Latest / Design Speaks Weekly / Does architecture have a PR problem? | Elizabeth Farrelly
Transcript
- 0:00An Architecture Media podcast, supported by the Australian Institute of Architects, produced on Boonwurrung Country.
- 0:11Welcome to Design Speaks Weekly, a podcast that explores the biggest stories in Australian architecture and design. I'm your host, Georgia Birks, and today I'm joined by Elizabeth Farrelly, one of Sydney's leading public intellectuals, and a columnist for Architecture,Au. We'll discuss the public's perceptions of architecture and how it impacts the value of the profession. But first, here's the latest news headlines from Architecture,Au.
- 0:41In the news this week, Melbourne's long-awaited Metro Tunnel Project has opened, delivering five new stations, including Arden, Parkville, State Library, Town Hall and Anzac. Designed by Hassell, Weston Williamson and Partners, and Rogers Stirk Harbour and Partners, the Victorian Government has called it the biggest transformation of the State's railway network in 40 years. And in South Australia, plans for a 900 million dollar, four tower, development in Adelaide’s East End have been unveiled. Designed by Bates Smart, the mixed-use project would be among the largest of its kind in Adelaide, featuring a 200-room hotel and 700 apartments. And lastly, the Design Institute of Australia has appointed Simone LeAmon, former curator of contemporary design and architecture at the National Gallery of Victoria, as its new Chief Executive Officer, replacing Joanne Kellock. Those are the headlines for this week. For the full stories and more news visit ArchitectureAu.com. I'm Adair Winder. It's Tuesday, December two.
- 1:51We all interact with architecture in some way, but the public's understanding of the value and services of architects continues to be limited. Is this simply a professional image problem or a symptom of something greater? Elizabeth Farrelly is a veteran critic, urban thinker and architectural educator, trained in architecture and philosophy, and with a PhD in urbanism from the University of Sydney, Elizabeth is a former City of Sydney councillor and was the Sydney Morning Herald's weekly principal essayist on urban planning and city making for 30 years. In this episode, Elizabeth considers why architects have the reputation they do, and whether it's holding the industry back from leading on contemporary issues. Hello Elizabeth, and welcome to the podcast. Speaker 2 Thanks, Georgia. Good to be here. Speaker 1 Elizabeth in one of your recent opinion pieces for Architecture,Au, you stated that “architecture is the most public of the arts yet the least publicly discussed”. Everyone interacts with architecture in some way, but the topic is clearly still niche. Why do you think this is and can it be changed?
- 2:59Oh, look, I think there are probably lots of reasons for the, if you like, the elitist niche that architecture tends to occupy, particularly in the minds of the public. And part of it is to do, probably quite a lot of it really is to do with the profession itself. I suspect. There's a sense that…there are quite a few things. There is a sense that nobody understands architecture, and that therefore to kind of persuade them, you have to, have a, have spin. Architects, or people in the profession, very seldom speak truthfully about architecture and what we really think about architecture, and not only whether we like something or don't, but about whether why architecture matters. We hardly talk about those things, and we tend to try and justify it in fairly, you know, practical terms like economics or function or efficiency. But actually, we all know that architecture is about making life more enjoyable for people. Really, that's, that's what it does. It enriches lives, and we don't, sort of, we don't talk about that because it's qualitative and slightly embarrassing, especially if you get onto stuff like aesthetics, or if you want to call it beauty, you know, that is even more embarrassing. You can't talk about that. Try saying that at a council meeting. So there's, there's that, you know, I feel like they just laugh at you and think that's ridiculous. But there's also, there's also a sort of protectionism, which works in a number of ways, like, I think architects are very reluctant to criticize each other, because there's, there's a kind of sense of a guild. We're a gang. We must be nice to each other. Everybody, you know, we're very happy to bitch about each other's work in, over in the pub, over a drink, but we're not happy to have that conversation in public. And I think actually, it'd be much better to be the other way around. It'd be much better for us to be able to say in public, “you know, this guy's a friend of mine, but that is not his best building, and it's not his best because of this. You know, he's done these great things, and this is good, but this lets him down”, say, and then people would understand and so the bigger picture of trying to build a constituency for architecture would be, would be contributed to, I suppose. So that's a thing. And I also think the media is so rubbish about this. The mainstream media, you know, there's so much talk about architecture and housing and all that stuff within the professions and but the mainstream media offers almost nothing, about art, but even less about architecture. And what you do get is so ill-informed, so superficial, so much based on just regurgitating the press release and so daft. I mean, silly stuff like was in the paper the other day about one of Norman Foster's buildings being inspired by the shape of the handlebars on his racing bike. I mean, come on, you know? And that's kind of stuff that PR people put out and journalists should not repeat. So I think there's, a lot of reasons for it, and I think that all of them contribute to the reduction in quality of the public not just the public debate, but public understanding and in the end of the public world that we occupy.
