Latest / No Way Out / Mastering the Medium with Andrew McLuhan
Transcript
- 0:21Mark McGrath: So, Ponch, you and I have both been guests on Ed Brennegar's podcast on leadership, and it was at the end of last year.
- 0:29Mark McGrath: Ed sends me this email, CC Andrew McLuhan and he's like you two guys absolutely have to meet.
- 0:36Mark McGrath: And there I am kind of dumbstruck that I'm getting connected to Marshall McLuhan's grandson, connected to Marshall McLuhan's grandson and Marshall McLuhan, who I became deeply familiar with I only had a surface understanding with until I started studying with John Robb years ago, who's been a guest on our show three times, of drawing the parallels between what Boyd was saying.
- 0:57Mark McGrath: You get.
- 0:59Mark McGrath: You get a better understanding of what John Boyd is saying if you understand what Marshall McLuhan was saying and vice versa.
- 1:04Mark McGrath: I feel like I have a better understanding of what John Boyd is saying if you understand what Marshall McLuhan was saying and vice versa.
- 1:07Mark McGrath: I feel like I have a better understanding of what Marshall McLuhan was saying if I have an understanding of what John Boyd is saying.
- 1:14Mark McGrath: And, Andrew, we're really glad that you can join us and I think the one thing that we could all could agree with at the very beginning all three of us is that either John Boyd or Marshall McLuhan.
- 1:24Mark McGrath: Either way, the masses don't understand what exactly John Boyd was trying to say and what Marshall McLuhan was trying to say.
- 1:31Mark McGrath: So in Boyd's case, he's reduced to OODA loop, for example, or in Marshall McLuhan's case, it's the medium, is the message.
- 1:39Mark McGrath: That's what he said and it's almost as if there was nothing else beyond that.
- 1:43Mark McGrath: So here we are, exploring the ideas and broadening them and trying to demonstrate to people that knowing one helps you know the other better, and it's a massive, massive edge as volatility, uncertainty, complexity, ambiguity continue to unfold.
- 2:01Mark McGrath: So where should we start, Ponch?
- 2:06Mark McGrath: I'll start with you.
- 2:06Mark McGrath: What's your immediate impression of that?
- 2:10Ponch Rivera: So over the course of the podcast we've had a lot of guests on and some of them from neuroscience, talking about the four E's of cognition.
- 2:17Ponch Rivera: So the idea of embodied, embedded, inactive and extended is critical to understand John Boyd's OODA loop.
- 2:22Ponch Rivera: And I think when I first heard the medium is the message I'm like I don't understand this, and then I started to make more sense of it.
- 2:28Ponch Rivera: It's just that extended thing.
- 2:30Ponch Rivera: That's part of the OODA loop, right?
- 2:32Ponch Rivera: We never put the OODA loop around the brain and say it's just the brain, it's scale-free, it's a fractal.
- 2:37Ponch Rivera: So when we talk about the OODA loop, we like to put a boundary around whatever it is the mind, the body, the mind and the extended mind, which could be a computer, it could be the internet, it could be X or Twitter or whatever it used to be called, but that's it right.
- 2:54Ponch Rivera: So that was a big connection for me is to hear the neuroscientists talk about 4E cognition and those from the cognitive science background talk about it as well.
- 3:03Ponch Rivera: So that's where the connection is for me, as well as information theory when you look at McLuhan's work.
- 3:09Ponch Rivera: So that's where I am on this Mark.
- 3:10Ponch Rivera: I'm looking forward to today's conversation.
- 3:12Mark McGrath: So, andrew, we're going to introduce you.
- 3:14Mark McGrath: Now You're the grandson of Marshall McLuhan and there you are at the end of last year, minding your own business, and Ed Brennegar connects you with an email to me and the next thing you know, we're Zooming.
- 3:27Mark McGrath: I remember exactly where I was.
- 3:28Mark McGrath: We're Zooming for like two or three hours and I'm telling you about John Boyd.
- 3:32Mark McGrath: Why don't you start from there and let's steer it back?
- 3:37Mark McGrath: So here's me telling you in December John Boyd, john Boyd, the connections, what do you think?
- 3:44Andrew McLuhan: Yeah, it's funny, I'll get a text message and my son, ezra, will say oh, is that Mark?
- 3:51Andrew McLuhan: Again, because we've been talking pretty much nonstop, very regularly, since we were introduced by Ed, and not only were we introduced to each other, but I was introduced to John Boyd and the OODA loop, which it's been really interesting, because I think every conversation that we've had has been, you know, a step toward this larger goal which we both have, I believe, which is that we see Marshall McLuhan's work in understanding the nature and effects of technologies and we see John Boyd's work in decision making and understanding all the parts of that process, decision-making and understanding all the parts of that process and we see that these are very, very much parallel kind of things even running on on the same thing, and what we're we keep trying to put them together and seeing how they, how and where they interface.
- 4:57Andrew McLuhan: And the the fun thing, the fun part, or the the fun or maddening part, is that it's like we know they fit together, um, but what we've been trying to do is, you know, it's like when you, when you know something, um, deeply in yourself, it's like, yeah, I know, one plus one is two, but how do you actually articulate that?
- 5:23Andrew McLuhan: How do you express that so that other people can understand it?
- 5:26Andrew McLuhan: And, in a sense, that's been a lot of my work with my family's work and, as he said, marshall McLuhan was my grandfather.
- 5:38Andrew McLuhan: My father, eric McLuhan, was his eldest son and I'm kind of the third generation in this area, which is a whole other story.
- 5:47Andrew McLuhan: But, you know, a lot of my work is preserving the work that my father and grandfather did, but not just preserving it.
- 5:57Andrew McLuhan: Bring it forward to where it's useful, because I think this is the thing which characterizes, I think, boyd's work is its utility, right, its applicability.
- 6:08Andrew McLuhan: And for me, that's what's most interesting in my family's work is its utility and applicability.
- 6:16Andrew McLuhan: Because, you know, while I'm proud of my heritage and the history, I'm really more.
- 6:24Andrew McLuhan: I think we're at a point in time today where history and museums are great, but we need tools and we need to be able to understand what we're doing, uh, in order to make better informed decisions, which is what the ooda loop's all about as well.
- 6:39Mark McGrath: Right, absolutely so.
- 6:41Mark McGrath: That was one of the things that I learned in our discourse starting in December was that your dad was, you know, as renowned of a scholar on these ideas as your grandfather was.
- 6:54Mark McGrath: He just didn't have the sort of 60s pop culture publicity I guess you'd say, or notoriety I guess, that your grandfather had.
- 7:05Andrew McLuhan: I guess you'd say that or notoriety, I guess that your grandfather had.
- 7:08Andrew McLuhan: Yeah, well, and that's because you know I say I'm the third generation, but you know my great-grandmother, marshall's mother, elsie Naomi Hall McLuhan, was a performer.
- 7:20Andrew McLuhan: She was what was called an elocutionist, which is a term you don't hear anymore, but basically she was a dramatist.
- 7:29Andrew McLuhan: So she was a stage performer and she would read or recite poetry, dramatic monologues one person plays this sort of thing.
- 7:38Andrew McLuhan: She was an entertainer and Marshall was very much an entertainer as well.
- 7:48Andrew McLuhan: Critically, he saw that the work he was doing was important in the world and he was a university professor, an English professor, and as an English professor at St Michael's College, university of Toronto, he was able to interact with and impact students' lives.
- 8:10Andrew McLuhan: But it was the world that needed this work and he went out into the world and became a household name in the 1960s and basically a world figure and part of popular culture.
- 8:24Andrew McLuhan: My father, on the other hand, who, incidentally, in the early 1960s joined the US Air Force he was born in St Louis, missouri was a United States citizen, like his mother, who was born in Texas and did his tour in the US Air Force, did his tour in the US Air Force.
- 8:48Andrew McLuhan: He was not very outgoing, to say the least.
- 8:51Andrew McLuhan: He wanted to be in his library reading books, researching, studying, exploring and writing.
- 8:57Andrew McLuhan: I, on the other hand, I think, am more of a throwback to the other side of the family, which is, you know.
- 9:05Andrew McLuhan: I think I'm more of a throwback to the other side of the family, which is, you know, I'm a poet.
- 9:06Andrew McLuhan: I've been interested in words and poetry since as long as I can remember and interested in performing as well.
- 9:16Andrew McLuhan: I played in a punk rock band for many years and I like to think that the poetry and the punk rock kind of tells you a lot about how I do things and my methods and my interests and my approach from this, because the thing about and you're going to have to interrupt me when you want me to stop because I'll talk forever but the thing about McLuhan work, as you suggested with Boyd, is it's not just the medium, is the message, it's not just the OODA loop, like Marshall's interests cut across all human activities.
