Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Asbury Yard Sale, Tesla Cuts Deeper, TikToker Blames the Dealer
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Can you hear it, Kyle? It's the final countdown being played. Ooh. It's the last day of the month, and everyone's excited.
- 0:08We're talking about Asbury selling stores, Tesla cutting deeper, and a TikToker who's blaming- Everywhere I go... guess who? People really wanna know. Are they- No... taking responsibility?
- 0:17No, they're blaming the dealer. We're gonna talk about that. They're blaming the dealer. We'll talk about it. I mean- We'll try and, you know, we'll try and keep it civil around here. We have a fun show today.
- 0:26I mean, those stories- It is a fun-... are gonna be fun. Uh, our first one, we got a comment from Alan Haig, and we have a picture of Alan Haig's dogs on the show [laughs] today. Aw.
- 0:35And I get to show you something that you don't even know I have. Oh, no. I'm, I'm already jealous- Ta-da... that you... Ah. [laughs] Oh, the scarf. Oh my goodness. The scarves came in yesterday for ASOTU CON. Oh.
- 0:49Look at these. How's it feel, Paul? It, it feels better than last year's even. Good. I can tell. I can tell. It's got... And we want- It's, it's the HD. Yeah... let's just give the shout-out right now.
- 0:57We wanna thank our friends at DealerOn for being the sw- Whoa... Let me get this logo up there. To, for being the swag sponsor- Holy... this year. I feel like dollar for dollar, this is the best sponsorship at ASOTU CON.
- 1:08Ah. Because you get- Everybody's wearing it around all day... you and I don't take these things off the whole weekend. We're showing it on the show. Never. Just remember that next year if you're looking for one.
- 1:15Oh, and the back's got kinda like the ASOTU CON conversation bubble in it. It looks really great.
- 1:21Yeah, if you d- if you don't know, uh, this is our third ASOTU CON, which means it is our third ASOTU CON scarf, and I- Oh, tell them why we do a scarf every year. Oh, my gosh. Give it to them.
- 1:31Kyle, I think- Kyle would hear it from you... I think... Okay, I was gonna say, I think you need to tell them. Okay. So I, I didn't pay any attention to soccer my whole life, ever. And then I met Kyle, [laughs]
- 1:42and I started paying attention to soccer. And what I paid attention to the most is the absolute fanaticism and community around the sport. I can't wait to go to my first game still. We're gonna go. It's gonna be amazing.
- 1:52Are you gonna take me to a game in Nashville? Yeah, just the energy around we're in this together, uh, is unlike almost no other sport. And- And it's, it's wrapped up in, in a garment, right? And, and it is.
- 2:05And this is a rite of passage because you can have- Yeah... ones that show you're an OG. You can have ones that show you're in the moment and you, you're in support of the team. It's, it's easy to wear- Yeah...
- 2:13with everything. And so when first ASOTU CON came around, there was only one appropriate piece of swag that we knew we had to have, and that was a soccer scarf or a football scarf. He's got this story.
- 2:22And if you're watching, you'll tell, you can tell that I, I'm a little bit- He's got two or three. [laughs] Got a couple, two, three. He's probably got a dozen in that shot easy.
- 2:30Uh- And I know you have more around there. I've been in that office. Way more. Yeah. It's kinda nuts how many- And so if you come this year- Yeah, I got more...
- 2:35you will for sure, every attendee/participant gets an ASOTU CON scarf. And I'll tell you, it's so fun to watch these walking around the whole time. Uh, we also got these really sweet More Than Cars pins. Oh, metal pins.
- 2:49We ha- We're handing out some of these at, like, the p- I just can't wait. Everybody's like, everybody's gonna be running in like, "Give me the swag bag"... "Give me the swag bag." We went all out this year.
- 2:57It's gonna be so much fun. If you haven't heard about it or seen about it on LinkedIn or, uh, you probably will. Um, but if you haven't, go to asotucon.com. Check out the speakers, the agenda.
- 3:07Um, Kyle, we've been doing panel prep calls for the last two weeks. And, like- It's been wildly fun... we take these 50-minute panel prep calls where we get everybody in, um, and basically I had...
- 3:17So I w- I want you to tell me what, what your favorite was so far, the one that stands out in your mind.
- 3:22Mine, uh, three auto trade association presidents, plus Mike Stanton, talking about dealers advocating for the voice of the consumer.
- 3:31The name of the session is, on day one, Your Voice, Our Fight: How Dealer Associations Are Elevating the Voice of the Consumer with Pete Kitzmiller, Mike Stanton, Don Hall, Virginia, Don, John Devlin, Pennsylvania.
