Latest / Chatter that Matters / John Ruffolo - Canada, It's Time.
Transcript
- 0:04Each week on Chatter That Matters, I share a story of someone who overcome
- 0:07circumstances. And in doing so, they get to chase their
- 0:11dreams and change their world and ours for the better.
- 0:15But once a year, in honor of Canada's birthday, I break
- 0:18format. Instead of focusing on an individual,
- 0:22I look at Canada and what our country needs to do
- 0:26to dream and to set up future generations to have the
- 0:29same opportunities we did.
- 0:34Today's show features 2 brilliant Canadians,
- 0:37John Ruffalo and John Stackhouse, And both of these
- 0:41individuals worked tirelessly to create the circumstances we need as a
- 0:44country to create growth and success.
- 0:51Before I invite John Ruffalo to join me, I also want to share my thoughts
- 0:55on Canada. Mind over matter is what truly matters.
- 0:59Let's be honest, we have stopped believing in the Canadian dream, and I don't
- 1:03blame you. The math and daily reminders do not lie.
- 1:07Our economy, our standard of living, and our productivity are in a
- 1:11free fall. If Canada was a product that a grocery store,
- 1:14it might be stamped outdated, and the alarmist would say
- 1:18expired. And I ask, how is that possible for a country
- 1:21with so few people and so much wealth? What if we
- 1:25focused on what really Matters, Growing Canada.
- 1:29It's time for Canadians to believe in what we can be if we have the
- 1:32will, and my belief is that Canada can become an economic and
- 1:36cultural superpower. But first, we have to
- 1:40shed our inferiority complex. Key have to believe in
- 1:43our ability to do much bigger things. Next,
- 1:47we must stop boring and burring our way to fiscal collapse.
- 1:52And finally, as voters, we must replace our love for handouts
- 1:56with a passion for dreaming and doing. Every level of government and
- 1:59academia needs to support the dreams of the mass majority. I want a
- 2:03country where crime doesn't pay, hard work is rewarded,
- 2:07entrepreneurship is celebrated, and academia is for preparing
- 2:11our students to Three, And our tax dollars are revered,
- 2:15and we see accountability, efficiency, and transparency are the
- 2:18only guarantees for a public service job.
- 2:22Canada needs to unlock our 1,000,000,000,000 of dollars of natural resources,
- 2:26our farmable land. We need to show the world that Canadians and the Indigenous
- 2:29peoples can harness this opportunity in the most ethical
- 2:33and environmental sound manner possible. And these taxes that
- 2:37we garner will fuel our new economy and fund our dream of being a superpower
- 2:41in Made in Canada Three Technology. It's also looking to strengthen
- 2:45our social net and pay down our debt. We also have to realize
- 2:49that much of the future economy is business without borders. It operates
- 2:52in the cloud with fewer restrictions and freer enterprise. Three
- 2:56creative entrepreneurs who drive the future are nomadic and will choose to locate where the
- 2:59best conditions for their ideas to flourish and the best place for their talent and
- 3:03themselves to live and raise a family. So why not
- 3:07Canada? We've all the ingredients to create the best living place,
- 3:11democratic, energy, water, diversity, culture, and
- 3:14abundant nature. We just need the growth conditions
- 3:18for entrepreneurial ideas to come alive and thrive. Instead of
- 3:22wet cement poured in the feet of dreamers and doers, we must jackhammer
- 3:26away bureaucracy restrictions and political narrative in favor of
- 3:29an environment that champions our economic drivers. They are the
- 3:33heroes. We must give our growth engines the fuel they need,
- 3:37supercomputers to model their ideas, capital to fund their growth, and a
- 3:40favorable taxation system that understands risk and reward. We that
- 3:50Key and identify and target equally strong
- 3:53talent worldwide and fast track their citizenship. Canada, it's time to
- 3:57rekindle our dream and, more importantly, our collective will. Let's
- 4:01shift our mindset to positivity and possibility and chase purpose
- 4:05and pursuit. I hope you find time within your busy schedule to
- 4:08stick around for the entire show. And whether you live in Canada or any country
- 4:12around the world, this message of hope, prioritization, and
- 4:16unification applies to
- 4:46It's a great country. Why wouldn't you wanna live here? This is
- 4:49Chatter That Matters with Tony Chapman presented by
- 4:53RBC. My first guest is
- 4:57John Ruffler. He's both a friend and someone I admire for his acumen and how
- 5:00our economy works and the delicate dance between private enterprise
- 5:04and the role government can and must play. John pulls no punches, nor
- 5:08does he believe in the luxury of time. Canada must go after the future.
- 5:12Canada must make things happen versus watch and wonder what happened.
- 5:16John Ruffalo, welcome to Chatter That Matters. So, John, before we get
- 5:19into the show and talking about productivity and what matters most to Canada,
- 5:23I have to ask you because the last time you were on the show, and
- 5:25I think it was almost 4 years ago where I interviewed you, you had just
- 5:29come through a horrific accident and a lot of people
- 5:32said much of what you've we take for granted is gone but everything
- 5:36I've seen of you for the last 4 years is your way of saying,
- 5:40I'm not a victim, I'm not disabled, yes, I've got
- 5:44circumstances to overcome, but you're lifting the spirits of a lot of people, not
- 5:47just in Canada, around the world that says attitude and
- 5:51approach matters. Yeah. That you very much, Tony. And I
- 5:55again, I'm not trying to preach or
- 5:59to, virtue signal, but I I actually really do
- 6:02not feel or identify myself as
- 6:06a disabled individual even though I've I I know
- 6:09that I am and I'm not one of those guys that, you know, will
- 6:13use different words. I'm a disabled individual, but it doesn't
- 6:17stop me from doing the things that I need to do. I still on a
- 6:20daily basis do physio. I do about 18 to 20 hours of
- 6:24physio after about 4 years. It's a part of my life right now.
- 6:28I'm not going to stop until I start walking
- 6:32independently. I do walk with, on
- 6:35treadmills, with walkers, with poles, but I do have an
- 6:39aided device. I do cycle with my feet.
- 6:43Not as fast as I used to. I'll be at about 2,500
- 6:47kilometers of cycling this year. So I try to do the things
- 6:51that, that I know I could do, and I
- 6:55I tend to not fret about the things that I
- 6:58can't do. I always said to my Matters, if I could find that switch and
- 7:02just turn it on. You know, when you Key, when people are in the zone,
- 7:05they have that attitude, they are parting water, I mean, they are
- 7:09doing things that people think are impossible and they're making it
- 7:13possible. Is that also maybe the core idea that we gotta
- 7:16talk about today in the show that Canada and Canadians have to
- 7:20start feeling that way versus being pushed on their back feet. I cited
- 7:24Carolyn Rogers, the World Economic Forum, basically pronouncing as
- 7:27dead, like, as a country. How do we find a way to
- 7:31have Canadians start saying, there's so much that's possible that
- 7:35we can be creating as a country if we just believe in each other? Let's
- 7:38talk about the great things in Canada. We are blessed. We are we are
- 7:42a country that's blessed with natural resources,
- 7:46you know, a welcoming, population as it
- 7:49relates to immigration, good
- 7:53people. We have a a good standard of living. These are all
- 7:57the great positives. But we're also a nation
- 8:00that relies on victimhood and more so in the
- 8:04last dozen years or so. And this is where
- 8:08we start running into a problem. We are believing
- 8:12that, the folks who do have the grit, who
- 8:16do wanna make the difference are are
- 8:19disincentivized or in some cases, you saw this
- 8:23from from a recent Canadian federal budget,
- 8:28demonized for their success tenacity.
- 8:32And it's, you know, an obligation owing to them that,
- 8:36while we're a generous nation with progressive
- 8:40systems, progressive taxation is not enough.
- 8:44And again, there's victims out there that it's not their
- 8:47fault, and all of a sudden we need to
- 8:51feel guilty about it. And the the thing that I
- 8:55really believe in is kind of how I think about it with my
- 8:58disability. That this
- 9:01country really owes you is the equality of
- 9:05the opportunity. This is what I believe in, but not the equality of the
- 9:09result
- 9:17outcome. You know, I always talk about entrepreneurs. You've invested
- 9:21entrepreneurs. I've been an entrepreneur all my life, and they they don't mind getting on
- 9:25a high wire act between the sense of risk to
- 9:28reward. You know, they feel that they have they're surrounded with the right people,
- 9:32they've thought it through, they're not you know, they're very careful, but they're not afraid
- 9:35to get on it. But it seems like as a country, we're pouring wet cement
- 9:39on that high wire in terms of bureaucracy, taxation,
- 9:43to the point where nowadays, I don't necessarily need to be in Canada
- 9:47to be on that wire. If we lose that energy and that those beacons
- 9:51of people that have that have blazed the trails, what do we have left?
