Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Quick Lubes Beating Dealers, EVs Hold Their Range, US Consumers Want Chinese EVs
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Good morning. It is Monday, April 27th, the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Paul Jay Daly. We have the one and only Todd Caputo on the show. It's been way too long.
- 0:08Today, we're talking about QuickLube's beating dealers, EVs holding their range, and U.S. consumers getting a sneak peek at Chinese EVs from an American YouTuber who has gone to China. It's a fun story.
- 0:19We'll talk about it. Um, Todd, y- you don't look like you're in your normal setting. I'm in a secret, undisclosed location. Yeah, it doesn't look like a terrible place to be.
- 0:29In the, in the state of South Carolina, but that's all I'm telling you. Nothing more. Nothing more? Oh. Nothing more. You, you know, I, I know you've been working on some stuff, so- Yeah...
- 0:37um, in, in the background because it's one of those things. Like, car guys, especially entrepreneur car guys, can never really sit still.
- 0:45You can never get the business out of your blood, and you're always finding new ways, and it's been fun to watch you- Yeah...
- 0:50transition from, you know, having your own group to being a part of a public, and then being, like, determined to help dealers fix problems, whether that's through consulting or this new thing that you're working on.
- 1:01So I'm excited for that. So I'll give you a little, little drip. Okay. All right. Give the people a hint. Right? Yeah. [laughs] So myself and a couple other dealers that have had exits, we started an AI company.
- 1:13We partnered with a very large privately traded group, and, um, we are MVP-ing our first product in one of their Toyota stores as we speak- Oh, my goodness... and this is our first board meeting today.
- 1:26[laughs] Um, and that's all I can tell you at this point. Okay.
- 1:29All I know is this- Well, you said that in the beginning, and then you just told me all that, so maybe if I keep going, you'll tell- Well, that's all I'm gonna say at this point. [laughs] Okay.
- 1:34Like, at some point, I'll probably, we'll talk more about it. Mm-hmm. Um, but I'm really excited about how AI can really help people in car dealerships.
- 1:42I mean, I understand, Paul, and so do you, how difficult it is for people to do all these things that they're supposed to do every day in a dealership. Mm-hmm. It's impossible.
- 1:50It's a business of distractions in a lot of cases. So we are, um, excited to build AI solutions that are not going to replace people. They're going to enhance people.
- 2:00So if you're benching 200, you're gonna be able to bench 300. Oh, well- If you're benching 250, you're gonna be able to bench 450. That's our goal. Whoo. I gotta get to the point where I can bench 200 to start.
- 2:09Well, what, what better- Yeah, me too... what better segue into, into, um, talking about the AutoIndustry.ai Summit and ASOTU CON coming up in under... Well, we're about two weeks away. A little over two weeks still.
- 2:22But, um, basically, we wanna thank our friends at Reynolds and Reynolds and Gubagoo for being presenting sponsors of ASOTU CON this year.
- 2:29But May 12th through 14th, just south of the BWI Airport in Baltimore, a little bit north of the DC airports. You can get there very quickly from all three.
- 2:37We are going to have two days of ASOTU CON and one day of an AI summit. You can get all the info by going to asotucon.com. You can get all the tickets together.
- 2:47If you're already coming to ASOTU CON, it's only, like, 20 bucks to go to the AI summit, too, and that is gonna be an awesome practitioners event the day before ASOTU CON.
- 2:55We have Zach Shefska of CarEdge going to be our keynote.
- 2:58You, you've probably heard us talk about CarEdge quite a bit, and a lot of people, like Todd was saying, in the weeds on AI trying to figure out the best ways it can empower people in the store.
- 3:08We're also, and Kyle t- talked about this on Friday, we're gonna be opening the laptops, doing some live prompting, some building maybe on Lovable.
- 3:15He said, "You will leave this event, if you've never vibe coded, with your first vibe-coded application," because the point is figuring out the things we can build and fix together. So go to asotucon.com.
- 3:26Get your tickets. The hotel may be sold out by now. It's super-duper close. So if you wanna be in the event hotel, you gotta get your tickets soon there. That event is... It's gonna be awesome this year.
- 3:38I look every day on social media, I'm seeing these new people that you've got coming- Yes... who are gonna be presenting and speaking. And, um, you know, look it, the conference is the best.
