Latest / Success Story with Scott Clary / Lessons - Why We're Surrounded By Horrible Leaders | Dr. Kimberly Janson, Author & Leadership Expert
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to Lessons episodes of Success Story, part of the HubSpot podcast network.
- 0:14These lessons episodes will be shorter conversations with past guests, valued members of the success
- 0:21story community, and myself.
- 0:23They'll be focused on teaching you actionable, insightful takeaways that you can use to
- 0:28upscale your personal and professional life.
- 0:31What's broken with leadership based on your experience?
- 0:35I think the biggest thing that's broken is we're choosing the wrong people to be leaders.
- 0:41And in addition to this meta-analysis on thought leadership that I mentioned, I've conducted
- 0:47a number of sanctioned studies myself.
- 0:51And so one, for example, I looked at a number of different companies in the same industry
- 0:57and interviewed leaders at four different levels in the organization.
- 1:01The amount of variation on how those people think about what's required for leadership
- 1:07or what to look for in leaders was crazy.
- 1:12So how can you build a pipeline of leaders if everybody's looking for something else?
- 1:17Right, how do you find some good acorns to grow into Elm trees if we've got all this disjointed
- 1:24approach in terms of how we're thinking about them?
- 1:27That study was also powerful because what I found is the CEOs were more similar to each
- 1:33other than they were in their own company.
- 1:36And so it prompted a third study I ended up doing.
- 1:39The second study was a global quantitative study of more than 600 people.
- 1:43The third study though was with CEOs that I sat with, companies you know, the CEO of Target,
- 1:51the CEO of Panera, a foot locker, build a bear, really strong, powerful people who have
- 1:59ascended to success.
- 2:01And I wanted to get into their minds not only to see where the convergence was in their
- 2:06point of view, but to also give anecdotes to people on how to do this stuff well.
- 2:14And so what I think is the biggest gap is the fact that we're not choosing folks because
- 2:19of this level of variation and we're using poor indicators on leadership potential.
- 2:26So for example, one of the things you'll most frequently hear is I choose leaders based
- 2:33on their performance.
- 2:34Well, that's great if the performance is the same for the same job, right?
- 2:39But it is not absolutely not a predictor of performance at the next level.
- 2:45It should take it to entry to get into the conversation to be considered.
- 2:49But there's actually four, in my opinion, and while researched and tested, four dynamics
- 2:55you should look for when choosing leaders or even just assessing potential.
- 3:00One is intelligence, things only become more complex as you go up.
- 3:05You got to have that cognitive horsepower because what you get with what you come with
- 3:11when you arrive is what you have to work with.
- 3:14And we've got to be honest about that.
- 3:16The second one is personality.
- 3:18I've been the chief diversity officer in two fortune 500 companies.
- 3:21So in no way do I advise that we only one personality type, but there's a lot of derailing
- 3:27personality types.
- 3:28I mean, you and I could have an hour conversation right now about all the bad leaders you've
- 3:32seen along the way because they were incredibly self-absorbed or because they couldn't get
- 3:38out of their own way and make a decision, et cetera, et cetera.
- 3:41So the second dynamic is look for people who do have that fundamental gap in terms of
- 3:48a personality derailer.
- 3:49The third is motivation.
- 3:51You got to hire people with big engines.
- 3:53And if you want them to do more and be more in the future, they've got to have their own
- 3:57engine.
- 3:58And then the fourth is learning agility.
- 4:00We need people who are committed to reinventing themselves and also who couldn't assimilate
- 4:05ideas and information quickly and reapply them.
- 4:08So I think that the biggest issue is that companies and leaders do not really understand
- 4:15leadership and they don't understand how to choose leaders because if someone has those
- 4:20four elements, I can teach them anything.
- 4:23And I do.
- 4:24But if they don't have them, then it's a matter of compensating, masking, hiding, and
- 4:29eventually lack of success.
