Latest / The So What? / Electricity and Load Shedding
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to the So What podcast, in which political economic analyst JP Landman
- 0:11discusses the issues uppermost in the minds of South Africans. You can find a written
- 0:16version of this content on JP's website, jplandman.co.za. I am Ruda Landman and I am your host.
- 0:28These first few recordings were done at our dining room table, but we will soon be moving
- 0:33into a studio.
- 0:35Hello, and as always, a very warm welcome to another recording which goes with JP's
- 0:42latest newsletter. This one is dated the 20th of January 2023. And it's about, what else
- 0:51could it be about at this moment, about electricity. JP, you start with a quote from Antonio Gramsci
- 1:00and the quote reads, the crisis consists precisely in the fact that the old is dying and the
- 1:07new cannot be born. In this interregnum, a great variety of morbid symptoms appear. Who
- 1:16was Antonio Gramsci and why is this relevant?
- 1:21Gramsci was imprisoned by the fascists in Italy in the 1930s. And he actually wrote
- 1:26these words from prison. He kept a journal of his writings while in prison and this quote
- 1:33comes from there. Why is it relevant for South Africa today? Because I think it expresses
- 1:39absolutely precisely where we are with electricity. The old system of electricity provision in
- 1:45South Africa is busy dying. ESCOM, as we used to know it, is busy dying. The way that we
- 1:52provided electricity to ourselves and the nation is busy dying. And the new system is
- 1:57being born. A system that will be much different from and encapsulate much more than ESCOM.
- 2:05But the new system is not quite in place yet. The old system is also no longer working.
- 2:10And we caught in between that interregnum between the old electricity system and the
- 2:16new system. And flowing from that, Rudha, I just want to make this one point very, very
- 2:21clearly. I don't think ESCOM can be saved in its current format. If we look back in
- 2:26five years time, ESCOM as we exist today will no longer exist. It will exist in a much diminished
- 2:32and different form. So ESCOM cannot be saved, in my view, but electricity provision will
- 2:39be saved. And that is what this piece is about. And then you make a point which I think is
- 2:47one wants to say it's obvious, but I think we need to understand that we have load shedding
- 2:53because South Africa does not generate enough power. What is the gap and how will it be
- 2:59closed? The capacity gap is between 4000 megawatts and 6000 megawatts. There's no 100% consensus
- 3:08about the correct number. ESCOM as recently as November, they said the capacity gap was
- 3:154000 megawatts. What I do in this piece is I assume that the capacity gap is 6000 megawatts.
- 3:22And then I look at how one can whittle that 6000 megawatts down.
- 3:27And that is simply the gap between supply and demand.
- 3:30Yes, that is simply the gap between what ESCOM can produce when everything goes right and
- 3:35when everything runs well and what is demanded by the economy and by people and by households.
- 3:41And so that's the capacity gap. Now it's important to note that whether you use 4000 megawatts
- 3:46as your number or 6000 megawatts as your number, what we're talking about are baseload megawatts.
