Latest / Bitcoin And | Bitcoin & Economic News / Not Cold Enough | Bitcoin News
Transcript
- 0:02It is 08:48AM
- 0:05Pacific Daylight Time. It's the August
- 0:082026,
- 0:09and this is episode
- 0:11thirteen sixty four of bit coin, and
- 0:14we're gonna do the cold card thing because
- 0:18it
- 0:19we really need to do the cold card thing.
- 0:22I want to take us through the timeline
- 0:26of what's occurred
- 0:28and
- 0:29sort of tease out
- 0:31what happened.
- 0:33However,
- 0:35before I even get there,
- 0:37before I even
- 0:38look at the outline
- 0:40that I've drafted here,
- 0:43we need to talk about something else
- 0:46that has to do with cold card. And that is the fact that
- 0:50four years on this podcast, I've been telling people that
- 0:53cold card is great
- 0:56and I was wrong.
- 0:59I was really wrong.
- 1:01However,
- 1:03one thing that I can say is that I also use cold card. That's why, that's why,
- 1:11I recommended it because I used it. I didn't use a jade.
- 1:16You know, I wasn't using treasure.
- 1:18I used to use a ledger,
- 1:20but I, I bricked two of them.
- 1:24So I just, I'm not, I never liked their, their hardware in the first place after I bricked the first one.
- 1:32So I wasn't recommending that. However, it turns out the ledger is still safer than cold card
- 1:39and that's,
- 1:41that's really sad.
- 1:44And because I've been
- 1:46recommending cold card because I was using cold card, I want to go through a couple of things here.
- 1:54I tried,
- 1:56you know, it's like I don't have any sponsors on this show, but I did reach out
- 2:01and I'm not really good at reaching out to sponsors. I'm not one of, I'm for some reason I'm just not wired that way to reach out to sponsors, but I had been using cold card for so long
- 2:14and I had never had a problem with it
- 2:16that I, you know, that I knew about. That's, that's sort of the issue here with cold card.
- 2:21I did reach out to Novak
- 2:24Rodelphone Novak from CoinKite to see if they possibly be interested in sponsoring the podcast.
- 2:30And we went back and forth a couple of times and it, it actually kind of looked like they might actually sponsor the show. And then
- 2:37I don't know what it was. I guess, I guess I gave, gave them my numbers and this was, this was actually, I think this was a little bit over two years ago.
- 2:46I gave them my numbers like download
- 2:49and
- 2:50stuff like that. And everything seemed fine until they asked me the question,
- 2:54w how, how many followers do you have on Twitter
- 2:57and other social media? Well, I don't really have that many followers on Twitter and social media because I don't, I didn't normally use it. And if you've been following the show for any length of time at all, you know that I got booted off at Twitter
- 3:13and my, I can't remember how many followers I had at the time. It was, it was decent. It was still wasn't great. It wasn't like, you know, 1,800,000
- 3:22followers or anything like that. But you know, and all of a sudden
- 3:27once I gave those, once I said the numbers of my social media followers,
- 3:33I, they ghosted me
- 3:35coin cake. The people I was talking to at coin kite just ghosted me. I never heard another word from them. Tried writing them back, say, Hey, you know, where, where are we on this thing? And no response,
- 3:47just
- 3:48gone.
- 3:49The whole conversation just
- 3:51literally died.
- 3:53And even after that,
- 3:56I was recommending cold cards simply because I used it.
- 4:00That was the way that I was securing my own stack.
- 4:05And that stack was secured as single SIG,
- 4:09you know, one signature
- 4:11that was generated by the cold card with no passphrase
- 4:15and no rolled dice.
- 4:18So as you might imagine, when the news broke, you know, July, I think I first heard about it July 31.
- 4:25That was the first time that I had heard about it.
- 4:28I shit my pants
- 4:31and I went immediately to go check what the hell was going on
- 4:36with my wallet
- 4:38and everything was there.
- 4:40Everything was there.
- 4:43And the reason that I didn't lose anything was simply because
- 4:49that laziness
- 4:50that caused me to not construct
- 4:53a big pass phrase as a twenty fifth word
- 4:56to my 24 word seed phrase.
- 4:58And I didn't roll a 100, you know,
- 5:02rolls of dice to add extra entropy. And I didn't do any of that. That laziness also caused me to never
- 5:11upgrade the firmware of my cold card wallet
- 5:14after I received it in the mail.
- 5:17And there, there was even like, you know, kind of a warning on, well, not a warning, but there was a, Hey, advisable,
- 5:22update your firmware when you get this. Well, I never did that. So I was still on firmware version three
- 5:29point X, whatever, you know, whatever it was. I looked at it when I was migrating my funds, which actually came next.
- 5:38But that's the reason.
- 5:40And we'll go through
- 5:42in
- 5:43the outline of we'll go through what's,
- 5:46what has actually occurred,
- 5:48why that the, the firmware upgrade
- 5:51to four point X
- 5:54was the problem.
- 5:55Right? So I was able to get my funds off of that cold card
- 6:00address and onto a brand new address that was basically
- 6:04rolled by a different manufacturer
- 6:06whose name I'm not going to name
- 6:09because at this point I don't know what to advise anymore.
- 6:13Yeah.
- 6:15There's a couple of, there's a couple of hardware wallets that have been audited
- 6:21time and time again,
- 6:23but this time by AI,
- 6:25but you know, and they've come up, they've come up pretty green
- 6:29as far as, yeah, everything's okay. But I don't want to say the names at this point because I don't know who to trust,
- 6:36which is okay. That, you know, honestly that's sort of, that's sort of a,
- 6:41the best reaction that you can have is I don't trust anything.
- 6:45I don't trust anybody.
- 6:46I don't trust.
- 6:48There's nothing to do. I can't there. I can't trust
- 6:52at this point.
- 6:53Now I'm,
- 6:55think that that'll change as time goes on.
- 6:58But right now I don't even know whether to tell you to put all your Bitcoin onto some kind of central
- 7:05holding like river or unchained. But the second that I say those names, I'm like, well fuck, I don't know anything about, I don't literally know
- 7:13exactly what their custody setup is.
- 7:16So I can't recommend that either. Do you send it to,
- 7:20do you send all your money to a
- 7:23coin base?
- 7:24I have no idea what their, what their custody setup is because I've been so used to self custody
- 7:30for all these years
- 7:31that I don't know what to tell you.
- 7:34And I think that this is a, it's not a good place to be, but it's the best place that we can be because we're going back
- 7:43years to where it was, where when we said don't trust verified,
- 7:49we actually meant it and we failed
- 7:53across the board
- 7:54on the whole thing.
- 7:57Now there's
- 7:59I keep seeing like, I mean,
- 8:02Odell is just getting fucking savaged
- 8:05on X as well as Noster
- 8:09because
- 8:11his relationship
- 8:13with,
- 8:15$10.31
- 8:16and open dimes and
- 8:19Novak, who is the guy that started coin kite who builds the affirmation cold card
- 8:25because he was recommending it except that what I'm seeing is language that suggests that
- 8:30somehow he knew that this failure was there and he was recommending it anyway because
- 8:35God forbid that him and you know,
- 8:40you know, people like Marty Bent lose sponsorships.
- 8:44Well,
- 8:46I was recommending cold card and I didn't have a sponsorship. Never got a dime from coin kite. I tried.
- 8:53I want to make that very clear as I did earlier. I tried. I I kind of wanted them as a sponsor,
- 8:59but that just never materialized.
- 9:02But yet I was still recommending cold card because I used it.
- 9:06That's how I was securing my stack
- 9:09and I was wrong, but that's,
- 9:12that's why I reckon had been saying use a cold card.
- 9:16I did also mention, Hey, you know, you, you know, I've heard treasure is pretty good and
- 9:20bit box is pretty good, but you know,
- 9:24Bainly,
- 9:25I just stayed with cold card.
- 9:27I, I knew the system. I knew how, you know, knew how it worked. I was used to the used to the flow and it's that kind of
- 9:35attitude that gets people into trouble all the time. So what the hell are we supposed to do now?
- 9:41Well, one of the things that I'm pretty sure that we're probably not supposed to do is just go and blame all the podcasters
- 9:48and,
- 9:49influencers
- 9:50and anybody who said anything good about something that caused a lot of people to lose
- 9:56a lot of money,
- 9:59life savings,
- 10:00entire futures wiped the fuck out.
- 10:05And I also don't think that we should be blaming ourselves as users because a lot of people are saying that, see, you should have just stayed in. You should have just had your Bitcoin custody over at Coinbase and you'd be fine.
- 10:18Yeah. Well, I'm not sure if any of this is, is constructive at all.
- 10:23Actually for me,
- 10:25I know it's not constructive.
- 10:27It's just at this point, so many people are so wrecked.
- 10:34So many lives are completely destroyed.
- 10:37So many futures are now going to be unrealized
- 10:41because of this shit.
- 10:43I will say this though.
- 10:47If you want to blame anybody,
- 10:49it's gotta be, it's gotta be coin kite.
- 10:53It's gotta be the fact that they didn't do code review
- 10:56apparently.
- 10:58At least that's what it looks like to me. Nobody really went back and tested
- 11:03exactly
- 11:04how strong
- 11:06the entropy was in these cold cards to construct
- 11:10the addresses you or the wallet creation process.
- 11:14We'll get into it,
- 11:16but I just want to make it clear that I've contemplated,
- 11:20and this is my most important thing that I'm probably going to say today.
- 11:25I've contemplated deeply over the last three days.
- 11:30Should I say that I'm sorry?
- 11:34It's a good question.
- 11:36Rudolph, even Rodolpho Novak, the guy behind coin kite, he said he was sorry.
- 11:42Cold card made an announcement. He, they said, you know, the, or the cold card X account said they were sorry.
- 11:50Of course they made sure to, you know, basically say, and by the way, there's nothing we can do about your funds. They're gone.
- 11:57And I immediately started asking myself, well then what good is an apology?
- 12:04What good is it? I mean,
- 12:08what good is it? I'm not basically,
- 12:10I'm not sitting here saying that that I don't feel sorry. We'll get to that here in a second, but I'm trying to figure out what good is it?
- 12:21Is it going to bring back people's money? No.
- 12:27Is it going to make
- 12:30people that lost their money feel better? No.
- 12:34So the question becomes
- 12:36who's, what purpose does saying I'm sorry, serve?
- 12:41Is it for the person saying that they're sorry themselves? Is it like, think of it like a funeral. Who's the funeral for?
- 12:48Oh, it's for the guy that died. No, it's not.
- 12:52That person's dead for all it, you know, for all we know, we don't know if there's an afterlife or not. I happen to believe in one, but I, you know, I don't know.
- 13:04I have no proof. I can't audit that. Like I like I'm unable to audit the coin kite code.
- 13:10Well,
- 13:11mostly unable to audit the coin kite code. We'll get to that.
- 13:17No, the funeral is for the people that survived.
- 13:20That's who the funeral is for.
- 13:23But in this case, an apology is that for the the the people that lost all their money
- 13:29or the people that didn't lose their money?
- 13:32Who
- 13:34who's the apology for
- 13:36and what good does it do?
- 13:39After contemplating
- 13:40this for quite a while, I've decided that it's applicable to say, I'm sorry.
- 13:48If you got a cold card
- 13:50because
- 13:51I, that's what I used and that's what I had recommended.
- 13:55I can only say that I'm sorry,
- 13:58but that's
- 14:00honestly just saying it feels fucking ridiculous.
- 14:06There's nothing that anybody can do to really fix this.
- 14:11Not right now and not under the, not under the environment
- 14:17that we find ourselves in mentally.
- 14:21Now it's possible that
- 14:23this wallet that holds all the stolen Bitcoin,
- 14:27somehow or another
- 14:29is, I mean the fact that there's
- 14:32never been this many eyeballs on a single wallet since the Mount Gox hack and silk road, silk road hacks.
