Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #56: Can Radical Moderation Save Our Politics? w/ Lauren Hall
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:05politics.
- 0:06I am your host, Paul Raider.
- 0:08It's another great guest episode today we've got for you.
- 0:11Whether you are new or not to the show, I start off interviews with a disclaimer that I do not
- 0:16take a stance for or against the guests' political views or groups they belong to, but
- 0:20that hasn't been an issue.
- 0:21I mean, it's not gonna be an issue today.
- 0:23So on to today's topic.
- 0:25The vast majority of today's political discourse focuses on the extremities.
- 0:30Who can have the hottest takes?
- 0:31Who could be first with those takes?
- 0:33Who could be the loudest and most obnoxious?
- 0:36Who can own the other side?
- 0:38Such issues have contributed massively to the degradation of our political discourse and
- 0:43ability to solve problems.
- 0:45So is moderation the solution?
- 0:48More specifically, is radical moderation the answer?
- 0:52What even is radical moderation?
- 0:54When, where, and how do we apply that?
- 0:56How does it address polarization?
- 0:58Well, here to talk about that today is the very person who coined the term radical moderation,
- 1:03doctor Lauren Hall.
- 1:04Lauren is an associate dean of academic affairs as well as a professor and political science
- 1:09department chair at the Rochester Institute of Technology.
- 1:12She's also a public speaker giving talks on a variety of subjects, including the role of
- 1:17family and civil society, the work life balance of women, the ninth amendment to The US
- 1:21constitution, political theory, and, of course, her concept of radical moderation.
- 1:26Lastly, she is the cohost of the We Made This Political podcast alongside a previous guest of
- 1:31this podcast, Laura Forkham.
- 1:33So let's dive into radical moderation and how it can improve the our political dialogue.
- 1:40Please welcome to the show, doctor Lauren Hall.
- 1:43Lauren, thank you for coming on today.
- 1:45How are you?
- 1:45Hi, Paul.
- 1:46I'm doing great.
- 1:47It's always it's great to be here.
- 1:49Well, that's great to have you here.
- 1:51So let's go maybe not quite to the very, very beginning, but a little bit before this whole
- 1:57concept of radical moderation.
- 1:59So why did you take a particular interest in moderation and coming up with your own
- 2:05prescription for it?
- 2:07So, know, I'm a, as you mentioned, I'm a political theorist by training.
- 2:11And so my first book is called Family and the Politics of Moderation, and that came out in
- 2:162014, I think.
- 2:19And one of the reasons that I got interested in that topic in general is that as I was studying
- 2:24political theory sort of across many centuries, I was struck by these patterns that I was
- 2:31seeing and what seemed to me just really obviously false dichotomies.
- 2:34So false dichotomies between sort of the individual and the community, right?
- 2:38Between, I mean, I talk a lot about sort of false binaries, so black and white, like black
- 2:42versus white thinking.
- 2:45Black lives matter, blue lives matter.
- 2:46Like we'll talk, I'm sure, about a lot of these sort of like false, these false binaries or
- 2:50false dichotomies, but one of the really obvious ones from my perspective was the sort
- 2:54of false distinction between the individual and the community.
- 2:58Now I'm an individualist, which means that I take really seriously individual rights,
- 3:01individual freedoms, but it always struck me as just a misunderstanding of like how humans
- 3:07develop and how humans grow and how we live, which is that humans have these incredible
- 3:12individual talents that we contribute, but we also are raised, develop within a social
- 3:17environment.
- 3:18Our brains actually require other human beings in order to grow and develop properly.
- 3:24Things like our language acquisition, we literally can't do without other human beings.
- 3:28That part of the brain stops growing if you don't have other people around.
- 3:32So what I got interested in, you know, back then was thinking about the way that the family
- 3:37kind of provides this moderating influence between different kinds of political theories,
- 3:41the ones that focus really heavily on sort of the community to the sort of extremes of things
- 3:47like radical communism, and then the folks who go to the other extreme, which is sort of
- 3:52radical individualism.
- 3:53And my point is like, hey, look, so look at this, like, totally natural thing in the
- 3:57middle, which is the family, which helps support individualism, also is so it kind of
- 4:02buffers both into the individualism and the communitarianism that we see that I think can
- 4:07fly into extremes.
- 4:10And then I think most recently I've gotten reinvigorated by the concept of moderation just
- 4:17because it seems to me so obvious that it's what we need in our modern political discourse,
- 4:23right?
- 4:24We are, as I think you mentioned in the beginning, right, we are in an age of extremes,
- 4:28and so to me, I've been thinking really deeply about sort of how we think about political and
- 4:33social problems in a way that steps past or steps around this really dangerous sort of
- 4:40binary tribalistic thinking about politics.
- 4:44Yeah.
- 4:44That that's something I try to focus on a lot too is this whole fall you call false binaries.
- 4:50I false dichotomies, that sort of thing.
- 4:53I I think they point about the, excuse me, the individual versus the community.
- 4:59I think that's also a good point too.
- 5:01That's not necessarily talked about a whole lot.
- 5:03You you have to respect individual rights and people's own individual identities, but at the
- 5:09same time, we're social creatures.
- 5:12The community is a porn.
- 5:13It has to be also about what's best for the community too.
- 5:17So definitely good points there.
- 5:19So let's go ahead on to the central idea of our conversation.
- 5:24So what exactly is radical moderation?
- 5:27Somebody might hear that and think, well, that seems kind of oxymoronic, but why name it that
- 5:33and what makes it more effective than a more generic form of moderation?
- 5:38Yeah.
- 5:39So I chose the term very intentionally because I think there's sort of two reasons.
- 5:46One is a sort of pragmatic reason and the other is a more principled reason.
- 5:50The pragmatic reason is that, you know, I think moderation has a clear marketing problem.
- 5:54I think when people think about moderation, they think you're just compromising for the
- 5:59sake of compromising, maybe you're conflict avoidant, maybe you don't have any principles
- 6:03at all, right, and you're just like, Whatever makes everyone happy, I don't care, right?
- 6:07I think that's a really inaccurate representation of what real principled
- 6:12moderation can mean.
- 6:14But when I use the term radical, I'm actually using it in even a deeper sense, which is that
- 6:18when we think about the term radical, it usually means a sort of complete rethinking of
- 6:25the framework for how you think about a problem, right?
- 6:29And so very often when we talk about radical politics, we're talking about completely
- 6:33reframing the dialogue, the discourse in a variety of different ways.
- 6:38And so I would like to do that for the concept of moderation, and so the way that I'm thinking
- 6:43about it is I mentioned those, you know, sort of false binaries, the sort of polarized
- 6:50options that we have.
- 6:51So we have like, you know, Democrats on one side, Republicans on the other.
- 6:55We have, you know, whatever, the right versus the left.
- 6:58And so we're basically, if we think about it, we're thinking about politics essentially in
- 7:02one dimension, right?
