Latest / Film And Whiskey / Spotlight (2015) / Green River Single Barrel Wheated Bourbon
Transcript
- 0:00In 2015, director Tom McCarthy and star Michael Keaton gave the
- 0:05world a studious recollection of one of the most explosive
- 0:09stories in newspaper. History In 2025, we returned to
- 0:14Owensboro, KY to try a rarer bourbon.
- 0:18The film is Spotlight. The whiskey is Green River
- 0:21weeded bourbon single barrel. And we'll review them both.
- 0:26This is. The Film and Whiskey podcast.
- 0:48Welcome to the Film and Whiskey podcast, where each week we
- 0:51review a classic movie and a glass of whiskey.
- 0:54I'm Bob Book. I'm Brad Gee.
- 0:56And Brad Gee, it is 8:30 PM on a Monday nights and your boy is
- 1:02tired. I have.
- 1:05I've hit the age where 830 is like getting myself ready for
- 1:09bedtime now. I am right there with you. 9:30
- 1:13to 10:00 PM is a great bedtime, my friend.
- 1:16It sure is, dude. And we're going to get ourselves
- 1:18there, Brad. We are going to get out of here
- 1:20in an hour. And we're also going to keep the
- 1:21energy up. I will not let this episode flag
- 1:25because of our own tiredness, Brad, even though, if I can be
- 1:28frank, today's movie is a little more on the solemn and heavy
- 1:32side of things. Yes, we're talking about 2015's
- 1:36Spotlight. This is the movie that won Best
- 1:38Picture for the year 2015, beating out a movie that we've
- 1:42already done before, The Revenant, which was its primary
- 1:45competition that year. Brad, I've had Spotlight kind of
- 1:49circled as a film of interest for us because I know that to my
- 1:54knowledge, you had not seen it. And I was really excited to see
- 1:58what this kind of small, quiet procedural drama would would do
- 2:03for you as a movie viewer. Yeah, so this definitely was my
- 2:08first time viewing Spotlight. I was familiar with the content
- 2:14of the film, as most Americans were.
- 2:18I was very aware of all the wild things that happened in the
- 2:22early 2000s when the Boston Globe decided that it was time
- 2:26to uncover a lot of really gross stuff going on in the Catholic
- 2:30Church. It was a very interesting
- 2:34experience to watch this, Bob. I did not know that this won
- 2:37best. Picture.
- 2:38Yeah, it sure did. And it's like, I don't know how
- 2:42to explain it because it seems to be a very well liked movie.
- 2:46It has an 8.1 I believe on IMDb it's in the top 250.
- 2:51So in addition to in addition to winning best picture, it has
- 2:55checked that box in our four criteria for what could be
- 2:58considered a modern classic. The people seem to like it.
- 3:02The awards body certainly liked it.
- 3:04The critics really liked this movie.
- 3:06But it doesn't scream Oscari movie in in that like I think a
- 3:12more over the top version of this movie is what people would
- 3:16expect. You know, like where everyone's
- 3:18shouting and everyone like Mark Ruffalo has the one scene in
- 3:21this movie where he has his little Oscar clip.
- 3:24Aside from that, I feel like this movie is very purposely
- 3:27understated and tries to be matter of fact in the way that
- 3:31it portrays the events that happened in the movie.
- 3:33I really appreciate that. It also just kind of strikes me
- 3:37as an oddity for a a Best picture winner because we're so
- 3:40used to Oscar films being bigger and more sort of, what's the
- 3:46word, Brad? Bombastic.
- 3:49Hysterical, I guess. Yeah, exactly.
- 3:51Well, I'll I'll give you an easy way of comparison.
- 3:55The movie I would have thought would win this year might be Mad
- 4:01Max Fury Rd. You know what I mean?
- 4:04Like that, there's a world where I could see that winning Best
- 4:07picture in a lot of different years.
- 4:10It's not Even so much that it's, it's the subject matter that
- 4:13isn't awarded, but there was a really funny sketch that Seth
- 4:17Meyers did on his late night show a few years ago called
- 4:20Oscar Bait the Movie. And it was like a 5 minute
- 4:23trailer that just had every trope of an Oscar E movie
- 4:27smashed into it. And I, I think about movies like
- 4:31The King's Speech, which also won the Academy Award.
- 4:33And that is, is similar in that it's like a very small movie,
- 4:37but I feel like it's characters get their, you know, stare right
- 4:41down the barrel of the camera and deliver your impassioned
- 4:44speech moments way more than characters in this movie do.
- 4:48And so, yeah, I, I'm excited to dive into it.
- 4:50Folks, if you are new to film and whiskey, welcome in.
- 4:53We talk about movies here and we talk about whiskey this season.
- 4:57We're looking at movies from the past 20 years.
- 4:59We're asking the question, does this deserve to be considered a
- 5:03modern classic? Now, Brad, you've already said
- 5:06that this is your first time watching Spotlight.
- 5:09This is probably like my third or fourth time watching it all
- 5:11the way through, but it it definitely seems to be a fixture
- 5:16on, if not cable channels now, then it like the stars and
- 5:22showtimes of the world anymore. I always see it playing
- 5:24somewhere. So it seems to be a movie that
- 5:28people have gotten around to seeing.
- 5:29I'll be interested to see how many of our listeners follow up
- 5:33with us and tell us they have or have not seen this one.
- 5:36Do you think this has been a widely seen movie since its
- 5:38Oscar win? I have to imagine, no, mostly
- 5:44because I've never really heard anyone talk about it.
- 5:48Like even in our lead up to this, Bob, I don't know if I've
- 5:52ever really heard you mention it.
- 5:54It, it doesn't seem to garner a lot of conversation at at the
- 5:59very least in my world, in my sphere.
- 6:02So I know I don't think many people have seen this, Bob and I
- 6:06base this off the fact that I don't think so.
- 6:09Boom. That's all we can do, Brad.
- 6:11All right. Well, on that note, let's go
- 6:12ahead and jump into our first segment of the day, which we
- 6:15call Brad explains. Brad's going to give us the
- 6:17movie plots with only 60 seconds sticking on the clock, so let's
- 6:21go ahead and do your take with this little segment that we
- 6:24call, Brad explains. Brad Explains is the part of the
- 6:28show where Brad breaks down the plot of the movie that he has
- 6:31just seen, often for the first time.
- 6:34This is of course Brad's first time seeing Spotlight Brad.
- 6:38Usually we tend to be a little lighter hearted with breaking
- 6:40down the plot of our films. I don't think we could get away
- 6:43with that today, nor would I like to.
- 6:45So you have 60 seconds to spoil this movie.
- 6:49It is based on true events, so if you haven't seen the movie
- 6:52folks, you might be familiar with the subject matter of it.
- 6:54I would highly recommend watching the movie if, if for no
- 6:57other reason than you are an Oscar completist and you just
- 7:01haven't gotten around to it yet, Hit pause here, Go watch the
- 7:04movie Spotlight and then rejoin us for the rest of the episode.
- 7:07Brad, one minute and go. Spotlight is a film that follows
- 7:124 reporters who are a part of the Spotlight team at the Boston
- 7:17Globe whose goal is investigative journalism.
- 7:21They find themselves turned on to a story about abuse in the
- 7:26Catholic Church, encouraged by their new editor, guest lead
- 7:33editor Marty Baron, who's a newcomer to town and encourages
- 7:38them to pursue this story. They begin to track down leads,
- 7:42find lawyers who are involved in the cover up, and eventually
- 7:47make a discovery in the form of letters written to the Bishop,
- 7:53the Archbishop of the Boston area, that indicates that he
- 7:58knew about these abuses all along and worked to cover them
- 8:02up. All right.
