Latest / Automotive State of The Union / OEM Programs, ASOTU CON is Coming, & Carvana Back in Illinois
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Good morning. It is Friday, May 27th. Paul is hanging out with his wife for their 20th anniversary, so I brought my good friend Matt Lasher, and we're talking some deep stuff.
- 0:13Everywhere I go, the people really wanna know, who I is and who I be. They stop and stare when they see me. All right, Matt Lasher, joining us from the car. Got his mou- got his morning coffee.
- 0:24[laughs] How are you this morning, sir? Let's go. Let's go. Morning, Kyle. Morning. [laughs] S- listen, you're the only guy I think in the industry that coulda got me on their podcast in, like, six hours notice, so.
- 0:34[laughs] I did. I'm texting him late last night, like, "Sorry for the late text. I really apologize."
- 0:40[laughs] And, uh, yeah, thanks for getting up this morning and, and getting after it, and I know that you've had some crazy- And dude, shout out to Paul. Shout out to Paul and Sarah.
- 0:47Great, amazing family, so congrats on the anniversary too, so. Yeah, really cool. And they, they've... Uh, man, I wish I could tell everyone, maybe he will next week, just everything that, that he's doing.
- 0:57Also, if for some reason they listen to it and his wife heard and, like, spilled the story, that would be bad, too.
- 1:03But, uh, y- you know, the, the ever creative genius that he is, he's, he's not skipped on, on fun, for sure. So, um, all right. Well, I wanna get into it. Just a couple of notes for those listening.
- 1:16Uh, we, uh, obviously yesterday talked about, uh, the Uvalde f- uh, v- uh, families and the victims' relief. And um, we just wanted to make sure that, uh, people still got that link. We've got it in the show notes.
- 1:30Uh, we're just encouraging people to, to reach out.
- 1:32And, you know, I, I don't wanna get too deep in, into it, but even, like, as far away as where Matt Lasher is up in the greater Northeast, there are, uh, there are other elements of this, like, circling the US, and so we don't want to lose sight that, um, uh, of the crap that's happened in, uh, in our, in our country recently from, uh, a gun violence perspective.
- 1:55So, um, yeah, just wanted to lay that in there. Also, yesterday, and Matt, you don't know this yet, but yesterday we finalized the logo, which for me, it's like, uh, once you have a logo, you have something, right?
- 2:07So we finalized the logo- We're official now. We're f-... for ASOTU CON. I know, we're super official. So we're gonna flash it up there. Uh, if you go to asotucon.com, you can actually just stay in the loop.
- 2:17It's a quick type form. The website is nothing, but you can see the logo, get energized, feel the energy around it, uh, and stay in the loop as we start to announce stuff over the next three or four weeks.
- 2:27Um, having a lot of great partner conversations around that. Uh, the big takeaway is block off September 11th to 13th, because this guy, Matt Lasher, already said he's in.
- 2:38So I double locked him down, 'cause it's live now, right? [laughs] I gotta book a, I gotta book a plane ticket still, bro. So I don't know. Anything's possible. [laughs] Yeah, right?
- 2:47Especially plane tickets these days, for sure. All right. I wanna get into it.
- 2:51I asked Matt, uh, actually, uh, earlier this week, I made a post on LinkedIn that came actually out of a conversation that happened in the Auto Genius community that both Matt and, and I are a part of.
- 3:02Uh, and, uh, it was this sentiment around the fact that OEM programs, so if you understand, like, the marketing spectrum of, of tier three automotive, is there are, um, there are OEM programs, so you know, your Fords, your Mazdas, your, your Subarus, your Stellantis, all of that, put in place programs which either require or he- heavily recommend based on reimbursed funds, uh, exactly what products and services you should use.
- 3:30And, and there's this growing sentiment that it's continuing to stifle innovation. And, um, Matt, I...
- 3:36He and I have talked about this before, and I've seen you talk about this on, uh, in other spaces, on LinkedIn, on podcasts.
- 3:42And I, I just, I think you have a really, um, interesting perspective on exactly what stifling innovation when you, when you grow at scale, right? And you connect it back to the dealership a lot.
- 3:55Um, so tell me a little bit about, like, where you've seen that start to stifle innovation, these, like, mandated or locked in technologies or programs. Well, dude, just to, like, a little bit of a setup.
- 4:06So I worked at Nissan North America for a minute, uh, five years early in my career. I spent about 15 years in retail at West Herr.
- 4:12So I've seen sort of both sides, um, of, of the viewpoint in terms of, um, how innovative, how fancy, how, how, uh, customer focused our business entities.
