Latest / Film And Whiskey / The Tree of Life (2011) / Glenmorangie The Original 10-Year Single Malt Scotch feat. Bilge Ebiri
Transcript
- 0:00In 2011, director Terrence Malick and star Brad Pitt and
- 0:05Jessica Chastain gave the world an ethereal look at how the
- 0:09cosmos fits into the human soul. In 2025, we returned to the
- 0:16single malt that started it all. The film is the Tree of Life.
- 0:22The whiskey is Glenn Moringy 10 year.
- 0:25And we'll review them both. This is the Film and Whiskey
- 0:30podcast. Welcome to the Film in Whiskey
- 0:51podcast, where each week we review a classic movie and a
- 0:54glass of whiskey. I'm Bob Book.
- 0:56I'm Brad. Gee.
- 0:58Brad, I'm so freaking pumped. We're joined by somebody else
- 1:00that all the viewers can see. I'm going to hold off on
- 1:03introducing him just long enough to say I'm so pumped about this
- 1:07today, man. Because today we are talking
- 1:09about the Tree of Life. I feel like we watched this
- 1:14movie. It was like our fifth movie of
- 1:17the podcast. I was brand new into the world
- 1:21of like anything that could be considered high, high film,
- 1:26we'll we'll call it that. I had watched like a more 10
- 1:31years before on a on a whim with a friend.
- 1:33It was like what the F just happened to me.
- 1:37And so coming into Tree of Life, I was a little nervous.
- 1:41And I remember getting to the end of it and thinking, like, I
- 1:44feel like that was like an art house film.
- 1:47What? Yeah, common consumer would
- 1:49consider art house. But why did it feel so personal?
- 1:54Like, it felt way too warm to be like this.
- 1:58I don't know, Artistic, unapproachable movie.
- 2:02And I think we, I think I gave it like a nine out of 10, Bob.
- 2:05I'm just gonna say right now, this is a 10 out of 10 movie.
- 2:09Coming back to it five years later was a great experience.
- 2:14Well, I mean, way to just absolutely throw down the the
- 2:18gauntlet here, Brad, because now I have to introduce our guest
- 2:22and what if he just comes in and says like, yeah, it's fine, you
- 2:24know? Then he would be right. 7.
- 2:27He would be 100% right because our guest is Bilga Abiri,
- 2:31everybody. Bilga, how are you tonight, man?
- 2:34Thank you for joining us. I'm good.
- 2:36I'm I'm I'm very happy to join you for this movie, which is of
- 2:39course a 10 out of 10. It's it's on my side and sound
- 2:42list so you know it's it's. Like there you go.
- 2:44It's top five for me, but I did. I never listened to your first
- 2:48episode about it, so I don't know what you said at the time,
- 2:52but I'm sure it was. I was strongly cautioned against
- 2:55ever listening to anything from our season #1 this.
- 2:59This is what you told me. We've shared the story before,
- 3:02but in the early days of film and whiskey, we sat in a room
- 3:05together. We recorded on a conference call
- 3:08microphone, so the audio quality is just just pretty.
- 3:11We would just, we would do 4 films in a day.
- 3:14So like I had watched these four movies anywhere from like the
- 3:19night before to two weeks before and you know, we're drinking
- 3:23whiskey and review and it was like, I think Tree of Life was
- 3:26our last film of the day that we reviewed I.
- 3:30So so so by the end of the day, it's more of the whiskey and
- 3:33film. Podcast, yes, it's.
- 3:37More whiskey than? Film now Brad, to your point
- 3:40like this was this was kind of our first big artsy movie and I
- 3:44was very nervous about introducing this movie to you.
- 3:47And I will say I feel like I'm known as the the Snooty art guy
- 3:50on our podcast here. But if you look behind me at our
- 3:53our movie collection here, Brad, you will see that I have the
- 3:56Tree of Life and and eagle eyed viewers will also see my copy of
- 4:01the DVD for Joe Dirt right next to it here.
- 4:04So that's right, we contain multitudes here on the Film and
- 4:07Whiskey podcast. We sure do, man.
- 4:10Joe Dirt a a film I made my friends take me to for my
- 4:13birthday when it when it opened. So that was the last time
- 4:20anybody took me to a movie for my birthday.
- 4:23I I that is fact actually. The last movie that I went to
- 4:27see for my birthday was 2019. Brad turning 29.
- 4:32JoJo Rabbit. No, there you go, this is good.
- 4:36What a weird movie to pick for your birthday.
- 4:39You know, let me go watch this World War 2 Holocaust film to
- 4:44commemorate the day of my birth. Brad I.
- 4:46I have, I have great taste, Bob, what can I say?
- 4:49What can you say? All right, guys, let's get into
- 4:51talking about this movie. Bilga, I I want to throw to you
- 4:54early on because every season we send the list of films for our
- 4:58guests to choose from and you pretty quickly jumped at the
- 5:01Tree of life. Now I know that it's a 10 out of
- 5:0310 for you. It's on your sight and sound
- 5:05list, but I imagine that you've talked about this film
- 5:08elsewhere. I've seen you write about it a
- 5:10ton, so why does it still merit, you know, discussion for you at
- 5:16this point? Why do you keep coming back to
- 5:17it? That's a great question.
- 5:21It's so funny because I should be able to answer that question.
- 5:24I mean, beyond the fact that I I absolutely adore it and it is my
- 5:28favorite film from one of my all time favorite film makers.
- 5:31Also the fact that I I did write about it so much at the time
- 5:35and, and, and did a lot of reporting on it.
- 5:38What, what one thing that's that's always been in the back
- 5:43of my mind is, you know, when, when Tree of Life came out, I
- 5:47wasn't, I wasn't like a first string film critic anywhere.
- 5:51I mean, I, I, I wrote, I had my own blog and I would
- 5:53occasionally write stuff. I think I hadn't started doing
- 5:59full length film reviews for Vulture yet.
- 6:01So I would, you know, occasionally do things, but a
- 6:05lot of the stuff I wrote about the Tree of life, I basically
- 6:07just wrote for myself. There was one piece that there
- 6:10was one piece that I wrote for New York Magazine.
- 6:12That was actually that I started before I saw the Tree of life
- 6:16about kind of the, the 30 year process it it took to make the
- 6:20Tree of life that wound up being like a chart.
- 6:23Like I, I, I did all this reporting.
- 6:25I spent months interviewing people, some of whom like,
- 6:28really didn't want to be interviewed because they were
- 6:30afraid that Malik would be upset with them because he was such a
- 6:33private person. I did so much reporting and
- 6:38interviews. I mean, I, I haunted down people
- 6:40who had heard about this project called Q back in the day.
- 6:44I like, did a whole interview with Sam Shepard about some
- 6:47other movie just so I could ask him about Q because he had
- 6:50apparently once read the script. You know, I interviewed like,
- 6:56Jim McBride, the filmmaker Jim McBride about these other films.
- 6:59But like, I also wanted to ask him about Malik because he was
- 7:02kind of in that world a little bit.
- 7:04So I did all this stuff, you know, but I wasn't like, you
- 7:08know, I wasn't a writer who had the pull to get big pieces in.
- 7:12So, you know, all that work wound up being like a little
- 7:15chart in the corner of a page of New York Magazine.
- 7:19And then also cinema. I was redoing stuff for cinema
- 7:21editor. So I actually then went and
- 7:23talked to a lot of the editors for the film and did this piece
- 7:26for Cinema Editor, which was not a, it was a, it's the, I don't
- 7:30know if it's even still around, but it's the publication of the
- 7:32American Cinema Editors Organization.
- 7:36And that was not available online.
- 7:38That was actually just a print magazine, but I got permission
- 7:42from them to, you know, put that text up on my own, like personal
- 7:46blog. So part of it is that a lot of
- 7:50stuff about Tree of Life is kind of stuck inside me.
- 7:54I mean, over the years I've written about it in other
- 7:57circumstances, but but I feel still like like I didn't get the
- 8:02chance to like do the big tree of life piece back in the day,
- 8:05even though I've written about it for a vulture in places ever
- 8:07since. So yeah, it's kind of a like
- 8:10it's just kind of an ongoing thing.
- 8:11But also it's it's a film that, you know, it's a film that
- 8:15merits constantly thinking about, much like another one of
- 8:19my favorite films, Barry Lyndon. Like it's a film that you can
- 8:23kind of grow up with. I mean, I don't, I haven't had
- 8:25to grow up with Tree of Life because it came out, you know,
- 8:292011. I was, you know, I was a grown
- 8:31ass man when it came out. But like Barry Lyndon, for
- 8:35example, is a film I first saw when I was like a freshman in
- 8:38college, right. And, and every time I come back
- 8:42to it, there's a different part of that film that I find myself
- 8:45really connecting to as I get older, which is one of the
- 8:49magical things about that movie. Tree of Life is kind of the same
- 8:52way. Like every time I revisit it,
- 8:54there's some other part of it that I really, really gravitate
- 8:57towards. But also, it's just that, you
- 8:59know, I mean, I remember the first time I saw the Tree of
- 9:02Life and it was, you know, it was, I mean, it was still to
- 9:06this day, maybe the most incredible cinematic experience
- 9:10I've ever had. If there's two movies I wish I
- 9:14could see in theaters on release, it's Tree of Life and
- 9:20Mad Max Fury Rd. Basically see Mad Max Fury Rd.
- 9:24on on. Basically the same movie, but
- 9:27those would be the two. I mean, they're, they're good
- 9:30ones to see on a big screen. I'm happy to say I've seen both
- 9:35multiple times on the big screen.
- 9:36But but yeah, no, I, I totally know what you mean.
- 9:40When I saw Tree of Life, it was actually at a press screening.
- 9:43It was premiering at Cannes, but they actually did have a New
- 9:46York press screening during the day.
- 9:49I obviously had been, you know, obsessed with this movie for
- 9:52years. So I like went to the 11 AM
- 9:55press screening. It was at.
- 9:56The You were camped out cosplaying as Terrence Malick.
- 9:59Well it was funny because if there was like 4 people in the
- 10:01theater, like it was an 11 AM screening or something 10 AM
- 10:04something like that, it was at the AMC 68.
- 10:07If I. Remember was looking around like
- 10:08are are you guys so pumped for this?
- 10:10Everybody is. Like huge room, huge room.
- 10:14I was like 1 of literally like 5 people in there.
- 10:17But when and I, I told people this at the time when, during
- 10:21the the creation sequence, right?
- 10:24I mean, before the Earth emerges, when Speaking of
- 10:30Preisner's Lakrimosa is playing, I had what I believe is an
- 10:38episode of Stendhal Syndrome. Are you guys familiar with this?
- 10:44It's the only reason I know about the Stendhal Syndrome is
- 10:47because Dario Argento made a movie called The Stendhal
- 10:50Syndrome and used it as like a kind of a horror movie conceit.
- 10:53But it's a thing where and I guess it, it affected people
- 10:58like in the 19th century, in 18th century a lot.
- 11:01But like in the presence of certain works of art, you
- 11:05actually like, have like a nervous breakdown, like like
- 11:09you're. Like.
- 11:11Like, like you actually have what most people would call like
- 11:15a panic attack. Like you, your, you, you.
- 11:17Your breathing gets shallow, your heart starts racing, and
- 11:20you actually feel like you're about to die.
- 11:23It's like Bob at the end of Coco, Yeah.
- 11:25I, well, I, I imagine, I imagine this is a thing that happened.
- 11:30I mean, probably happens less now.
- 11:31It's actually kind of sad it doesn't happen as much anymore,
- 11:33probably to people because we're just constantly inundated with
- 11:37reproductions of art and we're just, you know, like, but like
- 11:40back in the day when people had to travel like days to see a
- 11:45painting or a cathedral or, you know, or, or let alone like the
- 11:50Mona Lisa or something. And they spent most of their
- 11:53normal days like herding sheep. Or any cheaper or whatever.
- 11:57Like, I mean, it's just, you know, whatever.
- 11:59Like, you know, but but like, you go and you travel and you,
- 12:05you won't, you find yourself somewhere and suddenly you're
- 12:08faced with like a painting by Michelangelo and you lose your
- 12:12mind, you know, And that's what happened to me during that
- 12:16sequence. I was like, what the fuck is
- 12:18happening to me? Do I have to leave the theater?
- 12:20Like I was actually freaking out and I was like, oh, no, no, no,
- 12:25this is awesome. Like what, what it what just
- 12:27happened is awesome. It's, it's, it was very scary,
- 12:30but it was awesome, you know? Well and true true to the word
- 12:33awe some like awe inspiring so awesome that it's overwhelming.
- 12:39I, I, I love the religious bents.
- 12:42We're kind of moving towards, of like movies can be a religious
- 12:46experience. And I, I mean, Bill guy I've
- 12:50had, I've recently come into a place where like there's certain
- 12:54times where I'm listening to like my kids are running around
- 12:58the table and we're listening to the 1812 overture and the
- 13:01cannons start blasting and the church bells are going and I'm
- 13:05running around the table with my kids and all of a sudden I just
- 13:07start crying. And I'm like, I like, I just
- 13:11can't imagine a more beautiful thing than what I'm experiencing
- 13:15with my children right now paired with this magnificent
- 13:20piece of art. So I, I, I don't know if that's
- 13:23the same thing, but I'm with you.
- 13:25Absolutely. And, and I feel like, you know,
- 13:29as I say this as someone who is not religious is like, I mean,
- 13:31I'm, I'm, I'm a total atheist, like raised by atheists, like
- 13:35religion has never come into play for me.
- 13:38So in my mind, this is a, like, this is the only religious
- 13:43experience, you know, like I don't have a religious
- 13:45experience in church. I mean, I, I've been to churches
- 13:47like I've been to, you know, I love churches and I've been to
- 13:49churches for people's events and weddings and, you know,
- 13:53whatever. But, but the only kind of
- 13:55religious experience I have is the things where you say it was
- 13:59like a religious experience. I'm like, oh, that, that is a
- 14:01religious experience for me. Yeah, yeah.
- 14:04It makes you rethink using the the phrase like transcendent
- 14:07flippantly, like I I touched something that was beyond myself
- 14:11in this, the experience of this thing.
- 14:13And just for the record, you know, that's that is how I feel
- 14:15about Joe Dirt. So I just want to get that out
- 14:18there. You know.
- 14:20You know guys. Different definition of touched
- 14:23something but. True, true.
- 14:26I think that it is. Unknowable.
- 14:32I think it's time for us to get into our first segment of the
- 14:34day, which is called Brad Explains.
- 14:36Brad's gonna give us the movie plot with only 60 seconds
- 14:40ticking on the clock. So let's go ahead and do your
- 14:42take with this little segment that we call Brad Explains.
- 14:46Brad Explains is the part of the show where Brad breaks down the
- 14:49plot of the film that he has just seen often for the first
- 14:52time. This is obviously not Brad's
- 14:54first time with The Tree of Life.
- 14:56Brad, have you checked it out in the interim between seasons 1
- 14:59and 10? I've held off.
- 15:01I have like tried to get a few friends to watch it with me.
- 15:05It always kind of falls through when I explain what the movie is
- 15:09and so it it's just never quite come around.
- 15:12It's always been on like the tip of my mind though of like that's
- 15:16a movie I want to come back to and experience and enjoy again.
- 15:20Not something I've returned to until two nights ago.
