Latest / 323 Bourbon Library Podcast / 07/28/26 EPISODE 012: BOTTLE BREAKDOWN - STAGG 24A
Transcript
- 323 Bourbon Library Podcast: you We're back again. Thank you all for continuing to stick with us here on the 323 Bourbon Library podcast. And for this episode, the guy said, let's not pop a new bottle. That's right. Share a bottle that you've already opened that we haven't tried. that you want to introduce us to. And so I was like, I started looking around the library and we found- took a while, by the way. It did take a while. It took about 15 minutes or so, because I really love popping new bottles. You got lost in the catacombs for a while. We are going to be sharing with them and getting their thoughts, my thoughts as well, on the Stagg 24A release. Okay. And this is 127.6 proof. thought I'd pull up a- A few statistics about Stagg You've probably filmed this already. You've already done some material on this bottle, but you did it alone. And now we're going to try it as a group. I like that idea. Yeah. I can't recall. I'm sure I filmed something on it. But yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So formally known as Stagg Jr. ⁓ In the last few years, they dropped the junior. It's just known as Stagg. 24A. it is a specific chapter. ⁓ so Buffalo trace released this obviously they got its big brother, George T. Stag. It's part of the Buffalo trace antique collection. ⁓ Huge bottle. Everybody wants it. ⁓ but before that, they, they started releasing this. ⁓ so stag is always at 15 years, right? Or excuse me, George T. Stag is always at 15 years. These are anywhere from seven to nine years. So about half the age. Half the age the proof is still up there. It's usually the 120s 130s. Okay ⁓ and Let's see here it this was released first When did they come out here? Let me find it here 2000 and mmm Dumb dumb dumb. Yeah, I'm ⁓ give me a minute here. So have you had any stag before? I don't think I have not this I've had like one or two tastings of some George T, but not Stag or Stag Junior. So initially Stag, it released in August of 2013. The very first release of it was in August of 2013. It was released as the younger cousin, whatever, to George C. Stag. It's seven and nine years. It originally was Junior and it would come out once a year. So it would be batch one, batch two, batch three. And then a few years ago they started, you know, 2023A, 2023B, 2023C, and I believe it was 2024. They released four different versions. So there was an ABCD that year. This happens to be the 24A. We've got it poured up for you guys. 127.6 proof. A lot of people when this released were like, damn. It's got some heat. This is hot, it's alcohol forward, it's young. It kind of came out a little bit to not a lot of fanfare. But some of the alcohol forwards are pretty good. when it's, at least for me, when it's ethanol forward, not interested, right? I haven't smelled this one yet, haven't put my nose in it, but if it's high alcohol, it can still be really good. ⁓ yeah. For sure we've had plenty of proof. We've had some heat stuff. So in 2021 on batch 18, right, was the last stag junior. ⁓ they dropped the junior. It's just known as stag now. I kind of wish it was junior. Yeah, I like the junior. I like the junior name. I don't recall which one. I think I have one or two bottles of junior still, deep in the archives. It's kind of like the Adams family. If they didn't call him cousin it, it just called them it. It wouldn't work, right? It's gotta be cousin. It's gotta be junior. So You probably got it. This one's 24A. Obviously the 24, the year it was released, A, first batch of the year. Oh, sure. So let's see here. This one comes in at 127.6 proof, anywhere between seven and nine years. It is a low Rye mash bill. Oh, okay, low Rye. Low Rye, under 10 % Rye on this. So before we nose it, are you going to tell us anything about what we should expect or is this just going to be like, On the blind, what does John Carlo and Barsh think it is? So, per the internet. Okay. Do you want to know what you should try I would like to know what the internet has to say. All right, so the internet says you should be on the nosing rich cherry cola, brown sugar, vanilla. It's my favorite cola. We haven't had any cherry cola tonight. this, this, okay, go ahead. Chart oak. Chart oak. On the palate, it shifts into being more darker, brooding, ⁓ Instead of a massive bright fruit explosion, drinkers noted deep dark chocolate truffles, espresso, leather, tobacco. It's almost earthy. Almost a savory undertone. Notes of charcoal. it okay if I just warn people as you describe this? If this tastes anything like Jack Daniel's, I'm probably going to spit it out. I'm spray across the room. Wait