- 3:53Now what is baseload? Baseload simply means the power is available for 24 hours of the
- 3:57day. It's not just available when the sun shines or when the wind blows. It is there
- 4:02all the time. Now, if you want to compare apples with apples, 6000 megawatts of baseload
- 4:08will require about 18,000 megawatts of renewable capacity supported by storage and gas. That's
- 4:17the way to compare apples with apples. The baseload people try to argue that you can
- 4:23get baseload only from coal or from coal and nuclear. And that is actually not true. Technology
- 4:30is developed in a different way. And you can now, there's a wind farm in Bosnian-Berg
- 4:36in the Northern Cape, not a wind farm, a solar farm that is now for 12 months provided electricity
- 4:4124 hours per day from the sun using a salt technology. For storage. For storage. So with
- 4:50renewables you need storage, whatever technology and you can use gas to make up for the times
- 4:58when the renewables are not working. So 6000 megawatts of capacity gap is 6000 megawatts
- 5:05of baseload and that translates into about 18,000 megawatts of renewable capacity that
- 5:13is needed. Okay, but we've been seeing renewable contracts being given. We all see wind farms
- 5:21everywhere. We see solar farms if you drive through the Northern Cape. Where are we in
- 5:27making up that gap? Right. So we've got about roughly 7,000 megawatts of renewables installed
- 5:34in the country that is already being used by ISCOM and to plug this capacity gap of
- 5:4018,000 megawatts renewables, you have to install 18,000 new megawatts on top of what you probably
- 5:49have. So the numbers look as follows. 9,000 megawatts of capacity is being built at the
- 5:58moment by private companies putting up power facilities for their own use and for the customers
- 6:03that they share in the world that they sell it to. That is private sector driven. It's
- 6:08about a hundred projects countrywide, consists of wind and solar and batteries in many cases
- 6:15and the number is 9,000. Then we have about 3,000 megawatts that have been procured through
- 6:21the official procurement processes run by the government, run by the Department of Mineral
- 6:27Energy. If I say government, it's also, it includes procurement processes being run by
- 6:33local governments, but that's minuscule. You can for all practical purposes ignore that.
- 6:38There's a lot of talking and noise about what municipalities are doing, but so far it's
- 6:42a very, very small number. So 9,000 private, 3,000 public. That gives you 12,000 megawatts
- 6:49of new capacity that's in one shape or form in the process of being created at the moment.
- 6:55And you think by the end of 2024, most of that will be online?
- 7:00Yes, absolutely. Certainly the private processes, no question about that. I see there is a statement
- 7:07from the presidency suggesting that a lot of it will come online during 2023. That may
- 7:13be I'm working on 2024 as the outside date. So we've got 12,000 and then there's another
- 7:212,000 that is being made available through ISCOM repurposing the land on which it's current
- 7:28coal fired power stations are standing. And what they've done is they've already leased
- 7:34out 6,000 hectares to private entrepreneurs to come and build renewable facilities on
- 7:40ISCOM land. There's no purchase agreement with ISCOM. They can sell it to whoever they
- 7:46want to and they have to pay ISCOM rent. But the upside of those sites is that they
- 7:56are already linked to the grid. Correct. Transmission is no problem because
- 8:00the coal fired power stations transmit the power. So that's another 2,000. So you've
- 8:05got 9,000 private, 3,000 through official procurement, the so-called bitwindows. You've
- 8:10got 2,000 from ISCOM that gives you 14,000. And then there is another 1,000 megawatts
- 8:18that will take the total to 15,000 of power that will be bought from existing independent
- 8:24power producers who have extra capacity. So you have a capacity for say 110 megawatts,
- 8:30but you're only selling 100 megawatts to ISCOM. So there's an extra 10 megawatts lying around.
- 8:36The idea is to buy 1,000 megawatts from existing independent power producers as well as the
- 8:42sub-African power pool. So we import power from other countries in sub-Saharan Africa
- 8:49which also belongs to power pool. Now the presidency or the National Energy
- 8:53Committee on electricity is of the opinion that 2,000 megawatts can be procured in this
- 8:58manner. I've cut that number in half and only using the number of 1,000. And that brings
- 9:04us then to a total of 15,000 megawatts that are currently in the process of being procured
- 9:10and which I think will be connected to the grid by the end of 2024 at the latest. And
- 9:17this full number of 15,000 are projects connected to the grid or who have grid capacity available
- 9:25to them. There's a problem with the grid as we can discuss later, but this 15,000 is covered
- 9:30by the grid. Okay, so we're left with 3,000 renewables
- 9:37or a bit less if it's baseload. Yes.