- 8:04That's Spotlight folks. So Brad, I'd like to just kind
- 8:07of turn it over to you when it comes to talking about this
- 8:11movie. Where would you like to start
- 8:13today? I think it's probably worth
- 8:17moving our way through the performances because it feels
- 8:24like there has to be a conversation eventually more
- 8:27focused on like the subject matter of the movie than the
- 8:31movie making itself. And I think the conversation
- 8:34about the subject matter could easily take up the entire
- 8:38episode. So I am I am curious to talk
- 8:41about the just the movie itself. And, and I don't say that in any
- 8:47way to minimize the subject matter.
- 8:49The the subject matter is probably the weightiest that we
- 8:53have ever covered here at at the Film and Whiskey podcast.
- 8:58Which is like, again, thank you for the disclaimer.
- 9:02Not wanting to minimize anything.
- 9:03When I think about this movie, I'm like, oh, that's a really
- 9:06good movie about the work of journalists and the day-to-day,
- 9:11like getting down and dirty with your job and and pounding
- 9:14pavement and knocking on doors and interviewing people and
- 9:18having dead ends. And like, yes, they uncovered a
- 9:21big story. I never think about it from the
- 9:23angle of like, Oh my gosh, the subject matter of their story
- 9:27is, is a significant downer of a film.
- 9:30Because like, I really do think to talk about the movie making
- 9:34here that what Tom McCarthy, the writer and director of this
- 9:38movie, has done is show that day-to-day life in such a frank,
- 9:44matter of fact, understated way that it never feels like they're
- 9:49going for this big, weighty, frankly Oscari type movie.
- 9:57It just like wants to portray just the facts, ma'am, you know
- 10:01what I mean? And I think that that is the
- 10:04best possible way they could have portrayed this subject
- 10:06matter because otherwise it starts getting a little bit too
- 10:09manipulative. And when you start being
- 10:11manipulative with real people stories that way, then I start
- 10:15to feel like this is icky, you know what I mean?
- 10:19100% And and that's actually, I read an article interviewing
- 10:24Sasha Pfeiffer, the real life Sasha Pfeiffer, who is one of
- 10:27the journalists who who did this story.
- 10:31And they asked her about why she and the others agreed to let you
- 10:36know, I don't know about their life rights, but to let their to
- 10:40let their story be portrayed by Hollywood.
- 10:43And she essentially said, like I and the others were initially
- 10:48extraordinarily hesitant to allow our stories to be told
- 10:54because we didn't want it to become a glamorous thing, that
- 10:58we were covering this horrific story.
- 11:01And it it wasn't until she sat down with Tom McCarthy and saw
- 11:05like, pieces of the script that he was writing that she was
- 11:09like, OK, I think that this is going to be done well.
- 11:12And upon review and watching of the film, all of all of the
- 11:17journalists seem to have very positive reactions to how their
- 11:22lives were portrayed. Let's, I mean, again, I think
- 11:25that's a really good thing. And to get back to your point
- 11:28about performances, I kind of said all that to say I don't
- 11:32think any of the performances in this movie are like, they didn't
- 11:36wow me, But that's also the intention of the movie, you
- 11:40know? And I think that's why sometimes
- 11:42people have poked a little bit of fun at Mark Ruffalo's
- 11:44performance. I actually think Mark Ruffalo's
- 11:46pretty good in this movie, but he is really the only one that's
- 11:50given this big dynamic scene where he gets to blow up at
- 11:53somebody. Nobody else gets that.
- 11:55And it's because they're playing real people, and real people
- 11:58have to either regulate or suppress their emotions at the
- 12:01workplace for the most part. Yeah, and they have to keep
- 12:05their jobs. Exactly right.
- 12:06That's and that's why they have to keep their emotions in check.
- 12:09And I think with that in mind, you're recognizing that
- 12:13everybody is is operating at a pitch or at a meter that is much
- 12:18more like compacted. You know what I mean, that
- 12:21there's no fluctuations in people's behavior here.
- 12:24But within that sort of paradigm, I think the
- 12:27performances are across the board really, really good in
- 12:29this movie, man. And I think that the Ruffalo
- 12:33blow up, they do such a great job of explaining it when he and
- 12:39Rachel McAdams are sitting down and I think they're drinking a
- 12:43beer together. And he explains to her, like, I
- 12:46know that I left the church, but I, I always had this hope, like
- 12:51deep buried inside me that one day I would return that, that it
- 12:56meant something to me, that it, it would be a safe place for me.
- 13:00And this whole story has essentially destroyed that hope,
- 13:03that dream, that safe place. And it's like, oh, yeah.
- 13:07Like, this is something that he didn't even realize how
- 13:10important it was to him until they were like, you know, 3/4 of
- 13:15the way through investigating this story.
- 13:18And I think that's why this script really succeeds is that
- 13:22it gives its characters the proper motivations and the
- 13:27proper understandings of the world that they live in so that
- 13:34they feel, like you said, Bob, just like incredibly real normal
- 13:39people. I I also think about Brian Darcy
- 13:44James, he has a realization that one of the Centers for like
- 13:51rehabilitation that they have housed these pedophiles in is
- 13:57like 2 streets over from him. And you get a really great
- 14:01tracking shot following him as he's like running down the
- 14:04streets at night and stands there staring at this house.
- 14:07And like, it's not as explosive as Ruffalo's scene, but it he he
- 14:13gets that weighty, meaty, honest human response to the the
- 14:18grossness of this of the subject matter of this film.
- 14:23I think let's kind of start down towards the the more supporting
- 14:27characters and work our way up here.
- 14:29So you mentioned Brian D'Arcy James.
- 14:31I think that he's like secretly the backbone of that entire
- 14:34newsroom. Really unsung performance and
- 14:38character 'cause he is just like the quiet one, but he also has
- 14:43maybe the most profound little story beat.
- 14:47And it is that like he has small children and he is living like
- 14:51essentially next to one of these centers and, and, and the way
- 14:54he's trying to deal with that information.
- 14:57And at one point he even goes in and talks to Michael Keaton,
- 15:00who's essentially his boss and says, like, when can we start
- 15:04telling people? Like I have friends who have
- 15:06kids in this neighborhood and they have to, they just have to
- 15:09sit on that information. And it it, it makes him a little
- 15:13queasy and it calls the audience to question like, hey, like I
- 15:17understand how journalistic ethics and journalistic
- 15:20integrity work, but like, is this really in the common good
- 15:24and interest to, to sit on this kind of a story?
- 15:27It's a really great like they use his character really well to
- 15:30help flesh out those ethical things of the story.
- 15:35And what I love about that scene and, and collection of scenes is
- 15:39that it points back to what we've said about this movie just
- 15:42feeling very raw and authentic when you compare it to something
- 15:47like The Imitation Game, which is, you know, pursuing the
- 15:51Enigma machine. And they finally break the code.
- 15:54And, you know, they realize that they can't act on the
- 15:57information, otherwise the Germans will realize that the
- 16:01code is broken. And I just remember that scene
- 16:04being like, like a death knell. And it was so dramatic and so
- 16:09overwrought. And it's like if it has a very
- 16:14similar vibe of like we have information and we have to sit
- 16:17on it for the for the common good.
- 16:20But it felt so much more impactful in a film like
- 16:24Spotlight than it did in something like The Imitation
- 16:27Game, that which is way more dramatic and but you know, both
- 16:30films are based on true historical events.
- 16:34All right, so moving on from Brian Darcy James, I want to
- 16:37talk just really briefly about John Slattery, who plays Ben
- 16:41Bradley Junior, who I believe is the editor in chief at the time
- 16:45at the Boston Herald or the OR the Globe, rather.
- 16:49Ben Bradley Junior is the son of Ben Bradley, the very famous
- 16:53editor of the Washington Post, who was there when the
- 16:56Watergate, you know, scandal broke.
- 16:59Slattery in this movie is really interesting.
