Latest / Raising Men / Raising Men Through Sibling Conflict and Identity Cries
Transcript
- 0:01Welcome back to Raising Men.
- 0:02I'm Shaun Dawson, and we're in the business of raising men of purpose and excellence.
- 0:09Today, we're going to open up the listener mailbag for another direct QA episode.
- 0:15We have two specific situations from dads who are dealing with some intense family dynamics.
- 0:24We're going to draw from the collective wisdom of
- 0:28All of the guests that we've had so far on this show.
- 0:31So let's jump straight into the first question.
- 0:35The first question is a father who contacted us because his sons are constantly fighting with each other.
- 0:41He writes, My son is constantly fighting with his brother.
- 0:46Should I let them slug it out like we did?
- 0:49Or should I intervene?
- 0:50You know, the old philosophy of letting boys simply slug it out.
- 0:56In the backyard feels like lazy parenting to me.
- 1:02And I think that it has a problem of it's valuing short-term compliance over long-term character development.
- 1:11And it's not giving them a healthy way of resolving their distant differences.
- 1:16So when you tell your sons to fight it out until someone quits or wins, then you're not teaching them how to resolve.
- 1:24A disagreement in a way that society finds acceptable.
- 1:28You're teaching them that physical dominance and emotional intimidation are tools that they can resort to, and that they're the ultimate metrics for settling human dispute
- 1:44disputes.
- 1:44And that doesn't actually work once they become adults.
- 1:50and it can lead them into a place where.
- 1:54They're just not really getting along well with society.
- 1:59The biggest boy wins, the smaller boy bides his time, and resentment maybe comes up with ways to get back at him.
- 2:07And both learn that conflict means that one perspective wins and the other perspective loses.
- 2:14They are not seeking win-win solutions.
- 2:19Now, flipping to the opposite extreme.
- 2:23is also damaging if you step in as a frantic referee and you know and and you do that the second your sons start raising their voices and you separate them immediately and you
- 2:39don't and and you and you resolve the issue for them, you're not letting them grow either.
- 2:45You're not teaching them, you're not enabling them to learn how to resolve their differences in a healthy way.
- 2:53Either.
- 2:55You become kind of a rescue mechanism.
- 2:58And your sons never learn to manage the friction of life, of a shared space, because you're constantly removing the friction for them, just like you would be if you're
- 3:10helicopter parenting them at school and interfering with their school's corrections and that sort of thing.
- 3:19So uh Damien Gomes shared a framework.
- 3:23During our show, during the episode eleven, that provides uh an interesting path to look at.
- 3:30He spent years, um, continues to spend years, leading young boys in the Boy Scouts.
- 3:36And conflict is basically an absolute certainty when you have young prepubescent boys running around in the woods.
- 3:45And he introduced us to a team building concept called storming, norming, and performing.
- 3:53So he pointed out that chaos is precisely where real world leadership and communication skills are built through active trial and error.
- 4:08And that's what he called storming.
- 4:11There's gonna be chaos.
- 4:13There's gonna be having to figure it out.
- 4:15There's going to be battles in between each other.
- 4:19And he noted that his hardest job as a leader.
- 4:23Was resisting the urge to rescue the boys too early.
- 4:28Once you get down to the norming part, where you're actually trying to get the result instead of figuring out how to get to the result.
- 4:38And then, of course, during the performing part, then you need to be involved differently.
- 4:45But ultimately, you need the boys to be able to figure it out for themselves, giving them
- 4:52Gentle nudges in the right direction.
- 4:56He, the way that he put it is that he wanted them to experience the discomfort of a broken process so that they could invent the solution themselves.
- 5:09So you can apply this exact methodology to your living room.
- 5:13When your sons begin to argue, your immediate job is to monitor the safety of the interaction, not to fix the problem.
- 5:24You're gonna step back.
- 5:26And you're gonna observe, and you're not gonna be opinionated about how it gets resolved.
- 5:32You're just gonna watch.
- 5:33Let them experience that tension.
- 5:37Give them that space.
- 5:38They're storming right now.
- 5:39Give them the space to try and to stumble and negotiate.
- 5:43If it gets physical, then maybe you call out and maybe you, you know, say, we don't hit in this family.
- 5:52By the way, this approach aligns really well with.
- 5:55Some of the research that I've read from Dr.
- 5:58John Gottman.
- 5:59He wrote a book called Raising an Emotionally Intelligent Child.