- 9:55Entrepreneurs are odd creatures.
- 9:59Some of the the greatest entrepreneurs are extremely
- 10:03odd. Money doesn't drive most of them. Solving
- 10:07something big in particular is what motivates
- 10:11them doing something that changes the world. And this is
- 10:15why again, I'm gonna, devolve back to this
- 10:18federal budget. It wasn't about the tax. It was the narrative
- 10:22and the narrative of taxing success and demonizing
- 10:26the success. And in essence,
- 10:32popularizing the notion that we're all better off if
- 10:36we're employees, you know, and perhaps
- 10:39employees of the state, you know, as opposed to even employees of
- 10:43private enterprise. And and the the
- 10:47problem with that narrative is the
- 10:51people who you're directing it to are actually the
- 10:54most mobile of people. And then, frankly, let's go back to point
- 10:58number 1. Their focus is not maximization
- 11:02of their wealth. Their folks their their their focus is,
- 11:05can I solve this big problem? And if I can't solve
- 11:09it in Canada, I am obligated to solve it
- 11:13anywhere in the world that, allows me the
- 11:16greatest advantage in winning. And
- 11:20that's the mindset that we need to think about in Canada.
- 11:24At a bare minimum, bare minimum, do not get in the
- 11:28way of these folks. Ideally, get out of the
- 11:31way and support him in some of
- 11:35the areas that could actually help them compete on a global
- 11:39basis. It seems so obvious, yet when I look
- 11:42at what our leaders are excited about is cutting a ribbon at a
- 11:46branch plant or, you know, investing in something
- 11:50big and as opposed to going you know
- 11:53there's such strength in numbers if we unleash this entrepreneurial
- 11:57class and we're solving these problems, they're not just problems we're solving
- 12:01for Canada. These are problems and solutions we can be exporting around the
- 12:05world. Yes. I mean, it's it's kind of funny, you know, from a public policy
- 12:08perspective. So when you look at no. So so Canada
- 12:12has great people and natural
- 12:15resources. That just use 2 as two examples. One of the
- 12:19things that we are lacking is the
- 12:23deep capital pools that that perhaps the
- 12:26United States has. And so we need to
- 12:30invite foreign direct investment that
- 12:33coming in and in particular as a source of capital. This
- 12:37has been a big weapon in the innovation industry. You
- 12:41need a strong domestic source of capital, but you need to
- 12:45supplement it, particularly when you need large capital.
- 12:49So inviting that in is definitely
- 12:52great for our economy. What's bizarre, though, so
- 12:56here we are capital constrained. And then what are we
- 13:00focusing instead? We're focusing in on
- 13:03inviting foreign based multinationals,
- 13:07giving them 1,000,000,000 of dollars as opposed to trying to
- 13:10help create the local winners. Now there might be
- 13:14some narrow cases where it's it's it's it's required,
- 13:18particularly if there's opportunities for technology transfer.
- 13:22But what we're really doing is subsidizing with
- 13:25massive taxpayer dollars jobs that
- 13:29frankly, I think we can do in a far more effective basis. So I
- 13:33agree with you, But I'll tell you, you know, it's the easiest thing for a
- 13:37lot of politicians to do is to cut a check
- 13:41that not their Tony. It's the taxpayer Tony. You know,
- 13:44cut a cut a ribbon and say, look, look at us as
- 13:48opposed to solving some of the underlying fundamental
- 13:52issues. I wanna pull us back a bit because one of my
- 13:55thesis is that we can't have voter literacy without
- 13:59having financial literacy. And one of the words that's been talked
- 14:03about a lot is productivity and I'd love for you to
- 14:06explain to listeners what is productivity
- 14:10and why does it matter? Why is it in fact the lifeblood of our standard
- 14:13of living? When I describe productivity to folks,
- 14:17I separate the notion of productivity
- 14:21from innovation. They're not the same thing, but
- 14:24they're related. So productivity and it's frankly
- 14:28a more of an old economy, computation,
- 14:32that's becoming less and less relevant, frankly, with with the the
- 14:36digital economy, but it's the best that we have right now. It is the
- 14:40value of goods or services produced
- 14:44per unit hour labor worked.
- 14:48So you you have two choices to
- 14:52increase your productivity. You either produce
- 14:56or provide higher valued goods or services,
- 15:01which, is really the great
- 15:05value or the great driver in the long run, but it's harder to
- 15:08do, or you cut the human
- 15:12input costs, which is a little
- 15:15easier to do. Well, how do you do that on the the
- 15:19denominator? Well, you replace human labor with
- 15:23machine labor. And machine labor is really coming
- 15:26from the innovation industry, whether it's robotics,
- 15:30artificial intelligence. And the problem
- 15:34that Canada has is both a numerator and a
- 15:37denominator. Let me start off with the easier one being the
- 15:41denominator. Many of our companies
- 15:45in the variety of industries are not
- 15:48utilizing or producing that product in the most efficient
- 15:52manner possible. And it's important, particularly when you're
- 15:56competing on a global basis, because if you don't have
- 15:59the best product or the most, effective pricing,
- 16:03you're just not going to sell your product. One of the issues that we do
- 16:07have in Canada is that we do have a lot of regulatory
- 16:11protected industries, in which case they're not
- 16:14actually competing globally, but they're enjoying the
- 16:17protections of that of of that regulatory
- 16:21environment in Canada and are not being as productive
- 16:25as perhaps that should be. And when you look to see
- 16:29Canada, not just use the United States, the robotics
- 16:33that are used in manufacturing process in the United States
- 16:36outweigh Canada tremendously.
- 16:41And when I see the Canadian firms that do the same thing,
- 16:44I was just speaking to the founder, Key of Linamar,
- 16:49and that was their key to success in
- 16:52in in leveraging robotics in their manufacturing
- 16:56processes. Where it gets a little bit harder, but it's
- 16:59absolutely essential is how do you produce higher
- 17:03valued goods? Let me give you a very easy example. In the natural
- 17:07resource industry, we extract
- 17:11oil from the ground, but we don't refine it here.
- 17:14And or if it's LNG, we don't refine that here. So we
- 17:18send off the raw materials. We have somebody else process
- 17:22it. And most astonishingly, we're actually
- 17:25buying a bunch of it back as a finished product
- 17:30and paying an exorbitant price. Well, if you
- 17:34keep the value chain here and capture the
- 17:38profits throughout the value chain,
- 17:42productivity would also increase. So those are kind of the
- 17:4522 levers. I want to break it down for the listener.
- 17:49So what I'm hearing is we could measure productivity. The average
- 17:52person could cut 10 logs in an hour. You give them
- 17:56a chainsaw, it goes up to 15 logs. You put it on an a more
- 18:00advanced machine, it goes to 20 logs and you can get so far with that.
- 18:03But if we really wanna think big is Key shouldn't be thinking about
- 18:07harvesting our tree and even cutting it a log. We should be thinking what can
- 18:10we do with that wood to turn it into a finished product and enjoy the
- 18:14margin that comes from that innovation. Correct. So
- 18:17that's a core component of of Canada that, you know, we're still that
- 18:21hewers of wood and pumpers of oil versus it. You've come
- 18:25out and really talked about the move we gotta make on the
- 18:28chessboard is one where we're gonna drive this
- 18:32innovation economy. You know, we've got so many
- 18:35resources, intellectual, emotional, natural resources, diverse
- 18:39population. We just have to have a mindset. But you you talk
- 18:43about team Canada in some of your articles. Talk to me about
- 18:47team Canada and why this must be a collective and conscious
- 18:51act upon all of us versus just maybe isolated to
- 18:55even some people like you that are just very focused on innovation.
- 18:59And I'll use the innovation industry. So this is more of the
- 19:02classically technology industry. So why is that important?
- 19:06We for two reasons. Number 1, if we build the innovations
- 19:10and sell them to the rest of the economy,
- 19:14it makes the rest of the economy more productive. But with
- 19:18a vibrant innovation economy, the value of
- 19:22the goods or services produced can be extraordinarily
- 19:26high because, you know, you look that, say,
- 19:29a company like, like Google,
- 19:34they're they're producing all of their profits based
- 19:37on intangible or intellectual property.
