Latest / Saigalseatrade Podcast / Inside the Mechanics of the Global Oil System - Part 2
Transcript
- 0:09Hello everyone, and welcome back to the Segal Sea Trade podcast.
- 0:13I'm Shruti, your host today joined by Mr. Sandesh Ghandat.
- 0:17Sandesh, welcome back to the podcast.
- 0:19Thanks Shruti. Thanks for inviting me.
- 0:22It's pleasure to be here. Well, we do have a lot of things
- 0:25to discuss and unpack today, so get up for a lot of insights.
- 0:30So my first question to you Sandesh is a huge chunk of the
- 0:33VLCC fleet is now effectively controlled by cynical linked
- 0:38entities and interest tied to Jianlugi Aponte.
- 0:42So why is this more than just a shipping story?
- 0:45Well, Shruti, you rightly said this is far more than a shipping
- 0:49story because tankers, they are not just a transport cost, they
- 0:53are part of I would say the oil markets, plumbing.
- 0:56When you concentrate control over the VLCC fleet, you are
- 1:00effectively influencing how, when and even whether the
- 1:04physical oil can move. So oil, it can be produced, it
- 1:08can be demanded, but it cannot move efficiently between the
- 1:12regions because the price discoveries breakdown.
- 1:15And that's why this matters. So what Sinukor linked entities
- 1:19and interest tied to the Jayan Liyogi Aponte are doing is
- 1:23altering the elasticity of the oil system itself, not by
- 1:27touching supply, but by tightening the connective tissue
- 1:30that links to the supply and demand.
- 1:32I am specifically addressing VLCC tankers and the worst
- 1:37control of the VLCC fleet. So how unprecedented is this
- 1:41level would you say, for the tanker concentration?
- 1:44In terms of precedent, this level of tanker concentration is
- 1:49extremely rare, arguably unprecedented in the modern
- 1:52crude market. Shipping has always been
- 1:55fragmented by design I would say we have Greek owner, Norwegian
- 1:59owners, Asian leading houses and then the state linked fleets.
- 2:04So no single group ever controlled enough of the spot
- 2:07VLCC pool to meaningfully influence the availability.
- 2:10So what's different now is it's not just ownership, but it's a
- 2:14control. And between the outright
- 2:16ownership and then the long term charters and strategic
- 2:19withholding, you're talking about 1/4 to potentially 1/3 of
- 2:24commercially tradable compliant non sanctioned VLCC fleet being
- 2:28effectively spoken for. So that's not a normal market,
- 2:32that's a structurally constrained 1.
- 2:34So when charters realize the availability is tightening, we
- 2:38have observe this quite a few Times Now because behavior it
- 2:42changes very fast because the oil traders as well as the
- 2:46refiners are deeply risk averse when it comes to the logistic.
- 2:50So nobody wants to be the last buyer scrambling for the ships
- 2:55with cargoes already priced. So the moment there is a
- 2:58perception that ships may not be there tomorrow or the charters
- 3:03rush to secure tunnish today, that panic don't move linearly.
- 3:07It moved in jumps, one or two filled fixtures, one or two eye
- 3:11watering red prints and suddenly everyone is booking ahead.
- 3:16So locking in ships early, extending durations and then
- 3:19paying premium. That's how freight goes
- 3:21vertical. And once freight goes vertical,
- 3:24the oil market start behaving strangely.
- 3:27So you can have an oversupplied oil market on paper and then
- 3:31still see localized crude prices collapse.
- 3:34And you may ask why because the sellers, they discount barrels
- 3:38to compensate buyers for the freighteries.
- 3:40And at the same time we have distant buyers, they step back
- 3:44because landed cost no longer makes sense.
- 3:47So physical oil prices weaken in some reasons even as the system
- 3:51as a whole titles. And then that's the paradox.
- 3:54So this high freight depresses the spot crude prices locally,
- 3:57but then it makes the global balance more fragile.
- 4:02So, Sandeep, you've clearly explained what happens when
- 4:04charters panic in a tight availability market, but do you
- 4:08also think tankers can control and influence oil prices without
- 4:13touching supply? Well, answer to that is yes, the
- 4:16tanker control can absolutely influence oil prices without
- 4:20touching supply and it does it through the arbitrage
- 4:23destruction. So when freight is cheap,
- 4:25barrels move freely and then when freight explodes, arbitrage
- 4:30windows close. So US crude can't reach Asia
- 4:33competitively. We have Atlantic basin barrels,
- 4:36they get trapped due to the high freight cost and then the Middle
- 4:40East producers regain the pricing power because proximity
- 4:44suddenly matters more than the benchmark spreads, The future
- 4:48curve kind of react, then the time spread tighten and
- 4:52volatility rises. We all know how this unfolds.
