Latest / Stage Talks with Bellingcat / "Building Environmental Investigations" with Costanza Gambarini
Transcript
- 0:02You're listening to a stage talk titled Building
- 0:05Environmental Investigations. This week we were
- 0:08joined by Costanza Gambarini, an award -winning
- 0:11environmental journalist from the outlet Source
- 0:14Material. Costanza walked us through some of
- 0:17her previous investigations and the obstacles
- 0:19she faced along the way, providing key insight
- 0:22into what it's like to uncover information linking
- 0:24governments and major multinationals to environmental
- 0:27harm. You can find links to all the resources
- 0:30mentioned in the talk in the podcast description.
- 0:33This talk was hosted by me, Charlotte Marr, on
- 0:35Thursday the 16th of July, 2026, in the Bell
- 0:38and Captage Discord server. Thanks for coming,
- 0:54all, to another Stage Talk. Environmental stories
- 0:57often involve complex supply chains, hidden corporate
- 1:00structures and impacts that cross borders. Investigating
- 1:04them requires persistence, careful reporting
- 1:06and increasingly digital research techniques
- 1:09that can uncover evidence hidden in plain sight.
- 1:12Today's guest is Costanza Gambarini, an investigative
- 1:16journalist at SourceMaterial and the Press Awards
- 1:18Environmental Journalist of the Year. Congratulations
- 1:20again. Her reporting focuses on uncovering environmental
- 1:24wrongdoing and holding powerful actors to account
- 1:27through rigorous evidence -based investigations
- 1:29on everything from unregulated tankers leaking
- 1:32oil at sea to big data centers consuming water
- 1:36in the driest of areas. In this conversation,
- 1:39we'll explore how she finds stories, builds investigations
- 1:42from the ground up, combines digital research
- 1:45with traditional reporting, and the lessons she's
- 1:47learnt throughout her career. Whether you're
- 1:49an experienced investigative reporter or just
- 1:52starting to explore environmental journalism,
- 1:55there should be plenty of practical insights
- 1:57to take away. As usual, you can place your questions
- 2:00in the chat accessible on the right hand corner
- 2:03of your screen. But please remember that this
- 2:06is being audio recorded for the podcast, so if
- 2:09you don't want me to mention your username, please
- 2:11add that as a note in your question. Okay, Koz,
- 2:15over to you. Tell us about yourself and how you
- 2:17work and I'm going to mute myself. Thanks, Charlie,
- 2:21for the intro. Hi, everyone. Thanks for having
- 2:24me. My name is Costanza. I am an environmental
- 2:29journalist at SourceMaterial. Just a couple of
- 2:32words about me and SourceMaterial. So SourceMaterial
- 2:36is a small independent newsroom based in London.
- 2:40It's only six of us. And we do work around climate
- 2:46corruption and democracy, which is quite a big
- 2:49brief, but it gives us a lot of freedom to pursue
- 2:53investigations that we find interesting. And
- 2:57I would say like how source material work is
- 3:03very much centered around collaboration. So both
- 3:07internally with my colleagues and then externally
- 3:12with our partner organizations. So we always
- 3:15publish with a larger media outlet here in the
- 3:18UK or in Europe and the rest of the world. So
- 3:21that's kind of how we work. That's also a little
- 3:25bit of a disclaimer for me that obviously All
- 3:29the stories that I do are very much in partnership
- 3:32with amazing other journalists, from a couple
- 3:35to like 40 journalists spread around Europe.
- 3:39So if I can't answer a question, it's probably
- 3:40because I didn't do that little bit of reporting
- 3:42that the question is about. And that's important
- 3:45to say, and also like one of the joys of journalism,
- 3:48I guess. And then just a bit about me. I was
- 3:53a broadcast journalist for a few years. I worked
- 3:55at the BBC in current affairs. and then I moved
- 3:58to source material three years ago. My work has
- 4:02really spawned a lot of different topics, but
- 4:05it's covered a lot of Russia -related things,
- 4:11especially the shadow fleet, like Charlie mentioned.
- 4:14And then I've done quite a bit of work on the
- 4:18impact of passive fuel companies in various different
- 4:23places from Indonesia. to Mozambique, Kenya and
- 4:28others. So that's been another relatively new
- 4:33beat for me, but I produced a lot of work in
- 4:36that area. So Charlie told me that the focus
- 4:40on my talk would be on three things. How do I
- 4:43come up with stories? What kind of methodologies
- 4:46I use? And then what are the risks associated
- 4:50to environmental journalism? So I will try to...
- 4:53briefly go through those three things and then
- 4:56opening up to questions. How do I come up with
- 5:00stories? It's obviously very different every
- 5:03time. Two examples that I think can be interesting
- 5:08for specifically this group are a story called
- 5:13Indonesian exporters in palm oil probe supplied
- 5:16European fuel majors. I think Charlie will put
- 5:19the link in the chat if you want to have a look.
- 5:23So this story was about how there was a bunch
- 5:28of arrests in Indonesia a few months back. And
- 5:34the RSCs were basically palm oil producers that
- 5:36were suspected of being involved in fraud. And
- 5:39the fraud was specifically presenting crude palm
- 5:42oil as Pome, which is a waste product. is treated
- 5:48differently in terms of taxation and also importing
- 5:51into the European Union. That story started because
- 5:56an NGO that we sometimes use as a source had
- 6:01access to interesting trade data showing that
- 6:05any Italian oil giant was importing crude palm
- 6:09oil whilst they had previously said that they
- 6:13hadn't been doing that for years. And they went
- 6:15on importing Palme, which is the waste product
- 6:18I was talking about. We then tried to substantiate
- 6:22that data from these trading platforms by getting
- 6:28costume documents from the Italian customs. That
- 6:31was a six -month project that ended up an absolute
- 6:34failure. I spent an absurd amount of money phoning
- 6:39Italy. I sent somebody to their... their offices
- 6:45in Rome that were empty, aside for this one security
- 6:48guard who kindly asked us to leave. So then we
- 6:53kind of gave up and we tried the Indonesian customs
- 6:56and we actually got the documents. And the documents
- 7:00showed that the imports were vomit, the waste
- 7:05product. So we kind of killed the story. only
- 7:08a few months later for this arrest to happen
- 7:10and showing that these same companies that were
- 7:12named in our documents were indeed accused of
- 7:17exactly doing that kind of fraud. So we then
- 7:21published the story with AFP and I think it's
- 7:24a good reminder of how one source of data is
- 7:27never enough and you should really try to corroborate
- 7:31corroborate the data that you have, even though
- 7:34it's coming up in a really nice format from a
- 7:37reputable trading platform. But then if we didn't
- 7:43have this Indonesian customs data, we wouldn't
- 7:46have had the names of these other companies that
- 7:48ended up being involved in this investigation.
