Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Healthcare, Homicide, and the Scales of Justice in Canada
Transcript
- 0:00Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan, though joining us now Barrister and Solicitor with Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 0:03Adam Stirling: Morning, michael, how we doing, hey, good morning, I'm doing great.
- 0:07Adam Stirling: Always good to be here.
- 0:07Adam Stirling: Always exciting things happening.
- 0:10Adam Stirling: I see doctors mentioned at the top of our list today regarding things, a reason we don't have enough doctors being litigated rather than fixed.
- 0:19Adam Stirling: What's happening out there.
- 0:21Michael Mulligan: This is a very interesting piece of litigation and I must say there's a half page of lawyers working on it, and the case has been brought by an organization called the Society for Canadians Studying Medicine Abroad, as well as two individuals who graduated from medical school outside of Canada or the United States and who are trying to get residency positions in British Columbia.
- 0:47Michael Mulligan: And a residency position would be like the practical training that a doctor would get after they graduate from medical school as a requirement to then actually become a doctor.
- 0:58Michael Mulligan: It'd be the rough equivalent of people are familiar with how it works for lawyers Perspective lawyer would need to complete law school and then they would need to go in article for a year, like work with a senior lawyer to get practical experience and sort of hands-on training before they'd be released on the world, and so practical training is a very good idea.
- 1:18Michael Mulligan: However, in British Columbia, what is developed is what is described as two separate streams of getting matched for a residency position.
- 1:30Michael Mulligan: Now I should first of all pause to say that concept of matching with sort of a decision you're going to this hospital, you're going to this place to get your residency training is different from how it would work for lawyers.
- 1:44Michael Mulligan: For example, if somebody's graduated from law school, they are free to go and apply to whatever law firm or senior lawyer or government or whatever it might be, to find somebody who's prepared to take them on for that year of article With medical training.
- 1:58Michael Mulligan: There is a process in place which assigns prospective doctors to these positions, and what's developed in British Columbia are that there are two streams a domestic stream, which includes people that have graduated from Canadian or US universities so domestic is a bit misleading and then there's an international medical school stream people that might have gone to medical school in Australia, new Zealand or the UK or France or whatever it might be, and what's happened is that that second stream for the international students has very few positions and it means that the vast majority of people who graduate elsewhere and want to do their residency in British Columbia cannot get positions and so they cannot become doctors.
- 2:46Michael Mulligan: We have people who want to come here, who have completed medical school, that want to go on and do their residency here and can't, and so this is a legal challenge to that state of affairs, and this is why you know at the outset, it's sort of unfortunate that we have a team of lawyers for all these different organizations fighting about this in court, rather than the more obvious solution, which would be stop doing this.
- 3:13Michael Mulligan: We need doctors.
- 3:15Michael Mulligan: If you have somebody who's graduated from a school that would provide that requisite training, get them a position, for heaven's sake, so that we can get the number of doctors that we need.
- 3:27Michael Mulligan: But that's not what we're doing.
- 3:28Michael Mulligan: We're litigating it, and the litigation is being brought on two grounds.
- 3:34Michael Mulligan: One is an administrative law ground, arguing that this government decision is unreasonable.
- 3:40Michael Mulligan: This is to say, separate these people into these two quote streams where there is nothing at the end of one of the streams that's kind of dry, and arguing that's just unreasonable.
- 3:51Michael Mulligan: And then the second part of the challenge is a charter challenge, saying this is unconstitutional.
- 3:56Michael Mulligan: Now the here's how that works.
- 4:01Michael Mulligan: So both of those have a potential limitation and that's what this decision that just came out is about.
- 4:07Michael Mulligan: So that's part of an interim decision as part of that litigation, and the Society for the Canadian Studying Medicine abroad and these two individuals brought this claim against a whole list of people, which is not uncommon in the world of civil litigation, like the College of Physicians and Surgeons and the Ministry of Health for British Columbia and the University of British Columbia.
- 4:30Michael Mulligan: But also they brought the claim against a couple of entities, including a thing called the Canadian Resident Matching Service.
- 4:37Michael Mulligan: That's sort of a non-governmental thing that does this matching process.
- 4:42Michael Mulligan: That has these two streams in it.
- 4:44Michael Mulligan: And so this particular piece of this litigation was that organization, the Canadian Resident Matching Service, and another thing, the Association of Faculties of Medicine of Canada, arguing that they can't be sued in these two ways.
