Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Credit Unions vs. Banks: What Q2 Data Reveals
Transcript
- 0:00Treichel: Hey everyone.
- 0:00This is Mark Trekel with another episode of With Flying Colors NCA released its
- 0:04quarterly Credit Union Data summary report for quarter number two of 2025.
- 0:10And the FDIC issued a couple reports, their overall banking profile report
- 0:15and a community banking report.
- 0:18And I'm here with Steve Farr, Todd Miller, and Dennis Bauer of my team to
- 0:22discuss whatever might have caught our eye when we read through these reports.
- 0:27Gentlemen, how you doing today?
- 0:30Farrar: Good.
- 0:30Good.
- 0:31Treichel: Glad, glad to hear it.
- 0:32Glad to hear it.
- 0:33Hey, uh, a quick introduction for each of you.
- 0:36Let's, uh, let's start with, uh, Dennis, this time.
- 0:39Bauer: All right.
- 0:40Yeah, thanks, mark.
- 0:41I've known Mark for about 39 years.
- 0:43Uh, we both started out with the NCA, uh, back in 1986.
- 0:48So that's where I, I started my career.
- 0:50I've worked in the credit union world for about 30, or
- 0:52had worked for about 38 years.
- 0:54So six of those years were spent with the N-N-C-U-A from, from 1986 to 1991.
- 1:03So I started out obviously as a field examiner and and also
- 1:06was a problem case officer.
- 1:08So in 1991 I transitioned over to a credit union in St.
- 1:12Paul, Minnesota, and I worked there for, um, 32 years at Ideal Credit Union.
- 1:18Ultimately, I retired this past, um, last September, so almost a
- 1:21year ago, um, as the chief financial Officer and executive vice President.
- 1:27In my, obviously my main focus at the credit union was my CFO role, but I
- 1:32oversaw other operational areas such as enterprise risk management, uh, payments,
- 1:37human resources, and it little bit, maybe a little bit unique for the credit union,
- 1:42we were consistently a high loan to share, high loan to asset credit union.
- 1:48A lot of my time as a CFO was spent obviously on interest rate.
- 1:52Risk management was big, obviously, but liquidity management where we
- 1:56tried to encompass di discipline pricing for loans and deposits.
- 2:01Obviously.
- 2:01Collateral, pledging collateral for wholesale funding.
- 2:04Worked a lot in non-member deposit, loan sales and participations,
- 2:08particularly the last 10 years or so, I was at the credit union.
- 2:11So we got a lot of experience in that.
- 2:13Uh, so over that period of time a credit union from, from 1992 to last
- 2:19year, we were, we grew from a hundred million in assets when I started to
- 2:23just over a billion when I retired home.
- 2:25So that was.
- 2:26It was our organic growth.
- 2:27And this past year I joined Mark's team and I enjoy staying engaged
- 2:32with, um, everything that's going on in the credit union world.
- 2:35Treichel: Dennis, as you're walking through that, it reminded me of, uh, that
- 2:39used to be a postal credit union, right?
- 2:41Bauer: Yep.
- 2:41Yep.
- 2:42It was, yeah.
- 2:42Treichel: I remember you and I being on an exam team there with Leon
- 2:45Hendrick and Leon was training you and he made you bring in this really big
- 2:50computer printout into the boardroom.
- 2:52Yeah.
- 2:53And he had you carry, and he told you you were gonna have to present it.
- 2:57And uh, and then he didn't make you do it.
- 2:59So he was just, he was just making you carry that around.
- 3:02'cause he could
- 3:03Bauer: Yeah.
- 3:03It was at a, it was at a steakhouse in, uh, St.
- 3:05Paul, Minnesota.
- 3:08And that's where I had my retirement party.
- 3:10Oh my God.
- 3:10Um, had great memories from my NC days,
- 3:14Treichel: the circle, the, the circle's complete.
- 3:17That's funny.
- 3:17That's awesome.
- 3:18Yeah.
- 3:19All right, Todd, you're up next.
- 3:22Miller: I have spent.
- 3:2334 years with N-C-U-A-I started in 1987, retired in 2021.
- 3:30Over that three decades, it breaks down to roughly three pieces of my career.
- 3:36That first third was spent as a problem, case officer and examiner.
- 3:40The middle third, I was a capital regional capital market specialist.
- 3:45And the final third, I was a director of special actions in
- 3:48the Western region dealing with.
- 3:49Troubled credit union's, supervising problem case officers, and regional
- 3:54capital market specialists.
- 3:56And for a period of time, even the regional lending specialist
- 3:59enjoyed my 34 years with NCUA.
- 4:02Learned a lot, was involved in a lot of conservatorships, um,
- 4:06returned a few to the members.
- 4:08Those are kind of highlights of the career.
- 4:10Unfortunately over that time we've seen a lot of credit unions go by the
- 4:13wayside, and unfortunately I had to close more than a few of them myself.
- 4:18But.
- 4:18Uh, all in all, it was a very enjoyable career.
- 4:22Had a lot of diversity in the career, spent a lot of time
- 4:25with complex credit unions.
- 4:27Spent some time with you for a full year during the corporate crisis at Westcorp.
- 4:31I call it my last year, but.
- 4:34All in all my 34 years with NCUA was a very enjoyable and diverse career, and
- 4:41I retired and two months later he called me up and said, Hey, come to dinner
- 4:45with Marie and I, and I told my wife, there's gonna be a job offer with this.
- 4:48Treichel: That's right.
- 4:49And here we are.
- 4:50Here we are many clients later.