- 9:41And you... Where will that come from? You risk putting Madhupi and Kusili into the
- 9:48picture. Yes, Madhupi not Kusili. We shouldn't treat
- 9:52the two of them the same. Madhupi and Kusili, both of them have six units each. At Madhupi,
- 9:58three of those units are in full operation and two of them have been running at the EAF,
- 10:03an energy availability factor of higher than 85%. In fact, one of them has run for 12
- 10:09hours at 92%. So the three units at Madhupi are doing quite well. The place is being run
- 10:16by an old ESCOM veteran, Mr. Zivelli Wittboi. He's been there for more than 20 years and
- 10:23they're doing well. Two of the units at Madhupi are not at full capacity yet because they
- 10:28must be modified to deal with carbon emissions. Madhupi or ESCOM applied for an emission exemption
- 10:37from minimum emission standards. They didn't get the exemption, so they have to fix the
- 10:41plant to reduce emissions. And that's why two of the six units are not in full production
- 10:48yet. And then the sixth unit, as you know, was damaged in 2021 in an explosion. Two employees
- 10:55were dismissed because of that explosion, no longer works for ESCOM. And that unit should
- 11:01be in operation, giving us about 800 megawatts by September 2024. So as you put it at the
- 11:09beginning of your question, we've got 1000 megawatts of base load that we need. We can
- 11:15get 800 megawatts of that from Madhupi, bringing an extra unit online. Plus the other two units
- 11:22that are currently being fixed for emission standards will probably give us another 200.
- 11:28But again, let's leave that out of the equation. Kusili actually is not doing that well at
- 11:34all. Of the six units, four were in operation by June last year, June 2020 too. And then
- 11:42there was an explosion that took one of them out of action. Don't know what the cause of
- 11:45the explosion is. Then a month later in October, an accident took place. We took out two more
- 11:53units. So one unit is running. I think it is safe based on discussions I've had with
- 12:00people on the inside to say that Kusili will not make a contribution to power supply in
- 12:07the country in 2023 and probably also not for the biggest part of 2024. So I ignore
- 12:15Kusili and I assume that there are no megawatts coming from there, only from Madhupi.
- 12:21And then the role of all the homeowners, like ourselves, many people are putting solar panels
- 12:28on the roof and in many cases by lunchtime the batteries are full.
- 12:34Yes. Now, of course, not all panel owners have got batteries. One must allow for that
- 12:39too. Some people just use panels and that's all. But it is a big potential source. Industry
- 12:45players reckon that the 3,600 megawatts of renewable panels on homes and offices all
- 12:52over the country and it's growing at the rate of 1,000 megawatts per year. Now, if you take
- 12:58that 3,600 and you apply the formula, it will give you a base load of over 1,000 megawatts.
- 13:06That's more than what Kusili is producing. It's quite a substantial amount of power.
- 13:12And what happens, as you correctly point out, is people satisfy their power needs, at least
- 13:17partially from these solar panels. But then there's always a bit of a surplus. So you
- 13:23run your dishwasher or you use your hairdryer or you make coffee and the panels provide
- 13:28you with power. And then after you've made your coffee or after the dishwasher is run,
- 13:33well the panels are still working. The sun is still shining in most parts of South Africa
- 13:38and that power goes to waste. So what would be a logical thing to do, and Vietnam has
- 13:44done this, Germany has done this, many countries have done it, is you use that power by allowing
- 13:50people to feed the power back into the local municipal grid or if they're connected to
- 13:55ISCOM to feed it back into the ISCOM grid. That is the basic idea. Why do we not do it?
- 14:01For two reasons. The one is what is the price at which you feed it in? So the so-called
- 14:06feed in tariff. And that must be, tariff must be finalized. ISCOM has developed a tariff.
- 14:13They call it a residential tariff. That's for homeowners. They call it home flex, but
- 14:19NASA has to approve of that. My understanding is that NASA did approve it last week when
- 14:24they announced their infamous tariff increases for the next two years. So that's an important
- 14:32thing to clear. And then of course you have to, the meter in your house will have to change
- 14:38and the connection of the grid will have to change. Remember our grid has been built as
- 14:42a one way street, one way traffic, power coming into the house. If you now change it to bring
- 14:48power into the house, but at the same time also send power out sometimes, you change
- 14:54from one way traffic to two way traffic and that requires technical changes. So although
- 15:00the concept is easy to understand and although the concept is quite clear, you needed appropriate
- 15:05price and you need technical changes. But then you can, you can move along this road.
