Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Minor’s Counsel 101: What You Need to Know When Counsel is Appointed with Hon. Sonia B. Dujan & Hon. Kendra Thomas
Transcript
- 0:06Welcome to Miners Council 101, what you need
- 0:09to know when council is appointed. I'm Alapoli
- 0:12Castro, CLE advisor for the Beverly Hills Bar
- 0:15Association. Today's program is presented by
- 0:18the family law section. Our family law section
- 0:20is sponsored by White, Zuckerman, Warsavsky,
- 0:24Luna and Hunt LLP. They provide a wide variety
- 0:27of resources to complete almost any project,
- 0:30large or small. They also provide traditional
- 0:32accounting and tax practice services. We invite
- 0:35you to contact them to discuss your specific
- 0:37accounting needs and learn how they can be of
- 0:39service to you. I'm delighted to introduce today's
- 0:43speakers, Judge Sonia B. Dujon and Commissioner
- 0:46Kendra Thomas. Judge Dujon is currently assigned
- 0:50to Department F -48 at the Chatsworth Courthouse.
- 0:53Her judicial responsibilities primarily involve
- 0:55family law matters. She has a rich background
- 0:58in family law. Before her judicial appointment,
- 1:00she was in private practice for over 25 years
- 1:03and focused on custody issues and often served
- 1:05as minor counsel in family law and probate guardianship
- 1:08cases. Commissioner Thomas serves as a family
- 1:12law commissioner in the Los Angeles Superior
- 1:14Court, also at the Chatsworth Courthouse in Department
- 1:17F58. She presides over various family law matters
- 1:21and has been in that role since 2024. Commissioner
- 1:24Thomas has a rich background as a certified family
- 1:26law specialist. While she was in private practice,
- 1:29she founded her own firm and dedicated a significant
- 1:31part of her practice to representing children
- 1:33as court -appointed minors counsel. Commissioner
- 1:36Thomas previously served as co -chair of the
- 1:38BHBA section and currently sits on our Board
- 1:41of Governors. Judge Dijon and Commissioner Thomas,
- 1:44we're so thankful that you're here with us today
- 1:46and we can't wait to hear what you have to share
- 1:48with us. Thank you. Thank you so much, Ella.
- 1:53Okay, let me go ahead and share my screen. Okay.
- 2:15Welcome, everyone. We are delighted to be here.
- 2:21Why don't we get started, Judge Dujon, with the
- 2:24purpose and the role of Miners' Council? Yes.
- 2:28Okay, so thank you for having us. This is about
- 2:32how to work with Miners' Council, and it's important
- 2:36to start really at the beginning. What is the
- 2:39purpose? What is the role of Miners' Council?
- 2:44Minors Council will get a little bit more into
- 2:46it, but it's the legal framework comes from Family
- 2:51Code sections 3150 through 3153. And it's important
- 2:58to know that Minors Council is an advocate for
- 3:02the child's best interest, and Minors Council
- 3:06comes at this from the child's perspective. So
- 3:11it's a It's a third perspective They come in
- 3:18as a neutral, but they don't necessarily remain
- 3:22as a neutral because they have a client to represent
- 3:26and And they'll zealously argue over their for
- 3:31their clients best interest and There's a difference
- 3:39isn't there Commissioner Thomas between a minors
- 3:42council, a guardian ad litem, a mediator, even
- 3:47an evaluator. Can you talk a little bit about
- 3:53the differences mostly between minors council
- 3:56and a guardian ad litem? Oh, absolutely. In terms
- 3:59of a minor's counsel, that is a legal advocate
- 4:03who is representing the child in the capacity
- 4:08of attorney. Guardian Adlitem is a representative
- 4:11in a different capacity. And later on, you'll
- 4:14hear from Judge Dujon why the distinction is
- 4:17actually very important and why we really rely
- 4:22on not only the bench officer, but the other
- 4:24practitioners in the room to know the difference
- 4:26because when one is appointed as minors council,
- 4:30they are actually limited in their capacity.
- 4:34And when one is appointed as a guardian ad litem,
- 4:36that is a completely different hat completely.
- 4:39So I think it's going to be interesting to see.
- 4:42And we saw actually there's a case that we'll
- 4:45be discussing in the last couple of years where
- 4:48this has become a very important distinction.
- 4:52Yes. And it's also important If you're going
- 4:55into court and you're asking for minors counsel
- 4:58or you get minors counsel appointed whether you
- 5:00ask for it or not Minors counsel is also not
- 5:04an evaluator and a lot of times I think attorneys
- 5:10for parties like to ask for minors counsel instead
- 5:14of an evaluator because it'll be quicker because
- 5:18it might be less expensive, but it's really two
- 5:21very different roles and One cannot be interchanged
- 5:26for the other. Why not? Well, first of all, minors
- 5:32council is an attorney. An evaluator is a mental
- 5:35health professional. Different trainings, different
- 5:38purposes, different roles. And minors council
- 5:42really cannot go into court and give recommendations
- 5:45that are based on a psychological assessment
- 5:52of the family. That is not minors council's role
- 5:56or training. So one cannot be interchanged for
- 6:01the other. And I think a lot of times attorneys
- 6:04do ask for minors council instead of an evaluator,
- 6:09again, because of the cost and the time that
- 6:14it might take an evaluator to complete an evaluation.
- 6:19Miner's counsel will represent the minor child's
- 6:27wishes and their best interest. Sometimes they're
- 6:30not aligned, but minor's counsel, that's part
- 6:35of what they're charged for, is both best interest
- 6:38and expressed wishes of the minor. Judge Dujon,
- 6:44if they don't align, which one governs? Well,
- 6:48that's really up to the court, isn't it? I really
- 6:52think that's up to the court because I think
- 6:57Miners Council presents both and the court decides.
- 7:01I think usually it's best interest, especially
- 7:05when you've got teenagers that really just want
- 7:07to manipulate a situation, but it's usually best
- 7:11interest, but it's up to each judicial officer.
- 7:16My two cents. But where does the court get the
- 7:20authority to appoint Minors Council? And that's
- 7:23Family Code Section 3150. And the sections that
- 7:30follow, which is 3151, 3152, 3153, those are
- 7:37all important. And 3151 we'll get more into in
- 7:43a little bit, but it really gives It gives attorneys
- 7:48their rights and responsibilities for representing
- 7:53children. And 3153 governs how minors counsel
- 8:02are paid. So that's actually important for the
- 8:06people that are actually representing children.
- 8:14Why might a judge appoint Miners' Council? Commissioner
- 8:18Thomas, what do you think? Well, the absolute,
- 8:22I'm still struck by my first day in Chatsworth
- 8:24on my RFO calendar. The number of individual
- 8:29attorneys that I was hearing their matters and
- 8:32as I was getting to my ruling and it seemed like
- 8:35they may not be victorious, as kind of a Hail
- 8:38Mary, they shot up their hand and said, well,
- 8:40Your Honor, before you do that, you want Miners'
- 8:42Council. And I laugh at it because I fortunately
- 8:48being someone who has represented hundreds of
- 8:51children in court, I was not necessarily in the
- 8:55courtroom at the time that that happened, if
- 8:57that's how I ended up getting appointed. But
- 9:00the realities are that it was the first time
- 9:03I really needed to look at. why I would appoint
- 9:06a Minors Council. Now, I know Judge Dujan, I
- 9:09think I'm in the minority on this. I use Minors
- 9:11Council probably more sparingly than the other
- 9:16judicial officers that I know. I have a very,
- 9:20very interesting ethos in terms of when I want
- 9:25Minors Council appointed, what I'm looking for.
- 9:27And what I'm looking for when I'm appointing
- 9:30Minors Council is What is it, what information
- 9:34or advocacy do I need from a third party for
- 9:38this child to be represented? So merely because
- 9:41there's conflict involving the child, that's
- 9:43not enough for me to say, okay, let me go ahead
- 9:45and get a minors council involved. But I specifically
- 9:49want to understand what advocacy I need that's
- 9:53best served by this child having independent
- 9:55counsel. Many times that could be parents who
- 9:58were engaged in high conflict. That could be
- 10:01allegations of abuse, neglect, domestic violence.
