Latest / Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques / 307. Accent-uate, Don't Compensate: Why Clarity Matters More Than Perfection
Transcript
- 0:03Matt Abrahams: When we communicate, we not only communicate our ideas, we communicate
- 0:06our identity My name is Matt Abrahams, and I teach Strategic Communication at
- 0:11Stanford Graduate School of Business.
- 0:13Welcome to Think Fast, Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 0:16Today, I look forward to speaking with Peter Novak.
- 0:19Peter is a former vice provost at the University of San Francisco
- 0:22and former dean at Yale University.
- 0:24He is the founder of the Strictly Speaking group.
- 0:27Peter leverages his doctorate and background in linguistics and
- 0:30acting to help non-native speakers master clear communication.
- 0:35He has an award-winning LinkedIn learning course on public speaking
- 0:38for non-native English speakers.
- 0:40Welcome, Peter.
- 0:41I am really excited to bring you to the show and to share what you've shared
- 0:45with my students here with everybody.
- 0:47Thanks for joining.
- 0:48Peter Novak: Thanks so much.
- 0:49I've been so looking forward to this conversation.
- 0:51Matt Abrahams: Shall we get started?
- 0:51Peter Novak: Absolutely.
- 0:52Matt Abrahams: Great.
- 0:53On the show, we've often spoken about how word choice affects the
- 0:56strength of our messages and the impressions people form of us.
- 1:00Your work highlights the impact accents can have on people's perceptions.
- 1:04Can you share a bit about this?
- 1:06And please make sure you define what you mean by accent bias, because
- 1:09I think this is really important for what we'll talk about today.
- 1:12Peter Novak: Absolutely.
- 1:12Let me start with the definition of accent bias.
- 1:14So accent bias is essentially that reflex that we have to trust people who
- 1:20sound like us, and this happens a lot with people who are the in-group and
- 1:26people who are part of the out-group.
- 1:28And the idea of accent bias, of who's in and who's out, and what that means,
- 1:35it really affects the workplace.
- 1:36It can affect hiring decisions, it can affect promotion decisions.
- 1:40It often affects how people feel about leadership qualities.
- 1:45And so all of these aspects of accent bias creep into our workplace
- 1:50without us really understanding or knowing the full impact of it.
- 1:53Matt Abrahams: And we could have our career and our trajectories be affected
- 1:56by something we don't even know.
- 1:58Have you found that there are advantages to having an accent, or
- 2:01that non-native speakers bring to their communication maybe through the
- 2:05focus of the specific words or the way they speak versus those who don't
- 2:10have an accent in a given environment?
- 2:13Peter Novak: Or who don't have the accent of the majority in the specific group?
- 2:16Absolutely, and I love the framing of this question around the advantages
- 2:20that non-native speakers have, because so often they come to the table
- 2:24thinking it's a disadvantage to have an accent when they're speaking.
- 2:27And so I think what's fun about that is that when you think about
- 2:31multilingual speakers, seventy-five percent of people in the US and
- 2:35Canada and Australia and Great Britain don't speak another language.
- 2:39And so when you've got multilingual speakers, their skills in being able
- 2:43to code switch between language and cultures, in being able to be more
- 2:47intentional, which is part of your question, I think, about that focus
- 2:50that they have about the language choice that they're having, is really profound.
- 2:55And I think it's up to native speakers to recognize that non-native speakers
- 3:00are doing a hell of a lot more work in the workplace than native speakers are.
- 3:04We tend to take our proficiency in English for granted.
- 3:08We don't think about how we use it.
- 3:10We don't think about ways to use it more clearly for non-native speakers.
- 3:14And I like to say, remember Ginger Rogers and Fred Astaire, the
- 3:17dancers from the 1940s and '50s.
- 3:19Everyone said that Ginger Rogers did everything Fred Astaire did,
- 3:23only backwards and in high heels.
- 3:25And in many ways, that's what non-native speakers are doing, too.
- 3:28They are in the moment involved sometimes in translating what was said into their
- 3:33first language, oftentimes, translating what they want to say from their first
- 3:37language or another language, thinking about tone, thinking about word choice,
- 3:42thinking about all these other things that native speakers don't have to.