- 4:52Almost closing in on 300 podcast guys.
- 4:56Time flies, Mr.
- 4:58Farr.
- 5:00Farrar: Hey, has I, I like what Todd says I on, on, uh, so our work
- 5:05being gratifying, I, I did, uh, 32 years at NCA broken into two parts.
- 5:10The first half was right in the field as a predominantly a, a problem case officer.
- 5:16And like Todd said, we worked really closely with our credit unions then.
- 5:21And, uh, you know, I felt like we were really kind of a, a part of
- 5:25the team that got some turnarounds and that provided a lot of.
- 5:29The job provided all the satisfaction you need when they would turn around
- 5:32and you knew when it didn't, that we'd given it the best effort.
- 5:35So those were, those were great times and you know, we,
- 5:38it took us all over the place.
- 5:40I mean, we were out in American Samoa and Guam, some of the really
- 5:43interesting places that we got to go to.
- 5:46Uh, then, uh, when you went to the central office, mark, I followed you
- 5:49there and worked remotely in the office.
- 5:52Of examination and ex and insurance and risk management for another,
- 5:57uh, you know, 15 plus years.
- 5:59And in, in there I got to be involved in many, many, uh, projects.
- 6:04Wrote a lot of, uh, policies and once you write one regulation and it goes through,
- 6:09they pointed you and say, we got more.
- 6:12So that was, uh, always interesting work.
- 6:15Uh, I enjoyed working with legal counsel on that.
- 6:18I did do training with the.
- 6:20Examiners on communications and that was very rewarding.
- 6:25Then towards the end of the career, I had spent the last part of it really
- 6:28working on risk-based capital, but it was really diversified, you know, and
- 6:31then we've been doing the consulting now for quite a while, and that's been great
- 6:35'cause we continue to sharpen our saw.
- 6:37In the industry and, and work at keeping up with that.
- 6:40And, uh, I, I really have enjoyed the consulting and that, uh, uh, we, we
- 6:46take the time to, try and work with credit union management like we did when
- 6:51we were resolving problems as a PCL.
- 6:54Treichel: Yeah.
- 6:54Steve, you that's a really I'm glad you highlighted that 'cause that is a.
- 6:58The, those PCO days, the DSA days when you, when you got in a good rhythm with
- 7:02the credit union where there, where they had challenges, you had to do supervision,
- 7:06but you could really work together to get the credit union back on path.
- 7:11We're exciting times and that's, and that's really kinda what we do now.
- 7:14So I, I hadn't really kind of in my own mind, I hadn't looked at it in that
- 7:17light, but it's kind of recapturing those, those days when we were able to do that.
- 7:22From not the NCA perspective, yet having that NNCA perspective to help
- 7:26the clients, which is kind of fun.
- 7:28Farrar: In fact, it's interesting.
- 7:29I'm good friends with the manager.
- 7:31One of the first credit unions I worked with as a PCO after all
- 7:35these years we're good friends.
- 7:37Treichel: Is that the one that has a boardroom named after you?
- 7:40Well, that's the
- 7:41Farrar: credit union.
- 7:45Treichel: Gotta love it.
- 7:46Gotta love it.
- 7:46All right guys.
- 7:47Let's see.
- 7:48We are going to be chatting about the second quarter data.
- 7:52Uh, which topic do we wanna talk about first from either one of these reports?
- 7:58Farrar: Todd, you can have first choice.
- 8:01Miller: I thought we agreed before this, that Steve was gonna
- 8:03direct this whole conversation.
- 8:05Treichel: I think he, I think he said he just did that.
- 8:09He just said, okay, Steve will direct it.
- 8:11Todd, what do you wanna do?
- 8:12He did a redirect.
- 8:14Miller: Okay.
- 8:14Well I'll, I'll start with just something kind of simple.
- 8:17Just looking at growth rates for.
- 8:19Banks and credit unions.
- 8:21Credit unions have done really well with their deposit and loan growth, much
- 8:25better than the community banks have much better than the banking industry overall.
- 8:30Pretty much since December of 2023, back in 2023, bank deposits were
- 8:36grown a little bit faster than credit unions, but ever since then, credit
- 8:39deposits have grown significantly faster than those in the banking industry.
- 8:44So far through the first six months of 2025, credit union deposits grew 6.4%.
- 8:51Banks only grew two.
- 8:53Wow.
- 8:53And you're seeing a similar thing with loan grow.
- 8:57Um.
- 8:59Credit union, both banks and credit union's.
- 9:01Loan growth was not very robust.
- 9:03In 2024, it was actually small numbers, but here in 2025 for the first six months,
- 9:10credit union loan growth was at 4.4%.
- 9:13Banks were only at 2.6%.
- 9:16So credit unions are doing much better at that loan growth key.
- 9:20Um, it's kind of interesting where the credit union loan growth is too.
- 9:23It's mostly in commercial loans and home equity lending.
- 9:28Um, there are other lending types that have been pretty much static
- 9:35Treichel: and those contend to be bigger loans, which could be how the
- 9:37growth numbers you, you get a, a, a little bit of a niche there that can
- 9:41add, add to those numbers pretty quick.
- 9:43Steven, Dennis, any, any thoughts on what Todd had to say or that topic?
- 9:50Bauer: No, that stood out to me as well, uh, with, particularly
- 9:54with deposit growth where.
- 9:56Credit unions were struggling for so many years, sort of lagging and
- 10:01this past year, over year over year.
- 10:03Yeah.
- 10:04As Todd said, you know, over 5% deposit growth and it's still
- 10:08being fueled, it looks like mainly by short term certificate growth.