- 3:41And this is a juxtaposition of how a lot of the world views dealers.
- 3:45And dealers are saying they, "No, no, actually, with, through all the EV mandating and all this stuff," dealers are like, "We're advocating for your voice, um, in legislation and in actual practice."
- 3:55So that's my favorite one. I can't wait to hear that. How about you? All right. My favorite one was Pitch Tank. And- Oh, it's gonna be nutso... so we've got two rooms the first day of Pitch Tank.
- 4:03You know Pitch Tank is close to my heart 'cause I love tech. I love what things, people are doing on the software side of the business. And- You love telling people what you really feel.
- 4:11[laughs] And then I love telling people what I really feel. And I'm on this call. I got Chase Frazier, Steve Greenfield, uh, Amit Chaturanga. Oh, my gosh. And we got Bill Caris is coming from Holman Strategic Partners.
- 4:24Good night. These cats, like- This is like the tippy top crust of the A team right here. [laughs] Everybody in this, in these two things knows exactly what is up in the SaaS world right now.
- 4:35It's not just the starting lineup. It's like the first- No... five batters. [laughs] Exactly.
- 4:40And so if you are wondering what's on the horizon and whether or not you should be paying attention, come listen to these people ask the questions that you would rather ask.
- 4:50Uh, because they were already like, "Can I do this? Can I..." I'm like, "Yes." Please do. Yes. Please do. You can. Yes, you can ask those questions. I don't know. We gotta see...
- 4:57[sighs] There's some, there's some talks, and I won't talk about it yet. We, we, I think we, Pitch Tank needs to come back in a strong way after ASOTU CON. It's gonna be nuts at ASOTU CON. I mean- But look-...
- 5:05uh, let's, we should figure that out... we should. If you haven't, if you haven't checked it out, go to asotucon.com. Check it out. Um, look at the speakers. You can still get a ticket.
- 5:14Um, if you're an industry partner and you wanna be a part of the event, we still have a few places left, so email or DM us. You can email crew@asotu.com or fill out the form on ASOTU CON website.
- 5:24Uh, we'd love to include you. I mean, you can't beat the swag sponsor. DealerOn crushed that one. But, uh- Whoa... there's a lot of other stuff too that we can still put together for you. Let's talk about some news.
- 5:33Let's get into it. All right. This is a good one. Uh, it is, 'cause we have a picture of dogs at the end of this story. Asbury Automotive News- [laughs]...
- 5:39ranked fifth amongst used dealershi- uh, I mean, sorry, US dealership groups, is looking to sell 10 of their dealerships after a recent divestiture of Kunz Lexus in Wilmington.
- 5:50Uh, you kn- you all know, or many of you know, um-You know, Asbury acquired Coons and the group just sold Coons Lexus for $102 million, aligning with Lexus franchise limits, say you can only own eight stores total, so they own that, um, across the country.
- 6:04So they listed 10 stores for sale for a total of $242 mill- million in assets, [bell dings] including the dealerships, real estate, uh, goodwill, et cetera.
- 6:14CEO David Holt said, uh, there's a highlighted focus on selective acquisitions and maintaining shareholder value. That's what publicly traded CEOs are supposed to say. [laughs] Naturally.
- 6:23Uh, [laughs] noting a leverage ratio of 2.6 times earnings. Uh, the group currently has 157 stores still. Um, and they've done a stock buyback this year, 240,000 shares for $50 million.
- 6:36Uh, CEO David Holt said in the current market, there's certainly a lot of stores on the market from an M&A standpoint, but I think we wanna be extremely selective.
- 6:43So we sent, uh, a little message to our friend Alan Haig, uh, founder of Haig Partners today, and we said, "Hey, what do you think about this?" So we got a statement from him- Ooh...
- 6:51this morning while he was actually walking his dogs. Um- Naturally... I think now is when we show a picture of the dogs. Aw. Here you go. Look at those dogs right there. This is Lena and Kitty.
- 7:00I don't know which one's the one- Uh-oh... but naming a dog Kitty, I think is just a great play. Um, so there's Lena and Kitty.
- 7:05And while Alan's walking his dogs, he said, "Many retailers that grow through acquisitions end up with smaller stores that were part of the groups they acquired.
- 7:12Uh, while the smaller stores can be good for smaller owners, they can be difficult for large groups to manage." Hm. "So periodically they will divest some of the smaller stores."
- 7:20Uh, he does mention the framework agreements with OEMs that requires them to sell the Lexus store, but he does say they get to pick which of their stores they wanna sell.
- 7:29So it wasn't like this was the last one and first one out. They said they, he, they selected this one. Um, and he said they also look at things like areas with low to negative population growth, high costs, et cetera.