- 3:46And I think we need to give them credit for that and then create the structures
- 3:50around that that enable a greater linguistic flexibility in the workplace.
- 3:55Matt Abrahams: And just recognizing that the difference even exists
- 3:58and that you should take the time to reflect and accommodate.
- 4:01I have found that the folks I know who speak multiple languages, some of whom
- 4:04who have accents and some who don't, their ability to listen and discern
- 4:08subtlety is far superior to mine.
- 4:11Really interesting.
- 4:13I have heard you say in my class and in things you've written, "It's not
- 4:17an accent, it's an identity." What do you mean by this, and how can it help
- 4:21someone who is concerned about their accent to reframe it in this way?
- 4:26Peter Novak: Sure.
- 4:26You know, language carries with it culture, it carries identity,
- 4:31it carries individual stories.
- 4:33And so why would we want to try and fix that?
- 4:37There's no reason to really fix that.
- 4:39The goal, actually, is clarity.
- 4:42And I think sometimes, there was a great episode of Modern Family with
- 4:45Eva Longoria, was that, who, who said, "Do you even know how smart I am in
- 4:50Spanish?" And this is what happens.
- 4:52If you ask a multilingual speaker, do they feel like different personality traits
- 4:57emerge with the different languages that they speak, they will say, "Absolutely.
- 5:02I am so much funnier in my first language, and I don't have access to the same
- 5:07type of comedy in English or in a second language that I do in my first." And so
- 5:12really, there's this interesting part of identity that shifts because of the
- 5:16different languages that we speak, and I think that needs to be celebrated.
- 5:20It needs to be brought into the workspace a lot more than it normally is.
- 5:25Matt Abrahams: You just reminded me, I was coaching a very senior leader
- 5:28who was a native French speaker.
- 5:30In English, he was a little more stilted, a little more buttoned up, but when I
- 5:35actually had him say the same thing in French, he became much more lively, much
- 5:41more connected, and we were able to use that as a tool, as a guide to allow him
- 5:47to feel more free speaking in English.
- 5:50It really is interesting how we have these different
- 5:53compartmentalizations based on language.
- 5:55Before I ask you to share some specific techniques that those with accents can
- 5:59take to feel more confident in their communication, I'd love to ask you to
- 6:02define some foundational principles that I know you refer back to.
- 6:05And in fact, these principles apply not just to people who are speaking in a
- 6:09language other than their native language.
- 6:11They, they apply to all of us.
- 6:12So can you help us understand what you mean by processing fluency,
- 6:16intelligibility, and comprehensibility?
- 6:19Peter Novak: Absolutely.
- 6:20So in a nutshell, processing fluency is the ease with
- 6:24which we understand something.
- 6:27And I think the goal of every speaker is to try and make what
- 6:30they say as easy as possible to understand for the listener, for your
- 6:35audience, whoever that audience is.
- 6:37And it really means getting to know your audience as well as possible.
- 6:40And processing fluency is essentially that.
- 6:42Processing disfluency is anything that gets in the way of that
- 6:46message being understood.
- 6:47That could be content, right?
- 6:49You ramble or you don't have a good structure.
- 6:52Or it could be delivery, right?
- 6:53Things that make it difficult for people to hear and understand.
- 6:57And that brings us to the linguistic ideas around intelligibility
- 7:01and comprehensibility.
- 7:03Intelligibility is how much I understand of what you say.
- 7:07Comprehensibility is how hard I have to work to understand you.
- 7:12It's the effort that I put in to understanding you.
- 7:15Let me put this into an example.
- 7:17Let's say you're on a Zoom call and it's a little glitchy on the other end.
- 7:21But maybe you understand what the person said, but still there was,
- 7:24"I'm losing you a little bit," and so you have to work harder to do it.
- 7:27That's the difference between intelligibility and comprehensibility.
- 7:30And the best part about this is that there were major studies done
- 7:3420 years ago and more that say that people who speak English as a
- 7:38second, third, or fourth language can improve both their intelligibility
- 7:43and their comprehensibility with no noticeable shift in accent.