- 4:32Now how does this play into your other framework, which is a high-performance framework?
- 4:38Because right now we're talking about finding the best leaderships, determining leadership
- 4:43potential.
- 4:44That's obviously integral for a successful organization.
- 4:47And you even mentioned right now, like there's a lot of big companies that do it.
- 4:50But the high-performance piece, the high-performing framework, the fast, simple, good done.
- 4:55Is this leadership principle?
- 4:56Is this just a principle for me, I'm trying to accelerate in my career?
- 5:01What's that?
- 5:02What is that?
- 5:03How does that fit into the success of a business?
- 5:05Yeah, it's really a lens by which you should look at the work in front of you.
- 5:09So let me just spend a moment flushing that out.
- 5:12So the first is fast.
- 5:14Speed wins the game, most times.
- 5:17Speed is a way to help you be first to market and not lose on needless things, etc.
- 5:25So how do we think about the things that are going to slow us down, most likely in the
- 5:31scenario?
- 5:32And then let's plan for that up front.
- 5:35The second is, because you know the expression, give it to a busy person, they'll get it
- 5:39done, right?
- 5:40Yeah.
- 5:41Someone has worked to them and then they can get a lot more done and so there's a real
- 5:46return on that verb.
- 5:49Simple, complexity often doesn't add value.
- 5:52It just adds time or cost more money.
- 5:55And complexity creeps in from, oh, this leader said this.
- 6:00So we have to make a change in the process or we've done it like this for so long, etc.
- 6:07In most organizations, if I throw a process up on the wall and I have a red pen and I say,
- 6:12what's the shortest distance?
- 6:14And then I challenge all of the assumptions about how we've done it.
- 6:18We're able to really cut things down.
- 6:21But what complexity does is it creates distance from people in the work and they get exhausted
- 6:27or it impacts morale.
- 6:30So let's drive for simplicity.
- 6:32And then focus on addressing complexity where it makes sense, where it's a complex idea.
- 6:39But let's be judicious in that.
- 6:41Fast, simple, good.
- 6:43What's good enough?
- 6:45We have a lot of perfectionist out there and this new generation in particular is very
- 6:50perfectionist oriented, but perfectionism is faulty thinking.
- 6:56It's tricking us to thinking that something isn't good enough or it isn't finished.
- 7:02But here's the way to think about that.
- 7:04If we were to buy a house for $10, why would we pay $15 for it?
- 7:09Right?
- 7:10Why don't we take the five extra dollars and put it in a new house?
- 7:13But what blowing past good does for us is we expend energy and time and resources in
- 7:23ways that maybe not are a good return on an investment.
- 7:27There's a company in the US that if I said their name, you would say, oh yes, but they're
- 7:34often voted the worst company in America and your experience with them is really frustrating.
- 7:41They have figured out what the right threshold is for customer satisfaction and they also know
- 7:50if, let's just say it's 80%.
- 7:52They know if they go above that, they don't get any more customers.
- 7:56They don't get any more revenue.
- 7:58It's nice to say it's a 97% satisfaction, but if you don't make money from that, don't
- 8:06do it.
- 8:07And so this idea of done, what's good enough, let's all agree up front what good enough
- 8:12is, is a major transformational component because it helps us recap resources that are being
- 8:18spent foolishly.
- 8:20And then the last one is done.
- 8:22There is an energy when you finish something.
- 8:24There is a learning that can happen, but a lot of times things in organizations have a
- 8:30long tail and they don't really finish hard.
- 8:33We need to be better at finishing.
- 8:35The imagery I think about on this one is in organizations, if I had a sweater and every
- 8:42undone thing had a fishing hook and that was stuck in my sweater, we drag around a lot
- 8:47of garbage.
- 8:49So how do we, what is done, look like, let's celebrate it because people want more positive
- 8:54feedback, by the way.
- 8:56And then let's learn from it and then let's really repurpose those resources towards something
- 9:01new.