Latest / Journey to the Fringe / What are those boy in blue up to?
Transcript
- 0:00From the unexplained to the mundane, come join us on a journey to the fringe.
- 0:13Hello and welcome to Journey to the Fringe, where Chelsea, I think it's a fairly reasonable
- 0:17thing to say that we've both had issues with authority, both in the past, not run-ins with
- 0:23them, just problems with authority.
- 0:24It's a personality trait that I think we both have.
- 0:27But with you not being able to take tests well because somebody's judging you, and I
- 0:30just having been sold that the police are out to get me since I was like three years
- 0:34old, just not trusting anything with an authority figure.
- 0:37I thought you were talking about all the arrests.
- 0:40Yeah, I know, I have to specify that.
- 0:42Anyhow, we are your podcast host, Taylor and Chelsea, here today, kind of giving you an
- 0:46idea, a sense of mass wrongdoings that the police have done in the past.
- 0:52And I, police might be the wrong word for it, because we're going to talk about sheriff's
- 0:55departments as well.
- 0:57But this is kind of a response.
- 0:59If somebody says, which I hate this response, when you're talking about them with specific
- 1:03cases of malpractice by police officers, and they say, well, that's just one bad apple.
- 1:08Which if you look at that entire phrase, one bad apple ruins the batch.
- 1:12In fact, means that is an entirely terrible thing to have the one bad apple there.
- 1:16But hey, these are going to be examples of, no, there's entirely huge problems with the
- 1:21police that need to be addressed.
- 1:24So we're only talking about specific cities issues.
- 1:27This is a systemic issue all throughout the first world, I guess will be a proper way
- 1:31to say it, or at least North America that needs to be addressed.
- 1:34You wouldn't think it would just be exclusive to certain cities.
- 1:37So Chelsea, strap yourself in.
- 1:39We've got three cases here to look at just to give you a warning.
- 1:43They're going to get worse as we go.
- 1:44Okay, so you went least worst to worst.
- 1:48Yeah, at least worst to worst.
- 1:50Yeah.
- 1:51They're not choice to make the worst one, but they're all pretty bad in their own right.
- 1:55So Chelsea, I hope you're ready for this.
- 1:57Did you know that if you're rich enough, you can just hire an entire police precinct?
- 2:02Do what?
- 2:03What would I be searching for in the court?
- 2:05Party double.
- 2:06We're not just talking about like if you're pulled over by the cops slipping them a 20
- 2:10and going on your way.
- 2:11No, we're talking an entire state's police being paid off to do particular things for
- 2:17a group.
- 2:18So like what would I want them to do that for?
- 2:21Oh, if you didn't want them to know what's happening?
- 2:23No, not necessarily that, but you're kind of on the right track to.
- 2:28Now this story, Vice News did a great job on this happening.
- 2:32This happened in 2021 from Motherboard, which is a subsidiary of Vice and it's specifically
- 2:38about a pipeline that was being built from Canada to the US.
- 2:42A Canadian oil company gave Minnesota law enforcement $2 million to fund the policing
- 2:47of protests against construction of this pipeline.
- 2:50Calgary based oil giant Enbridge set up a fund called the Public Safety Escrow Trust
- 2:55and May of 2020 as part of its permitting process for the line three pipeline route,
- 3:00which carries oil from Edmonton, Alberta to Superior, Wisconsin, which is not superior
- 3:06to Edmonton.
- 3:07I don't think it's just the name of the city that is going to.
- 3:10Nice tactic.
- 3:11Yeah.
- 3:12The funds in this account have been used to reimburse costs associated with maintaining
- 3:16the peace around the pipeline, including for officers, wages, lodging and boom trucks,
- 3:21according to the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission and line three permits.
- 3:25On July 29th, 2021, a group of unarmed environmental activists protesting the pipeline in Thief
- 3:30River Falls, Minnesota, were tear gas, shot with rubber bullets and arrested.
- 3:35Quote, it was a really brutal scene.
- 3:37The level of force being used partnered with the very close range that law enforcement was
- 3:43facing us led to some pretty serious injuries.
- 3:46It was really an extreme level of force partnered with a really punitive and oppressive style
- 3:51of jailing, said Tara Houska, an Ojibwe lawyer and activist who was arrested at the protests.
- 3:56The nearby Marshall County Sheriff's Department filed a reimbursement request for expenses
- 4:01associated with that day's patrol.
- 4:03A spokesperson for the Minnesota PUC, which we talked about earlier, confirmed to motherboard.
