Latest / Stories of Change: Helping You Navigate What's Next / Facing an Uncertain Future: Futurist Amy Webb's 2020 Perspective
Transcript
- 0:03Judy Oskam: Welcome to Stories of Change and Creativity.
- 0:06Judy Oskam: I'm Judy Oskam, a professor in the School of Journalism and Mass Communication at Texas State University.
- 0:13Judy Oskam: On this episode I talk with Amy Webb.
- 0:16Judy Oskam: She's a quantitative futurist, founder and CEO of the Future Today Institute and a professor in the NYU Stern School of Business.
- 0:25Judy Oskam: Webb is also a bestselling author of three award-winning books that focus on emerging technologies, uncertainty and corporate foresight strategy.
- 0:36Judy Oskam: Webb pioneered data driven technology, led foresight methodologies and processes.
- 0:42Judy Oskam: She and her team advise CEOs, government leaders and organizations about strategy and the future.
- 0:50Judy Oskam: I'm honored to serve with Amy on the Accrediting Council on Education in Journalism and Mass Communication.
- 0:56Judy Oskam: I'll include more bio information in the show notes.
- 1:00Judy Oskam: During our interview, Amy talks about her unique career path, how to deal with change and focus on what you can control.
- 1:08Judy Oskam: We discussed the current state of affairs with the pandemic and what it means to all of us.
- 1:15Judy Oskam: Webb says, when you don't know what the future is and you don't have control, it's important to lean in to uncertainty.
- 1:23Judy Oskam: I hope you find our conversation interesting and insightful.
- 1:27Judy Oskam: Thanks for listening.
- 1:29Judy Oskam: Let's start a little bit with your background.
- 1:31Judy Oskam: How did you become a quantitative futurist and what, what is that, what does that mean?
- 1:38Amy Webb: I can answer the first part of the last part of that question first.
- 1:42Amy Webb: It's the easy part.
- 1:43Amy Webb: I'm a futurist is somebody who models complexity and uncertainty in trying to understand next order impacts.
- 1:53Amy Webb: So contrary to what a lot of people think, our job is actually not to make predictions.
- 1:58Amy Webb: It's preparation.
- 2:00Amy Webb: It's creating a state of readiness for what might come, you know, what might come next.
- 2:06Amy Webb: Um, now how did I get to this point?
- 2:08Amy Webb: I got to this point because I was a, I was not a fun person to have in a newsroom.
- 2:14Amy Webb: So I started out as a journalist and.you know, I was pretty early to what was then called computer assisted reporting.
- 2:25Amy Webb: That was a spreadsheet jockey and I was based overseas.
- 2:30Amy Webb: So, um, I had very, like in the mid nineties, I had very early access to, you know, the first mobile phones that were connected to the internet.
- 2:42Amy Webb: I'm sorta proto smartphones and the latest and greatest, um, gaming technology and stuff like that.
- 2:49Amy Webb: I remember a friend of mine I had bought, had gone to, must've been Korea and come back and he, he bought a camera, a digital camera that also was an MP3 player.
- 3:03Amy Webb: So like I was the epicenter of tech.
- 3:06Amy Webb: And, when I came back to the United States, I just had a very, very difficult time fitting in.
- 3:12Amy Webb: It was like I had, I had traveled back in time on a time machine and, I, I was at that point much more interested in experiential, storytelling and hacking business models and like all the stuff that none of my editors wanted me to be working on, which totally makes sense.
- 3:34Amy Webb: I was, I was supposed to be a reporter.
- 3:36Amy Webb: Uh, so I get all of that.
- 3:38Amy Webb: And um, we, uh, I, I, I left slash got fired from my last job in journalism and decided, uh, to found a little R and D lab, where I was just testing out and trying to build, um, the future of news distribution really is how I got started.
- 3:57Amy Webb: But then that was almost 20 years ago.
- 3:59Amy Webb: So, so I went from that, studying strategy and taking courses in strategy.
- 4:07Amy Webb: And I happened upon this area of strategy, strategic foresight, which is about, you know, data-driven models, trying to understand the future.
- 4:16Amy Webb: And my academic background is game theory and economics anyways, so I think journalism was probably sort of a short stopover, on the way to the thing that I was always meant to be doing.
- 4:27Judy Oskam: I've listened to your the audio version of your latest book, The Big Nine: How the Tech Titans and their Thinking Machines could Warp Humanity.
- 4:36Judy Oskam: And I'm telling you, Amy, I found it both fascinating and terrifying a little bit, especially listening to it during this time period.
- 4:44Judy Oskam: But what was your primary goal?
- 4:47Judy Oskam: Writing the book.
- 4:47Judy Oskam: What was your main thesis there?
- 4:50Amy Webb: Yeah, so terrifying and fascinating is actually a way that I get described a lot.
- 4:55Amy Webb: So what was the, what was the point?
- 4:56Amy Webb: So, you know, I really focus on emerging technologies.
- 5:00Amy Webb: I, I always have, and I would say in the past 10 years or so in all the research that I've been doing I keep coming back to AI and and that was true, you know, in 2007 2008 around the financial crisis while we were looking at the future of the housing market and the future of the recession and everything else, I kept veering off into quantitative trading and, you know, high frequency trading funds and quant funds and stuff like that.
- 5:32Amy Webb: Anyhow, so AI has kind of been there and in the past several years as I'm doing the research that I'd be doing anyways for work, I kept coming back to these same companies over and over and over again, six are in the United States, three are in China.
- 5:49Amy Webb: And having lived in China for a while, and also Japan and also the United States.
- 5:57Amy Webb: You know, I started really thinking through the geopolitical and geo-economic implications.
- 6:03Amy Webb: And you know what, what it means when a technology that is really fundamental to everything that we do because it's the third era of computing.
- 6:14Amy Webb: It's not a thing.
- 6:16Amy Webb: You know, what happens in a free market economy with basically no regulations or restrictions and what happens in a closed society in, in the CCP where you've got an authoritarian ruler with a considerable in a country that owns a considerable amount of global debt.
- 6:39Amy Webb: What happens when AI is developed there?
- 6:42Amy Webb: And then more importantly, what happens if the developmental track of artificial intelligence is totally bifurcated going forward?
