Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Age Difference in Relationships (2017 Rerun)
Transcript
- 0:01Still so Roberto, off the top of your head, what kind of thoughts
- 0:10do you have about big age differences in marriages, you know, where one
- 0:15person is a lot older, like ten, fifteen years, twenty years.
- 0:21What are some of your thoughts about that. I think that there's a nice
- 0:25safe zone where if both people are adults and they're like you know, I
- 0:32think it's somewhere between mid twenties to maybe mid forties. I think there's a
- 0:39nice splash zone where I wouldn't be too bothered by anything. Meaning what like
- 0:43if the lowest person in the relationship is like twenty five and the highest one
- 0:48is like forty five, I wouldn't even raise an eyebrow. What if there
- 0:52were twenty five fifty five. Yeah, that's so when the gap starts broadening
- 0:57beyond that safe zone, Like, well, it's interesting that you're in your
- 1:00forties, you know, I just want to point sure, right right,
- 1:03But I think I I'm just going more from like when I look at a
- 1:10mid to late twenty year old and when I look at people our age,
- 1:14there's a lot of course there's like twenty years life experience in there, but
- 1:18like they feel compatible socially. What about like thirty five fifty five. I
- 1:25gotta say, when I was thirty five, I didn't feel like I could
- 1:30relate as much to people in their fifties and sixties. So it sounds like
- 1:34you have like a cutoff point, like at forty five you become an old
- 1:38person. Yeah, and you shouldn't frat and Rice. There's like basically everyone
- 1:42older than you is like out of the picture, right exactly. So now
- 1:47when I turn forty five, it's different because it's a moving range for me.
- 1:49Yeah, well, okay, so what are the problems with it?
- 1:53Exactly? So a fifty five twenty five was the problem? Well, I
- 1:59guess I think that there's a lot of relationships might have happened for one person
- 2:05not the other. There have been there There could be a real big imbalance
- 2:10in life goals at that point, like maybe one of them wants to have
- 2:14kids, the other one has no interest anymore in having kids. Maybe one
- 2:17of them already had several kids and his way past that stage in their life.
- 2:22There could also be very different professional goals or you know, like retirement
- 2:27goals and things like that, not between twenty five and forty No, no,
- 2:30no, it's of course it can still happen. But I'm saying instantly,
- 2:32like if we drew it in a graph, I think there would be
- 2:37less less of those issues. The closer to that middle, Like if they're
- 2:42both thirty, there're probably be very few of those issues, And the further
- 2:46they get away from thirty on each direction, you'll start seeing more of those
- 2:49issues pop up. Does society have a similar viewpoint as you do? I
- 2:53think so, yeah. I mean, prob it sounds like you're a little
- 2:58bit more liberal about it a little bit. But for example, I think
- 3:00most folks in modern culture would see like a twenty one year old and a
- 3:07fifty year old as somewhat problematic, and then somewhat I would think they would
- 3:12consider it massive mess problem. Yeah, and then there's certainly some gaps that
- 3:15would be considered flat out unacceptable, like, hey, a seventeen year old
- 3:20is marrying a forty year old, you know, stuff like that, Right,
- 3:23So it kind of depends on how old the youngest vers is. So
- 3:25a recent event in the media Stephen fry Do you know Stephen Frye, the
- 3:30English British guy? He married a or is he's with a guy who's thirty
- 3:37years younger? Than him Elliott Spencer, and the media is calling Stephen Frye
- 3:43a pedophile and a pervert for is he an underage kid? No, he's
- 3:50He's an adult. Elliott Spencer's an adult, a pedophile and a pervert and
- 3:54a dirty old man. I don't even understand how pedophile would apply. Yeah.
- 4:00Well, I also have worked with clients who are and have been in
- 4:05the closet about their relationships that they're in that have big age differences. There's
- 4:12a lot of shame about it, right, and research has shown that age
- 4:16gaps can result in couples feeling marginalized. I see, you know, similar
- 4:21to mixed race couples. By the way, what are we listening to right
- 4:26now? This is the Psychology and Seattle podcast. I'm your host, doctor
- 4:30Kirk Honda. I'm a therapist, a professor, and someone who forgets about
- 4:33introductions. Oh man, my name is Umberto Cast and I administer personality tests
- 4:40for job applicants. So the main questions here are I should speculate, I
- 4:45should I should specify that you don't do that, because that's ain Whenever you
- 4:47say a clinical job, I just have to clarify that. Do you know
- 4:51that in a different episode. You pointed out that I had never held that
- 4:56job, and I said, well maybe someday, because you know, you're
- 5:01the lay person. Other person, Well, I don't do it officially.
- 5:05It's it's like the training when someone is going to take them officially, I
- 5:10give them just like you know, little training ones. So you just stop
- 5:13people on the way into a business and you're like, are you applying for
- 5:15a job, And you're like, I'm gonna I'm gonna do a I'm gonna
- 5:18do my own version of personality that sounds more official than what I do,
- 5:21which is stand on corners and pester people. Yeah. So the questions that
- 5:26I have for us today berto are the following. Is there an actual problem
- 5:31with age differences? Is there an actual empirical science based problem with age differences?
- 5:40Question number two? Does age difference predict longevity of a relationship? Okay,
- 5:46you know, what are the trends in different cultures? And does evolution
- 5:51play a role? So we're going to get into that. Oh interesting,
- 5:56So in pop culture, what are the terms for people of age that you
- 6:00know? You got your cougars? Cougars? What else? Well, there's
- 6:03the whole cradle robber. Yeah, and I don't know what an old guy
- 6:10is called sugar daddy. Oh yeah, sugar daddy. Okay, yeah,
- 6:15a pedophile. Well that's extreme. But see, I don't understand why those
- 6:18are being grouped here. Well you got sugar mama, you got gold diggers,
- 6:25you got trophy wives. And you know, by the way this goes
- 6:28back to you know how I was talking about a safe zone. If you
- 6:30show me a person, an adult that's around eighteen to twenty one years old,
- 6:35and you show me an adult that's around let's say up to forty,
- 6:40right, maybe even forty five, there are not significant biological differences like where
- 6:46you're like, those are incompatible organisms, you know. But as soon as
- 6:50you start looking at kids and teenagers, then you start seeing like, well
- 6:55that looks that looks like a young specimen, Like that doesn't look but adults
- 6:59there's a nice long and there are eighteen year olds that look like thirty year
- 7:02olds, and there are forty year olds that look like twenty five year olds.
- 7:05Right, so there's a long there's a gray zone there. Okay,
- 7:10you also got boy toy and I think in the lesbian community they call them
- 7:15panthers and kittens, and you have like cubs in the gay community, and
- 7:21apparently they call him manthers. So if you're an older gay guy, you're
- 7:27a manther. I see maanther in a cub. Okay, what about the
- 7:30different rules that you have? You know, what's the rule of thumb that
- 7:36dominates our society and you know pop culture in America today? I think that
- 7:43usually people expect an older, wealthy guy with a young gal and they they
- 7:49are surprised or do not expect an older gal with a young guy. Right,
- 7:56But what's the rule of thumb? Like there's a there's a guideline,
- 7:59a mathematic equation that we're supposed to We've talked about the podcasts before, I
- 8:03think with Mandy, like years ago. Oh do you remember do you remember
- 8:07this rule? Well? I remember when we were talking about like age of
- 8:11consent and things like that, like no three years of difference. Now there's
- 8:13like a there's a rule that people follow in today's world. I forget them.
- 8:18It's the half your age plus seven rule. Oh and I don't remember
- 8:20this, Okay, half your age plus seven. I could have swear we
- 8:22talked about. Maybe we did, but I just didn't remember that. Yeah.
- 8:26So so what how old are you, Burdo, I'm forty two.
- 8:30And what's half of that? Twenty one and add seven twenty eight, So
- 8:35eight twenty eight, twenty eight year olds or younger is the rule. Oh,
- 8:39I can date twenty eight or younger. Yeah, I just joking,
- 8:41sweet, So twenty eight or older is the rule. And so what about
- 8:46your the person you could date who's older than you, So that would be
- 8:50minus seven of thirty five. And then so seventy seventy seventy yeah, so
- 9:01seventy so you could date from twenty eight to seventy. No, no,
- 9:05from that doesn't work. It doesn't, it doesn't. See that's what I
- 9:07was talking about that there was a good splash zone. But no, I
- 9:13can't date a seventy year old. Why that doesn't work? Why we are
- 9:18very at significantly different biological stages of life. Okay, so it needs to
- 9:22be more of a log rhythmic rhythmic scale, not a not a straight equation.
- 9:30And here's a very important consideration. And it sucks, right, but
- 9:33men can have babies a lot longer than women can. Yeah, and that's
- 9:39that's gotta be. That's that plays a role. Well, we'll get into
- 9:41that in a second. So I read the origins of this half your age
- 9:46plus seven rule, and they're they're not quite sure where it comes from,
- 9:50but they do know that it shows up in the literature like one or two
- 9:54hundred years ago as a guide for something else. Do you know what that
- 9:58was? Marriage? Yeah? Okay, So for men, they were like,
- 10:05the ideal age of your wife is half your age plus seven. So
- 10:09the thing is is, like most men one hundred years ago would be thinking
- 10:13about be you know, getting married around like twenty and so seventeen I guess
- 10:20is is so I guess the lower you get, the less problematic. Well,
- 10:24the plus seven is accounting for no, you're not getting to marry a
- 10:28child, right, right. So there's another rule that that Dan Savage put
- 10:35forth. Do you know what that's called? No, it's called the campsite
- 10:39rule. Can you think about what that would mean? The campsite rule?
- 10:43Well, like, see like a campsite. What's the rule of a campsite
- 10:48When you when you go into the woods, you know, in a park,
- 10:50and you have a campsite, you have to clean up after yourself,
- 10:56right exactly. So it's when when there's a large age disparity. At the
- 11:01end of the relationship, the older partner should leave the younger person in better
- 11:05shape than they found them. Okay, I like it. So in other
- 11:09words, like no diseases, no unwanted pregnancies, no emotional trauma. Interesting,
- 11:15So Dan Savage is like, because in the gay community it's much more
- 11:18acceptable to talk about these age differences than the heterosexual community. Huh. My
- 11:24hypothesis about that is a couple of reasons, and I think other people share
- 11:28these points of view. Is one, gay people traditionally have had have been
- 11:35marginalized as something abnormal and strange by society for you know, hundreds of years,
- 11:41and so therefore they're freer to some extent to choose how they want to
- 11:46how they want to act, you know, and what sort of rules they
- 11:50want to have in their community, you know what I mean, because because
- 11:52the dominant American society has already rejected them, and so they're like, well,
- 11:58we can sort of make up our own rules, you know, And
- 12:00so they just had more flexibility in that area. The other is that there's
- 12:05a tradition, particularly in the past, I think, and maybe even now,
- 12:11when gay people were marginalized even more in the past, and basically many
- 12:18people were closeted, mainly young people were closeted. You had a situation where
- 12:24say you're eighteen, twenty twenty five years old, and you're in the closet
- 12:28and you're afraid. You're afraid of losing your job, you're afraid of being
- 12:33murdered, you're afraid of your family disowning you, and then you're homeless.