- 10:05To the extent that a child is expressing a strong
- 10:09wish or is resisting visitation, there may be
- 10:13something that I feel independent advocacy would
- 10:15be helpful if there are allegations of mental
- 10:18health, substance abuse, capacity concerns, or
- 10:22sometimes I just want an independent. individual
- 10:26focused on the child to bring me admissible evidence.
- 10:30Because quite frankly, at the time that I'm making
- 10:32these decisions, I need to make whatever custody
- 10:35and visitation orders I make based on admissible
- 10:38evidence. And to the extent there's any type
- 10:40of complex medical education or cultural issue
- 10:43that I don't feel either parent or their counsel
- 10:47is in a position to address from the vantage
- 10:49point of the child, that's when I'm looking at
- 10:52that third party perspective or advocacy could
- 10:54be helpful. Judge Dujan, what about you? No,
- 10:59I agree. I think those are all. issues that may
- 11:03give rise to the appointment of minors council.
- 11:06I think there's also, I'll consider it whether
- 11:09when there's an issue of privilege, whether the
- 11:13minor child's privilege regarding their mental
- 11:16health treatment or their medical treatment should
- 11:20be waived or not waived. I'll appoint minors
- 11:25council maybe, or if there is some DCFS involvement,
- 11:31and sometimes there needs to be more information.
- 11:35Dependency hasn't filed a petition, opened a
- 11:40case, but there's DCFS involvement, and I may
- 11:45need some independent person that comes in as
- 11:50an independent to gather information as to what
- 11:53is happening, why. the situation is giving rise
- 11:58to DCFS involvement or if I need information
- 12:02from the child's perspective, right? A lot of
- 12:06times I feel that I may need some more input
- 12:11from the child's perspective and I'll appoint
- 12:13an attorney to help them. Or if there's a trial
- 12:18where the... child may testify on the issues
- 12:23of custody and visitation, and it's just to represent
- 12:27the child while they're testifying. It's just
- 12:32to get them ready to testify and assist them
- 12:35when they're testifying. But otherwise, a lot
- 12:39of the issues that Commissioner Thomas mentioned
- 12:42are also issues that I think would give rise
- 12:45possibly to the appointment of Minors Council.
- 12:48As a practical matter, you mentioned that when
- 12:51privilege issues are at stake, that's when you
- 12:54will consider appointing a minors council. At
- 12:57the point you make that appointment, how does
- 13:00that factor into the privilege and who holds
- 13:02the privilege once you appoint minors council?
- 13:05So minors council and we're pursuant to Family
- 13:10Code 3151 and we'll see it later a little bit
- 13:14too. They can assert or waive privilege on behalf
- 13:17of the minor child. So if there's an issue of
- 13:23privilege and the parents are arguing and I think
- 13:26that perhaps the minor child's therapy needs
- 13:30to remain privileged and confidential and they're
- 13:34not sure they want to, somebody wants to bring
- 13:36in the therapist and I'm concerned about preserving
- 13:40the child's relationship with their service provider.
- 13:44then I might appoint Miners Council to help with
- 13:47that determination whether privilege should be
- 13:52waived or not. But what are some other considerations
- 13:57that you make when appointing Miners Council
- 14:01Commissioner Thomas? Well, I'm definitely going
- 14:03to look at the age of the child, the maturity,
- 14:06the ability for them to participate with their
- 14:08minors council and at what level. I know that
- 14:12many, many times I may get the argument, well,
- 14:17the child doesn't want to see a parent or there's
- 14:19a strong refuse resist dynamic. I may actually
- 14:22look at the conduct that the child is participating
- 14:25in to figure out whether or not the child has
- 14:28the requisite maturity or whether I'm going to
- 14:31be enabling or emboldening them in the litigation
- 14:34if I give them their own advocate. I definitely
- 14:37look at the best interest, whether the best interest
- 14:40dictate them having an independent. representative,
- 14:45I look at the availability of qualified council,
- 14:47I look to funding. So I, to the extent that you
- 14:51raise your hand or you file your motion, tell
- 14:54me, what is your thought process in terms of
- 14:56how Miners Council will be paid for? Because
- 14:59to the extent I'm on the fence as to the probative
- 15:02value of a Miners Council, I'm going to look
- 15:05to finances as to why should the county be paying
- 15:09if it's not going to have such a probative effect
- 15:12relative to me determining the issues. And I
- 15:16also realize that there are there can be less
- 15:19intrusive means through which I can get the information.
- 15:23So I look at all of that in kind of a balancing
- 15:26act because I asked someone who acted as minors
- 15:29council, Judge Dujon, you know how intrusive
- 15:32it can be to now have a minors council coming
- 15:36into the life of not just the child, but also
- 15:39the child's family digging around for information.
- 15:42And you hope that that can be done the least
- 15:45intrusive way possible, but you definitely, there's
- 15:48definitely an impact. to making that type of
- 15:51order and appointing counsel for the minor child.
- 15:55What about you, Judge Dujon? What considerations
- 15:57do you look to? Yeah, no, I think they're the
- 16:00same. And I think that it's not just intrusive
- 16:02into the child's family. It's also intrusive
- 16:04into the child's school, again, mental health,
- 16:08even sometimes their extracurricular activities.
- 16:12If my nurse counsel has to talk to coaches or
- 16:17dance instructors or tutors. I mean, it can be
- 16:21very intrusive into the life of the child, right?
- 16:25So I think that I also like to proceed cautiously
- 16:29with it. And I also consider whether appointing
- 16:33minors counsel will delay the proceedings or,
- 16:37you know, will it help expedite? something in
- 16:40the proceedings or will it cause unnecessary
- 16:42delay? And I take that into account also when
- 16:46considering whether to appoint minors counsel
- 16:48or not. Here's my question Judge Dujan. I had
- 16:52mentioned that my first day I faced a lot of
- 16:56attorneys kind of raising their hand at the end
- 16:58of the hearing like give us minors counsel. Do
- 17:01you entertain that or do you require Miners Council
- 17:04to be requested with a properly pled and fully
- 17:08noticed request for order? Well, I certainly
- 17:14wouldn't entertain it when I'm giving my orders
- 17:18and that's when someone throws the Hail Mary
- 17:21at the end before, you know, it's all pronounced
- 17:24and I would not entertain that because that's
- 17:28just. really not liking the order and trying
- 17:31anything they can to avoid it. But I prefer that
- 17:37it's in a noticed motion so that the other side
- 17:40has notice, has due process. Hopefully there's
- 17:43a meet and confer and everyone can discuss it.
- 17:48If there's an agreement, they might even discuss
- 17:51a possible person for the role and how to pay.
- 17:55But if not, you know, I it's something that I'll
- 17:59adjudicate but there needs to be notice to the
- 18:01other side And I would agree with that, given
- 18:04the constitutional concerns when we are appointing
- 18:08a minors council, my preference is for, I mean,
- 18:11due process needs to be followed, there needs
- 18:13to be proper notice to the other side, a chance
- 18:15to respond, absent either an agreement or exceptional
- 18:19circumstances. Again, we do this for the best
- 18:21interest of the child, so best interest dictate,
- 18:24maybe ex parte or what have you, but all things
- 18:28considered, notice to everybody on both sides
- 18:31of council table is ideal. Yes, and so I know
- 18:35we talked about rights and responsibilities and
- 18:39and I think that Commissioner Thomas maybe if
- 18:44you talk a little bit about the form FL 323,
- 18:48which is the order appointing counsel for child
- 18:51and just really briefly why it's so important
- 18:54and what it is. Sure. So pursuant to Family Code
- 18:58Section 3150, that gives the court the power
- 19:01to appoint. At the time that we're appointing,
- 19:05we should be doing it on this form FL -323, which
- 19:08is the Order Appointing Council for a Child.
