Latest / The Resident Podcast / Fixing Portugal’s Housing Crisis – Resident Podcast Interview with Bobby O'Reilly – Ep.18 – 08-04-26
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: We have a different issue in Portugal right now, where
- 0:04we had a very good system with the Goal and
- 0:06Visa which brought in for a direct investment, which allowed
- 0:08Portugal and especially Lisbon to be reborn in the sense
- 0:14of renovated Lisbon. It became a destination for tourism. Tourism
- 0:19at one point was one twenty percent year a year
- 0:21until the airport became completely backed and it's over overcrowded
- 0:25as it is, hence them looking at building a new
- 0:27airport and the new infrastructures with their heighth speed trains
- 0:31and so on. So in a sense it has it
- 0:34has a good idea where what it needs to do
- 0:37which regards tourism. But right now the problem with Portugal
- 0:42is that there's a huge divide between the people who
- 0:47are on the property ladder and the people who will
- 0:49never get on the property ladder given yes, which we have,
- 0:52and that's getting worse.
- 0:53Speaker 2: Okay, you join me for a very fascinating and interesting
- 0:56conversation with Bobby O. Riley, better known possibly as investor
- 1:01and developer in and around Lisbon and especially the muj
- 1:04and Sulm where you have some interesting projects. Bobby, thank
- 1:07you for joining us. Today on the Resident podcast, and
- 1:10that was a great setup for what we're talking about.
- 1:13In a way, it's like the perfect storm for the
- 1:16most incredible, incredibly successful picture for everybody, like a win win,
- 1:21or it can go the other way and the gap
- 1:23between rich and poor can get bigger and bigger. And
- 1:26we're here today to talk about solutions for that because
- 1:28you've seen this. You saw it in Ireland, as you
- 1:30said that in our warm up, and it's something that's
- 1:34happening all over the world, this gap between rich and poor.
- 1:37How you know, speculation and profit is being enjoyed at
- 1:41the top end to the exclusion of our children's generation.
- 1:44It's becoming quite personal, isn't it. I think you said
- 1:47to me, you know, it's as parents we're thinking, how
- 1:49are our kids going to get on the property ladder?
- 1:51Speaker 3: What's their world going to be like?
- 1:53Speaker 2: And because you've seen this, you're bringing a very practical
- 1:56possibility solution to the to the Portuguese housing market.
- 2:00Speaker 3: Tell me tell us more about it.
- 2:01Speaker 1: Yeah, Well, I looked at it from a point of
- 2:04view of first of all, what are the problems? What
- 2:07are the issues, and of course affordability being the main one,
- 2:10and then the structure of how the tax system in Portugal,
- 2:13so that keeps the lay man down, keeps the working
- 2:15man down with regards to bring home to call it
- 2:19a living wage, but that's about it. It's a survival wage.
- 2:24And they're not incentivized, impliers are not incentivized to increase
- 2:28salaries for even people. And the attitude of the local
- 2:32Portuguese workers I need a contract more so than a
- 2:36career because they want that stability. They want that stability
- 2:41for their family that they can they can they can
- 2:44pay the rent or can pay the mortgage that they
- 2:45have it at the moment as well. And now with
- 2:48even global economics and global issues that's happening with inflation
- 2:52that's rising and food prices arising and either rising, there's
- 2:57an added i would say risk to the jobs they
- 3:03have at the moment, been able to survive within the
- 3:05jobs that they have at the moment, And if you
- 3:07don't correct it now, they're going to become dependent on
- 3:09the state even more so, which the state can't afford.
- 3:12Speaker 2: So there and the state will then just try and
- 3:15raise more tax on people who are already arguably paying
- 3:17too much of that burden.
- 3:19Speaker 1: Yeah, yeah, And actually how it's how it's divided. It's
- 3:23just not fair to even to either party, to be honest.
- 3:28Speaker 3: Yeah, right right, Yes, you.
- 3:31Speaker 1: Have you have people who feel that they're entitled for example,
- 3:35and I know I've said this for and people think
- 3:37I'm getting at civil service. But for me, the civil
- 3:39service is a way that it's not how good you
- 3:43are what you're doing, the fact that you have longevity
- 3:45in a job. Basically there is no no reason for
- 3:49me to to look to do anything better. But A
- 3:52I won't be long about taking care of that pretty soon,
- 3:54as you've done earlier on mone of your shows. AI
- 3:57and I'm A are now based on improving are hoping
- 4:02to improve the iless situation, and AI will without doubt
- 4:06take over a lot of jobs in the future, and
- 4:08so on and so forth. But if we work with the
- 4:10AI tools, with what we have in the structures of
- 4:12what we have, we can be become a lot more
- 4:15efficient and proficient with exactly how we're working. But really
- 4:19what we need to do first is we need to
- 4:21look at what's the main issue here, and affordability is.
- 4:23Speaker 3: The main issue.