- 7:52So it was really... It was really interesting
- 7:56how getting multiple sources of data, of the
- 8:00same data really landed to us being able to publish
- 8:03the story. And then the other one I wanted to
- 8:08talk in terms of how do I come up with story
- 8:11was Seeds of Doubt, a story about biofuel, biofuel
- 8:19production in Kenya. again involves any, maybe
- 8:23I have something against Italian art majors being
- 8:27Italian. But again, this story came from data.
- 8:34So we had this trade data showing that there
- 8:37was this large amount of rapeseed imports from
- 8:41South Africa to Kenya, and then from Kenya to
- 8:43Italy. And again, went against what any were
- 8:50saying at the time, which was that they weren't
- 8:52using food crops to produce their biofuels, but
- 8:55they were actually using all this like caster
- 8:58from the graded land, helping loads of Kenyan
- 9:02farmers having a better life. And just seeing
- 9:08this data led us to think like, okay, maybe that...
- 9:11that there is more to it, the story is quite
- 9:13different. And then, which then led us to travel
- 9:17to Kenya to see it for ourselves and then found
- 9:19out that, you know, the whole program was a joke,
- 9:23basically, and did an investigation about that.
- 9:26But again, that started with, with data. Oh,
- 9:30and an interesting, sorry, just like, so my own
- 9:32note, how we, we actually confirmed the trade
- 9:35data in, in this case was quite funny. We found
- 9:40On Instagram, a company that was doing tank of
- 9:44humigation in Cape Town. And they videoed themselves
- 9:50doing tanker fumigation. And in the videos, you
- 9:53could see this rapeseed, there's loads and loads
- 9:57of rapeseed on board these tankers. And the name
- 10:00of the tanker was mentioned, obviously Instagram
- 10:02had the date at which that post was posted. So
- 10:06we could compare the name of the tanker and the
- 10:09date to the trade data that we had and actually
- 10:12see for ourselves that the rapeseed was indeed.
- 10:15on board these tankers in Cape Town, which then
- 10:18went to Mombasa and then to Italy. So that was
- 10:22quite funny. Moving on to the methodologies,
- 10:33the investigative techniques, I guess, that I
- 10:35use for my investigations. Again, loads and loads
- 10:40of different ones. So it really depends on what
- 10:45the investigation is about. I'm going to talk
- 10:47about dark water, which was my first shadow fleet
- 10:51investigation. That one looked at the environmental
- 10:56impact of the shadow fleet. In particular, we
- 10:58were looking at oil slicks that were left around
- 11:02the world. We tried to map all the oil slicks
- 11:05left around the world by shadow fleet tankers.
- 11:09Shadow fleet being I'm sure everybody knows what
- 11:12a shop is, but it's just the tankers that move
- 11:16Russian oil and might be selling it above the
- 11:22price cap despite sanctions basically. For that
- 11:26one, we actually again partnered with an amazing
- 11:30NGO called Skytruth who'd been mapping oil slicks
- 11:33for all sorts of other reasons. They used Sentinel
- 11:39-1 data, which is the European Space Agency program,
- 11:45to basically map the leaks and then they would
- 11:47review them manually. What we basically got them
- 11:50to do was to cross -reference those leaks with
- 11:54the paths taken by shadow fleet vessels to identify
- 11:58cases where it was shadow fleet tankers that
- 12:01were responsible for leaving those leaks. And
- 12:04then what we did after, so we basically created
- 12:07a worldwide map of those lakes. And then we looked
- 12:11into the vessels that were responsible and the
- 12:15companies that owned those vessels. And that
- 12:17was like, you know, a whole lot of online research,
- 12:20as you can imagine, using, you know, companies'
- 12:23accounts. We used Orbis a lot. We are lucky enough
- 12:26to have access to that, although it's expiring
- 12:29in August and I think it's not being renewed.
- 12:31It's going to be in... the end of my investigations.
- 12:37So that was kind of like the basis of that story
- 12:39and the techniques we used. And then I guess
- 12:42the other one I can talk about is the data center
- 12:46story. And then if you have any questions about
- 12:51any other investigations I did, please ask in
- 12:54the Q &A. So this story was the big data center's
- 12:59push will take water from the world's driest
- 13:01areas. pretty self explanatory title, but we
- 13:04looked at water consumption for data centers
- 13:10belonging to Amazon, Microsoft and Google specifically.
- 13:15That was the first story that we did about data
- 13:17centers. So we didn't have any specific access.
- 13:21Later on, based on that story, we actually got
- 13:24a a leaked bunch of data from Amazon, from a
- 13:28whistleblower, which was great. But at that point,
- 13:30we didn't have access to any leaked data or anything
- 13:34specific, so we just used what was publicly available.
- 13:39There was a company called Baxter that had a
- 13:42public facing map of data centers belonging to
- 13:47these three companies. We then asked another
- 13:49company called Data Center Map. if they could
- 13:52provide us with some more data, which they did.
- 13:55And then we just analyze a whole bunch of local
- 13:58reports about data centers being developed or
- 14:03already operational. And we combined all the
- 14:07sources in a big spreadsheet of, I think it was
- 14:10632 data centers that were either active or under
- 14:14development. And then we... overlapped the locations
- 14:19of those data centers with a worldwide map of
- 14:23water scarcity, which we got from Volcom, which
- 14:27is a UN backed initiative. And then basically
- 14:32we used that map to look at how many of these
- 14:35data centers were located in area that were already
- 14:38considered of water scarcity. Just to say like,
- 14:44to give you an idea of how much we missed. When
- 14:47we then got the whistleblower to give us the
- 14:50Amazon data, we then found out that Amazon alone
- 14:54already had 924 data centers that were operational.
- 15:00We had 632 for the three companies altogether.
- 15:05So it was quite a few that we missed, which kind
- 15:08of adds it to the point of how secretive companies
- 15:11are about their data centers. So skipping through
- 15:17to the risks associated to environmental journalists.