- 19:11Now, this order is going to set forth the reason
- 19:14for the appointment, the determination of fees,
- 19:17how minors' councils compensated, any additional
- 19:20orders. What I find most important The reason
- 19:25for appointment I look at is the scope of appointment.
- 19:28I try to be as specific as possible when I'm
- 19:30trying to bring on a minors council and I really
- 19:32want to focus them on what I want them to do.
- 19:35Now, if I don't have specific concerns and I
- 19:38just want advocacy, I may say to investigate
- 19:41and advocate for the best interests of the minor
- 19:44child. But generally, if there are concerns I
- 19:47have, I'm concerned about education, I'm concerned
- 19:49about medical, I need admissible evidence on
- 19:52a certain subject, Provision four of this form
- 19:56is exactly where I'm going to set that forth.
- 19:58And the reason that I like that is because and
- 20:02as a practice point, when minors councils appointed,
- 20:05make sure you understand the scope of their appointment.
- 20:08Now I'm not saying that scope can't change, but
- 20:11I do think it's important that everybody understands
- 20:14why the minors council is there. And I think
- 20:17being able to tailor your advocacy to the minors
- 20:20council or their information or even the information
- 20:25you provide on behalf of your client can be very
- 20:28effective to ensuring the outcome that you need.
- 20:31Sonia, any thoughts relative to this form or
- 20:34information that attorneys should be looking
- 20:37for when they receive the order of appointment?
- 20:40Yeah, no, I think that the scope is really important
- 20:45and it falls under number four, which is the
- 20:47reason for the appointment. Sometimes it's very
- 20:52wide. Sometimes the judge really just keeps the
- 20:56scope and the reason very focused. And so everyone
- 21:00needs to be aware of that. FL323, I think, is
- 21:05crucial for people who are minors counsel because,
- 21:08again, that lays out all the rights and responsibilities.
- 21:13And on the second page, it gives the minors council
- 21:19the right to records to to obtain school records
- 21:25to waive privilege, all kinds of things. And
- 21:28that I know when I was doing minors council work,
- 21:30I would use this order to contact the school
- 21:34to contact therapists to contact any any third
- 21:39party provider that I needed to speak with regarding
- 21:42the minor child. And it's quicker and easier
- 21:46than a subpoena just for me to at least make
- 21:50contact and let them know who I am. But I think
- 21:56a practice pointer is a lot of attorneys who
- 21:59represent parents either have to do an order
- 22:02after hearing after minors council was appointed
- 22:05at the hearing and minors council wasn't there
- 22:08or sometimes you stipulate. to have minors council
- 22:12come on the case and you stipulate as to who
- 22:17it is and you submit that stipulation and it's
- 22:20signed with the court. I think a good practice
- 22:22pointer is then also, both with orders after
- 22:26hearings and with stipulations, prepare the FL
- 22:29323 and submit that to the court as a proposed
- 22:35order for the minors council appointment. because
- 22:39it gets everything going and started much more
- 22:42quickly. And it also, it's the form that minors
- 22:45council really needs to get started with their
- 22:47work. I would also advise going over the FL323
- 22:53with your clients. It's very important that parents
- 22:56understand what the duties are of minors council
- 22:59and what rights the council has. For example,
- 23:03reasonable access to the child. It is not helpful
- 23:07for me if I come back or I bring parties back
- 23:11on a hearing, like a review hearing, and the
- 23:14report from Minors Council is I didn't get access
- 23:17to my client so I couldn't move forward. And
- 23:20the response from Council Table is, well, my
- 23:22client didn't realize that she needed to make
- 23:25or he needed to make the child available. As
- 23:28we can see on the third page, subsection 9A,
- 23:32council has the right to have reasonable access
- 23:35to the child. So to the extent that the order
- 23:38appointing council has gone out and everything
- 23:40is as it needs to be, and I have either party
- 23:44arguing that they didn't realize that any of
- 23:47these things needed to happen, it's not going
- 23:50to be wholly persuasive. Right. And I also think
- 23:54that you have to be careful what you wish for,
- 23:56right? Because the attorney also representing
- 24:02the child needs to inform the court if the child
- 24:06wishes to address the court or has changed their
- 24:09mind and doesn't wish to address the court. And
- 24:12a lot of times, you know, you have The parents
- 24:17that are asking you to get the minor's counsel
- 24:20because their child wants to talk to the judge.
- 24:22Their child wants to talk to the judge and it
- 24:25may not end up being what your client thinks
- 24:29it's going to be or the child when they talk
- 24:31to an attorney about it. Decides I really don't
- 24:35want to. It was just my parent that was really
- 24:38putting pressure on me and now you have minor's
- 24:41counsel in your case and the child doesn't want
- 24:43to address the court. I mean just. Be careful
- 24:46what you wish for. There's always a lot of different
- 24:49sides to an issue in a case in family law. And
- 24:55the child's perspective will now come into play.
- 25:04So family code section 3151 is the code section
- 25:10that really gives the rights and responsibilities
- 25:13for the appointment. California rule of court
- 25:175 .242. It's one of my favorite rules of court,
- 25:21as nerdy as that sounds. It has the requirements
- 25:26for minors council and it details the qualifications
- 25:30that you need to become minors council, the training
- 25:34that you should have to become minors council.
- 25:37And also it lists the responsibilities of a person
- 25:41who is appointed to represent the child. There
- 25:46are trainings in Los Angeles County that will
- 25:52give you the training that you need to become
- 25:58minors council the first time and then to keep
- 26:00up with the continuing education because minors
- 26:05council for the first time have to take 12 hours
- 26:08of training and then every year after that you
- 26:12have to do eight hours of training that is designated
- 26:15to specific issues regarding the representation
- 26:19of children, including domestic violence, child
- 26:24abuse, substance abuse, and so on. So there are
- 26:29trainings in Los Angeles County that will give
- 26:31you that training. There are trainings in other
- 26:35counties that will give you that training. And
- 26:38you have to have some experience requirements.
- 26:40And then the rule really lays out also the responsibilities
- 26:47of Miners' Council. And it goes a little bit
- 26:50further than Family Code Section 3150 at SEC.
- 26:56So it's a very comprehensive rule. And we put
- 27:01Most of the rule in here, but really if you have
- 27:03questions about it, you should look at it and
- 27:05read it because it's quite lengthy, but full
- 27:08of really good information. Does the rule cover
- 27:17what minors council should do at the time they're
- 27:19appointed? Yes, so it does and I. Minors Council
- 27:26is required to submit a declaration. It's called
- 27:32the Declaration of Council for Child Regarding
- 27:35Qualifications. Super creative title. And that
- 27:41needs to be, it's really FL 322. And that needs
- 27:45to be filed within 10 days of receiving your
- 27:49appointment. And Commissioner Thomas just put
- 27:52that up. on there. It really it's for a person
- 27:57who was appointed as Minors Council to confirm
- 28:00that they have received the requisite training
- 28:03and experience because CRC 5 .242 also outlines
- 28:09some experience that you need to have or alternative
- 28:13experience if you don't have it and you want
- 28:17to start doing the job. So this needs to be filed
- 28:28with the court and hopefully within 10 days of
- 28:32receiving notice of the appointment to be minors
- 28:37council. And ideally it should be served on all
- 28:41parties. So would you ever address with counsel
- 28:47to the extent you don't have a qual deck in the
- 28:51file by the time you bring everybody back? Would
- 28:54you ask for it before moving forward? Or what
- 28:57is the significance in terms of looking for this
- 29:00document in the file? Well, I think it's important
- 29:04to I think. Are you asking me as far as a judicial
- 29:08officer or if you were practicing attorney? As
- 29:12a judicial officer, would not seeing this form
- 29:15in the file prohibit the matter from moving forward?
- 29:19Not necessarily. No. But I think that I might
- 29:23ask, you know, counsel, have you filed your FL322?