- 3:48There's no question about it, that you get a lot out of ASOTU CON. It's, you know, it's so different than NADA in a good way, and I'm not saying NADA is bad- No, it's amazing... 'cause it's not.
- 3:58But there's just so much more human interaction and communicating at this conference. And what's awesome is a lot of dealers, a lot of vendors, uh, and a lot of like-minded people. Mm-hmm.
- 4:10And I think that that really is the key, is all the like-minded people that are gonna be there on a lot of relevant topics. It is. So I'm, I'm really excited to be there, Paul. I, I can't wait. Me neither. Me neither.
- 4:20We're, we're so, we're so pumped over here. The ASOTU CON, uh, is, uh, everything is in full effect. I just got in. I don't have one with me, but, um, this is one of my favorite parts.
- 4:29Everything you just said, like the presence and the collaboration of everybody together. It's just a smaller space than, like, the NADA show, and everything's in one...
- 4:37The exhibit hall is kind of the center point of the entire event, where all these conversations happen, and it's very different than your typical trade show floor.
- 4:45Um, there's just so many people working on things, and all of the rooms emp- empty into that area.
- 4:50Um, I'm always super excited, too, about making an event that people have, like, a visceral experience, where they go in, they feel the hospitality right out of the gate.
- 4:58Even what they get, like, um, you don't get your typical swag from, from ASOTU CON, and this year I've curated everything and had some stuff very custom produced. Um, it's all human-based material.
- 5:08So we have these beautiful canvas bags that are, you're gonna want, you're gonna wanna take one home for, for your loved ones, and we got these, like, top grain leather key chains.
- 5:16So we really try to be cohesive with the experience because we feel like that opens people's minds up to, like, think and collaborate and do a little bit more. So there you go. Thanks, Todd.
- 5:25I can't wait to see you next week. I got one more question. Hit me. Are you doing the g- uh, the guitar this year? Are you doing guitars? I think somebody offered to donate the one that they won back. Yes.
- 5:35That's why I wanted to bring it up. So for those that don't remember, I got the first guitar from the first ASOTU CON. It's my favorite one. [laughs] Right? So, um, the, the nonprofit's gonna be, uh- Yeah...
- 5:47the same one as before, right? Yep, Vehicles for Change. Which is awesome. Yeah, so my guitar will be, uh, auctioned off.So it's amazing. Yeah.
- 5:55I think this year, too- And the money's going, the m- I want all the money to go to that nonprofit. So, um, we need to do that. I gotta figure out how I'm gonna get it there, but we'll figure that out afterwards.
- 6:03We'll figure that out. We- we'll figure out logistics after this call. We- we've shipped instruments around and things like that, so you don't- Yeah... have to fly with it. We'll get that done for sure. I can't wait.
- 6:10Yeah, we can't either. And Vehicles for Change, one of the best not-for-profits I've ever been a part of. And we're giving away more cars this year. Last year, it was a real tearjerker.
- 6:17We started giving away cars to families that needed them. It was unbelievable. So, um, yeah, it's gonna be a fun time. We're gonna try to open up the auction to people who aren't at the event this year as well.
- 6:27So we're- we're working on that right now. All right, let's talk about some news. Perfect. Let's talk about some news. Dealership service lanes are losing ground as quick lube shops are quietly gaining share in 2025.
- 6:37This is an automotive news story. New data showing fewer transactions and shrinking revenue for dealers, with pricing strategy emerging as the key battleground to keep service customers loyal.
- 6:48Study analyzes credit and debt transactions, or debit, across all service channels, including dealerships, independents, quick lubes.
- 6:56And tire change and overall service transaction dollars is down 8.3%, but dealers are down 11%, so declining faster.
- 7:05Dealership service transactions dropped 13% year over year, which is the steepest decline amongst all segments tracked, while quick lube shops gain market share while raising prices more slowly than dealerships, attracting more cost-conscious consumers.
- 7:21Um, here's a quote from, uh, let's see, uh, Ducker Carlyle, the data company. Nate Chinaco said, "The quick lubes are what everybody should be worried about."
