Latest / Democracy in Color with Steve Phillips / Part 1 - The Myth of Meritocracy
Transcript
- 0:17This is Steve Phillips, the founder of Democracy and Culture and the author of Our White Men
- 0:22Smarter Than Everybody Else Playing Offense in the fight for Racial Justice in America. We are
- 0:27living through a period of profound reckoning with race and equality, except that right now the
- 0:32reckoning is going in the wrong direction. In so many ways, this moment is akin to the period after
- 0:38reconstruction in the 1870s and 1880s, when resentment and rage against steps to foster
- 0:45equality resulted in attacks on and abandonment of many of the efforts to overcome white
- 0:51nationalism and move us closer towards truly becoming a multiracial democracy. Over the past
- 0:57several years, nearly every institution that made sweeping commitments to racial justice after the
- 1:02murder of George Floyd in 2020 has retreated. The programs dismantled, affirmative action
- 1:09struck down, diversity offices shuttered, websites scrubbed. And at the federal level, a
- 1:15full scale, gleeful assault by this administration on anything that looks like it is advancing
- 1:22equity and equality. What's remarkable about all of this is what's missing from the conversation.
- 1:28Nobody is asking why. Why does inequality in this country exist? Very
- 1:35few people not the politicians, not the pundits, not the CEOs, not the media are pausing to
- 1:42grapple with the underlying reality that gave rise to die in the first place.
- 1:48Widespread inequality that is reflected in a status quo where white men are profoundly
- 1:54overrepresented in every position of power in this country. All of the sound and fury and
- 2:00threats and attacks and complaining have focused on the remedies. We ignore the underlying disease
- 2:07that made remedies necessary in the first place. My new book, Are White Men Smarter Than
- 2:14Everybody Else, is an attempt to do my small part, to change the conversation, to force the question
- 2:20that is implicit in every attack on Dei, but that no one will actually say out loud if
- 2:27our systems are fair. If the playing field is level, if diversity programs are unnecessary, if we
- 2:34truly are a meritocracy, then what explains the ongoing inequality? What explains a country where
- 2:4129% of the population holds the vast, overwhelming majority of every position of power,
- 2:47wealth, and influence? But we can't answer that question if we won't first ask that
- 2:54question. So today we're going to ask not to academics or politicians, but
- 3:01to the people who come from the sector that has borne much of the brunt of attacks on pre
- 3:06equality efforts. So today we're going to ask it not to academics or politicians, but to
- 3:13the people who come from the sector that has borne much of the brunt of attacks on equality
- 3:19efforts. We sat down with three college students and asked them.
- 3:31My name is Lorenzo Caselli. I'm originally from Turin, Italy, but I've been living in the state
- 3:37since I was eight years old, and I'm currently a business administration major at Solano Community
- 3:41College. My name is Shreya Sreenivasan. Pronouns. Are she her? I'm currently a senior in high school,
- 3:47dual enrolled at Solano Community College, but I will be attending Stanford University this
- 3:51upcoming fall. I'll be majoring in feminist, gender and sexuality studies. My name is Connor. I use any
- 3:58pronouns. I'm a student at Solano Community College and I'm studying English.
- 4:11Hi everyone. I'm Charlene Chang, co-host of the Democracy and Culture podcast, and this is episode
- 4:16one of our special podcast series, Our White Men Smarter than Everybody Else. So before we get into
- 4:23the big questions, I want to set the stage. White men make up 29% of the US population. But if you
- 4:29look at who runs things in this country, from the white House to fortune 500 venture backed
- 4:35startups, the Senate, Hollywood media companies and other large, high profile institutions, it's
- 4:42all overwhelmingly white men. And that's the fact we're sitting with today. And the question that
- 4:47Steve's book puts before us is simple and a little provocative. Are white men smarter than
- 4:53everybody else? Let's discuss. I think just hearing the statistics can be always troublesome, even
- 5:00though I know that's the reality we're living in. Every single morning I wake up in the news and
- 5:05it's always shown in the lens of what a white man thinks. Not necessarily what a woman of color
- 5:09thinks, a person of color, somewhat of a minority. And that could be really troublesome. I've just
- 5:14noticed that everything is structured to support a white man and no one else. All of those
- 5:18structures that have been in place for decades still exist to this day, and are always pushed
- 5:23forward as an agenda, because the white men are always the one leading the agenda. And so because
- 5:27of that, that's why we're seeing the structures of most white men holding these places of power. And
- 5:31it's really hard to break those because they are already structures that have been enforced for
- 5:35that many years. I think a lot of it has to do with also, just like them having access to certain
- 5:40like resources, like better schooling or even like tutoring if they needed or just, you know, living
- 5:45in like a wealthier area. And also, I feel like this country, or the US in particular, was also
- 5:50structured around white men, just like controlling and having most of the power we're still seeing.