- 14:40But I, I
- 14:42think that what's going to happen is that this particular wallet and or set of wallet addresses that are involved in this are going to be the most looked after,
- 14:51the most watched,
- 14:53the most blacklisted
- 14:55wallet, which I,
- 14:57again,
- 14:58this goes right against everything that I've set up until now.
- 15:02No wallet should be able to be blacklisted,
- 15:05but this one,
- 15:07and I'm not even saying, I'm not even saying that it should be blacklisted.
- 15:11I'm just saying,
- 15:13get, how, how to, how do we proceed in our thought process
- 15:17after we've talked about Bitcoin being for enemies
- 15:20and you know, like, like say sanctioned countries using Bitcoin to get around all this stuff because Bitcoin is unstoppable.
- 15:28And yet we find ourselves in this huge conundrum because we know that that Bitcoin represents the absolute destruction
- 15:35of people's, not only their livelihoods and not only their futures,
- 15:39but suicides are going to occur from this if they haven't happened already.
- 15:44People are physically going to lose their life
- 15:48because of this.
- 15:51And I
- 15:53you know,
- 15:54it's
- 15:57hard to wrap the mind around the magnitude of what's happened because it struck at the center
- 16:03of
- 16:04what should have been
- 16:06an easy thing to decide.
- 16:09You custody your Bitcoin yourself because we have the tools to do it. And then we find out that the two some of the tools that we had to do it with
- 16:18were so far beyond being below par
- 16:23for the course that it was laughable,
- 16:27laughable
- 16:29to screw all this up.
- 16:33But again,
- 16:35there's nothing to actually say
- 16:37other than
- 16:39anybody
- 16:42who is,
- 16:44anybody who was affected by this or
- 16:47even close to the flames, even if you knew somebody who was affected by this, the only thing that I and anybody else can say
- 16:54is that we're sorry.
- 16:56And we also need to understand immediately that that doesn't do Dick.
- 17:01That's why I contemplated whether to, whether or not to even apologize
- 17:06because it doesn't, it's not going to bring anything back.
- 17:11It's not going to fix anything for me.
- 17:14It's not going to fix anybody out there.
- 17:17It's not going to fix the situation.
- 17:20It's just
- 17:21words,
- 17:24just words,
- 17:29But we've crossed a Rubicon,
- 17:33not just for Bitcoin, not just for self custody.
- 17:38This, this
- 17:40entire thing reaches so far beyond
- 17:44the Bitcoin sphere
- 17:46and the, and the financial sphere
- 17:49that it's kind of eye watering. We're never
- 17:53going to be able to go back
- 17:56to the world that was.
- 18:00And I
- 18:01find it
- 18:03oddly weird that this happens to this happens to be right before what's going to be a quarter century
- 18:10of September 11
- 18:13where the world changed forever again.
- 18:19I don't know why I'm connecting the two. It's just that I've been having these weird feelings
- 18:24over the last few months that something is terribly wrong.
- 18:28And I was, I had been feeling like that ever since nine eleven actually happened, except not not to this degree.
- 18:36So let's
- 18:38let's get into what
- 18:40exactly happened
- 18:42with cold card.
- 18:45So
- 18:47around
- 18:48early July the thirtieth.
- 18:52Bitcoin begins moving from
- 18:56particular addresses
- 18:57that were generated by cold card
- 19:00hardware wallets.
- 19:02They were from the addresses that were generated by the hardware.
- 19:07That is the cold card wallet, whether mark one, mark two, mark three,
- 19:11mark four, mark five or the new Q,
- 19:14right?
- 19:16Except that the mark ones and the mark twos
- 19:19don't seem to be having
- 19:22that much of an issue.
- 19:24We'll, we'll, we'll get to that.
- 19:26And it has something to do with the firmware. We've already talked about that a little bit,
- 19:30but the mark threes,
- 19:32the mark fours, the mark fives and the Q they're, they're definitely all affected
- 19:37if they have the firmware
- 19:39four point X on it.
- 19:42If you're before that,
- 19:44if you like 3.01
- 19:46or something like like, or 3.02
- 19:49or whatever,
- 19:51Those seem to be unaffected for various reasons that we'll get into.
- 19:56Still though, many of the owners believe
- 19:58that the seeds that have been generated by these wallets,
- 20:02even if they've never touched an internet connected device, then they believe that
- 20:07because they knew that they never connected their cold card
- 20:10to like the internet. They never put their seed phrase into a, Hey, check and check and see if my seed phrase is okay. Yeah, don't do that. None of that. There's like the, these, these seeds
- 20:21that were used to construct the wallets. And that's the most important part of the wallet is how it's constructed.
- 20:28Or in other words, the seed,
- 20:30some sometimes we use seed phrases, but there's also
- 20:34how does that how is the number generated that
- 20:39seeds
- 20:40everything
- 20:41in the wallet construction?
- 20:44You know, that's that's that's sort of what we're talking about. And none of this information
- 20:49for many of these people touch the internet. There was, it was not like somebody got ahold of their, their particular address
- 20:56and decided to target them,
- 20:59you know, or, or
- 21:01like, it's not like a whole, but some people figured out a whole bunch of the, somehow or another collected through the internet, everybody who had ever had a cold card and somehow or another leaked their, their seed phrase or, or their wallet private key
- 21:17on the internet. It's not, that's not what happened.
- 21:21They, they didn't collect all this information up and put it into a great big spreadsheet.
- 21:26And just one day decided to say, okay, here we go. That's not what happened.
- 21:32But one thing that did, one thing that we are sure of is that this was coordinated.
- 21:38These, these sweeps of these Bitcoin wallets
- 21:43were
- 21:44coordinated.
- 21:45They looked to me to be led. They were not just to me, to a lot of people. They looked like they were automated
- 21:53and there was an incredible amount of them.
- 21:58And we don't even know if this shit is over yet
- 22:01because there was a first wave.
- 22:04And then we discovered that there was like other waves. And right now we're still in this fourth wave
- 22:11of sweeps
- 22:12of
- 22:13cold card.
- 22:15That's the affected wallet
- 22:17as near as I can tell. And I've been looking at this all weekend long. I can't find any
- 22:23other, even MetaMask,
- 22:27which you should never use.
- 22:29Nobody's even stolen from these that thing. And that's, that's basically an Ethereum hot wallet that's, you know, on the internet. And even that,
- 22:39even that seems secure,
- 22:41which is sad,
- 22:43really fucking sad.
- 22:47So this bitcoin
- 22:48begins leaving wallets on the July 30 and
- 22:53it was leaving addresses
- 22:55that were generated by what should have been
- 22:59and what even I
- 23:01had purported to be one of the safest wallets on the planet. And I and everybody else was
- 23:08wrong.
- 23:10These devices, they were offline,
- 23:13you know, the backups hidden,
- 23:16some hadn't even been touched in years yet. The Bitcoin moved anyway.
- 23:21So
- 23:22how is it that somebody can steal
- 23:25from an air gapped wallet without ever touching
- 23:29the device?
- 23:30Well,
- 23:34the wallet
- 23:36that was generated
- 23:38by this particular firmware
- 23:41version on these particular wallets, the, the mark three, the mark four, the mark five and the queue from CoinKite.
- 23:49These are all cold card wallets.
- 23:51No other wallets that we know of are affected from any other manufacturer.
- 23:55Not yet. Anyway, we'll get to that,
- 23:58but
- 24:00there, these are called air gapped wallets. That's what I mean. The seeds never touched the internet.
- 24:06The device really, you know, the way that you can do it, you don't have to do it this way, but you can completely
- 24:13never ever hook the device to a computer
- 24:18to be able, you know, for, for the seeds to be able to somehow or another leak on the internet,
- 24:23that's called air gapping. Right. And like the way that I would do transactions when I needed to do it from a cold card is a partially signed Bitcoin transaction
- 24:33where I would, you know, essentially cons, I would construct
- 24:36the transaction
- 24:38on,
- 24:39I was using,
- 24:41not sparrow, a Spectre, the Spectre wallet, which,
- 24:45which I keep on my node. I have a full Bitcoin node on my start nine and that particular wallet does not have the seeds.
- 24:54I constructed that wallet with the cold card,
- 24:59but the, but I can look at that wallet and I can construct
- 25:03transactions on that wallet, but I can't sign
- 25:05the transaction from that wallet.
- 25:08I can construct the transaction and then I have to save it to an like a one of those micro SD cards.
- 25:15Then I have to pull that SD card
- 25:17as a partially signed Bitcoin transaction. And then I've got to shove it into my, my cold card
- 25:23and have it read that transaction.
- 25:26And then the cold card says, Hey, you want to sign this?
- 25:29It's the one that has the seeds and I don't have to have that hook to lie. I can just plug that into a wall socket to get it to power on. I don't have to use a computer to plug it into.
- 25:41That's why it's air gapped. And then I can sign that particular transaction.
- 25:45It signs it to that SD card. And then I pull the SD card out and I put it back into
- 25:51a card reader on my computer and then let the Spectre wallet read that transaction. And it says, Hey, this is a signed transaction. Do you want to send it?
- 26:02That's air gapping.
- 26:05And yet the Bitcoin from all these wallet addresses moved
- 26:10anyway.
- 26:15So
- 26:17the seed,
- 26:19the seed that builds these wallets when you get any hardware wallet from any manufacturer,
- 26:25essentially what happens is that
- 26:28the seed is generated inside the device
- 26:32and it should have
- 26:34a nearly unimaginable
- 26:37number of possibilities
- 26:39in in so far as there's so much and you'll come to know this word a little bit late, you know, as we go on through this entropy
- 26:49entropy is sort of like chaos,
- 26:52you know, theoreticians.
- 26:54If you ever watched Jurassic Park, the mathematician character,
- 26:57he was a chaos mathematician.
- 26:59That was his specialty was chaos theory.
- 27:02That's entropy.
- 27:04Right? So if you have
- 27:07the ability to construct a number
- 27:10using something like pure chaos,
- 27:13that's what you want
- 27:15because it's really hard to have the exact same set of parameters all in place
- 27:22to regenerate
- 27:24such a big number.
- 27:25And it ends up being exactly the same. It's like being able to not generate
- 27:31two
- 27:32immensely
- 27:33large numbers,
- 27:35the same, the same,
- 27:37twice
- 27:39that that sort of where entropy
- 27:42and chaos is coming into this and cold card in me included
- 27:47the users believe that our devices
- 27:50were choosing from that enormous space.
- 27:54And in my case it actually did.
- 27:58The fact there was 200 and like I know that my seed that was created on the cold card had a full two fifty six bits of entropy.
- 28:08And if you want to know what that is,
- 28:10take
- 28:11the number two
- 28:13and raise it to the power
- 28:15two fifty six
- 28:18It is an extraordinarily
- 28:20large
- 28:20number.
- 28:24And that's what should have happened with everybody
- 28:26using the cold card.
- 28:29In fact, that number that that wallet is actually still safe at this moment, even though I've emptied everything out of it. I don't trust cold card. I will never recommend
- 28:39coin kite products to anyone ever again in my entire life under any circumstances.
- 28:44I may not even, I may not be able to make any recommendations at all except for like
- 28:50what I've got, the people that I, that I have in the circle P which none of, none of which actually is a hardware wallet vendor.
- 28:57I don't know.
- 28:59I don't know. I've got, I'm going to be doing some, some deep soul searching on hardware wallets at this point, but that's neither here nor there.
- 29:07So why did mine,
- 29:09why did the number I generate
- 29:11adhere to the best practices?
- 29:14But after the firmware update occurred,
- 29:17those cold cards didn't.
- 29:19Well, that was a software integration error
- 29:23that sent the seed generator
- 29:26to fall back on a very predictable random number generator.
- 29:31What does that mean?
- 29:33Well,
- 29:34it means that
- 29:36instead of
- 29:39having to raise to the two fifty six power, which is again,
- 29:44an immensely large number,
- 29:46literally like
- 29:47the amount of stars in the known universe that we can calculate under standard mathematics
- 29:53to, to the raised to the two fifty six. There's more than that.
