Latest / The Great Retirement Debate with Ed Slott & Jeffrey Levine / S1 Ep13: GRD013: SECURE Act 2.0 - Deal or No Deal? Pt. 2
Transcript
- 0:00Intro: Hi, I'm Ed Slott, and I'm Jeff Levine.
- 0:02And we are two guys who just love to talk about retirement and taxes.
- 0:06Look, our mission is simple to educate you, the savers, so that you can make
- 0:10better decisions because better decisions on the whole lead to better outcomes.
- 0:14And here's how we're going to do that.
- 0:15Each week, Jeff and I will debate the pros and the cons of a particular retirement
- 0:21strategy or topic with the goal helping you keep more of your hard-earned money.
- 0:26Yeah, but we won't know which side of the debate we're taking until we flip a
- 0:29coin winner of the coin flip gets to pick which side of the debate they want to
- 0:33argue, and both of us will have to argue in favor of our respective positions,
- 0:38whether we agree with them or not.
- 0:40At the end of each debate, there's going to be one clear winner you, a more
- 0:45informed saver who can hopefully apply the merits of each side of the debate
- 0:48to your own personal situation to decide what's best for you and your family.
- 0:52So here we go.
- 0:53Welcome to the Great Retirement Debate.
- 1:02Jeffrey Levine: All right.
- 1:02Welcome back to the Great Retirement Debate.
- 1:04Ed, good to be with you again today.
- 1:06Ed Slott: Yep.
- 1:06We're back now on part two of Secure 2.0, that new tax law.
- 1:11Last version we did Part one, our Deal or No Deal on the RMD required minimum
- 1:19distribution provisions a lot there.
- 1:21Now, today we're going to switch to the Roth provisions, Roth IRAs and Roth 401ks.
- 1:28Jeffrey Levine: You know that old song, that kid song, like
- 1:2999 bottles of Beer on the Wall?
- 1:31I kind of feel like we're running through like 99 provisions and almost is 99
- 1:35provisions in this, uh, in this bill.
- 1:37All right, so we're gonna do Roth provisions today.
- 1:39Yes.
- 1:39Ed Slott: Yes.
- 1:40And we're going to follow suit.
- 1:42We flipped the coin last time and I picked no deal.
- 1:45Which was easier for me on those RMD provisions and you had a tough
- 1:49time, uh, defending some of that.
- 1:51So I'll stick with my no deal, uh, because it may be tougher for
- 1:55me on, on these Roth provisions, especially since I love everything
- 1:59about Roth IRAs cause I like tax free.
- 2:02So why don't....
- 2:02Jeffrey Levine: You know what you are Ed?
- 2:04You are a Rothaphile, I just realized that.
- 2:06Ed Slott: Yeah.
- 2:06Okay.
- 2:07, Jeffrey Levine: You're you're a Rothaphile.
- 2:09Ed Slott: Uh, yeah.
- 2:10Whatever's tax free a file is what I am.
- 2:12Keep more of your hard-earned money.
- 2:13So let's start with the most recognizable actually has to do with RMDs.
- 2:18Where we left off last time in Roth 401Ks.
- 2:23Roth IRAs have never had required minimum distributions during your lifetime.
- 2:29That's all I'm talking about.
- 2:30Not beneficiaries, but when Roth 401ks came out, uh, for some reason, maybe
- 2:36it was an unintended consequence.
- 2:39They did have lifetime RMDs for those people.
- 2:43Had Roth plans in their workplace plan like a Roth 401k, and that
- 2:47seemed to be a problem because they weren't treated the same.
- 2:51Now, uh, they will be treated the same starting next year, 2024.
- 2:56Why would I say there's no deal there?
- 2:59Uh, I wouldn't, I don't, I don't have anything on that one.
- 3:02I don't see anything negative.
- 3:03I think it's uh, that provision is great that, uh, they finally got around to it.
- 3:08You'll just have to wait till next year.
- 3:10If I had anything negative, uh, say no deal.
