Latest / Ovary-Acting / Tits Up — A Physical Therapist on Breast Health, Posture & Reconnecting With Your Body
Transcript
- Jennifer Ashby: welcome to Overreacting, your ecosystem for all things women where we take your health and wellness seriously, but ourselves ⁓ not so much. I'm your host, Dr. Jennifer Ashby, clinician, researcher, and mother, ⁓ and a very proud post-menopausal woman. And I am here to tell you that today we're gonna talk about breasts, boobs, chichis, tatas. When I was thinking about the first episodes that I wanted for overreacting, there were two topics that came to me that I thought we absolutely needed to discuss. The first one is boobs and the second is vaginas. I thought what is more quintessential to being a female than your boobs or your vaginas? So today, I'm very excited. to have Dr. Heidelisa Manbusian, physical therapist and so much more. Dr. Manbusian has quite the pedigree actually. She's a physical therapist who cares for patients in a variety of conditions, including cancer, musculoskeletal issues, and she leads the rehabilitative care for patients with breast cancer, as well as those with lymphedema, which is the swelling from injury to the lymphatic system. which can be seen very often with breast cancer treatment. She assists in triaging patients with active lymphedema and teaching people about the condition itself. She enjoys helping patients return to their daily lives as well as educating providers on her areas of expertise with the goal of building collaborative relationships across specialties. As someone who has been a caretaker herself, she is devoted to making sure patients and their families have smooth, and beneficial care experiences. Dr. Manbousian earned her doctorate in physical therapy at the University of St. Augustine for Health Sciences. She also has an executive master of business administration degree from Auburn University. And outside of work, Dr. Manbousian is a college football enthusiast, proud wife, and the adoring mom of her daughter and her fur baby. Welcome, welcome, welcome. We had the most amazing technical difficulties this morning and she not on her side, definitely on our side and she was beyond patient. So thank you very much and welcome to ovary acting. Hidelisa Manibusan: I'm Thank you so much. I'm so honored to be here and so excited to do this. Any words that we can get out, any knowledge that we can get out is always exciting. Jennifer Ashby: Yeah, I have to say that I find that ⁓ we talk about breast health in terms of breast cancer, very, very important, but nobody really talks about breast health outside of the realm of breast cancer. I find that in clinic, I am often sharing with women things like don't put lotion directly on your breasts, it absorbs to the skin. These are mammary glands. You don't want exposure to chemicals. hydration matters with boob health as well because your breasts are filled with the ductal system ⁓ that explaining how breast tissue goes beyond just what people think of as a boob, but on into the axillary and into your armpit and that entire area. So I was super excited you came highly recommended to me by our women's health nurse midwife, Dr. Linda do long or nurse practitioner Linda do long. And ⁓ so when you said yes, I was super excited. So thank you. So I usually begin with ⁓ one initial kind of personal question. And for you, this is the one that I've chosen. What is the hill you will absolutely die on when it comes to breast health and who have you had to fight for? Hidelisa Manibusan: Thank you. Okay. You know, being a physical therapist, and you could probably ask any of my colleagues on this, is just how important rehabilitation is after breast surgery. ⁓ It blows my mind that women still come to me and say, I had no idea that there was physical therapy for breasts. ⁓ Jennifer Ashby: So. Hidelisa Manibusan: It blows mind that ⁓ women still come to me and say, I had no idea that there was physical therapy for ⁓ I tell everybody, I'm here to help the surgeons. I'm here to help the plastic surgeons and make your breasts look good and feel like breasts again. ⁓ It's such a valuable tool ⁓ to patients and something that's so intimate. ⁓ tell everybody, I'm here to help the surgeons. I'm here to help the plastic surgeons and ⁓ your breasts look good and feel like breasts again. It's ⁓ such valuable tool ⁓ to patients and something that's so ⁓ intimate. to be able to feel like a woman again and to reconnect with your breasts to be able to feel like a woman again and to reconnect with your breasts because that's a part of who you are. And the grieving process that happens through cancer and through surgeries and through radiation, so many women identify with their breasts and not even necessarily realize it until something traumatic happens to them. So it's... Jennifer Ashby: Exactly. Yeah. Hidelisa Manibusan: The amount of women that are so grateful that we get to help them and reconnect with themselves is extraordinary. And I've been doing this almost exclusively at UCSF. I've been there for 14 and a half years. So I'd say at least the past 12 years, the amount of women that I've had come through has been extraordinary. And the amount of relationships that... I've kept on going even since patients have been discharged has been really amazing to me. ⁓ It's just so important and something that's just not offered often and not well known. Jennifer Ashby: Yeah, here I can actually, I can attest to the incredible work that. this does to people after any type of breast augmentation or surgery and the fact that it's not mandatory is almost criminal in my book. I it is true. I don't think women really realize how much they identify themselves through their own breasts. And that when they're changed, it's just not something we talk about or think about. And when they're changed beyond it being a choice, like an enhancement or reduction, don't think women really realize how much they identify themselves through their own breasts. ⁓ And that when they're changed, ⁓ it's just not something talk about or think about. ⁓ It is really ⁓ emotionally and spiritually devastating to have such an enormous part of your identity changed, not because you chose to. And even sometimes when you chose, you've chosen to, I have people that have had breast reductions that were shocked at, although they were excited about having the weight gone, that it really changed the way that they looked at themselves. And there's adjustment periods, huh? Hidelisa Manibusan: for. There is there's there's a grieving process and It there's so many women that come in when they come in to see me They won't even look at their breasts. They don't touch their breasts. They don't identify with their breasts anymore They they're just like they're not mine anymore. I don't want to I don't want to touch them I don't want anybody else to touch them. They don't want to give hugs. They don't want to carry their kids There is there's there's a grieving process and It there's so many women that come in when they come in to see me They won't even look at their breasts. They don't touch their breasts. They don't identify with their breasts anymore They they're just like they're not mine anymore. I don't want to I don't want to touch them I don't want anybody else to touch them. They don't want to give hugs. They don't want to carry their kids ⁓ And again as women that's so much of what we do ⁓ that for that to stop is just devastating and it affects your daily life and how you feel about yourself and how you feel about yourself as a woman to not be able to do those things that were so natural and so normal before. ⁓ you know, whether it's with children, whether it's with their partner and letting their partner touch their breasts. So much of that disappears and is so hard to get back ⁓ that, I really, I try to promote, you know, these patients to also see a therapist as we're going through this process because there's just so much and what I do and what physical therapy does is just a small piece of regaining that ownership of your body and your health as a woman. Jennifer Ashby: Right. Absolutely such a really good point. We kind of jumped in right in the middle, but I love it actually. think that breasts as an identifying factor of just being a woman is not actually something that's really discussed beyond IGEP. objectification or as mammary glands feeding. We don't really talk about the identity of a woman as being, you know, what our breasts are, right? Large breasts, full breast women, small breasted women, athletes and what they have to go through having maybe larger breasts. It's really interesting, ⁓ including those that choose to have their breasts removed, ⁓ Not for identity reasons and not and not the pain of having breasts when you don't want to identify with breasts. There's so many psychological factors that go along with boobs. What are all the names you can come up with? or boobs? Hidelisa Manibusan: Oh, this is funny that I'm actually thinking as we're talking about this, one of my patients, and this is a shameless plug for her, but she wrote a book, Tits Up, and it goes through exactly what you just asked me. What are the different names for boobs? Breasts, tits, you know, all the different names. And she kind of opted in this book, just tits. This is what she calls them. But it's funny, know, I've actually gone through this. I have a three-year-old and we're at the point where we're needing to identify body parts. And if I say breasts or boobs, my husband's like, ⁓ my gosh, don't say that. And I'm like, what are we supposed to call them? What is she gonna call them? She has to be okay with her body ⁓ as she grows and as we identify them, you know. Melons, watermelons, cantaloupe. I think I just saw something cantaloupe the other day and, you know, with the little emojis. ⁓ But all kinds of different slang. ⁓ You know, the ladies, the twins, sisters are just some of them. And it's funny because with what I do, I'll have some patients who say, I have to