Latest / The Momentum Experiment / Should you build habits with consistency or intensity?
Transcript
- 0:00When my friend posted about a book I was considering reading, her review
- 0:03was short and simple. And as soon as she said
- 0:07Opposite of James Clear, my curiosity was
- 0:11piqued. Now I'm talking about the book Unhinged Habits
- 0:15by Jonathan Goodman. And as a fan of the
- 0:18bestselling Atomic Habits by James Clear, I had to
- 0:22know what my friend meant when she said this
- 0:26is the opposite. So today I am discussing ideas
- 0:29from these two books. How do they differ on this idea of
- 0:33transformation and habits? And what are the
- 0:37approaches that they take because they are in opposition to each
- 0:41other, even though there are some things they have in common. Now, I will also
- 0:44share about where I fall on this spectrum and
- 0:48where I have gotten it wrong in the past and also seen
- 0:52a other people get it wrong. So let's start with the core
- 0:56ideas in these books that oppose each
- 0:59other. Now, Atomic Habits. This one is about making
- 1:03consistent incremental improvements that compound
- 1:07over time. And I've got this picture that I took from
- 1:10James Clear. This is from his website. And it's this idea that
- 1:14making these tiny consistent incremental
- 1:18improvements compound over time, just like a bank account.
- 1:22Now what he says here is that over time, Even if it's
- 1:261% per day, eventually it'll be
- 1:2937% by the end of, I think it's a year.
- 1:33Now I'm going to read a quote from the book. I've got a
- 1:37little. Got a little sticky here. And actually
- 1:41two, I've got two quotes. So the first one, improving
- 1:44by 1% isn't particularly notable. Sometimes it
- 1:48isn't even noticeable. But it can be far more
- 1:52meaningful, especially in the long run. The difference a
- 1:56tiny improvement can make over time is astounding. And then
- 2:00he goes on to say, people sometimes make a
- 2:04few small changes. They fail to see a tangible result and they
- 2:08decide to stop. They think, I've been running every different month,
- 2:12so why can't I see any change in my body? Once this thinking
- 2:15has taken over, it's easy to let good habits fall by the
- 2:19wayside. But in order to make a meaningful, different habits
- 2:23need to persist long enough to break through this plateau.
- 2:27And he calls it the plateau of latent potential. Essentially
- 2:31because this is a curve that starts out really slow, but then it
- 2:34starts to really lift. This is where a lot of people will say, I'm just
- 2:38not seeing these improvements. And so they give up. And I'm sure
- 2:41that many of us are familiar, I know I have experienced
- 2:45that, where it just doesn't feel like enough.
- 2:49Now what is the difference when it comes to
- 2:52Unhinged Habits. And what is this author saying?
- 2:56So I don't have a picture, but I am going to read a couple of
- 3:00quotes. So in Unhinged Habits,
- 3:04there's a particular chapter called Define youe Season. It says, this chapter
- 3:08offers a radical, almost unhinged alternative
- 3:12to the myth of balanced improvement. A seasonal approach where
- 3:15focused intensity on one priority replaces scattered
- 3:19consistency across many. By embracing intense
- 3:23seasons of growth followed by periods of rest or maintenance, you'll make
- 3:26transformative progress in what matters most while keeping the guilt at bay.
- 3:30This isn't about doing more, it's about doing less with
- 3:34greater intensity at the right time.
- 3:38Now, the other quote that I think is important to mention
- 3:42in this, in this context is that he's essentially
- 3:46looking at consistency versus intensity. However,
- 3:51Unhinged Habits still references consistency. And
- 3:55the author says consistency is undeniably important,
- 3:59but it needs to flank periods of intensity stacked atop one
- 4:03another. Focused on one aspect of your life you want to
- 4:06measurably improve. And in the book,
- 4:10just like in Atomic Habits, there's the example of running. Well, I'm running every day,
- 4:14but I'm not seeing anything in this book. The author,
- 4:17Jonathan, was a personal trainer, and so he does use the
- 4:21example of a transformation for your health. That for
- 4:25many people taking a period of intensity, say eight to 12
- 4:28weeks, really committing to a program and
- 4:32focusing on that, you will see faster improvements than if you say you
- 4:36started going to the gym twice a week, which is something maybe you want to
- 4:39do for the rest of your life. But if you just do that, you don't
- 4:42see them quickly. So we talked about that. Now this idea is that
- 4:46in the gym or with health, when somebody starts to
- 4:49see transformation early, that can
- 4:53actually be extremely motivating. Now, there's one other quote
- 4:57that I think is really important to mention in this book. And I don't think
- 5:00you'll be surprised that it stood out to me. And this is the author
- 5:04being brutally honest, saying, for better or
- 5:07for worse, my human brain craves novelty and excitement
- 5:11and immediate gratification. Maybe I'm not strong willed enough
- 5:15to overcome thousands of years of evolutionary physiology.
