Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / The Hidden Cost of Unrecognized Good Work
Transcript
- Lucas: We spend so much time talking about what to say when things go right. The thank-you notes, the team lunches, the public Slack shout-outs. But I’ve been reading some newer data on retention that suggests the real test of a manager isn’t how they handle success, but how they handle failure. Luna: That’s interesting because usually people associate mistakes with punishment or awkwardness. Why would fixing a bad outcome build loyalty? Lucas: It comes down to something called psychological safety, but specifically the version where an employee feels safe enough to be wrong. If you correct someone harshly, they learn to hide errors. If you ignore them, they stagnate. But if you correct them clearly and without judgment, they learn you’re invested in their growth, not just their output. Luna: So it’s less about the error itself and more about the emotional contract you sign during the correction. Lucas: Exactly. There was a study by Harvard Business Review last year that tracked mid-level tech workers over eighteen months. They found that employees who received frequent, low-stakes corrective feedback had significantly lower turnover than those who only heard from managers when there was a major crisis. Luna: That flips the script on the idea that we should save corrections for formal reviews. It sounds like daily calibration matters more. Lucas: It does. And the key word there is calibration. Most new managers treat feedback like a binary switch. Either you’re praising or you’re criticizing. But high-performing teams use feedback as a continuous dial. It’s not an event; it’s a rhythm. Luna: I’ve seen this happen. When a manager stops correcting small things, the employee assumes either no one cares or they’re being set up for a big fall later. Lucas: Right. And that assumption creates anxiety. Anxiety makes people risk-averse. They stop proposing new ideas because the cost of being wrong feels too high. So you get a team that’s quiet, compliant, and ultimately mediocre. Luna: So the silence isn’t peace. It’s disengagement waiting to happen. Lucas: Precisely. Now, let’s look at the mechanics of how this goes wrong, because even well-meaning managers mess this up. The most common trap is what I call the 'sandwich method'—praise, critique, praise. Managers think they’re softening the blow, but often it confuses the message. Luna: Because the employee waits for the other shoe to drop, or they only remember the compliments and ignore the correction entirely. Lucas: Or worse, they sense the insincerity. Today’s workforce, especially younger demographics, are incredibly adept at spotting performative empathy. If you bury a critical point between two generic compliments, they know. It undermines your credibility. Luna: So what’s the alternative? Just being blunt? That feels risky for building rapport. Lucas: Not blunt. Direct, but contextualized. Instead of wrapping the critique in fluff, you frame it around shared goals. You say, 'Here’s where the work diverged from our standard, and here’s how we fix it together.' It removes the personal attack and focuses on the professional gap. Luna: That shifts the dynamic from judge and defendant to co-pilots navigating a turbulence. Lucas: I love that framing. Co-pilots. Because when you remove the ego from the equation, the employee sees you as a resource, not a threat. And that’s when they start asking for harder problems. Which brings us to the next layer: timing. Luna: Timing is everything. I remember a job where my manager waited three weeks to tell me I’d messed up a client email. By then, the damage was done. Lucas: That’s the latency problem. Feedback loses potency exponentially the longer it’s delayed. If you wait until the monthly review to mention a mistake from June, you aren’t coaching behavior. You’re just auditing history. And audits feel punitive. Luna: So immediate feedback is better, even if it’s uncomfortable? Even in the moment? Lucas: Immediate doesn’t always mean in the middle of a meeting. That can cause shame. Immediate means within twenty-four hours. A quick private note or a five-minute walk. The goal is to close the loop while the context is still fresh in both your minds. Luna: That makes sense. It prevents the issue from festering in the employee’s head, where they might start rationalizing their mistake. Lucas: Exactly. Rationalization is the enemy of growth. If you leave a mistake unaddressed, the employee’s brain will eventually convince them it wasn’t a big deal, or that the standards were unclear. You have to interrupt that narrative early. Luna: But there’s a fine line between addressing the mistake and micromanaging every step. How do you keep it from feeling like policing? Lucas: You tie it to autonomy. When you give feedback, you also give the choice of how to apply it. You ask, 'What do you think went wrong?' before you offer your solution. That