Latest / The Vegan Report / Denouncing Antisemitism. With Meira, Donny, Bobby & Shani | Ep. 67
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Vegan Report, my name is Ryan and today we are discussing a deep division
- 0:07plaguing the vegan movement.
- 0:09Way back then I remember how Israel was looked at very favorably by vegans.
- 0:16One media outlet called it the Global Center of Veganism.
- 0:20Online I remember the many popular videos of Gary Yorovsky being interviewed on Israeli
- 0:27TV, always with Hebrew subtitles.
- 0:31But since October of last year, since the brutal attacks and kidnappings perpetrated
- 0:36by Hamas and then the violent retaliation of Israel, something shifted in the vegan movement.
- 0:44And I witnessed internal conflict, not about how effective activism should be done, think
- 0:51about welfarism vs. abolitionism, but about the Gaza war.
- 0:57And when I witnessed Jewish vegan activists leaving the community in drove, erasing even
- 1:04their social media presence, I knew that this represented the breaking point for the cause.
- 1:11To discuss this topic, I have with me 4 brilliant Jewish vegan activists.
- 1:17Donnie Moss, who is behind the popular Animal Rights Online News magazine, Der Turn, Mira
- 1:24Jacer, founder of the Jewish Animal Rights Organization Tikva for Animals, Bobby Soot,
- 1:32a distinguished filmmaker and photographer who has collaborated with notable figures
- 1:37such as Sean Mosin, Generation Vegan and musician Moby, and Shani Cohen, successful vegan entrepreneur
- 1:45behind Shani Seasoning and Urban Leaf Catering.
- 1:51I like to always ask the question, who is your vegan hero and why?
- 1:56I feel like it always allows to reveal who you are in the space of veganism, what your
- 2:04perspective is.
- 2:05So, who would like to start?
- 2:07Yes, Mira.
- 2:08Hi, I'm Mira Geiser.
- 2:11I would say my vegan hero is not a specific person necessarily, it's more just kind of
- 2:16the mindset that certain people have and just wanting to be as effective as possible and
- 2:22then not, you know, if they don't see the results that they'd like to see, they're willing
- 2:27to kind of shift their perspective and try new things and not necessarily be stuck in
- 2:32their ego of what they're more experienced in maybe if they're not seeing the results
- 2:37they want, but I would want to give a shout out to my mom who despite being very empathetic
- 2:42and really feeling what animals go through, she's gone to some awful places with me to
- 2:48get footage and it would not have been possible without her driving me there.
- 2:52So yeah, I'm just really thankful for that.
- 2:55Thank you, Mira.
- 2:56What about you, Donnie?
- 2:58So in 2004, I stumbled upon a veg fest in my neighborhood and left with a DVD, Meet
- 3:05Your Meat, and that was the start of my, that was a documentary film that shows, takes
- 3:11viewers behind the scenes of factory farms and slaughterhouses, and that was the start
- 3:15of my vegan journey and my journey as an animal rights activist.
- 3:19And I've loved PETA ever since.
- 3:22I would say my vegan hero is Jane Vales Mitchell, the former CNN anchor who is now a full time
- 3:30animal rights sort of campaigner, vegan campaigner with who created the vegan app Unshane TV.
- 3:38Thank you, Donnie.
- 3:39Shani?
- 3:40Hi, I'm Shani Cohen.
- 3:43I live in Vancouver, Canada, and I went vegan in 2013 after watching and it's funny that
- 3:50you mentioned that Gary Yorovsky famous speech, I am a Gary Yorovsky vegan and ever since
- 3:57then I truly have been looking up to him.
- 4:02His unapologetic stance of like on veganism is something that always moves me through
- 4:11all these years in activism and in life.
- 4:17And so yeah, I truly appreciate him.
- 4:19He's the one that gave me that push to open my eyes and and join the movement.
- 4:25So.
- 4:26Thank you, Shani and the fellow Canadian.
- 4:29Hi, Bobby.
- 4:30Hi, I'm Bobby.
- 4:32I'm in Austin, Texas.
- 4:34I'm an animal rights photojournalist.
- 4:38I guess my vegan hero would be my twin brother who after attempting suicide went to rehab
- 4:44and went vegan day one and says that that's what really saved his life was adopting a
- 4:50vegan lifestyle and he's the one who convinced me to become vegan.
- 4:55So he's definitely my hero.
- 4:58Thank you, Bobby.
- 4:59Okay, so let me start with this question.
- 5:03In the introduction, I talked about Jewish vegans, Jewish vegan activists leaving the
- 5:10movement.
- 5:12Is that factual?
- 5:13Did that really happen?
- 5:15Who wants to take that?
- 5:17Yes, Donnie.
- 5:18So just today, I received an email from a woman who I've never met before who said,
- 5:26I'm going to read it.
- 5:27Hi, Donnie.
- 5:28I've been an animal advocate and vegan for years.
- 5:31I pulled back from many vegan and animal rights animal activist groups after 10, 7.
- 5:35I thank you for your posts and have requested your friendship.
- 5:39I've gotten probably 20 emails like that since 10, 7.
- 5:45But I could also tell you that as an organizer in New York City, the number of vegan Jewish
- 5:53animal rights activists who participate in events has dropped precipitously.
- 5:59We've lost organizers.
- 6:01We've lost people who just show up and participate.
- 6:05And so, yeah, the loss has been pretty profound and sad.
- 6:10Mira.
- 6:11So it's interesting.
- 6:12I might have a different perspective than a lot of other vegan Jews, not necessarily
- 6:17everybody, but I started noticing a problem in 2020 during COVID.
- 6:23More people were home in quarantine, so they were online and they were posting more about
- 6:28their thoughts.
- 6:30And that's when I started seeing things blaming Jews for COVID, which was very reminiscent
- 6:35of Jews being blamed for the Black Plague.
- 6:40And it just, I think I started speaking out around then.
- 6:44I know I was interviewed for an article when James asked me to start talking about the
- 6:50animal holocaust and that was beginning of 2021 and the person was just reaching out
- 6:57to people who had been posting, Jews who had been posting.
- 7:01So I definitely started seeing an issue then, but I think at that point it was certain pockets
- 7:07of the vegan community or the animal rights movement.
- 7:09So if you weren't in those specific spaces, you didn't necessarily see it, but just over
- 7:14time I saw it get more obvious and also kind of spread throughout the community where it
- 7:21wasn't just like sporadic random scenarios.
- 7:27And I got to a point where the space I was in, I did not feel safe being in and also,
- 7:32especially when you're doing activism that's more high risk where you're working with
- 7:38other people and you need to make sure that you trust each other, especially safety that
- 7:42you have on another's backs.
- 7:43It just wasn't possible knowing what they thought about Jews and what they were saying
- 7:49about Jews.
- 7:50And again, this is way before 2023.
- 7:55And so it got to a point where I was kind of at a crossroads where I didn't want to stop
- 8:01advocating for animals, but I didn't really know where to go.
- 8:06There are certain approaches to help animals that I find I'm more effective with and maybe
- 8:16come more naturally and I just didn't see any of those spaces being welcoming to me.
- 8:23And so it got to a point where I thought maybe I would create my own thing, but I didn't
- 8:28feel knowledgeable enough and experienced enough.
- 8:34But I did notice there was a gap in the Jewish community in Israel as a country in terms of
- 8:39maybe things that, like approaches that weren't being filled.
- 8:44And certain, there was a lot of like vegan food advocacy and stuff like that, but there
- 8:52was less so maybe systematic stuff, abolitionist stuff.
- 8:55So I thought maybe I could fill in that gap.
- 8:58And just over time I saw more and more vegan Jews basically say like, I see it now and
- 9:07I'm willing to join you because I feel like there's no other option.
- 9:12And there were people, especially after October 7th, 2023 that I thought would never leave
- 9:20the spaces they were in that are not only leaving those spaces, but some of them are
- 9:24completely done and honestly so traumatized, they're not lending their expertise or experience
- 9:33to the community at all.
- 9:36And again, these are people that have been instrumental for a variety of things in the
- 9:41activist community that I never would have seen coming.
- 9:47I think that there is a disproportionate, in a positive way, amount of Jews across the
- 9:55globe that are involved in the activist community considering how small of a percentage we are
- 10:00population wise.
- 10:01I think it's like 0.2 or 0.2% of the world population and we're involved in all facets
- 10:09of the activist community, whether that's lawyers helping out an activist or animal rights cases,
- 10:17rescuers, investigators, organizers, protesters.
- 10:23And yeah, just seeing very few Jews actively involved in the larger community compared to
- 10:33where I was in 2020.
- 10:36Bobby?
- 10:37Yeah, I guess it depends on what we mean by leaving the movement.
- 10:42I organized the vigils in LA for six years and I did a lot of street activism and I'm
- 10:50not going to be doing street activism anymore.
- 10:57I was starting to clash with approaches to activism and effective communication that
- 11:04I was seeing on the streets and then after October 7th was kind of just the push that
- 11:12I needed to be like, I'm not going to be doing this anymore.
- 11:15However, I can't say that I've left the movement.
- 11:18I'm still an animal rights photojournalist.
- 11:21My photos are going to be on exhibit at Tel Aviv University in May.