- 4:23Often there, it comes from a place of misunderstanding the other side- Sure... I think. Um, I, so I guess I would start with, I think OEM initiatives are well-intended. Yeah. Um, I do think that they get sometimes, uh,
- 4:36bad advice by the people helping them execute, because the people helping them execute have most to gain. Mm. Um, so I don't need to call out the intermediaries- [laughs]... specifically here.
- 4:49Uh, but y- I think you guys know who I might be talking about. Um, you know, and I think also it comes from a tendency as managers, this is a human tendency, as managers, we tend to focus on the negative.
- 5:02So as an OEM, they're looking at their dealer network, right? And if you go back far enough, dealers were like, "I don't want a website. I'm good." Right. Like, "I don't need one," you know?
- 5:10'99, 2000, people were like, "Whatever." Like, "I don't... I, what do I need a website for? I sell cars. Like, people are gonna come to my dealership." So that was, like, the prevailing thought, right?
- 5:20And so, like, as websites gained momentum, it's a spectrum. Some dealers hop right on, right? And West Herr was an early innovator with a self-built website. So shout out to Kevin Lee- There you go...
- 5:32um, at Auction Simplified. He, he, he was in our camp, uh, that really made our group site from the beginning. A long time ago, westerr.com represented 90% of our total traffic.
- 5:44But then the OEMs got really demanding about- Interesting... their own websites, right? Yep. And so here came some of these mandated programs that I think you're referencing, right?
- 5:53And, um, for West Herr to be a good corporate partner, we have to support these programs, right? For sure. In the end, it-There's good and there's pros and cons, right?
- 6:03Um, where I think they brought the whole dealer network up to a certain level, right? So they probably addressed the most underperforming dealers. Well, that's- The dealers that- I, I talk about that a lot.
- 6:14It's, it, it is. There's this, like, recognition that there is a wide, uh, spectrum of attention to technology, um, understanding of new processes, new things out there, and adoption curves, right?
- 6:28So I do think that the- you're right, that there's an element of any programmatic elem- thing that says, "Hey, we're just gonna, like, streamline this so that everybody's singing off the same song sheet," which I think is the well-intentioned part that you're talking about.
- 6:43And, and they have brand standards that they're trying to protect against. You go- Sure... even further back, 30, 40 years, manufacturers had a problem with dealers not updating their signage, right? Right.
- 6:51And so you would see, like, a super old, like, Ford logo or Chevy logo or Nissan logo or something, and the manufacturer...
- 6:58That would, like, drive the manufacturers nuts, 'cause they're trying to, like, innovate themselves, right? So they're trying to, like, push the image forward. Yeah.
- 7:05So I think a lot of the, the standards came from, you know, these brand standards, advertising desires, as well as bringing up the bottom. Um, you know, but it, I think there's an interesting, um...
- 7:16So we were talking about this before, Kyle, but we were saying the larger than or- an organization or a tribe gets, I think the harder it becomes to innovate.
- 7:24And often at the top of the leadership food chain, uh, we come up with these ideas. We're like, "This is the thing," right?
- 7:32And the more central the idea, the more, the more focused it is, the actually worse it sort of spills out into the network, I think. Mm. The more unintended consequence there is, right? So- Yep...
- 7:44so what we're seeing a little bit, just fast-forwarding to, like, audio, o- OEM websites today, I think, is this constriction of vendors, right? So you have just... Take Western, for example. We have 35 stores.
- 7:55We have 22 brands or something that we represent.
- 7:59Um, if you look at all the brands that we represent and then compare it to all the required web- website providers that we're allowed to use for our websites, there's really only about two or three companies in the whole- Right...
- 8:12country that can service all of our child site websites. Yep. Okay? So o- obviously western.com is a free agent, could be on whatever platform that it decides to be.
- 8:22But all of our other storewe- we have pr- like 40 websites, right? Yep. And they have to be managed within just a handful of companies.
- 8:30Now, what that creates, especially in this industry with regional consolidation of websites and, and, uh, dealer groups as a whole, dealership groups are getting bigger and more dense, like Western is.
- 8:42And as a result, you have this desire to have a centralized customer experience or a consistent customer experience. Yes. And so, like, that's where some of, I think, the innovation that, like, dealerships maybe seek.
- 8:55Um, you know, I, I don't care what website they're on with Western necessarily. I would love for whatever vehicles Kyle's looking at on all of my websites to be, you know, in sync and, you know- Yes...
- 9:06similar customer experience, similar conversion flow. How in the world, um, is a dealership supposed to A/B test
- 9:1410, 15, 20 different variants of websites when the manufacturers themselves have trouble just A/B, A/B testing one website? Yeah. Right? This is right. So it's fascinating.