- 3:13Uh, most people in plans probably weren't subject to RMDs anyway, even
- 3:19when they were past the age if they were still working, because lots of
- 3:22companies have these still working exceptions where you can delay RMDs
- 3:27in a company plan, not an IRA if you're still working for that company.
- 3:31So, other than that, that's my only no deal part, that it's not as big a deal.
- 3:39Jeffrey Levine: Well, I think it's a pretty big deal because the fact of the
- 3:42matter is if you have money in a tax-free account, Ed, you know, you just said it.
- 3:46You love anything tax free.
- 3:47Ed Slott: That's right.
- 3:48Jeffrey Levine: So why would you take money from something that's tax free
- 3:51and move it to anything else unless you needed to spend those dollars.
- 3:56So the fact is that now individuals who have their hard-earned money
- 3:59in a 401k, but the Roth side of the 401k won't be forced to do that.
- 4:04They'll be able to continue to let that money compound for their entire
- 4:08lifetimes, 100% tax and penalty free.
- 4:11That means more for later in life when they really need it.
- 4:13That means more for spouses when they inherit that dollar, those
- 4:18dollars, that means more for beneficiaries if they get it.
- 4:21So all in all, this is a, a pretty big deal.
- 4:23And you know what, I'll say it's a big deal cuz it actually,
- 4:27in general, the Secure Act 2.0 does nothing for simplification.
- 4:32It just complicates matters absurdly.
- 4:34But this is one kind of corner of the universe where they actually did
- 4:39make things a little bit simpler.
- 4:40Now, if you have a Roth account, it has no required minimum distribution before,
- 4:45as you said, we had to keep track.
- 4:47Is it a Roth IRA?
- 4:48Is it a Roth 401k, or 403b etc.
- 4:51Now, I don't care.
- 4:53Your account is a Roth, and again, this is beginning next year in 2024.
- 4:58But I don't care now, it's just you don't have required minimum distributions.
- 5:02So anytime we can get any sort of simplification, Ed,
- 5:06it's gotta be a big deal.
- 5:07Ed Slott: I agree.
- 5:07I had a tough call on saying no deal on that.
- 5:10Uh, but like I said, some people may not, it may not affect as many people
- 5:15as you think because they, uh, may have had that still working exception.
- 5:19But the other thing, I'll have to take one other point on your side, some people
- 5:22may have wanted to keep, you know, uh, their money in a Roth 401k in the past.
- 5:27To, to avoid RMDs and the plans you would roll out to a Roth IRA,
- 5:32but for certain reasons, creditor protection, uh, investment of whatever.
- 5:36There could have been reasons you wanted to keep it in the 401k.
- 5:40Now you can in the Roth 401k and not be subject to lifetime RMDs for that money.
- 5:46All right, next provision deal or no deal?
- 5:49The 529 to Roth IRA rollovers, so I'm calling no deal on that
- 5:55even though I like the provision.
- 5:57I'll give you the basics of the provision for years people built up, uh, subs uh,
- 6:02some people built up substantial accounts in their 529 education funding accounts,
- 6:08and now they have too much in there.
- 6:10Maybe their child didn't go to school or they got a scholarship
- 6:13or something like that, and the money can't be used for education.
- 6:16If it's not used for education, uh, the earnings could be subject to
- 6:20tax and even a 10% penalty if it's not used for qualified education.
- 6:25This provision, if you just look at the headline, it sounded great, and all the
- 6:29advisors were jumping all over and say, wow, 529s to Roth, tax free rollovers.
- 6:34I have clients with 200,000, 300,000.
- 6:37In fact, uh, you had a piece in the New York Times and in one
- 6:41that re that, uh, we're going to link if we can to, that pro...
- 6:45that article linked to one of your articles talking about these,
- 6:48uh, these large accounts, right?
- 6:51Jeffrey Levine: Yeah, that's right.
- 6:52The, the so-called Dynasty 529 plan is what, what I, what I refer to it as.
