Latest / Shades of Jade Podcast / Israel's Geopolitics, America's Support, and Reimagining Democracy
Transcript
- 0:10Hey everyone, my guest today is Daniel Bookman.
- 0:13Daniel is a lawyer in Israel, Religious by conviction and
- 0:17rational by instinct. He approaches conflict, faith
- 0:21and a divided society with a medical mindset.
- 0:24Let's understand the problems, make the diagnosis, prescribe
- 0:27solutions and hopefully lower the temperature somewhat.
- 0:31Welcome to the show, Daniel. I was wondering if you could
- 0:34tell the audience a little bit about yourself and what you're
- 0:38working on. OK, a little bit about myself, I
- 0:41guess. Why not?
- 0:44I'm starting from now. I'm I live in Jerusalem, Israel.
- 0:49I practice as a lawyer. I'm a religious Jew.
- 0:53I am part of the ultra Orthodox community in Israel, which you
- 0:58may or may have not heard about. I think a lot of events that
- 1:02occur in the world are actually in some ways related to the the
- 1:08community themselves due to Israeli politics.
- 1:14I was born. I wasn't born in Israel.
- 1:16I was born in Glasgow, Scotland, in the United Kingdom.
- 1:19I was educated in Manchester from the age of 12.
- 1:22My parents sent me there to get a religious education.
- 1:25After that I studied in rabbinical College in Israel.
- 1:30I then I then took a law degree in England and then got married,
- 1:34came back to Israel, studied another number of years in
- 1:40rabbinical colleges, various colleges for married people.
- 1:43I then qualified for the Israeli bar, took a professional
- 1:49qualification. I worked for a number of years.
- 1:51I then took a break from working in law, went into high tech,
- 1:55worked as a computer programmer for a number of years.
- 1:58I then returned to law and since then I've been practicing law.
- 2:02I spend, try to spend quite a bit of my time when I'm not
- 2:05practicing law, studying the Jewish holy works, the, the,
- 2:11the, the various literature which is accepted, which is
- 2:16viewed as a a great religious obligation, moral obligation to,
- 2:22to study to, to study the Jewish works and texts.
- 2:26And I also look at the world a little bit and think about it
- 2:30and try to bring, we spent a lot of time analysing when we're
- 2:33studying, trying to using developer logical thinking to a
- 2:37large extent. That's one of my arguments in,
- 2:41in the book of, of that the presentation of the rational
- 2:44elements in religion. So I find myself to
- 2:47contemplating the world and when we have, especially in a place
- 2:51as volatile as Israel, when we have traumatic events, I try to
- 2:55look at them, analyse them and try to problem solve to a
- 2:58certain extent. I think that's that's where
- 3:03where I come here. Yeah, as as I Yeah, sorry.
- 3:08It's an interesting background. That's yeah.
- 3:11And took some work. I you know.
- 3:14Yeah. I have I have ancestors from
- 3:16Scotland so. Let's go.
- 3:21I don't. I know they came from the Caudor
- 3:23Castle and my mom and brother and sister went there and
- 3:27visited Nice and it looks beautiful.
- 3:31But I hear. And when did they go to America?
- 3:36We generations ago it's yeah, yeah.
- 3:40So I've never been right, but. OK, no, it's a very beautiful
- 3:44place. I haven't been there for quite a
- 3:45while. Right.
- 3:47Yeah. Yeah.
- 3:48And there is. Yeah.
- 3:49Ironically the Scottish there is a strong anti Israel element in
- 3:56in Scottish politics. Ironic.
- 3:58Oh, really? Yeah, which is of concern.
- 4:01It's. Been quite a while.
- 4:04I don't know maybe there are reasons for that but that's I
- 4:07don't know if it affects everyday life.
- 4:09But in politics they're quite vocal, strong anti Israel, pro
- 4:13Palestinian, which I'm not again pro Palestinian, but it's
- 4:17acquires an anti Israel bias before October the 7th that was
- 4:23that's that was quite marked. Yeah.
- 4:28Prevalent. OK, so this this leads perfectly
- 4:31into your your first book. The the first chapter I see is
- 4:38called Israel under Attack and. Right, the second book.
- 4:41OK, Yeah. Oh, I'm sorry, your second book.
- 4:43Chronologically, it's the second book.
- 4:45It may be in the list I gave you.
- 4:46Chronologically it's written recently in response to the
- 4:51essentially to the the strong wave of anti-Semitism that has
- 4:54been felt since October the 7th. That's why that's what motivated
- 4:58me to write that book. OK.
- 5:01Right. So yes, the first book, the 1st
- 5:02chapter, yes is Israel's response.
- 5:05OK. Yeah.
- 5:07Can you, can you talk to us a little bit about what that book
- 5:11is about? And I guess here in America, we
- 5:17don't we only see what's in the headlines.
- 5:20So could you give us a bit of an insider view on what things are
- 5:25like since October 7th? OK, that's two different
- 5:30questions. One is 1 is what the book is
- 5:34about and 1 is what life is about.
- 5:35So I'll start the easier what's life about here?
- 5:40Life is a concern. It's even life is always drama
- 5:43and always action and always worry.
- 5:46Prior to October the 7th, in some ways the situation was
- 5:52worse or it was very dramatic, traumatic.
- 5:56There was a lot of tension in Israeli society over politics
- 6:01that if you were like 3 years ago, I think it was the, there
- 6:03was a general election and the, the Israeli right, the Likud
- 6:09under Netanyahu were successful in the elections and they
- 6:13actually scored the was the greatest electoral success
- 6:18they'd had. Netanyahu has been in power for
- 6:20over 10 years. There's been a number of
- 6:21elections. This was considered the most
- 6:23successfully obtained an absolute majority, which allowed
- 6:27him to form a coalition of all parties aligned with his world
- 6:34view. The religious parties, the
- 6:36national religious, everyone on the right side of the political
- 6:39aisle, including the ultra Orthodox parties, which I'm more
- 6:43aligned with. And that was considered because
- 6:48there'd been a lot of tension in Israel between left and right,
- 6:51religious and anti religious. They'd been the problem.
- 6:57I have to like backtrack a little bit.
- 6:59There's a problem with, for example, the drafting of the
- 7:02religious, the ultra Orthodox into the army.
- 7:04That's been quite a contentious issue, as well as other
- 7:07religious issues, religion and society.
- 7:10And the, and the feeling was that the, the legal system had
- 7:14been and had been preventing legislation to try and sort
- 7:19these issues out. That had been a majority, A
- 7:22conservative majority that were trying to pass, pass religiously
- 7:26or, or conservative type legislation that would protect
- 7:30religious rights, that would try and regulate the issues of the
- 7:37ultra orthodox serving the army, things like that.
- 7:39And the High Court had in a number of occasions had to
- 7:42declare these measures illegal, unlawful.
- 7:45Was it like a judo, an extra quite a high level of judicial
- 7:49intervention and activism. So the hope was that there will
- 7:51be now enough political support, enough political power to to, to
- 7:58to enact laws that would finally limit, first of all, the High
- 8:03Court, the courts from interfering and limit all those
- 8:06other forces, the executive, the legal advisers from preventing
- 8:11conservative type legislation from being passed.
- 8:14That was the hope. Therefore, there's a bit of
- 8:17euphoria after that election here.
- 8:18We've got this general, this overall majority.
- 8:21We can now start the real legislation really getting
- 8:24things in order. The problem was that caused on
- 8:28the other side of the political aisle A trauma which moved from
- 8:32a trauma to a very powerful anti government movement with mass
- 8:38demonstrations and and and mass strikes and threats from all
- 8:43multiple sectors of of of to to to, of insurrection.
- 8:50Not to serve in the army to, to, to undermine many of the
- 8:54institutions. The very foundations of the
- 8:56running of the state were in danger.
- 8:59And that was I think the precursor to October the 7th.
- 9:02I think October the 7th some ways saved the country from
- 9:05descending into civil war 7th of October from then after 7th of
- 9:11October, the country sort of came together to A to a greater
- 9:15extent with no talk of interaction and and and of
- 9:18mutiny etcetera, which had been so that was a pre 7 October 7th
- 9:22drama. The post October 7th drama has
- 9:24also been or of this drama. It's trauma, terrible terrorist
- 9:32attack and what the country has done to respond, which has
- 9:37caused a lot of, you know, international and national.
- 9:45I know what's the best word? It's it's been a lot of tensions
- 9:51in society. That was also a lot.
- 9:53That was a renewal of the demonstrations.