- 19:41You don't need as many
- 19:45workers to do this because there's not
- 19:48physical supply chains building these products. So innovation is
- 19:52a huge driver of productivity. Now,
- 19:56so speaking on the innovation community, you know, when I talk
- 19:59about a a team Canada approach, I I
- 20:03use the analogy of a farmer. Think
- 20:07of the farmer as the as the entrepreneur.
- 20:12And it's up to the farmer to find the plot of land,
- 20:15to to hire the the, you know, the the the
- 20:18farmhands to pick the seeds, to determine which seeds
- 20:23will generate the greatest amount of value. And
- 20:26then the farmer relies upon the
- 20:30government to, perhaps
- 20:33make fertilizer more cheaply
- 20:37available, might develop the
- 20:40land, so that it is available for
- 20:44farming. It might provide irrigation systems so
- 20:47that the farmers could actually tap into. So it's those
- 20:51infrastructure like things. It might also pull
- 20:55away things that get in the way. So maybe there's an infestation
- 20:59of, of, invasive species
- 21:02or there's certain weeds that a government could kind of come
- 21:06in and take those away to maximize, the success for those
- 21:10entrepreneurs. And the third part of the wheel are,
- 21:16things that make the plants or food
- 21:20grow bigger, faster, stronger, better. So these are the sources of
- 21:24capital. This is venture capitalists, accountants, lawyers,
- 21:28the ecosystem around it. All Three
- 21:32need to be brought together to ensure the success of
- 21:35that farmer. And what happens, the entire community
- 21:40benefits from that success. And why doesn't that happen? Every
- 21:44time I listen to you, whether you're talking or when I read one of your
- 21:46articles or watch one of your videos, you really make such
- 21:50common sense. But it seems like more often than not when it
- 21:54comes to team Canada, there's a lot of uncommon sense.
- 21:57To be blunt, politics seems to be getting in the way. Canada
- 22:01Key to be pretty smug about the
- 22:05vast majority of Canadians for many, many years, for as long as I've been
- 22:09in my working life, have been really been
- 22:13governed and followed in the Chatter. Whether you were
- 22:17slightly left of center or slightly right of center,
- 22:21It never mattered because this is what Canada
- 22:24really is. And the United States, we witnessed
- 22:28the United States really over the last 2 to 3 decades, start to
- 22:32polarize and start to move away from the center
- 22:35and and folks starting to grab
- 22:39either either the left end or the right end. And we were kinda
- 22:43smug here, kind of astonished what was happening in United States.
- 22:47And it's crossed it's crossed the border.
- 22:51And what's happening is that when you start getting that polarization,
- 22:56you start pitting groups
- 23:00against one another. And, you know, that United States
- 23:04has its challenges on how they're pitting groups
- 23:07against one another. But in Canada, for some bizarre reason,
- 23:11we pit people against one another, economically speaking.
- 23:15And, you know, we're starting to see a lot of words around class
- 23:19warfare and zero sum gain. And
- 23:23when you start dealing in a zero sum
- 23:27gain and somebody is responsible for your
- 23:30perceived lack of financial success, this is when we start
- 23:34getting into the problem. So using my analogy, all of a
- 23:38sudden, people may not want to see that farmer so
- 23:41successful. Successful? And and, you
- 23:45know, I don't think that's very, very fair. And this
- 23:49is where Canada is starting to get into trouble and what we need to really
- 23:53stop. I believe that the first
- 23:56group that starts to come again together into
- 24:00the center and starting to work together,
- 24:05I think that will focus in on what the real
- 24:09prize is. It's not us against each other, but it it is
- 24:12Canada versus the rest of the world. And the only
- 24:16way that we're going to win, just like team Canada and
- 24:19hockey is getting our best, coming
- 24:23together and competing against the rest of the world and not
- 24:26within each other. So you talk about, you know, how Canada and
- 24:30I I agree with you. Paul Martin, Jean Chretienst, Stephen Harper,
- 24:35Brian Tony, they they really weren't that far apart, and much of
- 24:38our consensus happened in the middle ground. Do you
- 24:42think it's politicians, or do you think social media
- 24:45also has to be accountable for how effortlessly
- 24:49they seem to hurt us into these castles where we're surrounded by
- 24:53like minded people, liking like minded content, validating each
- 24:57other Three realizing, well, this is, this is all that's right,
- 25:01then those people across that across the valley must be wrong.
- 25:04Yeah. I don't think it's actually politicians at all. The politicians
- 25:08are a reflection of what's already becoming
- 25:12polarized, and then the politicians are responding
- 25:16to that polarization. It is interesting. It's kind of hard to
- 25:20put your finger on it. But, you know, when
- 25:24social media started to truly cross the chasm, it was
- 25:27about 2,008. And
- 25:31I don't know if you remember, Tony, in 2,008 when we were
- 25:35talking about the social graph and all of this great stuff
- 25:39that was going to happen. One thing I have learned over
- 25:4230 years of being in technology is that every single technology
- 25:46that I've ever invested in is a double edged sword. Everything.
- 25:50And on the social media, we were all looking at the bright
- 25:54side of this. So it's the same thing what's gonna happen on generative AI, by
- 25:58the way, unfortunately. And what happens is
- 26:02it was leveraged as an echo
- 26:06chamber following 2,008 Three
- 26:09slowly and haphazardly. And then all of a sudden you
- 26:13started listening and engaging
- 26:17with only the folks or only the sources that you really
- 26:21wanted to believe. And and
- 26:25seeing the other side, was was
- 26:28viewed as something bad. And and when the discussions
- 26:32from a economic or political perspective
- 26:36are Three decided not based on the quality of
- 26:40your thought, but rather which end of the
- 26:44political spectrum you belong. This is when
- 26:48we have a problem. And, you know, the funniest
- 26:52thing is even I'll use the political parties,
- 26:55we have far more in common than we have
- 26:59differences, but yet Key never ever talk
- 27:03about the similarities and and what we have in Chapman.
- 27:06Like family, like, you know, frankly, everyone wants
- 27:10a good environment. Everyone wants sustainability. But we
- 27:14deal with all of the small stuff in there or all
- 27:18the house because we believe in doing it in a different
- 27:21manner. So it is a very complicated issue,
- 27:25but I worry we're spending so much time on those
- 27:28differences that we're forgetting about the farmer. I wanna talk
- 27:32about some of the other things that you've you've been so vocal in the
- 27:36media lately, which I I totally respect a lot. A lot of people with your
- 27:39smarts don't have the courage or conviction to come
- 27:43out the way you are. First of all, impact to the capital gains that
- 27:47changes. You we touched on it a little bit when we're talking about incentive, but
- 27:51you're very against this for the very reason, not so much that
- 27:54entrepreneurs, whether it's about they're there for economic reward. It's just
- 27:58simply telling the world that the conditions for succeeding aren't there. So that's the
- 28:02problem. And this is the misnomer. And it's very, very hard to talk in
- 28:05in in sound bites. But it's not
- 28:09the taxation per se. It's the narrative around it.
- 28:13So so the full narrative is
- 28:17we've got ourselves into a spending problem in this
- 28:20country. I mean, again, let's just use common
- 28:23sense. Does anyone spend money that they don't have,
- 28:27or will they be incurring debts that your children
- 28:31or grandchildren are going to have to repay? Of course, you'd say that's absolutely
- 28:34nonsense, but that's what we're doing fundamentally. And then
- 28:38we're figuring out after the fact is how the heck are we going to
- 28:42pay for all of this stuff? And the part that
- 28:45really infuriated me was that, you know, about 4 or
- 28:495 months beforehand, it wasn't
- 28:53us who characterized this upcoming budget as
- 28:56the productivity and innovation budget. It was the government that
- 29:00actually said this is what it's going to be about. And
- 29:04the really sad part is, is that I was involved in the
- 29:07in the development of a few of the ideas,
- 29:11that r and d tax credit reform, the artificial intelligence.
- 29:17I was involved peripherally on the open banking, some really
- 29:21great things. And that's the sad thing I was saying. You know, there was some
- 29:24really good stuff in this budget, but then you
- 29:28overlaid it with the capital gains tax. And again,
- 29:32the entrepreneurs, ultimately, they don't even give it. They
- 29:36don't give a hoot about paying additional that. They're going for
- 29:40success. But but it's challenging for
- 29:44them at the best of times. They're struggling getting people in.