- 5:55Like obviously the repercussions from that. Yeah, I mean that it's never lost on me. When you're
- 6:00looking back at the history and the records and what people have decided to write down that it is
- 6:06very white centric, or at least that's the academia that a lot of college decides to focus
- 6:12on. Even the language that we're speaking in right now is English, and it's the language of a white
- 6:18country that was an imperialist country. And their literature and their literature canon is
- 6:25is what we teach in schools. It's most of what my degree is, what we have chosen to write down,
- 6:32or at least the records that have survived, is a lot of records of white men and their fathers and
- 6:38the land that they own. And it can go back as far as like 6000 years that we have records of us
- 6:45deciding who wins wars. And who owns what? And it's there in the Bible. It's there in Beowulf.
- 6:52It's never lost on me that it's all English all the time.
- 7:06So if that's the history, what about the present? We hear a lot about merit, that the system is fair,
- 7:12that certain successful people get to where they are, that they are accepted into certain
- 7:17universities or hired and promoted to certain positions based on their efforts and innate
- 7:23abilities. A combination of their talent, smarts, skill and effort, and nothing
- 7:30else. Is that true? So I do think like, there is definitely like still a lot of issues, like I
- 7:36think regarding like nepotism, being like a white male that maybe comes from like a family that's
- 7:41very connected in industry, a huge and crucial role in these like, you know, high positions
- 7:46because I know that like one of the data figures that was shown was like how I think like 90% of
- 7:51like UC presidents and are like white males, even though they make up, you know, 29% of the
- 7:56population. I think a lot of that goes back to like nepotism and just, you know, already having
- 8:01those connections and even somebody that probably was like a more, a more like a stronger candidate
- 8:06that had like more experience, like I think they may be undermined just because they just don't
- 8:11have those insider connections. And I think that's like a huge problem that's very persistent
- 8:16nowadays. And I think a lot of like people our age, like young people are starting to like, realize
- 8:20that and wake up to that and like really starting to like see how like nepotism, like really just
- 8:26like is very persistent in our current society. The meritocracy is suggesting that people who
- 8:33have achieved the most people who merit the most are the people who deserve the power. But I think
- 8:38what we're consistently seeing with the meritocracy, what we're seeing with the statistics
- 8:43that you're mentioning is this idea that it's not an equal system. We're not all starting from the
- 8:49same place. We're not all individuals. We have connections that set us up. We have systems
- 8:56and structures that sometimes we don't even notice or recognize. There are systemic
- 9:02inequalities that survive through the generations that are giving certain people a better chance
- 9:09of achieving. And I think those chances are not often going to people who are not
- 9:15men and not often going to people who are not white. Yeah. I think both Lorenzo and Connor bring
- 9:21up really great points, in the sense that you can have a bunch of merit to a bunch of accolades, but
- 9:27if you were to compare, like, say, a woman of color and a white man, typically the opportunity goes to
- 9:31a white man. And that's mainly because a white man is considered a social status, even if, say, the
- 9:37women of color were to have a bunch of accolades, I think you can even turn to the recent
- 9:41presidential election, where we had a woman of color running for office who had a bunch of prior
- 9:45experience. She didn't get it, most likely because she was a woman of color and a minority, that you
- 9:50can have differing opinions on that. But we see that again and again coming up in society. So
- 9:54society has these kinds of cues, these identities that we uplift. And so even if someone were to
- 10:00build up their merit and to take every opportunity they had as a minority, a woman of
- 10:04color, whatever it might be, they had to work double as hard as they a white man would have to
- 10:08just because they look that way. And so to say that we live in a meritocracy, it's not. It's
- 10:13honestly laughable to me because most of the positions we see in power, they weren't given
- 10:17based off of merit. They were just given based off how they were born.
