Latest / No Way Out / The Power and Origins of Decision-Forcing Cases: History, Application, and Transformational Learning with Bruce Gudmundsson
Transcript
- 0:22Mark McGrath: Okay, Bruce.
- 0:23Mark McGrath: So decision forcing cases are something that we heard on a previous episode from our mutual friend, Chris Butler, who has never spent one day in the military and is an avid devotee of decision forcing cases, and we had a great discussion about it.
- 0:37Mark McGrath: Now, Chris has never spent one day in the military and sees a lot of value in this methodology for organizational learning, for team building.
- 0:48Mark McGrath: Give us the big view and then we'll get down into specifics.
- 0:53Mark McGrath: What is a decision forcing case and where do they come from, and why do you think they're important?
- 1:00Bruce Gudmundsson: Okay, a lot of questions there.
- 1:02Bruce Gudmundsson: Start off with what it is.
- 1:04Bruce Gudmundsson: It's an exercise, it's something that people do, and it's an exercise that puts the player, the participant, in the position, in the role, in the shoes, if you will of somebody, a real person, who, at some time in the past, was faced with a challenge, faced with a decision, and a decision that required not just a binary choice up down, left right, but a creative solution, something that was custom tailored to the problem at hand.
- 1:50Bruce Gudmundsson: You could say that a DFC a decision forcing case is an exercise in which people practice the bespoke art of custom tailoring.
- 2:04Bruce Gudmundsson: It's not about pulling something off the shelf.
- 2:07Bruce Gudmundsson: It's about making something new.
- 2:10Bruce Gudmundsson: Now, where does it come from?
- 2:12Bruce Gudmundsson: It comes from lots of places.
- 2:16Bruce Gudmundsson: It's one of those things that pops up at certain points in the past and then goes away.
- 2:24Bruce Gudmundsson: The mother church of the DFC is the Harvard Business School.
- 2:30Bruce Gudmundsson: Right now, it's 2023.
- 2:34Bruce Gudmundsson: About 1923, they started using these to teach the business administration.
- 2:45Bruce Gudmundsson: They've been going strong for about 100 years.
- 2:49Bruce Gudmundsson: Unfortunately, a lot of people take the materials that Harvard has created for people at Harvard.
- 2:58Bruce Gudmundsson: I used to be one of them.
- 2:59Bruce Gudmundsson: I used to be a case writer, not at Harvard Business School, but across the river at the Kennedy School, they take the case materials and use them for other purposes.
- 3:12Bruce Gudmundsson: This is our biggest problem with the world of formal education.
- 3:17Bruce Gudmundsson: People want to take the elements of the game, the physical materials, the articles, the charts and diagrams and such, and turn those into something else, usually materials for a lecture.
- 3:33Bruce Gudmundsson: That's the biggest problem we have with DFCs and why they thrive for a while and then they go away.
- 3:45Bruce Gudmundsson: There's these Camelot moments.
- 3:47Bruce Gudmundsson: One of them was my favorite actually is the US Army Infantry School down at Fort Benning when George Marshall you may remember him from such hits as the Marshall Plan and World War II, George Marshall was using these.
- 4:06Bruce Gudmundsson: He called them historical map problems.
- 4:09Bruce Gudmundsson: They were used at Fort Benning for about nine years 1931, 1939, as far as I can tell.
- 4:21Mark McGrath: They stopped in 1939, right, because nothing was going to happen after that, right.
- 4:27Bruce Gudmundsson: Actually quite the opposite.
- 4:28Bruce Gudmundsson: The difficulty what happened is after 1939, prior to 1939, the folks at Fort Benning were preparing the infantry officers for a wide variety of contingencies.
- 4:41Mark McGrath: I see.
- 4:42Bruce Gudmundsson: And what's really, really interesting.
- 4:43Bruce Gudmundsson: In fact, before we started, I was looking at the Marine Corps Gazette from the 20s and 30s and struck by the sheer variety of scenarios.
- 4:55Bruce Gudmundsson: People were dealing with A great deal of interest in everything from landing in a port city we imagine Marines in the 30s practicing landing on beaches, and there was a bit of that.
- 5:12Bruce Gudmundsson: But they were also practicing landing in cities, which is something we tend not to think about these days and imagining all sorts of different scenarios.
- 5:26Bruce Gudmundsson: Will get sent back to Central America to deal with the actually to keep the Japanese from building a canal through Nicaragua.
- 5:39Bruce Gudmundsson: I think that's the real reason.
- 5:40Bruce Gudmundsson: But a lot of possibilities.
- 5:44Bruce Gudmundsson: And then 1939 comes and the list of possibilities narrows and people start thinking well, what we need to do is we need to start raising this mass citizen army, and this mass citizen army requires a script.
- 6:02Bruce Gudmundsson: So they replaced the decision games with these scripts and these problems that had scripted solutions.
- 6:12Bruce Gudmundsson: This is the famous school solution.
- 6:15Bruce Gudmundsson: It's a bit of graffiti that was popular at Fort Benning during World War II.
- 6:21Bruce Gudmundsson: This is after this period and it goes something like this here lie the bones of Lieutenant Jones, a student at this institution.
- 6:30Bruce Gudmundsson: He died on the night of his very first fight, while applying the school solution.
- 6:38Bruce Gudmundsson: A little bit of doggery from World War II.
- 6:43Mark McGrath: Sounds like something that sounds like a poem that John Boyd would love to read and remind people.
- 6:49Bruce Gudmundsson: Yes, I know, and I'm sure he knew of that Because he was of the generation trained by the generation that was trained in this very doctrinaire way and again this idea of doctrine that there's going to be a script for everything and all you need to do is read the cookbook and very, very, very different from the philosophy of Marshall and his colleagues at Fort Benning.