- 7:31So Todd, you- you- you had independent service, you had franchise service, you've had them all. Yeah. What's your i- what's your input? So, so a couple things.
- 7:38So first of all, I would like to know, like, what they're comparing that to, because when anybody buys a new car, typically there's- there's, uh, free maintenance involved for sometimes it's the first year, uh, 12,000 miles, sometimes it's two year, 24.
- 7:52Depends on the OEM. Mm-hmm. Right? So as a dealer, um, you know, I'll go back to the basics 'cause I'm a basics kind of guy. Um,
- 8:02the way to do it, at least the old school way to do it, was when the customer comes, you schedule them for their appointment the first. Mm-hmm.
- 8:09When they take delivery of the car, you walk 'em up to the service department, you take 'em to the service lane, introduce them to the service advisors so they start to build a relationship.
- 8:17Now, they're gonna come at the beginning because it's free. What we used to do, right, at my stores, is we had a simple coupon book, right? [laughs] And we had it in the deal jacket, and it came in their paperwork. Hmm.
- 8:29So it was in all the intervals for all the services, and we tracked it. And you know what? It worked. Um, most dealerships can definitely compete with quick lubes, right? Mm-hmm. There's no question about it.
- 8:41Most dealerships now are open all hours of the day, um, especially in major metro markets. Saturdays, some dealerships are open on Sundays. I think it's a perception thing really more than anything else.
- 8:52The perception is car dealer service is expensive, car dealer service is inconvenient. Um, and that's not the case at all at most stores, not the stores that have evolved and progressed.
- 9:03So you gotta really look at your marketing really more than anything else. And you also have to look at your menus and bundling packages of services together. Mm-hmm.
- 9:11Um, and again, it's, a lot of it's just perception in my opinion. And you can still get the older cars that are out there, too.
- 9:16And most importantly, like dealerships are just better equipped to service people cars, even for the maintenance. Mm-hmm. I mean, straight up. Oh, for sure.
- 9:23I mean, you got technicians that go through all kinds of schooling, training, technology. And I can tell you a lot of horror stories from customers that went to quick lube places where...
- 9:33Now, I'm not knocking these places, right? I'm not knock, trying to knock- Sure... the people that work there.
- 9:36But I can't tell you how many times somebody went there and the oil filter was not put on properly, and all of a sudden the engine blew. Yeah. Right? And- You definitely have a higher standard at a dealership. For sure.
- 9:45There just seems to be more accountability, less turnover, and a- and all of that.
- 9:48You, I also would say dealerships have increasingly better technology, like when you drive in for the check-in process, tire alignment, all of that tread depth. That happens really fast.
- 9:58I do think you hit on something, the marketing. And I do believe that if you're at all able to, and you have the size and the scale to do it, you need to have and advertise dedicated quick service lanes.
- 10:12I think a lot of dealers have them, but they don't advertise them. And I think when the quick lubes make the headway, one of the big reasons could- could be perception of price.
- 10:21But I think one of the biggest reasons is convenience and the understanding that I can just drive up and wait in line and get my stuff done now, because that's when I have the time, right?
- 10:30And if I have to schedule, I'm out. I can't. Like, 'cause it's Saturday, and I need to get in line somewhere and have it done. Well, that comes back to mystery shopping your website.
- 10:37When someone goes there and they wanna schedule a service appointment- Mm-hmm...
- 10:40look at what the customer actually has to go through to actually set an appointment up, and look at the time slots that are either available or not available. And if, a lot of times I've done this, right? Mm-hmm.
- 10:49When I mystery shop dealerships or I do consulting with them, I'm like, "Wait a minute. I just wanna get an oil change," and it says I can't do it till next week or two weeks from now. Mm-hmm.
- 10:56Who is managing your scheduler? Who is mystery shopping your store? Who's calling and saying, "Hey, I need an oil change," and talking to a BDC person or a service advisor? That stuff is super important.
- 11:05The only other thing I just thought of while you were talking too, Paul, is mobile service, right? Mm-hmm. A lot of dealers are getting involved in mobile service now. Big time. Big time.
- 11:11There's some companies out there that are involved in helping dealers do that. I think that gives dealers an edge, too, if they want to invest in that.