- 29:30And it depends who the counsel is. Also, if it's
- 29:32counsel that filed it in another case that was
- 29:35in front of me yesterday and didn't file it in
- 29:38this case. I would just ask because it was probably
- 29:42just a clerical error, but it is a mandatory
- 29:49form. Would it prohibit you, Commissioner Thomas,
- 29:54from going forward? I think that I would handle
- 29:57it the same way. I would probably be a little
- 30:00more leery if it was a council that I didn't
- 30:02have experience with or didn't know their background,
- 30:05because I think the form is very clear in terms
- 30:08of what the education, the training and the experience
- 30:10needs to be. So though it wouldn't be a reason
- 30:13for me not to move forward, it may be a reason
- 30:16for me to take a moment, print out the form and
- 30:19ask council to submit it, or at least run through
- 30:23their qualifications if it was. that I am not
- 30:27necessarily familiar with or that I don't understand
- 30:29has the training and the experience, because
- 30:32I really do want to make sure that anyone that
- 30:35I am appointing or signing off on to represent
- 30:40the minor child is in a position to do no harm
- 30:42and is trained accordingly. I agree. I agree.
- 30:49So just really quickly, let's talk about forms
- 30:54of payment for minors council just quickly because
- 30:57it might affect what you ask for and I think
- 31:00it also helps clarify for the attorneys that
- 31:04represent parents who don't do minors council
- 31:07work sometimes there's words thrown out by minors
- 31:11council in the court that you really don't know
- 31:13what they mean and that is the pace rates right
- 31:16so minors council can be appointed and paid by
- 31:21the County of Los Angeles, which is the PACE
- 31:24program. And PACE currently, they went up, they
- 31:30pay $165 an hour, used to be a lot less. And
- 31:37it's at, when the court appoints Minors Council
- 31:42and we determine that it will be a PACE appointment,
- 31:46we have to determine at what level. And there
- 31:49are four different levels, and that caps the
- 31:52fees at those levels. And if my nurse counsel
- 31:55is going to move past that cap, they need to
- 32:01ask the court for an approval to move to the
- 32:04next level. So if you're in a hearing and my
- 32:08nurse counsel says, Your Honor, I need to be
- 32:10moved up to the next pace level, and you hear
- 32:14any type of conversation with the court about
- 32:19that, that's what that means. If they're appointed
- 32:22at pace level one, which caps their fees at 1
- 32:26,500, I think it might have changed, but let's
- 32:28say caps their fees at 1 ,500, what they're really
- 32:32saying is I need to go to the next level, which
- 32:34caps their fees at 3 ,000. So that should also...
- 32:41be with notice to everybody, but I know that
- 32:43a lot of times it might not happen. And that's
- 32:49where it is. And in most cases, the court also
- 32:52reserves jurisdiction to modify or reallocate
- 32:56the fees. And if the court decides that PACE
- 33:00is not going to pay for Minors Council, then
- 33:04the parties will be ordered to pay for the fees
- 33:07of Minors Council. And that can be divided in
- 33:12different ways and be allocated between the parties
- 33:15in different ways, depending on their financial
- 33:22forms, right? And hopefully what their INE show.
- 33:28Judge Dujan, do you ever convert a PACE appointment
- 33:31to a private pay appointment? Yes, I have. Under
- 33:35what circumstances? Well, it depends so sometimes
- 33:41people are in front of me and I don't have any
- 33:46financial information about them and I would
- 33:50like minors council to get started working right
- 33:52away if I'm appointing minors council and I will
- 33:57order that their fees be paid by pace so that
- 34:01they're at least guaranteed they'll be paid subject
- 34:05to reallocation or subject to be modified, and
- 34:09then I order the parties to file and serve an
- 34:12income and expense declaration two weeks before
- 34:15they come back, letting them know that I will
- 34:19be looking to see if that PACE payment needs
- 34:23to be modified or reallocated. As a practice
- 34:28pointer, at least in my courtroom, And I know
- 34:32that my ethos may be a little different. It is
- 34:35probably more difficult to get a minors council
- 34:36appointed in my courtroom than other courtrooms
- 34:39because I just realized that I'm really looking
- 34:43for the probative value. But when you are making
- 34:47your motion or your request for minors council,
- 34:50please address compensation with me. It is very
- 34:53difficult. if you bring a motion for a request
- 34:57for minors council and I see both parents represented
- 35:01by fine and not necessarily affordable but expensive
- 35:08council and then the argument is but there's
- 35:12no money in this case for for minors council
- 35:15but we desperately need it so use the county
- 35:18to pay for it to the extent that you are bringing
- 35:21any type of motion requesting that Please have
- 35:24your financials in order and please also explain
- 35:28to me to the extent that this does need to be
- 35:32a county resource. Why and. make sure that I
- 35:36feel good about utilizing that resource appropriately.
- 35:40I think that also ensures your best chance of
- 35:44the court appointing someone in a situation where
- 35:47the court may be on the fence. Judge Dujan, what
- 35:49say you relative to information you find helpful
- 35:52regarding compensation when you're trying to
- 35:55ascertain whether or not to appoint or whether
- 35:57it should be paced or private pay? Yeah, no,
- 36:00I agree with you. I agree with you. I think we
- 36:03need all the information, including how much
- 36:06they're paying in attorney's fees. We need that
- 36:11information to make a determination. And the
- 36:14last thing I want is to appoint an attorney as
- 36:19my nurse counsel who is not going to get paid.
- 36:23But at the same time, the county should not be
- 36:26paying for everybody. especially when there's
- 36:31money going to very competent attorneys. Well,
- 36:36one thing that we haven't addressed, we discussed
- 36:38PACE compensation. What does it look like in
- 36:41terms of private pay? Like, is that a retainer
- 36:44situation? Will you ever order parents to put
- 36:48down money on a retainer for Minors Council if
- 36:50it's private pay? I might, or I might just leave
- 36:54it for Minors Council to set their own retainer.
- 36:58I don't necessarily want to micromanage Miners
- 37:04Council's private pay fees and retainers. But
- 37:10sometimes if I feel like that needs to be done,
- 37:14then I would order it. What about you? So then
- 37:19what would also be helpful is if there's a stipulation
- 37:21or an agreement to a private pay Miners Council
- 37:23that the information regarding that compensation
- 37:28also be put before the court. We don't have access
- 37:31to information to know necessarily how much a
- 37:34private pay minors council is charging, what
- 37:36the retainer looks like or what that is. So I
- 37:39think just kind of jumping on Judge Dujan's thought
- 37:43process that it is helpful to us for that information
- 37:46to either be provided or that may be when you
- 37:49find your PACE appointment is converted to a
- 37:51private pay. Yeah. So. Let's talk about the scope
- 37:57of the appointment. Commissioner Thomas, do you
- 38:03write in your appointment orders when you do
- 38:06appoint, do you write anything about the reasons
- 38:11and the scope of the appointments? Oh, yes. Not
- 38:15only I think I find catharsis in in writing it
- 38:18out actually, but I will absolutely write out
- 38:21why why? the appointment orders being made what
- 38:25my focus is and what information I'm hoping to
- 38:28get out of it and Even I'll even go as far as
- 38:31if competing allegations have been made in the
- 38:33courtroom I will even point that out mom makes
- 38:37allegations of substance abuse dad makes allegations
- 38:41of gatekeeping or alienation I try to at least
- 38:45highlight what I understand the argument or the
- 38:48issues to be so Miners Council can get a sense
- 38:51of what they're asking for or a sense of where
- 38:54they should be at least starting their investigation.
- 38:57I never want to curtail where the investigation
- 39:00goes unless it's a really limited appointment,
- 39:03but I definitely don't want them to need to read
- 39:06through the 300 pages in the RFO. I had to filter
- 39:11through to get a sense of. to start when interviewing
- 39:14their client. And would you entertain from Council
- 39:20for the Parties, would you entertain what the
- 39:23reason or the scope is before you, you know,
- 39:27before you create that form? Oh absolutely. Absolutely.