- 15:12I'm really delighted to see that the presidency and their statement have made it quite clear
- 15:17that this is a major area of work now for government. They want to finalize the feed
- 15:24in tariff and get the show on the road. And that will add another few hundred megawatts
- 15:30of base load to the national supply. But what about the municipalities? Not everyone buys
- 15:35directly from ESCO. Absolutely right. The municipalities are very keen to hold on to
- 15:40the source of income. So they also are not prepared to let go. In fact, Salga, the association
- 15:47of local governments have brought a court case against the government for the court
- 15:52to declare that only municipalities are allowed to distribute power in a certain municipal
- 15:58area. Now we're going to see where the court case goes. One can understand where they come
- 16:03from. And again, you know, the old system is dying. The new one is being born, but precisely
- 16:09what must be the rules of the new one. And you don't, you don't design these things
- 16:15by way of artificial intelligence. And then it's there. It's a process of moving through
- 16:19the obstacles. And I think what municipalities want and what they can get as part of that
- 16:24process. And deeply political. And it's very deeply political. You know, we are all on
- 16:30the page of let's use renewables, let's change the energy system, let's become part of the
- 16:36global move to a greener economy and so on and so forth. A lot of people in South Africa
- 16:40don't accept that. And they are fearful of the changes. They are fearful that the poor
- 16:45will be left behind and so on. All those problems can be overcome. It is possible to overcome
- 16:51them all. Countries have done it. We will also do it, but it's a process of working
- 16:57through the issues. I think that's important. Any short term possibilities? Look, there
- 17:03are only two short term possibilities that I can see. The one is that you use diesel,
- 17:09which is very, very expensive and it's not a sustainable option. But if Treasury can
- 17:16find the money, ISCOM doesn't have the money. Let's be clear about that. ISCOM doesn't have
- 17:20the money and it looks as if NERSA has not allowed ISCOM to increase tariffs to allow
- 17:26for diesel purchases. That is what the NERSA decision looks like. So if you want diesel,
- 17:32you want to buy diesel more than what is allowed for in the ISCOM budget, you'll have to get
- 17:36the money from somewhere else. But that diesel is one option if Treasury gives you the money.
- 17:43The other option is that we go back to the car power ship option. I call it the dreaded
- 17:49car power ship option in the written piece. Why dreaded? Because it involves 20 year contracts.
- 17:56It involves very little permanent infrastructure and it brings with it undesirable environmental
- 18:01impacts. So you can argue that none of these things, 20 year contract and so on, none is
- 18:09as important as reducing load shedding. And that's a choice the society must make. So
- 18:14you can do those two things, gas at a huge price or diesel at a huge price. I think the
- 18:21better way to approach this is simply to say publicly and openly, we will have load shedding
- 18:27for another two years. There is no ways around that. There's no quick fix. There's no quick
- 18:32solution. This idea that you can do things and next week load shedding will be over is
- 18:38really, really nonsense. Even if you use gas and even if you buy diesel, it will still
- 18:45take time and it will be prohibitively expensive. So no, I don't think there are shorter solutions.
- 18:53But as you say, there are people who argue that ISCOM's power stations must just pull
- 19:01themselves together. Yes, absolutely. And then it will be over by tomorrow. Yes, absolutely.
- 19:05And particularly the politicians are doing that. They say ISCOM doesn't have a money
- 19:11problem. It has a management problem, quote unquote. I think that's total nonsense. Other
- 19:16people say there's no capacity shortage. They reject the capacity gap argument. What they're
- 19:22saying is that ISCOM has got about 44, 45,000 megawatts of installed capacity and it's only
- 19:27delivering about 23, 24,000. So clearly there's a lot of capacity there not being used. I
- 19:34think the problem with that argument is that it ignores the energy availability factor.