- 15:25I really thought about this one. I think a worthy
- 15:31mention as although maybe beyond the point of
- 15:35this talk, is really the risk taken by our sources
- 15:38when they talk to us. And that's physical risk,
- 15:42but also legal and financial risk. And I think
- 15:46this is my second little disclaimer of my speech,
- 15:50but as much as digital techniques are really
- 15:53important and we do a lot of data work, I would
- 15:57say that at least half, if not more, of my job
- 16:02is still very much source -based and there's
- 16:06still a lot of field work. I think it's easy
- 16:09to get excited about all the new tools that you
- 16:13can use to find out things and forget about the
- 16:16human element of the stories. I think that's
- 16:19beyond the scope of this talk, but if you want
- 16:21to ask questions about it, of course, I'm happy
- 16:23to answer, but I just want you to highlight that
- 16:25it's quite... It's still a very important part
- 16:30of my job. But other risks, I think the legal
- 16:35risk is probably the one that comes to mind.
- 16:39I'm based in the UK, so we have very strict libel
- 16:42laws. I think the most interesting thing with
- 16:47legal risk, and we've received our fair share
- 16:50of legal letters. My top one being for my Mozambique
- 16:56story, I received a letter from Schilling and
- 16:59specifically from the lawyer that defended Johnny
- 17:01Depp in his trial, which was quite funny. But
- 17:07I guess the interesting stuff about legal risk
- 17:11is how do you account for that and what do you
- 17:15do to make sure that... that you've got your
- 17:19bases covered. And I think that the main thing
- 17:21to think about is what can I do that would show
- 17:25a judge, you know, if we did get to like a court
- 17:28case that I behaved as a responsible journalist.
- 17:32And I do think that anything that you can do,
- 17:35it's worth doing because the risk is so big,
- 17:38even if it's like, you know, unlikely. And things
- 17:43like, you know, and that might mean, you know,
- 17:46a lengthy write to reply process or sending your
- 17:51more risky articles to lawyers to have a look
- 17:55at. There's been a lot of cases where we tried
- 17:59to contact especially companies in very far away
- 18:02jurisdictions and we send them a letter and then
- 18:06they never replied. But then if you can, make
- 18:09another phone call, find another email address,
- 18:12find another physical address. I always think
- 18:14it's worth doing. even though you know that 99
- 18:18% they're not going to reply to you, I think
- 18:21it's just like one of those things that it's
- 18:23a bit annoying, but definitely worth doing. And
- 18:25that's, I think the biggest risk, especially,
- 18:28you know, I work for a very small company, so
- 18:30a lawsuit would be potentially ending for us.
- 18:36So I think that's the main thing to think about.
- 18:41And then one last thing, when I think about risk
- 18:44is With environmental journalists or climate
- 18:49journalists, you are bound to work with NGOs
- 18:55and activists. And I think that the risk there
- 18:58or like the thing that I do think about a lot
- 19:01is how can I use their amazing knowledge and
- 19:07access in a way that keeps me editorially dependent
- 19:13from you know, whatever their opinion or agenda
- 19:16is. So it's like really treating NGOs as sources
- 19:21for stories rather than partners while at the
- 19:24same time not putting them off working with you
- 19:27because, you know, that's a fundamental part
- 19:29of my job. And I think that that, you know, line
- 19:33between journalism and advocacy, it's something
- 19:36that I didn't have to think about when I was
- 19:38back at the BBC, but it's definitely something
- 19:40I think about a lot now that I work as source
- 19:43material. And I don't know if others have had
- 19:45the same experience or what you guys work, but
- 19:48I think it was something that came to my mind
- 19:50when I thought about risk. And I think that's
- 19:55it for me. I'm on 80 minutes. So happy to open
- 19:59up. You are so punctual. I love that you are
- 20:03continuously checking the clock. Bless you. Thank
- 20:07you so much for going through all those amazing
- 20:10investigations and giving us the lowdown really
- 20:12quickly as well on those. And yeah, pointing
- 20:15out some of the risks involved with your work.
- 20:19For example, as you just mentioned, the NGO sector
- 20:22can be a wealth of information for source contacts
- 20:25as well, connecting you with the people that
- 20:29have lived experience of what you're reporting
- 20:31on. But that can also turn into quite an exploitative
- 20:34relationship if you're not careful as well. And
- 20:37there is actually, we did have a stage talk on
- 20:39that a couple of months ago, which I'll link
- 20:41in the chat in a second, if you want to hear
- 20:44a little bit about how you kind of navigate that
- 20:48space. I wanted to start off and ask you, and
- 20:52I know I'm taking you back through the points
- 20:54that you just covered, but I wanted to ask you,
- 20:56where do good environmental investigations come
- 20:59from in your opinion? What are you paying attention
- 21:02to? What are you monitoring regularly? as part
- 21:05of your work, maybe a little bit further away
- 21:08from kind of sources bringing it directly to
- 21:11you. Is there anywhere that you regularly monitor
- 21:14as an environmental journalist, just looking
- 21:16for stories? I would say that I, and I think
- 21:22maybe that's more personal taste, but I definitely
- 21:25read more analysis and feature journalism as
- 21:29opposed to straight off news. So like that, is
- 21:35often an inspiration. I think something that
- 21:37had led, for example, to my first Shadow Feet
- 21:41piece was, can we take something that is topical
- 21:46and look at it through a climate lens or an environment
- 21:52lens? Has the environment or climate story on
- 21:57the Shadow Feet been done when... There was already
- 22:00a lot being published about the shadow fleet,
- 22:03but maybe not through that lens. So I think that's
- 22:08a good way to find topics that have been discussed
- 22:13a lot. And same with maybe data centers, although
- 22:17the climate connection was a bit more immediate.
- 22:22But again, it was talked already from maybe electricity
- 22:26or emission point of view, maybe not a water
- 22:28one. So is there like, amongst things that have
- 22:31already been talked about, an angle that hasn't
- 22:33been explored that has that lens? Always looking
- 22:39for unique angles is basically what you're touching
- 22:43on, right? We had a question earlier from an
- 22:48audience member. They were asking, with your
- 22:51reporting, what piece is the most successful
- 22:54in leading to government action or changing public
- 22:56opinion? Did the framing of the story or the
- 22:59facts verification matter more? I think maybe
- 23:07the most successful piece that I produced has
- 23:11been my Mozambique work. So this was stories
- 23:14about Butal Energies LNG project in Northern
- 23:19Mozambique that had really worrying, a really
- 23:24worrying human rights track. could and exposing
- 23:27that. I think that brings me back a bit to what
- 23:31I was saying about the human angle and how that
- 23:34helps to give a data story. That story was initiated
- 23:41by a bunch of documents that we obtained through
- 23:43FOI in Italy, but how making a story more personable
- 23:50by doing the field work really helps to bring
- 23:54it home with an audience and then hence, you
- 23:57know, give it more, you know, giving it a better
- 24:01chance of an impact. So in that case, you know,
- 24:05we got several, several governments to drop out
- 24:08from financing the LNG project. I think, sorry,
- 24:15I don't know if there was a question about presentation.