- 39:31And in fact, I've even taken stipulations from
- 39:33council where they're not necessarily in agreement
- 39:37to a wide sweeping scope for minors council,
- 39:41but they'll agree on this limited issue. We're
- 39:44agreeable to minors council, which then gets
- 39:48council through the door. And then once I have
- 39:51a minors council involved, if they feel they
- 39:54need to expand the scope of their appointment,
- 39:56Maybe they find out that they need to expand
- 39:59the scope of their appointment, or maybe they
- 40:01find out that their appointment is absolutely
- 40:04fine. But I will always listen to advocacy relative
- 40:08to what the scope should be, because the least
- 40:12invasion I can cause into the family system or
- 40:15the life of the child, I think the better. Yeah,
- 40:19I agree. I agree. All right, so. So a lot of
- 40:27time, people want minors council because they
- 40:30want the children to be heard in court. And that
- 40:35brings us to California rule of court 5 .250,
- 40:40which is Commissioner Thomas's favorite rule
- 40:42of court. Oh, it is. I'm starting to realize
- 40:46through this presentation, we may actually need
- 40:48hobbies at this point in time. It's kind of sad
- 40:51when like favorite California rules of court.
- 40:54But the reason I love California rule of court
- 40:565 .250 is because it governs the children's participation
- 41:00in testimony and family court proceedings. And
- 41:03really it was designed to implement family code
- 41:06section 3042, which Judge Dujon will touch on
- 41:09in a moment. But what I enjoy about this is it
- 41:12really gives us some guidance relative to whether
- 41:16we hear from the child, how we hear from the
- 41:19child, who's present, whether parents are in
- 41:22the room, whether they're not, the findings the
- 41:25judicial officer needs to make relative to the
- 41:28parents being in the room or not being in the
- 41:30room. It also gives a mechanism or ideas of ways
- 41:35of determining if the child wishes to address.
- 41:38the court or has changed their minds. I can hear
- 41:41that from a minors council. I can hear that from
- 41:44a court evaluator, someone from Family Court
- 41:47Services. Subsection C of the rule gives a whole
- 41:51bunch of information relative to determining
- 41:53how to ascertain if a child wishes to address
- 41:56the court. There's also guidelines for determining
- 41:59whether addressing the court is in the children's
- 42:01best interest. Now, These are guidelines. We
- 42:05have a lot of judicial discretion in this area,
- 42:10but it's very helpful for everyone in the room
- 42:12to be aligned relative to the guidelines that
- 42:15guide us. There are also guidelines for receiving
- 42:18the testimony and other input. To the extent
- 42:21that a judicial officer makes a determination
- 42:23that it's not in the child's best interest to
- 42:26testify, and I am a believer wholeheartedly that
- 42:29it is not always in the child's best interest
- 42:31to testify. And experience has shaped that, but
- 42:37also case reading cases has definitely formed
- 42:41that opinion. Ultimately, it is helpful for me
- 42:45to understand that there are other options that.
- 42:49Apart from hearing from the child directly, there
- 42:52are other parenting plan assessments. Other individuals
- 42:57have the ability to garner the information that
- 42:59we need, even a child interview, which helps
- 43:02in a more delicate or sensitive situation, still
- 43:05put the information you need before the court,
- 43:08but doesn't necessarily require the child to
- 43:09come into court. There's also additional responsibility.
- 43:13of court -connected and appointed professionals.
- 43:16So if you're looking at a team approach for how
- 43:18to work with this family or getting information
- 43:22relative or advocacy relative to the child, this
- 43:25is the subsection F is going to guide you. And
- 43:28methods of providing information to parents and
- 43:31supporting children, I think is very important
- 43:33as an advocacy to familiarize yourself with,
- 43:36which is subsection G. And then subsection H
- 43:38talks a little bit about the expected education
- 43:41and training that the court staff and the judicial
- 43:44officers were expected to have. Right, and that
- 43:48I think that goes along with Family Code Section
- 43:513042, which talks about preferences of the child
- 43:57and whether a child wishes to address the court
- 44:02and what the court needs to consider, right?
- 44:06The sufficient age, the capacity to reason. And
- 44:13it also outlines how that there's different ways
- 44:18of taking child testimony and that it really
- 44:25just gives some guidance to judicial officers
- 44:28and attorneys as to how this should be done.
- 44:32And I think there's a difference between a child
- 44:38testifying as to preference for custody and visitation
- 44:44for whatever reasons for them to testify as to
- 44:48preference versus a percipient witness. And there
- 44:51is, I think, a difference in how the testimony
- 44:55is set up. There's the difference whether how
- 45:00much really leeway the court has in allowing
- 45:06a child to testify or not allowing a child to
- 45:09testify, whether that testimony is going to be
- 45:12as a percipient witness or preference. And I
- 45:15think a lot of times attorneys forget that part.
- 45:20A percipient witness is a percipient witness.
- 45:23They saw something, they observed, they were
- 45:27a witness to something that they need to testify
- 45:30about. a child who wants to be heard regarding
- 45:37preference is just very different. And that's
- 45:40where I think the court has more discretion to
- 45:45decide whether they do address the court or not
- 45:49and how it's done. But regardless, whether it's
- 45:52a percipient witness or preference, the court
- 45:54really has to control the the testimony of or
- 46:01how the testimony is taken of the child because
- 46:05it is a child witness. I want to get back to
- 46:10something you said there that has been kind of
- 46:12the bane of my existence since I started in this
- 46:16elevated position. Do you believe the judicial
- 46:20officers is the standard the same? Relative and
- 46:23is our discretion the same relative to whether
- 46:25we're taking preference testimony or precipitate
- 46:28witness testimony? Our discretion as to what
- 46:32as to whether the child testifies? I don't think
- 46:35it's the same. Tell me. Well, this is our conversation
- 46:41here. You know if. If someone comes in and has
- 46:46a child who has a witness who is a child. And
- 46:52it's to an issue that is germane to whatever
- 46:57the hearing or trial is about. And it's really
- 47:01not about preference of custody and visitation,
- 47:06but it's germane to something. I think they have
- 47:10a right to call that witness. As long as the
- 47:17child has competency, as long as the child is
- 47:20a an age where they understand what they're doing.
- 47:27You know, you can't bring in a four -year -old
- 47:29to testify that they saw mom withdraw a bunch
- 47:34of money from the bank. I mean, that's not going
- 47:37to work. A four -year -old wouldn't have the
- 47:40competency to do that, right? But I think this
- 47:45comes in a lot more in terms of domestic violence.
- 47:51And if the child witnessed any domestic violence
- 47:55between the parents, then I think they're a percipient
- 48:00witness. And that adult has a right to proffer
- 48:06them as a percipient witness. I mean, I'll consider
- 48:09their age. And then because that different standard
- 48:13applies, I would ask for if you are going to
- 48:17fight against a child being called as a recipient
- 48:19witness in a contempt proceeding or in a domestic
- 48:23violence, be armed with argument, maybe even
- 48:27a pocket brief, and recognize that my standard
- 48:31is not just best interest at that point in time.
- 48:34There are times that I don't believe it's necessarily
- 48:37in the child's best interest, but the child is
- 48:39the only witness to something horrific and my
- 48:43hands are tied. So as much as I may not want
- 48:46to put that child on the stand or hear from them
- 48:49because I'm concerned about re -traumatizing
- 48:52them, there's limited... there's limited discretion
- 48:57that I can apply to say, no, we're just not hearing
- 48:59from this witness. All I can do at that point
- 49:03is ensure that the testimony comes out in a way
- 49:06that is least damaging to the child. But when
- 49:09you're addressing contempt, and for example,
- 49:12like the core C defense, or you're looking at
- 49:15the child testifying as a domestic violence witness,
- 49:18that is very different standard and needs to
- 49:20be treated very differently. then say 3042 preference
- 49:24testimony. I agree and and I just want I don't
- 49:28want everyone to think that we're saying bring
- 49:31us child witnesses and this is the way you're
- 49:34going to do your case that in every family law
- 49:36case if you bring in the children we have to
- 49:39take their testimony and then you're going to
- 49:41prove that your client is right and everything
- 49:43he or she is saying and the other side is completely
- 49:46wrong. That's not what this is and I really don't
- 49:50want people to come away thinking I just have
- 49:54to bring the children as percipial witnesses.