remember that they're sisters and not twins. ⁓ Jennifer Ashby: Heard cousins as opposed to twins. Like sometimes they're just cousins, but yeah, like there's a whole bunch of like almost caricature like descriptors as well. ⁓ Hidelisa Manibusan: in different ways that different cultures identify with their breasts. Some cultures are, this is very much a part of child rearing and feeding and nurturing. There's this whole sexual component to that. When that happened and what culture that happened and... the use of bras and whether or not we use bras and how comfortable we are with that and who, you know, it was a man that designed a bra, right? So it's, you know, again, identifying with what is it that... Jennifer Ashby: ⁓ we'll have to get into that. didn't know that. I have some broad questions at the end here for you. Hidelisa Manibusan: we identify with our breasts in the different cultures and where we stand and how comfortable you are with that. And different cultures, you know, identify with different things. For some, it's, you know, it's no big deal. You know, we have African tribes where women are walking around Topolis and there's no shame in that. But you walk down the street here and even in San Francisco, you know, where we regularly see people walking around with all clothes, there's still some shame to the breast and they have to be covered. And even when women breastfeeding. ⁓ Again, depending on the culture and depending where you are, how shameful it is for the breast to be exposed when you are providing life to a child. Jennifer Ashby: so full and so rich. have so many things to ask and so many things to say. You know, one of the things I say when I'm teaching patients proper posture is I use the fabulous Miss Maisel's tits out because you can tell people to like put your shoulders back. You can do that and still have terrible posture. There's so many, but the one descriptor that Liz's sternum leading like proper posture is tits out for men and women because it throws your body into a proper Hidelisa Manibusan: I'm Yes. Jennifer Ashby: ⁓ position where your skeleton can support itself. ⁓ I find it fascinating that in order for breasts to be acceptable, in some, guess it's social media. The most important thing to be covered is the nipple. What I mean that I'm sorry, that's a little, that's men like neon light, like showing us their Hidelisa Manibusan: it. Right. Jennifer Ashby: Infantile, what is it? ⁓ God, now I can't say the word. Infantilizing, can't speak. Showing that nursing is a fantasy and that the nipple makes them an unacceptable visual, right? Like I find that to be the most ridiculous thing. So you have this whole mammary gland and the thing that makes it unacceptable is a nipple. Do you have any insight into like the history of that or why the nipple would be the thing that needs to be covered? Hidelisa Manibusan: I don't, I don't. You know, it's funny because I feel like lately, right, the sexy thing to be exposed is the side boob. Everybody wants to see the side boob. ⁓ But the nipple, think part of it, it probably goes back to just the association with these men and their mothers, right? Like that's supposed to be something that's private and nursing is supposed to be private. ⁓ know, sexualizing and what men do to our breasts is supposed to be private. And there's something about exposing that and being proud that's all of a sudden shameful with that when we start sexualizing what should just be natural ⁓ for men. I blame men a lot for some of our issues with our breasts. Jennifer Ashby: Yeah, especially around the boob health. I'm not a man hater, but I'm feminist and I'd have two sons and so raising them to understand things like this is important to me. But yeah, this ⁓ demonization of our boobs is just an absolute ludicrous notion to me. But I have to say, side boob is sexy. Hidelisa Manibusan: Yeah. It is, it is. I forget what the name of the, it's on Amazon with like the superheroes, ⁓ but one of the main characters, his obsession is sucking on the teat. You know, he wants to get the milk. He wants exposure to the nipple and like. there's so many inserts on this show of in reference to the fact that he wants to go back to that mother figure and their shame in sexualizing the mother figure and putting those women on a pedestal. So I imagine there's probably something along those same realms of why all this and our nipples are so private and they should be covered and they shouldn't be exposed. Jennifer Ashby: Mm-hmm. I don't believe that it started with women either, for sure. Pure, pure, puritanical men. ⁓ So I want to get into some specific points that I think that we can really use. I could talk about pop culture and history and boobs with you forever, I feel like. ⁓ And maybe we will just do an entire episode on the history of attitudes toward boobs. Hidelisa Manibusan: No, no, I don't think so. Thank you. Jennifer Ashby: But today I want to give our listeners really some practical ideas, notions, feedbacks, things that they can do at home, talk about bras and posture. So do you mind if we jump into some of those questions? Great. So I wanted to ask you since your specialty is physical therapy, especially what role does posture play in breast health? ⁓ Are there postural corrections that you can tell our listeners that you would recommend? Hidelisa Manibusan: Okay. Yeah, know, posture's so important. I describe it as kind of our starting point for our body to run efficiently. ⁓ There's lots of research that talks about if we correct posture, does that in itself decrease impairments? And not necessarily so. ⁓ Sometimes over-correcting can actually cause more problems than leaving the posture as be. ⁓ but just the idea of opening up the neck and opening up the chest and opening up the shoulders. it kind of gives you a lead into our muscles being able to move efficiently, for our joints to be able to move efficiently, ⁓ for our breasts to be in a better position and a little bit supported versus this rounded position. Our chest muscles, our pec muscles are such strong muscles. And as soon as we start going into that forward rounded posture, it pulls everything in. ⁓ So it's not unusual for patients, large breasted ⁓ women, to have complaints about neck pain, upper back pain, shoulder pain, shoulder impingement. ⁓ So opening up the chest, opening up the shoulders, really utilizing all of these muscles that We don't use like we used to. We spend so much time on the computer. We spend so much time hunched over in these forward flex positions. It inevitably puts us here. ⁓ So opening up the chest, opening up the shoulders, opening up the neck. ⁓ That posture is just so important to give us a good strong foundation. ⁓ And what that posture, what that correct posture should be looks a little bit different on everybody depending on what your body type is. You know, what is your body weight? Where's your where's your pelvis? You know, I mean, you can you could take your stereotypical Latina or African American woman who tends to have an exaggerated lordosis and I say exaggerated very loosely. Jennifer Ashby: Will you explain lordosis just for our listeners? Hidelisa Manibusan: Lordosis would be the natural curve in your lower back. And again, just on stereotypical body types, right? We have an exaggerated or increased curve that accentuates the booty. ⁓ One of the dominant and loved things about African-American women and Latino women, they tend to have, but it accentuates the bum and accentuates the butt. So, you know, for those particular women, as we start working on the core and pelvis position, it's going to affect what the posture is doing. But if we try to over-correct that, you can actually cause more lower back pain. We're putting the body in a position that it doesn't naturally want to be in as compared to a woman who maybe has a little bit of a flatter spine and she doesn't necessarily have those accentuated curves or those accentuated... ⁓ lordosis, right? So to come in and try to drastically change that may actually cause more problems than solving them. So trying to find a balance of where somebody is and what kind of just opens them up a little bit and puts them in a slightly better position where all of a sudden all these muscles don't necessarily have to work so hard. They're not overworking, they're working efficiently. Jennifer Ashby: So that kind of begs the question for me, like how much do boobs weigh? And when you're making these corrections around, whether it's for someone who's had surgery, and I would love for you to get into like what surgery does in terms of ⁓ mobility with the muscles and stuff. Okay, so let me, I'm gonna, I'll ask this in order. Boobs can be really, they can weigh a lot, right? And that forward, what is that forward? hole do on women, women will often try to hide their boobs. So that does that rounding protection motion. We are in because East Asian medicine, you know, is my shtick. That is the yin, the most yin part of kind of the exterior body. And we often protected we go into a protection stance. So that also affects our posture. But also when we're in that kind of forward roll, like breast protective posture, it infects our lymphatic system as well. Lymphatic system. So, so let's talk about the weight of boobs, what that does to your thoracic spine and what all that does to like lymphatic flow and why it matters that our lymphatic system flows freely. Hidelisa Manibusan: Sure. So the weight of the breast obviously depends on the size of the breast. ⁓ I had a woman come in the other day and prior to her breast reduction she was a 36 double J. ⁓ She probably was still a full C, D by the time I saw her, but she said she had 10 pounds removed of breast tissue ⁓ from her chest, which just blows my mind. As compared to somebody who's maybe an A, small B, we're probably looking at maybe a couple of pounds. ⁓ But even that small amount of weight makes a big difference, particularly if... we are asymmetric. ⁓ So if we've had somebody who has had