Latest / Dark Murder: True Crime Cases / Episode 99
Transcript
- 0:06Dark murder true crime cases five four, three, two, one one one
- 0:21one. Welcome back. I'm your host, Jordan Lee. I'm sure you
- 0:31are all ready to dive into some dark, creepy stories, So let's get
- 0:34started. Marriage of murder the case of Caroline Nail. When a married couple
- 0:46separates, there can be some very strong emotions rising up in one or both
- 0:50parties. You can't find many better motives for murder than pain and betrayal.
- 0:56These feelings typically show up when a person starts to move on with their life
- 1:00while another is still anchored in the past. And we all know that sometimes
- 1:06your past comes back to haunt you. Even at forty eight years old,
- 1:11Caroline Nail was still considered a beautiful woman. Her stunning figure wasn't the only
- 1:15thing of note about her, though. She attended college to become a nurse,
- 1:21and through hard work, managed to work her way up the ladder to
- 1:23the position of Director of Nursing at Marshall Memorial Hospital, located in medil a
- 1:30small town of just three thousand people in Oklahoma. It seems the only thing
- 1:34about her life at the time that could be considered a drag would be her
- 1:38husband, Joe nail worked in the oil fields, and when he wasn't doing
- 1:44that, he spent his days drinking a lot. It wasn't that Joe didn't
- 1:48know he was married to a woman who far exceeded his grasp since he was
- 1:52in constant fear that Caroline would up and leave him. In nineteen eighty nine,
- 1:57his fears became a reality. Caroline filed and received a divorce after the
- 2:02drinking and threats she'd endure during the time they spent together had finally pushed her
- 2:07to the breaking point. Joe was furious that his wife had left him.
- 2:13On many occasions, he'd made the comment of friends that he'd find a way
- 2:16to even the score between Caroline and himself. As for Caroline, she began
- 2:22to make a new life for herself. Part of doing this was the beginning
- 2:27of a relationship with a successful contractor named Don Hofferber. Though sixty years old
- 2:32and divorced, the two were constantly in each other's company and to their friends,
- 2:38it was simply a matter of time before the two would make the pairing
- 2:40official. Violent crimes were not known to occur in the small town of medil
- 2:46So when an anonymous call was received on June second, nineteen ninety at the
- 2:52local hospital from a woman who was begging for help. The response was immediate,
- 2:58though they would only get a partial address before the line went silent.
- 3:01The ambulance was directed toward the home occupied by Caroline Nail. Officers arrived on
- 3:07the scene first. When they found the glass in the back patio door broken,
- 3:13they had to consider the possibility the intruders might still be inside. A
- 3:17quick sweep of the home found it empty except for the bodies of two people.
- 3:23The first was Don Hofferber, who was lying at the foot of the
- 3:27bed, having been shot in the neck, the stomach, and the arm.
- 3:31Caroline Nail was beside the bed. She herself had been shot five times.
- 3:37The three wounds in the back were the ones that would kill her.
- 3:40Don had been killed instantly, while Caroline managed to drag herself to the phone
- 3:45and attempt the desperate call for help before succumbing to her own injuries. Police
- 3:52would later determine the bullets were fired from a twenty two caliber rifle. The
- 3:55shooter had stood in the vicinity of the doorway when they opened up on the
- 4:00couple. Also found at the scene were seventeen hundred dollars in Don's wallet,
- 4:04which ruled out a robbery, and Caroline's pitbull, who was cowering in the
- 4:09corner of the bedroom. The police initially suspected the killer had been a jealous
- 4:15rival of Hoferber, he had a reputation for being both crude and ruthless in
- 4:19his business dealings. This theory fell to the wayside when they learned of the
- 4:25hateful feelings Joe nail harbored against his ex. It was discovered that Caroline had
- 4:30been in such fear of Joe that Don and she had purchased a pair of
- 4:34firearms for protection. Police questioned Joe at his trailer, located about forty miles
- 4:41from the murder scene. Not only did he admit to hating Carolyn, but
- 4:46expressed no sadness that some one had murdered her. He did stipulate that it
- 4:50wasn't in fact him that did the killing. He claimed to have been fishing
- 4:55alone at the time she had been killed. According to Joe's statement, the
- 5:00last time he'd seen his ex alive was a few days beforehand, when he
- 5:03dropped off the pit bull after spending the day with it. The search of
- 5:08the trailer didn't uncover any evidence linking Joe to the crime. Regardless, investigators
- 5:14still believed that Joe had gone on a drunken rampage and killed his ex wife
- 5:17and her new lover. They were just going to have to find a way
- 5:21to prove their theory. When the story of the murder began to spread through
- 5:27the town, it was the public's opinion Joe was the killer as well.
- 5:30Police began to hear stories about the dog they'd found in the home was known
- 5:34to be aggressive. The idea that this animal would have allowed a stranger to
- 5:39roam freely through the home without attempting to protect its owner seemed odd, But
- 5:44if the animal knew the killer, that would better explain its behavior. Secondly,
- 5:50a couple of eye witness accounts that placed Joe at the scene all but
- 5:54sewed up their case. One came from a neighbor who said she saw a
- 5:58white truck parked in front of the home. When she came back outside a
- 6:01few minutes later, the vehicle was driving toward her, and she swore that
- 6:05the driver and her locked eyes. The driver was Joe Nail. The second
- 6:12eye witness was a security guard at the trailer park who stated that he'd seen
- 6:15Joe driving out of the park two hours before the murder had occurred, and
- 6:18returned an hour after the killing. This was during the time Joe had told
- 6:24police he'd been fishing. All of this gave them enough to arrest Nail and
- 6:29charge him with the two murders. When the trial started, these along with
- 6:33a number of acquaintances, came forward, telling jurors that Joe had made threats
- 6:39against Caroline. They even proved that Carolyn had once purchased Joe a twenty two
- 6:43caliber rifle for Christmas. The defense tried to convince the jury that Dawn had
- 6:47a number of business enemies that would want him dead, and his family was
- 6:51set to inherit a great deal of money in the event of his death,
- 6:55but they didn't buy that version of the events. After handing down a guilty
- 7:00verdict on both counts, Joe now faced the possibility of the death penalty.
- 7:05His attorney went on the offensive, stating that the murders were acts of passion
- 7:10and therefore his client shouldn't be put to death unlike the crimes themselves. The
- 7:15jury sided with a defense on this matter. Joe Nail would be sentenced to
- 7:19life in prison without the possibility of parole on both counts.