- 4:08According to the utility regulator between June 8th and July 31st, that Sheriff's Department
- 4:13was reimbursed $20,057.90 by Enbridge for personnel expenses associated with line three
- 4:19at assists.
- 4:20In the Marshall County Sheriff's Department did not respond to a request for comment.
- 4:24Enbridge justifies the pipeline expansion as necessary to uphold high safety standards,
- 4:29but community members living near it say the project exchanges environmental destruction
- 4:34and sacrifices land for a polluting energy source.
- 4:37The pipeline has also been tied to several instances of sex trafficking, harassment and
- 4:42assault.
- 4:43There's a whole other article that we're not going to get into because this is going
- 4:45to be a long episode in itself of local community members.
- 4:49Environmental activists many from indigenous territories through which the pipeline would
- 4:52run have opposed the project for the last seven years.
- 4:56Activists efforts ramped up in November 2020 when Minnesota's Pollution Control Agency
- 5:00MPCA issued Enbridge water crossing permits.
- 5:03Grassroots collectives like Honor the Earth, Minnesota 350 and Stop Line 3 have garnered
- 5:08international support, including from the likes of Jane Fonda for direct actions held
- 5:13to obstruct the HULT pipeline construction in the months since.
- 5:16Many of these direct actions have been met with violence by local police.
- 5:19Though the July 29th incident was not the first time activists have been met by resistance
- 5:23from law enforcement, it was the first time police had used less than lethal weapons.
- 5:27The Guinea Collective and Environmental Activist group led by indigenous women and two spirits
- 5:31people organizing against the pipeline wrote in a Facebook post on August 1st of 2021.
- 5:36Many activists were arrested and taken to Pennington County Jail, where several were
- 5:40denied food and medical care for their injuries and health in solitary confinement.
- 5:45Among them was Genu Collective founder Huska, who stated after being attacked and zip-tied
- 5:49she was kept in solitary confinement for days, denied food that aligned with her dietary
- 5:54needs and ultimately hospitalized.
- 5:56Pennington County Jail Administrator Dave Casanova, the existence of the Public Safety
- 6:01Escrow fund has been known for some time thanks to activists and media reports. An April report
- 6:06from the Minnesota Reformer based on documents obtained through public record requests showed
- 6:11that Enbridge established a financial relationship with Minnesota law enforcement in May of 2020
- 6:15as part of the permits that PUC issued, creating quote, a public safety end quote reimbursement
- 6:21fund for any pipeline related police action and emergency responders.
- 6:26In its permitting documentation, the PUC cited increased law enforcement expenses around
- 6:31pipelines in other parts of the country as reasoning for establishing the fund. The funds
- 6:35live in an escrow account managed by a state appointed official to whom agencies send requests
- 6:41for reimbursement of costs related to quote, coordination of public safety and emergency
- 6:45responders public safety related costs for maintaining the peace in and around the construction
- 6:50site or view an oversight of any private security services, end quote, and other similar costs.
- 6:56It's not public safety if the oil company is paying the Jesus Christ.
- 7:02The financial arrangement allows the state's police departments to get reimbursed by the
- 7:06fossil fuel corporations for quote, maintaining the peace in and around the pipeline construction
- 7:11site and coordinating services at kin reported that included those undertaken by a task force
- 7:17of 18 sheriff's departments, the Northern Lights Task Force, which was created to deter
- 7:22pipeline protests in April of 2021. Enbridge had paid law enforcement over $500,000 out
- 7:29of this fund. We've also learned that figures have ballooned far from their per spokesperson
- 7:34of the MPUC. The well giant has paid $1,957,011.37 in law enforcement expenses to date. That
- 7:44is a really hard number. That's too many numbers. Just round it, please. How many cents? Why
- 7:51are they paying cents? Round up, please. For the sake of those saying the number at least.
- 7:58That's a compassion. These expenses likely helped cover what Husqa
- 8:03says has been relentless surveillance by Minnesota police along the pipeline's route for the
- 8:08last year. Quote, there's a law enforcement officer parked right across the dirt road
- 8:13that we live on right now. Like that's the daily occurrence there 24 hours a day. End
- 8:17quote says Husqa. Husqa says the financial relationship to an Enbridge and the state
- 8:21regulator is an indication of its undue influence. She recalled receiving flippant comments from
- 8:26arresting officers as she and fellow protesters were detained, alluding to the partnership.