- 11:25They're in an art magazine in Japan.
- 11:27It was just published.
- 11:28So I'm still doing that.
- 11:30I'm just not out on the street so you won't see me active.
- 11:33You might say he left, but I haven't left.
- 11:35I'm just changing my approach.
- 11:37Shani?
- 11:39I can only, like I don't know about Jews in general, but I can speak for myself and my
- 11:43Jewish friends in the community here in Vancouver and I definitely can tell that we are choosing
- 11:56not to participate in events outreach because of, we just feel ostracized and just that feeling
- 12:07of being unwelcome in the movement just has caused us to kind of like do our own thing
- 12:14within ourselves, which is just weakens the movement altogether because our power is in
- 12:23numbers when we do outreach, when we do protests and to alienate that part of, and like Mary
- 12:33said, Jews are essential in any human rights fight that we had over the years.
- 12:43If it's the fight, BLM is part of it, animal rights movement, all of this stuff.
- 12:50And so we just don't feel welcome anymore.
- 12:54And so then choosing not to participate and yeah, definitely it's something that has
- 13:01been happening since October 7 and the explosion of anti-Semitism in the movement.
- 13:09Well I guess naturally my second question is what caused that departure from the movement?
- 13:18And Mira, you alluded to that.
- 13:21Now Shani, you've named it explicitly.
- 13:25So why?
- 13:26Why are Jewish activists not feeling safe, not feeling welcome?
- 13:33What's happening?
- 13:34Donnie?
- 13:35Well, I mean it really started right after October 7th when you would know, you know,
- 13:42after that massacre where 1200 people, 1200 people in Israel were literally burned in their
- 13:48homes, raped, murdered, kidnapped.
- 13:52I mean in additional 250 kidnapped.
- 13:55The typical expressions of support that were accustomed to seeing, we just, the victims
- 14:02of that, of those atrocities weren't afforded, those words of compassion and sympathy and
- 14:09it was just, and what is that?
- 14:11Why is that?
- 14:13But it became, sort of, it got dark very quickly.
- 14:15Long before Israel even responded militarily, you know, the, instead of reaching out to
- 14:24Jewish people in the community, people started to post that this was an act of resistance
- 14:30that this was justified, that they were, this was exaggerated, that Israel did this to itself.
- 14:40I mean, the mental gymnastics employed to not just say what it was, a horrific terrorist
- 14:51attack against innocent civilians, including children and families and kids dancing at a
- 14:58festival, it became, sort of, odious, hateful right away.
- 15:04And then shortly thereafter, the accusations of genocide and colonialism and apartheid and
- 15:15ethno-state, I mean, these were activists with whom I've been working in the streets
- 15:22for, in some cases, 20 years, not once in my career, well, I should go out of career
- 15:28because I'm a volunteer, but not once in my life as an animal rights activist, did any
- 15:33of these people even talk about Israel or Zionism?
- 15:38The fact that I was Jewish was irrelevant, and then all of a sudden, people's identities,
- 15:46they sort of transformed their identities into anti-Zionists.
- 15:50Where did that come from?
- 15:51And many of them sort of secretly admitted that they didn't know anything about the issue
- 15:55or the region.
- 15:57They were just jumping on this bandwagon, and it was just anti-Semitism.
- 16:05One of the things that struck me, and then I'll turn it over to somebody else, was that
- 16:09not long after Israel began to defend itself and tried to get the hostages back, three
- 16:15animal rights organizations who had never commented on geopolitical issues and were really focused
- 16:23on animal rights made inflammatory posts falsely accusing Israel of genocide.
- 16:32And thousands upon thousands of animal rights activists in the movement who've maybe never
- 16:37given the Middle East conflict any thought, who didn't know anything about the region,
- 16:43were then seeing that these groups that they supported and were members of and respected
- 16:49were accusing Israel of genocide, which is not what happened at all.
- 16:55And so I think that that really pushed things forward in terms of alienating Jews from the
- 17:02movement.
- 17:03I started to say earlier that I'm an organizer in New York City.
- 17:08I used to get, I could easily get 40 or 50 people to come out to a protest.
- 17:12Now I not only have Jewish activists who aren't coming out anymore in many cases, but I also
- 17:19have activists who don't come out because I'm Jewish.
- 17:23And so this is really hurting, this is really hurting not just Jewish activists, but the
- 17:27animals for whom we all should be fighting.
- 17:30And to make matters even more worse or complicated is that many of the people who are alienating
- 17:37us and attacking us aren't really even active in the movement.
- 17:43So they're sabotaging, they've almost co-opted the movement to and are sabotaging it at the
- 17:50expensive animals.
- 17:52Yeah, I think that there's a few factors involved with what happened.
- 17:59And I think that if we're honest with ourselves, we can admit how much intolerance is in the
- 18:04vegan animal rights community.
- 18:07I mean, vegan activists and animal rights activists are intolerant.
- 18:11I can't tell you how many times I've heard them say, well, I'm not going home to my parents.
- 18:15They're monsters.
- 18:16They're not vegan.
- 18:17They have this binary view of the world after becoming vegan that you're vegan, you're good,
- 18:22and if you're not, you're bad.
- 18:25And so if you're not, then you're not welcome.
- 18:27And you combine that with this new approach to fact checking, which is just how I feel
- 18:37about something is enough.
- 18:40And you combine that with the fact that we don't put one and one together anymore to
- 18:46get two on our own.
- 18:47And we turn and look to the crowd and the crowd is the loudest voice.
- 18:51I think that those had a lot to do with what happened.
- 18:58It was weird because it was surprising and not as surprising as I would expect at the
- 19:03same time because I have found animal rights groups to be incredibly angry and intolerant.
- 19:14And it's like, well, par for the course, I guess.
- 19:21But what was difficult was with groups that I'd worked with for 10 years, organizations,
- 19:27on October 8th, I put up a post on my Instagram page saying I stand with Israel and all of
- 19:32them called me and told me to take it down.
- 19:35And I was like, well, hang on a second because we as an organization, we stood up for George
- 19:41Floyd.
- 19:42We stood up for Ukraine.
- 19:43We stood up for the shootings at gay bars in Orlando.
- 19:46We stood up for all these things.
- 19:47But now because it's a Jewish problem, we're just going to say, well, it's too complicated.
- 19:53We're going to stay away from this one.
- 19:55Well, at the same time, using words like genocide and their posts on their websites.
- 20:02So I think that the problem is that people have, because of things like cancel culture,
- 20:09have become scared with saying what's right versus what's popular because most of people's
- 20:16lives exist on social media and that life can be taken away so easily with someone just
- 20:21saying, we need to cancel this person.
- 20:24So I think what happens in the animal rights movement in terms of views of things can often
- 20:30be microcosm of the larger world.
- 20:34And the surge of antisemitism was not just in the vegan community.
- 20:41It's been an issue worldwide.
- 20:44In some places, the statistics of antisemitic events has been as high as it has been basically
- 20:52since the Holocaust, depending on the location, or as early as it started to be tracked basically
- 21:00by certain organizations.
- 21:03And I think, you know, then you're bound to get, you know, some of those people that are
- 21:10in the vegan community to have those opinions as well.
- 21:13But I will say, I've basically never seen any accountability in the animal rights community
- 21:19for xenophobia towards Israelis and just antisemitism towards the Jews in the community.
- 21:28I will say there was one instance where someone, again, this was way before October 7th, 2023,
- 21:33when one person had made a blatantly stereotyped nonfactual comment about Jews.
- 21:45And I had called this statement now, and then their friend had talked to them and they reached
- 21:50out to me.
- 21:51But in terms of organizations, especially after October 7th, having any accountability
- 21:57for the organizers or people involved, I have seen none.
- 22:02And if anything, these people are continuing to be platformed more and more.
- 22:06And I'm talking about people that are blatantly supporting the kidnapping of people, people
- 22:12that are trying to justify why it's okay to take hostages, why Hamas was doing something
- 22:18good, why Hezbollah was doing something good.
- 22:20I mean, some of these people have, I don't know, close to 100,000 followers in the community
- 22:28and then they're sharing that stuff and they're not getting any repercussions for that.
- 22:36And then there's me and my friends, none of us who have a significant amount of followers
- 22:41trying to say anything.
- 22:42And it's really just not getting anywhere.
- 22:44And kind of like what Bobby said, that people just have the choice of either being in a
- 22:50very hostile environment where not even everyone wants to work with us, but then they end up
- 22:57just resigning from positions they're in.
- 23:02And yeah, I mean, it got to a point where I was trying to keep track of different statements
- 23:08made and I've just run out of storage on my phone from all the screenshots of things being
- 23:12said.
- 23:14And it's basically most major organizations in the community I've seen have said awful
- 23:21stuff or knew about awful stuff and we're trying to justify it and just ignore it.
- 23:29And that's where I find it to be very problematic because like what hope of recourse is there
- 23:35if everyone's either going to ignore it or tolerate it.
- 23:39This is very interesting because something I found sinister about this all is how, like
- 23:46you said, there was no media coverage, nobody is talking about it.
- 23:51There's this huge shift in the vegan movement, the vegan community, and it just goes unnoticed
- 24:00except for a few influencers here and there raising their voice against those positions
- 24:09and against anti-Semitism.