- 7:03This like one dimensional line where you're either on this end or you're on this end, and
- 7:07then the people in the middle are just sort of random, right?
- 7:09But there's this line, a single one dimensional line.
- 7:13Well, actually think about how the world actually operates, right?
- 7:15The world operates in all four dimensions.
- 7:18And so when I'm thinking about what radical moderation means, I'm really asking people to
- 7:22stop thinking about social and political problems along one dimensional right left
- 7:28lines, and instead, let's figure out a way to make it easier for ourselves to think and talk
- 7:35about political and social problems in all four dimensions.
- 7:39And so what that means is you not only have to understand sort of your own individual values,
- 7:43but you also have to understand what I call the second dimension, which is the people around
- 7:47you, the social network that you find yourself in, the broader kind of community that your
- 7:52decision has to be made in.
- 7:54The third dimension in sort of physics terms is height and depth, but in the social space,
- 8:00right, that's how hard is this thing?
- 8:02Like, what kinds of pits are people likely to fall into?
- 8:05What kinds of peaks do we have to climb?
- 8:07Like, what are the kinds of things that we really have to I mean, just there's a reality
- 8:11that some people walk along more complex life paths than other people.
- 8:15Some people have a lot much greater challenges than, for example, I do.
- 8:19And so that third dimension is really important to understand.
- 8:21And then the fourth dimension is one that I think we really often overlook, which is time.
- 8:27And so time impacts our politics and our social world, both in terms of historical time, you
- 8:34know, like US politics is different from European politics because we have totally
- 8:39different histories, totally different developmental paths, but then also, you know,
- 8:44you think about lifespan.
- 8:45My desires and interests and values at age 20 were very different than they are now that I'm
- 8:51a mother of three kids, I'm a administrator, I'm a writer, I have lots of things going on.
- 8:56So I think that, you know, and we can give a couple examples, you know, as we go through
- 9:01today, but I think that when we start thinking about political and social problems, instead of
- 9:07reducing them to these binary choices, these false dichotomies, really trying to dig into
- 9:13the full four dimensions of those political and social issues.
- 9:17And what I think you'll find, the first thing that you find is just deep complexity.
- 9:22And I think we've got to get comfortable with complexity, and we've got to get comfortable
- 9:25with not having immediate answers.
- 9:28Yeah.
- 9:28Because it's always easy to try to paint everything as more simplistic than it actually
- 9:33is.
- 9:33It's one of my biggest gripes personally with politics is everything's gotta be very boiled
- 9:38down to very simplistic terms, which, yeah, I mean, it's gonna get you more clicks and views
- 9:43and all that, but it's not helpful for overall discourse.
- 9:47And one of the early points you brought up in that answer, I remember seeing I saw a post
- 9:53actually, a LinkedIn post that you had also responded to about those misconceptions of what
- 9:58moderation actually is how a lot of people think it's apathetic when it's like, well, some
- 10:04people might be, but that's not inherent to being a moderate.
- 10:08So let's actually go a little bit more on along that line because on your sub stack, was
- 10:13reading, of course, what you had written about radical moderation there too, but you also
- 10:18wrote about what radical moderation is not, which perhaps is just as important as what it
- 10:24is.
- 10:24So besides what we just talked about there, what are some of the potential misconceptions
- 10:30you wanna clear up?
- 10:31Is it inherently middle of the road or always given to compromise, or is it just about the
- 10:36approach to political discussion?
- 10:38What are some of the other misconceptions that you wanna make clear are not the case?
- 10:42Yeah.
- 10:42So I think the the most obvious way that we often locate moderation on the political
- 10:47spectrum is sort of, like it's it's in between.
- 10:50Like, so if you're if you're a moderate, you're in between Republicans and Democrats, or you're
- 10:55sort of in between the right and the left, or you're sort of like maybe you're undecided.
- 11:00Right?
- 11:00And I just think that's a misunderstanding because I think we're falling victim to the
- 11:05idea that this one dimensional binary is the best way to describe human political life in
- 11:10the first place.
- 11:11So I think what we really have to do is say, Hey, let's stop using that framework
- 11:16altogether.
- 11:18Principled moderation does not fit into this false binary.
- 11:23It doesn't fit into the left right framework.
- 11:26And people have tried to make the political framework more complex.
- 11:29You can find the Political compass online, right?
- 11:32So people talk about sort of authoritarianism, like, so I mean, there's ways to make it more
- 11:36complicated and more, a little bit more complex, but either way, I think you can't
- 11:41easily locate moderation in space because it's so context dependent.
- 11:48And I want to be really clear that I don't mean it's relativistic.
- 11:51What I don't mean and this is the danger here.
- 11:54What I don't mean is that, like, the moderation is whatever you kind of want it to be.
- 11:58But what I do mean is that moderation is really sensitive to the context in which people find
- 12:03themselves.
- 12:04And so the specific policy solution for someone living in rural Alabama might be very different
- 12:09from the kind of policy solution that works in a place like my relatively affluent suburb in
- 12:15Upstate New York, and I think we have to pay attention to context.
- 12:18Like, we know that humans respond to their environment, and so it's really weird that we
- 12:22think that, like, a policy could just fit every single context, like, regardless of
- 12:27socioeconomic class or whatever other, you know, kinds of complexities people have.
- 12:32So I think it's really important that people know that, like, I don't moderation is not
- 12:35just, like, pick a middle point between two extremes because if those two extremes are
- 12:39terrible, then the middle is not going to be much better.
- 12:42But it's also not unprincipled.
- 12:44I think some of the most principled people I know, and in fact, some of the people who are
- 12:48writing, who are doing really important work on moderation right now, are deeply principled
- 12:54people.
- 12:54They care really deeply about human flourishing.
- 12:56They care really deeply about how we help solve some of the really, or at least overcome some
- 13:02of the really deep challenges that we're facing.
- 13:06But they don't see either side doing what needs to be done.
- 13:10And so I think that when we think about moderation as primarily about solution finding,
- 13:15right, coalition building, bringing people together to find actual solutions to our
- 13:21problems, that's certainly one, you know, sort of positive vision for it.
- 13:25But in terms of what it's not, right, it's not just like they're compromised, it's not just
- 13:29undecided voters, right, it's not just people who are sitting around sort of thinking like,
- 13:33Well, I don't like either side, so, you know, I'll just watch football.
- 13:38Right?
- 13:39Which is, by the way, that's a position that I'm super sympathetic to.
- 13:42Right?
- 13:42Like, it's I I have a PhD in political science, which means I'm sort of, like, contractually
- 13:47obligated to follow politics.
- 13:49But if you don't have to, you shouldn't.
- 13:53Like, it's not like modern politics is not about helping people.
- 13:57And so I actually don't think people should watch CNN or, like, Fox or I mean, I don't
- 14:01think people should I think you're better off watching football.