- 10:26Has inequality touched your lives? I loved what she was saying about the idea
- 10:32that the meritocracy is kind of laughable. I think the big the lie of it is this idea that if you
- 10:39work really hard, then you will be successful regardless of your situation. And we just sort of
- 10:45know that that isn't true. And I would say the most profound way, not necessarily that inequality
- 10:51has touched my life. I wouldn't claim that, but that it has touched the lives of people that I've
- 10:56known or loved is just this idea of people who who work so much. I've known single
- 11:03mothers who are undocumented, these people who are working 2 or 3 jobs, these people who are single
- 11:10mothers, these people who their entire life has been work for this country on behalf of this
- 11:16country. And it was sort of my responsibility to protect them from this country, to
- 11:23be that advocate voice. I can't even share their names, right, because of their status. That's not
- 11:30fair. That doesn't acknowledge their work and their contribution and treat them as people.
- 11:36Yeah, I remember I was like, working back when I used to live in Las Vegas. I was working at a
- 11:42luxury like High Rise, and I pretty much did like valet and security there. I had like a lot of
- 11:46coworkers that like, you know, they worked very, very hard, you know, sometimes 60 hours, 60 hours a
- 11:52week just to, like, barely be able to, like, afford in, like a afford like a little like apartment
- 11:56with a roommate, you know, compare like with, like some of the residents of the building because as
- 12:00I said, this is like a luxury, like high end, high rise. So a lot of them are very like wealthy, like
- 12:04business people or doctors or and it was just like, that was like a luxury. And I feel like a lot
- 12:08of that had to do with the status that they were born into and like the resources they had and
- 12:13like what Connor was saying with like a lot of, like undocumented people for them, they can't even,
- 12:17like really just apply to a regular job because, you know, they need to have IDs and Social
- 12:22Security cards and, and, you know, they have to, like, opt for whatever they can get or something that's
- 12:26like maybe like under the table. And obviously that puts them at like a huge disadvantage
- 12:30compared to like the an average like American or it's just definitely something the US. As a nation,
- 12:36you still have to work through and try to improve as much as we can. Inequity is different
- 12:40definition of different experience for everybody. And so to be to acknowledge that's really
- 12:45important off the bat. When I was working on my first ever state bill um AB 229, they know your
- 12:51period bill, which advocated for comprehensive menstrual education in all California schools,
- 12:55came out of my own experience of having lost my period for three years due to anorexia nervosa,
- 12:59but not having access to information online or from my pals teachers just because it wasn't
- 13:04offered in our school systems. And so when I was working on that bill, coming out of and talking to
- 13:08Assembly members and getting it into the Assembly and eventually to the governor's desk. Throughout
- 13:13that experience, I was undermined just because purely I was women of color, and I was a young
- 13:17person in a space of politics and in the space of where policy was passed, not necessarily the facts
- 13:22or anything that I had to present to them, but just what they assumed of me at face value. And so
- 13:27just by being a woman of color in America today, I'm assumed of certain things, assumed of certain
- 13:32capabilities, and that can be really frustrating for not only myself, but my other peers who are
- 13:37minorities in America, or not even minorities. It's just everyone faces inequity in their own way. But
- 13:43at least for me, the experience I've experienced it the most in spaces where I'm predominantly
- 13:48surrounded by white men in spaces of politics. And that can be really struggle. Awesome. But
- 13:51unfortunately, I've had to grow accustomed to that and feel comfortable in my own skin in those
- 13:55spaces.
- 14:03We're going to shift gears over to Di. As you may know, intense backlash against Dei and dismantling
- 14:09of diversity and equity initiatives and backpedaling have been ongoing over the past
- 14:15three years. Brands like Target and Walmart have backed down, but Costco, for example, has
- 14:22stood firm. Does it matter to you as a consumer or future employee where companies stand on Dei?