- 24:12I waited, like who is going to cover this story?
- 24:18Why is nobody talking about it?
- 24:22So I don't know if you have an answer for that, but yes, Shani.
- 24:25Sorry, I was muted.
- 24:28I just wanted to answer to your previous question.
- 24:31Why don't we feel safe?
- 24:34And I agree with what everyone were talking about, I really felt it because I've lived
- 24:42everything that you guys just said.
- 24:46And for me, it was even more personal when in the first, I think, week or two after the
- 24:54October 7 attacks, the Vancouver vegan community has really rallied up and started to make
- 25:03lists of businesses that were put in on some sort of like a black list of do not support
- 25:12these genocidal Zionist businesses.
- 25:19And I was among them and to reiterate what Mary said, like these are accounts with thousands
- 25:25and hundreds of thousands of followers sometimes.
- 25:29And the impact of that was just unimaginable.
- 25:33Like it's to be put on a list kind of like throws you back to really dark times in our
- 25:41history.
- 25:43And that's alongside with all the posts and DMs that people have been sending me.
- 25:49So I just to reiterate what everyone said.
- 25:55So yeah, just personally, my business was alienated was put on a list not to support
- 26:03in the local community.
- 26:05So that was the main event that made me feel unsafe in this community in particular and
- 26:15the vast community in general.
- 26:19And to your question why nobody's talking about it, I can't tell.
- 26:29It feels like you say there's the cancel culture that we're all been marinating in for years,
- 26:38not only in this subject, but in other subjects as well.
- 26:42And I don't know, it feels like there's like the vegan community as a whole is part of
- 26:50this like more general and larger human human rights movement and progressive movement.
- 27:01So naturally, these people took the stance of supporting Hamas and absolutely ignoring
- 27:09the suffering of the Jewish people and especially after the massacre in Israel.
- 27:15And it just became just like the people before me said they jumped on the bandwagon.
- 27:20Nobody, it doesn't feel like anyone has truly critical nuance conversation about what is
- 27:27happening in Israel using slogans like genocide, apartheid, ethno-state.
- 27:34It's just, it's fashion.
- 27:37It feels like just fashion.
- 27:39He really stops to talk about this and all the complicity around it in a, yeah, in a
- 27:53matter that will give space to everyone because there are legitimate grievances to the Palestinian
- 28:02population who lives in and outside of Israel in Gaza and Judea and Samaria.
- 28:08There is a legitimate criticism that we can put on the Israeli government.
- 28:14We're not saying we're angel.
- 28:16We also have our own grievances towards our government.
- 28:20But from this to where we are and where days after, like Bobby said, we were massacred,
- 28:30there's a big, big gap that I don't know how to bridge that gap, how to make it make
- 28:39sense.
- 28:40Donnie.
- 28:41I think we should clarify that a lot of the people who have been attacking us are disguising
- 28:51their anti-Semitism behind anti-Zionism.
- 28:55What we know, or I mean, I can only speak to them for myself, that when someone calls
- 29:00me a Zio or a Zionist, that's really a stand-in for Jew because an estimated 95% of Jewish
- 29:07people believe that Israel has a right to exist.
- 29:11I mean, Zionism is a right for Jewish self-determination in our ancestral homeland.
- 29:19If that word has somehow been transformed or bastardized, now it means racism and colonialism.
- 29:26It doesn't mean any of these things that are being attached to it now.
- 29:33My belief is that the vast majority of people who are anti-Zionism is anti-Semitism because
- 29:41you're basically stating that Jews don't have a right to live in their ancestral homeland,
- 29:48which they've inhabited for 3,000 years except for certain expulsions, and that Israel is
- 29:53actually the most successful decolonization project in the history of the world.
- 30:00To somehow suggest that Jewish people who are indigenous to the region or Jews who have
- 30:06fled persecution, pogroms, post-war Europe, and have gone there to suggesting that we
- 30:18don't have a right to be there, and those indigenous Jews who have been there for generations
- 30:22are never right to be there.
- 30:23It's just anti-Semitism.
- 30:26Masked as something else.
- 30:28Mubbi?
- 30:29Yeah, I totally agree with Donnie.
- 30:32I think that Israel is the new Jew when it comes to anti-Semitism.
- 30:36They just say that they're attacking Israel instead, but we all know what that means.
- 30:42I think what made this feel different, I grew up in the 80s in Texas as a Jew.
- 30:53I've seen anti-Semitism since I was a kid.
- 30:56What made this different is for the first time, anti-Semitism was trending.
- 31:02It became the new thing to do.
- 31:07You have people like Kanye with a Super Bowl commercial.
- 31:12It's for his website, which is just a shirt with a giant swastika on it, HH1.
- 31:20Nobody's calling that out.
- 31:22Nobody's saying anything about that while at the same time calling Jews Nazis for defending
- 31:27their homeland and defending their people.
- 31:30It's gotten to where as long as you have freedom of speech and people will listen, it's okay
- 31:38for you to say something as long as you are either a victim or championing victimhood.
- 31:45The victim is just who social media decides that the victim is.
- 31:49It's usually just the smaller group.
- 31:53This is dangerous because these are easy answers.
- 31:56These are easy.
- 31:58This correlates to something that I saw a lot in Animal Rights Movement that was making
- 32:03me want to step out in the first place was we use easy, lazy activism.
- 32:08We use shaming and ridicule as a way of saying that we're holding someone to account.
- 32:15It has nothing of you to shame and ridicule someone.
- 32:17I don't need to know anything about Donnie to start ridiculing him right now.
- 32:22Nothing.
- 32:23The difficult part is having understanding and being able to create open discourse, validating
- 32:27people's experiences because none of us were born vegan.
- 32:30We don't want to do that.
- 32:32We just want the easy answer.
- 32:33We want the easy enemy.
- 32:35I think that that moved into anti-Semitism.
- 32:38I think anti-Semitism was already there.
- 32:41Mira.
- 32:42I forgot who had said it.
- 32:46Just that people aren't really thinking necessarily about what they're saying.
- 32:51They're jumping on the bandwagon.
- 32:55I think in the case of anti-Semitism, it's definitely true in the movement.
- 32:59In the larger world, people just have a fundamental misunderstanding or lack of understanding as
- 33:04to what anti-Semitism is and how it functions.
- 33:07People assume it's like every other bigotry, but instead of seeing Jews as less than it's
- 33:12often what they call punching up, where the evil puppeteers over seeing and controlling
- 33:20things.
- 33:21It's almost like a copy and paste template throughout the years, whatever is cherished
- 33:25in society, were the ones that are messing that up.
- 33:29If social justice is what's deemed very important in this time period, Jews are the ones getting
- 33:36in the way of that.
- 33:39When capitalism was important, Jews were the communists.
- 33:42When communism was important in certain regions, Jews were the capitalists.
- 33:47I also don't understand how the Soviet Union played a role in literally the rhetoric we're
- 33:53talking about now.
- 33:55My grandmother would go undercover into the Soviet Union to help try to free Jewish political
- 34:03prisoners.
- 34:05She would take photos of what she was seeing in the area just to remember her trips.
- 34:13I was looking at one of her photo albums and there was propaganda at a bookstore.
- 34:23I read it and I was like, this is literally what we're seeing now.
- 34:27It was like, I don't, the gist of it, because I don't remember the details, was basically
- 34:31it was depicting Israel as a not as Hitler actually, like controlling and grabbing.
- 34:42I think it was the US.
- 34:45Then at the bottom it says Zionism is nobzyism.
- 34:49That's literally what we're seeing.
- 34:50People just don't understand what they're saying is not only not a new original concept,
- 34:57it's literally very old.
- 35:01Those that understand how anti-Semitism was looked in the past are like, yeah, this makes
- 35:07sense, but people aren't really taking the time to look at that.
- 35:12To them, it's how could it possibly be anti-Semitism?
- 35:19It doesn't look the same as other forms of discrimination, I guess.
- 35:23Shani?
- 35:26To continue what Merah was saying, I look at anti-Semitism as kind of like a virus.
- 35:35It's funny that after COVID people can now understand this analogy of a virus being mutated
- 35:43and changing.
- 35:46It moved from hatred that is based on religion based with the Christianity and moved on to
- 35:57science, what we saw with the Nazism of the race differences, etc.
- 36:04In today's world, when the religion is social justice and liberation and everything that
- 36:12this movement is standing for, anti-Zionism in air court, just like Bobby said, is anti-Semitism.
- 36:19It's just another trope, it's just another version of anti-Semitism and these people
- 36:24just cannot see it.
- 36:27It's just important to understand that it's just like a virus who gets mutated.
- 36:33It's just a form of Jew-hatred through the centuries, through different times in our
- 36:37history.
- 36:40This is just another version of it.
- 36:47They think they're so original and so revolutionary, but it's just another form of Jew-hatred.
- 36:54Bobby?
- 36:56I have a question that I want to pose to everybody.
- 37:02That is, I don't understand how and when it became socially acceptable to be anti-Semitic,
- 37:11but it is.
- 37:12All the proof you need is you look at college campuses in the US.
- 37:16If there were protests stopping African Americans or LGBTQ groups from getting into class and
- 37:24terrorizing them, those would have been shut down immediately.