- 7:48And so there are some really interesting things to focus on to
- 7:51help you do that without worrying about what your accent really is.
- 7:56Matt Abrahams: So processing fluency is the ease with which
- 7:59we take in the information.
- 8:01And there's a whole bunch of things we can do, making sure we know our
- 8:03audience so it's easier for them.
- 8:05We're using relevant concepts and ideas that they can connect to.
- 8:08Structuring the information, making it more concise.
- 8:11And then intelligibility is the understanding, and the comprehensibility
- 8:15is how hard we work to understand.
- 8:18And anything we can do to reduce comprehensibility, I would assume,
- 8:22helps with processing fluency.
- 8:24Excellent.
- 8:25So let's get very tactical and practical.
- 8:27What are some techniques and approaches you recommend to help people who want to
- 8:30work on their accents or increase their intelligibility while not increasing the
- 8:35comprehensibility of what they're saying?
- 8:37Peter Novak: Well, they want to do both.
- 8:38They want to have both high intelligibility and
- 8:40high comprehensibility.
- 8:42And so what I would say is that the goal is clarity.
- 8:45That's number one.
- 8:46First and foremost, the goal is clarity.
- 8:48Matt Abrahams: So clarity of meaning.
- 8:50Peter Novak: Clarity of meaning, right, and then clarity also of delivery.
- 8:53Matt Abrahams: Got it.
- 8:54So I clearly understood you, but I also clearly heard you.
- 8:57Peter Novak: That's right.
- 8:58Matt Abrahams: Okay.
- 8:58Very good.
- 8:59Peter Novak: And so there was an interesting study from McGill University
- 9:02in Canada, and basically it said this: Your car breaks down in a city that you
- 9:06don't know very well, and your phone is out of juice, and so you're trying
- 9:10to find a garage that you can go to.
- 9:12And so you ask the first person, they tell you to go one direction.
- 9:14You ask a second person.
- 9:16The first person is a native speaker, sounds like you.
- 9:18You ask a second person, they tell you to go in the opposite direction, and
- 9:21they have an out-group speech or accent.
- 9:25That's right.
- 9:25Foreign or something you don't recognize.
- 9:27Who are you going to trust more?
- 9:29And in essence, the study found that you trust people who sound like you more.
- 9:32That's what accent bias is.
- 9:34However, if the person who speaks with a different accent than your own speaks
- 9:39with confidence, then it reduces that gap.
- 9:43And so the question becomes, what does speaking in English
- 9:47with confidence actually mean?
- 9:50What are people who speak English as their first language listening for
- 9:55that tells us that person is confident?
- 9:58And so we know this.
- 10:00We know what some of those elements are, and some of them
- 10:03are all related to prosody.
- 10:06So prosody is an element of speech that thinks about the musicality of
- 10:10the language, which thinks about volume and pacing and the power that you
- 10:16lend to certain words and inflection.
- 10:19It's all of the things outside of the words and the sentences that carry
- 10:23meaning that we often don't think about.
- 10:26Matt Abrahams: When we had Lerone Martin on talking about Martin Luther King Jr.,
- 10:29we talked a lot about prosody and, and how he was able to leverage that as part of
- 10:33the, one of the many things that made his orations really powerful and meaningful.
- 10:38Peter Novak: And every language has its own musicality.
- 10:41So the biggest return on investment is understanding and really
- 10:45working on prosody of the language.
- 10:47Not individual words, not individual phrases, and if you've got the
- 10:51pronunciation just right, you don't need to worry about any of that.
- 10:53It's really more about the paralinguistic features outside the language itself
- 10:59that carry more meaning, that make us relate better when we're communicating.
- 11:03Matt Abrahams: Can you give me an example or two of maybe an activity
- 11:05or a thing you would coach people to do to really touch on that?
- 11:09Peter Novak: Sure.
- 11:10And I'm gonna give some advice that is often the opposite of
- 11:13what a lot of speech coaches give.
- 11:15And that is, if you're giving a presentation or if you're talking over
- 11:19Zoom even, to prepare by recording yourself into a speech-to-text app.
- 11:26And that speech-to-text app will give you a transcript of what you're saying.