- 29:47Cost of living for their employees is tougher. Their markets
- 29:52are better than the United States. US government is a
- 29:55better procurer of Canadian innovation than Canadian
- 29:59governments on. I can list like, so many you know, the capital
- 30:02availability goes on and on and on, and they're still here
- 30:06because they love this country. And then the
- 30:09government comes out and in their narrative
- 30:13basically said, you know what? You
- 30:17are benefiting too much. Yeah. I don't
- 30:20care about the risk that you're taking. I don't
- 30:24care that you're betting it all and can lose it all. And frankly, you
- 30:28know, Tony, you would know as well as anybody. The odds of success
- 30:32are so stacked against you. And they're daring
- 30:35compare this to employees
- 30:39of public services who
- 30:43never take a risk. It's they're needed and they're valued,
- 30:47but they take no risk. They get, you know, huge
- 30:50pensions. Their jobs are largely guaranteed, and
- 30:54you're basically saying, I don't like the fact
- 30:57that, you know, they're they they might,
- 31:01and I say might have, a a
- 31:05higher effective tax rate. Well, they don't have a higher effective tax
- 31:08rate. One element of the income of an entrepreneur
- 31:12might be a capital gain once in their lifetime after
- 31:16blood, sweat, and tears, and earning nothing. And it was
- 31:20received as a big slap in the face. It was
- 31:24received by the entrepreneurs of, goddamn it.
- 31:27I'm killing myself. I could make that move, and it's
- 31:31very easy for me to do it, but I am patriotic. But
- 31:35at some point, now that you're shitting on me and you're
- 31:39vilifying me and people are calling me greedy, screw
- 31:43you. I'm just gonna go to the United States because frankly,
- 31:47that's probably where the logical answer is. And
- 31:50this is where I was astonished in trying to explain
- 31:54to government saying, folks, do you know what you're
- 31:57doing? You're actually biting the hand that feeds
- 32:01you. But at the end of the day, what we're dealing
- 32:05with is a political issue of solving
- 32:10a massive spending, frankly, to attract
- 32:14votes. You know, the polls are not, you know, lying here.
- 32:18The prevailing government is so far behind,
- 32:23the opposition that they're doing desperate measures, but it's
- 32:26bearing them further into the ground. And
- 32:30that is why there has been a massive,
- 32:35opposition to that, not only from the innovation sector, but from all
- 32:38of the small business owners, doctors, dentists, cottage
- 32:42owners Three realize, oh my god. You're coming after me too. And it's
- 32:46that little adage of you better speak up because you
- 32:50know what? You just might be next. That, that's one area that I
- 32:53think is just a massive psychological blow and I think your point
- 32:57is this is is the narrative is even more powerful
- 33:01than the actual number and I think that's that's profound. I I also wanna
- 33:04talk to you about talent and immigration, because to me, I
- 33:08never thought that immigration as a quota is a number. I always thought it was
- 33:12a strategic advantage for Canada. People would, cut off their arm
- 33:16to come and live in this country. And with that scarcity
- 33:19and that opportunity, we had the ability to attract the best and the
- 33:23brightest. But it seems to me now that it's not about the
- 33:26strength and talent, but it's about this number that
- 33:30I just can't believe that we can be vetting all of these people and
- 33:34saying that they make sense for what we need to do as a
- 33:37country going forward. Canada has great talent.
- 33:42I put it up against anyone in the world. No question.
- 33:46The issue is building a lot of these companies, particular innovation
- 33:49just requires a lot of talent. And we're not just producing
- 33:54enough of the talented folks, whereas other countries, you know,
- 33:57particularly India, China, etcetera, are.
- 34:01And we need those folks in order to
- 34:04compete globally. So, you know, we need to be welcoming these
- 34:08folks. Now Canada also has a birth rate
- 34:11that's well below the 2.1,
- 34:15children per person. We're down to a I can't
- 34:19remember if it's 1.3 or 1.5, so extremely
- 34:23low. And so we need a replenishment factor or
- 34:26else we're not gonna have people, to help
- 34:30support all of the social programs that we that we value in
- 34:34this country. What the change has been, though,
- 34:37in Canada was actually relatively consistent for for
- 34:41a few decades that we were sort of
- 34:45averaging around Three ish 1000
- 34:48immigrants. You know, I think the peak immigration
- 34:53in the last, almost 100 years was in the
- 34:57mid 1950s where it peaked at around 400,000
- 35:01people. But we had a much smaller population.
- 35:05But so again, so we've averaged in Three 300, 350
- 35:09for a number of years. It still was above the
- 35:13rate of housing. Our housing was a number
- 35:16that was between 200 and 300,000
- 35:20housing starts. So still didn't quite make it, but it was reasonably
- 35:24close. Our infrastructure was a was a different story.
- 35:28But what they would do is that they would cap categories of
- 35:31immigrants. And my understanding was, is that they capped
- 35:35the refugee immigrants at 25,000 out of that Three
- 35:39ish, which, you know, Canada is a great country. We have a
- 35:43social conscious. Let's do that. And but the rest
- 35:47were family unification, but mostly
- 35:51economic immigrants, which we need. So basically, these are
- 35:54folks who are coming here to work and to add value,
- 35:58whether you Key in the trades, doesn't matter, all good, but but
- 36:02basically skilled labor. What's happened running the clock
- 36:05over the last few years is that now we're at 1,200,000,
- 36:11like monstrous increase. We are, if I'm not
- 36:14mistaken, the biggest immigrating company country in the
- 36:18world. I although I gotta double check that with the
- 36:21United States. But if it's not if we're not number 1, we're in the top
- 36:252. Population size, we're certainly number 1. We we're number
- 36:281 pop yeah. A relative population by by far.
- 36:32And and yet Key didn't change any of our infrastructure and housing, and
- 36:36we don't even have enough jobs to support that. And and frankly, and if
- 36:40we did, we're not even bringing in the same skilled labor.
- 36:44We're bringing in many folks who are
- 36:48then going on social assistance, and we're just
- 36:52compounding the actual
- 36:56problem. So we went from a great advantage
- 37:00of immigration, and I would call it, you know, it was it was never perfect,
- 37:04of course, but I'd call it smart immigration to
- 37:08irresponsible immigration. And now what's gonna happen is that
- 37:11we're gonna have to massively cut that right
- 37:15back and to fix our problems, and that has to happen. And
- 37:19and again, we took this wonderful advantage
- 37:23into now something that's now a political hot potato.
- 37:27And a lot of folks are now vilifying immigration when in fact
- 37:30we still need it, but not the way it's being done right now.
- 37:34How many jobs will be lost because of AI and making
- 37:38and how many jobs will be created because of AI? And that has to
- 37:42factor in in terms of our immigration, or we're just gonna be, as you
- 37:45said, bringing in a lot of people that are gonna be relying on social assistance
- 37:49when they really wanna be chasing the Canadian dream. Yeah. This is
- 37:53a complicated analysis. And, again, lots of different
- 37:57views, so I'll give you my view. We have
- 38:01definitively shortages in certain areas of the economy,
- 38:05so the trades. My my friends who are home
- 38:08builders can't find anybody at all. And you've got a lot of
- 38:12talented folks around the world who would do anything
- 38:16to become, you know, plumbers, electricians, bricklayers,
- 38:20you name it. So folks like that welcome them
- 38:24in. You know, we really need to,
- 38:27to to to move the needle. Now when it
- 38:31relates to, say, innovation jobs in AI,
- 38:35let's go back to what I said at the very beginning.
- 38:39Productivity is, you know, on the denominator front is
- 38:42about the replacement of human labor with machine
- 38:46labor. In the short term, you will need fewer
- 38:50folks. And the difference on AI is it tends to be white
- 38:54collar folks, not the blue collar folks. The blue collar folks
- 38:58went through their changes over the last few decades
- 39:01before that. I do believe it's a temporary friction.
- 39:05I don't know how long it's going to last, but what does what is likely
- 39:09going to happen is there are going to be a number of folks
- 39:13who were in white collar, who will find themselves
- 39:17that if they don't retrain, they may be
- 39:20displaced. And finding jobs that are
- 39:24below their their their skill sets.
- 39:28And that will create frustration and that will
- 39:31require social assistance to to help support
- 39:35them through the transition. But like every
- 39:38other introduction of transit of
- 39:42technology, this has happened since the industrial revolution
- 39:46that, you know, the replacements Chapman and then people figure
- 39:50out different jobs Chatter never imagined before.
