Latest / KAJ Business & Money LIVE / Looking from a Legal Angle the closure of the 2002 case against PM Modi
Transcript
- 0:11Speaker 1: Welcome to this very special edition of the KJ Masterclass Live,
- 0:15Speaker 1: the show which ensures that you profit from your time
- 0:17Speaker 1: spent here with experts either through their industry insights, information,
- 0:22Speaker 1: or simply learning from them. Before I move forward, may
- 0:26Speaker 1: I request you to subscribe, follow, like, and comment on
- 0:29Speaker 1: whichever platform you are watching or listening to this show on.
- 0:34Speaker 1: And today, we have Supreme Court Senior Advocate Vivek Sood, sir,
- 0:39Speaker 1: And we'll be talking on the closure of allegations against
- 0:42Speaker 1: Prime Minister Narendra Modi in the 2002 case.
- 0:46Speaker 2: Welcome to the show, sir.
- 0:49Speaker 1: Talking about the Supreme Court verdict quitting the Prime Minister
- 0:54Speaker 1: of the 2002 case.
- 0:57Speaker 2: Tell us about this. The genesis of this case.
- 1:01Speaker 3: Is 27th February 2002. the Sabarmati Express, the train was
- 1:11Speaker 3: returning from Ayodhya and at the Godra railway station at
- 1:20Speaker 3: about 7.45 a.m. morning, you know, the train was carrying
- 1:26Speaker 3: car-sevaks from Ayodhya to Gujarat and the train was set
- 1:32Speaker 3: on fire. 58 Innocents were charred to death. Now following this.
- 1:44Speaker 2: This incident. There were. Incidents of violence. In the state
- 1:51Speaker 2: of Gujarat.
- 1:53Speaker 3: Amongst those various. Incidents of violence. There was this. Gulberg
- 1:59Speaker 3: society case.
- 2:02Speaker 2: Where 69. Muslims. were killed.
- 2:09Speaker 3: Now this is all documented in the Supreme Court judgment
- 2:13Speaker 3: that has come recently in the month of June.
- 2:18Speaker 2: This is not my statement of the facts.
- 2:21Speaker 3: I have taken the facts from the Supreme Court judgment
- 2:24Speaker 3: as it is. Now the investigation was initiated into various cases.
- 2:34Speaker 3: And then the National Human Rights Commission filed a writ
- 2:40Speaker 3: petition in the Supreme Court that the investigation should be fair,
- 2:47Speaker 3: it should be honest, it should be competent, it should
- 2:50Speaker 3: be scientific so that the culprits are prosecuted effectively. The
- 2:58Speaker 3: Supreme Court on 26th March 2008 formed a special investigation
- 3:08Speaker 3: team to investigate these cases effectively. And may I tell you, Ajay,
- 3:19Speaker 3: the special investigation team consisted of Mr. R. K. Raghavan,
- 3:27Speaker 3: retired CBI director, Mr. C. B. Satpati, retired Director General
- 3:36Speaker 3: of Police from Uttar Pradesh, Geeta Johri, Sivanand Jha, and
- 3:46Speaker 3: Ashish Bhatia, these rank police officers. Now the Supreme Court
- 3:55Speaker 3: appointed this SIT, Special Investigation Team, to effectively investigate All conspiracies,
- 4:06Speaker 3: you know, because there were allegations against the top people
- 4:14Speaker 3: in power, top level police officers, ministers. There were allegations
- 4:22Speaker 3: against the then Chief Minister of Gujarat, Shri Narendra Modi
- 4:29Speaker 3: as well.
- 4:30Speaker 2: Now this SIT, investigated.
- 4:36Speaker 3: All the angles of the allegations against the top level ministers,
- 4:46Speaker 3: including the Honourable Chief Minister, then police officers, etc.
- 4:51Speaker 2: etc.
- 4:53Speaker 3: That investigation took place. And that investigation is recorded in
- 5:01Speaker 3: the Supreme Court judgment. Of June 2022. Hundreds of witnesses
- 5:11Speaker 3: were examined. Thousands of documents were examined during the investigation.
- 5:21Speaker 2: If I may say so.
- 5:23Speaker 3: With 30 years of experience on the criminal side. An
- 5:30Speaker 3: in-depth investigation was conducted. by the special investigative team and
- 5:38Speaker 3: they arrived at the conclusion based on evidence, based on documents,
- 5:46Speaker 3: based on recorded statements, based on call detail records, they
- 5:55Speaker 3: came to the conclusion that there was no larger conspiracy.