- 12:39Well, if an older gay man takes you under his wing and says,
- 12:45you know, I will bring you into our community because I've been here longer
- 12:50and I know the ropes, and I have more confidence, and I have
- 12:54resources, and so there was a big appeal to that kind of thing.
- 13:00Not to make it sound like all people in the past hooked up with older
- 13:03men when they were young, I'm just saying it just perhaps made it more
- 13:09of a norm in their in their community. What about some celebrity couples that
- 13:15you can think of that are that have age gaps greater than ten ten years?
- 13:20Oh, I don't know if they were greater than ten years. So
- 13:20there was the Ashton Kutcher and Dememore. Yeah, I don't know how big
- 13:26the gap fifteen years it was fifteen years okay, yeah, and there was
- 13:30certainly Hugh Hefner with all his girlfriends. Right well, Crystal Harris is the
- 13:33one that I found online. Do you know the age gap there? Fifty
- 13:37sixty years? Sixty years? Wow, that's a little more than half plus
- 13:43seven. Yeah, anyone else? Yeah, there's the recently I just read
- 13:50one of these billionaires just married. Who was it, though, I don't
- 13:54know, one of the famous tech billionaires or so, I don't know.
- 13:58So we got beyond I'm saying jay Z twelve year gap there? Oh okay,
- 14:03but that one doesn't seem as twelve twelve years. It's you know,
- 14:07if in normal society that would raise eyebrows. I see there was the Woody
- 14:13Allen, Yeah, Mia Farrow, No, not me. The next one,
- 14:16uh yeah, soon years yeah, Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie twelve years.
- 14:22See another one that doesn't. That one doesn't seem at all this part.
- 14:28You know, Ellen DeGeneres and Portia de Rossi. I think her Nate
- 14:31Porsche Drossi from Arrested Development fifteen years, Elton John and David Furnish fifteen years,
- 14:39Rachel Maddow and Susan mccoola fifteen years, George Clooney and A Mall Clooney
- 14:46seventeen years, Mary kay Olsen and Olivier Sarkozi seventeen years, Harrison Ford Han
- 14:54Solo a cliss To Flockhart twenty two years. Okay, that's that one.
- 14:58That one is odd. Yeah, yeah, yeah, why well, they
- 15:03just don't They don't even look compatible, let alone age wise interesting. So
- 15:09it's how they look. That's how you get. So you got Donald Trump
- 15:11and Malania Trump twenty four years, Oh, Catherine Zada Jones, Michael Douglas
- 15:16twenty five, Alec Baldwin, Hilaria Hilaria, I don't know, Thomas twenty
- 15:24six years. At the other at Elson twin and Richard Sachs twenty eight years.
- 15:30It definitely seems to work a lot more in the direction of old guy
- 15:33young woman. Yeah. I mean, I think the only hetero where the
- 15:37woman is older is the Ashton Kutcher one that among which is why stood out
- 15:41so much. Patrick Stewart and Sonny Azelle thirty eight years. What, Yeah,
- 15:48Liberaci and Scott Thorson forty eight years. Oh, and as you said,
- 15:52Hugh Hefner and Chris Crazy, I didn't know about it all right around
- 15:56the world in different cultures. So on the world, do you think there
- 16:02are differences in whether or not men are older, or men are the same,
- 16:07or you know, is there a trend? Is there a trend around
- 16:10the world? What do you think? I do believe there's got to be
- 16:12differences and why why would there be differences? I think that maybe the less
- 16:22developed a society is technologically and financially, it affords less opportunities for these big,
- 16:33big difference as an age. Also, I think that religion would play
- 16:36a big role in this, meaning that less developed societies have less of an
- 16:41age gap, would be my guess. Yes, interesting, and I would
- 16:45I would think that religion plays a role in this as well. In that
- 16:48case, maybe the opposite way, but not necessarily. But I feel like
- 16:52there's a lot of arranged marriages in certain cultures, in which case they might
- 16:57be about the same age, and you know, factors like that. Also
- 17:03in many places where it's been like really economically depressed, I just think that
- 17:11first of all, there's a lot less people surviving, and so it's interesting
- 17:15as wouldn't work as well. It's correct me if I'm wrong, But it
- 17:19almost seems like you're associating wealth with the ability to have a trophy wife essentially
- 17:26in a way, yeah, or trophy boyfriend or whatever. Interesting, Okay,
- 17:30what about and sorry? And partially because I do believe that like the
- 17:34old depending on the gap, the old person in this in this situation or
- 17:40the older person needs to have something compelling to offer the young person. And
- 17:45I would venture to say that, at least when it comes to guys,
- 17:48I think money might be very appealing. Okay, So all right, so
- 17:53let me just lay out some of the stuff here. In all cultures,
- 17:57among header, we're gonna talk a lot about hetero marriages, just to let
- 18:00you know one because that's well, the sole reason is because most of the
- 18:07literature is about that. There is literature about gay and lesbian couples, which
- 18:11I'll get into in a second. But among hetero marriages around the world,
- 18:15women in almost every culture, if not every culture, every culture studied had
- 18:21the women on average are younger. And we're talking about averages. Yeah,
- 18:26you know, we're not talking about that. You know, there's certainly relationships
- 18:30where the woman is older and much older, but on average, women are
- 18:34younger in every culture studied around the world, and I'm not surprised about that
- 18:38they're younger, But what's the gap? Do you know what's the average?
- 18:41Well, we'll get to that in a second. Also around the world,
- 18:45when women on average prefer same age or older men, and adult men on
- 18:52average prefer younger women. That makes sense. Uh teen Boys also around the
- 18:59world seemingly prefer either girls their age or women who are older. So it's
- 19:07not like all men and all males prefer younger partners. It's that there seems
- 19:12to be a kind of gravitation around the twenties. I can see that people
- 19:18prefer to marry. When do you think when they study people all around the
- 19:22globe, what age do men and women like to get married? Mid twenties
- 19:30exactly, average age for females they prefer to get married at twenty five,
- 19:36and average age of their mate that they prefer is three years older, and
- 19:41men prefer to get married at twenty eight around the world, and they prefer
- 19:45females to be three years younger. Convenient. So the average preference for your
- 19:52first marriage is man twenty eight, women twenty five. And at what age
- 19:59are women the most fertile on average? Would you say eighteen? Nope?
- 20:03Twenty. Yeah. I that surprised me too. I thought I thought that,
- 20:10you know it, fertility was pretty robust at after you know, at
- 20:18some length after puberty and until but apparently it at the the average age of
- 20:26like most likely to conceive is is twenty five. Apparently. I don't know
- 20:32the biology on that. Maybe there's some'd be fascinating to see how that switched
- 20:37over the last million years. Yeah, so now by region, you know,
- 20:41let's look for some differences around the world. Okay, so, uh,
- 20:47this is all broken up into western, central, northern continents. So
- 20:52you got you got Western Africa, you got Eastern Europe, you have South
- 20:56America. So in terms of those kinds of things, what areas do you
- 21:02think have the largest age gaps on average between men and women who are married,
- 21:10the largest age gaps Western world? No, it's it's the opposite.
- 21:17What about what about the greatest uh wait wait wait the less developed parts of
- 21:22the world have the greatest age discrepancy. Yeah, your your hypothesis was exactly
- 21:27wrong. Wow, yeah, souh Africa has the greatest age gap. What
- 21:33do you think the average age gap is there? And then I'll go ten
- 21:37years not not not that far, it's it's between four and seven, with
- 21:42Western Africa having the largest age gap of seven and Eastern having four. Then
- 21:49what's what's next in line? Oh? Sorry, I I think I understand
- 21:52why my I so I could see how the averages would be such, because
- 22:00you would imagine it would take longer, maybe for a man in a less
- 22:03developed part of the world to have financial like enough finances to be able to
- 22:08get married and stuff like that. And however, what I still would believe
- 22:17is that big, big, big gaps would be less prevalent. But I
- 22:22don't have that data. I suspect you're wrong even on that because and although
- 22:27I did a super frickin deep dive on this, there's a lot of literature
- 22:32and a lot of bs on this, and it took a long time to
- 22:33kind of comb through it. But the gestalt I got was that the more
- 22:40educated, the more wealthy, the more equal between men and women the society
- 22:45it is, the much less likely you're going to find an age gap.
- 22:51And in other countries where there is less wealth, less education and a much
- 22:59I mean think about like the Middle East, where you have women who are
- 23:03you know, essentially second class citizens. They can't drive they can't walk outside
- 23:10without you know, a thing over them. Well, the it kind of
- 23:14lends itself. It doesn't really matter if the woman is ten years younger,
- 23:18because she's basically a child in that society anyway, you know what I mean.
- 23:22I see what you're saying. Whereas in our society, it's it's it's
- 23:26you know, women can kind of The other thing is women in our society
- 23:30in the United States have a greater ability to choose who they want to be
- 23:36with, and therefore will say, you know what, Mom and Dad,
- 23:41you're setting me up with this old dude who will quote unquote provide for me.
- 23:45But he's ugly and I don't like him. I guess I'm going to
- 23:48modify my statement. Then, I'm going to say, in the United States,
- 23:52I bet you that they're greater those big I got that. I got
- 23:56that when the man is richer. Yeah, but there's no data on that.
- 24:00And again I suspect, I suspect you're not I suspect you're not accurate
- 24:04on that. No, on that one, I think you have to go
- 24:07with me because I can't go with you. I don't have the data,
- 24:08I know, but using your own data, your own analysis, because if
- 24:12you think about the boy, you can't imagine, you can't imagine like a
- 24:17relatively rich man in Western Africa having a really young wife. No, no,
- 24:22no, I'm talking about us only. I'm saying in the US.
- 24:26I bet you that the greatest age discrepancies occur for wealthier older people. Actually,
- 24:33anecdotally, that's not my experience. I mean, certainly that's the news
- 24:37because what you were what you were talking about is that in the Western culture,
- 24:40women are tend to be more equal to men. Hence most women and
- 24:45most men are probably marrying at the right around the same age. Well,
- 24:47I can tell you anecdotally. I remember in high school I had a classmate
- 24:52who was dating a sixty five year old man. A woman. It's you
- 24:56know, a sixteen year old girl was dating. It was poor, yeah,
- 25:00very poor he was. He was he didn't have a job, you
- 25:03know what I mean. And so you know, I think again, I'm
- 25:07just not going to go with you on on that one. The point is
- 25:10is that in Africa they have the greatest distance in terms of the mean age
- 25:15difference, and it's between four and seven, which actually isn't that much.