- 39:53The difference this time, though, versus the last
- 39:57150 years, the rate of change of
- 40:01displacement is the fastest it's ever been.
- 40:05And we as humans cannot move that
- 40:08fast in society. And so, yes, will there be
- 40:12a temporary friction in society for sure?
- 40:15Hopefully, it's not permanent, but that is the social
- 40:19challenge, with the, with the introduction of AI.
- 40:22So if you even took a conservative estimate of the jobs that would
- 40:26be lost, is it fair to say that even though we're
- 40:30not creating the birth rate to keep our to sustain our
- 40:34population, it is possible to say that
- 40:37Canada could be run very efficiently at
- 40:4115,000,000 or 20,000,000 people or 25,000,000. It doesn't
- 40:44necessarily mean that the numbers we've always put
- 40:48forward because it it we're gonna be going into an era where
- 40:52less people and more potentially more productivity. Yep. Yeah. I mean,
- 40:55there's a live experiment going on in the world today called Japan.
- 41:00Japan's had, I guess, about 3 decades of stagnant
- 41:04productivity, but it hasn't imploded
- 41:08as fast as we thought. Because if you go to
- 41:11Japan, the amount of replacement
- 41:15from a robotics perspective is astounding.
- 41:19Just walk in the streets of Tokyo, you'll see vending machines
- 41:24absolutely everywhere where they used to be
- 41:27humans that would be, you know, if you wanted a drink or
- 41:31snacks, etcetera, or convenience stores. And so
- 41:35you're absolutely right. It's a big question whether,
- 41:40do you need, aside from the trades and building
- 41:44stuff, which I'm not right now, we, AI is not gonna physically
- 41:47replace that, at least not today Takeaways, but, you know, maybe in the future.
- 41:52But maybe we don't need the same level of replacement.
- 41:57But I would say to you, once you do
- 42:01get below the 2.1, Three is
- 42:04a hole there. But it feels like
- 42:08we're we're we're filling in a gap that's getting us
- 42:12beyond the 2.1 needed to sustain a society. You've
- 42:16talked about Canada enjoys these great free trade agreements with
- 42:20countries all over the world, but when we look inside, we've got massive
- 42:23walls and barriers preventing us from doing business with each other. How
- 42:27does that change? Go back to the common sense. I'd use energy policy for a
- 42:31moment. And here's Germany. After Fukushima
- 42:35that, the anti nuke lobby in
- 42:38Germany convinced the government to decommission all of their
- 42:42nuclear power. And the very last
- 42:45one was being decommissioned as, the
- 42:49Russians moved into the Ukraine. And there was this
- 42:53moment of Tony shit. What did we just
- 42:56do? And I don't think that timing was very coincidental.
- 43:01And now without the nuclear power, the Germans were
- 43:05reliant upon the Russian natural gas, you know, and
- 43:09we're supporting the Ukrainians and and the Germans
- 43:13ask us, can we ship them LNG?
- 43:18And we have so much capacity of LNG, and
- 43:22we basically gave them the proverbial finger, and Germany
- 43:26had to turn around and go to the Qataris,
- 43:31a country where, you know, we have some serious
- 43:34concerns with, number 1. But number 2,
- 43:40if we said no, the only energy supply
- 43:44right now that that will give Germany enough baseload
- 43:48power is coal because they do have solar, they do
- 43:52have wind, but it doesn't give them baseload. So can
- 43:56you imagine then, you know, here we are with our high horse of
- 43:59sustainability encouraging in essence countries to
- 44:03burn coal, which is the worst of all possibilities. And I know
- 44:07that LNG is a carbon based fuel, but but there
- 44:10are no absolutes in life. And and guess what
- 44:14we get to do? We also get to,
- 44:18help folks out west and will Canada makes
- 44:22a great amount of money on that so that we could invest in more
- 44:25renewable energy, etcetera. So we get caught in
- 44:29the way of politics, and that's what drives me nuts.
- 44:33We view Canada as team Canada first, and how do we
- 44:37most effectively compete against the rest of the
- 44:40world, I think that would help us go a long way.
- 44:45That something Canada can turn into a competitive
- 44:49advantage globally because a lot of investors
- 44:52looking for those long term opportunities. I've sat around
- 44:56tables. It's been a beautiful sight to see how they see
- 44:59that in indigenous leaders. And there's, there's an
- 45:03opportunity there that Canadians have to, lean into
- 45:07this and turn it into that national, collective advantage.
- 45:11Those are the words of John Stackhouse, who works tirelessly campaigning as both a
- 45:14citizen of Canada and a senior executive of RBC to
- 45:18encourage positive change. He believes that we can have it all, growth
- 45:22and prosperity, care for each other while also caring for Matters nature.
- 45:26When we return, I pose one of the biggest questions I've ever asked on
- 45:30Chatter That Matters, one that involves all of us. And
- 45:33Sean's answer? Well, it might surprise you.
- 45:40Hi. It's Tony Chapman. Investing in Canada? Well, that matters
- 45:43to RBC. 500 $1,000,000,000 in sustainable financing
- 45:47to combat climate change. 500,000,000 for future launch.
- 45:51A 10 year program to prepare youth for the jobs of tomorrow, helping
- 45:55to discover the next generation of Olympians, artists monetizing their
- 45:58talents, women entrepreneurs pursuing their dreams, supporting mental
- 46:02health, and so much more. Investing in Canada, well, that
- 46:06matters to RBC. Oh,
- 46:09Canada.
- 46:15Native land. How beautiful the country is.
- 46:19Universal health health care, I think that's one thing that defines Canada and
- 46:22Canadians. People are wonderful here. Mhmm. It seems to be pretty nice. You can walk
- 46:26a couple blocks and there's something different. Everything. Maple
- 46:30syrup. Maple syrup. The weather. It's amazing. And I love Canada
- 46:33in, in the summertime. It's awesome. It's just so
- 46:37clean, free, open, and everyone just is so friendly. All the
- 46:41different arts and community, culture, outdoor life as
- 46:44well. I'm free to be me. Fuck this. These people. A
- 46:48happy Canada Day.
- 46:54You're listening to Chatter That Matters with Tony Chapman presented
- 46:58by RBC. My guest today is John Ruffalo. His mind fires with
- 47:02brilliance, his heart roars with passion, and his ideas are
- 47:05pragmatic and actionable. You talk
- 47:09about government procurement support and how there's
- 47:13a lot of countries that say small business is the lifeblood of our
- 47:16economy. We take advantage of the the size of the
- 47:19government spending and give them their fair shot. But that's not really happening in
- 47:23Canada the way it should be. Not at all. It's actually it's atrocious.
- 47:27So if I were to pick the number one
- 47:31bow bone to pick by innovators, it's the procurement
- 47:35policies of all three levels of
- 47:39government. The innovators are not asking for a handout
- 47:42at all. What they're really saying, all else
- 47:46being equal by Canadian, and we act like
- 47:50a bunch of Boy Scouts in Canada. Oh, well, we can do that
- 47:54because someone's gonna complain that, you know, on the the
- 47:57World Trade Organizations or what have you. And I keep on
- 48:01saying, have you have any of you guys ever heard of this thing called Buy
- 48:04America or have you heard of the Inflation Reduction Act?
- 48:08And every country in the world has their
- 48:11domestic policies. And and yet
- 48:15Canada is so afraid to be proudly supporting
- 48:19that. Now when you look at procurement,
- 48:232 very noticeable observations.
- 48:27The risk aversion by folks that are procuring
- 48:30is is astounding. And in particular,
- 48:34if there is a competitive bid and there is a well
- 48:38known international name, particularly US based name
- 48:42versus a Canadian domestic, almost every
- 48:46time the foreign international
- 48:49wins the bid for a few reasons. They get
- 48:53to people love to have selfies with some of
- 48:57these big companies because it's sexier.