- 9:55It was all about releasing the hostages, trying to finish the
- 9:58war and to release the hostages. I've written about that in the
- 10:01book a little bit. What was maybe appropriate, what
- 10:03was not. So basically Israel has been a
- 10:05war, a sort of passive war or active war for the last two
- 10:09years. It's finally coming to an end to
- 10:12a certain extent. The hostage have been released,
- 10:14the war, there's been an official ceasefire trying to
- 10:17work things out. No one's quite sure politically
- 10:19or or geopolitically where things are actually going to go.
- 10:25Trump is a very common word and there's really vocabulary these
- 10:29days. Right, right.
- 10:32Trump and Netanyahu, they sort of dominate the conversation and
- 10:35headlines and and politics to a large extent, although the
- 10:38religious issues are also quite prevalent.
- 10:42That's on a political level. That's what's going on in
- 10:44society. Obviously in 2 minutes.
- 10:48I guess that's so my book coming.
- 10:51I guess to your second question, OK, my book was a response.
- 10:55I, I was looking last couple of years with alarm at what's going
- 11:00on internationally. Whatever your view is, what do
- 11:05you like what Israel's doing or not, Whether Israel had a
- 11:08choice, did not have a choice. But there was certainly a
- 11:12tremendous upsurge in anti-Semitism throughout the
- 11:15world, in much some of which is reported and some much of which
- 11:20is not even reported. And Jews were feeling
- 11:23increasingly unsafe. And I was starting to hear as
- 11:26well the, the, the, the debates, the discussions, the, the
- 11:29accusations becoming emotive and, and, and very vocal.
- 11:35And, and we're not focusing a lot on, on, on rationality, on
- 11:38logic, just bashing Israel, which can become dangerous is
- 11:42like the, the, the mob could feel the mob and, and, and it
- 11:48could feel the, the, there was an intense dislike, a hatred of
- 11:52visual that was, it was developing.
- 11:54So I started thinking about what was the, the argumentations that
- 11:58were being advanced for and against and trying to understand
- 12:02on a deep what's really going on?
- 12:03Why are we pro? Why?
- 12:04Why are people who are pro pro? What are we against?
- 12:07What's actually the, they weren't being articulated so
- 12:09clearly. Me too.
- 12:11I sort of integrated this with my everyday sort of life, which
- 12:15is trying to understand in a deep, rational way what's going
- 12:18on. So I started relating thoughts
- 12:20that started the first chapter, like you're saying, was
- 12:24explaining the Israeli position from a more hopefully profound
- 12:30perspective. And that led into a conceptual
- 12:34discussion of of many other things in society as a whole,
- 12:37not just in Israel, but throughout the the western
- 12:39world, geopolitics, ethics, anti-Semitism, democracy.
- 12:45And and I ended up trying to suggest solutions.
- 12:48I don't know if I have the right to do that, but that's what the
- 12:51part, that's what the book does. The last point is it was
- 12:54actually written in two, set in two time frames. 9 chapters out
- 12:59of 10 were written like I just described.
- 13:02The final chapter of the book is actually a proposal for no a new
- 13:08model of democracy. I argue that the parts of the
- 13:13division in society is due to democracy itself.
- 13:16That was written pre October the 7th when Israel itself was
- 13:20descending into chaos and anarchy and and and and mutiny,
- 13:24rebellion, civil insurrection. And I said, what's going on?
- 13:27This is democracy. I was like perplexed.
- 13:29There's been AI have two heads, so to speak.
- 13:32I I have a religious approach to things, which is this is God's
- 13:35will and we have to improve ourselves.
- 13:37That's how we view it. And this is not so much relate
- 13:40relative to us applicable to us. Our job is to be good Jews, to
- 13:44be good people, be as good as we can.
- 13:46We can't really affect what's going on in society.
- 13:48But I also have my rational, for whatever reason, some would say
- 13:52why, why you're getting involved?
- 13:53I do get involved intellectually.
- 13:55Why is this happening? I'm questioning democracy.
- 13:57Why is this happening? There's been a democratic
- 13:59election. One side has been successful.
- 14:01They have an, an agenda. Let's get on with it.
- 14:04Why does it have to be this war? The, the country plunged into
- 14:08civil war over this. You'll have the other chance
- 14:10that the left will have their chance in four years time.
- 14:12That's the, that's the basics of democracy.
- 14:14So it got me thinking about it. On the basis of that, I, I, I, I
- 14:17offered my analysis to what democracy has got to do with it.
- 14:20And maybe even our current model, Western modern general of
- 14:24democracy is perhaps responsible for a lot of this division,
- 14:28which was seen in Israel particularly in acute form, but
- 14:31also exists very much in America as I'm sure.
- 14:32You're aware? Absolutely.
- 14:34Yeah, Yeah, Yeah, yes. While you're while you're
- 14:38talking. I was, I mean it, it basically
- 14:43you're describing what's going on in America right now too.
- 14:46And it's like, Oh yeah, I know. I know what you're talking
- 14:49about. Yeah, I had it very much in
- 14:50mind. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 14:51And I was trying to understand that.
- 14:53And with a certain degree of alarm, I.
- 14:55Look, America's becoming politics is becoming so toxic,
- 14:59so divisive, it's endangering America itself.
- 15:03And everything is about politics.
- 15:05There's no rational discussion between the parties.
- 15:07There's no collaboration, everything is just to get
- 15:10points. So I'm trying to understand why
- 15:12that is and to suggest I I've proposed A diagnosis for what's
- 15:17going on and and and offered the solution.
- 15:20Yeah, yeah, it's, you know, IA little a little bit off topic,
- 15:27but I, I've noticed that so many people are living too much of
- 15:32their lives based off of politics and what influencers
- 15:36are saying. And I, I guess I personally have
- 15:41limited my time online to only be podcast related for the most
- 15:47part or posting on my personal page, posting pretty pictures.
- 15:51I'm not going to get into arguments or follow the accounts
- 15:56that are kind of rage baiting, but yeah, you know, I if people
- 16:02make money off of making people upset about stuff.
- 16:06So yeah. Yeah, yeah, it's, it's a culture
- 16:08that's not, doesn't seem to be designed to, to improve people's
- 16:12life or the lives of society. And people are willing to, to
- 16:16sow division for the sake of, of, of, of their own prominence
- 16:20and what that brings. And that's, that's sad.
- 16:22That's, that's a culture of the Internet.
- 16:25And you were saying that you limit your, your exposure to the
- 16:27Internet. That's very much in line with
- 16:29the Orthodox, ultra orthodox religious approach to technology
- 16:33in general. It's generally frowned upon.
- 16:36And exposure to the Internet in general is very, very limited.
- 16:39Only for specific. It's not really allowed so much
- 16:42in our community at all. And for good reason, I think,
- 16:45like you were describing, but you're describing the, the, the
- 16:50toxic atmosphere that surrounds politics and, and, and the
- 16:54reason why I think there aren't so many, so much, so much
- 17:00argumentation and strife and, and, and, and, and, and, and
- 17:03toxicity in these discussions. And why influence influencers
- 17:07are able to, to, to leverage so much emotion is because there
- 17:12must be something there that grabs people, that affects
- 17:14people profoundly. And and that's part of my
- 17:17analysis of what politics is about why it is my the book,
- 17:20I've called it beyond power. And I suggest that that's my
- 17:27understanding that it's, it's a lot to do with power and and
- 17:30power is what motivates people very profoundly.
- 17:34Impotence and and and empower and not having power.
- 17:38That's why it's able to grab people.
- 17:42And, and I also think that's part of anti-Semitism is
- 17:44indirectly very much related to that.
- 17:48I don't know if you want to get into discussion of that or
- 17:50whatever. Yeah.
- 17:52Can you, I don't, there's only like 1 very specific question.
- 17:56I don't want to ask when we get there naturally, but but I do.
- 17:59I would like to discuss the the rise of anti-Semitism because
- 18:03we're seeing that here in America and it's it seems like
- 18:08there's different reasons for it and different groups of people.
- 18:12But, you know, like, some people are upset that Israel has too
- 18:18much control. Others are mostly just, well,
- 18:21we're supposed to be America first, not Israel first.
- 18:23But like, that doesn't, you know?
- 18:27So yeah, if you want to, I'd like to go into that a bit.
- 18:30Yeah, there's a few elements to that.
- 18:32So first of all, you're alluding to, yes, the, the argument that
- 18:35is very commonly made that America seems to be too involved
- 18:40in Israel and to and, and, and the argument that the case is
- 18:44made that the Jewish lobby in America is, is, is, is
- 18:50influencing American policy, perhaps against the interests of
- 18:54America itself. And I've, I've dedicated a
- 18:57chapter to that. That's called it responding to
- 18:59Candice Owens. She was one of the first ones to
- 19:01clearly articulate the isolationists sort of it's
- 19:04called approach that America would do better to, to extricate
- 19:09itself from Israel, from supporting Israel from the
- 19:11Middle East. And maybe that would make
- 19:13America far a far more safe and and prosperous place without so
- 19:19much being invested in so much paying such a they do pay a
- 19:23price in terms of security, in terms of in terms of diplomacy,
- 19:27maybe in terms of economics and in terms of focus.