- 49:56It's really truly in specific circumstances that
- 50:00the children are percipient witnesses and and
- 50:04really should testify, right? This doesn't. This
- 50:07isn't for everything. I just want to know. And
- 50:10to the extent that we find children who are brought
- 50:13in, who shouldn't be brought in, or it's not
- 50:15probative and it's damaging, guess what? If we've
- 50:18got custody and visitation in front of us, that
- 50:20may be a metric where that tips the scales also.
- 50:23My apologies, Judge Yushan, I stepped on your
- 50:26last word there. No, no, I just wanted to, I'm
- 50:30just wary of the time and I know we have questions,
- 50:32so we're gonna leave time for questions. But
- 50:35when we talk about taking children's testimony,
- 50:39I think that is really important to bring a spotlight
- 50:43on the case of Cardona versus Soto. And Commissioner
- 50:48Thomas, do you want to talk about this a little
- 50:50bit? Because I think a lot of times, attorneys
- 50:55for parents come in, or guardians come in, and
- 51:00they just say, my client says the child really
- 51:04wants to talk to the court. First of all, It's
- 51:07not talking to the court. The child is going
- 51:09to come in and testify, right? But you come in
- 51:15as a parent's attorney and you say, the child
- 51:19really wants to address the court, but they can't
- 51:23do it in front of everyone. They're afraid of
- 51:25the other side because the other side is horrible.
- 51:28And so you need to take them into chambers. They'll
- 51:30talk to you in chambers by yourself. Commissioner
- 51:34Thomas. What do you do with that? Would you do
- 51:36it? Oh no. No, no, no, no. And here's why. So
- 51:41in 2024, we have the case of Cardona versus Soto.
- 51:45And in that case, Karina Soto and Jose Cardona
- 51:48had a 12 -year -old daughter. Now Soto brought
- 51:53a domestic violence restraining order against
- 51:55Cardona. alleging that while inebriated, he violently
- 51:59beat her in their daughter's presence. Daughter
- 52:01made an audio recording of the incident and then
- 52:04contacted a relative to ask for help. He also,
- 52:08I think, slapped the daughter. He was arrested
- 52:11and the wife was taken to an emergency room.
- 52:13There were also other allegations within the
- 52:16domestic violence filing. At the hearing, though,
- 52:19the daughter spoke in chambers to the court without
- 52:23a court reporter. Oh, exactly. Just one -on -one
- 52:30with the child, has discussion, comes out, does
- 52:33not summarize any of it, and then proceeds to
- 52:36make orders. And characterizes, he listens to
- 52:39the recording, speaks to the child, characterizes
- 52:41it all as pretty awful, and then proceeds to
- 52:45grant SOTO, sole legal and physical custody,
- 52:48denies visitation, issues the domestic violence
- 52:50restraining order. There's an appeal the appellate
- 52:55court reverses and finds that the trial court
- 52:57violated due process and violated due process
- 53:01because based on the Basing the ruling on the
- 53:06interview but not giving the contents of the
- 53:09interview were not having a chance For dad to
- 53:12understand what was said he had no ability to
- 53:14refute or argue Against it and the court didn't
- 53:17summarize any of the testimony for the parties.
- 53:20So this case is really a cautionary tale for
- 53:25when you are asking for a child to come in the
- 53:27court, think through how the testimony is going
- 53:31to be proffered, what that's going to look like.
- 53:35Set the stage for the judicial officer. Now the
- 53:37judicial officer is the final say, but think
- 53:40through these things because asking merely, can
- 53:44you take the child into chambers one -on -one,
- 53:46no one should be around is probably not going
- 53:49to be a strong position. Judge John, I don't
- 53:52know about you, the number of children who start
- 53:55their testimony with a, or somewhere in their
- 53:58testimony, tell me, well, Your Honor, I'll tell
- 54:02you, but I don't want to tell anybody else. If
- 54:04we can go somewhere privately, I'll tell you.
- 54:07It needs to be explained from the get -go that
- 54:10that's not what this process is. Go ahead, go
- 54:14ahead. No, and most importantly, it needs to
- 54:16be explained to the parents or, you know, guardians,
- 54:20whoever is bringing it. You need to let your
- 54:23your clients know it's not going to be a private
- 54:26one on one chat with the judicial officer. And
- 54:30chances are well, really not chances are. Both
- 54:36parties are going to know what the child said,
- 54:40and chances are that. Even both parties will
- 54:44be in the courtroom when it's being done. You
- 54:47know, perhaps it's done in chambers with a court
- 54:50reporter and if there's counsel with counsel
- 54:52for the parties present, but eventually both
- 54:56parties are going to know what the child said
- 54:59and they need to understand that because I do
- 55:02think that a lot of times attorneys for. For
- 55:06the parties ask for these things and it's not
- 55:10something that's appropriate but and also When
- 55:13you're asking to have a child address the court
- 55:16Come prepared to tell us a little bit about what
- 55:19that child is like. Do they have special needs?
- 55:22Do they you know? Are they? a child that's timid?
- 55:29Are they a child that's outgoing? What's their
- 55:31schedule like? Because if I grant your request,
- 55:33I'm going to want to set it at a time that is
- 55:37the most convenient, if possible, to the child's
- 55:42school. And so I need information. And I think
- 55:46a lot of times attorneys come in just with what
- 55:49their client wants, but not ready to give us
- 55:53enough information to even make any orders regarding
- 55:56what their client wants. So moving on, the duties
- 56:02of Miners Council goes along with the rights
- 56:06of Miners Council. Again, you can look at it
- 56:08in 3151, in FL 323, and in 5 .242. So we're not
- 56:16going to spend too much time on that. But here's
- 56:21what you could do. Effective communication with
- 56:23minors council, right? When you're representing
- 56:27parties and minors council gets appointed, how
- 56:30do you deal with it? Effective communication,
- 56:34good communication is key. First of all, provide
- 56:39minors council with relevant documents that you
- 56:42want them to consider and look at. Don't dump.
- 56:46boxes and boxes and even like all kinds of financial
- 56:50documents, you're going to you're going to make
- 56:54Miners Council weave through things that are
- 56:55not relevant. So provide relevant documents that
- 57:00they can get through. Notify as you're going
- 57:03through the case, notify Miners Council of any
- 57:07significant changes. Sometimes, you know, Miners
- 57:11Council thinks they know the case and they get
- 57:12to court and they're they're told something.
- 57:18Respect Minors Council's independence and look
- 57:22at their rights and responsibilities. Minors
- 57:25Council doesn't have to tell you if they talk
- 57:27to the therapist. They don't have to tell you
- 57:29if they talk to the child's school. They don't
- 57:31even have to tell you what those people said.
- 57:34If it's going to be brought up in court, yes,
- 57:37there needs to be a meeting conferred. There
- 57:40needs to be, they need to reveal that. However,
- 57:46if they're speaking with the therapist and the
- 57:48therapist, they decide they're not waiving privilege
- 57:51on behalf of their client and it's best to preserve
- 57:54that relationship and not say anything, they
- 57:57don't have to tell you. Respect that. But ask
- 58:01them for whatever information they can give you
- 58:04regarding their positions. There should be some
- 58:06open communication, but not manipulation. And
- 58:12again, that communication needs to be civil,
- 58:15respectful, follow the code of ethics. I think
- 58:21a lot of times minors council gets threatened
- 58:24and that doesn't work well. That's not helpful
- 58:27to figuring out what is in the child's best interest.
- 58:33If you go to litigation, Commissioner Thomas,
- 58:36what do you think are the best practices? Make
- 58:39sure they're involved. If there's an evaluation
- 58:41of the child, they need to be there pre -trial,
- 58:44like depositions. Minor's counsel gets a seat
- 58:46at that table. They need notice. They need to
- 58:48be involved. Discovery. They need to be involved.