- 10:13Um, obviously there's some money market growth as well as regular shared
- 10:18growth, so it's great to see that.
- 10:19And then, right as a result, I think you, you see borrowing
- 10:23the borrowing to asset ratio for credit unions decline a little bit.
- 10:26'cause liquidity is probably improving as well.
- 10:29So, so that was, that was good to see that.
- 10:34Treichel: Great point.
- 10:34Steve, anything on that before we move on to another category?
- 10:38Farrar: No, I think we've covered it pretty well.
- 10:40Treichel: Very good.
- 10:40All right.
- 10:40Net interest margin.
- 10:41Steve, I know this one's near and dear to your heart, so I you wanna chat a little
- 10:45bit about what your thought is on that?
- 10:47Farrar: Well, it, it, it's kinda probably always near and dear to
- 10:50all of our, all of our hearts here.
- 10:52And that, uh, it, it, it drives so much and it's kinda like, you know, well,
- 10:55how, how is it really going for the credit unions the net interest margin.
- 11:01You know, it did increase, was it eight weight basis points for the quarter?
- 11:06Pretty consistent with what you saw in the, uh, community bank area there.
- 11:12They had that their net interest margin increase 16 basis
- 11:15points for the prior quarter.
- 11:17So everybody's seeing that in, in increase and improve, and that was a key
- 11:21driver to try and get income to come up.
- 11:24Kinda what I wanna talk about with that one is.
- 11:28And I, I always talk about what, what, what, what do we think is
- 11:31gonna happen next quarter and throughout the rest of the year.
- 11:35I kind of would wanna throw that out and see what Todd and
- 11:37Dennis have to say about mm-hmm.
- 11:39Where we're at with that from the quarter performance and how it
- 11:43looks for the rest of the year.
- 11:45Bauer: Yeah, yeah.
- 11:45From my perspective, depends on what happens with short term rates, fed rates.
- 11:51Right.
- 11:51The Fed funds rate.
- 11:53I think if the Fed gets aggressive, which they may because of maybe un
- 11:57or unemployment issues and seems like maybe inflation is tamed, they
- 12:01may go pretty aggressive, maybe 50.
- 12:06They've been talking about this next week, may probably 25,
- 12:09but maybe another 50 to 75 to a hundred before the end of the year.
- 12:14I think if that happens.
- 12:15Right, just because of the makeup of balance sheet, a little bit
- 12:18more cash, you might start to see margins maybe narrow a bit.
- 12:22But I don't think it would be, I don't think it'll be that significant though.
- 12:25But in the short term, when rates, when short term rates drop credits,
- 12:29generally the margins would, would tend to narrow, uh, a tad.
- 12:33So that, that's what my take is on it, you know, over the.
- 12:36You know, when you look, when you take a look at the makeup of why the net
- 12:39interest margin, I looked at it on a year over year basis rather than a, on
- 12:43a quarterly basis for credit unions.
- 12:46They picked up a lot of yield on earning assets.
- 12:49That was up about 25 basis points over the last year, whereas cost of
- 12:55funds declined roughly five basis points, which is interesting when
- 12:59you look at all FDI insured banks.
- 13:02You know, you, the big banks, I think struggled on the margin a bit.
- 13:05'Cause if you look, if you just look at all banks altogether their margin
- 13:09only improved seven basis points.
- 13:12But if you look at, if you strip out the larger banks and just look at the
- 13:15community banks, their margins increased similar to to credit unions at, around,
- 13:20you know, 25 to 28 basis points.
- 13:24Um, and the makeup of how that happened in the community banks, the smaller banks.
- 13:29Was is was sort of split.
- 13:30It wasn't all related to yield on earning assets.
- 13:33It was partly yield.
- 13:34It's probably 50 50 yield on earning assets increased by about 16 basis
- 13:39points, whereas their cost of funds declined by 12, making up the 28.
- 13:44So that was interesting to see that that little bit of a nuance
- 13:48I guess in community banks versus credit unions of how.
- 13:52How the net interest margin improved is what I, I saw during my review.
- 13:57Treichel: That's interesting.
- 13:59That the big one, the big ones dragging the average down.
- 14:02Uh, and then when you compare the, like the community banks which are
- 14:06more similar to credit unions, there's a little bit more of a correlation,
- 14:10but still, still a difference.
- 14:12Miller: Yeah.
- 14:14I have kind of another take on it.
- 14:16I'm gonna go put my old problem case officer hat and my DSA hat on.
- 14:21You know, and when credit unions had earnings challenges, one
- 14:24of the things we always talked about was operating expenses.
- 14:27'cause that's the thing they have the most control over.
- 14:30It's really interesting.
- 14:31If you look at the six quarters since December of 2023, the banking
- 14:36industry have reduced their expense levels every quarter, and the credit
- 14:39unions have went up every quarter.
- 14:42And right now there's about a 40 basis point ROA difference between credit unions
- 14:46and community banks, and it's almost all in that operating expense difference.
- 14:51Treichel: Yep.
- 14:53Well, that, that could be a podcast in and of itself.
- 14:56That's interesting.
- 14:57Yeah.
- 14:57And
- 14:58Bauer: yeah.
- 14:58Yeah.
- 14:59Where that hap and where that happened mainly for credit unions.
- 15:02Again, I look year over year was up 12.
- 15:04Roughly 12 basis points, I think.
- 15:06Yeah, non-interest expense was up 12 basis points for credit
- 15:10unions and for all banks.