- 8:31Quote, the police who are standing around as we're wearing zip ties are talking about
- 8:35how much fun they had and they hoped we came back real soon and that they're going to
- 8:40get time and a half. We're sitting there hurt and unable to open our eyes because we've
- 8:44had so much mace in them and they're just laughing at us. End quote Husqa says since
- 8:48the creation in 2020, $327,000 of the Enbridge fund has gone to the Cass County Sheriff's
- 8:54office located 180 miles north of Minneapolis for security patrols of pipeline property
- 8:59through a former noted. This amounted to around 7% of the department's salary and overtime
- 9:04budget for that year between November 28th, 2020 and February 19th, 2021 over 40 employees
- 9:10dedicated more than 7,000 hours to safety patrol. And another $171,000 went to Beltrami
- 9:16County Sheriff's Department for officers training as early as 2017 preparation for
- 9:21the pipeline and mileage for response to line three protests. All of this was paid for by
- 9:25Enbridge. Enbridge spokesperson Julie Kellner said that the company recognizes the protesters
- 9:30rights to quote express their views about the energy we all use, but it does not tolerate
- 9:35illegal and unsafe acts. That's the end of the quote. That's the end of the article.
- 9:39That's how easy it is to just buy a police department. I feel like Enbridge doesn't
- 9:43make the law to say what they can support and not and the police don't need to be paid
- 9:49to uphold peace. Especially when that's what we're doing. We're supposed to be doing that.
- 9:53That's the whole point of taxes. Yeah, we already pay you to not get paid by somebody
- 9:58else so that you could protect them. The billionaire. So I mean, I laugh, but it's
- 10:03disgusting. That's the first one. You can just buy a police department if you really
- 10:07need to. You got enough money. Well, now that I know that maybe when I need them, I'll buy
- 10:12a police department. Okay. And if you guys want to give us enough money to actually buy
- 10:15a police department, please do so. So far you have given us zero monies to buy a police
- 10:19department. So any extra help. They haven't paid us money to do shit with. I'm sorry.
- 10:27It's true. No judgment here. Don't worry, guys. Next up, did you know that departments
- 10:33can be full of gangs? What kind of departments in this case, it's a sheriff's department,
- 10:38but I'm going to boldly go out there and say it's probably not the only one it likely
- 10:41could also extend out to police departments. Okay, law enforcement. What's the difference
- 10:46between a sheriff and a law enforcement? You keep sticking them. I was really trying to
- 10:50figure this out. Basically, sheriffs are generally in elected position. I don't know the case
- 10:55here. We're talking about the LA Sheriff's Department, which is the largest sheriff's
- 10:58department in the US. Generally, sheriffs will be elected, but I don't know the case
- 11:03specifically with the LA Sheriff Department. And there is also the LAPD and I don't know
- 11:07the specific separation here. Generally, sheriffs will also provide, I shouldn't say policing,
- 11:12but policing to courthouses and prisons, as well as they'll take care of the more state
- 11:19oriented laws. Okay, that's good enough for me. That's simple enough to explain it. There's
- 11:24way more to it than that. But I think that's enough to at least get us going from here.
- 11:29And you said they're run by gangs? No, they're full of gangs. You're a part of the gangs.
- 11:35Just read the story and you're going to learn as we go because this is this was absolutely
- 11:39ridiculous when I learned this and it's a fairly recent revelation. So LA SD, Los Angeles
- 11:45Sheriff's Department has over 18,000 employees and that makes the LA County Sheriff's Department
- 11:50the largest in the US. But it is plagued by dozens of often violent gangs and cliques
- 11:56organized by sheriff's deputies. This has been going on since at least 1973.