- 17:01So this is like right, I believe right after or right before Mad
- 17:07Men wrapped up and he was really popular because of Mad Men.
- 17:11He's never really made a huge dent in Hollywood.
- 17:14I really do think that if I had to pinpoint 1 performance,
- 17:17that's I don't want to call it the weakest performance, but
- 17:20like you could slot anybody into that role.
- 17:22It's it's this one because I feel like he's just playing the
- 17:25guy from Mad Men, but they put him in a more frumpy looking
- 17:29shirt and they said, OK, here you go, now you're Ben Bradley.
- 17:32I don't know. Did you have any any thoughts on
- 17:34him? I thought he was just OK.
- 17:36I, I've never been impressed with him as an actor.
- 17:40You know, I, I watched the entire Mad Men series.
- 17:42I thought he was good, not great.
- 17:44The one confusing piece of this script is that they make it seem
- 17:49like, and maybe I'm wrong on this, to me it felt like they
- 17:53made him seem like the guy who covered up the story in the
- 17:57first place, right it? It seemed like it was going that
- 18:01direction. So let's let's touch on this
- 18:02really quickly. So very early on in the movie,
- 18:05they they are encouraged to probe deeper into a story that
- 18:09was like on Page Six of the paper about this priest who had
- 18:13abused children and maybe possibly Cardinal Law knew about
- 18:19it. And so they're starting to
- 18:21probe, and they talk to a past victim of abuse who has a
- 18:26survivors network in Boston now. And the guy basically says,
- 18:29like, I have a whole box of stuff here.
- 18:32I sent this to you guys like five years ago.
- 18:34You didn't do anything with it. And then about halfway through
- 18:37the movie, there's another revelation that a lawyer who
- 18:41seems like a sleazeball who's, like, doing the church's dirty
- 18:44work, actually was trying to be a whistleblower and submitted a
- 18:48whole list of names to the paper as well.
- 18:51And that got buried. And it seems like they are
- 18:54working their way towards this revelation that John Slattery's
- 18:57character, you know, unknowingly or knowingly, was the one that
- 19:01killed those stories. And it just never goes anywhere.
- 19:04And in fact, like, it goes in a different direction at the end
- 19:06of the movie. But I feel like that revelation
- 19:10lands with so much more of a thud because it feels like
- 19:13they're trying to manufacture some sort of dramatic reveal
- 19:16here. Yes, and I I didn't realize it
- 19:19until we started talking about how natural this movie feels.
- 19:23I think that's why it feels so weird is because it feels like
- 19:28the the scriptwriter, the director who met would I guess
- 19:32it's the same person that right. It feels like Tom McCarthy is
- 19:37trying to shoehorn in some sort of drama into the story like,
- 19:42oh, their editor is actually the one who killed it the first time
- 19:47and is he going to try to do that again?
- 19:49And and it's like, no, Michael Keaton just it was his story
- 19:53back in the day and he lost track of it because he's a busy
- 19:56news man. And like, I actually love leave
- 19:59Schreiber in that moment and the the way he handles it with grace
- 20:04and basically is like, hey, crazy stuff happens in the news
- 20:07world because we're really busy and there's grace for that too.
- 20:11You guys are doing great work. Now let's get this story out
- 20:14there. I great, great scene from Leave
- 20:17Schreiber. It just felt like there was a
- 20:20lot of time and energy wasted throughout the rest of the film,
- 20:24making John Slattery the bad guy when when he really wasn't.
- 20:29All right, let's talk about Liam Schreiber because I think I've
- 20:31always loved him as an actor and I feel like he is a pretty
- 20:34underrated actor. He's done a lot of great work.
- 20:37He's, you know, been the the headliner of a number of
- 20:41television shows. He's been the headliner of a
- 20:43number of movies and yet he just doesn't seem to have like the
- 20:47star power that one would think for a guy that's been acting for
- 20:502530 years now. I think that his turn as Marty
- 20:54Baron is the supporting actor nomination this movie should
- 21:00have gotten. So Ruffalo gets nominated.
- 21:03I think that Liev Schreiber is the guy that, like, understood
- 21:06the assignment better than anybody else.
- 21:07Like, his character is a man of very few words.
- 21:10He doesn't seem to have much of A personality at all.
- 21:13And yet he is quietly like, the moral compass of this movie
- 21:18where everybody else is, you know, they've been too close to
- 21:21the story to recognize their own moral failings until later on in
- 21:25the movie. He is an outsider, just comes in
- 21:27and is like, no, we like, this is our responsibility.
- 21:31Let's do this thing. Absolutely dude.
- 21:33I, I was blown away by his performance and you know, not to
- 21:38not to disparage anyone else, I think he's the only person in
- 21:42this movie that I was like blown away by.
- 21:45I think that when he looks at Michael Keaton, I believe maybe
- 21:51it's John Slattery when he looks at that one of those two early
- 21:55in the film and just so incredibly gently says this
- 22:01sounds exactly like the story a local paper should cover.
- 22:05I like the way he delivers. That line is just so freaking
- 22:11good. I I could not get over his
- 22:15performance in this movie and, and the, the scene with oh,
- 22:20who's who plays the Bishop. Oh, who does play the Bishop?
- 22:24Len carry you? I'm not familiar with him, but
- 22:27yeah. He is the patriarch in the TV
- 22:32show Blue Bloods. That is the only reason I know
- 22:35of him. He I thought that the scene
- 22:37between the two of them was so freaking good.
- 22:41And when he opens up the present and it's like a catechesis,
- 22:45like, you can feel like the little bit of anti-Semitism.
- 22:50Like. In the present, it's it's just
- 22:55freaking perfect. And his response to it is like
- 22:58just kind of just could to stare at it.
- 23:01It's such a great performance from Liev Schreiber.
- 23:05I'm so sorry to to derail us here.
- 23:07Let's talk about Len carry you for two seconds.
- 23:09How am I not familiar with this guy?
- 23:10He's been in so many movies. He has one of those faces where
- 23:13it's like, I know I've seen this guy before, but he was Tony
- 23:18nominated for the musical Applause.
- 23:22He was in the Sondheim musical, A Little Night Music.
- 23:25He also was the originator of Sweeney Todd on Broadway.
- 23:29Like, no, yeah, my guy, what a career.
- 23:32Unbelievable. Wow, the original Sweeney Todd.
- 23:36He is Sweeney. There you go.
- 23:38That's. Wild.
- 23:39I so I've literally seen him as a former police chief of New
- 23:45York City, and I've seen him as a corrupt Archbishop of the
- 23:50Catholic Church. There you go.
- 23:52Sweeney Todd didn't quite make it onto my list of suspected
- 23:56roles. All right.
- 23:58We've touched on Ruffalo. Let's talk about Rachel McAdams
- 24:01because I think that she has a really difficult ask in this
- 24:04movie, too. She's the only woman in this
- 24:06movie, essentially. I mean, she might actually be
- 24:09the only female person. Except for like when when
- 24:12Michael Keaton goes over to his buddy's house and his wife
- 24:15answers the door like. It's or or when the when she is
- 24:19interviewing the one priest at the door and he's just like,
- 24:22yeah, it touched kids. And then his sister comes to the
- 24:25door and is like, get out of here.
- 24:27It's. A great Boston accent man, by
- 24:29the way. Thank you.
- 24:30Yeah, Rachel McAdams, I think a pretty thankless role once
- 24:33again. She she has one of the more, I
- 24:36don't want to call it like a boring character, but like I
- 24:39think that you are supposed to really empathize with her and
- 24:45with Ruffalo's character. And one of the bigger flaws in
- 24:49the movie for me was that maybe it's because they're supposed to
- 24:53be like they're the 30 somethings.
- 24:54They're the ones we're supposed to relate to.
