you took a you took that away then. Fine. They are these are people with like a sexual past and a history. But then preserved sort of this sense though, ⁓ even s a weird, stronger way, that ⁓ however the has to be like revolutionary. Right. And so and you're pushing it further and further back in the book as almost like a reward for saying I love you, opposed to part of like the journey of figuring out like, is this person like right for me or not? Or it doesn't matter. Like, ⁓ know, my feelings don't actually have to be driven by this. So I think that's the part that's like really interesting about it to me is there's no sense. I mean, now ⁓ just like, it's like you can see the author's Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Mm-hmm. jen: like doing everything they can to like kind of slam the brakes on in like the dumbest, weirdest ways. Like how many times can the phone ring? How many times can the door knock? Right? Just as they're starting to make out or whatever. So I think like that is that's like a real object lesson in the fact that like you don't have to tie the like achievement of the HEA to the sex at all. And I wish people would stop being so prescriptive about it. Andie James: Right. Right. Yeah. Right. Right. jen: but it's also a really good example of like what we do say, which is like it should show the emotional journey, right? Like they're in the you know, in the on this journey and he's kinda like right, and then like, you know, there's a whole thing when they get back about how like his bed had been sort of in a public place and she wants to move it to a private place, right? And like the evolution of this is the evolution of their romance is being shown through these scenes. Andie James: Yeah. Like in the forest or something. Yeah. Yes. Yeah. jen: So yeah, I think we really and I don't like I said, puritanic it's puritanical in a way now, but I think 'cause of politics. But I also think people just really like lost sense of it. Like this isn't, you know, tying out spice all the time. Whatever. Like, that's not what the books are about. The books are about love. Like what are we doing? Andie James: Well, yeah. And I think this is don't know. For as an author, which is not what we're here to talk about today, so I'll be real quick about this, but like this has always been ⁓ personally biggest like insecurity and hang up because I don't write super spicy. Like they do it in my books because it's a natural evolution of ⁓ relationship, Like it's a natural consequence of growing feelings and but I don't like ⁓ linger it a lot, you know, and jen: Sure. No. Andie James: It's interesting because I think when am conceiving my stories, I am thinking about the love story and what makes sense for that. Not that I have to hit some spice target. ⁓ And but yeah, but I feel like sometimes I don't know how to market my books or I don't know where to place them because like, you know, my li my last book that I just released, it ended up Kisses Only because it just with the time ⁓ jen: Mm-hmm. Right. And that's how it should be, right? That's how it should be. Mm. Andie James: timeline of the book, it didn't make sense to me for who those characters were. But then like, you know, a book coming, spoilers people, like I've got my whole current series plotted and a book that's coming, like the first scene is gonna open with sex. So like I, you know, it just kind of depends on the story to me. But then it's like I don't know how to market my books to people in the current jen: Of course. Andie James: Because it's ⁓ don't know if I would ever place my books under the title Steamy, because then I think people are often disappointed. But I can't market it as closed door because that's not accurate. And it's like, why are we so hung up on these terms? Why is this all we're focusing on? Enough of my side diatribe, but ⁓ jen: Yeah. Yeah. Right. Right. Well No, I mean I think that's a good question. And you know what I mean I guess I would say like my thing is like you're is to me also like a real it's a real trap ⁓ the is you can say steamy and people be like, what are you talking about? And other people will be like, Yes, it was, wow. Right? ⁓ So, you there's no accounting for that. Like you can't actually like really ⁓ and I think we should, right? Like it should be what's happening for the characters. And so like in this case, right? Like ⁓ they are ⁓ you know, thing that Andie James: Mm-hmm. Yeah. No. Yeah. Mm-hmm. jen: their romance is about is about like changing minds, right? Like sort of it it is about like him accepting her and seeing. I think one of the things that's like really like threaded