- 12:00What? Like are we talking about like Crips and Blitz? No, that's the only gangs I know
- 12:05in the area. It's entirely unique to the sheriff's department and you're going to learn about
- 12:10it here. It's just ridiculous. We're going to be pulling from two sources. One is the
- 12:14Civilian Oversight Commission on Sheriff's Department in LA. This is a document that
- 12:19was drafted and came out as February 2023, as well as there is a pretty good NPR article
- 12:24on this. So we're going to be pulling from both of these. To start off from the COC,
- 12:28the Civilian Oversight Commission. We're going to start with this. Deputy gangs and deputy
- 12:31cliques have existed in the LA County Sheriff's Department since at least 1973. That year,
- 12:36an internal department memo dated December 5th documented the existence of a group known
- 12:40as Little Devils and identified 38 members who bore sequential numbered tattoos of a
- 12:45devil. What? In the Sheriff's Department? In the Sheriff's Department, yes. In 1992,
- 12:51the Colts Commission report confirmed the existence of deputy gangs and deputy cliques,
- 12:55including deputy gangs called the Vikings in the department. After holding evidentiary
- 12:59hearings in Los Angeles in 1993 and 96, the United States Commission on Civil Rights in
- 13:031999 issued a report focusing on the violence and trauma the deputy gangs had inflicted
- 13:08on communities of color and people struggling with mental illness and urged the LASD to
- 13:13take decisive action to eradicate the deputy gangs from its ranks. In 2012, the Citizens
- 13:18Commission on Jail Violence, CCJV, found that the deputy cliques existed in patrol and on
- 13:24certain floors of men's central jails, MCJs, if that comes up again, and that they contributed
- 13:29to the use of excessive force in the jails. The CCJV's report contains five pages of
- 13:35recommendations to address the problem. The Loyola Law School Report documented the department's
- 13:40long history of eight deputy gangs and deputy cliques in 2021, and the Rang Corporation
- 13:44also confirmed the existence in its report titled Understanding Subgroups within the
- 13:49LA County Sheriff's Department in 2021. All the deputy cliques share harmful characteristics,
- 13:55while not all deputy cliques engage in identical, unprofessional conduct. Most share at least
- 14:00some of the following characteristics, and they have done and continue to do certain acts
- 14:04of unprofessional and dangerous policing. Deputy cliques run the stations or units
- 14:09where they exist, as opposed to the sergeants, lieutenants, and the captains who are charged
- 14:13with the duty to run the station. Exercise influence over and often decide assignments
- 14:18and shifts, training and overtime. Exclude deputies from the deputy cliques, often based
- 14:23on race, ethnicity, and gender. Intimidate deputies that are not part of the deputy cliques.
- 14:28Give orders not to provide backup to disfavored deputies who are not members of the deputy
- 14:34cliques. Order work slowdowns if management of a station attempts to rein them in. Encourage
- 14:39a we-they attitude as in a separate, we are the gang and there's everybody else who's
- 14:43against us, and not just between them and the public, but with other deputies within
- 14:47the station. Operate in secrecy, lie in reports to protect each other, and threaten the public
- 14:52with use of excessive force without justification and be little deputies unwilling to engage
- 14:56in such acts. Most troubling, they create rituals that valorize violence, such as recording
- 15:01all deputy-involved shootings in official books, celebrating with shooting parties, and
- 15:06authorizing deputies who have shot a community member to add embellishments to their common
- 15:11gang tattoos. This is literally from a civilian oversight commission. Like this is documents
- 15:18that they collected on it, and we're gonna talk about people actually talk to them about
- 15:22this as we get going. Typically to be invited to become a member of a deputy gang or deputy
- 15:33clique, a deputy must demonstrate, quote, offness, and quote, that is frequently associated
- 15:38with the use of excessive force or other forms of unconstitutional policing. Often the euphemistic
- 15:42term peer leader is used to describe the members. Deputy gangs and deputy cliques also have
- 15:47used and continue to use assault of behavior against fellow deputies who do not belong
- 15:51to their group as a show of power and influence. Certain of these altercations have led to
- 15:56public exposure in the media. The COC investigation uncovered these other incidents, including
- 16:00threatened use of weapons by deputies upon other deputies. The pernicious effects of
- 16:05these groups go well beyond assaulting other deputies. Recent publicly released body cam
- 16:11footage of a deputy threatening to shoot a man in a parked car without any evidence of
- 16:15wrongdoing illustrated in real time gang behavior characteristics of deputy gangs and deputy
- 16:19cliques interacting with the public served. Not all members of deputy cliques engage
- 16:24in acts of misconduct. Even those members who do not engage in misconduct, however,
- 16:27contribute to the unprofessional influence of deputy cliques and their negative impact
- 16:32on the department and on other deputies. Deputy cliques have and continue to do great
- 16:37damage to the reputation of the department and the public hearings demonstrate that they
- 16:41have unquestionably destroyed trust between the department and the public.