- 4:56What we have seen in the past specifically when the economy
- 5:00started to regain in the market after the COVID imbalance and I
- 5:05would say that none of that requires a single barrel of
- 5:08production to be cut because we all know that how freight can
- 5:13destroy the market share as well as how they can influence the
- 5:17oil prices without touching the supply.
- 5:19So there is also forward-looking dimension to that because
- 5:23markets are under pricing. So tanker don't get built
- 5:27overnight. The VLCC order book is right now
- 5:30historically thin relative to the fleet size.
- 5:33And then the yards specifically those in Korea and Japan, they
- 5:37are full with the LNG and container ships.
- 5:39And then we have environmental regulations.
- 5:42They are pushing owners to delay orders and at the same time we
- 5:46have highest number of vessels under sanctions from the VLCC
- 5:49point of view. Currently 153 VLCCC are
- 5:52sanctioned and the sanctions have effectively removed a chunk
- 5:56of the fleet from the clean trade.
- 5:58So even if those ships still exist physically, we will still
- 6:02see a significant impact on the freight.
- 6:06When a large well capitalized player accumulates control.
- 6:10Now they are positioning themselves ahead of the period
- 6:13where the optionality becomes extremely valuable.
- 6:16So the deeper issue that oil market are still being analyzed
- 6:19as if logistics are frictionless sanctions, consolidations,
- 6:24environmental rules and the capital scarcity have turned the
- 6:28shipping from a passive service into an active constraint.
- 6:32So when you overlay that with the geopolitical risk, the
- 6:35tanker market becomes a volatility amplifier.
- 6:39Yes, exactly Sandesh. So Sinecor and upon tailing
- 6:42interest aren't just buying ships, they're buying leverage
- 6:45over timing overflows and indirectly over price formation.
- 6:49So you have rightly said. So.
- 6:51Calling this just a shipping story misses the whole point.
- 6:54This is about control over mobility in a world where oil
- 6:58still needs to travel thousands of miles to clear.
- 7:01And even in the past cycles, supply shocks, they drove the
- 7:06prices and in the next one logistic shocks may get there
- 7:10first. Well, I agree with you, Sandesh
- 7:12here. And I think we are seeing a
- 7:14situation where oil prices fall in some regions because freight
- 7:18explodes. Or how can you explain this
- 7:20freight crude paradox? Well, the freight crude paradox,
- 7:25it exists because oil pricing is not just about the barrels, but
- 7:30it's about the mobility. So when freight explores, it
- 7:34doesn't reduce supply or demand on paper.
- 7:37It raises the cost and the risk of moving barrels so sharply
- 7:41that the markets temporarily stops clearing efficiently.
- 7:46So oil that should flow doesn't flow and then the arbitrage
- 7:50windows slam shut and regional markets kind of disconnect.
- 7:54So overall, that dislocation then pushes local crude prices
- 7:58down even as the global system becomes tighter and more
- 8:02fragile. So you end up with the falling
- 8:06prices in some regions precisely because the system is under
- 8:10stress, so not because it's well supplied.
- 8:13So in that case, how do the high freight rates distort regional
- 8:17differentials? Well, I would say that the high
- 8:20freight rates, they distort the regional differentials by
- 8:23breaking the normal relationship between the benchmark because in
- 8:27a low friction world, a barrel in the US Gulf or West Africa or
- 8:32even in the Middle East. So they traded within the
- 8:34predictable spread to Brent or Dubai because you know, the
- 8:38transport is relatively cheap and reliable.
- 8:41So when the VLCC rate jumped from the let's say $30,000 per
- 8:45day to recently, we have seen more than $120,000 per day.
- 8:49So that adds several dollars per barrel to the long haul version.
- 8:53So suddenly AUS Gull for VAF cargo that looked competitive on
- 8:58paper becomes extremely uneconomic once the prate is
- 9:01laid in. So buyers in Asia step back and
- 9:05then the arbitrage flows tall. So and the sellers, they are
- 9:09forced to discount locally to clear barrels.
- 9:11And that's how you get the negative differentials widening
- 9:15even though the global balances haven't loosened.
- 9:17And then the distortion also works in rivers.