- 15:12It was up, let's see here, about two basis points.
- 15:15And for community credit or banks, it was up it was up three basis
- 15:19points and right for half of it was related to salary and benefits.
- 15:25That's where the, um, the bulk of that increase occurred.
- 15:28So, right.
- 15:29I, I don't know, partly maybe inflationary pressures on credit unions related to that
- 15:33cost of living might've resulted in that and, and banks sort of held back a bit on
- 15:39increasing probably salary and benefits
- 15:42Treichel: And hypothetically maybe bank bankers are paid a little bit better.
- 15:47It is getting more competitive out there to keep people around.
- 15:50The credit unions are having to pay money to either bring people in.
- 15:55Or up people to keep them there.
- 15:58That possibly could lead to the, the, a little bit of that credit union growth.
- 16:03Miller: How much of it was salary and benefits debt
- 16:07Bauer: of the 12?
- 16:08Um, I think it was up, from what I remember, I didn't, I didn't write that
- 16:12down, but roughly, I think about six basis points, about half of that, I believe
- 16:17came from salary benefits when you broke it down into the various categories,
- 16:21that one sort of stuck, stood out to me.
- 16:22I
- 16:23Miller: wonder if some of it, you know, we've had a lot of clients that went
- 16:26through data processing conversions.
- 16:28I wonder if some of this is just keeping up with technology, keeping up with
- 16:31data security or information security.
- 16:35I didn't look at the breakdown.
- 16:37You know, it's just an observation that they're going
- 16:40in the opposite directions and
- 16:42Farrar: yeah,
- 16:42Miller: the two industries.
- 16:43Bauer: Yeah.
- 16:43One, one ratio I always follow is just the average.
- 16:45What is the average salary and benefits for credit unions?
- 16:48And if I didn't pull this report, I, not in front of me, but I believe
- 16:52I believe that average salary and benefits for all credit unions was
- 16:57approaching a little bit over a hundred, a hundred grand right in front of me.
- 17:02A hundred nine, five
- 17:03Miller: hundred ninety
- 17:04Bauer: $9.
- 17:05Yeah.
- 17:05So that's up I think a, a, a bit from a year ago.
- 17:09About six or 7,000 I believe per, a year ago it was 1 0 2, so it's up almost 4%.
- 17:15Yep.
- 17:15So I think that's, I think that's where the big, the bulk of that
- 17:18expense is, is, is occurring.
- 17:22Treichel: Fascinating.
- 17:22Farrar: Yeah.
- 17:22There is some increase also in just education and promotion,
- 17:25and that's not surprising.
- 17:26And that we talked about competition and that would be the reaction because you do
- 17:31see, credit union advertising out there.
- 17:35In more spaces that you didn't use to see it.
- 17:38So
- 17:38Treichel: stadiums and the like.
- 17:40Farrar: There we are.
- 17:42Treichel: I didn't say it.
- 17:46I did.
- 17:47All right.
- 17:48What, so what, uh, any, any last talk topics on we, we did NIM, we kind of did
- 17:54expenses as it relates to profitability.
- 17:56Uh, what's, what's next, Steve?
- 17:58Farrar: Let's go.
- 17:59Loan loan portfolio performance.
- 18:02Um, you know, the thing, trend looked pretty good, I think
- 18:06on just overall delinquency.
- 18:09Uh, let me look at it again real quick.
- 18:12I did delinquency is just, up just a touch from where it was a year ago, up
- 18:20a bit from the, the quarter compared to the community banks, they're, the numbers
- 18:26aren't always so comparable it seems like.
- 18:28The credit union delinquency is higher than that, and that's reflected in the
- 18:32loan losses, uh, because the credit union industry does operate pretty
- 18:37significantly higher loan losses than are in the community banks.
- 18:43And that, of course, is another element, uh, affecting
- 18:46that, uh, overall net income.
- 18:48You know, and that, uh, the PLL average assets for the credit
- 18:52union was, uh, was like 0.6%,
- 18:57a little less than that.
- 18:57And it hasn't moved much over the last few quarters, but in
- 19:01banking, it's, it's only like 0.2.
- 19:03So that's a pretty significant difference that's, that's occurring between
- 19:07the two businesses, uh, out there.
- 19:09So, uh, that was my observation on loan quality.
- 19:15Miller: Overall, what you see is delinquency trends in
- 19:17the banks and credit unions.
- 19:18They're almost going in lockstep, even though the banks measure that
- 19:22delinquency number a little bit different than the credit union industry does.
- 19:26'cause they throw non accruals into their delinquency and they
- 19:30start measuring at 30 days.
- 19:32Credit unions start measuring at 60 days, but the trends are just virtually
- 19:36for the whole portfolio the same.
- 19:38And what you do see in the community banks is their commercial
- 19:42loan delinquency is very low.
- 19:44Credit union's, commercial loan delinquency, and it's one of the
- 19:47fastest growing portfolios, but their delinquency in that commercial
- 19:51loan portfolio is inching up too.
- 19:55In fact, it jumped almost 20 basis points just in the last six months.
- 19:59So, it's like 1 0 5 now for just their commercial delinquency
- 20:03in the credit union industry.
- 20:05And that's a number that I would think would have the folks at
- 20:09N-C-U-A-A little bit nervous.
- 20:12Treichel: I'm so nervous they're eliminating the risk ratings, but
- 20:15that's a topic for another day.
- 20:18Bauer: Just to add a little bit onto that combination of where loan growth
- 20:22is occurring and what's going on with charge offs and delinquencies.
- 20:26Right.