- 37:28But because it was Jews that weren't being able to get to class, it was considered a
- 37:34freedom of speech or PC, which is just fascism disguised as political correctness.
- 37:44My question is, does anyone have an answer for why it became okay to be anti-Semitic
- 37:52when it's still not okay to be racist, it's not okay to be homophobic, it's not okay to
- 37:56be transphobic, but anti-Semitic is fine.
- 38:00Donnie?
- 38:02I mean, I could try to answer that question.
- 38:05At the beginning of this post-10, 7 world, someone framed it to me like a lot of people
- 38:14were jumping on the bandwagon with all of this anti-Semitic rhetoric under the guise
- 38:18of oppressor versus oppressed.
- 38:21And there was this perception that Jewish people are white, despite the fact that I
- 38:25believe that a white Jews are in the minority in Israel.
- 38:30I don't know what the exact numbers are, but there are plenty of Israelis who are people
- 38:34of color from Ethiopia and other parts of the Middle East and Africa.
- 38:39And so I think that they latched onto this sort of oppressor versus oppressed narrative
- 38:46and that gave people a free pass to behave and to use such anti-Semitic language.
- 38:53I mean, we think in social justice movements, people criticize microaggressions.
- 38:59Not only are microaggressions against Jews not being addressed, full-blown attacks against
- 39:06us are now perfectly acceptable.
- 39:09And I just want to read, this is just one post made by a former DXE spokesperson.
- 39:16And DXE is an organization that I loved and supported financially and made video.
- 39:21I mean, I was really on board and for them to not put a stop to stuff like this.
- 39:27So I'm going to read it.
- 39:28And this is again, a former DXE spokesperson on social media, potentially thousands of
- 39:35people or tens of thousands of people saw this.
- 39:38All Zionists are infiltrators when they operate within any other cause or movement.
- 39:45They would rather nuke the entire organization than allow it to take a stand against the
- 39:50genocidal ethno-state.
- 39:52Their ultimate solidarity is with white supremacy and fascism.
- 39:57But the Western left has allowed them to embed themselves within our ranks because we have
- 40:02been brow-beaten into submission by claims of anti-Semitism made by those same infiltrators
- 40:08to silence us when we attempt to build intersectional multinational coalitions.
- 40:13This is especially sinister in the animal rights movement.
- 40:17A movement long ago, a long co-opted by Zionists to humane wash their sinister and virulent
- 40:25ideology.
- 40:27Zionists cannot be animal rights activists.
- 40:29All Zionists are infiltrators within the animal rights movement and their influence
- 40:34is a ticking time bomb.
- 40:36Their solidarity with your cause or organization is entirely contingent to your submission
- 40:41to their theocratic genocide, ethnic cleansing of the Middle East, and black hole drain on
- 40:47the American economy.
- 40:49All Zionist influence in progressive movements must be rooted out and destroyed by any means
- 40:54necessary.
- 40:55All Zionists are inherently infiltrators because their ultimate goal is the acceptance
- 41:00of Israel within progressivism.
- 41:03And they will never accept that the best tactic for progressive causes is to abandon Israel
- 41:07before we associate too closely with genocide.
- 41:11Their contributions regardless are made to obfuscate the reality that they are in fact
- 41:15murderously Islamophobic and they use your deeply held beliefs to mask their bloodlust.
- 41:22Zionists dress up and mock progressive activists by even appearing at rallies and other events.
- 41:29This actually goes on.
- 41:31But just replace the word Zionist with Jew, which is exactly what this person meant and
- 41:36which is exactly what 95% of Jews are.
- 41:42And this was, you know, people like this and share it and comment it and thank her for
- 41:48posting this.
- 41:49Where do you go from here as Jews in a movement?
- 41:53So I've been living in Israel the last couple of years and it has been difficult in the
- 42:00sense that not all the sanctuaries there have bomb shelters and let alone for the animals,
- 42:08like it's just not possible like financially to build like a very small bomb shelter is
- 42:14like tens of thousands of dollars or dollars or shakals.
- 42:18I don't remember which currency it was, but just to create a small enough shelter to be
- 42:23able to continue to have staff and volunteers come and make sure the sanctuary is functioning
- 42:28for the residents.
- 42:30And I remember wanting to fundraise for some of them, especially when there were like way
- 42:34more rockets happening up north in Israel and there's a sanctuary up there that, you
- 42:40know, the person running it just had to lay down in a field and pray that the rocket wasn't
- 42:43going to hit her.
- 42:44And I remember thinking I need to fundraise, but who in the community can I actually share
- 42:48this fundraiser with because like no one's going to want to share it, which is in fact
- 42:52very true.
- 42:53I mean, sanctuaries themselves and sanctuary founders have said disgusting things themselves.
- 42:58So it's not like I could share it with fellows, sanctuaries necessarily.
- 43:01And it was just this moment where I know it's been brought before the animals are suffering
- 43:05because of that.
- 43:06And like I just had no idea who I could share the fundraiser with.
- 43:12And ended up being I just shared it in the Jewish community and non-vegans were donating.
- 43:17And that's kind of the situation where it's been and activists, you know, for example,
- 43:23in the U.S. where I've done animal activism, just have no idea what it's like, you know,
- 43:32trying to help animals when you're worried about rockets and like just, you know, I don't
- 43:39know, trying to document animal cruelty at a dairy farm and like driving up north where
- 43:45there's way more concentration of rockets at that point and being like, you know, praying
- 43:51on the highway that you won't need to get out, lie on the side of the highway and cover
- 43:55your head and pray a rocket doesn't hit you because like there's no wild Michelle at your
- 43:58nearby, but you got to do to help the animals.
- 44:00And then there's, you know, people in the U.S. kind of saying like, I hope the rocket
- 44:04hits you.
- 44:05Like it just, it's not, yeah, it goes back to the question.
- 44:10Like I don't really know how you could reconcile this when even the animals that need the help
- 44:20so that volunteers continue to come and, you know, make sure their spaces are clean and
- 44:25that they're getting the exercise they need are not enough for these people to put whatever
- 44:30ideas they have aside and be like, okay, let's make that happen.
- 44:34I just, it's a very good question.
- 44:36I don't know, but it was very eye opening.
- 44:39Bobby.
- 44:40Yeah.
- 44:41I'll actually just let you go ahead and move on to the next question.
- 44:44I just wanted to add not surprised at all that that comment came from DXE.
- 44:48Not surprised at all.
- 44:50Well, I'm wondering now about DXE.
- 44:53What's the story behind that?
- 44:55Yes, Mira.
- 44:58I will just say, just for the purpose of me talking about seeing anti-Semitism during
- 45:03COVID, they were the first ones that were on my radar.
- 45:08And ultimately why I decided to try to start my own thing for Jews, just because even back
- 45:14during COVID, it started to seem like things were ramping up and kind of just being acceptable.
- 45:23But yeah, I think at this point, it's clearly not just them.
- 45:28You know, like we've said, other organizations have put out statements and it's not just
- 45:33attendees, you know, it's organizers and it's kind of widespread now.
- 45:38So yeah.
- 45:39Yes, Donnie.
- 45:40I want to make an observation about, Mira was talking about being in Israel that there's
- 45:48I think a lot of misunderstanding about the history of Israel and what Israel is Israel.
- 45:56In the United Nations, there are 48 Muslim majority countries and 23 of them have Islam
- 46:04declared as the quote, state religion.
- 46:09Israel is the only country that identifies as Jewish.
- 46:15There's no official state religion, though.
- 46:18That's not Jews live in peace with Arabs in Israel.
- 46:24There are two million Israeli citizens are Arab and there are Christians and many others
- 46:32in Israel.
- 46:34Yet, there's this accusation that Israel is somehow an apartheid state.
- 46:41Despite the fact that in all of these surrounding countries, Jews have been persecuted, chased
- 46:47out and and and when they fled.
- 46:51So there's such a miss, you know, how Jew Howard, how is Israel a colonial state?
- 46:57There's one country.
- 46:59But these wouldn't these these other religions or ethnicities that have conquered countries
- 47:06around the world be colonists?
- 47:08Why is this one Jewish state being accused of colonization?
- 47:12It doesn't make any sense.
- 47:14It's the ancestral homeland of the Jewish people.
- 47:17There's just Israel's the size of New Jersey.
- 47:20It's a tiny state and it's racially diverse, ethnically diverse.
- 47:26But it's the center of the world's fury and that double standard to me is just more proof
- 47:32that all of this hate stems from antisemitism.
- 47:36As Shani referred to in the past, you know, Jews used to be persecuted because we were
- 47:42Jewish.
- 47:45Now we're being persecuted because we have a state.
- 47:49They're always just looking for a reason.
- 47:52It's a shape shifting virus looking for a reason to hate Jews.
- 47:55And now they're hiding behind the fact that Jews have a homeland, a state, but it's tiny.
- 48:02It's the size of New Jersey.
- 48:03And it seems like people won't and including many animal rights activists won't sit still
- 48:08until it's wiped off the face of the earth from the river to the sea in a global anti
- 48:12Fada, a violent uprising against Jews.
- 48:15Yeah, I just thought I find it really interesting that, you know, because much of the animal
- 48:22rights and vegan community is on the left in terms of political views and they're progressive.