- 25:18I mean, you're like, oh, ten years, you know, and
- 25:19between four and seven on average. You know, it's it's it's a it's
- 25:25a big gap, but but not huge. Right. Okay, what's the
- 25:27next area in the world do you think in terms of you know, what's
- 25:32the second most largest outside of Africa? Yeah? Well then Middle East?
- 25:37Uh right, so Middle East which they're calling Western Asia, and south Central
- 25:42Asia, so India, you know that whole region there. What's the next
- 25:47next in line? Do you think South America? Nope, it's actually Eastern,
- 25:52Southern and Western Europe. So most of Europe. Everything in Europe besides
- 25:56is three so interesting. So Middle East and India are four years average,
- 26:02and then Eastern Europe, Southern Europe, which is you know, Italy and
- 26:06Greece, and then you have Western Europe, which includes Spain in France,
- 26:08you have three year difference. And then the next one is Central America.
- 26:14Oh well, you got it right, Central America. South America is also
- 26:17three. So and then the people who the next the group who has the
- 26:23smallest age gap is two years, and that is Eastern Asia, so we're
- 26:29talking like Japan and China, Southeastern Asia so Vietnam, those areas, Northern
- 26:33Europe, which is UK, Scandinavia and North America, United States, Canada,
- 26:41and Australia New Zealand. Okay, so the developed world has the least
- 26:48age gap of average of two years between between married partners, whereas in on
- 26:56the other end of spectrum you have in Africa you have between four and seventy
- 26:59years different. Yes, yeah, that makes sense. Okay, So study
- 27:04in the US, men accept what range of age relative to their own on
- 27:10average, So when they study, you know, a wide range of men,
- 27:14say, you know, twenty five to sixty five, what age range
- 27:19do they prefer relative to their own? How many years younger, how many
- 27:23years older, ten years younger, two years older? Pretty good, ten
- 27:30years younger and to five years older. Years older. Women accept what range
- 27:36of age relative to their own five years younger and fifteen years older? Oh
- 27:41well, not bad, five years younger to eight years older. You seem
- 27:47to have a slight bias that were that were coming out here. Well you
- 27:49got close, it's close. Yeah, okay, what about Okay, So
- 27:56there's a difference between first marriages and later marriages. So with first marriages,
- 28:02eighty percent of men marry partners within five years of their age. So so
- 28:07you know, in the United States for heterosexual marriages, which is actually similar
- 28:12for gay marriages as well. Eighty percent of people essentially marry someone within five
- 28:19years in their first marriage, yeah, and then ten percent between six and
- 28:23nine years, and then five percent ten years or older, and then five
- 28:27percent marry women who are older. When remarrying, the age discrepancy gets larger.
- 28:33That's kind of one of the points. And in gay and lesbian couples.
- 28:37When I looked up the data on that, I thought I would see
- 28:41like a significant difference, but I actually didn't. The difference among gay and
- 28:47lesbian couples is actually pretty similar to heterosexual you know, people in their early
- 28:55twenties, the average age difference of the couple is two or three years,
- 29:00which is, you know, very similar to hetero people. And then when
- 29:03people are in their forties, the average is seven years. So probably so
- 29:08a little bit a little bit wider of a gap, but not significantly.
- 29:12You know, we're not talking like a massive thing. So the gestalt that
- 29:17I pulled away was that most people, regardless of sexual orientation, tend to
- 29:22couple with people their own age, Yeah, which is which is interesting.
- 29:26Okay, so let's take a break and we get back, let's continue with
- 29:30this discussion. What do you say, bro, let's do it. Okay,
- 29:37we're back from the break. If you haven't become a patron of the
- 29:40podcast, please do so go to patreon dot com. All right, so,
- 29:44mortality risk. Do you think there's any differences between couples that have age
- 29:48gaps as opposed to people who are the same age? Yes, what do
- 29:52you think? I think couples that have that are closer in age tend to
- 29:57live longer. No, ask, So the difference is that if you have
- 30:03a younger spouse, you will live longer. Oh, but if you have
- 30:08an older spouse, then you die sooner. Oh no, that's not good.
- 30:15So, and the other factor here is, or the other data point
- 30:19here is that regardless of that, married people still live longer than single people.
- 30:26So even if you have an older spouse, you're still gonna on average,
- 30:30live longer than someone who doesn't have a spouse at all, even though
- 30:34your lifespan is shorter relative to people who are married to someone of the same
- 30:41age, and particularly if you're married to someone younger than you. So could
- 30:45you live indefinitely long if you kept marrying every year? A twenty one year
- 30:49old. You're just like sucking the life out of young people. So men
- 30:56who are seven to nine years older are how much less likely to die than
- 31:00men who have the same age wife? What do you think men who are
- 31:03seven or eight years older older than their wife are how much less likely to
- 31:07die in a given in a given you know, year percentage was yeah,
- 31:14geez uh yeah, good, okay, eleven eleven percent. I was hoping
- 31:18it wasn't higher than that. Now it's unknown reason. They they used to
- 31:22speculate about this and they thought they had narrowed down the reason, but it's
- 31:26actually pretty complicated and they can't figure out why do you have any speculation as
- 31:30to why this phenomenon would be happening? Well, given that, for example,
- 31:37in in Okinawa, the research into the centenarians there, they they have
- 31:42seen that one of the aspects that is common to the folks that are that
- 31:47I've lived a long time there is that they're very engaged in the community,
- 31:51and actually they spend a lot of time around kids, right and around young
- 31:53people. So that's not a reason, but it does seem to be like
- 31:57consistent. So what you know, hyper aesthetically, like I would say,
- 32:01you know, it could be that there's energy there, so they don't they
- 32:05don't feel like what's the point of living? And they feel more like there's
- 32:08something to do. There's more activities, yeah, more physical tired, yeah,
- 32:14more physical activity right right. And when you are in trouble, someone
- 32:20is likely to be there to help you. So all those factors that that
- 32:24alone is a great point. Like if you actually if as you do start
- 32:28getting older, if you take us a fall, you're you're older. If
- 32:32the other person is just as old as you, they might not be able
- 32:35to help you at all. Right. Another factor that's shown in the data
- 32:38is when your spouse dies, you're you have a greater risk of dying yourself.
- 32:44Oh man, So if you're young and you have an older spouse,
- 32:47then your older spouse is likely to die earlier than if you had a spouse
- 32:52the same age, right, yes, And so because you are because if
- 32:57you have an older spouse, you're much more likely to be widowed at some
- 33:00point, and therefore you're much more likely to die sooner. Because people have
- 33:06an increase there's a and there's various reasons why people have an increased risk of
- 33:09mortality that upon their spouse dying. Some of it is practical, like they
- 33:14no longer have someone to help them, but also some of it's psychological and
- 33:17that there's there's some people it's like, well there's really no point in move
- 33:22going, you know, moving on with life, that kind of stuff.
- 33:23So I think the lesson here is, if you're married to an older person,
- 33:28make sure you have a twenty one year year old on the wings.
- 33:31Yeah, as soon as the older person dies, you marry the twenty one
- 33:35year old, and that suck the life. That counterbalances. Yeah, you
- 33:38just like suck the Okay, the larger the age gap, the more likely
- 33:44uh that there is that people are to get a divorce. So this is
- 33:47one of the major This is one of the major findings that you see and
- 33:52the literature online and stuff is is like, the bigger the gap, the
- 33:57more likely you're going to get divorced. Makes sense to me. Okay,
- 34:00But before we go into those stats, we have to ask ourselves what is
- 34:04the percentage of marriages, regardless of age difference, that end in divorce?
- 34:07So what's what's the percent you know in the US what, Yes, And
- 34:13we have one of the highest divorce rates in the world. Forty three percent.
- 34:17It's it's fifty percent per yeah, so it's it's about fifty percent for
- 34:23all marriages. What about first marriages? Oh that was all marriages, Oh
- 34:30sixty percent. No, it's forty one percent. Oh really Yeah, so
- 34:35for first marriages it's forty one percent. So that means that people that get
- 34:38divorced are more likely to get divorced again. Right, So second marriages is
- 34:43sixty percent and third marriages is seventy three percent. Wow, so third marriages
- 34:47are almost certain to be to end in divorce. So if you if you're
- 34:52like, okay, how many times have you been married? Four times?
- 34:55You're like, well, let's get a divorce right now, we're not even
- 35:00married. You know. It's interesting. I didn't see any literature on fourth
- 35:04marriages, you know, because I wonder if it would change, if it
- 35:07would like go backwards, because it's like event because because they don't count if
- 35:10you die, you know what I mean. It's like okay, okay,
- 35:15so for for for uh so for all marriages, it's about fifty percent fifty
- 35:22likelihood of divorce. So what percentage increase in the risk of divorce is associated
- 35:28with being with being one year difference one year difference. Okay, so this
- 35:34is the fifty three ideal. The ideal is you're the same age. So
- 35:37let's say so you're the least likely based on age only to divorce if you're
- 35:44the exactliest thing, you know, within six months. But what about one
- 35:46year? That's two percent difference? Good, three percent? What about a
- 35:51five year age gap? Now we're talking closer to ten percent difference more eighteen
- 35:55percent, well, eighteen percent increased chance chance, So we're talking about instead
- 36:00of fifty percent, you now have like a sixty percent or something, or
- 36:05or fifty eight percent ten year age gap. Okay, one percentage in,
- 36:10yes, thirty or thirty percent increase good, thirty nine percent. So that
- 36:17means instead of fifty percent, you have like a seventy percent chance or something
- 36:24like that. Twenty year age gap. Yeah, that goes that shoots all
- 36:29the way to fifty percent increase chance ninety five percent. Oh my god.
- 36:34So I don't know exactly how the statistics work here, but because I don't
- 36:38know if they're talking about first, but twenty year age gap, your chance
- 36:44of divorce goes up, it goes up almost double. Yeah, So from
- 36:50fifty percent, it can't be one hundred percent because for a thirty year age
- 36:52gap, that's one hundred and seventy two increased percentage chance. So I don't
- 36:58know if the same age people are like maybe same age people are like thirty
- 37:04percent chance and like, oh, that would make sense because fifty is all
- 37:08of them, that's everybody, right, right, So I suspect that,
- 37:12like, if you're the same age, your risk is thirty to forty percent
- 37:16or something, and when you get to twenty year gap, then you're looking
- 37:21at a seventy to eighty percent, and when your thirty year gap, you're
- 37:23like ninety percent or something. Sure, interesting, Okay, So so but
- 37:30the question here is is this due to the age gap or is this due
- 37:35to the second and third marriage issue? Because if you have a twenty year
- 37:39age gap, chances are this isn't your first marriage. It's not your first
- 37:44rodeo, right because one it might be one of the people's first marriage,
- 37:49but probably not the older person. You know, if you're forty five and
- 37:52you're marrying a twenty five year old, chances are this is at least your
- 37:57second marriage, you know what I mean? And so, man, that
- 38:00means that means that Jerry Maguire is probably divorced again. Uh now, there's
- 38:06very bad reporting on this when I because because this study in terms of like
- 38:13laying this out, was cited all over the place on the internet as like
- 38:16you know, in Cosmo and huff Po and oh bad reporting as in the
- 38:22way it was reported, right, So so they reported it that they basically
- 38:27were saying that if you were within one year, you only had a three
- 38:31percent likelihood that you would get a divorce. Oh okay, you know what
- 38:35I mean. So that's how they would report it. I see, I
- 38:37thought when you said it was poor report, I thought you meant like the
- 38:40self reporting of the stats, you know, like like they sent out the
- 38:45surveys, and you've that the self reporting was bad. But you mean how
- 38:49it was portrayed in the media, right, And uh so, so they
- 38:53they misunderstood statistics essentially. That's why I was very trying to be very clear
- 39:00that it's an increased chance, not not the chance. You know. For
- 39:04example, this is a quote from the Internet citing this study. So the
- 39:08couples who were least likely to split up just a three percent chance had an
- 39:13age gap of one year. Okay, meaning according to science, this is
- 39:17ideal. Right, So I just want to read this again. So the
- 39:22couples who were least likely to split up just a three percent chance, had
- 39:24an age gap of one year, Meaning according to science, this is ideal.