- 24:56I just found myself way more interested in Liev Schreiber and
- 25:00even Brian Darcy James's characters than with either
- 25:04Ruffalo or Rachel McAdams character.
- 25:07I I enjoyed Rachel McAdams. I I think that she gets a decent
- 25:11amount of screen time and and you're allowed to get to know
- 25:14her. I I think her performance is an
- 25:18example of where the script is so understated and so based in
- 25:24realism that she's not the most interesting character.
- 25:29And, and it's like supposed to be that way.
- 25:31And it's supposed to be just this, you know, girl who lives
- 25:34with her grandma and goes to church with her sometimes and is
- 25:38a reporter. And that's kind of boring.
- 25:41And that's the whole point. But it's also a little boring.
- 25:45Yeah, I will say though, like, they they really pay that off
- 25:49though, because as you watch her grandma read the article at the
- 25:54end of the movie and just like, ask for a glass of water, that
- 25:58is like, what a crushing line, dude.
- 26:01Because you know exactly what that means.
- 26:03Like that woman's entire world view has been shattered.
- 26:07Yeah, yeah. And and that's like I said, we
- 26:11wouldn't totally get into the the subject matter a ton, but
- 26:15like, that's the brutality of what happened and why it needed
- 26:20to be uncovered. Is that for better or for worse,
- 26:24the Catholic Church can and should represent some of the
- 26:29most beautiful things on this earth.
- 26:31And and that's why it's so damning and so disgusting when
- 26:36you see the brokenness that was uncovered.
- 26:40All right, man, let's finish up this cast list.
- 26:42Michael Keaton is in this movie The year after he is nominated
- 26:46for the Academy Award for Birdman.
- 26:49And I always think that he won it.
- 26:50And then I remember that Eddie Redmayne won it that year.
- 26:52And so it. I won't get into that,
- 26:55obviously. Yeah, I think Keaton's fine
- 26:59here. I think that like, he's a really
- 27:02good person to slot into a movie where he has lines that are
- 27:05like, come on, Jimmy, this is our town.
- 27:08We were, we're we're Boston boys.
- 27:10We grew up here. Like, that's a great Michael
- 27:12Keaton line. I don't necessarily know if he's
- 27:15like the perfect person for this part, but I thought he was
- 27:17pretty good. I I think that this is like if
- 27:22this was a more traditional All the King's Men, Goodnight and
- 27:27Good luck. This is like a classic George
- 27:29Clooney role. I think because they are trying
- 27:33to base it more in real life, they need to get a less good
- 27:36looking actor. And so they got Michael Keaton
- 27:40and like Keaton's fine, he, he's decent.
- 27:43I I don't know if there's anything about his performance
- 27:46that really stands out to me though.
- 27:48I respect that Michael Keaton is always going to be Michael
- 27:50Keaton in a movie, though. And like, he has this, this
- 27:54repressed manic energy. You know, it's the thing that
- 27:57made him such an interesting Batman because he goes from
- 28:00being really calm 1 moment to like smashing the vase and
- 28:03saying, you know, do you want to get nuts?
- 28:05Come on, let's get nuts. And he's always going to have
- 28:07that, like, right under the surface as Michael Keaton, but
- 28:11for such a long time. You know, Bill Simmons makes
- 28:14this comparison all the time, But he talks about how, like,
- 28:16Michael Keaton and Tom Hanks were kind of neck and neck
- 28:19throughout the 80s because they were mostly comedic actors, and
- 28:23they were trying to branch out. And then all of a sudden, Hanks
- 28:25took off. And I think about like, if you
- 28:28put Tom Hanks in this movie in the Michael Keaton role, I think
- 28:32it's a significantly worse movie because Tom Hanks is going to
- 28:35try to do the like, I'm taking this very seriously, Tom Hanks
- 28:39thing, and I listen, I love Tom Hanks, but we talked about this
- 28:44even in like our Captain Phillips thing a couple months
- 28:46ago. Watching Tom Hanks try to play
- 28:50realism is just something that I don't think is really in his
- 28:54catalogue anymore. He's been a movie star for so
- 28:56long that he can only act as a movie star.
- 28:59And I think Keaton's still able to tap into the the energy of
- 29:03like, I'm a guy from the streets of Boston.
- 29:06And it works so much better here.
- 29:08Yeah, it kind of reminds me of like a Harrison Ford.
- 29:12I was a Carpenter in Hollywood for a long time trying to get
- 29:15acting jobs. And like you said, Tom Hanks.
- 29:20Is is Tom freaking Hanks like he is a a bonafide a list movie
- 29:26star. I think Keaton, like I said, he
- 29:31gives the role the right amount of energy.
- 29:37I I don't I think what I'm trying to say is I don't know
- 29:40what to do with this movie. Bob I I like it.
- 29:44I don't think I love it and it's weird because the reason I don't
- 29:49love it feels like it's not movie like enough for me.
- 29:57But it it's not trying to be movie like it's trying to be
- 30:01honest about a real life story that only happened 12 years
- 30:05before the movie came out. So I I don't know if I want this
- 30:10to be a more dramatic film in a more classic Hollywood style,
- 30:15but because it's not, there's part of me that just feels like
- 30:18it's a little bit inaccessible. Yeah, it's it's.
- 30:21Does that make sense? It kind of reminds me in a very
- 30:23weird way about what I said about Wolf of Wall Street was
- 30:25that last week where I talked about how Scorsese formatted
- 30:31that movie like Don Quixote. And it's like very purposefully
- 30:34done. But when you when you purposely
- 30:37structure your movie that way, like the inherent flaws of that
- 30:40decision also are like you're, you're acknowledging like, all
- 30:43right, my compromise is maybe the ceiling on this movie is
- 30:47like a nine and a half because it's going to be 1/2 hour too
- 30:50long. And I kind of feel the same way
- 30:52with this movie. Like, yes, I, I feel less of a
- 30:56visceral connection to it because I'm used to my dramatic
- 31:01movies being more overly dramatic.
- 31:04And so I feel like the decision to make it a little more
- 31:08understated was objectively the right call for this material,
- 31:13but it also like necessarily lowered the ceiling of how good
- 31:17the movie could be to like a, you know, nine and a half, nine,
- 31:208 1/2, wherever you're at with it.
- 31:23It's weird because I I do acknowledge that it's better
- 31:26that they did it this way, but it's just not going to feel like
- 31:30as I'm not going to feel as connected to it as a result.
- 31:35The more we talked about it, the more I think that if they were
- 31:38going to make the, if they were going to raise the ceiling for
- 31:42this movie, I almost think they needed to go more artistic with
- 31:46the cinematography and like maybe the lighting or some of
- 31:51the design elements of it. Because one of the very few
- 31:54moments where I noticed like a choice by the director behind
- 32:00the camera or the cinematographer, whoever made
- 32:02the choice, was when they are talking to the expert from
- 32:09Maryland, I think from the Seton Institute.
- 32:12And he is telling them that based on his stats, it should be
- 32:176% of the total priests. And they realize that that
- 32:22number is 90 instead of 13. I, I don't know if you noticed,
- 32:26but the camera like slowly zooms out.
- 32:31It, it doesn't move, it doesn't pan, it does.
- 32:33It just slowly zooms out till the four reporters only take up
- 32:38like maybe 20 to 30% of the screen and the rest of their
- 32:44cluttered empty office like takes up the rest of the screen.
- 32:49And it's a great camera shot to emphasize how small they feel in
- 32:55light of how huge this scandal is.
- 32:59And I, I wish there were more things like that throughout the
- 33:03film that feel like a, a little bit more like a traditional
- 33:07movie. It's, it's not big or flashy or
- 33:11showy, but it, it helps highlight the magnitude of what
- 33:16was going on in this film. And, and I think if they did
- 33:19more things like that and, and maybe if they just had a few
- 33:22more artistic, like, I don't know, like a shot of Keaton
- 33:28sitting on a bench in front of a massive Catholic Church, like I
- 33:33like, you know, maybe that's two on the nose.
