Latest / FE exam in the car / PROFESSOR KRIS D'AOUT DISCUSSES MINIMALIST SHOES3
Transcript
- Welcome to Celebrity Exercise and Diet Secrets. We discuss how celebrities stay in shape and more. So let's get started. Welcome back everybody. Well today we're gonna have a fascinating conversation with a fascinating gas professor Chris Dot. That's d apostrophe ao ut d apostrophe aout. You can find him at Liverpool dot ac dot uk. Well who is he? You probably are asking, boy, He's a biomechanist or mechanist mechanist so anyway, are you gonna know what I mean? Biomechanist with a zoology background from Antwerp University in Belgium, with a longstanding interest in human locomotion. If you're thinking we're gonna be talking about walking, you're right, and also minimalist shoes as well. He works in the Evolutionary Morphology and Biomechanics Group of the Institute of Life, Course and Medical Sciences of the University of Liverpool. And we're gonna be talking about walking feet, minimalist shoes, shoes in general, and a whole lot more. But you know what to do before we get started, to make sure to share, subscribe and hit that I Like button. You know we like it. It's not wasting any more time. Welcome to the show, Professor Dode. Welcome, sir, Hello, nice to be you. Thank you for doing this. As I've talked to you before the show, I think it was a week or two ago. Feet keep coming up a lot of feet discussions lately, and toes and things. So I guess my first question to you, what got you interested in feet and shoes? Well, I've found a bit of a journey and you just said inn intro. I have asology background, so I've always been interesting in how animals move, so I've done a lot of research on apes for an exam PG was actually and how fish swim. So it's it's it's it's a bit of a long story how I got there, but how it happened is I'm not just zologist, but also very interesting one particular species, which is ourselves, humans, and we've done something quite spectacular and unique during our history, our ivolutionary history. We decided to walk on two feet, so we became upright creatures. And in fact, that decision between inverted commas, because it wasn't towardsn't just any decision obviously, but that has influenced us enormously. We can see anatomically adaptations throughout our bology. But the fact that we have these large brains, that we have such highly developed cognitive skills, etc. It all boils down to basically becoming upright creatures. So obviously feet are very interesting because once you are upright, you don't use their hands anymore to walk around. The only mechanical link to your environment is through your feet. So you can't be an efficient and effective bipet if you don't have highly functional feet. So that's how I became interested in feed to me feet a sort of what tires are to form all of ut racing cars. You might have the most powerful engine, you might have the best ierodynamics. If you don't stick to the road using your cars, you're not getting anywhere. So that's why I believe our feet are so important. But also clinically, not just biologically. Clinically, a lot of people suffer for food problems. So it's an interesting topic from from different angles, beat fundamental or clinical. You know, it's interesting. I know when we talked about before I had interviewed the podiatrists, I mean, this whole thing started with I'll give them a shout out cal Deetthlica train or River University of Minnesota, and we were talking about as athletes, and he trains a lot of Olympic athletes and it's one of the things that keeps standing out to me over the years. Thing has been doing it for twelve years. Was the big toe and how important the big toe was to everything, including the big toe in the butt were the two most important areas, he said for athletes where he saw the power to balance explosiveness. Explosiveness which is power. But he mentioned the big toe and did remind me of something I forgot to mention to you last time. It was interesting because I had worked years ago as a physical therapy aid and I remember an individual who was working as a machine shop and his toe got cut off. It was his big toe and he was having a heck of a time and trying to balance without it. It was really interesting to see it. He just really couldn't walk and people would think, you know, just one toe, but it was the big toe. Yeah. Yeah, Well it learned about because some people lose big toes, for instance, if after a trauma or maybe because they had diabetes, et cetera. It's possible, but big toes are definitely very important. And also if you look on an evolutionary scale between like a typical eight foot and arboreal foot, so made for life in the trees, and then how our feet evolved as hominiones, as early humans and eventually Homo Homo sapiens. That's one of the big changes happened. It is a shape and the position and the sturdiness of the big toe. If you look at our ancestors and also early hominies, the big toe was more of a grasping though it was maybe not much bigger than the other ones. It was set to the side, so what we say abducted, it looked a bit more like like a human hand. And what we see with the transition to like upright walking as a normal way of life, that the big toe became in line with the other photos to add to a very sturdy platform that allows us to push off very efficiently at the end of stands. And it also became very strong and stable, supported by a muscle as well as bones and ligaments. So the big from an evolutionary perspective, we definitely see huge changes in the big toe, and that has to mean that it's important to have a good big toe because evolution doesn't just happen at random, it's it's a result of selective pressure that help shape how our anatomy changes. But also if you look at it here and now, a lot of pressure go through