- 6:34That's right, and I completely agree. Elizabeth, how about the public perception of architecture and architects. How has that changed over history?
- 6:46Well, a lot, I suppose, although maybe not as much as people might think. I mean, we have in our, you know, those of us educated who've been through architecture school still have that kind of background, sense of the gentleman architect, you know, the kind of somewhere between sort of Michelangelo and and sort of 19th century Bozar, kind of classicist, you know, and that, and that, someone who does beautiful watercolor drawings and makes a beautiful place for very wealthy clients and so on, and sometimes gets to work on public buildings and public spaces and that. So it's a creation of not just of beauty, but of a sense of order and sort of civic pride and those kinds of things. We tend to think of that now as being very old fashioned. And of course, the economic situations have changed, and architects seldom get a contract that allows them to behave in that way and to, you know, to do the old fashioned thing of doing the sketch drawing and then doing the working drawings and having that all costed and then starting to build and being in charge of the whole thing and making sure it all works. So that is a, is a kind of privilege of the past, I suppose. But, you know, I still think that in the end, architects have this capacity to offer a deep enrichment of life, and there's a tendency to trivialize the aesthetic as being a kind of superficial, nice to have, but I think actually it's much more important than that, because it gives people a sense of purpose and meaning and shared connection with, with each other, but also with place and with history through time. At its best, it can give it can really enrich people's lives in a way that doesn't necessarily make them better people, but encourages us to be our better selves.
- 8:49And would you say also, pride comes into that? Community pride?
- 8:53Yeah, yeah, yeah. I will. Well, I'm a bit resistant to the idea, to the word “community” – haha – it's one of those words… although one of my students this morning did take me to task for using the word citizen, they're going, “What do you mean by citizen?” I think it's not meant to be exclusive, but what I like about words like “citizen” and sort of “civic pride” is the idea that, we're not just consumers, we are as members of the public, we are, we have a sort of duty to the collective, if you like, and that we need to engage in a way that gives to it as well as taking from it.
- 9:39Elizabeth, another question I have for you, speaking about, you know, giving back as well, giving to the civic pride, an architect's critical thinking and problem solving skills can have impact beyond the built form itself. What do you think is holding architects back from being leaders in solutions to contemporary issues, such as the housing crisis?
- 10:04Yeah, interesting question. Look, the housing crisis in particular, I don't really think is an architectural problem. I know architects see the word housing and think, “oh, that's us, we’ll have that problem” but I actually think the housing problem, the housing affordability crisis, which I imagine is what you mean, is much more to do with 35 years of neoliberalism and all of the structural inequalities that have become normalized over that time, which generate this ludicrous situation where, you know, X percent of the population owns a house and the rest of them probably never will. And that is, that is, really ridiculous and should never have been allowed to happen. And it is, I think it's a direct result of neoliberal economics and monetarism and the whole. When you look at inequality, income inequality levels in Australia, they've skyrocketed since the 1970s and I think it's about that more than, much more than about just building more or better dwellings. So I'm sceptical about that, but I do think that, what you've called critical thinking, I would probably call something a bit more like “Imagineering”, is a really important role that architects could and should play, because very few, I can't think of any other professions actually, who are trained to imagine the future in three dimensions and be capable of expressing that, you know, in image form. And that is an incredibly powerful tool, which I think architects don't use. And, you know, you get the same old renders doing the same old people, with their babies and their cycles and their trees and their blah blah and the footpaths, and it’s all very, oh, yeah, sure, great. Um, but could we have something a bit more interesting, please? And what about, you know, what about, how would the world look if my neighbourhood becomes zero carbon? If this is a circular economy, what will that look like, if we've got, you know, I don't know, recycling on the footpaths and all that? You know, the stuff that could be happening and should be happening, this could be imagineered by architects, and I think that would be so exciting.
- 12:29And do you think architects also then have the skills to think about that vision, imagine that and then find the teams to make that happen?
- 13:59Well, look, architects don't have power. You know, in any normal sense. They don't have decision-making power. Nearly always, they're working for rich people or powerful people, or people who are both, which is to say, developers, politicians, wealthy elites, all of the above. And that means that when the really important decisions get made, the ones about money, the architects tend to get wheeled out of the room and wheeled back in to do the kind of pretties. So they, their capacity to make things happen is quite limited, but their capacity to inspire things to happen is quite profound. And I think that's where they need to be. They need to be braver and much more out there in terms of, “look at this world we could make”. You know, this is going into a green future, doesn't necessarily mean we all deprive ourselves of fun and pleasure, which I think is how people still see it. It could be, it could be so exciting, and it should be, and we can all participate in making this happen, you know? And I think that's where architects should be showing some thought leadership. By, by, through imagery. You know, that kind of pictorial capacity is so important and potentially so powerful in changing hearts and minds. Speaker 1 It's a communicating tool, isn't it? The image.