- 4:25Speaker 1: There's two ways to correct affordability, the rise and income
- 4:29and how do you do that and then basically bringing
- 4:32down the price of houses, and how do you do that?
- 4:35Speaker 3: Yes, and both of those are going in the wrong direction.
- 4:38Speaker 1: At the moment, absolutely, and a lot of people think that, oh, Bobby,
- 4:43and what do you talk about? Bringing down price of
- 4:44houses is going to be no profit in it. We
- 4:46work on margins. Developers and construction companies work on margins.
- 4:52They don't work on amounts. They work on margins. So basically,
- 4:56by keeping the margin at the same but by lowering
- 4:58the taxes and by low the you can lower the
- 5:03cost of construction. And then you can incentivize the buyer
- 5:07by given tax credits et cetera as well and other
- 5:12programs that I have outlined in a paper that I
- 5:15sent you earlier on that will allow people to buy
- 5:19and give a guarantee sort of underwriting from the government
- 5:22with regards to the value over the next ten years.
- 5:26And what that also does is it allows investors to
- 5:29have confidence in investing in Portugal over the next ten years,
- 5:33because that's what they're looking for. They're looking for confidence
- 5:36within the governmental structures that you know, we don't change
- 5:40things tomorrow and the next government comes in change that.
- 5:43Because they didn't think of it, and although they're not
- 5:45the people who vote for us, so we need to
- 5:47change for these And the thing is really what they're doing,
- 5:51they're shooting themselves in the foot each time. So what
- 5:55there needs to happen is there needs to be a
- 5:57common together of lobbyists, developer, politicians, etc. With an idea
- 6:05to fix the issue. And not one parity can fix
- 6:08this issue, because you're going to only have the other
- 6:12one give up and complain about Because.
- 6:15Speaker 3: Quite so, there's two things to do here.
- 6:18Speaker 2: One is to understand the idea and I'd love you
- 6:20to share a little bit more about the technicalities of it,
- 6:23and then make the invitation to people who might come
- 6:25in and make this a win win. That is thinking
- 6:29bigger than personal gain, because there's a lot of stake here.
- 6:33I mean in some of our communication, you're talking about
- 6:35a pretty drastic situation and it's not just Portugal that's facing.
- 6:38Speaker 3: This is a.
- 6:39Speaker 2: Globalized issue, isn't it of how young people, less well
- 6:43off people are being priced out of the housing market
- 6:45in real terms, their income isn't going up and that
- 6:48gap is getting bigger and bigger. So first and foremost
- 6:50then before before we could issue an invitation to see
- 6:53who might be interested in joining this in a sort
- 6:55of non partisan and a big picture way. What is
- 6:59the general idea, because I think you've got some experience
- 7:01of this working in Ireland or you've seen it at
- 7:04work in Ireland as a as a prototype.
- 7:08Speaker 1: Yeah, in two thousand and seven when I was working
- 7:09in Ireland, I was working actually for a large development
- 7:13company that were quite exposed with a lot of land
- 7:19banking and so on, and we could all feel the
- 7:22market changed very quickly after Fairy May and what was
- 7:28a fairy Macro, Fanny mayor whatever the world? The two
- 7:30big banks, Yeah, they collapsed in the US and then
- 7:34of course that had a roll on through the wold
- 7:38I suppose banking crisis, let's call it, which then created
- 7:42the housing crisis. And the problem was that properly PISA
- 7:46started the fall, nobody knew whether they were going to stop.
- 7:49And we needed to draw a line in the sand
- 7:52and said to underpin the value that people could have
- 7:55confidence back in the market, that this is the lowest
- 7:57price that this is going to be today. And then
- 8:00we created back then, myself and two other colleagues created
- 8:06a paper that well, an actual program that went in
- 8:10front of the Irish government and actually in front of
- 8:12the Prime Minister the t Shop at the time, Brian
- 8:14cownt and the Housing Minister, and I actually remember the
- 8:21Prime Minister's words to me said, Bobby, this is a
- 8:24brilliant plan, but the only problem is, and this was
- 8:27the optics issue that we had in Ireland, was this
- 8:31is a great plan, but it's going to be seen
- 8:33like and bailing out the builders, you know, another political suicide.
- 8:38Speaker 2: So we've done that with the bankers, We've done that
- 8:40with the bankers. We called it for the builders as well.
- 8:42Speaker 1: So this was even before the bailed out of the bankers,
- 8:46and this would have stopped them having the bail out
- 8:48the bankers had they actually implemented it. They did actually
- 8:50take on board the document, but it took him ten
- 8:53years stroll that out. They introduced i think called NAMA,
- 8:56which was the National Asset Management Agency, which had certain attributes,
- 9:00some bad and you could compare it today with what
- 9:04was bank the spiritu sangtu good bank, bad bank if
- 9:07you know me a novo bank going the best. But
- 9:11it was a quite similar situation of what they did
- 9:13back then. But I won't go into the details of ironment.