through this book is, know, he's like, I'm the Kincaid, I'm the leader, I'm the laird, right? And you shouldn't be questioning me or giving me orders. She's like, that's crazy. ⁓ like what she does is she like unites clans essentially at the end. Andie James: Yeah. ⁓ huh. Yeah. jen: Right. And the way she does this is not on purpose, but by just being like a good person, right? And having a set of skills that are highly valued at that time. The primary one being like a healer, right? I mean, all of the ways, it's no mistake. All right. So that like about halfway through the book, like they're married and kind of like, what's gonna keep the book going? There's this sort of great line that's like, you know, she started three wars in the first week or whatever. And Andie James: Yes. Yeah. jen: But the thing is, is every single one of them started by ⁓ and helping people, right? Every single one of them, right? So she heals one of his soldiers, ⁓ takes in a baby who is sick from his mother's milk. You she saves the little boy, ⁓ you she protects her sister. And so all of the things she does are rooted in a sense of like ⁓ what clan is. Andie James: Helping. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Mm-hmm. jen: actually supposed to stand for, right? Which is togetherness and unity and community. And so like that's the part that's like really great about this book, right? Like Alec is the one who's like, I'm the leader. And she's like, okay, but what if instead of warring with people, we actually just like sort of help them. And and because of her, because again, this is 1100 or whatever, the fact that she can heal people is Andie James: Right. Yeah. I loved it. Mm-hmm. Yeah. jen: a huge ⁓ like this is something that is desperately needed. You this is no, you know, Kaiser Permanente where you can roll into the doctor's office. ⁓ And that think is like the other part is like Alex has to realize like, wait, there's another way I can I can conceive of like our role as Highlanders, right? As being community oriented. Andie James: Huge. Mm-hmm. Yeah. I think one of my favorite moments in the book, which then leads to another moment later that's a little anyway. But I think it also is a huge it was super romantic and it also showed the miscommunication with the follow up, I guess. But ⁓ they're they're originally they've just gotten married. ⁓ married Alec, her sister's married, I can't remember his friend's name, but Daniel, yes. jen: Daniel, I think. Andie James: He's part of another clan. they're tra they're all traveling back ⁓ they get set upon by some, you whatever ⁓ thieves, And ⁓ gonna yeah. ⁓ it's it's it's not good. It's not a good situation. ⁓ Yeah, there's real danger here. This is not just, and Daniel kinda hangs back help protect the women and ⁓ Alec goes out there fight. jen: mean they're gonna steal these women and you know yeah. No. Right. Andie James: And I mean ⁓ he eviscerates them, I mean, ⁓ know, because ⁓ the Kincaid. but he does this purely with himself, like just his body. And Jamie like he doesn't have a sword. And I might dismissed as I was reading, so tell me, I don't think they ever actually explain why he doesn't have a sword with him. jen: Yeah, of course. I mean, I think like it what's implied 'cause he has swords at home when she gets there, right? So what you're gonna talk about is he I mean, I read it as kind of two things. One is like he doesn't need a sword, right? Kick everybody's ass, right? Andie James: Right. Yeah. Yeah. Yes. He doesn't need one. Obviously he he can handle everything himself. Yeah. Yeah. jen: Right. But I also read it as remember they are traveling from London. And I also read it as he would not have been able to carry a sword, his sword, into London without being viewed as a threat by the king or whatever. And so I sort of read it as like kind of both of those things. ultimately it didn't matter because he's, you know, Alec Kincaid. Yeah. Andie James: Yes. In London. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Right. A threat. Yeah. Okay. That makes sense. That makes sense. Yeah. Yeah. It didn't matter. But anyway, she observes that he doesn't have a sword. she thinks that he just doesn't have one. Like, ⁓ know, either he lost it along the way or he's too poor to have one. I don't know. But she interprets it as he like truly doesn't have one. And can't remember exactly when or how. I read this like two weeks ago, people. Sorry, you know, things don't stick in my brain. But jen: Right, at all. Andie James: She's thanking she's grateful for something. She's thanking him for something. And so she says, ⁓ I know what I'm gonna do to like show you my gratitude, give you my thing. She's like, gonna get you a sword. And he's like, What? ⁓ she's like, Well, you don't have one. And he is so touched and it's such an beautiful, ⁓ he doesn't correct her to say, ⁓ I I do have a sword. Like, I've got tons of ho, you know, whatever. but just I just thought that was such a sweet jen: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Andie James: of showing her observation, her care, her whatever. And I think he was truly touched. But then I think it also shows just kind of the miscommunication between them a little bit and the different ways that they operate. Because then when they arrive ⁓ back at his home and sees all his sword, like his weapons, including swords, like up on the walls, she's like. jen: Right. Right. She's pissed. She's like, how dare you did not you made a fool out of me, right? Yeah. Andie James: Upset. She's really upset. Yeah. She's like, yeah, yeah. She yeah. She's very much like, you just let me believe all this stuff and I made a fool of myself. And he's like, you know, he he's like, no, you didn't like it. It sweet. You know, but like, don't know. But it just, I just I love that moment. So I did want to bring that up. jen: Yeah. Well, and then this is like kind of the s big spoiler alert time, right? Like then at the end, like what happens is there's like sort of a some foreshadowing at the beginning, like a sense that like one of the things that Jamie's father has done is he's bad with money. He took the tax money for himself and he has taken a loan from Baron Andrew or whatever, and in to like so that he Andrew can marry Jamie. And Andie James: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah. Yes. Yes. jen: Jamie's like, You sold me? And he's like, No, my love, just alone. Right. And Beak is like, he sold you. And, you know, but then she marries Alec and takes off. And like we kind of forget about it until ⁓ reappears at the end, sort of demanding, ⁓ demanding, ⁓ that Jamie be turned over to him. And then like really, truly, like this is again, like, I don't want to spoil it. If you haven't read it, you should stop listening. Andie James: Yeah. No, no, no, no. Yeah. It's like, yeah, honey. Yeah. Andrew shows up. Where's my woman? Yeah. Everyone knows that my book episodes is spoilers. So jen: Yeah. It really is like one of the most memorable scenes in romance, right? Because essentially every Highlander in the Highlands goes to get her. All instead of like the the whole thing about like I started war is actually she brought them all together. So all of these people that she helped come to come with Alex, right? Come with Alec. And then people who want her help in the future, right? And so what they're and what Alec does is he's sort of like his sword is like Andie James: Mm-hmm. Yeah. jen: Encrusted with like jewels and stuff, and he he has it with him, and he like kind of pops out this like these jewels that are priceless, right? Or whatever. And he kind of tosses it at Andrew, and it's like, you know, repayment, repayment for Lady Kincaid. And then all of the other chieftains do the same thing. And yeah, it's awesome. It's a great it is a great scene, truly. Andie James: Yes. Mm-hmm. Like this big ruby or emerald or whatever. Yeah. Yeah, it was really moving. Yeah. Mm-hmm. jen: And then, you know, the best part is like then we get Andrew kind of like sc and again, you couldn't do this in any other like kind of narrative point of view, except this head hopping one. He's like scrabbling around on the floor, like sort of gathering up his riches, and then he looks up and they're all just gone. Right. Like they've just all like disappeared, like mist I think like that's the part about this moment is just like how thoroughly she these are her people now, right? There's no part of her that belongs to England at all anymore. Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. They've claimed her. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah, it was really good. jen: Yeah, it's great. It's great. Yeah. What an ending. Andie James: So kind of the last thing I I I do want to touch on, and I so another kind of structural slash story element here is a ⁓ I don't how many moments, four or five, throughout the book, where we get in the head of a ⁓ villain So prologue opens with kind of the funeral of Alec's jen: ⁓ yeah. Andie James: first wife and it is believed that she killed herself. ⁓ we don't know why. Yeah. jen: Mm-hmm. Right. And then that becomes that you know, as were rumors spread that Alec killed her, right? Andie James: Yes. So the myth that, you know, Jamie hears, right, when it's known that this man's gonna