- 19:32There's a lot of focus on that. So that definitely is a point I,
- 19:40I respond to that first of all in, in to whenever I hear the
- 19:44argument made, the case made, the accusation levelled that the
- 19:50Jewish lobby in America is far too powerful and Trump is in
- 19:52Netanyahu's pocket all sorts of like it's a caricature, but it's
- 19:59presented in a it represents a lot.
- 20:02There's a deep resentment, one could say, of that and.
- 20:07My response first of all, to that is it's not that the the
- 20:10Jewish lobby. That's not why that's the Jewish
- 20:14lobby would not be effective if there wasn't a very deep
- 20:18sentiment pro Israel sentiment that is very deeply embedded in
- 20:23American Society as a whole. And yes, the Jewish lobby maybe
- 20:26is is is quite effective. You can argue how effective is
- 20:31it in, in, but, but it's only effective in rallying and, and
- 20:35leveraging the, the, the sentiment, the deep sentiment
- 20:38that lies there, the deep sentiment and, and affinity that
- 20:41America has for Israel at least once.
- 20:45It was completely across the board in American political
- 20:48society. And that's becoming a little bit
- 20:50more divided between left and right.
- 20:52But nevertheless, there is a deep sentiment felt.
- 20:56And therefore, I would, I argue it's not the Jewish lobby, it's
- 20:59it's the American people themselves have a close affinity
- 21:02for Israel. And, and, and therefore argue
- 21:05maybe one has to understand why that is.
- 21:07Is it just a sentimental, is it biblical?
- 21:09Is it religious? What is it?
- 21:11And, and I make the case, I, I like, argue the case against
- 21:15like if it's just based on sentiment or religious grounds,
- 21:20is that a justification for America to, to, to be so
- 21:24involved in Israel and to pay to give so much credit to Israel
- 21:27and so much aid to Israel? Would that justify it?
- 21:30And I, I, I, I look for a deeper substantive pro American
- 21:35argument and our basic pro American arguments that are made
- 21:39why it isn't America's interest to be pro Israel arguments like
- 21:45the, the security collaboration gives America greater Israeli
- 21:50intelligence, etcetera. The counter argument to that
- 21:52would be On the contrary, it's the collaboration that requires
- 21:55that renders America more vulnerable security wise become
- 21:59a target for extremist Muslim or Middle East terrorism because of
- 22:03the support for Israel. So that sort of negates that
- 22:06argument. Other arguments are economic or
- 22:10or technological. There's a lot of technological
- 22:12development, which definitely is true, but is that sufficient
- 22:18justification? So, so the real justification in
- 22:22my opinion comes from a deeper understanding of of geopolitics
- 22:26itself. It's a geopolitical, there's a
- 22:28deeper or we can go into anti-Semitism.
- 22:32There's two different things, anti-Semitism, they're all
- 22:35founded on similar concepts. So maybe we can talk first about
- 22:38geopolitics if you want. Sure, Yeah, and.
- 22:40Then we can get to anti-Semitism.
- 22:43Or do you want to start? Where do you want to start?
- 22:45It's up to you. Yeah, let's not.
- 22:46I want to. Oh, you know, no, you're fine.
- 22:49Yeah. So I guess I, I'd like to start
- 22:53with geopolitics. I with, with Trump's second term
- 22:57here, he has been really involved on the geopolitical
- 23:02side and, and I think a lot of people don't quite the problem
- 23:09here in America is that people everyone's in politics into
- 23:12politics now. Everyone's putting in their
- 23:15having an opinion. A lot of people don't understand
- 23:18what information, the information they're consuming.
- 23:21So and I and I think with the Geo geopolitical side, a lot of
- 23:26people don't understand very much.
- 23:29I'm not trying to call people stupid, but it's it takes an
- 23:32understanding. This isn't something that you
- 23:34can just. Because it's hard, because there
- 23:36are so many geopolitical epicenters and and and and
- 23:41events and episodes that are occurring and and do they
- 23:45necessarily? Is there a correlation between
- 23:47them? I've looked for an underlying
- 23:49logic and I'm going to propose there is an underlying logic
- 23:51that can make sense of it to make that would be useful, I
- 23:55would hope. And, and, and it would explain
- 23:57Israel as well. I'm offering really a, a, a new
- 24:00understanding for the Middle East itself based on that.
- 24:03So I guess I'm going to start then with geopolitics.
- 24:07So let's take the conflict in the Ukraine.
- 24:11Let's start with that and try to understand that maybe.
- 24:15And I started with a basic question, Why did Vladimir Putin
- 24:20and Russia, why did they take such a seemingly out of the
- 24:25blue, such a dramatic step of initiating war, a full out war,
- 24:32war almost of annihilation, attrition and attempt
- 24:34annihilation of, of, of a neighbor that ostensibly was in
- 24:38no way a threat militarily to them?
- 24:43That's a very perplexing question, which I don't know if
- 24:47it's people think about it enough.
- 24:49It's almost like assumed, yes, that's they were a threat and
- 24:52that's it. And now they've gone to war and
- 24:53let's just deal with the war. I want to understand why, why,
- 24:56why? There must be some deep seated
- 24:57reason why Russia thought it was necessary to go to war.
- 25:05There's never been a war in Europe for like a real war since
- 25:07Bosnia or whatever and and Yugoslavia.
- 25:10It's a real war between east and West for 60-70 years.
- 25:12Fortunately, since there were or even before that, there was
- 25:15never a war. It was a Cold War.
- 25:16There was never an active war. Suddenly we're actually in a
- 25:18war. Real life modern day 21st
- 25:20century war. Why is that?
- 25:23Do you ever I'm asking you maybe, maybe I shouldn't.
- 25:26Am I allowed to ask the interview do?
- 25:27You have an opinion of why? Why is that happening?
- 25:29Yeah. The theory here is that he is
- 25:35that we had a weak President Biden and that he saw an
- 25:40opportunity to get away with grabbing more territory.
- 25:45I'm not saying that's correct, but that's.
- 25:48In other words, it's primarily it was like it was colonial
- 25:52colonialism almost. You're saying Russia wants to
- 25:54expand his colonial interests, maybe his economic interests?
- 25:58Yeah, yeah, basically. And then also isn't, isn't
- 26:03there. He believes he has the right to
- 26:05some of this territory as well. Yeah, there's some historical
- 26:08claim and the Russian people and the Ukrainian people are close
- 26:10related. Maybe it was once part of the
- 26:12original Russian Confederate. Nevertheless, are these reasons
- 26:17good enough to go to war? I mean, I don't think Russia has
- 26:20gained economically particularly from this war.
- 26:23And I think it was maybe quite predictable take over a country
- 26:26and not pay a huge price. Therefore, I, I, I, I, I, I'm
- 26:30using this as a model to explain what I think is a fairly simple
- 26:34geopolitical reality dynamic that underlies everything.
- 26:40And it's, it's, it's based basic, it's based on democracy.
- 26:44The term in the West we have democracy.
- 26:47Democracy is the rule of the people.
- 26:49And I draw distinction. I, I don't know if I'll get into
- 26:52a conceptual distinction, but there's, there's two types of,
- 26:55of societies. There's a society that rules
- 26:57itself, that's democracy. And there's a society that does
- 27:00not rule itself, that's ruled by others.
- 27:02That's authoritarian socialism or dictatorship, whichever
- 27:08communism, whichever form, but they're not democracy.
- 27:10There's democracy and there's controlled a country being
- 27:13controlled by the people controlling itself its own
- 27:15destiny politically or a country being controlled by a regime or
- 27:19a dictator. And that is the fundamental
- 27:22mover, I think in geopolitics, because I argue when you have a
- 27:28dictatorship, dictatorship confers an incredible amount of
- 27:33power on those that are privileged to be in the ruling
- 27:36regime. They control the whole country.
- 27:38They have every they control everything.
- 27:41What for them and and power corrupt because why does power
- 27:45corrupt? Because power is the lure of
- 27:47power is, is so incredibly powerful.
- 27:50Nobody who has power is willing generally to link, relinquish
- 27:53it. And absolute power corrupts
- 27:55absolutely because absolute power you're never going to
- 27:56relinquish. And, and, and dictators and
- 27:59people in power historically and, and it's basic, it's a
- 28:01basic facet of human nature. However much power they have,
- 28:04they're going to be obsessed with securing that power,
- 28:09maintaining that power and, and, and, and responding to any
- 28:13perceived threats to that power. That's the basic dynamic, I
- 28:16think the mindset of of of a dictator and and the ruling
- 28:20regime. Yeah.