- 9:16But what happened was that we realized that in advance
- 9:21there was a correction that happened. But what you had
- 9:24to do was create a confidence to create that correction,
- 9:28to stabilize first of all, then incentivize after. So what
- 9:33we have to do here, first of all is we
- 9:36have to have to look, as I said already, what's
- 9:37the affordable issues? And the issues really are about two things.
- 9:41One is the way the social security and taxation on
- 9:47everybody in Portugal on the living wage that's say, allows
- 9:51it doesn't allowed them to compete within a property market
- 9:55of purchasing, so they can't get on the property ladder.
- 9:59And then also the tax station that's on the cost
- 10:01of housing and the fact that there is a limited
- 10:03amount of housing being granted and planning being granted every year.
- 10:08Hence they brought in a new program to try and
- 10:10speed it up again. But people, even developers, are still
- 10:13afraid to build that speed because they don't know what's
- 10:15going to happen next year, will people be able to
- 10:18afford them next year, what's going on in the world,
- 10:20So they also need that I would you say security
- 10:25that there's going to be a market to sell too,
- 10:27So there's a number of things that have to do.
- 10:29The first thing they have to do is they have
- 10:31to lower and by the way, the program that are
- 10:35the plan that I've created, it's fiscally responsible. It just
- 10:39changes the way the taxation is done and who's taxed
- 10:44and bringing in more stealth taxes than than actual direct
- 10:47taxation on the lower paid. So people who are for example,
- 10:51buying a carrol over sixty thousand euros would pay extra
- 10:54taxes on a car, buy a boat, it's or luxury
- 10:57items would be this. But on essential snow, on grocery essentials,
- 11:01there's no style taxes increase. But there has to be
- 11:04a lowering of the social security from both sides, from
- 11:09the employer side and the employee side. Why because you
- 11:11want to have the employer incentifize, to incentivize his staff
- 11:17to work harder for a pay rise and to work
- 11:20better so it gives them more security. But also from
- 11:23the employee side that he has more money in his pocket.
- 11:26And when you read my paper, that gives them between
- 11:29ninety to one hundred euros more per month in his pocket.
- 11:32Now it sounds not like a doesn't sound like an
- 11:35awful lot more, but when you compare it as a
- 11:37percentage ice what they have, it's probably around another ten
- 11:40to fifteen percent of what their take home pay is
- 11:43at the moment.
- 11:44Speaker 3: Okay, And it changes direction, doesn't it.
- 11:46Speaker 2: It changes direction and intention I guess around how enterprising
- 11:52people might be rather than the resignation, the sense of resignation.
- 11:56I think you've articulated well there that we see.
- 11:59Speaker 1: Yeah, I think people actually have in their head now,
- 12:01I can never afford a host And that's actually also
- 12:03why you have the brain drain so many young people
- 12:05coming out of and what you're training them to work
- 12:09in your competite competitive countries, You know what I mean?
- 12:12Speaker 2: Yes, that's exactly what happens in Portugal, isn't it. The
- 12:15standard of education is excellent. Young people are trained to
- 12:19a very high standard. And the first thing they do,
- 12:21because it's been drummed into them since they were kids
- 12:23by their parents and their older siblings and their cousins,
- 12:26is to go and take all of that knowledge and
- 12:28work abroad for three times the money they would get
- 12:31at an entry level job here in Portugal.
- 12:33Speaker 1: Correct, And then they're can afford housing, and they can
- 12:37afford a lifestyle, and they can have the lifestyle that want.
- 12:39But I can guarantee that everybody, every one of them
- 12:42that are in whatever country and part of the world,
- 12:44if they could afford to live in Portugal and have
- 12:47the standard of living of which a lot of us
- 12:49enjoy did come home.
- 12:51Speaker 3: Why wouldn't they?
- 12:52Speaker 2: Why wouldn't they? You know, Bobby, So dad is a
- 12:55very well known concept. I've got a new one that's
- 12:59about this, which is go dad, which is what the
- 13:02foreigners have when they see exactly what we've just talked about.
- 13:06We love the life and the culture here in Portugal,
- 13:09and to see young people go from it gives me
- 13:13go dad, gives me a sadness about how young people
- 13:15are leaving it and the country that they would ideally
- 13:19love to bring their children up in, but go and
- 13:21work somewhere else to earn decent money. That is a
- 13:24terrible problem that this country hasn't And I love the
- 13:26sound of a project that might be put in that right,
- 13:30which is what you're talking about.
- 13:31Speaker 1: Yeah, And then we have what we call the incentivization
- 13:36side of it. How do I incentivize somebody to get
- 13:39on the property ladder and again being physically responsible, and
- 13:44as I said here, we won't go into the actual
- 13:47mathematical detail of it, but it's in the document that
- 13:50I that I sent earlier, and it's for sharing for
- 13:53anybody who wants to see it. Okay, But actually after
- 13:56year five it'll increase the purse buy between four hundred
- 14:01and five hundred million euros a year by doing this.