come and take one of her or her sisters is that ⁓ this man who killed his wife, right? and there's kind of a little bit of this I don't if I'd call it a full on mystery, but this thread throughout of like what happened to 'cause it doesn't necessarily make sense that she killed herself. Like it kind of came out of nowhere. jen: Right. Yeah. Well, especially like everybody just thought like, ⁓ she'd been hiding. And then it's Jamie who like finds her things is kinda like, No, this is not a woman who killed herself. Like she brought her like you know, she brought linens and baby clothes. Like this is a woman who wanted to like sort of take care of to be married to Alec, essentially, right? Andie James: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And we you know, we find out or Jamie finds out, ⁓ that had been married previously and her husband had died and she had a daughter with him. And so she was planning to bring her daughter ⁓ And that was another I guess that's a whole other storyline we didn't touch on, but it was I I found it very sweet is that Jamie goes and retrieves this girl once she finds out about her and brings her back and she just is like tells Alec like, You're her father now. jen: Yeah. Yeah. Right. Yeah, we're our parents now. Andie James: Because like you should you you should have been like you married her mother and like this was always the plan that she was gonna come and whatever. left her with relatives thinking she was cared for, it's a whole thing. But anyways, Jamie brings her back and it's just seeing Alec with her is really sweet, but ⁓ I'm a sucker for that, right? ⁓ yeah, ⁓ anyways, where I was going with all this is so it's kind of what happened to her. jen: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, right. Andie James: And but we find out immediately, again in the prologue, because we switch into the the point of view of this villain that this person has killed her because think that she was not meant to be with Alec, not Alec's true wife. And I I don't know, it's like four or five times we switch into the point of view, it's not a ton. jen: Mm-hmm. Right. Right. It escalates as the book goes on. I would say, listen, I would say this to me is a very common. in that it from that time. And even still, like, you know, Nora Roberts does this all the time. Like we're ⁓ drift into like the sort of villain's point of view as they are kind plotting and planning their dastardly deeds. ⁓ Right? Andie James: It does. ⁓ yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. For sure. Yeah. No, I've seen this before. This isn't unique. but I don't I necessarily personally love how it was resolved. ⁓ because we find out this is the 1989 of it. Yes, very much so. And so we find out, again, spoiler, yeah, ⁓ but find out that it is Annie who is a young woman who was jen: ⁓ yeah, sure. This is the this is the eight nineteen eighty nine of it all, right? Right. Andie James: I'm totally blaking on his first wife's name, but his first wife's sister, Helen. Okay, yeah. Helena. Yeah. Helena's sister. she ⁓ ⁓ jen: Helen. Or Helena, maybe. She's developmentally disabled in a way we don't know, right? I mean, because they don't have language or words for this. Right. Andie James: She's develop yeah, we don't all they don't have language or terms, but she's developmentally disabled. They talk about her kind of being a woman with a child's mind, basically, right? so I didn't love that kind the killer ended up being ⁓ the disabled person. But what we find out is that ⁓ she been intended to be Alec's wife, but then it became apparent that as she grew that she ⁓ was developmentally disabled. Alec was like, she's not mm, that's not jen: Here's what I would say, like, okay, I did a real quick r reread of this. My re read of this always would have that it was actually like Annie and Helena's family who decided. Right? Like like not that Alec was like, I'm not gonna marry her, but just that they were like, This is inappropriate. This isn't appropriate, right? Not realizing that, you know, Annie had also had, you know, sort of a Andie James: Okay. Okay. This isn't appropriate. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. ⁓ jen: I I don't know, like right, like susceptible to like sort of some like misunderstanding from another character and you know, like sort of but yeah, I mean, yeah, sure, this is right. Andie James: Yes. Influenced by some other yeah characters and yeah. So I mean I I did I did appreciate that like you said, it was kind of determined this would not be appropriate. And so hence after Helena's husband died, they marry Helena to Alec instead. But it's kind of this idea that Annie is like, ⁓ no, I was the true bride. I have to like get these obstacles out of my way, basically. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And so I didn't jen: Yeah. Right, and then he'll be mine, right? Andie James: Love that. I didn't hate the concept. Like you said, I think I've read this in other books. It's not uncommon to have kind of this point of view and kind of this sketchy what's gonna happen feeling. ⁓ I didn't mind that. But a part of me was almost a little bit though, like I kind of forgot that was happening sometimes until we'd get another point of view ⁓ in because and so there was almost a part of me that wanted a little bit more. I'm like, if you're gonna do it, let's lean into it a little. jen: Of course. Yeah. ⁓ yeah. Yeah, absolutely. You know, I think yeah, it's intr but it's at the same time, it's not romantic suspense, right? Like this is not a this is not a until what happens essentially to like kind of turn, I think maybe the turn the corner in terms of it is this Annie. don't know what's Annie yet, right? Like but essentially Jamie is out and she gets trapped into a cottage and Andie James: I don't know. It's not. No. jen: that is then set on fire they know that someone did it to her on purpose because the, you know, they've she's essentially been like locked in or barricaded in. And it's and this is probably 70% of the way through the book at that point, right? It's pretty far in that then then the whole thing where it's kind of like, okay, wait, if someone tried to kill, if someone tried to kill Jamie, ⁓ maybe it is true that someone killed Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, it's pretty far in. tried to kill Helena, ⁓ Helena. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. jen: Someone did kill Helena and therefore this is now real threat, right? But it's not a whole book threat at all. Andie James: Yeah. It's not. You're right. You're right. No. Yeah. jen: You know, it's a it's a it is a third act. There's foreshadowing of it. Like we as readers know it's gonna happen, but like Jamie and Alec are completely unaware of the fact that someone is targeting her until it happens in a way that they can't ignore. So I mean, I guess I would say like in terms of like the plotting, now whether or not this is like satisfying to you totally, I get is like a different question. you know, is this, you know, is ⁓ Andie James: They're oblivious. Yeah. Until yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. That's a good point. Yeah. jen: I think one of things is like and but I would argue that like because of the foreshadowing of it, because we get those occasional points of view, we as readers know what's coming. It's just like the characters aren't aware. But this can be a really tough needle to thread. Because the the thing that if it when it when things like this are done poorly, the way it feels is, well, this author didn't really have enough for a whole book. Andie James: Hmm. No, I appreciate that. It is. jen: And therefore they invented a sort of like late stage crisis, an e late stage external crisis gonna like push us through to like the end of the book till Alec realizes he's in love with her and then the book can end. and I would just say, like, you know, this is Kleypas always has a late stage external threat, ⁓ right? This kind of just how books were, right? And I Andie James: Right. ⁓ yeah. Yeah. No, you're right. I think in that context I do I get it that that was you're right that it wasn't for them it was not a thing and it's not romantic suspense. And so I get that. I think like you said, it was just the way ⁓ maybe it's just because it it did end up being Annie. That's why I was a little unsatisfied with it. Yeah. jen: Yeah, sure. Yeah. Sure, that it's like kind of yucky. For sure, of course. Well, and I think like the thing that, you know, it's like you might be like, okay, so that's how it works, but like, what's the emotional payoff? And I would order, and here's what I would argue, right? Like ⁓ one thing that these dudes are constantly like, this is if this is if being part of a good husband is like taking care of your wife, then a threat to your wife, ⁓ Andie James: Yeah. Yes. jen: literally to her person is going to activate something in him that, you know, isn't going to be activated otherwise. So I think like one of the if you have these sort of like old school like alpha heroes or whatever, right? It's like, well, what is going to scare the shit out of them enough to realize I'm in love with this woman? And it is a threat to her person, right? Because that is the thing that they have been trained their