- 49:02They they have the companies have far greater,
- 49:06lobbyists on staff, marketing budgets, wining
- 49:10and dining budgets, all of this sort of stuff. But
- 49:14the the even if all of that was solved,
- 49:19they are, and I say I see this so many
- 49:22times, far more deceptive in the way
- 49:26that they win their procurement. So what they do is
- 49:30the biggest brownie points goes to cost. And frankly,
- 49:34it's almost always cost because they can't assess
- 49:38the value differential. So they just simply say,
- 49:41Key. Who's got the lowest cost? Well, if you have a big multibillion
- 49:46dollar organization, let's go and and,
- 49:50let's go with them. And, it looks like that the lowest
- 49:53price. But what they don't understand is that there
- 49:57is differences in scope. And then what ends up
- 50:00happening is there is a variety of scope Chatter. And then
- 50:04over the course of time, they actually end up
- 50:07spending a lot more than they've ever imagined. You want a
- 50:11real live example? We're going through one right now, which is under criminal
- 50:15investigation as the whole ArriveCAN app. When you see
- 50:19what that original procurement I I I can't remember if it was
- 50:22800,000 or it was some small
- 50:26number and it ended up being $54,000,000 with all of
- 50:30these additions, changes, and blah blah blah. Like, the number
- 50:34of Canadian companies that said with the with what they actually
- 50:38delivered, like, I could produce that at a fraction of
- 50:41that dollar, but yet our Canadian companies,
- 50:45you know, frankly, maybe it's wrong. They go on Three on an
- 50:48ethical basis saying, well, you've you've said this is what you
- 50:52want and this is what it's going to cost. And maybe it's the lack of
- 50:56sophistication of our folks who, you know,
- 51:00don't realize maybe there's an opportunity for them to cheat the government.
- 51:04But, you know, it it drives me nuts. There's a is
- 51:07that is the single easiest way where you basically say
- 51:11every department, all else has to be
- 51:15equal. So this would add tens of 1,000,000,000
- 51:19of dollars of revenues to the Canadian companies.
- 51:23The greatest value you can drive to any
- 51:26business is to deliver them revenue, and particularly if it's recurring
- 51:30revenue. And yet Key can't do this very basic
- 51:34ask. Before we wrap it up, you touched upon, you know, being
- 51:38a superpower in LNG to our
- 51:42allies. Isn't that same argument Key could be the
- 51:45most ethically sourced food, could be involved, like, some of the places
- 51:49we could be a superpower in. I mean, we were a superpower
- 51:53superpower in AI. Can we hold on to that? I think of
- 51:56Nortel years ago with our switching technology and basically those patents
- 52:00ended up in in China. Our lithium mines are getting
- 52:04sold. I mean, is there a way we can, have this north star as
- 52:08a country that says in these 3 or 4 areas, we are
- 52:11gonna be a superpower to the world, at least to the allies that
- 52:15value the moral compass of Canada. You know,
- 52:18all things being equal, they'd rather buy from us than anywhere else in the world.
- 52:22Why can't we bring that forward as a strategy for a
- 52:26new economy? Tony, you're you're you're absolutely bang on.
- 52:30You know, I always worry that we don't devolve
- 52:33back to our past of being, you know, the drawers of water and hewers of
- 52:37wood. Yeah. But we should not be
- 52:41ignoring our strategic advantage. Let's talk about sustainability
- 52:44and EV. What did we focus in on? We
- 52:48focused in on paying 1,000,000,000
- 52:52of dollars to have, foreign based
- 52:56multinationals to set up
- 53:00battery assembly plants. Yet that
- 53:03raw materials, whether it's
- 53:08lithium, cadmium, graphite, nickel, you name
- 53:11it, is being imported by other countries.
- 53:15And why isn't it that we're not
- 53:18linking that to a Canadian
- 53:22supply chain, doing it in a sustainable way. I mean, in the past, we
- 53:26did these things horribly. It created environmental damage.
- 53:29Well, we figured that out, mostly,
- 53:34and and use that advantage in exactly what
- 53:38you said. You know, one thing about Canada, which, you know,
- 53:42as a proud Canadian, we used to have
- 53:45this moral authority in the world,
- 53:49And we we did lose it and but it's not
- 53:53gone forever again. And if we
- 53:56want to be the champions of,
- 54:00say, sustainability and renewable energy, and
- 54:04boy, very few countries know energy like like Canada.
- 54:08Let's take advantage of the great resources we have,
- 54:11you know, encourage the transition to the world,
- 54:15mine the materials that are that are needed, and
- 54:19we have the expertise. And how do we get
- 54:22it to be bigger, faster, cheaper, more
- 54:26sustainable with all the great innovations that we have?
- 54:29It's all a nice virtuous circle.
- 54:35But we need to get started on it. And, you know, the last thing I
- 54:38would just say is, it was part of the question you asked me earlier.
- 54:41Canada is going to be
- 54:45in serious trouble where if the focus of
- 54:49our nation is how do we carve up
- 54:52our pie by making each one of us
- 54:56fight over remaining crumbs of that pie
- 55:00as opposed to how do we just make this pie
- 55:04bigger for absolutely everyone to participate and
- 55:07enjoy? That's the mindset. That's the mentality
- 55:11that we need, and it takes strong leadership
- 55:15to get everyone thinking along those same lines.
- 55:19You think democracy as it stands today
- 55:23can bring us to that? I fundamentally believe
- 55:27in democracy and but I also fundamentally believe in
- 55:31capitalism. I believe in
- 55:35smaller government, not from an ideological perspective
- 55:39whatsoever. I just believe that the private
- 55:42sector is the most efficient allocator of
- 55:46scarce resources through pricing mechanisms.
- 55:50And until something else shows me it's more
- 55:53productive in the long run, I'm still waiting to hear that.
- 55:57So based on those 2, I think that,
- 56:01you know, we don't really have a choice, number 1. And
- 56:05number 2, I think it's very possible. I
- 56:09do think, though, where we're on this treadmill is
- 56:14whenever I go back to the polarization issue
- 56:18and you could see it very clearly and the U. S. Was even a little
- 56:22bit of a better example. Once you
- 56:25start to pull away from the center,
- 56:29then you get an equal and opposite reaction
- 56:33from the other side of the political spectrum that pulls
- 56:37it not even equally, but just a little bit
- 56:41more. And then you get the opposite. And then you start to
- 56:45realize, oh my god. We're really far
- 56:48apart on the political spectrum now. How did this
- 56:52happen? Well, what it really is going to take, and I would say
- 56:55specifically in Canada, and I'm gonna say that
- 56:5980% of Canadians like to be governed in
- 57:02the Chatter, and everyone who I speak to. And it
- 57:06doesn't matter on their, what their station in life or
- 57:10what they do, you know, again, they they're kind
- 57:14of in that center. I think we just gotta
- 57:17stop keeping on yanking to the
- 57:22to moving further to your political spectrum
- 57:25and move back into, you know, as close as
- 57:29possible to the center. And again, doesn't matter if you're left or right,
- 57:33it's all the same thing. I think that's the path
- 57:36forward. And and hopefully the
- 57:40first person to offer the olive branch is saying, you know that
- 57:44I love to see? I love to see this in question, period.
- 57:48Somebody get up and say to the government, you know what?
- 57:52That was a really good idea. Well done. And sit right back down.
- 57:55Wouldn't that be it would Key, like, I
- 57:59think we'd be shocked and wondering what the heck is going on. And of
- 58:03course, you will always get the 20%,
- 58:07you know, on extremists on the other side. And who cares?
- 58:11Because the 80% in the middle is is what we
- 58:14should be focused in on. But but I would
- 58:18love a little bit more of actually governing
- 58:22and doing things to create value and not so much politics.
- 58:26But that's what that's why I would make a very bad
- 58:30politician, I guess. You know, it's it's funny because I I hear you
- 58:33and John Love and some of the people that are very
- 58:37accomplished CEOs. They know how to prioritize resources. As
- 58:41you said, private enterprise is the best in terms of scarce resources.
- 58:45So to me it's not so much democracy that I wanna take
- 58:48away the right of the people to vote, I wanna have democracy
- 58:52come backwards for the people and not the party. It's probably the best way I
- 58:55could say it. You know? And I just look at the size of our government,
- 59:00the fact that accountability is a Key that you said. I mean, that we don't
- 59:03treat our tax and borrowed dollars as precious. We consider
- 59:07them almost, this this magical printing press. So I
- 59:11wanna leave with you sort of just saying, if you were prime minister
- 59:15I know you're working that some public policy themes, and I know that there's
- 59:19some big thinking that you're that you're investing in right now. Is
- 59:23there anything you can kinda leave the audience with saying if I was
- 59:26prime minister or if there's a prime minister that would get my full
- 59:30support, what would they be doing over the course of the
- 59:34next 12 to 24 months to just at least show
- 59:37Canadians that there's a sense of attitude, the switch is going on? I
- 59:41would say there's 2 key components without getting to
- 59:45the very specifics of the categories of whether it's economic
- 59:49policy or what have you. Number 1, can we have a
- 59:52plan? There is no strategic plan
- 59:56for Canada. What's the first thing that a CEO does
- 1:00:00when they get a job in a company league and organization.