- 29:58There's more, there's more numbers
- 30:01in two raised to the two fifty six than there are stars in the known universe. As far as we know, that's
- 30:08pretty big.
- 30:10That's more, that's more than the number of grains of sands on a beach.
- 30:15In fact, if I remember right, it's more than the number of grains of sands on all the beaches on the planet earth combined and more.
- 30:23So,
- 30:26but what happened was that the firmware upgrade
- 30:33caused the seed generator
- 30:35to do a fallback and that fallback instead of using what it should have used,
- 30:42it used a shittier version of it.
- 30:45And instead of generating two to the two fifty six
- 30:49it was generating two to the thirty second
- 30:52in some cases
- 30:53a little bit more, but not by much.
- 30:56And it turns out that even though two raised to the thirty second power is also an immense number,
- 31:03It's trivial for a laptop computer
- 31:07to be able to replicate that number.
- 31:10And that's what was going on.
- 31:12All the seed phrases or all, or all the seeds that were generated
- 31:17with
- 31:18version firmware version four and above,
- 31:22none of them,
- 31:23none of them were developing
- 31:25true
- 31:26entropy
- 31:27and none of them were even close to approaching
- 31:31two to the one twenty eighth power,
- 31:34which is a 12 word seed phrase or two to the two fifty six power, which is a full 24 word seed phrase.
- 31:41The
- 31:42attacker
- 31:43essentially could generate candidate
- 31:46seeds
- 31:47somewhere else
- 31:48and derive the addresses
- 31:50and compare them with the public blockchain to verify that the wallet is that was generated
- 31:57was able to generate a like a, or the private keys generated
- 32:02would be able to generate
- 32:04a wallet that would match something that already existed on the public blockchain, which is infinitely scannable.
- 32:12There's no remote access. There's no malware.
- 32:16It's just it's it was literally just using math
- 32:23against
- 32:25cold cards,
- 32:27shitty C generation after firmware 4.0
- 32:31upgrade.
- 32:33It's not an upgrade, it's a downgrade.
- 32:35So just imagine buying a lock advertised as having more combinations than anyone could ever search for
- 32:42and then learned that the factory had really been choosing combinations from just one relatively
- 32:47small binder of possible numbers.
- 32:51The combination still looked pretty complicated, but someone with that binder
- 32:55could just work right through them. And that's what happened.
- 33:02Five years
- 33:04of unverified trust
- 33:06is what we've put into
- 33:08CoinKite and their product line.
- 33:14So this vulnerable pathway that I'm talking about
- 33:19firmware
- 33:19for,
- 33:20and all the versions above that entered into production in 2021
- 33:25and
- 33:28nobody knew
- 33:29that it was there. Nobody knew that the seed generation was falling back to a shitty random number generation method.
- 33:43Now that we've discovered it,
- 33:45cold card said, Hey, well we've got a firmware upgrade.
- 33:50So you know,
- 33:52you what you'll let, you know, what you'll have to do is you'll have to take your Bitcoin. You'll have to put it somewhere else. And then you'll use your cold card Mark three, four or five Q whatever you'll put in this new firmware and you'll, you'll construct a brand new wallet out of it. And then you'll put your Bitcoin back. Yeah. Don't do that. Just, you know, never use another cold card product ever or a coin kite product ever again.
- 34:14None of them. I wouldn't even trust the block clock at this point.
- 34:19Not that the block clock is something that should or should not be trusted because it's just a clock, but fuck them.
- 34:25Don't give them any of your money. They don't deserve anything at this point.
- 34:30This breach of trust is
- 34:32reprehensible
- 34:33beyond
- 34:34everything that I've ever seen before. I've seen some, some bullshit
- 34:39in corporate, in the corporate world. Well, I'm talking about like, you know, products that suck,
- 34:45but, but nothing,
- 34:48nothing that has had the damaging
- 34:50effects that this thing has had. So don't use cold card,
- 34:54Don't use coin kite products.
- 34:56Don't use open dimes. Don't use block clocks. I don't care if coin kite made it,
- 35:03get rid of it and never buy from them ever again.
- 35:07That company's fucking toast.
- 35:09It better be
- 35:11their revenue better go to zero.
- 35:14Just saying,
- 35:16let me collect my thoughts for a sec. Hold on.
- 35:19Yeah. The firmware upgrade.
- 35:22Okay. So technically
- 35:24or supposedly
- 35:26cold card
- 35:27builds a brand new firmware version
- 35:30just for this because of what's going on over the last few days.
- 35:33I, it came out like yesterday morning or late the night before or something like that. And they were like, look, we fixed it. We fixed the problem. And people are like going, yay. Well, so they, you know, they, they had already gotten their Bitcoin off and then they go to generate a brand new wallet,
- 35:50right? They're not upgrading their old wallet because that won't work. That old wallet is, is forever
- 35:56screwed.
- 35:58No, it doesn't matter.
- 35:59So get all of your, all of your Bitcoin off there if you haven't done so already. I'm just, I know it's ridiculous to say at this point, but it is what it is. So these people that they get this firmware upgrade, they download it, they put it into their cold card, whatever.
- 36:16And now we're getting reports that the firmware upgrade bricks, the unit
- 36:21turns it into a
- 36:23paperweight
- 36:24as it were
- 36:25just like a $500
- 36:27Like I think in the case of the cold card
- 36:30queue or something like that there, it's really expensive. It's like $350
- 36:35or something. I don't know.
- 36:37It's expensive
- 36:39and it's now worthless.
- 36:41It's bricked.
- 36:42And even if it, you know, honestly even
- 36:45I'm, I'm not even saying you should do this. Just get your money off of any coin kite product and never go back. Just
- 36:53do, we'll do something else.
- 36:55But coin kites dead. But even then they released this firmware thing and it starts
- 37:00bricking
- 37:01people's cold card mark fours,
- 37:04their cues,
- 37:05they're very expensive
- 37:07soon to be thrown in the trash, which by the way, don't do that. Keep,
- 37:12keep the physical unit.
- 37:14God only knows you may need it later. I don't know, but don't throw it away.
- 37:19Throw it like, like after all the dust is cleared and you know, the, the, the, the, the final cat is in the bag is, you know, died then maybe throw it away. But there's going to be lawsuits.
- 37:32If there's going to be class action lawsuits, there's going to be people trying to recover
- 37:37stuff.
- 37:37There's going be all kinds of stuff. Don't throw the physical unit away. Don't throw away your old passphrase.
- 37:43Keep everything for evidence if nothing else,
- 37:47right? Don't use it.
- 37:49Get your shit off there,
- 37:51but don't throw it away. Not, not yet.
- 37:54Anyway,
- 37:56the only
- 37:57real remedy for any of this is to go to some other manufacturer
- 38:01that is reputable. And I, I blow the say anybody's name because I was so wrong about cold card,
- 38:09but go find them, generate a new wallet to, you know, roll the dice if they let you do it, do the passphrase. If they let you do it, do everything,
- 38:19get your shit off.
- 38:20Or if you have to put it on coin base.
- 38:24I hate it when you know, even having to say it, but it's better than keeping your shit on the cold card.
- 38:31Don't do that. Go to coin base, go to river, go to unchain, go to, I don't know, put it on exchange, go to cracking,
- 38:37you know, at least until you, at least until you figure out what you want to do.
- 38:43Do you want to remain with self custody? Do you want somebody to custody your shit for you? Everything at this point is on the table
- 38:51because cold cards primary job was to just generate
- 38:56an unpredictable
- 38:57key, an unpredictable
- 38:59private key from which all your wallet addresses would be derived from. And they couldn't even fucking do that.
- 39:06They used to be able to do that,
- 39:08but somewhere in 2021 they decided, I don't know
- 39:12what for reasons. And we may touch on some of those. I'm not sure exactly
- 39:17if I should talk about it, but at this point I kind of don't care.
- 39:22They
- 39:24had the hardware to actually
- 39:27do the key generation,
- 39:29but their firmware upgrade basically screwed that
- 39:33and review apparently confirmed
- 39:36that security components did in fact exist on the cold card
- 39:41and they
- 39:42had a firmware up. They did a firmware upgrade that basically made it moot.
- 39:47They spent the money on the secure elements to actually do all this stuff and the firmware upgrade itself basically bypassed
- 39:54them.
- 39:56Your cold card queue has everything on board that you would need to generate a completely unpredictable
- 40:03private key, but their firmware
- 40:06negated it. That's what's going on here. And that's what's been going on for five
- 40:11years.
- 40:12It was a failure of end to end verification.
- 40:16You know, it wasn't like one unfortunate line of code,
- 40:21you know, family reserves,
- 40:23retirement savings, business capital
- 40:25inheritances,
- 40:27years
- 40:28of stacking,
- 40:29years of deferred
- 40:31consumption.
- 40:33You know, these were, these were people who removed their Bitcoin from exchanges and accepted the burden of self custody because they were trying to do things the right way and they got hosed.
- 40:47So how did this whole thing play out? Okay. So there's, there's a cup, there's like basically three phases, four phases, right?
- 40:55So phase one
- 40:59of after we've discovered this,
- 41:01after we like, you know, at first there was dismissal
- 41:05and then we come to find out that the danger was real. And then we come to find out that the danger is actually expanding,
- 41:11you know, like, like in phase one who was blamed,
- 41:15right? We, we know that that early
- 41:18July thirtieth
- 41:20wallets were being swept and you know, and it was, was not done by the wallet owners.
- 41:27And when the dust start, when, I mean the dust started to settle or a little bit,
- 41:32all of a sudden the victims themselves were blamed.
- 41:35There were early reports,
- 41:38you know, that, that were treated as, Oh, well you just, it was your fault. You compromised your seat,
- 41:45you know? And then, and then a lot of people started to assume that malware
- 41:50somehow was injected.
- 41:53Well,
- 41:55it was maybe you accidentally,
- 41:57I don't know, photo took a picture
- 42:00of your seed phrase and somehow it got leaked. So all the victims are being blamed.
- 42:07And then we moved to phase two.
- 42:09So again, phase one, all the victims are blamed. The people that are saying all my Bitcoin's gone. And then everybody going, yeah, it must be your fault. Can't be the cold card. It was
- 42:23phase two.
- 42:26This reveals
- 42:27this phase revealed
- 42:29coordination on the blockchain
- 42:32because researchers
- 42:33were starting to identify
- 42:36patterns
- 42:37that were common in these
- 42:39sweeps of Bitcoin from these affected wallet addresses.
- 42:44You know, it's not just isolated
- 42:46thefts.
- 42:48It's a systemic
- 42:49problem in endemic to cold card,
- 42:53not to any other hardware wallet that we know of, at least not, not yet.
- 42:57Right. And that's the, we should all be very,
- 43:01very
- 43:02careful
- 43:03as to, Oh, well now it's safe because I'm not on a cold card.
- 43:07Yeah. Take a deep breath and just think to yourself,
- 43:10what if it's not safe?
- 43:12What if it's not safe there? Don't now don't freak
- 43:16because when we freak out, we make bad mistakes, bad errors, and we don't want to do that here.
- 43:22But we do need to think seriously about is it safe?
- 43:27Sort of like Gandalf
- 43:28coming back to Frodo and Lord of the Rings. Is it secret?
- 43:32Is it safe?
- 43:34We should basically be telling ourselves,
- 43:36I'm not sure
- 43:39and actually spend the time to do something about that. We'll, we'll, we'll get to that. But there was, you know, we got these, these common sweet patterns that researchers started to identify.
- 43:51It's it's systemic
- 43:52cold card problem.
- 43:55And the working theory at that point
- 43:59was,
- 44:00Oh my God,
- 44:01somehow or another there's some kind of prediction.
- 44:05There's some sort of predictable
- 44:08seed generation
- 44:09that somebody has found in the cold card. And that is in fact what happened.
- 44:15But
- 44:16coin kite pushes back. That's phase three.