- 24:17Like I think, I think the data has to be strong.
- 24:21But I think that it has to be delivered in a
- 24:24way that is understandable to an audience that
- 24:27is not an audience of experts. And I think that
- 24:30really helps the fact that we work with partners
- 24:33that are usually through mainstream media in
- 24:38terms of like, you know, our website could be
- 24:41super nasty because nobody reads it that is not
- 24:44already interested in environmental journalism.
- 24:46And so it's probably quite an expert audience
- 24:48in that sense, but we try to make our stories
- 24:50not aimed at an expert audience. And that's why
- 24:55we're quite successful in partnering with mainstream
- 24:58media, which is why then we have a better impact.
- 25:01And I think that's a very important part of being
- 25:03an environmental journalist, because as any type
- 25:07of journalist, you do care about your stories
- 25:09having an impact because you care about the issues
- 25:11that you're writing about. I really want to touch
- 25:14on that collaboration part in a second, but just
- 25:17while we're on the Mozambique piece. As you mentioned
- 25:21earlier, risks are a real risk in environmental
- 25:26journalism. And particularly in this case, for
- 25:29example, some of the larger multinationals that
- 25:30you're reporting on, the gas company, for example,
- 25:32have troops on their paywall. What does your
- 25:35risk assessment look like before you start an
- 25:38investigation? Are you aware of the kind of powers
- 25:40of the companies that you're investigating have
- 25:43ahead of the investigation being commenced? Like
- 25:48what does the risk assessment look like for your
- 25:50team? I think we started, we're sort of a work
- 25:54in progress to be honest. We've been doing some
- 25:56of the riskier things more recently and I think
- 25:59we've definitely have had some lessons learned.
- 26:04I think like one of them, for example, was when
- 26:07we've been doing all this like work on Russia.
- 26:12I know a lot of that for a couple of stories
- 26:15involved as being on telegram channels. And then
- 26:19we sort of realised like sort of halfway through
- 26:21that we were just using our normal phone numbers
- 26:23and you know, our password ones. And like, you
- 26:27know, just like logging into these conversations,
- 26:31like these group chats with, you know, who knows
- 26:35who. And, you know, there was quite a few of
- 26:39these things that I guess came from naivety that
- 26:44we did to begin with. And then now maybe we're
- 26:49a bit more careful with how we proceed with things,
- 26:55got VPNs and things. But I think the two things
- 27:02that we always think about before an investigation
- 27:04starts is where is going to be the legal risk?
- 27:08And surprisingly, although some of these big
- 27:10companies are very good at sending legal letters,
- 27:16once the story is published, unless they really
- 27:19have strong grounds, they rarely pursue it. Or
- 27:23that's been our experience, but sometimes it's
- 27:25the individuals that get really pissed off. So
- 27:29actually we do pay a lot of legal attention to
- 27:34all the cases where we name specific individuals
- 27:37rather than just companies. And so that's one,
- 27:41the legal risk. And then the other thing that
- 27:43we think about a lot is the physical risk if
- 27:46we're going to report from places that we're
- 27:48going. So that's the most amazing example is
- 27:50a really good example for that. We had like a
- 27:52security companies that was basically monitoring
- 27:56us from a distance and was ready to extract us
- 27:59at 20. I hope not 24 hours, actually. I hope
- 28:03it was shorter than that. We did hostile environment
- 28:06training. There was a whole lot of things that
- 28:10had to go in place. Also working to guarantee
- 28:14the security of the people that we were going
- 28:16to talk to and what the aftercare was going to
- 28:19look like for the months after publication, what
- 28:21the anonymization was going to look like in order
- 28:24to avoid sort of... cross identification by saying,
- 28:30for example, which village something happened
- 28:32or something like that. So that's, I think, source
- 28:36protection and our own physical protection is
- 28:38probably the thing that we think about the most
- 28:39and then legal risk. Yeah, you have to be pretty
- 28:42confident, I think, in your reporting and what
- 28:45you're going to find as well, if you're going
- 28:47to take that much resource and that much risk
- 28:50to travel over and hire a security company and
- 28:54everything like that. It's a big gamble, but
- 28:57pays off a lot of the time. You talked about
- 29:01collaboration earlier, and obviously a lot of
- 29:06the time in environmental investigations, the
- 29:08investigation often crosses borders and disciplines.
- 29:11How do you work with other journalists and experts?
- 29:15And in your opinion, what makes an effective
- 29:17collaboration on environmental peace? I mean,
- 29:21as you said, that collaboration is kind of bread
- 29:23and butter of source material. I don't think
- 29:25necessarily every investigation needs to go to
- 29:28journalists from seven different countries. There
- 29:31is definitely like an argument that that very
- 29:34much complicates matters. But I do think that
- 29:38the projects where I did work with a very large
- 29:41group of and cross -border that are those projects
- 29:45that are more international in nature themselves.
- 29:50shadow fleet projects, it was very helpful to
- 29:53have people distributed in different European
- 29:55countries that were dealing with the shadow fleet
- 29:57issues in different ways and could access different
- 30:02sorts of documents and intelligence sources and
- 30:05all other sorts of sources and look at different
- 30:08data that was country specific. So that very
- 30:11much helps to build a more complete picture of
- 30:16an issue that is an international issue. that
- 30:19would have been possible if we were only tackling
- 30:21the issue from a UK perspective. For example,
- 30:24I would say even more important is to work with
- 30:28people, and that's both journalists and experts
- 30:34from the countries that you're talking about
- 30:37if you're not talking about your own country.
- 30:40And that's, I mean, I hope self -explanatory,
- 30:43but like, I can't stress enough how much of that
- 30:47and added value. Someone who's local and has
- 30:52lived experience of the issues that you're talking
- 30:55about is to do an investigation. So if I'm doing
- 31:00an investigation about plastic pollution in Ghana
- 31:05or the investigation I did on Mozambique or Indonesia,
- 31:10Kenya, they all relied on very good journalists
- 31:16from there and very good experts from there that
- 31:20had been spending the past 20 years looking at
- 31:22Tunisia was able to spend the last five minutes.
- 31:25So I think being able to acknowledge your limitations
- 31:28and ask for help from people who are more knowledgeable
- 31:33than you is very much a big part of being an
- 31:35environmental journalist. And I think that's
- 31:37because you are tackling such a broad range of
- 31:39topics. No one is an expert. Like I never really
- 31:43knew anything about the shadow fleet before something
- 31:45writing about it or human rights in Mozambique.