- 20:27Unemployment's still relatively low, which is a good thing.
- 20:30And real estate values obviously are sky high, uh, which right now is a good thing.
- 20:36But if that concentration of, continues to grow in real estate and we start to
- 20:42see an increase in unemployment and we start to see housing values drop, then
- 20:47that most likely is gonna have a impact on the Cecil calculation, which could impact
- 20:52credit unions probably more significantly, I think, than net interest margin.
- 20:57If we start to see that downturn in potentially in the economy right.
- 21:02We're sort of at the high point, if you will, for, for unemploy.
- 21:06You know, unemployment's been picking up a bit, but not significantly
- 21:09in real estate values, right?
- 21:10So we're at a very good position with both of those.
- 21:12So, um, most likely those are gonna deteriorate a little bit or
- 21:16significantly depending upon what, what goes on with the economy that could
- 21:19impact the provision for low loss.
- 21:23Miller: Kind of an observation along that lines, I didn't look at NCUA
- 21:26state profiles, but the FBI's quarterly profiles, they do put regional.
- 21:32Information in there.
- 21:34And for delinquency, like for community banks, you know, it ranges from 0.4
- 21:40in San Francisco to 0.68
- 21:42in Dallas.
- 21:43I mean, there's a 20 basis point difference in delinquency just
- 21:47amongst their different regions.
- 21:49And they have similar differences in ROA, there's a big spread in ROA
- 21:54between, the different bank regions.
- 21:57Like I said, I didn't dig into NCA's regions are their state profiles,
- 22:03but I wonder if maybe some of that still exists within NCUA as well.
- 22:09Maybe we have some regional differences going on within our credit unions is I
- 22:15Treichel: would imagine that's the case.
- 22:17Uh, Steve, any any thoughts on asset quality?
- 22:22Farrar: No, I, I think we've, we've covered it pretty well
- 22:24and how, you know, that reflects back into affecting earnings.
- 22:28Treichel: You got it.
- 22:29Well, and, and earnings, and Cecil, you know, it, and I know enough about
- 22:32Cecil to not quite be dangerous, but it's definitely not my expertise.
- 22:36It used to just be the allowance and you'd, you know, you'd, you'd
- 22:39individually classify it and be gone.
- 22:40And we've changed it a few times from there.
- 22:42But there were some, some sways with credit unions on how
- 22:45that when they implemented it.
- 22:48And it had some unintended consequences.
- 22:50And then the next, the second year, there were some, some challenges
- 22:54that it created in some institutions.
- 22:56But as Dennis, if, if, uh, if the economy starts to slip, it's almost
- 23:02like a double hammer now in that Cecil, 'cause you've got the, you've got the
- 23:05real delinquency in the losses, and then you have some other, environmental
- 23:09factors and different things out.
- 23:11You know, there, this isn't a Cecil podcast, but I could
- 23:14see that really having.
- 23:16A bigger increase or a bigger impact than pre Cecil.
- 23:20Bauer: Yeah.
- 23:21And then, right.
- 23:21There's so many different flavors of Cecil.
- 23:23They're not consistent at all.
- 23:25I know the one we used is heavily influenced by sort of what's going
- 23:29on with real estate values and what's going on with unemployment.
- 23:33That can, even though you might, it might look like your delinquency
- 23:36is, is great and your charge offs.
- 23:38I mean, if that starts the.
- 23:40Those environmental factors change that really supposed to
- 23:42influence that calculation, so.
- 23:44Right.
- 23:45Um, and I don't know if that's probably not being done consistently,
- 23:48obviously across the board.
- 23:49Miller: Good point.
- 23:51One thing you see a little bit of economic, you know,
- 23:54struggles amongst individuals.
- 23:57While unsecured lending isn't a huge part of credit union's loan
- 24:01portfolios, I mean the charge off ratios for credit cards, unsecured
- 24:05lending, they've been inching up.
- 24:07And you know, within the credit union industry, charge off
- 24:11ratios on credit cards are 5%.
- 24:13That's probably getting up there where bank.
- 24:16Charge off ratios are other.
- 24:18Unsecured lending is in the 4% range, so it's a small part of the portfolios, but
- 24:23it's a big chunk of credit union losses.
- 24:25And you know, I don't know, over my last five to 10 years that NCUA,
- 24:30you did see a lot of credit unions leaving the credit card space.
- 24:33And, you know, it's not necessarily growing to any degree.
- 24:39But it's definitely costing credit union some money and charge offs.
- 24:45And I think it's just the whole thing, the economy and saving rates and everything.
- 24:50But those unsecured charge offs are pretty significant.
- 24:53Treichel: Yeah.
- 24:53Those are big numbers, which were, um, I, I had pulled up a, a tweet
- 24:57or, uh, do you still call 'em tweets?
- 24:58Even though Twitter changed from Twitter to X?
- 25:01Is it still a tweet?
- 25:02I'm gonna have to go to the dictionary to check that out, but somebody
- 25:06who listens to this podcast, who is X-N-C-U-A, sent me a tweet from,
- 25:10uh, uh, the co cobi Ossi letter.
- 25:14I'm not sure if I'm saying that right, but the tweet was this,
- 25:16and you know, if it's on Twitter or X, it's gotta be true, right?
- 25:19Because, so this data has to be as.
- 25:23High quality as NNC and fds.
- 25:26Tongue in cheek, uh, the car market bubble is bursting subprime auto loan.
- 25:30Delinquency rates have now surpassed 5% for the first time in history.
- 25:35The 60 day delinquency rate for subprime auto loans has more than
- 25:39doubled over the last three years.