- 16:45This is just one group of members of the jump out boys shared a common number tattoo that
- 16:53depicts a red eyed skull wearing a bandana with the letter OSS and holding a revolver
- 16:59next to an ace of spades and an aid of spades the so-called dead man's hand in poker. Their
- 17:04creed recited that members understand quote when the line need to be crossed and crossed
- 17:10back and quote that they quote sometimes need to do things that they do not want to in order
- 17:15to get where they want to be and quote it also directed members to keep a quote black
- 17:19book and quote that records the dates of every deputy involved shooting that records the
- 17:24date of every deputy involved shooting that authorize each shooter to embellish his common
- 17:29tattoo with smoke coming out of the gun. Seven jump out boys members were fired but because
- 17:35there was no clear policy against joining a deputy gang at the time, the civil service
- 17:39commission reinstated four of them. That was one of the recommendations I believe that
- 17:47wasn't really what I was looking at at this point and like there's so much we have to
- 17:51go into still with even this that it's hard to catch it all and there's another story
- 17:56after this one which I think is worse. It is indisputable that for nearly 50 years deputy
- 18:00gangs and deputy cliques have existed within the department and their existence and negative
- 18:05impacts were known to the leadership of the department yet there was no sustained effort
- 18:09during this period to eradicate deputy gangs and deputy cliques from the department. All
- 18:13prior efforts were inadequate, lost continuity and failed to eliminate deputy gangs and deputy
- 18:17cliques. Owing to this failure, deputy gangs and deputy cliques are embedded in the culture
- 18:21of the department either tolerated or ignored. Indeed during the tenure of Sheriff Baca,
- 18:26the under sheriff, Paul Tanaka was a tattooed member of the Vikings. According to the numerous
- 18:31witness interviews, former sheriff Villanueva's under sheriff Tim Miracami has a caveman tattoo,
- 18:38another gang. This is from the commission, I have another thing that will change this
- 18:41number but there's at least a half dozen impossibly more deputy gangs and deputy cliques currently
- 18:46in the department primarily at patrol stations and they include the executioners, the banditos,
- 18:51the regulators, the Spartans, the gladiators, the cowboys and the reapers. And now we're
- 18:59going to move to a bit from the NPR article on this. Two recent under sheriffs, the second
- 19:03in command posts for the department were identified by the commission as having gang tattoos. Paul
- 19:07Tanaka, the under sheriff from 2011-2013 and Tim Miracami, the under sheriff reporting to
- 19:13Alex Villanueva until 2022 who we're just talking about. An extensive investigation by
- 19:19nonprofit newsroom Nock LA, which if you're looking for good information on this, go read
- 19:24Nock LA. That is the best location for this. Alleged dozens of gangs were associated with the
- 19:29sheriff's office but also noted the county's district attorney routinely denies to charge
- 19:34members. The newsroom also reported the department tends to settle excessive force cases and other
- 19:39lawsuits involving alleged members before they go to trial, costing taxpayers millions. In the
- 19:44years since the oversight commission conducted an exhaustive review of its own, culminating the
- 19:48report published in March, the new report found evidence of gang control of at least six sheriff's
- 19:53department stations. Compton station, East LA, station Lennox, Sentry station, Lancaster and
- 19:59Palmdale station, as well as within Aero Buero, the department's helicopter division. The gangs
- 20:04are well documented for using excessive force on civilians, harassing other deputies and using
- 20:09violence on inmates inside jails. The deputy gangs have historically proved a threat to the chain of
- 20:14command according to multiple reports. According to the 1992 report, deputies at the then notorious
- 20:19Linwood station, quote, harass and intimidated any sergeant or lieutenant who stood in their way,
- 20:25end quote. The report went on to say deputies would quote command field sergeants to leave the
- 20:30scene of arrest, to slash the tires of supervisors they did not like, to disregard orders not to
- 20:35roam freely outside their patrol areas in the city of LA and to smear, excrement and other noxious
- 20:42substances over the engines of their supervisors cars. The intimidation tactics have continued to
- 20:47this day. In 2018, alleged members of the Bandito's deputy gang brutally attacked
- 20:53non-gang deputies in the East LA station. The beating hospitalized two LASD deputies who are
- 21:00now involved in years long litigation against the department for harassment and discrimination.
- 21:04And Chelsea, just to give you an idea, this comes right from knock LA. There are at least 24 gangs
- 21:10within the LA County Sheriff's Department officials at various government agencies,
- 21:14including the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors, the Los Angeles County District Attorney,
- 21:19the California Senate Subcommittee on Police Officers Conduct and the United States Commission
- 21:24on Civil Rights have heard testimonies on the violence inflicted on communities at the hands of
- 21:29deputy gangs for decades. Deputy gangs have killed at least 40 people, all of whom were men of
- 21:34color. At least 10 of them had mental illnesses. LA County keeps a list of lawsuits related to
- 21:39the deputy gangs. Litigation related to these cases has cost the county at least $100 million
- 21:44over 30 years. How come we don't really hear anything about this for like running rampant?