entire lives, right? To Andie James: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Right. Right. Yes. jen: do. So I mean I think in that sense, like again, we don't maybe see it as much anymore, but there's a reason. a thematic, emotional reason ⁓ it why it happens in that Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. The Annie of it, sure. Right. The Annie of it is is terrible, right? But I think it's it is ⁓ Andie James: Mm. Yeah. ⁓ absolutely. That I didn't question at all. Because like seeing Alec, you know, and all his protectiveness is of course what we want. And yeah. Yeah. jen: product of I I'm not gonna excuse it. I'm not saying that the fact that it's from nineteen eighty nine excuses it, but I'm saying like you used to see kind of this kind of thing all the time. Yeah, right. Andie James: Right. ⁓ no. No no no. It's the understanding the context. Yeah. Yeah. It's not an excuse. It's an understanding. Yeah. Yeah. For sure. But well, I mean, I loved it. I'd like to read more Garwood. think like I said, there was just something very familiar and comforting about it that I just felt like I could just like fall into its little arms and I knew it would be a good time. ⁓ ⁓ it was, it was. Well, you so much, Jen. ⁓ jen: Yeah. Yeah. Well and I it it sounds like it was, so yeah. Of course. Andie James: for joining me today and for suggesting this book. and I mean it's been ⁓ a few years now, but I know you and Sarah did a deep dive on this book ⁓ at some point. ⁓ I will find that episode and link it in our show notes so that you can find that too. I purposely did not re-listen to it because I just wanted to have this conversation, but now I kind of want to go see what you guys highlighted. ⁓ jen: We did at some point, so yeah. Sure. I'd I I didn't either, I don't think. Well, and it's funny because I would say the one thing I do really vividly remember is like I often only reread I'm a scene rereader. So at that point it had been a long time since I'd reread it like from beginning to end. And I think like the pacing stuff is really probably what surprised us the most, right? Andie James: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Well, it's funny too because I I have heard your episode talking about this, but it was a while ago, you know. So I don't remember any of the details. But it's funny because there's another I don't even know if it is Garwood, but in my head, I thought this book was a different one you guys have talked about. That it might be a Garwood, it might be a McNaught, it might be, but like jen: Mm. Andie James: I thought it was the one where she's like a young girl promised to this guy and then jen: ⁓ there yeah, that exists too, but that's like a different that's is that the guardian maybe or the gift? Yeah. Yeah. Right. Andie James: Yeah. I don't remember but like and she like is in love with the image of him and then as she's older she goes to him and they it they can be married. Anyway, that's what I thought this was gonna be. Yeah, and so I started reading it. For some reason in my brain, I thought the bride was like that concept anyways. But I I'm ha it was I'm glad it wasn't and I do now wanna go relisten to that episode 'cause I think it would be fascinating having now read it, but ⁓ jen: Right. Yeah. ⁓ and you're like, ⁓ this isn't totally different, yeah. Yeah. Perfect. Well, thanks for having me. Andie James: Anyway, again everyone, if you're not listening to Fated Mates as well, should be. And and also have started kind of a great community. They've got a Patreon and you can join a Discord, which I am terrible that Discord because it's so overwhelming to me. ⁓ It's they're just lot people, but it is fantastic if you want to find other people to, you know, chat romance things with. jen: It's like drinking out of a fire hose, yeah. It is. I think there's like a what's my book channel, so maybe you should get in there and ask about that candy thing and see if somebody remembers. Andie James: There you go. There you go. I don't know. I mean, it's it's interesting. I just remember that scene. Like I don't, but I have no idea what the book was. Read it in high school. So, you know, 25 years ago at this point. So, anyways, again, thank you so much. Everyone go listen to Fated Mates and ⁓ Jen just fantastic and she's helped so authors like myself and some of the books you love, she's had her hands in, and yeah. jen: Yeah. We all have that book. We do. Course. Andie James: It's exciting times. Well all right. Well I will see you guys again in a couple weeks and just happy reading and happy listening. All right. Bye. jen: It is exciting times, all right. Thanks.