- 5:03Michael Mulligan: And the basis for their claim, first of all, was on the administrative law grounds, arguing this was just an unreasonable decision.
- 5:10Michael Mulligan: There's no basis for dividing people in this way and preventing people from getting the training.
- 5:15Michael Mulligan: That kind of a claim for a judicial review or request for a judicial review on reasonableness grounds can only be brought against a sort of for public decisions like government decisions.
- 5:28Michael Mulligan: You know, if, let's say, walmart unreasonably refuses to let you return something, you can't do a judicial review of their decision not to let you return your plastic tub or something.
- 5:38Michael Mulligan: That's not a government decision.
- 5:40Michael Mulligan: That just may be unreasonable at all, but courts don't wait into that.
- 5:45Michael Mulligan: So those entities argued well, this wasn't really government decisions.
- 5:49Michael Mulligan: And they also argued we don't really make the decisions, we're just implementing them right.
- 5:55Michael Mulligan: These other entities have told us what to do in terms of creating the two streams one with water and one without and so we're just doing that.
- 6:02Michael Mulligan: You know, we're putting in people's preferences for where they might want to live and work and that kind of thing, and what positions are there?
- 6:06Michael Mulligan: We don't decide, so we shouldn't be part of this litigation.
- 6:12Michael Mulligan: And then the other argument is and this is an important thing to know constitutional rights only attached to things the government is doing.
- 6:20Michael Mulligan: You can't make a constitutional charter claim against Walmart when they don't take back your crappy plastic tub.
- 6:28Michael Mulligan: That's not a government entity, right?
- 6:29Michael Mulligan: And so they're saying well, you know, not only do we not decide this, but we're also not really a government entity.
- 6:36Michael Mulligan: We're just kind of carrying out this function and on those grounds that succeeded.
- 6:43Michael Mulligan: And so this litigation will go on against all the other groups rather than just addressing the fundamental problem.
- 6:50Michael Mulligan: Instead, the College of Physicians and Surgeons and Ministry of Health, the University of British Columbia and the other remaining entities are going to fight about this in court, which I don't know.
- 7:01Michael Mulligan: That's the best response to it all those entities that just do it and don't really decide, even though one of them had some role in consulting with the government about these streams aren't going to be part of it because they don't really decide and they're not a government entity and so they can't be subject to charter scrutiny.
- 7:21Michael Mulligan: The other thing decided at this stage is that those two claims the unreasonableness claim on administrative log grounds and the charter arguments are going to be dealt with separately and the court is going to first address the reasonableness claims.
- 7:36Michael Mulligan: Is it reasonable to create these two streams?
- 7:38Michael Mulligan: And then that might answer the whole case right.
- 7:42Michael Mulligan: If the answer to that is no, then we don't have to get into the constitutional argument.
- 7:46Michael Mulligan: If the argument is yes, that is a decision within the realm of the reasonable, then you could move on to the constitutional argument.
- 7:53Michael Mulligan: I must say the reasonableness part has a lot of merit to it, at least to my eye reading this.
- 7:59Michael Mulligan: I must say I smiled a little bit reading about the various constitutional claims.
- 8:06Michael Mulligan: One of the other interesting elements of all this is that for people who are in the domestic stream, people who went to law school or to medical school in the United States or Canada, when they get matched up, do their residency, they're free to go work anywhere they want.
- 8:20Michael Mulligan: And that's an interesting thing and that's a challenge because, of course, many people would like to be a doctor in the west side of Vancouver, for example, as opposed to, maybe, prince George.
- 8:31Michael Mulligan: People like the weather, or they want to go golfing, or their family lives there, whatever it might be right.
- 8:36Michael Mulligan: And so we allow doctors to basically go anywhere they want and set up.
- 8:41Michael Mulligan: That's an interesting question about whether that's good public policy or not.
- 8:45Michael Mulligan: But for people who are in the international stream, which also happens to be dry, if you do get somehow down the river, they require anyone who does go through that stream, even though the people are Canadian citizens and they might have gone to medical school in, you know Australia rather than you know California, the.
- 9:04Michael Mulligan: They also require them to sign an agreement that, if they do their residency here, they managed to get up the dry stream.
- 9:11Michael Mulligan: They have to enter into a return of service contract which permit, which compels them to go and set up for a number of years working in a location that the ministry minister of health tells them to go and work it.