- 44:20That's that's was the next thing that happened is that, you know, early warnings
- 44:25were all publicly dismissed
- 44:28by coin kite.
- 44:29You
- 44:31know, the theft is active and it's ongoing and customers are trying to figure out what the hell to do. You got all these reports basically saying, we think it's an issue with the cold card seed generation setup and CoinKite says, no, it couldn't possibly be. We're the most secure wallet on the planet. All these people love us. Even people who we don't pay like even podcasters
- 44:53that we don't support,
- 44:54you know, love our products that they'll tell their, their listeners, Hey, you might want to consider a cold card.
- 45:01Fuck me, man. Anyway, phase four.
- 45:04Now the advisory gets the advisory
- 45:07war and the warnings get even wider.
- 45:10Older models are implicated.
- 45:13Older models are cold card
- 45:15and the later models are now brought into the warning. And that's where the mark four, mark five and q because at first it was just the mark three.
- 45:23That's all you needed to worry about, which just happened to be the model of cold card that I had, which is why I completely shit my pants.
- 45:31You know, the users who initially believed that they were safe learned that, you know, they might need to migrate,
- 45:38you know, Mark fours and Mark fives,
- 45:40or at least Mark, there's a couple of cases of Mark fours
- 45:44address generations that were, were swept.
- 45:48And then there's a couple of situations where, and it's anecdotal cause I can't verify it,
- 45:55but that
- 45:56Mark fours that had like a simple passphrase as a 24 word as a twenty fifth word
- 46:02for their 24 word seed phrase
- 46:04are also being swept.
- 46:10You know, the, the, like coin kite at this point,
- 46:14they appear
- 46:16that they're learning about the scope
- 46:19while the attackers continue to operate. So they're, you know, coin kites just
- 46:24figuring out that maybe they should, maybe they should take a different stance and take this seriously instead of just dismissing
- 46:30people saying,
- 46:32have your product and all my shit's gone bro.
- 46:35And now only net, like only at the very end, took like forty eight hours
- 46:41for the coin kite team to get their ever loving shit together and at least stop blaming the victims.
- 46:54And I didn't
- 46:57whole thing is really sad.
- 47:02And
- 47:04think of what time of year it is right now.
- 47:09This is the best time
- 47:11to construct this kind of attack. Why?
- 47:15Summer.
- 47:16What happens in summer? People are on vacation with their families.
- 47:20That's what happens in summer.
- 47:23This is
- 47:24the vacation season
- 47:26for
- 47:28most of the civil, what you would consider,
- 47:31like I was about to say civilized world. Most of the first world
- 47:35they get, you know, we get to take vacations and shit. We do it in summer. You're a w it generally speaking, you don't take your hardware wallet with you in summer.
- 47:44You don't,
- 47:45you don't those travel with your hardware wallet,
- 47:48Right? So you leave it somewhere. You'd be like 200, 400, 1,400
- 47:53miles away. And many people were.
- 47:58You know? And while they're sitting there,
- 48:01while they're sitting there
- 48:03on vacation with their families,
- 48:05they know what's going on and they know that they can't get back to it. Can you imagine the psychological
- 48:11trauma
- 48:13of trying to enjoy your time with your family and you have
- 48:18your entire family's future tied up in a cold card at this point and you can do nothing about it?
- 48:26You know, first. And this is what I had to do,
- 48:30you know, or, or, well, I had to generate a completely new seat. I just happened. I was lucky that I happened to have another hardware wallet from another manufacturer, but if I didn't, I would have just,
- 48:42I would have gone to Coinbase probably.
- 48:45I would have just put it on Coinbase, but I happened to have another wallet. So I had to generate a completely new seed on a completely new wallet.
- 48:55Know, then I had to verify and backup or receive address
- 48:59and I had to back up the entire wallet. And I do that. I do that twice. I'd make two backups
- 49:05and I keep the backups in two different places
- 49:07so that if one place burns down, then I've got a chance to recover from the other place.
- 49:13Then, then I got to do a test transaction.
- 49:16And if that, you know, make sure that the test transaction goes through and then I can remove, you know, move the remaining balance before the attacker finds them,
- 49:25you know, and there's a bunch of people on vacation. They can't do any of this.
- 49:30I mean, if they were home, it sucks anyway
- 49:33to have to do this.
- 49:35Imagine being, I don't know, 1,500 miles away and you know, you got to take four airplane rides and you're trying to just enjoy time with your family whose future is now in jeopardy
- 49:46because of coin kite and their shitty security practices.
- 49:57It got to the point like people like American huddle.
- 50:02We're telling people to call one of their friends
- 50:06that either has a key to their house or can break into their house and, and tell them exactly where they keep their cold card and walk them through exactly how to send all the funds somewhere else.
- 50:20You're trusting your entire life savings in some cases
- 50:23like, like more than life changing amounts of money
- 50:27with
- 50:28your friend
- 50:29or your neighbor and just hoping that they don't steal from you. And I think in most cases they probably wouldn't,
- 50:36but the chances that they make a mistake
- 50:39is high and yet what's the best advice American huddle could give,
- 50:44you know,
- 50:47normal physical
- 50:48security rules. Yeah. Just abandon that shit.
- 50:52You know, when respected Bitcoiners are seriously discussing
- 50:56breaking a window to reach a hardware wallet. Yeah. All the abstraction is overdue.
- 51:02BTC
- 51:03sessions,
- 51:05you know, he's helped a lot of people. He's
- 51:07got a lot of tutorials of a lot of different hardware wallets and other stuff too. He's, he's has,
- 51:15has recommended a cold card as well. He's done tutorials on cold card.
- 51:20He started reporting that even an MK three wallet
- 51:24that was protected by a two word passphrase was drained.
- 51:28It's not to say that all passphrases were, were defeated, but still
- 51:32short predictable passphrases
- 51:34can be searched alongside the reduced seed space. And that just basically means
- 51:39the, this reduced seed spaces, that whole entropy only being, you know,
- 51:45trivial,
- 51:47trivia, trivially
- 51:49regenerated
- 51:50by a laptop
- 51:52because it had two to the 32
- 51:55bits entropy instead of two to one hundred and twenty eighth or two to a two fifty six,
- 52:03you know, Mark Mark four, the same thing happened with a passphrase.
- 52:10Yeah, think about it. Think about it. The first way wave
- 52:14of this attack
- 52:16just targeted
- 52:17large balances.
- 52:19Anything. I think it was anything over 1.15
- 52:21Bitcoin,
- 52:23but then there was a late, the later waves started coming in.
- 52:26I think we're on wave number four right now,
- 52:29but the second wave moved down the balance curve. So in like the things that had only 1.15
- 52:37Bitcoin and below were being savaged.
- 52:40Then the transaction
- 52:42patterns they changed
- 52:44suggesting adaptation,
- 52:46but it also suggested, you know, multiple attackers,
- 52:49you know, copycat guys that were like, Hey, that's a great idea. That we know how to do it, you know, we can back engineer exactly how to do it given what we've, what we know so far from the news on X
- 53:01and then other people got into the game.
- 53:04The theft is still unfolding at this time. You cannot keep
- 53:09your Bitcoin on a cold card. Even if you generated it
- 53:13with firmware
- 53:14on a mark one or mark two or even firmware on a mark three that was not
- 53:19firmware version four. It was underneath likes like three point x or something like that.
- 53:26Don't trust it
- 53:27at this point. Don't trust it because we don't, I mean if, if coin kite failed so spectacularly
- 53:36on this particular, the upgrade, the upgrade, I say that in quotes, the upgrade from version
- 53:43three point X to version four point X,
- 53:46if that was such a fabulous and spectacular
- 53:48fail,
- 53:49what else could be lurking in there? So if you've got, if you've got like, like let's say you got a mark two and
- 53:55you've already checked your balance and you've been checking it all weekend long and you checked it before you went to work this morning and everything's fine.
- 54:04You need to get your shit off of any
- 54:07coin kite product.
- 54:09Go somewhere else. Go to Coinbase. I don't know. Go to Kraken. I would never, never in my life
- 54:16think that I would ever be advising anybody
- 54:20to do like some kind of centralized custody yet. Here we are.
- 54:25If you, I mean, if you, if you've got another hardware, you know, vent wallet vendor that, that you now trust more than CoinKite,
- 54:34I don't know what, I don't know what to tell you because I was advising people to go get a cold card and I was so horribly wrong. I don't want to advise anybody doing anything ever again.
- 54:44I'm sure one of these days I will when the smoke clears, but right now I don't feel good about advising anybody to do goddamn thing except wherever you put it,
- 54:54get your Bitcoin off of the coin kite product. But when you, if, if for whatever reason you decide to do that,
- 55:02you can't do it in a panic because you'll make a mistake.
- 55:05You're going to do like a Mark one
- 55:08and you really believe it's safe.
- 55:10You have breathing room.
- 55:13You can calm your mind,
- 55:15maybe do meditation before you even start doing this.
- 55:19Take your time setting up a different wallet or take your time figuring out if you do centralized exchange,
- 55:26which one you want to go to. That's gotta be up to you.
- 55:30Cause like I said, I don't feel good about advising
- 55:33cracking over river or river over unchanged or unchanged over coin business. I don't want to say any of that
- 55:39because I don't want to be wrong again
- 55:42at this fucking scale.
- 55:45Still though,
- 55:48keeping
- 55:49the Bitcoin on
- 55:51any coin kite product at this point
- 55:54I think is foolish.
- 55:58That's the only thing that I can really say about that one.
- 56:01The theft is still ongoing.
- 56:03It just, it, it's like it won't stop.
- 56:07People that thought they were protected with passphrases are finding out, well, I only had a two word passphrase and it got, got, I got stolen from.
- 56:16So
- 56:20this is a hard time for Bitcoin.
- 56:24I imagine it was like, I imagine the feelings are similar to Mount Gox. I got into Bitcoin right after the Mount Gox hack. So
- 56:34I don't know what the sentiment was really like
- 56:36because it happened, you know, much earlier than, than when I got, got into Bitcoin in 2015.
- 56:42Still though, I can't imagine
- 56:44it not feeling like a kick in the crotch, a gut punch and a punch to the nose all at once
- 56:50for even people that weren't on Mountain Cox because they were like, what does this mean for the, for the whole space?
- 56:58Right.
- 57:00And like I, like I said, the attack is still ongoing, but now it's it, you know, there's, there's a completely different format of it. The first format of just sweeping actual physical addresses generated through shitty entropy. That's still ongoing.
- 57:14Right? But now they've, now we have an added later layer called phishing
- 57:20emails are now being sent.
- 57:23You know, the like they're like a Jack Spear co kind of like predicted. He said that this, the phishing incidents will occur.
- 57:32People are going to start getting emails about, Hey, you know, we're cold card and your shit got hacked and we're here to help. They are though they're not there to help. They're not there to help. They're not there to help. I mean, even foundation devices
- 57:46has set out a warning saying something about phishing incidences with the foundation name on it.
- 57:52All, every hardware manufacturer
- 57:54is going to have a phishing
- 57:57expedition
- 57:58sent in their name.
- 58:02Be aware,
- 58:03right? So they begin like these phishing incidents will look like this. It'll begin with truthful information about the cold card.
- 58:10It'll, they'll have links to legitimate reporting.
- 58:14They'll use language that talk about entropy and random number generator failures, also known as RNG
- 58:21random number generator.
- 58:23The need for urgent migration.
- 58:26They'll offer some kind of fake security pro protocol or God forbid a wallet audit.
- 58:32Don't don't do it.
- 58:34They'll, they'll ask you to enter in your seed phrase
- 58:37or, or
- 58:39they'll ask you to install malicious software.
- 58:42Then they're going to drain the wallet.
- 58:45That's in that's, we're going to start getting reports about people who have physically gotten their wallet drained off of, you know, their wallet created by a ledger
- 58:54because they fell for a phishing
- 58:56incident.
- 58:58This is going to last for a very long time.