- 19:40The ISCOM plant is old. The average age, if you exclude Madhubi and Kusili, is more than
- 19:4740 years. Now, if you will know from your fridge in your kitchen or the lawn mower in
- 19:53your garden, you use a 40 year old piece of equipment, it doesn't give you the same performance
- 19:58as a new fridge or a new lawn mower. Just as simple as that. Added is the fact that
- 20:04a lot of the ISCOM plant has not been maintained for a long time. We know that. How do we know
- 20:09it? Because an industry association, VGB, based in Germany, to which ISCOM also belongs,
- 20:16track and monitor the energy availability factor, the EAF, of power stations worldwide.
- 20:26The reality is that ISCOM was absolutely on par in its energy availability factor, its
- 20:33efficiencies with the world average, the global average, until about 2011. Since 2011, now
- 20:41that is now 11, 12 years ago. Since 2011, ISCOM's energy availability factor has simply
- 20:48fallen away from the global average. So there's clear empirical evidence that there's a strong
- 20:55problem with the efficiency of the ISCOM installed capacity. So to talk about we've got 24,000,
- 21:03we must just use it properly, is really, it is simply wrong. It is simply wrong.
- 21:08And the figures that you quote, the global average is 75% or more, EAF. ISCOM is 53.
- 21:17That's a very important point. The ISCOM fleet is running at below 54%, 53.9 to be precise.
- 21:25This year, last year, they ran also at those levels. There is an energy analyst, Mr. Clive
- 21:32Mallinson, who's done extensive work on the energy availability factor of the ISCOM fleet.
- 21:39And it's been coming down for a long time. And he is predicting that this will go down
- 21:44below 50. So nevermind the 53.9 that we're doing currently, it may drop even lower. And
- 21:51that has been the trend. So yeah, absolutely. We are way below what ISCOM used to be. You
- 21:57know, we must forget at the beginning of the 2000s, ISCOM was voted the best utility in
- 22:03the world. It was really a superbly run and producing organization. But that is 11, 12
- 22:10years ago.
- 22:11No, that's 20 years ago.
- 22:12That's 20 years ago. I'm sorry. It's 20 years ago. And things change. Things change.
- 22:17And machines get older and older and older.
- 22:19And machines get older and they get older quicker if you don't look after them. And
- 22:24that is precisely what happened here. So now I'm afraid the efficiency argument doesn't
- 22:29hold up.
- 22:30But then the next problematic area is the grid transmission.
- 22:35Yes. What came out clearly in December is something which people have been warning us
- 22:41about. And that is that there isn't enough transmission capacity, transmission lines
- 22:46to carry power up and down. Now, again, our grid, our national grid was developed to move
- 22:51power or electricity in one direction, one way traffic from the power stations in the
- 22:58eastern side of the country, Mipumalanga, to the rest of the country. What is happening
- 23:03now with renewables and power plants going up all over the show is you need a grid that
- 23:08can do electricity in two directions. Secondly, you need a grid that can cope with the intermittency
- 23:16of wind and sun. If the sun is shining, there's power. Cloud moves in before the sun, there's
- 23:20no power. That's a bit taxing on a grid. And you've got to adapt the grid for that.
- 23:26And a lot of the new of the renewable power stations are in completely different places
- 23:32now. Northern Cape, Eastern Cape. Yes. There's no, there are very few transmission lines.
- 23:38Well, they're not enough transmission. Let's put it that way. And this became very clear
- 23:42in December when the government announced the results of bit window, bit window six.
- 23:49The bit window was 4,200 megawatts big. There were 56 bits that came in. So people are interested.
- 23:56People are definitely interested. What the bits tell us is that people want to invest.
- 24:00For all the stories about people not wanting to invest in South Africa, blah, blah, blah.
- 24:06People with real money and real checkbooks have actually written the checks to participate
- 24:10in the bit and they've submitted bits, very competitive bits. But only of that 4,200,
- 24:16only about 850 or 860 in the end could be allocated because only those bits had access
- 24:25to the transmission grid. So you have 56 bitters, only six bitters had access. So you lost 50
- 24:32bitters, so to speak. You wanted to get 4,200 from the bit round, but you only got about
- 24:38850. There may be another 150 coming, calling it, call it a thousand, but the gap is quite
- 24:45big. So the round was a big disappointment. And I think what the round tells us is that
- 24:51the upgrade of the transmission grid is now really important.