- 6:57It just simply refers to the ability of basically to accumulate obscene
- 7:01amounts of, of money inside 529 plans, and then change your beneficiaries,
- 7:07for potentially generations in order to continue to use these dollars.
- 7:11So yeah, I appreciate the plug , Ed, and uh, I owe you one, I guess.
- 7:14So your case of brandy is on the way.
- 7:16Ed Slott: Yeah, yeah.
- 7:17Uh, meanwhile that's the deal part, but that's all a lot of advisors and even the
- 7:21public saw, they only saw the headlines.
- 7:24Uh, well now I may have to burst a few bubbles.
- 7:27If you're an advisor out there or a consumer and saying, wow,
- 7:31this is great, I have 200,000.
- 7:32Um, it'll never be used for education.
- 7:34I, I, I can't see how.
- 7:36Wow.
- 7:37I could roll it to a Roth and, uh, tax free and now build it up in a
- 7:41Roth or with all the Roth rules.
- 7:42No.
- 7:44There are severe limitations.
- 7:46It's not all it was cracked up to be.
- 7:49Uh, and I'll tell you number one, it has to go to the beneficiaries.
- 7:53Roth IRA, this rollover.
- 7:54All right, not a big deal.
- 7:55Like you said, change beneficiaries.
- 7:58That's no big deal.
- 7:59Not available till 2024.
- 8:01Not a big deal.
- 8:01You can wait.
- 8:02Here are the big deal limitations.
- 8:04You must to qualify for the rollover from the 529 to the Roth.
- 8:09The account must, the 529 must have been in existence for 15 years.
- 8:14That could throw off a lot of people, even if you met that.
- 8:17It's like each hurdle, each time you get past a hurdle, there's another
- 8:21one that may be tougher to hit.
- 8:23So let's say you got past that, then any contributions that were made in
- 8:27the last five years don't qualify.
- 8:29All right.
- 8:30Maybe you got past that one.
- 8:31And now the big one where people, where everybody was licking their chops.
- 8:35Wow, look at all this money.
- 8:37I can get into a roth.
- 8:38No, there's a limitation.
- 8:40A $35,000 lifetime, $35,000 lifetime limitation.
- 8:47So you say, all right, I can move 35,000.
- 8:49No, you can't.
- 8:51The , the, uh, 35,000 can only be moved in increments of whatever the
- 8:57annual contribution is for that year.
- 8:59Now, this is not available till 24.
- 9:02We don't know what the annual IRA or Roth IRA contribution limit will
- 9:06be next year, but, For arguement say now it's 6,500 without the catch up.
- 9:11Let's say, uh, it went up to 7,000 just to make the math easy.
- 9:147,000.
- 9:15It would take five years to get that 35,000 out.
- 9:19But even then, if you say, all right, I'll wait the five years and use
- 9:22the 35,000, it only works if the beneficiary would otherwise have
- 9:27qualified for his or her own IRA or Roth IRA contribution by having,
- 9:32uh, wages or self-employment income.
- 9:35So as we get down the ladder of all these, uh, of all these limitations, you're
- 9:40going to see, yes, it can help with some small balances and the ideas good, or
- 9:45to chip away at some larger balances.
- 9:47Uh, if there's, uh, any way to expand it, it might be that it's,
- 9:53we believe it's per beneficiary.
- 9:55Jeffrey Levine: That's right.
- 9:56Yeah.
- 9:56And I think it's a pretty big deal, Ed, because you know, right now
- 9:59retirement accounts are kind of like, they're on their own island.
- 10:03They basically can only transfer money from retirement
- 10:06account to retirement account.
- 10:09And you know, there are just things that happen.
- 10:12And, and by the way, not only can they only transfer money from
- 10:14retirement account, retirement account, but they can only take
- 10:17money from other retirement accounts.
- 10:19You know, you can't decide like, Ooh, my HSA, I wanna move it in there.
- 10:23There is a one-time ability to go from your IRA to an HSA, but it's very limited.
- 10:28Probably most people on here have never even heard of it, something called a
- 10:32qualified HSA funding distribution.