- 9:54Andrew McLuhan: In fact, the media, the medium he talked about, were not just communications technologies but all human innovation.
- 10:03Andrew McLuhan: Communications technologies but all human innovation, everything from words and speech and writing to telephone and telegraph and television and computer, to clothing and automobiles, forks and knives and eyeglasses.
- 10:15Andrew McLuhan: He called them extensions of man or extensions of human powers.
- 10:20Andrew McLuhan: When he's talking about media, he's talking about all human technologies, not just communications media and certainly not just the press like newspapers and television stations and stuff.
- 10:35Mark McGrath: So because of that, his interests go across the world as well.
- 10:39Mark McGrath: Let's dive into this now.
- 10:41Mark McGrath: So that was a great segue.
- 10:41Mark McGrath: Let's dive into this now.
- 10:42Mark McGrath: So that's a great segue.
- 10:42Mark McGrath: So let's let's really dive into this.
- 10:44Mark McGrath: And maybe a place to start is what you just alluded to that most people misunderstand.
- 10:50Mark McGrath: When he says the medium is the message, they limit the thinking of what McLuhan is talking about only to communications or media or the press or social media or whatever.
- 11:14Andrew McLuhan: They're not thinking of a broader definition of media, which was his intent.
- 11:16Andrew McLuhan: Is that a good place to start?
- 11:17Andrew McLuhan: It's a very good place to start.
- 11:18Andrew McLuhan: So I'm a poet and he was a professor of English, of poetry, and a student of it and a lover of it, and he understood that poetry is very different from prose.
- 11:34Andrew McLuhan: For example, you don't tend to read a book of poetry cover to cover in one sitting.
- 11:41Andrew McLuhan: You approach it differently than you would read a work of fiction or nonfiction, which you can start at the start and move your way through, and that's because the way that it uses language and the way that it expresses thought and emotion and feeling are very different.
- 11:57Andrew McLuhan: Poetry is condensed, thought, right, it's really distilled down and like those little dinosaurs that you get for your kids and you put it in water and watch it grow.
- 12:08Andrew McLuhan: Poetry involves you in making it grow, in adding meaning, in finding meaning, in discovering things, whereas we expect we're more spoon-fed from prose.
- 12:21Andrew McLuhan: So poetry, condensed thought, is more involving.
- 12:26Andrew McLuhan: It involves you and it requires you to make more meaning from it.
- 12:30Andrew McLuhan: The medium is the message, is a poetic statement.
- 12:35Andrew McLuhan: It's five little words, but they contain so much and they not only invite you to think more deeply.
- 12:46Andrew McLuhan: They demand you think more deeply because it doesn't make any sense on the surface.
- 12:50Andrew McLuhan: It's a paradox.
- 12:51Andrew McLuhan: The medium is the message.
- 12:54Andrew McLuhan: Well, I mean the message is the message.
- 12:56Andrew McLuhan: What do you mean?
- 12:57Andrew McLuhan: The medium?
- 12:57Andrew McLuhan: What are you talking about?
- 12:58Andrew McLuhan: So if you want to get anything out of it, you have to think.
- 13:01Andrew McLuhan: And the first thing you have to consider is what does he mean by medium?
- 13:06Andrew McLuhan: And he means several things.
- 13:09Andrew McLuhan: By medium, he means mainly environment.
- 13:15Andrew McLuhan: What he said later was he said if I were to say the environment is the message, that's a better way of saying the medium is the message.
- 13:22Andrew McLuhan: It's not as pithy or as poetic perhaps, but another word for medium is environment, like a growth medium, you know, a bacterial medium, a sample in which you grow something from a medium environment, a milieu.
- 13:39Andrew McLuhan: And this is how we consider technologies, because technologies don't exist alone or in isolation.
- 13:46Andrew McLuhan: They tend to create an environment around them, an environment of services and disservices.
- 13:54Andrew McLuhan: And they act the same way.
- 13:56Andrew McLuhan: For example, if you, if you think about an environment in pollution right, if you've got a factory on one end of the lake that's pumping something nasty into it, it doesn't just stay at that one end of the lake.
- 14:11Andrew McLuhan: It affects the total system, and technologies work this way as well.
- 14:16Andrew McLuhan: When we get a technology, it quickly becomes environmental and surrounding us and involved in all parts of our life.
- 14:25Andrew McLuhan: Even something like AI, which is relatively kind of new on the scene, has quickly become very involved in our day-to-day lives, and one way to test this is to kind of conceptually take it out of the situation.
- 14:43Andrew McLuhan: So, like with smartphones, for example, what would happen?
- 14:50Andrew McLuhan: I do this exercise with kids and it's so much fun.
- 14:54Andrew McLuhan: We spend a little time looking at the smartphone and all the things which are involved in smartphones.
- 14:59Andrew McLuhan: You know research and development, natural resources, education, finances, global systems, electricity, internet networks all these things which are wrapped up in this small device called a cell phone, and then all the things that we do with it communication, purchasing, all these things.
- 15:21Andrew McLuhan: Now, what happens if you take that out, all these things?
- 15:27Andrew McLuhan: Now, what happens if you take that out, if you remove smartphones from our society overnight?
- 15:29Andrew McLuhan: What does tomorrow look like?
- 15:31Andrew McLuhan: Tomorrow looks like chaos.
- 15:32Andrew McLuhan: Imagine you wake up tomorrow and your smartphone doesn't work and it's never going to work, and nobody's smartphones work.
- 15:42Andrew McLuhan: What happens to our society?
- 15:44Andrew McLuhan: It collapses, and the crazy thing is that everything the smartphone does.
- 15:52Andrew McLuhan: Essentially, we can do different ways.
- 15:54Andrew McLuhan: It might be a little bit slower, it might be a little less efficient, but we can do things differently.
- 16:01Andrew McLuhan: It's just we've come to depend on it so much that we're we'd have pulled it out all of a sudden, just like shutting off the power, for example Society collapses and things get medieval very quickly.
- 16:15Andrew McLuhan: So this is one way to think about the medium as a message, way to think about the medium as a message because, um, it's, it's less the content or the uses to which we put these things which determine the personal and social impact of these devices.
- 16:34Andrew McLuhan: You know, as far as that smartphone goes, it matters less that we're having this conversation.
- 16:42Mark McGrath: Uh, on mcclellan and boyd this is where people get stuck right, exactly, but this is the point.
- 16:48Mark McGrath: Yeah, this is where people get hammered.
- 17:49Andrew McLuhan: We could be having a business meeting.
- 17:51Andrew McLuhan: That Is a little to the side Of the effect of the actual device In society and that is why the medium Is the message, because it accounts for really 90 of the effect whereas people generally get so hung up when they hear that they focus solely on content, they're not thinking of environment, technology and those sorts of things yeah, they get up, they get upset about it really, um, and they they say all kinds of things.
- 18:22Andrew McLuhan: Uh, I, they get up, they get upset about it really Um, and they, they say all kinds of things.
- 18:25Andrew McLuhan: Uh, I love the way that in 1964, marshall published a book called the uh understanding media uh, in which the first chapter is the medium is the message.
- 18:35Andrew McLuhan: And in that he there you go, nice one, mark.
- 18:38Andrew McLuhan: Uh, in that he's no-transcript, it uploads it all to the cloud and stitches it back together.
- 19:10Andrew McLuhan: Well, I have an upload speed at my farm of one megabit per second and it takes.
- 19:18Andrew McLuhan: Last time I did this at home on this software, it took like literally 10 hours to upload the whole thing and me sweating the whole time that the connection is going to get reset or something you know, versus coming into town with DSL and it uploads in seconds.
- 19:34Andrew McLuhan: Right, but in in understanding media in 64, in the medium is a message, marshall goes to great lengths to give you different examples of the Medium is a Message and he talks about the content by paraphrasing TS Eliot.
- 19:51Andrew McLuhan: And he says in Understanding Media that content is like the juicy piece of meat carried by the burglar to distract the watchdog of the mind carried by the burglar to distract the watchdog of the mind.
- 20:05Andrew McLuhan: And so, far from being irrelevant, content actually has very important functions, the main one being distraction.
- 20:20Andrew McLuhan: And you know it took me a long time.
- 20:21Andrew McLuhan: It's one thing to hear and say, yeah, that makes sense.
- 20:22Andrew McLuhan: It's another thing to really understand it.
- 20:23Andrew McLuhan: And it took me a long time to understand what he's talking about Because it's like, okay, if you take this analogy, what is okay?
- 20:32Andrew McLuhan: Content is the juicy piece of meat.
- 20:33Andrew McLuhan: I get it.
- 20:35Andrew McLuhan: The medium is a burglar, but what are they stealing?
- 20:40Andrew McLuhan: What is being burgled here?
- 20:42Andrew McLuhan: What's happening?