- 24:55This sounds as if it could be expensive. It will be expensive. The ESCOM transmission
- 25:01division, which is due to be set up as a separate company, but reporting as part of ESCOM, they
- 25:09published a transmission development plan every year. And the last one was published
- 25:14in October last year for the next 10 years. And essentially what they are saying is that
- 25:19they, at the cost of about 72 billion Rand, they can add 16 and a half thousand megawatts
- 25:25of transmission capacity. And they've got a number of projects, 23 in one case and 13
- 25:33in another case. So it's more than 30 projects all over the country, which if they implement
- 25:39the projects, they can upgrade by the 16,500 megawatts I referred to. That will cost 72
- 25:45billion Rand. So where will the money come from? At this stage, the idea is that the
- 25:50money must come from the green climate funds that South Africa got in the deal that it
- 25:55signed at COP27. Now I wrote about that in December last year. If you look at the detail
- 26:01of that plan, 131 billion Rand is set aside in the plan to upgrade the South African transmission
- 26:08grid. And the president in fact has already said it, some press conference, that the first
- 26:14cash from that COP agreement or climate funds agreement will go towards upgrading the grid.
- 26:22So I don't think that it is a constraint now. It is a problem now. I don't think it's a
- 26:27permanent constraint. You can throw money at the problem, create the extra capacity
- 26:32and connect all the new producers and the money is available via the climate green funds.
- 26:39Do you think government is on top of this? Yes, they're on top of the issues, but they're
- 26:45behind in time. What I mean by that is the Ramaphosa government has made a number of
- 26:50important changes in electricity policy over the last four years. But the reality on the
- 26:57ground has developed faster and quicker than what the government has reacted. So yes, they
- 27:02are on top of it in terms of understanding the issues and what needs to be done. There
- 27:07is also division in government. We know that Greddy Mantashe wants to pull in one direction,
- 27:12but they hasn't stopped policy development so far. But load shedding is happening faster
- 27:19and quicker than what government policy is evolving. And I think that is the basic constraint.
- 27:26Government is not getting ahead of the problem. They are just always a few steps behind. And
- 27:31that's, I suppose that's in the nature of governments, but it is a problem for electricity
- 27:36provision. So what should happen this week to start getting us out of what you call the
- 27:43mess at one point? Well, first of all, the 9,000 megawatts of
- 27:48private power must be allowed and helped to become real. Don't put obstacles there. Don't
- 27:54prevent their progress. Ditto for the 3,000 megawatts of publicly procured power through
- 28:01the bit windows. Those bits have now been allocated. Everybody knows what the prices
- 28:06are, who is in, who is out. Allow those projects to go ahead. So basically dealing with the
- 28:12administrative issues around procuring power. That's number one.
- 28:16Number two, I think a feed in tariff from home and this must be put down and municipalities
- 28:23must be guided to change their approach and accept what needs to be done to make that
- 28:30happen. I think that is number two. If we're going to stop adding any of the capacity that
- 28:37I've referred to, any of that 18,000 megawatts capacity, then load sharing will persist beyond
- 28:43two years. If we can get the 18,000 megawatts of capacity, we can deal with load sharing.
- 28:50And then lastly, of course, we must get a clear effort to finance the upgrading of the
- 28:55transmission grid. That money from the green climate change funds, green money must be
- 29:02used to upgrade the transmission. So it's quite clear what needs to be done. Just sit
- 29:08down and do it and make it happen. That is really where we are.
- 29:13From your lips to, I won't say God's ears, from your lips to the relevant people in government's
- 29:19ears. Thank you very much and thank you for all the work that went into this.
- 29:24No, thank you. Go well.
- 29:30Thank you for listening to the So What podcast. If you enjoy this content, please don't forget
- 29:35to leave a review and a rating and please consider subscribing so you don't miss any
- 29:40future episodes. Also tell your friends. Remember, you can find a written version of all JP's
- 29:47content at jplandman.co.za.