till I... Like the way you're describing it, it's like a Jack Daniel's bottle and I fucking hate Jack Daniel's. Don't know why. That charcoal filter, that tobacco note, as you're describing it right there, I'm oh, this sounds like Have you had to check Jack Daniels, excuse me, 10, 12, or 14? What was that special bottle of Jack that we've had? That actually was decent, but regular Jack Daniels. We need to put I'm 1980s, 1990s, hair band, swigging on a Jack bottle. No. seven. No, no, I can't do it. No. That is worst than Budweiser, it's headache in a bottle, not know that. Well, I'm also not an old number seven fan, but on a future episode, stay tuned. I'm gonna throw, we're gonna put a blind of whiskies in front of this man and they're gonna be all Jack Daniels and he won't know it. I believe it. And it's gonna knock his dick off. Yes it will. Cause they're put my dick in the dirt as long as it's not old number seven. I don't know why. It's very popular, a lot of people like it. I'm just not a Jack Daniels guy, sorry guys. That's fine. And you don't have to worry about it. I own zero old number seven. So I won't pour that in your cup. All I have is special releases. I definitely have a bottle at home of something. I don't know what it is, but it's a higher end of Jack that you and some other friends have had. All right. Thank you. Let's let's you smell this one now. You should have been nosing it. I was not nosing. You're over here worrying about Jack Daniels. You describe the bottle to the viewers. Talking shit about them. All right. Fine. Fine. Fine. Fine. Daniels, love you, especially your 12, 14 year old bottles. All right, John Carlo, you start talking. Tell us what you're smelling, I'm gonna go in. Wow. Caramel, vanilla? Yeah, definitely caramel and vanilla. I can make fun of the Jack stuff all I want, but this is not a Jack Daniels smell at all. We're off the Jack Daniels. It's not even in the same distillery. I now know that. I do get that. So they said it had like a rich cherry cola. I did get a dark cherry note in there. Yes dark cherry not a sweat I wouldn't say sweet not a sweet cherry nothing. I'm not getting sweet notes off of this I'm getting deep dark layered flavors really good. I Don't you say dark it almost goes too far. It's I'm trying to get a right word, but it's it's complex Dark fruit Dark fruit. Yeah, absolutely. So what do you think like what is cola, right? I've always I've always liked bumped up against this is like, what is cola? Is it like, so Dr. advertises that they're like- 23, 27 flavors? 23 different spices or flavors, right? So what is cola? Is it like 17 different flavors? It's a blend of like- This is kind of like a Dr. Pepper- Various spices, right? Correct. It's like cinnamon, nutmeg. Yeah. There's other ones, but there's not as many as like Dr. Pepper. Right, right. But it's, is, it's reduced. pretty much. So, syrup. this is not the polar bear sledding down the mountain cola. No. This is the RC, this is the CNC cola of the 19th. No, seriously. Canadian club? That is CNC cola. Is this a New York, Long Island thing? That's Or are we just, am I just too young? no idea what CNC You're too young to What the fuck is CNC cola? CNC cola was like a non-name brand. I know RC cola. Yes. Okay, so Polar Bear and Pepsi were on the top of the shelf. You go down a few shelves and eventually you get to C and C Cola. Is that like Walmart or like Kmart? Oh, we're talking before Walmart, Kmart were even a thing. Bottom shelf. Like Shasta? Yes, before there was Store Brand, there was C and C Cola. That's what was in the cooler when you're having a big party because it was cheap. And guess what? It must be a Long Island thing. It could be New York thing. I don't, I don't recall seeing this. This is, this is definitely bottom shelf. It's not polar bears, not Pepsi. That's bottom shelf. No, the smell is reminding me of the the cola. The cola. It's not a name brand. people say cola nowadays, it's like Coke and Pepsi. That's it. Right. Back in the day, we had other tiers. We had hammer. We had CNC. We had RC Cola. Yes. Hammer Cola. Hammer Cola was the bomb because it gave me the burps. Anyhow, this is what it smells like. This is old fashioned cola. Not Coca Cola. How does it taste? I'm about to tell you. mean, in a second I'm gonna dive in. Who's tried it yet? Have you tried it No, I haven't tried it yet. All right. Go ahead. As you guys try it, I'll talk through the cola notes that you may be tasting. Wow, we took a deep dive there with the RC Cola, C and C Cola. We pulled some shit out of the archives. I mean, we're not doing ⁓ a bagger or a bum, but this is banging. No, this is really good. I like it. This has got a lot of deep texture