- 9:25Michael Mulligan: And so on one level you might say, well, that's sort of you know, that's maybe, maybe that's good If the government can direct somebody.
- 9:31Michael Mulligan: Hey, we need a doctor in Nanaimo where we need somebody in Prince George or whatever it might be, rather than letting you know that's how we hire people for every other kind of job in the world.
- 9:40Michael Mulligan: You don't just kind of say, hey, you want a job you know doing whatever, feel free to go anywhere you want to do.
- 9:47Michael Mulligan: That's not generally how the government contracts for things.
- 9:51Michael Mulligan: You wouldn't say you've got a contract to fix roads, go do that anywhere you like, right.
- 9:56Michael Mulligan: You would be like, hey, we need roads here or we need this fixed there, and not just go anywhere you want.
- 10:01Michael Mulligan: So maybe that's a good idea, maybe it isn't, but the argument here is that these two quote streams are treated differently.
- 10:09Michael Mulligan: This is what caused me to smile.
- 10:11Michael Mulligan: There are various arguments constitutional arguments being proposed about that not being constitutionally permissible under the charter.
- 10:19Michael Mulligan: One of them that caused me to smile was an argument that that requirement to go and work in a smaller community, somewhere where the government requires you, they are arguing, would be cruel and unusual punishment under the charter.
- 10:33Michael Mulligan: Wow, that strikes me as that seems like a bit of a stretch.
- 10:36Michael Mulligan: But you know, you never know.
- 10:37Michael Mulligan: I'm not sure that many people in smaller communities would take kindly upon the suggestion that being required to work there for a period of time would amount to cruel and unusual punishment.
- 10:50Michael Mulligan: But the overall impression of all of this mess is that every dollar in every minute we are spending in court arguing about this stuff is a dollar in a minute lost, and we ought to sort this out.
- 11:01Michael Mulligan: If we've got Canadians who went to medical school somewhere else and it was qualified medical school and they want to come back here and practice, for having the sakes, put some water in the stream or get rid of the second one, get them into a residency and get them out working.
- 11:15Michael Mulligan: Having them sitting in court litigating this thing is a total, absolute waste of time.
- 11:21Michael Mulligan: And so that's what's going on.
- 11:23Michael Mulligan: It's continuing.
- 11:23Michael Mulligan: Hopefully somebody will look at this and just fix it rather than continuing to fight about it, but that's what we're doing.
- 11:30Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan, with Mulligan Defense Lawyers, legally speaking will continue right after this commercial break.
- 11:34Adam Stirling: All right, legally speaking continues here on CFAQs1070.
- 11:37Adam Stirling: Michael for our next story sentencing.
- 11:40Adam Stirling: It says here after a jury acquits of murder but convicts a mother of manslaughter, what happened A?
- 11:48Michael Mulligan: tragedy.
- 11:48Michael Mulligan: So this case is a case of a Port Elberni and it was a mother who was charged with the second degree murder of her adult son, and the essential fact pattern was that the it sounds like a troubled household.
- 12:05Michael Mulligan: They lived together in Port Elberni.
- 12:06Michael Mulligan: It sounds like both mother and son had some mental health challenges and the son was very intoxicated.
- 12:12Michael Mulligan: The son came running at the mother who was holding a rifle, that much was agreed and the son wound up being shot and died.
- 12:27Michael Mulligan: So a tragedy by any account.
- 12:32Michael Mulligan: Now there are several things wrapped up in that that are, I think, of interest.
- 12:35Michael Mulligan: First of all, there's a jury trial, as is the Norman murder cases, and the jury was charged properly on a concept of what's called a lesser included offense.
- 12:48Michael Mulligan: And what a lesser included offense is is that it's an offense that you must necessarily have committed in order to commit a more serious offense, right.
- 12:57Michael Mulligan: So that's what would make something a lesser included offense.
- 13:00Michael Mulligan: And on this fact pattern, one of the lesser included offenses was the offense of manslaughter, and the significant one of the primary differences between a charge of murder and one of manslaughter is that to be guilty of murder, a person must have intentionally killed somebody else or intentionally caused serious bodily harm they know is likely to result in death, whereas for manslaughter, if you simply engage in some unlawful activity and it has the effect of resulting in death, there are a couple of other technical requirements, but that's the essence of it.