- 6:48Amy Webb: So that's really what led to it.
- 6:50Amy Webb: And I thought, you know, the AI community is pretty far into the weeds thinking about the future of the tech side of things.
- 6:59Amy Webb: Regulators tend not to pay attention, to something until it reaches a critical mass in public consciousness.
- 7:07Amy Webb: And then they get excited.
- 7:09Amy Webb: And wall street has no patience and demands continual returns.
- 7:15Amy Webb: And while all of that's been happening in the U S in China, AI has now intersected with a bunch of top level policies that range from repatriation of experts in academics to emerging markets, programs and other things.
- 7:31Amy Webb: So all of this is leading to a very, very bad place.
- 7:34Amy Webb: And I thought I should read, I should write a book that helps everybody get on the same page.
- 7:38Judy Oskam: I love how you, you explain from the business perspective the importance of business versus government and those roles and how they're intersecting or not intersecting.
- 7:50Judy Oskam: And I think that's it's, and you know, your writing is, it's a readable, it's funny, I mean, I've loved some of your humor.
- 7:57Judy Oskam: I think it's come through, but it kind of helps explain in what could be seen.
- 8:02Judy Oskam: Yeah.
- 8:02Judy Oskam: Scary kind of a forward movement here.
- 8:06Amy Webb: Yeah.
- 8:07Amy Webb: And that's the, so the book is structured in three parts.
- 8:11Amy Webb: The first part is sort of a here's what you missed on Glee version of artificial intelligence.
- 8:17Amy Webb: It's a quick history.
- 8:18Amy Webb: It's very dense, but it's like a, actually, totally sidebar here.
- 8:22Amy Webb: But, so the book got nominated for several awards and it won some things.
- 8:28Amy Webb: It got nominated.
- 8:30Amy Webb: Amazon was listed as Amazon, one of Amazon's best history books.
- 8:35Amy Webb: It's a, it's a book about the future, but it was named one of the best history books written for 2019 and then also one of the best books about tech.
- 8:45Amy Webb: But the history component, um, is because I think a lot of people don't realize that artificial intelligence has been in some form of development now for hundreds of years.
- 8:53Amy Webb: The third part is how do we fix the future.
- 8:57Amy Webb: The second part a re these scenarios.
- 8:59Amy Webb: And so there's an optimistic framing, a neutral framing, and a catastrophic framing.
- 9:04Amy Webb: And optimistic doesn't mean sunshine and rainbows.
- 9:07Amy Webb: I t just means we made the best possible decisions that we could given t he data that we have.
- 9:13Amy Webb: And I, when I was on book tour, I got asked all the time, which one of those scenarios do I think is going t o happen?
- 9:20Amy Webb: And at the time, so the book came out last a year ago, so last March.
- 9:25Amy Webb: At the time I said, you know, I feel like we're in that neutral camp, which is where AI becomes excessively commercialized and we have this new stratification of digital haves and have nots and privacy is dead.
- 9:37Amy Webb: And some people would argue that was the catastrophic framing.
- 9:39Amy Webb: But I k ind o f thought that's where, y ou k now, we were going to be i n t hat situation with the emergence of the pandemic, a nd the erosion of privacy and now AI being used to track and quantify people.
- 9:57Amy Webb: A nd with China now deploying a lot of technology that it was already hoping to use anyways, but this acted as a catalyst.
- 10:04Amy Webb: I think we are in that catastrophic framing, which is not good.
- 10:09Judy Oskam: You talk about the methodology that you go through to model.
- 10:13Judy Oskam: Can you take us through sort of that, that scenario process?
- 10:17Amy Webb: Yeah.
- 10:18Amy Webb: So there are futurists that really just focus on scenario modeling, scenario planning.
- 10:25Amy Webb: So, and, and the modern version of that comes from a guy named Pierre Wack, who in the seventies, uh, was at Royal Dutch Shell and the tradition of modern scenario planning was really born there.
- 10:41Amy Webb: Now foresight as an academic discipline and a social science goes back a hundred years.
- 10:47Amy Webb: And before we got to scenarios, there was risk assessment, risk modeling and what we would call today trends analysis.
- 10:56Amy Webb: I just offer that because it is a serious discipline.
- 11:03Amy Webb: It is very rigorous.
- 11:04Amy Webb: It is not a matter of reading a couple of trade publications and sort of going with your gut.
- 11:10Amy Webb: This is rigorous, data-driven work.
- 11:16Amy Webb: Now in our case, there's a lot of groundwork that leads up to the scenarios process.
- 11:23Amy Webb: So, we, we use different frameworks to model longitudinal trends, but once we get that process done, then we build out scenarios.
- 11:33Amy Webb: That's a multistage process for us.
- 11:34Amy Webb: Everybody does it differently.
- 11:36Amy Webb: We began with something called the axis of uncertainty, which is like trying to create a taxonomy of like all the things we don't know about in categories.
- 11:45Amy Webb: And those categories tend to be things over which no one entity has control.
- 11:49Amy Webb: So we try to figure that out.
- 11:50Amy Webb: We create a bunch of two by two matrices and select different uncertainties and sort of basically write headlines.
- 11:58Amy Webb: If these two things were to happen, then what?
- 12:01Amy Webb: And from there we prioritize all of that information and then write first-generation scenarios.
- 12:05Amy Webb: I mean, this is where the journalism training comes in.
- 12:09Amy Webb: So we, we, it's just that we use a very formulaic set of inputs.
- 12:16Amy Webb: Well, actually, so it's not unlike writing for a ne wspaper p aper, right?
- 12:19Amy Webb: You've got your lead, yo u g ot your, your significance graph.
- 12:23Amy Webb: You know, I mean this is, it's a lot of the same.
- 12:26Amy Webb: Yeah, it is.
- 12:28Judy Oskam: It's strategy.
- 12:28Amy Webb: It is.
- 12:29Amy Webb: Yeah.
- 12:29Amy Webb: Uh, so I think it's similar.
- 12:31Amy Webb: We use a framework that forces us to think like very broadly.
- 12:37Amy Webb: And then once we have a bunch of scenarios written, we say, okay, given what we know to be true, because they should be based in evidence.
- 12:45Amy Webb: Right?