- 25:41Delinquency rates are now one point, roughly 1.5
- 25:45percentage points above the 2008 financial crisis peak.
- 25:50At the same time, prime Auto Loan delinquencies rose to
- 25:53their highest level in 15 years.
- 25:56Conclusion, an auto debt, auto debt crisis is brewing.
- 26:01My first reaction to that was how is it possible that 5% is
- 26:06the highest that subprime auto loan delinquency has ever been?
- 26:11Any thoughts on what I just rambled on about there?
- 26:15Miller: I suspect it's been much, much higher, right.
- 26:17In different times in the past.
- 26:20For credit unions though, that just kind of a side observation is their
- 26:24auto loan delinquency has been creeping up just about every quarter.
- 26:29It's up to one, one now.
- 26:30Um.
- 26:32Just two years ago it was only 63 basis points, so it's doubled in two years.
- 26:37Okay.
- 26:38But credit unions, in 2024, there was no loan growth in the auto segments at all.
- 26:44So their portfolios are not going anywhere.
- 26:47And you know, I think part of it is, is, you know.
- 26:51Car prices are ridiculous and cars are ask lasting a little bit longer.
- 26:57I haven't looked at automotive sales in a while, but, um, only those
- 27:02auto loan portfolios which we're craving breads and butter have not
- 27:06been growing the last couple years.
- 27:09Bauer: Yeah, I think inflation killed the consumer's ability
- 27:13to service all those high costs.
- 27:15Auto loans purchase the.
- 27:17Auto, you know, if you purchased an auto prior to inflation, right?
- 27:20Then all of a sudden, you're up 20%.
- 27:22And with inflation, that's what I can remember experiencing the last
- 27:27year I was at the credit union.
- 27:28You, you saw that that household income drop was impacted significantly
- 27:32and it's probably still impacting a lot of the, the consumers up there.
- 27:37Treichel: Yeah.
- 27:37Makes sense.
- 27:39All right.
- 27:40What, what's, what next on the list there, Mr.
- 27:42Farr?
- 27:43Liquidity.
- 27:43The big L
- 27:44Farrar: liquidity and, and that one I do have to throw to the operational
- 27:48experts on our panel is, uh, that is not my area of expertise, but it is always
- 27:53a, a topic that's, you know, our clients are dealing with quite, quite a bit.
- 27:59So Dennis and Todd,
- 28:02Bauer: yeah.
- 28:02What, what was good to see is the unreal life losses on in the investment portfolio
- 28:07improved significantly year over year.
- 28:10Um.
- 28:11I, I thought I had this number as a percentage of investments, but it's a
- 28:16percentage of assets is what I found.
- 28:18And so that is improved 41 basis points from a year ago for credit unions.
- 28:22I didn't have that for banks.
- 28:24So Right.
- 28:24That helps out that helps out obviously liquidity positions significantly.
- 28:29I think too, right, that just the balance and growth that we're seeing in
- 28:33loans and deposits, right, we're not.
- 28:35We don't have loans.
- 28:37Outstripping deposit growth, though, that's provided some, some relief.
- 28:41So that cash, the cash position for credit unions has remained pretty stable compared
- 28:46to a year ago as a percentage of assets.
- 28:48It's dropped, but probably assets are growing a little bit faster.
- 28:51So that's from a racial perspective that that accounts for the, the racial.
- 28:56But I think it's far as far as cash, if I remember reading that.
- 28:59I think that's up.
- 28:59A significant amount compared to 12 months ago.
- 29:02So from, from what I see, uh, liquidity positions have improved just in general,
- 29:08uh, for credit unions as a whole.
- 29:11Miller: That's in part because now we've had a year and a half shared
- 29:15growth, outpacing loan growth, you know, so cash and on hand is, the
- 29:21ratios haven't really changed much, but they've paid down borrowing money.
- 29:25Um.
- 29:27While those unrealized losses have improved, they're still significant.
- 29:32And you can definitely see that the credit industry thinks interest rates
- 29:36are gonna go down because the piece of investments that grew the most.
- 29:41Yeah.
- 29:41Was that three to five year period the really, I'm surprised that, think back
- 29:46in 2000, let's go do it again in 2025.
- 29:50Bauer: You must think we're at the high end, but yeah, I was surprised
- 29:52to see that that area grow again.
- 29:54Oh my,
- 29:58well, the 10 year rate, it was nice to see the 10 year rates down to around 4%.
- 30:03Um, so I, I would think if that continues, I think the third quarter,
- 30:07which is fast coming to a conclusion, we'll start to see, we'll still continue
- 30:11to see better, um, on realized losses in that portfolio I would assume.
- 30:15Treichel: So they're betting on that 75 basis points to come by
- 30:18going to uh, three to five years.
- 30:19Well, we'll, we're gonna find, you know, we'll do this
- 30:22quarterly hereon until eternity.
- 30:24We'll, uh, we'll just, we'll cut this and we'll play it in a year and go, that
- 30:29was really smart, or that was really not.
- 30:34Oh.
- 30:36Okay.
- 30:36We covered liquidity, we covered, uh, earnings.
- 30:39We covered asset quality.
- 30:41Have we talked about capital?
- 30:42Or Steve?
- 30:43Where are you taking us next on this journey?
- 30:44That,
- 30:45Farrar: that was, uh, the last topic I still had on here.
- 30:48It was capital because that kind of, it, it reflects everything
- 30:52we've talked about previously.
- 30:53Uh, the, the news is good for the industry and banking industry.