- 11:17And that's not for everybody, but that takes- But it's for a lot of people... people paying more for convenience. It's for a lot of people. It's for a lot of people, though. I, I agree. And it's more and more accessible.
- 11:25Yeah, I totally agree. We're gonna have a lot of conversations around that specifically at ASOTUCON.
- 11:29So if you're just starting or you're dipping your toe in the water, or if you're, like, considering dipping your toe in the water, the best place to talk to some dealers who have done it, thinking about doing, and the companies that enable them to do it, is at ASOTUCON in a couple weeks.
- 11:41I've- I've seen people start m- mobile service from their time at ASOTUCON because they got that last bit of confidence and information that they needed to do it.
- 11:50So if you're considering it, ASOTUCON would be a great place to, like, put those things together. All right, let's talk about- 100%... let's talk about EVs.
- 11:56Um, electric vehicle range is- We're always talking about EVs... always, 'cause I love EVs. Why are we still talking about EVs? Yeah, because they're awesome. Uh, electric vehicle range- They are awesome...
- 12:05isn't fading the way many buyers initially feared.
- 12:08New data from over one billion, with a B, miles of driving shows modern EVs are holding onto their range far better than expected, thanks to both improving battery tech and smarter software.
- 12:20Our friends at Recurrent released this data report showing EVs retaining about 97% of range after three years. That's way better than my iPhone. AndUh, ni- and 95% after five years of ownership.
- 12:33The study's based on real-world driving data factoring in climate, usage, and battery age, not just the EPA estimates. 68% of 2023 model year EVs are still exceeding their original EPA range today.
- 12:46Automakers are offsetting degradation with over-the-air updates and built-in battery buffers that unlock over time. So this feels like a total win for EVs. I, I would agree completely.
- 12:57So- And you've owned an EV, I think... I own an EV. Yeah. Yeah, like, I own an EV, you own an EV. EVs are great, um, for a lot of reasons. We definitely need more infrastructure. Mm-hmm. Right?
- 13:07They need to charge faster, um, and the range needs to get even better. But what you talked about when it comes to the battery degradation, that was the big fear. Yeah. Right?
- 13:15The big fear was, okay, these batteries are not gonna last, they're gonna run out. There's Teslas running with 150, 200,000 miles on them, right?
- 13:24Think you and I know someone in Cazenovia who's a big-time Uber driver- We do... in social media used to work with, right? He's always talking about- Give a shout-out... how great this battery life is... Levi Spires.
- 13:31Go file, follow Levi Spires on LinkedIn, the best. Exactly. Levi- Levi, you- Right. Yes.
- 13:36[laughs] But, you know, I'll tell you the only thing that concerns me, right, from an environmental perspective is what are they gonna do with all these cars and these batteries when the times, comes time to crush these cars when they get old?
- 13:47Well- Like, what are they gonna do with these things? Well, I think there's some solutions that are, that are coming up that gives them a lot more life.
- 13:53Like, we just saw last week or a couple weeks ago Rivian using, um, some batteries that were, like, kind of no longer usable for the vehicle but still had a lot of storage capacity.
- 14:02Maybe not fast charge capacity and maybe they're 60, 70% where that wouldn't really work in the car anymore, but they're stringing these together.
- 14:10Now they're using as battery backup and power, like, power for warehouses and data centers.
- 14:15And Cox Automotive also has a pretty substantial, like, second-life battery, um, I don't know what to call it, a vertical, where they've been doing a lot of research and, and te- technology.
- 14:26So I do think there is a viable option.
- 14:28Now, I don't know how long, how long that goes at that type of usage, but I really do think that that could extend the usable life of everything that we did to manufacture and put together these batteries that are hazardous materials to, like, plug them in for another decade of usable life, and that gives us more time, too, I think, to figure out what to do with the materials.
- 14:46So I see a path there. I see a path there. I hope so, and I think those cars are gonna last a long time. I really do. And a- a- again, like,
- 14:55the problem is if the battery goes, it's almost like it's time to throw the car away, 'cause it's pretty- At that expense... expensive to put the battery in. Oh, for sure. For sure. Yeah, it is. It's too expensive.
- 15:02So, uh, I mean, it remains to be seen. A lot of people are convinced that in 15, 20 years from now every car is gonna be electric. Mm-hmm. Um, I don't know if that's gonna be the case. I think a lot more will be.