- 14:05I mean, we're Bills fans, so, of course, we have to be.
- 14:07But but this is the you know?
- 14:09So so, anyway, the I I think, you know, when we think about what moderation is not, it is not
- 14:14that sort of, like, mealy mouth, just sort of meeting in the middle for the sake of avoiding
- 14:20conflict.
- 14:22Yeah.
- 14:22I I the you know, you hear that phrase, it the truth is always somewhere in the middle, which
- 14:27I think is there's a problem with that being just as simplistic as just going too far one
- 14:33way or another.
- 14:34It's like, no, that that's that's that's not really thinking about it.
- 14:37Yeah.
- 14:37Sometimes the truth is somewhere in the middle.
- 14:39Sometimes maybe one side is right.
- 14:41And the thing about the complexity of it of these different regions, I think that's I think
- 14:49that's a good thing too because I think there is a problem when we have whether it's parties
- 14:55or ideological camps becoming too hegemonic where the Republican Party in everywhere or
- 15:01every state and then the Democratic Party in every state is becoming too we gotta fall in
- 15:07line on the exact same things.
- 15:08I don't think that's helpful for other people.
- 15:11Yeah.
- 15:11There's still some differentiation in the regional parties, but it's starting to become
- 15:16less and less at least from what I've observed.
- 15:19So, of course, we're gonna talk more about the theory of of radical moderation.
- 15:26And you're, like you said, you're a political theorist by trade.
- 15:29And so you you know very well that theory is one thing, but the actual application of a
- 15:34concept is another.
- 15:35So what do you think are, I don't know, two to three of the biggest roadblocks to actually
- 15:42applying radical moderation?
- 15:46Yeah.
- 15:46The first one, I think, would definitely be just the political incentives of our system.
- 15:50Right?
- 15:50So we have a winner take all system.
- 15:52We it's very, very hard for I mean, I think winner take all systems do a couple things.
- 15:56One, they tend to weed out political diversity.
- 16:00As you pointed out, right, it's becoming more and more the case that in order to be a
- 16:04Democrat, you have to have this very clear set of, you know, guiding values.
- 16:11I think people forget that that wasn't the case, you know, even twenty years ago.
- 16:16You could have blue dog Democrats and progressive Democrats, you could have Democrats
- 16:20from kind of all over the place, and they were held together by like a couple kind of like key
- 16:25values, but they weren't, there wasn't this like ideological purity test.
- 16:29Now the Republican Party has gone even further sort of over that ledge, which is that now you
- 16:34have like the MAGA sort of loyalty test, and you have more moderate Republicans or just more
- 16:42diverse Republicans and I'm using diverse in the sense of politically diverse Republicans,
- 16:47being primaried, right?
- 16:48Like they're just being primaried out of existence.
- 16:50So I think both parties have moved into the space of sort of deep ideological purity, but a
- 16:55lot of that is encouraged by the winner take all system, and so it becomes a lot easier for
- 17:01someone like Trump to sort of expect the party to fall in line behind his particular view of
- 17:08what politics should look like.
- 17:10I actually am a little heartened.
- 17:11I think it's interesting to see that there's a little bit of diversification happening on the
- 17:15Democratic side, in part because I think they've figured that they no longer really know
- 17:19how to appeal to voters, so they've got to try something new.
- 17:22You're seeing, I think, a little bit more of the cracks in the edifice on them, a little bit
- 17:26more potential pluralism on the Democratic side right now.
- 17:30But either way, the winner take all system, I think, makes it really hard for people to keep
- 17:38political pluralism and politically diverse candidates in the pool.
- 17:43The other thing that it does, though, is that it animates tribalism, so when you have this
- 17:47one or take all system, when you have a system that supports two parties, the assumption is
- 17:53that it's us versus them.
- 17:55And we actually saw this rhetoric in the last election, is, Oh, well, the Democrats are an
- 18:00existential threat to democracy, or, you know, the Republicans are an existential threat to
- 18:05democracy, and so we're feeding affective polarization just by the way that our sort of
- 18:10political system is set up.
- 18:11So that's one thing.
- 18:13As part of that process, we actually have a really weird primary system.
- 18:17I mean, one of the problems that we see in our broader political system is that a very, very
- 18:22tiny number of voters determine who the president is.
- 18:27And what I mean by that, we think we all vote, but the really crucial votes are actually the
- 18:32primary voters.
- 18:33And so when we're looking at Congress, when we're looking at, you know, either the House of
- 18:37Representatives or the Senate or the presidency, the most important voters in any
- 18:41election are primary voters, and so if you have these really they tend to be more extreme, they
- 18:48tend to be more ideologically pure, and they tend to be really much more politically active.
- 18:54Those are the people who are deciding for the rest of us what candidates we're voting for in
- 19:00the first place.
- 19:00So the primary system actually ends up being this really key sort of lever that is leading
- 19:07us into, I think, more and more extremist kinds of candidates.
- 19:11But the second thing is the media.
- 19:13I mean, I think a lot of us are aware that we have this really fragmented media landscape.
- 19:19It's becoming much I mean, algorithms, feed.
- 19:22I see this in my own my own posts.
- 19:24You know, I've been trying to figure out, like, sort of how to how to get people to see things
- 19:27on LinkedIn, and it's it's, first of all, a black box.
- 19:31I don't I still don't quite know why things some things go sort of semi viral on LinkedIn
- 19:36and others don't.
- 19:37I'm I'm with you there.
- 19:38It's like a weird right?
- 19:39It's like the weirdest I don't I do not understand it.
- 19:43But you do like, I find myself having to play all these, like, word games where I'm trying to
- 19:49sort of, like, ride the edge of outrage, but my whole point is that we don't wanna do that
- 19:56because otherwise no one will see anything that I write.
- 19:58And so it's really frustrating kind of, and I think, you know, in the podcasting space, we
- 20:02struggle with the same thing.
- 20:04So the algorithms and the way that I think social media has really sort of changed the
- 20:11broader media landscape is another thing that I think is really keeping us polarized.
- 20:17And as part of that, another thing that I'm really deeply concerned about as a political
- 20:20scientist is the speed at which misinformation and disinformation spreads on social media is
- 20:28just dramatic.
- 20:30And there's research that shows that false information spreads more quickly than true
- 20:35information.
- 20:36And a lot of that's because, well, it's more interesting, right?
- 20:40Like if you hear something that's just crazy, you're like, wow, let me check that out, right?
- 20:43And then you click on it.
- 20:44And I've seen really, I've seen people that I respect, you know, start spreading.
- 20:50You know, I mean, you have the sort of narrative that the twenty twenty election was
- 20:55stolen, but now there's another narrative on the other side that the twenty twenty four
- 20:59election was stolen because there was all of this monkeying with different kinds of
- 21:03electoral things, and as far as I can tell, there's almost no evidence for that, but people
- 21:07keep sharing it because it reinforces their preexisting beliefs and it seems like it makes
- 21:13them feel better.