- 21:51Well, part of it is it's really hard to report on police department's ends Sheriff's departments
- 21:56because they have good protection within and they don't really have any oversight. And one thing
- 22:01that comes with this is they are absolutely ruthless with targeting people who try to kind of
- 22:07bring them out. Anybody who talked to the commission I was talking about the COC,
- 22:12there was one woman I didn't write her name down. She was in the Sheriff's Department. As soon as
- 22:16she started talking to him, she was demoted immediately demoted and put on graveyard gifts.
- 22:21Okay. She also said that people were tailing her 24 seven. Oh my god. Other people who were
- 22:27talked to the commission said that they had warrants for the search of their properties
- 22:34issued multiple times throughout the investigation that they were involved in. I guess they are a gang.
- 22:40Yeah. Okay. Wow. Disturbing. That is absolutely fucked up. Just something you would not expect
- 22:46to hear. Even then, like when you hear that, you don't quite understand what it means because
- 22:50you're like, yeah, the bloods are the crypts. No, their own unique gangs within the department.
- 22:54In addition to the bloods in the crypts operating not in the police department,
- 22:59they didn't have the proper law structure like the police department has with the gang. But
- 23:04that is messed up. I can't believe this. For the last one here, apparently police departments can
- 23:10sometimes have black sites where they torture people. This comes from the Chicago police department.
- 23:14And we're just going to read this story. There's many different stories on it. There's a Wikipedia
- 23:18article I decided to go with the Guardian article on it. It seems like it was fairly well covered in
- 23:22it. We're just going to go through this and this is rough. Okay, shit. The Chicago police department
- 23:28operates an off the books interrogation compound rendering Americans unable to be found by family
- 23:33or attorneys while locked inside what lawyers say is the domestic equivalent of a CIA black site.
- 23:39Oh, God. The facility, a nondescript warehouse in Chicago's west side known as Homan Square,
- 23:45has long been the scene of a secretive work by special units. Alleged police practices at Homan
- 23:50Square, according to those familiar with the facility who spoke out to the Guardian after
- 23:54its investigation into Chicago police abuse include this is what happens here, keeping arrest out of
- 23:59official booking databases, beatings by police resulting in head wounds, shackling for prolonged
- 24:05periods, denying attorneys access to the secure facility, holding people without legal counsel
- 24:10for between 12 and 24 hours, including people as young as 15. At least one man was found unresponsive
- 24:16in Homan Square's interview room and later pronounced a dad. Brian Jacob Church, a protester
- 24:21known as one of the NATO three. And this is actually where it comes from, Chelsea, where we actually
- 24:25learned about Homan Square being a thing. There was a NATO summit in 2012 in Chicago.
- 24:31Chicago police said that they didn't arrest anybody, but there were three people missing.
- 24:35And that's basically where journalists are to dig. And they discovered this. This is where it came
- 24:40out. It had been going on a lot longer than 2012 and only 2012. Officers are showing church for the
- 24:45better part of a day denying him access to an attorney before sending him to a nearby police
- 24:50station to be booked and charged. Homan Square is definitely an unusual place. It brings to mind
- 24:55the interrogation facilities they use in the Middle East. The CIA calls them black sites. It's a
- 25:00domestic black site. When you go in, no one knows what happened to you. And quote church told the
- 25:05Guardian, the secretive warehouse is the latest example of Chicago police practices that echo the
- 25:10much criticized detention abuses of the US war on terror. While those abuses impacted people
- 25:15overseas, Homan Square said to house military style vehicles, interrogation cells, and even a cage.
- 25:21Trains that focus on Americans most often poor black and brown. Unlike a precinct,
- 25:25no one taken to Homan Square is said to be booked. Witnesses, suspects, or other Chicagoans who end
- 25:31up inside do not appear to have a public searchable record entered into a database indicating where
- 25:36they are. As happens when somebody is booked at a precinct, lawyers and relatives insist there's
- 25:42no way of finding their whereabouts. Those lawyers who have attempted to gain access to Homan Square
- 25:46are often turned away, even as their clients remain in custody inside. Quote, it's sort of an open
- 25:52secret among attorneys that regularly make police station visits this place. If you can't find a
- 25:56client in the system, odds are they're here. End quote said Chicago lawyer Julia Bartmas. Chicago
- 26:02civil rights attorney Flint Taylor said Homan Square represented a routinization of a notorious
- 26:06practice in local police work that violates the fifth and sixth amendment of the Constitution.