- 13:34Michael Mulligan: But intentionally killing the other person, you can be guilty of manslaughter.
- 13:38Michael Mulligan: And so the jury was told about all the elements of murder and told about the elements of manslaughter, and the jury deliberated and eventually came back and found the mother not guilty of murder but instead guilty of that lesser included offense of manslaughter, something open to them.
- 13:55Michael Mulligan: Now, that's the concept of lesser included offense.
- 14:00Michael Mulligan: Now, the next thing that's of interest here is that in Canada, juries don't sentence somebody.
- 14:06Michael Mulligan: That's a job for the judge.
- 14:08Michael Mulligan: And so when you have a jury find somebody not guilty of the offense charge but instead guilty of, in this case, a lesser included offense, then the question becomes how should the judge sentence a person?
- 14:20Michael Mulligan: And that's interesting because of course the jury doesn't give reasons for their decision, right?
- 14:27Michael Mulligan: In fact, what's talked about in a jury deliberation is private and it's an offense to reveal what was talked about.
- 14:34Michael Mulligan: And so the jury doesn't come back and say well, we found that the unlawful thing here was this, and this is why we found you're guilty of manslaughter and not murder, right?
- 14:43Michael Mulligan: It doesn't do that, it just comes back in with a verdict.
- 14:47Michael Mulligan: And so for the to send over to the judge about well, what do you do to sentence the person?
- 14:54Michael Mulligan: And the first principle and this is something the Supreme Court of Canada set out a number of years ago in case of Ferguson is that the judges first of all bound to accept the factual implications of the jury's verdict.
- 15:09Michael Mulligan: And so, for example, the fact that the jury found the mother not guilty of murder, right, necessarily means the jury concluded she didn't intentionally shoot her son, right?
- 15:20Michael Mulligan: So it would not be appropriate for the judge to say well, the jury convicted of manslaughter, but still I think she did this intentionally and so therefore, I'm sentencing you to life in prison.
- 15:30Michael Mulligan: That's an available sentence for manslaughter, right, but would be completely incompatible with what the jury found.
- 15:36Michael Mulligan: And so a judge is not allowed to do that.
- 15:39Michael Mulligan: They have to sentence a person accepting facts that are implied by what the jury found to have occurred, and then, if it's ambiguous, like we just can't tell, how did the jury come to this conclusion?
- 15:52Michael Mulligan: Did they come to the conclusion that she shot him not intending to kill him, like was trying to shoot him in the foot or something, or what could the lawful act have been in this case?
- 16:04Michael Mulligan: Careless use of a firearm.
- 16:06Michael Mulligan: On that front, both the Crown of the Defense agreed here that in part because of a question the jury asked before coming to their verdict, and they asked a question about a reasonable person quote test when determining whether the handling of the firearm was objectively dangerous.
- 16:27Michael Mulligan: That that question indicated that the jury was coming to its decision based on a finding that the mother had handled the firearm in an unsafe way and that resulted in the son's death.
- 16:40Michael Mulligan: And on that front there seemed to be lots of evidence for it.
- 16:43Michael Mulligan: The firearm was loaded, there wasn't a trigger lock on it.
- 16:47Michael Mulligan: She was handing on her evidence, she was handing it back to him and he bumped into her, causing the gun to go off.
- 16:53Michael Mulligan: Well, if you're handling a firearm safely, you have to assume it's loaded.
- 16:57Michael Mulligan: You don't hand somebody a gun that's loaded, kind of pointing to the point.
- 17:00Michael Mulligan: You just don't do that.
- 17:01Michael Mulligan: You don't store it again loaded, you have a trigger lock on it.
- 17:05Michael Mulligan: There's all sorts of things about this which would be just unsafe, and so the judge would look.
- 17:11Michael Mulligan: The jury must have come to its decision on the basis that she was unsafely handling this firearm and when they collided when the intoxicated son collided with the mother the gun went off, and so that must be how the jury came to his verdict, and so the judge has to respect that when deciding what the appropriate sentence is.
- 17:33Michael Mulligan: It's also another thing to note is that in Canada, the manslaughter doesn't usually have a mandatory minimum sentence, but it does when it's a manslaughter that's a result of a firearm, and the mandatory minimum sentence is four years in prison.