- 39:30Now that's like you open this door that inside is science, and science
- 39:35goes one year is the ideal? Yeah, No, no scientist is going
- 39:40to say something's ideal. They're just going to say here's the data. You
- 39:45know, because you love when I'm scrolling through Facebook all the time, there's
- 39:49these scientists find you know, such and such. Yeah, and so I
- 39:52always picture these rooms full of these you know, white lab coded people sitting
- 39:58around announcing thing. You know. But honestly, before I became a scientist
- 40:04myself, I had an extremely distorted view of what scientists were and what they
- 40:10did and how it all worked. It's just such a weird field, you
- 40:15know, and unless you're in it or very close to it, you know,
- 40:19it's just hard to know, particularly if if you don't have a lot
- 40:22of education. You know, like this happens with physics and astronomy constantly.
- 40:28They're like half the matter of the universe just vanished. Yeah, I mean,
- 40:35and I blame the media, because when you read these these headlines,
- 40:38you're like, because on Reddit there's always these, someone will post something like
- 40:43that, and I immediately someone's like, no, you're wrong. Actually I've
- 40:46done that before. Someone actually posted a psychological study saying that Facebook using Facebook
- 40:55causes depression, and so I was like, hmm, that sounds a little
- 41:00funny to me, you know what I mean. And so I actually looked
- 41:02at the study and it took me a while to kind of figure it out,
- 41:05and I actually refuted it and laid it all out, said, here's
- 41:07here's what the study said, right, and it nowhere does it say or
- 41:13nowhere in the data does it suggest that using Facebook causes depression. I see.
- 41:17The data is much more nuanced than that, you know what I mean.
- 41:22Okay, So, now, so far we've been talking about marriage,
- 41:24which is really only one type of romantic relationship. You got dating relationships where
- 41:30you you know, either you're unsure if you want to marry them, or
- 41:35you're not even thinking about dating somebody. Have you heard of polyamory? Right,
- 41:39So there's a lot of data where about dating relationships? Where where do
- 41:44we find just a slew of data regarding how people date tender. Yeah,
- 41:51but yeah, in general, just dating website websites and okay Cupid is actually
- 41:55very open about their data. They have philosophy. Yeah, they post all
- 42:00sorts of stats and things. Yeah. So what percentage of so this again
- 42:07heterosexual? What percentage of conversations are started by men as opposed to women starting
- 42:14a conversation? You know, reaching in so in dating sites? Yeah,
- 42:16on okay cubid specifically freaking eight close eighty percent. You're pretty good at this.
- 42:22I was gonna say eighty, but I it was like double down.
- 42:25Yeah, okay, men sending messages. Men tend to message younger women,
- 42:31and the older women get the younger the women they message relative to their age,
- 42:37right, so the older So, so say a thirty year old,
- 42:40well, the average thirty year old man on okay cubid has the average person
- 42:46that they message will be twenty five or something. Yeah, and whereas a
- 42:50fifty year old man, the average the average fifty year old man will message
- 42:54someone who's forty years old. You know, so it just gets bigger and
- 42:58bigger. Oh. I thought, okay, that's understandable. I thought it
- 43:01meant the older you get the younger though. No, it's just relative to
- 43:07your age. Now, what about women sending messages? You think there's similar
- 43:13or different? You know, I think that in general they'll send messages to
- 43:16people around their age or a bit older. Yeah, so that's the assumption,
- 43:22right, because based on all that evolutionary psychology stuff and like the statistics,
- 43:25but it's actually not that at all. Women tend to message men who
- 43:30are closer to their age, but as they get older, they actually send
- 43:35a lot of messages to younger men. Well, okay, that's that's the
- 43:37cougar effect. And well, well label it. You'll label it the cougar
- 43:43effect, but it's the same for men. It's just a human effect.
- 43:46Yeah yeah, but in women it's called the cougar effect. But it's funny
- 43:51that you feel compelled to label it something. It's natural for men, but
- 43:54for women it's the cougar send all messages. I'mbardo at hotmail dot com.
- 44:04That probably was your hotmail account, wasn't it. It's probably no, It
- 44:07never was. No, So I never used my real name for any email
- 44:15account. I always use my name because I just was like, I just
- 44:20didn't understand. I didn't want to confuse people anyway. So the old,
- 44:22so the older women get not only do they send messages to younger men,
- 44:28but they also respond more readily to younger men. So this flies totally in
- 44:34the face of the data, right, So we have to reconcile this somehow,
- 44:37because according to okay Cupid, women prefer younger mates, older women prefer
- 44:43younger mates, and younger women prefer the same age mates, not older men.
- 44:49On average. Right now, there's certain younger women who prefer older men,
- 44:52but on average they tend so not so some younger women actually prefer younger
- 44:58men, you know what I mean. So, so it's because on average
- 45:00they tend to gravitate towards their age, but as women get older, they
- 45:04tend to respond and message younger younger, uh, younger men. I mean.
- 45:07One idea I would have is that a lot of those sites are initially
- 45:12so visual that I think, you know, men and women probably are both
- 45:20looking initially and going like, well, this person's attractive, and I feel
- 45:24like, you know, younger people of both sexes would tend to be a
- 45:29bit more quote unquote attractive by more standards. Hard to know. Hard to
- 45:32know because the profiles will talk a lot about their life as well. And
- 45:38photos might exhibit lifestyle and that kind of stuff. So but either way,
- 45:44it's surprising and it flies in the face of all the other data. And
- 45:46so we have to figure out how why that is. We have to,
- 45:51but we'll get into that at the end here. Okay, the other So,
- 45:54so we've talked about longevity. So whenever they measure like marriage in the
- 46:00cowage, the quality of a marriage or something, they will talk about longevity
- 46:06and another factor. What's the other factor they talk about marriage longevity and health?
- 46:14Satisfaction? Oh, satisfaction. So who satisfied? Satisfaction with the marriage
- 46:17or with life with the marriage? So men who marry younger, men who
- 46:24marry younger, same or older? Women? Who's the most satisfied? I
- 46:30see, I would say men that marry around the same age, Nope,
- 46:35younger what yeah? Women possible? What about for women? Who's the most
- 46:39satisfied? Women who marry younger, the same or older men? Women who
- 46:45marry the same age younger. No, this doesn't make sense, not culturally
- 46:52well, but it also doesn't make sense based on the marriage divorce statistics.
- 46:55Right, So both men and women are most sad when they marry someone younger
- 47:01and least satisfied when they marry someone older. So did this would tend to
- 47:06imply that the divorce is led mostly by the younger person. Uh maybe.
- 47:12Actually, however, that initial satisfaction fades over time. So even if you
- 47:16do tend to prefer you're like, yay, I married a younger person,
- 47:22that satisfaction tends to fade after six to ten years, particularly if the couple
- 47:28faces economic problems. They found because the speculation is that as the you know,
- 47:32say, your ten years difference, the strain on a marriage is perhaps
- 47:39a little worse for couples in general who have greater age differences, because it's
- 47:45perhaps more likely that one person is carrying the financial burden. Yeah, okay,
- 47:51So again terrible reporting in the media about this because so basically, what
- 47:57you know, the study looked at one way is well, sure you'll you'll,
- 48:01you might like it at first, but satisfaction rates plummet after that.
- 48:07But that but that's not what the study demonstrated. It just reduces, it
- 48:12just maybe comes back to normal. And so basically when they report this to
- 48:15the media, it's like, if there's an age gap, you're doomed,
- 48:20you know. So here are some headlines based on So there's there's two main
- 48:24studies that keep getting talked about. One was that increase in more likelihood of
- 48:30divorce as the age gap gets higher, and then this initial satisfaction reduction over
- 48:35time. So here are some headlines. What's the best age gap in a
- 48:39relationship. How much age gap is okay in a relationship? The marriages marriages
- 48:50with large age gaps may not last. I like that one because it's like
- 48:55any marriage may not last. Science has an answer to the perfect relationship age
- 49:00gap. Science has spoken the age gap between you and your partner dictates how
- 49:08long your relationship will last. Take dictation please. Yeah, It's like these
- 49:15are headline written by people who don't understand statistics. It's it's there's risk factors.
- 49:22There's there's you know, a slight increase in risk of this and that.
- 49:27It's not you know, your age gap doesn't dictate your your future.
- 49:32It just it just increases your risk. It's like it's like saying it's like
- 49:36saying driving a car will dictate that you will die in a car accident.
- 49:42You know what I mean, your astrological sign guarantees how long your marriage will
- 49:45well, that's even more ridiculous. Okay, So, so why is there
- 49:52a age gap? You know? So reason reason why there isn't? Oh
- 49:58so one instant one interesting question to ask about all this as I was looking
- 50:01over this is why isn't there a greater age gap? You know, in
- 50:07in the western world you have an age gap of two years on average.
- 50:09Yeah, that's a pretty small gap. Yep. That means that like a
- 50:15huge amount of people are within like zero to five years difference. Yeah,
- 50:20you know, people getting married at young, people getting married old. And
- 50:23so one question to ask when we really step out if we're aliens. On
- 50:28another, you know, watching us from the moon, it's like, you
- 50:32know, you can as an adult, legally speaking, you can couple with
- 50:37as someone of any age. That's right. So, when you're twenty five
- 50:42in single, why is it so predictable that you're gonna that you're gonna marry
- 50:46someone your age when you can marry someone of any age? You know,
- 50:50So, what's the what's the reason why? Well? I have one possible
- 50:54reason is that up until the age of around twenty three, you spending the
- 51:00majority of your time outside of your parents with people of around your same age.