- 14:29Does it matter to you as a consumer, as a prospective employee. Where
- 14:36companies stand on Dei. Why or why not? Yeah, I think you bring up a really tricky question,
- 14:42Charlene, because unfortunately, um, ever since, like, the new administration came into play, a lot of
- 14:48different institutions have had to take back their Dei protocol. Even colleges that we've
- 14:52attended to have had to push back on their Dei programs. And honestly, it takes a lot of time out
- 14:57of our own days to try and figure out which ones do. And that can be really hard for, say, a busy
- 15:01college student who's trying to live their life and try to get something as quick and snappy, but
- 15:05aren't able to go out of their way to find the company that has the Di protocols in place. And so
- 15:11in that sense, it's really hard for us consumers, but it doesn't mean we don't have to be cognizant,
- 15:15like we can go out of our way to do some research here or there if we are in the place and have the
- 15:20privilege to do so. I do make an effort to to choose alternatives to things like Amazon, to
- 15:26things where I have seen like there are data centers for AI issues, and it's like supporting
- 15:32those things or things that would definitely go against my my moral code. When I hear people say,
- 15:38you know, we're going to boycott this or we're going to do that, it's usually not difficult for
- 15:44me to participate in that because I'm often not a consumer there. But that's sometimes because I
- 15:50have privilege. I have access to other alternatives. Yeah. So I personally think that the
- 15:55AI is like very imperative in a country like the US. I think also a lot of these corporations, I
- 16:01don't think a lot of them truly like care about, like the moral side of Dei, especially like during
- 16:06like early 2020s when, you know, the George Floyd situation was happening, a lot of these companies
- 16:11were marketing themselves as, oh, like, we're we're the one of the good corporations. Or they could
- 16:15like, trust us, you should support us, you know? And now that like the new administration has come in,
- 16:21a lot of them are just like now showing their true colors more where at the end of the day, like
- 16:25the corporations don't really care about, like the average person's well-being or like social
- 16:29movements. I just think they're mostly just trying to like, profit, and they'll do whatever they need
- 16:34to in order to, like, maximize their profits and look good to shareholders.
- 16:50What about your generation? Do young people care about issues of inequality? Our generation cares. I
- 16:56just don't think people take enough time to hear what our generation has to say. But what makes it
- 17:00double times as hard is the fact that people on the news, people in political spaces, people who
- 17:05are sharing about these issues don't look like us. There are not many young people in politics, and
- 17:11so if we're not able to see people having these conversations who look like us, who are we to take
- 17:15off as the reference of how we should act or how we should talk about these conversations with
- 17:19each other? And so I think it's really like, hard to say that we don't care because we do. We see it
- 17:25impacting us? And so we do care. We just need more spaces to show that we care. Something came to
- 17:30mind. I'm reading a novel for my Ethnic Studies course right now, and it's about an Indigenous
- 17:36Americans and reservation culture and stuff. And a speaker gets up and says, our generation
- 17:43is buildings are on fire, their house is on fire, and they're jumping out of the window. And we
- 17:48think that the jumping is the problem and not the house being on fire. A lot of the
- 17:54attention that our generation gets when it comes to these issues is, is the jumping and not
- 18:01necessarily the slow, gradual build of these
- 18:07systemic problems of these these inequities. I think young people really do care. But I think at
- 18:14the same time, they've watched a lot of the promises that were made to them be broken. Our
- 18:21culture really likes to promise things to young people. It likes to promise that if you get that
- 18:25education, if you get that job, if you work really hard, if you get to retirement, then we have all
- 18:32these benefits waiting for you. We have all these promises, and I'm just sort of watching those
- 18:37promises not be delivered and watching the houses burn down. I'm watching people jump and lash out
- 18:43and I'm I'm sort of at a loss. I'm sad for this generation, but I'm hopeful at
- 18:50the same time that that will inspire us to want to participate
- 18:56more. Yeah, I think that our generation is very outspoken when it comes to these type of issues,
- 19:02because I also think that these current issues that are happening just as an example to like
- 19:07what's happening in Iran currently is like mainly going to affect our generation, like older
- 19:12generations, you know, they have to they'll see like rising gas prices. And but like, I feel like
- 19:17our generation are the ones that are going to have to really face it and deal with like the
- 19:21aftermath and the consequences. And a lot of these decisions that are really shaping our world
- 19:26currently, and our current events are being made by like people that are 2 or 3 generations above
- 19:32us, right? That like our generation has like barely any representation when it comes to these formal
- 19:37like government. I feel like most of the decisions, like are primarily affecting us and people
- 19:41younger than us. And we're going to be, as I was saying before, dealing with the consequences of
- 19:45that. There should be like some restructuring around the system. Our generation overall really
- 19:50does care about these issues very much, I think even more than older generations personally. Yeah.