- 58:51Settlement talks. The number of times that I'll
- 58:53say, go meet and confer. And then even about
- 58:56custody and visitation, bring the parties back
- 58:59and find out that Minor's counsel was nowhere
- 59:00near that meet and confer. They provide advocacy.
- 59:04They are attorneys. And also, You need to be
- 59:08prepared to examine or cross -examine appropriately
- 59:11based on what the case is. So if Miners' Council
- 59:14is bringing in witnesses, if they're participating
- 59:19in the litigation, which is what they're expected
- 59:20to do, be prepared to advocate accordingly. We
- 59:23don't expect you to co -sign on whatever Miners'
- 59:26Council says, but to the extent that you're pushing
- 59:28back, we expect advocacy in pushback and we expect
- 59:33legal arguments. So practical considerations,
- 59:38right? So again, include minors council in ex
- 59:45parties, in settlement negotiations or settlement
- 59:48talks, in visitation discussions. Not only could
- 59:52they add something that would be really helpful,
- 59:56but if you reach an agreement and you don't have...
- 59:58minors council signature on it, it's most likely
- 1:00:02not going to get signed by the court. If you
- 1:00:04bring an ex party and you didn't give minors
- 1:00:06council notice, it's not going to. It's most
- 1:00:09likely going to get rejected for lack of notice.
- 1:00:14They are an attorney on the case. They have rights.
- 1:00:17Again, go back and read them and they need to
- 1:00:20be included. Have your clients not prepare their.
- 1:00:27their children for the interviews with Minors
- 1:00:29Council. One of the worst things that I would
- 1:00:32think as an attorney representing an adult is
- 1:00:35for the child to go in and say, well, my mom
- 1:00:37said to tell you this, or my dad said that I
- 1:00:41need to tell you that. That doesn't bode well
- 1:00:43for your client, right? And I think what's really
- 1:00:46helpful is if you reach out to Minors Council
- 1:00:50or your client reaches out to Minors Council
- 1:00:52and says, What would you like my client to tell
- 1:00:56the children about before coming to meet with
- 1:00:59you or before you come to meet with them? How
- 1:01:03can my client explain who you are before you
- 1:01:06come here? And for those of you that have never
- 1:01:09taken the Miner's Counsel training program, at
- 1:01:12least the LA County one, Miner's Counsel is taught
- 1:01:16how to explain their role to a child in a child
- 1:01:20-focused way. So they will do it when they first
- 1:01:23meet the child. And I think what could be difficult
- 1:01:28is how does the parent or the adult tell the
- 1:01:31child, oh, we're going to this meeting, and who
- 1:01:34is this person, or this person is coming to meet
- 1:01:36you? Reach out to Minors Council and just ask.
- 1:01:40Every attorney that represents children has their
- 1:01:42own way that they may want a parent to tell a
- 1:01:47child about their meeting. And again, just help
- 1:01:51your clients provide relevant information to
- 1:01:54Minors Council. I think that helps the process
- 1:01:58move along. So you've had the hearing. These
- 1:02:05are common pitfalls to avoid. Remember, Miners'
- 1:02:11Council represents the child, not the parties.
- 1:02:19Miners' Council is not a shortcut to discovery.
- 1:02:22Miners' Council has all the privileges that you
- 1:02:24have as an attorney, right? Work product, it's
- 1:02:28their work product. You don't get it necessarily.
- 1:02:33Minors Council can't go into court and speak
- 1:02:35for your client or help you present your case.
- 1:02:39They're presenting their case. They're speaking
- 1:02:41for the child. And Minors Council has access
- 1:02:45to a lot of, or may know a lot of resources just
- 1:02:48because they do the job a lot, but they're really
- 1:02:51not a social worker and should not be treated
- 1:02:53as such. Commissioner Thomas, anything you want
- 1:02:58to add? Well, and as we're talking about not
- 1:03:01a shortcut to discovery, Miners Council is not
- 1:03:03a witness. It is actually the order appointing
- 1:03:07council has been amended to include that and
- 1:03:09it's part of the code. Miners Council is not
- 1:03:11a witness, should not be called as a witness,
- 1:03:14and to do so is very problematic. Now, since
- 1:03:18we're talking about pitfalls, why don't we get
- 1:03:21into AF versus Jeffrey and end on that note before
- 1:03:24we close out and look at the chat for any questions?
- 1:03:27Because I think AF v. Jeffrey is definitely a
- 1:03:31pitfall that we need to be mindful of. Right,
- 1:03:34so AF versus Jeffrey F or versus Jeffrey, and
- 1:03:38you need to look at it. It's actually, I think,
- 1:03:39a 2023 case, but you need to look at it. There
- 1:03:43were more than one because there were a number
- 1:03:45of appeals on this case. And this was where there
- 1:03:51was a minors counsel appointed in the dissolution
- 1:03:54action and then the minor child brought a DV
- 1:03:57proceeding on her own against her father. And
- 1:04:02the first appeal deals with the minor child hired
- 1:04:09their own lawyer and the judge disqualified that
- 1:04:13lawyer and there was an appeal on that. But then
- 1:04:16the the trial court appointed or expanded the
- 1:04:20scope of minors council to include representing
- 1:04:24the minor in prosecuting the restraining order
- 1:04:27she brought for herself. I believe she was 11
- 1:04:31or 12 at the time, maybe even younger, but what
- 1:04:36the court of appeal found in AF versus Jeffrey
- 1:04:39is that the statute makes it clear The appointment
- 1:04:43of minors counsel occurs in custody or visitation
- 1:04:47disputes pursuant to Family Code 3150 and not
- 1:04:52in a DVRO proceeding. A neutral minors counsel
- 1:04:56in a dissolution matter plays an entirely different
- 1:05:00role than counsel hired in a civil matter, which
- 1:05:04is what the child was trying to do in this case.
- 1:05:08Minors Council has a statutorily imposed duty
- 1:05:13to represent what the attorney believes is in
- 1:05:17the child's best interest, as well as the child's
- 1:05:21wishes. And that's straight from the appellate
- 1:05:23court. But in a civil matter, attorneys representing
- 1:05:27minors are bound by the Business and Professions
- 1:05:30Code, the State Bar Rules of Professional Conduct,
- 1:05:36and they have an obligation to zealously represent
- 1:05:40their client's interests within the bounds of
- 1:05:42the law. So the court found that it was not appropriate
- 1:05:48to appoint minors counsel under Family Code 3150
- 1:05:53for a child bringing her own restraining order
- 1:05:57to prosecute that restraining order. And I think
- 1:06:00this is important because I know a lot of attorneys
- 1:06:04when you're representing parents, you find out
- 1:06:08or you may know that the child filed their own
- 1:06:12restraining order. And a lot of times you think
- 1:06:15that, oh, well, we'll have minors council appointed
- 1:06:17and they'll prosecute the restraining order.
- 1:06:20And AF versus Jeffrey found that that's just
- 1:06:23not appropriate. That's not how it works. Unfortunately,
- 1:06:28what it also means is if people don't have money
- 1:06:31to hire a lawyer, that child may have to do it
- 1:06:34by themselves Or they could have a guardian ad
- 1:06:37litem appointed, which is different than a minors
- 1:06:40council. But I know that happens a lot. And when
- 1:06:45I was working as minors council, I would get
- 1:06:49called by attorneys asking if I could be available
- 1:06:52to take a case where the minor child brought
- 1:06:55their own restraining order. And that's no longer
- 1:06:58allowed. The court doesn't say. if there's minors'
- 1:07:03counsel and the minors' counsel believes that
- 1:07:05they need to file a restraining order on behalf
- 1:07:08of their client, the court doesn't talk about
- 1:07:11that. However, I think the argument could be
- 1:07:15made that would be done, that would be in the
- 1:07:18best interest of the minor child if the attorney
- 1:07:21appointed under 3151 is bringing that action.
- 1:07:30leaves a little bit of room open, but that's
- 1:07:32really what that case says. And if you're in
- 1:07:35that situation, you should get to know it because
- 1:07:37it's a different standard. So I think at this
- 1:07:44point, even though we may have a few more things,
- 1:07:48we should answer some questions. Absolutely.