- 21:14Like, oh, now I understand the world in a better way.
- 21:17So those are two things that I think are really I mean, I think the structure of our system and
- 21:22then the media landscape itself are both really difficult things to to deal with right now.
- 21:29I I think the whether you're even if you don't agree with moderation, radical moderation, I
- 21:35think a lot of people can agree on both of those overall points.
- 21:39And there's there's so many things I wish I could respond to that you just great points
- 21:43that you just made to made there that I wish I could respond to all of them, but obviously
- 21:48don't have time for all that.
- 21:50But with, yeah, what they they you were talking about with LinkedIn.
- 21:53I I like a month ago or so, I'm I made a post about how what real accountability is, and it's
- 22:02like, not just if you're only holding people accountable that are that don't think like you,
- 22:09that's not real accountability.
- 22:10But Mhmm.
- 22:11At but that one did big numbers out of nowhere, and nothing else I've had has come even close.
- 22:17I don't I don't really understand.
- 22:18Although one person somehow reposted and got the idea that I was still trying to basically
- 22:25proselytize for one particular ideology, which I really didn't know how they got that out.
- 22:30I'm very careful to not try to favor one side or the other.
- 22:34But but like I said, obviously, can't speak on all those great points you made there.
- 22:40But so we know why the most extreme voices in politics like to paint things as false binaries
- 22:47or dichotomies because they have a political incentive to do so.
- 22:50And a lot of times they I mean, some people are grifters that don't really actually believe it.
- 22:55They just wanna make money and get clicks.
- 22:57But oftentimes, they truly believe everything is as black and white as they think it is and
- 23:01that they figured everything out.
- 23:03But do you think that people that are not necessarily as extreme in their partisan or
- 23:07ideological views are also susceptible to binary thinking, and why or why not do you
- 23:13think that is?
- 23:15Oh, absolutely.
- 23:16So, you know, I I I call myself sort of a recovering, immoderate.
- 23:22When, you know, when when social media first, you know, I was a young faculty member when
- 23:26when social media first kind of got going, and and, man, I was obnoxious, right, in terms of
- 23:33sort of being that, like, person, like, well, actually, right, like, here's some data.
- 23:38Right?
- 23:38You're
- 23:39I definitely did that too.
- 23:41Right?
- 23:41I mean, it's really it's it's and I remember what actually what actually really got me to
- 23:49rethink that was first of all, I mean, was obvious that it wasn't having any like effect,
- 23:55right?
- 23:55Like I wasn't actually changing anyone's mind, but that actually wasn't the most relevant
- 23:58thing from my perspective.
- 24:00But what I found is that it was actually, I was like, it was really triggering my anxiety And,
- 24:07and I was just getting agitated.
- 24:09And so I would find myself thinking about Facebook posts, you know, when I'm trying to
- 24:14put my kids to bed.
- 24:15And that's like a weird feeling, right?
- 24:17When you're like, I have three beautiful human beings who I love more than anything in the
- 24:21world, and I want to spend time with them.
- 24:24And meanwhile, my brain is thinking about, like, trying to own someone on a Facebook
- 24:29thread from, like, two p.
- 24:31M.
- 24:31Like, what am I doing?
- 24:32Right?
- 24:33So I think part of what I, you know, the practical, I think there's a big picture
- 24:38problem of polarization that I hope radical moderation can help address.
- 24:42But in my personal life, it has been transformative because it has helped me back
- 24:48away from a lot of the behaviors and approaches to the world that were inadvertently feeding
- 24:54like my anxiety and overwhelm.
- 24:56So thinking that your neighbors are your enemies, that actually leads to like a lot of
- 25:01anxiety and overwhelm.
- 25:02It leads to like agitation, it leads to anger, a lot of negative feelings, Thinking that half
- 25:07of Americans are racists or bigots is like a pretty crappy way to go about your day.
- 25:12Like it actually feeds a lot of really negative things in your brain.
- 25:16And so to me, radical moderation, when I actually started practicing the sort of what I
- 25:23was preaching in terms of being curious, being humble, stepping back from the keyboard and
- 25:29not, you know, like anytime you're tempted to say, well, actually, like, your mouth and go
- 25:35take a break.
- 25:35Here's why you're stupid.
- 25:37Yeah.
- 25:38Like, don't don't do that.
- 25:39So everyone is susceptible to this because the human brain is we're wired to think in terms of
- 25:46tribalistic kinds of, right?
- 25:47We're wired to think in terms of group membership.
- 25:50It's a huge part of who human beings are.
- 25:54It's why, for example, you know, sports fans get so rabid about their particular sports
- 25:59team, but it's also why we get so rabid about politics even when we actually dislike a lot of
- 26:04what our political leadership is doing, right?
- 26:07We still find ourselves in this kind of tribalistic space.
- 26:10So I don't think, I mean, I think there's some people who are more likely to think in black
- 26:14and white terms than others, but I think it's a real mistake to think that you're either a
- 26:22black and white thinker or you're like this deeply nuanced complex thinker.
- 26:26I know as a former black and white thinker that you can absolutely move into the nuanced space.
- 26:31It's just a matter of practice.
- 26:33I mean, lot of this stuff is actually stuff that people learn in like cognitive behavioral
- 26:36therapy, which I didn't know about until very recently, but like just the way that your
- 26:41thoughts color your experience of the world is
- 26:45a
- 26:45really powerful thing.
- 26:46So so, yeah, I think practice makes perfect, but we are all susceptible to these kinds of
- 26:52things because we're human.
- 26:54We're deeply human, and that's okay, but we just have to be aware of it.
- 26:58I was pointing to myself when you described that how you used to be on social media.
- 27:03Minus minus the kids part.
- 27:04I don't have kids.
- 27:05I would like to have kids someday, but minus the kids part, I was I was definitely the same
- 27:09way, especially when I was in high school.
- 27:10Oh gosh.
- 27:11I was just I was wasn't intentionally obnoxious just was, but I I think that's I'm glad that
- 27:17you you brought that up because with the effect of polarization or affective polarization that
- 27:22you talked about, because that's something I've been working on too and trying to get a TED
- 27:28talk going on about is basically this effect of polarization, but and then also an educational
- 27:33email courses because anybody can be polarized.
- 27:37It Yep.
- 27:38You even if you're not polarized long partisan lines, maybe you're a hardcore independent.
- 27:42Maybe you're you're moderate ideologically, but you can still absolutely hate both the left and
- 27:51right.
- 27:51And that's still a form of polarization because it's it's how you feel about people.
- 27:55So that's something I try to also teach people to like, no, anybody can be polarized.
- 28:01You don't think that you're not susceptible to it.
- 28:03It happens to me sometimes.
- 28:05Sometimes I just have a knee jerk reaction to somebody.