one breast removed or one breast is significantly smaller, that's going to affect the symmetry between both sides, ⁓ particularly long term. ⁓ So we've got one side that is tighter and has scar tissue. And that side's being pulled forward and this side's back. Now we've got an asymmetry that we're not really looking for. And it throws off our posture. throws off the positioning. But even with larger breasts, or you see this with some of our taller women who just, they wanted to shrink because being tall, when they're growing up through puberty, you get into this really tight forward posture. And so you can almost think of the spine as a chain. the cervical spine, your neck goes into this forward position, ⁓ so it's a little bit more extended. Our thoracic spine, our mid-back, is rounded and we're stuck in this forward position. ⁓ And the spine doesn't move well in that position. It doesn't extend. It doesn't allow our ribs to fully expand and move. So as we breathe, our ribs are supposed to go up and down. And when we get into that more rigid position, it just doesn't move quite as well. ⁓ And then our muscles start getting tight. So it's like, well, which came first, the chicken or the egg? ⁓ The muscles start getting shortened and tight. And then we kind of get stuck here. ⁓ Probably you've all seen these women that are either larger chested or a little bit larger in body size, but they're here and they have... down your supper, they have a hump on their back and their necks are really tight ⁓ and they're just not moving well. You know, you don't get full range of motion in your shoulder once we get into this position. So it affects everything in that whole upper quadrant. And again, you know, we come back to the core. If that core is not strong, if our central stabilizing base isn't strong, then everything collapses on each other. And so when the neck goes one way, the thoracic spine is going to go another way. Our lumbar spine or lower back going to go another way. That's going to affect our hips. That's going to positioning in the legs. That's going to affect how our feet position itself and how we stabilize ourselves. So it's just kind of, it's a chain reaction when we start coming into this position. Jennifer Ashby: That is so helpful. It's a really good description. I like to say to my patients that your your spine is like a double helix. So whatever happens on one end eventually is going to happen on the other end. But then that affects your hips and your knees and your feet. But also the way that we hold our body in relation to our boobs, shy, big, whatever it is, it really does have a full body, physical, neuromuscular skeletal effect. Hidelisa Manibusan: I will say even an emotional effect, right? mean, being able to have a woman walk around tall and... that just changed me. mean, you know, even you or me, you know, we can be blocking, like we're having a bad day, you know, we haven't been feeling well, we're kind of in this slump forward posture. But you start walking around loud and proud, and it changes your entire mood. You feel different. You feel lighter. So even just that shift in posture and how we're holding ourself, you can tell everybody, well, fake it till you make it. Walk around proud. Walk around with your chest up tall. It can affect you mentally and emotionally as well. ⁓ So it just makes such a big difference in how we're feeling. Jennifer Ashby: That's a really good point. That's actually a really good point that when we're sitting, walking with our shoulders slumped, we feel slumped. And when we're standing tall, we're actually standing tall. That's such a good point. You're speaking my mojo now. ⁓ So tell me how, well, I have two questions. ⁓ So you just talked about the core in terms of breast health and back health and chest health and. Hidelisa Manibusan: Mm-hmm. Thank you. Jennifer Ashby: neck health and all of that. People hear a whole bunch about, know, core core exercises core this, but our core is really the solid foundation of everything. Like nobody builds a house from the second story first. So if you don't have a good core, nothing's going to happen. Will you like just briefly, if you can, because this is not a core podcast, talk about what the core is and why it is actually the first place that Hidelisa Manibusan: Thank you. Jennifer Ashby: should be addressed for any strength and health within the body. Hidelisa Manibusan: Yeah, it's a little bit different about what most people think of, A lot of people will start with sit-ups, crunches, which actually aren't fantastic for your back. But we have layers of muscle around our core. We have our transverse abdominis. We have our internal and external obliques. You've got your pelvic floor, which most people don't even think about as being associated with the core and how much of a role that has. Again, that rectus abdominis, what people think of their six pack. ⁓ The only motion that that does is flexion. It doesn't actually help support our spine or transverse. Jennifer Ashby: which is what we're trying to avoid. When we're open, we're not flexing those muscles. Hidelisa Manibusan: Yeah, exactly. Yeah, yeah. So, you know, that transverse abdominis, which is like that innermost layer, and it goes from the front to the back, it connects to the ribs, it connects to the diaphragm. You know, that's actually what gives women that nice trim. waist that that we're so desperately searching for. But it's so important because that muscle in addition to your obliques and ⁓ the rectus and you know our layers. they all have to work together and that transverse abdominis should be activated in most of what we do ⁓ because it supports our organs. It keeps our organs where we are. It keeps our spine in the position. It helps protect us with movement, lifting, carrying, reaching. mean, how many times have you heard of somebody throwing their back out by bending over and just lifting something really light? Yeah, I mean, I, you know, Jennifer Ashby: girl I did it with Tupperware a month ago. Hidelisa Manibusan: Again, my daughter's three, three and a half years old. And I had a C-section and everything, every layer was cut through. And it took me the longest time to realize that I just was not connecting with my transverse abdominis. I wasn't able to activate, I just couldn't feel it. And that led to back pain, especially, you we talked about strengthening in this progressive load and, you know, what better progressive load than a growing child. But my back was hurting all the time. And I was like, wait a second. Like I never had these problems before. mean, I was able to move and you know, just as soon as I started working out everything, know, any aches and pains that I had went away. And I was joking with my trainer the other day as well. My glutes, my glutes. I tell you, since I've had my daughter, I feel like I cannot fire my glutes. I used to be able to build my glutes really easily and shamefully so. And now I'm like, Like, what is this pancake, but all of sudden happened because having her threw off my spine, it threw off how I activated my muscles. It threw off my pelvis, right? And all of a sudden, all that change in alignments changed how I can fire my glutes, my core, my pelvic floor. ⁓ Even though I didn't have a vaginal birth, everything was affected. Jennifer Ashby: But cutting through all those major abdominal muscles affected all the muscles through and through, right? Like that's the core part that it's not just the front and it's not just the back. It's all the muscles that go from front to back and back to front. It's like, it's almost like if you were to think of a bowl of muscles and they all interact with each other and that is your core, correct? Hidelisa Manibusan: Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely. It's that whole bowl and that stabilization, right? That, so to speak. ⁓ Which is why, you know, when people have back pain, you know, the back brace, feels good ⁓ because it's doing what your core is not supposed to be doing. But then we start relying on an external source for that support. We do that too long and all of a sudden our muscles really aren't working. And it's really hard to find that connection, you know, and particularly for women who never Jennifer Ashby: you Hidelisa Manibusan: really had a good mind-body connection. That's the hardest thing to teach is that body awareness. And so we want that activation. We want to teach them how to find their body, how to reconnect to their body ⁓ is so important. And even just breathing, diaphragmatic breathing is one big way to reconnect, right? Whether we're stressed, whether we're exercising, you know, whatever it is, we're trying to activate that core and to kind of calm the system down. Jennifer Ashby: ⁓ yeah. Absolutely. You bring up some really good points. I love to lead a room of like two or 300 people through diaphragmatic breathing. The minute I feel the energy like go down in the room, I go, Hey guys, let's do three deep diaphragmatic breaths. it changes a room instantaneously. But that's a talk for another time. Will you Hidelisa Manibusan: Mm-hmm. Jennifer Ashby: Will you explain to us since we're talking about movement and connection, ⁓ our lymphatic system, which is a really important part of our, ⁓ our entire mechanism that not only detoxifies our body by filtering out things that go through the blood and our tissue, ⁓ but also ⁓ helps to transport nutrients throughout our body and oxygen. ⁓ So please, can you talk about lymphatic health, breast health, and let the listeners know if there's any type of lymphatic, maybe self-drainage techniques that they can do at home to help improve not just their overall health, but breast health specifically. Hidelisa Manibusan: Sure. So our lymphatic system runs with our circulatory system. It runs with our arteries and veins. ⁓ The interesting thing with our lymphatic system is that it does have one-way valves, and it has its own smooth muscle, particularly within the deeper layers of our