- 7:20Bruce Gudmundsson: So this thing it pops up and then it goes away.
- 7:23Bruce Gudmundsson: But it's incredibly useful for helping people deal with new problems, and by new I mean problems that are new to them, and sometimes I like the phrase wicked problems Confuses people when I try to explain it when I'm in New England.
- 7:47Bruce Gudmundsson: But wicked has a different meaning.
- 7:52Bruce Gudmundsson: But a wicked problem, all kidding aside, is a problem that doesn't sit still while you're trying to solve it, and it's a problem that when you solve it, your reward is often another problem, very, very different from the kind of problem solving we learn in math class.
- 8:20Mark McGrath: So you're speaking our language, so we're consultants who help build confidence and complexity, and one of the ways that we do it is helping improve organizational learning and following void for exactly what you're talking about novel problems and wicked problems.
- 8:38Mark McGrath: So decision forcing cases are a way to help get people in the right frame of mind, right type of thinking that they're going to need when something is emergent that didn't previously exist.
- 8:50Mark McGrath: This would be an aid for that, like a training and learning aid for that.
- 8:54Mark McGrath: Is that my following?
- 8:56Bruce Gudmundsson: Yeah, very much, so very much so.
- 8:58Bruce Gudmundsson: And I think that it's got a sibling.
- 9:02Bruce Gudmundsson: Another type of exercise that's similar, called the tactical decision game or the decision game.
- 9:09Bruce Gudmundsson: And the decision games or these fictional decision games are very similar to DFCs rather, but based on imaginary scenarios.
- 9:23Bruce Gudmundsson: And you may know of John Schmidt, who wrote FMFM1 Warfighting, that famous manual that changed the certainly the style of, not the substance of, american manuals for a generation, and he recommended looking up his book Mastering Tactics.
- 9:44Bruce Gudmundsson: He's a man of immense creativity, you know, kind of person who in I think, if he hadn't joined the Marine Corps, would have become a novelist.
- 9:58Bruce Gudmundsson: And he's very good at coming up with scenarios, fictional scenarios, imaginary scenarios, and those have their uses as well.
- 10:10Bruce Gudmundsson: I much prefer to use things that actually happened, one because I'm not as creative as someone like John I usually only see something when I see it but also because it helps people to avoid the trap of fighting the scenario.
- 10:35Bruce Gudmundsson: So, for example, you know I'll use a Marine Corps example If you give your Marines a scenario in which you know the ammunition didn't arrive, the canteens are empty, the orders are incorrect, the intelligence is wrong, they will say wait a minute.
- 11:04Bruce Gudmundsson: You're messing with us.
- 11:05Bruce Gudmundsson: You know you're just.
- 11:07Bruce Gudmundsson: This is just the harassment package.
- 11:09Bruce Gudmundsson: But if you give them an actual scenario, something from history, where all those things were true, which is more normal than not, you can simply say well, this actually happened.
- 11:29Bruce Gudmundsson: I'm not messing with you.
- 11:31Bruce Gudmundsson: This is a situation that Brigadier Thompson faced on the Falklands or Jeremy Moore faced later in the Falklands on this day.
- 11:42Bruce Gudmundsson: What we're working on now.
- 11:44Bruce Gudmundsson: Yes, yes, no, no, I'm not.
- 11:45Mark McGrath: So for the listeners yours truly, your co-host here on no Way Out.
- 11:51Mark McGrath: I'm a member of Bruce's Case Method Club, which is made up of people from all kinds of backgrounds, certainly not just military.
- 11:59Mark McGrath: There are people from all over industry and everything all over the world in fact, and we get put in these scenarios that are actual historical scenarios that we get pre-reading on, and what you're trying to do is get us in a frame of reference to approach a problem that's going to involve multiple decision points versus, say, like a TDG, maybe only one or two, right?
- 12:28Bruce Gudmundsson: Yes, you can have any number of decision points.
- 12:32Bruce Gudmundsson: That's at least one.
- 12:34Bruce Gudmundsson: So for example, at the Harvard Business School, a lot of their cases will have one or two decision points.
- 12:42Bruce Gudmundsson: Okay.
- 12:44Bruce Gudmundsson: In fact, having two decision points is a rarity.
- 12:48Bruce Gudmundsson: They call that having an A and a B case, and there's a great deal of background material.
- 12:55Bruce Gudmundsson: So before you get to the decision, if you're a student at the Harvard Business School, you're going to get a big, thick article full of data and observations and information and that's what you use to make your decision, because usually the business decisions are single decisions.
- 13:17Bruce Gudmundsson: They are, in essence, strategic decisions.
- 13:22Bruce Gudmundsson: Tactics are different.
- 13:25Bruce Gudmundsson: Tactics is about a number of events that follow each other in rapid succession, each of which requires a decision, and the type of cases I tend to do with the decision game club is that that's the group of which you are a member.
- 13:45Bruce Gudmundsson: Those tend to have multiple decisions.
- 13:54Bruce Gudmundsson: There might be six, seven, eight decisions in the course of a single hour.
- 14:03Mark McGrath: Yeah, well, so one of the things that it's appealing to me to talk about decision force in cases so that our audience hears it is that I think that there are invaluable tools to improve learning and complexity and in those scenarios that are there so these things actually happen.
- 14:21Mark McGrath: So these are things that we can learn from.
- 14:23Mark McGrath: We talked about the various decision points.
- 14:26Mark McGrath: You're certainly usually more than one and you're trying to put yourself in the shoes of someone that dealt with something that was certainly volatile, uncertain, complex and ambiguous.
- 14:36Mark McGrath: And then they're open-ended, right, I mean, you're asking open-ended questions to get people to sort of zero down on what they think that they would do given the scenario correct.