- 28:07And then I sometimes have to catch myself.
- 28:09So all that self awareness and teaching yourself like you were talking about.
- 28:14So Actually, Paul, can I add one quick thing?
- 28:17Sure.
- 28:17You know, I think one of the things too, there there isn't anything necessarily wrong by
- 28:22itself with polarization.
- 28:24So I know, you know, I'm a Catholic convert and I have friends.
- 28:30I mean, like, every single religious belief system is out there in my friend group, but we
- 28:38all believe very different things.
- 28:40Either you believe that Jesus is the son of God or you don't, and so that is a polarized
- 28:45belief.
- 28:46But it's okay to have different beliefs from other people, but your point, which is a really
- 28:50important one, is that it's the affective polarization that's so dangerous.
- 28:54So if I'm having lunch with my Jewish friend, right, we're just hanging out doing our thing,
- 29:00we can have very polarized beliefs about certain kinds of things, and yet those beliefs
- 29:05don't have to interfere with the way that we care about each other or join with each other
- 29:10in friendship.
- 29:13Where it becomes dangerous is when my beliefs, I start thinking that the people who don't
- 29:17believe like me are actually dangerous, and that is where we are politically now.
- 29:22And so it's not a matter of, like, I can have wonderful conversations with libertarians and
- 29:28communists all day long.
- 29:31What gets dangerous is when I start thinking that libertarians or communists are dangerous
- 29:36to me as a human being because that's what animates subtribalism and that's what animates
- 29:41the really dangerous kind of affective polarization that we're seeing.
- 29:44So, you know, I think it's I don't want people to think that we're arguing that strong beliefs
- 29:50are bad or that having deeply held beliefs about the world is a bad thing.
- 29:56That's not a bad thing.
- 29:57The bad thing is what you were pointing to, which is thinking that the other side is either
- 30:02dumb or equal.
- 30:03Right?
- 30:03That's affective polarization.
- 30:05That's toxic polarization, and that's what we really wanna try to avoid.
- 30:09Yeah.
- 30:10That whole anything that's not not like me is an existential threat, and it's just, like you
- 30:15said, it's sports too.
- 30:16I I mean, I don't I don't quite get existential threat about football.
- 30:20My my undergraduate alma mater's football season actually starts today.
- 30:23So I'm gonna go go go into the game later.
- 30:25But, yeah, I sometimes, you know, every once in while you get animated and get very annoyed at
- 30:30one side.
- 30:30But yeah, like actually thinking that there are threats to your existence.
- 30:34We gotta pump the brakes here a little bit guys.
- 30:36Yep.
- 30:37But I mentioned before that you are a professor, but you're also now a lot more also
- 30:42on the education administration side.
- 30:44So regardless of whether when you were just a professor or your professor and education
- 30:51administrator now, did you teach this concept of radical moderation in your classes in some
- 30:56way?
- 30:57And whether you did or didn't, how can elements of it be implemented in our educational system,
- 31:02but particularly when it comes to civics and government?
- 31:04Yeah.
- 31:05I actually think I made some really important mistakes as a political science professor over
- 31:10the years that I didn't that I wish that I had come up with this framework much sooner.
- 31:16And this is actually why I think people who teach politics should also take some classes in
- 31:22political psychology and social psychology to try to understand sort of how people think
- 31:27about these principles.
- 31:30And that's becoming more common in political science departments, but it's not, it's still
- 31:33not the norm.
- 31:35And so, you know, when I think about, so I used to teach a class called Ethical Debates in
- 31:39American ics, and what I was trying to do is get students to see so this is where the
- 31:44radical moderation came in.
- 31:45What I was trying to get students to see is the complexity of what they are thinking about as
- 31:50binary choices or these false dichotomies.
- 31:54So, you know, we looked at, like, you know, pretty contentious issues like abortion, gun
- 32:00control, immigration.
- 32:02Right?
- 32:02And and my goal was to try to get them to understand the full moral landscape of these of
- 32:09these policy issues.
- 32:12Where I think and and so I I think I did an okay job in that realm.
- 32:16Where I really screwed up, though, is that one of the final assignments for that class was an
- 32:22in class debate where students had they were assigned one side or the other, and they had to
- 32:27debate each other.
- 32:29And I realized later looking back on it, you know, I haven't been in the classroom for a
- 32:32couple years now because I'm I'm in the dean's office, but, I was looking back on that, and I
- 32:36was like, what a stupid thing to do.
- 32:38Like, you spend this whole semester trying to get people to think about like this idea, these
- 32:42ideas in a complex kind of nuanced way.
- 32:44And then you end with this, like, straight up tribalistic fight.
- 32:49Right?
- 32:49Like, now you guys are gonna get at it.
- 32:51Right?
- 32:52And and students, they got a lot out of it.
- 32:54I think that, you know, the debate was the debate format was not what I would have chosen,
- 32:59but it was really helpful to have them verbalize.
- 33:02Right?
- 33:03The I mean, like, it's always good to get public speaking practice and all that kind of
- 33:06stuff.
- 33:07But I didn't realize that I was I was actually undoing a lot of the work that I'd been doing
- 33:12over the course of the semester.
- 33:13So when I'm thinking about how we can do this better in the classroom, there's a lot of
- 33:20different frameworks that people are developing and this is I'm really excited about these.
- 33:24One is the Pluralist Lab, which was put together by folks at the Marketa Center, and
- 33:30you can watch it in action in the movie Undivide Us, but they did it's just a really
- 33:36neat model where it it encourages people.
- 33:39So so the normal sort of academic process is I tell you what I believe, and then you tell me
- 33:45what you believe, and then we try to convince each other that we're wrong.
- 33:49Right?
- 33:49Like, that's like the usual academic context.
- 33:51The Pluralist Lab actually starts with asking people to think curiously about their own
- 33:57understandings of what other people are believing.
- 34:00Right?
- 34:00And so it starts from a place of curiosity and humility instead of starting with, I am going
- 34:06to defend my belief in X, Y, or Z.
- 34:11So it moves us out of this defensive posture and into an open and curious posture.
- 34:16There's other models, the breaking bread model, there's like a number of other Braver Angels
- 34:21does a lot of work in this space.
- 34:23So I think there's a lot of people experimenting with what education could look
- 34:27like that doesn't start with either a professor at the front of the room telling students what
- 34:33to think about a specific issue or pitting people against each other in this one
- 34:38dimensional kind of way.
- 34:40And the role I think of education should be, I mean, if we want to be well rounded human
- 34:44beings, leading, you know, leading lives of sort of meaning and purpose, we have to learn
- 34:49how to talk to each other and we have to learn how to talk to people who are different from
- 34:52us.
- 34:53And the only way that you can really do that is if you get curious about why they think
- 34:58differently than you.
- 34:59Like, that's, I think, the sort of starting point that you have to to be at.