- 14:04So the first thing they have to do is to
- 14:06give a tax credit to buyers homeowners, not investors, not investors.
- 14:12As second home investors, there is a taxation and second
- 14:14home and also incentive on investors as well. But say
- 14:17we take the bare minimum first of all, that somebody
- 14:21who is looking to get on the proper ladder today
- 14:23should get a tax credit, a five year ten year
- 14:26tax credit. But that basically means of an amount that
- 14:30they will not pay x amount of tax if they
- 14:33buy this house that comes out of their normal direct
- 14:36income tax, which actually leaves them more affordable in the
- 14:40sense that they again they'll have more money in the
- 14:42pocket for the fact that they're buying this house. Okay. Also,
- 14:46they need to decrease the taxation on the development cost.
- 14:52Right now to build a house, everything you buy is
- 14:57a twenty three percent plus. It's even on top of it.
- 15:00So if a brick cost the euro, it's plus twenty
- 15:03three cents, okay, on top of that, plus the IRS
- 15:07plus the planning plus this plus that plus the other.
- 15:11It's all plus plus plus plus. Yes, I think we
- 15:15worked there with something like thirty three percent of the
- 15:17cost of construction. It's gone in taxes. So people say
- 15:21that the health prices are increasing, it's because the taxation
- 15:23is increasing. And if the cost of of an I
- 15:26is going up, cost of steel rises, concrete rises, labor rises,
- 15:30that means it's it's climate letters twenty three plus those
- 15:33extras and top again. So the cost of construction has
- 15:36gone to a point where it's it's putting it out
- 15:40of control of the people who need to buy the housing. Yes,
- 15:44so there's two things that happen. You need to reduce
- 15:47the IRS by fifty percent, bringing it from twenty to
- 15:50ten for construction on the taxation of the profits, and
- 15:54also do away with the IMT and the EVA on
- 15:58the actual construction cost. What that does it reduces the
- 16:03cost of construction considerably. Now it would only be granted
- 16:09to construction companies that are let's say approved, like what
- 16:18you would do with a planning permission that you're building
- 16:21an affordable housing scheme, not a social housing scheme, an
- 16:24affordable housing scheme, and that affordable housing scheme is the
- 16:27aim between building a property a house home beteing two
- 16:30hundred and fifty and three hundred and fifty depending on
- 16:33the location of where it is because of the cost
- 16:35of land and so on. Okay, by doing this program
- 16:40and rolling out around the country, you increase the amount
- 16:43of properties that become available. You also, by doing that,
- 16:46you actually end up correcting the land prices as well
- 16:51the cost of the land that you build on, because
- 16:55now the market is starting to get saturated with properties,
- 17:00but affordable properties. And for a developer to like myself,
- 17:05for example, to come under those bands, I would have
- 17:08to satisfy the criteria that would be set out by
- 17:13the government that these houses will be sold to these
- 17:16prices at these standards and will be a greenhouse, an
- 17:19A or an A plus house. Okay, So I can
- 17:23work out as a calculation this is what's going to
- 17:24cost me, but it's still within my margin, and we
- 17:27work between fifteen to eighteen percent margins on construction, okay,
- 17:32on costing and building to sell. So it's a fifteen
- 17:35to eighteen percent margin what you're looking at after your
- 17:37land costs and so on. And then if you then
- 17:41allow for the people that who are buying it to
- 17:43have the tax credit because they're buying that affordable housing
- 17:46and it's an A plus housing they say, but also
- 17:49another one hundred, one hundred and twenty euros a month
- 17:51on utility builds. So again they have more money in
- 17:54their pocket every month as well because they bought the
- 17:58green plus house. Now I'm inviting investors to come in
- 18:03and to buy the same house but under a fixed
- 18:07rental structure. So for example, they buy the house for
- 18:10three hundred and fifty thousand or three hundred thousand, but
- 18:13a rent is set between eight hundred and eight hundred
- 18:16and fifty euros a month for the house that they
- 18:18can rent it for, but they don't pay any tax
- 18:21for ten years on the rental income. Now you would say, well,
- 18:25what's the where's the government's incentive there? Number one, they're
- 18:28getting people into houses straight away and they don't have
- 18:31the burden to actually have the house people and given
- 18:35other supplementary payments for people who need housing and so on.
- 18:40So the thing is that that person has to keep
- 18:43the rent at that price, allowing for the indexation of
- 18:47the government allowance perannum as well over that ten year period,
- 18:50but pay no tax on the income for ten years.