- 14:51Bruce Gudmundsson: Precisely right.
- 14:51Bruce Gudmundsson: There is no multiple choice, there's no simple.
- 14:59Bruce Gudmundsson: I mean sometimes it's go left or go right, but there's a lot more to going left or right than meets the eye.
- 15:08Mark McGrath: So and you fuse that with Socratic Method.
- 15:10Mark McGrath: So you're putting people in a nice way because we're all there to learn, but I have no idea that I'm going to be called and I have to be paying attention and you're going to implement the Socratic Method, asking us a question, whereas we're going to give you an answer on what we think could happen based off the events.
- 15:31Mark McGrath: Correct.
- 15:32Bruce Gudmundsson: That's correct.
- 15:33Bruce Gudmundsson: Now permission, sir, to geek out on Socrates a bit Absolutely.
- 15:36Mark McGrath: If I may Okay.
- 15:39Bruce Gudmundsson: So there's two approaches to the Socratic Method, which leads still it's been leading to confusion, to a lot of confusion for about 2,500 years now.
- 15:48Bruce Gudmundsson: There's the Socrates in the Platonic Dialogues and he's got a point of view and he's pushing his point of view.
- 15:58Bruce Gudmundsson: He's very often he's actually asking questions that he ends up in many cases answering himself, but he's got a very clear sense of where he wants to go.
- 16:08Bruce Gudmundsson: There's another Socrates which I much prefer, which is that of Xenophon.
- 16:13Bruce Gudmundsson: You may have heard of Xenophon.
- 16:14Mark McGrath: Oh yeah.
- 16:16Bruce Gudmundsson: He took a long trip with 10,000 of his closest friends through the Persian Empire and his approach is again much more open-ended.
- 16:29Bruce Gudmundsson: His Socrates is genuinely interested in the student solution.
- 16:35Bruce Gudmundsson: He's all about empowering the solution.
- 16:37Bruce Gudmundsson: Plato's got an agenda and Xenophon doesn't, so if I use the term Socratic Method quite often, this is right here in this little pamphlet which I'm happy to send to your listeners.
- 16:59Mark McGrath: Yeah, we'll link to it in the show notes.
- 17:01Mark McGrath: What I'm hearing you say, though, is that the Xenophon interpretation of Socrates which you apply is empowering the player in the decision-forcing case.
- 17:11Mark McGrath: So if an organization is running these, or if we're helping facilitate a decision-forcing case scenario, or a class or something like that, we're empowering them to come up with their own solutions, their own decisions to get them to the point where, eventually well, it was the Socratic Method we get you down to the say I don't know right, because we're trying to trigger and continue learning correct.
- 17:36Bruce Gudmundsson: Very much so.
- 17:37Bruce Gudmundsson: But the point is not to inflict the facilitator's opinion upon the participant, upon the player.
- 17:47Bruce Gudmundsson: It is to give the player experience in exercising judgment.
- 17:57Mark McGrath: Yeah, breaking their orientation and revising it and reorienting and based off new facts and then using their viewpoints to deal with the mission at hand or the case at hand, correct?
- 18:10Bruce Gudmundsson: Very much so.
- 18:11Bruce Gudmundsson: And again, you're mentioning John Boyd and I'm sitting here in the old headquarters building in Quantico Town, about a block and a half from the place where I had lunch with John Boyd in 1989.
- 18:27Bruce Gudmundsson: And one of the points he always liked to make was the most important step in the Udalloop is orientation.
- 18:36Bruce Gudmundsson: So a big question that I often ask in the course of teaching a case is who are you, when are you, what are you trying to do?
- 18:53Bruce Gudmundsson: Release these orientation type questions.
- 18:59Mark McGrath: So the military, military history, rather, is chock full of examples that are just ready made for these things, right?
- 19:09Mark McGrath: I mean, you don't have to go and create hypothetical scenarios.
- 19:13Mark McGrath: These are real things that actually happened.
- 19:15Mark McGrath: Do you see?
- 19:16Mark McGrath: Now, if HBS is doing this, are they using decision forcing cases inside of actual business scenarios too?
- 19:23Mark McGrath: Do they point those out?
- 19:26Bruce Gudmundsson: Yes, very much so.
- 19:26Bruce Gudmundsson: When Dean Wallace B Dunham, who is the godfather of the case method at Harvard very interesting guy he quickly realized that there was no business equivalent of military history, even in 1923, you go into the Boston Public Library or the New York Public Library and there'll be just the shelves will grown under the weight of military history, not so much for business.
- 20:05Bruce Gudmundsson: So he ended up developing, creating a little research shop.
- 20:12Bruce Gudmundsson: Its name has changed off over the years.
- 20:16Bruce Gudmundsson: I think it was originally called the Institute for Business Research or the Business Research Something, but anyway, to actually write the business history.
- 20:26Bruce Gudmundsson: And the difference with military based cases is that you have this treasure trove of military history to work off of.
- 20:39Bruce Gudmundsson: This is certainly something that General, then Colonel George Marshall, realized that you could just simply go to the shelf and pull off books and find a lot of the raw materials for DFCs, whereas again, the business folks have got to work a little harder.
- 21:03Bruce Gudmundsson: And it's interesting you think about different fields.
- 21:07Bruce Gudmundsson: I know there's some folks in the firefighting business, particularly wilderness firefighting police officers, who do these, but their difficulty often is finding the scenarios.
- 21:24Mark McGrath: So it's not.
- 21:24Mark McGrath: I mean, I've always thought that, again, I'm biased.
- 21:27Mark McGrath: I'm a veteran and I'm the son of a career officer myself, so it's like I'm biased towards military history.