- 6:02Speaker 3: Chief Minister of Gujarat, Shri Narendra. The investigation was on
- 6:07Speaker 3: the complainant Zakia Jaffrey from the Gulberg Society had also petitioned,
- 6:18Speaker 3: had also filed her complaint and the matter went up
- 6:23Speaker 3: to the Supreme Court.
- 6:25Speaker 2: Now in her complaint, she.
- 6:28Speaker 3: Levelled allegations against the high and mighty, the top ministers, etc.
- 6:39Speaker 2: Now the Supreme Court.
- 6:43Speaker 3: Referred that complaint to the special investigation team, the SIT.
- 6:51Speaker 3: And the Supreme Court, way back in 2009, directed the
- 6:54Speaker 3: SIT to to look into this complaint as well and
- 7:05Speaker 3: probe and investigate whether there was a larger conspiracy involving
- 7:15Speaker 3: the Honourable then Chief Minister Mr.
- 7:18Speaker 2: Narendra Modi and the other ministers.
- 7:24Speaker 3: Now after a detailed investigation, an in-depth investigation The judgment
- 7:31Speaker 3: of the Honorable Supreme Court runs into about 300 pages.
- 7:36Speaker 2: I have gone through the judgment in detail. After an.
- 7:43Speaker 3: In-depth investigation, it has been found by the SIT that
- 7:51Speaker 3: there was no larger conspiracy. No involvement of the then
- 7:58Speaker 3: Honourable Chief Minister Mr.
- 8:00Speaker 2: Narendra Modi.
- 8:03Speaker 3: The allegations levelled by these officers, B. Shri Kumar, Sanjeev Bhatt.
- 8:17Speaker 2: And Mr.
- 8:18Speaker 3: Harain Pandya, the allegations levelled by these three persons, have
- 8:26Speaker 3: been found to be patently false. They are not in
- 8:33Speaker 3: the realm of doubt. The SIT has found their evidence
- 8:41Speaker 3: to be false. Final report of the SIT was placed
- 8:47Speaker 3: before the magistrate.
- 8:51Speaker 2: The magistrate after applying his mind.
- 8:56Speaker 3: Has found the investigation by the SIT and its report
- 9:03Speaker 3: to be correct. So there has been judicial application of
- 9:10Speaker 3: mind at level one. Then the matter is taken to
- 9:16Speaker 3: the High Court of Gujarat. The High Court of Gujarat,
- 9:23Speaker 3: by a speaking order, by a speaking judgment, After appreciating
- 9:29Speaker 3: and analyzing the SIT report and the closure of the
- 9:36Speaker 3: case by the magistrate.
- 9:39Speaker 2: Has found the SIT report to be correct.
- 9:46Speaker 3: Level 2 judicial application of mind has taken place. The
- 9:53Speaker 3: matter travels to the Supreme Court. and the supreme God
- 9:59Speaker 3: are deeply analyzing the SIT report the appreciation of the
- 10:06Speaker 3: report by the magistrate.
- 10:10Speaker 2: The deep appreciation of the same.
- 10:14Speaker 3: By the Gujarat High Court and after independently examining the
- 10:22Speaker 3: SIT report threadbare in detail. It has found the SIT
- 10:30Speaker 3: report to be correct and therefore the clean chit given
- 10:36Speaker 3: to the then Chief Minister Shri Narendra Modi, now the
- 10:43Speaker 3: Honorable Prime Minister of India has been upheld. And may
- 10:48Speaker 3: I tell you Ajay, It is not on the basis
- 10:53Speaker 3: of benefit of doubt that the clean chit has been given.
- 10:59Speaker 3: The allegations by Zakia Jafri and Teesta Seetalwad have been
- 11:06Speaker 3: found to be patently false. The evidence that was sought
- 11:11Speaker 3: to be set up by Sanjeev Bhatt, Harain Pandya, now deceased,
- 11:18Speaker 3: and R. B. Shrikumar, has been found to be false.
- 11:27Speaker 3: Not benefit of doubt. There is a distinction between benefit
- 11:31Speaker 3: of doubt and making false allegations, fabricated allegations. So the
- 11:38Speaker 3: Supreme Court, comprising of three honorable judges, has found the
- 11:44Speaker 3: SIT report to be absolutely correct. Right, sir.
