Latest / SPEAK LIKE A CEO / 246: How to Win Your Audience’s Trust. Dr. Carmen Simon
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to Speak Like It CEO.
- 0:03My name is Oliver Alston, my job on this podcast is to interview world-class experts and
- 0:07inspiring CEOs to help you become the top 1% communicator.
- 0:11I guess today's doctor Carmen Simon, she's a cognitive neuroscientist who specializes
- 0:16in how the brain processes and retains information.
- 0:18But after Simon teaches at Stanford, advises companies such as HP, Google and JP Morgan,
- 0:24who just published an excellent new book made you look.
- 0:28In this episode, she shares her insights on the science behind effective communication
- 0:32and how you can use it to create better presentation, sales pitches and marketing messages.
- 0:38We discuss what their attention spends are really getting shorter, how to control your
- 0:4110% and how to correctly use priming and framing to achieve your goal.
- 0:46Enjoy this episode with all of the world's leading experts on how to use brain science
- 0:50to attract attention and persuade others.
- 0:57Carmen, thanks so much for being here today.
- 0:59Thank you so much for inviting me and welcome everyone.
- 1:01So where does this podcast find you?
- 1:03I am located here not too far away from San Francisco, a little bit further south.
- 1:09So if you're ever in California, stop by and say hi.
- 1:13I know that we are addressing a global audience and it's interesting to think about communication
- 1:19from a global perspective because as a neuroscientist, I always look for guidelines that appeal
- 1:25to the global brain and not just to the local brain.
- 1:28Right, at the biological level, of course.
- 1:31So what does a cognitive scientist do who research is how we communicate and what resonates?
- 1:36I use neuroscience tools in my profession and those include an EEG cap.
- 1:42So imagine that you get your buyer to be exposed to a sales presentation, for instance.
- 1:49And that buyer in my experience, in my experiments, will wear an EEG cap.
- 1:53So I capture an electroencephalogram signal.
- 1:56Because what happens when you're faced with communication, your brain produces various
- 2:00brain waves, so we get to capture those.
- 2:03Then on their chest, I place an electrode and I capture then an electrocardiogram signal.
- 2:10Then on their arrest and fingers, I place a device that's called a GSR, a galvanic
- 2:15skin response.
- 2:17And the reason for that is because when your buyers, your audiences, are exposed to
- 2:21content, if they have a reaction to that content, big question if, by the way, if they
- 2:26have a reaction to that content, positive or negative, their skin will physically change.
- 2:31So we capture that change.
- 2:33And also on the device where I ask them to view some communication like a sales presentation,
- 2:37for instance, or a website, I place an eye tracker.
- 2:41And the reason for that is because I want to see where they look for how long.
- 2:45So we record the duration and direction of their gaze.
- 2:49And the reason for that is because typically you'll look to where you think.
- 2:52So there's a connection between visual attention and cognitive processing.
- 2:57And the reason you want to abide by a combination of these signals and not just a few, is because
- 3:03they will give you a more comprehensive look into how brain and body interact with your
- 3:07materials.
- 3:09And you also bypass self-reports.
- 3:11Because otherwise you could go to your buyers and ask them what captured your attention
- 3:16from my sales presentation, for instance, or what kept you most engaged or what motivated
- 3:21you to keep going.
- 3:23And people will tell you, but their self-reports are often unreliable.
- 3:28People often don't remember what just happened.
- 3:30We forget our lives almost as quickly as we live them.
- 3:33So that's why you always want to look for a way to capture reactions implicitly, not explicitly.
- 3:39And how long have we been able to do that, to basically look into someone's brain?
- 3:43We've been doing that for almost a decade now, because the equipment itself has advanced.
- 3:49Like, for instance, if you came to a neuroscience lab ages ago, we may have had to put these
- 3:55electrodes on your scalp, those were what was called wet electrodes.
- 3:59So we would have to inject the gel, and if you had beautiful hair, that would just mess
- 4:04up your style and the whole experiment would just be negatively tampered with.
- 4:09One day, the technology is much easier to use.
- 4:13It is much more convenient for participants.
- 4:15In fact, the equipment that I just described fits into small subcases.
- 4:20So we can go to clients' locations and create these small pop-up labs.
- 4:26And because of that, then we've had more participants contribute to science and I'm grateful
- 4:32to all of them, because it's because of their time and energy that we can even bring
- 4:37some practical guidelines that we're about to share with all of you.
- 4:41Interesting.
- 4:42And are you doing these in the lab, or do you examine people in the wild, so to speak?
- 4:47Because I would imagine that if you're sitting in the lab with all the electrodes and the
- 4:50EEG and the eye movement trackers and so on, that it would influence how I look at something
- 4:55or think about something.
- 4:57We typically set up the labs at customers' locations, already people feel a bit more at ease
- 5:04in an environment that they recognize, so things are not so rigid.
- 5:08We still control for noise and distractions, of course.
- 5:12And it's a good thing that the brain habituates fairly quickly to some conditions.
- 5:17Like for instance, initially you are indeed aware of the electrodes and you are aware
- 5:21that something a bit more unusual is happening.
- 5:24It's not your typical sales presentation that you attend by being strapped to all this
- 5:28gear.
- 5:29We have betrayed very quickly.
- 5:30For a while that we are being reminded yet again that something is going on, so that's
- 5:34why we keep the length of the experiments fairly short.
- 5:38I'm sure that in time, as technology will continue to advance, we will be able to extend
- 5:44the length of the experiments as well because the technology will be even less intrusive.
- 5:49But the reason for EEG technology, for instance, as a neuroscientist, that's my preferred method,
- 5:55is different than an FMRI machine, for example.
- 5:57So you could come, I also teach at Stanford, you could come to one of the formal labs and
- 6:02we could put your brain in an FMRI machine.
- 6:05But by the time the machine takes a picture of your brain, a second or more elapses, and
- 6:10that could be an eternity in terms of cognitive processing and affective processes.