- 26:11Quote, this Homan Square revelation seems to me to be an institutionalization of the practices that
- 26:17date back more than 40 years of violating a suspect's or witnesses' rights to a lawyer and
- 26:23not to be physically or otherwise clueless into giving a statement. End quote said Taylor.
- 26:28Much remained hidden about Homan Square. The Chicago police department did not respond to
- 26:33the Guardian's questions about the facility, but after the Guardian published the story,
- 26:36the department provided a statement insisting without specifics that there's nothing untoward
- 26:41taking place at what is called the quote sensitive end quote location home to undercover units.
- 26:47This is their statement quote CPD abides by all laws, rules and guidelines pertaining to any
- 26:53interviews of suspects or witnesses at Homan Square or any other CPD facility. If lawyers have a
- 26:59client detained at Homan Square just like any other facility, they're allowed to speak to
- 27:03and visit them. It also has the CPD's evidence recovered property section where the public
- 27:08is able to claim inventory property. End quote the statement said something numerous attorneys
- 27:13and one Homan Square arrestee have denied and a little bit more from it quote there are always
- 27:18records of anyone who was arrested by CPD and this is not any different at Homan Square. End quote
- 27:23it continued. The Chicago police department statement did not address how long into an
- 27:26arrest or detentment those records are generated or their availability to the public. A department
- 27:32spokesperson did not respond to a detailed request for clarification. When a guardian reporter arrived
- 27:37at the warehouse on a Friday, a man at the gatehouse outside refused any entrance and would not
- 27:42give any answers to questions. Well, this is a secure facility. You're not even supposed to be
- 27:46standing there. He said a former Chicago police superintendent and a more recently retired detective
- 27:51both of whom have been inside Homan Square in the last three years and a post police capacity said
- 27:56the police department did not operate out of the warehouse until the 1990s. But in detailing episodes
- 28:01involving their clients over the past several years, lawyers described mad scrambles that led
- 28:05to the closed door of Homan Square, a place most had never heard of previously. The facility was
- 28:11even unknown to Rob Warden, the founder of Northwestern University Law School Center on
- 28:16Wrongful Convictions until the guardian informed him of the allegations of clients who vanished
- 28:21into inherently coercive police custody quote they just disappear until they show up at a
- 28:27district for charging or are just released back onto the street end quote said Anthony Hill,
- 28:32a criminal defense attorney. This just keeps getting worse. Jacob Church learned about Homan
- 28:37Square the hard way on May 16, 2012. He and 11 others were taken there after police infiltrated
- 28:42their protests against the NATO summit. Church says the officers cuffed him to a bench for an
- 28:46estimated 17 hours intermittently interrogating him without reading him his Miranda rights to
- 28:52remain silent. It would take another three hours and an unusual lawyer visit through a wire cage
- 28:58before he was finally charged with terrorism related offenses at the nearby 11th district
- 29:02station where he was made to sign papers fingerprinted and photographed in preparation for the NATO
- 29:07protest church who is from Florida have written a phone number for the National Lawyers Guild on
- 29:12his arm as a precautionary measure once taken to Homan Square church asked explicitly to call
- 29:17his lawyer and said he was denied quote essentially I wasn't allowed to make any contact with anybody
- 29:23and quote church told the Guardian in contradiction of a police guidance on permitting phone calls
- 29:27and legal counsel to arrest ease purchase left wrist was cuffed to a bar behind a bench in
- 29:31a windowless center block cell with his ankles cuffed together he remained in those restraints
- 29:36for over 17 hours quote I had essentially figured all right well they disappeared us and were probably
- 29:42never going to see the light of day and close in church though the raid attracted major media
- 29:47attention a team of attorneys could not find church through 12 hours of active searching
- 29:53Sarah Gelsamino church as lawyer recalled no booking record existed only after she and others
- 29:58made a major stink with contacts in the offices of the corporation council and the and Mayor
- 30:03Rob Emanuel did they even learn about Homan Square they sent another attorney to the facility where
- 30:09he ultimately gained entry and talked to church through a floor to ceiling chain link metal cage
- 30:15finally hours later police took church and his two co-defendants to a nearby police station for
- 30:20booking after serving two and a half years in prison church is currently on parole after he
- 30:24and his co-defendants were found not guilty in 2014 of terrorism related offenses but guilty of
- 30:29lesser charges of possessing an incendiary device and the misdead of quote mob action and quote the
- 30:35access that nato three attorneys received to Homan Square was an exception to the rule even if Jacob