- 20:43Andrew McLuhan: And actually what's happening is we are being subtly but profoundly rewired and reshaped, because who we are is very dependent on, because who we are is very dependent on.
- 21:11Andrew McLuhan: You know, marshall says elsewhere that any culture is an order of sensory preferences.
- 21:17Andrew McLuhan: In talking with Mark about this, I often revert to the analogy of the blind person, because when somebody cannot see, they don't care what color their sweater is, they don't care what art is on the wall, they don't have any visual preferences at all.
- 21:36Andrew McLuhan: But if you think about our society and our culture and what we value, we value visual things dearly Visual art, art galleries, art markets, clothing.
- 21:46Andrew McLuhan: So much of our identity is wrapped up in the things that we wear day to day.
- 21:51Andrew McLuhan: This was driven home to me when we had a house fire when I was a teenager and all my clothes burned up.
- 21:57Andrew McLuhan: I had to go buy new clothes and I felt like I didn't know who I was because all my identity was so wrapped up in the things that I wore I didn't even realize it.
- 22:08Andrew McLuhan: So this is an extreme case, the case of the blind person.
- 22:12Andrew McLuhan: But if you put all these blind people together, you have a society, and as a society they value completely different things than a sighted society, right?
- 22:25Andrew McLuhan: Well, media technologies, all human technologies, affect us on a sensory level first.
- 22:32Andrew McLuhan: Our opinions, our feelings about things are things that happen after we interact with information through our senses.
- 22:42Andrew McLuhan: That act of perception happens before opinions, before feelings, before values and morals and all the rest of it.
- 22:50Andrew McLuhan: But what it does is it shapes us in certain ways and sort of sets our senses up in a ratio, in a calibration, and it's more subtle than being suddenly struck blind, but it's no less impactful.
- 23:07Andrew McLuhan: And what's happening with the burglar and the piece of meat and the content is, when we focus on the content we aren't paying attention to what's happening while we're focusing on that content which is the shaping of our senses.
- 23:29Andrew McLuhan: Because the thing about our senses is that they're not neutral or unchanging.
- 23:36Andrew McLuhan: It's not simply a pipe that water goes through.
- 23:42Andrew McLuhan: They're organic living systems and they're affected by what goes through them.
- 23:47Andrew McLuhan: And that is the whole point that, while this content is going through, we're being adjusted and reshaped so that, when we have a lot of visual content through, our eye is being dominated.
- 24:04Andrew McLuhan: The other critical part of this and I know I'm going on the other critical part of this is that our eyes, our senses, don't exist independent from each other, but they exist in a balance.
- 24:20Andrew McLuhan: So if you were to go blind, when you go blind later in life, people mention how, as their visual faculty dims, their other senses react.
- 24:32Andrew McLuhan: Your sense of hearing becomes more acute, your sense of touch more sensitive.
- 24:37Andrew McLuhan: Our senses respond to any readjustment among them and that readjustment is a new identity, it's a new culture, it's a new human.
- 24:49Andrew McLuhan: This is why the medium is a message, because that readjustment doesn't happen because I'm watching an educational program or I'm watching the latest Marvel movie.
- 25:00Andrew McLuhan: It happens because I'm watching the technology.
- 25:06Ponch Rivera: Hey, andrew, I'm a knuckle dragger here and I want to go back to the external environment.
- 25:10Ponch Rivera: This is interesting.
- 25:12Ponch Rivera: So I think there's a connection to increasing VUCA volatility, uncertainty, complexity and ambiguity with the changing environment, and there's also a connection to snowmobiles and I'll bounce that off a mark here in a second.
- 25:21Ponch Rivera: There's also the connection to Stuart Kaufman's, the Adjacent Possible, basically saying that as we build something new today and Mark builds something new and you build something new, somebody tomorrow could look back and repurpose those three new things we built independently to create something new.
- 25:39Ponch Rivera: So that's this hockey stick growth, if you will, in volatility, uncertainty, complexity and ambiguity is based on the environment that we're actively changing, the technologies we're creating, which goes beyond technologies as well, as you put it.
- 25:59Ponch Rivera: So, mark, I'm kind of seeing another parallel here on the external environment in the OODA loop to the snowmobile capability, stuart Kaufman's work with the Jason Pospoles and, of course, what McLuhan has.
- 26:10Ponch Rivera: So I want to make sure I'm grasping this concept before I turn it over to Mark.
- 26:14Ponch Rivera: One thing we learned from Boyd and others when Boyd was studying the Toyota production system, he made it very clear that control is outside and bottom up.
- 26:23Ponch Rivera: The outside controls you, and I think that's what Andrew just pointed out.
- 26:26Ponch Rivera: So, mark, any thoughts on what I just shared with you.
- 26:31Mark McGrath: Well, I think that the biggest tie-in that I've always seen with McLuhan's work, with Marshall McLuhan's work, is flowing right into destruction, creation and conceptual spiral.
- 26:44Mark McGrath: Because, as you say, we're constantly destroying and creating new things as time goes on and in that we're building off of things that previously existed.
- 26:57Mark McGrath: So, if I took Heisenberg, gödel, godel and thermodynamics, second law, entropy, you know I can create doodle loop, sketch that that was Boyd's basic basic idea.
- 27:08Mark McGrath: Or, as you say, the snowmobile, I could take the handlebars off of this and the motor off of that and skis off of that, et cetera, and I feel like there's a lot of synergy into thinking that.
- 27:18Mark McGrath: I mean, it's really.
- 27:19Mark McGrath: I guess this was really my foundational point with with Boy McLuhan was drawing the connection at Destruction, creations, conceptual Spiral, which are his two most important contributions, and how they synergize.
- 27:36Mark McGrath: Because, as Andrew's describing, that constant change in technology, that constant change because Boyd talks about, talks about those technological changes in conceptual spiral, all of that is changing your environment.
- 27:48Mark McGrath: You know, if you have air conditioning in a house, that's changing your environment.
- 27:51Mark McGrath: That's going to have an effect on, that's going to have an effect on you.
- 27:54Mark McGrath: If you have, you know, pasteurized milk, you know that's going to have an effect on you, right?
- 28:13Andrew McLuhan: Is that in line with a lot of the things that we've discussed?
- 28:17Andrew McLuhan: Would you say, andrew?
- 28:18Andrew McLuhan: Because people get hung up on content when you're talking about communications technology and it's a lot harder to get hung up on content when you're talking about air conditioners.
- 28:30Andrew McLuhan: But air conditioners are an incredibly powerful shaping force.
- 28:37Andrew McLuhan: They have not only an effect on your relative comfort.
- 28:42Andrew McLuhan: They have not only an effect on your relative comfort, but they make it possible to live in Florida all year round or in the Gobi Desert.
- 28:50Andrew McLuhan: Not only that, but a culture without air conditioners in a hot climate develops something like the siesta, where you take a couple hours in the hottest part of the day and you don't even try to work because your brain is boiling right.
- 29:13Andrew McLuhan: Introducing air conditioners removes the necessity of the siesta and by doing that it profoundly impacts the culture, because siesta has become entrenched in the culture and it's become valued as well.
- 29:32Andrew McLuhan: We move from necessity to value.
- 29:35Andrew McLuhan: Media is.
- 29:46Andrew McLuhan: I think it's a village in India.
- 29:46Andrew McLuhan: This well-meaning Westerner comes in and sees that the women spend like half of their day going back and forth to the well to fetch pots of water and he says look, we can bring in pipes and plumbing.
- 29:58Andrew McLuhan: We can do this fairly easily and you get half of your day.
- 30:03Andrew McLuhan: Imagine the things you can accomplish.
- 30:05Andrew McLuhan: And they said, yeah, that sounds great.
- 30:08Andrew McLuhan: But you know, while I'm at the well waiting my turn to get the water, I'm talking with Margaret about you know what happened to her son yesterday and I'm talking with Julia about you know what we're going to do next week and it's an important part of their culture.
- 30:29Andrew McLuhan: To add plumbing would destroy that.
- 30:31Andrew McLuhan: Add air conditioning and you can have a building that's 30 stories high, which you can't without air conditioning because you need to open the windows.
- 30:39Andrew McLuhan: You can't open the windows in a 30-story building.
- 30:47Andrew McLuhan: There's a reason the windows don't open.
- 30:51Andrew McLuhan: With or without air conditioning, you have completely different possibilities, services and even disservices.
- 30:56Andrew McLuhan: Same with the electric light.
- 30:57Andrew McLuhan: The electric light means that we can work 24 hours.
- 31:01Andrew McLuhan: It means we can have 24-hour cities.
- 31:04Andrew McLuhan: It means we can have all kinds of things, and this happens with the air conditioner, for example.