- 6:15Whereas with the EEG, that signal, even though with the electrodes, we stay only on the
- 6:19surface, we stay only on the scalp.
- 6:21Our corporate clients are not allowing us to surgically insert the electrodes.
- 6:26Our signal, though, is at the millisecond level.
- 6:29So if you have a sales presentation, for instance, and you want to know what happens at minute
- 6:34two, 32, we will know what happens at that moment with millisecond precision.
- 6:40So what you give up in terms of how deep you can go into the brain, you gain with a temporal
- 6:46resolution.
- 6:47That is super interesting.
- 6:49And what fascinates me and correct me if I'm wrong about this, but my understanding
- 6:52is that a lot of the neuroscience that has emerged in the last 10 years or so confirms
- 6:57what the ancient Greeks, for instance, already knew about ethos, pathos, logos, and things
- 7:01like that.
- 7:02So maybe they just didn't understand why that was the case, but there seems to be a big
- 7:06overlap between what we kind of knew if we read the ancients and what neuroscience has
- 7:11found out.
- 7:13There are some things that are definitely being confirmed.
- 7:15Some things that we can debunk, for instance, one of my favorite myths to debunk, and that
- 7:19will be good news for anyone listening, is the notion that we have a short attention
- 7:25span.
- 7:27You hear that statement all the time, and I'm here to remind you that this is definitely
- 7:31not so.
- 7:33The brain is capable for prolonged amounts of attention.
- 7:36You don't even have to be a neuroscientist to know this.
- 7:38All you have to do is be very helpful and honest with yourself and admit how many hours
- 7:45you have binge watched on a TV show.
- 7:47And I guarantee that if somebody asked you that question and you answered it, your answer
- 7:52would not be in the amount of minutes or seconds.
- 7:56Your answer would be an amount of hours that you would have been glued to a device to
- 8:01watch something.
- 8:03And that's a good news for all of you listening and thinking about practical guidelines because
- 8:08you don't have to worry so much about attention span in the sense of, oh, I better keep this
- 8:13short because my audiences are not going to be able to focus for a long amount of time.
- 8:19If you're stimulus is interesting enough, and important enough, ideally both, your audiences
- 8:26brains are physically capable, and of course you're dealing with healthy brains.
- 8:30They are capable of staying focused on what you have to offer.
- 8:33Yeah, that's also my impression.
- 8:35Thank you for backing this up and watching something for hours of reading a complicated
- 8:39book with lots of plots and subplots and characters.
- 8:42We can totally do this.
- 8:43I'd never bought into the notion that we have short attention span, the goldfish, and apparently
- 8:47we don't even know what the attention span of goldfish is, so that's even unfair on the
- 8:51goldfish.
- 8:52But so you made a very interesting point.
- 8:55It's not that the attention span is short, it's that we need to get someone's attention
- 8:59to first place.
- 9:00And obviously you've written wonderful books called Impossible Took Nor and the new one
- 9:05which recently came out made your look.
- 9:07So what does make us look?
- 9:10There are quite a few things that will prompt us to look.
- 9:14And in this most recent book, I've been looking at attention from two dimensions.
- 9:18Obviously, we could spend a lot more than 30 or 40 minutes speaking of attention because
- 9:23it is one of the widest topics that you can address, especially in business because you
- 9:29exist in business because some customers are paying attention to you and not anyone else.
- 9:35And you can look at attention from the angle of where do people are, where do what your
- 9:40customers look for how long so that's attention across time.
- 9:44You can look at it from the segment of are they focused on one small thing or are they
- 9:49focused on a wider area?
- 9:51From an evolutionary perspective, by the way, it helped us if we weren't just so extremely
- 9:55focused on one area at the expense of another bigger one because you would have had to take
- 10:01into consideration all that was happening in your surrounding.
- 10:04And of course, you can look at attention from an executive function, meaning that even
- 10:09as you're listening to us right now, in the back of your mind, you might keep in mind
- 10:15some things that you haven't accomplished, some projects that you have, some goals that
- 10:19have yet to be completed.
- 10:20So there's something that's always running in the back there and your customers are not
- 10:24going to be any different.
- 10:26In the book, I look at attention from just two dimensions only to keep speaking of focus,
- 10:30to keep our attention a bit narrower.
- 10:34And those dimensions are, where do people look?
- 10:37And the more unique insight is that you don't always have to look externally to figure
- 10:42something out.
- 10:43It's possible for the brain to look internally.
- 10:46So keep in mind that dimension.
- 10:48And then the second dimension is who is prompting the looking?
- 10:52Because sometimes the brain can decide on its own accord, I'm going to look here, I'll
- 10:56pay attention to your website.
- 10:58I will read your thought leadership paper or it might be going according to its own devices
- 11:06and at some point, something makes it look the title of the book.
- 11:11So if you picture these two dimensions and now forming quadrants, it's possible that
- 11:16at some point, somebody makes you look externally, somebody might prompt you to look internally,
- 11:22or at some point, you might decide to look externally yourself or you might decide to
- 11:25look internally yourself and go for some moments of introspection.
- 11:29So perhaps for the rest of our conversation, we can attach some practical guidelines around
- 11:34each one of these quadrants.
- 11:36But if you're thinking who makes you look, then it's really two quadrants, somebody that's
- 11:40prompting you to look outside or inside of you.
- 11:44Interesting.
- 11:45And is this the same regardless of whether this is, to say, sales presentation or an investor
- 11:50pitch for funding, an internal presentation, speaking on stage, are these principles cross-cutting?
- 11:59Yes, I've looked for principles that would go beyond the nature of the stimulus and
- 12:05also would transcend some demographics.
- 12:07For instance, it shouldn't matter that you are 35 or 65 and it shouldn't matter that you
- 12:14are from California or from China.
- 12:17What are some principles that are universal and you can abide by regardless of your population
- 12:24that you're addressing?