- 15:24Wow, this is special. I'm actually, I've been looking
- 15:26forward to Brad explains maybe more than any other part of
- 15:29today's episode because, you know, Bill got Brad and I are
- 15:31both from a religious background.
- 15:33We actually are both seminary grads who have worked as pastors
- 15:37at some point. So like we bring an explicitly
- 15:40Christian lens to a lot of what we watch.
- 15:43And I think that like, you know, I was in college when this movie
- 15:47came out. I was a a theology undergrad
- 15:50and, you know, this movie hits me and I think it came out the
- 15:54year before Life of Pi Brad. And I remember thinking, even at
- 15:58the time, you know, I don't necessarily think that you can
- 16:02just copy paste these directly onto a Christian, you know,
- 16:06screed or worldview or whatever. But I couldn't believe how
- 16:11seriously these films were taking questions of faith in a
- 16:16way that I had really only seen to that point in like European
- 16:19cinema. Like if some if some religious,
- 16:24something religious happened in an American movie, especially in
- 16:27the late nineties, 2000s, it was usually portrayed as a negative
- 16:31or it was something like Paul Dano's character in There Will
- 16:35be Blood or, you know, Robert Duvall in The Apostle or
- 16:38something like that. And so to wrestle with these
- 16:41really deep philosophical questions, this movie
- 16:45immediately like shot up my list.
- 16:47And I remember even at the time seeing like atheist readings of
- 16:52the Tree of life and thinking to myself, like, this is the most
- 16:55explicitly Christian movie I've ever seen.
- 16:57I don't know how you could have an atheist reading of this
- 16:59movie. And I think what I've been so
- 17:01blown away by is that each time I return to it, yes, for me,
- 17:05because of my lens and my world view, Like I, I see this as a
- 17:09movie that is very nakedly referencing and, and talking
- 17:13about the Bible and the Christian God.
- 17:15But I see every other interpretation of it within this
- 17:19movie as well. Like, I see this as Terrence
- 17:23Malick as a transcendentalist, I can see this as a movie about
- 17:26just childhood. And this is a movie about
- 17:28parenthood. And I think there's so many
- 17:30different lenses that you can read this through as the primary
- 17:34lens. And I think that for me is what
- 17:36makes it a great work of art. And I say all that to say,
- 17:39that's why I'm looking forward to Brad explains today, because
- 17:42I'm, I'm looking forward to seeing how your views on this
- 17:46movie have shifted with another, you know, six years of life
- 17:49experience under your belt here, Brad.
- 17:51Yeah, man, you have put the pressure on Bob.
- 17:55I will see see what I can do to live up to these expectations.
- 18:01One minute on the clock to explain the plot of this film,
- 18:05which spans at least 4 billion years.
- 18:07So, Brad, how about it, man? One minute and go.
- 18:11You're not a young earther, Bob. 4 billion years.
- 18:14Huh, that's true. I meant 6000.
- 18:18Right there you go, 6000 years. Oh man, Ken Ham is going to have
- 18:23his way with you. The Tree of Life is a film that
- 18:28follows a family. I believe it's the O'Brien
- 18:32family, which I've learned because I read Bill Gaz's
- 18:35articles and that is a helpful piece to start by saying that
- 18:41this is a film that follows them in a memory format, that we see
- 18:47the film as if it is the memory of Sean Penn, the older
- 18:52character, remembering his childhood.
- 18:56Part of it is things that he can barely remember, and it moves by
- 18:59quickly. Part of it lingers, especially
- 19:03as he gets older, into his young teenage years, but it follows
- 19:07him wrestle with these ideas of grace and law and discipline and
- 19:14love and try to work out what it means to be a human being in
- 19:19light of this vast universe of chaos and rigidity and, and
- 19:26figure out what it means to be a human.
- 19:28And I, I think that it is an incredibly personal film that
- 19:34feels so warm to me. And that's my brain explains,
- 19:41'cause there's not a, there's not a plot, guys.
- 19:44I I mean there, there is and there is, there is that's it's
- 19:47another thing that is so interesting about this film is
- 19:50like I, I took notes and I'm, you know, you got to forgive me.
- 19:53I'm jumping all over the place in these notes here, but like, I
- 19:56think there's two kind of paths that the story takes in terms of
- 19:59how it frames itself. And the the most obvious one
- 20:02here is that the film is kind of bookended by these grand sort of
- 20:06cosmic visions and, you know, explanations of the origins of
- 20:11the universe. And I think that framing this
- 20:15small domestic story in the context of this cosmic, you
- 20:19know, drama that's happening is really what Malik is getting at
- 20:23here. And so I think I'd like to start
- 20:24by talking about. The sort of grand cosmic saga
- 20:28that we're presented with here, because the movie starts out in
- 20:31its opening moments as sort of a meditation on grief.
- 20:35You find out at a time period which looks like the early
- 20:381960s, that Brad Pitt and Jessica Chastain's son has been
- 20:43apparently killed. I would say killed in action,
- 20:45right? That's the what I got from that.
- 20:47Maybe in the Korean War or some early skirmish.
- 20:50It looked like a was. Was it a military delivery of a
- 20:53letter Brad that he got? I feel like she 'cause he's at
- 21:00the airport on the pay phone when Brad Pitt, when he gets the
- 21:04call, I to me, it felt like a younger child passed away.
- 21:10And I think that's the well he's. 19 I think, right.
- 21:13He's 19. It's actually, I mean, it it it
- 21:18in the real life in the Malek family, it was a suicide.
- 21:23Yeah. And and this is hinted, they
- 21:26don't say it in the film. So, but it's hinted at because,
- 21:33you know, Brad Pitt's like early on when he's kind of thinking
- 21:36about, you know, thinking back on on his son, he talks about
- 21:41how he used to like hit himself when he would criticize him,
- 21:46turning the pages too fast and stuff.
- 21:48So there are these little hints at like, was there some inner
- 21:53shame or fear or, or self loathing?
- 21:56Like there is speculation, but, you know, it's all very
- 21:58glancing. And I don't think it's meant to
- 22:00be, you know, I mean, that's sort of what it was in their
- 22:04family. And I think Malik has brought a
- 22:06lot of his own, his own life into the film.
- 22:11But I think he keeps it open for a reason because it does.
- 22:14Does it really matter? I mean, it's, you know, so,
- 22:18yeah. But yes, that was that was the
- 22:20that was the thing, I think. I think the the guy in the
- 22:22uniform is just like a mailman or whoever would have delivered.
- 22:25Got it. OK, alright, that makes.
- 22:27Sense And, and that's why he's not there, because he was, I
- 22:29mean, the, the, the story is he, he was a very talented musician,
- 22:33a very talented guitarist, I believe.
- 22:35And he had travelled to Spain to work with Andrés Segovia.
- 22:43And, and I think, you know, he was just really, I mean, who
- 22:49knows, but like very neurotic, hard on himself.
- 22:52There was apparently there was even a thing where he had maybe
- 22:54like broken his fingers because he didn't think that he had, you
- 22:58know, that, that he was getting it.
- 23:01And I guess I, I guess he, I guess he died, you know, while
- 23:04he was away somewhere. So yeah, it's a very sad.
- 23:07Story, yeah, that for sure. And I think it, it deepens even,
- 23:11you know, once you know that context, the, the level of grief
- 23:15that they're processing at the beginning of the film.
- 23:18And it starts with a quote from the book of Job, which is
- 23:21essentially, you know, like, where were you when I, when I
- 23:23hung the heavens and the earth in their place?
- 23:26And then it launches into this small domestic story about
- 23:30processing grief. And, you know, if it's your
- 23:32first time seeing this film, you're not expecting the
- 23:35sequence that is to follow that. Like, it's about, you know, 1520
- 23:39minutes of a kind of a montage of watching this family go
- 23:43through the loss of a child and asking these questions of God or
- 23:48the universe or what have you. Like, why is this happening?
- 23:50Where have you been? What have I done to bring this
- 23:53on? Have I neglected you somehow?
- 23:55Did I neglect my son? And then you get this sort of
- 23:58big cosmic response, which I think is an immediate call back
- 24:02to that verse in Job. And Malik launches you not just
- 24:07into this sort of, you know, response of scale of, like, look
- 24:12at the universe and how small we are in it.
- 24:15But what I think is really the key to getting at the movie is
- 24:20that he walks you through the entire narrative of the way that
- 24:24these two responses to life, the way of nature and the way of
- 24:28grace have been woven into the earth from its foundation.
- 24:33Like you get this incredibly janky CGI dinosaur sequence, but
- 24:41it's a sequence that, you know, on its face, you're kind of
- 24:43like, why was that there? You know, it's it's like this
- 24:45Velociraptor or something that finds a wounded dinosaur on the
- 24:49side of a riverbank and overpowers it and puts its foot
- 24:52right on its head and is clearly in a position to kill this
- 24:56smaller creature looks at it and feels some dinosaur sense of
- 25:02pity and then has grace upon it and walks away.
- 25:06And I think that, you know, you start to see that what Malik is
- 25:10doing is not necessarily just this book of Job, like, hey, I'm
- 25:13God and I am bigger than you. And you don't know what what
- 25:16you're talking about. It's it's a response that is
- 25:20yes, it's about scale, but it's also about you small family in
- 25:25Texas living your small domestic life are actually part of this
- 25:29story that is playing out on a grand cosmic stage throughout
- 25:34the history of the Earth. And I think to be able to
- 25:37communicate that nearly wordlessly across what is
- 25:42essentially a 40 minute montage is one of the the biggest and
- 25:47most impressive feats of filmmaking I've ever seen, guys.
- 25:51I'm I'm with you 100% man. I, I remember specifically
- 25:55saying the first time we reviewed it, like I understand
- 25:59that the 1st 40 minutes is montage and it's when he's young
- 26:03and you're not. It's meant to be fast-paced.
- 26:05But for me it like when the movie slowed down a little bit
- 26:08is where I really start to enjoy it.
- 26:10Now I'm like, I just enjoyed the entire thing.
- 26:14I Bob, I'm with you. That first 40 minutes is so
- 26:18freaking brilliant of his ability to communicate all of
- 26:22this. Like you said, 4 billion plus
- 26:25years of the existence of of existence and to communicate
- 26:31that in the terms of the biggest life questions that humans ask
- 26:37like why do bad things happen to me?
- 26:41Do my actions even have an effect on the world around me?
- 26:43Do I have purpose and meaning? Am I safe in the world?
- 26:47He communicates all of that stuff through snippets of
- 26:51dialogue through 1 sided conversations on the phone.
- 26:54And then I called it the first time.
- 26:56The National Geographic sequence of the creation of the universe.
- 27:03Bilga I'd like to hear your interpretation of it, though,
- 27:05you know, because it, it's pretty rare these days that you
- 27:08get a film that starts off with a quote from the Bible like
- 27:12that. You know, I've, there's
- 27:13obviously been a few, I think Scorsese's Silence does as well.
- 27:16And that's another movie that takes questions of faith and
- 27:19doubt very seriously. But waging be ends with a kind.
- 27:23That's true, yeah. When you see the kind of
- 27:25narrative that Malik is trying to structure in what seems like
- 27:31a pretty formless first part of that film, like what?
- 27:34What are your what are your reads on that?
- 27:36What are your interpretations there?
- 27:41I have a lot of interpretations. I want to talk about the
- 27:45dinosaur scene briefly. I I love the dinosaur scene and
- 27:50that it doesn't seem as it doesn't seem that janky to me.
- 27:53Although watching it again last night, I was, I mean, I can sort
- 27:56of see the scenes. I mean, the problem with CGI is
- 27:59it looks so great the first time you see it 20 years later.
- 28:02It looks so nodgy. But but that scene, I can't
- 28:08shake that scene because and I have no idea.
- 28:15I mean, I, I've talked to a lot of people who've worked with
- 28:17Malik. I've talked to a lot of people
- 28:18who worked on this film. I talked to a lot of people
- 28:19who've, you know, who know Malik never asked any of them this.
- 28:24And I don't know that they would even know.
- 28:27But I see that as you know, we have watched, obviously we have
- 28:33watched the creation of the universe.
- 28:35We've watched the creation of the earth.
- 28:38We've watched all these things, and I can't help but think that
- 28:44that scene, the dinosaur scene, is his answer to the question,
- 28:51what was the universe's first act of mercy?
- 28:55You know, like what was the first time that a sentient
- 29:01creature showed mercy, you know, and, and what you know, was it
- 29:06like a human doing that? And if so, when?
- 29:08You know, like it's mercy exists now.
- 29:11So it started somewhere, like the universe started, the earth
- 29:15started the, the, the, the continent started the organisms,
- 29:19all this shit started. So where did mercy start?
- 29:22You know, and obviously you can talk about, I mean, obviously
- 29:25there are spiritual ideas around it as well, but like, what was
- 29:29the universe's first act of mercy?
- 29:32Maybe it was a dinosaur choosing not to kill a wounded dinosaur.
- 29:36I, I love that. Like, I, that to me, like every
- 29:39time I see that, I mean, I cry a lot watching this movie, but I
- 29:43definitely cry at the dinosaurs. So that's, I just wanted to
- 29:47touch on that. The, the thing about the, the
- 29:50narrative structure of the film to me, and this is also because
- 29:54of the, the, the reporting I did about the film before I even saw
- 29:57it and because I knew about this project.
- 29:59Q That had dribbled out, you know, over the years because,
- 30:03you know, Malik sold story, which you're I'm sure familiar
- 30:06with, is he makes Badlands, he makes Days of Heaven.
- 30:10Charlie Bludorn at Paramount loves Days of Heaven so much
- 30:15that he basically gives him $1,000,000 and says whatever you
- 30:19do next, I want you to make it at Paramount.
- 30:22It's kind of like a first look deal, basically.
- 30:26And Malik has this idea that he is going to make a film that
- 30:31kind of incorporates the life and death of the universe into
- 30:35it. And he, you know, and this is
- 30:39the era of like, I mean, Kleaniskatsi is a little later,
- 30:42but you know, this kind of ambition is in the air with
- 30:46other films as well. But, you know, he's a guy who's,
- 30:49you know, obviously has thought long and hard about these
- 30:52things. And there's also this story that
- 30:54like when he was a kid, there was like a, a, like a newspaper
- 30:58supplement or something like that or some kind of book that
- 31:01he had that was kind of very much a picture book about the
- 31:05creation of the universe. And people said like, he
- 31:07actually still had this thing. So there was very much a kind of
- 31:10National Geographic kind of, you know, simplifying it in some way
- 31:15while allowing it to exist in all this kind of awesomeness.
- 31:20So he starts this thing which over the years is referred to as
- 31:24Project Q. At some point it was called
- 31:26Casita. But much of the time I guess it
- 31:28just didn't even really have a name.
- 31:30And he gets a small group of collaborators together.
- 31:33He gets like an effects guy, he gets a cinematographer, his his
- 31:36brother is involved. There's a producer like it's
- 31:39really like a 5 or 6 Man Group and you know, they just start
- 31:45gathering footage, stuff, ideas, you know, he sends people out to
- 31:50go shoot an eclipse. He sends people out to go shoot
- 31:54a glacier, he sends people out to go shoot lava.
- 31:56I mean, just all sorts of things.
- 31:58He doesn't really know exactly how it's all going to fit
- 32:01together and he doesn't really have a script.