- 48:30Israel stands against everything they hate.
- 48:33Israel is the only place in the Middle East where you can be openly gay, openly trans.
- 48:38It's the only place that has freedom of speech where you can you can protest against the
- 48:42government.
- 48:43All of these things that they that these groups say that they hold like that they stand up
- 48:49for Israel is the only only country in the Middle East that actually stands up for these
- 48:54things.
- 48:55And this just shows like how unwilling these people are to actually do any research to
- 49:02actually do it to be educated in any way on what they're fighting against.
- 49:07Or it shows the depth of hatred against Jews.
- 49:10They're willing to throw Israel under the bus, despite the fact that it represents all
- 49:14of these progressive principles.
- 49:16And just to add to that, Bobby, I mean, Israel is, you know, many people describe it as the
- 49:21vegan capital of the world.
- 49:24You know, my friends who live in Israel just say that the whole country has been sort of
- 49:30veganized and maybe, you know, maybe Myro or Shani can speak to that more.
- 49:37But to then sit then accuse us of of vegan washing or humane washing.
- 49:44I mean, it's all it gets spun around.
- 49:47But it's true at Israel is a is a is a center of animal rights advocacy and veganism and
- 49:54all of these other progressive principles.
- 49:56Yet people in our community are are siding with those who want to do away with all of
- 50:03these principles just doesn't make any sense.
- 50:07Santicemitism.
- 50:08Yeah, I actually produced a vegan travel show.
- 50:12And an episode we episode one was in Israel.
- 50:16And the vegan community there was, you know, this was seven years ago was incredible.
- 50:22And what I found was incredible was how accommodating even the IDF, the military is for vegans
- 50:29in terms of like giving them vegan gear and vegan food.
- 50:33And it's just where else is that do you find these values so prevalent and yet so vilified
- 50:41at the same time?
- 50:43Well, Donnie, you said that anti Zionism was anti-Semitism.
- 50:51What do you make and that 95% of Jews, something like that, the overwhelming majority agrees
- 51:00with that?
- 51:01What do you make of those vegan Jewish activists who take the side of being anti Zionists?
- 51:13And I've heard some of that coming from just I noted his name Alex Hirschhaft, Ivan Redd,
- 51:24Peter Singer, you know, writing things along those lines.
- 51:31What do you make of those Jewish vegans in the community?
- 51:37Well, I don't.
- 51:38And first of all, there's a distinction to be made between between criticizing Israel's
- 51:43policies, which is fair.
- 51:44I mean, it doesn't feel like a double standard in light of horrible things that are happening
- 51:49in Sudan and Congo and all over the world, why the whole world has chosen to focus on
- 51:56on Israel.
- 51:57Again, that just feels like a double standard and stoop steeped in anti-Semitism.
- 52:01So I don't know if the the individuals who you mentioned are truly believe that Israel
- 52:06doesn't have a right to exist, or if they were critiquing Israeli policy, disagreeing
- 52:12with Israeli's military operations, suggesting that they employ different strategy.
- 52:17I don't know, but there are, of course, in any group, there are going to be people at
- 52:21the extreme, people who vote against their own interests, people who just want to jump
- 52:27on a bandwagon, people want to be accepted by the larger community.
- 52:31It would be easier for me to say right now that Zionism is terrorism, and Zionism is
- 52:37racism, and Zionism is colonialism, and and get back to being the animal rights activist
- 52:42I was before than it is to stand up for the truth and to stand up in principle.
- 52:47So there are always there are always going to be people who on the fringe, who are going
- 52:52to speak out and maybe take this alternative view.
- 52:58Maybe others have another explanation.
- 53:00Well at the very least, they were not vocal about the anti-Semitism that everyone on this
- 53:08call has been the victim of, you know, in terms of denouncing it.
- 53:14People are afraid.
- 53:15I just want to just interrupt.
- 53:16Yesterday I watched the closing ceremony or the closing session of the Anti-Defamation
- 53:21Leaks annual summit at the Javits Center in New York, and one of the keynote speakers was
- 53:28David Schwimmer, the actor from Friends, and he said, look, it might be uncomfortable to
- 53:34speak out.
- 53:35But I think that people have been alienated and isolated and criticized and, you know,
- 53:39canceled in some circles for speaking out against anti-Semitism.
- 53:43But he encouraged people in Hollywood, people with a platform in the music industry and
- 53:48the sports industry and entertainment industry to use their platforms to speak out because
- 53:52people like us who are public figures need that solidarity.
- 53:56We need to see that and we need people with huge platforms to correct the record, to go
- 54:00on record and say what's really happening here.
- 54:03And I'll be.
- 54:05Yeah, I think it just comes down to cowardice.
- 54:08You know, it's people are afraid of real activism, which is interesting because activism
- 54:18that asks something of you that asks you to step out on a limb that asks you to put yourself
- 54:22in an unflattering light, I guess.
- 54:29And yeah, that's just, that's really where I can come to a conclusion on is that just
- 54:39people are scared of what someone might say about them online.
- 54:43Who cares?
- 54:44You know, like I get that people have social media followings that are like, you know,
- 54:50part of their income and things like that.
- 54:53But I mean, so someone says something negative about you online.
- 54:57Some skinny tattooed punk vegan says something about you.
- 55:01You care?
- 55:03Who cares?
- 55:05Shiny.
- 55:08I think not only what Bobby and Ryan said about being cowards and afraid to go against
- 55:18the stream, which the stream and the majority of the movement, the progressive movement
- 55:23and the veian movement is anti Zionist.
- 55:27And I say that because we all know it means anti Semitism.
- 55:31Not only that, I think it's mostly the lack of understanding that Judaism is a Zionist
- 55:43movement.
- 55:45What I mean is that for thousands of years, three thousands year, we are a people who speak
- 55:52the same language, believe in the same book and pray for Zion.
- 55:59It's part of Judaism.
- 56:01So all these movement groups of not in my name or Jewish, Jewish voices for peace and
- 56:10all these people who are in the costume of, oh, as a Jew, I don't stand for what Israel
- 56:17does.
- 56:18It's just they're using their Judaism to mask their self-hatred because if you are a Jewish,
- 56:34you know that for, like I say, thousands of years, we've been speaking the same language
- 56:39and all of our prayers and all of our costumes and traditions are aimed towards Israel.
- 56:45All of our holidays, it's all stems from the land and the land of Israel.
- 56:52So I think that lack of understanding that you cannot separate Judaism from Zionism
- 56:58is also a driving force of those minority fringe Jewish people who jump to say, not
- 57:06in my name.
- 57:07I think it makes them feel more virtuous, more, I am Jewish and I'm against that.
- 57:12So you can't say you're Jewish if you don't understand that basic, like the other name
- 57:21of Israel is Zion.
- 57:23So you cannot separate the two.
- 57:26If you separate the two, you misunderstand the fundamental meaning of being Jewish.
- 57:35So it's just ignorance and the need to be so virtuous above you.
- 57:43I'm so moral.
- 57:46That's the explanation that I get from that.
- 57:52And ironically, I mean, I feel like displaying that level of hostility is just one more argument
- 57:59to have a Jewish state and an army to be able to defend yourself.
- 58:06Why is that issue the one that triggers vegans now?
- 58:16Why was it not, I don't know how Turkey was taken over by basically a dictatorship and
- 58:25thousands of journalists were thrown in prison.
- 58:28Why was not maybe the persecution of the Uyghur people in China?
- 58:36I could go down the list of horrid foreign tragedies, human rights in Iran.
- 58:48The woman there, not wearing a hijab and being sent to prison for like eight years.
- 58:54Why is this not the cause that vegans have adopted?
- 58:59Why is it the Israeli conflict?
- 59:04And I guess a second follow up question around that is why the vegan movement should anyway
- 59:14talk about those social issues.
- 59:16We're here for animals.
- 59:19We're here to stop the exploitation of animals.
- 59:23Why do we feel the need to disperse ourselves and talk about other social issues?
- 59:30Why are we not just solely focused on that very important issue that other groups, social
- 59:38groups are not talking about?
- 59:43Bobby?
- 59:44Yeah, I think that that's the negative side of intersectionalism.
- 59:51This is the idea that if I'm talking about veganism at a vegan event and not anything
- 59:54else then I don't care about anything else other than veganism.
- 59:58There's a very small percentage of the human population that has dedicated their lives
- 1:00:02to the liberation of animals.
- 1:00:05And all those other topics do is turn our attention to human centric causes when we're
- 1:00:11taking the small time that we have to look at animals and help animals.
- 1:00:17And I think to your first question, yeah, when you look at like child soldiers in Africa,
- 1:00:23what's happening in the Congo or the Muslims in China that are being rounded up by the
- 1:00:27millions, all these things are, you know, what's happening in Turkey, what's happening
- 1:00:31in Syria, all these problems.
- 1:00:33It's like people say, well, they care about these problems too.
- 1:00:35Well, I'm sorry, I don't see the same vitriol and hatred that I see towards Israel.
- 1:00:41And it's not a complicated answer.
- 1:00:43It's anti-Semitism.
- 1:00:44That's all it is.
- 1:00:45Anti-Semitism and an easy target and an easy villain.