- 6:04So Gottman's long-term studies on sibling relationships show that children who learn to manage interpersonal friction without parental guidance, without the parents coming in and
- 6:18erasing their experience, they develop significantly higher emotional intelligence down the line.
- 6:25However,
- 6:26Gottman's data also shows that if structural aggression is left completely unchecked and completely unguided, it will devolve into a destructive bullying pattern that erodes
- 6:44family trust.
- 6:45So there's like everything we talk about on the show, there's a tension.
- 6:50So your role, the way to think about it, I think.
- 6:54Is to move from a referee to an active coach.
- 7:00You let them storm, but you establish boundaries against physical violence or even verbal abuse.
- 7:07If the argument starts to cross from a healthy disagreement into destruction, then you step in and you manage the environment.
- 7:15You're not managing the verdict.
- 7:17You don't get to decide who wins, who gets the toy, or you don't get to resolve.
- 7:24The issue.
- 7:26Instead, you help them look at the reality.
- 7:30And you say, and and this is one of the things that a number of our guests have talked about.
- 7:37Just to be an observer.
- 7:39You say, I see your flin fists are clenched, and your brother's voice is shaking.
- 7:44Call attention to each other's physical attributes, to both boys' physical attributes.
- 7:49We're gonna pause this conversation until your systems cool down.
- 7:53Once their brains are back online, you make them execute what Damien called a redo.
- 8:00You sit them down and you have them restate their needs calmly.
- 8:05You ask, okay, what can we do to solve the problem so both of us can move forward?
- 8:09And you force them to take total ownership of the situation and of the resolution.
- 8:16So by stepping back during the storm, and then by stepping in, only to guide.
- 8:23Recovery, you're teaching your sons that conflict is an opportunity as much as it is a problem.
- 8:33So they get an opportunity to strengthen their relationship, to repair their o their relationship, as opposed to an excuse to fight, an excuse to have a war.
- 8:47Our second question comes from an adoptive father whose son is starting to ask heavy questions about his biological father.
- 8:56He says, My son is adopted, and he's starting to ask about his real dad.
- 9:02How do I handle his feelings of being discarded?
- 9:10Now, I don't have any direct experience to this, but I did talk to Ryan North, and he's the co-founder of One Big Happy Home, and he had some great wisdom about this issue.
- 9:23And I urge you to go back and listen to his episode.
- 9:28I think that I can imagine that when your adopted son starts talking, asking about his biological father, that might be a challenge.
- 9:38Right to your own insecurity.
- 9:41And that insecurity might try and hijack the room.
- 9:44I think that it would be easy to default into viewing these questions as a direct threat to your authority or a sign that the love that you have poured into him isn't sufficient.
- 10:03You might feel a defensive urge to minimize the conversation or to
- 10:08protect your ego or just avoid the subject entirely.
- 10:15And I think that along with everything, along with, you know, similar to the way that I talk about how I experience my son's uh dalliance with sports, you gotta drop it.
- 10:31It's not about you, it's about them.
- 10:33Your son's questions, moreover, your son's questions are not a rejection of your fatherhood.
- 10:39They're probably just a cry for identity.
- 10:44And safety, which are things it's your job to provide.
- 10:49He's not trying to replace you, he is trying to understand the missing pieces of his own story.
- 10:55And that's something that you should be encouraging, not discouraging, as you know, uh assuming that your reflex is the way I think mine might be.
- 11:06So Ryan North walked us through this.
- 11:10exact reality.
- 11:12And and that was episode nineteen, if you want to go back and look for it.
- 11:15And he has raised six children.
- 11:19Four of those children entered his family through adoption.
- 11:23And he reminded he reminded us that a foundation a foundational principle that every father should memorize is that all behavior is communication.
- 11:39So
- 11:39When an adopted child begins articulating feelings of being discarded, they're not just making a statement about the past.
- 11:50In fact, maybe they're not making a st uh a statement about the past at all.
- 11:55They're really testing the structural integrity of the present.
- 11:59They're asking, are you able to handle my grief?
- 12:03Or will my anger cause you to leave me too?
- 12:08So Ryan's core framework for running a household is that nurture plus structure creates safety.
- 12:17So if your son senses even a flicker of defensiveness, of anxiety, of irritation from you when he brings up his biological father, you're damaging that safety.
- 12:32And he reads your tension as a sign that the topic is dangerous.