- 35:03So so there's really interesting models.
- 35:06I have not used any in the classroom because I sort of didn't realize how much I was screwing
- 35:10up until I was out of the classroom.
- 35:12So so I'm a cautionary tale.
- 35:14You know?
- 35:14Well, we all got out there.
- 35:16Yeah.
- 35:17We all got things to improve on.
- 35:18Right?
- 35:18We're all human beings.
- 35:19But but I mean, I mean, that makes sense.
- 35:22That's the normal way of thinking like, oh, you gotta take one side even if it's not the one
- 35:26you normally think, and then you have to defend it to the death.
- 35:28But I think it's perfect way to, you know, get people to really think now some people you
- 35:34still gotta try to convince them to think honestly about their own views, but the whole,
- 35:39hey, really think hard about what's a blind spot in your personal view.
- 35:44What's a point that somebody else made that, you know, okay.
- 35:46I see what they're saying there.
- 35:48I think those are, you know, great tools to teach kids.
- 35:51Unfortunately, I think a lot of people in general haven't been taught that and even, you
- 35:55know, beyond college, we have to be able to teach people that because they don't have
- 35:59classes to go to for that.
- 36:01Mhmm.
- 36:02But but that's that might be out of the purview of this discussion.
- 36:06So let's now, excuse me, let's actually instead envision a society where more people have
- 36:13adopted at least some aspects of your model of radical moderation.
- 36:20What do you think this would lead to?
- 36:22What outcomes do you want to see?
- 36:25Well, the biggest I mean, I think there's two there's an individual level outcome and then a
- 36:29and then a sort of social society wide outcome.
- 36:33The the individual level outcome is, I think, people would be much less overwhelmed.
- 36:39They would be much less anxious, and they would be much more likely to participate in political
- 36:44activity if political activity wasn't so ugly.
- 36:47And I don't mean political activity in the sense of people running for office.
- 36:52I actually don't care as much about stuff like that.
- 36:53But getting out into your community, helping people, creating a space where people want to
- 36:59be together and they want to make their communities better.
- 37:01So on an individual level, I think that if we practice I know that for me, radical moderation
- 37:07has been really, really helpful, and it helps in my administrative work because when someone
- 37:14comes to me with a problem, I'm able to instead of going with my gut reaction, which is what I
- 37:20might have done fifteen years ago, I I'm able to take a step back and say, like, let's say
- 37:26let's survey the entire sort of four dimensions of this space, including the reality that,
- 37:30like, the person coming to me only has a piece of the story too.
- 37:34Like, I can't I can't just assume that this person in front of me is telling an entirely
- 37:39accurate story, not because they're bad people or deceptive, but because everyone has
- 37:43different perceptions about how conflicts arise or whatever the situation is.
- 37:47So on a personal level, I think it's really powerful, but on a social level, and this is
- 37:52what I think really kills me at the end of the day, our political binaries and the sort of
- 37:58false binaries, the false dichotomies that we allow to flourish are deeply, deeply harmful
- 38:03because they prevent us from finding solutions to the problems problems that we need to solve
- 38:07the most.
- 38:08So if we look at why our immigration policy is so awful and inhumane, it's because we have not
- 38:17been able to get an actual real bipartisan effort to care about immigration in a
- 38:22meaningful way because it's been much more effective for the two parties to just aim barbs
- 38:27at each other instead of actually trying to help solve the problem.
- 38:31Criminal justice reform has been stymied for years, And by the way, I'm not talking about a
- 38:36specific vision of immigration reform or a specific vision of criminal justice reform.
- 38:41I'm just talking about a system that works better for the people who are stuck in the
- 38:46system, And so even if we decided, you know, maybe we decided that we we go we really,
- 38:53really restrict immigration.
- 38:54Right?
- 38:55That would not be personally a position that I would agree with, but you could come up with a
- 39:00humane immigration system that dramatically restricted immigration that would still be
- 39:06dramatically better than what we have now.
- 39:08Right?
- 39:09Because right now we have millions of people living in legal limbo who have no easy way out
- 39:14because our politicians have just abdicated, right?
- 39:18They've just said, Well, this isn't our problem because there's no incentive for us to solve
- 39:22it.
- 39:23So that gets back to your first point about like the political incentives are not actually
- 39:27aimed at solving human problems.
- 39:28They're aimed at winning elections.
- 39:30So I think that if we got better at radical moderation, we would be better at talking about
- 39:35these really hard political topics, and we would be better at identifying bipartisan,
- 39:40nonpartisan, creative solutions to these problems that are much more humane, that
- 39:47contribute to human flourishing in really meaningful ways, that almost definitely save
- 39:52money.
- 39:53Right?
- 39:53The worst possible way to do policy is the way that we do policy, which is in this really
- 39:58disorganized hyper polarized way where you undo the stuff the previous president did, you waste
- 40:03all of these resources in order to do so, and you're just scoring points, right?
- 40:09What a huge waste of taxpayer dollars.
- 40:13So to me, I think the only way out is to at least think about, and you don't have to call
- 40:20it radical moderation, right, but to actually think in a meaningful and complex and nuanced
- 40:26way about political problems and find people wherever they are, whatever party they're in,
- 40:33who can help you address those problems.
- 40:37It's you took the words out of my mouth while I was gonna I was gonna mention the whole, you
- 40:41guys you had already highlighted, and then you you you specifically said the whole pendulum
- 40:46inevitable.
- 40:47I it's always easy to think when you're on the outside looking in that everything's all doom
- 40:52and gloom, but the pendulum inevitably swings back and forth between the two parties.
- 40:56So you have a solution quote unquote.
- 41:00Now when a new regime comes in, it's just gonna swing the other way and then you we really
- 41:08haven't solved anything.
- 41:09You need something longer lasting.
- 41:11And like you said, unfortunately, there's just not a lot of incentive for it, and we don't
- 41:17actually solve anything.
- 41:18And now we have over $36,000,000,000,000 in debt, which it doesn't really matter what your
- 41:23politics are.
- 41:24That's not helpful for anybody.
- 41:25Nobody wants that kind of debt, but, you know, nobody has all the answers.
- 41:29We need to all actually come together and discuss things.
- 41:33But you you you kind of already touched on this question now, so let's go a little bit further
- 41:38into it because something I've been thinking about lately is how a lot of polarized and
- 41:43extreme people, they don't actually think that they're polarized or extreme.
- 41:48They think it's everybody else or at least the quote unquote other side.
- 41:52They're the ones that are extreme.
- 41:54I'm okay.
- 41:55So how do you think we address that issue?
- 41:57Is radical moderation something that could work for work with them?
- 42:03Yeah.
- 42:03I think part of why people often don't think that they're as as sort of extreme or they're
- 42:08as polarized and and, actually, by the way, the research on Americans as a country, right, like
- 42:14as citizens broadly, the American people are much less polarized than political elites are.