- 51:07Because all through college or sorry, all through high school and then mostly
- 51:10all through college other than professors and maybe some graduate students. So you're just
- 51:14used to people your age, and you're spending most of your time, and
- 51:17I think the familiarity and like how much time you're spending is how you meet
- 51:22people in the end and how you like actually make connections. So I would
- 51:25I would expect that a lot of people actually literally meet their spouse in college
- 51:30and their spouse happens to be around the same age, or they meet at
- 51:36work, where there tends to be you know, at least at your desk,
- 51:39there's probably similar age to people or something I don't well. In the
- 51:43literature they call it homogamy, which is basically marriage to the same person as
- 51:49you people are taught by You could say it's evolution, but also you can
- 51:53definitely say cultural conditioning results in people seeking out people to make people like themselves,
- 52:00so ethnicity and age and skin tone and to some extent body shape and
- 52:06accent and education. It's proven time and time again that in general, humans
- 52:12tend to be attracted to and particularly merry people who are almost identical to them,
- 52:17which is surprising, right because you would think that you would be predisposed
- 52:22genetically to seek diversity to you know, combine more better genes. Well,
- 52:31and we would also be selected to choose people within a similar gene pool because
- 52:39that means more likelihood of our gene pool being propagated. Right. Oh,
- 52:45I see, Okay, so there's two forces maybe competing there. Well,
- 52:47yeah, it's all speculation. The other thing is is that it is a
- 52:55it's a cultural thing. You know, we are taught if you grow,
- 52:59if you were raised in Africa, for instance, you were adopted in Africa,
- 53:06and you are around all dark skinned African people, right, then the
- 53:09chance that you would be attracted to and marry an African dark skinned person is
- 53:15much greater, right. Yeah. And actually it might have something to do
- 53:17with imprinting at a young age, right. So the so it it has
- 53:23seemingly less to do with our biological drive and more to do with the way
- 53:30we're socialized as we as we are raised in Okay, So reason for men
- 53:38and older. So what about speculation as to why we have a trend of
- 53:44men being older than women across all cultures in the world. Why would that
- 53:49be happening? Do you think? Well, I do think that there is
- 53:52something to the age of being able to give birth. And so so I
- 53:59say a conscious thing or an unconscious drive. That part is both conscious and
- 54:06unconscious. Like people are aware, you know, like if an older man
- 54:10wants to have kids, they are aware that there's an age past which they
- 54:16won't be able to with a female. And also I think both implicitly and
- 54:22sometimes explicitly, people are aware that I think, I want a younger,
- 54:27you know, woman to give birth to my kids because they'll be healthier or
- 54:30whatever. Whereas for men, which is not great unfortunately for women, but
- 54:36for men it's like, well, there's sperm is their sperm, you know,
- 54:39and it will still swim, even though actually epigenetically that's probably like not
- 54:44correct and I don't know. But so I think that there's that aspect.
- 54:47And then there's also the financial security aspect that I think, disregarding my original
- 54:54point, I think in general, the older you get, you tend to
- 54:58be more secure in your life and your finances and things like that. Right,
- 55:01So that's the prevailing evolutionary psychology theory, and even it's also almost a
- 55:07social psychology theory as well, in that we were selected as men to be
- 55:15attracted to the most fertile of women, which is in your twenties, and
- 55:19so therefore visual cues that indicate a woman is in her twenties is the most
- 55:27sexy to us or something. And so when you're fifty five, the closer
- 55:34you can get to that, look, the idea goes, the more likely
- 55:37you're going to be turned on by that, and the more likely you're going
- 55:40to want to get with that and marry that, you know. And the
- 55:45reasoning is that those men who had that psychological drive towards women in their twenties
- 55:52managed to pass on their genes more often than men who didn't discriminate on age
- 55:59of the adult women or sure, it's similar to how the vast majority of
- 56:05people are not attracted to children because we were selected away from that. Because
- 56:12those who are attracted to children tend to not propagate their genes, and therefore
- 56:16they get they get, you know, those genes become slowly kind of marginalized
- 56:21from from from oart. That's that's the idea. Now. Probably also why
- 56:25very close insist relationship might end up not being as common because those offspring may
- 56:32not be as viable, right, so, and so not only perhaps a
- 56:37biological drive to not have sex under those circumstances, but definitely a social dogma
- 56:45and religious dogma to discourage that sort of thing. Now, that's the theory.
- 56:50There's almost no way to demonstrate that effected. There's no way to demonstrate
- 56:54that effectively given our current scientific methods, aside from uh, doing really horrible
- 57:01experiments on babies throughout their entire life or a time machine. We just it's
- 57:07just hard for us to know because we're all born into a culture that says
- 57:13that younger women are better and older women are worse. You know, we
- 57:17definitely have that in our society, you know, not only in sexual partners
- 57:24or marital partners or something, but just in general. You know, people
- 57:29want to hire younger women the media when when you're a news anchor, like
- 57:34you know, when you're fifty five, you're much less sought after than when
- 57:37you're thirty, when you're a movie star. You know, I'm listening to
- 57:43Lauren Graham's audiobook from Gomo Girls. You know, Lauren, h I've actually
- 57:47listened to Bossy Pants and Yes please, So bossy Pants is the thirty Rock.
- 57:55Yeah, Tina Fey and the Woman from Parks and Amy Amy Polar yeah,
- 58:01I've listened to this is I've listened to the trifecta of audio books from
- 58:07these comedian women's women, and they have a very similar tone to their writing
- 58:12and a very similar topics that they get to, but they're so delightful and
- 58:15funny. The Lauren Graham all three of Tina Fey, Sarah Amy Polar I'm
- 58:22just terrible with names, and Lauren Graham are hilarious people. And all of
- 58:30them talked about how past a certain age, essentially when you become like thirty
- 58:36five forty, all of the offers dry up, you know, because you're
- 58:42you're you're disgusting now and you're irrelevant. You know, you're past the age.
- 58:46And so so we definitely have a society like that. So it's hard
- 58:50to know if it's evolution or if it's society, right yep. Yeah,
- 58:54and well and in some cases, like you mentioned, you know, religious
- 58:58factors and stuff like that. But even that's always hard to know because you
- 59:01know, does it say in some texts don't eat pork because it coincidentally like
- 59:08they just thought it was bad for totally subjective reasons, and coincidentally that prevented
- 59:15them from catching for kenosis. Did they you know, like or was it
- 59:19that they observed over many many years, like hey, maybe we shouldn't be
- 59:22eating those things and then made a religious rule around it. Right, They
- 59:27just were like, you know, people can't help themselves if we say I
- 59:32think it's a bad idea that doesn't have as much weight as God, God
- 59:36dictates it. Yeah. Well, so so why do we do this,
- 59:43you think in society? So let's say that it's not an evolutionary thing.
- 59:45You know, let's just say that we definitely can say that society has a
- 59:50double standard about age for men and women. You know, men get hotter
- 59:52and women don't in our society. You know, why why do we do
- 59:58this? You know, why did we dive? Because it's around the world?
- 1:00:00Ye, so why would we develop that social construct? Do you think?
- 1:00:06Well, I mean I do think that especially in history, the there
- 1:00:12was an actual survival aspect, meaning you know, there was a powerful male
- 1:00:19in the region that ran things and they he probably had a few lieutenants and
- 1:00:24powerful you know, and so if you're a female, like you're gonna want
- 1:00:29to be allied, allied and good graces with those people. And if you
- 1:00:35can be married, even better. And so I think that there was actually
- 1:00:38like a real life or death question in many cases. Yeah, yeah,
- 1:00:44I think that's overlapping with what I my total speculation again because there's really no
- 1:00:47way to ever answer this question. But but yeah, men have traditionally had
- 1:00:52power around the world for whatever reason. It's hard, it's it's sort of
- 1:00:57weird, like to think back, like, at what point did that become
- 1:01:01codified in our in human society, you know, was it in early hominid
- 1:01:07society or something that and we all just sort of inherited that cultural notion because
- 1:01:12it's really a cultural notion. There's no inherent reason why men should be leading
- 1:01:17and men should be dominant in society, particularly as we start to change our
- 1:01:24moras in Western society particularly, but really around the world, and we start
- 1:01:29to see all these differences wash away, you know. So it's just like
- 1:01:35it's it's just kind of interesting to think about. But for whatever reason,
- 1:01:37men have traditionally held power at least in you know, historical times up until
- 1:01:44today. And therefore, in order and when you have power, one of
- 1:01:49the big things you need to do is retain that power, right, and
- 1:01:54one of the ways that you can retain that power is by making sure you
- 1:01:59have a spouse that knows her place right. And so I think total speculation
- 1:02:05that way back when and up until you know, recent times, it actually
- 1:02:12was a smart move to some extent to retain power by making sure that you
- 1:02:20didn't have someone your age or older. Because imagine if you're the other thing
- 1:02:24I suppose now that I'm thinking about is the the the observation or perception of
- 1:02:30power. If there's actually examples from Roman history where you had a powerful mother
- 1:02:36kind of suggesting things to her son who was an emperor or something, and
- 1:02:40society didn't like that. There's like, oh, you know, he's a
- 1:02:44mama's boy and that kind of stuff. When it's like, well, how
- 1:02:46about he's just getting advice from his mom, Like what's wrong with that?
- 1:02:51You know? And so so it works better, and you know, the
- 1:02:53optics look better when you have a younger woman who is like doing what she's
- 1:03:00told in that kind of thing, you know what I mean. But I
- 1:03:02mean, like, we have examples in nature of animals that don't have anywhere
- 1:03:08near the cultural development that we do. So take gorillas, right, like,
- 1:03:13why is the silver back guerrilla in charge? Because they're the biggest,
- 1:03:16the strongest. So their society and their survival and their social structure is based
- 1:03:23on a strong like king essentially achieve And so for whatever reason in our evolution
- 1:03:32the hominids that we came from, there was evolutionary advantage to one sex becoming
- 1:03:38sort of the physical protector or whatever. And on the unfortunate side effect is
- 1:03:45that well, the other sex couldn't actually compete physically and therefore had to be
- 1:03:51as soon as it became that one sex wanted to exert power, there was
- 1:03:54like not really a good choice there and then and back then, there weren't
- 1:03:59things like well I have a good job or I have a degree or no,
- 1:04:01no, there wasn't any of that. It was just who can beat
- 1:04:04up who? And it was pretty much like one sex could beat up on
- 1:04:09average the other sex more frequently. So glad you brought us up. I'm
- 1:04:12going to completely shoot it down that you're bringing up gorillas. It's fine,
- 1:04:15but chimps and bonobo is completely opposite. They don't have they don't have male
- 1:04:19dominance in the way that the way that apes do. But but they're physically
- 1:04:25the way that gorillas is right, but they're they're pretty physically equivalent, that
- 1:04:29the the female bonobos and the male bonobles are not significantly different physically. Well,
- 1:04:33the point is is that it's unknown what our quote unquote natural state is
- 1:04:39is the point. That's that's my point. It's like, we just don't
- 1:04:41really know. But but but that would be making an argument that through society
- 1:04:45alone, males on average, right, No, I see, this is
- 1:04:51you are doing what people do on the internet. To me, right now,
- 1:04:55I'm saying we don't know, and by and and what. Whenever I
- 1:04:59say that, people on the internet will say, well, how do you
- 1:05:01know? And I'm like, I'm saying, I don't know. No one
- 1:05:04knows. Well, no, no, but there are some things we do
- 1:05:06know. And that's what I was trying to say, is that we can
- 1:05:10observe champs in their behavior. We can observed bonobos, we can observe we
- 1:05:14can observe gorillas, But we also have we're a different species. That's hard
- 1:05:17to know. But we have no evidence that significant sex differentiation can occur in
- 1:05:25a short amount of evolutionary time, it meaning thousands of years for example.