- 19:56I just wanted to quickly top off of what Lorenzo was saying, positions that have been created for
- 20:01young people like, say, a student trustee position on a school board, like I was a student trustee at
- 20:05Solano Community College or even a youth commissioner at like a local county commission.
- 20:10Those are all advisory positions. They don't have actual votes. They don't have an actual power. I
- 20:16never actually had a vote on that board. And I think that same structure is applied in multiple
- 20:21situations where organizations have youth advisory boards. Like there are so many positions,
- 20:26options available for young people to share their voice. But at the end of the day, they're not the
- 20:30ones who are allowed to make the executive decision.
- 20:47Thanks so much for all of your answers so far. My last question is what is one change you would
- 20:53like to see in our country? I think like more representation from people that are generally
- 20:58like much older in general and that aren't just like white males. Um, more representation. I also
- 21:03want to say like less like dependency on other nations. I think like a large reason why. Like the
- 21:09wrong situation is happening is also because I know that Israel kind of has problems with Iran
- 21:14as well. And I think like we should like further distance ourselves and, you know, try to just
- 21:20really focus on us as a nation and rather just always just like doing stuff for other nations
- 21:24like that. My generation talks a lot about the redistribution of wealth as sort of a way to
- 21:30redistribute power. And I love that idea, this, that, you know, opportunity
- 21:37for young people, opportunity for marginalized groups is associated with money and the
- 21:42distribution of wealth and the ownership of assets and and land and resources for those
- 21:48resources to be distributed with a little more equity is definitely something that I appreciate
- 21:53in in the future. I would want to see a better distribution for wealth, to not rule this country,
- 22:00for the people, to rule it. The one thing I would hope for to change in the over the coming years
- 22:06is people's willingness to listen. I think a lot of times, a multitude of the problems that we face
- 22:11today is just from the lack of communication from both parties. Typically, it's like simply a lot of
- 22:17the problems we have can be faced with a singular conversation, and just having that open, open mind
- 22:23to be able to listen to other people's opinions, even if they're on completely opposite spectrums.
- 22:27And so if each just take a little bit of extra practice and time to have those open ended
- 22:32conversations and really listen to what other people have to say, I think we could fix a lot of
- 22:37the problems we face today. Thank you all so much. You all did a fantastic job. Thank you. Thank you
- 22:44so much.
- 22:54I want to thank these students for their honesty and their courage, for being willing to sit with
- 22:59questions that most adults, especially those in positions of power, refuse to even entertain,
- 23:06because that's exactly what needs to change the conversation we just had. That's the conversation
- 23:13the whole country needs to be having. Not around the edges, right at the center. In episode two, we
- 23:19will go deeper into the history, the science, and the systems that produced the reality of
- 23:25inequality that we've been talking about today. How did we get here and what does the evidence
- 23:30actually tell us? Stay tuned. This is our white
- 23:37men, smarter than everybody else. The podcast this special series, podcast is a
- 23:43Democracy in color production written by Steve Phillips and Charlene Chang. Produced by Olivia
- 23:50Parker. Folha Jennifer is our associate producer. Special thank you to our three
- 23:57guests Sridhar, Lorenzo and Connor, as well as Solano Community College Vice
- 24:03President of Student Services Lisa Neely.