- 21:33Mark McGrath: But, to your point, there's no shortage of materials, going all the way back to the ancients, to present, that can be used in these scenarios.
- 21:41Mark McGrath: And what I see, and even the club that you have and that you guide and lead, with all these individuals coming from various backgrounds, not military, what I see people doing is they're extracting principles, they're learning principles that happen to present themselves to somebody in a military situation.
- 22:02Mark McGrath: Yet you can take those principles out and apply them to your manufacturing company, and apply them to your law firm, and apply them to your football team, whatever.
- 22:10Mark McGrath: It's the same type of thinking.
- 22:12Mark McGrath: Am I following on that?
- 22:15Bruce Gudmundsson: Yes, yeah, I'd be careful with the word principles, because a lot of people use it to mean something else.
- 22:22Mark McGrath: People often use principles to mean guidelines and rules of following them, even hard and fast rules.
- 22:28Bruce Gudmundsson: Yeah, what would you say that if I'm going to what you'll get from DFCs, but you will get habits and attitudes.
- 22:37Bruce Gudmundsson: You will get certain skills that you can apply to a wide variety of situations.
- 23:45Mark McGrath: Which we would say, I think, and we would agree, that would round out and augment someone's orientation, as they continue to interact with volatility, uncertainty, complex ambiguities at fair, yes, yes.
- 24:02Bruce Gudmundsson: And a big part of what people learn it's not all of it, but a big part is being comfortable with those things.
- 24:08Bruce Gudmundsson: They have people who are comfortable with discomfort.
- 24:12Bruce Gudmundsson: Okay, they don't expect things to be laid out for them.
- 24:18Bruce Gudmundsson: If you look at what most students do in school, most of the time that they are being asked to solve problems that have very narrow limits on them and all of the orientation work has been done for them and that really, again going back to Boyd is the most important step is orienting yourself Really.
- 24:52Bruce Gudmundsson: It's the problem.
- 24:54Bruce Gudmundsson: Framing, it's the figuring out what's going on.
- 25:01Bruce Gudmundsson: A Ferdinand Foch you remember him as the man who won World War I.
- 25:06Bruce Gudmundsson: He was a French officer with a German library.
- 25:13Bruce Gudmundsson: It's very, very interesting realizing watching him grow up in the French army trying to use what he learned about the once in future enemy and trying to instruct his compatriots in these methods.
- 25:35Bruce Gudmundsson: But his central question was de quoi s'agit-il?
- 25:42Bruce Gudmundsson: What's going on here?
- 25:44Bruce Gudmundsson: What's happening?
- 25:48Bruce Gudmundsson: I used to refer to this as Marvin Gaye's question, but now the time has passed, no one remembers my reference to the song what's Going On?
- 26:01Mark McGrath: It's funny that you mentioned that we did actually record it with someone today and they brought up what's Going On by Marvin.
- 26:07Bruce Gudmundsson: Gaye.
- 26:08Mark McGrath: I'm not exaggerating.
- 26:12Bruce Gudmundsson: Yes, that's a sort of reference, that.
- 26:14Bruce Gudmundsson: But 10 years ago I'd make it and I called it my Master Sergeant and above reference, the old timer's got it and the youngsters gave me a blank look so I stopped using it.
- 26:29Bruce Gudmundsson: But that idea again going back to this idea of orientation, figuring out what the problem is, Right, what's actually going on.
- 26:40Mark McGrath: So we get, in order to get people comfortable, being uncomfortable in complexity as it unfolds, we, in a decision forcing case, we put them in the shoes of a protagonist, so a historical protagonist.
- 26:56Mark McGrath: And then, reading off of Chris Butler's article here, he says that there's six components for a DFC.
- 27:03Mark McGrath: There's the introduction, then there's the context setting the story, and there's the questions to explore the context as a group.
- 27:11Mark McGrath: And then the fourth part is to prompt to make a decision and compare and contrast between participants.
- 27:19Mark McGrath: And then five is to repeat two through four as many times as appropriate, and then six discuss the actual outcome.
- 27:28Mark McGrath: Is that the basics of what I need for a successful DFC?
- 27:32Bruce Gudmundsson: Yes, yes, I think Chris is probably being a bit more systematic than.
- 27:37Mark McGrath: I am.
- 27:38Bruce Gudmundsson: But this is often the case with the practitioner.
- 27:42Bruce Gudmundsson: It's like the famous Frenchman who didn't realize he'd been speaking prose all his life.
- 27:49Bruce Gudmundsson: So very much so.
- 27:53Bruce Gudmundsson: I think there is that and we often miss.
- 27:57Bruce Gudmundsson: I know and this is my fault in our discussions, because I'm so keen on keeping things exactly to an hour we often miss that last stage, which is the reflection, reflecting back on the case and asking ourselves okay, so we've worked through this case, we've made, we've dealt with a bunch of problems, we've made a bunch of decisions.
- 28:24Bruce Gudmundsson: We've seen how those decisions played out, both in the near term and sometimes in the longer term.
- 28:30Bruce Gudmundsson: So what is this case about?
- 28:33Bruce Gudmundsson: What's standing on one foot?
- 28:35Bruce Gudmundsson: Tell us, what's the story here?
- 28:39Bruce Gudmundsson: What would you call this?
- 28:42Bruce Gudmundsson: What's the headline?
- 28:44Mark McGrath: One of the things that I love about it is, no matter how much I think I know about a certain historical event, the way that you've designed them and you're designing them.
- 28:53Mark McGrath: I think it's brilliant.
- 28:53Mark McGrath: I hope others look into this.
- 28:55Mark McGrath: But you, even if you know a lot about something, you're still put into situations where you're thinking and you know how this ends.
- 29:05Mark McGrath: But there you are faced with these scenarios and now you have a better understanding of what that person was actually encountering and the complexities that they were actually encountering and the forces of nature and the unknowns and things that they didn't know.