- 18:54That will typically bring DAIR return from four point eight
- 18:58percent to six point eight percent over ten year period
- 19:00on an annual basis. And at the end of the
- 19:03ten years they have a tangible acid that now they
- 19:05can sell at a normal market rate. And if the
- 19:07program rocks and rolls out properly, you will have a
- 19:10good supply of properties all over that basically should balance
- 19:15the level of housing prices throughout the whole country. Yes,
- 19:21and my proposal is that you would run a test
- 19:24through five different cities in Portugal where the housing crisis is,
- 19:30let's say, more demanding than the rest of the country.
- 19:34Not try to get people to build houses in places
- 19:36where nobody wants to live, because people are moving to
- 19:40where the jobs are, and people are moving where the
- 19:42lifestyle is in the country is and so on. And
- 19:45then alongside of that, and this is probably the key,
- 19:50we introduce a new Golden visa. But it's the solidarity visa,
- 19:53and the Solidarity visa is a visa like the Golden Visa.
- 19:57But it's it's it's the the opposite of what the
- 20:01Golden Visa did. A lot of people say, all the
- 20:03Golden Visa sort of destroy the housing prices in market
- 20:06and so on by everybody buying in the city center,
- 20:09pushing people out and so on, so forth, and rows
- 20:12the cost of housing. I don't agree with that, first
- 20:15of all, because number one, there's only been about twenty
- 20:17thousand applications in the last twenty or last and we
- 20:23see what we're talking about thirteen years, we do an
- 20:27average one hundred and eighty to one hundred and twenty sorry,
- 20:29one hundred and eighty to two hundred thousand transactions on
- 20:32real estate every year, and if you're talking about twenty
- 20:35thousand over a thirteen year period, it didn't have then done.
- 20:39There What the reason we have price increases because nobody
- 20:42is building and not houses, because no one can afford
- 20:46the type of housing that they are able by. And
- 20:48everybody is now aiming at the high end market because
- 20:51it's the only affordable market that's there right now. And
- 20:55outside and arwa here they're looking for a million euros
- 20:57for one hundred and sixty square meter house. Yes, there's
- 21:01no one Portugal today and that has a normal, regular
- 21:04job can afford that house or even to rent it.
- 21:06It's one hundred and sixty square meter house, not a mansion,
- 21:09it's a normal house. And it's still forty minutes to
- 21:12get to Lisbon or thirty five minutes to get to
- 21:13Lisbon by the commute. So it's unrealistic to assume that
- 21:19that can continue bar we have loads and loads of
- 21:21more foreigners that's going to come in and up take
- 21:24it because they can afford it. Anything else to the
- 21:27community other than the taxation that the government is getting
- 21:30on those prices of those houses.
- 21:32Speaker 2: Whilst they're pricing out local people because they can afford
- 21:35the rent.
- 21:37Speaker 1: That eighty percent of your buying market is still Portuguese.
- 21:41But but yeah, buying stuff that's pre nineteen eighties, that
- 21:45is built before nineteeney and not fit for purpose.
- 21:48Speaker 2: Now, and they're they're facing another burden of energy costs
- 21:52from a poorly built home. Arguably the other thing there
- 21:56with with the Golden Visa and it is it's kind
- 21:58of a useful, polite cool illusion, isn't it to have
- 22:02people who have been priced out of housing blaming people
- 22:05who are buying the houses that they would never have
- 22:07probably bought anyway, but they are seen as the enemy.
- 22:09The obvious thing was, presumably, and people must have suggested this,
- 22:14I know it certainly occurred to me, is to take
- 22:17what came in from the Golden Visa and invest that
- 22:19into affordable housing. That seems like a really obvious mechanism.
- 22:24That's what you're talking about, is it not?
- 22:26Speaker 1: Well, not really, because they'd helped the money that because
- 22:29of the deficit that we had in after the banking crisis,
- 22:33that they use that money to basically rebuild the country
- 22:36to where it is at the moment. So they're taking billions,
- 22:39not billions and billions of billions with regards to not
- 22:42because the Golden Visa investor didn't just buy five hundred
- 22:45thousand euro house to kept investing. I had investors that
- 22:48would have invested ten and twenty million euros and twenty
- 22:50million meters into different projects as investors as they went along.