- 42:21Right?
- 42:22The highest levels of affective polarization are among political elites, and so that's like
- 42:26a fancy word for like politicians, right?
- 42:29Really well known public speakers, academics, like news, you know, figureheads on the news,
- 42:34right?
- 42:35Those kinds of people.
- 42:36So the average American actually is pretty non polarized, but what is happening, and we just
- 42:43interviewed Daniel Yidkin on our podcast, who works for More in Common, and they coined the
- 42:50term the exhausted majority, right?
- 42:52The vast, you know, majority of Americans are sort of in this space, and I'm actually sure
- 42:57Laura talked about this too in talking about independent voters, right, like that growing
- 43:00block of people who are like, what the heck is going on?
- 43:04So now I've lost track of your original question, my overall point was, you know,
- 43:10there's a lot of optimism when we look at the American people themselves because we are
- 43:14actually, I think, better than our political leaders.
- 43:16We're better than the political elites out there.
- 43:19But we have to find a way to make our voices heard, and that is where it's so hard, right?
- 43:24Because of all the clickbait and the algorithms and all the other things that we talked about
- 43:28previously and the political incentives, it's really hard for a bunch of, like, exhausted
- 43:32people who are working full time jobs and raising kids and living their lives to counter
- 43:39the kind of really pointed and incentivized polarized dialogue that is coming out of
- 43:48Washington and other places.
- 43:51So I don't know if that addressed your question, but I I like to think about, you
- 43:55know, how the American people are better than than our leaders.
- 43:59No.
- 44:00I think that's a good point that that you brought up.
- 44:02You know, we gotta make sure that we realize that elites, politicians, candidates,
- 44:07campaigners, they're not they don't think the exact same way as the American people even
- 44:12though they like to think that they speak for the American people all the time.
- 44:17So I wanna get to there's a couple more questions now, and then I wanna get the well,
- 44:22if we have time and then the random fun, not political question.
- 44:26But Yeah.
- 44:27I I came across a LinkedIn post of yours actually the other day that I wanna explore
- 44:32further with the audience.
- 44:34You basically talked about rising authoritarianism in The US.
- 44:37Now whether for for those of you who whether you think Donald Trump is authoritarian or not,
- 44:42that's that's that's beside the point.
- 44:44And but in short, you said that even though you should speak out about you should not force
- 44:49people to take a side because that's what authoritarians want.
- 44:52And now I I agree with that sentiment even though I think some people who aren't
- 44:55necessarily authoritarian also wanna force you to pick a side, but that's also beside the
- 44:59point.
- 45:00So how do we how do you think we teach people this idea that you shouldn't force people to
- 45:05take a side when politicians, influencers, social media, regular media media, etcetera,
- 45:11all want to instill this you're with us or against us mentality?
- 45:14How do we address that?
- 45:16Well, it's not even just like those stakeholders that you just mentioned, but I
- 45:21mean, I have lots of friends who hated that post, who thought I was deeply morally wrong
- 45:28because their position is like, you have to stand up against authoritarianism.
- 45:32Like if you have, I mean, I know people who are comparing the current administration to, you
- 45:37know, 1940s Germany and saying like, look, we are, you know, if you're sitting here in the
- 45:42wings, you are contributing to the downfall of liberal democracy.
- 45:46Right?
- 45:47I don't think we're there yet by any stretch of the imagination, but what I think those folks
- 45:53don't see, and these are really principled people who love liberal democracy as a, you
- 45:58know, I'm using the term liberal democracy in, like, the broadest sense, like a democracy that
- 46:03cares about people's rights and freedoms.
- 46:06If you love liberal democracy, you are going to need coalitions.
- 46:11You're going to need people to want to work with you later.
- 46:16And so what was so powerful about Hitler's rise Germany was that he was able to pit the
- 46:26population against each other.
- 46:28He actually forced people to take sides.
- 46:30And so by doing so, he made people enemies who should have been allies, who could have been
- 46:36allies if they hadn't fallen into this trap that he set for them.
- 46:41He did that intentionally, right?
- 46:42Or at least the party did.
- 46:44And so when I see people saying, you know, if you voted for the X candidate, I can't talk to
- 46:50you anymore because you are a racist or a bigot or an authoritarian or whatever, right?
- 46:56Like you stand for whatever this person stands for or whatever I think this person stands for,
- 47:01you're cutting yourself off at the knees because politics and a lot of resistance is
- 47:08about relationships.
- 47:10It's about getting into the it's about creating coalitions.
- 47:15It's about creating relationships.
- 47:16It's about creating communities of people who may share not very much in common other than
- 47:23coming together and realizing that this particular thing is really bad.
- 47:26And so I think the ideological purity test that I see people on the right and the left
- 47:32requiring of people is really, really dangerous.
- 47:35Now that doesn't mean that you don't come out, right, as a political scientist.
- 47:39I can look at certain kinds of things like the consolidation of power in the executive,
- 47:47attacks on federalism, right, the the all of the ways that the Trump administration is, in
- 47:52fact, centralizing power.
- 47:54Those are actual empirical facts that from a political science perspective are in fact
- 48:00dangerous.
- 48:01Right?
- 48:01They they have the potential to lead in dangerous places.
- 48:05I can say that out loud.
- 48:06I can write it on my substack.
- 48:08I can say it here.
- 48:09But the last thing that I should do is say, hey, Paul, you have to agree with me that Trump
- 48:16is an authoritarian.
- 48:17Right?
- 48:17By the way, that's a much different claim than the claim that I just made about centralization
- 48:23of power and so on.
- 48:25But when I shift over to saying, you have to agree with me on this particular issue, or I
- 48:31won't be on your podcast, or I won't talk to you on Facebook or LinkedIn or whatever, well,
- 48:36now all of a sudden, I've taken someone who might actually agree with me on a number of
- 48:40issues and I've just alienated you.
- 48:43Then the next time somebody says like, Hey, what do you think about Lauren Hall and her
- 48:45work on radical moderation?
- 48:47Gonna be like, Ah, it was kind of weird.
- 48:48No, she sucks.
- 48:50She's terrible.
- 48:50Yeah.
- 48:51But I, you know, so I think it's I understand why people feel as though when you speak out
- 48:57about things, part of speaking out means that you you need to persuade other people to agree
- 49:02with you.
- 49:04But I think they should actually try to cut that second piece off.
- 49:08Speak out about the dangers you're seeing.
- 49:10Absolutely.
- 49:11But when you start forcing other people to take your side in order to maintain relationships,
- 49:18in order to be in community with them, that's where I think we're we're playing into the
- 49:23authoritarian playbook in a really dangerous way.
- 49:28I think that's a great point.
- 49:29And excuse me.
- 49:31Yeah.
- 49:31There are some times where, yes, you have to take a stand about something.
- 49:35There is some truth to the if you don't stand for something, you'll fall for anything.