turns the correction into a dialogue rather than a decree. Luna: So you’re inviting them to diagnose their own process. That builds ownership. Lucas: It does. And it reveals whether the error was a skill gap, a motivation gap, or a resource gap. Only you can solve those differently. Skill gaps need training. Motivation gaps need alignment. Resource gaps need budget. One-size-fits-all correction fails because it treats all errors the same. Luna: That’s a crucial distinction. Most managers just assume everyone needs the same level of guidance regardless of the root cause. Lucas: Right. And if you train someone who’s already motivated, you’re wasting their time. If you motivate someone who lacks skill, you’re setting them up to fail. Feedback has to be diagnostic first, prescriptive second. Luna: So the manager’s job is part detective, part coach. Not just a boss handing down verdicts. Lucas: Exactly. And this requires a lot of emotional bandwidth. It’s exhausting to be constantly attuned to these nuances. Which leads me to a question for the listeners out there managing teams for the first time. Do you feel equipped to handle this kind of granular feedback, or does it feel like extra administrative weight? Luna: I think a lot of new managers fear that constant feedback looks like incompetence on their part, like they can’t delegate. Lucas: That’s a valid fear. But delegation isn’t abdication. You can delegate outcomes while retaining responsibility for the standard. In fact, doing this work upfront saves you from putting out fires later. Luna: Preventative maintenance versus emergency repair. The math is simple, even if the conversation is hard. Lucas: It is. And speaking of maintenance, we’re going to take a brief pause here. This show is built on conversations like this, and listener support helps keep the production consistent and ad-free. If you’ve found value in these discussions, consider supporting us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Every bit helps keep Lucas and Luna digging deeper into these topics. Luna: Yeah, and honestly, knowing that people are listening makes the prep work worth it. It’s a small gesture that keeps the whole network running. Lucas: Thanks for that. Now, back to the core tension. Even with good intentions, managers sometimes struggle with their own discomfort. They avoid giving tough feedback because they don’t want to be the 'bad guy.' Luna: The benevolent dictator syndrome. Trying to be liked instead of being effective. Lucas: Spot on. But here’s the paradox: employees respect clarity more than kindness. A manager who tells you exactly where you stand, even when it hurts, is more trustworthy than one who smiles and nods while you drift off course. Luna: Because ambiguity is stressful. Certainty, even negative certainty, reduces cognitive load. Lucas: Yes. You can plan around clear expectations. You can’t plan around vague hope. So reframing feedback as a gift of clarity helps managers overcome their hesitation. Luna: It takes the emotion out of it. It becomes a professional service you’re providing, not a personal judgment. Lucas: Exactly. And that professional distance protects the relationship. You’re not attacking the person; you’re optimizing the work. Once you make that mental shift, the conversations become much easier. Luna: Do you think this approach scales? Like, in very large teams, can managers maintain this level of personalized feedback? Lucas: It has to scale through systems, not just goodwill. Regular one-on-ones, clear documentation of expectations, and perhaps peer to peer feedback loops. You can’t do it all personally, but you can create a culture where feedback is normalized. Luna: So it becomes part of the workflow, not an exception to it. Like checking code or reviewing design specs. Lucas: Precisely. When feedback is as routine as a status update, it loses its sting. It just becomes how we work. And that’s the ultimate goal. A team that corrects itself. Luna: A self-correcting system. That sounds like the holy grail of management. Lucas: It is. And it starts with the courage to have the hard conversations early, often, and kindly. Because in the end, we’re not just managing tasks. We’re managing human potential. Luna: And recognizing that potential includes helping people navigate their own stumbles without losing confidence. Lucas: Right. So the next time you’re faced with a mistake, try seeing it not as a failure of the employee, but as an opportunity to deepen the trust. Luna: That’s a powerful reframe. It changes the entire tone of the room. Lucas: It does. And I’m curious, for those of you listening, what’s the one piece of feedback you received that actually changed your career trajectory? Was it given kindly? Luna: I bet most of us have a story about a manager who pushed us harder than we thought we could handle, and we’re grateful for it now. Lucas: Probably. And that’s the legacy we want to leave behind. Not just happy teams, but better professionals.