- 22:55So anyone who's paying five hundred thousand duros to have
- 22:59their family have a plan B has a lot more
- 23:03money to invest. So really what it became was the
- 23:05fishing hook for people to see Portugal and understand the
- 23:11actual opportunities that were in Portugal which they never would
- 23:13have seen in the past, So the Golden Visa would
- 23:16have been I would say ten percent of the business
- 23:19that the actual Golden Visa brought is, in words, the
- 23:21money that the Golden Visa took in directly only representative
- 23:25with ten percent of the actual real investments that people
- 23:28who've discovered Portugal ended up investing in after. Yeah, what
- 23:32my plan with is Solidarity Visa is to turn down
- 23:35its head. So you lower the Golden Visa amount to
- 23:39three hundred and fifty thousand quite because we're still competing
- 23:43with the rest of Europe. But that three hundred and
- 23:45fifty thousand needs to go into affordable housing for renting. Yeah,
- 23:51so you're asking people to come and buy an affordable
- 23:55house that someone can afford to rent, and they're not
- 23:58taxed for ten years either, because they're still only going
- 24:01to get six point ty percent return over the next
- 24:04ten years. Well to providing housing. Now, if I go
- 24:07into the world and today and say we have a
- 24:11residency application here that you invest three hundred and fifty thousand,
- 24:16but we're going to invest in the infrastructure around affordable
- 24:21housing and it's government packed, and it has government approval
- 24:25and government incentives for people to rent in, government incentives
- 24:28for people to buy. It's goal star. It's basically there's
- 24:32no one out there going to be in it, and
- 24:33it's going to become probably the most popular residency program
- 24:39in the world by far. And there is where we
- 24:43can actually make huge in roads. So you have big,
- 24:47big construction companies such as the chair duart Al, Robeiro,
- 24:52Gazaige and others that could even back up this because
- 24:57I said, what they're interested in is margins. Yeah, it's
- 25:02it's it's not amounts, it's margin. Once you have the margin,
- 25:07the volume then becomes easy, you know. And if you
- 25:10have a clear route to market where people can afford,
- 25:14and it's backed by the government, and it's backed by
- 25:16the local municipalities, and and it's seen as a good thing,
- 25:21and the locals are looking at yes, we want your money.
- 25:23We want you to invest into local housing and local infrastructure.
- 25:26They're not complaining about the foreigners anymore.
- 25:28Speaker 3: Everybody wins, everybody wins, we see you coming.
- 25:31Speaker 2: Portugal is a very welcoming country to foreigners until they
- 25:34until local people feel like that, and then thoses rubbed
- 25:37in the results.
- 25:38Speaker 3: However, with this it would be different.
- 25:40Speaker 2: So it's difficult to argue with the mathematics and the
- 25:43win win nature. Presumably, the challenge here is to capture
- 25:47the imagination of the municipalities and to sit and have
- 25:50politicians brave enough to give this a try. So what
- 25:53what what can you do? What are we going to
- 25:56do in that in that department?
- 25:58Speaker 1: Well, look, I'm not a politic and far from it.
- 26:01I wouldn't last long in it either. But the thing is,
- 26:06I'm a businessman and I recognize the the opportunity for
- 26:12for somebody that has the will and the power to
- 26:17do this. This needs to go to governmental It needs
- 26:20probably go through lobbyists, but as I said, it needs
- 26:23to be sort of a bipartisan brainstorming. Look what I've
- 26:29done is I've created an outline document that shows a
- 26:35way forward. You need to get everybody in a room
- 26:38and let the marge without and come actually out of
- 26:40green saying okay, this is what we're going to plan
- 26:42to do, and this is what year one, year two,
- 26:44year three, and we stick it and see you know.
- 26:47So basically it's about let's give a let's try it out.
- 26:51Let's do it. See does it work? How does it work?
- 26:54And then as it grows you you you will see
- 26:59that I believe you will see that the prices that
- 27:05are out there at the moment will normally come down
- 27:07because now they have to compete. The prices are where
- 27:10they are at the moment is because of the lack
- 27:12of supply and the over demand. And also there's also
- 27:17this over zealous imagination of what people believe their houses
- 27:22are worth. When I started selling houses not away twelve
- 27:26years ago, ten twelve years ago, the average house inside
- 27:29her Dad was five hundred thousand euros. And now you
- 27:33have guys looking as on them for three and a
- 27:34half and four million euros in this kind of ground
- 27:37and they're dreaming, you know, they're in Cookoland. And it's
- 27:44because there was a COVID bounce after COVID and there
- 27:47was some people who thought, oh shit, I needed to
- 27:49buy something here, or if I want this is what
- 27:51I want, this will have to pay. And it created
- 27:53a false bubble, right that bubbles. It hasn't burst because
- 27:58no one's put a pin in it, but it's it's hovering,
- 28:01if you know what I mean. So we're in a
- 28:04dangerous place right now, where we're saying that we're building
- 28:06houses only for people who can come to Portugal to
- 28:09afford it, or people who are making a lot of
- 28:11money out of people who are coming to Portugal to
- 28:13buy their properties or their goods or whatever it might be.
- 28:16They could afford it. But we're very dangerous by ignoring
- 28:19the mass, which as I said, eighty percent of the
- 28:22purchases in Portugal is still Portuguese. But they're buying houses
- 28:28that are not fit for purpose in the modern world.
- 28:31But we are in a position to correct it, and
- 28:33it just means that we need to sit down, think
- 28:35about it and come up and do the math, do
- 28:39the math and see how do you balance it. And
- 28:41stealth taxes balances it out. And if you have enough
- 28:44people that's coming here that will pay the stealth taxes
- 28:47for the extra and don't mind paying it, will actually
- 28:50bring down the prices of their million dollar homes and
- 28:52they're two and their three million dollar homes as well,
- 28:54because there is more offer. There's more offer in the market.