- 1:00:48It's like, oh, they're the problem, you know, because, you know, if you talk about child
- 1:00:52soldiers, that's a complicated issue in Africa.
- 1:00:54There's a lot going on.
- 1:00:55And like to understand that geopolitical landscape and people claiming that they understand the
- 1:01:01political landscape of the Middle East, which is ridiculous, you know, but they don't have
- 1:01:04to worry about that because they just have to say, oh, it's Jews.
- 1:01:09You know, so that's easy.
- 1:01:10I can get on this side.
- 1:01:12That's where I think that comes from.
- 1:01:14Donnie.
- 1:01:16You asked why the focus on Israel as opposed to the Uyghurs, Sudan, Congo, places where
- 1:01:25there are actual genocides taking place in no Jews, no news.
- 1:01:30I think that's part of it.
- 1:01:31I think that this conflict has given people who are anti-Semitic a platform to spew anti-Semitic
- 1:01:39hate, but sort of hide behind a Kaffee or the, you know, a mask of anti-Semitism.
- 1:01:47But it's anti-Semitism.
- 1:01:51Why, again, why have all of these large multinational animal rights organizations addressed only
- 1:01:59one geopolitical issue on their social media platforms, which have hundreds of thousands
- 1:02:04of followers?
- 1:02:05Why this and not all of these other horrible things that are happening?
- 1:02:10And you know, it comes down to anti-Semitism.
- 1:02:15Why did they choose to step out of their lane for this cause?
- 1:02:22And so, yeah, again, it all comes back in the end.
- 1:02:25It really does all come back to anti-Semitism.
- 1:02:28Shani.
- 1:02:29I just want to play a devil's advocate because that's what I do a lot.
- 1:02:34Like I try to think like they think, like I try to think, what would they say to that?
- 1:02:39Like why do you concentrate on Israel so much?
- 1:02:42And I want to ask the group, what would you say to the people who say, well, in Sudan
- 1:02:48and Congo and all of these places, U.S. don't play a major role in being ally, like they're
- 1:02:58ally to Israel and these people who are protesting and like are so vocal about Israel and what's
- 1:03:09happening in the Israel-Gaza war, what would you say to those people who say, well, the
- 1:03:17U.S. government don't fund Congo.
- 1:03:19They don't fund these places.
- 1:03:21This is the one conflict that they can put an impact on because this is their country.
- 1:03:28Like if it's protesters from the U.S., let's say, or Canada or U.K., these are places who
- 1:03:34actively and financially support in Israel and are allies.
- 1:03:40And that is their reason why they concentrate on this conflict because this is the one conflict
- 1:03:45that they can impact on with protesting.
- 1:03:50What would you say to these people?
- 1:03:51I'd like to hear what that group say because this is an answer that I can hear at pro-Palestinian
- 1:03:57activists say, well, we can't control this, but we can control that.
- 1:04:03What would you say to those people?
- 1:04:05Miran.
- 1:04:08I would say ironically for at least some part of the war, the U.S. was actually in some
- 1:04:16way funding both sides.
- 1:04:19So I don't see that really being addressed, whether it's the resources that Hamas was
- 1:04:26getting through Iran or aid that ended up in Hamas's hands that was then used, whether
- 1:04:34that's fuel for rockets or whatever.
- 1:04:38It's not as clear cut as people might assume that Israel is the only one, whether it's
- 1:04:44directly or indirectly being supported by the U.S., at least at some point, like in
- 1:04:502023.
- 1:04:53And so, yeah, I mean, if you really want to talk about, like, if someone as an American
- 1:04:58wants to talk about their country's involvement in this, at least talk about what's happening,
- 1:05:05that both sides were getting some help, again, whether indirectly or directly from the U.S.
- 1:05:13That's a great point.
- 1:05:14Thank you for that.
- 1:05:17Bobby.
- 1:05:18Israel offers more aid to Gaza than any other country in the world.
- 1:05:23This is a country that's basically at war with another country.
- 1:05:28And while at the same time being expected to make sure that country is safe, make sure
- 1:05:32that they have food and water and fuel and defend yourself, but when you do that, don't
- 1:05:38hurt any of them.
- 1:05:40It's this weird double standard that no other country has ever been held to.
- 1:05:46It's ridiculous.
- 1:05:48And I think that just becomes, it comes from a place where facts don't matter anymore.
- 1:05:56You can look at objective truth right in the face and they'll just turn it the other way
- 1:05:58because it doesn't align with their narrative.
- 1:06:01It doesn't align with whatever is holding up their fragile little world that they've
- 1:06:05built, so it makes them comfortable.
- 1:06:07And I think the problem is that people aren't honest with themselves.
- 1:06:14People are, oh, I know what's happening over there.
- 1:06:16No, you don't.
- 1:06:17Are you kidding?
- 1:06:18Oh, I'm going to stop America from eating.
- 1:06:21No one out there on protests on the street has the influence to change what America or
- 1:06:27Israel is going to do in this situation.
- 1:06:29They just want to be a virtue signaling loudmouth, patting themselves on the back as like on
- 1:06:34the moral compass for everybody here.
- 1:06:37That's what I mean.
- 1:06:38We see that in all activism.
- 1:06:41It's really unfortunate.
- 1:06:43And I don't know how we can get back to people being willing to say, I don't know enough
- 1:06:51about this to have an opinion.
- 1:06:54You don't hear that anymore.
- 1:06:56Donnie.
- 1:06:57I think the objection that Shani raises that, oh, well, we're out on the streets because
- 1:07:06we fund, the US funds Israel.
- 1:07:09I think that those who do use that argument, for most of them, I believe that it's a smokescreen.
- 1:07:16First of all, I don't believe that most people who are taking to the streets calling for a
- 1:07:21global intifada and river to the sea, they don't know which river to which sea.
- 1:07:26I don't think they would even be aware of the fact that Israel supports Israel but doesn't
- 1:07:30support some of these other countries where atrocities are taking place.
- 1:07:34I think that would be giving a lot of these activists too much credit.
- 1:07:39But I will say also that I think for most people are followers and they're jumping on,
- 1:07:46even if their participation isn't rooted in anti-Semitism, it's rooted by a desire to
- 1:07:50be part of the issue du jour or to be part of a community or to get off of social media
- 1:07:55and get into the streets with people.
- 1:07:57There are many different reasons why people have joined this free Palestine, really anti-Israel
- 1:08:02movement.
- 1:08:06There are other examples that I can think of in recent history where people just jumped
- 1:08:12on something that they knew nothing about and it became this trend.
- 1:08:15I don't know if anybody here remembers, but there was a military leader in Uganda named
- 1:08:22Kony who was rounding up children and turning them into soldiers.
- 1:08:26There was all kinds of footage of these children with rifles, really disturbing.
- 1:08:32It became this trend that everybody, this was probably right at the dawn of social media,
- 1:08:40just jumped on this, we've got to track down Kony, this military leader.
- 1:08:47It just became a thing in that moment and then it left.
- 1:08:50And of course my hope is that this will eventually subside too and that sort of this anti-Semitic
- 1:08:56vitriol and hate will go away.
- 1:09:00And I guess that's my closing question for you.
- 1:09:07How do you think or how do you feel about the future of the vegan movement, of animal
- 1:09:14rights as it has displayed this level of, I would say, stupidity if we think about it
- 1:09:23strategically and politically?
- 1:09:27Why did we get into this?
- 1:09:29Why did we create such division?
- 1:09:32This has not helped the movement at all.
- 1:09:35This has not saved any animal lives.
- 1:09:38So how do you think about the future?
- 1:09:41And do you have the same hope as Kony, you have expressed that this anti-Semitism, this
- 1:09:50wave of anti-Semitism will go away and maybe with peace in the Middle East and we can at
- 1:10:02last be a more unified vegan movement?
- 1:10:06Bobby?
- 1:10:07Yeah, I think the problem is that once vegan activists started becoming celebrities, it
- 1:10:15became an egoic movement where people weren't interested in facts, people weren't interested
- 1:10:21in effective communication and effective activism, they were interested in loud activism.
- 1:10:27It was about, get your voice, be loud instead of be effective.
- 1:10:33And I think that it's going to be trending that way.
- 1:10:37I don't know what's going to happen with the animal rights movement, but at the same time
- 1:10:41I don't excuse them for this because they use that way too often to avoid accountability.
- 1:10:47A group will do something wrong and then say, well, if you attack us, then you're attacking
- 1:10:51this group that's doing all this good for animals.
- 1:10:54Well, I'm sorry, that was your mistake.
- 1:10:58We can't just say, well, we can't attack vegan or animal rights organizations because
- 1:11:03they're doing all this good work and they are doing good work for animals.
- 1:11:06But that's not a shield, it's a real hypocritical, disgusting shield that they hold out in front
- 1:11:11of them so that they can say, well, yes, we said that, so what?
- 1:11:15You can't do what you want to publicly shame us and hurt our funding and hurt our work.
- 1:11:22It became all these different groups being the veganist vegan group instead of all of
- 1:11:31us working together on the same cause, which is what we started out as.
- 1:11:36But now it's too self-interested.
- 1:11:39I don't know what's going to happen, but I think that the ego needs to go away.