- 59:01So this is a completely
- 59:03second layer like in foundation.
- 59:07It was a foundation. Oh, foundations fake. I mentioned foundations fake. Here's what it looked like.
- 59:13It started with technical language.
- 59:16They manufactured
- 59:18the authority because they had like, you know, the, the logo foundation devices on it and all that stuff.
- 59:24Then they gave the user in the email a deadline. Oh my God, you got to do this now. You gotta do it now.
- 59:30They actually put on, they actually put a button
- 59:33in the phishing email that says urgent and it's a button that you can push to immediately take you through the steps and the procedure
- 59:42is exactly
- 59:44what some frightened
- 59:46user would want to see and it's going to result in the exact same shit. They're going to drain all your Bitcoin
- 59:54and it's not going to be any one of these hardware wallet manufacturers
- 59:58fault so far.
- 1:00:00All of them seem to be pretty solid. But again, I I'm loathe to believe
- 1:00:05anything at this point.
- 1:00:07Just, I'm just saying
- 1:00:13as regarding these phishing attacks,
- 1:00:15no
- 1:00:16wallet manufacturer
- 1:00:18needs your seed phrase.
- 1:00:20If they ask for it, it's fake. It is a fake email and it's designed to take all of your money.
- 1:00:28Never enter a seed phrase into any website for any reason whatsoever.
- 1:00:34If they call you for somehow
- 1:00:36on the phone,
- 1:00:38don't tell them your seed phrase or any information at all because a wallet manufacturer
- 1:00:44will not ask.
- 1:00:46Don't ever install some kind of emergency
- 1:00:49tool
- 1:00:50from an unsolicited message. That basically means you just got it without you actually reaching out to somebody like
- 1:00:58bit box or bit key or,
- 1:01:00or, or block stream or whatever. If you didn't write them
- 1:01:04an email that says, please respond to this email. Help me, help me, help me. What the fuck do I do? Then they send you one back. This con that's replying to that email that you sent
- 1:01:15that is solicited.
- 1:01:18If you just get an email, like you wake woke up this morning or you wake up tomorrow morning and there's like some kind of email from
- 1:01:25some hardware wallet manufacturer,
- 1:01:28it's just, it's unsolicited.
- 1:01:30You should probably delete it,
- 1:01:33Right?
- 1:01:35You need to find the official source
- 1:01:38independently.
- 1:01:40Do not trust any links
- 1:01:42sent to you. Any text messages sent to you, any phone calls made to you, none of that. That is all unsolicited.
- 1:01:51You've got to be the one to reach out and do the work. And I hate it that you have to do the work, but here we are.
- 1:02:02But I want to end
- 1:02:04today with talking about
- 1:02:06the other reactions
- 1:02:08to this entire
- 1:02:10entire thing.
- 1:02:13The volunteer rescue teams
- 1:02:16that sprung to action and are still working some without
- 1:02:21sleep for forty eight hours. I'm I'm
- 1:02:25serious.
- 1:02:27Of course. Then again, I have to say, well, do I believe that that Rob Hamilton hasn't slept in twenty four hours? I don't know. I'm not in Rob Hamilton's apartment or house. I'm not watching Rob Hamilton do his shit, but he's one of the guys that's trying
- 1:02:41to help,
- 1:02:42but I can't verify any of this, but it looks to me
- 1:02:46like there are many,
- 1:02:48many people like BTC sessions,
- 1:02:50Rob Hamilton.
- 1:02:52I can't remember all the names.
- 1:02:54I wish I could. I wish I'd had
- 1:02:57the, the wherewithal to, to write them all down on a list of paper, but there are
- 1:03:03hand, there are like multiple handfuls
- 1:03:06of people that are doing nothing
- 1:03:08but essentially customer service
- 1:03:11for companies
- 1:03:12that they don't work for or companies that aren't even their companies. You got foundation devices advising people on how to help
- 1:03:21people that have a completely different hardware wallet from a completely different manufacturer.
- 1:03:27They're helping, they're doing everything.
- 1:03:30You know,
- 1:03:31mentors
- 1:03:32have been forming
- 1:03:34private coordination groups,
- 1:03:36volunteers
- 1:03:37handling affected users one on one volunteers
- 1:03:42saying if telling people on, on things like telegram and Twitter and master, if you need help,
- 1:03:49reach out to me. I will try to help you.
- 1:03:54You know, these people are working without sleep or compensation.
- 1:03:57Some are spending their own money
- 1:04:00to help other people or, or, or basically
- 1:04:04reinforce
- 1:04:05at the, at the level of the common good.
- 1:04:11You know, some calls ended in relief.
- 1:04:14Some of these, you know, there was a lot of calls that,
- 1:04:17that these volunteers were actually able to help these people
- 1:04:21get their funds somewhere else. And then other phone calls just ended in tears because their funds were already gone.
- 1:04:29And once they're gone,
- 1:04:31they're gone.
- 1:04:34You know, BTC sessions is one of those people that's been helping.
- 1:04:39He reported that volunteer efforts at this point have helped protect tens of millions of dollars.
- 1:04:47You know that that figure is coming out of BTC sessions.
- 1:04:50I'm not hanging out with BTC sessions right now. I'm not at his house or wherever he is. I think he's in Australia. I'm not there. I'm not watching him. I'm not having a beer with him. I'm not trying, you know, I'm not there to help him. So I don't know, but
- 1:05:05tens of millions of dollars.
- 1:05:06I don't know. I could see it.
- 1:05:09You know, there's Mandrick
- 1:05:11made X as well as you know, Rob Hamilton. They're all trying to help
- 1:05:17you know, people
- 1:05:20represented only a fraction
- 1:05:22of those that are actually helping like Mandrick and BTC sessions and made X. These are the guys that I was that I was able to see,
- 1:05:30but there are so
- 1:05:33many other people
- 1:05:34that are like literally just losing sleep
- 1:05:38to try to help
- 1:05:39everybody else.
- 1:05:42People that don't work for coin kite coin kite is barely said a fucking word except that, Hey, they got a firmware update that we find out it doesn't work. Oh, Hey, we're, we're destroying all the cold cards that we have that are affected that we have an inventory.
- 1:05:56We'll go whatever
- 1:05:58not helping.
- 1:06:00They coin kite still had this shit for sale for forty eight fucking hours
- 1:06:06after everybody knew what was going on and we knew that it was coined kites fault and they were still selling their shit except they had a warning label on their website.
- 1:06:20Yeah. Individuals and teams dropped
- 1:06:23their normal work. We're talking people from river, people from unchained,
- 1:06:27maybe even Coinbase. I don't know. I haven't heard anything from Coinbase, but it wouldn't surprise me
- 1:06:32if they weren't dropping
- 1:06:33all of their work,
- 1:06:36putting everything on hold to help people they don't know they've never met and they're not going to get any money to do anything
- 1:06:44and still
- 1:06:46are there helping them trying to salvage this situation.
- 1:06:55The community is handling
- 1:06:57essentially technical support
- 1:06:59for every company under the sun,
- 1:07:03You know, migration,
- 1:07:06transaction tracing,
- 1:07:08research,
- 1:07:09God forbid emotional
- 1:07:11triage
- 1:07:13because the emotional effects of this are devastating
- 1:07:16for the people that lost the money, surely,
- 1:07:19and most horrifically,
- 1:07:21but even to the people who didn't because everybody, the foundations are now physically shook.
- 1:07:28This is, this is
- 1:07:30the immune system that we've always talked about in Bitcoin
- 1:07:34showing itself.
- 1:07:36This is the fever
- 1:07:39except in this particular case
- 1:07:45it's people like BTC sessions and Rob Hamilton
- 1:07:48losing sleep so they can help people that they've never met.
- 1:07:52That's the fever that the immune system causes
- 1:07:56when it's trying to heal the body.
- 1:07:59Now when the institutional immune system
- 1:08:02fucking shit the bed,
- 1:08:04it was the Bitcoin community that produced its own white blood cells.
- 1:08:08Rob Hamilton used this language.
- 1:08:12This may be one of the highest leverage harm reduction moments in history.
- 1:08:19Nothing
- 1:08:20was more important than preventing the emotional and financial destruction
- 1:08:24of losing
- 1:08:26everything.
- 1:08:28In contrast, we have coin kite who had years to verify its product.
- 1:08:35Volunteers.
- 1:08:36They had hours to rescue its customers.
- 1:08:40Jesus.
- 1:08:44So I mentioned that we've crossed the Rubicon.
- 1:08:47The hell does that even mean? People use that term. Oh, we've crossed the Rubicon. And I think that there's still probably a lot of people that don't understand the meaning of what that means.
- 1:08:59It's Caesar
- 1:09:00back in the times of ancient Rome.
- 1:09:03He
- 1:09:05was traveling with his army coming out of Gaul,
- 1:09:08which is modern day France.
- 1:09:11And,
- 1:09:12he crossed the River Rubicon with his army
- 1:09:15that worse, that was still an armor and was still armed with swords and shields and helmets and spears and all the accoutrement that goes along with the Roman army. They were supposed to completely divest themselves of all armament
- 1:09:31before crossing the Rubicon. That was Roman law.
- 1:09:34You could not cross the Rubicon
- 1:09:39with an army
- 1:09:41and Caesar did it and he did it for a reason. He did it because that's the Caesar that we all know that took over Rome. He did it by force. He did it with a single army that he was in command of when he did it and he became dictator.
- 1:09:56When he crossed the Rubicon,
- 1:09:58he said this,
- 1:10:00the die is cast.
- 1:10:03And it was somebody on Noster that reminded me that Caesar said that
- 1:10:07when he crossed the Rubicon in full knowledge that what he was doing was not only illegal,
- 1:10:12but he knew what he was going to do.
- 1:10:15The die was cast. It's ironic
- 1:10:18that that applies here because people, this whole
- 1:10:21dice rolling meme that we've got going on,
- 1:10:25you know, if you didn't roll the dice,
- 1:10:27well you, it's your fault that you lost all your shit.
- 1:10:30I won't, it won't even get into to the vagaries of that one, but
- 1:10:34the irony is real
- 1:10:36still.
- 1:10:39As we all know, Caesar then took over Rome. Then he was the dictator for years and years and years and he wasn't exactly the nicest, the nicest guy ever. He was the guy that basically got stabbed to death by Brutus and Marcus. Was it Marcus?
- 1:10:54I can't remember Marcus Aurelius, I guess it didn't know that was a, that was another emperor. I can't remember.
- 1:11:01It was Marcus something. I can't remember his name. It was a trusted friend and Brutus was one of his best friends too. And even those guys
- 1:11:09along with the entirety of the Roman Senate stabbed him to fucking death.
- 1:11:13You get shake, you get a Shakespeare play out of that one, by the way,
- 1:11:17in either event,
- 1:11:20we've crossed the Rubicon
- 1:11:23like Caesar crossed his and
- 1:11:25it's not Bitcoin that crossed the Rubicon.
- 1:11:29It's artificial intelligence
- 1:11:31because that's sort of how this entire thing was perpetrated.
- 1:11:37Now we don't know for sure,
- 1:11:40but I can imagine AI not being used to discover the vulnerability
- 1:11:45in the cold card stuff.
- 1:11:48And I also think that it helped build search processes,
- 1:11:53construct, and then conduct the transactions,
- 1:11:56you know, basically automating all the sweeps of all the Bitcoin and all the affected wallets.
- 1:12:02You know, we haven't conclusively demonstrated that is the truth publicly,
- 1:12:06but I'm, it's not going to surprise me when that news breaks.
- 1:12:14AI systems can now read
- 1:12:16giant code repositories.
- 1:12:19It can trace dependencies.
- 1:12:21It can propose,
- 1:12:23you know, exploits and it can even automate the testing and attackers
- 1:12:27can rerun improved models against open source projects just
- 1:12:33again and again and again and again.