- 12:38So that closes his jawbridge and he pulls back into his armor his armor.
- 12:46And that dynamic is supported by work of John Bowby and Mary Ainsworth on attachment theory.
- 12:55And that's kind of all the rage these days, and it's worth understanding.
- 13:00And they've done extensive research that demonstrates that a child requires a secure base.
- 13:08To explore the world.
- 13:09And again, you know, our job as parents is to give them that secure base.
- 13:17And that exploration includes their own internal psychological history.
- 13:22So if the base becomes unstable or threatened by the child's behaviors or the p child's um emotions, they're gonna experience.
- 13:37Profound sense of anxiety and isolation.
- 13:42So your son can only process his grief if he knows that his relationship with you is strong enough to hold all of the questions that he wants to bring to bear.
- 13:58That's another kind of another thought that occurs to me there is that these are tough questions, and this is a way.
- 14:08That you have of modeling how to deal with tough questions.
- 14:14It also comes to mind that you don't have to be perfect because not being perfect and then apologizing for not being perfect is a way of modeling healthy masculine behavior as well.
- 14:28So one tool that you have to bridge this divide, to approach this um kind of situation is to move directly toward it instead of away from it.
- 14:41But bring curiosity.
- 14:44And so whatever he's bringing to the discussion, you don't try to fix it.
- 14:51You don't try to offer solutions.
- 14:54You don't try to make the pain go away or or
- 14:58Make the discomfort go away.
- 15:00You don't tell him why he should feel glad to be in your home or why, you know, why you deserve more respect or whatever it is.
- 15:12You just want to validate his feelings.
- 15:15You just want to be curious.
- 15:18And it it means that you need to figure out how to stay re completely regulated.
- 15:23You look him in the eye and say, you know.
- 15:27It makes sense to feel this way.
- 15:29And I can imagine that that's really heavy to wonder about these things.
- 15:33And it's fine to feel angry or or sad about it.
- 15:37But then you need to also establish a culture in the home where his biological history is treated with honesty and it's respect.
- 15:48It's not being swept under the rug, and it's not something that you need to avoid talking about.
- 15:53It's not a shameful secret.
- 15:57If you don't know the answer to his questions, that's fine too.
- 16:00You can say so without having to panic about it.
- 16:04You tell him I don't know the answer to that right now, but I don't know, we can figure it out together.
- 16:11Another thing I might mention is We all have varying degrees of success in handling conversations like this.
- 16:19And this applies to all difficult conversations, not just this specific one.
- 16:25But if you've snapped or you've gotten defensive, or if you've shut them down, then you should execute a formal apology.
- 16:34And Ryan North also gave us a refer repair framework.
- 16:40You go to your son and you own your own mistake explicitly.
- 16:45You apologize.
- 16:48You explain what you're apologizing for.
- 16:51You explain how you view how your reaction impacted him.
- 16:57You say you're sorry, and you commit to doing better next time.
- 17:01That's the recipe for a good apology.
- 17:05When your son sees you handling his deepest kind of emotional wounds or
- 17:10Really, just any difficult conversation with steady presence.
- 17:16He's gonna learn that he's wanted.
- 17:20You don't have to tell him that.
- 17:22You will be showing him that by your example.
- 17:25And you will replace whatever fear he has, a fear of abandonment, which I can imagine would be totally no natural in this circumstance.
- 17:35You will replace that with a fe with an unshakable foundation of belonging.
- 17:41Maybe even one that is stronger than one than the one that he would feel if he were your biological son.
- 17:52So that brings us to the close of this QA session.
- 17:56You know, we talk a lot about how fatherhood is not about running a flawless script.
- 18:04It's not about being perfect every day.
- 18:06It's not about having a clean answer for every complex emotional dilemma our kids throw at us.
- 18:13It's about being relentless with your willingness to stay in the room, to connect with your son.
- 18:22Manage your own baggage, to stay regulated, and let our children teach us what they need.
- 18:31Like I say, your son is watching your daily movements.
- 18:35They're tracking our own steps.
- 18:37They are walking in our footsteps to learn what it means to be a man.
- 18:42So if we want them to grow up, if we want them to have purpose, if we want them to have strength, if they want them to be
- 18:51excellent men, we have to start by demonstrating those exact qualities in our own actions.
- 18:57Thank you for listening to Raising Men.
- 19:01And remember, you are a great parent.