- 12:25Because I know that at some point, it's not possible to control the demographics.
- 12:30You will have a non-homogeneous mix of people who are coming to listen to you.
- 12:35Yeah, that makes a lot of sense.
- 12:37So can we get practical?
- 12:39I would be curious to hear from you.
- 12:41Let's say we're launching a new product and this product is, I mean, pick something.
- 12:48Is it a toothpaste?
- 12:49Is it something really new and innovative, but what catches people's attention?
- 12:54So if we think about Quadrant One, you're looking at the external world and somebody is prompting
- 13:01you to look.
- 13:02So that means this organization that's now launching a new product is responsible for
- 13:07getting someone's attention externally.
- 13:10There are some things that are fairly intuitive in terms of manipulating the physical properties
- 13:14of some stimulation.
- 13:15Like, for instance, you would have color to impress you with.
- 13:18You have sounds.
- 13:19You would have the size of your stimulus.
- 13:22Sometimes when everything is small, something that is big captures your attention.
- 13:25It goes the other way around, too, by the way, if everything is big in your surroundings,
- 13:28something that is very tiny will capture your attention.
- 13:32But take color, for instance.
- 13:33I like to debunk some myths because sometimes, as a neuroscientist, I'll get the, especially
- 13:38focusing on business content, I'll get the question, well, what color is better is in our
- 13:43color palette?
- 13:45That's not really the most important question for you.
- 13:48The most important question is, can you demote some things so that other things can stand
- 13:53out?
- 13:54So removing color quite often is the way to go.
- 13:58So you emphasize by de-emphasizing, ideal with a lot of complex content and B2B type
- 14:04of products.
- 14:05They're not as sexy as that toothpaste that you mentioned or some shoes that you might
- 14:08wear.
- 14:09And in a complex world where a lot of communicators want everything to be vying for attention
- 14:15because this segment is important and it's other segment is critical and this thing you
- 14:19should just wait until you hear this.
- 14:22At some point, the practical way to look at this is to say, what can I de-emphasize and
- 14:27de-grade in some way so that this one thing that's really the most important even has
- 14:32a chance to stand out?
- 14:34That's very interesting and I think that's one of the big mistakes I think companies make
- 14:38that it is too busy, there's too much going on, whether that's a presentation or speech
- 14:42by the CEO or a LinkedIn post, it's just overwhelming and the message gets lost.
- 14:49Exactly.
- 14:50You know, it wasn't until the late 1800s, early 1900s at the word priority and started
- 14:58gaining a plural like right now, even in business meetings, you might hear the question, what
- 15:03are our priorities for this year?
- 15:06What are our priorities for this sales presentation or an investor deck?
- 15:11That should only be a singular and in communication, I usually say, what is your main message
- 15:17and only one, it can only be singular and then of course, a few supporting points, the
- 15:21more clarity you have around that's one single idea, the easier it is to then create
- 15:27some attention getting strategies around that.
- 15:31I love our thinking is very much aligned on this.
- 15:33One objective, one key message and yes, a few supporting points, if you like.
- 15:38So once I have someone's attention, how do I persuade them because that's the ultimate
- 15:44objective, moving someone to action and that can be in a meeting to say, right, let's
- 15:49move forward on this project or it can be for someone to buy toothpaste, but how do
- 15:53persuade?
- 15:55So the two go hand in hand because usually you would have captured attention with some
- 16:00principles that already alludes to some motivational drivers, those could be extrinsing
- 16:07motivation and tracing motivation, we can talk about those in a moment, but make sure
- 16:11that even at the act of grabbing attention, you're already thinking beyond that segment,
- 16:17like for instance, another thing that you can use in terms of attracting attention externally,
- 16:23so making somebody look in the outside world could be this notion of being provocative.
- 16:29And not that many people, especially to be, are developing the courage to even be provocative,
- 16:35usually you want to maintain some status quo and not really challenge what's happening,
- 16:43stay a bit too traditional in my view, sometimes people don't expose assumptions.
- 16:50So the moment that for instance, you have developed that courage to be a bit more provocative,
- 16:54so you might question a social norm, you might expose those assumptions, you might take
- 16:58the perspective of somebody else, persuasion follows because if I expose some assumptions
- 17:04that I thought you had, and I give you that very brief aha moment, already you're igniting
- 17:10this notion of I'm going to stay with you for a while and I'm increasing the chances
- 17:15to act.
- 17:16And how much of that is based on trust?
- 17:20Ooh, of course, that's a strong segment that can come at play.
- 17:26Here's how we calculate trust by the way from a neuroscience perspective because we often
- 17:30look at that and in the business world, you want to come across a stressed worthiness.
- 17:36Here's some variables that we monitor in our neuroscience experiments.
- 17:40On the cognitive side, I look at attention, so that comes from the EEG signal and I calculated
- 17:45across time.
- 17:46So are people likely to stay with you for a while?
- 17:49I look at cognitive workload, slash working memory.
- 17:53Our listeners might be familiar with these concepts, working memory means how long you're
- 17:57willing to hold something in your mind for a while until you complete a cognitive task.
- 18:03Usually the cognitive task that we give people in the experiments is to listen to a vendor
- 18:07and to decide kind of in the back of their minds is this a person that they're willing
- 18:11to listen to again and has that person pick their interest enough or is this a person
- 18:16that you might not necessarily want to hear from?
- 18:19I also look at fatigue and I look at the motivation to keep watching and the likelihood
- 18:24that you'll then act.
- 18:26So that's cognitively speaking.
- 18:28Effectively speaking, I look at two dimensions.
- 18:31One is valence, meaning how much people enjoy the experience and I look at a rousal,
- 18:36which means how alert and awake people are during that experience.
- 18:41Those two dimensions, by the way, are the foundation of all our emotional states.