- 32:03He just has pages and pages of just like very poetic
- 32:05descriptions of like the beginnings of the universe.
- 32:08Just he's just, I mean, it's very like, I don't think he was
- 32:10ever a pothead, but it's very much like you kind of can just
- 32:13imagine the, the, the you know, the, the smoke wafting from like
- 32:17whatever trailer or, you know, you know, back lot office
- 32:21they're on. But and like, you know, in the
- 32:25studio, people are like, hey, you know, are you going to give
- 32:27us a script? And he's like, here's 20 more
- 32:29pages of like poetry, you know? Yeah, poetry.
- 32:33And like this is this is where the ground comes from, you know.
- 32:38And so this goes on for for a while.
- 32:41I think they, you know, this goes on for like a couple of
- 32:43years, I believe. And eventually he kind of loses
- 32:48interest. A couple of things happened. 1
- 32:51He has this idea, but he never can figure out what the actual
- 32:54narrative is going to be like. Like this is supposed to be kind
- 32:57of woven in with a with a narrative of some sort.
- 33:00Like it is going to be an actual movie with a story at at some
- 33:04point. I mean, different people have
- 33:06speculated and you know, things have filtered out.
- 33:07But at some point, apparently it was going to be like a World War
- 33:10One story. At some point it was going to be
- 33:13like like prehistoric cave people, like a romance.
- 33:16It was going to be a lot of things.
- 33:17He never quite figured it out. And then he, you know, at some
- 33:24point, he abandons the project. I think it kind of winds down a
- 33:27little bit. But then he, you know, he goes
- 33:29to France. He falls in love.
- 33:31He decides to move to France. He gets married.
- 33:33And he's just like, listen, let's not worry about this thing
- 33:37anymore. I'm going to go over here now.
- 33:39And I see here. Yeah.
- 33:41And the people who worked on the film, a couple of them were just
- 33:43like, I was like, really, really sort of just heartbroken at it
- 33:49because they were really excited by this.
- 33:51I mean, the thing they always say was like, everyone who is
- 33:54spent time with Malik says this. He's like, they're like, he is
- 33:56just like a really cool guy. Like, he's just like the coolest
- 34:00guy. And you would love just hanging
- 34:02out with him and talking to him and working with him.
- 34:04And, you know, they were all really disappointed when the
- 34:06thing just wound down. And and then, you know, he's
- 34:10gone for 20 years. I mean, he's, you know, pops up
- 34:13here and there does some work. It's not like he's, he's not a
- 34:15recluse really. I mean, he has his reputation as
- 34:18a recluse because he doesn't like to be photographed and
- 34:21doesn't do publicity and stuff. But, you know, the people that
- 34:24know him know him. You know, we lived in Austin
- 34:26much of the time. I know people who used to play
- 34:29like, you know, pick up basketball with him.
- 34:32You know, he was just a guy and. Just in the local Y league.
- 34:37Yeah, no, like literally no, he wasn't, you know, he was, he was
- 34:40a, he was a high school. He he's a high school football
- 34:44star. Like he was a real kind of real.
- 34:46I mean, he's a brilliant guy, but also a real jock.
- 34:48So he is still, I mean, now I don't, I mean, he's like in his
- 34:5280s. So I don't know what he does
- 34:53now, but I I do like he was into running, he was into basketball.
- 34:57So he did all. So what you're telling me is he
- 34:58was the original Zac Efron from High School Musical?
- 35:01He did. He could do it all.
- 35:03There is a great, great story, Paul Williams, who is who was
- 35:09involved with Malik's early films.
- 35:11He was a director, producer in the 70s, made a number of films
- 35:16with like real stars and stuff. But but the films were never
- 35:20very big. But he wrote a memoir.
- 35:24Oh gosh, I wish I could remember, but I, I read it a
- 35:26couple years ago. I posted this on Twitter, so you
- 35:28might have seen it. But there's a part of it where
- 35:30he talks about going to going to Cuba with Malik 'cause, you
- 35:36know, Malik had written an article about Che Guevara and
- 35:40stuff, and at some point he was going to make the the film that
- 35:42became Soderbergh's Che was at one point going to be a Terrence
- 35:45Malik film. But it's a story about playing
- 35:50basketball with Terrence Malik, Fidel Castro, and oh gosh, who
- 35:57was the other person? Hang on, I'm going to find it.
- 36:01Sorry, sorry. That is wild.
- 36:07No, we we will vamp while we look for the the Fidel caste
- 36:10'cause we have to finish the story now, Brad.
- 36:12Like there's no. Yeah, it is OK Paul Williams,
- 36:17Terrence Malick and Francis Ford Coppola.
- 36:20I'm gonna, I'm gonna, I'm gonna read the section.
- 36:23The next morning, the three on three basketball game pits solid
- 36:27Fidel and two buff Cuban soldiers, all in fatigues
- 36:30against Rotunda Terry, hefty Francis and skinny me.
- 36:35There are no other Cubans there. Fidel needs no additional
- 36:38security in this land where he is so adored.
- 36:41Castro fouls me hard as he elbows his way into the post and
- 36:44makes an easy layup. We get we get the ball out on
- 36:48the next play and I back him into a deep post and give him a
- 36:51hard elbow in the ribs. Fidel says foul.
- 36:54I say no, that's the same as you did.
- 36:56He says foul, foul, foul. He takes the ball out of my
- 36:59hands, walks to the free throw line.
- 37:00He takes two shots on the next play.
- 37:03I am careful not to foul him, but I guard him so tightly that
- 37:06he has to stop dribbling. I quickly fall off him to help
- 37:09my 2 chubby directors guard their two Fleet Soldier
- 37:11athletes. Fidel can't find a passing lane.
- 37:15Castro simply begins to dribble the basketball again and head
- 37:18straight in for another easy layup.
- 37:20I say hey hey, that's a double dribble.
- 37:22Fidel looks at me. I say that ain't basketball, you
- 37:25can't do that, it's our ball. Fidel holds the ball and looks
- 37:28at me. I look at him.
- 37:29I see he is serious, he just must win.
- 37:32He says this is my country, I can do whatever I want here and
- 37:36laughs with a smile. We laugh, too.
- 37:40Some egos are so big they can cradle a nation.
- 37:43And he says before we fly away, Huey says Cuba is still racist.
- 37:47Black Cubans are victims of discrimination by the lighter
- 37:49skinned Cubans. And he says he misses American
- 37:52hamburgers. And by the way, that Huey is
- 37:54Huey Huey Long. Oh, so I said not good long Huey
- 37:59Newton. Sorry.
- 37:59Yeah, yeah, yeah. But just.
- 38:04Like that's wild, man. What a story.
- 38:07Anyway, sorry, total tangent. Apologies, love that tangent.
- 38:11Ridiculous tangent. But so I mean, getting back to
- 38:16the story, you know, Malik is gone for 20 years, you know,
- 38:19comes back playing. Basketball with Fidel.
- 38:22Yeah. I mean, this is before that, but
- 38:24I'm sure it's, I'm sure there was a lot.
- 38:25Of straight years, that's all he did.
- 38:27Yeah, he was probably playing basketball with like George W
- 38:30Bush or something, 'cause, you know, being a, a Austin guy.
- 38:33Yeah, but the so he comes back, you know, he does Thin red Line,
- 38:40the New World, and it really does feel like he's back and
- 38:42then. But what's interesting to me is
- 38:45you know, when I, you know, when, when Tree of Life finally
- 38:48came out, it was clear that it was this, it was the Q project.
- 38:52And I found it so touching that after all these years of trying
- 38:57to find the narrative that's going to sort of make the whole
- 39:01thing work, this most reclusive and publicity shy of directors
- 39:06was just like, I'm going to tell my own family story.
- 39:09Like, that's the story he found. And how perfect is it?
- 39:12Like, that's the thing. It's it's just because in the
- 39:15finished film, it feels so organic.
- 39:16It doesn't to me feel like, oh, why did he figure?
- 39:19Why did he put this story here? But it actually took him like
- 39:22years and years before he figured out that that's the
- 39:25story he needed to tell. I think it's beautiful and I
- 39:30think it's a good segue into what I had written down as sort
- 39:33of the other way of framing this film.
- 39:34So you obviously have a a small domestic story framed against or
- 39:39I guess in in line with this story of the cosmos.
- 39:43But then you also have this decision to ask huge universal
- 39:48questions about humanity through the eyes of a small boy.
- 39:52And so it essentially becomes like the most important movie
- 39:56ever made about puberty. And I kind of watched most of
- 40:01this movie through that lens today, Brad, Because for some
- 40:04reason I, I got so lost in the other framing device of the film
- 40:08the first few times I'd seen it that I really neglected to look
- 40:12at this as a coming of age movie, or at least a movie that
- 40:15encapsulates a really. Volatile time in a young boy's
- 40:20life. And I think the the extent to
- 40:23which this is a movie about puberty is worth talking about
- 40:27because it's a super interesting, I guess, way of
- 40:31commenting on the whole human race, right?
- 40:33Like, you're going through puberty, you're going through an
- 40:36incredible amount of of hormonal changes.
- 40:39You're constantly beating yourself up, you're constantly
- 40:42questioning your own innate goodness or vadnais.
- 40:46You're measuring yourself against how much of this is in
- 40:49my blood versus what is a choice that I can make you.
- 40:53You're doing things that you don't want to do and you can't
- 40:55explain why. I think it's just an absolutely
- 40:59perfect kind of metaphorical encapsulation of the questions
- 41:04we all ask. And putting it in the eyes of
- 41:06like a 12 year old boy or however old he's supposed to be
- 41:09is like it is brilliant, honestly.
- 41:12Well, and for me it like it almost takes it a further step
- 41:15back. It's not through the eyes of a
- 41:1712 year old boy. It's through the eyes of a 52
- 41:21year old man thinking about his 12 year old life.
- 41:25And how often do we see people later in life begin to look back
- 41:31to make sense of what's coming ahead.
- 41:34And I, I, and that's not to say that anything you said is wrong,
- 41:38Bob, I, I agree. This is a movie about the
- 41:40importance of taking seriously the inquisitiveness of children.
- 41:47The there's a, there's a, a mentor in my life that talks
- 41:52that has this phrase where he's like, there's no such thing as a
- 41:54junior Holy Spirit, right? And if we think of the Holy
- 41:57Spirit as a mentor, a guide, somebody that helps us in our
- 42:01life, like we so often don't take children seriously and we
- 42:07have infantilized the teenage years to it feels like we have
- 42:13prevented them from being allowed to ask these really
- 42:17important questions about purpose and value and meaning
- 42:21and, and what does it mean to be good and bad?
- 42:24And as I was watching it this time through, I really was
- 42:27reminded of East of Eden and the the main characters of East of
- 42:31Eden, like struggling with like, well, he's just Cain and I'm
- 42:35Abel, or, you know, I'm Abel and he's Cain and I'm evil and I
- 42:39just am evil and I can't do anything about it.
- 42:41And there's so much of that that we ought to take seriously as
- 42:46adults. And yet, if I'm being blunt, I
- 42:49think so few of us have ever truly, deeply wrestled with
- 42:53these questions of what it means to be a human and good and evil
- 42:58and all these things that we can't take it seriously when our
- 43:01kids ask it then 'cause we don't have answers ourselves.
- 43:04And Malik Malik is like, his whole movie is just thrust at
- 43:08this heart of we are asking the questions of the cosmos from the
- 43:13time we are born, right? All the way through the end of
- 43:18his life, You know, as Sean Penn seemingly is entering the
- 43:21afterlife. Yeah, and I think, Bilga, part
- 43:25of the reason I bring this up is because I I read a really good
- 43:28blog post of yours from when the film was released and you were
- 43:32kind of musing on something that you had done as a parent.
- 43:36You had you had said something that startled your toddler and
- 43:39and you walked away wondering like, did I do the wrong thing?
- 43:42Did you know I was trying to protect my child?
- 43:44But I've also scared my child in the process.
- 43:47And I think that there really is a fine line between viewing this
- 43:50movie through the lens of the child and the imprint the
- 43:53parents have on the child. And also viewing the movie
- 43:55through the lens of like this is a very sympathetic movie
- 43:58ultimately towards the parents and their own need for for self
- 44:02reconciliation and self actualization.
- 44:05I just love to hear what you think a little bit about the the
- 44:08puberty angle of the movie. I mean, there's that there's
- 44:15there's that line that always sticks out for me in the film.
- 44:18It's it's part of the voice over from the boy when he says
- 44:22father, make me good, right? And it's we don't know who he's
- 44:28talking to. Like, you know, like, I mean,
- 44:31this is, I mean, this is a child with a fraught relationship with
- 44:34his father, but it could also be father, you know, father a God,
- 44:38but but like, or a priest, you know, but this, this idea,
- 44:44father make me good. You know, he's, he's yearning to
- 44:48be good and he's wrestling with the fact that he isn't or that
- 44:51he does petty things or that he does cruel things.
- 44:54It's like I'm trying to remember when this this actually comes.
- 44:56I think really during those, I think when we're actually
- 45:00watching Jessica Chastain in the plane, I think it's right around
- 45:02that point. There's this little, the film is
- 45:05full of little brilliant pieces of montage.
- 45:07And there's this, this little montage there where she's in the
- 45:10plane. She's she's telling them the
- 45:12story about this time that she went up in the plane.
- 45:15And then and then we see her floating next to that tree.
- 45:21There's that really kind of one of the oddest, oddest shots.
- 45:24In the movie, yeah. Yep.
- 45:27It's and it's all this little montage of sort of like this,
- 45:32this kind of questioning this yearning.
- 45:35I mean, the whole film is like that, but it's all full of
- 45:36little moments like that too. The thing that I wanted to sort
- 45:43of bring in was you guys have seen Scorsese Silence, another
- 45:49film about faith, and I find it interesting.
- 45:53Both films have such a interesting relationship to the
- 45:58question of of like where God is or not or how does how do you
- 46:04find God right? I mean, silence is an incredible
- 46:09movie as well. And but like silence has such AI
- 46:12mean it's almost like like it turns the concept of where God
- 46:16is into like a a third act narrative twist almost right.
- 46:19I mean, it's because it's like all throughout the film, you
- 46:23know, Andrew Garfield's priest character is is confronted by
- 46:27this this guy Kichijiro, who's, you know, kind of a very
- 46:31pathetic figure and keeps doing the wrong things and keeps
- 46:34betraying people. I mean, just the really, really
- 46:38broken character who keeps wanting to the the priest to
- 46:41hear his confession. And the priest is always like,
- 46:43OK, well, you know, like, just like wants to keep him at a
- 46:46distance. And this is a priest who at the
- 46:49height of his own suffering, sees, you know, sees his face
- 46:55reflected in a pool of water and then sees Jesus and thinks, Oh,
- 46:59you know, like I have achieved, like I have achieved not, not
- 47:03godhood, but like, I, I have become like I'm seeing God.
- 47:06And he absolutely he's not. It's that, that like, it's a
- 47:08completely red herring in many ways.
- 47:12And then at the very end of the film, because he's looking for
- 47:14God, the, the whole movie, he wants to, you know, he wants God
- 47:18to hear him and to, to answer him.
- 47:20And at the end of the movie, like towards the end of his
- 47:23life, Chigiro comes and, and he finally hears his confession And
- 47:28suddenly he hears the voice of God.
- 47:30And like, that's where it is. Like the idea that you find God
- 47:34in the most base suffering, pathetic, broken person.