- 10:34That's an ability, once in a lifetime to take one year's worth of contributions,
- 10:39uh, from your IRA and move it into an HSA.
- 10:43But in, in general, we're talking about isolating money
- 10:46in their own respective buckets.
- 10:47This is a, a change to that philosophy.
- 10:51And you know, a lot of times Congress is, you know, they're like
- 10:54a little kid going to the beach.
- 10:55They don't just run in, they dip their toe in the water and
- 10:57they see how it goes first.
- 10:59And, uh, this might be Congress starting to dip its toe in the
- 11:03water and saying, you know what?
- 11:04We're gonna give people, uh, the ability to redirect or change the
- 11:11reason, the purpose that they were saving for tax preference money.
- 11:16And right now there are a number of reasons, right?
- 11:17It could be.
- 11:18For, uh, you have health, you have education, you have retirement.
- 11:23Right now, they're largely siloed in their own buckets.
- 11:26Maybe this is the beginning of, uh, of a, of a, of a new trend
- 11:30for Congress to just allow almost universal style tax preferenced
- 11:36savings accounts, which a lot of people have been clamoring for, for years.
- 11:40Ed Slott: Yeah, the 35,000 limit though is a kind of a killer and you may even
- 11:44be the blame for it, if I had to blame somebody probably that times article.
- 11:49Jeffrey Levine: Thank you.
- 11:49Thank you.
- 11:49I appreciate all the hate mail I'm gonna get now.
- 11:51Ed.
- 11:52Thank you.
- 11:52Yes.
- 11:53Ed Slott: Oh, probably Congress was reading that.
- 11:54It was a full page, you know, top, uh, front page in the New
- 11:58York Times business section.
- 12:00I could see Congress in there, what?
- 12:02Uh, no, no, no.
- 12:04We're not doing that.
- 12:05Jeffrey Levine: Well, that's, uh, Hey, great.
- 12:08My mailbox is gonna be, uh, stocked full of..
- 12:11Ed Slott: Well, you know what?
- 12:11Maybe they read your stuff.
- 12:13I don't know.
- 12:14Jeffrey Levine: Alright, well hopefully they read somebody's stuff, something
- 12:17because they don't read the bill.
- 12:18That's for sure.
- 12:19Ed Slott: Yeah.
- 12:19Right, right, right.
- 12:20Uh, about 350 pages of the 4,000 page bill.
- 12:25All right, so there, there's another provision on the Roth.
- 12:28Uh, one more, the plan this is the 401k catchup contributions.
- 12:34Can only go in certain instances to a Roth 401k.
- 12:39This is a special provision in secure 2.0 for high income people,
- 12:44and the provision says, the catch up contribution, if your wages from the
- 12:50company you're working for are in excess of 145,000, you must, uh, you can,
- 12:56the catch up must go to the Roth 401k.
- 12:59I like the idea of a catchup, uh, you know, loading up a Roth 401k, but it
- 13:05must go because you're high income.
- 13:07And, and what if the plan doesn't have a, a Roth 401k?
- 13:10Then you have no catch up, so it takes some of your choices away and some
- 13:15higher income people might want to keep it in the 401, the tax deferred side.
- 13:20So, uh, I call no deal on that.
- 13:22The idea is good, but, uh, to me personally, I like to see more
- 13:26people load up on Roth 401ks.
- 13:29But what's, say you on the big deal?
- 13:31Jeffrey Levine: Ed, you know, I'm gonna have to take this, uh, to say it's a, it's
- 13:35a big deal, but for a negative reason.
- 13:37Precisely, uh, for some of the reasons you stated and, and I'd start with
- 13:41the fact that this only applies to individuals who have wages of more
- 13:46than $145,000 in the previous year.
- 13:50So we're talking about people with relatively high incomes, at least compared
- 13:54to, you know, the American public at large and American taxpayers at large.
- 13:58And if you have high income and you think you might be in a lower tax
- 14:01bracket later on, maybe when you retire.