- 18:46So if you're speaking about trust, the way that we calculate that from a neuroscience perspective,
- 18:51I will combine the EEG and ECG signal and we will look for positive valence, meaning
- 18:56that your buyers are liking what you have to offer.
- 19:00I also look for low arousal because you don't always have to get people so amped up when
- 19:04they trust you.
- 19:05They can relax a bit more and also counterintuitively enough, I look for a lower level of attention
- 19:13because when you trust a situation, I can let my guard down a little bit more.
- 19:19So for example, if you're presenting your products virtually, sharing the camera is mandatory
- 19:24because that's when we're seeing this combination of positive valence, low arousal, low attention.
- 19:30If you are presenting your products virtually, for instance, we're seeing that even the
- 19:34attire that you wear can contribute to that.
- 19:37So for instance, I calculated the impact of casual wear, like somebody just came from
- 19:42the gym and they're just wearing a t-shirt or they're wearing a button up shirt that's
- 19:46conditioned to, or they're wearing a shirt and the jacket, who are noticing that the
- 19:50formal attire is indicative of that notion of trust.
- 19:56You know that one of the more intriguing findings, as people are questioning the impact of AI
- 20:03on the business brain, I noticed that if you are using an AI tool, for instance, to improve
- 20:08your skills in some way, perhaps, let's just say, handling customer objections.
- 20:12Now there are AI tools for that that you can go at it again and again and again.
- 20:17The more that you pick a skill and you practice it with sameness, it's the same thing again
- 20:23and again and again.
- 20:24You tend to trust that situation more so consistency is also associated with this notion of trust.
- 20:30Wow, that is quite a lot to take in.
- 20:33I just wondered, let's say, I'm a CEO, I'm on stage or just presenting, how can I do
- 20:40to garner trust from my audience now understanding all of that, because there are things, it doesn't
- 20:46seem to me that I can necessarily control these things except for maybe what I wear, but what
- 20:51can I do in practical terms to increase trust?
- 20:55So let's summarize what we've mentioned so far.
- 20:58We already said that the moment that you're showing up in person, so if you're the CEO
- 21:02on your own stage, already people can see you and that's a plus.
- 21:06If you're virtual, make sure people can see you, that would be a plus.
- 21:10You can already control your attire.
- 21:12Make sure that you're not just being yourself because authenticity often is linked to trust
- 21:19and some people believe, especially the higher up you're in the hierarchy that you have earned
- 21:25the position in which you can just be yourself.
- 21:29But from a business perspective, we would say that's not the best guideline, not even
- 21:34the guideline that your mom may have told you, be your best self.
- 21:37You want to be your best self in the service of an audience.
- 21:42So controlling your attire is definitely within your reach.
- 21:45I calculated something else just recently, which is the language that you use to promote
- 21:50your services or your ideas.
- 21:53And the reason for that is because I've seen an increase in the amount of profanity that
- 21:58some people use.
- 21:59Have you noticed this?
- 22:01Yes, absolutely.
- 22:03So sometimes, especially yet again, the higher in the ranks, people can might be thinking
- 22:09that they have earned the right to just not apply any filters.
- 22:14So I look to see what do curse words do to the buyer's brain?
- 22:19Are they ready for those in a sales or a commercial context?
- 22:23So I had the group that listened to a sales presentation, for instance, and these were
- 22:27potential buyers where there was no cursing.
- 22:31And then I increased to the amount of profanity that the presenter would have shared.
- 22:37And group number four went all the way, some words that I'm sure that you can picture.
- 22:44And that is definitely not a situation that you would associate with trust, even though
- 22:50that may be your style.
- 22:52There isn't a corollary though to that finding, which is if you are indeed the more colorful
- 22:58linguistic speaker, and you do like to use salty language, there is one area in which
- 23:05you can annihilate all the negative consequences for cursing, which is if you prepare the audience
- 23:11for it.
- 23:12I suspect that the reason why audiences did not do so well in terms of attention, in
- 23:16terms of that valence, overall in terms of that trust, is because they weren't prepared
- 23:21for it.
- 23:22And those colorful words took them by surprise.
- 23:26Because by the way, biologically speaking, it's always bad for the brain.
- 23:29The brain wants to predict what happens next.
- 23:32So if you want to give people the joy of predicting, then be preantive about that style.
- 23:39That's interesting.
- 23:40What you said about surprise, I need to double click on that, because it is a key element
- 23:44of storytelling, right?
- 23:45That there is a surprise.
- 23:47That's where the emotion is stirred, and that's where people get excited and pay attention.
- 23:53It is a counter-intuitive statement, because the brain has a few functions, and one of
- 24:00them is to be able to predict the next moment.
- 24:03So whenever we want to determine where to go next, what to do next, truly by this product,
- 24:09versus this product you're talking about persuasion, the more you're able to predict, with some
- 24:15accuracy, what the next moment will bring you, the more likely that you will go in the
- 24:20favor of that idea or that product or that cause.
- 24:24What a surprise, but a failure to predict.
- 24:27So I remember this image that I used to use in one of my workshops.
- 24:31You would see an X shell, and then the X shell would be broken, and outcomes a little
- 24:35baby elephant out of that tiny little X shell.
- 24:39And it was just a very brief moment, but that moment you could not predict.
- 24:43So therefore you would react.
- 24:46These people treat surprise and novelty as being equal terms, but they're not.
- 24:51Novelty is something that you indeed haven't seen or experienced before.
- 24:55Surprised is something that you have seen or experienced before, but did not expect,
- 25:00like an X shell you have seen, a baby elephant you may have seen, the two combined you did
- 25:04not expect to see that combination.
- 25:07And the difference between what the brain expects to see and what happens in real life
- 25:12is how the brain learns.
- 25:14This is why stories that will have that pure surprising moment will be powerful to the
- 25:19brain, if the surprise is indeed worthwhile, because that would be a learning, a teachable
- 25:25moment.
- 25:26Not all stories have amazing surprising elements, but when you do.