to it, deep flavors. It doesn't come across hot. Really? No, this is not coming across hot for me. I would disagree with you. Fine, please do. That's the point of this. You should disagree with me. But for me, this is not coming across hot. There's no burn. There's no hug. I'm not diving for my water glass. This came across really nice for me. Let it be known to the general audience that he took a smoke break and went out and fired up a few Marlboro Reds. So we may have toasted his palate. How are you supposed to enjoy bourbon without having a nice smoke? I mean, some say you can't. ⁓ But you saying that this stag is not hot? I'll tell you it's got it's got high proof alcohol, but it is not I'll tell you a funny story literally just swallowed and immediately talk normally when it's hot. I'll hold my breath I won't talk to anybody like 15 seconds. I'm sipping and talking right away. This is good. It's great It's a great sip. It is absolutely hot. It is hot It is it has got a ton of proof on it. It drinks all of the 127.6 proof the way down like I've had I've drank hot hazmat that don't drink as hot as this I think I've had too many taquitos that you brought over earlier then because I'm not getting that heat all the way down. the burn. No, I get it, but I'm not feeling that. I've always said the first time I ever tried stag, I was at a buddy's house. It was definitely an end of the night pour. And he's like, hey, I got a little game room above my garage. And so we went up the stairs to his little loft or whatever and checked out his game room or whatever. Oh, I know this guy. had lunch with him today. And on the, by the way, the stairs were carpeted. Right. Not him. It's a different story. I came down, when I came down, were not carpeted. The stairs were carpeted on the way up and there was no more carpet. No, there was carpet. But my heel caught the end of the stair and I slid on my ass all the way down the stairs. And so for years I said, stag, we'll knock your ass down the staircase. That was my, cause I was like, holy fuck, this is crazy. This is high proof. It's ethanol. It's punchy. Alright, you gotta give me a little bit This wasn't the guy that I'm talking about that lives here locally. You went hunting with this guy in Texas. ⁓ Yeah, sorry folks. Years ago, in my time in Chattanooga. That gentleman was with us for like a week and he didn't take a shower once. Shout out to my buddy Will. Tennessee strong buddy, Tennessee strong. He did great. And honestly he- You're saying this is drinking like a hazmat to you guys because you're getting the burn. I'm not saying it's drinking like a hazmat, but you're over here acting like it's a fucking Woodford Reserve 90 proof. It's like a double Oak Woodford as far as the hug and the it's not it's it's really good. Hmm. It's not hugging and burning at all. Little litmus test for the viewers. Maybe you should dive into some pack of Marlboro Reds before getting into high brew whiskey because apparently it's singes off your palate. It takes off the edge. All right. So what are you getting on the other than you're not getting proof while you talk. You're saying full flavor. What are you getting? Here's my take on it. Yeah. This drinks its proof to where I don't get much else. Really? I get sweet, spice, and just proof on my palate. It's good. I can taste the sweetness. I can taste the spice, but its proof kicks me in the dick. It is definitely big, bold spice. The proof is there. This is one you're not going to forget you drink. Like you could have a drink after this and you'd be like, ⁓ I'm still tasting that stag. I don't think I've had anything that has kicked me as much as this ⁓ has. ⁓ I've definitely had stuff that he's given me that kicked me hard and like it hurt and I couldn't talk and I lost my voice. This is phenomenal. I'm agreeing with everything you guys are saying, except it's just not kicking me that hard. Yeah, fair enough. So this is wild because for the longest time, this bottle... If you were to go try to find a bottle of it, two, 300 bucks out on the streets. ⁓ Lately I've been seeing it for $150. I think at 150 and less, it's worth it. ⁓ gosh, yeah. But the last couple I've boughten, I've gotten it like 65, 70 bucks, which is like MSRP. For what it brings for, if you can get it for 60 or 70 bucks. ⁓ yeah, I'd it all day. This is amazing. Yeah. Because. Compared to any other $60 bottle. We're right now drinking out of Glencairn's we're drinking me right right you throw an ice cube in this Take some of that that proof off of it You have water up here. Well, you have water up here. Oh You have Tennessee water here. Oh, I'm still water. You Tennessee limestone water I will Kentucky limestone for the