- 11:29So you just have to rehearse it once, and then all of a sudden you've
- 11:31got a script of what you're doing.
- 11:33You can then put it through AI if you want.
- 11:35You can put it through AI and say, "I need this to sound like me still, so
- 11:39keep my syntax, keep the way that it…" So that it sounds authentic to you.
- 11:43And once you have a script, you score it.
- 11:46And one of the best techniques that I can think of is to underline what are called
- 11:51content or focus words in a sentence.
- 11:53If I have the sentence for you, "I never said you should have hired
- 11:58him." If I stress a different word, it means something different.
- 12:02I never said you should hire him.
- 12:04I never said you should hire him, right?
- 12:06I never said you should hire him.
- 12:08I never said you should hire him, right?
- 12:10Every time you say the sentence and you put a stress on a different
- 12:13word, it changes the context.
- 12:15And if you look at your words and your sentences in your prepared speech, and
- 12:19you start to underline or bold just those three or four content words per second
- 12:24and focus on those words, the meaning of what you're going to say will come
- 12:28across regardless of anything else.
- 12:31And so if you're stressing just those words, all of a sudden you get a really
- 12:35clear picture of what's being said.
- 12:37So that's one thing that you can do to score your script for what are called
- 12:40operative or focus words or content words.
- 12:43The second thing is to put in slash marks for small pauses, because people
- 12:49forget to pause when they're speaking.
- 12:52And oftentimes non-native speakers get told to slow down when that's
- 12:56not always the best advice.
- 12:58What's more helpful is to take a sentence and divide it into thought clusters,
- 13:04groups of speech that have complete meanings on their own but don't often
- 13:10have the punctuation to make you pause.
- 13:13And these are simple phrases in a sentence like even when I was just
- 13:16saying a thought group is a group of words that has a complete set meaning on
- 13:20its own that we don't give meaning to.
- 13:22And so when you break up a sentence into those thought groups, it becomes
- 13:26easier to understand and follow.
- 13:28And so putting those slash marks into a script can help do that.
- 13:31And then the third way that you can really help is to provide intonation assistance
- 13:36in a script, in a scoring a script, using downward inflections, which words
- 13:41to focus on in different ways, how to use inflections and we have three basic
- 13:46inflections in English: the upward, where I'm asking a question; the downward, where
- 13:52I'm making a statement, and we do that in two different ways; and then the sustained
- 13:56inflection, which I really like, which is so, it's all on one note, and you're
- 14:01waiting for me to either go up or down.
- 14:03When you learn to incorporate some of those inflections, you're
- 14:07really tapping into, I think, the power of the language in ways that
- 14:11native speakers are listening to.
- 14:12Matt Abrahams: Paralanguage, the things that happen around the
- 14:16words are so powerful in so many ways, and I love these activities.
- 14:20Using a script as a tool to help you plan and prepare your
- 14:27paralanguage, I think is beautiful.
- 14:29I love this idea of getting a transcript of what you're saying.
- 14:33Not to say that you're going to say it exactly that way, but to begin
- 14:36to look at what are those words of inflection, of focus of that vocal
- 14:40highlighting that need to stand out.
- 14:42And this is a tool that I think will help everybody, not just non-native speakers.
- 14:46Thinking about clustering of the key concepts and how to punctuate them in
- 14:51terms of pace and rate, really important.
- 14:53In fact, I believe they found some versions of the Declaration of
- 14:57Independence that had weird marks on them that they finally concluded
- 15:01were actually marks for oration.
- 15:04That, that when people would read it, because so much of the population
- 15:07at the time was not able to read.
- 15:09So giving yourself these little cues and clues of what to do.
- 15:12And then finally thinking about how you end phrases and words.
- 15:17Many of us will swallow what we say and get quiet.
- 15:19Some people have uptalk where everything sounds like a question.
- 15:22And just it being able to strategically think about it as a question,
- 15:26although I believe I know the answer.
- 15:28The more you do this, the more it becomes a habit where you don't need to do it.
- 15:32Peter Novak: That's right.
- 15:33Matt Abrahams: You have extensive training in phonetics.