- 1:05:30So since we don't have that kind of evidence, I think you would have
- 1:05:35to have really good proof that it was that you know, males and females
- 1:05:41were about the same physically and all of a sudden culture in the last I
- 1:05:45don't know. Yeah, right, men are on average bigger and have more
- 1:05:47upper bodies, and I think, but it's hard to know exactly why that
- 1:05:51is. Oh yeah, totally why that happened, I agree with you.
- 1:05:55But because that happened, unfortunately, I think it led to a physical overpowering
- 1:06:00of one sex over the other. And then therefore, when when other things
- 1:06:04didn't matter, like what your career, your degree or anything, it was
- 1:06:08simply literally who could beat up whom? And most guys that were stronger could
- 1:06:13beat up the weaker guys and most of the women. And that assumes a
- 1:06:18sexual selection based on who you can beat up which is which is? I
- 1:06:23think anthropologists would would have a problem with that, with that very simplistic view
- 1:06:29of sexual selection for humans. But anyway, let's take a break and we
- 1:06:32get back. Let's get into the bottom line here. What do you say,
- 1:06:36Burdo, Let's do it. So, is there an actual problem berdo
- 1:06:46with age difference? After we've gone over all this stuff, is there an
- 1:06:50actual problem, like a moral problem, a societal problem, you know,
- 1:06:57a public health problem with age differences in relationships. I think, to the
- 1:07:03extent that we've been discussing, in other words, ruling out actually with minors.
- 1:07:11It's definitely seems more inconclusive now than when we started. Like I would
- 1:07:15have said at the beginning, Yeah, after a certain amount, it's gone.
- 1:07:19But when you say, like why, say, well, you might
- 1:07:23get divorced more often, and then I'm not sure if that's enough of a
- 1:07:27reason. Right, yeah, right, I mean that by that logic,
- 1:07:30no Americans should get married because Americans are much more likely to get divorced than
- 1:07:35people in Poland. Right, So therefore Polish people can come over here and
- 1:07:40go like, you know, you shouldn't get married because you're really likely to
- 1:07:43get divorced, you know. And we didn't talk about any sort of psychological
- 1:07:47damage from the age gap, which has not been demonstrated. I just want
- 1:07:51to be clear now it hasn't been investigated that that. But we'll get more
- 1:07:56into that in a second. But anyway, so let's summarize the re search
- 1:08:00here. Now. If you're if they're the greater the age gap, the
- 1:08:03the less likely the relationship will last until you die. Is the way I
- 1:08:10would put it. You know, so if there's a five year age gap,
- 1:08:14then instead of like a thirty forty chance of divorce, you now have
- 1:08:18like a like a forty five fifty percent chance. Ten year age gap,
- 1:08:25instead of like a thirty to forty, you now have like a fifty to
- 1:08:29sixty. If there's a twenty year age gap, instead of a thirty to
- 1:08:32forty percent chance, you now have like a sixty to seventy or something.
- 1:08:36So, so the greater the age gap, the more the more likely it's
- 1:08:42to an invorce. Also, according to research, marriages is it's more vulnerable
- 1:08:47to economic problems. So if if you have a if you have an age
- 1:08:51gap, you're you seem to be more vulnerable to economic downturns. Also,
- 1:08:57there's an altered life expectancy both pro and con which is also born out by
- 1:09:01the data. And there seems to be different satisfaction rates for each member.
- 1:09:06So if if you married a younger person, you tend to be more happier
- 1:09:11about it than the younger person does U. But this is on average.
- 1:09:15This is this is on average, okay. And also none of these reporting
- 1:09:19I could find effect sizes, so that because That's another thing, is like
- 1:09:23if there's a significant difference, it could be like instead of a eight point
- 1:09:28one satisfaction out of ten, you have an eight point zero And with a
- 1:09:33large enough sample size, that's a significant difference. But does it is it
- 1:09:39meaningful? You know? So it's hard to know, So the question so
- 1:09:44there, so there's two things that you can really there's really only one thing
- 1:09:46you can point to in terms of the data, That is a difference between
- 1:09:50same age marriages and age gap marriages, and that is is that age gap
- 1:09:56marriages tend to tend to dissolve quicker and more often. Right, So,
- 1:10:00so now what people will say and according to those you know, those headlines,
- 1:10:06science has proven the perfect eight. But the thing is is is longevity
- 1:10:12good? You know? Is it does? Lut does long lasting relationships?
- 1:10:15Does that equal good? You know what? Because the question that I always
- 1:10:20have to be because people will always use this language. I have a I
- 1:10:24have a failed marriage. Yep, you know, I have a broken marriage.
- 1:10:28I have a broken family. You know what I mean? And these
- 1:10:30words are reflective of social constructs that there's nothing empirically wrong with getting married five
- 1:10:36times. So imagine if people talk like that about other things, like I
- 1:10:41had a failed school experience, Why well, eventually I graduated in the left,
- 1:10:45right, or even or even with jobs? Right, I failed at
- 1:10:48my last job, Why well, because I have a new job. Right,
- 1:10:51because I sort of grew out of that job and I have a new
- 1:10:54job that pays me more. So I failed at my last job, right,
- 1:10:58exactly. It's it's now. People out there you might be going like,
- 1:11:00well, come on, guys, I mean, you know marriage is
- 1:11:03different from a job. Well not really, is it. Now? You
- 1:11:06know, the only thing you can point to is children. When you have
- 1:11:12children and there's divorce, it's particularly if it's ugly, then kids can suffer.
- 1:11:16But a lot of times all that suffering can be mitigated with with good
- 1:11:21divorce behaviors. Right. You know, Well, in fact, what you
- 1:11:25just said is important because if we want to talk about failure, we could
- 1:11:30talk about did I fail at handling the ending of a relationship properly? But
- 1:11:35because you know, you could imagine, like if you measure failure in terms
- 1:11:40of human suffering and negatively affecting people's lives, well yeah, you could totally
- 1:11:45make cases for bad marriages, bad divorces, bad remarriages bad, everything right,
- 1:11:49right, So that makes sense. But but you're right when you say
- 1:11:54I had a failed marriage because it ended right. That is odd. The
- 1:12:00thing because I talk with a lot of clients about this. The thing is
- 1:12:02is so burto just in your head. You don't have to discuss them,
- 1:12:06but just count rough estimate back of the napkin. How many romantic relationships beyond
- 1:12:13a couple months' length have you been in in your life? Back of the
- 1:12:16napkin? Probably like ten? Okay, are you in a polyamorous relationship right
- 1:12:21now with ten different with all ten of those people? No, so it
- 1:12:26failed all those So like you are a total failure now, So according to
- 1:12:32that, we're all complete failures. And that's because our society says unless you
- 1:12:42have to meet someone young, marry them and stay with them for the rest
- 1:12:45of your life. Anything other than that, that very old model that was
- 1:12:49probably based on like agrarian society. Agricultural societies, you know, is that
- 1:12:55the same as agrarian? Yeah, yeah, you know. Unless you do
- 1:13:00that very normative path, then there's something wrong with you, particularly if you
- 1:13:06got married and divorced. There's plenty of people who fall in love they decide
- 1:13:13to get married, and they start to fight a little bit, they grow
- 1:13:15apart, and then they're like, you know what, let's divorce. It's
- 1:13:19amicably and the relationship. Is that a bad thing? Well, that's what
- 1:13:25these studies are looking at. They're counting that as a or at least they're
- 1:13:29me doing. They're starting from the assumption, well that the media does.
- 1:13:32The scientists don't necessarily do that, but they kind of do. But particularly
- 1:13:36the media, they're like, okay, well, you know, larger age
- 1:13:40gaps more likelihood of divorce. Therefore, larger age gaps are bad, which
- 1:13:45is funny because given the statistics like fifty percent and in divorce, right,
- 1:13:49you basically have to You're at the same time saying, look, as we
- 1:13:53all know, staying in a marriage indefinitely is the ideal and what we all
- 1:13:57should do. So we have a crisis, world wide crisis, well particularly
- 1:14:00United States. Fifty of those fail utter failure. Right, divorce is,
- 1:14:10among some statistics, basically the norm. So whenever, and you know,
- 1:14:15as a person who studies this all the time, whenever I go to a
- 1:14:19wedding, I'm always kind of like, eh, you know, I mean,
- 1:14:21they seem in love right now. But you know there's so But that's
- 1:14:28the thing. It's like, it doesn't take away from the magic. It
- 1:14:30doesn't take away from the love, it doesn't take away from the meaning,
- 1:14:33It doesn't take away anything. It's just one of those things you know when
- 1:14:38you date someone in college and you're like, I'm not really interested in marriage,
- 1:14:42but you know we'll have two years then it'll be great. Is that
- 1:14:45a failed relationship? No, you just it was temporary, as most relationships
- 1:14:49are. Now, if the bride ends up sleeping with the best man during
- 1:14:53the honeymoon, does that take away at all? Or is that still depends
- 1:14:57on the arrangement and you know, the satisfaction of all the members. I
- 1:15:01see, I mean because you know, the groom could be in the corner.
- 1:15:04You know, that's sort of an inside joke that Bruno and I have.
- 1:15:13Okay, so the difference also, the other thing here is that couples
- 1:15:18with age differences are marginalized when they actually study they've actually studied this and found
- 1:15:24that there's two different kinds. There's two different spectrum. There's a spectrum of
- 1:15:29age difference couples. You have couples among people who have big age differences between
- 1:15:34them. You have some people who perceive a marginalization in their community and society,
- 1:15:40and then you have another set of people who don't perceive it. Okay,
- 1:15:43And for the people who perceive a marginalization, they're more likely to divorce
- 1:15:46quicker. Oh interesting, So right, So now what other kinds of couples
- 1:15:54are marginalized in our society today? Well, gay couples, right, and
- 1:15:58interracial couples. Right. So I don't know that the gay inter racial stats,
- 1:16:02but I do know that gay and lesbians are more likely to kill themselves,
- 1:16:08right, Wow, And we know fairly certain that it's because of marginalization.