- 1:12:36And that's one of the, one of the ways that we think
- 1:12:40this, the first wave attacker was able to find this vulnerability because
- 1:12:45think about it. This didn't go on for five years
- 1:12:49and yet the, the, it could have, it could have happened at any time in the last five years since 2021
- 1:12:55this shit could have happened anytime and it didn't.
- 1:12:59So I,
- 1:13:01the theory is,
- 1:13:02is that somebody decided to say,
- 1:13:05you know what,
- 1:13:07let's look at all the firmware upgrades that coin kite has done. Or actually what they probably did is say, let's look at all the firmware upgrades
- 1:13:16of all the hardware wallet manufacturers and see if we can find a vulnerability that's exploitable. And they found one in coin kite
- 1:13:24specifically in inside the cold card,
- 1:13:26specifically firmware version four and above.
- 1:13:31And it looked like the AI was basically able to immediately, and this has been replicated a couple of times by other users who have done the exact same thing. It said, basically
- 1:13:40look for the firmware upgrades for CoinKite.
- 1:13:43And tell me if you can find an exploit
- 1:13:45and time after time, after time, the AI, no matter what model is being used seems to come back with,
- 1:13:52in this firmware upgrade,
- 1:13:53it's basically given the ability, the ability for the cold car to fall back to a random number generation
- 1:14:01schema that doesn't really work.
- 1:14:04And it only provides
- 1:14:05this much entropy,
- 1:14:07this, you know, to raise to the 32 bits of entropy,
- 1:14:11which is again,
- 1:14:12trivial for a laptop to be able to break given about eight, you know, nine minutes.
- 1:14:17This, this attack has been replicated by all kinds of white hat hackers that have actually been able to find wallet addresses that have already been affected and drained on their own without any, without giving
- 1:14:30Kimmy or whatever, any prior knowledge to that wallet address was able to find the same wallet address using the same methods,
- 1:14:38hundreds of wallet addresses. In fact,
- 1:14:42so
- 1:14:44this is why AI is most definitely involved even though it hasn't actually been, you know, verified, but it will be, I guarantee it.
- 1:14:53So now that AI systems can read these huge repositories and you know, multiple firmware upgrades and compare them to each other and find vulnerabilities,
- 1:15:03you know, periodic human audits just aren't enough
- 1:15:08because of that.
- 1:15:11Now audits
- 1:15:12are going to have to be done
- 1:15:15every day.
- 1:15:17So Rob Hamilton
- 1:15:19in between helping most people try to, you know, not have a reason to kill themselves.
- 1:15:26He basically
- 1:15:27spent has spent so far as far as we know. And again, I'm not with Rob Hamilton. I'm not at his house. I can't verify, but he said that he has spent more than $10,000
- 1:15:39on tokens
- 1:15:40specifically for Kimmy K three
- 1:15:45he scanned and audited more than a 100 Bitcoin related libraries
- 1:15:51with that $10,000
- 1:15:53worth of tokens using Kimi K three.
- 1:15:56You know, the human red team has been put together to validate the AI's findings when the audit is complete,
- 1:16:04to make sure that there's human eyeballs as well as artificial intelligence eyeballs
- 1:16:10involved in this ongoing set of, of, of audits that Rob Hamilton has been doing since the news of this cold card hack broke. And I don't like calling it a hack. Technically it's not a hack. It's an exploit of a shitty system.
- 1:16:27Now technical and non technical been Bitcoiners.
- 1:16:30Rob handle Hamilton is invited to contribute.
- 1:16:34You don't even have to be technical,
- 1:16:37you know? And I'm sure if you were to say, Rob, you said non technical bitcoiners can help. I don't know how maybe he'll direct you to somebody who can tell you exactly how you can help. Maybe there's something written. I don't know. Rob Hamilton is
- 1:16:50blowing up on Twitter right now because he has basically been fucking tireless trying to help,
- 1:16:56you know, whether,
- 1:16:57whether or not AI found this exact bug first is almost really beside the point.
- 1:17:04Know, here's the point
- 1:17:06from now on. This is why I've said that we've crossed the Rubicon because from now on on this side of the Rubicon,
- 1:17:14every company must assume
- 1:17:17that adversarial
- 1:17:18machines
- 1:17:19are reading every line of code. It publishes
- 1:17:23every second of the day, every day, every week for fifty two weeks, a year,
- 1:17:30300, you know, three seventy five days a year,
- 1:17:34every single year.
- 1:17:35That mean for, from now on,
- 1:17:38from now on, if one, one
- 1:17:41potential hacker isn't doing it
- 1:17:44on, on some system, another is, and this goes far, far, far beyond Bitcoin
- 1:17:51every,
- 1:17:52and this is what, this is what I don't understand. Why didn't they attack banks first
- 1:17:57is banks is bank security
- 1:18:00like, well actually I, I, they probably have,
- 1:18:03but bank security
- 1:18:04as far as entropy is concerned is
- 1:18:08in, you know, industry standard 128
- 1:18:11bit to two fifty six bit encryption
- 1:18:14cold card never had that or hasn't had that in five years,
- 1:18:20you know, but it, but I guarantee you that those systems are being tested.
- 1:18:25You got water systems in Missouri or what in the Midwest that had been attacked. God only knows why water systems are online
- 1:18:33or why water systems would want to be at, you know, why you would want to attack water systems
- 1:18:38unless you want to shut down a water supply to
- 1:18:41an AI,
- 1:18:43you know, warehouse data center.
- 1:18:46Know, may my wife suggested that because you're not getting any money out of that attack. That's for damn sure you're spending money on that attack,
- 1:18:56but banks are at risk. Governments are at risk. Why, why didn't they attack the IRS?
- 1:19:02You know, why not? Why not completely destroy the IRS
- 1:19:06computing system so that we don't have to work with these fuckers anymore?
- 1:19:10They didn't do that. No, they went after cold card. They went after Bitcoin. They didn't go after Ethereum.
- 1:19:15You know, like there's,
- 1:19:18you could construct all manner of conspiracy theories around it, but none of it really matters right now.
- 1:19:25Where we are is not where we were.
- 1:19:29That's what I'm getting at every
- 1:19:32single day from now on. Now of course you'll be saying, well David, this has been going on for like, you know, probably three years. Yeah. But this is the visible crossover point, at least for me,
- 1:19:42maybe not for you. Maybe your crossover point was somewhere else, but I get the feeling that this is crossing the Rubicon
- 1:19:49for a large percentage
- 1:19:52of the world.
- 1:19:54Well, actually for Bitcoiners, but also it's going to be for people that are looking, have been looking at Bitcoin that aren't Bitcoiners going, what
- 1:20:01does this mean for, I don't know my electrical grid. What does this mean for my water system? What does this mean for my bank account, my pension account, my retirement stuff, anything like
- 1:20:13what is this? What is,
- 1:20:15what kind of attack
- 1:20:17could I perpetrate on a homeowner
- 1:20:20specifically
- 1:20:21about their deed?
- 1:20:23Could I falsify their deed
- 1:20:26in
- 1:20:27the digital domain? Is there a way that I could take possession of their property?
- 1:20:34This goes way beyond Bitcoin.
- 1:20:38This is a token war.
- 1:20:41It's, it's a new, it's a security
- 1:20:43moat. Remember we talk about regulatory moats. Well,
- 1:20:48to security moating.
- 1:20:49I
- 1:20:51lost my Bitcoin in a moating accident.
- 1:20:54You know, you can just say it like that. Like for instance, the token war,
- 1:21:00you know,
- 1:21:01continuous AI review cost tokens.
- 1:21:06You know, it also costs compute and skilled human validation
- 1:21:10when shit's found out
- 1:21:12wealthy companies can buy a lot more scrutiny
- 1:21:15and run a lot more models more often than you can.
- 1:21:20You know, like smaller firms
- 1:21:22just may be unable to afford the new minimum security standard.
- 1:21:26This all
- 1:21:28let me put a tinfoil hat on for a second. They planned it this way.
- 1:21:32No, I don't know that if that's true, but that's where we find ourselves.
- 1:21:36It's become a form of regulatory
- 1:21:39moating.
- 1:21:40It's just not with a regulator.
- 1:21:43The cost
- 1:21:44of proving safety
- 1:21:47becomes the license required
- 1:21:50to compete.
- 1:21:51And if you cannot be like Rob Hamilton, where you can just
- 1:21:56puke up $10,000
- 1:21:59in goodwill,
- 1:22:00he's doing this for goodwill,
- 1:22:03right? He's not
- 1:22:05trying to test a product that he wants to offer. He's doing this for goodwill. And in three days he spent $10,000
- 1:22:13in tokens. Imagine you want to constrict like you've got an idea for a brand new Bitcoin hardware wallet, and you want to compete on the open market. How much money do you have for
- 1:22:23continual
- 1:22:24AI based
- 1:22:26auditing of your code,
- 1:22:28all your firmware,
- 1:22:29everything.
- 1:22:31How much money do you have to do it every day?
- 1:22:35Because that's what's going to be fucking required at this point,
- 1:22:39At least
- 1:22:40every firmware upgrade,
- 1:22:42but
- 1:22:43who, I mean you're racing against the clock
- 1:22:46against somebody that also has a shit ton of money to buy a lot of AI tokens to be able to do continual
- 1:22:54code review over several models of your code
- 1:22:59to find vulnerabilities
- 1:23:01because your code secures
- 1:23:03something of value. Again, it doesn't have to be Bitcoin. It can be
- 1:23:09central records in Houston, Texas where you keep like the tax office or whatever, where you keep deeds.
- 1:23:18Are we still going to trust a paper deed with my signature on it?
- 1:23:22And I don't know the tax assessor's office on it. I don't know. I can't, I've been so long since I've seen a house deed. It's not even funny, but are we going to trust the paper over the digital record? And if not,
- 1:23:35how, how do we know that the digital record hasn't been changed
- 1:23:39because the system securing those digital records was compromised
- 1:23:43five years ago by fucking AI or something.
- 1:23:47You get where I'm going with it. That's why I say we've crossed the Rubicon.
- 1:23:55It's
- 1:23:56just that the cost of doing this at this point is now an added cost of doing business And a lot of small businesses can't compete as it is.
- 1:24:07And this whole thing,
- 1:24:09if, if you're a hardware wallet manufacturer right now, and you're not prepared
- 1:24:14to do
- 1:24:16AI testing at scale on your code and your firmware and everything about your product,
- 1:24:22you need to advise all of your customers
- 1:24:25that they need to migrate off of your shit.
- 1:24:28And then only after
- 1:24:30no more customer support tickets are coming in. Do you close your company
- 1:24:36because you're going to get somebody hurt.
- 1:24:39And that's where we are. We are on the other side of the Rubicon.
- 1:24:45However,
- 1:24:48there's one other thing
- 1:24:50that could possibly be happening that is good.
- 1:24:58Participate in shared open source auditing infrastructure.
- 1:25:01Like what Rob Hamilton said, Hey, technical and non technical bit Bitcoiners alike can participate
- 1:25:07in what what's been going on with the cold card, but that could also occur into the future with no end date insight.
- 1:25:16Right? We could maybe
- 1:25:19build a pool to, you know, for token funding for compute and prompting,
- 1:25:25you know,
- 1:25:26testing human review
- 1:25:28of, of those AI audits,
- 1:25:31all of that.
- 1:25:32We could all take part of that even at the, the lead like, yeah, we could be a complete retard
- 1:25:38and at least try to help
- 1:25:40because out of out of
- 1:25:43hundreds of people,
- 1:25:45know,
- 1:25:46doing executing their own audits,
- 1:25:48even if they don't know exactly what they're doing. Maybe they actually turn up a red flag because they used a different AI model to review the code on the GitHub repository for company X.
- 1:26:01And then they say, Hey, I don't know what it means, but I found this
- 1:26:06and here it is. I'll, you know, I'll give it, you know, here it is. I'll give it to you because a lot of us already have the ability to do something like that without buying an exorbitant amount of tokens.