lymphatics. The deepest lymphatic trunk actually runs through our diaphragm, which is why breathing and deep breathing plays such a huge role in how well our lymphatic systems moving. The fluid that goes through our lymphatic system is a little bit different from our arteries and veins, but some of that fluid is derived from our blood. But it's very honey-like and thick in consistency, and it moves very slowly at like 10 to 12 beats per minute. So, again, it has its own kind of pulse rate, which is why that diaphragmatic breathing and kind of slowing our system down can really, really help regulate it. So it runs all the way through the body, but we have areas that have clusters of lymph nodes. So we have clusters behind essentially our necks and our ears. ⁓ We have them in our armpits. We have them in our groin areas, but you may have a lymph node kind of, you know, randomly at different places, but those are mainly where the clusters are. And this is why it's so important why we pay so much attention to our lymphatic system when a patient is having lymph nodes removed, whether in their groin area, say they have a uterine cancer or prostate cancer or breast cancer where we have lymph nodes here, head and neck cancer, they remove an extraordinary amount of lymph nodes from the neck. But that affects how well our system is moving. I tell everybody, it's like if you live in San Francisco, I-80, it's like shutting down I-80 with two or three exits. We still have the same amount of cars going down the freeway, but we just don't have as many avenues for the cars to filter out. ⁓ Our lymphatic system, so we still produce about two liters of lymph fluid per day, and that doesn't change when we have lymph nodes removed. via surgery, via radiation, via trauma, injury. different factors that can affect the lymphatic system. Again, it shuts down that efficiency of the lymphatic system. ⁓ We don't always truly know to what extent the lymphatic system can be damaged or what it's damaged when we do radiation with a lymph node because everybody has a different number of lymph nodes in those areas. But it's really important because in addition with the good factors, it also, you it helps to... drain our body essentially helps to remove some of the larger cells that our arteries and our veins can't factor. So a good lymphatic drainage, a good lymphatic massage, you're probably going to notice you have to pee afterwards because it just gets everything moving and gets it moving through our pancreas, through our bladder, through our kidneys. We want to keep that good healthy lymphatic system and keep things moving. But because of that smooth muscle, it also will learn how to adapt over time. And I think that's something that people don't take into account. ⁓ know, again, with that smooth muscle, training your lymphatic system is much like training your body for a marathon. You wouldn't go out and run a marathon tomorrow without any training. I mean, your entire body would light up. We'd be inflamed. We'd have injuries, tendonitis, whatnot. your lymphatic system will work in that same way. So, you know, after injury, after surgery, after radiation, if we overload the system too fast, then that's when we're a little bit more subjected to lymphedema, to our system just not functioning as well. So we want to start returning to everything, but a little bit more slowly. I have a 50-50 rule where, you know, I tell everybody, go back to 50 % of where you were. Progress 50 % as quickly as you would have. Allow your body to adapt to what your body is functioning at right now. But also, we want to train it to be able to handle everyday load and more. So that way, when we're done, your body can do everything and more compared to what it did before. Because now it's trained. We've made our body more efficient. Jennifer Ashby: So what would we do, what could you recommend that could be done for those who maybe have not been through surgery or recently had an injury where they could ⁓ keep their lymphatic system healthy for, with the focus of breast health? Is it hydration? Are there particular massages? Are there links online that you suggest to people? Hidelisa Manibusan: Hydration is Yeah, Jennifer Ashby: Thank Hidelisa Manibusan: So hydration, super, important for everything. And again, that lymph fluid is what we call high protein, low water ⁓ content fluid. So thick, it's honey-like. But that protein is a magnet for water. So if we are dehydrated, ⁓ your lymph system going to try to pull water from wherever it can in your body. ⁓ Jennifer Ashby: and Hidelisa Manibusan: So, you know, whether we're traveling, whether we're at altitude, whether we're exercising a lot, whether it's hot outside, we want to keep that fluid moving so it's moving efficiently. You know, I referenced earlier the Tahoe nights where, you know, that's the absolute worst thing that you can do for your lymphatic system. You know, getting into a hot tub after you've been skiing all day and dehydrating and having a bottle of wine and, know. Jennifer Ashby: Yeah. Hidelisa Manibusan: You know, it's everything that your lymphatic system doesn't want. ⁓ But the more hydrated we are, it just, helps with everything. It helps with our eyes, our skin, our hair, our nails, our GI system. ⁓ It just helps everything because our, you know, most of our body is actually water. ⁓ So it means that water to function at 100. It's a lot. It's quite a bit. Yeah. Jennifer Ashby: Like 70 some percent. It's a lot. I want to I want to just jump in real quick and just I want to say it again, your minimal amount of hydration, which is water or herbal tea with nothing in it, nothing else fully counts as hydration. I call it unsung and unsung hero in my book for perimenopause and menopause. It's actually the first thing you should do to see what symptoms you're left but Hidelisa Manibusan: you else. Jennifer Ashby: The equation is your weight in pounds divided by two is the minimum number of ounces of water you should have a day. You can also over hydrate, but also to say that there's about 34 ounces in a liter. So it's an easy translation, weight divided by two minimum number of ounces and there's about 34 ounces per in a liter of water. Hidelisa Manibusan: Mm-hmm. Yeah, and I mean, I, you know, I are a nice Stanley Cup with 20 ounces, you know, get through three to four of these a day. You know, it's once we start, you everybody's like, Oh, but it's so hard to carry that around. Once you start your body adjusts and it becomes, it becomes a habit. It's a good. Jennifer Ashby: It's habit habitual. Absolutely. That's what I say and to pre measure in the morning pre measure the water you need in the morning. And that's how you know if you get through it. Okay, so do you have any favorite like self lymphatic drainage techniques? Like, there's that guy online that does the big six that I think are very simple, easy way to do it. Do you have any favorites? Hidelisa Manibusan: So, you know, again, that diaphragmatic breathing, always starting with diaphragmatic breathing, you know, nice deep breath in, exhaling. I teach my daughter, we're blowing out candles ⁓ and that's how we're working on regulating her ⁓ emotions. ⁓ But starting with that diaphragmatic breathing is a good way to start. You're short on time, just work on that diaphragmatic breathing. ⁓ But you can do like small circles ⁓ right behind the neck, again, stimulating right through here. And lymphatic massage should really be very, like just enough to make that top layer of your skin move or just to make the little hairs on your arm move. But coming up to the neck and 10 small circles, we actually have a video that I distribute to our breast patients. ⁓ And the video has 10 repetitions. You're short on time. We get the same benefit from three to five repetitions. So again, diaphragmatic breathing. three to five circles here, three to five circles here into the groin area. ⁓ And again, we could, you know, we could go into further discussion on, you know, if there's breast or pelvic involvement, but that's always just a good way. And movement, quite honestly, movement is probably one of the best ways that we can get our lymphatic system moving, so going out for that walk. moving our arms ⁓ is really primary. And I always tell patients, well, what kind of exercises should I be doing? And quite honestly, I'm like, you I don't actually care. I want you to do something that you're actually gonna like and that you're gonna do on a regular basis. ⁓ You know, we always, say 150 minutes of cardiovascular activity per week, two full bot, two days per week of full body strengthening. ⁓ But again, when push comes to shove, I don't actually care. I just want you moving. Jennifer Ashby: Thank you. Hidelisa Manibusan: Thanks, everyone. Jennifer Ashby: Agreed, agreed, agreed, agreed. ⁓ Is there anything before we move on to I want to get on to nursing and lactation? Is there any like main idea that you want to share just about like postural, lymphatic, neuromuscular skeletal stuff? Like if there was one pearl golden rule that you'd want to share, what would that be? Hidelisa Manibusan: I tell you, squeeze your shoulders low. Just squeeze. And you'll see, a lot of times when you tell somebody to fix their posture, they come up here. Jennifer Ashby: Yeah. Hidelisa Manibusan: We use our upper traps way too much as it is. And so you don't really want to activate that as we're trying to position. So I tell you, just squeeze low, squeeze low. You don't have to squeeze at 100%, but just that 50 % squeezing low, holding it there as soon as you find yourself here again, squeeze low. And you feel, even when we're doing it here, by doing that, you actually activate your core at the same point, because we kind of, we all of sudden come up and. Jennifer Ashby: Yeah. Everybody listening is totally doing this right now. I'm doing this right now. It's like suggesting cables. Hidelisa Manibusan: Absolutely. You need to be doing it throughout the day. But that is my pearl. If there's any one