the pig toe. If you if you take a measurement of how the pressure in the foot unrolls as we step from say a heel strike, and then we have our typical unrolled pattern to the toes. At the end of stance where we push off very strongly, that's when the center of pressure goes to the big toe. So evidently it plays, it plays a big role area. So having a strong big toe has to be important. That's crazy. It's really amazing because you don't think about it. You don't think about it much. I mean I never did before, and now it has changed alive. We're almost verty the seguay. It looks like to the minimal shoes before we get over there, wanted just just get your thought on something I thought about to The last conversation we had was not recorded, folks, it was pre interview, but um, I thought about the apes and how they kind of walk on their feet. They walk a lot more on their hands. It seems like they're kind of like quadrupeds. But then I thought about the kangaroo. Somebody mentioned the kangaroo to I mean, I thought, that's a good point, but I don't know they're people are not because they kind of hop talks about the kangaroo. So so when I say that we as humans are very special, that is compared to all the other primates. So if you look at more distant, distantly related groups, obviously all the birds are bipeds when on the ground because their their arms have developed into wings, um and more soupials there are another example of animals are bipeds, but that's a totally different kind of bipedoles and than humans. So if kangaroo's really hop and they are m full of all tendons, But the tendons function like very strong elastic bounds and the story and release energy when they jump or when they hop, which which is actually fascinating because they are very very efficient. If we walk, we don't we don't really do that, so we are less efficient in that sense. When we run, we also do use some storage and release of elastic energy, but we're not quite as good as it as a as in your kangaroos. No, it's interesting that I'm looking at thinking about physiology and concentric and excentric and just watching them bounce and how they probably store up energy the booms bring up exactly. This is not a kangaroo even I was wanted to talk about kangaroos. That's fascinating indeed. Um, so let's head over now. You know, people like to always were some people. There's some groups out there and just not a knock against them, but some people will say, hey, you know, we were cavemen or cave women or whatever they call it, hominids and all kinds of different names for these individuals. People like to always revert back some groups. Yeah, you know, this is the way we used to eat, this is the way we used to live. Which I don't know if they how much they really know about how they live in but how did they used to walk? Now? Because I remember the Bible, if you can count the Bible in the six thousand years, whatever it is it you want to do that if you believe in that. But you know the Egyptians and the Israelis, they used to use sandals. I remember, I remember correctly, But I'm talking way before the Sandal episode. Do you think they always walk barefoot? Did they use some kind of leaf or bark of trees or something or what do you think? Yeah? So, yeah, so we have done what every other single animal species does, which is walk barefoot. There are no animals at your shoes, and so we also haven't done it for well the first six to seven million years of our evolution as homilions, which means so actually walking upright is a diagnostic feature of of a hominium or an early human, if you will. So it's that important. So that's seven seven million years ago, so we're not talking about six thousand years. That's in another realm that we would be a topic of another post. I suppose I'm going to talk about science today, and that's it. So yeah, So the first so when I say seven million years ago, that's six million years something like that. That's when we became bipeds. But we looked very different. We looked much more like say, like a chimpanzee, more like a chimpanzee in terms of body proportions, et cetera. We were anatomically modern Homo sapience about one hundred thousand years ago, so one hundred thousand years ago, people looked exactly that they were our species. They looked exactly like us in terms of anatomy, et cetera. So if you if you moved with a machine one hundred thousand years flash forward to current life, you put them in the suit, you wouldn't you wouldn't notice that they are like us essentially, and we only we have the So the oldest shoes we found in the in the archeological record are about eight thousand, three hundred years old. Some reasons to believe that the old but of course you don't always find the very first show. That would be quite a coincidence. If you find something that, it's quite likely it has existed for a few years. So probably footwear was invented because it is it is a human invention, maybe twenty or thirty thousand years ago, but it is basically after we became anatomically modern. So that does say we can we can function very well without shoes. UM. On the other hand, and that's coming back to your your initial thoughts like shouldn't we shouldn't we do that because that's the biologically normal condition. Um, Now that's a trap we shouldn't fall into it's called naturalistic fallacy, and that would be assuming that everything which is natural is good and everything which is unnatural is bad. But there are so many examples of exceptions to that rule, it's not really a rule. Like all of medicine is basically unnatural. We try to fight things like fire, infections, et cetera. Which is it's natural to die of diarrhea as a child, but we need to fight as footwear is the same thing footwear in a way, you could say it's not natural, but that doesn't mean