- 31:10Andrew McLuhan: It happens regardless of whether you're the New York Stock Exchange or whether you're an air conditioner factory.
- 31:16Andrew McLuhan: It's the affordances by the very presence and the environment of the technology which factor.
- 31:24Andrew McLuhan: Now VUCA, you know volatility, uncertainty.
- 31:29Andrew McLuhan: These things are kind of anti-entropic.
- 31:34Andrew McLuhan: I love that you've mentioned both snowmobiles and hockey sticks.
- 31:37Andrew McLuhan: I feel very much at home up here in Canada I'll introduce the third term and that's the idea of the snowball.
- 31:42Andrew McLuhan: Up here in Canada, I'll introduce the third term and that's the idea of the snowball Snowballs.
- 31:47Andrew McLuhan: You roll a snowball down the hill and it gathers speed and it gathers mass.
- 31:50Andrew McLuhan: This is what has happened steadily with technology over the centuries and again there are pluses and minuses to that.
- 32:01Andrew McLuhan: When technology proceeds really slowly so let's go back before electricity when things happen really slowly, you don't notice them as readily and you have time to adjust as well.
- 32:20Andrew McLuhan: Marshall liked to bring up an analogy of Bertrand Russell.
- 32:24Andrew McLuhan: Bertrand Russell said that if you only raise the temperature of the bath water by a degree every hour, you wouldn't know when to scream.
- 32:32Andrew McLuhan: Okay.
- 32:35Andrew McLuhan: So when change happens really slowly, when you sit in a lukewarm bath and you slowly add hot water and hot water and hot water, you can get that bath up to a really hot temperature and be quite comfortable.
- 32:47Andrew McLuhan: But if you were to step into that hot bath from the lukewarm air environment of the bathroom, you'd burn your foot right, you'd pull your foot right out.
- 32:58Andrew McLuhan: So this is what happens with the increased scale and pace of technology is that we don't have time to adjust.
- 33:08Andrew McLuhan: We increase volatility and uncertainty and ambiguity as well, but we notice it, and noticing it gives us the opportunity to make different choices and decisions.
- 33:22Andrew McLuhan: Maybe we don't want to live in a steam bath, maybe we like room temperature a little more.
- 33:30Andrew McLuhan: Maybe that's better for us and for our society, or worse.
- 33:35Andrew McLuhan: The point is, the more attention we have, the more agency we potentially have.
- 33:43Mark McGrath: So so just pulling out of the first chapter of understanding media, and that's the you know, we would recommend to people that are listening that's the critical book to, to get and focus on the first seven chapters that really underscore and explain what exactly Marshall McLuhan is saying.
- 34:02Andrew McLuhan: But there's one quote from You've been paying attention, Mark.
- 34:04Mark McGrath: Well, you've been a great teacher, but the parallels that I've seen anyway with Boyd like.
- 34:09Mark McGrath: Here's an example.
- 34:10Mark McGrath: This is on page 20.
- 34:11Mark McGrath: It says for the message in quotes of any medium or technology is the change of scale or pace or pattern that it introduces Introduces into human affairs, into human affairs.
- 34:24Mark McGrath: So what Boyd is talking about and depicting with OODA Loop Sketch is people, ideas, things, a human, human cognition, shaping and sense making inside of an environment as circumstances unfold, inside of an environment as circumstances unfold.
- 34:40Mark McGrath: And it's really where I see the connection point Marshall McLuhan, your grandfather, was saying basically the same exact thing is that it goes a little further.
- 34:48Mark McGrath: It says the medium that shapes and controls the scale.
- 34:51Mark McGrath: It's the medium that shapes and controls the scale and form of human association in action.
- 34:58Mark McGrath: And that's what Ponch and I are in the business of of helping humans make better decisions, make better actions, individually or together in associative groups, be they sports teams or companies, et cetera.
- 35:15Andrew McLuhan: Yeah, well, the thing is the more.
- 35:16Andrew McLuhan: The fact of the matter is that the more that you know, the more information you have, the more informed decisions you can make.
- 35:24Andrew McLuhan: I think it was toward the end of that chapter.
- 35:28Andrew McLuhan: Marshall despairs saying I'm in the position of Louis Pasteur telling people that their greatest enemy is all around them, unseen people that their greatest enemy is all around them, unseen.
- 35:43Andrew McLuhan: Louis Pasteur, one of the grandfathers of modern science and medicine, basically discovered the role of bacteria in human health, which wasn't possible to know before the microscope, before we could see bacteria.
- 35:55Andrew McLuhan: After we understood that, we operated literally quite differently.
- 36:01Andrew McLuhan: We washed our hands, we sterilized our instruments because we understood that it's great if the operation is a complete success, not so great if the patient dies, you know.
- 36:14Andrew McLuhan: So this is In that chapterall explains over and over what he means by the medium is the message and why the medium is the message.
- 36:27Andrew McLuhan: And it's because, as you quoted, it is the medium, it is this technological, the technology, the environment shaped by it, which controls the scale and pace and pattern.
- 36:40Andrew McLuhan: And if you think about those three things scale and pace and pattern content has little effect on those things, but it's scale, it's the fact that our technologies are worldwide.
- 36:58Andrew McLuhan: That scale versus before the telephone and telegraph, before written language, when the only way to communicate with each other was from my mouth to your ear, or maybe you tell one person, they tell another person, they tell another person.
- 37:18Andrew McLuhan: That is a completely different scale than when I can be on a three-way video call with you right now, and not only with you right now, but with whoever is watching or listening to this after the fact.
- 37:32Andrew McLuhan: That is scale, scale and pace.
- 37:36Andrew McLuhan: So speed right is also a huge factor.
- 37:39Andrew McLuhan: The fact that we can have this simultaneous discussion rather than you know, the fact that you and I, mark, can be texting each other and you're on a ferry to Nantucket or you're in Washington Square what we like to call the human internet versus a written correspondence where I'm writing a letter that takes a week to get to you, you're taking a day or two to respond and I hear from you a week later.
- 38:05Andrew McLuhan: That's two weeks between parts of a conversation.
- 38:09Andrew McLuhan: Reducing the friction, reducing that speed to instantaneity.
- 38:14Andrew McLuhan: That happens.
- 38:16Andrew McLuhan: That is the factor, not the fact that we're talking about fish and chips or technology.
- 38:23Andrew McLuhan: It's not the content, scale and speed and pattern everything about our society right.
- 38:36Andrew McLuhan: It means that I can live in the country, not having to move to New York or to Washington to continue my work and my outreach.
- 38:47Andrew McLuhan: It is the medium which controls scale and pace and pattern in human affairs.
- 38:55Mark McGrath: That is you know, Ponch, what do you think of those pretty buoyed words?
- 38:59Mark McGrath: Pace scale, speed pattern?
- 39:04Ponch Rivera: we hear about them all the time, right?
- 39:05Ponch Rivera: Uh, pattern matching beans, that's a good thing.
- 39:07Ponch Rivera: We know about tempo and speed, um, and then scale is, uh, yeah, and I can't stop.
- 39:12Ponch Rivera: You know I'm thinking about assembly theory, things are coming out of santa fe institute, things like that, that, very much aligned to the whole idea that evolution is dependent on what we make today, can be, you know, doubled, quadrupled, exponentially more tomorrow.
- 39:26Ponch Rivera: So that is the pace and scale aspect of it.
- 39:31Ponch Rivera: And the pattern repeats itself, right, so it's a fractal pattern.
- 39:34Ponch Rivera: You start with.
- 39:35Ponch Rivera: Let me just come up with some numbers here real fast.
- 39:36Ponch Rivera: You know, 10 things today equals 45 possible things tomorrow.
- 39:37Ponch Rivera: A fractal pattern, you start with.
- 39:38Ponch Rivera: Let me just come up with some numbers here real fast 10 things today equals 45 possible things tomorrow.
- 39:41Ponch Rivera: 100 things today equals 4,500 possible things tomorrow.
- 39:45Ponch Rivera: So that's the pace and it's fractal in scale.
- 39:48Ponch Rivera: It's a pattern.
- 39:48Ponch Rivera: So that's that hockey stick we're talking about in uncertainty.
- 39:53Ponch Rivera: So uncertainty, you can think, is a function of change and that's where we are today.
- 39:58Ponch Rivera: So I think the parallels are absolutely insane.
- 40:05Ponch Rivera: I think more people need to get into books and not just look at what your grandfather did, but look at what Boyd wrote about and make the connection.
- 40:08Ponch Rivera: Bring an assembly of ideas together, if you will, and use them from assembly theory.
- 40:12Ponch Rivera: Bring these things together to see that from physics, from neuroscience, from chemistry, you name it there's a lot of overlap here, and this is what informs, in my opinion, what informs John Boyd's OODA loop, and I think that's what your grandfather was working on as well.