- 47:42I find that just incredibly moving.
- 47:44And, and there is, and this film has some of that too, not in
- 47:49that sense, but in the sense like you find God, the like the
- 47:56search for God is God, you know, like the like the the yearning,
- 48:01the searching, the grief, the rage, the, the it's all kind of
- 48:06it. It like you're just like that's,
- 48:08that's it. Like that's, that's like, that's
- 48:12and that's what's so impressive about like that, the fact that
- 48:14it's something can contain all that.
- 48:17And, and, you know, and I think that's sort of maybe what the
- 48:22what the Sean Penn character is sort of working his way towards,
- 48:25you know. 100%, yeah. And I, I think that that's kind
- 48:29of echoed too, in the way there's a moment kind of early
- 48:32on in the movie where you see our main character like praying
- 48:38at his bedside. And it's interspersed with
- 48:41narrative of him asking these big questions of God.
- 48:44But when it's, when he's actually vocalizing out loud,
- 48:46like what his prayers are, they're just these tiny little
- 48:48like, help me not, you know, kick the neighbor's dog and help
- 48:51me not get mad. And it's the kind of things a
- 48:53kid says. And it makes you wonder as a
- 48:56viewer, like, is it just that he can't articulate the real
- 49:01questions that he has? And So what we've been hearing
- 49:04in in voice over, are these actually people even asking
- 49:08these things of God or are these kind of subconscious questions
- 49:11that even they can't can't vocalize And and that's.
- 49:14The yearnings of their heart. Yeah, 100%.
- 49:18I think it's just a really beautiful.
- 49:19And again, it it tips into this sort of mystery of the film that
- 49:25it's it's so hard to achieve, Brad.
- 49:26It's so hard as an artist, like, to not just come out and say
- 49:32what you want to say and at the same time to not be so, like,
- 49:36obscured that no one knows what you're trying to say.
- 49:39But the fact that, like, we can sit down right now and have a
- 49:42conversation about like, atheist readings of this film versus
- 49:46Christian readings of this film. And like both of those are not
- 49:49just extremely valid interpretations of the film, but
- 49:53I think there are intentional things strewn about the film
- 49:58from both perspectives that ultimately speak to the same
- 50:02core principle. And I think before we go to
- 50:05break guys, I want to talk a little bit more about the way
- 50:08Malik communicates that because, you know, the idea of like a
- 50:12movie being a tone poem or something is is so overused.
- 50:15But I think with Malik, like there really is no other way to
- 50:18talk about his use of the language of cinema than poetic.
- 50:23It really is. It's it's impressionistic.
- 50:26It's it's like a 2 1/2 hour montage, But that's underselling
- 50:30it. I don't know if vignette is even
- 50:31the right word for what you would use, but it made me think
- 50:35of Brad. This is the nerdiest thing I'm
- 50:37gonna say all day. When I first, when I first
- 50:41started getting obsessed with like classic movies, I bought
- 50:44the DVD of Casablanca, which I, I believe Warner's released that
- 50:48great two disc DVD in like O 4. And I watched the hell out of
- 50:52that thing and Roger Ebert recorded a commentary for
- 50:56Casablanca. And I watched the entire movie
- 50:59of Casablanca just listening to Ebert's voice over on there.
- 51:04And they get to the point where after Rick kicks Elsa out, you
- 51:07know, and is super mean to her, and then it goes into the
- 51:10memories of them in Paris and you finally get the flashbacks
- 51:13to what happened. There's a there's a rear
- 51:15projection shot of them driving in the countryside.
- 51:18And then it fades to the city of Paris or wherever they are.
- 51:22And it's the cheesiest rear projection shot.
- 51:25And Ebert comments on how people have kind of ridiculed that shot
- 51:29over the years. And he starts defending it.
- 51:32And it was so eloquent because it was so simple.
- 51:36But he just said that's the way memory works when we remember
- 51:40things. That's the way memory works.
- 51:42And I think that you really hit the nail on the head here in
- 51:45that this is a movie, that it it defies traditional narrative
- 51:50structures or even strictures because it is so entirely
- 51:55reliant on the way human memory fills those gaps in.
- 51:59You can piece together the narrative without him having to
- 52:02hold your hand through it, because we as people know
- 52:05exactly what it's like to just remember small snippets of
- 52:08things that were super impactful for us.
- 52:11Well, and, and human memory is wholly reliant on the emotions
- 52:15that fueled those important moments of our lives.
- 52:19And the, and that is the beauty of this film is that whether he
- 52:23is explaining the origin and demise of the cosmos at large,
- 52:30or he's talking about that moment where dad's gone and, and
- 52:35he's this, this disciplinarian that we don't love.
- 52:38And now we get to have like a 10 minute montage of them truly
- 52:42enjoying life. And like, tell me that that
- 52:46montage is not the most picture perfect.
- 52:50This is what I want my children to remember Summer like.
- 52:55Like that is the most perfect representation of the emotions
- 53:00of summertime as a 8 to 12 year old.
- 53:04At least what we all want our own life and our children's life
- 53:07to be. The way he captures the emotion
- 53:12of your dad trying to teach you something and you're just not
- 53:15quite getting it. And you can feel his shame and
- 53:18disappointment in you and you feel your soul shrinking at the
- 53:22idea that you're not good enough for the man who brought you into
- 53:26the world. I like how he's able to capture
- 53:30that, the emotionality of that with just bare bones minimum
- 53:34story. I, It's, it's truly incredible.
- 53:41I man, well. Before Bilga jumps in, I, I want
- 53:45to piss you off a little bit because there, there was this
- 53:48one moment. It's the moment where, you know,
- 53:50the, the music starts to turn a little sinister.
- 53:53And it's as, you know, our protagonist starts to make poor
- 53:56decisions and we start to see him, you know, really ethically
- 54:00dabble in some things he shouldn't be doing as a young
- 54:02man. And they're busting out the
- 54:04windows. And then they're like, let's put
- 54:06a frog under this rocket. And it, it gets more and more
- 54:08destructive. And it reminds.
- 54:10Sid from Toy Story. Yeah, it reminded me of the
- 54:14sequence in Eternal Sunshine, which I know is a movie that you
- 54:18absolutely hate. But it's when they go back to
- 54:21Joel's, like, deep, deep childhood.
- 54:23And he's remembering this time where they had like, they have
- 54:28him in like a little kids outfit and they're like you, they're
- 54:31surrounding him with a hammer. And they're like, you have to
- 54:32hit this bird in a wagon and kill it.
- 54:36And you see grown up Jim Carrey do it and then like, breakdown
- 54:41in tears because he still is a grown man.
- 54:43Like feels so much guilt and shame about this core memory
- 54:46from his childhood. I I don't know why I thought of
- 54:49that in the moment, but I think that moment multiplied by 100 is
- 54:53kind of the effect that the tree of life has on me.
- 54:57I mean, I'll, I'll jump into a way opposite end of things as
- 55:00far as you you fancy film people.
- 55:05The kid with Bruce Willis. And yeah, you know what I'm
- 55:10talking about. Excuse me, Disney's the kid is.
- 55:13Disney's the right title is that movie.
- 55:15You are right. That is the official title.
- 55:17Disney's The kid has that right. The whole movie is around.
- 55:20Like why is this? Why am I here in the present 12
- 55:25year old me? Why is he here in my present and
- 55:27annoying me? And Bruce Willis is great at
- 55:29being annoyed. And he's trying to help him
- 55:32figure out, like, what's this thing in my past I need to
- 55:34change? Where did I get this tick that,
- 55:37you know? And he thinks it's, oh, I got
- 55:39beat up trying to defend this dog in the schoolyard.
- 55:42And then they get back to the house after, you know, he got in
- 55:46trouble for getting in a fight at school.
- 55:49And his mom has cancer. And his dad grabs him by the
- 55:53shoulders and just screams at him, like, what are you doing?
- 55:57You're killing her. And it's that moment of just
- 56:03pure shame and guilt. And he realizes this is the
- 56:08moment that my whole life trajectory changed.
- 56:12And I think that you see that captured here in Tree of Life
- 56:17of, you know, Sean Penn reflecting like, where did where
- 56:22did my life change? Where were the moments that I
- 56:25set myself on a course I couldn't pull myself back from?
- 56:30And I love the the tension between law and grace that he
- 56:34holds the whole time. Because at the end of the film,
- 56:37you see that both of them have a role to play in his life.
- 56:41And I think the first time I watched the film, I, I
- 56:43definitely was on a like anti Brad Pitt, like he's just a bad
- 56:47dad. I think this time through you
- 56:50see a lot. I saw a lot more grace for him
- 56:53as he got older. And I actually, I need you guys
- 56:56to answer a question for me 'cause I, I realized this as you
- 56:59were talking about Terrence's personal life.
- 57:04So at the start of the film, we have the letter and the phone
- 57:09call and the brother has killed himself, died somehow overseas.
- 57:15Do we think that that's the brother with like, blonde hair,
- 57:19his younger brother? And that's like, yeah, that was
- 57:22head. That that's the younger brother.
- 57:25Yeah, because you, they're also in a new house at that point
- 57:27too. You can see that they're in a in
- 57:29a different space. And I, I would imagine it's
- 57:32probably, what about a 10 year jump into the future?
- 57:34Yeah, yeah. I mean, it is, it is the younger
- 57:37brother. And I know it's, I mean the
- 57:38youngest brother who had killed himself.
- 57:41And that is, you know, it's very amorphous, but that's the
- 57:45indication that it was him. Now, of course, by this point, I
- 57:48believe the the other brother had also died much later, years
- 57:53later. But so in in many ways, this is
- 57:57Terrence Malick remembering both his brothers, but it's
- 58:00specifically this family trauma was one that really, really
- 58:04resonated obviously, and, and, you know, one that really kind
- 58:09of affected all their, you know, relationships and, and, and
- 58:13lives afterwards. Brad, the short answer is yes,
- 58:18that was. It's a jump ahead in time.
- 58:22I, I think that the reason I asked that I, I did not pick up
- 58:25on that until now as we were talking about it, to realize
- 58:28that that was actually set ahead of where you go after that.
- 58:33The reason I say that is it, it makes a lot more sense that Sean
- 58:37Penn is now looking back at the death of his brother and
- 58:40reflecting on the years previous to that to ask these questions
- 58:44of like, who am I? Who have I been my entire life?
- 58:49Is this who I've always been? For me, the moment that has
- 58:54stuck with me both times watching the film most deeply is
- 58:58the moment where he holds his brother's finger above the BB
- 59:02gun and shoots it. For me, that is like the crux
- 59:07point of the film where he is, is he going to choose law and
- 59:14nature And you just it's the it's the survival of the fittest
- 59:19man. Like if you can't take this and
- 59:21you can't take life. And clearly his younger brother
- 59:24is a sensitive soul. Or is he going to choose the way
- 59:28of grace and his mother? And what I love about the film
- 59:32is that in the moment, he chooses the path of nature, and
- 59:36yet he feels that human sense of regret and empathy.
- 59:40And what if somebody shot me in the finger?
- 59:43And eventually he finds his brother and apologizes to him
- 59:46and tells him that he loves him. And it sets him on a different
- 59:49path once he's experienced both nature and grace.
- 59:54And I think that's such a fascinating commentary on the
- 59:57human experience. Well, I don't know if you
- 1:00:02noticed what's the music that's playing during that sequence is.
- 1:00:07It's the Lacrimosa again on the piano.
- 1:00:10Version of the Lacrimosa which and I mean those are the kinds
- 1:00:14of things I think Malik actually paid a lot of attention to
- 1:00:17because one of the things that the people I spoke to said well
- 1:00:22even about the original Q project was that he had become
- 1:00:25obsessed with the symphonic form.
- 1:00:27I think I I wrote about this a little bit, but you know, the
- 1:00:29way that music repeats in the film, I mean, it has the film
- 1:00:34kind of has a symphonic structure instead of just like a
- 1:00:37traditional narrative, you know, three act structure.
- 1:00:41You know, you've got you've got like your overture and you've
- 1:00:43got, I mean, you, you, you know, there are all these little
- 1:00:45things that that coincide with the way symphonies work.
- 1:00:49But but the way that music is repeated, you know, sort of from
- 1:00:55the first half to the second-half, I think is always
- 1:00:58kind of an interesting indication of, of where his mind
- 1:01:01is and how he sees certain scenes.
- 1:01:05But but yeah, I know that's a beautiful, I mean, it's an
- 1:01:07absolutely beautiful scene. And it is also like the kind of
- 1:01:10thing, I mean, look, I'm sure this guy has done worse things
- 1:01:13in his life. Like that's the thing.
- 1:01:14It's like you focus on these little things.
- 1:01:16And also that that scene where he that where he's, you know,
- 1:01:23literally just nice to that to that boy who has the burn marks,
- 1:01:28you know, who who he had kind of been like keeping his distance
- 1:01:32from earlier. Like I'm sure he's done nicer
- 1:01:37things in his life, but like the fact that he focuses on that,
- 1:01:40like, you know, I mean, it's just beautiful.
- 1:01:43And it's like, that's absolutely how we are as humans.
- 1:01:45That is absolutely how we are. Like, this doesn't feel petty or
- 1:01:50minor or pointless or kind of irrelevant.
- 1:01:52It's like literally he has captured just something.
- 1:01:55So the fact that he captures something so immense in this
- 1:01:59movie with its structure and with like the opening and the,
- 1:02:02you know, the closing and all that.
- 1:02:03And then in between, he finds all these like moments that feel
- 1:02:07so true to human experience. Like that's, this is like, you
- 1:02:12know, this is an extremely high degree of difficulty movie that
- 1:02:17he's working. I mean, that's the thing.
- 1:02:18That's why whenever people like, I mean, when The Tree of Life
- 1:02:21came out and for a few years afterwards, you know, whenever
- 1:02:23people did lists of best movies of the recent last 10 years,
- 1:02:26blah, blah, you know, it would always show up like #1 #2 very
- 1:02:29high up. And now recently, it's kind of
- 1:02:31like like the New York Times lists of the 100 movies, you
- 1:02:35know, the best movies of the last 25 years or whatever.
- 1:02:38It's like, I don't know, it's like 87 or something.
- 1:02:42I'm just like, you know, too low, man.
- 1:02:45Like, like that is too low. Like just sit back for a second
- 1:02:49and think back on what this movie sets out to accomplish and
- 1:02:53what it actually accomplishes. Like this is like, you know,
- 1:02:58this is like all timer stuff, you know, like it doesn't work.
- 1:03:02Like, if it doesn't, if it doesn't, like if it doesn't
- 1:03:05work, you know, that's one thing.
- 1:03:06But like, the fact that it actually works at such a such an
- 1:03:11immense level of such an immense scale of ambition, I think
- 1:03:15speaks to the achievement, you know?
- 1:03:19Too. Fascinating.
- 1:03:20We'll we'll break for whiskey here in a second.
- 1:03:22Brad, like I, I want to talk about that sequence because that
- 1:03:26kicks off. So what Brad talked about with
- 1:03:29the the BB gun or the pellet gun or whatever it is, you know, is
- 1:03:32kind of like the low point. It's the, it's him bottoming
- 1:03:35out, it's The Dark Knight of the soul.