- 1:11:44We've all heard that change starts with, first there's awareness, then conversation, then
- 1:11:52change.
- 1:11:53We've been doing awareness for 80 years.
- 1:11:56We've been doing a yelling and screaming at people's faces so that they can hear us since
- 1:12:001940.
- 1:12:01When the word vegan first showed up, the world is what?
- 1:12:041% vegan?
- 1:12:06I think everyone here is smart enough to realize maybe that approach isn't working anymore,
- 1:12:10maybe it's time to move to conversation.
- 1:12:13But that's the hard part that not everybody can be involved in and that doesn't get likes
- 1:12:19on Instagram.
- 1:12:21So I don't know what's going to happen.
- 1:12:25In the introduction, I talked about the breaking point and I can't help but feel like this
- 1:12:32rise of anti-semitism, this division is a symptom of something else, maybe a transformation
- 1:12:39in this movement more than the central thing.
- 1:12:44So yeah, anyone else want to jump in?
- 1:12:50Mira?
- 1:12:52It's interesting you said a symptom of a larger problem because there is that phrase that's
- 1:12:59often attributed to anti-semitism especially when it exponentially grows in a society or
- 1:13:04a specific country that it's the canary in the coal mine.
- 1:13:09I don't know if it's technically speciesist because canaries were used in the coal mine
- 1:13:14to see if they died and there's a sign that something's not safe down there, which obviously
- 1:13:18is horrible.
- 1:13:20But that kind of countries that devolved into rampant anti-semitism ended up having larger
- 1:13:29issues and anti-semitism and that society was rotting.
- 1:13:35Just to your point, it has historically shown that way that we're kind of like the first
- 1:13:41line of defense that something's wrong.
- 1:13:45I personally, because of the anti-semitism experience, it has for better or for worse
- 1:13:54allowed me to see that there are issues in my own community that I can address, whether
- 1:13:59or not that will be easy as a separate question.
- 1:14:03But in a way I feel like if I'm willing to do it and I have the knowledge since it is
- 1:14:08my community, I have more knowledge than someone that's outside the Jewish community,
- 1:14:13hopefully I can use that to my advantage.
- 1:14:16Kind of like I said, fill in gaps that I'm seeing.
- 1:14:20I'm in the process of trying to launch an organization that will be based in Israel,
- 1:14:25but then kind of spread out to Jewish communities around the world because there are decisions,
- 1:14:29especially like in Israel there was a decision to make certain methods when slaughtering animals
- 1:14:38illegal and then that spread to a big kosher certification organization that's based in
- 1:14:45diaspora like around the world.
- 1:14:47They implemented that into their organization as well.
- 1:14:51They won't certify animal bodies that I guess were killed with that method.
- 1:14:58It does have a ripple effect.
- 1:15:00The aim for that is to kind of take like a macro look at the movement in Israel as a
- 1:15:06whole and see kind of what approaches are maybe not implemented as much and assist in
- 1:15:12making and kind of plugging in the holes and creating like a unifying message in the
- 1:15:16community and allowing for more collaboration.
- 1:15:20So it kind of can be more cohesive and yeah, kind of just looking at where I can help.
- 1:15:29So that is my plan to still stick more within the spaces I'm already in as a Jew because
- 1:15:40yeah, I think what better way to make an impact than the communities I'm already in I guess.
- 1:15:48Donnie.
- 1:15:49I would say over the past, since 10.7, I've spent way more time than I want addressing
- 1:15:57anti-Semitism because I felt like I absolutely have to be irresponsible not to and I've done
- 1:16:04that at the expense of time that I would have normally spent advocating for animals and
- 1:16:09that's a shame and I really look forward to a time when that ends because my heart is
- 1:16:14within this movement.
- 1:16:16My heart is in animal rights and as Bobby said earlier on, how I am an activist will
- 1:16:23change or already has changed but I'll always be here for the animals because that's where
- 1:16:30my heart is, that's where my passion is.
- 1:16:32Bobby.
- 1:16:33Yeah, I think that I'm guessing that almost every Jewish vegan animal rights activist had
- 1:16:41the same experience where I spent the last 10 years working with people like Sean Monson
- 1:16:49and Moby going inside slaughterhouses, going undercover into factory farms, literally being
- 1:16:55at a slaughterhouse three times a week every week for six years to the point where I was
- 1:16:59in a mental health clinic for 12 weeks and I was known for that.
- 1:17:04That's who I was.
- 1:17:05I was the guy who was organizing all the vigils and the guy who was cinematographer for Sean
- 1:17:10Monson and doing all this frontline activism, rescuing over 100 and something animals and
- 1:17:16all of that went away on October 8th and I became a Jewish vegan and I became a vegan
- 1:17:24who couldn't work with groups that was, I was working with groups where it was my dream
- 1:17:27to work with them.
- 1:17:30Activists and artists who I was so excited to finally be working with and then they started
- 1:17:34posting things and I was in good conscious, couldn't continue working for the organization
- 1:17:39and so now here I am in Austin, I'm not in LA anymore, struggling with a real identity
- 1:17:44crisis on what I'm going to dedicate the rest of my life to and how is that going to
- 1:17:48look, what is that going to look like because even though it was detrimental to my health,
- 1:17:53if someone said, hey, we need you to go and film inside a slaughterhouse right now, I
- 1:17:56would do it in a heartbeat because that's where my passion lies, right?
- 1:18:00But I can't in good conscious promote groups that promote hate and so I feel completely,
- 1:18:11it's like in a spy movie where the main character realizes they've been double crossed and what
- 1:18:16they thought was friendly ground is now enemy territory and they don't know what to do or
- 1:18:21who to trust or where to go and that's where I am right now and I think that there's a
- 1:18:26lot of Jewish vegan activists that are feeling like that.
- 1:18:29Shani, did you want to add something or?
- 1:18:33I didn't because my view on it is really pessimistic so I don't know where we go from here and
- 1:18:43I'm so connected to what Ryan just said, I, as a Jewish animal activist, I just feel homeless
- 1:18:51right now.
- 1:18:53I feel like almost the need of reinventing ourselves in that space which is just hurting
- 1:19:04the movement because like I said at the beginning, our power is in numbers, the more we grow
- 1:19:10the movement, the more it becomes more mainstream, the more veganism, lifestyle and the liberation
- 1:19:17of animals is on the table.
- 1:19:20The more people joining, we want to get to a point of critical mess, we all know that
- 1:19:26term of like when it becomes like a bit more common, your last look at the point is weird
- 1:19:33or fringe and this divisiveness in our movement just hurting our movement and it's just, I
- 1:19:44don't know if we can ever recover from that because like just like Ryan just said, you
- 1:19:54feel like in your own movement you don't know who to trust, you don't know who's, I can't
- 1:20:01see myself going back to the community here almost to a point where I have like serious,
- 1:20:08serious thoughts of going back to Israel because I feel so alienated in Vancouver as a large
- 1:20:16and the vegan movement especially.
- 1:20:19So I didn't want to say anything because I'm pretty pessimistic about what's the future
- 1:20:26of that look like but I, one can only hope that we will find those spaces to keep advocating
- 1:20:32for animal rights and the liberation of animals from our plates, from our culture, clothing,
- 1:20:41whatever all the implications of that.
- 1:20:45But right now I don't see the way out, I don't see how this becoming, how this goes away,
- 1:20:53I wish I had better answers but yeah.
- 1:20:59Donnie?
- 1:21:03This is a little bit out of place but one of the things that has struck me and over the
- 1:21:09past year and however long it's been since 10-7 is that our colleagues in the movement
- 1:21:18have been sort of attacking Israel and attacking us under the guise of free Palestine but I've
- 1:21:24never heard anyone in the movement state the obvious that if they really genuinely cared
- 1:21:31about the plight of people living in Gaza, why aren't they calling to free Palestine
- 1:21:38from Hamas which strips people of their human rights, which uses their citizens as human
- 1:21:44shields, which reigns with terror.
- 1:21:49It's hard to even take their approach and their point of view seriously when they're
- 1:21:57not even stating the obvious that if they believe that the people living in Gaza are
- 1:22:04victims, who are they victims of?
- 1:22:08Israel wants nothing more than to live in peace with their neighbors but their neighbor,
- 1:22:13the leadership of their neighbors and many just plain old civilians state openly, proudly,
- 1:22:20publicly that their desire is to wipe Israel and Jews off the face of the earth.
- 1:22:29As Golda Meir once famously stated, how do you negotiate with people who have come to
- 1:22:34kill you?
- 1:22:36And there's just never any discussion about that in our movement and so it just reaffirms
- 1:22:43this feeling that I have that all of this free Palestine activism is rooted in hate
- 1:22:49against Israel and Jews more than a desire to actually help the people who they're claiming
- 1:22:56to advocate for.
- 1:22:59Bobby?
- 1:23:01Yeah, I completely agree.
- 1:23:04I try to make this comparison when I'm talking to people.
- 1:23:07It would be like the KKK starting an uprising in, I don't know, Mississippi or wherever,
- 1:23:15you know, West Virginia and then asking all the African Americans and Jews, why can't
- 1:23:23you guys just, you know, like, figure this out, get along?