- 9:25But, but I think the unintended consequence to these mandated OEM programs is this: vendors have a scale problem. Yeah.
- 9:32So vendors want the business, right, but then they bolt on 700 Ford dealers or whatever, and then now they, like, are overwhelmed by questions or, like, "How do I update this thing?" Or, like- Well, so you-...
- 9:45some dynamic-... you come into, you come into two issues. You come into support issues, right? So it's harder to support.
- 9:51And then the other issue is you come into it's harder to innovate because you have a fixed program that's in so many places that you can't actually become change agents for all of those places.
- 10:02So, and then you took this to the... I, I really wanna get to the place where it's like Western experiences this when you change- Yeah...
- 10:10a process or a technology or anything that's implemented group-wide, where you actually have- Yeah. Well, look, we need empathy, right? Right.
- 10:18Like, so in our industry, this is happening all the time with all the fancy marketers in, in our world, right? [laughs] Like, we gotta deploy empathy in terms of what's really happening. Yep.
- 10:27Sometimes change is as a result of organizational structure limitations or whatever. So Western, I have two really quick examples. One is about used car photos.
- 10:37So our leadership team wanted to get a centralized look to how the first photo on the website is, okay? That led us down the path of photo booths. Mm-hmm.
- 10:48Now, I was the one executive in the team that was like, "We shouldn't do photo booths because it's gonna generic everything," and, like, "Cars are outside.
- 10:56Let, let's make them lovely and realistic and emotive and whatever," right? Yes. So I was coming at it from an art side.
- 11:02But, you know, our team decided collectively, and I got on board with this, that we wanted the first photo to be the same, okay? Yep. So we invested hundreds of thousands of dollars in 10 photo, 360 photo booths.
- 11:14Um, shout out to Jay, whatever. The product's pretty good. Yep. 360 booth. Um, but here's what we did. There it is. Yeah. Yeah. We brought the bottom up, but we brought the top down. Mm.
- 11:24So we got, we got less innovative in photos by our attempt to manage consistency, right? Got it. Yep. So if you go to western.com now today, and I encourage you guys to, to do that. Shout out Dealer Inspire.
- 11:37Thank you for helping us with our website. But, um, our top most expensive cars, we've deployed a very talented artist. His name's Colin Gray.
- 11:46He's, he takes super, super cool and very unique pictures of every car over, well, we're g- we're aspiring to, every car over $100,000. Now, we have maybe 30 or 40 carsRight now in that bucket.
- 12:02But, you know, if look- you're looking at a $700,000 car, I don't want that to get the same treatment as, like, the f- $20,000 Corolla, right? Right. Yeah. So we've deployed some art into- Wow... our process.
- 12:18I'm looking at it right now. So we broke the bottom- And if, if, if you're not near a computer and y- it's, it takes and puts these cars actually in innovative spaces across the city it looks like, right?
- 12:28So it's like, it's, it's not just, it's not just art, it's also connection to community. So that's really interesting that you've taken this approach of...
- 12:37And I think that, you know, uh, we've had conversations in this marketer community of what if the approach was taking that top tier, especially in marketing and technology, the ones that really understand it, maybe the consolidated groups or the really innovated single roof- innovative single rooftops, and gave them some freedom to go, "Oh, you really understand what's up next.
- 12:59You really are looking over the horizon. Maybe there's some freedom for you that you can, like, push the boundaries," right?
- 13:06And I think that actually utilizing the approach that you've done just on something that seems simple on photos and going, "Hey, there is a top percent that need to be given freedom to actually push the OEMs, push the industry forward," right?
- 13:19Because or else we're all just gonna be kinda sitting in five years ago. And I think that that could be a really interesting approach to the OEMs to say, "Hey, look, we realize we gotta bring the bottom up.
- 13:30There needs to be c- some consistency in branding, but there may be some level of access for the most innovative, the most technological savvy, the most forward-thinking that puts us actually, like, five years in the future."
- 13:43And that, that, that, that level of empathy.
- 13:46I wanna get to one more story only because I th- I, I heard you say this word empathy, and I think it's really clear to me right now that there's not a lot of empathy for some of the conglomerates, one being Carvana.
- 13:58You know, recently... And I, I'd love to get your take on this, but recently Carvana was kind of pulled out of Illinois.
- 14:04Well, it was just announced, uh, that they get to go back into Illinois with a bunch of stipulations. Uh, but the main thing that they were dealing with was titles and registrations.
- 14:14Now, I don't know how West Herr is doing, um, but I've heard multiple stories across the industry that because of, uh, shortages in departments of transportations, accelerated vehicle sales, uh, you know, m- movement of vehicles from wh- wholesale purchases and private purchases, that titles and registrations are issues, not just for the large companies, but also for, uh, the local companies.