- 33:35But, well, there is that one shot where Rachel McAdams is
- 33:37like interviewing somebody on their front porch and then,
- 33:40like, the church is towering behind the house.
- 33:43And it's like, this is very on the nose.
- 33:45But also this is a really accurate representation of how
- 33:48much they feel like this. The church is like breathing
- 33:51down their neck at all times, and they can't.
- 33:53They can't escape it, you know. Exactly.
- 33:56And and so I just wonder if they made a few more decisions like
- 33:59that with the camera, if it would have raised that ceiling
- 34:03back higher than it than it is with their folks.
- 34:08It's not obvious enough. That's what we're saying.
- 34:10Make it more obvious, folks. Come on.
- 34:14All right, man, let's take a break here.
- 34:15Let's drink some whiskey. What do you say?
- 34:17Let's get to it. All right, so today we are
- 34:25checking out Green River Kentucky straight weeded single
- 34:29barrel bourbon. Now, last week we tried the
- 34:31standard Green River wheated a whiskey that we both really
- 34:35liked. Brad, I am such a big fan of
- 34:37Green River. They are first and foremost like
- 34:40among the most generous of brands to work with.
- 34:43And I don't just mean like they give us stuff.
- 34:46They're just like very welcoming, very hospitable.
- 34:50You know, they've got the Bardstown team behind them and
- 34:52the Bardstown team knows how to treat people really well.
- 34:55So just thank you, Green River, for being cool to work with.
- 34:59I will also say they are a brand that within, you know, two years
- 35:04has gone from being like, oh, this is pretty good to they have
- 35:08multiple labels now where I'm like, oh, that's among the best
- 35:12in its category. Absolutely.
- 35:14Yeah, there there's a book out there, I think it's called like
- 35:17Unreasonable hospitality or like Outrageous Hospitality.
- 35:21And, and I'm pretty sure that they have read that book because
- 35:24they just treat guests incredibly and that that's at
- 35:30Bardstown, that's at Green River.
- 35:33I am so excited to drink this single barrel today.
- 35:35About yeah, me too, man. So they have just come out with
- 35:38this as a new skew. Like I said, we tried the weeded
- 35:41bourbon last week. The single barrel variety,
- 35:44depending on which barrel you're drinking from or which release
- 35:46you're getting, it could range from anywhere from 110 to 130
- 35:50proof. The one we're trying today is
- 35:52118.6 proof. It is cask strength and it's
- 35:57aged for a minimum of five years now.
- 36:00I do not currently have. Oh yes, I do.
- 36:02I stand corrected. I have the mash bill, Brad.
- 36:05Hey, 70% corn, 21% wheat, 9% malted barley.
- 36:12Brad, I poured this out a long time ago and it's just been kind
- 36:15of sitting here in my glass teasing me.
- 36:18And the very first note that I will give and then I'll turn it
- 36:20over to you. This is back to classic weeded
- 36:24bourbon notes. There is like a whole bunch of
- 36:27cola on this thing and I am a big, big fan.
- 36:30Yeah, yeah, dude, the nose on this is so beautiful.
- 36:35There is tons of like effervescent cherry cola.
- 36:39It's Carmelie, there's oak and there there's almost like a
- 36:42cinnamon roll vibe going on. Like you get a little bit of
- 36:46that cinnamon spice, a little bit of frosting the the
- 36:49sugariness of it. I I really like this nose there.
- 36:53There's nothing here that is complex, but there's a lot of
- 36:56great notes. It is an 8 out of 10 for me.
- 37:00I'm actually going to give it a nine.
- 37:01It has everything I want from a weeded bourbon nose.
- 37:05And once in a while, you know, we or our guest will mention
- 37:09something being perfumey. This is one of the first times
- 37:12that I really mean it. And and like I can think of the
- 37:15exact perfume that is coming off of this.
- 37:18It's super floral. It's not quite like Chanel #5 or
- 37:23anything. It's more of frankly, it's more
- 37:24of like an old lady perfume and I dude, it's, it's the 9.
- 37:30Out of 10, it's seriously know what you're into Bob dude.
- 37:33It's the amount of floral notes on this that it's not just rose,
- 37:36it's like really deep perfume notes on top of classic caramel
- 37:41and cherry cola. I love this man. 9 out of 10 for
- 37:44me. I think I'm going to lower my
- 37:46score knowing that it's a grandma's perfume for you.
- 37:50What can I say, man, I am into the old ladies, Brad, and it's
- 37:54coming out here today. Are you are you starring in the
- 37:58local production of The Producers?
- 37:59What's going on soon, Bob? Yeah, You know, we've talked
- 38:02about Sweeney Todd. We'll just go to the producers
- 38:05now. Oh man.
- 38:08Well, moving on from that as fast as humanly possible.
- 38:11The palette here is delectable. There is tons of caramel for me,
- 38:18the cream cheese frosting is there.
- 38:21It gets into a little bit of like a peanut butter vibe there.
- 38:25There's almost some like toasted almonds that comes through.
- 38:29Just really a really pleasant experience.
- 38:32I'm going to come up a little bit from my nose to an 8 1/2.
- 38:36Brad, this is an interesting whiskey.
- 38:37It's super prickly on the palate.
- 38:40I, you know, it's been a couple weeks since we've had a barrel
- 38:43proof whiskey, so maybe I'm just returning to being more of a
- 38:45lightweight, but it really packs a punch on the tongue.
- 38:49There's not as much of A Kentucky hug after you swallow,
- 38:51but we'll get to that in a minute.
- 38:53I think that I was expecting something a little more viscous
- 38:56here. It's pretty thin on the
- 38:58mouthfeel and it doesn't have those like deep, dark, decadent
- 39:03bourbon notes. To me, it stays in that kind of
- 39:05upper, brighter register. The floral notes are definitely
- 39:08there. And then I think you get a
- 39:10little bit more of like a raw wheat note on this.
- 39:13It's similar to the one we had last week.
- 39:15I do like it way more a barrel strength though.
- 39:17I'm going to give it a 7 1/2 on the pallet.
- 39:20I think the finish for me is where it starts to fall off just
- 39:23a little bit. Still really great flavors.
- 39:26It it, it falls into like kind of like a honey wheat split top
- 39:31bread there. The cinnamon comes back.
- 39:34There's a little bit of those peanuts coming through.
- 39:37It gets a little bit oaky at the end.
- 39:41I'll give it a 7 1/2 out of 10 year.
- 39:43I still like the finish, it's just a little bit of a drop off.
- 39:46Yeah, I'm in the same spot, man. It gets oaky and and like a
- 39:49really heavy char. On my first sip I got that and
- 39:52then on the second sip it almost turns a bit sour towards the
- 39:55back end. And that was a note that we had
- 39:56last week on the regular weeded bourbon as well.
- 39:59I think I'm also going to come down to A7 on the finish.
- 40:02And then overall on balance, I think I'll give it a 7 1/2.
- 40:07There was definitely. A drop from nose to taste to
- 40:11finish, which is a little bit of a disappointment, but it's not a
- 40:15huge disappointment because this is still a pretty solid whiskey
- 40:17all around. Yeah, I, I think I'll give it a
- 40:207 1/2 on balance, mostly because it, it lacks a little bit on the
- 40:25finish and and it's not an especially complex whiskey,
- 40:30although it delivers in all the ways you want it to for a weeded
- 40:34whiskey just doesn't have anything that makes it like
- 40:36really stand out. But I, I think it's worth a 7
- 40:401/2 year on balance. Now Bob, this is going to set
- 40:44you back MSRP $60.00, which I I think it's a fair price point
- 40:52for a five year single barrel product.