next episode. I will bring some Tennessee limestone, Kentucky water droplets up here I just want to say is I tap water with you guys, but it's just not Hugging me lack of a better term that hard. I like this. I enjoy it. I would have more of this I think I agree I would I would but I'm a cube guy. Give me it. Give me a big craft ball of ice I'm happy I love that my hair but we want to know what you guys think tell us what we're not talking about. us what we're not and we don't give you Because we're just a couple idiots sitting here talking about bourbon right now. I just put a couple drops of water from my Tumbler in there? Right. It's pretty good. Oh yeah, it's much better. It's still, it takes a little bit of that edge off. The edge off. It's still there. Oh yeah. By the way, they're complaining about the edge and I'm the only one with anything left in my glass. I'm not complaining about it. It's really good. No, I'm not complaining about it. You've given me stuff that hugs with pain. This is not hugging with pain. I think this is a great bourbon in it, especially at 65 bucks. Oh yeah, I'd buy it all day. Of course, yeah. If you had 65 bucks, I would buy the store out. I'd have a bunch of bottles on the shelf. Less than 100, please do. It's good. Yeah, that's definitely a good one. Cool. And so maybe in the very near future, I've picked up all the 2025 releases. Which are how many? A through what? D? C or D? There's at least three. What was it? This one or A? This is 24A. This is 24A, okay. Yeah, and so... I've been very cautious of it. I've been very cautious of it. I don't know if I wanna do a blind of three or four of these in one sitting. I feel like you're gonna toast your palate real quick. It's gonna be hard to do a blind of these, but stay tuned. Maybe we'll review them. Let us know in the comments. Stag. AKA Stagg Jr. Is it a bottle that you're hunting for? Do you collect it? Do you like it? What do you see? Let us know in the comments. What do you see in it for price wise in your market? Yep. For us, it's a buy all day long at 65 bucks. It's a pass at $300. It's not worth $300. Don't pay the- If it's MSRP at 65, I would go up to 150. After that, I would start passing on it, but at $100 to $125, I'd be buying that bottle all day long, buy the store out, it's good. You won't drink it that fast, because it is a higher proof. You won't drink it that fast, but that's definitely a bottle to have on the shelf to share with people. That's a camping bottle, Down the road, I've got a single barrel store pick stag at like 138 proof. That's got a little bit more heat than this. That I hear is ridiculously good. Okay from the store owner. Okay, so we'll pop it We'll compare it to get this to some of these like standard releases and we'll see if it's any good But that's the best part of some of these bottles that we've already opened is we can bring them back out And try them with another bottle as a comparison as I had to head. ⁓ yeah, haven't been doing that We've been doing fresh cracks. We've been going back to some of these open bottles We're gonna get to a point where the viewers are gonna ask us for this. We're gonna start putting some bottles head-to-head And I think they should comment on that. Like, what do you want us to head to head against? What is your favorite bottle? What do you want to try? And we'll give you our best advice as, you know, three idiots in a room. What do we like better out of those two? I got an idea. Go for it. What if we head to head Stagg Jr. Right. And Daddy Stagg? ⁓ GTS. Blind. That's going be more than a 20 minute episode folks. We're to have to dig into that one a little bit deeper because we're going to need blind. We're going to time for each one of those. That's going to be a long podcast. Like you guys are going to have to like hunker down and be ready for a 45 minute to an hour episode for that. Oh yeah. And I think, you know, stay tuned. I got an idea. I think we're going to do a segment in the near future where we're doing head to head bourbons. Can you put that out as a survey? See what they want us to do. If they want us to do that, we should do it. That particular matchup? Give them a couple options. Stagg versus Stagg. This matchup. Stagg Jr. Exactly. This matchup, that matchup. Let the viewers kind of come back and say, here's what we want you to match up. I think that might surprise us, but let's do it. Hey, let us know in the comments. Do you want to see a high age, high proof, high dollar versus low dollar similar bottle? I kind of want to do it, I do too. Hopefully vote for it. We'll see you very soon for another episode on the 323 Bourbon Library podcast. Like and subscribe. Thanks everybody. Enjoy.