it can't have a role, it can't be useful to us, like so many other things. So even though I'm a biologist and always have this evolutionary background in the back of my mind and very wary of sort of extrapolating that everything which is natural has to be the best, well, I completely agree with it. Sometimes they'll say things like, you know, I don't want to get too far everything, but they'll say certain substances are good for you because they're natural. And I'm looking at the bachelorism of in a shielf with that thought. Pretty quick if you want to go that route, well, be dealed by the toxins of a black Beadow. He's perfectly natural. But that's right. Um, yeah, well I gotta go there. But yeah, it's interesting. And I just brought that up because I know sometimes people would argue with that, and I like the Hegelian principle a lot too, and I think we can apply it sometimes in this capacity, right, the thesis and antithesis ecosynthesis, And that's what kind of what we see over time, especially because cars changed a lot of things. And I don't know, it's always fascinating to see when things started. And I'm kind of drifting away for a second, but when did we start? Do you know when we started? You say we started using sandals around eight thousand years back? Do you know why? What was the reason back then? Was because of the roads or what was the deal? We can only guess, but back in that time, well there were no roads, as we know, probably earlier than that, so let's talk about maybe twenty thousand years ago. So, well, we see that these these sandals, these very early shoes, that they're very flexible, etc. So they don't provide any cushioning or support, but what they would do is provide us against trauma. So maybe it would feel more comfortable to walk over sharps and over rocks. Some of the old shoes they might insulate against against the cold, and I think those two functions are still important functions of footwear, just providing us with some comfort and protection. And that's what not just these very old shoes did, but actually most shoes until very recently did that. If we look at quite recently in our history, if we look at Roman shoes which are well documented, or Egyptian shoes two three thousand years ago, they are very minimal in a sense, so they are quite often made of leather or plant fiber, but very flexible. They might be decorated, but mechanically they didn't do much. They didn't they don't have heels or art support or cushioning or anything like that. All of these features came much later, even even in the last century, like cushioning, for example. Heels are a bit older than that, but they are probably not very functional. They might have had more like a status symbol where if you could afford heels, you could also physically stand up from from the dirt, which was very common in the streets, say in the Middle Ages. So there's a lot of reasons why our shoes became what they are today. Not all of them, and probably not many of them are actually by mechanically useful, and some of them are even by mechanically harmful. So we can almost say we were ordered backwards. With the minimal shoes of today, we're kind of going back to the original ones. Yeah, yeah, yeah, you could say that. But the thing is, some populations have never abandoned. So if you if you travel, you go to indigenous populations, some populations still where they've never stopped wearing these shoes that are helpful in terms of installation and protection but don't too much else. So if you look at like a mocasine or like the sandals that people in hot areas, if you go to Africa to Asia, people wear their historical shoes still to some extent, and so they've never they've basically skipped what we've done, which is have all these fancy issues with lots of features. They've they've stuck to what they knew worked for centuries. Interesting, they didn't let their ego get in the way. I want to look Daller, I want to look better. Yeah, but that's it. That's often why people where the shoes they do. It's nothing to do with by mechanics. It's to do with cultural aspects of footwear, and shoes have always had an important role in culture. It used to be a status symbol. And even now sometimes you hero, oh, these people are really good. They can't even afford choose. It's it's considered shoes have this very special position, like if you can afford good choose or shoes, that's you've achieved something that they are important culturally. It's interesting when I asked social psych students in the past, there's a chapter we talk about love and relationships, and there's one section of it with attraction. We talk about attraction and social psych And I said, what's the first thing you notice? When I asked the girls about boys, meaning if they're hedosexual, what's the first thing you notice about boys? Always say the same thing. It's the shoes. And it's like, oh, and that hasn't changed for years. I think. I remember they used to tell me that when I was single twenty years ago. It was the same thing. Girls, look at your shoes. It's like, really, look at my shoes. I don't even look at my shoes. Yeah, fascinating stuff. I think they think we look at their shoes, but I don't. I don't look at their ses. There's quite a lot of interesting research being don't actually on high heels. Yeah, yeah, so we know from a bi mechanical point of view, there's a lot we don't know about footwear. But one thing we definitely do know is that high heels are unhealthy. That's very well documented. But there's these interesting more like psychological studies on high eagles, and they do influence the way you walk, and that has a sexual signal and signaling function, so that they are they are functional in that sense sexual point of view, but not from a biomechanical point of view. It's interesting, that's