- 40:26Mark McGrath: So, ponch, one of the things that Andrew and I had run into, I had given him the custody thing from the Marine Corps archives.
- 40:35Mark McGrath: You know that has all the books that Boyd read and all the authors and what was interesting to note, that Marshall McLuhan was not on the list.
- 40:45Mark McGrath: However, as Andrew pointed out, he literally bracketed everything my grandfather was reading and citing and sourcing, like like all the way around it, without actually hitting and reading anything by McLuhan.
- 41:00Ponch Rivera: That's a good thing, and let me explain why that's a good thing.
- 41:02Ponch Rivera: So, when we talk about red teaming techniques and a shallow dive into chaos, I don't want to know what you know, right, I don't.
- 41:07Ponch Rivera: We want to break that apart so independently.
- 41:10Ponch Rivera: If we come to an overlapping conclusion or agreement, that's a good thing, right, but I think echo chambers like you and I studying Boyd could be a bad thing, right?
- 41:21Ponch Rivera: Or it could be a good thing.
- 41:23Ponch Rivera: You're looking at some things that I'm not and I'm looking at other things that you may not be looking at, but at the same time, we're coming back to hey, this is how this works.
- 41:30Ponch Rivera: So, again, we were looking at the archives there to see if Boyd looked at McLuhan, but he looked at everything that, not everything, a lot of things that McLuhan looked at.
- 41:41Mark McGrath: Yeah, the synergies are staggering and it is interesting, as we've pointed out in other episodes with Hunter Hastings and others, how, even in disciplines like economics and Marshall McLuhan's case English literature, it's amazing that sort of this interdisciplinary approach generally there are thinkers like Boyd McLuhan, hayek and others that come to this conclusions or point to these, you know, very similar conclusions.
- 42:07Mark McGrath: Yeah, it's always fascinating.
- 42:11Mark McGrath: Never a dull moment with this stuff, right, andrew?
- 42:16Andrew McLuhan: No, never.
- 42:17Andrew McLuhan: I mean, in fact's.
- 42:18Andrew McLuhan: That's kind of the kind of the difficult thing about it is.
- 42:22Andrew McLuhan: It's, um, it's funny when I, when I started the mccluhan institute a handful of years ago, my uncle uh noticed the acronym tmi, uh the mccluhan, and he says, andrew, you know what that means, right?
- 42:39Andrew McLuhan: I said, yeah, exactly, too much information.
- 42:43Andrew McLuhan: That's the problem and this is the solution, right?
- 42:48Andrew McLuhan: So the difficulty here, the thing I'm confronted with in the work, is that it's so vast, it's an ocean, and it's easy to get bogged down trying to count or account for water droplets.
- 43:05Andrew McLuhan: You really just have to pick a path, because there's way much work, there's way too much work for any person to do in a lifetime.
- 43:14Andrew McLuhan: So you kind of have to pick and choose a lifetime.
- 43:23Andrew McLuhan: So you kind of have to pick and choose, and what I pick and choose from is my entire focus is pulling out what is practical and useful from that work, from those decades and generations of work, for us to apply to and use today to understand what's happening.
- 43:39Andrew McLuhan: And that, indeed, I think, is what my grandfather was trying to do, because he didn't simply study specific technologies, he studied technology as a category and he wanted to explore the nature of human innovation in general, and he managed to find out quite a lot about it.
- 44:06Andrew McLuhan: And why that is useful is because, if you're only studying digital technologies, what happens when we move on from digital technologies technologies?
- 44:21Andrew McLuhan: What happens when we move on from digital technologies?
- 44:23Andrew McLuhan: What Marshall discovered was that all human technologies, all human innovations, behave in certain ways.
- 44:29Andrew McLuhan: And when you know that, you have good starting points for looking at any human technologies because, as many people have observed that our technologies are the most human things about us you mentioned evolution, mark, and evolution is a technology.
- 44:56Andrew McLuhan: It's a way of you know, ensuring our survival and optimizing things.
- 45:03Andrew McLuhan: But like raising the bathwater a degree every hour, it's very, very slow.
- 45:09Andrew McLuhan: It is as sure as it is slow, but it's very, very slow.
- 45:13Andrew McLuhan: And I think when humans took that fork in the road that separated us from all the rest of nature was when we decided that evolution wasn't enough and we wanted to go faster, and we picked up a stick and used it like a hammer or a spear, and it's gone hockey stick since then.
- 45:35Andrew McLuhan: We left behind evolution in favor of innovation, and here we are.
- 45:46Mark McGrath: Staying on.
- 45:47Mark McGrath: So again, I would recommend anyone listening to start by reading two things.
- 45:54Mark McGrath: One is the interview from 1969 of your grandfather and playboy, which is, I think, would you agree that's very, I mean, that's, that's extremely instructive and entertaining.
- 46:06Mark McGrath: But the other, one.
- 46:07Andrew McLuhan: It's a lot.
- 46:08Mark McGrath: It's yeah, it is a lot.
- 46:09Mark McGrath: And then the other one, you know, understanding media.
- 46:14Mark McGrath: In that first chapter, the medium is the message.
- 46:17Mark McGrath: Again, we want to help as many people understand that there's more to the normal tone that you hear.
- 46:25Mark McGrath: He talks about in great depth the electric light and a lot of the things that you see the clips on YouTube and others of Marshall McLuhan talking about electricity and the electricity and the electric light.
- 46:38Mark McGrath: You know it has the title Marshall McLuhan predicting the internet or predicting Twitter or predicting, you know, social media.
- 46:46Mark McGrath: You know how would you recontextualize that for people to actually understand what it is he was saying in the medium and the message when he's talking about the electric light?
- 46:58Andrew McLuhan: well, um, as I said it, uh, it makes you think.
- 47:05Andrew McLuhan: Uh, the whole point of it is to make you think because, after all, um, we learn.
- 47:15Andrew McLuhan: You know we're not really taught anything, but we're helped to understand and learn because that happens on an individual basis.
- 47:25Andrew McLuhan: Teachers think a lot of themselves as teaching people, but we really just, you can lead a horse to water, right, but the horse has to drink.
- 47:36Andrew McLuhan: The number one tip I give people for reading Understanding Media or any of McLuhan's work, is to approach it like poetry and, as I explained, poetry requires a lot from you.
- 47:51Andrew McLuhan: You really complete the picture.
- 47:54Andrew McLuhan: The poem describes it.
- 47:56Andrew McLuhan: If you want to think about it like this and you paint it, you know you really create that act of understanding and generating meaning.
- 48:06Andrew McLuhan: The best thing you can do in reading understanding media is take it a page, a paragraph, even a sentence.
- 48:14Andrew McLuhan: At the time, just like we talked about for a few minutes, you know that one quote off page 20.
- 48:20Andrew McLuhan: That is the medium that shapes and controls human action, scale and speed and pace, whatever human affairs.
- 48:27Andrew McLuhan: You really have to have to chew that over and talk it out.
- 48:31Andrew McLuhan: You know, add, add water to make it expand.
- 48:35Andrew McLuhan: Excuse me, but well, I got thrown way off track.
- 48:43Andrew McLuhan: Maybe I'm too caffeinated.
- 48:45Andrew McLuhan: Where did we start there, mark?
- 48:47Mark McGrath: Well, I mean just like the electric light, because it is, he says in the chapter.
- 48:55Mark McGrath: It's totally radical, pervasive and decentralized.
- 48:58Andrew McLuhan: Yeah, in the chapter it's totally radical, pervasive and decentralized.
- 49:05Andrew McLuhan: Yeah, uh, yeah, marshall liked to use the electric light because, um, he said it's a medium without content, as it were.
- 49:09Andrew McLuhan: Right, um, but you were talking about, uh, you know, mccluhan predicting quote-unquote the internet well, that's what they take, right they, they take his quotes, yeah yeah, the interesting thing is that uh marshall said that I'm very careful to only predict things which have already happened.
- 49:32Andrew McLuhan: And now he was somebody who liked to play with words and play with people.
- 49:35Andrew McLuhan: Um, he had an extraordinarily quick mind and he enjoyed encounters like this and speaking a kind of verbal sparring and all the rest of it.
- 49:47Andrew McLuhan: But he was actually being quite genuine and he is usually being quite genuine and serious when he says stuff like that.
- 49:55Andrew McLuhan: He insisted that he generally just described what he saw around him and he said that people live.
- 50:08Andrew McLuhan: You know, basically we march backwards into the future, he said.
- 50:13Andrew McLuhan: And he talked about the rearview mirror.
- 50:15Andrew McLuhan: We tend to it's very, very hard, it's very difficult to see the present and what is happening moment to moment.
- 50:29Andrew McLuhan: It's a weird thing about people that we tend to kind of live 10 plus years in the past.