- 25:31So as a practical guideline, I would invite anyone listening to reflect on their content
- 25:36and how they're promoting their products or services.
- 25:39And at some point, take the brain on one path and derail it unexpectedly.
- 25:46Can you jolt the familiar?
- 25:49Because otherwise people make the mistake of jolting the brain with too much novelty,
- 25:53like this is new and this is new and this is new and this is new cognitively that becomes
- 25:57tiring versus giving the brain something that's familiar already that has some cognitive
- 26:02ease and then derailing it unexpectedly.
- 26:06Ideally with your key message, right?
- 26:08So if you have the clarity of the key message, then you can use it to amplify it and make
- 26:14it memorable.
- 26:15It's true.
- 26:16Like for instance, you know, in one of the workshops that I teach on the neuroscience
- 26:20of memorable content, I remind participants that the business brain forgets what you're
- 26:25sharing with it about 90% after 48 hours.
- 26:29Sometimes even more, we're lucky if they take away 10% from your communication.
- 26:34And I'm not so concerned about the amount of forgetting the 90% as I am about being
- 26:39in control of the 10 because otherwise, if you're not deliberate about what you want people
- 26:44to take away, not only do people forget a lot, but the little they remember is random.
- 26:51And that's why sales cycles are longer, for example, because people will listen to you
- 26:54and when a buying group that's increasingly getting bigger will go away and not take
- 27:00the exact same message, then deliberation is a lot longer.
- 27:04So you want to aspire after a unified memory.
- 27:07So my main message for that workshop is control your 10%.
- 27:12So notice how that's phrased.
- 27:13It's not phrased with words.
- 27:14You may have not heard before or something that just doesn't roll off the tongue.
- 27:19The word control already I know is juicy to the brain.
- 27:2210% is just a percentage.
- 27:24You will have heard a percentage before.
- 27:27Combining them and something that you may not necessarily be all that familiar with,
- 27:31but on the background of some familiarity, and that's a good combination.
- 27:36I'm hoping that all of you listening will strike in your value propositions.
- 27:40Yeah, and it resonates with the work I do day to day, where I tell something
- 27:47similar to my coach of clients, for instance, when we talk about the key message and how to get it across
- 27:52and how to make it memorable and sticky, and it goes in the same direction.
- 27:56Now, one of the received wisdom's axioms, if you like, is that you should tell people what
- 28:01you're going to tell them, then tell them, and then tell them what you just told them.
- 28:05I think it's got the three T's.
- 28:07I never believed in that.
- 28:08I don't like it.
- 28:09If people do that, but I'd be curious to hear what you think about repetition.
- 28:14I'm so glad that you mentioned this because there is repetition and then there is repetition.
- 28:19And we can definitely debunk the T3 as it's called principle.
- 28:24You're going to tell them, then tell them, then tell them what you told them.
- 28:27I had a hunch that this was not so.
- 28:29And from a neuroscience perspective, I wanted to study this.
- 28:32So picture the study.
- 28:33You invite groups of buyers and group number one.
- 28:37You give them a sales presentation and some sort of value propositions in a way that is unstructured.
- 28:43And you just simply have a conversation with a customer.
- 28:46I'm sure that everyone listening at some point would have been part of a context like this,
- 28:49what a seller says.
- 28:50I'm just going to meet with a customer and just simply have a conversation.
- 28:53So everything is very fluid.
- 28:55Group number two had the exact same content except at the beginning of the sequence,
- 29:00they had an agenda.
- 29:01I'm sure you've been in this context where somebody says this is what we'll cover in this session.
- 29:05And you have some bullet points.
- 29:07And then you do a lot of telling after that.
- 29:09Group number three is this proverbial T3 principle where we had an agenda in the beginning.
- 29:14This is what we'll cover.
- 29:16Then you do a lot of telling and at the end, you summarize what you just told them.
- 29:20So that's essentially the T3.
- 29:22So these two strong points where you announce what's going to happen,
- 29:25you do the telling and then you summarize.
- 29:28And then group four, which is my preferred one and I'm hoping that
- 29:32like of this conversation, you'll abide by this principle.
- 29:36You had a lot more of what we call cognitive closure.
- 29:40Cognitive closure means that the brain is constantly in search of decisive and non-ambiguous
- 29:46knowledge.
- 29:47The moment you show up in front of your audience and you say, this is so.
- 29:50I control your 10% for instance, which is my mantra.
- 29:54Then I'm giving you the certainty that the next time you apply that,
- 29:58something predictable will happen.
- 29:59For instance, you will stay on people's minds.
- 30:02And the more frequently you cognitively close these concepts for your audiences,
- 30:07the more they will stay with you and remember that message.
- 30:10So you come up with one being mantra, no more than three or four supporting points
- 30:14like you were advising early and you come back to that again and again and again and again
- 30:20throughout the entire sequence.
- 30:21You also end with that and the more frequent cognitive closure you have,
- 30:26the stronger, not only the attention, the lower the fatigue by the way.
- 30:30So the more that you engage in this repetition of the exact same thing,
- 30:34the less fatigue people become.
- 30:36And also the sharper their memory is for that message after 48 hours.
- 30:40Otherwise for the tea tree principle by the way,
- 30:42not only did they have the lowest of the memory scores out of the four groups,
- 30:47they were also more tired.
- 30:49And ironically, they are the only group that had a eureka effect,
- 30:52like in a ham moment.
- 30:53And I suspect it is because if you only tell people what's important in the beginning
- 30:58and you summarize it at the end, that's when you're giving them that feeling,
- 31:02oh, so that was what was important, but by then it's too late and your presentation is over.
- 31:07Very interesting, either that's fascinating.
- 31:09I think I have a theory about this.
- 31:11And I think what you described, the high retention,
- 31:15that sounds to me like a master communicator who's just elegantly weaving in the key message
- 31:20into the speech or presentation.