- 1:23:27You know, when it says, and when it says in Hezbollah's basically charter on their flag
- 1:23:33that we are here to destroy Israel and to destroy Jews, when Hamas says we are here
- 1:23:37to destroy Israel and destroy Jews and then you say, well, they're a political party.
- 1:23:42Why can't you guys just get along?
- 1:23:44You know, you wouldn't say that if it was someone in a clan outfit coming on the news
- 1:23:50and spouting out hate and you go, oh, that's a political party.
- 1:23:54This is ridiculous.
- 1:23:57Yes, Tony.
- 1:23:59On October 7 and October 8 when the video footage of the hostages that were recorded
- 1:24:07by Hamas and civilians who participated in that attack, when we started to see that,
- 1:24:14what we saw is thousands of civilians in Gaza and Hamas taking to the streets cheering
- 1:24:22over the bodies of dead and bloodied people who were in Israel, whether they were Israelis
- 1:24:28or visitors in Israel, just the people who were taken hostage.
- 1:24:33You just would never see anything like that on the other side of the border in Israel.
- 1:24:38And so, you know, for me as a Jewish person, you know, I don't know, I don't know what
- 1:24:46the way forward is for Israel.
- 1:24:48How do people in this country, the peace-loving Kibbutzniks who lived on the border with Gaza
- 1:24:53who were transporting people from Gaza into Israel for medical treatment at Israeli hospitals,
- 1:24:59you know, who were then victims of Hamas and were still being held captive by Hamas, how
- 1:25:04do they go on?
- 1:25:05And so, I just, I want to be here as an American, as a Jew and as an animal rights activist
- 1:25:12to say that, you know, I support them and will continue to advocate for them until this
- 1:25:20nightmare is over one way or another.
- 1:25:23Bobby?
- 1:25:24Yeah, I think that one thing that was so telling for me was on October 8th, when all these
- 1:25:30videos are coming out, this goes to my point to where people just make up their own reality.
- 1:25:35People were saying, oh, well, that didn't really happen.
- 1:25:37I was like, it did happen.
- 1:25:39And that's Hamas showing you and bragging about it, that it happened.
- 1:25:43And they're like, no, that's all fake.
- 1:25:48You know, what are you supposed to say when if you're having a conversation with someone
- 1:25:51and all they do is bark, no at you?
- 1:25:55You know, they don't have anything to back up their beliefs other than hate.
- 1:26:00And so it's like, Jews are good people.
- 1:26:01No, they're not.
- 1:26:02Why not?
- 1:26:03Because they're not.
- 1:26:04Okay, I guess this conversation's over, you know, because they're just not willing to
- 1:26:08believe it.
- 1:26:10And so that's where my, people call it pessimism, I call it realism, comes into, I don't know
- 1:26:17because this speaks to a larger problem in terms of a lot of other groups and a lot of
- 1:26:25other issues where people just say, that's just not true.
- 1:26:28The earth is flat.
- 1:26:30You know, how do you know?
- 1:26:32I just, I just know, I just feel like that's true.
- 1:26:34Oh, okay.
- 1:26:35I guess that's good enough then.
- 1:26:37You know, it's a form of negationism, like Holocaust denial, shiny.
- 1:26:47And to what just Ryan just said, on one hand, there's this like, belentled denial of what
- 1:26:55happened on October 7, but then on the other hand, they praise what happened on October
- 1:27:007 and said it was a great act of resistance.
- 1:27:04So which one is it?
- 1:27:05Because they just keep contradicting themselves all the time, which is funny from, for someone
- 1:27:12who knows exactly what is happening to see it from the side, it's like, so which one
- 1:27:16is it?
- 1:27:17Did it happen or did it not happen?
- 1:27:19Just another point of like, you guys have no idea what you're talking about.
- 1:27:24Yeah, I feel like, you know, creating this podcast and really, you know, diving deep
- 1:27:31into the world of vegan activism.
- 1:27:35I have found that this division exists with many other groups, not as strong, you know,
- 1:27:41as with Jewish vegans, you know, the level of hostility and all of that, what we have
- 1:27:47covered in the past hour.
- 1:27:53But you know, you talk with vegans who label themselves as conservatives and, you know,
- 1:27:59they will tell you, I don't feel welcome in this community or vegans who are Christians
- 1:28:04and they will tell you, hey, my way of doing veganism is not, you know, what is represented
- 1:28:13usually in the community as a general rule.
- 1:28:16You know, I did the whole episode debunking the documentary Christ, piracy, you know,
- 1:28:24presenting the perspective of Christians on that documentary.
- 1:28:31But things like that, you know, it again, I go back to that point of this being a symptom
- 1:28:38of something else that is wrong in this movement.
- 1:28:44Bobby.
- 1:28:45Yeah.
- 1:28:46And to your point with like conservatives, that has been a problem that has been bothering
- 1:28:52me ever since I became a vegan is that they don't want to leave the echo chamber.
- 1:28:58Like I said, they want it to be easy activism.
- 1:29:00They don't like, you know, we all want people who think differently than us.
- 1:29:04What are you talking about?
- 1:29:05Of course you want people who think differently than you.
- 1:29:08It's not doing us any good just preaching to the choir, but they're unwilling to do
- 1:29:12it because they say, oh, they're, you know, it's again, the binary view of the world.
- 1:29:17Oh, conservative, bad, you know, non-vegan, bad.
- 1:29:21And it's just unwilling to see the complexity in things.
- 1:29:24And this idea that, you know, a conservative would never be vegan is ridiculous.
- 1:29:28My father's conservative, he's vegan, you know, it's just, again, I think it just comes
- 1:29:34down to lazy, easy activism where they're not really confronted that much by opposing
- 1:29:40views.
- 1:29:41And if they are all that they do is scream and shout as loud as they can.
- 1:29:43And they think that they sort of had some sort of impact.
- 1:29:47I think until we can get over that, until we can get over ourselves and not make it
- 1:29:52about how angry we are and instead make it about how effective we can be, I think we're
- 1:29:57going to be in a stalemate for a while.
- 1:29:59I will put an end to this conversation because, you know, I want to respect your time.
- 1:30:05And let me just say, you know, this has been an honor talking with you.
- 1:30:10Thank you so much for having shared, you know, your insights and your experience.
- 1:30:16I really hope that this podcast makes some small difference in showing a different perspective
- 1:30:22to, again, those activists who are in this echo chamber and, you know, are not seeing
- 1:30:31the light anymore, are bombarded with the same messaging.
- 1:30:38I do think that there are plenty of vegans and I've talked with some of them who are
- 1:30:45silently supportive of, you know, the Jewish cause and are really not happy about what
- 1:30:56has happened in the past year with anti-Semitism.
- 1:31:01But again, you know, I would have expected that a movement like veganism, which is highly
- 1:31:08non-conformist, would be more likely to speak up about those issues, have the courage to
- 1:31:16do so.
- 1:31:17But yeah, thank you so much.
- 1:31:19I'm really happy to have done this.
- 1:31:22Any parting words?
- 1:31:23I just wanted to say thank you for creating that space, creating this conversation because
- 1:31:30I don't think there's anything that the movement is facing right now that is more important
- 1:31:36than that because just like Mera said, this is just the canary in the coal mine and this
- 1:31:41is just the beginning of the erosion if you look at the history.
- 1:31:50So thank you for addressing it.
- 1:31:53Thank you for having me, having us, having this conversation.
- 1:31:57It is super important to me.
- 1:32:02And I love everything that everyone said, I'm connected deeply to the arguments and the
- 1:32:10examples that everyone has just shared.
- 1:32:14And I just wanted to say thank you so much for creating space for this conversation.
- 1:32:19Thank you, Shani.
- 1:32:20Doni?
- 1:32:21By virtue of giving us a platform to talk about this issue, something which we have desperately
- 1:32:27needed, you're going to be subjecting yourself to criticism.
- 1:32:31So I just want to thank you for going out on a limb for us, for the Jewish community,
- 1:32:36and for giving us this platform to talk about what we've experienced and how we're feeling.
- 1:32:41Thank you, Doni.
- 1:32:42Mera?
- 1:32:43I very much second what Doni said.
- 1:32:47Thank you so much for reaching out and for wanting to have this conversation in the first
- 1:32:51place and making it, I guess, a discussion with more than just one Jew to kind of see
- 1:32:58that there are multiple Jewish voices that are on the same page.
- 1:33:01And I really hope that you won't be, I guess, on the receiving end of too much hate, which
- 1:33:09sometimes does come along with, you know, I guess, going against the grain regarding
- 1:33:16things around the Jewish community and Israel.
- 1:33:18So yeah, just thank you so much.
- 1:33:22Thank you, Mera.
- 1:33:23Thank you everyone for listening.
- 1:33:25I kindly invite you to share this podcast with the vegans you know.
- 1:33:29Let's encourage more people to take action.
- 1:33:32Again, thank you so much for caring, and I will see you next Tuesday for a new episode.
- 1:33:41I just want to say sorry, but the way that the Zoom was shown to me, I kept calling Bobby
- 1:33:47Ryan, so I just realized that.
- 1:33:53So if that confused anyone, the names just didn't show up properly.
- 1:33:58So technical thing, but sorry, Bobby, for misnaming you the whole time.