- 5:18Maybe my mind is naturally weaker than others. If so, it is what
- 5:22it is, right? Regardless, it's up to me to work with the
- 5:25physiology that I've got. It's probably no surprise
- 5:29that that is a quote that would stand out to me because I
- 5:33do think how we're wired matters. And even if you
- 5:36are someone, when you read different books by different authors, you can get A pretty
- 5:40good sense that their style
- 5:44lends itself to the book they're writing. This is how they operate,
- 5:48it works for them. So they write a book and they share with other people
- 5:51how that works. In essence, this is
- 5:55personal. There's a very good chance you have tried both. I
- 5:58know I have. I've tried the consistency, I've tried the intensity.
- 6:02And I think there is room for both.
- 6:06But there's also a very good chance that you have a preference.
- 6:10And I don't think you should feel judged if
- 6:14one way works better than you or the other. And it's not necessarily
- 6:18an either or. And there might be things in your life for which this intensity
- 6:21followed by consistency might work really well for you.
- 6:25And then there are other areas of your life where actually just straight up consistency
- 6:29is gonna work. Now what I wanna do is let's look at some of the
- 6:32pros for both of them. So an
- 6:36advantage to atomic habits is that you focus on
- 6:39establishing it's a sustainable practice. Or
- 6:43as James Clear likes to talk about, it's a system. And that can
- 6:46last over the long haul. So it's sort of this idea of start the way
- 6:49you want to finish. And let's use the example of going to the gym
- 6:53twice a week. So if you can make it twice a week over the long
- 6:56haul, you'll probably be healthier than someone who just shows up to the gym for
- 7:00a few months, then stops for six months, et cetera. So having something that is
- 7:04sustainable over the long haul is great. And because the
- 7:07atomic habits focus on having these systems in place
- 7:11that you can repeat over, over a long period, it does mean you
- 7:15can focus on multiple habits at one time and sort of
- 7:19build them in a way where they fit into your life and then you
- 7:22can continue on fitting them into your life. Now, an
- 7:26advantage or a pro to the unhinged approach is that you do
- 7:30see progress faster, which can be very motivating
- 7:33for people. And the emphasis on this
- 7:37transformation through this intense season of your life
- 7:41and then flipping to maintain, that can be an
- 7:44effective way to keep up what you've gained. So with the gym example,
- 7:48if you do gain strength or increase your muscle mass,
- 7:52change your body composition, then later you can go into
- 7:56more of that consistent, maintain phase. And it doesn't require the same
- 7:59level of intensity. As long as you continue with your
- 8:03good habits now consistent, there are some
- 8:07disadvantages. So atomic habits, we already talked about this idea that sometimes you aren't seeing
- 8:11results and you start to question the effort. Is this worth
- 8:14it? I Don't see any payoff. And sometimes with this
- 8:18incremental approach, if you are not going all
- 8:21in, it might feel like you're not really committing or giving it the
- 8:25attention that you think it needs in this moment. And so it also might
- 8:29play with some mindset things around is this even really a priority?
- 8:33Now? A con for the unhinged habit is that it does,
- 8:36as he said, focus on this and do less
- 8:40of the other things. So you need to deprioritize other
- 8:43practices in your life during that season and you
- 8:47might start to resent maybe how much time it's taking. If you
- 8:51are really, really, really zeroing in on this and this is the season, it's taking
- 8:54up a lot of your time, you might start to hate that you're saying no
- 8:57to other opportunities as a trade off for this period of intensity.
- 9:02The other thing is that you have a high risk of, let's call
- 9:05it a post intensity drop off, which is a
- 9:09mistake that I know very well and it's a mistake that I've seen a lot
- 9:13of other people make with these periods of intensity.