- 31:22The person who uses that tea tree is I think someone who is not a master communicator and
- 31:27uses it in a former leg way.
- 31:29And my experience is that whenever you use a certain formula in an obvious way,
- 31:35people roll their eyes internally and think, oh, here we go again.
- 31:38The same, I think, is true for what I call the shit sandwich,
- 31:41when sometimes sometimes still recommended when you give someone feedback,
- 31:44oh, start with something positive, then the constructive criticism,
- 31:48and then something positive again.
- 31:49So you end on a positive note.
- 31:50The problem is everyone knows these formulas,
- 31:52and therefore they not only lost their effectiveness,
- 31:55but they backfire because the other person knows you're using a formula on them to persuade you,
- 32:00and that's what I think causes the backfire.
- 32:03It could be true, and it's an interesting thing that you're bringing up around formulas.
- 32:10With this guideline that I'm recommending,
- 32:12it's still somewhat of a formula except that it's a repeated formula
- 32:16through which you're helping somebody else's brain detect patterns.
- 32:21Because this is what will happen.
- 32:22If you are that CEO and you are on stage,
- 32:24and you mention something that you believe is critical,
- 32:26not only for your business, but for your customers as well.
- 32:29Ideally, you're phrasing these things from your customer's perspective,
- 32:32and you mention that message once, and then you say it again,
- 32:36and then you say it again, and then you say it again,
- 32:38and then you say it again, and then you say it again, and then you say it again,
- 32:41and only then maybe people notice it for the first time.
- 32:45Sometimes people shy away from that much repetition
- 32:48because they think, well, maybe I'll come across as nagging or remedial,
- 32:53or if you're married, exactly what I'm talking about.
- 32:58And indeed, there is a very fine line between repetition and nagging,
- 33:02but in business, especially when content is highly complex,
- 33:06and people will forget most of what you said after about a minute and a half,
- 33:11two minutes intervals, after which you have to refresh,
- 33:15if you really want to say in charge of what people say.
- 33:19I've noticed this in terms of practical guidelines.
- 33:21I studied what happens in a five-minute presentation,
- 33:24not only five minutes.
- 33:26If you repeat your main message five times,
- 33:29and that gets you to, after 48 hours, people remembering the precision,
- 33:35what you want them to remember,
- 33:36then I increase the presentation time.
- 33:38What happens if you deliver something for 10 minutes?
- 33:41Does it matter if you repeat now for six times?
- 33:44So six times is a minimum amount of repetition.
- 33:46So I tried to then 12-time repetition in a 10-minute frame.
- 33:51Then I increased that even more.
- 33:52So I said 20 minutes.
- 33:54What happens then?
- 33:54How much should you repeat?
- 33:56Six times is still the minimum 12 times as ideal.
- 34:00But in that research, I asked the question,
- 34:03what happens if in 20 minutes you repeat your main message 24 times?
- 34:08Would anybody after 48 hours come back and say,
- 34:12boy, or boy, there was just this one message that came up again and again?
- 34:16Not one person in that group came back to complaining
- 34:20of too much repetition and in business content.
- 34:24That's fascinating.
- 34:24And I love it.
- 34:26And often tells you that you're the chief repetition officer.
- 34:29You just need to repeat your key message,
- 34:31your vision for the come over and over and over again,
- 34:33because we know from studies that in many companies,
- 34:35the majority of employees don't know what the company's strategy is
- 34:38and don't understand it.
- 34:39So thank you for backing me up.
- 34:41Just to clarify, I'm formulas,
- 34:42mess their structures.
- 34:43I'm all in favor.
- 34:44I'm all about that.
- 34:45I just think there are few which are basically blunt instrument by now.
- 34:50And it is, ideally, I'm using it as the speaker presented,
- 34:54but the audience doesn't know this is happening.
- 34:56It just looks very natural.
- 34:58What else can we do to control the 10 percent?
- 35:02See, I like that that mantra already in them,
- 35:04hoping that if we were to conduct a study with our audience
- 35:08after 48 hours, they will remember that.
- 35:11So we talked about repetition, which indeed is the mother of memory.
- 35:16And obviously, clarification of that 10 percent message
- 35:20is by far step number one,
- 35:21because if it's clear to you what they should pay attention to
- 35:24and remember, it's more clear to them.
- 35:26If it's nebulous to you,
- 35:28it will be more nebulous to them.
- 35:30I want to bring a very important aspect associated with a mistake
- 35:34that I notice people make a lot in business content,
- 35:38especially the more complex it becomes,
- 35:41which is maintaining a consistent mental model.
- 35:44Remember how we're talking about trust and consistency?
- 35:47Yes.
- 35:48When you talk about your 10 percent message,
- 35:50and now we understand the importance of the repetition,
- 35:53make sure that whatever mental model you associate with that
- 35:56also stays consistent all throughout the sequence.
- 35:59Because the mistake I see is that people present their message in one format,
- 36:03let's just say at minute two.
- 36:05You might have one main message and maybe a vertical arrangement of your points.
- 36:10Then comes minute five or six.
- 36:12It's still the main message.
- 36:13It's still the same points,
- 36:15but now they are horizontally arranged.
- 36:17And now comes minute 10,
- 36:19and it's still the same points and the same main message,
- 36:22but now we see them as a chart of sorts.
- 36:25And then the presentation continues,
- 36:27and minutes later we still see perhaps a reflection of the same points,
- 36:30but now arrange in some images and some other kind of format.
- 36:34The more we mess with people's mental models,
- 36:37the harder it is for you to be in charge and control that 10 percent after 48 hours and beyond.
- 36:44Because one of the main reasons for forgetting is this notion called interference,
- 36:48where some things will interfere with other things,
- 36:51and after a while you won't be able to tell which one was which.
- 36:54So the stability of your mental model will definitely help you control that 10 percent.
- 37:00Interesting.