very true. I'm gonna switch gears and head over to the minimal issues now. But minimal is shoes. Somebody who's telling me their predecious talking about things in Australia, we're talking about when you when you land the key acid, so the minimal shoes explaining that happens with the toes. What's your take on that? Is that accurate? Yeah? So it depends on whether we are running or whether we're walking. Their mechanically quite different, but also simplistically speaking, running involved much higher forces. So if we land during a run, yeah, then the food deforms and it can do so less if you have a constricting shoe with an arrow toebox, so that that's definitely true. Now, minimal shoes. I find it always funny to talk about minimal shoes because I think we should consider them as the normal shoes. Yeah, or most people, they're not. They're not on normal shoes. Normal shoes would be what you find in most shops. But actually these are very special to me because they have all these features that we've put in for whatever reason. So manyimal shoes to me are just or should be just shoes. And yeah, one of the ideas that they have a last that's compatible with the shape of a human foot, which most typical shoes you can buy are not. So there's quite a lot of work done on shape and fits of shoes, and the majority of people use shoes that are actually narrower than their feet. So that's something we wouldn't actep for it, Like nobody would wear a jacket that's too narrow and that's squeeze your body. We would say, well, that's unconsortably not accepting that in terms of food where we are willing to accept that because narrow shoes are perceived, at least in our in the Western society, are typically perceived as more attractive. We have narrow, narrow feet, so minimal shoes allow allow the natural movement of your foot, which and that's coming back to what's natural. I think unless we can really prove that unnatural is better, we have to we have to take our default position that natural is better, which will very often be decayed. So I think the burden of proof lies with people who claim that unnatural features of footwear are there to help. I'm absolutely willing to accept that, but I need to see proof. If there is no proof, then my go to footwear would be footwear that does not have any impact on how we walk. That that's sort of my default position because it has worked for seven million years, so it might not be perfect, but it's pretty good. I agree. Does your mechanics change on sand dry sand compared to dirt or carcrete? Does it change? The substrate has a huge influence on the way we walk. Well, mostly if you have a compliance substrate, it makes walking more costly, so it costs you more energy. That's quite a bit of a because you basically you deform the substrate. If you walk in sand, you spend energy deforming a substrate, and that's energy you can't use in propelling your body forwards exactly. So it's less efficient if you walk on very complex substrates or very sleepily substrates. We tend to move with more bent hips and bent knees because we feel more stable that way, but it's also more costly. So if you just try and stand up, it will cost you almost no energy. If you flex your knees a little bit, you can just imagine you'll start to feel your quads quite soon. That's not even moving. So if you walk with more flexed posture, yeah, it's gonna costume more energy, but it will make you more stable, more able to respond to small deformations of the substrate, et cetera. It's interesting in the way, in a way a shoe with cushioning, it's a bit like a like a variable substrate. I like to think of it like that. It's if you have a flexible soul under it's almost as if you're walking on something flexible all the time. You folks actually did it stary on minimal shoes. Where did you find in that step? Yeah, we've been studying animal shoes for a few years and we looked at a few aspects, again because they're interesting from a biological point of view, but they are also interesting from a clinical point of view. One aspect is strength, so we looked at if you wear minimal shoes rather than conventional Western shoes, dot that change the strength of your feet And the answer was very clearly yes. So we had randomized to groups. One group just carried on wearing their normal shoes and the other group he gave them minimal shoes and they had to wear them not all the time, but at least seventy percent of the time, and apart from that, they didn't change their hands, so they carried on their normal lives. After the year, we saw that the group that had been wearing the minimal shoes gained about sixty percent in foot strength. So that's that's a huge amount. If you if you go to the gym and you gain sixty percent in strength, that's that's a good workout. It costs you a lot of sweat. Just changing the different shoes can also give you those benefits. Now, what's the benefit of having that sixty percent increase in shoe stringth I mean foot strength. Yeah, So the muscles that support our feet, they're really important for a lot of things. They support our arch, the arch of the foot, so they make the food stronger during push off, but also in terms of balance. If we are disrupted in balance, which we are all the time, we don't notice, but we are constantly making small adjudgments to our balance if we stand still or if we walk. And usually these perturbations from the outside world could be like maybe a tile that's a little bit oblique, or some little stony and steps whatever. It can be. Intrinsically, even on a completely flapsot trade, we vary between the one step and the other. So how we deal with those perturbation and how we stay stable and upright and don't fall. We have a sequence of things we do, and the first attempt to stay upright is all what we call the