- 31:48And I think, but I think that shouldn't discourage
- 31:51us from tackling these issues and bringing them
- 31:53to the attention of European readers, because,
- 31:57you know, very often edit or, you know, Western
- 32:00readers, because very often we're kind of the
- 32:03source of some of these issues being going on.
- 32:05But I think that that also requires a bit of
- 32:08like, being a bit humble about exactly how much
- 32:13we understand a topic. In data journalism, in
- 32:18environmental journalism, sorry, you're often
- 32:20dealing with huge amounts of data as well, right?
- 32:24So like having lots of newsroom eyes as well
- 32:27can be really useful for just dissecting that
- 32:30volume of data as well. It can be absolutely
- 32:33overwhelming. And if you are interested in working
- 32:36on environmental stories, We do have a space
- 32:40in the Discord called environment and wildlife
- 32:43and that's where we talk about those kinds of
- 32:45things. We have quite a few people talking about
- 32:49data centers in the chat. As you can imagine,
- 32:52it annoys a lot of people that the world is being
- 32:56taken over by data centers. Subtle Knife, our
- 32:59moderator said earlier that there was a report
- 33:01the other day that there's one in the Netherlands
- 33:03that uses 1 % of the entire country's energy,
- 33:06which is crazy. We've had a question specifically,
- 33:10and I don't know if you're familiar with it,
- 33:11on the Stargate project. Somebody is asking for
- 33:15your opinion on it. I don't know if you are familiar
- 33:17with it or can speak a little bit about your
- 33:20experience maybe reporting on data centers in
- 33:22general. Yeah, I'm familiar with the Stargate
- 33:26project, but I think the main thing, this story
- 33:31has been like... It blew up when it was published.
- 33:34It's been one of our most successful stories
- 33:36and we followed it up with a few other stories
- 33:39that actually wasn't involved in. And it's obviously
- 33:44a really important topic just because of like,
- 33:47it just magnated of, you know, this data center
- 33:49boom happening all over the world. And also,
- 33:53as I said before, how secretive companies have
- 33:55been about it. I've done since quite a few speeches
- 33:58and I try always to steer away from giving my
- 34:01own opinion about data centers because I feel
- 34:03like it's kind of beyond the point of what my
- 34:06personal opinion is on them. And it's just the
- 34:10fact that it's an undeniable fact that this is
- 34:12happening. So I think an interesting question
- 34:15was actually talking about, how about this with
- 34:17my colleague, Luke, who by the way, Luke Barrett,
- 34:21who's been working on our data center stories
- 34:24throughout. And if you're interested in data
- 34:27centers, he's your man. So you can contact him
- 34:31and look at sourcematerial .org. And he, I'm
- 34:35sure will be loving having a conversation about
- 34:38data centers. But I think an interesting thing
- 34:41would be like, how do we meet? We've now sort
- 34:44of exposed the scale of the energy consumption,
- 34:47all the problems that the water consumption,
- 34:49all the problems that come with data centers
- 34:52and still data centers are happening. And so
- 34:55it's like what, for me, an interesting question
- 34:57could be like what does and can it exist a sustainable
- 35:04data centers? Like what would be like a good
- 35:10data center? Can we, what are the solutions?
- 35:14And I think that's maybe something that has been
- 35:17partially covered, but But that is worth looking
- 35:23at just because I don't know what other people
- 35:25think, but to me, it almost felt like an inevitability
- 35:29of how we're consuming AI now that data centers
- 35:36are being developed all over the world. Yeah,
- 35:39I'd love to read a solutions -based journalism
- 35:42piece on data centers and see what alternatives
- 35:44are out there. That would be really interesting.
- 35:47I am also not familiar with. a story like that.
- 35:50If anyone has come across any, please pop them
- 35:53in the chat. I'd love to read that. Flicking
- 35:57slightly back again to collaborations, somebody
- 36:01asked a question while you were talking through
- 36:03that. They said, how do you manage multiple languages
- 36:05in this work? Or how do you ask for experts to
- 36:08pass data or teach you to pass data yourself?
- 36:10Like, do you pay them to help you or ask for
- 36:12in -kind help? I think the question is really
- 36:15kind of like, how do you get that expertise?
- 36:19How do you approach people about that expertise?
- 36:23So with our partners, we don't, well, first of
- 36:29all, we don't sell our stories. So we are philanthropically
- 36:34funded and we offer our expertise for free. It's
- 36:39basically like, we kind of offer investigative
- 36:42capacity. I guess the newsroom set might not
- 36:45have as much investigative capacity as they should.
- 36:49to focus on these kinds of stories. In terms
- 36:54of managing different languages across different
- 36:56regions, if there is a language barrier, we usually
- 37:01have translators or we find the way around it.
- 37:06It's never been a limiting issue in terms of
- 37:10whether we would decide to work or collaborate
- 37:12with an individual or an organization. And then
- 37:16obviously everybody publishes their stories in
- 37:19their own language. In terms of the expertise,
- 37:24we absolutely do not pay sources or experts who
- 37:30are quoted in our stories or provide expertise
- 37:38that goes into the story. We credit them, Julie.
- 37:42In the stories, we never claimed that any data
- 37:45that didn't belong to us would belong to us.
- 37:49We credit the organizations that provided us
- 37:51with the data as sources. We are very transparent
- 37:56about our process for crediting and how people
- 37:58are credited and we agree on everything in advance
- 38:01so that it's perceived as a fair exchange for
- 38:08everyone. I don't know, I really feel like there's
- 38:14very few instances where we've paid somebody.
- 38:16We obviously pay lawyers for their expert opinion,
- 38:20but anyone who could be even remotely perceived
- 38:24as a source, we wouldn't pay for ethical editorial
- 38:30reasons. So yeah, we have had also a lot of no's,
- 38:34especially from satellite companies that never
- 38:37want to give their data for free. But yeah, usually
- 38:44we find a way. And there's amazing organizations
- 38:47around that really like a lot of people that
- 38:50really do a lot of work with us. Like Data Desk
- 38:54is one that comes to mind. Loads of like SkyTree
- 38:58that I mentioned earlier. There's so many organizations
- 39:01that really do great work. Yeah. And that's exactly
- 39:05how Bellingcat works with our collaborations
- 39:07as well. very similar formats, I think, in terms
- 39:11of exchanging resources and exchanging knowledge.
- 39:14Sometimes we don't even co -publish. For example,
- 39:18sometimes we might just be helping out a newsroom.
- 39:21Most occasions we do try to aim for co -publication.
- 39:24And on that point, as we're talking about collaboration,
- 39:27Jane asked earlier, when you have a finding that
- 39:30you want the public to know about, How do you
- 39:32go about spreading that to the general public?