- 37:01Also that the mental model is so important in memorization retention
- 37:05and getting a message across what common mistakes or other mistakes do you see
- 37:10presenters, speakers, business communicators make?
- 37:14Well, here's one that may be harsh to hear at first,
- 37:17but then in light of what we just talked about,
- 37:19it might be a little easier to consume.
- 37:21If you are indeed using slideware and many people do,
- 37:25thank you slides must die.
- 37:28And the reason for this is because if we're talking about this 10 percent message
- 37:33and keeping it consistent and repeated and by the way distinct from everything else to fight
- 37:38that interference, at the end of your sequence you don't want to end up with something that
- 37:43just simply says thank you or Q&A or just your global slide,
- 37:48but rather you want to reinforce that message because I'm sure that many of our listeners
- 37:53have heard of the primacy effect, the recent see effect,
- 37:56the longer the sequence goes, the more we would have already forgotten the beginning.
- 38:00So that is just gone to oblivion to begin with.
- 38:04Now the last segment has even more potency for your audience's attention and memory.
- 38:10Why would you want to waste that one final segment or you can make that one final impression
- 38:15with a thank you slide or Q&A?
- 38:17Besides, if you simply have a Q&A slide and you're asking people,
- 38:21do you have any questions based on what I just said and you don't give them any cues?
- 38:26Coming up with questions is going to be appearing as if it's not marked by cognitive ease,
- 38:31it's like now I have to strain my brain to come up with some questions.
- 38:34Whereas if you still have your 10 percent slide there with some supporting points,
- 38:38you're giving people something to react to and you're associating your content with some cognitive
- 38:42ease. I totally agree. I hate these slides. Thank you for your time, I think it's the worst.
- 38:49And I don't mean isn't it too arbitrary. I think we've, I've used them, everyone has used them,
- 38:52but at some point I stopped using them because I learned more about primacy and
- 38:56recency bias. And I think you could say something similar about the beginning of talks and presentations,
- 39:01right? So this is prime real estate and often people say, thank you, I'm glad I'm being here.
- 39:06And to me this is really not ideal.
- 39:09I like your perspective and I also sometimes get the question, well, if people
- 39:14only remember 10 percent, let's just give them that, like forget the 90. And that's not the
- 39:20right perspective. The right perspective is you're still keeping all of your 90 because that's
- 39:26what is in service of the 10. So one mistake that I often hear people make is when they say,
- 39:34if you remember nothing else, remember this. I would love for all of us to erase that phrase
- 39:40from our vocabulary and instead say what's most important for you to remember and for your
- 39:46business and for your own customers is this. And everything else that you hear me share is in
- 39:51service of this one main message and the few supporting points. This way you do justice to your
- 39:5790. And by the way, you're talking about storytelling, a good story is a good one, not because
- 40:04people keep it simple, but because of all the elaboration that happens around a course set of
- 40:09ideas. And if that course set of ideas is very clear to your audience, then you know,
- 40:13for to add the extra details and that 90 will seem palatable and juicy even because they serve
- 40:20to emphasize and bring to surface this important message that you come back to every so often.
- 40:25I really really like this idea of control the 10 percent, but make sure that 90 percent are in
- 40:29service of the 10 percent. That is such a strong idea, which I will definitely take away from
- 40:35this conversation. Where does priming fit into all of this?
- 40:40Ooh, I like that question so much because priming is one of those techniques that is
- 40:44underused in business content. Priming means that you're showing your audiences one stimulus,
- 40:52and because of that you're influencing how the next stimulus is being processed. So for
- 40:56instance, if all of our listeners here did not speak Chinese, but they came to a lab room for
- 41:04an experiment and a scientist would ask them, what do you think this Chinese symbol means? And
- 41:09you have no idea. But to some people you're showing them prior to that symbol, a positive picture,
- 41:15and to some people you're showing a negative picture, people who were primed positively would
- 41:20more likely associate that Chinese symbol with something positive, and the opposite for the other
- 41:25group they would associate that symbol with something negative. So it's possible to show the brain
- 41:30something or tell the brain something and influence how they process the next moment.
- 41:35This is an important technique for you because quite often the reason people don't pay attention
- 41:40and they don't remember is because they're not ready to pay attention and remember. And priming
- 41:46can help you jolt the brain out of their either a distracted state or a multitasking state.
- 41:53So for instance, in a lot of business presentations that I help people develop, we would have your
- 41:57predictable slides, your template high slides, things that the brain, the business brain has learned
- 42:03to expect in a business context. And right before something that you would have been filled with
- 42:08charts and data and all the substance that you're alluding to, we would put in a more intense moment.
- 42:15Like just this morning I was sharing some some slides and this one slide said fast implementation.
- 42:21Obviously the message is the related to business is not like you're taking them off the charts
- 42:25somewhere. Said fast implementation and you just a few split seconds you will see a cookie that
- 42:31was at first cookie dough and suddenly you'll see a baking and just coming to why fasting
- 42:36implementation in a very, very speedy way. I was speaking of fast implementation. I remember
- 42:41developing another one where you saw the raw apple ingredients in just a few split seconds that
- 42:46became an apple pie. You was just a very fast implementation. And because that's not something
- 42:51that you would have expected to see in a business sequence like this yet again recognizable you see
- 42:56that's the surprise something that they have seen before or did not expect. That strong intense
- 43:02moment gets the brain in an alert state for the next slide. So it's not so much that you want people
- 43:07to remember the cookie or the apple pie. You really want to get the brain in a ready state to be
- 43:12prepared for a message that you really believe to be important. Fascinating. And what's the
- 43:17difference between priming and framing? Oh so I really like that question a lot. So with priming
- 43:25you're getting the brain in a ready state. With framing you're getting the brain to see something
- 43:31from a different perspective. And sometimes they may agree with that. Sometimes they may not. So
- 43:38now some system of beliefs may come into play. So priming is a little bit more implicit with a
- 43:45reframe. You're asking people explicitly to and more consciously to reflect on something.