- 14:03You may be better off going into the pre-tax account now and then
- 14:07converting maybe in a gap year in between when you retire and when you
- 14:11start taking social security and start taking required minimum distributions.
- 14:15But now you can't do that.
- 14:16So I think it's a big deal there.
- 14:18And perhaps the even bigger deal is that not every plan has a Roth option today.
- 14:23And if there's one person who makes more than $145,000, uh, $45,000 in wages in the
- 14:31previous year, and they are 50 or above.
- 14:35So basically like one eligible person to make a catch up, who can't make
- 14:40because of the fact that there is no Roth option in the plan, no one in the plan
- 14:46gets to make a catch up contribution.
- 14:48That's high income, low income.
- 14:50Roth, not Roth.
- 14:51Uh, so there's one, and I got one other big deal for you, Ed.
- 14:54Um, and that is, I think it'll get fixed.
- 14:57I, I do think it'll get fixed before, but as it stands now, Congress made a mistake.
- 15:04Portion.
- 15:05They accidentally deleted the section of the law that allows for
- 15:09catch up contributions, period.
- 15:11So, although I think it'd be fixed eventually, or IRS will just ignore
- 15:15it, uh, it's a kind of a big deal that Congress, you know, they they, they,
- 15:20they put this thing together between the Senate and the House version so quickly
- 15:24that they ended up in a scenario where they accidentally deleted the entire
- 15:28portion of the catch up contribution law.
- 15:30Ed Slott: Yeah.
- 15:30It's called cut and paste.
- 15:33Pretty much, except they forgot to paste.
- 15:34Jeffrey Levine: They, I was, I was gonna say, there's too much
- 15:35cutting and not enough pasting here.
- 15:37Yeah, indeed.
- 15:38Ed Slott: All right, there's a couple other miscellaneous things,
- 15:40uh, just so we cover the, the Roth provisions or as many as we can.
- 15:46New beginning of SEP and simple Roth IRAs and even matching contributions
- 15:52to Roth, uh, 401ks, which none of these were allowed before.
- 15:57And, and they're allowed now.
- 15:59Uh, what's the downside of that?
- 16:01Well, I think it'll gonna take a while to get into the system because the law
- 16:07was enacted December 29th, so SEP and Simple Roth IRAs became effective a few
- 16:13days later, even if you wanted to do it.
- 16:16I don't think any custodians going to have the paperwork, the
- 16:19administrative headaches of, of getting these up and running.
- 16:22Eventually it'll smooth out, but for right now, it might be a rocky road on those.
- 16:27Jeffrey Levine: Yeah, I, I think this is also a big deal and I've gotta argue that.
- 16:30So I have to think that and, and, uh, you know that right now, It
- 16:35is not everybody has the ability to get money into a Roth early on.
- 16:40For instance, you know, simple IRA owners, they've had no ability to
- 16:45get money into a Roth account for the first two years of their plan because
- 16:48they are stuck in the simple for two years, you can't move it anywhere else.
- 16:53So the fact that you're able to do this now, this is a, you
- 16:56know, that's a pretty big deal.
- 16:57The fact that you are able to get your employer to put money directly
- 17:02into the Roth, now, yes, today, practically speaking, it's not there,
- 17:06but it'll be there soon enough.
- 17:08And that eliminates a step.
- 17:10And as we know, Ed, any time there are steps involved in something,
- 17:13anytime it, it takes, if it takes three steps to do something, instead
- 17:17of two, fewer people will do it even if it's, it's in their best interest.
- 17:20So re reducing friction here.
- 17:23You know, one of the greatest inventions for retirement security
- 17:26over the last, uh, you know, last 25, 30 years has been auto enrollment.
- 17:32Why?
- 17:32Not because it allows people to get into a plan where they weren't before,
- 17:36but because it removes friction, it takes away a step for them to do it.
- 17:40So now the fact that people will be able to have money go right into a Roth
- 17:44from their employer means more of them will probably get that money in there.
- 17:48And that could be a very good thing for a lot of people down the road.