- 39:35My outlet has struggled with that. You mentioned
- 39:37earlier about how your site doesn't have much
- 39:39traffic. So how do you get your stories out there?
- 39:42How do you make an impact with them? Yeah, as
- 39:46I said before, unfortunately, not really through
- 39:50our website. Although I think our website does
- 39:54fulfill an important purpose, which is to showcase
- 39:59our work to the wider community of journalists,
- 40:03investigative environment, or whatever that can,
- 40:06you know, when we, we have some established partnerships
- 40:08because with, you know, media outlet that we've
- 40:11published multiple investigations with, and like,
- 40:14when we go to them with a new thing, you know,
- 40:18already know who we are and trust us to do, to
- 40:22do solid work. But when we approach new partners,
- 40:25having our website, showcasing our previous work,
- 40:30it definitely helps to get that partnership going
- 40:34and build trust. I would say that our website
- 40:40is meant for a more specialized audience of journalists.
- 40:46I think the partner publication is the place
- 40:51where the impact happens and where you know,
- 40:53the public is reached. And that's why for us
- 40:55is a hard rule. Like we do not publish anything
- 40:58without an media partner on board. Like we're
- 41:00not, we might begin like this and like sort of
- 41:04scoping around, but it's, we, we try to get a
- 41:08partner on board as early as possible, both because
- 41:11we think it's important to develop a story with
- 41:13a partner because different partners will have
- 41:15an interest in different angles. They will, you
- 41:17know, they very often is not always able to provide
- 41:21their own expertise, access, and everything else.
- 41:25So they're very much a core part of the reporting
- 41:27process. They're not just publishing partners
- 41:29in the vast majority of cases, but also because
- 41:34we believe that that's where the impact happens.
- 41:38That's an interesting hard line to take that
- 41:40you don't publish anything as an independent
- 41:43newsroom. And Jane's followed up with that and
- 41:46said, how do you go about reaching out to potential
- 41:49partners? And says, we've never had one long
- 41:51term. So what does that initial outreach look
- 41:55like? Is it a cold email? Is it a phone call?
- 41:59It really depends. Like my editor always says
- 42:02that we are not allowed to use the word pitching.
- 42:05So we do not send pitches and we do not pitch
- 42:08our stories. Which basically means that we don't
- 42:18try to hard sell ourselves at all. We usually
- 42:26try to go for reporters because we really want
- 42:28our partners to be hands on and we find that
- 42:30sometimes going to editors means that the thing
- 42:34either needs to be already ready or they're very
- 42:36busy doing lots of different things. So we try
- 42:39to go to reporters that we think Sometimes we
- 42:43already know them because we're all journalists
- 42:44that worked at different newsrooms beforehand.
- 42:47But even if we don't know them, we try to find
- 42:49somebody who has been publishing stuff about
- 42:52the topic that we are aiming to tackle and that
- 42:57we think would genuinely be interested in the
- 42:59investigation. And we have a contact we can find,
- 43:03but we usually just say like, oh, we're source
- 43:06material. This is our website. This is what we
- 43:09do. And we have like a story that we think could
- 43:12be interesting for you. Do you want to have a
- 43:14chat? We don't really send anything more than
- 43:16that most of the times. And then, you know, if
- 43:19they say, yeah, I'm curious, let's have a chat.
- 43:22And we have a chat, you know, about the story.
- 43:25And if they're interested, we kind of crack on
- 43:28from there. We're trying to be a little bit more
- 43:30systematic now with sort of laying out maybe
- 43:33like in just an email, we don't have any like
- 43:35sort of form. or specific NDAs or anything like
- 43:39that. But we tried to lay out a little bit of
- 43:43the collaboration and the aim of the collaboration,
- 43:45how we collaborate in writing now after a few
- 43:51experiences that didn't go quite as well. But
- 43:57I think the overarching thing that we say is
- 44:00that we're pulling all the resources or all the
- 44:03knowledge that any partner has at any point needs
- 44:05to be pulled in. Uh, everybody has access to
- 44:07everything at all times. Uh, beyond that, we
- 44:13sort of agree on who's doing what on a daily
- 44:15or on a sort of like weekly basis, whatever it
- 44:17is. But, um, but then like, we're very free to
- 44:20publish whatever we want to publish. So we don't
- 44:22just do copies of this, like, we don't just publish
- 44:25the same copy. If, if, you know, our partner
- 44:28wants to like publish it, you know, 5 ,000 words
- 44:32piece with a specific focus. We don't have to
- 44:35publish the same equally if they want to publish
- 44:37a news piece of 150 words. That's what they want
- 44:42to do. That's fine as well. So we're then very
- 44:45free to kind of do our own thing beyond that.
- 44:51Yeah. At Bellingcat it's called a Memorium of
- 44:55Understanding, MOU. That's usually the document's
- 44:59name. Yeah, it's super super useful to kind of
- 45:04just plot out each partner's responsibilities.
- 45:07In regards to environmental investigations, often
- 45:10you can start an investigation and have impact,
- 45:14but you're not necessarily going to solve the
- 45:16environmental issue that you're reporting on
- 45:18because it's just too massive. What do you...
- 45:22source material declare as, thank you Sussan
- 45:26and I if you're right, memoranda of understanding
- 45:28is exactly the wording. What do you kind of mark
- 45:32as impact in regards to a successful investigation?
- 45:37What would you deem a successful investigation
- 45:40when it comes to environmental? I think what
- 45:47we count as impact is really not in the sort
- 45:51of like viewing stats and sort of how many social
- 45:55media likes we get. Also because being published
- 46:00with partners that we don't really have access
- 46:02to any of that information, but we try to focus
- 46:05on real world impact. So whether that's like
- 46:09policy change or investment not going anymore
- 46:16to the company that we exposed. We've had quite
- 46:24a bit of success since early on. Before I even
- 46:28joined my company, we did a lot of work on carbon
- 46:33offsetting. We did that for a story with The
- 46:37Guardian that basically broke the carbon offsetting
- 46:41market. We tried to, after that, continue to
- 46:46do to do the sort of investigation that really
- 46:50can lead to change. My editor mentioned the other
- 47:01day some figure about how many millions of dollars
- 47:06of impact we've had, which is a very crude way
- 47:10to describe our impact, but also very effective
- 47:14if you think about how much money... at a very
- 47:19basic level these companies have and these industries
- 47:26are worse. So yeah, I think the two things are
- 47:30really like policy change and just an astral
- 47:36impact. Thanks for that insight. We've got about
- 47:4010 minutes left. So if anyone has any questions,
- 47:43now is the time to ask them. We had a question
- 47:46earlier about opportunities for applying environmental
- 47:51OSINT methods in conflict settings, like Sudan.
