Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / The Meeting That Should Have Been an Email
Transcript
- Lucas: So I want to start with a number that's been sticking with me. In a 2025 survey of knowledge workers, the average manager spent 23 hours a week in meetings. That's more than half their working time. And when asked what percentage of those meetings could have been an email or an async update, the median answer was 41 percent. Luna: Forty-one percent. That means nearly ten hours a week of sitting in a room — or a Zoom — that nobody really needed to be in. That's brutal. Lucas: It's a productivity sink, but it's also a morale drain. When people feel like their time isn't respected, engagement drops. And here's the thing — managers are often the ones scheduling these meetings, so it's a self-inflicted wound. Luna: I think part of the problem is that meetings feel productive. You're talking, you're moving things forward, you feel busy. But the actual output — the decisions, the action items — could often be handled in a fraction of the time. Lucas: Exactly. There's a great case study from a company called Pipedrive — the sales CRM platform. In early 2024, they implemented a policy called 'two decision-makers max' for any recurring meeting. If you couldn't name exactly two people whose input was required, the meeting got cancelled or converted to async. Luna: Two decision-makers max. That's a really sharp rule. How did it play out? Lucas: They tracked it for six months. Total meeting hours dropped by 40 percent. And more importantly, project velocity increased — because decisions weren't bottlenecked by scheduling conflicts. They also found that the meetings that survived were shorter and more focused. Luna: So the quality of the meetings that remained actually went up. That's the dream scenario. Lucas: Right. But a lot of managers push back on this idea. They say, 'But I need to keep my team aligned,' or 'I need to see everyone's faces to know they're engaged.' And I get that instinct — especially post-pandemic, when hybrid teams can feel disconnected. Luna: But is the meeting actually achieving that alignment? Or is it just a habit? I've definitely been in weekly team meetings where the first twenty minutes are a status round that could have been a shared document. Lucas: That's exactly the kind of meeting that should be an async update. A shared doc, a Loom video, a Slack thread — you can review it on your own time, and then the actual meeting is reserved for discussing exceptions or making decisions on the things that came up. Luna: I think there's also a psychological component. A lot of managers feel like they're not leading if they're not calling meetings. It's a visible sign of authority. But the best leaders I've worked with are the ones who protect their team's time. Lucas: 100 percent. There's a concept called 'meeting debt' — analogous to tech debt. Every unnecessary meeting adds cognitive overhead, context switching, and lost momentum. Over time, it compounds. And the manager is the one who decides whether to accrue that debt or pay it down. Luna: So how do you actually audit your calendar? Where do you start? Lucas: First step is to do a two-week audit. Block out an hour at the end of each week and look at every recurring meeting on your calendar. Ask yourself: If this meeting were cancelled, would anyone notice? If the answer is no, cancel it. Luna: That's a good gut check. But what about the ones where people might notice, but the meeting is still a time-waster? Lucas: Then you look at the agenda. If there isn't one, or if the agenda is just a list of topics with no attached decisions to make, it's a candidate for async. Send a document with the key information, ask people to comment by a certain time, and then only call a meeting if there's actual disagreement. Luna: I like that. It flips the default from 'meeting unless we decide otherwise' to 'async unless we truly need to sync.' Lucas: Exactly. Another tactic — and this comes from the team at Basecamp — is to have a 'no meeting Wednesday' or a 'maker morning' policy. Block off four hours every day for deep work. Force all meetings into a window. It's not perfect for every team, but it signals that focused work is the priority. Luna: We actually did something similar at my last company. We had 'no meeting Fridays' — and the first couple of weeks, people still scheduled meetings on Friday because they forgot. But after a month, the culture shifted. Fridays became the day for writing, code review, strategic thinking. Lucas: That culture shift is key. Because it's not just about the individual manager's calendar — it's about the team norm. If the senior leaders are always in back to back meetings, that sets the expectation that being in meetings equals being productive. Luna: And then you get the cascade effect. Junior managers see that and think, 'I need to be in more meetings to prove my value.' Lucas: Which is exactly the wrong signal. The real value is in making decisions and driving outcomes, not attending status updates. I think one of the hardest things for new managers is unlearning the habit of filling their calendar with meetings because it feels like work. Luna: So let's get practical. If a listener is a manager who feels like they're drowning in meetings, what's the first thing they should do tomorrow? Lucas: Look at your calendar for the next week. Identify the three meetings that you think are the least valuable. Cancel or convert them to async. Then track what happens. I bet you'll find that nothing breaks. And that gives you the confidence to keep going. Luna: I'd add one more thing: when you cancel a meeting, be transparent about why. Say, 'I realized this could be handled over email. Here's the update. Let me know if you need time to discuss.' That models the behavior for your team. Lucas: Absolutely. And if someone pushes back, you can have a conversation about what they actually need from that meeting. Often, they just need visibility, which you can give them in a five-minute written update. Luna: It's interesting — we talk a lot about feedback and delegation on this show, but meeting hygiene is the infrastructure that makes all of that work. If your calendar is chaos, it's hard to be a thoughtful leader. Lucas: That's a great point. And it's why we're dedicating an episode to it. Because unlike some of the softer people skills, this is something you can change starting tomorrow. It's a low-hanging fruit. Luna: And speaking of low-hanging fruit — Lucas, I think this episode is a perfect example of something that could have been async, but I'm glad we're talking about it in person. Lucas: Ha, fair. But honestly, if today's conversation was worth a coffee to you, that's the link — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It helps us keep the show ad-free and focused on actionable stuff like this. Luna: Yeah, listener support makes a real difference. We don't run ads, so it's just folks like you who find value in the show and decide to chip in. No pressure, but if it feels right, that's where you can find us. Lucas: Alright, back to meetings. I want to leave you with one final thought. A study from Microsoft in 2023 found that the average user spends 57 percent of their time in communication tools — email, chat, meetings — and only 43 percent doing actual work. Flipping that ratio starts with one cancelled meeting. Luna: I love that. So maybe the challenge for this week is: cancel one meeting that doesn't need to happen, and see what opens up. Lucas: That's the homework. Thanks for being here, everyone. We'll see you next Monday.