- 17:51Big deal.
- 17:51Ed Slott: Maybe it's a start of something.
- 17:53They're opening up the spigots for the Roth.
- 17:55Why?
- 17:55Because they need revenue.
- 17:56And that's where all these Roth provisions are in secure 2.0 in
- 18:00the revenue provisions because it brings in money up front.
- 18:03So I say take advantage.
- 18:05I'm a big Roth fan.
- 18:06There're just a couple of bumps in the road and hopefully we'll
- 18:08get over a lot of these things, including that one on the catch up.
- 18:13But I, I don't even really address that cause you know they're gonna fix that.
- 18:16Jeffrey Levine: Yeah.
- 18:16I think at some point they will.
- 18:17I agree.
- 18:18And, and Ed, I, I think, you know, we agree on the fact that.
- 18:21This is, you know, the Roth is something that the government loves
- 18:25because it brings in money today.
- 18:26And so, while normally I'm hesitant to say you can trust the government to
- 18:30keep its word about anything because the laws get changed so quickly and one
- 18:34party comes in and changes the rules, the other one may, this is one thing
- 18:37that everybody really likes because it looks really good on a budget report
- 18:41when you bring in those dollars today.
- 18:43Ed Slott: That's right.
- 18:44Short-term thinking, take advantage of it for long-term planning.
- 18:48Jeffrey Levine: That's right.
- 18:48Well, so we agree on that.
- 18:50And Ed, one thing, the other, you know, one other thing we always agree on is
- 18:53the fact that while, uh, there are two sides to every argument, to every coin.
- 18:59Your life and your decisions are too important to leave up to a coin flip, and
- 19:02that's why one thing that we always agree on is making sure that you talk through
- 19:08any big decision with a knowledgeable financial advisor or tax professional
- 19:13so that you can weigh the pros and the cons of different decisions against
- 19:16your specific goals and your objectives.
- 19:20It's too big of a deal not to take advantage of that option.
- 19:24And so if you'd like to continue the discussion with Ed and I, we'd
- 19:27love to hear what you think of the Secure Act 2.0 Roth provisions.
- 19:31Are they a big deal or are they not a big deal?
- 19:33Which one do you think will have the greatest impact on you and your family?
- 19:37You can reach out to us, uh, Ed on Twitter @TheSlottReport that's
- 19:42@TheSlottReport or myself, @CPAPlanner.
- 19:46Again, that's @CPAPlanner, Ed and I look forward to hearing your thoughts and Ed, I
- 19:52certainly look forward to our next debate.
- 19:55Ed Slott: Oh yeah, me too.
- 19:56And there may even be more to come on secure 2.0 when we find out what
- 19:59Congress really meant or what I, what we, what IRS thinks Congress really meant.
- 20:04Jeffrey Levine: Indeed.
- 20:05We're gonna wait for those regulations.
- 20:06And Ed, I think one last thing that you can, I you and I can agree on
- 20:09is the fact that we could be glad we don't have to be the ones writing the
- 20:12regulations for a hundred new rules.
- 20:15Ed Slott: Oh yeah.
- 20:15Can you imagine?
- 20:16But we'll give them, what you get here is the debate in English
- 20:20on what we think they mean.
- 20:22Jeffrey Levine: Fair enough.
- 20:23And we'll give you some more debate next time here on the Great Retirement Debate.
- 20:27See you soon.
- 20:28Outro: Jeffrey Levine is Chief Planning Officer for Buckingham Wealth Partners.
- 20:32This podcast is for informational and educational purposes only, and should
- 20:35not be construed as specific investment accounting, legal or tax advice.
- 20:38Certain information mentioned may be based on third party information,
- 20:41which may become outdated or otherwise superseded without notice.
- 20:44Third party information is deemed to be reliable, but it's accuracy and
- 20:47completeness cannot be guaranteed.
- 20:49The topic discussed in corresponding arguments are those of the speakers
- 20:52and may not accurately reflect those of Buckingham Wealth partners.