angle strategy. We make small adjustments using our ankle muscles to bring us back on the right track, and nine times of ten that's in that fails, then we start moving our whole body. If that fails, we start waving our arms. If that also fails, we step into the direction we're going to fall, or we stick out around. But basically the most important and the first thing we do to remain stable, it's a it's an angle strategy. So the stronger your foot muscles, the more you will be able to stay stable. And that's so we also measured stability directly, not in people who have been trained to have stronger ankle muscle, but just people we got into the lab. We gave them conventional shoes with cushioning. We also asked them to walk barefoot and to be asked them to walk with minimal shoes. And as a work of my post doctormash to Dako, we saw that our different instability. So basically, cushioned shoes make you less stable. Barefoot walking is more stable. But interestingly, and that was not really expected, the minimal shoes are a little bit more stable still than barefoot walking, so they offer an improvement over barefoot. So that's one example how our invention could be helpful to us. You think it was, let me see our phraseapp I guess it makes me wonder just curiosity and it's probably just completely conjecture, But as a psychological the differences you saw there between the few the minimals. You know why, when you're walking perfect might be a little bit more tentative where you step, you're going to feel more things. But the minimal issue you kind of I just bot mine. Yeah, two weeks ago. Well, if you change a condition, if it's difficult to completely exclude psychological obviously, how we try to minimize that is by not telling people exactly what we what we are interested in. We just give them different types of hues and barefoot them. We measure their gates, so we don't we don't really tell them that if they do this or that will be happy as research, so we keep we keep them blind to Obviously there are different conditions. They do realize it's impossible to completely blind our research in many cases, as you can do if you inject a drug, you inject a liquid, and you can make your participants completely blind to whether the liquid contains an active substance or just water. We can't do that. If you give people shoes versus barefoot they obviously know that there's a difference. But luckily we are we are measuring mechanics, and even if there is a psychological difference, which I don't think is very likely. But even if it would be the case, we still measure an effect. It's still true for whatever reason that if you walk barefoot, if you walk in minimum shoes, you're more stable. In addition, we have insights from physiology that makes us that give us good arguments why it's probably not psychological, but it's an actual physical, physical effect going on because we have a lot of mechano receptors in the source of our feet. I mean, I think we all know how nice it feels to have a food massage or even just to walk barefoot over a nice substrate. Our feet are full of sensors and our joints are as well, to give them what we call appropriate reception, a sense of awareness of where our own bodies if we are barefoot or in minimal shoes. We allow these sensors to work. We give a lot of information to our brain about what's happening with our feet, how they sense the substrate. We are very sensitive to what's happening and with that input, your brain can produce a good motor program to keep stable. Now, if we wear very cushion shoes, what makes them comfortable also means which is the cushioning also means that we are sort of filtering out all the information we could have. Whatever happens with the ground, we'll only sends it's very, very poorly if we have this big cushioning device under under our feet. So from that point of view, it makes sense that we don't have as much neurological input in our system to help us stay stable. And secondly, purely mechanically, if you have a cushion shoe, it is a bit like sitting on a gin ball. You're constantly babbling it. It makes you naturally less stable. So because of these mechanical and physiological factors, we believe the effect is a real and it can't exclude some psychological input, but we think it's it's a real mechanical effect. Fastanding stuff. Again, we have a few minutes to go, and this is probably going to be a complete guest in your perfect You understand mechanic biomechanics, So well do you think, trying how I'll phrase it, do you think it will reduce knee issues and a low back paint if people started shifting over the minimalist shoes. I guess I'm also assuming that it caused a lot we started wearing the heeled shoes, but do you think you have an impact there? So do we whether we'll have less issues with minimal shoes? Yeah, do you think people? So there is really fascinating research being done, mostly backed by other people who are into for example, knee osteoarthritis that is very important to limit the loading on the kne as well as as hip by mechanics, and some of these studies they give us very counterintuitive results. So you would think intuitively that cushioning is a good thing to have less load on the human body. The thing is, we are not robots. If we walk with cushion shoes, we adjust our gate and we walk in a less cautious way, and the end result might be that despite the cushioning, to force on our body is actually higher. And that's been measured. So there is a there's a research team in Brazil that works on knee of stuartritis. They've found that if you wear very thin shoes, very cheap thin salt minimalist shoes, that the loading on the knee joint is actually lower than with conventional heeled shoes. So that that was very interesting. The second study that used, so that worked on total