thing that you remember that I tell you is to squeeze low, then that will put you in better alignment for everything. Jennifer Ashby: as well. I want to transition into nursing and lactation and breast health right now. What are the most common musculoskeletal issues that arise from breastfeeding and how would you as a physical therapist address them? Hidelisa Manibusan: Sure. Again, coming back to our posture. lots of neck pain, neck tightness. We get shoulder impingement, upper back pain, because nursing and holding, again, we're kind of holding in this four round position, particularly when we're only nursing from one side. So trying to go from side to side, again, as much as your breasts allow if you're breastfeeding, but even if you're not breastfeeding, but being able to switch and hold. I tell patients, try to make it as passive as you possibly can. Use the support that you have around you. Use the pillows, ⁓ the boppy pillows, the armrests. Allow your body to take that weight off because again, the baby's gonna be growing, they're gonna be moving. And that's no different from having breasts and just pulling that forward. ⁓ So, you know, again, kind of opening it up, making it a passive, trying to be as upright as possible ⁓ with that switching between sides is going to be important. Jennifer Ashby: I find that ⁓ the most important thing that I tell women breastfeeding is that if they can have elbow support to create that passivity, then they're not actually engaging the traps and that there's so much so that they get into that terrible like upper body like I'm dying here or holding the weight of the baby. You know, there's so much support out there bolster your pillows. That's what I say. Hidelisa Manibusan: I'm sorry. Yeah, I mean, I distinctly remember, especially during the middle of the night, and I'd get so mad at my husband every time he moved this pillow, but I had a habit of feeding her right to left. ⁓ But I had a pillow that rested on my armrest of our chair because that would keep me upright and keep me from rolling forward. Otherwise, I would be all scrunched up. you know, throughout the day. And you could feel it. You could feel the differences and just how my back, how I was moving throughout the day. Because we're just, you know, you're there for, gosh, what sometimes feels like forever if the baby's, you know, not feeding or not latching. ⁓ But being in that position, you know, just again, being upright as best as we can and using as much support as you possibly could. So all the pillows. Jennifer Ashby: Because when we're holding collapsed and looking down, which I still remember even though my kids are well into adulthood, like, wow, there's not a lot of worse things you can do prolonged for your neck and your thoracic spine. I don't think. Hidelisa Manibusan: No, and I mean, I was not producing when I had my daughter. She was about a month premature. ⁓ And I remember the conversation and the lactation specialist coming into the hospital and trying to get me to triple breastfeed. ⁓ And that was absolutely the worst thing ever. Just as a mom, as a woman, like nothing made me feel more defeated than the act of triple breastfeeding because the triple breastfeeding, you try to get the baby to nurse. And once that's done, then you, I remember distinctly, we, you know, Jennifer Ashby: Can you explain what triple breastfeeding is for? Hidelisa Manibusan: you get the line and the nipple. And I clearly have tuned some of this out because it was so traumatic. ⁓ I remember this whole setup of trying to essentially trick the baby into drinking. so we ⁓ had the line that I had to set up and tape on and get the baby. Jennifer Ashby: I don't need you to re-traumatize yourself. I'm sorry. So the line for people that don't know actually provides nutrition to the child while it's near the breast so it thinks that it's getting milk from the boob. Hidelisa Manibusan: Yes, it just still just says uncomfortable. And then after all of that, trying to pump. know, you I mean, gosh, they would say, well, you have to do this eight to 10 times a day. It took me 45 minutes to be able to go through all that and sometimes upwards of an hour. That is the entire time that I'm spending with my baby at home. My husband went back to work after two weeks, so I'm at home by myself trying to do this with her. It was traumatizing and I felt like the biggest failure because there was so much pressure to breastfeed and to get her that breast milk. And I mean, I just... That put me into postpartum depression because I just felt like as a fail, I felt like a failure as a mother that I couldn't, that I wasn't producing. And when I did produce, I wasn't producing very much and she wasn't getting enough nutrients and I couldn't tell how much nutrients she was getting. I finally saw my OB, my outpatient OB, and she was like, you're fine. You were fine. Your mental health is so important. And if this is affecting you that much, just stop. Your baby's gotten enough breast milk at this point. You can keep trying to do what you can, but it is okay to let that go. And the second I did, my mental health vastly, vastly improved. Jennifer Ashby: Good, I'm glad you met with her. I had a fourth degree tear with my first child. And so my breastfeeding was a little bit different and then I could not move. So I couldn't actually take her off the boob if I was home by myself. And so by the time I could move, when she was off my body, she could not handle it because she'd never really... Hidelisa Manibusan: Thanks ⁓ my god. Wow. No. Jennifer Ashby: been off the boob unless she was sleeping and fell off the boot. It's so interesting. We all have these stories and we're isolated in these silos when we're going through them. And it's such an unnatural way to be. We should not be isolated going through this. once, ⁓ many years ago now, we did a study at Stanford University ⁓ working on ⁓ depression in pregnant women and postpartum. Hidelisa Manibusan: Mm-hmm. Jennifer Ashby: And I was an assessor for this for the study for a few years, which was a wonderful study. It we were published in the New York Times. It was incredible. But listening, spending three years listening to women's stories about isolation and pregnancy and postpartum, it really made me want to write a book just about the conversations I had in treatment rooms with women. Breastfeeding is a really interesting part of our culture. I'm going to have I have a breastfeeding. I have a lactation specialist who just finished her fourth tour in Gaza. ⁓ Yes, ⁓ teaching women how to breastfeed because if you don't breastfeed your baby perishes because there's no formula, right? There's no supply chain. Anyway, so she'll be coming to talk to us too. ⁓ So I have a question. So ⁓ how can a new mother prevent or treat block Hidelisa Manibusan: Wow. you Jennifer Ashby: ducts and mastitis using your physical therapy techniques or that any women listening that can teach their daughters, granddaughters, nieces, fairy god nieces, whatever about how to prevent mastitis and blocked ducts. Hidelisa Manibusan: Massage vibration ⁓ really does wonders for the breast, stimulating, ⁓ trying to get those ducts moving, trying to get them unclogged. ⁓ Jennifer Ashby: How did they do that? Hidelisa Manibusan: So they've got these little wonderful massagers ⁓ that they sell online and some of them have heat, some of them don't. ⁓ But you essentially just kind of work around the breast and get the vibration to kind of stimulate and get movement ⁓ in the breast tissue. And that can often help quite a bit. ⁓ know, mastitis, it's complicated and there's multiple factors that contribute to that. ⁓ But that sometimes can help get things moving, ⁓ warmth. warm compress ⁓ can sometimes help or the combination of the two. ⁓ A lot of times even with patients that I'm working with, there's, and I joke that I should have invested in this because I have probably 90 % of my patients purchase this little handheld massager to help break up scar tissue, to get the breast tissue moving. It's like 27 bucks online and it's just one speed vibration and to get in there and. Even with patients who aren't lactating, we get movement of fluid through their ducts. We sometimes occasionally will get discharge coming out through the ducts or, you we're actually helping to express some fat necrosis before it's developed. So vibration, just getting stimulation to the breast can often help with that. Jennifer Ashby: What is your device called? Hidelisa Manibusan: So it is a Norco mini massager. You'll see a lot of occupational therapists use it, but it's just this little handheld massager. comes with three different tips, one speed, gentle enough for the breast tissue. ⁓ So I have my patients just apply a thin layer of lotion and then just to follow and kind of track those areas that are feeling a little bit hard or a little bit full or where the tissue just feels a little stagnated. ⁓ Can help with that. Jennifer Ashby: And then one of the things I tell my patients, I would love to hear if you agree with this because I actually have never asked a breast professional about this, is, I'm gonna lean up and put my chest in the picture. I make sure that they move from lateral down toward the nipple, like nothing should come up, but keep everything moving in the direction where you want it to be expressed, which is out the nipple. Do you agree with that? Hidelisa Manibusan: Yeah, yeah, I mean, I've got a patient right now who, I mean, we just keep breaking things up and as soon as we get that, we start getting expression from her breasts and it completely makes her breasts so much softer and so much more comfortable. And a lot of times that discomfort in the breast isn't coming from one thing in particular, but just the swelling and the fullness and the lack of fluid movement in the breast. ⁓ can make that uncomfortable and make the breast painful. So anything that you can do to get that fluid moving. again, in our breast tissue and our body, we have multiple layers