- 1:16:15So by that definition we should be like, well, the ideal sexual
- 1:16:18orientation is to be straight, you know what I mean? And so it's
- 1:16:21not a direct analogy, but you get. My point is that, you
- 1:16:25know, just because society is crapping on age difference couples doesn't mean that age
- 1:16:32difference couples shouldn't exist. It means as a society, we need to stop
- 1:16:36marginalizing. That's a good point, you know. Now can you imagine when
- 1:16:41the aliens come down and we and they look nothing like humans, and but
- 1:16:45they're they're sentient. We're sentient and we have language. So so neeviatively,
- 1:16:50they're going to start having you know, alien human relationships and marriages and stuff
- 1:16:56and and so what that's going to be a mess, gonna be a lot
- 1:17:00of discrimination. So many factors play a role other than age difference in terms
- 1:17:05of not only longevity, but but marriage satisfaction. You know, there's a
- 1:17:11lot of there's a lot of factors that play a role. You know,
- 1:17:15like what other kinds of factors besides age play a role in ending religion and
- 1:17:19ending marriages or that, and and satisfaction, you know, longevity, longevity
- 1:17:24and satisfaction. I think financial you know, how how well off the couple
- 1:17:29is doing? Okay, financial security, I should say, whether they have
- 1:17:33family support I suppose, and and of course the environment around them, like
- 1:17:41if they're in a war zone or if they're But what about differences between them?
- 1:17:44Oh I see, Okay, Well, yes, definitely if they want
- 1:17:47to have children or not, that's a big one, right, And that
- 1:17:50might have to do with age, but it might not. What else different
- 1:17:55career or or financial goals, Like you know, one of them wants to
- 1:18:00travel a lot and kind of spend the money they have, the other one
- 1:18:02wants to save and buy a house. Right. What else? What other
- 1:18:05differences might play a role? Social differences like one person really likes to go
- 1:18:11out and party every day. Right, So, there are a lot of
- 1:18:15domains and factors worth considering if you're going to be thinking about whether or not
- 1:18:24this partner or that partner is good for you, or what sort of partner
- 1:18:27you should be looking for. So age is one of those. Imagine if
- 1:18:30we shamed all those like, oh, you're one of those couples where she
- 1:18:34likes going out and you don't. Right, yeah, it's exactly the same.
- 1:18:41It's exactly the same. You guys have how do you have? Said?
- 1:18:43Yeah? Pedophile parenting style is another big one. Your values, your
- 1:18:48culture, your education, your interests. One person likes to hike, the
- 1:18:51other person hates hiking. You know, these these similar these eight you know
- 1:18:58these differences can play a and age can have something to do with that.
- 1:19:01But but maybe not. One person's a vegan, the only one only eats
- 1:19:04raw meat. Your life path again, which could be interested you know,
- 1:19:11related to your age, but maybe not. You know, when you're gonna,
- 1:19:13as you said, have kids, or if you're gonna have kids.
- 1:19:15Religion, Yeah, religion, whether or not you're in love, whether or
- 1:19:20not you're committed to each other, whether or not you feel good when you're
- 1:19:24around each other. These are all much more important things than age, you
- 1:19:29know. In fact, anyway, the other thing to think about if there
- 1:19:33is an age difference is whether or not you your family and community will support
- 1:19:40that. So, so if you're a couple out there and you're like or
- 1:19:44you're thinking about dating someone who's a lot older or younger, think about your
- 1:19:47society around you because that can that actually can play a role at whether or
- 1:19:53not you last, Yeah, very long. But again, lasting isn't the
- 1:19:58only metric upon which we need to uh, you know, couch our meaning
- 1:20:02all right, what if you had a super happy five years and you end
- 1:20:05it nicely? Yeah, exactly, all right. So in conclusion, there's
- 1:20:11no empirical problem with age difference. It's a total social construct, just like
- 1:20:16difference in heights or difference in whether or not you go hiking or not.
- 1:20:20It's just it's just a difference. And you know where we have a massive
- 1:20:26social construct in our society that you need to conform to the norm. Right,
- 1:20:30if you're you got to be hetero. You gotta be white, you
- 1:20:32got to be Protestant. The couple has to be the same age. You
- 1:20:36need to be at least a middle class. You need to address a certain
- 1:20:39way. You know. You can have tattoos, but not too many.
- 1:20:43You can have piercings but not too many, and all these things are there's
- 1:20:46just this. We just have a society of conformers and and so if you
- 1:20:51have an age difference in your relationship, you're not conforming to the norm,
- 1:20:56and therefore people hate you. So is that T shirt that you're wearing from
- 1:21:02back in when you were in high school? Yeah? Like did you own
- 1:21:05it this whole time? Yeah? Okay, let me ask you. How
- 1:21:09is it not faded to all? Hell? Yeah? So Berto's changing the
- 1:21:14subject significantly right now. He's just noticing a T shirt that I wear almost
- 1:21:17all the time. It's my high school. So when you played football,
- 1:21:23you were given a T shirt you could wear underneath for practice, you know,
- 1:21:27like underneath your pads. And this is actually the one I got in
- 1:21:30eighty seven, which is actually my junior year. But you wear it all
- 1:21:34the time. Yeah, and it's not faded. I know, it's although
- 1:21:39I think I started to see a hole somewhere. But yeah, it's totally
- 1:21:43insane. This shirt is made out of something. Yeah, okay, so
- 1:21:50and it's very comfortable to you, by the way. Okay. So that's
- 1:21:55one reason for this social construct is we just have a general conform to the
- 1:21:59norm notion. We're very upset when people step out outside of that. Other
- 1:22:05reasons is basically we have a panic in our society about pedophilia and sexual harassment.
- 1:22:13Now, we definitely need to raise awareness about pedophilia, child molestation and
- 1:22:17sexual harassment and sexual exploitation and power differences and all that kind of They often
- 1:22:24say power differential, always kind of bothers me just say power difference. No,
- 1:22:28it's a power differential. But like, in what other context do you
- 1:22:31use the word differential? Cars? Yeah, there's a there's a drive train
- 1:22:38differential. So it's like why not power difference, you know, like why
- 1:22:42do we use a different form of of you know. But anyway, so
- 1:22:45we we definitely need to think about power differences, and we definitely need to
- 1:22:49raise awareness and we we have a problem with that in our society that we
- 1:22:53have not been addressing well enough. And to some extent, the pendulum has
- 1:22:58swung the other we've we've end up. In our effort to catch the tuna
- 1:23:02in the net, we have also caught dolphins because in our effort to catch
- 1:23:08child molesters and sexual harassment people, we are also catching age difference people.
- 1:23:14Yes, we're just saying, we're just labeling any age difference in sexuality as
- 1:23:18automatically sexual ros that's harassed, some kind of weird sexual thing. It's a
- 1:23:25power differential train, yeah, which is ridiculous. We're stupid as humans.
- 1:23:30My god, we're so dumb. Okay, now here's the other thing though,
- 1:23:34because really, what age are we talking about? Because there is a
- 1:23:40cutoff, right, I mean, there is a power difference. There is
- 1:23:43an age difference in which we're like, well, you know, so where's
- 1:23:46you know, where's that cut What? What age does the younger youngest person
- 1:23:50have to be? Yeah, like an eighteen year old and a ninety eight
- 1:23:55year old go right, or you know, a twenty year old and you
- 1:24:00know, at what age is it? Okay? Because basically what I'm saying
- 1:24:03is there's no empirical reason why a twenty five year old couldn't date a hundred
- 1:24:11year old if they wanted to. If those two people consented to it,
- 1:24:14yeah, fine, you know, for whatever reasons they had. No one
- 1:24:17should be judging that. But at what age does the youngest person get to
- 1:24:23do that kind of thing? You know? Right? Well, you think
- 1:24:26and before I answer that, there is a possibility that an extreme difference like
- 1:24:30that, like a twenty two year old and a six seventy year old or
- 1:24:33something like that, there could have been abuse when they were younger. Well,
- 1:24:39it's just interesting that you have to go there in your head, do
- 1:24:42you know what I mean? Well, yeah, you're going to that place.
- 1:24:45It's the same way that people go to when they say, well,
- 1:24:47you know you're gay. Well you know, it's maybe you were abused and
- 1:24:50that's why you're gay. Well, let me I mean, maybe, you
- 1:24:54know, put the question a different way. Maybe a same age couple has
- 1:24:57been a sexual abuse when they were young, Sure, and they chose same
- 1:25:00age people, But let me ask let me ask the question a different way.
- 1:25:03If a person had been abused when they were, say a teenager,
- 1:25:08by a significantly older person, and as they become an adult they choose to
- 1:25:14be with a significantly older person, could that be re traumatizing for them.
- 1:25:18Yeah, but you know, back in the day. I don't know if
- 1:25:23you remember this, but when we did one of our very first Psychology in
- 1:25:25Seattle episodes with the polyamorous and the SMM people, Alena Gabosch, and just
- 1:25:30watching that last night ironically or coincidentally, really yes, interesting. I ran
- 1:25:35into her recently. Actually we need to go to the Erotic Arts Festival and
- 1:25:41all anyway. But the thing is is I asked a very similar question to
- 1:25:45her about S and M. Was I was like, well, you know,
- 1:25:48research shows that people who have been abused ten might sort of get involved
- 1:25:54in the S and M community and activity because they're replaying their abuse or something.
- 1:26:00And what she said was, I'm really glad you asked that, but
- 1:26:02it's a really stupid question. Is kind of the attitude she had, because
- 1:26:06she said, like everyone always asked that question. And basically what she said
- 1:26:12was, does that mean that someone can't participate in something that they want to
- 1:26:19do? Do you know what I mean? Like, maybe they're working it
- 1:26:23out and and and maybe someone The fact that the thing here is S and
- 1:26:30M can be harmful to people, and it can be helpful to people,
- 1:26:33and it could be neither to people. And some of that might have to
- 1:26:36do with past abuse, and some of it might not be, you know
- 1:26:40what I mean. So take someone who was abused and that gives them a
- 1:26:45greater attraction to super old men or something, Well, maybe a relationship with
- 1:26:50a nice super old man will help them heal. Like, who are we
- 1:26:54to say from the outside whether or not a consenting adult should or should not
- 1:27:00engage in a relationship or not. Well, relationship is tough. But you
- 1:27:03know what if we changed that and we said, you know, this girl
- 1:27:08was abused sexually and now she is a prostitute, and you know, does
- 1:27:14that the same thing? Man? If she wants to be a sex worker
- 1:27:16and that's her thing, then you know, freedom live and let live.