- 40:56Yeah, it's barrel strength, it's single barrel and it's a weeded
- 40:59bourbon. So they're in the category of
- 41:02your rebels, of your wellers. I think that in general five
- 41:07year bourbon at $60.00, it feels a little bit overpriced to me,
- 41:11but that's also just kind of where the markets at right now.
- 41:14But I think I'll give this a 6.5 on value.
- 41:18It's not a bad value, but I either other green rivers that I
- 41:21like better than this at a similar price.
- 41:24I give it a 7 out of 10 on value.
- 41:26I'm kind of in the same place. I I think $60.00 is a little
- 41:29much. I think if this was a $50 bottle
- 41:32I I would rate it more highly, but there are a lot of other
- 41:37options in this price range that I'd probably recommend over it.
- 41:41So I'll give it a 7 out of 10 and that is bringing me out to a
- 41:4738.5 out of 50. I'm at a 37.5, so we're coming
- 41:52out to a 38 out of 50 or 76 out of 100 on average.
- 41:57I think that's a great spot for this, Brad.
- 41:59It's just barely over the recommend mark for us.
- 42:04And I don't really think that it's because of the value.
- 42:06Like we said, it's a tad overpriced or it feels just a
- 42:09bit high. But I think at the end of the
- 42:11day, this is kind of just like a very solid, respectable whiskey
- 42:15from Green River. It does not approach the the
- 42:18king of their lineup for me, which is that foolproof.
- 42:21But once again, they just continue to deliver really,
- 42:25really solid offerings here. Yeah, I absolutely love Green
- 42:31River. Aaron Harris is doing incredible
- 42:34work over there. And Bob, we, we need to make our
- 42:37way down there sometime. I completely agree.
- 42:40I've been like in and around where I guess around Owensboro a
- 42:44whole bunch, and I've never been able to make it to Green River.
- 42:47So Aaron, let's make this happen, dude.
- 42:49All right, Brad, what do you say we get back into talking about
- 42:51Spotlight? Let's get to it.
- 42:58All right, everybody, That was Green River Weeded single Barrel
- 43:03bourbon whiskey that it's like almost there.
- 43:07I really, really like it. I encourage you to try it.
- 43:12I will say though, normally I would have a quippy awesome,
- 43:16perfect Segway into our Section 2 facts and a falsehood, but I
- 43:21texted Bob about this earlier. I don't know if I feel
- 43:25comfortable making up facts about a movie that covers a
- 43:30topic like this. And so we're actually going to
- 43:33skip 2 facts in a falsehood today, Bob.
- 43:36The question is, do I receive an automatic victory because of
- 43:40your forfeit? That's really what what this is
- 43:42about, Brad. I was thinking about that.
- 43:45I think both of us like gain an automatic loss for the fact that
- 43:51the subject matter of this movie happens under our religions
- 43:56auspices. That's true.
- 43:58And that's that just kind of sucks.
- 44:01Yeah, man. OK, so let's let's get back into
- 44:03talking about the movie itself. And I do think we obviously need
- 44:06to touch on the subject matter a little bit here.
- 44:08But I grew up Catholic and I grew up Catholic at the time of
- 44:14the events of this movie, you know, the 2001, early 2000 when
- 44:18I was 10 years old. And so it's, it's very, it's
- 44:22weird and it's jarring to watch a movie about the abuse scandals
- 44:26in the Catholic Church that were happening obviously long before
- 44:30I was born, but that we're breaking at a time where I was
- 44:33at an age that a lot of these children were victimized.
- 44:38And it's, it's it's weird for a lot of reasons, obviously.
- 44:41But I think I was not shielded from it.
- 44:45And my parents were not super religious.
- 44:48My mom grew up Catholic and I was just kind of culturally
- 44:50Catholic and I was an altar boy. But like we never were in the
- 44:56group of people that I think anyone who grew up Catholic
- 44:59would know what I'm talking about.
- 45:00In every Catholic Church there is like it, it is a, your
- 45:04involvement with the church is a status symbol.
- 45:07And like the most involved people in the church are usually
- 45:10like among the wealthiest people in the church because you get to
- 45:13get up in front of the whole church and read the
- 45:14announcements or whatever. And you do it in your best suit
- 45:17and tie. And I understand, like, I, I
- 45:20look at a movie like this and I, I'm not from Boston.
- 45:23I didn't grow up in Southie or wherever.
- 45:26But like poor kids in neighborhoods where there is not
- 45:30much hope to get out, like rely heavily on the church,
- 45:34especially in heavily Catholic areas.
- 45:36And when that one kid was talking about, you know, the guy
- 45:39was saying like it was like God coming to my house when the
- 45:43priest came over. You know, it's it, it's a real
- 45:47thing. And I think that people that
- 45:48either don't grow up in religious households and or
- 45:52especially grow up Catholic, it's hard for them sometimes to
- 45:55wrap their mind around. And it's, it's not even
- 45:58necessarily that like people are brainwashed or people are in
- 46:02some sort of cults. It's just it is so interwoven
- 46:05with the social dynamics of those areas that you can't
- 46:09separate it from your day-to-day life.
- 46:13Yeah, I it, it, it might not seem obvious to everybody in our
- 46:17culture, but religion has dominated the human experience
- 46:22for the majority of human history.
- 46:25But like, the amount of time that it hasn't is so vastly
- 46:31small compared to the time it has.
- 46:34And so it, it might seem wild to us, but you're right, Bob, like
- 46:39the, like the, the way, especially the Catholic
- 46:43religion, because it is so universal and worldwide, the,
- 46:48the way it integrates itself into a person's life is
- 46:54holistic. And, and I think, you know, what
- 46:57I said earlier is true. That's what makes this so
- 47:03disgusting and so warped, is that the church, when it's done
- 47:09right and well, ought to be the most wholesome and uplifting
- 47:14integrative experience of a person's life.
- 47:18And yet it can be twisted into becoming one of the most dark
- 47:22and demonic. And like, that's just, it's so
- 47:27hard. And, and I will say, like I, I
- 47:30grew up Protestant and I do I, I did not have an understanding of
- 47:36how intense the Catholic Church is until I got to college.
- 47:42I got to know some, some people who went to Walsh and were
- 47:46devout Catholics. I never realized how much of an
- 47:50impact it had on people until I was older.
- 47:54Well, and I think that when you look at the scandals of like the
- 47:56evangelical church that you grew up in, Brad, they, I mean,
- 48:00they're power is at the root of both of them and the abuse of
- 48:03power, but they present themselves very differently,
- 48:06right? It's, it's more about a cult of
- 48:08personality with evangelicalism, whereas it's about like a, an
- 48:13oppressive systemic structure with Catholicism.
- 48:17And I think they do a really good job of capturing that in
- 48:20the movie. Before we get out of here today,
- 48:23Brad, There's like I've, I've noted 3 scenes in the movie that
- 48:27I found to be not just really powerful, but also like really
- 48:30instructive for how to, to view the movie.
- 48:33And I made mention of the first one in the first half of the
- 48:35episode. But I want to bring it up here
- 48:37because one of my favorite performances in the movie is
- 48:40from Billy Crudup, who we haven't talked about on this
- 48:43podcast in a long time since we did Almost Famous.
- 48:46Russell Hammond. I love him in that movie.
- 48:49I love him in this movie as the lawyer, Eric McLeish, because
- 48:53you think that they're setting him up to be the sleazy,
- 48:56arrogant, a hole lawyer. And Billy Crudup is so good at
- 49:01being like both really vulnerable and easy to empathize
- 49:08with and also really good at playing cocky and arrogant.
- 49:11There's just something about his posture and bass that he can
- 49:14play it both ways and he does it in this movie.
- 49:17They go to see this guy three times.
