Latest / Comeback Files: Resilience, recovery & starting over / The Secret Joy of Creating for No One: Unapologetic Private Art | Comeback Files
Transcript
- There is a specific kind of freedom that arrives only when you realize no one will ever see what you make. It feels like taking off shoes after a ten-mile hike, but for your soul. I want you to close your eyes for just a moment and picture a drawer. Maybe it’s the junk drawer in your kitchen, the one with the tangled cords and half-empty pens. Or maybe it’s a shoebox under your bed, tucked away behind old tax returns and birthday cards you never sent. Inside this imaginary space, there is something you created. A sketchbook filled with charcoal smudges. A journal of poems that rhyme too perfectly or not at all. A playlist of songs you wrote on an acoustic guitar while sitting on the floor of your bathroom. Now, imagine that for the next year, absolutely no one else knows this thing exists. Your friends don’t know. Your partner doesn’t know. Your mother doesn’t know. There is no Instagram post. No LinkedIn announcement. No gallery opening. Just you, and the work, and the quiet hum of your own attention. This is where I want to take you today. We are going to talk about the courage it takes to start a creative project purely for private joy. Not because you’re building a portfolio. Not because you’re trying to heal a trauma in public. Not because you hope to monetize it or build a brand around it. But simply because the act of making it makes you feel alive. In a world that screams at us to share everything, to document every meal, to perform our hobbies for an audience of strangers, choosing invisibility feels radical. It feels almost rebellious. And I think, if we’re honest, it might be the most healing thing you can do for yourself right now. Let’s look at what’s actually here. We live in an era of the curated self. If you bake sourdough bread, you must photograph the crumb structure against a marble countertop with natural light filtering through linen curtains. If you paint, you must film the time-lapse of the brushstrokes. If you write, you must tweet the first line to generate engagement. The message we absorb, constantly and quietly, is that creation without visibility is creation wasted. That if a tree falls in the forest and no one posts about it, did it really fall? But this performance trap has a cost. When we create for an audience, even a small one, we begin to edit ourselves before we even begin. We ask, 'Will they like this?' instead of 'Do I love this?' We choose safe topics over risky truths. We polish the rough edges until there is nothing left to hold onto. The art becomes a mirror for their approval, not a window into your experience. And slowly, the joy drains out of the process. You stop creating because it feels good, and you start creating because it feels necessary. That is a heavy burden to carry. That is a way to burn out your spirit, not nourish it. So let’s talk about the alternative. The courage to create in the dark. When you remove the audience, you also remove the critic. Not the internal critic—we all have that, and it’s stubborn—but the external pressure. You are free to make bad art. You are free to write terrible sentences. You are free to draw stick figures with disproportionate limbs. And in that freedom, you rediscover play. Remember play? It wasn’t about winning. It wasn’t about being the best at it. It was about the sensation of being in motion. I remember a friend of mine, Elena, who started knitting scarves during the height of the pandemic. She didn’t sell them. She didn’t give them away. She just knitted. Every night, after the kids were asleep, she would sit by the window and knit a long, ugly, brightly colored scarf. Sometimes the stitches dropped. Sometimes she unraveled three feet of work because the color combination offended her. But she kept going. Later, she told me that those scarves were the only time she felt like herself. Not a mother, not an employee, not a daughter. Just Elena, with her needles and her yarn. The fact that no one saw them gave them weight. They were hers. Entirely, completely hers. When we were children, we didn’t create for likes. We built forts that collapsed immediately. We drew pictures that looked like muddy brown blobs, and we showed them to the cat with immense pride. We created because the impulse was inside us, demanding release. As adults, we tend to lose touch with that impulse. We become so concerned with competence that we forget how to be beginners. We think we need to be good at something before we allow ourselves to enjoy it. But joy doesn’t require skill. Joy requires presence. Starting a private creative project is a way to return to that state of beginner’s mind. It allows you to explore parts of yourself that you usually keep locked away. Maybe you’ve always wanted to write mystery novels, but you’re afraid people will judge your plot holes. So you write them in a notebook that stays on your desk. Maybe you’ve always wanted to dance, but you feel awkward in front of others. So you put on music in your bedroom and move however your body wants to move. These acts seem small. They seem insignificant to the outside world. But inside you, they are monumental. They are declarations that you belong to yourself. I want to mention something from last week’s episode, 'Why Setting a Timer for Worry Lets You Breathe Again.' We talked about containing anxiety so it doesn’t spill into your whole day. There is a similar containment happening when you create privately. You are creating a container for your emotions, your thoughts, your energy. But instead of worrying about what might go wrong, you are focusing on what you are making. This isn’t mindfulness in the sense of sitting still and breathing. It’s active mindfulness. It’s engaging your hands and your mind in something tangible. When you work on a private project, you aren’t performing wellness. You aren’t signaling that you’re okay. You are just being. And sometimes, being is enough. Sometimes, the messiness of the process is the point. You might finish a painting and hate it. You might read a poem and cringe. And that’s okay. Because the value wasn’t in the object. The value was in the hour you spent alone with your thoughts, shaping them into form. You practiced showing up for yourself. You practiced listening to your own voice. That repetition builds resilience. It builds a muscle we often neglect: the ability to find satisfaction in the doing, not just the result. So here is my invitation to you. It doesn’t have to be big. It doesn’t have to be permanent. Pick one thing. A medium. A format. Something that calls to you, even if it scares you. Buy the cheap watercolors. Borrow the camera. Find the blank pages. And then, hide it. Literally, if you need to. Put it somewhere no one will look. Tell yourself, 'I am doing this for me. Only for me.' Give yourself permission to be bad at it. Give yourself permission to stop whenever you want. Give yourself permission to never show it to anyone. The comeback starts in the quiet. It starts in the moments where you choose yourself over the applause. It starts when you realize that your creativity is not a product to be sold, but a language to be spoken. Speak it softly. Speak it loudly. Speak it in secret. Just speak it. Because the world has enough performances. What it needs, what you need, is truth. And truth often lives in the shadows, waiting for someone brave enough to turn on the light for just themselves. Thank you for spending this time with me. Keep creating, keep hiding, and keep believing that your private joy is enough. Until next time, I’m Sophie Fergus. Be gentle with yourself.