- 28:58I'm not saying you have to stop building luxury homes
- 29:00or build a home, bigger homes and whatever. So what
- 29:02I'm saying is that there has to be and I'm
- 29:05not talking about building smaller homes either. I'm talking about
- 29:09if you allow and it's and you form an approval committee,
- 29:16let's say, in each camera that sets out from the
- 29:21government of this and these are the criteria that you
- 29:24have to sign up for, and it's it's oversaw by
- 29:28regarding how you build, what you build, even building said
- 29:31to the bream system with regards to and actually it
- 29:34corrects a lot of the Portuguese criteria, okay, and and
- 29:43and also what they have to achieve between the European
- 29:47Union as well with regarding housing and environmental issues and
- 29:51so on as well. So there's a lot of win
- 29:53for the government in this as well. And what I'm
- 29:55saying can be done fiscally responsible, but in a sense
- 30:00that it creates it corrects the last twelve to thirteen
- 30:05years of undersupply. Now, I know we've had the banking crisis,
- 30:10We've had COVID, we've had lots of other things that
- 30:14sort of affected the market, but the biggest thing that
- 30:17has affected the market is bad decisions around policy.
- 30:21Speaker 3: That horizon.
- 30:24Speaker 2: The result of that is looming large and darkly. I
- 30:28would say you know, I'm seeing that that you don't
- 30:31have to look far on YouTube to see an analysis
- 30:33of Portuguese society and economics and what's on what's in
- 30:39the post if we don't do something. Because on the
- 30:41one hand, you know, we can talk theoretically about what
- 30:43will be great ideas, and this does sound like a
- 30:45great idea, But the other way of looking at it
- 30:47is what happens if we don't do anything about it,
- 30:50and that's a really grim picture. If these trends continue,
- 30:54it will and with the backdrop the context of rising
- 30:57energy prices and global conflict, that's a really grim picture.
- 31:01So something does need to be done, for sure, because
- 31:05the trend is going in a very awful direction.
- 31:08Speaker 1: Yeah, but we're even talking about now it doesn't even
- 31:12consider what's happened globally at the moment. But actually sign
- 31:17sound trying to sound a little bit modacious in the
- 31:19sense that this is actually where the opportunity is as well,
- 31:22because people are looking for a place to invest right now,
- 31:26considering wherever they're living or where they are now at
- 31:29the moment, they're looking for alternatives. If by giving them
- 31:33the alternative they help fix the issues.
- 31:36Speaker 3: That we have, why not yes, right, absolutely, rather.
- 31:41Speaker 1: Than getting them to invest into something and right now
- 31:44they're investing in venture capital funds and so on, of
- 31:47which sixty percent of the money has to say, in
- 31:48Portugal and forty percent can be invested outside of Portugal.
- 31:51But a lot of the venture capital funds, and there's
- 31:53but one hundred and fifty of them more or less
- 31:55that qualified for Gold and Visa will probably lose a
- 31:58lot of money for world and these investors. So, but
- 32:02a lot of the mode a lot of them will
- 32:03make money. Don't get me wrong, there's a lot of good,
- 32:05good venture capital funds there as well. But the problem
- 32:09is it's it's a toss of a kind in the
- 32:11sense of you're still guessing, you know where if you
- 32:15put surety and security and you underwright by the government
- 32:22that this is the plan, this is the plan for
- 32:24the next ten years, and you roll it out over
- 32:27the next five years, and then you'll if you would
- 32:29after five years. So anyone who builds properties in the
- 32:33I would you say, in the in the framework of
- 32:36what's been designed for affordable housing that allows people to
- 32:40buy and to rent and fix the affordability part fiscally responsible,
- 32:48then I think that you can turn it on its
- 32:51head and Portugal becomes a different proposition to investors and
- 32:56also to fund investors, not just a golden visa solidarity investment.
- 33:02I'm changing it from golden visa because that has a
- 33:05bad connotation when people Portuguese people think of the golden
- 33:08visa andered, what's that mean to me? It does nothing
- 33:10for me?
- 33:10Speaker 3: Exactly who gets the gold not me? Right?
- 33:14Speaker 1: Yeah, yeah, So now it's solidarity. So basically we're in
- 33:18a socialist friendly country that basically should be socially responsible.
- 33:24And how you socially responsible is that you're looking for
- 33:26foreign direct investment that's going to actually help you to
- 33:29fix the issues that you already have. And it's a
- 33:31big gap. It's a wide gap, and governments in power
- 33:37for four years if and then it's changed, and then
- 33:40the change, well, where the airport's going this year and
- 33:42where it's going next year and whatever it is and
- 33:44so on, and the high speed and all great ideas,
- 33:47but they need to start getting their act together, and
- 33:49they need to start putting plans into motion and moving
- 33:52things forward. And they also need to take confidence from
- 33:55the Portuguese people themselves. I hear so many people moving
- 33:58far right now because oh yeah, Saga, because Sega's saying
- 34:02this and Sega saying that. And I'm not complaining about Shaga.