- 49:18The first time he's just getting that information on how the the
- 49:21church settles cases. Then they learned that he was
- 49:24the one settling a lot of these cases.
- 49:26So they go back and kind of confront him and he's like, I
- 49:29can't answer that. I can't answer that.
- 49:31They go back a third time and and you think it's going to come
- 49:34to a head with him. And then he's like, you guys, I
- 49:37tried to tell you all this. And it's this moment where I
- 49:42think the movie is doing a really good job of telling you
- 49:48as the audience, like, we are not going to go for the easy,
- 49:51like this guy's the villain route because a, everybody's
- 49:56complicit in this. Even if you weren't aware, just
- 50:00being around it made you complicit in it and be like even
- 50:05the people that you think had had their hands in doing this.
- 50:09We're trying to find ways to end it, and either that structure
- 50:14was oppressing them into not being able to do it, or some
- 50:17other system or structure like the Boston Globe thwarted their
- 50:22plans to do it. I I thought that was a really
- 50:24brilliant scene, Brad. And I think for me, it's not I,
- 50:29I think what this movie does well is not that it just points
- 50:32out the system having power. It takes you through all of the
- 50:38different people who are supporting that system.
- 50:41Because I, I, as somebody who is, you know, a little more
- 50:45conservative in his political leanings, I find myself often
- 50:51skeptical about claims of systemic power and systemic
- 50:56violence. And not from the fact that it
- 50:59doesn't happen, but from the fact that systems are made-up of
- 51:03people. And, and it's all of these
- 51:06people that have combined together.
- 51:09Whether it's through the forgetfulness or the busyness of
- 51:16Michael Keaton's character and accidentally covering up the
- 51:19story 5-8 years before, or it's people who are actively covering
- 51:25it up within the church. Like it's not necessarily just
- 51:29this giant system that is covering everything up.
- 51:32It's a bunch of individual people.
- 51:35And, and I think that's what this movie does so well.
- 51:37Is that it? It almost wants to like drown
- 51:41you with characters that are hard to keep track of because
- 51:45it's like this maelstrom of people who are on the periphery
- 51:51of what's going on. And yet once you get to all of
- 51:55the people individually, you put together this massive picture of
- 52:00brokenness and destruction and and vile activity.
- 52:05And and I think that's what's so fascinating about it.
- 52:07And you're right, Billy Crudup is kind of at the center of that
- 52:12within the this movie. There is one stretch of the
- 52:15movie where I feels, I feel like it, it goes for old Hollywood
- 52:19style filmmaking and it's a montage basically like the night
- 52:23before. Maybe not the night before, but
- 52:26there's a montage where these children are at mass singing
- 52:31Silent Night and Mark Ruffalo's character like goes into the
- 52:35back of the church and is watching them and they're
- 52:39intercutting it with the, the daily lives of all of the
- 52:42different reporters. And it, it was like the moment
- 52:45where you've been watching for like an hour and 45 minutes,
- 52:49probably of them doing like the day-to-day work of journalistic,
- 52:53you know, digging. And you've seen some of the
- 52:58faces of victims who have like who are adults now talking about
- 53:02their stories. But it's really the first time
- 53:04you're confronted with like child aged children, you know,
- 53:08who are maybe, maybe not victims in this moment and no one knows.
- 53:15And it's, it just crushed me, dude.
- 53:18The movie made me cry at a couple moments.
- 53:20And that was one of them because it's, again, it's really
- 53:22understated. They don't go over the top.
- 53:25There's nobody like looking at the cameras talking about like
- 53:28these children. It's just you see small children
- 53:32in a in a place that's supposed to be safe for them and they're
- 53:35not. And it's like, dude, it, it
- 53:38broke me, man. Yeah, I, I think the moment for
- 53:41me that really made me cry was the absolute final little bit of
- 53:46the movie when Keaton shows up to the office that Sunday, that
- 53:52the paper was delivered and the front secretary is like, yeah,
- 53:56it's weird. It's been quiet in here, but it
- 53:59seems like your office is really busy and.
- 54:01And he gets down there and every single person in the room is
- 54:05answering phone calls. And I, I think it's Rachel
- 54:09McAdams that just looks at him and goes, it's all victims.
- 54:13They're all calling in. And I, I think that's the point
- 54:18for me, that just crushed me of like the power of an
- 54:26establishment like the Boston Globe giving voice to people who
- 54:31have been broken and hurt. That like, that's a place where,
- 54:36once again, it's not even necessarily that it's the
- 54:39establishment of the Boston Globe, although its reputation
- 54:43is something that gives its credence.
- 54:45It's the fact that those four reporters and their supporting
- 54:49editors worked so freaking hard and put in so much time and
- 54:55effort to uncover such a tragedy that now all of these people are
- 55:01able to come forward with their stories, come forward with the
- 55:06truth. And if you look on the Boston
- 55:10Globes website, you can like look up the original story and
- 55:14see there was like, I think it was like 18 to 20 stories that
- 55:19came out through that year about all of this stuff.
- 55:23I think they say in the final credits that like over the
- 55:26course of two years, they published like 600 follow up
- 55:29stories. Like it was, it was a staggering
- 55:31number of stories that came out of this.
- 55:33Yeah, I think for me, you know, along the same lines, we haven't
- 55:36even talked about Stanley Tucci's character.
- 55:39And I love Stanley Tucci to death, but he's also like one of
- 55:42those actors where in the same movie, he is being like the
- 55:46campiest person in the movie and then can also just absolutely
- 55:50blow everyone else off the screen with how good he can be.
- 55:52And he does that here like he's wearing some sort of hairpiece.
- 55:56Or if he did grow his hair out somehow for this movie, they
- 55:59judged it up a whole bunch. He's doing like the worst of the
- 56:02accents of anybody in this movie.
- 56:04He's the most eccentric, but he has this moment right at the end
- 56:07of the movie where there's like 2 little kids in his office.
- 56:10And Mark Ruffalo like came by to, to give him a copy of the
- 56:13paper. And he's walking out and he
- 56:16looks at Mark Ruffalo. He says like both of these kids
- 56:19were just abused 2 weeks ago. And you can tell he's like about
- 56:22to start breaking and he just like puts his finger in his
- 56:25chest and just like, just like keep doing your work.
- 56:30And he his hand drops and there's so much like the weight
- 56:34of the world is on this guy's shoulders.
- 56:37And it's such a good line reading.
- 56:39I just, I had to say something because it also made me break
- 56:43there. You know, it's not necessarily
- 56:48a, a cynical or a pessimistic ending, but there is this
- 56:54acknowledgement there tacitly that like, this isn't over now,
- 56:58like this isn't just going to stop happening.
- 57:01And there are people still out there that are doing the work
- 57:04every day of having to care for these people whose lives have
- 57:08been upended by it. Absolutely.
- 57:11And I think that one of the reasons I like Stanley Tucci in
- 57:14this film is that he has an actual arc where at the start he
- 57:20feels like he is completely alone in trying to not only
- 57:26expose what is happening, but protect the people who have been
- 57:30hurt. And so he's so protective of his
- 57:33witnesses and he does not trust the globe to actually see it
- 57:38through and do the job well. And because of his relationship
- 57:44with Ruffalo, he slowly begins to trust him to to report on the
- 57:50story. Well.
- 57:51And it all culminates in that final, final scene when he, like
- 57:55you said, he has his finger in his chest and he tells him,
- 57:57like, you keep doing this work, You keep doing what you're
- 58:01doing. And then he walks into the room
- 58:04and like the way he interacts with the kids for like, you
- 58:08know, 1/2 of a line that we hear before the door closes, you just
- 58:12go, oh, this guy is doing this for all the right reasons.
- 58:17And it's it's such a great performance from Tucci.