- 1:26:19If, if we, if we pool all this, like we used to talk about like pooling,
- 1:26:25like, like mining pools, they first started,
- 1:26:29they first started with a bunch of small miners getting together saying we're stronger together
- 1:26:34and we'll pool our resources.
- 1:26:37There's no reason not to do it again,
- 1:26:39except this time it's for things like code review, but it goes beyond code.
- 1:26:44I call, I think I want to use the term swarm audits
- 1:26:50like
- 1:26:51a smaller project
- 1:26:53may have to depend on accepting community swarm audits of their code.
- 1:26:59And it may be confusing
- 1:27:01and it may be filled with a lot of noise,
- 1:27:04but there's
- 1:27:05people there that are probably trying to help. There's also people there that are probably trying to, that would probably try to inject something in like
- 1:27:12that because of maliciousness
- 1:27:14exactly how that would. And I don't mean to inject something into the code base, basically trying to construct an argument as to why some, you know, a line of code needs to be taken out and falsified and nothing, nothing is off the table at this point, but I want to believe that there's more good people than bad people and that the signal, the noise between good versus bad,
- 1:27:35the good people will squelch out the bad.
- 1:27:38I can't guarantee that,
- 1:27:40but swarm audits
- 1:27:42like me, like I did it.
- 1:27:45I did an audit on bit box. Oh, two Nova's code base,
- 1:27:49which happened to be the code base that they're using for a lot of their products. No, I'm not, I'm not saying, I'm not saying I'm not recommending it. I'm not recommending anything today.
- 1:28:00One of these days,
- 1:28:01maybe I will find somebody. I don't know. But right now I don't want to recommend shit. I just want to tell you what I did. I went to Grock and like at the level of coding
- 1:28:11and auditing code,
- 1:28:13I don't know what the fuck I'm doing.
- 1:28:15I don't.
- 1:28:16And it's okay for me to admit it's better for me to admit that shit than to fake it. Right? So I don't know what I'm doing, but I do do this.
- 1:28:25I get to grok and I say, look,
- 1:28:28will you do me a favor?
- 1:28:31Reach out and discover
- 1:28:33on the interwebs
- 1:28:35where
- 1:28:36bit box the company
- 1:28:38keeps their code for the bit box to or bit box Oh two Nova and audit the code and discover if there's any vulnerabilities
- 1:28:48and report back to me
- 1:28:50just to see if it would work. I mean, I did this. I did that prompt just to see if it worked.
- 1:28:57It I had to walk away from it because I was like, I don't know. I mean, I didn't even give it the repository URL.
- 1:29:05I didn't know where to go look. I mean, I knew where to go look, but I didn't know if I'd, you know, I wasn't sure. So I just said, look, I just want to do an experiment.
- 1:29:13Get Grok to go find a GitHub repository that I don't know the URL to and see if it actually finds it, audits it and comes up with a report. And it fucking did.
- 1:29:23It did. It came up with a report
- 1:29:26said it was clean. Now I don't believe it because I believe in nothing. And I don't want anybody to think that I'm advising anybody to do shit
- 1:29:35except get your Bitcoin off of a coin kite product at ASAP.
- 1:29:39Other than that, I'm not advising anybody do shit. You got to figure the rest out on your own, I guess at least for right now until we all of us figure out
- 1:29:49how to advise people without getting them in trouble,
- 1:29:52you know, because nothing is safe anyway.
- 1:29:56So it comes back. It not only finds the GitHub repository,
- 1:29:59but it starts like I actually put a screenshot
- 1:30:02of a lot of the messages that it sent back before it, you know, I don't know if you've ever used Grock, but it will tell it kind of like give you a timeline of what it's doing or where it's at or what, what it went to or, you know, things like that. And then when it finally finishes doing all, you know, actually thinking about the situation and starts writing out the, you know, its response,
- 1:30:22it basically wipes all that. So I made sure to take a screenshot
- 1:30:25of what it was doing. And if not only did it find the BitBox,
- 1:30:29GitHub repository,
- 1:30:30it started telling me what libraries it was looking for
- 1:30:34firmware stuff. It was looking for the
- 1:30:37libraries that it found
- 1:30:39firmware that it found code base that it found.
- 1:30:42And then it came back with the report and said,
- 1:30:45Hey, this is what I found. And I'm just going to say that there was another person
- 1:30:53that
- 1:30:54sort of did kind of the same thing except they were much more technically advanced and I cannot remember their name, but they basically audited
- 1:31:01all the major hardware wallet manufacturer brands
- 1:31:05like Jade,
- 1:31:07anybody that was open source,
- 1:31:09right? And one of the reasons that cold card failed so miserably is that in 2021,
- 1:31:13right after, as they were doing that firmware upgrade,
- 1:31:16they basically turned their code from open source, fully open source to close source. It was code viewable, which I've said before on this podcast, but I didn't realize
- 1:31:26what the fuck I was talking about. I just let's just admit it to be so we can get past it. It was source viewable. You could view the source and I guess you could take screenshots or maybe even like, you know, lift some, code directly off of it, but it's not like being fully open source. It's not FOSS free and open source software,
- 1:31:47but all the, these other manufacturers
- 1:31:49that this guy listed in this basically a brief of, you know, is this wallet company, you know, secure or is this wallet manufacturer's
- 1:31:59hardware secure?
- 1:32:00He basically made a table
- 1:32:02and the only one that completely failed miserably was cold card.
- 1:32:06And the real reason is it true for two reasons. One, we already know how badly it failed, but two, it couldn't get to the source code to actually examine it,
- 1:32:16but everything else basically passed, but there were four manufacturers that were in the green had a little, you know, basically said we find nothing
- 1:32:25at all problematic.
- 1:32:27There was a couple of other wallet manufacturers were while they're safe.
- 1:32:30They had like other issues that didn't have anything to do with entropy. Like, I don't know, some other kind of bug,
- 1:32:37you know, that wasn't had, didn't have anything to do with wallet generation or anything like that. But basically everything was safe, but four manufacturers were in the green and I'm not even, I can't tell you their names. Why?
- 1:32:49Because I don't want to, I don't want to add
- 1:32:53misery to anybody in case this guy's cause he's a dude on the internet
- 1:32:59and I have to not trust him. He's probably a fine individual.
- 1:33:05You know, his children may, you know, maybe think he's, you know, hung the moon and his wife thinks that he can do no wrong and maybe he's a monk in his off time. I don't know,
- 1:33:17but I'm not going to tell you the names of who came up green,
- 1:33:22but four of them came up green with no issues being, being found.
- 1:33:27Imagine if we all did something like that
- 1:33:30each to his skills
- 1:33:33or her skills
- 1:33:35each to the level of money that they are willing to spend on tokens. I get a certain amount of tokens basically every month from open AI and from Grok. Now I'm not a subscriber to Grok, so I get way less tokens,
- 1:33:49but I basically had enough to at least do a cursory examination
- 1:33:53of bit boxes,
- 1:33:55you know, code repository.
- 1:33:57And it came up clean as far as Grock was concerned.
- 1:34:01But wouldn't it be nice if somebody else did the same thing, but even deeper,
- 1:34:05but used something like Kimmy K three to do it. But that's what Rob Hamilton is kind of doing, but I, and I'm sure at one point or another, a full report is forthcoming. I haven't seen it yet. I don't know. And I'm not going to conjecture any further than that. I'm just saying that this is what I mean by swarm auditing.
- 1:34:23You know, a lot of us have
- 1:34:25tokens that we can basically donate
- 1:34:28basically by either,
- 1:34:30well, probably not by direct donation.
- 1:34:32Probably can't do that on your basic monthly subscription to open AI,
- 1:34:36but maybe you could put it out in on Noster or Twitter saying if I had to write a prompt,
- 1:34:44knowing anything about code review
- 1:34:46for, you know, X particular model, you know, whatever model that you have access to, what
- 1:34:53prompt would you want me to send so that I can help the community with the audit process? But the swarm auditing
- 1:35:01idea,
- 1:35:02this can't just end. It can't be a flurry of activity right up front. And then like a couple of weeks later, we just stopped doing it. We are not on that side of the Rubicon anymore.
- 1:35:14We are on this side of the Rubicon
- 1:35:17and I guess we're all going to have to be responsible
- 1:35:21for all the products that are out there
- 1:35:24when it cuts, at least when it comes to Bitcoin,
- 1:35:27at least when it comes to self custody,
- 1:35:29at least when it comes to wallet software,
- 1:35:31whether it's generating a seed or it's just being used as a, as for some, you know, for, for a wallet interface and it uses the seed generation from something else, you know, some other manufacturers hardware wallet did the seed phrase we're going to, maybe we should be responsible
- 1:35:48or not responsible, but maybe we should do everything we can to figure out a way to audit Coinbase's,
- 1:35:55you know, a custody software.
- 1:35:57I don't know. See, that's the problem. I don't have all the answers,
- 1:36:01but the term swarm
- 1:36:03audit,
- 1:36:04I want you to remember that
- 1:36:07it, this idea may go nowhere.
- 1:36:10You know, it's, I'm not a huge voice on Twitter. I'm actually
- 1:36:15barely visible on Twitter. I've got one of the smallest fucking podcasts in the Bitcoin space.
- 1:36:22You know, I don't get on YouTube and I don't have flashy
- 1:36:25backgrounds and like, you know, cool
- 1:36:28suit to wear and flashing my fucking Rolex and all that kind of shit, you know, that, so I literally
- 1:36:35bought it. I'm bottom of the barrel
- 1:36:38podcast right here. I don't have any sponsors at all.
- 1:36:44You know what?
- 1:36:45It's nobody's
- 1:36:46going to listen to me, but maybe they'll listen to you.
- 1:36:50If you think swarm audit is a good phrase
- 1:36:55and one to pass along to somebody that you know because people do listen to you because you're have a larger presence than I ever will on X or something like that. Then if you find the idea with merit, then spread it. Don't even give me credit. I don't care.
- 1:37:11Take credit.
- 1:37:12Say it was my idea. You know, I, I don't care because I think that this is the only way that smaller businesses and plebs can survive.
- 1:37:22Small projects are going to have to audit their shit all the time. Now we don't live
- 1:37:27on the other side of the Rubicon.
- 1:37:30We live here now.
- 1:37:33You know, we could maybe the swarm audit looks something like this.
- 1:37:39Submit the repository,
- 1:37:41run multiple AI models against critical code paths,
- 1:37:45compare results,
- 1:37:46escalate credible findings privately
- 1:37:49help fund token usage. As we've, as I've said, encourage every project to maintain a security.
- 1:37:56Md. That would be a markdown file of all their security stuff like their security practices, their audits, their any, anything that has something to do with their security
- 1:38:08that the public can see
- 1:38:11needs to be
- 1:38:14accessible
- 1:38:15on a second by second basis. So people can look at it.
- 1:38:20You know, never mistake unverified
- 1:38:22model output for some kind of confirmed vulnerability,
- 1:38:26but also never mistakes. Some unverified model out, you know, model output for, you know, for confirmed
- 1:38:33security,
- 1:38:35multiple audits from multiple people using multiple models
- 1:38:39every day. That's why this is so
- 1:38:44awful
- 1:38:46that we have to even contemplate
- 1:38:48becoming a security
- 1:38:50force.
- 1:38:54We're always used to companies doing this for themselves. Not,
- 1:38:58not for us, Pat, just passing
- 1:39:01the cost of that onto the consumer. That's what we're used to. We're not used to being part of not just one company,
- 1:39:09but all of them.
- 1:39:11And that's why this side of the river looks so much different than the other side of the river. The one that we came from
- 1:39:17because a AI is here and it widens the whole searchlight,
- 1:39:21right?
- 1:39:23Now we can still determine whether the finding is real and how to disclose it, but we're going to need
- 1:39:31help.
- 1:39:32And we're going to need to be using the same tools that are being used to tear the system down.