- 28:22When you have a dictatorship neighboring with a democracy,
- 28:29particularly where there's an affinity, a cultural and racial
- 28:32affinity linguistic between the two countries, they're closely
- 28:36affiliated and the dictate the democracy by virtue of being a
- 28:40democracy is successful culturally, economically,
- 28:44diplomatically. So what's that going to
- 28:47engender? What's going to happen?
- 28:49The result of that is going to be that the neighboring country,
- 28:51the population are going to start looking themselves to that
- 28:56democracy and saying hey, these guys have got rights.
- 28:58These guys have got freedom, freedom of speech, freedom of
- 29:01thought, freedom of business, freedom of commerce, everything.
- 29:04And they're being successful and they appear to be having a great
- 29:07life, an improved life. And they're going to start to
- 29:10entertain the thoughts themselves.
- 29:12Why can't we have that? Maybe we should entertain that.
- 29:14And what's that going to, what's the response going to be that?
- 29:17What is that? That is a tremendous threat that
- 29:20is like the the greatest threat for the ruling regime of a
- 29:23dictatorship, the the aspirations of the populace for
- 29:28political freedom and independence, because that
- 29:30basically is an existential threat to their ruling, to their
- 29:32power, to their privilege, to everything they have.
- 29:35That I think is why Putin felt that was what motivated.
- 29:41That's a fundamental motivation for him seeing and and framing
- 29:46Ukraine as a threat. It's not a threat read to
- 29:49Russia. He framed it in in one of his
- 29:50speeches he spoke about that was a threat to the Russian people.
- 29:53I don't think it's a threat to the Russian people.
- 29:55I think it's an opportunity almost to the Russian people.
- 29:57It's a threat to the ruling regime.
- 30:00And that was why he felt that the threatened existentially his
- 30:03rule and that of the ruling regime felt so threatened and
- 30:07therefore, to the extent that they were prepared to engage in
- 30:09war. That's the first geopolitical
- 30:14example. The other one, which I think we
- 30:17can't go into too many, but I think is Taiwan.
- 30:21OK. Let's look at Taiwan.
- 30:23There's there's a tremendous amount of tension existing
- 30:26between China and Taiwan. China claims that Taiwan is part
- 30:31of the Chinese Republic from historically etcetera.
- 30:33And therefore it's ours. It's a very undemocratic claim,
- 30:37but that's what they claim. And, and they, they're very
- 30:40prepared to, to, to take affirmative action to enforce
- 30:45that. There's all sorts of military
- 30:48maneuvering and, and, and plans. And it had, it's very clear if
- 30:51they would have the opportunity, they would take Taiwan by force,
- 30:55no question about it. Similarly, similar to the
- 30:58takeover, the Chinese takeover of Hong Kong, they, they, they,
- 31:02they maneuvered very determinedly to, to, to secure
- 31:07Hong Kong from the British and to limit the Hong Kong
- 31:10democratic freedom. So again, why is that?
- 31:13Why is China obsessed with Taiwan?
- 31:15And America is only the American defense, the robust American
- 31:19defense of Taiwan that has prevented it.
- 31:24So why is that? Why is China obsessed with
- 31:26Taiwan? And the answer, I think again,
- 31:28is because China is very much based on it's a communist or
- 31:31socialist regime where there's a lot of power concentrated with
- 31:35the ruling regime. And for them, Taiwan, an
- 31:40independent, democratic, successful nation, is a threat
- 31:44to the whole Chinese, not an empire, the whole Chinese
- 31:50Republic, whatever. If, if they are allowed to
- 31:53achieve independence, that's going to give the Chinese like
- 31:56they had in Taiwan, Taiwan, Taiwan Square.
- 32:01The Chinese do obviously have entertain thoughts of
- 32:04independence and therefore Taiwan is a threat, is very much
- 32:08a threat to the ruling regime and that I think explains why
- 32:11that is why the Chinese obsession with Taiwan.
- 32:14Yeah, that makes complete sense. So, so that in my understanding
- 32:20is the fundamental force and and and and and the motivation that
- 32:25explains the the basics of, of, of geopolitical, these
- 32:29geopolitical conflicts and tensions.
- 32:33Sorry to interrupt, I just wanted to tell you about my
- 32:36sponsors real quick. Are you looking for a gift for a
- 32:39music lover? Or maybe some apparel to show
- 32:41off your quirky side? Old Glory has you covered.
- 32:44With over 300,000 officially licensed items covering music,
- 32:48sports, entertainment and pop culture, you're guaranteed to
- 32:51find the perfect item. They even have seasonal gear.
- 32:54My husband enjoys The Beatles and Led Zeppelin apparel and I
- 32:57love the Billy Idol apparel. I even found items for my fellow
- 33:01plant enthusiasts. This family owned superstore is
- 33:04known for their quality and customer service.
- 33:06Offers free standard shipping on all orders and orders are
- 33:10shipped the same day you purchase.
- 33:12My discount code gives you 15% off your entire order and it's
- 33:15currently the best deal available.
- 33:17Just visit oldglory.com and enter in my promo code JADE.
- 33:21That's JADE at checkout. Looking for a game changing way
- 33:27to improve your health? Zevo Life is the world's most
- 33:30nutrient dense whole plant packed with over 50% plant
- 33:33protein, essential amino acids, fiber and antioxidants.
- 33:37Harnessing the best nature has to offer, Zevo Life nourishes
- 33:41your body while driving your performance, vitality and
- 33:44overall well-being. Each serving is a concentrated
- 33:47source of clean, well balanced nutrition designed to support
- 33:51modern lifestyles. And just one teaspoon a day
- 33:53supports your gut, boosts energy and promotes healthier skin and
- 33:57tear. It's no wonder that it's
- 33:59receiving rave 5 star reviews. Step into a healthier future
- 34:02with a 30% discount and a 30 day risk free guarantee by visiting.
- 34:07ZIVO. Dot life and using my promo code
- 34:11to support my show and to receive 30% off your entire
- 34:14order and to my promo code Jade that's JA.
- 34:18DE at checkout I was also thinking about I was talking to
- 34:22someone from Iran that was part of the resistance and she was
- 34:27explaining that it's more of a broader pattern to anytime
- 34:33there's someone new entering into the dictatorship.
- 34:36It seems like, seems like they're fine, seems like they
- 34:39want to make changes, but the longer they're in and the more
- 34:42power they get, the the less they care about the people that
- 34:46they're supposed to be. Because.
- 34:49They're representing of their own.
- 34:50Power. Absolutely.
- 34:52Where, where where you seeing that?
- 34:53And around, you mean every time there's a new president, Prime
- 34:55Minister, he'd so talk about reform and there is hope of
- 34:59reform. Ultimately it's it's it doesn't
- 35:02proceed anywhere. Yeah.
- 35:03Because, yeah, the ruling regime is concerned with power, whether
- 35:07that individual themselves perhaps would be willing to
- 35:09grant more power, but those around them are also threatened.
- 35:13Yep, the ruling regime are, therefore they won't allow it to
- 35:16occur. And yes, that's very much what's
- 35:18happening in Iran. And that's my that's so that's
- 35:21my take. In actual fact, very simple.
- 35:24I'm offering of a simplistic take on on on a geopolitical
- 35:29conflict that's baffled, baffles the world, that baffles me,
- 35:32baffles everyone. The Middle East.
- 35:34Why is the Middle East so obsessed with Israel?
- 35:37Yeah. Why?
- 35:38What is this obsession? Is it purely a self
- 35:40determination issue for the Palestinians or is it more than
- 35:43that? So if I've argued an actual fact
- 35:46that we take this geopolitical principle that I'm trying to
- 35:50argue that actually explains maybe what's going on in the
- 35:53Middle East. Because for hundreds or even
- 35:56thousands of years, the Middle East was, was has been run to
- 36:01whatever extent there were countries.
- 36:02But whatever the society itself was always, it was never a
- 36:06democratic society. Democracy has only been in
- 36:09Europe for like 500 years. The Middle East has been based
- 36:13on the ruling regimes and the the ruler, the king, the
- 36:16emperor, whatever he is exercising full control over the
- 36:20citizenship. So when this my theory, when
- 36:25Israel came along and planted itself in the Middle East, it
- 36:29was very much importing and importing democratic ideals.
- 36:34It was it was setting itself up as a democratic outpost.
- 36:39I'm going to argue that the Jewish state is really the
- 36:42source of democracy itself. I argue somewhere else.
- 36:44That's why it's particularly acute threat.