- 15:35For our listeners who feel their voice doesn't always carry authority,
- 15:39whether native speaker or not, what are some vocal adjustments that we
- 15:43can make to come across with the gravitas and clarity that we look for?
- 15:48Peter Novak: There are so many different things that we can do.
- 15:50First and foremost, one of the things that I recommend is to really
- 15:53understand, that I talked about earlier, intonation, how we end sentences.
- 15:59In English, we do that in two ways.
- 16:00One is we either step down, like on the words, "I'm a professor,"
- 16:05where you notice we go up on the penultimate sound and then come down.
- 16:08"I'm a professor. I teach math." And so we either step down or we
- 16:14glide down at the ends of sentences.
- 16:17And oftentimes people will swallow their last few words.
- 16:21They don't end with strength, and let me talk about what that means.
- 16:25And so if you combine the strong downward inflection in speaking with
- 16:31slowing down your last few words when you're done speaking, it signals
- 16:36that you've completed your thought.
- 16:38It signals a strength in the end of your communication, and you can use
- 16:42it almost any time you're finished speaking to make sure that people
- 16:46know you've finished speaking.
- 16:48And it works really, really well.
- 16:51And you can either score that on a script that you've got for text, or you
- 16:54can think about ending just by slowing down and using that downward inflection.
- 17:00Matt Abrahams: I love that technique, and I loved how you role modeled it.
- 17:03Thank you.
- 17:04And we can all record ourselves on audio voice memo and listen to hear
- 17:08how we're doing it and to become more sensitive to what others are doing.
- 17:12We can work on these skills through reading out loud.
- 17:16I often encourage people reading out loud allows you to focus on how
- 17:20you're saying something because the words are right in front of you.
- 17:22So I'm not saying reading your script to give a presentation.
- 17:24I'm saying just read your emails out loud.
- 17:26Read anything and notice how you can do that to train your brain
- 17:30to be more comfortable doing it.
- 17:32Behind all of it, I believe, is also this notion of breath and breath control.
- 17:35You know, when we get nervous, we breathe shallow and up.
- 17:38So we have to remind ourselves that your voice is a wind instrument and that
- 17:42you have to have the breath behind it.
- 17:44So I often tell people we need to build vocal stamina through breathwork as
- 17:48well, which could be reading out loud, just becoming aware of where it is.
- 17:53You have provided so much rich information.
- 17:55Thank you.
- 17:56Before we end, I'd like to ask you three questions.
- 17:58One I make up just for you, and two I've been asking everybody for a long time.
- 18:01Are you up for that?
- 18:02Peter Novak: You bet.
- 18:02Matt Abrahams: Excellent.
- 18:03You created a national curriculum regarding alcohol abuse and
- 18:07sexual violence prevention that reached over a million students.
- 18:11When you're communicating about such sensitive, high-stakes, and
- 18:14emotionally charged topics, how do you balance clarity with the necessity
- 18:19of being empathetic and concerned?
- 18:22A lot of us are in situations where we have to talk about
- 18:25emotionally charged issues.
- 18:26What advice do you have that came from that experience?
- 18:28And by the way, thank you for creating a curriculum like that.
- 18:31Peter Novak: It, it's my pleasure.
- 18:31I was, uh, the Stanford graduate students actually took our program, which is
- 18:35great, and it was throughout, I think, over now 2,000 universities have used it.
- 18:39And it was deeply important work for me, but you're right,
- 18:42it is very emotionally charged.
- 18:45And so what you have to create first and foremost is a psychologically safe
- 18:48space for people to be able to speak, and that requires a great empathy and
- 18:52understanding what happens with trauma.
- 18:55Once you've created a psychologically safe space, the goal is to not
- 18:58re-traumatize with your language or to re-traumatize by asking people to
- 19:03contribute their story when they don't feel psychologically safe to do so, and
- 19:08to build in a system of the way that you communicate that has its foundation in
- 19:13trauma-informed ways of communicating.
- 19:15And I think that's an incredibly helpful tool that has empathy at its core and that
- 19:20really helps us understand communicating on a very human-to-human level.