- 49:39Mhmm.
- 49:41Praise for lack of a better term.
- 49:42But like you said, if if you are trying to force people to nobody wants to be forced to
- 49:49think something.
- 49:50And you might find people who on the surface are very MAGA, but if you try to push them
- 49:56away, you can't really have any dialogue to say, like, hey.
- 49:59But don't you think this thing that Trump did is terrible?
- 50:02And likewise, if you find somebody who's a Democrat and you tell them they have to get in
- 50:06line with Donald Trump, well, now maybe there might have been something that Donald Trump did
- 50:09that they might actually support, but you're you're, again, you're pushing them away.
- 50:14Nobody actually changes their mind when you force them to unless they're just doing it just
- 50:18to placate you.
- 50:19But I Perfect points there.
- 50:23So before the the final final question, any final thoughts on moderation, radical
- 50:32moderation, polarization, anything of that sort that you want to share?
- 50:37No.
- 50:37I just I just think, you know, what I would love people to know about radical moderation is
- 50:41that I think if we all practiced it more, our own lives would be actively better.
- 50:46We would be less anxious, less overwhelmed, less frustrated with the people around us, but
- 50:52then it would also have a really powerful impact on the way that we talk about the the
- 50:57problems that we need to solve the most as communities.
- 50:59So Yeah. Hope
- 51:01Hope you will follow.
- 51:03Yeah.
- 51:03And that and that's that's what it's all about is actually solving problems now.
- 51:07Obviously, polarized people who are definitely not moderate.
- 51:11They definitely think that they've got the solutions and that they've already fixed the
- 51:16problem, but, of course, that's that's a whole other discussion that it's a little bit outside
- 51:21this purview, and we don't have time for it anyway.
- 51:24So let's go ahead to the final question.
- 51:27So if you're new to the podcast or if I mean, if you're, I mean, if you're you're familiar
- 51:31with it, you already know this.
- 51:32But if you're new to the podcast, I like to always end guest episodes by asking a random
- 51:37nonpolitical question for fun just to add a little variety to show and uplift things a
- 51:43little bit because politics obviously can be often negative, unfortunately.
- 51:48But for you, Lauren, today's random question of the day is, and this is not an attack on New
- 51:53Yorkers because we have plenty of these people in Florida here too.
- 51:57What is a common bad driving behavior that really bothers you?
- 52:00If you want, can give two examples.
- 52:03A common bad driving?
- 52:05Is that what you said?
- 52:06Yeah.
- 52:06Yeah.
- 52:07Oh, okay.
- 52:09We're really terrible about driving in the left lane, which should be reserved for passing.
- 52:15And I mean, this is, I think, a nationwide problem, but probably our largest frustration
- 52:19is on the New York State Thruway.
- 52:21People who hang out in the left lane.
- 52:24No.
- 52:25Get to the right.
- 52:26People need to get around you.
- 52:28Yeah.
- 52:28That would be one one big frustration.
- 52:33I don't know if we have I mean, so I'm I'll I'll say this.
- 52:37I'm in Western New York, and so we don't have the same traffic.
- 52:42I do not drive in New York City because you take your life in your hands doing that.
- 52:48Yeah.
- 52:48So the Downstate New York City drivers are a different breed than those of us Upstate.
- 52:56We have to grapple with snow and ice and all sorts of natural disasters that they don't have
- 53:03to do, but they just have to deal with other people, and that's bad enough.
- 53:06So
- 53:07Yeah.
- 53:07I I will admit.
- 53:08I I don't I don't drive slow in the left lane, but admit I will admit that I sometimes I don't
- 53:14do this a lot, but I will sometimes ride in the left lane when I need to get over to the right
- 53:18lane.
- 53:18I've been a lot better about it recently, so I I I but I have to be honest there.
- 53:22We all all have to be self care.
- 53:24Good.
- 53:24Paul, you know, you can be a better person by just practicing, not driving in the left lane.
- 53:30That's right.
- 53:31Medical moderation while I'm driving.
- 53:34For me, my so I I still hate this, but it's not the biggest gripe I have right now.
- 53:40The lack of turn signals that that really grinds my gears.
- 53:43Yeah.
- 53:44But the
- 53:44but the the the thing that has now supplanted it recently, and that's it.
- 53:48Even in my neighborhood, come across these people.
- 53:52If you are turning, do not cut your corners, please.
- 53:56Yeah, I have had too many times and especially when somebody's actually coming up to a stops
- 54:02stop sign.
- 54:03Just they cut into your lane.
- 54:05And this is like, look, I have to come up here so I can see where I'm going here.
- 54:09And this is it's just happening with reckless abandon, and it's it's it's driving me up a
- 54:15wall.
- 54:15So that is actually supplanted lack of turn signal.
- 54:19So please people, even if there's nobody there, don't cut your corners.
- 54:23You don't you you're really not saving much time.
- 54:25You're saving maybe half a second, one second at most.
- 54:28Just don't cut your corners, especially because you don't know somebody is coming around the
- 54:33the bend there.
- 54:34But that's that's that's my big thing right now.
- 54:38So but that is going to wrap things up today.
- 54:42So hopefully hopefully, any bad drivers that are also listening to this podcast, they can
- 54:47become a little bit better by taking account of some of those some of those those things.
- 54:52But, Lauren, thank you very much for coming on.
- 54:55Actually, real quick.
- 54:56Any more links you wanna share?
- 54:58And I can put them in the show notes.
- 55:00Yeah.
- 55:00So you can find me and all my stuff on laurenkhall.com.
- 55:03That's the easiest central repository, but then my substack is the Radical Moderate's Guide to
- 55:08Life, and I would love for people to subscribe and share.
- 55:11It is a really fun space, excellent commenters, really fun group of people, and I would love to
- 55:17have others on board.
- 55:18Oh, and then, of course, the podcast.
- 55:20We made this political, which is you can also find on Substack or any of the podcast
- 55:24platforms.
- 55:25Well, there you go.
- 55:26I will add those to the show notes below, but we are gonna wrap things up here.
- 55:31So for all of you listening at home and and or watching, thank you very much for listening to
- 55:37the podcast.
- 55:37My links, my Facebook, my LinkedIn, my five day educational email course about effective
- 55:44polarization.
- 55:45Why we're so all can be so given to it, why we make those mistakes even when we're trying to
- 55:51depolarize politics, and how we can fix those mistakes.
- 55:55My book, why independents rarely win elections and how they become more competitive, not
- 55:59necessarily arguing that we should have more independence, just why they have issues and
- 56:03what they can do to make things better for themselves.
- 56:05That's on Amazon and my medium.com profile where I write on politics from time to time and
- 56:13probably a couple of other things, but I'll put those in the show notes as well.
- 56:17So that's gonna wrap it up for today.
- 56:19So as always, thank you so much for listening, and until next time, take care.