- 15:11But, you know, I saw this the other day that Ford is coming out with a truck, um, based on the Lightning, but it's gonna be, like, an extended range EV- Yep... where it's gonna be partially on gas.
- 15:21It's gonna go 7- I saw 700-mile range. Yeah. Did you see that? I mean, Stellantis, Stellantis was the first one, uh, uh, that I saw with this e- Ram REV that was like that. Wow. It's, like, 7, 800 miles. Yeah.
- 15:32And that's, that's why I think that we've seen Scout originally said, "Hey, we're gonna have that version," and now said the majority of the vehicles they produce in the beginning are going to be these EVREVs because that is what consumers are saying they want.
- 15:44Um, so I think, I think that'll be okay. I, I still think there's, like, a lot of complexity once you're having a combustion engine back in.
- 15:51But I think the major constraint in 15, 10, 15, 20 years for us is not going to be consumer adoption or infrastructure. I think it is going to be electricity availability. I think- So I-... with all these warehouses.
- 16:03So I think as we try to figure out how to generate more electricity is really gonna maybe come the ceiling in how fast EVs can be adopted.
- 16:12It's a big vulnerability, but, uh, sure is a l- a lot of fun to watch and, you know, it, it's really hard for me to drive gas vehicles after I drive an EV every day. You get in it and the thing just- Mm-hmm...
- 16:21the thing just feels like a slug. I don't care how fast it is. [laughs] You're right. I agree. All right, uh, speaking of, uh, cutting edge EV technology. Segway time. Last one.
- 16:31This, this one is, uh, one to watch, and I've been seeing stuff about this online.
- 16:35At the Beijing Auto Show, American YouTuber Ethan Robertson, um, of, his handle is Wheelsboy, is giving global audiences a firsthand look at Chinese EVs, helping shift the perception from cheap copycats to serious innovation leaders.
- 16:49He led an international visit, visitor, like, group through Beijing Auto Show, showcasing their latest EVs and tech designs.
- 16:56Perception shifting dramatically with Chinese brands now recognized for advances in battery technology, software, and charging.
- 17:03Attendees highlighting futuristic interiors, features, calling the vehicles a new generation of driving experience.
- 17:10Competitive pricing, though, is the major disruptor here, with fully loaded EVs only costing around $30,000 in US. Um, here's a quote from him on an interview.
- 17:21He said, "Our comment section is full of people saying, 'I can't believe the government won't allow them to sell this car in my country.'" If it did, it would put all the automakers out of business.
- 17:33Yeah, and put it, so- You think about that for a minute. I- Think about that... I have. I was just having this conversation with somebody yesterday at church. They were like- So-... "Why can't we buy these here?"
- 17:41The nicest car that they build, somebody can buy for 30 grand, and for 30 grand right now, you get a nice car, but you're not getting, you're gonna get a used EV.
- 17:50You're not really gonna get a new one, um, because the, you know, the, the, the federal subsidies are gone. You know, at some point, I, I think you're probably gonna end up seeing those cars here.
- 18:02I think it, especially if they're going into Canada, right? They're gonna be d- they're gonna be- Canada and Mexico now... selling those cars in Canada. Yeah. And Mexico, so they're to the north and they're to the south.
- 18:12And I'm pretty familiar with how a lot of cars get imported in the US from Canada especially, a lot of these Canadian cars. Yeah. They're gonna come.
- 18:19Unless they find a way to stop those Canadian or those, those Chinese cars from coming across the border once they hit Canada, it's gonna happen.
- 18:26But, you know, if you buy one of those as a consumer, we're gonna get it fixed.Right? I think that's the big thing, right? Oh, yeah. Wow. There's a lot of work to be done. Mm-hmm.
- 18:33You know, and is it, is it direct to sales model? Is it having franchises? I can't think of any Chinese automaker that's actually been able to set up a franchise network in the US and make it. Not one.
- 18:45There's been a few that have tried- No, no Chinese... and thought about it. No Chinese. But they're Chinese... None of them have done it.
- 18:51You know- And there was, you know, there was talk, like, every, like, every five years at NADA, "Oh, there's this, there's this automaker from Vietnam," or, "There's this automaker from China and they want to open up franchises."