- 36:48So I argue that that's why that's really the alarm that the
- 36:52countries in the Middle East felt towards Israel, because
- 36:54they're not democracies and they saw Israel developing and
- 36:58thriving as and and functioning as a democracy even pre 1948
- 37:03before it became officially a state.
- 37:04But it was very much operating on democratic ideals.
- 37:09And that I think was the real threat.
- 37:12The real that was what really my understanding was what
- 37:16powerfully motivated and threatened the regime, the
- 37:19ruling regime, not the people themselves.
- 37:21Initially the the Palestinian indigenous population, from my
- 37:26understanding, my reading of history were very welcoming to
- 37:29the Jewish settlers came in the 19th, 20th century.
- 37:33They were building the country up.
- 37:34It was for everyone's benefit. But when the, the ruling regime
- 37:39started realizing that this is actually a threat to their rule,
- 37:44there's, they're empowering the population, empowering the
- 37:46people to seek a better life, to seek a more independent life.
- 37:49It's, it's, it's affecting the power structures themselves.
- 37:53That was when the, the, the, the, the, the extreme opposition
- 37:57to the Zionist movement crystallized around that, around
- 38:01that theme. That, in my opinion, is what has
- 38:04really been responsible for perpetuating the, the, the, the,
- 38:09the, the conflict. It's, it's the threat to power
- 38:13of all the regimes. And if you look at there's a
- 38:14correlation even between the degree of opposition to Israel
- 38:18and the degree of freedom and democracy in that particular
- 38:21regime. Most extreme example being like,
- 38:23as you mentioned, Iran. Iran is probably the most
- 38:27repressive of all the regimes and it's the most hostile
- 38:30towards Israel, close second. Or maybe Lebanon and Syria,
- 38:36Libya further away, but of the immediate neighbor neighbors,
- 38:39Libya, Lebanon and Syria, which are also more repressive regimes
- 38:45and we're more implacably anti Israel.
- 38:48You have in the middle countries like Egypt, which has become
- 38:52more democratic. You have the United Arab
- 38:56Emirates, which is more democratic or is more benign as
- 38:59a dictatorship who wants the best for his people.
- 39:02These are less threatened by Israel and therefore they're
- 39:04able to come to a political accommodation with Israel.
- 39:08That's the my understanding of the Middle East.
- 39:14It's quite a innovative. It's, I think it's a new
- 39:17understanding to a certain extent, but now coming back to
- 39:20America. Yeah.
- 39:22So, so, so I'm arguing very like a deep argument here.
- 39:28I'm suggesting what would happen is there be no Israel?
- 39:30What would happen if Israel I, I, I, I, I, I, I present the
- 39:35theoretical scenario. Let's say America would the the
- 39:38aspirations and the dreams and the fantasies of the anti Israel
- 39:42camp would be realized and America would say, yeah, we're
- 39:44now no longer invested in Israel or withdrawing political
- 39:48support, withdrawing economic support, withdrawing and
- 39:52diplomatic support. What would happen to Israel?
- 39:54What would happen at all in the world?
- 39:57And Israel in all likelihood, I think would be severely
- 40:03challenged. I don't think it would be able
- 40:05to really endure. For particularly long it would
- 40:09embolden the, the, the, the, the enemies of Israel would
- 40:12gradually even those who are perhaps positively predisposed,
- 40:17predisposed towards Israel currently.
- 40:19But I think there would there would be a turn against Israel
- 40:21and Israel would be, I don't want to even say it, but up in
- 40:26war and be annihilated. And where would that leave the
- 40:28world? Where would that leave the
- 40:30world? Where would that leave the
- 40:34Middle East? Where would the Middle East be
- 40:35without Israel? It wouldn't.
- 40:38It wouldn't be better off, that's for sure.
- 40:40It would probably it would I, I project my argument is it would
- 40:45descend into it would once again revert to the the the
- 40:51dictatorship type of regime which the populace would be
- 40:56suppressed and there'd be just repressive regimes and what
- 41:01would the implication be then for America?
- 41:05So this I'm coming back now backing up to geopolitics.
- 41:10In geopolitics, it's seen as America against Russia, America
- 41:14against Iran, and America against China.
- 41:17That's the three major geopolitical fronts America is
- 41:20faced with. And if you think about them,
- 41:22they're all very much, why is that?
- 41:24Why? Why is geopolitically has
- 41:27America facing all these sort of this sort of Cold War?
- 41:32Why are they challenged by these nations?
- 41:35And I'm arguing it's the same geopolitical dynamic because
- 41:38America as a democracy is a threat to China.
- 41:41It's a threat to Russia. It's a threat to Iran, where
- 41:45America itself means no harm. America has no aspirations to
- 41:48attack China or to do anything to China.
- 41:50It's a democratically why would they just want to thrive and be
- 41:53prosperous, nothing else. Yeah, China views America, I
- 41:56think, as China is the one that and Russia and Iran view America
- 42:00to a certain extent as the enemy.
- 42:01They're responsible for the tensions.
- 42:02That's what I'm arguing, because America is a threat as a
- 42:06democracy and therefore they have to frame the relationship
- 42:09with America as one of an enemy. Therefore, take extrapolating
- 42:13from that, I'm saying if the Middle East would be left
- 42:16without Israel to its own devices, it would probably
- 42:19descend, deteriorate into dictatorships.
- 42:23Iran would acquire far more influence, and the implications
- 42:26would be for America. That America then would be the
- 42:29Great Satan again would be the threat.
- 42:31There wouldn't be the the fantasy of this close
- 42:34relationship and cooperation between America and the Middle
- 42:37East. I don't think that would happen.
- 42:38I think that the Middle East would be forced through Iran and
- 42:41the other more extreme regimes into a position of with the old
- 42:43dictatorships, who would therefore naturally align one
- 42:46with another, with Iran, with China, with Russia against
- 42:50America. America would find itself a
- 42:52natural fact isolated in a world that would be extremely
- 42:59antithetical towards America. We just like would would view
- 43:04America as a threat. Therefore America's geopolitical
- 43:07and long term geopolitical standing would be far more
- 43:10prejudice without Israel. Therefore, my argument is I
- 43:14think people implicitly understand, but as part of the
- 43:16deep sentiment, I'm coming back now.
- 43:18Deep sentiment of affinity for Israel's.
- 43:20Maybe based on this deep understanding, without Israel,
- 43:24the world will become a far more like dangerous place for
- 43:27America. Yeah, yeah.
- 43:29You know, and I, I, I don't think a lot of.
- 43:32People. No, no, you're fine.
- 43:35I don't. So I don't think a lot of people
- 43:38see it as that way. And it, I mean, it is kind of
- 43:40right in front of your face. There's China and Taiwan, Russia
- 43:43and Ukraine and, and I, I just don't think people understand
- 43:49the concept like we, we need to be sticking up for those that
- 43:54are, that are allies and those with democracies and.
- 44:00And I'm arguing this and it's in America's interest to support
- 44:02democracy. It's not just an ethical even or
- 44:05or or a, an emotional issue. It's a geopolitical strategic
- 44:12interest, I think, to support democracy because without
- 44:15democracy, a country that's non democratic is going to view
- 44:18America as as as an enemy, as a threat.
- 44:21Right. Yeah, that is why I think
- 44:24America does support democracy. It's on that.
- 44:26I think it's predicated on that understanding that it needs to,
- 44:31you know, to support democracy for its own standing, to make
- 44:34the world safer for democracy. Yeah, yeah, it's I I've also
- 44:41been kind of thinking about all of our all the pro Palestine
- 44:46protesters here in America and it, I just don't understand how
- 44:52well I do I I this is going to edge in the conspiracy theory
- 44:59land. But but we're finding proof that
- 45:02people are paying protesters to believe a certain to to
- 45:06represent that they feel a certain way.
- 45:08I think that's been pretty evident in the pro Palestine
- 45:12movement and it you know, it's it's not to say that people
- 45:16can't care for people on both sides and and I think I think
- 45:21that's important to to care about the people involved that
- 45:25are, you know, suffering because of their governments, but it.
- 45:30Doesn't produce solutions. No in.
- 45:32Israel doesn't produce solutions.
- 45:34No. And I can tell, I can tell you
- 45:37if you a lot of these protesters, if you were to ask
- 45:40them if they understand anything about what's going on, they most
- 45:45of them don't. They're just there because
- 45:48they're following others that. Seen a lot of disturbing issue
- 45:53images in the media. No question about it on the.
- 45:57Yeah, yeah, but but I don't think that they're understanding
- 46:01any of it because there's money behind it.
- 46:03You get people outraged and they're just mad, and that's all
- 46:07they know is that they're mad. You know, yeah, I mean, it seems
- 46:13to be associated with what's called the progressive radical
- 46:17left movement is that. Would you agree with that?