- 12:46Amy Webb: Use the similar to how you would write a data driven.
- 12:49Amy Webb: Yeah.
- 12:49Amy Webb: I mean it's reporting, right?
- 12:50Amy Webb: It's good reporting.
- 12:52Amy Webb: Um, then we say, okay, now let's define our preferred future state, right?
- 12:58Amy Webb: So you can end with like, here's how the world, here's the catastrophe, here's the optimistic framing.
- 13:03Amy Webb: Or if you want to get to strategies, say, okay, well this is our preferred scenario and then we backwards engineer that.
- 13:08Amy Webb: But you do that, your company with, uh, governments, businesses, corporations, institutions, right.
- 13:17Amy Webb: So we, the work actually began with news organizations.
- 13:24Amy Webb: And I got so frustrated.
- 13:25Amy Webb: (laughs) so now we, we work intentionally, my team and I work across different industry sectors.
- 13:34Amy Webb: There are futurists who specialize in health for example, or specialize in the energy sector.
- 13:40Amy Webb: And I think that there is, um, depending on the type of work that you're doing, you know, sometimes it's better to have somebody with extensive domain experience, you know, sometimes it's useful to have people with more of a cross-functional or cross-disciplinary experience.
- 13:58Amy Webb: And that's us.
- 13:59Amy Webb: So we work with fortune 100, we work with, some government agencies.
- 14:05Amy Webb: We also do some fun.
- 14:06Amy Webb: I mean, it's pretty heady strategic work, but sometimes we, for fun, um, we, we do advise, uh, people making television shows and movies.
- 14:18Amy Webb: We serve as script consultants.
- 14:19Amy Webb: We've worked on some shows and commercials and television, movies and stuff.
- 14:24Amy Webb: You mentioned your Dad in your opening credits, did your, how did your family nfluence your thinking?
- 14:30Amy Webb: Because I'm fascinated with how your brain works and I've, I've seen you in meetings over the years and, and I just, I love kind of watching you think and, and, um, percolate while things are going on.
- 14:41Amy Webb: But did your family influence you?
- 14:45Amy Webb: I mean, I have a very, very tight knit family, but on sides of my family they are radically different.
- 14:55Amy Webb: My mother's family are immigrants.
- 14:59Amy Webb: Eastern European.
- 15:01Amy Webb: Jewish and, came to the United States, worked and worked and worked and worked at, you know, very, very, very poor, worked incredibly hard, hard work, productivity and education were more important than anything else.
- 15:16Amy Webb: My dad's side of the family are evangelical Christians.
- 15:22Amy Webb: Um, and we're at one point, some of them are Pentecost, so deeply, deeply religious.
- 15:28Amy Webb: Also, Oh, very, you know, very poor at, were very poor.
- 15:36Amy Webb: My dad was family, was very poor growing up, subsistence farming and, but hard work, productivity, you know, paramount and education.
- 15:47Amy Webb: My dad was the first to graduate from high school and his family.
- 15:50Amy Webb: And with those, with my last name and our family, I'm the first to graduate from college.
- 15:56Amy Webb: So I think, um, you know, and, and now the thing that I pray that, that I prize more than anything else is hard work and productivity and forward momentum.
- 16:09Amy Webb: So, I think that that my family influenced that now on the future stuff.
- 16:17Amy Webb: I kind of knew what I wanted to do when I was in elementary school.
- 16:21Amy Webb: Like I kept journals from a pretty young age and was prolific...I wrote a lot.
- 16:26Amy Webb: I didn't have a lot of friends.
- 16:27Amy Webb: I wrote a lot.
- 16:29Amy Webb: Um, so I've always wanted to do features work in some way or another, even when I didn't have the vocabulary to describe it.
- 16:35Judy Oskam: Before, it wasn't a career path that people really thought about.
- 16:40Judy Oskam: I just wonder about that and.
- 16:42Amy Webb: Yeah.
- 16:43Amy Webb: Um, I mean I've, I want it to be solicitor general.
- 16:46Amy Webb: Like, that was my, I was like 10 and for a heartbeat, like I thought I wanted to be president and then I, I don't know, I guess it must have been something about Reagan in the eighties and somehow I just thought like, I, you know, I'm looking at the, I'm looking at the world through like ten-year-old eyes.
- 17:05Amy Webb: So I don't, obviously there's, there's a lot there that, but I think at some point along the way it was like the executive branch doesn't have all the power that I think it does.
- 17:14Amy Webb: President doesn't.
- 17:14Amy Webb: I should be a Supreme court judge.
- 17:18Amy Webb: I'll go to law school and that's what I'll do.
- 17:20Amy Webb: And then I thought, I don't want to, I'm not a good team a nd I'm not probably a good team players, just solicitor general.
- 17:26Amy Webb: I want to be arguing.
- 17:28Amy Webb: I want to like, y eah.
- 17:29Amy Webb: So t hat was my dream job.
- 17:32Amy Webb: Yeah.
- 17:32Amy Webb: Like, I want to show up and like, you know, figure out the puzzle and l ike try to rearrange things and I out think everybody, s o that's what I wanted to do and I made a last minute decision not to go to law school.
- 17:46Judy Oskam: Have you ever, ever rethought that.
- 17:48Judy Oskam: Have you ever thought about that?
- 17:50Amy Webb: No.
- 17:51Amy Webb: I um,
- 17:52Judy Oskam: so it was the right decision then?
- 17:54Amy Webb: I didn't.
- 17:55Amy Webb: Yeah, I mean, and that's the, I think one of the failures of American education is that we don't challenge kids enough to think differently.
- 18:09Amy Webb: You know, we, we really, it's weird, like we seem to, like we seem to want to reward individual thinking and achievement and like, you know, the American spirit, all these things.
- 18:21Amy Webb: And yet we just do a terrible job of helping kids understand that there's a great constellation of potential opportunities.
- 18:30Amy Webb: And even, and then I think that even happens in college, you know, I had a scholarship to music school, music conservatory which I, sort of knew was going to...I got recruited when I was in ninth grade, so I didn't have a lot of options.
- 18:47Amy Webb: My parents said I could go to college anywhere as long as I had it paid for, Sure.
- 18:53Amy Webb: So I was going to go to music school and when I got there I wanted to take a bunch of other classes.