- 11:51Speaker 1: Like with Other cases, many cases, people have their own
- 11:55Speaker 1: points of view about the outcome, about the verdict, any verdict.
- 11:59Speaker 1: And you can always look at any verdict in your
- 12:02Speaker 1: own manner.
- 12:02Speaker 2: Now, here a lot of people have.
- 12:05Speaker 1: Expressed happiness and there are quite a number of people
- 12:08Speaker 1: also criticizing the verdict. Help us understand in terms of
- 12:12Speaker 1: as a common man, what should I make of it?
- 12:14Speaker 3: First of all, every citizen enjoys the freedom of speech
- 12:20Speaker 3: and expression.
- 12:22Speaker 2: In our country.
- 12:24Speaker 3: People have a right to speak. People have a right
- 12:27Speaker 3: to criticize. But may I. Point out. That before. Criticizing
- 12:36Speaker 3: this verdict. Please read the verdict. It's a 300 plus.
- 12:45Speaker 3: Pages verdict. Where every argument. Raised by. Zakia Jaffrey and
- 12:55Speaker 3: Teesta Seethalwad and others has been considered on merits by
- 13:02Speaker 3: the Supreme Court.
- 13:06Speaker 2: In my view, it is investigated.
- 13:11Speaker 3: The investigation in this case was conducted by a high-powered SIT.
- 13:21Speaker 3: under the monitoring of the Supreme Court of India. May
- 13:25Speaker 3: I tell you that the SIT was appointed in 2008.
- 13:30Speaker 3: The investigation concluded in a final report, in a closure
- 13:38Speaker 3: report by the SIT in 2012 or something like that.
- 13:46Speaker 3: The BJP government was not in power at that point
- 13:49Speaker 3: of time. The SIT comprised of high-ranking independent police officers.
- 14:02Speaker 3: Now to question the SIT report in the media is
- 14:06Speaker 3: not fair. It has been questioned before the magistrate's court.
- 14:14Speaker 3: The magistrate applied his mind, found the report to be correct.
- 14:21Speaker 2: The matter was taken to the Gujarat High Court.
- 14:25Speaker 3: The SIT report was re-examined by the Gujarat High Court,
- 14:30Speaker 3: found to be correct.
- 14:33Speaker 2: Then the matter travels to the Supreme Court of India.
- 14:36Speaker 3: Again, the SIT report is examined threadbare.
- 14:42Speaker 2: In an open public forum, the court of law.
- 14:46Speaker 3: And the apex court has found the SIT judgment to
- 14:51Speaker 3: be absolutely correct. Now in this scenario, you know, we
- 14:58Speaker 3: live in a country where there is rule of law.
- 15:04Speaker 2: We as citizens of India must respect.
- 15:12Speaker 3: A report by an SIT appointed by the Supreme Court,
- 15:18Speaker 3: monitored by the Supreme Court, And the report has been.
- 15:24Speaker 2: Judicially examined at three levels.
- 15:29Speaker 3: We must as citizens, we must understand the concept of
- 15:35Speaker 3: rule of law.
- 15:37Speaker 2: There is a legal process. The legal process.
- 15:44Speaker 3: Has found the SIT report to be correct and the
- 15:49Speaker 3: allegations to be patently false. Now as citizens of India,
- 15:55Speaker 3: we must respect the three levels of the judiciary. So
- 16:03Speaker 3: this criticism in my view is totally misconceived. Having said so,
- 16:12Speaker 3: people have the right to freedom of speech and expression.
- 16:17Speaker 2: They have the right to criticize the judgment.
- 16:20Speaker 3: But may I tell you, After three decades of experience
- 16:25Speaker 3: on the criminal side, and now as a senior counsel,
- 16:30Speaker 3: having examined the judgment in detail, I find that the
- 16:37Speaker 3: judgment is meritorious, well-reasoned, and therefore, all criticism of this
- 16:47Speaker 3: verdict is nothing but political.
- 16:52Speaker 2: And totally misconceived in nature. Right, sir.
- 16:58Speaker 1: And how do you use these letters being sent to
- 17:01Speaker 1: the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of India?
- 17:05Speaker 2: How do you look at that?
- 17:05Speaker 3: People have the right to respond and write letters, but
- 17:12Speaker 3: as a lawman, there is only one remedy. If this
- 17:17Speaker 3: verdict of the Supreme Court is to be challenged and
- 17:23Speaker 3: that remedy is to file a review petition before the
- 17:31Speaker 3: Supreme Court. This kind of letter writing is not part
- 17:40Speaker 3: of the legal process. It is extraneous to the legal process.