- 19:00But it never, it never actually seems to actually happen. Yeah. Um- I mean, VinFast is, is the only one I can think of that's, that's making some progress, but very slow and still very uncertain.
- 19:09Uh, and then that's Vietnam- Yeah... I believe. Um- Yeah, it's Vietnam. So, so this is a major hot topic of debate lately, especially, um, we were at the New York Auto Forum. We spoke to Senator Bernie Sanders.
- 19:20I'm sorry, Bernie Sanders. Bernie Moreno. Um- There's a big difference there. There is a large difference between those two gentlemen. A huge difference, sir.
- 19:27[laughs] And, um, and Senator Moreno was very emphatic that the new legislation that he's in- introducing is intended to, and he believes it will go through s- uh, legislation that will, to use his words, make sure that we, Chinese automakers are hermetically sealed out of the US market for multiple reasons.
- 19:48Some of the primary reasons, though, are security related, saying the, the Chinese vehicles impose a major security risk in the US.
- 19:57But he also talks about, uh, the manufacturing and the subsidies and how it's not a level playing field. That's what Mike Stanton talks about as well. And so- Sure... there are a lot of complexities.
- 20:06Like, you and I are big-time free market capitalists, and there also is not such a cut-and-dry element when it comes to Chinese automakers. Um, I was... Kyle and I were able to drive several. Michael Cirillo as well.
- 20:18We drove many Chinese auto cars when we were in Kazakhstan, uh, late last year, and they truly are amazing vehicles with amazing technology at amazingly low price points. And it's very difficult, I think.
- 20:30I think it's gonna be very difficult to keep a consumer away from a product that they see as superior. I think the US automakers are focused on keeping, or, like, m- bridging the gap.
- 20:40Jim Farley's been talking about it nonstop lately, saying, "We've, we're, we're back in innovation. We need to catch up." I think it's known that US automakers do that.
- 20:48But this is gonna be one, I don't think, I can't think of a, uh, like, a comparable instance in a comparable industry that, that has ever been a thing, especially at this scale.
- 20:57So I don't know if anybody knows what's gonna happen. Well, 30 grand or less is the sweet spot, right? Affordability is obviously the big issue. Um, I think you're kind of seeing it this month.
- 21:06New car sales aren't great. 30 grand- But it's still okay... but 30 grand is fully loaded. Like- 30, and that's what I'm saying... what, what people don't understand- So-... is, like, the next, like, for, like,
- 21:1517 grand, you can get one that's, like, fine. It's nice. It's basic. A2B. A2B. Mm-hmm. A2B. And it still, it still feels kind of nice and clean, right? Not a lot of- Yeah.
- 21:24A- a- and Paul, I'll be curious to see how Slate does, Slate Auto- Mm-hmm... with those, those little trucks they're gonna build. Yep, yep. Um, I don't know when they're coming out.
- 21:32They're saying maybe it's another year. Yeah. But that's 30 grand, give or take- Mm-hmm... right? For a small little pickup truck or a little SUV. Very bare bones. Right. And it's very bare bones.
- 21:40Um, I, you know, I guess it remains to be seen. Um, but you know, again, what I would say is if you're, if you're a franchise dealer in the US, um, it's just like anything else.
- 21:51There's always gonna be something coming at you every day. There's always gonna be a disruptor. There's always gonna, whether it's technology, AI, Chinese EVs- Mm-hmm... quick lubes, it doesn't matter.
- 21:59Like, you just gotta be ready for anything. You don't know what you're gonna wake up to, especially on a Monday morning in the car business. That's right.
- 22:04And even so, like, EVs are one thing, but I think affordability still is going to be the main driver, no matter what drivetrain it has in it.
- 22:12And if the automakers, US automakers can fix that via a ice engine or an EV, I think that really is what's gonna drive adoption. Todd, thank you so much for joining us- Thanks for having me... on the show today.
- 22:22I can't wait to be with you in just a couple of weeks at ASOTU CON. Everybody, remember, asotucon.com. Get your tickets. Come to ASOTU CON. Hang out with everybody, and then make your business better.
- 22:33[upbeat music]