hip replacements. So prostasies artificial hips and they they implanted hips into the patients with four sensors within the prosthesis. So these sensors measure actually what's going on inside or inside the socket, so it doesn't like it's an actual measurement, it's not an estimate. And they found the same thing that but minimal shoes and bare footwalk in the load on the hip prosthesis is actually lower. So there's definitely a lot going on and counter intuitive, which is why we need to measure it now. I'm not gonna say that we should all be wearing minimal shoes and every single patient should. There's definitely a place for heels in some patients. For example, heels do offloadya kill the stendards have kiss tender nineties. They might be at least temporarily a good solution to help you recover people with diabetes, for example, they need they need very good shoes to prevent formation of ulcers, and cushioning could be definitely be one part of it or a rocket profile. So I'm definitely not bas go minimal. Always follow the doctor's advice. And for some patients. A shoe is an intervention. It's not supposed to be minimal. It's supposed to have a function. But what I would say is for most people who are healthy, I want to stay healthy for as long as possible. Minimal shoes are a good idea, and in some patients groups they could be. But I'm not going to make a blanket statement like minimal shoes are the best for everything. But that's that's not true. What do you see a difference? And again I know it's going to be another guess. Maybe do you see a difference of growing up with minimal is shoes? So at the age of four or five we start of wearing shoes, probably younger than that, but we start wearing minimal is shoes all the way through. Do you think that would make a huge difference for that individual? Yeah, I don't have to guess, luckily, because there are a few studies good. They're not so much on minimal shoes but on barefoot walking and so there are studies from Africa, from India, those are the most huge amount of volunteers, so very good quality data, thousands of so for example, one study from Africa studied children who went to school, so young age before all the foot bones are bone, so because they only turned to bone a sort of the age of six or seven, so they're their cartoonage before that, so they're highly flexible. They found that children who keep on walking barefoot they have less the odds of them having a low arch, so flat foot are smaller than kids that war shoes. So basically being barefoot give you the best chance of developing a well developed foot arch. So that that was interesting. So it makes sense that being barefoot gives our feet to the right mechanical arm to develop into strong feed if you overprotect them. It's like anything if if you have an accident and you'll break your arm, you put it in a plaster of Paris cast. After six weeks weeks, your your muscles will be atro feed, your bone will become weaker, et cetera. So if we if we give kids very very supportive dirty boots, where is a mechanical input to stimulate their feet to become strong. So there is now good evidence and actually the American Association of Pediatrictions the guidelines for decades now have been to give kids well to stimulate them to walk barefoot, or to give them very flexible shoes. So the evidence is quite good there, and I think, to be honest, people like you and me, if we start walking in minimal shoes, there's only so much we can do because our feet won't grow anymore. They are fully ossified. But children's feet are so plastic that they do respond to whether their barefoot or shots about mine or two weeks ago. I love them. That's really been fun we're walking around with them. I haven't. I haven't really paid attention to any changes. I'm not sure if I'm a ball arena or anything right now in balance, but I'm definitely a lot better than I was just walking. It's interesting. I definitely thought it was going to cause me some issues down below, causing kind of tendern issue or something. But no, don't do a darn thing. Feel really good. Have to listen to your body, if you if you, if you switch, it's like anything new, your body has to adjust to it. So if you switch from a very protective, sturdy, supportive shoe to a minimal shoe, especially at a later age talking about me, not about you, that you have to take it easy. Your body has to adjust it. It's all shown that if you start running with minimal shoes and you keep the same mileage. You go from a cushion trainer to a minimal shoe within within a few weeks. Basically you are probably looking for trouble. You have to take it easy. You have to keep your body time to adjust. Good point. I can keep your all day. They have so many more questions. Part chill. You're running out of time. We'll have to bring it back and we can continue to explore because I was also going to look at athletes and cleats and all kinds of other types of shoes and lots of stuff going on out there. The professor do thank you so much for doing this. Yeah, my pleasure and nice talking to you folks again. If you want to learn more, you can go to Liverpool dot AC dot UK. I think it's life course. I can't see exactly what this is, but you can type go ahead life course and medical Sciences. That's my institute. There you go, so Liverpool dot AC dot UK Life Course Medical Sciences. You can find Professor DoD that's the apostrophe. AO ut to learn more, check it out, go look out minimal is shoes if you haven't tried them. I just like Professor said here, I would probably try it first and see how they goes for you slowly and surely, and tell us let us know if you like them as much as I do. Thank you so much everybody for listening, Share, subscribe, hit that I Like button. You know we like it. We don't walk barefoot every so often, would you