- 17:47Speaker 3: It amounts to bro beating It has no legal sanctity.
- 17:55Speaker 3: But people have a right to write letters to the
- 18:00Speaker 3: Honourable Chief Justice of India. But there is no substance
- 18:06Speaker 3: in these letters. These letters are not part of the
- 18:12Speaker 3: legal process, the due process of law. The only remedy
- 18:18Speaker 3: is to file a review petition against the verdict of
- 18:22Speaker 3: the Supreme Court.
- 18:26Speaker 2: The action against Krista Sattelwaad and others. Tell us about that. Normally,
- 18:31Speaker 2: you don't find this sort of thing happening.
- 18:33Speaker 3: If you read the Supreme Court verdict, the Supreme Court
- 18:40Speaker 3: has said in clear terms that the allegations are false.
- 18:48Speaker 3: The allegations have been leveled to sensationalize.
- 18:55Speaker 2: A dead horse. It's like flogging a dead horse.
- 19:01Speaker 3: The allegations are politically motivated when the Supreme Court has
- 19:08Speaker 3: found the allegations to be patently false. And when the
- 19:16Speaker 3: Supreme Court says that the allegations are politically motivated and
- 19:24Speaker 3: they have been leveled only to sensationalize this case as
- 19:30Speaker 3: a natural fallout of the Supreme Court verdict. Action has
- 19:36Speaker 3: been taken against Tista, Seethalwad and others. Again, they have
- 19:44Speaker 3: a remedy. They have a right to apply for bail
- 19:48Speaker 3: They have a right to file a petition for quashing
- 19:52Speaker 3: of the proceedings etc. So the legal remedies are available
- 19:59Speaker 3: to them. However, in my view, keeping in view the
- 20:08Speaker 3: observations and findings of the Supreme Court in this case,
- 20:14Speaker 3: action taken against Teesta Seethalwad and others.
- 20:21Speaker 2: Cannot be said to be misconceived. It is.
- 20:29Speaker 3: A consequence of this verdict which has come out very
- 20:35Speaker 3: strongly against the falsity of these allegations. The Supreme Court
- 20:44Speaker 3: has upheld the SIT report which concludes that Harin Pandya,
- 20:55Speaker 3: Sanjeev Bhatt and Sride fabricated allegations to falsely implicate the
- 21:03Speaker 3: then Chief Minister Mr.
- 21:06Speaker 2: Narendra Modi and others.
- 21:10Speaker 3: Now when you have observations like these in a Supreme
- 21:14Speaker 3: Court verdict, consequence these accused, Tista, Seethalwad and others, they
- 21:23Speaker 3: have judicial remedies available to them. They can apply for bail,
- 21:32Speaker 3: they can file for washing of the proceedings, etc. So,
- 21:37Speaker 3: the rule of every citizen of the country, from top
- 21:43Speaker 3: to bottom.
- 21:46Speaker 2: Right, sir.
- 21:46Speaker 3: Right.
- 21:47Speaker 1: Now, again as a common man, what should the common
- 21:50Speaker 1: man understand out of the post-verdict actions that has taken?
- 21:56Speaker 1: Should a man, a person, whether acquitted by the trial
- 22:02Speaker 1: court or any other court of the country, feels that
- 22:06Speaker 1: there was an abuse of the due process of law
- 22:09Speaker 1: by whichever party, either from the investigating side, from the police,
- 22:14Speaker 1: from the prosecution side, or whoever it is. Do they
- 22:18Speaker 1: have the same legal remedy or right available to them
- 22:23Speaker 1: and they ask for actions to be taken against those
- 22:26Speaker 1: people who put the person into so much of trouble.
- 22:31Speaker 2: Is it the same for everybody? Yes.
- 22:36Speaker 3: The key takeaway from this case for the common man
- 22:42Speaker 3: is let us respect the conclusions arrived at by investigative agencies,
- 22:55Speaker 3: especially the SIT in this case, Comprising of top police
- 23:04Speaker 3: officers with monitoring by the Supreme Court. Let us respect
- 23:10Speaker 3: it as citizens of India. Let us respect judicial verdicts. Otherwise,
- 23:18Speaker 3: there will be chaos in the society. That is one. Secondly,
- 23:28Speaker 3: The law is applicable to one and all. Be you
- 23:33Speaker 3: ever so high, the law is above you. The law
- 23:37Speaker 3: applies consistently to every citizen. Consistency is the ornament of justice.