- 1:03:37And then it immediately pivots kind of into this what builds
- 1:03:42into this sort of like phantasmagoric, like crescendo
- 1:03:46of reunification and forgiveness and reconciliation.
- 1:03:51And you see it, you know, he, he reconciles with his brother.
- 1:03:54He reconciles with the boy with the burn marks.
- 1:03:56It's just as simple as a hand on his shoulder.
- 1:03:58He reconciles with Brad Pitt and they give Brad Pitt an
- 1:04:01incredible moment in in the garden there.
- 1:04:04And we'll talk about performances in the second-half.
- 1:04:07And then and then you kind of just get like, what I love about
- 1:04:11it too, is that it doesn't end there.
- 1:04:13It could end there and get right back into the cosmic stuff.
- 1:04:17But they then they have the like, we're moving away bit
- 1:04:21where you see that like, yes, Brad Pitt did have his sort of
- 1:04:24moment of grace. And then as they're moving, he
- 1:04:28looks right back at his son again.
- 1:04:29And he's just like, what are you going to stand there like a bump
- 1:04:31on a log, put the suitcase in? Like there is an element of he
- 1:04:35is a he is a man who is struggling with his own nature.
- 1:04:38And he always will be. But even he can experience these
- 1:04:41moments of grace and sort of reunification with the way of
- 1:04:44grace. And I think that that that
- 1:04:46moment for me was even more key because it it keeps the movie
- 1:04:50from getting cloying. It keeps the movie from getting
- 1:04:52schmaltzy. And it helps build to that final
- 1:04:55point. Jessica Chastain kind of, you
- 1:04:58know, voice narrating voice over like the only way to be happy is
- 1:05:03to choose the way of grace. They you see them like burying
- 1:05:06these things in the dirt and then it it explodes into the end
- 1:05:11of the universe. Are we just revisiting God
- 1:05:14again? Sean Penn is ascending this
- 1:05:16elevator. And, you know, the way I
- 1:05:18interpret it, Brad is like, he has this sort of like, out of
- 1:05:21body transcendent experience where he finally is able to let
- 1:05:25go as Jessica Chastain does, where she finally let's go and
- 1:05:29says, like, I give my son to you.
- 1:05:31And you watch him kind of come out of that building at the end,
- 1:05:34crack a smile, movie's over. And it's like, oh, yeah, I get
- 1:05:38it. I get what's happening here.
- 1:05:40And he's done all of this in service of this dude having a
- 1:05:45midlife crisis and finally figuring out that, like, it's
- 1:05:49all gonna be OK. And it's just such a beautiful
- 1:05:52way of capturing that man. Sits down at the typewriter.
- 1:05:55Types out the tree of life, you know, end of movie.
- 1:06:02Right. Oh man.
- 1:06:03Big smile, you know? Yeah.
- 1:06:05Yeah, guys, we have talked for an hour on this movie.
- 1:06:08I think it is time for us to drink some whiskey.
- 1:06:11We have provided Bilgo with a bottle as well.
- 1:06:13So what do you say we all go try this?
- 1:06:14Glen Moringy, 10 year Brad, what do you say?
- 1:06:17Dude, I am so excited. Let's get to it.
- 1:06:25All right, so today we are checking out Glenn Moringy 10
- 1:06:29year. This is also known as Glenn
- 1:06:30Moringy the original. This is a Highland single malt
- 1:06:34Scotch, Brad. This was the first single malt
- 1:06:36Scotch I believe we ever had on the film and whiskey podcast.
- 1:06:40It might. Have been the first one that
- 1:06:41I've ever drank. I was gonna ask you the same.
- 1:06:44So, being the cheap bastards that we are, we found this sort
- 1:06:48of sample pack back in the day. Of these is that of Glenn
- 1:06:52Moringy. Does that mean we're distant
- 1:06:54cousins of Fat Bastard? Yes, yeah, yeah, yeah, OK.
- 1:06:58We come from the cheap side of things, but it, it contained 4
- 1:07:01samples of Glenn Moringy and at the time Brad and I had
- 1:07:05absolutely no facility in the the world of Scotch.
- 1:07:07And so it was like this is a pretty low barrier to entry for
- 1:07:11trying these scotches. And so we started with the
- 1:07:14original. Now at the time this was a 10
- 1:07:16year age stated whiskey. It is now Brad, I've discovered
- 1:07:20they've rebranded it and it's a minimum of 12 years.
- 1:07:23So it's 12 year Age stated. Now, I wanted to try to find a
- 1:07:26bottle of the 10 year to send to Bilga to sip alongside us, which
- 1:07:30made it pretty difficult 'cause I had to find a liquor store
- 1:07:32that still had the old bottles in stock.
- 1:07:34So yeah, Bilga, I believe you got the 10 year version.
- 1:07:38I wanted to ask you. All right, there you go.
- 1:07:41First of all, Bilga, have you ever had Glen Moringy?
- 1:07:44And beyond that, what is your experience in the world of
- 1:07:48Scotch? So I don't know if I've ever had
- 1:07:51Glenmorne G It's possible I have I'm, I'm, I'm more of a bourbon
- 1:07:57person these days than a Scotch person.
- 1:07:59Like it's actually been a while since I've had Scotch, single
- 1:08:01malt or otherwise. I mean, you know, it's
- 1:08:07delicious, but if I, if I, if I were going to try and like
- 1:08:12analyze the taste, I'm not sure I, I would have the words for
- 1:08:16it. But but yeah, I'm, I used to, I
- 1:08:18used to enjoy cinema Mont Scotch, you know, years ago, but
- 1:08:23along the way I became like a bourbon person.
- 1:08:25So now when I taste Scotch, it's kind of like, oh, wow, that's
- 1:08:28it's not the same thing, you know, like it like in my mind
- 1:08:32it's different. It's all whiskey and it's like
- 1:08:34no, no, no, no it isn't. Right.
- 1:08:38But no, this is. I want you to know that this is
- 1:08:40this is how we all feel when we talk about movies with you.
- 1:08:43You, you think you may not have the words about whiskey, but,
- 1:08:46you know, talking about movies with you, it's like, yeah, I
- 1:08:49think Oppenheimer's good. And then Bill is like, yeah, I
- 1:08:51was talking to Chris Nolan about it last week.
- 1:08:53It's like, OK, alright. I guess you got me beat there.
- 1:08:56So Brad, this is a single malt Scotch whiskey.
- 1:08:59I, I know sometimes we get away from giving definitions.
- 1:09:02So when you see single malt on a label, that word malt means that
- 1:09:07it is made entirely from barley. If it was made with a blend of
- 1:09:10grains, it would be called grain whiskey.
- 1:09:12And that word single means that it comes from one single
- 1:09:15distillery. A lot of Scotch that you'll find
- 1:09:18is actually a product of multiple distilleries that are
- 1:09:21blended together. So that's why when you pick up a
- 1:09:23bottle of Cutty Sark, it'll say like blended Scotch whiskey
- 1:09:27instead of single malt. So.
- 1:09:31Cutty Sark is some good $20. Listen, if you only have $17.00
- 1:09:36to spend Cutty Sark, you could do a hell of a lot worse, man.
- 1:09:39Cutty Sark is a is a is an important an important movie
- 1:09:43whiskey. It is.
- 1:09:45This is true. You know, Goodfellas and
- 1:09:48everything, it's it's show like that.
- 1:09:49That's the movie that I believe in.
- 1:09:53On Raging Bull there was some line about Cutty Sark and Martin
- 1:10:01Scorsese. They they were trying to get the
- 1:10:03line clear in post, like just get a clear edit of the, of the
- 1:10:08dialogue and the line about Cutty Sark and, and, and it's
- 1:10:13like the movie, like the like the movie had to come out right.
- 1:10:16They they were running out of time and Martin Scorsese was
- 1:10:19like, we have to get this right. And they're like, no, we don't
- 1:10:21have time, which he has to go out the way it is.
- 1:10:23And he's like, I want my name off the picture.
- 1:10:25Like like he tried to have his name removed.
- 1:10:28Over Cutty Sark. Over a Cutty Sark line.
- 1:10:31So Cutty Sark is an. That's a man of the people,
- 1:10:33yeah. Gets a Nero back in here.
- 1:10:36We need him to record 2 words. Yeah, but but yeah, no, sorry.
- 1:10:41Keep going. I interrupted you.
- 1:10:43No, Bill got I, I think this is actually the first time you're
- 1:10:45going to sip alongside us. So we'll, we'll set some ground
- 1:10:47rules here. The way we typically do this is
- 1:10:49we review across a number of categories.
- 1:10:51So nose, taste, finish, balance, and then value.
- 1:10:56Now when we get to the balance, we're essentially asking like,
- 1:10:59was this a consistent experience or was there something like the
- 1:11:02nose was good, but then the taste sucked.
- 1:11:04You know, that'll affect the score of that.
- 1:11:05So as we get into this, you know there are no wrong answers
- 1:11:09because as we know, all nosing notes are complete BS Brad, what
- 1:11:13are you picking up on the nose of this?
- 1:11:15Glenn Moringy here. Bullshit, Bob.
- 1:11:17Lots of bullshit. I'm getting whiffs of it today
- 1:11:21man. Oh my gosh, I this is honey.
- 1:11:27It's a little bit of apricot. There is just like a tiny bit of
- 1:11:33salinity to it. I think that this is just a
- 1:11:36really beautiful classic. Glenn Moringy like it.
- 1:11:42If you had to point to like a baseline for their brand, it
- 1:11:45makes sense that it's this. I, I think this is a really
- 1:11:49beautiful Scotch. I, I, I, I love Scotch Bilga.
- 1:11:54It is like if I'm going to spend my own money on something and
- 1:11:57not get a free sample, I'm going to send it, spend it on Scotch.
- 1:12:01And it's because of stuff like this.
- 1:12:02So I I personally am at like probably an 8 out of 10 here on
- 1:12:06the nose. Yeah, I'm going to give it an 8
- 1:12:09as well, Brad. And I'm picking up a lot of that
- 1:12:11fruit character that you're getting on this.
- 1:12:13Usually when we drink Scotch it, it comes from three regions.
- 1:12:17Typically there's 5 Scotch producing regions.
- 1:12:19But the space side region we have found is like the most
- 1:12:24delicate. There's lots of floral notes,
- 1:12:26really soft fruit notes on that. And then you've got your Isla
- 1:12:29scotches, which is where like the heavy PD stuff is is made.
- 1:12:33And Highland I find to be kind of right in the middle of those.
- 1:12:36It's great for first time Scotch drinkers because it gives you a
- 1:12:39little bit of the lay of the land.
- 1:12:41It it has a little bit more spice, it's often a little bit
- 1:12:44more alcohol forward, but it still has on the nose a ton of
- 1:12:48that fruit character. I'm getting a a bunch of lemon
- 1:12:50zest on this one, Brad. It's coming through a little bit
- 1:12:52more citrusy for me, but I cannot wait to dive into this
- 1:12:56thing. I'm in an 8 out of 10.
- 1:13:00Bug. How you feeling?
- 1:13:01I totally get what you mean about the, you know, the fruity
- 1:13:06smell. Is that the word you smell?
- 1:13:08Yeah. That's good, man.
- 1:13:09Is that correct? No, I, I, I, I'm not I, I do
- 1:13:14totally get it. You know, again, I, I, I don't,
- 1:13:17you know, not having kind of done even this process before, I
- 1:13:21don't know what I would smell if I tried something else, but but
- 1:13:24I definitely, I can Like everything you you described
- 1:13:28actually feels very spot on, like as you described.
- 1:13:30Oh yeah, yeah, I can smell that. Yeah.
- 1:13:32And I think that that's a sign of of something that's a little
- 1:13:35bit more complex, right, Even though it's a this is not an
- 1:13:38expensive whiskey when you're talking single malt Scotch.
- 1:13:40But if you can find all of those notes just on the nose of it,
- 1:13:44like you're a bourbon drinker, like vanilla is all over
- 1:13:48bourbon. And if that's the only note
- 1:13:49you're getting, you pretty much know like this is this is a one
- 1:13:51note bourbon. I know what I'm expecting here.
- 1:13:53This is much more layered than that, Brad.
- 1:13:55And I get the same thing on the palate here.
- 1:13:58I do get a bit of vanilla, but it's definitely like a not quite
- 1:14:02lemon meringue, like some sort of a lemon bar for me.
- 1:14:04There is a bit of honey to it, but it has like a shortbread
- 1:14:07type quality. It's really like fatty and
- 1:14:10buttery. And then when you kick it to the
- 1:14:12back of your palate, it does get that sort of like Scotch
- 1:14:15bitterness to it. Not burnt, not ashy, but it tips
- 1:14:19just bitter enough that it brings some of that kind of like
- 1:14:22herbal vegetal notes to it. Really, really good, man.
- 1:14:25I'm going to give it an 8 once again.
- 1:14:27I'm going to jump up to an 8 1/2.
- 1:14:29I, I haven't had this tenure in a very long time.
- 1:14:33And it, it is that balance of honey and lemon meringue is the
- 1:14:39most perfect note for that initial burst of flavor.
- 1:14:43And then the lemon kind of turns into a very tart, like almost
- 1:14:48like a fair lemonade that like, yes, it's sugary, but it
- 1:14:52actually tastes like lemon as well.
- 1:14:55And mixed with that vegetable bitterness at the end that is
- 1:15:01just medicinal and beautiful. And I, I'm at an 8 1/2.
- 1:15:06I think it's so freaking good. Yeah, Bill, I'm interested to
- 1:15:10hear, you know, being a bourbon guy like this is definitely out
- 1:15:14of that flavor profile, like completely out of that flavor
- 1:15:17profile. And it's, you know, it's corn
- 1:15:19versus barley. Like it's just two completely
- 1:15:20different grains that are being used here.
- 1:15:22But I'm sure you can pick up on some of what we're talking
- 1:15:25about, especially on that back half of the pallet.
- 1:15:29Yeah, absolutely. I mean, for me, you know, am I,
- 1:15:33I've never been a, a, a refined drinker.
- 1:15:36So like, I mean, occasionally when I would drink a single
- 1:15:39malt, I, I, I always enjoyed it. But the thing that the thing
- 1:15:42about, you know, the thing about Scotch that kind of pushed me
- 1:15:46away was actually the, the, the blended flavors.
- 1:15:49Like there is, there's a kind of mealiness to them.
- 1:15:53You know that, I mean, I'm sure this is, I'm sure there's a
- 1:15:57more, you know, effective way to describe it, but there's a kind
- 1:16:01of really, I mean the, the thing I always say, I mean, I, I
- 1:16:04enjoyed them. It's not like I won't drink
- 1:16:05them. I, I do like them, but there is
- 1:16:07a kind of like, I feel like somebody already drank this, you
- 1:16:10know, like, like, like I feel like somebody already drank this
- 1:16:12and I'm just drinking what they just drank.
- 1:16:15Like not, not. Getting a note of backwash.
- 1:16:17Yeah, that's exactly I'm. Like I feel like I I feel like I
- 1:16:19drank something that has already been drunk.
- 1:16:22I think that might be the the centuries of English oppression,
- 1:16:26just just. It's just really percolating
- 1:16:30feels I feel like. Yes, yeah, I'm drinking and I, I
- 1:16:32feel exploited. I feel I feel exploited and
- 1:16:39invaded. Yeah.