- 58:20The last thing I noted about the movie, and it was the last thing
- 58:22that made me cry, is the the closing credits where they just
- 58:25say, like, here are all the places that scandals have been
- 58:29uncovered. And it's 3 columns on each
- 58:33screen of probably, I don't know, 20 names per column, city
- 58:37names per column. Yeah, I saw Cleveland, OH on
- 58:39there. You know, I saw Toledo on there.
- 58:41It fades out. It fades back in.
- 58:43There's another 60 cities, and then it fades out again and
- 58:46fades back in. And now it's global.
- 58:48And it is, it's presented again. So matter of factly, they're
- 58:52not, it's not overwrought. They're not overdue doing it and
- 58:56just the the sheer volume of names on that list is harrowing,
- 59:03man. It sucks dude.
- 59:06It sucks a lot, Brad. It like.
- 59:09Yeah. Yeah, dude.
- 59:11And it's just such a hard movie. And I think that like that I am
- 59:14not in any way trying to steer us towards something lighter
- 59:17here, but I think this is actually a very natural segue
- 59:19into what I want to talk about with our next segment.
- 59:22Let's make it a double. We're near the end of the
- 59:24episode, so thanks listening to the film and Whiskey show.
- 59:28Let's have another film with this one, even if it's
- 59:30struggling. It's the final segment of the
- 59:32day. Now let's make it a double.
- 59:34Let's Make It a Double is the part of the show where we pick a
- 59:36movie to pair up with this one to make the perfect double
- 59:39feature. Brad, you picked this movie a
- 59:41few weeks ago and I'm going to, I'm just going to run with it.
- 59:45I'm going to go with Schindler's List for this movie.
- 59:48And I think it's literally just the the list making element of
- 59:51it, that there's a moment where Ben Kingsley's character pull
- 59:56the last sheet of the list out of the typewriter and looks at
- 1:00:01Liam Neeson and says, like, the list is an absolute good.
- 1:00:05The list is life, right? And then in this movie you have
- 1:00:09a list of cities. That are like in a list of
- 1:00:12priests, even in in the Boston Globe's investigation that are
- 1:00:17the complete opposite of that, that are like taking life and
- 1:00:20and marrying and obscuring what is good about life.
- 1:00:25But I love that the, I love that they just called this movie
- 1:00:29Spotlight. Like, it's obviously an accurate
- 1:00:31representation of what the Spotlight team does, but there's
- 1:00:34a reason that their team is called Spotlight.
- 1:00:36Like they are shining a light on something that has been hidden
- 1:00:40for far too long. And so in its own weird way,
- 1:00:43like that list is also, you know, bringing, I don't want to
- 1:00:48say restoration, but bringing the attention needed for these
- 1:00:51people whose lives have been broken to be restored back to
- 1:00:54life. And so yeah, my my pairing would
- 1:00:57be Schindler's List. That was the movie I had as
- 1:00:59well. I, I was trying to find any
- 1:01:04other procedural movie, you know, I, I feel like a lot of
- 1:01:07people would, would pair it with maybe like a Zodiac.
- 1:01:10You know what I mentioned earlier.
- 1:01:12Good night and good luck. You know, there's obviously tons
- 1:01:15and tons and tons of movie about, about such a thing.
- 1:01:19For some reason, though, Schindler's List is what popped
- 1:01:21into my head as well. And, and, and, and it's the
- 1:01:24power once again of individuals who care about other individuals
- 1:01:30enough to do something about it. And I think for me, it wasn't
- 1:01:35necessarily the list. It was that idea of people going
- 1:01:40against the grain to care for those who can't care for
- 1:01:43themselves. And like that is what the church
- 1:01:47is supposed to be all about. But like you can't read the
- 1:01:51Bible and not see it saturated with evidence that we ought to
- 1:01:58be the shepherds who care for the sheep who are broken and
- 1:02:01lost that live in the darkness and we need the light.
- 1:02:07It just I, I think this movie gives us a picture of journalism
- 1:02:15truly at its best. And I think it does such a great
- 1:02:19job of not the the director does such a great job of not
- 1:02:23editorializing. It just presents you with here's
- 1:02:28the story that was found. Here's how they went about
- 1:02:31exposing the story. And here are some of the
- 1:02:35results. And you know, we we've talked
- 1:02:39about the Big Short a few times throughout this season in
- 1:02:42addition to watching it. And I think I I continue to sour
- 1:02:47on that movie because it feels like Adam McKay was
- 1:02:51editorializing. He like he was trying to give
- 1:02:54his spin on how he views the world.
- 1:02:58And and Tom McCarthy here just allows the reality to stand for
- 1:03:02itself and sink into you as you watch the film.
- 1:03:06All right, that was let's make it a double presented by
- 1:03:08Blackwood Distilling Company. No matter what movie you pair
- 1:03:11this up with, you can always make it a double with Blackwood
- 1:03:15Distilling Co. If you go to
- 1:03:16bourbonoutfitter.com/film Whiskey and use our Code of Film
- 1:03:20Whiskey at checkout, you can receive 5% off your bottle of
- 1:03:23Blackwood. Brad, let's get into final
- 1:03:26scores here. You know, we said in the first
- 1:03:28half that the decision for how to frame this movie was the
- 1:03:32correct one, but then it also kind of put a cap on how much I
- 1:03:37could get into it. It feels very weird talking
- 1:03:40about a movie with this subject matter that like like that I
- 1:03:43wanted this story to be more entertaining.
- 1:03:45You know what I mean? Like, I feel like a hypocrite
- 1:03:47saying that. I do think that like, if I'm
- 1:03:51thinking objectively, how well done, how well made is this
- 1:03:56movie? I think it's a nine out of 10.
- 1:03:58If I'm talking specifically about like the extent to which I
- 1:04:05like vibed with this movie, I think it's like an 8.
- 1:04:08I think it's like a really, really good 8 out of 10.
- 1:04:11So I'm going to split the difference.
- 1:04:12I'm going to give this an 8.5 out of 10, Brad.
- 1:04:15I'm kind of in the same place. I, I think this is an 8 1/2 out
- 1:04:18of 10. I think it's a really important
- 1:04:21movie about a about a extraordinarily important event
- 1:04:26in human history. I just don't, Yeah, like you
- 1:04:31said, I, I don't know if I vibe with the movie to, to give it
- 1:04:34like a 10 out of 10, but I think it's an extraordinarily
- 1:04:38important movie that that everybody should watch.
- 1:04:42And I, I think it's helpful that I think the movie takes faith
- 1:04:46seriously. I think it takes the important
- 1:04:51things that the church does do seriously and allows that to
- 1:04:55stand as like a testament to how dark the subject matter is.
- 1:05:00So, So yeah, I'm. I'm with you, Bob. 8 1/2 out of
- 1:05:0310. All right, so it's an 8.5 from
- 1:05:06us, but we'd like to know what you think.
- 1:05:07Have you seen Spotlight? You know, did it deserve to win
- 1:05:11Best picture? Is it better than a movie like
- 1:05:13The Revenant or like Mad Max Fury Rd.
- 1:05:15You can let us know by reaching out to us at any of our social
- 1:05:18media accounts, Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, TikTok, or
- 1:05:23YouTube at Film Whiskey. Or you can join the conversation
- 1:05:26on our Discord server. You can find a link to it at the
- 1:05:29end of every single one of our show notes.
- 1:05:31Next week we're going to be joined by special guest Noah
- 1:05:34Gettel, a guy we haven't talked to in quite a while, Brad.
- 1:05:36I'm excited to bring him on and talk about one of his favorite
- 1:05:39movies of the last 10 years, Quentin Tarantino's Once Upon a
- 1:05:42Time in Hollywood. So join us for that next week,
- 1:05:46but until then, I'm Bob Book. I'm Brad G.
- 1:05:49And we'll see you next time. Music.