- 43:51I'd like the notion of a reframe because if it's done well then you can give the brain that
- 43:57aha moment and that element of surprise. So perhaps what ties the two concepts together the
- 44:04priming and the reframing is that moment of ooh I haven't really expected this and I haven't
- 44:11thought of it that way. Interesting. So priming first framing next. Yes. Yeah why not? I like the
- 44:18sequence already. So for instance I was just doing a neuroscience experiment just a few months
- 44:23ago. So this is just fairly fresh off the presses. Or of course I had to see how the brain reacts
- 44:29to an AI tool versus how the brain reacts to a human. We have already seen some merits by the way
- 44:36of the AI tool compared to the human. But in this one experiment I was looking to see how the brain
- 44:42reacts when it's interacting with an AI tool for coaching purposes. So let's just say I'm a
- 44:46seller and I want to improve my objection handling skills. And in objection handling one of the steps
- 44:54that we are teaching people through this AI tool is called a reframe. And the reframe will go
- 44:58like this. The customer will say yeah sure I can understand your sales pitch and your solution but
- 45:04your price is too high. And the way to address that is you obviously have to acknowledge the
- 45:09customer objections. Say I understand that this is about pricing. You're not supposed to say
- 45:14but you're supposed to say and and one way to look at this is to consider other companies that
- 45:20also have high prices like for instance Patagonia. Their prices are high but they still have customers
- 45:26because their quality is high. In the same vein we too offer higher prices and you can expect
- 45:33the higher quality. So that would be the reframe. But prior to this in light of our conversation
- 45:38I would have primed the brain to already be ready for something that's insightful. Otherwise you
- 45:43might have the best reframe but if people were distracted or multitasking they could just entirely
- 45:48miss that. Yeah thank you that makes a little sense to me. And a question that I'll be thinking
- 45:54about a lot. Let's take a sharp left term. For a long time I've been arguing that communication
- 45:59is a learnable skill set. So we can all learn to be better public speakers. We can learn a new language.
- 46:04We can train our voices but it's something innate about strong communicators. Their communication
- 46:10gene were some people are just naturally better at it. I wonder if some of our innate abilities would
- 46:17transfer a bit more easily. Easily for instance some people may be even as a set point happier
- 46:27than other people. And because of that you might have some more energy for some topics versus
- 46:33other topics. Speaking of energy some people may innately have more of these dopamine receptors
- 46:38as a result. Probably have that drive innately we might be more curious about some things versus
- 46:46other things. So we may remember some things better than other things which the more you know
- 46:53the more you can learn and therefore share with other people. So yeah there might be some
- 46:58something innate traits. More recently by the way we started associating some neuroscience
- 47:01markers with personality traits like an introvert versus an extrovert or some openness to experiences.
- 47:09Beyond those though so you may have been blessed with some of these things or not. I like your
- 47:15perspective in the sense of some of these things are teachable moments and skills that you can
- 47:21create for yourself. And very few things about persuasion in general feel natural anyway like
- 47:26you would have had to work at it. And like you very wisely mentioned earlier the brain detects
- 47:31plastics as some of these skills and techniques have lost their luster. Luckily though it is
- 47:39possible to still convince the brain and the brain does take bribes. So wonder for example for
- 47:45your next communication artifact what could be a reward that you're giving to somebody else's
- 47:51brain to even award you attention and memory because those could be at some point effortful acts.
- 47:58And one way to look at rewards is to not offer them each time like you might say you pay attention
- 48:03to this and you might get a discount or you're looking at this website you add something to the
- 48:08cart and if you don't complete your cart purchase some companies are now wiring our brains that we
- 48:13expect a discount 48 hours later or even 24 sometimes even hours later just a few hours.
- 48:20Consider your words that you're offering on an intermittent schedule so sometimes you meet your
- 48:25customers and you give them everything. Sometimes you may give them just a little bit less and
- 48:30sometimes you might give them nothing at all and silence is the best reward. The less people can
- 48:36predict the rewards that they will get for you the more they will continue the behavior because the
- 48:41brain wants to predict like we said and if you don't know and something is coming you will persist in it
- 48:47until the resolution happens. Wow amazing carbon-silent thank you so much for this really insightful
- 48:55and like the conversation much much appreciated and wherever listening mate you look is the title
- 49:01of Carmen's new book which is highly recommended it dives deep into what we've discussed today but
- 49:07also gives you chance to really understand these concepts at a very simple level because you're
- 49:13doing a great job of making it accessible for us non-cognitive Euro scientists. Where can people
- 49:19find it more about you? You can find me on LinkedIn Carmen Simon if you enjoy some of these
- 49:26neuroscience experiments I have some videos around those on YouTube I'm just about to open
- 49:32a community so maybe you're not can stay in touch and I'll share the link to that community where
- 49:37you can see the science of slides. I mean treat by slides because they're such a universal medium
- 49:42and I think with them we can make a profound difference and I'm hoping that all these guidelines
- 49:47will indeed help you control your time percent. Control your time percent thank you what's your
- 49:52best piece of communication advice Carmen? In addition to that at the moment that you can control
- 49:58your time percent you're more likely to put a memory in people's brains and know this your
- 50:04customers your internal teams even your families and your teenagers will make decisions in your
- 50:11favorite based on what they remember not on what they forget. Thank you that is wonderful that's
- 50:16a wonderful piece of advice and that would definitely take a lot of away from our conversation
- 50:20control your 10% make sure that 90% are in service of the 10% and make sure you not only bring
- 50:27your best self but insurance in service often audience I just like that idea so much and I really
- 50:33really appreciate you and that you think of the time and appreciate your book and appreciate all
- 50:37of you thank you for this and have an inspired week and see you all next week. Thank you so much
- 50:42everyone it's it's been a wonderful conversation and I look forward to hearing about your successes
- 50:47as you control your time.