- 1:16:42On the finish here, like again, this is I think the low point
- 1:16:45for me because it does turn bitter and you don't get any
- 1:16:47sort of real lingering fruit for me.
- 1:16:50The barley is super heavy here and it's it's just a little bit
- 1:16:52too like herbaceous vegetal for me.
- 1:16:55I'm gonna give it a 7 out of 10 and I think I'm being just a tad
- 1:16:58generous there too. But this is definitely the
- 1:17:00lowest point of the experience for me.
- 1:17:02Yeah, I'm at a 7 out of 10 as well.
- 1:17:04It it falls off a little bit, doesn't fall off a Cliff or
- 1:17:07anything, but all of the flavor is packed into the nose and the
- 1:17:11front end of the palate, and it definitely falls into that
- 1:17:14vegetal area on the finish. I'm fine with it.
- 1:17:18I like it. It's not quite at the heights
- 1:17:21that it had been at. So yeah, 7 out of 10 for me
- 1:17:23here. It's really where the oppression
- 1:17:25starts to come across. I think, you know, I'm I'm
- 1:17:27really, I'm finally picking up those notes here.
- 1:17:31Yeah. I mean, I, I do, I do think that
- 1:17:33the, the experience is, is a lot better when you first drink it
- 1:17:37than sort of afterwards. For sure.
- 1:17:40I that I realize that's a very inarticulate way of putting.
- 1:17:43No, no, I mean, I think that's, that is a perfect segue into our
- 1:17:46balance category here because I don't think, you know, if, if
- 1:17:50all three categories were an 8 out of 10, I actually think my
- 1:17:53balance score would be higher than that because you get marks
- 1:17:55for something being consistently good.
- 1:17:58So I think I'm going to come down to about a 7 again on this,
- 1:18:00Brad, because there was such a fall off on the finish for me
- 1:18:04here. I think that's fair.
- 1:18:07I I for me the movement from like the sweet into the
- 1:18:13herbaceous is smooth and I enjoy it all the way throughout so
- 1:18:18I'll I'll give it a 7 1/2 here. I would agree though this is not
- 1:18:21like a stand out experience of single malt well balanced
- 1:18:27whiskey. Sure.
- 1:18:30Well, that gets us into our value category.
- 1:18:32So I don't know what is this currently retailing for around
- 1:18:35us, Brad? That is a great question.
- 1:18:37I man, I feel like it's got to be in the $50 range.
- 1:18:44It's, I mean, I can tell you what it cost.
- 1:18:46You know, in Bilga's neck of the woods, it was about $50 there.
- 1:18:48So I think that's a good baseline for us.
- 1:18:50To I was gonna say, I was gonna say I got it for free.
- 1:18:53So it's a great value because he bought it and mailed it to.
- 1:18:58Me 399. Yeah, I think at $50, this is
- 1:19:02still a really great value, Brad.
- 1:19:04There's only a couple single malts that I can even think of
- 1:19:07that would be approaching this age statement at this price
- 1:19:11point. Like, you know, and I hate to be
- 1:19:13like, oh, it's the only 1, so it's a great value.
- 1:19:15But I think this is a well above average single malt Scotch.
- 1:19:20It's 10 years old. I'm bad news gonna I'm gonna
- 1:19:24give you some great news. This bad boy in God's chosen
- 1:19:28state of Ohio is 2999. Are they trying to liquidate it
- 1:19:35though to get rid of the 10 year stock it is?
- 1:19:4030 bucks man. It doesn't say anything about
- 1:19:42the liquidation or last call 30. Dollars, Donald Trump,
- 1:19:48Liberation Day. The tariffs are working.
- 1:19:51Yeah, boy. Listen, at at 30 bucks, this is
- 1:19:57a no brainer. Even at 50, I was going to give
- 1:19:59this like an 8. So if it's any less than 50, I'm
- 1:20:02just going to go right ahead and bump it up to a 10 out of 10,
- 1:20:04Brad. That's a, that's a, that is a
- 1:20:06really good price. That's that's shocking. 30 bucks
- 1:20:09for a bottle of this hooch I am in.
- 1:20:13This is a 10 out of freaking 10 value Bob.
- 1:20:17Yeah, man. And that and that brings me out
- 1:20:19to a 40 out of 50 on this. Now for some context, 35 out of
- 1:20:2350 is usually where we start recommending like you should try
- 1:20:26a pour of this at the bar or consider buying a bottle. 40 and
- 1:20:29above is usually this is a no brainer and I think the value
- 1:20:33score definitely helps this one a bit.
- 1:20:35But if you're looking to break into the world of single malt
- 1:20:38Scotch, there really is no lower price point that you can get
- 1:20:42entry into this world. And it's a darn good whiskey.
- 1:20:45So I think my 40 is well earned here.
- 1:20:48Yeah. And and I'd imagine so I'm
- 1:20:50coming out to a 41 out of 50. I, I am with you.
- 1:20:53I did not expect going into this to give it that high of a score.
- 1:20:58And even they're like I was at a 31 out of 40 just on the the
- 1:21:02taste categories, right? So like this is a 7 and a half
- 1:21:06eight out of 10 type of whiskey that if you're paying 30 bucks
- 1:21:10for it, even Bob, I'd imagine the 50 bucks was, you know, 50 a
- 1:21:15little shipping this and that. Even at 50 bucks, I think this
- 1:21:18is a good value guys, if you're looking to break into the world
- 1:21:22of Scotch, if you're tired of your chasing after bourbon and
- 1:21:28and always trying to find that perfect pinnacle of is it over
- 1:21:32oaked or not oaked enough, Come on over to Scotland boys.
- 1:21:37We we got a drink for ya. It's $30, It's Glenmore in G10,
- 1:21:41and it's freaking delicious. What better whiskey to pair with
- 1:21:46the creation and destruction of the Cosmos brat than Glenmore in
- 1:21:50G10? Yeah, I mean, isn't that what's
- 1:21:52the, the original, the the, the original word for whiskey and
- 1:22:00and like Irish or Gaelic, whatever it is.
- 1:22:02Yeah, it's the water of life. Water of Life.
- 1:22:05There you go. Wow.
- 1:22:06OK, there you go. The tree of life with the water
- 1:22:09of life. I love it.
- 1:22:10Brad, thank you for drawing a connection that I somehow didn't
- 1:22:13see. If you water the tree of life
- 1:22:15with the water of life, it will die.
- 1:22:19This is true. Thank you for attending Botany
- 1:22:23Corner with Bill Gibiri this week, folks.
- 1:22:26Don't pour whiskey on your trees.
- 1:22:29That brings us to an 81 out of 100 or a 40.5.
- 1:22:32On average. Folks go out and get a bottle of
- 1:22:35Glen Moringy 10. Fellas, what do you say we get
- 1:22:37back into talking about the Tree of Life?
- 1:22:39Let's do it. All right, everybody.
- 1:22:46That was Glen Moringy 10A whiskey that I forgot how good
- 1:22:52it was. Bob, I'm so glad.
- 1:22:55It definitely directed me towards the way of grace, Brad,
- 1:22:57let's just say it that way. Hey, hey, Glory.
- 1:23:03Well guys, I was so excited to have Bilga here to talk about
- 1:23:07the Tree of Life today that I was like, forget 2 facts and a
- 1:23:11falsehood. We don't need to waste our time
- 1:23:13on Canada's favorite segment. We need to talk about the Tree
- 1:23:15of Life more. And with that being in mind, I
- 1:23:19am fascinated to hear what you guys have to say.
- 1:23:23No, hold on, I need to lay down something here.
- 1:23:25If we're not doing 2 facts in a falsehood, do I get an automatic
- 1:23:30victory? Are we counting that as a win
- 1:23:31for me? The way of grace, Bob, it's all
- 1:23:33yours. Yes, thank you, Terrence Malick.
- 1:23:39I appreciate it. Oh.
- 1:23:41Man, I am fascinated to keep you guys.
- 1:23:45I I'm sorry, I just wanted to say Bilga keeps his spotless
- 1:23:48record in 2 facts in a falsehood alive.
- 1:23:51I think it is 3 and O now. So there you go.
- 1:23:53That is important. We have some guests that do Bob
- 1:23:56dirty. They do, Bill.
- 1:23:59Bill's still gonna keep getting whiskey sent to him in the mail,
- 1:24:01so thank you for that. Yeah, Bob is very judicious in
- 1:24:06who he sends his whiskey to. I want to know what you guys
- 1:24:12have to say about Chastain, about Brad Pitt.
- 1:24:17I like, we, we've talked about Malik, we've talked about the
- 1:24:21movie itself, the music, the direction of, you know, we
- 1:24:25didn't talk a ton about the style of filmmaking, about the
- 1:24:28cinematography, which is bonkers good.
- 1:24:32But I, I, I don't feel like I can get out of here without
- 1:24:36talking about how impressed I am with Brad Pitt and Jessica
- 1:24:41Chastain in addition to the child actors.
- 1:24:44But I'm, I'm going to let you guys kind of lead the lead the
- 1:24:47role here 'cause I want to hear what you guys have to say.
- 1:24:51I think maybe let me let me throw out my hottest take and
- 1:24:56that that can be our starting point here.
- 1:24:59I honestly think this might be the best Brad Pitt has ever been
- 1:25:04in a movie. And I think the reason it
- 1:25:07doesn't get discussed amongst his best performances is because
- 1:25:12his character in particular, I don't want to say suffers, but
- 1:25:17like the characterization of him, all of his resolution is
- 1:25:21tacked onto the front of the movie.
- 1:25:24And so you only really see him being this hardened guy
- 1:25:27throughout the rest of the film. And so it doesn't seem like he
- 1:25:29brings a lot of shades to the character.
- 1:25:33But that's why that garden scene towards the end of the film
- 1:25:36stuck with me so much because you get Pitt has always been
- 1:25:40really good at playing men who struggle to process feelings.
- 1:25:45Like we talked about it in Moneyball.
- 1:25:46I think he's just really good at at kind of suppressing emotion
- 1:25:49and letting that come through the cracks a bit.
- 1:25:51And he's always been to some extent, just a very weird actor.
- 1:25:55Brad, like, because he's Brad Pitt, I think he gets away with
- 1:25:59some of the very strange choices he makes in terms of his line
- 1:26:02readings and the constant eating and things he does with his
- 1:26:05mouth, and he's just a strange actor, but he's so.
- 1:26:09Beautiful. He just gets away with it.
- 1:26:11You don't care, Right? Exactly.
- 1:26:14And here I think it works maybe to its fullest extent.
- 1:26:17And you get it in that garden sequence of him finally, like
- 1:26:21embracing his son and having emotion and calling him my sweet
- 1:26:25boy. And then as they break the
- 1:26:27embrace, he doesn't know what else to do except shake his
- 1:26:29son's hand. And it's it's almost funny.
- 1:26:32And he realizes it as he walks away and stops and turns and
- 1:26:38realizes that something within him will not allow himself to
- 1:26:42say anything else on the matter. And then he turns away again.
- 1:26:46And it's just like, it's both beautiful because he, you know,
- 1:26:49he did the best he could and also crushing at the same time.
- 1:26:55And I just can't imagine anybody but Pitt in this.
- 1:26:58Role. I think that it is the epitome
- 1:27:03of showing one of the most important things we can do as
- 1:27:11humans is tell the truth in love.
- 1:27:16And I think the way Malik visualizes an entire generation
- 1:27:24of men is so honoring in the way he he illustrates them with
- 1:27:33truth and love. He like, he's not shying away
- 1:27:38from the bullshit that Brad Pitt's character puts upon his
- 1:27:44children. And yet you see why he does it.
- 1:27:49You see where he came from You, you understand who he is.
- 1:27:54And like you just said, Bob like as much as he is allowed to do
- 1:27:59based on the culture he grew up in and his his parents
- 1:28:03generation, like as much as he can show love, he does.
- 1:28:07And even at the end of the film, you know, like Jack is the
- 1:28:12child, the main character, right?
- 1:28:14Jack basically says to him like Dad, it's your house.
- 1:28:18Like, he almost like enforces what the dad has been saying
- 1:28:26this whole time of like, my authority is the authority.
- 1:28:30And even the main character at the end is like, yeah, dad, this
- 1:28:32is your house. And there's just this beautiful
- 1:28:36wrestling with the fact that man, oh, man, he sucks.
- 1:28:41But he knows that he sucks. And he tries his best to show
- 1:28:44love to his children. And he's restricted by so many
- 1:28:48things and it leads to some good outcomes and some bad outcomes
- 1:28:53in the long term life that we see in Sean Penn as as an older
- 1:28:57man. And I just think that Pitt
- 1:29:01captures all of that so well. And I would be so fascinated to
- 1:29:06hear like a very intimate long form interview with Pitt to hear
- 1:29:11about his experience working on the film because Malik pulls so
- 1:29:16much out of him. Yeah, I mean, it's it is a great
- 1:29:21performance. I mean, this is also the year
- 1:29:26that he had Moneyball, which I think is actually probably his
- 1:29:29best performance. But but still like this, you
- 1:29:32know, this is I mean, this is the one that's most precious to
- 1:29:35me. You know, I was I was talking to
- 1:29:39somebody else about this the other day.
- 1:29:42I mean, Terrence Malick movies have prompt such strange
- 1:29:46reactions. I mean, Tree of Life was a film
- 1:29:49that was widely beloved and it was kind of his first film that
- 1:29:53that really was widely beloved in a while.
- 1:29:57Because I mean, I remember when The Thin Red Line first came
- 1:30:00out. I mean, it did it did was like
- 1:30:03nominated for some Oscars and won some critics awards.
- 1:30:05And there were some very good reviews.
- 1:30:07And a lot of us were like, this is the best movie of the year.
- 1:30:09But it was a very divisive movie, especially since it had
- 1:30:13come out the year the same year as Saving Private Ryan.
- 1:30:15And it was such a kind of it was like the exact opposite of
- 1:30:18Saving Private Ryan in so many ways.
- 1:30:21But it was a really divisive movie, especially among critics.
- 1:30:23Like people like, like I always say, I mean, you know, I called
- 1:30:27it the Malek Wars. And every time he made a new
- 1:30:30movie, it sort of flared up. But the, the thing that I was
- 1:30:35talking to this person about was so I remember when the new world
- 1:30:39came out, the new world was, I mean, Thin Red Line was
- 1:30:43divisive, but largely got good reviews.
- 1:30:46The new world was much more divisive.
- 1:30:49And I went to, I'd seen it already, but you know, before it
- 1:30:53went into wide release that there was a kind of an all media
- 1:30:57press screening where you go to a theater and it's like critics,
- 1:30:59but it's also, you know, people who won like radio contests and
- 1:31:02stuff like that. And they fill up the, the, the
- 1:31:04room and, and, and these people hated the new world, Like they
- 1:31:09hated it. I mean, you could just, and I
- 1:31:12love the new world, but you know, I can recognize it's not
- 1:31:16an easy film to love. For a lot of you could read the
- 1:31:18room. Yeah, I know and I remember and
- 1:31:20I will always tell people about this.
- 1:31:22I remember walking out and sort of the the area, not the lobby,
- 1:31:26but the area right outside the theater out, you know, 'cause I
- 1:31:28most theaters have like 2 doors. So people are coming out if you
- 1:31:31there are like trash cans there. And I saw this group of women
- 1:31:38come out on one end and another group of women come out on the
- 1:31:40other end and they're all kind of laughing and they all stop
- 1:31:45and they all point to each other and they go, did you hate that
- 1:31:48much as much as I did? And these were two totally like,
- 1:31:52these were not people who knew each other.