- 30:58Both Is that it?
- 30:59It improved in the quarter, uh, you know, for credit union.
- 31:04With the, as you know, net worth growth did outpace asset growth.
- 31:09So that was good.
- 31:10And we, so it did increase, we got 13 basis points in the banks, basically
- 31:14on the same ratio had 10, or the community banks had 10 basis points.
- 31:18So it's nice to see that one growing up.
- 31:20And then the, uh, the risk, risk-based capital increased also, but we have
- 31:24all those credit unions using the.
- 31:26Credit union the complex credit union leverage ratio.
- 31:29So you expect that number to remain, you know, uh, pretty
- 31:33high, and it, it looks good.
- 31:35With that, it feels like, you know, the capital strength of the industry
- 31:39is, is doing well even behind those capitals, but the insurance funds.
- 31:46Both had good quarters, especially the FDIC insurance fund, which kinda
- 31:51sits back there and, you know, that affects their expenses is that that
- 31:55reached the level where they're no longer subject to a, a resolution plan.
- 31:59So the, it increased greatly for them so that, that that's good news for
- 32:04the entire industry, I would say.
- 32:05So capital with both the, in the institutions and in
- 32:09the deposit funds improved.
- 32:13Miller: That's a good, I'll say there is one observation now that's worth
- 32:16noting is, credit unions largely compete against those community banks.
- 32:20And those community banks have about 130 basis points more in
- 32:24that capital than credit unions do.
- 32:26And that gives them a little bit of competitive advantage, you know, and I
- 32:30don't know if we'll see a point where.
- 32:33Subordinated debt grows, you know, back in 2023 it went up about 9%.
- 32:39The last, 18 months, it's only been growing at about 1%.
- 32:43Maybe if rates drop here a little bit, we'll see a little bit more
- 32:48issuance of subordinated debt.
- 32:50Um, certainly I think there's, you know, low income credit unions out there that
- 32:54could still take advantage of that.
- 32:56To a certain degree because loans are still growing.
- 32:59Having a little extra capital always improves your strategic
- 33:05options, so to speak.
- 33:07Treichel: Always good to have options.
- 33:08I think that's a good observation.
- 33:10That rates coming down will create that opportunity.
- 33:13And, and thinking out loud, if credit unions are 130 basis points
- 33:17behind, if we take community bank.
- 33:21Community banks.
- 33:22Okay.
- 33:23Community banks behind community banks.
- 33:25130 basis points, lower net worth ratio credit unions have, is it 230
- 33:30basis points if you discount the N-C-O-S-I-F or did you already do that?
- 33:35Miller: No, I did not discount the N-C-O-I-S-F.
- 33:38So that makes it a little bit bigger difference.
- 33:40It's even now, overall, if you compare 'em against all banks, credit unions
- 33:44have more capital than all banks.
- 33:45But you know that direct competitor, the community bank, the community banks are.
- 33:52More capitalized than the larger banks.
- 33:55And I think a lot of it is their family owned banks too, so.
- 33:58Treichel: Right.
- 34:01Makes sense.
- 34:04What else on capitals, guys?
- 34:09Farrar: I think that's it.
- 34:10Treichel: Any, any last thoughts on, on quarter two?
- 34:16Miller: I just think there's headwinds for the credit unions out there.
- 34:18Like I said, they haven't been able to grow those auto loan portfolios.
- 34:22That growth is in home equity loans and commercial loans.
- 34:26Um, you always.
- 34:29It always makes me nervous when like the banking industry is contracting on a
- 34:33product, so you know, they're shrinking their commercial loans or holding
- 34:36them stable, and that's where they're growing the f within the credit unions.
- 34:40Now, in the big scheme of things, the credit union's market share in that
- 34:43commercial loan area, it's minuscule.
- 34:46I mean, credit unions have six, 7% of their assets in commercial loans.
- 34:51Those banking industries, that's up in that 30 40.
- 34:54So it's a totally different business model, but it always would make me
- 35:00nervous as an examiner supervisor, when you see credit unions growing an area
- 35:05that the banking industry is shrinking, it's like, is your timing really good?
- 35:09Are you getting in this at the exact wrong time?
- 35:12Too many times in history it's like, well, you got in there at the exact wrong time.
- 35:16You know, being as credit union's, market share is small, there probably
- 35:19is a lot of cherry picking going on where they're just picking off
- 35:22some of the absolute best borrowers.
- 35:25Um, but at the same time that delinquency in those commercial
- 35:28portfolios is inching up.
- 35:31And you know, that's a tough one because net charge offs have an inched up.
- 35:35Delinquency has inched up a little bit and you know, how will that play out?
- 35:39Because the resolution timeframe, especially for credits, which it's
- 35:43a lot of commercial real estate, you know, you don't fix that very easily
- 35:49when people start getting behind.
- 35:53Treichel: Great points, Dennis, Steve, any last thoughts?
- 35:57Farrar: I think, you know, I always like, looking forward is that way to
- 36:01try to focus on, and, you know, looking at even some of the pronouncement OC
- 36:04put out and looking forward is this uncertainty that we continue to deal
- 36:09with the market and nobody likes dealing with uncertainty, but, you know, we, you
- 36:14do have, you know, weakening signs that could affect the consumer loans if, uh.
- 36:20Inflation picks up or we hit stagflation.
- 36:23All not good for the loan portfolios.
- 36:26Interest rate uncertainty is certainly elevated and factors in infecting that,
- 36:32that we're not used to dealing with.