- 19:24Matt Abrahams: So it starts with empathy, which builds to psychological
- 19:27safety that then requires some intentional thought about how to allow
- 19:33for the kind of dialogue that needs to happen in these emotionally charged
- 19:36situations without retriggering or causing people to become defensive.
- 19:40Tricky, but possible.
- 19:41Peter Novak: Tricky, but possible, and you also have to build the
- 19:44structure of all of that into your policies, into your procedures.
- 19:48So it's not just the one-on-one communication, it's also the
- 19:51larger support structure also needs to be framed that way.
- 19:54Matt Abrahams: I like to talk a lot about people, process, and
- 19:56infrastructure, and you need all three of those to come together when
- 19:59you have emotionally charged issues.
- 20:01Question number two, who's a communicator that you admire and why?
- 20:05Peter Novak: I love Trevor Noah.
- 20:07I think his cultural discussions, his ability to see different cultural
- 20:14dynamics and how they manifest, not only from his native country and the way he
- 20:18speaks, but to the US and to Europe and to every place that he tours and bring,
- 20:23he brings different stories, and he does it in a way that is enlightening, that
- 20:27is approachable, that is funny, and he has a lot of humility, believe it or not,
- 20:32in the way that he communicates, too.
- 20:34And so he's one of my favorite people to listen to.
- 20:36He's got some great stories around accents.
- 20:38He does take on some accents sometimes and talks about them, but he's
- 20:41got some really profound things to say around language and accent and
- 20:47accessibility and what is considered a standard sound and what isn't.
- 20:52There is no standard for English.
- 20:53There are world Englishes, and I think Trevor Noah gets to that really clearly.
- 20:58Matt Abrahams: He is a very engaging speaker, great storyteller, and he
- 21:02does a really nice job with some of these paralanguage clues and
- 21:05cues that you're talking about.
- 21:07Final question, what are the first three ingredients that go into a
- 21:10successful communication recipe?
- 21:13Peter Novak: The first is comfort, feeling comfortable in being able to,
- 21:17and that's where the psychological safety, I think, comes in as well.
- 21:20The second would be conversational, and this is all delivery, by the way.
- 21:23This isn't content.
- 21:24This is delivery, I would say.
- 21:26So the second part is really making it sound conversational,
- 21:29like you're actually talking to someone, not talking at someone.
- 21:33And the third, I would say, is conviction, or people will say confidence, but
- 21:39having the passion behind what it is that you're saying so that you're making
- 21:43a connection that is important to you.
- 21:45Matt Abrahams: I love things that are easy to remember.
- 21:47The three C's: comfort, conversational, conviction.
- 21:51And those are all helped by the techniques that you have taught us
- 21:55and that you teach on a regular basis.
- 21:57Peter, thank you so much for your time.
- 21:59I appreciate you highlighting the value that people who speak
- 22:03another language bring and the tools that can help all of us feel more
- 22:07comfortable in our communication.
- 22:09Thank you.
- 22:10Peter Novak: Thank you so much, Matt.
- 22:10It was great being here.
- 22:13Matt Abrahams: Thank you for joining us for another episode of Think
- 22:15Fast, Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 22:17To learn more about communication best practices, please listen
- 22:20to episode 82 with Nancy Duarte.
- 22:22This episode was produced by Katherine Reed, Ryan Campos, and me, Matt Abrahams.
- 22:27Our music is from Floyd Wonder, with special thanks
- 22:30to the Podium Podcast Company.
- 22:32Please find us on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts.
- 22:35Be sure to subscribe and rate us.
- 22:37Also follow us on LinkedIn, TikTok, and Instagram.
- 22:40And check out fastersmarter.io for deep-dive videos, English language
- 22:44learning content, and our newsletter.
- 22:47Please consider our premium offering for extended Deep Thinks episodes, AMAs, and
- 22:51much more at fastersmarter.io/premium.
- 22:54You'll also find value by joining our Think Fast, Talk Smart Learning
- 22:57Community at fastersmarter.io/learning.
- 23:01You'll find video lessons, learning quest discussion boards, my AI
- 23:05coach, and book club opportunities.
- 23:07Again, that's fastersmarter.io/learning to become part of our Think Fast,
- 23:11Talk Smart Learning Community