- 46:22Yep. So I've tried to understand that
- 46:27why are they because they if there is a lot of finance going
- 46:30into it, but they obviously are finding fertile ground.
- 46:33There is a latent sort of anti Israel and it seems to go anti
- 46:38Israel, seems to go together with anti America, anti
- 46:41patriotism. Yeah, yes, You know, I, so I
- 46:47used to vote Democrat. I used to be on the left, and I
- 46:52lived in a very liberal city, and I realized that if you go
- 46:59against the grain at all, you're a bad person, you know, or
- 47:04whatever. And it's like, oh, so we can't
- 47:07think independently. They don't see and I see that.
- 47:11Yeah, yeah. And I see that the right is kind
- 47:13of starting to do that a little bit in America here now too,
- 47:16but. That's partly politics has taken
- 47:20hold of it and everything is about the the, the struggle for
- 47:23power. Yeah, yeah, Unfortunately,
- 47:27inhibit everything you have to identify.
- 47:29It's political. Identification is everything,
- 47:32yeah, because power is so all consuming, and this is.
- 47:35Really. What I'm saying geopolitically,
- 47:36power seems to be to be like motivating everything and, and,
- 47:44and, and that's internationally and also in internally it's,
- 47:48it's about power. And that's, I don't know if you
- 47:51want to talk about that that, but that's what's behind it, I
- 47:53think. That's, you know, that's the
- 47:56reoccurring theme of almost anyone I talk to from any side,
- 48:01from any, any country, any angle.
- 48:04It's I mean, everyone can recognize that power is the
- 48:09driving force to all the division, basically everything.
- 48:15But what do we do about it, you know?
- 48:18So that's chapter. Ten.
- 48:21Yeah, well, let's go. Let's go into it.
- 48:23OK, I, I, I argue that it seems to me we're very divided in
- 48:28society. Maybe I'm going to articulate
- 48:31what you're saying. You're saying it seems to be
- 48:34about power. Because I, I looked at Israel, I
- 48:37looked at America, I looked at Europe, I looked at democracy in
- 48:40general. And on the one hand, it seems to
- 48:41be extremely divided and, and, and passions are high and is
- 48:45toxic. On the other hand, if you look
- 48:47in society as a whole, look in the workplace and maybe in
- 48:50families and education and culture, whatever it is, people
- 48:54seem to get on when they don't talk about certain topics,
- 48:58people get on, people collaborate, people are friendly
- 49:01and maybe they're not as divided as they would have as believe.
- 49:03There are many good friendships between individuals on the right
- 49:07and the left and and the collaborations and businesses
- 49:10and they function perfectly well.
- 49:11They're all good people, which said to me, therefore, that
- 49:15maybe we're not actually divided, but it's politics
- 49:18that's dividing us when it comes to politics.
- 49:20When we speak about politics, when we get involved in
- 49:22politics, then we become divided.
- 49:24The tensions rise. So it seems to be the politics
- 49:27itself is what's dividing meaning political power.
- 49:32So I don't think we're going to have time.
- 49:34I'm not going to waste too much time to get into a whole detail.
- 49:37But basically I, I've argued that it's political power.
- 49:40It's the the, the struggle for political power that is
- 49:45toxifying that is, is, is causing this.
- 49:49And the reason, partly I think the reason is because our
- 49:54democracy itself, democratic model is ours itself, is
- 49:56encouraging this to a certain extent.
- 50:00And like you're saying, what can we do?
- 50:02You know this. Is great we.
- 50:04Can't ideally maybe the ideal form of of rule as well as we
- 50:08have in the religious community where we have the great
- 50:11spiritual leaders, the great rabbis.
- 50:12They control everything. They're people who are, you
- 50:15know, ethically have no, you know, they're ethically
- 50:18completely elevated and, and and they have no interest.
- 50:22That maybe is what would work best for society as a whole, but
- 50:26it's obviously not going to be in the end.
- 50:28It has to be democracy. It has to be elected leaders.
- 50:31No one's going to agree who the spiritual leaders should be.
- 50:34So the democratic model itself, I think is perhaps responsible
- 50:38and, and I'm arguing it, it's actually not completely
- 50:41democratic if you think about it, because what is, what do
- 50:45elections determine the determination of an election
- 50:49generally is? Is it going to be Trump or is it
- 50:51going to be Harris or? Right, right.
- 50:55It's it's a binary question and it's whoever gains essentially
- 50:5851% of the vote, the successor is the victor, is the political
- 51:02victor. And how much power do they get
- 51:04for that 51% of the vote? All of.
- 51:08It 100%. Yeah. 51% of the population.
- 51:13The representatives of the population control 100% of the
- 51:15power. That you could argue is is is
- 51:19undemocratic to a certain extent.
- 51:22It's not fair that the 49% are thereby forced to submit
- 51:26themselves to the rule of the the majority, the 51% majority
- 51:32and those two politicians who actually control have acquired
- 51:35that of power. Therefore, democracy in actual
- 51:38fact confers almost absolute unlimited power to a certain
- 51:41extent. Therefore, if I if I redefine
- 51:43democracy, it's not truly democracy.
- 51:46It's, I would say it's electing all powerful leaders, electing
- 51:50monarchs, it's choosing who your all powerful dictator is almost.
- 51:55And that's why that's why I think elections create so much
- 52:00tension and so much, so much as is is predicated on the
- 52:03elections, because the victor is going to have absolute power and
- 52:06the one who's not in power is going to have to submit
- 52:09themselves to absolute rule of somebody else.
- 52:12Therefore it's all about absolute power and therefore,
- 52:16and that's the source of all division.
- 52:18That's why it's, it's so emotive and so captivating.
- 52:21And therefore the solution I've suggested, the solution is the
- 52:24democratic model itself, that there should be a model that's
- 52:27more representative. There's not actually offering
- 52:30100% power to the 51% victor in the elections, but rather it's
- 52:35genuinely reflecting the, the wishes of the populist.
- 52:39The 49% also have their full 49% say in the, in the political
- 52:45governing system. That's the principle.
- 52:47Very briefly, briefly, I spent a whole chapter articulating what
- 52:51I how I think that model might look like.
- 52:55Yeah. You want to get into the
- 52:56technical detail? It might become boring if we
- 52:58might fall asleep. Well, so I mean also with the
- 53:03way that we have it, it's basically the the new president
- 53:09undoes as much as they can that as the previous president and it
- 53:14you know, in. Because power becomes the end
- 53:17itself. Because everyone's so focused on
- 53:19power, we don't even have time to think about policy.
- 53:22It's certainly not long term policy.
- 53:24It's about the personality who's most likely to win the election.
- 53:27Everything becomes focused on power, but power becomes the end
- 53:29in itself. And therefore, yes, they will do
- 53:31the the It's about competition between the two powers.
- 53:34The other side is viewed as an enemy because they're a threat
- 53:36to my absolute power. Right, right.
- 53:40And it's. Possibility of collaboration.
- 53:42Yeah. And you know, I mean the the
- 53:45previous president, they OK, I mean, they were elected.
- 53:50So some of the things they did, that's what the people wanted
- 53:53them to do. Absolutely.
- 53:54At that time. And that's I, I think that
- 53:57contributes to, to how people feel with with the elections and
- 54:02why it why it does. Disappointment and
- 54:05disillusionment with the political system.
- 54:09Yeah, I'm arguing a system that would be more genuinely
- 54:12representative of the wishes of the people would would would
- 54:15foster far greater belief and confidence in the system itself.
- 54:20Would would limit corruption. Would, would, would, would force
- 54:24politicians to to to focus on genuinely what's good for the
- 54:28people. Because it wouldn't be a fight
- 54:29that the system I'm proposing haven't explained it yet, but
- 54:33would would would focus more on issues rather than power.
- 54:37Yeah, do you? Do you want to explain it?
- 54:40We'll have readers by the. Book, but yeah, yeah, I'll try a
- 54:43little bit. OK OK, you'll tell me when you
- 54:46get bored or I'll see you falling asleep because the first
- 54:51point I I mentioned when I say this is it's a little bit more
- 54:53complicated than the current. The voting system is more
- 54:57complicated and that's presented as a potential objection.
- 55:00You know, nowadays we're we're spoiled.
- 55:02We have a binary determination. Is it Trump or Harris?
- 55:05Very easy, we just have to spend always watching all the various
- 55:09political drama and then we'll decide probably better than
- 55:11anything before. And that's actually my argument.
- 55:14My argument is if we're prepared to spend that waste, I call it
- 55:17waste. It's waste of time on the
- 55:19political drama. It's just like watching any
- 55:21other Hollywood wasting our time on the on the media.