- 9:20So the regions close to the demand centers, particularly
- 9:24let's say Middle East to I5 to 8 days of voyage, gain the pricing
- 9:28power. So shorter voyage means lower
- 9:31freight exposure. And so the proximity becomes
- 9:33more valuable than the quality. And that compresses the spread
- 9:38between the Middle Eastern grades and local Asian
- 9:41alternatives. So in effect, freight replaces
- 9:44the quality and benchmark linkage as the dominant pricing
- 9:49variable. But while I'm saying this, you
- 9:51have to also understand this that any decisions for the
- 9:55procurement that has been taken by the refinery, it's all
- 9:59relative to the benchmark or we can say the internal crude
- 10:04baskets. So from what I understand here,
- 10:06Sandesh, this pressures physical prices short term but they turn
- 10:11bullish later. So why is that?
- 10:13Well, in the short term, this particular dynamic is bearish
- 10:16specifically for the physical prices, because it creates the
- 10:20illusion of oversupply. So barrels pile up in exporting
- 10:24regions because we have inventories, those rise locally
- 10:28and then the spot prices weaken as seller compete for the fewer
- 10:32reachable buyers. So traders, they mark down the
- 10:35physical values and headlines, talk about the soft demand and
- 10:39the market narrative turns negative.
- 10:41So, but structurally this is where the setup flips.
- 10:44So over time, high freight tightens the system and when the
- 10:48arbitrage shirts, oil stops moving to where it's most
- 10:52needed. So the refiners, they adjust the
- 10:55runs, inventories drawn evenly and spare barrels become trapped
- 11:01behind the logistical barriers. And then meanwhile, higher
- 11:04freight cost discourage spot trading and push buyers towards
- 11:08the long term contracts, reducing the liquidity.
- 11:11At the same time, tanker ability tightens further as ships get
- 11:16locked into the longer voyages or Congo charters.
- 11:20So I think the result here, Sandesh, is that the system
- 11:23loses flexibility. So once demand surprises to the
- 11:27upside or supply hiccups start to occur, there's no slack left.
- 11:31And I think that's when prices gap higher, not because
- 11:35production fell, but because the system can't respond fast
- 11:38enough. And I think This is why freight
- 11:40driven weakness is often a precursor to bullish conditions
- 11:45and it's not resolving imbalance.
- 11:47I think it's just postponing it and you're compressing
- 11:50volatility today and storing it for later.
- 11:53But now that being said, Sandesh tell us which regions are most
- 11:57exposed in this dynamic right now.
- 11:59Well As for which regions are most exposed right now, I would
- 12:03say that the Atlantic basin is at the epicenter. the US Gulf
- 12:07Coast is highly sensitive because it's barrels mostly rely
- 12:10on the long haul exports to Asia and that is because they want to
- 12:15clear the marginal supplies, specifically US crude backups
- 12:18domestically depressing the WTA linked grades even if the global
- 12:22demand is fine. So West Africa face the same
- 12:25issue because they are interchangeable grades, suite
- 12:28grades. I'm talking about the Nigerian
- 12:31grade. Other than Nigerian Angolan
- 12:34crudes also suffer when freight jumps because they also lose the
- 12:37access to the Asian buyers and get trapped competing in Europe
- 12:41or floating in the Atlantic. So Asia ironically feels
- 12:46insulated at first because the Middle Eastern suppliers, you
- 12:49know, specifically in the Arabian Gulf region, they, they
- 12:53benefit from the proximity and the local refiners can still
- 12:56secure feedstock without paying extreme freight.
- 12:59But I would say that this is temporary because as Atlantic
- 13:03barrels get stranded and shipping Titans, Asia becomes
- 13:08more dependent on the smaller supplier basis and that
- 13:11concentration increase the vulnerability to any disruption.
- 13:15So whether geopolitical or operational or any other.
- 13:19So Europe, it seized awkwardly in the middle and time to time
- 13:23get benefited from cheap Atlantic barrels in the short
- 13:27term, but becoming exposed if you know the global flows
- 13:30tighten abruptly. So the key takeaways, falling
- 13:33oil prices caused by the rising freight are not a sign of
- 13:37comfort, they are the warning signal.
- 13:39So they tell you exactly the markets plumbing is clogging.
- 13:44And in the commodities, clogged plumbing almost always leads to
- 13:49the violent price and moves later.
- 13:52So the paradox, the stocks only exist if you look at that price
- 13:57in isolation. So once you look at the mobility
- 14:00as well as the optionality specifically from the Asian
- 14:03point of view and the logistics. So it makes perfect sense and
- 14:08it's quietly one of the most bullish medium term signals for
- 14:12the market producers. Well, Sandeep, that was quite an
- 14:14interesting take. Well, with that, we come to an
- 14:16end to this episode and I think it has been quite an insightful
- 14:20conversation and a lot to gain from it for all our listeners.
- 14:24And do not forget to share and subscribe to our podcast.
- 14:27Until next time, navigate safely and stay tuned.