- 23:47Speaker 2: So, even in.
- 23:51Speaker 3: Common cases involving commoners, many a times it is said
- 23:58Speaker 3: In the verdict of acquittal.
- 24:01Speaker 2: That there was false implication.
- 24:03Speaker 3: Of the accused. An action be taken. Against the police officers.
- 24:09Speaker 3: Or the complainant. Or the witnesses. Who committed perjury. Or
- 24:16Speaker 3: concocted part of the legal system. It is not an
- 24:19Speaker 3: exceptional case. Where the supreme court. Has made such strong observations.
- 24:26Speaker 3: Against the complainant. It happens every day in the criminal
- 24:31Speaker 3: justice system. An action is initiated against the complainant or
- 24:39Speaker 3: the police officers involved in falsely implicating the accused.
- 24:45Speaker 2: It is not an.
- 24:46Speaker 3: Exceptional verdict that has come from Jupiter or Mars.
- 24:52Speaker 2: It is very much part of the legal system in India.
- 24:57Speaker 3: False implication has its legal consequences in many cases that
- 25:04Speaker 3: we come across on a day-to-day basis. They may not
- 25:07Speaker 3: be reported in the media, but they are part of
- 25:12Speaker 3: the criminal justice system in India.
- 25:17Speaker 2: Right, sir.
- 25:17Speaker 1: So, in this particular case, sir, what is the message
- 25:21Speaker 1: even for police officers who are such an integral part
- 25:26Speaker 1: of the justice delivery system.
- 25:28Speaker 3: The message that flows out of this case for police
- 25:33Speaker 3: officers at large is this this case is a template
- 25:39Speaker 3: fair and scientific investigation police officers must read this case
- 25:47Speaker 3: from an investigative perspective the hard work that was put
- 25:53Speaker 3: in by the SIT, the number of witnesses examined by them,
- 26:02Speaker 3: their analysis of the investigation, the thousands of documents that
- 26:07Speaker 3: were appreciated, examined.
- 26:12Speaker 2: So this case is an example of.
- 26:17Speaker 3: Exemplary investigation by the SIT in my view. The in-depth
- 26:27Speaker 3: investigation that was conducted should serve as an example for
- 26:34Speaker 3: police officers, for younger officers who are called upon to
- 26:39Speaker 3: investigate cases day in and day out. What is scientific investigation?
- 26:47Speaker 3: What is fair investigation? What is deep investigation? The SIT
- 26:53Speaker 3: report is a classic example of exemplary investigation in my view.
- 27:05Speaker 2: Okay, sir.
- 27:06Speaker 1: Now, the larger aspect of this particular case, sir, a
- 27:09Speaker 1: lot of NGOs work in different fields and they keep
- 27:13Speaker 1: on providing information to different agencies, including the police, especially
- 27:19Speaker 1: related to children and a lot of other domestic violence
- 27:22Speaker 1: and abuse cases.
- 27:24Speaker 2: So in those cases, Are the NGOs to think.
- 27:28Speaker 1: That they have to investigate any wrong that is going on?
- 27:32Speaker 1: Do they understand that the police will take care of
- 27:35Speaker 1: whatever evidence or information that they provide in the work
- 27:39Speaker 1: that they are.
- 27:41Speaker 2: Doing?
- 27:42Speaker 3: See, NGOs, whistleblowers, sting operations are part of our system. Right.
- 27:52Speaker 2: Let's not wish them away. Right.
- 27:56Speaker 3: However, they have their role to play but investigation is
- 28:03Speaker 3: the domain of the law enforcement agencies.
- 28:09Speaker 2: They can.
- 28:11Speaker 3: Assist the investigative agency or they can question the investigative
- 28:17Speaker 3: agency but there has to be a Laxman Rekha between
- 28:23Speaker 3: the role of an investigator and the role of an NGO.
- 28:29Speaker 3: The judiciary has its role to play. NGOs have their
- 28:35Speaker 3: role to play. But they should not interfere in the
- 28:40Speaker 3: investigative process or the judicial process. They can act as
- 28:48Speaker 3: facilitators or they can act as checks and balances in
- 28:56Speaker 3: the system.
- 28:57Speaker 2: With this, it's a wrap on this edition of the
- 28:59Speaker 2: KJ Masterclass.