- 7:41Um, he said, "Divesting stores doesn't mean they are declining in any way. It means reallocating capital to better uses." Yeah, you can tell they're lining up some capital, right?
- 7:50They're, they're, they're repurchasing, uh, some shares for $50 million so they're, y- you know, they're, they're, they're, like, moving around money to position for something. Yes.
- 8:01That's what, that's what's o- on my mind is like, hey, we're divesting 10 stores, we bought back some shares so that we're not beholden to some shareholders. We got some different...
- 8:10Like, there's some money movement happening around intentionally, in my opinion- Mm-hmm... to make a big move.
- 8:17Um, so I would, that's what I would look out for is for Asbury to make a big move here, uh, coming up in the next couple quarters.
- 8:24Yep, and Haig Partnership, uh, Haig Partners is going to have some representation on the stage, main stage at SO2C.
- 8:30We're having a big M&A panel talking to, uh, three major firms, gonna have a great conversation around, uh, valuations and legacy and when's the right time to sell.
- 8:38So, uh, if you're kinda like curious about the M&A world but you don't wanna raise your hand because that can get tricky, you can come listen to people talk about it and ask your questions- Come on...
- 8:45anonymously via the app. Just saying. Uh, speaking of the app- Hey. Stop. Segway. Time. [upbeat music] Tesla's got a great app, by the way. But- They really do. It's- I know. It's just really good... it's really nice.
- 8:57Uh, but Tesla is continuing its aggressive cost-cutting strategy, announcing further layoffs that affect senior executives, and get this, they are laying off the entire 100% of the team working on the Supercharger.
- 9:12Um- Gone. Obviously this comes amongst, amidst a lot of other broader tech layoffs and a pretty big earnings shortfall that was just reported in their last quarterly, uh, statement.
- 9:21Tesla's laid off more than 10% of its workforce, including these high-profile, profile executives. We're approaching now 20% of the company being laid off. Wow. The elimination of the- That's unbelievable...
- 9:30entire Supercharging team led by Rebecca Tinucci, uh, signals a, a potential pivot in their approach to charging infrastructure. I mean, you think about it, Kyle.
- 9:39This is the person that got, like, the, the NACS adopted across all OEMs. They're like, "Great. Thanks. See you. Bye." [laughs] Ah, thanks. Bye. Yeah. Alongside the layoffs- It is weird...
- 9:48they, they see departures of some key personnel like Drew, uh, Baglino, VP of Powertrain and Energy Engineering.
- 9:55Um, and you know, like, these, they're trying to talk about doing a shareholder payout that's apparently pretty sizable. So it's, they got layoffs, they got shareholder payouts impending.
- 10:04Uh, Elon Musk said, um, there has to be a stringent review of all executive performance, stating, quote, "Executives whose subordinates don't obviously pass the excellent, necessary, and trustworthy test will find themselves relieved of duty."
- 10:19Since the announcement- Wow... shares are up 15%, still down 36% year over year. Well, uh, okay, first of all, down 36%- Up for the year... 15 since what? It was a little, uh, you know- Up 15 since this week...
- 10:32since last week, I think it was- Yeah... or earlier this week. Yep.
- 10:34Like, you know, you, you've, you've told me this, and I haven't read the book, but the strategy for Elon is, like, there's resetting buttons always, uh, and forever.
- 10:44And hey, that, the quote of, like, "Do your peo- Are your people good?" Yeah. "Have you gotten them good?" Yep. If not, are you the right person to be in leadership?
- 10:55That's a question that every single company should be asking. Are my leaders making the people better, and are they getting their people to the right place so that we can be successful?
- 11:04And if they're not, find new leadership. Man, it's- Um, you know, we've- Yeah...
- 11:08uh, it's, uh, like people, people will yell and shout at large layoffs, but I think a lot of these companies, it's just a part of the rhythm of the company. Um, and for me, it's like, hey, look, [laughs]
- 11:24got a whole bunch of people that probably know their way around auto- Mm-hmm... so no reason why you can't go find those people and bring them into, into the fold. Yeah, without a doubt.
- 11:33They even said that one, one guy who had at, at one point slept in his car so he could work more hours, uh, was also laid off. Definitely. With Elon Musk, it's very bi- like, the decisions are very binary.
- 11:45It's not like- Right... oh, you did this. I mean, if you ever have a doubt, like, is Elon Musk a car guy? [laughs] He's like, "Oh, that was great last month. This month, eh-Ah, you're a guy. Ah. [laughs] It's old school.