- 1:00:04They develop the 5 year strategic plan. Where are we
- 1:00:08going? None of us know where we're going. We're all
- 1:00:11confused. And even when you look at this
- 1:00:15latest budget, it looks like it was hastily put together,
- 1:00:19and we can't define the past so
- 1:00:23that if we have to go through some pain, I think everyone
- 1:00:27would be willing to go through some pain if we see what the other
- 1:00:31side might look like or where you might be going. That's number
- 1:00:341. Number 2, what I would do, and this is where
- 1:00:38governments run into a big problem, is that you're not
- 1:00:42engaging with stakeholders When you start to
- 1:00:45think that you know the answers, because I certainly don't,
- 1:00:50and if I was in there, the first thing that I would do is
- 1:00:53understand the various constituencies. At the end of the
- 1:00:57day, government is there for the people, not for their own
- 1:01:01self interest. So they need to really figure out
- 1:01:04not only what the strategic plan is, but what is it that the
- 1:01:08people want? And it might be that the people
- 1:01:12want something that's not attainable, and your job is to
- 1:01:16is to get them to understand what
- 1:01:19is possible and what is not. But that
- 1:01:23dialogue and the last thing I would just say is that, you know, as part
- 1:01:26of that dialogue, Like, I really would love to see
- 1:01:29nonpartisanship. I I I I was on the
- 1:01:33board of an environmental organization,
- 1:01:37and we were looking at our board makeup and trying
- 1:01:41to figure out what characteristic of a
- 1:01:44board member that we needed. And I said that
- 1:01:49we need to find the most influential
- 1:01:53purpose, the person that
- 1:01:57really dislikes our organization and
- 1:02:00is opposed ideologically
- 1:02:04to that organization. And could we convince that person
- 1:02:08to be on the board Because we need to listen
- 1:02:11to the objectives and to try to identify
- 1:02:15where are the points that we would agree. It would be the
- 1:02:19healthiest thing, but we tend to be afraid. We try
- 1:02:23to seek affirmation with the same people who you
- 1:02:26already know in advance are going to agree with you. So again,
- 1:02:30it creates this echo chamber. So, you
- 1:02:34know, again, Tony, when you ask why have I been so vocal, I
- 1:02:37believe in democracy. I also believe that you need to
- 1:02:41speak up and you speak up not out of your own self
- 1:02:45interest, but what you honestly believe is for the good of Canada and
- 1:02:48give your reasons why. You might disagree with it.
- 1:02:52The more we do that in this country and actually engage in
- 1:02:56discussion, I think will be the
- 1:03:00pathway for us to hopefully get over some of these
- 1:03:03huge impediments. So John, I always end my shows with my Three
- 1:03:07takeaways and one, I am such a fan of yours
- 1:03:11because I am so aligned with how much you love Canada because
- 1:03:15I love this country, and I see nothing but possibility
- 1:03:18and positivity if we have that north star.
- 1:03:22And one of the things you said at the end is that strategic plan that
- 1:03:26says this is what we're gonna bet on and this is why it's gonna matter
- 1:03:29to us and more importantly, it's gonna matter to your children and future children
- 1:03:33because everybody that immigrated to Canada came here for a better life for
- 1:03:37their children. Nonstop. Every immigrant, every refugee I've had on this show,
- 1:03:41I left my country, my culture, everything I knew because
- 1:03:44I wanted a better life for my children. And that's the first thing I would
- 1:03:47love to see that you talk about is that strategic plan
- 1:03:51that has everybody saying we're all in. I love that. Second thing I
- 1:03:55love what you said about entrepreneurs. They're not there for Tony. They're there to
- 1:03:58solve big problems. They're there to identify unmet
- 1:04:02needs and fill those needs. That's what they play with. And as you
- 1:04:06said, they're often odd, they're different, they're unique. Sometimes they're on the
- 1:04:09spectrum, but they're extraordinary minds and that
- 1:04:13positive energy they create comes jobs and innovation and
- 1:04:16export, and we have to do everything we can to make Canada a
- 1:04:20magnetic place for them versus a plate turn the magnet around, and
- 1:04:24we're repelling that. So I totally buy into it, And the last thing that Key
- 1:04:28really was a cornerstone of this conversation is how, as a
- 1:04:31country, we need to move back to the center and find common ground and
- 1:04:35consensus. And left versus right really is just
- 1:04:38tiny shades of the fact that this is about Canada, what
- 1:04:42we stand for, what we're building as a country together, and having
- 1:04:46that sense of mutual respect versus what I find question period now is
- 1:04:50just being, getting snackable content from my little social media
- 1:04:54sound bites and a level of smugness that Key said
- 1:04:57and no, you said. I think all of that coming together.
- 1:05:01North star for this country, celebrate our entrepreneurship,
- 1:05:05invest in them, support them, revere them. Isidore Sharps
- 1:05:08and the Murray the Kofflers and Aldo Shoes and and the
- 1:05:12Lululemon's, all these incredible entrepreneurs that have come out of Canada,
- 1:05:16punch the boat that a waste glass, and find the center. I think if we
- 1:05:19could do those Three and maybe convince you to run for prime minister, today would
- 1:05:22be a good day's work. Well summarized.
- 1:05:28Joining me now is John Stackhouse, who's been on my show
- 1:05:32several occasions and why he has context. He's a former editor in
- 1:05:35chief of that Globe and Mail, Canada's national newspaper. Today, he sits in
- 1:05:39the office of the president of RBC as their senior VP.
- 1:05:43He heads up many strategic portfolios, including really
- 1:05:46trying to get a handle on the future. John,
- 1:05:50welcome back to That of the Matters. Hey, Tony. Great to be with you. My
- 1:05:53first question is there has to be 3 of you. As I follow you on
- 1:05:56LinkedIn, you are everywhere, and I'm not just talking about across
- 1:05:59Canada, but around the world. And really not only
- 1:06:03participating as sort of an attendee, but very often shaping the
- 1:06:07content on the stage. So my first question is, how do you find
- 1:06:11time to do all of that? I I think Three of me is a very
- 1:06:14scary, thought, but, thank thank you that observation,
- 1:06:17Tony. I mean, 90% of it is a great team. I get to work with
- 1:06:21wonderful people here at RBC. I think focus is really important just
- 1:06:25knowing what you're going to execute on every day, every
- 1:06:29week. There is something also to the 10000 hours
- 1:06:33school that the more you do, the more you can do. I just had Malcolm
- 1:06:36Gladwell on my show, and one of the things he said is he never ever
- 1:06:39imagined that 10000 hours would have been the thing that exploded out
- 1:06:43of his Chatter. And everybody comes up to him and says, guess what? I have
- 1:06:4610000 hours. He goes, that wasn't the point.
- 1:06:49So you talk about focus. What are you focusing on? Because I think, you know,
- 1:06:53the way I characterized you is you are deeply committed and
- 1:06:57passionate about Canada and the country we can become.
- 1:07:00If it's one word, Tony, it's competitiveness. Key need to be more
- 1:07:04competitive as a country, more competitive as an economy. We're pretty
- 1:07:08good, but not a lot of prizes for a and a 3rd or
- 1:07:124th place on the world stage. We've been doing a lot of research at
- 1:07:15RBC through our economics team on productivity, as have Matters.
- 1:07:19And it's alarming. It's really alarming. We are
- 1:07:23poorer per capita when you factor out inflation than we
- 1:07:26were a decade ago. We have fallen behind
- 1:07:31the likes of Australia over the last 25 years. Similar
- 1:07:34countries, similar economy, similar people in many
- 1:07:38ways, but they've really upped their game where we have not. We've
- 1:07:42fallen well behind the United States. And this means if
- 1:07:45you're in Ontario and looking at someone doing the same
- 1:07:49thing in California, they're producing,
- 1:07:53you know, 20, 30 percent more doing the same thing.