- 9:17Now, in case you couldn't guess, I am a person who naturally
- 9:21gravitates to go sort of all in. I love a grand
- 9:25plan. I usually like to name my plants. I love this
- 9:28focus. And maybe it's hyper fixation, but in
- 9:32many cases I do experience a transformation from
- 9:36these seasons of intensity in my life. They can be very
- 9:39fulfilling and I can get really into it. But there
- 9:43is a big but it can come with this risk which is the
- 9:46maintain. It's that part where you're staying consistent afterwards.
- 9:50And that is where I am naturally wired to kind of get into
- 9:54the really intense. I like this. This is novel, this is exc. But
- 9:58then when it becomes, dare I say, boring or that
- 10:01maintenance phase, it just doesn't thrill me and it's a little bit harder to keep
- 10:05up. I get so focused also on the plan for
- 10:09the intense period that I don't spend any time
- 10:12coming up with an off ramp. And this is something
- 10:16that you need in order to ease yourself back into consistent
- 10:20practices so you don't lose everything that you built
- 10:23towards during that. Now, I'll use a personal example
- 10:27for both me, but also as a practitioner. So over
- 10:30the years, because of chronic health and autoimmune diseases,
- 10:34I have played around with my diet. I've done a lot of
- 10:38elimination diets, which I have learned so much, a tremendous amount
- 10:42about what works for me and what maybe deters against my
- 10:45health. And during Those periods, I was full
- 10:49on. I was all in, full, full on. But as soon as those periods
- 10:53were over, because I hadn't come up with an off ramp of
- 10:57what does this look like long term? What does this look like sustainably? Everything
- 11:00kind of crumbles and falls apart. And that is where
- 11:04I tend to go wrong. But also, I worked in nutrition, I was a practitioner,
- 11:07I had my own clinic and or I was part of a
- 11:11clinic. And when I was seeing clients for nutrition,
- 11:15the same thing would happen to them if we didn't come up with a plan.
- 11:19And the other thing is if it's something like an elimination diet, which can be
- 11:22used therapeutically of learning what works with your
- 11:26body and what doesn't, pulling out all those foods as soon
- 11:29as that intense period is done, a lot of people feel like, okay, now
- 11:33I'm just gonna just have all the things I've been missing. So without
- 11:37that off ramp, you can undo or hinder or harm
- 11:40what you have spent all of this time and effort on. Now I
- 11:44truly believe that either option can work.
- 11:48And really what they have in common is they both require
- 11:51intention. You need to know what your outcome is. You need
- 11:55to think about what you need to do and what your goals are, what
- 11:59are you actually aiming for, and whether you go with a more
- 12:02consistent, more consistency approach, the atomic
- 12:06habits style, or a more seasonal
- 12:09intensity and then consistency approach, both cases
- 12:14you can apply the momentum formula. And one of
- 12:18the things, I bring this up because it's something I am thinking about in
- 12:22my life right now after reading this book. It got me reflecting a lot on
- 12:25what has worked, what hasn't worked, and what has the
- 12:29potential for me, but also needs work. And I bring this up because
- 12:33when it comes to creating a plan, whether that's just straight up
- 12:37consistency going atomic habits or whether that's going
- 12:40for intensity followed by consistency, in both cases
- 12:45you need to think practically. So, so what is the actual method? What am
- 12:48I doing? What's my system? I know Atomic Habits talks a lot about
- 12:52systems, so what are the things I need to do in order to improve?
- 12:56Whether it's 1% or whether it's intense, but
- 12:59also thinking about how do I make this personal? And that's where
- 13:03mode comes in. How do I have this work for me? And
- 13:07we took that quote, or I read you that quote from Unhinged Habits around
- 13:11this is what works for my brain. I think that's really
- 13:15important, but not just during the intensity, but also afterwards,
- 13:18what is going to suit me long term. I know that Sometimes I struggle
- 13:22with boredom if it's just a maintaining thing that can get dry.
- 13:26So how do I incorporate an off ramp, a plan for maintaining
- 13:30that also includes something that personally suits me
- 13:33and also mindset. Mindset is so important and for this we can think about what's
- 13:37the perspective I need for whatever it is I'm doing.