- 18:58Amy Webb: I wanted to major in other things.
- 19:00Amy Webb: Also I was told n o.
- 19:03Amy Webb: Eventually I dropped out of the music program and y ou k now, c hanged my major and I, there was no way for me to study all of the different, like I couldn't, the credit hours, the major, the whole system was set up so that, yeah.
- 19:18Amy Webb: Yeah.
- 19:18Amy Webb: So like if I wanted to major in political science, like I had to follow this set of ideas or, or i t was either that or I could do economics or I could do.
- 19:30Amy Webb: And what I wanted to do was k ind o f study computer science, math, political science, game theory and economics.
- 19:38Amy Webb: There was just no way to combine all that into one major, you know?
- 19:42Amy Webb: And I was thought like I would be so much better at my job today.
- 19:47Amy Webb: I think I would be a more productive member of society if I had had a broader constellation of um, classes that I could have taken.
- 19:57Judy Oskam: Well, and, and I have to ask you, are, do you play or do you sing?
- 20:00Judy Oskam: What's your instrument or are you a singer?
- 20:02Amy Webb: I was a clarinetist.
- 20:03Amy Webb: Oh, clarinet.
- 20:04Amy Webb: Okay.
- 20:05Amy Webb: My sister is an opera singer.
- 20:07Amy Webb: Oh, okay.
- 20:08Amy Webb: So yeah, that's great.
- 20:11Amy Webb: Do you play?
- 20:11Judy Oskam: the guitar.
- 20:15Amy Webb: Oh cool.
- 20:15Amy Webb: Yeah, yeah, do you read music or do you chords?
- 20:17Judy Oskam: I'm a chord person.
- 20:18Judy Oskam: Yeah.
- 20:18Judy Oskam: Just the chords and um, I'm going to try and write a little song or two during this covid thing, but just kind of have a little fun.
- 20:27Judy Oskam: My daughter graduated from college last week.
- 20:30Amy Webb: Oh, that's great.
- 20:32Judy Oskam: I'm trying to think about doing something for her because she's sort of self quarantining a little bit with her group.
- 20:37Judy Oskam: So she, she's one of those that I think, you know, now she's got the whole world in front of her and the path is so wide and I, and I agree.
- 20:47Judy Oskam: Think we all can do a better job of saying to students that there is a wide world out there.
- 20:54Judy Oskam: And the options are what you make of it.
- 20:58Judy Oskam: Um, and I think, uh, I think, you know, you know, you're the perfect example.
- 21:01Judy Oskam: You've got some great tools on your website that talk about the modeling and some downloads that I think can help organizations of all kinds as they think through some of these processes of change.
- 21:15Amy Webb: Yeah.
- 21:16Amy Webb: You know, I know that we are all dealing with a soul crushing amount of uncertainty.
- 21:24Amy Webb: And when you are dealing with deep uncertainty, the limbic system response that a lot of us have is to just preserve the status quo at all costs or to revert to what felt comfortable.
- 21:38Amy Webb: And there's a biomechanical reason for that.
- 21:41Amy Webb: You know, o ur, our brains like patterns and you know, what's happened since effectively January is that e very d ay we're having to learn a not insignificant number of new patterns that range from Zoom meetings.
- 22:00Amy Webb: You know, people talk about zoom fatigue and there may be some of you who are like, how hard is it to just click a button and talk to somebody on the video?
- 22:08Amy Webb: And the answer is you're actually asking your body and your brain to start engaging in cognitive processes that h ave, it's never had to do before.
- 22:18Amy Webb: So it's a little bit like waking up one morning and running a marathon.
- 22:22Amy Webb: Technically, can you do it?
- 22:24Amy Webb: Yeah.
- 22:24Amy Webb: You've got, you know, if you're, if you c an walk, right.
- 22:27Amy Webb: U m, b ut, but all b ut think of every single muscle, Oh, we've got all these tiny little muscles and muscle fibers, right?
- 22:33Amy Webb: They're going to be screaming at you.
- 22:35Amy Webb: L ike, y ou k now, why are you doing this?
- 22:36Amy Webb: It's a similar situation that we're all in right now with just, you know, with everything.
- 22:43Amy Webb: But I'll focus on zoom for a minute when we're no longer around other people, all of the c ues, u m, that we process automatically.
- 22:54Amy Webb: U m, you know, we have to kind of we're like breaking in all these new cognitive muscles, right?
- 22:59Amy Webb: So it's, it's equivalent.
- 23:01Amy Webb: U m, you know, cause your brain is not used to processing a two dimensional v irtual grid, a four by four grid of faces.
- 23:08Amy Webb: And we're not used to not hearing everybody.
- 23:12Amy Webb: I mean it's just, it's a totally different, it's totally different.
- 23:15Amy Webb: And so it's a little bit like forcing your brain to run a marathon when it's only ever walked around the block before.
- 23:20Amy Webb: Right.
- 23:20Amy Webb: Now that being said, I would argue that part of our current challenge is perception.
- 23:27Amy Webb: You know catastrophe can be a catalyst for change if you allow it b e.
- 23:36Amy Webb: I think the problem is a lot of people are not willing to be o pen m inded and think about alternative futures.
- 23:45Amy Webb: Whether that's our u niversities where I think this is a major, major problem.
- 23:51Amy Webb: U m, you know, or some of our government agencies that like refused to allow people to work remotely for some reasons that were valid.
- 24:00Amy Webb: Other reasons that weren't and are now just trying to figure, you know, like we've created a lot of problems that were avoidable.
- 24:07Amy Webb: So what does that tell us about the future?
- 24:09Amy Webb: It tells us that, there are physical, there are things outside of your control that can't be helped.
- 24:18Amy Webb: And then there's all t he stuff that's within your control that you can do something about.
- 24:23Amy Webb: If you're graduating from college and your plan was to go work at some company and that job has been furloughed or it doesn't exist anymore, o r the internship doesn't exist anymore.
- 24:34Amy Webb: Okay, now we know that we've got that data and now l et's recalibrate and figure out the next step.
- 24:40Amy Webb: U m, and sometimes that can be easier said than done, but if you don't actively challenge yourself to b e u p for the task, u m, then, then you don't get anywhere.