- 1:31:54And they were just like bonding, total strangers bonding over how
- 1:31:59much they fucking hated the new world.
- 1:32:04So but and I was, I'm sitting there like, you know, like I
- 1:32:07don't have to talk to these people, but it is kind of fun to
- 1:32:09just be Privy to this conversation.
- 1:32:12I mean, they really hated it. And it would, you know, and then
- 1:32:15I remember I was at a party like a week after this and it was not
- 1:32:20a party where like, like wasn't I didn't like know a lot of
- 1:32:22people there. And somebody came up to me.
- 1:32:24This woman came up to me and she was not, you know, she was not
- 1:32:27somebody who who knew that I was a film critic or anything or
- 1:32:31that I had seen this movie or that I had liked this movie.
- 1:32:35And she comes up to me. I just saw this movie called The
- 1:32:38New World. It is the worst piece of shit
- 1:32:40I've ever seen. Have you seen it?
- 1:32:43And I was like, yeah, I have actually.
- 1:32:44I'm like, but like, she just started going off on how much
- 1:32:48she hated. And I tried to defend the movie
- 1:32:49and it's just like, really awkward.
- 1:32:51And, you know, never, I have not seen that person since.
- 1:32:54But it was just such a weird random interaction at a party.
- 1:32:59So a few years later, you know, the, The Tree of Life comes out
- 1:33:05and, and I'm walking down the street and I've seen the Tree of
- 1:33:08Life at this point, you know, I mean, I've seen it it for its
- 1:33:11press screenings and all that. I've seen it a couple of times.
- 1:33:13And now it's actually out in theaters.
- 1:33:16I'm walking down the street in Brooklyn right by Prospect Park,
- 1:33:21and this guy comes up to me. Not a person I've ever met in my
- 1:33:24life, not a person who knows me. Older gentleman, like
- 1:33:29significantly older than me, you know, probably, probably crazy
- 1:33:33on some level, I don't know. But like comes up to me and he
- 1:33:37goes. I just saw a movie called The
- 1:33:39Tree of Life and you know, it just like completely rocked my
- 1:33:45world and I suddenly realized I could like, I understood my
- 1:33:50father so much better. This guy, it's like random
- 1:33:54person, I have no idea who this person was, just came up to me
- 1:33:56in fucking Brooklyn and just started talking to me about the
- 1:33:59Tree of life, my favorite movie of the year.
- 1:34:02So two things like the, you know, the, the, the, the new
- 1:34:05world reaction, the, the random strange people who just kind of
- 1:34:09have to just blurt out into the, into the universe that they
- 1:34:12hated the new world, that that reaction.
- 1:34:14And then the tree of life reaction, people who just have
- 1:34:17to blurt out into the world that they love this thing.
- 1:34:20I actually think it's kind of the same response, you know,
- 1:34:25like, like it's the same, like it's like he's touching the same
- 1:34:28thing only in one from what? Because of the nature of the
- 1:34:33movie, the nature of the story or whatever, you know, the
- 1:34:37person responds and just like recoils from it, like, Oh my
- 1:34:40God, this is so fucking corny. Like how can I can't do this?
- 1:34:43Like this is, Oh my God, horrible, horrible.
- 1:34:45Anybody else seeing this? Do you all agree with me that
- 1:34:47this is terrible? You know, and then in the other
- 1:34:50and then the other one is just like actually kind of the same
- 1:34:53thing. This is so raw on some level and
- 1:34:55so just like not the kind of thing you would see in a movie.
- 1:35:00So I can't just watch it and process it and be like, Oh yeah,
- 1:35:02that was nice. I'd like have to just go find
- 1:35:05the a random person on the street and yell at them about
- 1:35:08like what this film did to me. I actually think it's kind of
- 1:35:11the same response, but but I do think that there is something, I
- 1:35:15mean, the fact that this was an older person who claimed and
- 1:35:18there were critics who said, like I remember Lou Luminik of
- 1:35:20the New York Post, who I don't think was a Malik fan.
- 1:35:23Like I can't imagine Lou be having been a big thin Red line
- 1:35:26fan. He was a very sort of meat and
- 1:35:28potatoes film review. He's still around and he's
- 1:35:30retired from film criticism. Really nice guy actually.
- 1:35:33But he talked about how this film and he was he was quite a
- 1:35:36bit older than me, but he talked about how this film really kind
- 1:35:39of resonated with him because it sort of made him think about his
- 1:35:42own father. And, and I think he even said,
- 1:35:44you know, this is the kind of film that really does sort of
- 1:35:48connect to a whole generation of men.
- 1:35:52So I mean, I, you know, like there is absolutely something
- 1:35:57there. And I think Brad Pitt's
- 1:35:59performance really connects to that.
- 1:36:02And I, and I think probably Brad Pitt on some level understood
- 1:36:05this as well. You know, I, I know nothing
- 1:36:10about his family. Like, I don't know, I don't know
- 1:36:13what his parents were like or anything like that.
- 1:36:15But but I do think that there's probably something in that
- 1:36:19portrayal that probably connects to something that that he
- 1:36:23himself recognized as as a younger person.
- 1:36:26And you know what I mean? It's what's sad is, I mean, Brad
- 1:36:29Pitt's life has exploded in so many ways since then with, you
- 1:36:33know, his divorce from Angelina Jolie and his kids like changing
- 1:36:37their last names and stuff. I mean, you know, he's, you
- 1:36:41know, he's, he's, you know, he's gone through some bad times and,
- 1:36:45and done some bad things. But, but I do think that there
- 1:36:47is, I mean, there's also this, you know, this, this strain.
- 1:36:53I mean, we can call it toxic masculinity.
- 1:36:54We can call it all sorts of, you know, Twitter friendly catch
- 1:36:58phrases. But there is like, it's just,
- 1:37:00it's, it's just a thing that runs in the heart of people.
- 1:37:03And it is carried on among men, among among women, too.
- 1:37:08Like it is something that's just, it's, I mean, it's, you
- 1:37:10know, the way of nature and the way of grace actually kind of
- 1:37:13explains it in a fascinating way.
- 1:37:15You know, the thin red line opens with with the lines.
- 1:37:19What's this war in the heart of nature?
- 1:37:21Why does nature vie with itself, the land, contend with the sea,
- 1:37:25You know, and then it says, is there an avenging power in
- 1:37:27nature? Like, I mean, it's these
- 1:37:29soldiers kind of having these ruminations about, you know,
- 1:37:33the, the, the peace that they feel kind of, I mean, especially
- 1:37:37in the opening of that film, it's, you know, these two
- 1:37:39soldiers who've gone AWOL among a a, a village of natives on
- 1:37:45Guadalcanal. And they've like, it's like they
- 1:37:47found Eden almost right, which is a very Malik thing, like the
- 1:37:52Eden and then losing it is, is like kind of structurally in all
- 1:37:56his films on some level. But but the fact that they found
- 1:38:00peace, but within that peace, all they can think about is like
- 1:38:06the people at the time dismissed it as, oh, soldiers wondering
- 1:38:09what is war. But that's not what they're
- 1:38:10saying. They're not actually saying what
- 1:38:11is war, but what they're saying is like we have we have
- 1:38:16experienced these two incredibly powerful forces that are both
- 1:38:22all around us in just like the the gorgeousness of this place
- 1:38:25that we're in and just the absolute fucking horror that's
- 1:38:29being wreaked on it and also within us.
- 1:38:32And you know that that through line carries through all the
- 1:38:36films. And I obviously I think it's it
- 1:38:38finds it's sort of purest and most kind of expansive
- 1:38:42expression in the tree of life. But but it is, it's there in in
- 1:38:46all the films. And it is something that he's
- 1:38:48clearly reckoning with and not reckoning it with because he was
- 1:38:53like a soldier, but reckoning it with because he went through the
- 1:38:55war of growing up, right? He went through the combat of
- 1:39:00being brought up as a boomer in in Bartlesville, OK, and Waco,
- 1:39:05TX, you know, and I think that there's there's something there
- 1:39:08and, you know, he captures it. Pit captures it.
- 1:39:11And I mean, just like a Chastain we can talk about too.
- 1:39:13She's fantastic. But you know, I've I've
- 1:39:15monologued enough. Blame it on the Glenmore, Angie.
- 1:39:21Yeah, I know, right? I want to ask you real quick,
- 1:39:23Brad. And we can't talk about
- 1:39:24Chastain. And I think Chastain's really
- 1:39:26good in this movie, but you know, she has an incredible run
- 1:39:29throughout 20/11/2012. She had made a ton of movies.
- 1:39:32A lot of them kind of got sat on and then they all got released
- 1:39:36in 2011. I think she had at least 6
- 1:39:38movies come out, but like Take Shelter, she did Coriolanus,
- 1:39:43Tree of Life, and The Help all came out in 2011.
- 1:39:46Then the next year she was in kind of a blockbuster called
- 1:39:49Lawless and she was in Zero Dark 30.
- 1:39:52So between the beginning of 2011 and the end of 2012, she is just
- 1:39:55immediately catapulted to like, mega stardom.
- 1:39:59And she didn't get quite good here.
- 1:40:00She didn't get caught holding the leash, so she's she's Scott
- 1:40:04Freeman. There you go man, I always have
- 1:40:07to make a reference to that one particular line in 0.
- 1:40:10That is a memorable line, Bob. Dude, if I can, if I can quickly
- 1:40:15pivot to something 'cause I've been thinking about this most of
- 1:40:19the episode and it was not on my radar before, but my perhaps my
- 1:40:24least favorite Christopher Nolan film is Interstellar.
- 1:40:29And I don't think that it is his worst film, but I think it's my
- 1:40:33least favorite of his. And I have just never been able
- 1:40:37to get over the hump of the Anne Hathaway, the universe is tied
- 1:40:40together by love monologue. It's just it's never ever worked
- 1:40:44for me. And I realized watching the Tree
- 1:40:48of Life this time that that is essentially the same argument
- 1:40:50that Terrence Malick is making at the end of this film.
- 1:40:52Like Jessica Chastain's final, final lines in this movie, aside
- 1:40:56from, like, I, I give my son to you is when she's talking in
- 1:41:00voice over about like, you know, the way to be happy is to love
- 1:41:04everybody and choose to love everything.
- 1:41:07And it's like, wow, this is really as simple as this thesis
- 1:41:10ultimately ends up being. And I don't know of another
- 1:41:13movie that tries to make a similar argument on such an
- 1:41:15audacious level as Interstellar does.
- 1:41:18You know, they're both making these very small pleas for love
- 1:41:23spread across the universe. And Brad, I know that
- 1:41:26Interstellar works for you a lot better than for me.
- 1:41:28I'd like to hear you just very quickly, like, do I mean, a, do
- 1:41:33you think that they are the same argument being made?
- 1:41:35But why? Why is it that you think that
- 1:41:38one seems to work better than the other, at least to some
- 1:41:41extent? Man, I mean, I think both films
- 1:41:43capture that idea in scripture of like he has hidden eternity
- 1:41:49in their hearts, that like humanity has this picture of the
- 1:41:53cosmos hidden within us. And for some reason it feels
- 1:41:59like love is the thing that unlocks the secrets of eternity
- 1:42:04throughout all of human history. Like you can go across all
- 1:42:08cultures, all poets, all, you know, people who make art from
- 1:42:12all anywhere in human history. And it seems like love is one of
- 1:42:16those key things. I think the reason it works
- 1:42:19better in Malik versus a Nolan film is that Nolan is trying to
- 1:42:26explain things, Malik is trying to help you feel things.
- 1:42:31And I for better, for worse. Like the reason I think Nolan
- 1:42:35has become a better film maker as he's moved along is like
- 1:42:38Oppenheimer isn't necessarily trying to explain things to you.
- 1:42:43Oppenheimer is trying to help you understand and feel
- 1:42:48something in addition to explaining a few things.
- 1:42:51But just think about the exposition in Interstellar
- 1:42:55versus Oppenheimer, right? Even even like Inception versus
- 1:42:59Oppenheimer, I, I think Nolan is maturing as a director in that
- 1:43:02way. And I think that's but I, I do
- 1:43:06think that's why it works in a film like tree of life, because
- 1:43:11love isn't something that you can explain.
- 1:43:13It's not a science equation. You know, people try to explain
- 1:43:17like, oh, why does that 10 fall in love with that six?
- 1:43:22And it's like, oh, well, he must have something, you know, he
- 1:43:25makes a lot of money or this or that.
- 1:43:26It's like, right, right. Maybe, but maybe love is just
- 1:43:30weird and you can't, you can't reduce it to a formula.
- 1:43:35And maybe it is a feeling and maybe it's the beauty of your
- 1:43:39mother being a, a, a wayfish beautiful wisp of a woman who
- 1:43:45just enjoys life and floats around a tree and brings a smile
- 1:43:50to your heart. And I who knows what love is,
- 1:43:54but I feel like we experience it here with Malik in a way that I
- 1:44:01mean, you have the father's love for his daughter in
- 1:44:03Interstellar, but there's just so much that happens in between
- 1:44:06and so much explaining and it's. It's much more plot heavy for
- 1:44:09sure. Yeah, Bill, am I, am I crazy
- 1:44:12here? Is it an unfair comparison?
- 1:44:13It just, it really did remind me of that this time.
- 1:44:17I don't think it's an unfair comparison.
- 1:44:19I mean, I say this as someone who who loves Interstellar but
- 1:44:23like, I mean thank. You, Bill.
- 1:44:24No, I'm, I absolutely adore Interstellar, but it's also, I
- 1:44:28mean, I've written about it and everything, but like, you know,
- 1:44:31I wouldn't compare the two films in that.
- 1:44:34I mean, I wouldn't compare the two films as like 1.
- 1:44:36Which one's better? I mean, if I had to put a gun to
- 1:44:40my head, I would pick tree of Life 10 times out of 10.
- 1:44:42But you know, like doesn't mean I don't love Interstellar.
- 1:44:47Not very, not where, not very way of grace, though, to put a
- 1:44:51gun to someone's head and force in the picture between
- 1:44:54Interstellar and tree of Life. But I think that the the thing
- 1:45:02that both both films are getting to and you're right.
- 1:45:06I mean, Nolan does have to explain things that the thing
- 1:45:09about Interstellar is, you know, it originated as a Spielberg
- 1:45:12movie. I mean, like, Jonathan Nolan
- 1:45:14wrote the script, but it was written for Spielberg.
- 1:45:19And, and what I find fascinating about Interstellar is that it
- 1:45:22it, it does feel at times like Nolan wrestling with something
- 1:45:27that would probably have been very easy for Spielberg to do.
- 1:45:30I don't know that Spielberg would have made a great film out
- 1:45:32of Interstellar. But the parts that Nolan, like
- 1:45:35Nolan's mind works very differently from Spielberg's.
- 1:45:37And there are moments where you're like, oh, this is a
- 1:45:39Spielberg moment that Nolan is trying to turn to, to sort of
- 1:45:42wrap his head around and make his own.
- 1:45:45And I think he succeeds at it. But it is it does it.