- 55:24If we're prepared to invest so much time in following all the
- 55:27the drama. So let's spend 3 or 4 hours
- 55:29learning a new political system to to change the life of the
- 55:32whole country. It would be worth it.
- 55:34Therefore, in response to the, the, the, the, the, the
- 55:37objection that the my system is a bit more complicated, I'm
- 55:41saying I think it's definitely worth it and it's not lost time.
- 55:44You'll spend less time wasted on on on politics anyway.
- 55:48So yeah, OK, to give you a taste on the 1st element is what I
- 55:54call the pre election. Pre election, what do I call it?
- 55:58I have to remember pre election disclosure, pre election
- 56:01disclosure meaning there's no formal structured requirement
- 56:07for parties or candidates in America.
- 56:09You only have two parties, many regimes, you have multiple
- 56:11parties. There's no formal method by
- 56:15which they explain who they are. Like at the beginning of my
- 56:18interview I, I give an informal sort of explanation of who I am
- 56:23in politics. Actually you give something in
- 56:24general who I am and what I sort of believe in.
- 56:27I believe in trans rise, I believe in Israel.
- 56:29And that's basically sort of about the defence.
- 56:32It's quite vague. So I'm saying that's there
- 56:35should be more accountability and transparency when you're
- 56:38vying for something as important as power and part should be
- 56:41forced to make a structured pre election disclosure of where
- 56:46they actually stand substantially on all the
- 56:49cardinal issues. And education expands democracy,
- 56:54religion, whatever is important in society.
- 56:58And they should be able to. There should be like 10 or 20
- 57:00questions framed that quantify that, that describe these
- 57:04issues. Are you pro this, pro that
- 57:06against the abortion or whatever.
- 57:09And each party has to give a numerically graded number answer
- 57:14to where we stand on that from zero to 10 or from zero to 100
- 57:18or from -10 to plus 10, whatever you want, however you decide to
- 57:21actually do it. And that forces parties to
- 57:25really quantify where and explain to the public where they
- 57:28actually stand on the issues themselves.
- 57:30It's becoming already less about people, it's about the issues
- 57:33themselves. And, and you might say, I can't
- 57:36give a #2 how pro this or that I am.
- 57:40And right, it's not really scientific and mathematically
- 57:44susceptible of, of, of description.
- 57:46But that's in the interest of, of, of the system.
- 57:49I think it's far preferable than leaving things completely vague.
- 57:52Have an imperfect system that gives a number and people will
- 57:54know exactly where they stand. That's the first element.
- 57:59The second element is, is, is and one of the parameters more
- 58:03than this, one of the parameters that they have to parties have
- 58:06to express clearly where they stand is on the on the issue of
- 58:12collaboration and cooperation itself with other political
- 58:14parties. You have to tell us, the public,
- 58:17where do you stand on cooperation with the other
- 58:19parties? Are you pro pro cooperation?
- 58:21Are you anti cooperation, you pro collaboration or not?
- 58:25And it can either be a general, you know, could be a general and
- 58:29pro collaboration or it can be on even on a per party basis.
- 58:32I respond to each party I would want to attend cooperate with
- 58:35party A or not cooperate with them.
- 58:38And that I think will because my theory is my understanding or
- 58:42theory is that most people want cooperation.
- 58:45Most people are against the political infighting and and
- 58:48division that exists. Therefore, that will strongly
- 58:51motivate a party to present a pro cooperation agenda.
- 58:58Yeah, yes. You know, you know, and I, I
- 59:02mean, a lot of people I think are more in the middle than
- 59:06what, right, than what you would think.
- 59:09But we get forced into these categories and, you know,
- 59:13pressured to not veer off the path of the right or the left
- 59:17right. So here, so this system you can
- 59:19have also more nuanced, you can people can present a more
- 59:22nuanced opinion on each matter. But also it's very much like
- 59:28you're saying, I believe yeah, most people are on the political
- 59:30middle and are therefore very in favor of cooperation.
- 59:33And therefore parties that present themselves as being pro
- 59:36cooperation will I think be successful and that will
- 59:40motivate that should to motivate everyone to to think twice.
- 59:44Are we going to be against or pro cooperation?
- 59:47And, and even whether or not you make it a legal requirement to
- 59:50live up to that, I think the political system will self will
- 59:53motivate if you signify signal that we're pro cooperation.
- 59:57And then during the tenure when you you, you're anti, you do
- 1:00:00everything to thwart cooperation.
- 1:00:01No one's going to trust you the next election round.
- 1:00:04So yeah, basically there's a strong motivation to to to, to
- 1:00:07live up to what it is you're going to be professing and
- 1:00:10you've quantifiably. Very visibly stated where you
- 1:00:14stand on these issues on on the issue of cooperation, therefore,
- 1:00:17that creates a lot of accountability, political
- 1:00:20accountability. Yeah, Yeah.
- 1:00:23That would be. I mean, we need that.
- 1:00:26We need some accountability in there.
- 1:00:28Yeah, almost like score sheets. Yeah, yeah, Final, I think not
- 1:00:32the final, but maybe an important element.
- 1:00:34I, I, I would just want to mention already discussing would
- 1:00:37be the actual political power, how political power is actually
- 1:00:39distributed. The parties would when you vote
- 1:00:44for a party, a party itself, like I said, would have to
- 1:00:48express where it stands on each issue.
- 1:00:51How much is a pro this? How much is a pro that the
- 1:00:54election results? First of all, to be more, I
- 1:00:58would award for each person instead of a binary vote.
- 1:01:00One vote for Biden by for for Trump.
- 1:01:04You'd have 50 voting points, for example, which were built to
- 1:01:07distribute between the parties as you choose between each
- 1:01:10party, which gives you far greater the voter far greater
- 1:01:13control and say a nuanced ability to, to, to express his
- 1:01:17preferences. The voting results would then be
- 1:01:21translated into giving each party a, a, a a a a a
- 1:01:27representation based on how many points they had gained from the
- 1:01:30electorate based also on the factor of how they prioritized.
- 1:01:35So if you've prioritized education and you've got a high
- 1:01:38voter turn out in your party, you're going to get a high
- 1:01:41representation in the Ministry of Education because you've
- 1:01:45you're only allowed to, for example, you have to express,
- 1:01:48express also your priorities for which office would you
- 1:01:51prioritize on? You can't say I'm for everything
- 1:01:53and I want everything. The party is going to have to
- 1:01:55express their own priorities. Where do we prioritize?
- 1:01:58And the election results are going to accord them power based
- 1:02:02on graded power, on how much vote they acquired and what
- 1:02:07their priorities were. So it will create, I'm saying
- 1:02:12it, I'm not going into too much detail, but it will create
- 1:02:14ultimately envisage a system in which power is just distributed
- 1:02:19very much according to the will of the people in a very finely
- 1:02:24resolutioned format. Each ministry will not be
- 1:02:28governed absolutely by one party.
- 1:02:31It will be formed. It will be composed of
- 1:02:33representatives of each party where their voting rights will
- 1:02:39be according to the, the, the, the percentages they've gained
- 1:02:43for this particular office becoming a bit too technical
- 1:02:47now. And one more, yeah, can I say
- 1:02:50one more economy? Because it's really, it's really
- 1:02:52it's about cooperation that the each part, let's say take the
- 1:02:58Ministry of Education or Defence.
- 1:03:00Each party will, will submit 4 candidates for that office.
- 1:03:06There will be a requirement for each party in who's got any
- 1:03:12voting rights in this, in this office to reach an agreement of
- 1:03:16going how they're going to actually enact this mandate
- 1:03:21achieved, how they're going to actually collaborate together on
- 1:03:25this. They have to reach an agreement.
- 1:03:26They don't reach an agreement, then they can't function.
- 1:03:29The individuals who are representing the party cannot
- 1:03:31be, cannot occupy that office. Therefore, there'll be a strong
- 1:03:34incentive. Let's say the number one tires
- 1:03:37in each party try to get an agreement.
- 1:03:39They fail to, then it will fall to the number 2 representatives.
- 1:03:43If you can reach an agreement between all of you, you will be
- 1:03:45the ones in power managing this office, which creates a strong
- 1:03:49incentive for collaboration to reach an agreement.
- 1:03:52How we're going to run this together?
- 1:03:54Because if you don't reach an agreement, you're not going to
- 1:03:56be actually the individuals in power in this office.
- 1:03:58Yeah, yeah, I really like that. So, you know, sometimes when
- 1:04:05when we have elections, it's like, well, I really like this
- 1:04:08person, but if this person got it, I would I would also be
- 1:04:12happy. And you almost feel sad that
- 1:04:14that you have multiple people that you like that that didn't
- 1:04:18make it very far. It's forced into binary choice.