- 36:34And, you know, and then, you know, the EVA evolving and complex
- 36:37operating environment is, uh.
- 36:40Is proving to be difficult for some especially not so large credit unions.
- 36:46So lots of uncertainty out there to deal with.
- 36:50Great point, Dennis.
- 36:51Last thought.
- 36:53Bauer: No, it just, in, in general though, credit unions to
- 36:55continue to be well capitalized.
- 36:57Hopefully they're managing credit risk and concentration risks so
- 37:00that they can see some of those.
- 37:03Headwinds coming and, and have proper, have proper risk management in place
- 37:07to, to minimize any, any downturn that we may have in the economy.
- 37:12And I think in general, most credit unions do that.
- 37:13So there's gonna be some outliers.
- 37:15Crane industries remain strong through various cycles, so I would
- 37:19think that would continue throughout.
- 37:22Throughout the next, uh, few years in, in front of us here.
- 37:26Treichel: You got it.
- 37:26And couple of you mentioned headwinds and that made me think of this.
- 37:30I've been listening to a couple of different FinTech podcasts.
- 37:34Uh, one because the guy's just really funny and, and has
- 37:37been teaching me some things.
- 37:39And they have a podcast on once every other month or something where they talk
- 37:43about FinTech companies and they say it's not investment advice, but they find these
- 37:47companies that are doing unique things.
- 37:50And they were talking about one that was in the payments arena.
- 37:54And the guy basically said, this is really cool and I'd like if it
- 37:57was on an app, but I don't know how, how they'll win this market.
- 38:01And he talked it in a concept of are you just surviving or are you winning?
- 38:06And I thought about it when I heard that.
- 38:07I thought about, with mergers and things.
- 38:10And so when I hear headwinds and I think about, possible challenges with.
- 38:14With the economy, MITRE might not happen.
- 38:18Unemployment Mitre might not happen.
- 38:20It's happening a little bit, but then again, the numbers are squishy.
- 38:24Credit unions that are in this survival mode and then they just
- 38:26tap out and they end up verging.
- 38:28Uh, and what are you do, what are you doing to make sure you're, you
- 38:31know, gonna be here 5, 10, 15 years?
- 38:34Uh, I think is probably the biggest challenge that I see
- 38:37financial institutions taking and having to deal with right now.
- 38:41Farrar: Yeah.
- 38:41Another uncertainty, of course, that's gonna affect everybody is that
- 38:44turnover that occurred with all of the banking regulators in terms of.
- 38:49A lot of senior staff is, is departed.
- 38:52Staffing levels are, are lower.
- 38:54So it's, uh, hard to say exactly what the impact of that will be.
- 38:59You'd like to see some gains in efficiency in examinations, not taking quite so
- 39:03many resources from credit unions.
- 39:05But, uh, ex experienced examiners, I think, you know, are, are one
- 39:10of your best resources and a lot of those aren't there anymore.
- 39:14Treichel: Yep.
- 39:15Great point.
- 39:16All right, guys.
- 39:16Well, it the, boy, we're recording this.
- 39:18What is it?
- 39:19Wednesday?
- 39:19This episode will go out Thursday, two days ago, the JJ McCarthy era for the
- 39:24Minnesota Vikings start off to a shaky
- 39:26Bauer: start.
- 39:27Treichel: What's that?
- 39:28Bauer: He was off to a shaky start.
- 39:30Treichel: I don't know.
- 39:30He's the first, first, first time starter to ever have three
- 39:34touchdowns in the fourth quarter.
- 39:35I think you're wrong, Dennis, your Pittsburgh, your Pittsburgh guys
- 39:39have a 42-year-old quarterback.
- 39:41Mike.
- 39:42Mike JJ is only 22 and the Micah Parsons era has started in Green Bay.
- 39:47We'll see.
- 39:49We'll see.
- 39:49We'll see.
- 39:49We'll see.
- 39:49I'll, I'll, I'll.
- 39:50In two years, Dennis, when we check if the commercial loan increases, were good.
- 39:56We'll see where Aaron Rogers is and where JJ McCarthy is.
- 40:01And, and as JJ said where else would you rather be?
- 40:05Miller: Yeah.
- 40:05In Minnesota as a Packer fan, I stopped watching the Chicago, Minnesota
- 40:11game in the third quarter thinking, yes, Minnesota's gonna start the
- 40:14season with a loss, see right away.
- 40:16And then the next day it's like, well, dang, that didn't turn out.
- 40:19The
- 40:19Treichel: way happened.
- 40:20That didn't quite turn out, that didn't quite turn out.
- 40:22He's a, yeah, they have
- 40:23Bauer: these on the NFL, they have these probability charts and I think.
- 40:27I think in the third quarter, Chicago had like a 95% chance of winning the game
- 40:30and um, there was a little questionable call I thought on, on the holding.
- 40:35Yeah, yeah, yeah,
- 40:35Treichel: yeah, yeah, yeah,
- 40:36Bauer: yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 40:37Treichel: Come on, Dennis.
- 40:39Bauer: But the Steelers have the B man, they kick field goals all year long.
- 40:43Treichel: Sure, that's right.
- 40:44Yep.
- 40:44Yep.
- 40:45Well, we will see.
- 40:46And Steve, who are you rooting for this year?
- 40:48Farrar: The referees.
- 40:50Treichel: The referees.
- 40:51Yeah.
- 40:51Let's hope they get it right this year.
- 40:53All right, guys.
- 40:54As always listeners, thank you for listening.
- 40:56I hope you'll listen again soon.
- 40:58Mark TriCal signing off with flying colors.