- 47:54I can say from Bellingcat's side, there's absolutely
- 47:58opportunities for applying environmental OSINT
- 48:00methods in those settings. It's needed in lots
- 48:04of different conflicts around the world. But
- 48:07in terms of your experience, Costanza, where...
- 48:11Does the way that you report and the way that
- 48:14you approach stories differ if the area that
- 48:18you're reporting on is hard to access, insecure
- 48:23in general? Have you done stories where accessing
- 48:27on the ground is just impossible and how do you
- 48:30adapt to that problem? We take risks, I guess,
- 48:44when we think that the story is worth taking
- 48:47those risks and we try to mitigate for them as
- 48:50much as possible. So a lot of people would have
- 48:52said that it's impossible to go to Cabo Delgado
- 48:55for a journalist. And indeed we were probably
- 48:58one of, you know, I was probably one of a handful
- 49:01of journalists who've been to Cabo Delgado in
- 49:03the last few years. But I think that there is
- 49:07other, it's about How can you tell the story?
- 49:11So I think what you said about, you know, using
- 49:15digital tools to investigate and with the invalid
- 49:19cut work, right? Like I haven't never done anything
- 49:22that comes even close to be as good, but you
- 49:24know, that's definitely like a method that that
- 49:29is worthwhile using because nobody wants to go
- 49:33and die or be kidnapped. Of course, we should
- 49:38use any method that is available. I think there
- 49:40is a value in gathering testimonies on the ground.
- 49:45But I think there has been cases of stories that
- 49:48I'm currently working on. And then we have published
- 49:51a specific one that comes to mind. about Nigeria
- 49:55is based again in a very insecure area with a
- 50:00lot of violence going on. And in those cases,
- 50:04we can think about, can we outsource the work
- 50:11in a safe way? What can we do? Because it's obviously
- 50:15the risk for us, but if we send somebody else,
- 50:17it's the risk that they are taking. and our duty
- 50:19of care towards them. And if we're involving
- 50:22sources on the ground, then they are taking our
- 50:24duties of care towards them. So I think all these
- 50:27conversations need to be had and there is no
- 50:29right answer. It's very much case by case. But
- 50:34I think that all should be done that is possible
- 50:38to be doing safely without having to go to the
- 50:42places. I think all these digital tools should
- 50:46be used to their fullest. And then when they
- 50:50fail, let's say, or when you reach that limitation,
- 50:54then I think that's when you start thinking about
- 50:56how can I do the work on the ground in a way
- 50:59that safeguards myself and everyone else who
- 51:01is involved. And I think those are very hard
- 51:03questions to answer sometimes and require months
- 51:06of work. And I cannot stress enough how we took
- 51:10a year before we went to Mozambique just to organize
- 51:12the trip and make sure that we were doing it
- 51:15in a safe way. It's not like a one -off risk
- 51:20assessment sort of checklist that you do in a
- 51:23couple of days. Yeah, it takes work and time.
- 51:27You mentioned earlier the Sentinel satellites
- 51:30that you've used. Obviously we often use satellites
- 51:35when access on the ground is difficult. And sometimes
- 51:38there's no satellite coverage, which makes reporting
- 51:41really digitally really hard. And you do have
- 51:43to have those conversations about, okay, so How
- 51:46do we gain eyes? How do we find a way to find
- 51:51out what's happening there? And those can be
- 51:54some hard questions to answer. In regards to
- 51:58tools, and we've only got time for about two
- 51:59more questions. In regards to tools and techniques,
- 52:02digital ones, what are your go -to tools and
- 52:05techniques that you use when you are doing the
- 52:08digital side of your reporting? Yeah, I think
- 52:12it really depends on the topic, but for example,
- 52:15with Yeah, I'm sure lots of people here are going
- 52:17to be familiar with ship tracking website, but
- 52:20there's some really great open tools like Global
- 52:25Fish and Watch. I use it a lot to track vessels.
- 52:31It's very good. Some of the organisation I mentioned
- 52:33before, I was just going through my story, Shadow
- 52:38Cruise. I think that was about the sailors that
- 52:42work on Shadow Fleet vessels. So we tracked them
- 52:45down through Telegram, but then we used a website
- 52:48called crewdata .com, which is kind of a LinkedIn
- 52:50for Russian speaking sailors mostly. We got loads
- 52:57of information from that website. I don't know
- 53:00if it's still available, maybe you need a VPN.
- 53:05But that was like, we got loads of information
- 53:08from there. For that, we use like all sorts of
- 53:14company's house or like company registries from
- 53:18a variety of different countries. I mentioned
- 53:21earlier Orbis is obviously very useful to find
- 53:24out about companies and people. It kind of like,
- 53:30I guess, yeah, satellite as I mentioned SkyTruth.
- 53:42Yeah, trade companies like Kepler and we'll do
- 53:4715 ,000 companies that do kind of the same job.
- 53:55I think what I try to do, and every time I do
- 53:58a new investigation, I kind of find new tools
- 54:00that are new companies that are keen to help
- 54:04out with different things. And they have got
- 54:07their very niche specialism. I'm literally booked
- 54:10in with another company that does ship tracking
- 54:14that I'd never heard of in a couple of days to
- 54:19check out there. their platform. So I almost
- 54:23think like every time I've got a new beat or
- 54:26like a new topic, I kind of try to like Google
- 54:31or find companies that provide data that is relevant
- 54:37for that specific topic, the forestation. Obviously
- 54:39we've got the amazing Santara Atlas that covers
- 54:42Indonesia, Malaysia and Colombia, I think in
- 54:45a few other countries. loads of other like a
- 54:50differentiation platforms. So it's really dependent
- 54:52on what topic you're looking at. And then we
- 54:56do like a lot of Google search and a lot of social
- 54:58media search, like just to find like, you know,
- 55:03when we had the dark guard story, the story about
- 55:07mercenaries working on shadow feed tankers, we
- 55:09got the original crew data from like a lot of
- 55:12different, the original crew data was like obtained
- 55:16by the dossier center, and I can't really go
- 55:18into how they got it. But we got loads, like
- 55:20thousands and thousands of sailors that worked
- 55:26on each other's feet. But then we just like used
- 55:28Google and social media to try and find them.