- 50:40Ponch Rivera: I want to stop here.
- 50:41Ponch Rivera: This is awesome.
- 50:41Ponch Rivera: Okay, say that again, because this is absolutely critical in understanding the OODA loop, and I'll rephrase this For you to achieve a state of flow, to be peak performance, you have to be present.
- 50:54Ponch Rivera: You have to be present.
- 50:56Ponch Rivera: The OODA loop helps you do that.
- 50:58Ponch Rivera: I mean, I hate to say do that, but what you just said there is critical.
- 51:02Ponch Rivera: If you look at what's going on globally, there's a lot of people that are not present, understanding what's actually happening now.
- 51:09Ponch Rivera: They're projecting out their attitudes and beliefs about what's going to happen in the future, regardless of what's happening now.
- 51:16Ponch Rivera: Can you restate that?
- 51:17Ponch Rivera: I want to hear that again regardless of what's happening now.
- 51:20Andrew McLuhan: So can you restate that?
- 51:21Andrew McLuhan: I want to hear that again.
- 51:22Andrew McLuhan: Well, he said, you know the future of the future is the present.
- 51:27Andrew McLuhan: But the thing is is that he did insist that anything he talked about was something which had already happened.
- 51:39Andrew McLuhan: The funny thing is people say, oh my god, he was predicting the internet, or he was predicting the future, and I see it all around us.
- 51:47Andrew McLuhan: What he said then we're living it today.
- 51:50Andrew McLuhan: He insisted that he was describing his present, and if you think about it, 1964 was 60 years ago, and if what he was saying in 1964 is visible to the rest of us today as being our present, that means that we're living 60 years in the past.
- 52:12Andrew McLuhan: And the thing that keeps me up at night a little bit is that what is happening right now, that I'm not going to see for several decades, because that's the implication and that's kind of spooky.
- 52:33Andrew McLuhan: Now, one thing which we hadn't talked about yet is the arts and the artist, and Marshall McLuhan relied very heavily on the arts and artists, because again, it comes back to that, uh, that kind of well, I've been working on a sort of model of communication or media, um, to help graphically, uh, understand the mechanics of this process.
- 53:05Andrew McLuhan: But, um again, our senses experience things in real time, our cognition experience things in real time.
- 53:14Andrew McLuhan: Our cognition, our feelings, our opinions are always a step behind, and this kind of relates to how we're living in the past, because we're always playing catch-up to the actual information that we're interfacing through our senses.
- 53:31Andrew McLuhan: Artists are different Because, you know, you and I, the rest of us as we age, our senses dull.
- 53:44Andrew McLuhan: You know, mark and I are wearing glasses because our eyes are deteriorating.
- 53:50Andrew McLuhan: You know my sense of hearing probably standing in front of really loud amplifiers for a few years didn't help me there.
- 53:57Andrew McLuhan: But our sense of hearing, all our senses again, are organic systems which hit a peak performance and then decline.
- 54:09Andrew McLuhan: Artists are a little different because artists are people in society who are always trying to experience things in new and fresh ways and to express them to the rest of us.
- 54:26Andrew McLuhan: Artists are people who, unlike the rest of us, whose senses are dulling over time, they're constantly sharpening their senses so that they can encounter new things in new ways and because of this they're very valuable to the rest of us.
- 54:45Andrew McLuhan: But this is why new art and this is a very broad category, it covers music, visual arts, all the rest of it.
- 54:52Andrew McLuhan: This is why new art often looks strange or even offensive to our senses.
- 55:01Andrew McLuhan: If not our sense of propriety, it's because it's alien to us.
- 55:06Andrew McLuhan: The artist is experiencing the present in real time that we aren't going to catch up to.
- 55:13Andrew McLuhan: But I think about it like this you know, elvis Presley, right, it's hard to imagine a more vanilla kind of benign figure than Elvis Presley, right?
- 55:25Andrew McLuhan: Pretty harmless dude, right.
- 55:26Andrew McLuhan: But in the 50s, when Elvis was new, was new, he was not a harmless dude, he was a shock.
- 55:41Andrew McLuhan: People our age back then were hiding our children from Elvis Presley, swinging his hips like that and talking like the way he did.
- 55:46Andrew McLuhan: That was a shock to that culture.
- 55:50Andrew McLuhan: But today it's quite harmless.
- 55:53Andrew McLuhan: Put them aside, like Marilyn Manson or something, and there's no comparison, right, but even Marilyn Manson might not be the shocking figure that he was 10, 20 years ago.
- 56:05Andrew McLuhan: So, artists and new art is often offensive because the new art is meeting the old sensibility.
- 56:15Andrew McLuhan: You know, when we talk about our ourselves being the sum of our senses in an order of sensory preferences, when, uh, when, something new, when we encounter something new that, uh, doesn't really mesh with that culture or order of preferences.
- 56:36Andrew McLuhan: It's offensive.
- 56:37Andrew McLuhan: But what quickly is new and strange and even offensive, it can quickly become cherished and valued, right?
- 56:50Andrew McLuhan: What's more American than Elvis Presley?
- 56:53Andrew McLuhan: Right, like what's more american than elvis presley?
- 56:55Andrew McLuhan: You know well, he certainly wasn't, wasn't a paragon of america at the time.
- 57:01Andrew McLuhan: Uh, you know, he's not not quite in line with traditional american values in the 1950s, but now.
- 57:11Andrew McLuhan: But now it's an inseparable part of that time in our imagination.
- 57:14Andrew McLuhan: So the artist is very, very useful to us and the arts are very, very useful to us because they are our kind of canary in the coal mine.
- 57:28Andrew McLuhan: They are more sensitive than we are Now.
- 57:36Andrew McLuhan: It's one thing to say that, it's quite another to extract any meaning from it.
- 57:40Andrew McLuhan: But one way to do it is to think about language, because language is a living thing.
- 57:52Andrew McLuhan: Our language isn't static, it changes all the time.
- 57:54Andrew McLuhan: Slang, as Marshall talks about in Understanding Media, should be very important to the student of media, because language is a living index to change.
- 58:19Andrew McLuhan: Language is how we describe the world around us and how we communicate.
- 58:25Andrew McLuhan: We can only describe what we have words to describe, what we have words to describe, and when things change, we change our language to accommodate those facts.
- 58:45Andrew McLuhan: So I pay a lot of attention to slang, because slang tells you a lot.
- 58:53Andrew McLuhan: For example, the way we describe time has changed a lot.
- 58:59Andrew McLuhan: We'll say it's been a minute, meaning it's been a long time, but we used to say, wow, it's been a while.
- 59:08Andrew McLuhan: Now we say it's been a minute, or we say it's been a hot second or things like this it's been a minute.
- 59:14Andrew McLuhan: Or we say it's been a hot second or things like this.
- 59:16Andrew McLuhan: Pay attention to when language changes, because language doesn't change just for the hell of it.
- 59:20Andrew McLuhan: Language always changes in reaction to something.
- 59:28Andrew McLuhan: So you trace that backward and you can try and find the source, like what is being reacted to, to what has changed in the environment.
- 59:35Mark McGrath: That forces us to change our language to account for it so when an 11 year old tells me that something is skibbity, under no circumstances look up skibbity toilets yeah someone's uh, sigma, like sigma has got a lot of riz.
- 59:56Mark McGrath: Yeah, these are the canaries in the, in the canaries in the mine, as you say.
- 1:00:03Mark McGrath: Well, I think you know and understand that things have changed yeah, well, I think, I mean, I think one of the the big overarching themes with both boyd and m and McLuhan and sort of fusing them together, is improved situational awareness.
- 1:00:18Mark McGrath: You know, as you say, as Pancho was talking about, being in a state of flow, you know it's not so much just looking backwards, it's being ready, that you can be more anticipatory, you know, to make better decisions and actions as you go forward, or at least understand, uh, have a better understanding of what.
- 1:00:36Mark McGrath: You know, what's actually, what's actually going on.
- 1:00:42Andrew McLuhan: Well, I mean, it does beg the question.
- 1:00:44Andrew McLuhan: It's like well, that's great, but uh, who cares?
- 1:00:48Andrew McLuhan: You know, why does it matter?
- 1:00:50Andrew McLuhan: Well, um, it matters if, uh, uh, you care about your life, uh, your way of life and your culture.
- 1:01:00Andrew McLuhan: Um, understand that a new technological paradigm is a cultural shift and a value shift.
- 1:01:10Andrew McLuhan: And if you have things which you wish to preserve, for example, you've got a saltwater aquarium and you've got all these beautiful fish in it, you understand that you've got to be measuring and maintaining the pH balance and the salinity of that aquarium if you want those fish to survive and thrive.
- 1:01:39Andrew McLuhan: Well, our cultures are no different.