- 1:04:21Yes, and also the what do you, what do you think about like
- 1:04:26just two parties or? So, so I think so, yeah.
- 1:04:30I mean, it's debatable based on on on economic monopolies.
- 1:04:35Is it good to have just a very limited amount or is competition
- 1:04:38in multiple parties a good idea? So I suggest I argue with the
- 1:04:43system I'm proposing. It would naturally evolve, I
- 1:04:47think into multi parties. I think we'll be forced to
- 1:04:50because parties will be forced to define themselves
- 1:04:53ideologically and politically in a far more defined way.
- 1:04:56I think the current system, because power is everything, it
- 1:05:00allows people to be vague about the policies and and large
- 1:05:02parties can be like monolithic entities that hold multiple
- 1:05:07views. That's why you have parties
- 1:05:10which are not really one party as many nuances.
- 1:05:13So I think it would result and we can debate is that good or
- 1:05:16not in in smaller parties that are more ideologically coherent
- 1:05:21within themselves. I think that would be the
- 1:05:23result. I think overall that would be
- 1:05:25healthy because it will give representation to everyone in a
- 1:05:28dynamic of cooperation that does fostering cooperation.
- 1:05:31I think it would be good people. Everyone would feel represented.
- 1:05:33Like you said, you wouldn't have this disappointment.
- 1:05:35I wanted this guy, not this guy. You'll have everyone right,
- 1:05:38Everyone. Right.
- 1:05:42All right. I have one last question for you
- 1:05:46before at the end. I I'll ask you and if there's
- 1:05:50anything else you want the audience to know.
- 1:05:51But I have one last question. For you, I think I've spoken
- 1:05:53enough. I think I've spoken enough.
- 1:05:56What So the Gaza peace deal, do you think it's going to be
- 1:06:00successful? What are people thinking about
- 1:06:03that in Israel? There's two different questions.
- 1:06:06Do I think it's going to be, says a lot of people thinking.
- 1:06:09I think obviously there's a huge amount of of, of scepticism,
- 1:06:14maybe even cynicism, you know, are Trump's plans realistic?
- 1:06:20There's an understanding something has to happen to a
- 1:06:24certain extent. I don't know.
- 1:06:26You look at the art, Gaza was radicalized, was quite radical
- 1:06:32pre October the 7th. And the way I understand it is
- 1:06:36because of the political structure, because it was a
- 1:06:39dictatorship, wasn't a democracy, Democrat
- 1:06:41dictatorships radicalized because the ruling regime is
- 1:06:43forced to radicalize the population to maintain power.
- 1:06:46That was the the dynamic. So I argue the only real hope
- 1:06:50for Gaza is somehow obtaining democracy, somehow evolving
- 1:06:56towards our our leadership that's more concerned with the
- 1:06:58will of the people, the good of the people than obtaining power
- 1:07:03itself. So there are two cases in
- 1:07:04geopolitics, 2 notable cases in which dictatorships did evolve
- 1:07:09into democracy and that's Germany and Japan post World War
- 1:07:12Two. Yeah, the German, the Nazis and,
- 1:07:15and, and Japan who have become who have both become
- 1:07:18outstandingly successful democracies, going from absolute
- 1:07:21dictatorships to an emperor and A and a for a fear or whatever,
- 1:07:24who are more mongering and only wanted war to becoming
- 1:07:27successful democracies. And tragically, the way that
- 1:07:30occurred was only through their absolute military defeat by the
- 1:07:33the powers. When you have the absolute
- 1:07:36military defeat that somehow provided the opportunity for the
- 1:07:39country to do a reset. So in response to your question,
- 1:07:43so maybe in Gaza, however tragic and it's terrible what's
- 1:07:46happened in Gaza, there's been a lot of suffering.
- 1:07:48Maybe there's been an absolute overturn and maybe there's been
- 1:07:51a parallel to what happened in Germany and, and, and, and Japan
- 1:07:54that maybe allows a political real, real reset to Gaza.
- 1:07:59And maybe it will emerge despite the culture as a democracy.
- 1:08:05There's going to be a lot of the, the surrounding countries
- 1:08:08themselves that are not democratic are going to be
- 1:08:10threatened by this. In some ways.
- 1:08:11They're motivated not to allow that to happen.
- 1:08:14Therefore, it's an open, it's, it's a very complex question.
- 1:08:16Can it happen? Yeah, yeah, it it does sound
- 1:08:20like there's other countries involved with it that maybe
- 1:08:24would help help it be more. I think Trump was very clever on
- 1:08:28that initiative. He's, he's, he's got his
- 1:08:30initiative and he's got 50 countries, each one contributing
- 1:08:32a billion dollars. And for the rebuilding of, of,
- 1:08:36of Gaza, where do you think maybe Israel should be paying
- 1:08:38the $50 billion they knocked it out?
- 1:08:40Maybe. But I, I think it's
- 1:08:41diplomatically very clever because if you think about it
- 1:08:45till now, Hamas didn't really think twice before they would
- 1:08:49take a responsible actions that would result in, in, in, in
- 1:08:52destruction in Gaza. But now you've got the whole
- 1:08:55world basically invested very strongly in Gaza.
- 1:08:59I I would think and hope that that might itself cause the
- 1:09:02Gazan leadership to think that they're forced almost to
- 1:09:05cooperate. You've got 50 nations investing
- 1:09:07each a billion dollars. Can we really lightheartedly
- 1:09:10just to allow this to to, to take actions?
- 1:09:13They're going to result in the likely destruction of all this?
- 1:09:16Right, right. So therefore, I think Trump has
- 1:09:19approached this. Whatever you think of Trump, I
- 1:09:23think that was whether that will work and whether it was going to
- 1:09:26contribute or isn't really going to happen, I don't know.
- 1:09:28Historically hasn't worked till now.
- 1:09:30So I don't know. Maybe we're just going to carry
- 1:09:32on with this back and forth. I don't know.
- 1:09:36I hope it's successful. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:09:38I mean, the World Peace depends largely on this because Israel
- 1:09:43is such a powerful focus of world geopolitics.
- 1:09:47And so peace in the Middle East is is is is crucial for the
- 1:09:49world. Yeah.
- 1:09:52We'll just say maybe like I say, God does, maybe they want us to
- 1:09:55have peace. Maybe we're not.
- 1:09:56We don't behave ourselves enough when there is too much
- 1:09:58perspective. So maybe we just have to always
- 1:10:01be on on edge and on on our toes.
- 1:10:03Maybe that's just better for a spiritually, I don't know.
- 1:10:05I. Don't you know, I wonder that
- 1:10:08sometimes too, people. Want to hear that but.
- 1:10:12Yeah, is. Is there anything else you'd
- 1:10:15like the audience to know? No, I think I've said plenty,
- 1:10:19probably said too much. There's other things we could
- 1:10:21talk about. We didn't get so much on the
- 1:10:22anti-Semitism. Maybe that would be another
- 1:10:25talk. But then I want to thank you
- 1:10:26very much for for the opportunity.
- 1:10:28Of course, yeah. And I apologize, I've talked too
- 1:10:31much. I hope I made.
- 1:10:32Sense yeah, don't apologize. I like when I I learned a lot
- 1:10:38from the conversation, which means my audience is learning a
- 1:10:41lot too through this and that's that's what I like.
- 1:10:44And you're welcome back anytime if there's more you'd like to
- 1:10:47talk about. I think my main message is, is,
- 1:10:50is to try and inspire people to think for themselves, to think.
- 1:10:53Like you said, we people look at things they don't understand.
- 1:10:56I also look at many things don't understand.
- 1:10:58Let's try and think before we act, before we opinion, before
- 1:11:01we attack. Just let's think.
- 1:11:03And that that's the way forward, I think.
- 1:11:05Yeah, yeah, All right. Can you tell the audience where
- 1:11:08they could get your your both of your books?
- 1:11:11One of them they can't actually get.
- 1:11:13They'd have to come to my house. Because I was wondering that,
- 1:11:15yeah. Published yet that's the one on
- 1:11:19the religion and and then fundamentals and creation and
- 1:11:22all morality. That is, I wrote it and just I
- 1:11:25left it for a reason. The second one, which is what we
- 1:11:27discussed politics and geopolitics and society and
- 1:11:29democracy is available on Amazon, can be purchased as a
- 1:11:35paperback or downloadable as a for $3.
- 1:11:39It's only $3 to download it. OK.
- 1:11:41Thank you so much. Yeah, thank you.
- 1:11:43Thank you for being here today. And I will keep in touch with
- 1:11:48everything with the episode. So, OK, amazing.
- 1:11:50OK. Thank you so much.
- 1:11:52Have a great day. Yep, you too.
- 1:11:53You too.