- 14:37And, um, I, I think a bit of empathy around that is probably necessary. I don't know what your experience is with that recently. So, so first off, this is a human condition. We like to see our heroes fall. Right.
- 14:48And, and, and, and, and so, like, I think there was some jealousy of Carvana's success, um, amongst many in the industry, right?
- 14:56And so when their stock price collapses and they get pulled out of Illinois or whatever, like, the, people are, like, celebrating the fallen hero, right?
- 15:04And, you know, hopefully we can celebrate their r- their rise from their struggles, but no doubt. And we only operate in New York State, so I can't comment to, like, any of the other states. Sure.
- 15:13I have no idea about titling and paperwork there. Outside-- We use Jupiter Tag and Title for, like, out-of-state sales.
- 15:19But, um, in New York State, there is a electronic process that's been reasonably well-adopted, I think, by most of our title teams. So- Gotcha...
- 15:27um, i- in, in that sense, um, you know, I don't really have enough perspective on, on the Illinois thing specifically, but, but you're right, dude. Like, like, lots of things take, take time.
- 15:37I remodeled my bathroom in my house, and I'm still- [laughs]... waiting on the shower glass. [laughs] Right. I did this three months ago. I'm like... You know what I'm saying?
- 15:44Like, things are, things are different right now. Yeah. Supply chains got impacted. People's lives got impacted. So, you know, I think we should never judge, right? We should seek to understand.
- 15:54We can disagree, and I think we should try to find healthy ways to disagree because that's gonna move us all forward, you know? But this idea of innovating, right? There's no one-size-fits-all.
- 16:04There's no, like, unified answer. There's no exact way. I love your idea of, like, trying to tap into some trusted dealers to, like, innovate and try. Right.
- 16:13Um, you know, and there's an executional problem of like, okay, cool, we came up with this good idea for this dealer. How do, like, more dealers in the network- Scale that... take advantage of it? Sure. Right? Yep.
- 16:24Um, which is ch- you know, there's a lot of challenge in all of that. Um, but, but you know what? We're, we're so blessed to be in the industry, um, you know- Yeah... and be a part of it.
- 16:32It's such a dynamic industry with a lot of really intelligent people on every side, tech side, dealer side, uh, OEM side.
- 16:39So I, I think it's really just about us enjoying the, the ride and, and trying to piece it together. And by the way, dealers get a lot of shit for not being that innovative.
- 16:48But my experience with other businesses and other verticals, dealerships are pretty damn innovative. That's, uh, that's- We are pretty good-... absolutely right. [laughs] You are kidding.
- 16:56We're pretty good at responding to leads. We're pretty good at being customer service oriented, servant leaders, philanthropic businesses in the community. Like, dealerships do a ton, a ton, a ton of good.
- 17:08And sometimes I think we like to hate on them a little bit just because, you know, we're doing all the marketing things. You know, we're doing the fancy retargeting. We're doing the, you know, all the stuff.
- 17:17Um, and could it be better? Of course. But every business could be better. Absolutely. Every person, human being could be better. Yeah, no, I, I completely agree.
- 17:26I think actually over the last two years, we've seen dealerships being, uh, being the most innovative, the most forward-thinking, the most groundbreaking in retail in a lot of spaces just because we were always open.
- 17:38We had no choice. We had to figure things out. And, uh, so I...
- 17:41Like, don't skip on, on sales people and, uh, and, and variable ops and fixed ops and accounting teams that have completely flexed and made new processes, uh, innovated in technology alongside industry partners over the last two years.
- 17:57Um, I'm not counting dealers out for sure over the next- No... five to seven years. Bro, I gotta say this. Related to innovation, it's often equated to technology, okay? I'm a believer in the people, okay?
- 18:09And I'm never gonna change that tune. Yes. All the people, the 2,600 employees that we have at West Herr, team West shout out. Let's go. It's not about the technology.
- 18:18Technology can help the people do things better, but people are the true innovation. People are the ones that are gonna continue to go.
- 18:26If dealers fail to recognize that point, they will be replaced with direct-to-consumer sales processes and kiosks, okay?
- 18:34So dealers need to embrace the idea that the people that they employ and work within the building are their most valuable asset and always will be. That's what we do. We're a people business. Look,
- 18:48I couldn't have said it any better myself. The technology and the processes shou- shou- should serve the people, not the other way around. Matt, thank you for joining us today. It's been an absolute pleasure.
- 18:58Enjoy your Memorial Day weekend. [upbeat music]