- 24:52Judy Oskam: I think it's a good point to think of it as data and a data point because it sort of puts it in a, a more objective state that I think some of our students are wondering what shall they do now?
- 25:05Judy Oskam: And some of the faculty are wondering how they're going to accomplish this.
- 25:08Judy Oskam: Yeah.
- 25:10Amy Webb: I mean, I'll tell you, I, you know, cause I also teach, I'm a professor at NYU Stern.
- 25:16Amy Webb: I've always, I teach a very intense class.
- 25:21Amy Webb: It's a little bit like everybody's going into battle together and on the end of it, all of my alumni and I, you know, we, we stay in touch.
- 25:30Amy Webb: I have like a series of Slack, groups, usually one for each class and there's a big alumni channel.
- 25:36Amy Webb: You know, and the answer is, y ou have to be willing to the way to, so when you don't know what the future is and also you don't have control over everything, you have to lean into uncertainty.
- 25:56Amy Webb: Otherwise anxiety takes over and you lean into uncertainty by saying, I'm willing to pilot to sort of quickly iterate.
- 26:07Amy Webb: U m, an iterative action is more important than, than sort of sticking to your guns or trying to create huge changes.
- 26:14Amy Webb: So what does that mean?
- 26:15Amy Webb: That means every day y ou, y ou k now, if my end game, if my end goal is this, then today I'm going to try this thing.
- 26:23Amy Webb: I'm going to quickly experiment, learn, tweak, gather data, and then recalibrate and move on over and over and over and over and over again.
- 26:32Judy Oskam: I would think too, I've enjoyed how you kind of, how you approach things in meetings and you talk in terms of sprints.
- 26:39Judy Oskam: And I think we're in a series of sprints with..
- 26:42Amy Webb: I think can be, you know, and I think we should be, but that's not, listen, I've had the extraordinary luxury of not working for somebody else now for I guess, 16 years, which means while I do a tremendous amount of work with corporate America and with government, I am not an employee.
- 27:04Amy Webb: And even when I was a journalist, I really only spent about three months inside of the main newsroom.
- 27:09Amy Webb: I was always in a, you know, um, so I've had the luxury, uh, especially in the past 16 years of not having to operationalize change.
- 27:24Amy Webb: And that's hard.
- 27:25Amy Webb: I've also had the luxury of being outside of the politics of teams and departments and you know, so my perspective on this is wildly skewed and it's easy for me to meeting to say let's approach this in this other way, which makes totally like perfect logical sense to me.
- 27:46Amy Webb: But for everybody else that's, that would be a fairly seismic cultural shift.
- 27:50Amy Webb: So I like, I acknowledge all of that.
- 27:52Amy Webb: I don't think it's a reason not to try something different.
- 27:55Amy Webb: But know,
- 27:57Judy Oskam: Well, my brother is fond of saying that that, you know, the solution or the answer is simple but not easy.
- 28:04Judy Oskam: It's very clear and simple, but it's not easy.
- 28:07Judy Oskam: And I think that's probably true.
- 28:09Judy Oskam: But I wanted to ask you what, what keeps you up at night?
- 28:13Judy Oskam: Because I, I just wonder and I really enjoyed reading, especially that section of the book where you talk about the future and I'm seeing this pandemic is going to drive us there sooner rather than later.
- 28:27Amy Webb: What keeps, keeps me up?
- 28:28Amy Webb: Like what am I worried about?
- 28:30Judy Oskam: Yeah.
- 28:30Judy Oskam: What keeps you up at night?
- 28:32Judy Oskam: Uh, when you, when you think about future.
- 28:35Amy Webb: So I would say that I am a pragmatist.
- 28:40Amy Webb: Um, so, and if anything, I'm, I'm, I'm very emotionally detached when it comes to what the work reveals.
- 28:50Amy Webb: I'm very emotional, like I'm very dedicated to the work.
- 28:55Amy Webb: I think if I allowed myself, when I, when I wrote the big nine and got to the catastrophic scenario, which is all about AI, it's actually not about AI r obots coming to murder us in our sleep.
- 29:09Amy Webb: It's, it's worse than that.
- 29:11Amy Webb: U h, i t's, it's, it's a giant, geopolitical shift and economic turmoil and a bunch of other horrible things.That felt so visceral and real to me that I went I was in a pretty dark place writing that section of the book.
- 29:28Amy Webb: And that's pretty unusual for me.
- 29:29Amy Webb: Normally I'm pretty detached and I think, you know, I think I have to be My, I sort of trace my lineage futurists, strategic foresight and futures work.
- 29:43Amy Webb: Y ou k now, it's kind of a weird f ield.
- 29:45Amy Webb: There's not a huge number of people who have done it.
- 29:49Amy Webb: And if you go back in time, there's a couple of different schools of thought.
- 29:53Amy Webb: U m, I would say that I follow the school of Herman Kahn who was at the Rand corporation at the height of the cold war, u m, i s actually the reason I invented the word scenarios at least as it relates to strategy work.
- 30:12Amy Webb: And, u m, was the person who wrote on Thermo, thermonuclear war, which described what it would be like fo ur p eople, especially children to survive a nuclear attack by Russia, this unreadable.
- 30:29Amy Webb: And it was, u m, t he, the, it was all rooted in data.
- 30:32Amy Webb: It was not speculative.
- 30:34Amy Webb: It was so disturbing.
- 30:36Amy Webb: It was so horrifying.
- 30:37Amy Webb: Did you ever read it or no?
- 30:39Judy Oskam: No.
- 30:39Judy Oskam: No.
- 30:39Judy Oskam: But I've saw some of the Rand stuff before.
- 30:41Amy Webb: Yeah.
- 30:42Amy Webb: So it was so horrifying that, uh, people, when it became public, people lost, like lost it.
- 30:51Amy Webb: And there's a really interesting slash hilarious interview between Herman Kahn and Margaret Mead and Margaret Mead is just like ripping into him.
- 31:01Amy Webb: How could you possibly, you know, this is basically saying, just like, go ahead and drop the bomb and everybody will survive and this'll be the aftermath.
- 31:10Amy Webb: And he's like, and everybody misunderstood.
- 31:13Amy Webb: Um, the point was not to say go ahead and drop the bomb and now this is how we live.