of tissue. And in between those fascial layers, we have ground substance that's water, that's cells, that's everything that keeps our body nice and lubricated and moving. And when those layers start sticking together, then we get a lack of movement. We get the lack of movement. ⁓ And you almost kind of feel it. I tell her it kind of feels like modeling play ⁓ when the fluid's not moving. And sometimes you'll even see the pores in your skin. And so getting that moving and getting that self-training, working on the diaphragmatic breathing, sometimes compression can help if there's not a lot of inflammation, it's just more fluid buildup. Sometimes that will help get things moving. movement exercise, right? We want... Jennifer Ashby: Hydration hydration hydration you cannot produce breast milk abundantly as a dehydrated person. Where do you think that fluid comes from? Hidelisa Manibusan: Absolutely, absolutely. And it's like, you know, we've got to watch our caffeine intake. We've got to watch our alcohol intake. We've got to watch some of those things that naturally dehydrate our bodies and be more mindful of what we're doing. Salt intake, right? Too much salt is not going to be good for us. ⁓ So, you know, I tell my patients hydration, you know, eating as cleanly as possible, really everything in moderation. So, sure. Jennifer Ashby: Can we talk about that? Can we talk about like, like what what ⁓ drinks might not be healthy for breast tissue and what foods might not be healthy for breast tissue and also lactation. Hidelisa Manibusan: Yes, so caffeine as I sit here drinking my my Phil's coffee. ⁓ You know, one cup a day, two cups a day are really kind of at max what we recommend. But you'll talk to women who have five to six cups of coffee a day. ⁓ Your body. Jennifer Ashby: I'd be like a chipmunk on crack, man. If I drink that much coffee. I don't drink coffee at all. Hidelisa Manibusan: I have cup of coffee after two o'clock and I can't sleep that night. ⁓ So caffeine, know, anything with caffeine, whether it's coffee, energy drinks, ⁓ you know, I can still be like, well, how about black tea? Black tea's got quite a bit of caffeine as well. ⁓ So we want to go more green tea or start going, you know, half and half or going decaf if you're really like wanting the taste of the coffee. ⁓ Wine, wine, I know we're in San Francisco in the Bay Area and we love our wine. too much alcohol ⁓ is not great for our hydration. also... Yeah, there's a high correlation with alcohol intake and breast health and breast cancer. ⁓ So it's, know, lot of my patients have stopped drinking completely or they're down to maybe a glass or two of wine a week. ⁓ But it can, yeah. It's... ⁓ Jennifer Ashby: And does it affect breast tissue? Does alcohol have a negative effect on breast tissue? Hidelisa Manibusan: particularly with the risk of breast cancer and again, dehydration, that's always a big factor. ⁓ too much preservatives, too much salt in the diet, again, can dehydrate the body. ⁓ Spicy foods, particularly when we're eating out, and the spices themselves are not bad, but when we put them in combination with the sodium, with the preservatives, everything that's there to make the food super, super tasty, right, when we go out and about. Saturated fats, we wanna try to go more non-saturated. ⁓ There's a little bit of contrast controversy back and forth that talks about like soy. And again in moderation, ⁓ know. Jennifer Ashby: in terms of it being a phytoestrogen. Hidelisa Manibusan: Exactly, Yeah. So, you know, there's, there's a little bit back and forth on that. And I think inherently it's by itself, it's not a bad thing if we're only drinking soy, then, you know, that's, that's a whole different story, but in everything in moderation, ⁓ I think is, is, is fair game. ⁓ Jennifer Ashby: know that this isn't part of, thank you for that, I know that this isn't part of the PT part of breast health, but I still get patients whose doctors have told them that what they eat doesn't affect their breast milk. Where do you, and which I believe is the most ludicrous notion ever, and not to sway the interviewee, but where do you stand on an idea like that? Hidelisa Manibusan: Sure. Mmm, mm-hmm. Yeah. Thank Yeah, you know, mean, just in general, like protein intake is something that's become very, very prominent. You know, we need all of those factors. You need a healthy amount of carbohydrates. You need a healthy amount of proteins. We need a healthy amount of fats. So we don't want to completely eliminate fats from our body, but more likely less animal-based fats. We can still have a little bit of that in there, but it's usually not as much as people think. You know, and I think a lot of it comes down to general health. ⁓ If we're living off a diet of, you know, carbohydrates, potato chips, you know, things that are processed, ⁓ I think that affects how our body is moving. Our body is not meant to process and digest all of those foods. And so, of course, we're going to start feeling stopped up. Of course, you know, things are going to not move as well as they should. you know, sometimes you'll just hear people, soon as they start eating healthier, everything, your body just starts kind of clearing everything out, right? And so I think overall healthy, healthy diet, healthy balance, protein, hydration, less alcohol, less caffeine can certainly help with that, but. Jennifer Ashby: And breastfeeding is a metabolic event, right? It takes calories to produce breast milk. takes calories. It takes energy to actually recover from birthing a child. This idea of like no carb, low carb, quick weight loss after childbirth is actually not great for lactating either. Like it throws the body into an extra state of shock. And that's a conversation for a whole other episode. ⁓ Hidelisa Manibusan: Yeah, we need those calories. ⁓ even with patients that are going through chemotherapy, ⁓ I know you're trying to go and have this nice anti-inflammatory diet. You're trying to be healthy. But that's not the time that we start depriving our body of calories. Like if you want a milkshake, go eat a milkshake, go drink a milkshake. Like you need those calories to be able to handle the caloric load that your body needs to be able to fight that cancer. And the same, you know, with, with breastfeeding and with, ⁓ we need those calories and too much to put your body in a position of depletion. Your body has to fight that much harder and it's going to come at a cost somewhere, somewhere is going to make up for that lack of calories and intake. Jennifer Ashby: great milkshake recipe for oncology patients that isn't just like full dairy sugar in case you're ever, it's like dates and avocado and nut milk and bananas and plant-based chocolate protein. It's like absolutely delicious. I actually eat it, but it doesn't give all that crap that you're saying, talking about avoiding. Okay, I digress. Hidelisa Manibusan: Yeah. Jennifer Ashby: I wanna segue into stress in the breast because even in East Asian medicine, the connection between breast health, whether it be ⁓ cancer, whether it be ⁓ cystic breast, whether it be just breast health prior to menstruation and breast pain, stress has a huge ⁓ effect on the breasts. ⁓ And I would like to ask you, our breast expert, how does chronic stress affect the breast? tissue health, the lymphatic drainage in and around the breast and inflammation. We are not talking about just to clarify, I am never talking about not having stress. It is the 21st century. It is modern day that is an impossibility. We all have stress. What I teach, I teach a course called the epic eight, it's called boom, the epic eight, it's your basic optimal outcome method. And the epic eight are diet, hydration, sleep, breath work. Hidelisa Manibusan: Alright. Jennifer Ashby: constitutionally appropriate movement and exercise, gut health and bowel movements. And to those six essentials, I had two practices. The practice of experiencing joy and awe every day. I say joy is an inside job, awe is an outside job. Sometimes you don't wanna get outside, can you cultivate it inside? Sometimes you can't cultivate it inside, but there's always, especially where we live, you can always find something externally to be in awe of. Hidelisa Manibusan: Mm-hmm. Jennifer Ashby: because it boosts our innate immune system, which is what helps fight cancer. And the eighth one in the Epic Eight is tools to not embody stress. And again, it's not having stress, it's having tools to differentiate the difference between inconvenience and when a saber-toothed tiger is actually chasing you. Modern life asks us to respond to stressful responses like the tiger's always chasing us. And it's a way of keeping us engaged in life and work. Hidelisa Manibusan: Mm-hmm. Jennifer Ashby: but it is making us all sick. I want, and again, in East Asian medicine, we've got this whole boob thing. So learning tools to not embody stress, diaphragmatic breathing is one of my biggest tools that I teach patients. I would love to hear from you what you tell patients about that breast health tissue, lymphatics, drainage, inflammation, and stress. Again, this is chronic stress, not occasional stress. Hidelisa Manibusan: Mm-hmm. Yeah, I always think I can think of two patients ⁓ in my history of teaching or working with breast patients that always make me think about how much stress affects our breast health. ⁓ When we look at lymphatic risk factors, particularly for breast cancer patients, the... There's multiple factors that we look at, but the three main things we look at are how many lymph nodes have they had removed? ⁓ Have they had radiation? What's their BMI? Anything above 30 is ⁓ considered high risk. But these two women in particular on paper were very, very low risk factors for lymphedema. They had a very healthy, clean, green diet. They had one lymph node removed. ⁓ no radiation. But these two women, every single time we would have a flare in the breast or the breast would essentially swell ⁓ was when they had major life