- 1:07:51And the first question, Judge Dujan, is it appropriate
- 1:07:54for minors counsel to request an evaluation,
- 1:07:57either a PPA or a CCE, a parenting plan assessment
- 1:08:00or a child custody evaluation? I think it could
- 1:08:02be. And Family Code 3151 says that you can. You
- 1:08:09could even request, or Miners Council, not you,
- 1:08:13Miners Council can request psychological evaluations
- 1:08:17of their client, mental health evaluations of
- 1:08:20their client. I think if it's in their client's
- 1:08:24best interest, they certainly can. This is an
- 1:08:28interesting question. Often I see Minors Council
- 1:08:30giving a report to the court on what the child
- 1:08:32told them. You said you have to make decisions
- 1:08:35on admissible evidence. Wouldn't Minors Council's
- 1:08:37report be hearsay and inadmissible? Well, Minors
- 1:08:42Council's report is is not hearsay. I mean, it's
- 1:08:48not evidence, right? It is hearsay. A lot of
- 1:08:52times, I know judicial officers will ask for
- 1:08:55a Sanchez waiver when they're appointing minors
- 1:08:57counsel, or if attorneys are asking for minors
- 1:09:00counsel to be appointed, will ask if they will
- 1:09:03waive Sanchez. You know, minors counsel can make
- 1:09:10argument on behalf of their client, but really,
- 1:09:15It is hearsay. But it's the same hearsay that
- 1:09:20attorneys are presenting the adults stand up
- 1:09:24and start arguing a bunch of facts, right? Or
- 1:09:28that's not admissible evidence. That's coming
- 1:09:30straight from the attorney. So it's in that same
- 1:09:32way. So do you take the report as an offer of
- 1:09:35proof? Sorry, I do. I do. If Miners Council is
- 1:09:42appointed and will be paid privately, is it appropriate
- 1:09:45or acceptable for Miners Council to have their
- 1:09:47own stipulation and order that covers any issues
- 1:09:50beyond the FL323 form? Or is it better that Miners
- 1:09:54Council put that out in a letter to council and
- 1:09:57parties and request they acknowledge it? You
- 1:10:03know, I don't know if... we can answer that because
- 1:10:08it might go towards the, really, I think some
- 1:10:13of it is case specific, but some of it might
- 1:10:15be ethical concerns. I think what we can say
- 1:10:23is that, Minors counsel their attorneys. They
- 1:10:27went to law school, they are counsel, and they
- 1:10:30get the autonomy to function like any other attorney
- 1:10:33would function. We merely appoint them by bringing
- 1:10:37them into the case, and if they're privately
- 1:10:39paid, then they have the autonomy to conduct
- 1:10:42that transaction, however is ethical and appropriate,
- 1:10:45just like any other attorney. And I think you
- 1:10:48can look at the case of Metzger. which talks
- 1:10:52about the appropriateness of fees of private
- 1:10:54pay fees for minors counsel, if you need to.
- 1:10:59If counsel for their client has their own concerns
- 1:11:01for the minor based on new facts obtained from
- 1:11:04their client, can they file a request on their
- 1:11:06own accord? If not, what is the best course of
- 1:11:08action for that attorney? You can certainly file
- 1:11:12a new request on... on the adult client's own
- 1:11:17accord, you can also reach out to Minors Council.
- 1:11:20If there's something new that came up that you
- 1:11:22have a concern based on new facts, reach out
- 1:11:26to Minors Council and let them know and ask if
- 1:11:28they can look into it and get back to you. You
- 1:11:32know, sometimes that's a quicker way to deal
- 1:11:36with things or a better way, but you can also
- 1:11:40file. You can certainly file a new request. And
- 1:11:45I'm also putting a site to the marriage of Metzger
- 1:11:47in the chat. If you know that Miners Council
- 1:11:56has had limited access with the minors on the
- 1:11:58case, or you're having a difficult time getting
- 1:12:00a response or filing for Miners Council prior
- 1:12:04to the hearing, is that something that can be
- 1:12:06raised at the hearing? And is there a way to
- 1:12:08see how much Miners Council is billing on a case
- 1:12:10when it's being billed through PACE? I don't
- 1:12:15know if there's a way for you to see the pace.
- 1:12:18It used to be before it was electronic. I don't
- 1:12:23know. I would suspect that if you ask, you should
- 1:12:26be able to get it. I think, let me see, where
- 1:12:31is that question? Oh, it just disappeared. My
- 1:12:34apologies. It is answered. So it's answered.
- 1:12:39It sounds like this is concerns about about Miners'
- 1:12:42Council's work. And I think the first thing you
- 1:12:46should do is call Miners' Council or write them
- 1:12:49an email and say, look, I have some concerns.
- 1:12:52I'd like to discuss them with you before we go
- 1:12:55to court or before I have to bring them up with
- 1:12:59the court. And that's just so that not only do
- 1:13:02you give notice, but you might also find out
- 1:13:04that Miners' Council has actually been doing
- 1:13:06things that you don't know about. And if not,
- 1:13:10you can bring it up to the court. I would just
- 1:13:12say be careful and proceed cautiously and gently
- 1:13:17when you do that because you don't want the conflict
- 1:13:21to become between you and minors council and
- 1:13:24take away also from your client and the children's
- 1:13:27needs. So California rules of court will 5 .241,
- 1:13:32which requires the court to set compensation.
- 1:13:34This section outlines the procedure for determining
- 1:13:37the compensation. You cannot leave it to minors
- 1:13:39council to set the rate. I do not disagree with
- 1:13:43that. However, if it's private pay, we can honor
- 1:13:46the rate as historically set by minors council
- 1:13:49in their appointment. But that is absolutely
- 1:13:52a correct statement. Would the same standard
- 1:13:57apply if a 15 -year -old child wants to testify
- 1:13:59regarding preference as to custody? I think the
- 1:14:03standards that we went through, I think, would
- 1:14:05apply to considerations for any child wanting
- 1:14:08to testify regarding custody, but especially,
- 1:14:11I think, 30, 42 at the age of 15. I think there's
- 1:14:14a built -in presumption that they should be addressing
- 1:14:17the court, and they should be allowed to address
- 1:14:19the court. Correct me if I'm wrong, Judge Jushun.
- 1:14:22No, I think you're right. I would agree with
- 1:14:24you. Not that I'm the know -it -all, but I would
- 1:14:27agree with you. I'll recognize you as the know
- 1:14:30-it -all. No, please don't. And the final question,
- 1:14:33can the court appoint minors counsel where a
- 1:14:35young child is not being asked to testify but
- 1:14:38has witnessed things and is in therapy with a
- 1:14:40disputed diagnosis? Absolutely. I would think
- 1:14:43so, especially the disputed diagnosis. Depending
- 1:14:48on what it is, this is very case specific. there
- 1:14:54might be more facts to make a different determination,
- 1:14:57but those are two issues right there that might
- 1:15:01give rise to the appointment of Minors Council.
- 1:15:04Absolutely, absolutely. Well, with that, I do
- 1:15:08not see that there are any additional questions.
- 1:15:11Is there any parting wisdom you would like to
- 1:15:14impart on our crowd, Jess? No, I think we've
- 1:15:17gone over our time, so I really apologize for
- 1:15:19that. I just think that you can have a really
- 1:15:23good working relationship with Minors Council,
- 1:15:25and even if they're not advocating exactly what
- 1:15:29your client wants, it could be very helpful to
- 1:15:32you in your case. Just make sure you know what
- 1:15:35their rights and responsibilities are and you're
- 1:15:38able to work with them. And remember that they
- 1:15:41are people and attorneys too. Treat them accordingly.
- 1:15:44But thank you for watching. and thank you for
- 1:15:47being here. All righty this concludes today's
- 1:15:52presentation. Thank you so much Judge Dujon and
- 1:15:55Commissioner Thomas for joining us today and
- 1:15:57of course thank you to our audience. Have a good
- 1:15:59afternoon.