- 1:39:39While
- 1:39:40this episode is being recorded, the final number of Bitcoin stolen and the final number of wallet addresses,
- 1:39:47which is like, it's approaching like 2,000 Bitcoin in like 6,000 wallet addresses. By the time I finished with this, I don't know.
- 1:39:55Haven't looked
- 1:39:58vulnerable seeds are still vulnerable. You can't change that.
- 1:40:02Attackers are definitely still searching
- 1:40:05and nobody knows how many wallets remain funded.
- 1:40:08I should say affected wallets.
- 1:40:11So
- 1:40:13the takeaway is move
- 1:40:16vulnerable
- 1:40:17funds.
- 1:40:18I can't tell you where I wish I could,
- 1:40:21but I'm really shaken in everything because I for so long had recommended for to so many people like five days a week, the cold card and I was so fucking wrong about it. I can't recommend anything right now, but I can recommend that you get your vulnerable funds
- 1:40:38somewhere else.
- 1:40:41Second
- 1:40:42demand
- 1:40:43continuous
- 1:40:45security
- 1:40:46verifications,
- 1:40:48not only from the companies,
- 1:40:50but from ourselves as well.
- 1:40:53Now we need to ask our wallet manufacturers
- 1:40:57what
- 1:40:58in your organization is continuously
- 1:41:01audited.
- 1:41:02I mean, do we need to start auditing the circuit?
- 1:41:07Do we need, I mean, what about the chips involved?
- 1:41:11You know, not just the code and the firmware and all the stuff,
- 1:41:15you know, all the rest of the stuff that we don't think about, like, like literally do, should we be auditing,
- 1:41:20take a pit, like break open,
- 1:41:22like, like let's say that I, you know, all the dust is clear and I finally think it's okay to destroy my cold card. Should I rip it out of its clear case and take pictures of the circuit board front and back and send it to AI and say, can you find anything physically wrong with the way this circuit board is laid out?
- 1:41:39I don't, I don't know. I mean, I'm asking you if that may be completely stupid.
- 1:41:44I don't know, but maybe there is a vulnerability in circuit boards
- 1:41:49And that's how bad this is, right? You know, how often do you audit all your code or whatever it is that you can audit it? What tools do you use to audit your code?
- 1:42:01Who the fuck validate dates these findings and how do they validate them?
- 1:42:06Does your testing include production firmware or does it, do you use actual hardware behavior?
- 1:42:14You know, what, what do you do? And honestly,
- 1:42:18all this, is
- 1:42:20there something that's unresolved that you need to tell us about
- 1:42:24something that we need to know?
- 1:42:29You know, join the swarm. Maybe that's the, maybe the swarm is the third thing that, that I'll suggest where we do the whole thing of submitting repositories
- 1:42:38for review and funding the audits. And, you know, like, like I said, it's like, you know, we're already strapped for cash as it is. Nobody's got a lot of money right now. Let's just be honest. And that's pretty much all of the West. There's not plebs just don't have a whole lot of cash laying around.
- 1:42:54Some people do. I think most don't,
- 1:42:57but you know, how can, can you review the findings?
- 1:43:00Can you spend some time,
- 1:43:03you know, do you, are you
- 1:43:05competent enough to maybe test a potential fix,
- 1:43:10you know, build open security infrastructure,
- 1:43:13help,
- 1:43:14help the white blood cells find the disease before the attacker does. I mean, what, what can we do on our side?
- 1:43:21Can we do anything at all? Or are our hands completely tied whether or not we want to help,
- 1:43:28whether or not we do have the money to help.
- 1:43:31But the swore modded idea, I think, I don't think we can get away from not from doing that. I think we're going to have to. I don't think we have a choice.
- 1:43:40July 30
- 1:43:42was not simply the day cold card failed.
- 1:43:45It was the day that
- 1:43:47every software company lost the right
- 1:43:50to point toward an audit completed in the past and called security
- 1:43:54attackers.
- 1:43:55You know, they're just going to bring machines to the repository every single day now.
- 1:44:01And the defenders of that repository are going to have to do the same.
- 1:44:05You need to really move your funds
- 1:44:09and we also need to demand evidence of security.
- 1:44:14You know, we trusted,
- 1:44:16but we didn't verify and that shit needs to end
- 1:44:19right now. We used to be way more adversarial than we are
- 1:44:23and we need to get back to that somehow.
- 1:44:30I,
- 1:44:32heart goes out to anybody that's affected
- 1:44:35because the emotional trauma is,
- 1:44:38I don't even,
- 1:44:39there's no way to,
- 1:44:41there's no way to audit that
- 1:44:43for a single individual
- 1:44:45or everybody as a group. There's no way to even think about the fact that a lot of people who didn't lose their funds are literally losing sleep right now because they don't know if their funds are safe or not
- 1:44:57because it's this thing shook everything to the foundation,
- 1:45:01But please be aware of one thing.
- 1:45:05This was because of
- 1:45:07Rodolfo Novak
- 1:45:09and coin kite
- 1:45:11and their shitty code,
- 1:45:14their fault, their, their
- 1:45:17allowance of their firmware
- 1:45:20update to allow the cold card to fall back to a shitty number generation
- 1:45:26schema.
- 1:45:27That's
- 1:45:28why this happened.
- 1:45:31I see zero reports
- 1:45:33of any other hardware wallet manufacturer
- 1:45:36getting hacked. And you'll say, you told us about ledger. That was an email hack. That was a, and that's bad.
- 1:45:42I'm not saying it's good.
- 1:45:45The ledger,
- 1:45:46two ledger data hacks are a breach of customer confidence,
- 1:45:51no doubt,
- 1:45:52but was not, what was not breached was their actual wallet.
- 1:45:57Nobody in those two data breaches lost any of their funds.
- 1:46:02And I talk shit about, I've talked shit about ledger this entire time,
- 1:46:07you know, well at least since
- 1:46:092022
- 1:46:10I guess,
- 1:46:11but you get, you get what I'm saying.
- 1:46:16They didn't lose anybody's funds, treasure and ledger, both are shit. You know, they're shit coin wallets.
- 1:46:22Although treasure does have a Bitcoin only version, but treasure
- 1:46:26hasn't had any problems.
- 1:46:29I I'm not saying that they won't. I'm just saying that right now, as of right now,
- 1:46:35I haven't seen a report on any other hardware wallet manufacturer making this level of a fucking mistake.
- 1:46:42It's inexcusable.
- 1:46:47It's
- 1:46:49inexcusable.
- 1:46:50The whole thing is inexcusable.
- 1:46:54You know, if you want to take it out on me because I recommended a cold card and I fucked up your life,
- 1:47:01I don't blame you.
- 1:47:04You can do with me whatever you want.
- 1:47:08I don't know.
- 1:47:10I know there's a lot of like, there's a lot of people that are,
- 1:47:15now being called
- 1:47:17influencers.
- 1:47:18I'm going to take a,
- 1:47:19an example here. Marty bent
- 1:47:22and Matt Odell,
- 1:47:24they're getting fucking savage by people who I'd never thought would go after them. And here's my, my standpoint.
- 1:47:32Yes, they are investors in coin kite as part of a ten thirty one that's their sort of their venture capital arm.
- 1:47:41Yes, they are, you know,
- 1:47:44part of this whole deal.
- 1:47:46I don't think that they're bad people.
- 1:47:49I just don't. I've been, I've, I've
- 1:47:53met Matt O'Dell personally a couple of, you know, least once
- 1:47:57talked to him for a long time, you know, a bit block boom.
- 1:48:01I've listened to him and Marty on various podcasts,
- 1:48:05sometimes together, sometimes separate.
- 1:48:07I haven't found anything that, that makes me think they're malicious
- 1:48:12or, or
- 1:48:14anything like that.
- 1:48:16It doesn't mean that I'm saying that you, you need to trust them or whatever. That's, that's not what I'm getting at. I'm just getting at that. There's, there's going to be a lot of collateral damage is,
- 1:48:26is what I'm saying.
- 1:48:28A lot of reputations got burnt to Ash. And if mine is part of it, well, you know, then mine's part of it.
- 1:48:37Now I already told you the deal with cold card. Don't need to, to, you know, with, or with me trying to get a sponsorship with coin kite, I don't need to rehash it.
- 1:48:48But I've said on, on several occasions on this show over the years
- 1:48:53that it takes years to build a reputation and it takes seconds to burn it down.
- 1:48:58Sometimes that's not entirely true because for five years
- 1:49:03I was recommending a vulnerable hardware wallet.
- 1:49:07So that means it took seconds to realize that my reputation was going to be burnt to the fucking ground, but it took five years to get there.
- 1:49:16Everything,
- 1:49:17everything is,
- 1:49:19not, not exactly what it seems,
- 1:49:22but
- 1:49:24if we start
- 1:49:26chaining liability,
- 1:49:27then where does that chain of liability end?
- 1:49:31Because right now
- 1:49:33it's just on,
- 1:49:35let's say,
- 1:49:40Matt O'Dell. It's all his fault because he's part of ten thirty one and, and,
- 1:49:45ten thirty one is an investor in coin kite and coin kite lost all my money. So it's Matt O'Dell's fault too.
- 1:49:52Is it?
- 1:49:54What if your friend
- 1:49:56told you about Matt O'Dell and
- 1:49:59you started listening to Matt O'Dell because your friend
- 1:50:02told you, Hey, I trust this guy. You should listen to his podcast. He's got a, you know, he's on a couple of different podcasts, blah, blah, blah. And then you start listening to Matt O'Dell and then you go, okay, well he recommends cold card and Oh look, 1031,
- 1:50:16which is, you know, he's a co founder of is part of, of Cole. I'm going to get a cold card because I, you know, I trust, I trust this and then you get all your money is taken away from you because of the, the, the vulnerability.
- 1:50:29Is it Matt Adele's fault or is now your friend's fault, your best friend, your friend that I don't know, you went to in college and you asked to be your best man at your wedding.
- 1:50:39Is it now his fault?
- 1:50:41Is he the fucking cold cold card shill?
- 1:50:45Maybe your best friend heard about it from somebody else. Maybe his own nephew
- 1:50:50said, Hey uncle,
- 1:50:52I mean, I'm listening to these two guys and they're really funny and blah, blah, blah. Is it,
- 1:50:56is it the nephew's fault?
- 1:51:01This is why I hate what I hate the most about liability chains
- 1:51:06because nobody ever thinks to do the most simple thing
- 1:51:11to focus their energy on where it belongs.
- 1:51:14Cut the chain.
- 1:51:17There's only one person at fault here and his name is Rodolfo Novak.
- 1:51:24His shitty company
- 1:51:26allowed shitty code
- 1:51:29and it destroyed thousands of lives
- 1:51:33all at once.
- 1:51:35And it very well may be unrecoverable.
- 1:51:38There's people that are looking at the wallet address that have a address or addresses that have absconded with all the Bitcoin. It seems to be possible
- 1:51:47that the attacker accidentally linked,
- 1:51:50the attacker's identity by using a,
- 1:51:54a third party service to facilitate the attack. Even though that third party
- 1:51:59didn't really know what was going on because they, Hey, they, they offered this service where, you know, some kind of blockchain service and this guy bought it. Is it possible that
- 1:52:08identity
- 1:52:09went along for the ride
- 1:52:11because we know what we, we know what service it is. I can't, I don't know the name myself, but many people have said that we know who this is.
- 1:52:19Is it possible to find that person
- 1:52:22link them to the, you know, we know the addresses are linked.
- 1:52:26Is it possible that people could possibly get their money back from this? I don't know. I hope.
- 1:52:33I hope
- 1:52:34I'll pray for it, but
- 1:52:37that's sort of like apologizing and saying, Oh, I'm sorry.
- 1:52:41It's just words.
- 1:52:45Even if there were 24 of them,
- 1:52:48they might not mean
- 1:52:50what I would hope that they would mean.
- 1:52:53I'll see you on the other side. This has been Bitcoin. And and I'm your host, David Bennett. I hope you enjoyed today's episode and hope to see you again real soon.
- 1:53:03Have a great day.