factors happening. you know, one was going in the middle of going through a bad divorce, the other one already divorced, but going through child custody issues. And every single time one of those stressors hit, we had a major breast swell. So I always use that example, and it's an extreme example, but that gives you an idea of how much stress affects our lymphatic system, how much stress affects our breasts. And again, as women, there are so many things that is communicated to us through our breasts. Hormonal changes, right? Like if the hormones change, you know, we notice changes in our breasts. Nipple sensitivity, breast tenderness. ⁓ Our breasts alert us to a lot. Changes in the breasts will tell us, we might have cancer. We might need to get this examined. But breast health in itself and stress, inflammatory properties, the hormones. We talk about chronic stress. Well, that raises your cortisol level. Cortisol is a hormone. That's going to affect. how our body is holding on to that. And there's no amount of anti-inflammatory diets or supplements that's going to take care of that. And it's funny, we mentioned stress and I always told my breast patients, like we need to figure out a way to manage stress. And that's very odd for me to tell a patient who is going through cancer treatment and is managing all of their life factors that you need to manage your stress. But I tell them what I really want you to do is to figure out, know, when's the last time that you did something joyful for yourself? When's the last time that you did something that you really loved? Even if it's spending five minutes on whether it's reading a book, whether it's going outside for a walk, whether it's playing with your puppy, we wanna try to do something. at each point in the day that brings us joy, that kind of re-centers our being. ⁓ Learning how to manage those stressful moments. Again, that diaphragmatic breathing, or with my daughter and actually with my husband too, I'm quite often saying, okay, let's take a time out, let's blow out our candles, let's throw out, blow out. three birthday candles and we take that time to slow down our autonomic system, taking that deep breath in, slow breath out. ⁓ You know, going out in nature, going out into the sun, the sun's wonderful for us. ⁓ We need that vitamin D, it helps our moods. ⁓ You know, again, just trying to find something that works for you. For my women going through treatment, let's set a goal. Let's set something that you have to look forward to after each phase of treatment. That can be a dinner. That could be a Lululemon sports bra. You know, whatever it is. It's important to give yourself something to look forward to no matter how small or big. But we also want to make it sure that it's attainable, it's reachable, right? That it's something that's not so lofty of a goal, but we want to give ourselves those small breaks that make us feel like we've accomplished our goal, to make us feel like we've accomplished, that we've moved through a phase, ⁓ bringing that joy to your point. Jennifer Ashby: Yeah. ⁓ that's so good. I love that you brought up the nervous system, cortisol dysregulation and the breast. Outside of breast cancer with cyclical breast pain and tenderness, is it the same recommendations that you make to patients? Hidelisa Manibusan: It is. is. So much comes back to movement and a healthy lifestyle. I always tell patients, when you're going through this, I don't want you to think of these recommendations as rehab. I don't want you to think of this as treatment. What we really want are small, obtainable lifestyle changes. that we can continue if we go from zero to 100. I forget what study it was, it was talking about just people who exercise and the three different ways that we exercise. You've got your people who are from zero to 100. ⁓ You've got your patients who just kind of people who just have a hard time getting started and then you've got your slow and steady. And the slow and steady ones are the ones who are going to be more apt to stay with a program and stick with a problem longer or zero to 100. They try everything and they build everything, but it's not sustainable because they're not changes that we can continue to do. So making everything small and measurable ⁓ as we start to build those goals. Jennifer Ashby: it. I love it. So so so can you name three mind body practices that you would recommend for breast health? think you just mentioned them. But look, can we put them in a list of like the three top? And then could you just say the three top things that you think are ⁓ dangerous or detrimental for breast health? Just as we and then we're going to talk about bras. Hidelisa Manibusan: Sure, so the three top things for breast health, movement, exercise, hydration, diet, know, very, very easy things for us to obtain that sometimes feel like they're unobtainable. The worst things that we can do for our breasts is just to ignore ourselves, to not pay attention to ourselves. We as women, The worst that we can do ⁓ for our breasts ⁓ to ignore to pay attention ourselves. We as women, ⁓ are so used to taking care of everybody else that it is hard for us to take a step back and take care of ourselves first. And I'm constantly reminding women, you are no good to anybody else unless you're taking care of yourself. We have to make that a priority. are so used to taking care of everybody else that it is hard for us to take a step back and take care of ourselves first. And I'm constantly reminding women, you are no good to anybody else unless you're taking care of yourself. We have to make that a priority. I don't know, is that one, two, and three? Jennifer Ashby: Yeah, thank you. I love it. I want to ask you, ⁓ there's so many things I want to ask you, but I know that we can't just talk forever and you were so patient this morning with those tech issues. Hidelisa Manibusan: Thank Jennifer Ashby: I think that breast health and the somatic experience of just being part of your breast since most of us don't understand how much we actually identify with our breasts as we mentioned earlier. Is there something that you can share with our listeners so that they can determine what would be a normal breast experience and sensation and when there's a breast experience or sensation that warrants going to a doctor and getting checked out? Hidelisa Manibusan: Sure. ⁓ Tenderness, breast pain, that's not necessarily associated with our menstrual cycle. ⁓ Swelling of the breast. You may notice skin changes, either redness, warmth. ⁓ Again, we kind of give that orange skin texture our signs that's orange. Jennifer Ashby: orange peel like the lemon or orange peel. Hidelisa Manibusan: Exactly. ⁓ Nipple changes. ⁓ So if that nipple is starting to invert, ⁓ discharge from the breasts are all good morning signs that we sum things up. ⁓ Regular breast examinations. Again, a lot of us, and myself included, I am guilty of not necessarily examining my breasts and getting a good feel for what normal feels like for me. ⁓ Women with denser breasts. Jennifer Ashby: You're like the cobbler who needs new shoes. Hidelisa Manibusan: I am. I mean, I just went through this whole phase of examining my breasts. I work in breasts. I work on breasts every single day. And ⁓ I just kind of was feeling around. And I thought I had had ⁓ just like a little ingrown hair in my armpit. ⁓ And then all of sudden, I noticed one day it was a little bit larger. It's tender to the touch. ⁓ And so, you know, again, knowing what I know, and I'm like, this, this would be ridiculous for me to come in as a breast practitioner and completely ignore all the signs and senses that something's not right. And so I, you know, I had gone into my PCP and had her examine and she's like, I think it's a sebaceous cyst, but you know, we'll just kind of keep an eye on it. And again, I'm a healthcare practitioner. I'm very guilty of this in my own right, but I'm thinking, well, that's lovely. You're a primary care physician, fantastic, but you are not touching breasts on a regular basis. So I immediately sent an email and text to the breast team that I work with. And I was like, I would just feel much better if I had somebody who's touching breasts on a regular basis. to do an exam and tell me that this is normal or this is abnormal. And they worked me in super quick, did a breast exam. They thought the same thing as ⁓ my PCP, but I found a second lump in the same area that was a little bit deeper. So I'm myself, currently in the process of getting that next diagnostic mammogram and ultrasound, and I will feel a lot better once everything's done with that. Jennifer Ashby: sprinkling like magic sparkly good juju dust all over you. Hidelisa Manibusan: ⁓ And I think, you know, and I'm sure everything's fine, but it's like I cannot be an advocate for breasts and not follow my own advice. ⁓ And breasts, again, I'm guilty. I'm guilty of not. you know, feeling my breasts on a regular basis, particularly after breastfeeding, particularly after, you know, childbirth, they've changed. They don't sit the same way they used to. They don't feel the same way that they used to. So, you know, knowing what that norm is, is super important. And even after breast surgery or, you know, any trauma to the breast, maybe we're not necessarily feeling for lumps, but we're feeling for changes. And you only know a change if you're acquainted. with your bra. Jennifer Ashby: You got to be familiar with your I have super fibrous breasts. I have small breasts and they're super fibrous and I'm I'm either all up in there like every month or like I'll forget for months when I forget for months I get a little panicky because I have to remember Then like wait was that there before have we already gone in and looked at that stuff? So when you have dense fibrous breasts, they're harder to see through with mammogram and they can't detect everything Hidelisa Manibusan: Most women have dense breasts and it doesn't matter what size breasts you are, but it does. Like on palpation, on