- 1:45:47Yeah. But the two things that both
- 1:45:49films are, the thing that both films are kind of exploring and
- 1:45:53circling around is, is the idea of love as an actual force,
- 1:46:00right, As an actual power. And I think that this is
- 1:46:05something that, you know, like within sort of the religious
- 1:46:11tradition. I mean, the idea of love as
- 1:46:13something somehow both humbling, but also like that makes you
- 1:46:21capable of, of great things. Like that makes you capable of
- 1:46:27imagining, you know, the, the, the origins of the universe and
- 1:46:33also imagining the end of the universe.
- 1:46:37I mean, like, for example, you know, when we talk about
- 1:46:41religious art and you know, there was a time when pretty
- 1:46:43much all art was religious art, right?
- 1:46:45I mean, you know, if you think about the Last Supper, if you
- 1:46:52think about the, you know, the, the, the, the creation of Adam
- 1:46:56or you think about the, the, you know, the cathedrals of the
- 1:47:02Middle Ages, like how the hell did humans build this right?
- 1:47:07And there's always, you know, there's always the explanation.
- 1:47:10They, they built it because of, of, of, you know, of their fear
- 1:47:14of God or because they believed in God, which obviously, you
- 1:47:19know, the person who painted the Last Supper probably believed in
- 1:47:22God. Like I'm, I'm willing to concede
- 1:47:24them that, but I but, but, but what's really working there is
- 1:47:33love, right? I mean, you cannot create the,
- 1:47:38the creation of Adam if there isn't some incredible force of
- 1:47:43love driving you. I mean, yes, there's ambition
- 1:47:47and stuff like that, but there are a lot of people who are
- 1:47:49ambitious and there are a lot of people who are ambitious and
- 1:47:52talented. But like there's, there's like,
- 1:47:57like a small handful of people who are capable of this kind of
- 1:48:00work. And I do think that love has to
- 1:48:03play a part in that. And you know, and, and God is
- 1:48:06the connect connection there. Like, you know, you have to love
- 1:48:10something greater than yourself, I think, to be able to do work
- 1:48:14like that. And, you know, and, and Tree of
- 1:48:19Life is an expression of that. And that's the other thing about
- 1:48:20Tree of Life is that like it, it feels like it could stand
- 1:48:23alongside a great work by da Vinci or Michelangelo, you know,
- 1:48:29you know, like, like it feels like, you know, obviously it, it
- 1:48:33has scale, so it has that kind of momentousness, but it feels
- 1:48:36like it was it was created with the same sort of life force
- 1:48:41coursing through the people that made it.
- 1:48:45And and yeah, like that's, that's that's my answer, I said.
- 1:48:51That's what I guess. Yeah, No, I think that's a
- 1:48:53perfect segue into our last segment of the day, which we
- 1:48:56call Let's Make it a double. We're near the end of the
- 1:48:59episode, so thanks. Listening to the film and
- 1:49:02Whiskey Show, let's have another film with this one, even if it's
- 1:49:05struggling. It's the final segment of the
- 1:49:07day. Now let's make it a double.
- 1:49:08Let's Make It a Double is the part of the show where we pick a
- 1:49:11movie to pair up with this one to make the perfect double
- 1:49:14feature? Guys, we've mentioned a lot of
- 1:49:16films today, Brad, I wrote down a short list of movies that
- 1:49:18could be on my Let's Make It a Double.
- 1:49:20East of Eden was one of them. I think East of Eden is a really
- 1:49:23great comparison 'cause this does become a Cain and Abel
- 1:49:25story for a good chunk of the movie.
- 1:49:29You know, I'll turn it over to you first.
- 1:49:31Brad, who do you want to or what movie would you like to pick
- 1:49:33today for? Let's make it a.
- 1:49:34I'm going to take it to a place we have not talked about yet.
- 1:49:37This is another of my favorite movies in the genre of like,
- 1:49:44examining what it means to be a human right like that.
- 1:49:48I feel like that's a genre of film.
- 1:49:51And I mean, is that every film? Who knows?
- 1:49:55I'm going to pair it with Akiru. Oh man, Akiru just does such a
- 1:50:02masterful job of taking the human experience.
- 1:50:06I think that for a movie made in the 1950s, it has way too much
- 1:50:11relevance for a generation. A culture that our modern
- 1:50:15culture that is distracting itself into oblivion the same
- 1:50:20way that his government work was just nulling or dulling his
- 1:50:24senses into oblivion. And the wake up call to purpose
- 1:50:29and meaning is so powerfully portrayed.
- 1:50:33And then the the drunken we're going to live for this man.
- 1:50:38And then they just fall back into their old patterns.
- 1:50:40Like what an examination of the human experience.
- 1:50:45I think it would be a really depressing and beautiful and
- 1:50:48awesome like 7 hours of watching Akiru and Tree of Life
- 1:50:53back-to-back. That's wonderful, man.
- 1:50:56That's such a good pick, Brad. I'll go ahead and go next so
- 1:50:59that Bilga can have the last word here.
- 1:51:02I was gonna. Pick Toy Story 3.
- 1:51:03And watching No, no, I'm gonna pick Toy Story 4.
- 1:51:08Brad no, I almost watched the three hour cut of this movie
- 1:51:13that's featured on the Criterion Blu-ray and I chose not to
- 1:51:16because I was thinking for a time.
- 1:51:19I have never gotten around to seeing the Coen brothers movie A
- 1:51:22Serious Man, which is ostensibly the only other job related movie
- 1:51:28to come out in the last, you know, 1520 years.
- 1:51:31I don't think I'm gonna pair it with that.
- 1:51:33And I don't know if that tells you what I thought of A Serious
- 1:51:34Man or not, but I I did not get around to watching the longer
- 1:51:38version of The Tree of Life. But what really stuck with me
- 1:51:42about the version we watched was that sort of middle section
- 1:51:46about puberty and these two brothers who were at odds with
- 1:51:50each other. That's why East of Eden came up.
- 1:51:52But it reminded me of a film that kind of had the same kind
- 1:51:56of boots on the ground, almost verite style of filming young
- 1:52:00people while also telling a really dramatic story about what
- 1:52:05it means to deal with with guilt and shame.
- 1:52:09And that's a French film that came out just a couple years ago
- 1:52:11that was released under the title close in the United
- 1:52:14States. And this was a a really
- 1:52:17affecting movie. Like it just one of the better
- 1:52:20movies about kind of preteen coming of age that I've seen in
- 1:52:25a really long time. It's it's a bit of a tragic
- 1:52:27story, but it's about two boys who are struggling with their
- 1:52:32parasocial relationships and the expectations of them from
- 1:52:35outside forces and what it means to try to preserve this sort of
- 1:52:39really innocent boyhood friendship in the face of the
- 1:52:43realities of life. So I'm going to pair it with
- 1:52:45close. Dude, I think that's the first
- 1:52:48time we've ever paired 2 foreign language films for Let's Make It
- 1:52:53a Double. This is our least accessible
- 1:52:56Let's make it a double yet. Bill Go.
- 1:52:58What foreign film do you have for us to to cap it off?
- 1:53:02I, I don't have a foreign film. You know, it's funny because
- 1:53:07it's, I mean, you know, when you have a film you love so much,
- 1:53:10you, you, you always want to pair it with all sorts of other
- 1:53:13films. Because a movie like this
- 1:53:15contains so much that I'm like, I could pair it with anything,
- 1:53:17you know? Jaws.
- 1:53:20Jaws yeah, why not? But the movie that I actually, I
- 1:53:24actually have mentioned this before as a because I, I saw
- 1:53:29these movies. Well, it's the the second one I
- 1:53:32saw a little later, but it, but it kind of always reminds me of
- 1:53:36the tree of life. It's, it's a movie called It's
- 1:53:39Such a Beautiful day by Don Herzfeld, the the independent
- 1:53:44animator. It's 62 minutes long, like it's
- 1:53:47not a long film. We talk about the 90 minute film
- 1:53:52being being a masterpiece. We we have not had a 60 minute
- 1:53:56film yet, Bob. You know, and it's funny because
- 1:53:58it's like it's 62 minutes and it's like, I mean, not the tree
- 1:54:01of life is that long, but but it is funny because it's such a
- 1:54:03kind of like, you know, like a, a film that occupies space.
- 1:54:09And I mean, it's such a beautiful day.
- 1:54:11I believe is actually kind of stitched together from three
- 1:54:14shorter films, although it, it feels very much like 1
- 1:54:17continuous film. And it's like, I mean, Herzfeld
- 1:54:20works in these like like stick figure animations.
- 1:54:22It's a very basic animation, but it's it's the film is about a
- 1:54:25guy who is kind of going through his day realizing something is
- 1:54:30wrong and and he may or may not be like terminally ill, but he's
- 1:54:35also going through his memories and remembering a brother who
- 1:54:39kind of suggested that he died. But like, I mean, it's, it's all
- 1:54:45very sort of very fleeting little moments.
- 1:54:48And then it incorporates, you know, nature footage and all
- 1:54:51sorts of other things. So it's feels more like a
- 1:54:53collage really than an animation.
- 1:54:56And it is, I mean, but it has a very similar kind of feeling as,
- 1:55:01as the tree of life because it, it does feel like, I mean, the,
- 1:55:06the, the story of the sky is awful, Like all these awful
- 1:55:09things are happening to him. But you know, the, the whole
- 1:55:13thing winds up becoming about just like the importance of
- 1:55:17loving and appreciating everyone and everything around you in the
- 1:55:20sense that that we're all really kind of connected in this like
- 1:55:25incredibly complicated, beautiful, terrible reality that
- 1:55:29we live in. It's a great, great movie.
- 1:55:33You know, I mean, it's, it's, it's, it's really hard to
- 1:55:37describe, even harder to describe than the tree of life,
- 1:55:40but would make a mind blowing double feature with the tree of
- 1:55:45life. At least you didn't have Bob
- 1:55:46telling you that you have to do the best job you've ever done
- 1:55:50before you tried to explain that movie.
- 1:55:52That's true. Yeah, Now I will say, Brad, I I
- 1:55:57saw a review of Tree of Life. I can't remember, maybe it was
- 1:55:59Bilga. It was somebody I was reading
- 1:56:00before we jumped on here. And and there was this a short
- 1:56:02little snippet that was defending the movie against
- 1:56:05allegations of being pretentious.
- 1:56:07And it just said like, this movie is too sincere to be
- 1:56:10pretentious. And I, I thought that was just
- 1:56:13the best encapsulation of why this movie works, because I
- 1:56:16think that explaining it to somebody it, it can sound
- 1:56:19pretentious. Anybody that decides to make
- 1:56:21their movie about the foundations of the universe and
- 1:56:24link it to their own personal autobiographical story like that
- 1:56:27sounds a little bit haughty, you know, like I, I, I think just to
- 1:56:31hear it from outside terms, but there is something about the
- 1:56:35level of sincerity and, and authenticity.
- 1:56:39And I don't know what's the word that you use, Brad, You use
- 1:56:41sincere, but there's another word that you use sometimes.
- 1:56:44Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:56:45I mean, it's just you can tell that this is this guy really
- 1:56:49means what he's doing, and he's thinking deeply about this.
- 1:56:53And I'll tease a movie that we have coming up at the end of the
- 1:56:56season, Brad, that most people hate called American Beauty,
- 1:57:00that I will be perhaps the world's sole defender of because
- 1:57:05it's the only other movie with the balls to just come right out
- 1:57:08and talk about how beautiful things actually are.
- 1:57:11I'm looking forward to just wallowing in the corniness of of
- 1:57:16affirming life along with you and the Tree of Life and Ikiru
- 1:57:21Brad. Yeah, dude, I, I am all about
- 1:57:24it, man. Bill got it's been so good to
- 1:57:27have you on. Thank you so much for joining
- 1:57:30us. I was going to say let's do
- 1:57:32final scores, but I think it's a 10 for all of us, right?
- 1:57:35Like there's just, it's a no brainer. 10 out of 10 here,
- 1:57:38yeah. This, this would be like on my
- 1:57:42list of films I wish I could get people to watch and take
- 1:57:45seriously. This might, this is probably
- 1:57:48number one. I, I really wish there were more
- 1:57:52people that would watch this and, and know that going in,
- 1:57:56it's going to be different than a traditional movie experience.
- 1:58:00And to go into it with that mindset of let's take seriously
- 1:58:05these questions that I often like to hide within my own soul.
- 1:58:10I man, tree of life. Well, it feels a little bit.
- 1:58:15What a picture. It's a real chef's kiss of a
- 1:58:19movie. It feels a little bit trite to
- 1:58:22to pivot from that to asking Bilga, like what articles he has
- 1:58:25coming out soon. But we got to let the guy plug
- 1:58:27himself a little bit. Bilga, what?
- 1:58:29What's coming down the Pike and where can we find you?
- 1:58:31When this when this hits, I will be at the Venice Film Festival.
- 1:58:37I'm supposed to cover that this year.
- 1:58:38So, you know, usually that's just like a deluge of reviews
- 1:58:44for me. That's kind of, you know, so I
- 1:58:48can't tell you yet like what, what the reviews will be.
- 1:58:51I mean, there are there are a bunch of.
- 1:58:52But there will be reviews. There will be reviews.
- 1:58:55Absolutely hated the new Luca Guadagnino.
- 1:58:58It's, it's crazy, he already told.
- 1:58:59US guys, that's nuts. I mean, I will probably have
- 1:59:03reviewed the new Luca Guanino by that point.
- 1:59:06So so maybe I could hate it, who knows, but yes, so that that'll
- 1:59:10be that'll be the thing. I mean, there's always stuff I'm
- 1:59:12working on, but you know, you never know when something will
- 1:59:15actually be published or when I will actually file it.
- 1:59:18But during the festival, I do, I do, I do hit my deadlines well.
- 1:59:23We can't say enough how how grateful and how honored we are
- 1:59:25that you spent some time with us again, Bill got you know, you,
- 1:59:28you're a very humble guy. I think it's fair to say that
- 1:59:31you are, if not America's pre eminent critic at this point,
- 1:59:34that you were certainly among them.
- 1:59:35And so to come here and drink some whiskey with us and talk
- 1:59:38about Joe Dirt. I I can't thank you enough, man.
- 1:59:42Listen, you know 222 men of the cloth.
- 1:59:49Joe Dirt was kind of my dream all along there.
- 1:59:54You go. No, this was great.
- 1:59:56Thank you so much. I mean, I, I love talking about
- 1:59:58this film. You know, you mentioned as soon
- 2:00:00as I saw the list, I was like that like 3 of life, you know, I
- 2:00:04mean, there were many, like there are a lot of great movies
- 2:00:06on that list. So I'm really looking forward to
- 2:00:09the season. But but yeah, I'm, I'm very
- 2:00:12happy, very happy always to talk to you guys, but also especially
- 2:00:16happy to talk about this film. Well, Brad, we are going to
- 2:00:20pivot from talking about the origins of the known universe to
- 2:00:24the origins of the Marvel Cinematic Universe next week.
- 2:00:27Because we are looking at 2008's Iron Man.
- 2:00:31I cannot possibly think of greater tonal whiplash between
- 2:00:35two films. Than the ones.
- 2:00:39I can't wait to do our best angry Jeff Bridges voices next
- 2:00:42week. So join us for that next week.
- 2:00:47I want you to do your outro in that voice.
- 2:00:49Join us next week for Iron Man. But until then, I'm Bob Book.
- 2:00:53I'm Brad G. And we will see you next time.