- 29:19Mark McGrath: I think that it gives you a completely different context.
- 29:23Mark McGrath: Even if you think you know a lot about a certain event, like, say, for example, we're doing the Falklands War right now it is amazing to me that, no matter how much you've read and studied about that, when you're putting those shoes to make those decisions, it really does sort of bring out that discomfort that you need to grow, to improve your learning and improve your ability to shift perspectives.
- 29:49Mark McGrath: Does that make a sense?
- 29:51Bruce Gudmundsson: Very much so, in fact, the other side.
- 29:55Bruce Gudmundsson: Mostly when I'm using DFCs or teaching DFCs, facilitating DFCs, what I'm doing is helping people use history to practice decision-making, to deal with problems of a certain kind.
- 30:15Bruce Gudmundsson: For example, with our Falklands cases that we're working through in the Decision Game Club, a lot of what we're dealing with is the problem of how to get forces on land to cooperate with forces at sea.
- 30:33Bruce Gudmundsson: That's a lot more complicated than certainly I thought before we started doing this series.
- 30:44Bruce Gudmundsson: But at the same time as I put these problems together, as these exercises together, I'm also learning a great deal about history.
- 30:56Bruce Gudmundsson: All sorts of questions pop up that aren't in the references I'm using and that forces me to dig.
- 31:06Bruce Gudmundsson: You realize there are a bunch of things that are happening in the scenario that didn't turn out to be important but could have been.
- 31:18Bruce Gudmundsson: For example, I just discovered that most of the fighting in the Falklands war happens on the island of East Falkland, where most of the people live, but there's another island called West Falkland.
- 31:36Bruce Gudmundsson: I just discovered, after doing this since Christmas time right, it's now middle of July that there was an Argentine garrison in a place called Port Howard on.
- 31:52Bruce Gudmundsson: West Falkland.
- 31:53Bruce Gudmundsson: Nobody talks about that in the memoirs because it was a beached whale.
- 32:03Bruce Gudmundsson: It was a garrison that just got landed, wasn't supported and was just basically keeping itself alive, not doing anything.
- 32:16Bruce Gudmundsson: It also didn't have any transport and what have you, but it was always there.
- 32:21Bruce Gudmundsson: If you think about the decision makers, that's always in the back of their mind.
- 32:26Bruce Gudmundsson: That's one of the reasons they're keeping a lot of resources out of the fight, or the fight that turned out to be, because they're concerned about how do we deal with these 800 guys in Port Howard, but because nothing happened of it, it's at best a footnote.
- 32:55Mark McGrath: So when you do present us with these problems and we get these questions, it seems like one of the things so clearly.
- 33:01Mark McGrath: It's helping us make better decisions in a pressure situation where people are watching you right.
- 33:07Mark McGrath: So we have everybody zoomed in from all over the world.
- 33:10Mark McGrath: You don't know when you're going to be called.
- 33:11Mark McGrath: You're making a decision.
- 33:13Mark McGrath: You've got to do it quick and you have to be able to explain your rationale and learn from it.
- 33:21Mark McGrath: I think the other thing is that you're developing.
- 33:24Mark McGrath: You're really putting yourself in someone else's shoes, you're putting yourself in a leader's shoes, so that in a way, I guess we could say we're gaining maybe some empathy when we find ourselves in those exact situations.
- 33:38Mark McGrath: And maybe we're not in the Falklands War, but maybe we're in a scenario within our own company, or we're in a scenario within our own law firm or football team or whatever.
- 33:48Mark McGrath: And that ability to challenge yourself, like that challenge your thinking, is going to pay benefits as you continue to learn, as you go forward.
- 34:02Bruce Gudmundsson: Yes, very much so.
- 34:03Bruce Gudmundsson: And it's also, it's about having developing these habits of thought, yeah, and, it happens, of character really, because one of them is humility.
- 34:14Bruce Gudmundsson: It's realizing what you don't know.
- 34:20Bruce Gudmundsson: If you have a particular character… should we say doctrine?
- 34:28Bruce Gudmundsson: Right, you went to school, you learned this method and you're now going to go out in the world and apply it, that can give you a kind of false confidence, right, and until you fall on your face, you have this immense faith in this method.
- 34:48Bruce Gudmundsson: If you study by means of cases, you realize there's a whole bunch of really smart guys, really smart people who made some hard decisions and sometimes it worked and sometimes it didn't, but they were venturing into the unloan, they were going to the Terra Incognita where the dragons dance, and it's a very sobering thought, I think, both not humiliating but humble making yeah, it's like the nuance there but also very liberating.
- 35:41Bruce Gudmundsson: So you end up realizing that there's a whole bunch of stuff you don't know In fact, most things you don't know.
- 35:55Mark McGrath: Isn't that?
- 35:56Mark McGrath: The greatest part of it Is that you realize that there's a whole lot you don't know and you now have the opportunity to learn in order to adapt.
- 36:04Mark McGrath: And I think that that's the when I think of decision forcing cases, and why would recommend it to If I was talking with leaders in a company that were looking to build more team cohesion around organizational learning in order to create better adaptiveness.
- 36:18Mark McGrath: If you're not learning, you're not adapting.
- 36:21Mark McGrath: Period.
- 36:21Mark McGrath: And this is a way where people can exercise those intellectual muscles, those insight muscles that they have inside their cognitive power to put themselves in a scenario that's relatively capital, light, right, it doesn't cost anything really to get on the internet or go through a scenario.
- 36:41Mark McGrath: You don't have to buy or build anything and you're exercising your most potent weapon your mind.
- 36:50Bruce Gudmundsson: Yes, no, you mentioned the term cohesion.