- 1:27:20Now, there are sex workers who are living a life in hell, and
- 1:27:27there are sex workers who are not. So it sounds like to me like
- 1:27:30you're only drawing the line if I'm just saying, it's interesting that we go
- 1:27:35there when we think about these sorts of things. Well, we certainly have
- 1:27:38to go there when certain when it applies when they start with the thing that
- 1:27:43they are doing affects negatively someone someone's freedom or rights. Right, Well,
- 1:27:46sure, but that doesn't mean it is wrong. It means that that person
- 1:27:50is suffering and we need to help them or they need to reach out for
- 1:27:54help, do you know what I mean. But so we do draw that
- 1:27:56line, we say like, okay, look, this person has pedophilic ten
- 1:28:00and sees they're they're they're abusing kids, and it turns out they were abused
- 1:28:02as a child. Well, well that's just wrong on its face anyway,
- 1:28:05because you're right, you're molesting children. Yeah, but but he or she
- 1:28:10is doing it as a result of their their abuse. Well, let's let
- 1:28:14me give in let me give you another example. So let's say you were
- 1:28:18as a man abused by someone who a woman who is tall, you know,
- 1:28:24very tall, and as a result, you grow up into your adult
- 1:28:28life and you find yourself attracted to women who are your height or taller.
- 1:28:32And at some point you're in therapy and you're like, you know what,
- 1:28:34I think. I'm actually I think one of the reasons why I'm attracted to
- 1:28:38tall women is because when I was young, I was abused by a girl
- 1:28:41who was taller. Who cares, you know, if you're if you're in
- 1:28:45therapy and you're like, and I'm in hell then by all means, look
- 1:28:48at that. But if you're just like, huh, that's interesting that I'm
- 1:28:51attracted to that, you know, Okay, fair enough. So the height
- 1:28:55one is a great example, but we can certainly agree so for getting sex.
- 1:28:58For a second, I had a bad financial example as a kid.
- 1:29:01Now I have a gambling addiction, and I come to therapy and I'm like,
- 1:29:05I have a gambling addiction. Right, We certainly wouldn't say, oh,
- 1:29:09hey, you're an adult man, you can spend your money every one.
- 1:29:11So, by analogy, if an eighteen year old comes into therapy and
- 1:29:15says, I'm attracted to super old dudes, and I'm fairly sure it has
- 1:29:18to do with the fact that I was abused and when I engage in relationships
- 1:29:23with old dudes, it's a mixed bag of like good and bad for me,
- 1:29:28and I don't feel like it's quite right for me. Yeah. Absolutely,
- 1:29:30But you have evidence that the person is presenting it on its face though
- 1:29:35an eighteen year old or I say, a twenty five year old with one
- 1:29:39hundred year old there's in my book, I can't see any reason to condemn
- 1:29:44that. I can't see any reason what you're saying is that there's certain things
- 1:29:47in life that on its face we would condemn, like this person's murdering or
- 1:29:51stealing, but certain things we wouldn't. Based on this new analysis, we'd
- 1:29:57say, like, no, on its face, that age gap, we
- 1:30:00shouldn't condemn it, period, because you have two people who want to do
- 1:30:03something, and who are you to talk about that, even if it's based
- 1:30:06on nothing Like the Hugh Hefner. I don't know the details with his relationships,
- 1:30:14but let's just say the twenty five year old women that he was involved
- 1:30:17with were completely you know, they didn't feel oppressed in any way or controlled.
- 1:30:24Let's just say they they did another with, you know, their own
- 1:30:27free will, and let's say in their their head they're like, yeah,
- 1:30:30I really like the guy, and you know he's a lot of fun,
- 1:30:32and yeah, sure, you know, if he wasn't Hugh Hefner, I
- 1:30:36wouldn't go out with him. But you know, I really I really like
- 1:30:40this, you know, and the age gap is six years. Like in
- 1:30:44that one example, I said, like, as it from the outside,
- 1:30:46we can't look at that and go like, oh, we can't look at
- 1:30:49that and say there's something wrong with that. Okay, Then I'm going to
- 1:30:53try to draw a more subtle line, because we clearly seem as a society
- 1:30:59to understand and that you are not quite mature enough just because you've turned eighteen
- 1:31:04for everything, right. So that's the point is maturity, right, which
- 1:31:10is a very weird subject to get into, which is a whole area of
- 1:31:14controversy in the literature, because it's like we set this arbitrary number at eighteen
- 1:31:20and say, as soon as the day you turn eighteen, you are now
- 1:31:25free to marry and be in a sexual relationship with anyone of any age older
- 1:31:29than you, Whereas you can't drink alcohol yet. Yeah, you can't print
- 1:31:32the car, right, So you're not mature enough to drink, but you
- 1:31:36are mature enough to smoke and to now engage in a relationship with one hundred
- 1:31:41year old and go to the fight for your country and everything right. And
- 1:31:44so it's a very weird thing because maybe some sixteen year olds are quote unquote
- 1:31:51mature enough. I'm not proposing that by any means. Okay, I'm gonna
- 1:31:55draw a line at either you gotta be twenty five if you want to date
- 1:32:00anyone over fifty, or you got to pass a test that I'm going to
- 1:32:05devise. But and according to what we're saying here is might there be a
- 1:32:10twenty five year old who isn't mature enough? No? Absolutely, That's why
- 1:32:14I might devise a maturity test. Right, So age is perhaps associated with
- 1:32:18the maturity, but not necessarily right. Can you imagine the test I would
- 1:32:24come up with to determine maturity. Yeah. But basically what it comes down
- 1:32:28to is if we're worried about a power difference, then using age as a
- 1:32:33as a slam dunk factor in power difference is a very misguided way of looking
- 1:32:41at it, because you can have a younger a younger partner can absolutely abuse
- 1:32:45an older partner. I've seen it happen over and in the relationships that I
- 1:32:49look at, where there's where there's actual power difference, that an exploitation.
- 1:32:55Age difference is not one of the things that I often see. I see
- 1:32:59same people. I see younger people abusing older people. I see older people
- 1:33:02abusing younger people. It happened. You know, age might play a role
- 1:33:08like it might kind of add like a one or two percent factor in there,
- 1:33:13but there are much greater, much more nuanced factors that you can't see
- 1:33:17from the outside that you actually have to go up to them and talk to
- 1:33:20them and ask them what's happening in the relationship. You know, you can
- 1:33:25have a twenty five year old person who is extremely abusive to a forty five
- 1:33:30year old person, and you can have a forty five year old person who's
- 1:33:32extremely abusive to a twenty five year old person. So now might age play
- 1:33:39a role? Absolutely? You know, if you're an abusive person and you're
- 1:33:43going to try to find a person to control, then you're probably a little
- 1:33:47bit more likely to look for a younger person. But it's not guaranteed,
- 1:33:51right, So if we're looking, so there's this weird kind of discussion around
- 1:33:58at what age is someone mature enough to make a mature decision about a relationship.
- 1:34:02You know, that's a weird conversation to get into. The other thing
- 1:34:06is is if we're talking about power difference and that's and we're using age is
- 1:34:11like this automatic marker of a power difference, then you're stupid for doing that.
- 1:34:15Okay, In my clinical experience, I will say that people just as
- 1:34:20I was thinking about this, it's like, I find that age difference relationships
- 1:34:26with the clients that I've talked to have a certain electric feel to them.
- 1:34:31When I talk with my clients, they'll talk about how they I guess it's
- 1:34:38mainly older clients who are talking about having younger partners I see. And there's
- 1:34:45something very attractive about an age difference that can actually really facilitate the bonding of
- 1:34:49a relationship. You know. The differences are facilitative of that because there's something
- 1:34:57very exotic about living in an another person's world that you don't normally have access
- 1:35:01to. Right, the younger person has access to the older person's world,
- 1:35:05which is like very different than their world, and vice versa. Right,
- 1:35:10yeah, yeah, And there's a certain Romeo and Juliet quality to it that
- 1:35:15can play into it, like ooh, you know, we're playing against the
- 1:35:17rules here, you know. And so I've seen that happen as well.
- 1:35:21Like I have a friend in Colombia who is I don't know, she's in
- 1:35:29her twenties, you know, in university, and we we text on WhatsApp
- 1:35:34yep, and yet we have like Game of Thrones and other things like Stranger
- 1:35:41Things and other shows in common. So we talk about that stuff. And
- 1:35:46even though there's quite a bit of an age difference there, right, So
- 1:35:49if you were, you know, well, you know, there's there's there's
- 1:35:56a lot less particularly, I think maybe even today, with the Internet and
- 1:35:59everything thing and all the shared experience, I think age difference and culture,
- 1:36:05it's not as big of a deal as maybe it was before. I don't
- 1:36:09know. Anyway. The other thing I should say in terms of clinical experience
- 1:36:14is that sometimes when I encounter age differences in relationships, it's due to an
- 1:36:21issue of the one person needs to be held up as the strong person and
- 1:36:29one needs and the younger person needs to be held up as the weak person,
- 1:36:32and that facilitates a bond that can lead to problems later on. But
- 1:36:35anyway, but that's not because of age. It's just kind of something that
- 1:36:40I see sometimes. Okay, so what's the bottom line here, Well,
- 1:36:42the bottom line is as long as the younger person is past a certain age
- 1:36:45which I can't really define, and of a certain maturity, there's absolutely no
- 1:36:50clinical problem with an age gap. I'm stating that because and I dare anyone
- 1:36:56to refute that in a convincing way to me. Of course, unless you
- 1:37:00mean past sixty five. It's all a massive social construct based on our discomfort
- 1:37:05of things that don't conform to the norm. You know, like, wait,
- 1:37:10you identify as a different gender, or wait, you want to be
- 1:37:16polyamorous? You want to date two people at once? Ah? You know,
- 1:37:21wait you like the Star Wars prequels? Ah? What is that?
- 1:37:27You know there's a greater sure, there's a greater chance of the relationship ending
- 1:37:31sooner, particularly for large age gaps like through that. They're particularly for large
- 1:37:38age gaps like ten plus years. But that could be due to many issues
- 1:37:42other than relationship satisfaction, you know, marginalization. It could be due to
- 1:37:45the second third marriage statistic, that kind of thing. Do you realize you
- 1:37:49just solved it. By the way, what the test is, did you
- 1:37:54enjoy the Star Wars prequels? If the answer is anything other than no,
- 1:38:00then you cannot date that person. And the other thing is is even when
- 1:38:03we think about larger age gaps perhaps leading to a shorter relationship, we also
- 1:38:11have to remind ourself there's nothing wrong with having a short relationship. And again,
- 1:38:15when it comes to children, there are research looks into this. When
- 1:38:19you divorce, well, the all the problems that you see in kids regarding
- 1:38:25divorce are either massively reduced or they go away completely interesting. Whereas if you're
- 1:38:30in a relationship, that is, if you're in a marriage that is terrible
- 1:38:33and there's all this conflict, like a lot of problems happen to the kids.
- 1:38:38So live your life, fall in love with whoever the f you want
- 1:38:42to fall in love with, as long as it's legal and as long as
- 1:38:45there isn't an abuse of power difference. And we all need to stop marginalizing
- 1:38:49and bullying these people because it's unfair and it's frickin dumb. That's my bottom
- 1:38:55line, Burrow, what do you think, I think I hear you loud
- 1:38:58and clear, top a ages sixty five minimum, ages thirty. Well,
- 1:39:02that does it for that episode of psychology and Seattle, thanks for joining me
- 1:39:04out there. Please take care of yourself because you deserve it.