- 34:05I don't know enough about them to complain about them,
- 34:07but I know I don't want a very far right
- 34:08wing government within Portugal. But people are looking at them
- 34:12because they're fed up of the of the of the
- 34:15norm of the central right and left being central and
- 34:18being a little bit right a little bit.
- 34:20Speaker 3: Left and nothing changing and nothing changing.
- 34:24Speaker 1: Except it wasn't it it It was not our idea.
- 34:26We're changing it. I've seen here locally between two cameras
- 34:30where you had two local governments that were of the
- 34:32same party. One changed. They had a great plan between
- 34:36the two of them because one change decided no, we
- 34:38don't want that anymore, because we didn't think of it.
- 34:41And that's that's the stop. Yeah, I have to have
- 34:47to start thinking of the bigger picture. You know. To
- 34:50care about right now is how I get voted. I'm
- 34:53telling you how you get voted in It's correct the
- 34:55issues that you have, I mean, perhaps the problem.
- 34:59Speaker 3: Yeah, I have some good ideas well.
- 35:01Speaker 2: That's one thing that Shaker are doing right that they
- 35:03are getting votes because they have promised, whether or not
- 35:06they can deliver it, they're promising something different, right.
- 35:08Speaker 1: And this is this is the other issue. It's in
- 35:11in when you're in opposition. It's a bit like shin
- 35:16Fein and Ireland as well. When you're in opposition, you're
- 35:18going to come up with all the that's a bad
- 35:21idea and knows and we have a great plan of ground,
- 35:23but it has to be fiscally responsible as well, you
- 35:27know what I mean. But what happens in most countries
- 35:31and like in the US and everywhere else, we vote
- 35:34in the next guy because we're fell up with the
- 35:36last guy, because you can play the long enough that
- 35:39we've heard it that we vote them out. We're just
- 35:41voting were u k is the same labors in now
- 35:44because of and they'll be in and then they'll be
- 35:46out again and so on. So really we need to
- 35:50get smart and in a sense come together for the
- 35:55for For I'm an Irish person living in and you're
- 36:00in Portugal. But the thing is that I suppose maybe
- 36:04we have the advantage of looking at it from the
- 36:06old side inn and having run the experience of travel
- 36:09and business and so on, that I just feel that
- 36:13a lot of the Portuguese themselves have sort of resigned
- 36:17themselves to this is the way it is, and that's sad.
- 36:20Speaker 3: It's so sad.
- 36:21Speaker 2: It's so sad to see that, to hear that, and
- 36:24they know they're saying it, they know for themselves that
- 36:27they're saying that and feeling that way, and something else
- 36:30is possible, for sure. And another interesting angle on this
- 36:33probably is that around now is the fiftieth anniversary of
- 36:37the Portuguese Constitution that came after the Carnation Revolution.
- 36:42Speaker 3: And if you can't.
- 36:43Speaker 2: Inspire politicians on a four year term to get behind this,
- 36:47you might take their attention to the constitution, which has
- 36:51basic rights in it to do with housing and living
- 36:55a good life here in Portugal. That was the promise
- 36:57fifty years ago. And I think what you're talking about
- 37:00chimes with that.
- 37:02Speaker 1: Yeah, And as well as that, there's look, European Union
- 37:07has incentives as well and help there for governments that
- 37:13actually come out with plans that will help people. And like,
- 37:17we need to get into the party now because like
- 37:20if we still if we keep believing it out and
- 37:25sorry if we if we if we ignore the issue
- 37:30we have at the moment and we don't get engaged
- 37:33with what's required. We're going to be left behind. The
- 37:36others will get their act together first. Yes, And because
- 37:40if you look at Spain and the strong leadership that's
- 37:42coming in Spain right now, and even how it's dealing
- 37:45with the US and US attitude and so and so.
- 37:47Actually I wish I was we had the same government here,
- 37:51government with balls, you know what I mean, French, but
- 37:55with courage, let's say, and you can stand up more.
- 38:01Speaker 2: Yes, you know so, well, that's something people can resonate
- 38:04with and get behind, right message of that kind, and
- 38:07you know where you stand.
- 38:08Speaker 3: You might not like it, you might like it, but
- 38:09at least you know what you're dealing with. Bobby, this
- 38:11is great.
- 38:12Speaker 2: What we'll do is we'll make the paper available on
- 38:17a server somewhere so people can take a look at
- 38:19that and get in touch with you, so that we
- 38:21can lobby this and support and share it and have
- 38:25the discussion that you talked about. So I wish you
- 38:28all the best with it. Good luck, good luck with
- 38:30the project and everything you're doing. They're on the marsh
- 38:33and Saul, thank you very much.