- 36:53Bruce Gudmundsson: What happens is when you build, when you work through a bunch of these exercises with a group of the people in the group learn a lot about each other.
- 37:07Mark McGrath: Yes.
- 37:09Bruce Gudmundsson: And they also get into the habit of learning from each other.
- 37:16Mark McGrath: Well, to your point.
- 37:17Mark McGrath: It is interesting in our cohort with it right now with the Falklands War, to have people from so many different nationalities participate, to get a perspective where you as an American or you as someone from the UK, you think you know the story and then you hear it from other sides that you'd never heard of before and I think that that's enlightening in some respect because you're able to we talked about empathy but you're able to have an environment where you can gain another perspective that you would not likely have, sort of going through your own canon or stuff, through your own stuff that you learned in school or whatever.
- 37:55Mark McGrath: So there is that.
- 37:58Bruce Gudmundsson: Indeed, and the Decision Game Club has again, people from all over the world and people from many different walks of life, people of different ages.
- 38:07Bruce Gudmundsson: But I think that, even if you're this is something you're doing with your local company, with your 20-person company or 10-person company, even if everybody grew up in the same town, you're going to get a variety of perspectives, and perspectives in the most literal sense of the term, people who are looking at the problem from a different direction.
- 38:44Bruce Gudmundsson: Yes, and the problem has got multiple dimensions, so you're seeing it from different perspectives, and that gives you it helps you form a fuller picture of the problem.
- 39:01Mark McGrath: There's that famous example that Chuck Spinney uses in his epistemology of Boyd's Destruction Creation.
- 39:07Mark McGrath: But think of a pyramid.
- 39:09Mark McGrath: Right, if you're only looking at a pyramid from one point, one group only sees an isosceles triangle or an equilateral triangle.
- 39:18Mark McGrath: Somebody from they only gets one other vantage point, they only see a square.
- 39:21Mark McGrath: And then another group sees a triangle with a line down the middle or a square with an accident, right, and if we don't get those other perspectives, we're going to prepare for square and somebody's going to prepare for equilateral triangle, but nobody's going to be prepared for pyramid.
- 39:36Mark McGrath: Yes, and if we don't gain those perspectives?
- 39:39Mark McGrath: I mean, that seems to me one of the most common things or not common, but very widely rampant is that when other perspectives are stifled or when an environment, a learning environment like that, comes with a decision forcing case, perspectives are going to be maybe limited, maybe we're just going to get one side, one view, and we're not going to look at problems, we're not going to look at business challenges, we're not going to look at things from an array of perspectives, because we don't have the ability to do so and that's going to cost us in the long run.
- 40:16Mark McGrath: That's going to make sure that our orientation is misaligned from reality and it's going to have a negative effect on how we observe and it's going to have a negative effect on how we decide and act.
- 40:24Mark McGrath: And then the loop we're not going to be able to learn this effectively because we're going to be operating on a bad orientation or a misaligned orientation that's going to diverge as time goes forward.
- 40:35Mark McGrath: Because we're not going to have, we're going to just prepare for triangle.
- 40:39Mark McGrath: We're not going to ever consider pyramid, if that makes sense.
- 40:43Bruce Gudmundsson: Yes, and I would add to Chuck Spinney's analogy there that if you're inside the pyramid, what you see is flickering torches and a mummy chasing you.
- 40:57Mark McGrath: There, you go.
- 40:58Bruce Gudmundsson: There's a whole bunch of things going on and the fact that the DFC, or the historical map problem, if you will, to use the General Marshall's term, they also call it a hip historical immersion problem, because you're being dipped in history, you're being immersed in a historical situation, but because these things are not discipline specific, nobody is saying, well, you can't say that or you can't think of that.
- 41:40Bruce Gudmundsson: I think of so much of academic training.
- 41:43Bruce Gudmundsson: The things people get in the classroom is about limiting the framework, about limiting the perspective.
- 41:56Bruce Gudmundsson: In my own academic field, that of history, there are many people who will take great umbrage at people doing counterfactuals, going through the what if scenarios.
- 42:11Bruce Gudmundsson: Now, I find those incredibly useful for trying to figure out what actually happened and why people did what they did.
- 42:19Bruce Gudmundsson: But a lot of people will say, well, you can't do that, that's not history.
- 42:22Bruce Gudmundsson: We're trying to extend things into the future.
- 42:25Bruce Gudmundsson: There's no such limitation in the decision forcing case that there are.
- 42:35Bruce Gudmundsson: You don't have any of these preexisting limitations.
- 42:43Mark McGrath: Yeah, you're free to explore, you're free to question, you're free to challenge, you're free to test and ultimately, that's preparing you for something that you may be facing down the road in the reality of your world, be it business, military, etc.
- 42:59Bruce Gudmundsson: Very much so, and I also find that there are a lot of simple DFCs, and I do these very much to introduce the method to people and people in a wide variety of fields.
- 43:15Bruce Gudmundsson: One of them, very simple one, one of my favorites is that you're Queen Elizabeth the first, not the one we all know, but Queen Elizabeth from the 16th century.
- 43:35Bruce Gudmundsson: And you've just become queen.
- 43:36Bruce Gudmundsson: And you became queen because your sister, your sister Mary, died.
- 43:43Bruce Gudmundsson: And soon after becoming queen, you get a letter from your former brother-in-law, Philip of Spain, proposing marriage.
- 43:54Bruce Gudmundsson: What do you do, your majesty?
- 43:58Bruce Gudmundsson: You know and I've done that with you know groups of school children, I've done that with people in the airline business, and you get lots of interesting perspectives.