- 55:31And that was, you know, kind of unforgiving,
- 55:35extremely boring, and extremely like a low rate
- 55:38of success work. Yeah. And oftentimes that's
- 55:43kind of the work that we do. I just spent two
- 55:46hours this morning going through different vessels
- 55:50on Global Fishing Watch and a big spreadsheet
- 55:55to try and find sailors that worked on them.
- 55:59So it's kind of, yeah, it's kind of not that
- 56:03fancy. I'm going to have to push us a little
- 56:07bit over time because I want to ask a final question.
- 56:10But just as a quick aside on the tools, we had
- 56:13a talk from Christian Panton, who's amazing.
- 56:15He made a little tool called Sketchy Boats, which
- 56:18you might like, which is a list of boats that
- 56:21you probably need to be aware of, including some
- 56:24of the ones in your investigation that he monitors
- 56:27via a little tool. It's called Sketchy Boats,
- 56:30the tool. So definitely check that out. Also
- 56:33in this space, we have hashtag tools and sites,
- 56:36which is a list of tools and sites that might
- 56:38be useful. And we have the Bellingcat toolkit,
- 56:41which is not just Bellingcat tools. It is a list
- 56:45of open source tools, sorted by category. We
- 56:48have a category on environment and have a little
- 56:51look at that. There's lots of open source tools
- 56:53in there, including many of the ones that you
- 56:55just mentioned. So please do check that out.
- 56:58Final question to wrap. because we've had, obviously
- 57:02you're from source material. So we've had a lot
- 57:05of questions about sources. And there's quite
- 57:09a few, a bit of interest in how you get sources
- 57:13to feel comfortable to talk to you and what aftercare
- 57:17looks like when an investigation is about to
- 57:20come out with those said sources. So perhaps
- 57:23we can end on a little, a small overview of how
- 57:27you. maintain source relationship? Um, I think
- 57:32like something that is really helpful, um, for
- 57:35me is that I don't work for a daily newspaper.
- 57:38So I have plenty of time to develop relationships,
- 57:41uh, with sources. My investigation take, you
- 57:44know, from three months to a year and a half.
- 57:48So, um, that time is, is probably the main thing
- 57:52when it comes to building relationship with sources.
- 57:55I think. It's kind of the usual thing when you're
- 57:59interacting with another human being, be open
- 58:02and honest about what you're trying to achieve.
- 58:05I think there is no point promising things that
- 58:08you can't deliver. You will not know if their
- 58:11lives will be improved from you publishing the
- 58:14article. It's not something you can promise and
- 58:16it's very misleading. I think being clear on
- 58:20your objectives and why you're trying to talk
- 58:24to them and what their values are. what the value
- 58:27is of talking to them. I think all those conversations
- 58:33need to happen before you start having a conversation
- 58:36about the story and the stuff that you want to
- 58:39learn from them. I think that's kind of the basics.
- 58:44And then just jumping to the aftercare, I think
- 58:47that when I leave a place, let's say I've done
- 58:51a reporting trip or even if I've done it all
- 58:53digitally, There is usually quite a long time
- 58:56between that and when the story gets published.
- 58:58So it's important to maintain that relationship.
- 59:01It's not like, oh, once I got what I want, I'm
- 59:03out. It's kind of like, now we're staying in
- 59:09contact, I keep you updated on what's going on.
- 59:11If there is a delay, I'm explaining why there
- 59:13is a delay. At the same time, once you do that,
- 59:17you're kind of checking in on what's going on
- 59:19with them because their situation might have
- 59:21changed and it happened to us that you know someone's
- 59:24situation might have changed and all of a sudden
- 59:25it wasn't safe for them to be involved in even
- 59:28anonymously in the in the piece so we just moved
- 59:31them out and and I think just being I think a
- 59:35lot of like it's very cultural as well I think
- 59:37it's important to appreciate that not everybody
- 59:39responds the same way to things like you know
- 59:42people might be very blasé about the risks that
- 59:46they're taking, or people might be very afraid.
- 59:49So it's about judging as well, like, you know,
- 59:51trying to get to know somebody enough that you
- 59:54can judge when they respond in a certain way
- 59:57to a certain question about their safety or their
- 1:00:00wellbeing, what that actually means. Again, being
- 1:00:04a kind of human being. And then, yeah, once we
- 1:00:08publish, we usually inform them that the article
- 1:00:11is about to be published, that there might be
- 1:00:13like, you know, conversation around it. And then
- 1:00:17once we've published, we check in. And then I'm
- 1:00:21not going to pretend and say that, you know,
- 1:00:23I'm in touch with all my sources. I've done all
- 1:00:25my stories where it's of course not like. slowly
- 1:00:29things move on and relationships come to a natural
- 1:00:33end or there's a couple of cases where I'm still
- 1:00:35friends or acquaintance with some of the source
- 1:00:40I worked with. So it's just like a sort of naturally,
- 1:00:45once you've sort of made sure that there's not
- 1:00:48been any negative repercussions on them and all
- 1:00:51is good, then that's it. I hope that answers.
- 1:00:57Absolutely. And if you want to dive deeper into
- 1:01:01that, as I mentioned, we had that amazing talk
- 1:01:03with Eliza from the Fuller Project earlier this
- 1:01:06year. I linked it in the chat. I'll link it in
- 1:01:09the description of the podcast. It's called Protecting
- 1:01:10the People Within Your Research, and she covers
- 1:01:12a lot of this kind of source relationship stuff.
- 1:01:15So please do check that out. So much love for
- 1:01:19you in the chat, because thank you so, so much
- 1:01:23for coming in and just... enlightening us with
- 1:01:26your knowledge and your experience in this space.
- 1:01:30As I mentioned in the chat, if you're interested
- 1:01:32in talking about environment and wildlife stories,
- 1:01:35we have hashtag environment, wildlife, and we
- 1:01:37also have hashtag maritime. If you want to dig
- 1:01:39into ship tracking, there's lots of experts in
- 1:01:41that space as well, if you're ever looking for
- 1:01:44sources cause. And I have linked the contact
- 1:01:48email for source material if you want to get
- 1:01:50in touch with Cassandra and I've tagged her within
- 1:01:54the Discord as well in case you want to reach
- 1:01:55out here. But yes, thank you so much for your
- 1:01:58time and we'll be back in two weeks with another
- 1:02:01stage talk. Thank you so much. It was fun. Thank
- 1:02:04you for listening to the stage talk. If you'd
- 1:02:07like to catch a stage tour live where you can
- 1:02:10ask the guests questions, join the Bellingcat
- 1:02:13Discord server by visiting www .discord .gg slash
- 1:02:19Bellingcat. The music you've heard is titled
- 1:02:22Dawn by Newer Self and is courtesy of Artlist.