- 17:52Michael Mulligan: And so, even though in this case the there were lots of mitigating factors, the mother had no previous history, there was lots of factors, including her mental health and the son's mental health and all of what went into this, and there was no reason to think she was going to be some danger in the future to anyone, right?
- 18:10Michael Mulligan: She was in her sixties and never had done anything before in her life and didn't own firearms herself was the son's firearm.
- 18:17Michael Mulligan: Her evidence was she was trying to give it back to him, but nonetheless, the mandatory minimum sentence is four years in the penitentiary, and so that is what she's been sentenced to.
- 18:26Michael Mulligan: So I thought it was an interesting case, both in terms of that lesser included offense what a judge has to do when a jury makes a decision and then that final element, which is the mandatory minimum and what it meant in this case, because you know when you come up with these things you have in mind.
- 18:43Michael Mulligan: To say mandatory minimums, I think most people would have had in mind some you know gang fight or something, not a collision with a mother by a large impaired son where the gun goes off, but nonetheless, that's what we've got and that's what the mother's been sentenced to four years in penitentiary.
- 19:01Adam Stirling: All right, we've got three minutes left.
- 19:02Adam Stirling: Can we do the last one?
- 19:03Adam Stirling: I?
- 19:05Michael Mulligan: think we can, all right, shall we?
- 19:06Michael Mulligan: So the last case involves a concept of security for cost.
- 19:10Michael Mulligan: I think we've touched on that before.
- 19:12Michael Mulligan: The concept of security for cost is that if you're suing something, the starting point is, if you sue somebody and you sue them unsuccessfully, you may be required to pay part of their legal costs.
- 19:23Michael Mulligan: We have that to deter people from just willy-nilly suing people and causing lots of expense and dislocation.
- 19:29Michael Mulligan: The flip side also applies.
- 19:31Michael Mulligan: If somebody sues you and they've got a good claim and you nonetheless refuse to pay it and go to court, spend a bunch of time flailing about and ultimately lose, you've got to pay part of their legal costs.
- 19:42Michael Mulligan: So that whole system is set up to try to incentivize people to act reasonably and not waste time and money.
- 19:47Michael Mulligan: It's a good system.
- 19:48Michael Mulligan: Now, one of the issues that can arise is and this comes up in this case which is what if you're being sued by a company that has no money?
- 19:57Michael Mulligan: Right, that whole incentive kind of goes away, right?
- 20:02Adam Stirling: Yeah.
- 20:03Michael Mulligan: If they can't pay, then can you just create some company and sue away with no jeopardy.
- 20:08Michael Mulligan: Well, we wouldn't want that.
- 20:10Michael Mulligan: And so we have a provision for the security for costs, which could be an application made to say, hey, I want an order that the person put the potential legal costs in account with the court, so if they lose there'll be money there and it won't just be.
- 20:26Michael Mulligan: Well, I just litigated away for two months, lost, and then, too bad, I folded up my company and the Court is reluctant to do that but can do it with like an individual, like a person who's suing, when they don't have money.
- 20:40Michael Mulligan: But there's, you know there's some downsides to that If it means that if you don't have money you can't sue somebody.
- 20:46Michael Mulligan: We don't want that state of affairs, right.
- 20:48Michael Mulligan: So courts are very reluctant to do that with individuals, but not as much with companies, and so the law reflects that.
- 20:55Michael Mulligan: And essentially the way it works is, if you're being sued by a company and you can make out a prima facie case that the company won't be able to pay, if they sue you and lose, then the burden would shift over to the corporate entity to show that, yes, indeed, they do have assets, so that if they lost, they could be compelled to pay the court costs of the other side right, or the more than the court costs.
- 21:18Michael Mulligan: It's a portion of the legal expenses, and so in the case it was just decided, that is what was applied, and the company didn't seem to have much.
- 21:27Michael Mulligan: It was a new company, it had some assets, but nonetheless, the judge ordered that the money be put into deposited with the courts.
- 21:36Michael Mulligan: With the company lost, there'd be something to recover from, and so that's what security for cost is, and that's why it's different when the other side is a company as opposed to just a regular person.
- 21:47Adam Stirling: All right, michael Mulligan, with Mulligan Defense Lawyers, legally speaking, during the second half of our second hour every Thursday.
- 21:52Adam Stirling: Pleasure is always.
- 21:53Adam Stirling: Thank you so much.
- 21:55Adam Stirling: Have a great day, all right.