- 44:15Bruce Gudmundsson: In particular, what was interesting is that I did this with airline employees, both cabin crew and flight crew, from an airline based in Lithuania, and back in the 16th century, you know, Lithuania was a very, very big kingdom or Commonwealth, rather very, very big place, you know, all the way from the Baltic to Black Sea, and so they kept asking questions about well, maybe there's a Lithuanian prince that the queen can marry, and it's something that 99% of your British historians wouldn't think about, Because they're thinking about okay, I'm thinking about Spain, I'm thinking about France, thinking about Scotland, I'm not thinking about Lithuania, and that's one of the actually the joys of doing these with groups from different parts of the world.
- 45:25Bruce Gudmundsson: It says that you do get a different geographical perspective.
- 45:31Mark McGrath: So if you have a cohort of 20, and you're instructing ones, teaching in 21 or learning, Very much so yes.
- 45:41Bruce Gudmundsson: No, no.
- 45:42Mark McGrath: The great secret of case teaching is that the case teacher learns a lot more than the students do, and maybe as we wind down, then I mean it's also too a way to put people in situations without actually exposing them to, you know market risk or danger.
- 46:02Mark McGrath: You know it's a, you know you can think about decisions that had to have been made under fire in chaotic, adverse environments and it might prep you for one that you don't actually have to go to to.
- 46:15Mark McGrath: You know, cognitively, discuss it with others but at the same time ready you for scenarios that may come as your markets unfold or as business unfolds, right Indeed you know, the real world is expensive.
- 46:29Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 46:30Bruce Gudmundsson: You know, doing things in the real world is expensive.
- 46:32Bruce Gudmundsson: So having exercises with a lot of of cognitive fidelity, has to say the mental as far as your brain is concerned is a very similar exercise, but as far as your wallet is concerned is not.
- 46:49Bruce Gudmundsson: And to do that over and over again, to build up a vast stock of of experience, Without actually having to go do it.
- 47:01Mark McGrath: you could learn about it, you can test it, you can try it, you can discuss it, you can think about it, you can challenge each other on it, and not one bullet comes flying.
- 47:11Bruce Gudmundsson: Yes, yes, the no.
- 47:13Bruce Gudmundsson: No.
- 47:14Bruce Gudmundsson: Nobody's in danger of losing his livelihood.
- 47:19Mark McGrath: Now, some of these decision forcing cases, too, do take form on actual battlefields.
- 47:23Mark McGrath: We know of many businesses and corporations and we've done them as well over the years of taking people to actual battlefields and putting them in these scenarios to think about these things.
- 47:33Mark McGrath: So so there's, there's there's other methods than just virtual classroom or in-person classroom, right, there's also maybe some hands-on ways.
- 47:41Mark McGrath: If you're close to these types of things, I mean in America, certainly on the here, in the sort of the East, northeast and Southeast really, I mean there's lots of opportunities to go and do these things where these actually happened, correct, Very much so.
- 47:57Bruce Gudmundsson: Yeah, we call these on-site decision forcing cases or decision forcing staff rides, and so the and the method is basically the same, except that, rather than you know, showing people a map and saying, here you are, you're your major Beckham, and you're in charge of the, the horse artillery of General Stewart's cavalry, and it is the, I think, what is it?
- 48:25Bruce Gudmundsson: 5th, 6th, 6th of June, early June 1863, and you're about to head north and your, your battalion, is bivouacked.
- 48:36Bruce Gudmundsson: And you've got your horses, you've let them loose so they can enjoy the nice, nice, fresh summer grass, that good Virginia grass, before they have to haul the guns up up through the Great Valley.
- 48:49Bruce Gudmundsson: It's going to be hard to work for them.
- 48:52Bruce Gudmundsson: So horses are having a fine time.
- 48:55Bruce Gudmundsson: It's about time to get up.
- 48:58Bruce Gudmundsson: It's almost dawn, people are stirring in their blankets, some people have started breakfast already, and you hear two shots fire from from the direction of this, this creek.
- 49:10Bruce Gudmundsson: You know what do you do, major Beckham.
- 49:14Bruce Gudmundsson: And then, of course, there's a whole bunch of decisions that he makes over the course of the of the day, and that's something you know you can do if, if the battlefield is, you know, it resembles what it did at the time of the decision.
- 49:34Bruce Gudmundsson: But again this, this brandy station, battlefields in great shape, thanks to the folks at the Civil War Trust.
- 49:40Bruce Gudmundsson: The Battle of Fredericksburg.
- 49:45Bruce Gudmundsson: From the Union point of view, fredericksburg hasn't changed much.
- 49:51Mark McGrath: The Gettysburg and Antietam are my two favorites.
- 49:54Mark McGrath: I find that they're they're really good for that.
- 49:58Bruce Gudmundsson: Yes, yes, and because a lot of people have done a lot of good work, they're reverbing those parks, if you're like me and a big fan of the American War of Independence.
- 50:07Bruce Gudmundsson: And there's Moors Creek Bridge, which is a really interesting battle early in the war.
- 50:16Bruce Gudmundsson: All sorts of interesting things going on.
- 50:19Bruce Gudmundsson: There's an amphibious landing about to happen a few miles away.
- 50:24Bruce Gudmundsson: There's ethnic conflict, there's ethnic communities taking sides, there's tactics and there's politics.
- 50:35Bruce Gudmundsson: All these things coming together gives you a really good sense of the richness of the problems faced by the people involved in that war.
- 50:47Mark McGrath: Yep, and, like we said, we know many people, many backgrounds, that come to these things, that have never spent one day in the military and find a lot of value in this for their teams that they're leading Again the opportunity to not only enhance learning but enhance cohesion and trust and other things.
- 51:06Mark McGrath: There's a lot of benefit to this and it's definitely something we can go in depth and talk about with them Now.