- 31:18Amy Webb: The point was to scare them.
- 31:19Amy Webb: Hell out of everybody.
- 31:21Amy Webb: If this is the next order implication, if this is the impact, and we have to come up with some kind of disarmament plan.
- 31:29Amy Webb: Right.
- 31:30Amy Webb: Um, so he would say, and did say that his job was to imagine the unimaginable.
- 31:37Amy Webb: And I think that that's my job too, right?
- 31:40Amy Webb: So I have to concern myself with a future in which China has waged economic warfare and we don't realize it.
- 31:52Amy Webb: And in the United States, we're so politically divided that by the time we can align on what to do next, they have literally locked us out of global trade.
- 32:01Amy Webb: I know that doesn't sound a plausible right now or be all that scary, but if you think through the implications of that, we are not a self-sufficient nation.
- 32:10Amy Webb: I mean, that would that think of what everybody is going through right now.
- 32:15Amy Webb: [ You know, quintuple that negative feeling.
- 32:21Amy Webb: So, I'm always, and I tend to think more doom and gloom than, uh, you know, but I also believe that if you can spot risk early enough, you then you have an opportunity to mitigate it or better turn that into some kind of opportunity.
- 32:37Amy Webb: And that's like the really sick, that's the, that's the rub with this whole pandemic as far as I'm concerned.
- 32:44Amy Webb: China, there's cultural reasons why this would not have happened, but China could have in December said, Hey, world.
- 32:54Amy Webb: Um, we just, we, you know, we don't know where it came from.
- 32:56Amy Webb: We discovered this crazy, scary new virus.
- 33:00Amy Webb: Uh, we'd like other scientists to work with us, you know, work with us on this.
- 33:05Amy Webb: We don't know where it came from.
- 33:06Amy Webb: It's really bad, but don't worry, we are going to be the heroes and we're going to figure out what it is.
- 33:12Amy Webb: We're going to lock everything down and we're going to share information and we're going to come up with a cure for it or a vaccine for it.
- 33:20Amy Webb: And you know, we're, we're going to be good.
- 33:23Amy Webb: They didn't do t hat.
- 33:24Amy Webb: And they could have, they would have had so much political capital if they had done that and such an ability to k now.
- 33:32Amy Webb: So they didn't do that.
- 33:33Amy Webb: But conversely the United States had a huge opportunity to into some, and I should mention, I'm politically independent on on purpose, right?
- 33:42Amy Webb: Obviously because of the work that I do and I don't feel drawn to one side or the other, but it is difficult to look at our current situation and not think, you know, we also had a massive opportunity in December to say something like, we know there's intelligence saying there's a virus in China.
- 34:02Amy Webb: Historically speaking, they don't contain things well.
- 34:05Amy Webb: So let's come up with decisive action and we'll be the heroes for the world.
- 34:11Amy Webb: We will be the first, we'll we'll have like a five month head start on a vaccine.
- 34:15Amy Webb: We will have a coordinated response.
- 34:17Amy Webb: We won't just, you know, create a new supply of masks and PPE and all this other stuff.
- 34:23Amy Webb: We're going to invent anti-microbial face jelly or whatever.
- 34:29Amy Webb: Right?
- 34:29Amy Webb: We could have seen existential risk and said, okay, this is going to become an opportunity and this is the, this is the one of the big failings of the Trump administration.
- 34:40Amy Webb: They could have done this and they could have done it in a way, um, that, uh, bolstered the Republicans and could have effectively insured.
- 34:51Amy Webb: Know everybody got to stay in office by saying we're going to be the heroes.
- 34:55Amy Webb: We're gonna put our politics aside for five seconds.
- 34:57Amy Webb: We'll go back to arguing.
- 34:58Amy Webb: Don't worry, there'll be fun.
- 34:59Amy Webb: But, but right now, um, we're going to be the heroes.
- 35:03Amy Webb: We're going to, you know, some in the full night of American ingenuity and we're going to solve the world's problem and you're all going to have to rely on us.
- 35:10Amy Webb: We're going to make a ton of money in the process.
- 35:13Amy Webb: Yeah.
- 35:13Judy Oskam: Do you think though, people just don't want to see problems and just avoid problems?do you think that's human nature?
- 35:20Amy Webb: Well, I think I don't know.
- 35:23Amy Webb: I mean, I can tell you China, I can see culturally, yeah.
- 35:28Amy Webb: The country would, would not.
- 35:30Amy Webb: Yeah.
- 35:31Amy Webb: Well there's like a, there's also sort of a, an issue of face and whistle.
- 35:36Amy Webb: Like there's a pride issue, you know, I think, um, you know, the, the word FOMO, fear of missing out was kind of the thing that everybody would talk about.
- 35:49Amy Webb: Yeah.
- 35:49Amy Webb: Over the past couple of years.
- 35:50Amy Webb: And I, I really feel like we've traded FOMO for just abject fear in the United States.
- 35:55Amy Webb: We are fearful in ways that we haven't been before.
- 35:58Amy Webb: And I think that that is not a one sided problem.
- 36:02Amy Webb: I think that that has certainly come out of the White House and been amplified by all media outlets on all sides.
- 36:11Amy Webb: Um, so I think we're feeling afraid.
- 36:13Amy Webb: And my hunch is that in times when people are feeling afraid, they don't want to explore uncertainty.
- 36:21Amy Webb: Right.
- 36:21Amy Webb: And that cause that just makes you feel more afraid, but okay.
- 36:25Amy Webb: It's a different type of fear.
- 36:26Amy Webb: Fear of the unknown is, I think more challenging than being afraid of a boogeyman, you know?
- 36:33Amy Webb: So.
- 36:36Judy Oskam: How do you think media's played into all of that?
- 36:39Amy Webb: Well, I mean, how do you think the media is?
- 36:41Amy Webb: You should tell me.
- 36:41Amy Webb: How do you think they played in?
- 36:43Judy Oskam: I think it's been a little overzealous on a lot of fronts.
- 36:47Amy Webb: Yeah, I would agree.
- 36:48Judy Oskam: And I think I'm how organizations have acted and reacted has not necessarily been the right thing.