- 1:01:41Andrew McLuhan: Our cultures are delicate systems with pH balances and salinity and relative nutrients and whatever else.
- 1:01:50Andrew McLuhan: And when you change the mix, you change what's possible inside it.
- 1:01:56Andrew McLuhan: It's really hard to maintain certain values when you change the environment around them.
- 1:02:07Andrew McLuhan: Like, if I value family time and a quiet meal with my family, it's really hard to maintain that when everybody has a smartphone on the table.
- 1:02:17Andrew McLuhan: Our all-at-once, always-online, demanding culture makes it very difficult to maintain the older culture, those values, those things we value, which were built in a different set of circumstances.
- 1:02:40Andrew McLuhan: And you change the circumstances and you make it impossible to maintain those values.
- 1:02:45Andrew McLuhan: This is why you have some Mennonite or Hutterite sects who are very careful about introducing new technologies because they understand that their way of life is not necessarily compatible with major changes in technology.
- 1:03:09Andrew McLuhan: You have, for example, the United States and a system of government which was formed when things moved at horse and mail speed.
- 1:03:19Andrew McLuhan: When things moved at horse speed and mail speed, it made sense to appoint somebody from the community to go to Washington to represent your interests.
- 1:03:30Andrew McLuhan: Because we can't all go to Washington, so sure, we designate this person to go do it for us, but today we can all go to Washington in the blink of an eye, as easily as we can connect to each other on this podcast.
- 1:03:44Andrew McLuhan: For 90% of the circumstances, we don't need somebody to go to Washington for us.
- 1:03:51Andrew McLuhan: We don't need to hold a ballot of mailing things in.
- 1:03:55Andrew McLuhan: We can do it instantaneously.
- 1:03:57Andrew McLuhan: Circumstances have changed and the way we do things have not, and there's an extreme dissonance which happens when you don't take into account changing circumstances and you try to hold on to those values just by sheer will.
- 1:04:16Andrew McLuhan: Well, you're holding onto a cliff and you're piling weights on your legs and eventually you're going to lose your grip.
- 1:04:24Ponch Rivera: Yeah, so we study the Kenevan framework and what you just described there is spot on, as context matters, right?
- 1:04:30Ponch Rivera: And if you apply the wrong method in the wrong context, you end up in a confused state and sometimes it moves into chaos.
- 1:04:36Ponch Rivera: Chaos is good if it's on purpose, if you can control it, but it's not good if you fall in there accidentally, right?
- 1:04:42Ponch Rivera: So I think a lot of times what you just kind of pointed out there is we're not updating our methods to match the context.
- 1:04:50Ponch Rivera: Is that correct?
- 1:04:51Ponch Rivera: To match the context, is that?
- 1:04:52Andrew McLuhan: correct.
- 1:04:52Ponch Rivera: Yeah exactly.
- 1:04:54Andrew McLuhan: So you know it comes back to you know, once you understand, the more information you have about the system, the more control you potentially have.
- 1:05:05Andrew McLuhan: You know if, coming back to the aquarium.
- 1:05:08Ponch Rivera: Let's reverse that.
- 1:05:09Ponch Rivera: If you don't have an understanding's, say um, I want to be in a position of power.
- 1:05:15Ponch Rivera: I can use that to my advantage, correct?
- 1:05:17Ponch Rivera: Yeah, if I understand the system better than you, then I can.
- 1:05:20Andrew McLuhan: I can control you well, precisely, you know, thinking again about the aquarium, it's.
- 1:05:26Andrew McLuhan: It's like, if I understand, uh, the ph balance, I can control that environment and adjust the conditions for the health of the people or animals or whatever in it.
- 1:05:39Andrew McLuhan: And you know people, this can get dark right and people can talk about, oh well, engineering, people, and you know Big Brother and all the rest of it is like, well, you know, sure, you can take it kind of Orwellian if you want to, but you know, as my grandfather said, I refuse to simply sit back and let the juggernaut roll over me.
- 1:06:04Andrew McLuhan: He also said that there's a curious repugnance in the human heart against understanding the actions within which he is involved.
- 1:06:14Andrew McLuhan: It's very strange.
- 1:06:24Andrew McLuhan: He believes that understanding entails responsibility, and he's not wrong.
- 1:06:26Andrew McLuhan: If you understand the forces at work, you kind of accept responsibility for your role in them.
- 1:06:35Andrew McLuhan: It's a lot easier to just ignore certain things and then you can't be blamed for them, but you also have to live with the consequences.
- 1:06:43Andrew McLuhan: So I think, when it comes down to it, it's better to understand more fully the situation and at least try and do something about it than to be kind of willfully ignorant and hope for the best.
- 1:07:02Mark McGrath: One of the.
- 1:07:02Mark McGrath: So, if I have understanding media as you've shown me, the first seven chapters are really critical to understand.
- 1:07:11Mark McGrath: You know, conceptually, what it is that Marshall McLuhan is trying to convey, and then the remainder of the book is, you know, illustrative things like money and other things, that kind of show the show the concepts.
- 1:07:26Mark McGrath: One of the chapters that we spent some time on and I think there's some Boyd parallel too was the chapter on hybrid energy, and on page 76, where it says the present book, in seeking to understand many media, the conflicts from which they spring, the even greater conflicts to which they give rise, holds out the promise of reducing these conflicts by an increase of human autonomy.
- 1:07:59Andrew McLuhan: Yeah, beautiful.
- 1:08:01Mark McGrath: It's a beautiful statement.
- 1:08:02Mark McGrath: Unpack that, because I see a lot of Boyd parallels.
- 1:08:05Mark McGrath: But I want to hear, maybe from your standpoint, you know why is that?
- 1:08:09Mark McGrath: I mean, other than it explains what the purpose of the book is, but what's the most important thing to take away from that?
- 1:08:17Andrew McLuhan: Well, it's a more elegant way of saying what I just spent a couple minutes saying For Marshall McLuhan it's all about agency and autonomy.
- 1:08:28Andrew McLuhan: You know having a measure of control, you know steering the ship rather than just hoping it doesn't run aground.
- 1:08:39Andrew McLuhan: The title of the book, understanding Media, suggests that such a thing is possible To understand media, to understand the nature of technology, the effects of technology, of technology, the effects of technology, and maybe take more control instead of you know kind of designing things and hoping for the best.
- 1:09:05Andrew McLuhan: Because we understand that we design these tools, these technologies, these innovations for one purpose and when we look back at what actually happened, they do a whole lot of things that we didn't anticipate.
- 1:09:15Andrew McLuhan: We call those unintended consequences, but there's, I think, a very big difference between unintended consequences and unavoidable consequences.
- 1:09:29Andrew McLuhan: Okay, in the early 20th century down south there, you guys implemented something called the Food and Drug Safety Act and created the Food and Drug Administration, because people were getting sick from tainted meat, people were being sold snake oil and they demanded better.
- 1:09:54Andrew McLuhan: So the government said okay, you can no longer sell your drugs, your pharmaceuticals, without a much better understanding of what they're going to do.
- 1:10:03Andrew McLuhan: They have to be safe for human consumption and they have to be effective.
- 1:10:08Andrew McLuhan: They have to do what you say they're going to do.
- 1:10:10Andrew McLuhan: We don't do this with technology because we don't have a very complete understanding of their nature.
- 1:10:19Andrew McLuhan: We don't understand what safe and effective means, because it's not that simple.
- 1:10:26Andrew McLuhan: What it is is it's a new culture, a new set of values.
- 1:10:31Andrew McLuhan: Is that safe and effective?
- 1:10:33Andrew McLuhan: These are questions.
- 1:10:38Andrew McLuhan: So Marshall McLuhan wrote this book.
- 1:10:42Andrew McLuhan: He engaged in this work in order to increase human autonomy, so that we might have some measure of control, so that we might mitigate or avoid unintended consequences and do better.
- 1:10:58Andrew McLuhan: Because if we understand certain principles about technology, we can anticipate things.
- 1:11:05Andrew McLuhan: Just like we can study a drug and its effects and anticipate things.
- 1:11:11Andrew McLuhan: And if we think, oh, that's going to make you sick as a drug.
- 1:11:14Andrew McLuhan: Or if we think, oh, that's going to make you sick as a drug, or if we think, oh, that's going to shift this part of culture, we can take those into effect and we can maybe design a little bit differently.
- 1:11:24Andrew McLuhan: So what Marshall was doing in that book, understanding Media, is he's studying technologies as a category to understand and develop general principles.
- 1:11:36Andrew McLuhan: So part one when you look at the table of contents there of understanding media.
- 1:11:42Andrew McLuhan: You've got part one and part two.
- 1:11:43Andrew McLuhan: Part one is seven chapters and it basically entails seven different principles or ways of looking at the nature and effects of technologies as a category human innovation.