- 51:12Mark McGrath: If I want to learn more about your decision-forcing cases, I go to what website?
- 51:20Bruce Gudmundsson: Okay, so a couple of things you can do.
- 51:23Bruce Gudmundsson: One is what I call the Military Learning Gateway, which is a blogspot website.
- 51:31Bruce Gudmundsson: It's teachUSMC, and I wish I had called it learnUSMC but teachUSMCblogspotcom and then you'll find a couple of sites on the other side of that gateway that deal with decision-forcing cases.
- 51:54Bruce Gudmundsson: One is an introductory site and one is an advanced site, depending on how you like to learn.
- 52:01Bruce Gudmundsson: You can start with either one.
- 52:03Bruce Gudmundsson: The pamphlet that's up here on the screen takes an academic view, and you can find that on the site.
- 52:15Bruce Gudmundsson: I've got a bunch of other pamphlets that look at decision-forcing cases from different points of view.
- 52:29Bruce Gudmundsson: Some are more military than others.
- 52:35Bruce Gudmundsson: It's teachUSMCblogspotcom.
- 52:40Bruce Gudmundsson: You'll find all sorts of things there.
- 52:42Bruce Gudmundsson: Also, check out my substacks.
- 52:45Bruce Gudmundsson: I've got a couple of substacks which look at these problems from two different angles.
- 52:53Bruce Gudmundsson: One is called the Tactical Notebook, which, as you can imagine, is about military things, and the other one is called Extramurus, which is about self-directed learning Of course these things come together in the DFCs.
- 53:10Mark McGrath: Full disclosure.
- 53:10Mark McGrath: I'm a subscriber to Tactical Notebook.
- 53:12Mark McGrath: It's phenomenal.
- 53:13Mark McGrath: It's very straightforward to read and it's applicable.
- 53:18Mark McGrath: You can pull things out of it that, when you understand them and see them, you'll see it everywhere.
- 53:24Mark McGrath: It's like a lot of stuff with John Boyd Bruce, I mean.
- 53:27Mark McGrath: Once you see it, once you get it, it's hard to unsee it and then you just want more.
- 53:32Mark McGrath: This is another methodology that organizations and teams can implement pretty straightforward, pretty simply, to enhance their organizational learning, which in turn, enhances their adaptability.
- 53:46Mark McGrath: Organizations like the Marines, for example, have been doing this for a long time.
- 53:50Mark McGrath: You and I are both alumni of that organization.
- 53:52Mark McGrath: People that are alumni of that organization have taken that out and brought it to the business world.
- 53:58Mark McGrath: It's, I think, a great effect.
- 54:01Mark McGrath: I think it's a really good thing that people need to look into and they also need to say well, I wasn't in the military.
- 54:09Mark McGrath: And again they could go back to our episode with Chris Butler and say, no, I wasn't in the military.
- 54:13Mark McGrath: But there's a lot of value in this because it's forcing me to take multiple perspectives, to look at problems from more than one vantage point and come up with solutions quickly, under pressure, that are going to get challenged, that are going to get me uncomfortable, becoming uncomfortable, which I'm going to need to be if I want to thrive in complexity.
- 54:34Mark McGrath: Is that a?
- 54:35Bruce Gudmundsson: good summation.
- 54:35Bruce Gudmundsson: Yes, I think I get it.
- 54:37Bruce Gudmundsson: We've been talking a lot about the military aspect of this, but I've done these with rooms full of eighth graders.
- 54:44Bruce Gudmundsson: I've done an undergraduate course at Dickinson College based entirely on decision forcing cases.
- 54:52Bruce Gudmundsson: I've done this with rooms full of flight attendants.
- 54:57Bruce Gudmundsson: It's not something that's just for military folk or even primarily for military folk.
- 55:05Bruce Gudmundsson: Military people are the people I most often work with, but it doesn't have to be that way.
- 55:16Mark McGrath: I was in asset management for almost 20 years and it never ceased to amaze me how people would blow it off because it came from the military, that there was nothing you could learn from the military.
- 55:27Mark McGrath: Some did not all, but some did, and they would explore and try to understand these things and they would see hey, you're actually getting us to think about things from different perspectives.
- 55:38Mark McGrath: We need that operating capital markets, we need that if we're going to operate a hedge fund or a portfolio or things like that.
- 55:43Mark McGrath: I would challenge people don't dismiss this.
- 55:48Mark McGrath: Look into this and consider this, because your organizational learning is going to be the key to your adaptation as complexity continues to unfold.
- 56:01Mark McGrath: Leaders or readers and learners this is a big component of that to learn, sharpen the cognitive edge.
- 56:10Mark McGrath: When you're in scenarios that are similar in the future, you'll be better prepared than those that hadn't done this type of training.
- 56:19Mark McGrath: Is that a fair statement?
- 56:22Bruce Gudmundsson: I think, a very fair statement.
- 56:24Mark McGrath: Excellent, Bruce.
- 56:26Mark McGrath: Why don't we end it on that note?
- 56:27Mark McGrath: I think that was a great conversation.
- 56:29Mark McGrath: Anything else that you want to bring up and make sure that we know about decision-forcing cases?
- 56:34Mark McGrath: I think we know where to go.
- 56:35Mark McGrath: We've got the basics.
- 56:37Mark McGrath: Anything else to add?
- 56:41Bruce Gudmundsson: No, I think you find the website, you find the substacks and you're on your way.
- 56:46Mark McGrath: Excellent.
- 56:47Mark McGrath: Bruce Govinsen, thanks so much for joining us on no Way Out.
- 56:52Bruce Gudmundsson: Thank you, moose, it's been a real pleasure.
- 56:53Mark McGrath: We'll talk soon.
- 56:55Bruce Gudmundsson: Okay, bye-bye.