- 1:07:57And therefore they're going to be paid more, whether they're self employed as
- 1:08:00an entrepreneur or as an employee. That's just the math of
- 1:08:04economics. So how do we take a bit of a breath
- 1:08:08as a country and focus on that productivity
- 1:08:12challenge? This is a mindset issue because I would argue that some
- 1:08:16countries just seem to have a swagger that says Key belong as number
- 1:08:191. This is our destiny. We're we're here to make things happen
- 1:08:23versus Canadians that times Key more about watch and
- 1:08:26then respond to what happens? Yeah. That part of it, Tony. And I think
- 1:08:30that goes right down to our education system. It goes down to how we
- 1:08:34approach a number of challenges. And look, we are the envy of
- 1:08:38the world in terms of our inclusiveness, in terms
- 1:08:42of our taking care of others. And that's an
- 1:08:45incredible strength that we should not allow to
- 1:08:49erode. This is a great country to live and work in and to start a
- 1:08:52business in and to grow a business in. It's just got room
- 1:08:56for improvement. And part of that is the attitude. And
- 1:09:00why RBC taking this on? And I'm always been
- 1:09:03fascinated with organizations that maybe move beyond their core
- 1:09:07business and say that we have a higher purpose than just answering our
- 1:09:10shareholders. This is more about sharing values with the country.
- 1:09:14Well, I I'd say, Tony, it is our our core purpose to help
- 1:09:18clients thrive and communities prosper. And that communities
- 1:09:21prospering is about society prospering. And Canada particularly,
- 1:09:25our home market, needs to prosper more. Prosperity
- 1:09:29is not just economic growth, but it's hard to have all forms
- 1:09:33of prosperity without economic growth. We cannot
- 1:09:37afford another decade or so like
- 1:09:41we've just had. We can't go through the 2030s
- 1:09:45like we just have and expect to have the same social
- 1:09:48programs, the same infrastructure, even the
- 1:09:52same economic fabric of the country if we
- 1:09:55don't focus on these underlying challenges. I've been
- 1:09:59incredibly fortunate to be at RBC for close to 10 years
- 1:10:02now and do get to travel the country, get to talk to
- 1:10:06business owners, get to talk to community members and leaders
- 1:10:10in big centers and very small centers as well. And love
- 1:10:14this country. Love the ambition that you see pretty much in
- 1:10:17every region and think we have a great opportunity ahead of
- 1:10:21us in the decade ahead to really, turn, turn it up.
- 1:10:25I've often said that much of our success can be
- 1:10:28realized if individuals improve their financial
- 1:10:32literacy, therefore, they will improve their voter literacy. Because I find
- 1:10:36Canadians often cast their ballot for the free prize
- 1:10:40inside, or what's in it for me today, where I think a
- 1:10:43lot of what you're asking for is to have voters realize that we should be
- 1:10:47thinking about what's in it for Canada tomorrow. Is
- 1:10:51that fair? Yeah. And a a lot of it comes down to the
- 1:10:54basics of economics which have been, you know, these are truisms.
- 1:10:59Key cannot spend more than we save over a period of
- 1:11:02time. We are doing that as a society. Our governments,
- 1:11:06plural, are doing that far too much. Individuals are doing
- 1:11:10that too much. So, yeah, financial literacy, including for
- 1:11:14governments, is is pretty pretty important. So we need to
- 1:11:18save more as people and we need to invest that
- 1:11:21saving in entrepreneurs and people building companies. We have to
- 1:11:25allow for more of that in the in the private markets.
- 1:11:29Governments have to pull back a little bit, not radically,
- 1:11:33but a little bit to create more space for that
- 1:11:36private saving and for the entrepreneurs who turn
- 1:11:40savings into economic growth. Spending a lot of time
- 1:11:44understanding our indigenous peoples, I would argue
- 1:11:47unification reconciliation is about us working
- 1:11:51much better together. Where are you seeing the most
- 1:11:55promise, so that we can look at each other and say, above all, we're
- 1:11:59one human race, and this is one beautiful country to build. Yeah. What a
- 1:12:02beautiful way of putting it, Tony. I I I I get to spend a fair
- 1:12:06bit of time, with indigenous communities, again, across the
- 1:12:09country and and and always learn and feel very fortunate for
- 1:12:13those interactions. The desire and and and
- 1:12:17frankly, the growing demand for ownership in
- 1:12:21enterprises and in resource projects is really impressive. This
- 1:12:24is no longer about give us the benefits, and, you know, go
- 1:12:28go ahead and do your your project. Now it's about
- 1:12:32what indigenous leaders call say and share. So they want a say
- 1:12:36in a project but they also require a share of the
- 1:12:39project. They want to be owners, not bystanders. They want to be
- 1:12:43owners both to make more money off of their natural
- 1:12:46capital as well as their financial capital, but they also, as
- 1:12:50owners, know they can be better stewards of those projects
- 1:12:54and and think longer term which is an economy we need. That's
- 1:12:58something Canada can turn into a competitive advantage
- 1:13:02globally because a lot of investors looking for those
- 1:13:06long term opportunities, wanting to put money into something for 20,
- 1:13:1030 years. I've I've sat around tables
- 1:13:14and, it's it's been a beautiful sight to see how
- 1:13:18they see that in indigenous leaders. And there's
- 1:13:21there's an opportunity there that Canadians, many already
- 1:13:25engaged in it, but many more have to lean into
- 1:13:29this and turn it into that national collective advantage.
- 1:13:33Big fan of yours in LinkedIn, and I love the fact that every month you're
- 1:13:36almost doing Oprah's picks now, the books you're reading. So what
- 1:13:39one book if you could have every Canadian read a
- 1:13:43book in the hope that it helps move this agenda as a
- 1:13:47country going forward, what book would you want him to read? What a great, great,
- 1:13:50great question. I mean, a little known one that I just read was a biography
- 1:13:54of an amazing late Canadian, John
- 1:13:58Evans. And I compared it to the stunning
- 1:14:01biography of Elon Musk by Walter Isaacson because it
- 1:14:05makes a really nice couplet for innovation, sort of that
- 1:14:08bold American take chances and and and
- 1:14:12ignore ignore the risks with which Musk does and has created,
- 1:14:16you know, challenges, but also, incredible, incredible
- 1:14:19things. To that more Canadian John Evans approach of of doing
- 1:14:23things collectively, of building teams, of of
- 1:14:26ensuring there's support for something. And I I I think
- 1:14:30that's an important difference for Canadians to appreciate, but
- 1:14:33also to see how do we not only have that collective
- 1:14:37approach, but maybe a bit more of that drive. The other
- 1:14:41book I'm I'm reading now, which I think is really wonderful but
- 1:14:45very poignant for National Indigenous Peoples
- 1:14:49Month is, Valley of the Bird Tale, which is a
- 1:14:53heartbreaking but illuminating and in many ways inspiring
- 1:14:56story of 2 communities in rural Manitoba, and how
- 1:15:00they have struggled, this is a non indigenous and an indigenous community
- 1:15:04struggled through, generations. Kind of a metaphor for Canada.
- 1:15:08We live side by side, we work together, we go to school
- 1:15:12together even when we may not know that, and yet Key,
- 1:15:15are often, aliens to each other. So So John,
- 1:15:19my final question, because when I think of the people that I
- 1:15:23admire for their ability to think their
- 1:15:26heart roar, and have pragmatic actions, and you're one of
- 1:15:30them. I always ask, why aren't you going into the public service? Well,
- 1:15:34thank that you for the the the compliment. Look, I I I feel I'm able
- 1:15:38to help the country and as many are through the
- 1:15:41work I do now and there's an extraordinary range of
- 1:15:45men and women, at all levels of government, serving. So I
- 1:15:49applaud what they, what they do and hope that we have
- 1:15:53more representation of the country. But deeper point,
- 1:15:57especially for this conversation, is how to get more business people
- 1:16:00into public life. I'm always intrigued in the United States to
- 1:16:04see kind of this natural flow between government and,
- 1:16:08in the private sector. And it's not just about elected office. There's tremendous
- 1:16:12service that, that people can do in the bureaucracy,
- 1:16:16in administrative, positions. We've seen great Canadians like Michael
- 1:16:19Sabia go back and forth, and that's that should be an
- 1:16:23inspiration as well. So how do we create more of those opportunities
- 1:16:27for, government employees, civil servants to spend meaningful
- 1:16:31time in the private sector and vice versa. I think that would be a good
- 1:16:34challenge for us all to take on. John, I appreciate you carving out some time
- 1:16:38in your incredibly busy schedule. I'm a huge fan of your disruptors
- 1:16:42podcast. I hope you continue to find time to do that as well, and everything
- 1:16:45you're doing to campaign for a better Canada. So, thank you for joining me this
- 1:16:49special Canada Day, show. Tony, thank you for your leadership
- 1:16:52and always a pleasure. Chatter that matters has been a
- 1:16:56presentation of RBC. It's Tony Chapman. Thanks for listening.
- 1:17:00Let's chat soon.