feeling them, dense breasts are lumpy to begin with. I mean, my PCP, the first thing she said, she was like, well, your breasts are lumpy. But it's like, you don't want to hear that when you're trying to get an exam and you're like, but I felt a lump and something's off. Something feels a little weird. Jennifer Ashby: Yeah. Hidelisa Manibusan: But again, knowing how much of that lumpiness is normal and what is not normal. If anything's changing with that, is it getting harder? Is it getting softer? Is there an area that's particularly hard compared to how the rest of my breast, how my other breasts feel? So I'm working and trying to follow my own word and advice and be better about self-examination. Jennifer Ashby: Good, and thank you for all that. Thanks for exposing that and being vulnerable too. I think that that's what I want this podcast to be all about and not just information dissemination, but that we're women and we're all in this together. Hidelisa Manibusan: And honestly, that's the way I practice. I I joke sometimes and I come home sometimes and I'm like, gosh, I think I gave my patients TMI today. But I'm asking them to be very vulnerable with me. They are laying on a table, topless, for 45 minutes with me as I'm touching a very private, intimate part of their body. And I'm asking them to trust me. And so I often just approach my practice like, we're girlfriends hanging out. Let's talk about life. Let me get to know you. Let me let you in a little bit. Because you're not going to trust me if I'm here. If I'm not approachable, why on earth are you going to trust me and allow me into your life and into your body? Jennifer Ashby: I call it bringing humanism back into medicine and it doesn't matter what they ask me to speak about at UCSF. always, especially if they're med students, I always bring it back to humanism and medicine. We were not meant to have this dissociative experience with the people caring for us. Barefoot doctors did not do that. The family physician knew everything about everybody's stuff. This is a much more modern movement. And I get that there's really clear ethical reasons behind that. But what I really wish would have been taught is that the ethical part of being human, that there are ways of communicating and relating to the people that you're caring for that doesn't require the gap. And I think the gap has not always benefited the pursuit of Western medicine. But that also is another episode. I want to ask you about bra fitting considerations for everybody. What does that matter from a musculoskeletal point of view and Hidelisa Manibusan: Thank Jennifer Ashby: And what should women be looking at and pursuing when trying to get bras? Like with my small breasts, I don't need an underwire bra. That is the most ridiculous. Actually, and I have one right now, ironically, but I don't need underwire. Why do they make little boob bras with underwires? Anyway, talk to us about bra fitting. Hidelisa Manibusan: Yeah, so men, a man designed the bra the first time, which is why they're so darn uncomfortable. Yeah, I mean, we support. support essentially no matter how small or how large your breasts are. When our breasts are coming forward, when they're falling forward, again, that's going to change our postural aspect. But we need bras that are supporting us over our arms as much as supporting us underneath. And those needs may change depending on where we are, what our hormones, what our size are, are we on our period, are we not, are we exercising, right? All of those make a big difference. But essentially, and I always laugh because ⁓ one of the new trends, and I'm sure you've probably noticed too, ⁓ particularly in the Bay Area, a lot of these young women are not wearing bras. And I'm like, my goodness, help those puppies up because they're going to keep dropping, right? Our elasticity is going to change. If we can help support it, not that we need to glue them to our chest. But let's help our connective tissue and fascia as much as possible and give it the support that it needs. So that way it's not pulling on everything. Those breasts drop, it pulls everything forward. It's like hanging with two weights on your chest, essentially. ⁓ Jennifer Ashby: Sure. Hidelisa Manibusan: So it's important to make sure that, ⁓ and again, this changes depending on where we are, but we want the band around our trunk to be well-fit. We don't want it digging into the skin too tightly. It should rest and it should be a little bit firm, but not so much that it's digging in. There's some controversy on and off. we wear wires underneath our breasts? Do we not? What is the negative effect? What kind of chemicals are feeding into our skin with underwires? ⁓ I gave up wires a long time ago, not necessarily because of that, but just because I found wireless to be more comfortable. And wireless bras have really come a long way. They really give just as much support as some of the underwire bras, and the shape's a little bit better. it's OK to have your lovely, pretty bra. be a little bit more sensible with your bra wear on day-to-day basis. ⁓ But ultimately, you you want somebody to feel good about where they are and how they feel. Jennifer Ashby: You know, thank you. This kind of begs the question for me. Just playing devil's advocate a little bit. So why would... Hidelisa Manibusan: Okay. Jennifer Ashby: more indigenous populations that run around without bras not I'm guessing that they're not going to have the same forward weight issues because they tend to be more out there physically active people so therefore they don't have the same issues so is it our Sedentary more sedentary less movement lifestyles that make it so that not wearing a bra puts extra weight on our less muscular body Hidelisa Manibusan: 100%. I mean, we spend so much time sitting on the computers, on the phones, on the tablets that really pull everything forward. Everything that we do is forward. ⁓ With a lot of these indigenous cultures, they're very active. They tend to be healthier in body weight, healthier in BMI. And quite honestly, their breasts are not viewed as... as sexual. is viewed as a normal part of your existence and very human and a part of womanhood and childbirth and child rearing. Jennifer Ashby: So the way they carry them is just normal. There's not. Hidelisa Manibusan: Yeah, yeah. mean, and you know, I mean, we've seen the pictures, right? The breast may be saggy, but there's nobody who's judging them on how those breasts are because those breasts serve a purpose. It's not sexual. It's for nutrition. It's for food. It's for, you know, they view them very differently. And again, those women are walking around loud and proud. They don't have anybody who's judging them. So they've got that posture. They've, you know, they've got that stance. Jennifer Ashby: Thank Hidelisa Manibusan: So we've got a lot to learn now as well. Jennifer Ashby: So helpful. Last question. Is there anything that you wished I had asked that you'd like to share with the Overreacting Podcast listeners? Hidelisa Manibusan: ⁓ gosh, I, you know, we've covered so much and I feel like there's so much more to cover. ⁓ But it's just, you know, I think it's so important. I really appreciate you doing this because it's just let's make people, let's make women comfortable having this conversation about their breasts, about their bodies, ⁓ especially as we're changing. gosh, I was telling somebody the other day, you know, I just heard 45 and Jennifer Ashby: So nice. Hidelisa Manibusan: Being a woman in my 40s is so different from being a woman in my 30s, in my 20s. And I'm appreciating my body and who I am as a woman so much more in my 40s despite my three-year-old and lack of sleep. But there's something like I take care of my skin better now. I'm more aware of my diet and my exercise and my sleep. ⁓ my gosh, my sleep is so important and again, important with breast health. I just, if I don't get a good night's sleep, everything, everything is wrecked. ⁓ So I appreciate you bringing awareness to this, but ⁓ I do. Sleep hygiene, so important. Please make it a priority. Make movement a priority no matter how small or how large. ⁓ You know, we don't have to strive to be these ⁓ influencers that are 20-something years old and working out five days a week, because we just don't have time to do that, ⁓ nor the band to do that. But ⁓ doing what you can and giving yourself grace. And as women, need to give ourselves a little bit of flexibility and grace and to be okay with not being okay, to be okay with not being perfect. Jennifer Ashby: because all effort counts. Hidelisa Manibusan: All of her counts. I mean, there's just so many. see the memes, we see the Instagram post of like what women are expected to do. You know, we're supposed to be working full time and pick up the kids and have a clean house and be a wonderful partner and be a wonderful friend. it's like, who has time for everything? So give yourself the grace to feel like you're not at 100 % all the time, to be okay with shifting your priorities depending on where you were. Jennifer Ashby: from a wise woman, Dr. Hidalisa Manibusan. Thank you so much for coming on Over Reactive. Being my first interviewee, I love it, I love it. Thank you. Yay! I love it. And I may ask you back ⁓ on much more like focused boob topics. So let's celebrate the boobs. Together, women, keep tits up all the way. Hidelisa Manibusan: Thank you for having me. This has been an... It was my first hot grass. Absolutely. Let's do it. Jennifer Ashby: I wanna thank everyone for joining us on Overreacting today and a special thank you to Dr. Hidalisa Manobusi and thank you for all the important work you do at UCSF with breast health. And may you one day please write a book that we can all read and indulge in your wisdom. You're so welcome. Thank you for joining us. We will see you again soon. And I think our next topic is vaginal health. Hidelisa Manibusan: Thank you. Thank you so much. ⁓ Jennifer Ashby: If you're feeling brave, join us for vaginas.