- 11:55Oh, he's so a car guy. It's so old school. He is the car guy of car guys. Well, we'll see, we'll see what happens.
- 11:59I mean, obviously he's got a history of, uh, hitting the reset button and, and being able to bring things around.
- 12:03It's, it's, it's tough to bet against Elon Musk, as erratic as it can be sometimes, but that's what's going on. Speaking of erratic as it can be sometimes- That, that is what I was gonna- Time to talk about TikTok.
- 12:14[upbeat music] A TikTok personality named Blasi Arnold recently faced the harsh reality of auto loans when she decided to part ways with her Chevy Tahoe due to overwhelming interest payments totaling, in her terms, 50 grand.
- 12:29Uh, Arnold, uh, her original loan was for an $84,000 Tahoe- Which is fully, fully- At a 10.2-... fully, fully loaded. Fully loaded Tahoe. Came with a 10.2% APR from GM Financial. Great captive bank, right?
- 12:46She had no down payment, negative equity from a traded-in vehicle, and her payments were around $1,400 a month, and the way she felt was that it was barely making a dent in the principal amount. And she's right.
- 12:57What you're gonna need to do- [laughs]... is you're gonna need to click on the link in, in the story, right? I know that a lot of people say this all the time, but you need to go find this. It's worth your time.
- 13:07It's worth your time to understand, like, not just her video, but the comments on the article, the comments in the TikTok thread, on the way the perception of the auto industry becomes the reality.
- 13:22Now, there's some sly comments about her interaction. Uh, there's some sly comments, uh, about the, the way that dealers treat people.
- 13:31Um, but when you look at the overwhelming majority of culture, you see this misunderstanding of the industry, of interest rates- But what did she say?... of auto loans, all that. Tell us what she said. What did she say?
- 13:42She said, and then she said this: "I did not go with my husband, and as a female, I feel they took advantage of me. They knew I really wanted a c- the car, and was, and I was by myself." Like- Oh. That's the feeling.
- 13:55That's the perception. AKA the dealer ripped me off. Right. For the, to set the record straight, that is not a rip-off interest rate in this day and age for a car that expensive with negative equity. No.
- 14:07And we don't know what the credit score is.
- 14:09Um, and also, you go on in the video and you realize this, uh, she also did a similar thing buying her husband a truck with a $1,600 a month payment with probably a higher interest rate.
- 14:20And so, um, you know, this is, again, like you said, Kyle, this is how the auto industry gets a bad perception in culture. Yep. Right?
- 14:27It's just this victim mentality of like, "They took advantage of me," but actually you just made a really bad decision. Yeah. Right?
- 14:33If you're not happy with the decision you had made- But it un- it underscores the requirement for education along the purchase process. Yeah. Right? I mean, I won't even say it's a bad decision, right?
- 14:42Everybody makes decisions for- No... different reasons. Once, once I, I, my first job at a dealership, I was like 22. Never bought a car from a dealership, never leased a car, right?
- 14:52And I said something dumb, like kind of like I just didn't know, right? It was kind of arrogant. I said to the officer, "Why would anyone ever buy a new car? A used car is so much of better value," right?
- 15:02And he, like, very kindly explained to me the essence of value. [laughs] Right? Yeah.
- 15:08And why someone would wanna pay, even though financially you pay more, it depreciates faster, but, like, the value that it brings to be in a new car. And, and it just literally is the very beginning.
- 15:18It was probably like week two of my career in automotive. And- Yeah... this- It's, it's just simple education and understanding, right? It's the same reason why so many people are afraid of leases.
- 15:29But depending on the, the person, the driving habits, the desire for new cars, like, leases actually make a whole bunch of sense. Understanding that- Right?...
- 15:36a car is a depreciating asset and having equity- But you-... in a depreciating asset, actually if you ask an investment advisor, isn't a good idea. Right. Yeah. I mean, you know. I know. It was fun.
- 15:47It was fun to bring that out, right? I was, "Oh, yeah. Oh-" Yeah. "... that's being said. Oh, that's amazing." It's interesting enough. Click on the link in the show notes.
- 15:54We, and, and it's an awareness of broad culture and its reactions. Um- It's one of the reasons we do what we do. We do. And we wanna keep doing more of it through the More Than Cars docuseries.
- 16:03We do want to cross the consumer divide with our content when the time is right, but first we need, you know, more people in the industry to know about it. There you go.
- 16:12Which is why we have live events, called ASOTU Con in two weeks from today. Hey. Two weeks from today it starts. All of it.
- 16:17Come get a scarf, get swag, make relationships, and learn things you will never forget and will make you, your life, and your business so much better.
- 16:24[upbeat music]