- 1:11:58Andrew McLuhan: Then you have part two.
- 1:12:00Andrew McLuhan: Part two is 26 chapters Chapters on speech, on print, on telephone, on television, on clothing, on housing.
- 1:12:09Andrew McLuhan: He's taking these general principles from part one and applying them to specific cases.
- 1:12:16Andrew McLuhan: So he goes from general principles to specific application and he creates what I consider a field guide.
- 1:12:26Andrew McLuhan: So, chap, I think part two never ends because, uh, every time you read this book and I teach a course on understanding media, which I read it aloud, word by word, exploring all of every phrase, the way we have done here in this podcast with my students, and that turns into 36 three-hour classes weekly over about 18 months to get through the whole thing.
- 1:12:54Andrew McLuhan: I've done it all the way through with two cohorts and I'm one third the way through with a third cohort right now.
- 1:13:02Andrew McLuhan: And the thing is, the crazy thing about this book is, every time you read it it's a different book because it's a field guide and as such, it's evergreen.
- 1:13:18Andrew McLuhan: It's perennial Because, basically, you can read this book every time there's a new technology and you have all these new answers about it.
- 1:13:32Andrew McLuhan: It's quite a remarkable thing, and what I've realized is that it's not accidental but it's quite deliberate, because this is you know, you could retitle the book A Guide to Understanding Media, because that's what it is, and I was so excited to be taking this latest cohort through it when AI has just come off the ground, because it's so valuable.
- 1:14:03Andrew McLuhan: The medium is the message.
- 1:14:04Andrew McLuhan: What does that mean for AI?
- 1:14:08Andrew McLuhan: Media?
- 1:14:08Andrew McLuhan: Hot and cool.
- 1:14:09Andrew McLuhan: Is AI hot?
- 1:14:10Andrew McLuhan: Is it cool?
- 1:14:11Andrew McLuhan: Hybrid media how does that relate to AI?
- 1:14:15Andrew McLuhan: All these principles from those seven chapters, those seven principles tell you a lot and the thing is it's not like this work has all the answers for technology, but it has a lot of them.
- 1:14:31Andrew McLuhan: And when you know nothing, but it has a lot of them.
- 1:14:39Andrew McLuhan: Uh, and when?
- 1:14:40Mark McGrath: you know nothing, like, hey, I'll take seven ideas to get me kicking.
- 1:14:42Mark McGrath: Well, I think, um, I mean, we can, we, we could go on for days and and have a lot more discussions.
- 1:14:50Mark McGrath: That's true, yeah, no, because the the synergies between mcclellan and boyd are uncanny.
- 1:14:56Mark McGrath: Um, just even the concept of increasing uh, you know, reducing conflict and increasing human autonomy, I mean, he says in destruction, creation.
- 1:15:05Mark McGrath: John boyd says, you know, the intent is to improve our capacity for free and independent action.
- 1:15:10Mark McGrath: And I, and I think that what I would tell people, and what I do tell people, is that, the better you understand Boyd, and then you can augment that thinking with McLuhan, or vice versa, if I understand McLuhan, I can augment that thinking with Boyd is that I'm taking proactive steps to improve my capacity for free and independent action, whether it's me or the, you know, the family, or the team, or the organization or whatever it is that I'm a part of or leading in.
- 1:15:38Mark McGrath: There's a lot of upside and, as Ponch says, the hockey stick, the potential is geometric for those that get it where it clicks where it clicks.
- 1:15:50Mark McGrath: So, any, any, uh, any final thoughts before we uh, we pause here and we'll, uh, we'll save the rest for another, another episode.
- 1:16:01Ponch Rivera: Yeah, hey, hey, moose, for me the the same experience with John Boyd's work.
- 1:16:04Ponch Rivera: Anytime something new happens in the environment, you go back and read it.
- 1:16:07Ponch Rivera: You know I'll find something.
- 1:16:08Ponch Rivera: It means something different every single day.
- 1:16:11Ponch Rivera: Right, so you're looking at.
- 1:16:12Ponch Rivera: Yeah, every time you look at what's happening over in in Eastern Europe, you look at what's going on in the South China sea, you look at what's going on in the U?
- 1:16:20Ponch Rivera: S right now, with the election coming up, you find it, you find something valuable to go.
- 1:16:25Ponch Rivera: Okay, that's what that means, or, or this is how I can look at it.
- 1:16:31Andrew McLuhan: So know the funny thing, marshall McLuhan was interviewed by this guy is it Michael or something, mcmanus, excuse me?
- 1:16:42Andrew McLuhan: And toward the end of the interview he said to him you know, dr McLuhan, is there any period in time you would rather have lived in?
- 1:16:52Andrew McLuhan: Is there any period in time you would rather have lived in?
- 1:16:57Andrew McLuhan: And Marshall replied I would rather live in any period at all, so long as they're willing to leave it alone for a while.
- 1:17:05Andrew McLuhan: The funny thing is, the interesting thing is is my grandfather was a very conservative guy who really just wanted things to be left alone.
- 1:17:12Andrew McLuhan: Right, he wanted to sit and read and he was an English professor.
- 1:17:16Andrew McLuhan: He loved content, he loved literature and poetry.
- 1:17:20Andrew McLuhan: But he also, you know, his first year of university in Manitoba he did in mechanical engineering because he was really interested in how things work.
- 1:17:34Andrew McLuhan: He switched after his first year to English literature and to an arts degree.
- 1:17:44Andrew McLuhan: But I think the fact that he started in mechanical engineering is very telling because he's really interested in how things work and the fact that they have and that interest carried through and eventually made it impossible for him to stay just inside English literature.
- 1:17:58Andrew McLuhan: But quite remarkably, what he did and this is hard to really credit.
- 1:18:05Andrew McLuhan: But he took the principles he learned for studying the effects of literature and poetry and applied them to culture and technology to look at how culture and technology work and affect us, and in so doing, he essentially invented media studies, which is remarkable and is what it is.
- 1:18:31Andrew McLuhan: But the interviewer said is there a time you'd rather live in?
- 1:18:33Andrew McLuhan: And Marshall said no, I'd rather live in.
- 1:18:34Andrew McLuhan: And marshall said not, I'd rather live any time, as long as they're willing to leave it alone for a while.
- 1:18:38Andrew McLuhan: You know, um and mcmahon says but they're not going to, are they?
- 1:18:43Andrew McLuhan: And I said no, they're not.
- 1:18:45Andrew McLuhan: So the only thing left to do is to understand and be able to turn off as many buttons as you can and frustrate them as much as you can, and that's what he set out to do and to show us to leave behind.
- 1:19:02Andrew McLuhan: You know steps for us to do it.
- 1:19:05Andrew McLuhan: And is it easy work to read?
- 1:19:08Andrew McLuhan: No, should it be?
- 1:19:09Andrew McLuhan: I don't think so.
- 1:19:11Andrew McLuhan: Should it be?
- 1:19:15Andrew McLuhan: I don't think so Because, look, these processes that are all around us are incredibly difficult, dynamic, hard to understand things.
- 1:19:19Andrew McLuhan: It's going to take work.
- 1:19:21Andrew McLuhan: So either you're willing to put the work in or you're not, and for me, I find it quite rewarding.
- 1:19:35Andrew McLuhan: I got into this later in life because it never made any sense to me as a kid.
- 1:19:39Andrew McLuhan: I don't know why or what happened, but in my 30s what my dad was saying clicked and it made sense for the first time in my life.
- 1:19:48Andrew McLuhan: And when something makes sense, when you understand something, anything, for the first time, it's a seductive thing, isn't it?
- 1:19:58Andrew McLuhan: You want more.
- 1:20:00Andrew McLuhan: It's like, oh shoot, that's really cool.
- 1:20:03Andrew McLuhan: I want more of that.
- 1:20:04Andrew McLuhan: And that's kind of led me to where I am now and it's a never-ending.
- 1:20:10Andrew McLuhan: It never ends because you know, the world moves on and, uh, we can either be swept along or or swim along.
- 1:20:21Mark McGrath: I think the choice is ours well, it's a great place to pause for now.
- 1:20:25Mark McGrath: We'll make sure that people are directed to the mccluhan institute.
- 1:20:30Mark McGrath: Uh, and your and your substack the mcclu newsletter, which I highly recommend.
- 1:20:34Mark McGrath: I'm a subscriber Also to the Playboy interview.
- 1:20:40Mark McGrath: We recommend everybody get a 2003 edition of Understanding Media Extensions of man so that they can better understand what Marshall McLuhan work really is and how it ties to John Boyd Cool.
- 1:20:58Mark McGrath: Thank you, andrew.
- 1:21:01Andrew McLuhan: Hey, thank you, great to talk to you guys.