- 14:03Absolutely, and it's a, it's an exhilarating tool. You know, we can exhilarate the public about this.
- 14:09Exactly, Elizabeth, as the industry continues to rise to global challenges, or, as you say, move to a greener future with new systems and processes, the role of the architect seems to be shifting to encompass unconventional services that have the potential to achieve greater agency and impact. With this change, is there an opportunity to shift the perception of architecture in the future?
- 14:36Look, I'm, as you will have gathered, I'm a little bit sceptical about all the new roles that architects imagine for themselves, you know, and that includes, kind of, you know, emergency housing made of cardboard, and architects for climate change, which is great, but it's no more powerful than farmers for climate change, or, you know, whatever. It’s, it’s not, I don't think architecture will be improved by architects trying to grab new roles for themselves and reshape them. Even, I'm even sceptical about the thing that gets architects all excited again, as it did in the 1950s and 60s, which is the whole pre-fabrication thing. And you can, you know, you can build an apartment building in a factory and then erect it in three days, or whatever it is. And I think, yeah, great, but, and I suppose it is great, but I think the truth is, we're still the same primates that we've always been. And we really like things that are physical, and we really like things that are touchy, and we like things that are made, you know, made by human hands. We enjoy, there's something about us that gives us a sense of authenticity and connection when we have real materials and real textures put together in a real way, which is about real life. And there's something about a building with 350 apartments in it, and they're all the same, that stops you feeling “that one there, that's my home”, you know? And we all, we're nesting creatures. We do that. That's, so I think maybe that we need to be a little bit wary about, you know, leaping into kind of futurism of one kind or another. Without, and I think this, architects have always done this, I look at Corbusier, and I think, you know, Corbusier was obviously a genius, but what a nutcase, actually. Because, he, all these kind of ridiculous town plans that would have been great if human beings weren't actually human beings, if they were some kind of robot – great! You know but actually, let's look at, let's have a bit of self knowledge, and look at who we really are, what kinds of creatures we, we really are, and what we really like. And what we like is, is real stuff made in a real way, and we still respond to, you know, the way the light comes in and the, and the patterns it makes on the wall, and the textures of the quarry tiles that we walk on with bare feet and they're warmed by the sun. Those sorts of things are still the sources of pleasure and a sense of home and belonging. So I think we have to work from a deep understanding or deep sort of self knowledge, and that probably hasn't changed, and isn't going to change all that much. And I think that's important, because if we are going to be able to change to a greener future, we can't force it. You have to woo. You have to woo the human race. They need to be seduced into wanting this. You can't, you can't, you can't machine gun it into action, you know. So I think that it's, it's a really important thing for architects to think this is the creature we're dealing with. This is the weird psychology of the human race. Let's have a look at that, because aren't they messed up? And how do we make them feel better about themselves, and how do we dignify them and encourage them to, you know, join with community and be part of the big network and make the world better? So that's a complicated thing, and that's the same thing that architects have probably always been doing ever since, you know, ever since we put stones together in caves.
- 18:30Yes, we've got to go on the journey together, and remember that it's really a sensory experience and a relationship as well. Elizabeth, look to end our episode, we ask our guests the same question, so I'm going to ask you the same one as well. At this moment in time, what is inspiring you?
- 18:49Oh, look, I mean, I think it's a fairly bleak moment in time in lots of ways. I'm just going to say Trump, but perhaps that's quite a lot. The, I suppose the people who inspire me, and they've always been my inspiration, are the truth tellers, the people who are brave and honest. I sort of feel as though, if we all took our brave and truthful selves into our working lives, didn't just leave them, you know, on the coat stand at the door, we, the world would be a better place. And I'm, and I do think of lots of writers, people like Lionel Shriver, lots of women writers, actually very kind of, “this is, this is what it's really like”. But I'm also, I have to say, you know, we've just heard the news today that Mamdani has won the New York mayoralty. And I think, wow! That is a turn up! And I was saying to someone this morning, I reckon New Yorkers are going to go for him, because, and the more Trump is against him the more it will work in his favour. So look, maybe that suggests that there's a turning point and things are going to get better instead of go on getting worse from now. I hope so.
- 19:59Me too. Fingers crossed, Elizabeth! Look, it has been an absolute pleasure talking with you today. Thank you so much for joining me.
- 20:09Been lots of fun. Thanks, Georgia.
- 20:13Thanks for listening to this week's episode, which is supported by the Australian Institute of Architects. If you're enjoying this podcast, be sure to subscribe, share or leave a rating. I'm Georgia Birks, and this has been Design Speaks Weekly. Design Speaks Weekly is produced on Boonwurrung Country. We acknowledge the traditional custodians of Country throughout Australia, and recognize their continuing connection to land, waters and culture.