- 36:57Judy Oskam: And it's interesting to me how the States are trying to open up because we can't kill our economy over this.
- 37:04Judy Oskam: And that's another issue, but...
- 37:05Amy Webb: Right.
- 37:06Amy Webb: I think you're right.
- 37:07Amy Webb: And I have a sort of a concrete example, there's a short podcast produced by the Washington post called The Daily 202, which I don't know if you've listened to.
- 37:18Amy Webb: It used to be pretty good.
- 37:19Amy Webb: It's, it's like used to listen to it in the morning cause it was quick and it's just sort of like, like here's some stuff you need to know today.
- 37:28Amy Webb: And it was sort of a preview of what was going to be in the paper for the day.
- 37:35Amy Webb: Um, and I, I really liked it.
- 37:36Amy Webb: That morphed about a year ago into the daily Trump bashing.
- 37:44Amy Webb: It was just like new day, just like really, you know, sort of melodramatic way.
- 37:51Amy Webb: Yeah, the Trump administration is not a ton of bad stuff, but I think you start to lose some of your effectiveness when you go so far.
- 37:59Amy Webb: You know and now it is a daily, it's just daily stories in unnecessarily using detail that I don't think helps...advances, the narrative in any way of people who are dying or businesses that are closing to the point where I just have stopped listening to it.
- 38:22Amy Webb: Not that I don't care, but it's like, I don't know how this is, I'm not sure what I'm supposed to do with this information.
- 38:28Judy Oskam: And is it helping move the right country forward or not?
- 38:32Amy Webb: It feels more gratuitous.
- 38:34Amy Webb: It feels gratuitous.
- 38:35Amy Webb: It feels like there is an attempt to, to sort of get at an emotional response.
- 38:43Amy Webb: And I think we could use fewer, fewer media attempts to get emotional responses from us.
- 38:50Amy Webb: And I think we could use more guidance, strategic guidance and just helping us understand stories.
- 38:56Amy Webb: And to that end, I think, I mean I'm not the only one who thinks this, but The daily, which is the New York Times 40 person audio.
- 39:05Amy Webb: I mean that's a huge team with a huge budget.
- 39:08Amy Webb: But what I actually think they're doing it, it's, it's the same.
- 39:11Amy Webb: It's the same type of product news product.
- 39:13Amy Webb: I think they're doing a much better job of it.
- 39:15Amy Webb: Yeah.
- 39:16Amy Webb: Yeah.
- 39:16Amy Webb: Yeah.
- 39:16Amy Webb: Well, I, I just think it's a, it's a, it's a crazy time and I think, uh, um, I think as far as you're concerned, you know, with your background, what do you think are some two, two strategies that you think listeners can take forward about how they can deal with the future?
- 39:33Amy Webb: I liked your comment earlier about leaning into uncertainty and I think that's probably a good one.
- 39:39Amy Webb: Yeah.
- 39:39Amy Webb: So maybe, let me unpack that.
- 39:42Amy Webb: So cognitive behavioral science tells us that when you are feeling panicky or anxious about something,.
- 39:50Amy Webb: Our typical response is, is avoidance.
- 39:55Amy Webb: So most people will do whatever they can to avoid having negative thoughts.
- 40:01Amy Webb: Um, and they don't treat that content as content.
- 40:04Amy Webb: It feels urgent and at some point it starts to feel like reality, even though whatever that is is either unfounded or it hasn't happened yet or whatever.
- 40:14Amy Webb: So leaning into uncertainty is really about allowing those anxious feelings to happen and observing them, categorizing them, you know, with, and, and sort of doing that one step removed.
- 40:33Amy Webb: And, and the other piece of that is acknowledging that none of us has complete control over the future, if any of us did.
- 40:43Amy Webb: And so, as a futurist, I'm always saying, what would it take for X to be Y?
- 40:46Amy Webb: So what would it take for any one person to have control over the future?
- 40:51Amy Webb: Well, we would have to be living in somebody else's simulation and you would have to be the, the computer master, right?
- 40:58Amy Webb: Or somehow you would have to be omniscient and have all data at all.
- 41:02Amy Webb: It would have to be Dr.
- 41:03Amy Webb: Manhattan from the Watchman.
- 41:05Amy Webb: All right.
- 41:05Amy Webb: So, so we're, we're not ever going to have all of the data that we need, therefore acknowledge it.
- 41:15Amy Webb: And if we can't have all the data and we cannot know exactly what's going to happen and we can't control exactly what's going to happen either.
- 41:22Amy Webb: So it's a, you know, I know it sounds maybe sort of like a no brainer, but it's actually much more profound.
- 41:32Amy Webb: And once you accept that, then the strategy becomes constantly creating a state of preparedness for the future.
- 41:41Amy Webb: Now this is where you don't want OCD to take over because when OCD takes over, you become a prepper.
- 41:47Amy Webb: So, um, not always the healthiest approach, but yeah.
- 41:53Amy Webb: So that's the first thing I would say.
- 41:55Amy Webb: The second thing I would say is, uh, you know, if you are analytically inclined, you know, or somebody who prefers data and sensing versus intuition, then like find yourself a framework.
- 42:10Amy Webb: I've got something called the axes of uncertainty.
- 42:12Amy Webb: So if you just Google my name and axes of uncertainty, I have a step by step explanation for how to use it.
- 42:18Amy Webb: But you know, we're find somebody else's, like there are all these roadmaps and canvases and frameworks and tool kits.
- 42:24Amy Webb: Just like find one that feels right and start using it because, um, the nice thing about a framework is that it's just a guide to help your thinking about what to do next and then the pressure's off because you're not making a giant decision.
- 42:41Amy Webb: You're making a whole bunch of incremental decisions that get you, you know what I mean?
- 42:46Amy Webb: That like get you to the right place.
- 42:48Amy Webb: It's like making a series of small bets versus one big bet.
- 42:52Judy Oskam: And that can be, if you're looking for a job or changing your location or moving or you can take that and on a, on a micro or macro level, I would think too,
- 43:04Amy Webb: Right?
- 43:04Amy Webb: I actually know somebody right now who's in a job transition and really struggling.
- 43:12Amy Webb: And I think the problem is that she hasn't articulated what she wants to be when she grows up, you know?