- 13:41So if we are taking an incremental approach, what is the perspective
- 13:44so that I stick with this even when I'm not seeing
- 13:48progress right away? How do I handle any doubts
- 13:52that creep up so I don't self sabotage? Now, if you are
- 13:56going for a more intense period, you might have to say, how do
- 14:00I take a perspective or mindset where I don't feel
- 14:03like I'm resenting the other things that I'm letting go of during this period and
- 14:07I'm intentionally choosing this season and, and this is something, a choice I'm
- 14:11making instead of taking on a mindset where you feel like you're missing out
- 14:15on all these things that make you want to jump off and say enough of
- 14:18this. And then for that off ramp, what's the mindset of how do I
- 14:22transition so that I am not self
- 14:25sabotaging on the back end? What's the story I'm
- 14:29telling myself when it comes to maintaining these improvements that
- 14:32I've made and what does the next season look like because you don't want to
- 14:36let go of everything that you've built. And a lot of this is really important
- 14:39mindset work. And if we take that example for nutrition, the number
- 14:43of people who had this kind of all or nothing, I am on the plan,
- 14:47it's intense or I'm off and then everything falls,
- 14:51falls apart and crumbles. And then people end up feeling like garbage within a few
- 14:54weeks. So we don't want to swing so wildly. We want to
- 14:58think about that off ramp. Now, for me personally,
- 15:02I am going to be approaching a season, an
- 15:06intentional season of intensity. And I
- 15:09say that with quotes because the
- 15:13experiment for myself is actually around
- 15:16my rehabilitation for some injuries related to
- 15:19hypermobility. I've shared it before, but in
- 15:23the fall I was diagnosed with hsd, which is hypermobility
- 15:27syndrome disorder. And it is where a
- 15:30deficiency in connective tissue causes a lot of injuries, but it also causes
- 15:34other problems with different organs in my body. And, and this can make
- 15:37it really difficult. And I've worked with a lot of practitioners, many who are just
- 15:41not very familiar with how to deal with HSD or
- 15:45the other one, Ehlers Danlos syndrome, or eds. They're
- 15:49very, they're very linked. And what I have done is
- 15:53actually registered for a program that is specifically
- 15:57designed for people with HSD and eds,
- 16:01and I will be going through that program. Now, the thing about the program, the
- 16:04reason I say intensity, is that these
- 16:07programs are deliberately low and slow
- 16:12because of the chance of injury. Now, I
- 16:15have decided though, that there are other habits or
- 16:19practices or hobbies that I enjoy, but I'm going to
- 16:23kind of ease off a little bit on those in order to really dedicate
- 16:26time to making this a priority. Because I know if I can build that
- 16:30foundation and really zero in on that, then I can start to
- 16:34reduce the chance of injury. If I were say, to take more
- 16:37of the 1% incremental approach, then
- 16:41I just might not be able to get to the place I want to be
- 16:45in the same time period. So I really am motivated by this idea of
- 16:49that transformation, especially if it means that I can start to
- 16:53reduce the chance of injury. And this means saying no
- 16:56to other things and just not feeling guilty about it because I'm
- 17:00intentionally choosing the season. However, there are
- 17:04two plans that are required. One is during this season of
- 17:07intensity. So for me, over the next two months. So as I
- 17:11record this, this is. We're just starting April. It's April and May.
- 17:15And I have told the people close to me that I am doing this
- 17:19so that I can set expectations and I can start to make decisions
- 17:22that say, yes, this is something I'm focusing on and I can say no
- 17:26to some of the things that might get in the way of that.
- 17:30But I need a second plan which is my off ramp and that is
- 17:34really paying attention over the next two months. How do I keep this
- 17:37consistently? How do I maintain the progress that I've experienced
- 17:41and what does this look like on the maintain on the back end
- 17:45where it's a part of my regular routine, but it's just not as intense.
- 17:49And like the example with fitness,
- 17:53once you have built up a certain level, then it is easier to
- 17:56maintain because you've kind of built up that. That foundation. And so that's something
- 18:00that I really looking to do. But I'm going in with
- 18:04this mindset that I need to have a plan
- 18:07and it needs to be personalized to me and I need to have
- 18:11that good perspective around what does this look like
- 18:15both during. What's my mindset during the intensity, but also what is
- 18:19my mindset after the fact so that I can maintain it. Both
- 18:22require that intentionality and that is something that I'm looking to
- 18:26do. Because really regardless whether you go
- 18:29consistent all the way atomic habits or whether you
- 18:33choose something that's more intense seasons followed by those
- 18:36periods of consistency, both of them need intention, but
- 18:40both of them you can have momentum and keep it.