- 43:19Amy Webb: And that's fine.
- 43:21Amy Webb: Um, you don't have to know the name of the job title that you want to have.
- 43:24Amy Webb: I mean, I didn't know that there was a, I think as a futurist, you know, but can you articulate the core values and the, you know, there's, there's a, Ikigai there's like a Japanese framework.
- 43:39Amy Webb: It looks like a giant, horrible venn diagram, a mistake, but it, it asks you to think about your values and you know, what makes you happy, all those different things.
- 43:52Amy Webb: Figure that out.
- 43:53Amy Webb: That's the hardest thing to figure out.
- 43:54Amy Webb: And then, and then worry about the job title and then that helps guide your search.
- 43:59Amy Webb: You know,
- 44:00Judy Oskam: I think it's so hard for students because as you know, my daughters trying to look for that right now.
- 44:05Judy Oskam: I'm going to find, I'm going to find her a framework because she won't listen to me.
- 44:09Amy Webb: Well, I will tell you, I, for a long time, I used to not tell people what I did for a living.
- 44:17Amy Webb: And in fact, last night I was having a, well because I thought it sounded stupid.
- 44:23Amy Webb: I thought it sounded like I made up.
- 44:25Amy Webb: Well, okay.
- 44:25Amy Webb: But,.
- 44:27Amy Webb: You know, I was in my thirties.
- 44:31Amy Webb: You know, I, I didn't have the confidence and I, I don't have a normal life.
- 44:38Amy Webb: I don't have a normal job, you know, I'm 45 now and I think I'm pretty successful and I have a totally different outlook on life.
- 44:47Amy Webb: Yeah.
- 44:47Amy Webb: But I think it's that, I think it's finding the confidence inside and being willing to not have to fit into somebody else's taxonomy.
- 44:55Judy Oskam: I think that, and you probably knew that when you were 10 years old.
- 44:58Judy Oskam: I bet you just didn't know.
- 45:00Judy Oskam: If you could talk to your 10 year old self.
- 45:04Amy Webb: Honestly, if I could talk to my 10 year old self, I would say you've got a very, very challenging road ahead and, you know, suck it up, keep your head down and work hard.
- 45:13Amy Webb: Just like you did.
- 45:14Amy Webb: Just like harder even.
- 45:15Amy Webb: You know, I, and, and for some, like for me, uh, it took a while for me to accept having an unusual job.
- 45:27Amy Webb: But I can't, again, I think whatever career path, you know, coming out of college you choose or whatever it is, if you, you know, the people who are the, I think the most successful are the ones who are the most authentic to themselves.
- 45:41Amy Webb: If you can be the most authentic version of yourself and work as hard as you can, being that authentic version of yourself, you will succeed.
- 45:52Amy Webb: You will succeed in a down economy.
- 45:54Amy Webb: You will exceed in the midst of a global pandemic.
- 45:56Amy Webb: You'll be okay.
- 45:57Amy Webb: I think it's everybody else who really struggles.
- 46:01Amy Webb: Yeah.
- 46:02Amy Webb: Very long time to figure that out.
- 46:03Amy Webb: But yeah,
- 46:04Judy Oskam: Yeah, sure, sure, sure, sure.
- 46:05Judy Oskam: Well, I'm a lot older than you and it took me a while to, but, well, I'll ask you, you know, speaking of your authentic self, I always ask, and I think, you know, listeners like to hear what, what's a little known fact about Amy that, that we don't know that you would mind sharing.
- 46:21Judy Oskam: We know you played the clarinet.
- 46:22Judy Oskam: We know that now.
- 46:23Judy Oskam: Yeah.
- 46:24Amy Webb: What's a little known fact?
- 46:26Amy Webb: Well, I live in two cities.
- 46:30Amy Webb: One of the cities that I live in has a nice, u m, a nice yard and I for years we, my family grows most of the food that we eat during the warmer months.
- 46:42Amy Webb: U m, s o we have an enormous organic garden that I s pent a ton of time in.
- 46:49Judy Oskam: Oh, that's great.
- 46:50Judy Oskam: That's great.
- 46:51Judy Oskam: Yeah.
- 46:52Judy Oskam: And it's really important now when, when sometimes, you know, it's hard to get produce now, so sometimes, so,
- 46:58Amy Webb: It is, and in fact, we usually grow so much that we turn our little garden into a CSA for the neighborhood.
- 47:05Amy Webb: And usually in August, unless it's a rainy year, u m, we produce enough vegetables to distribute.
- 47:12Amy Webb: We have a little distribution route and usually the month of August and into early September, depending on how the weather has been, none of our neighbors have to buy produce.
- 47:21Amy Webb: And we just d on't, we, and we have a fairly s izable berry area too, so,
- 47:27Judy Oskam: Oh my gosh.
- 47:27Judy Oskam: So they go to Webb gardens and get their stuff, that's great.
- 47:30Judy Oskam: .
- 47:32Judy Oskam: Well, Amy, thanks for, thanks for talking with me today.
- 47:35Judy Oskam: I tell you, I really found the book fascinating.
- 47:39Judy Oskam: very educational.
- 47:41Judy Oskam: I can see why it was listed in the history area as well, but wow, what, what a great read, funny, informative, educational, uh, and timely, very timely right now.
- 47:54Amy Webb: Thanks.
- 47:54Amy Webb: I really appreciate it.
- 47:56Judy Oskam: Yeah, thank you.
- 47:56Judy Oskam: Thank you, Amy.
- 47:57Judy Oskam: Thanks.
- 47:57Judy Oskam: Thanks for chatting with me.
- 47:58Judy Oskam: I appreciate it.
- 48:01Judy Oskam: Thank you for listening to Stories of Change and Creativity.
- 48:04Judy Oskam: Check out the show notes for more information about this episode.
- 48:07Judy Oskam: You can find this podcast on any of your favorite streaming platforms.
- 48:12Judy Oskam: Please subscribe, leave a review and share this podcast with a friend.
- 48:17Judy Oskam: If you have a story to tell or know someone who does, reach out to me at judyoskam.com Or drjudyoskam@gmail.com.
- 48:26Judy Oskam: That's drjudyoskam@gmail.com.
- 48:30Judy Oskam: Thanks for listening.