- 30:39church's experience there was not three attorneys interviewed by the guardian report being personally
- 30:45turned away from Homan Square between 2009 and 2013 without being allowed access to their clients
- 30:50two more lawyers who hadn't been physically denied described it as a place where police
- 30:54withheld information about their clients whereabouts church was the only person who had been detained
- 30:59at the facility who agreed to talk with the guardian their lawyers say others fear police
- 31:04retaliation one man in january of 2013 had his name changed in the chicago central booking database
- 31:09and then taken to Homan Square without a record of his transfer being kept according to Eliza
- 31:14Soloway edge so Soloway edge sorry that's a hard name of chicago's first defense legal aid she found
- 31:20out where he was after he was taken to the hospital with a head injury quote he said that the officer
- 31:26caused his head injuries in an interrogation room at Homan Square I had been looking for him for six
- 31:30to eight hours and every department member I talked to said that they'd never heard of him he sent
- 31:35me a phone pick of his head injuries because I had seen him in a police station right before he's
- 31:40transferred to Homan Square without any end quote said Soloway edge Bartmess another Chicago attorney
- 31:45said that in September of 2013 she got a call from a mother worried that her 15 year old son had been
- 31:51picked up by police before dawn a sympathetic sergeant followed up with the mother to say her
- 31:55son was being questioned at Homan Square in connection to a shooting and would be released
- 32:00soon when hours passed Bartmess traveled to Homan Square only to be refused entry for nearly an
- 32:05hour an officer told her quote well you can't just stand here taking notes this is a secure facility
- 32:10there are undercover officers and you're making people very nervous end quote Bartmess recalled
- 32:15he'll believe she said she would return an hour if the boy was not released he was home and not
- 32:20charged after quote 12 maybe 13 hours in custody end quote on February 2nd 2013 John Hubbard was
- 32:27taken to Homan Square Hubbard never walked out the Chicago Tribune reported that the 44 year old
- 32:33was found unresponsive inside an interview room oh my god and pronounced dead after publication
- 32:39Cook County medical examiner told the Guardian that the cause of death was determined to be a heroin
- 32:43intoxication Homan Square is hardly concerned exclusively with terrorism several special units
- 32:50operating outside of it including the anti-gynatic drug forces if police quote want money guns drugs
- 32:56end quote or information on the flow of any of them into Chicago streets quote they bring them
- 33:00there and use it as a place of interrogation off the books end quote Hill said a former Chicago
- 33:05detective and current in private investigator Bill Dorr said he had not heard of the police abuses
- 33:11described by church and lawyers for other suspects who had been taken to Homan Square he had been
- 33:17permitted access to the facility to visit one of its main features and evidence locker for the
- 33:23department transferring detainees through police custody deny them access to legal counsel would
- 33:27be a career and or said dorsch quote to move just for the purpose of hiding them I can't see that
- 33:32happening end quote he told the Guardian you know what that's probably enough for that part we can
- 33:37skip a little bit ahead here because look at the end of the day the Chicago Police Department has
- 33:42acknowledged this in response to the Guardian's article which I was reading to you the Chicago
- 33:48Police Department first denied any wrongdoing but in 2015 as Chicago was experiencing activist
- 33:54pressures resulting from outrage over the Homan Square reporting and the murder of Laquan McDonald
- 34:00separate thing but anyways the city under Mayor Rom Emanuel announced a reparation deal for the
- 34:071970 survivors of torture and detention under former Chicago police commander John Burge the deal
- 34:14included 5.5 million dollar fund for torture survivors free college tuition for survivors in
- 34:20their families a memorial and inclusion of the torture cases in eighth and tenth grade history
- 34:25courses in Chicago school districts a coalition of Chicago activists including project and IA and we
- 34:31charged genocide were major backers of this deal so they did make some changes from what I've read
- 34:37people are not happy with the amount of changes that have taken place and they are not sufficient
- 34:41enough to clearly show the cpd as learned from their lessons and in fact the guy John Burge he
- 34:47did serve some time in jail he kept his pension until he died so it wasn't bad enough that he had
- 34:52money taken away from him this is insane I don't even want to know what to make of this one and
- 34:57whether or not this is the only one or if it's just the one that can't be it seems like it's the one
- 35:02that got found and really it's just the accidentally arrested somebody who had some money and a lawyer
- 35:07as opposed to the poor black and brown people as they talked about yeah at the end of the day we're
- 35:12never gonna know how many people were coerced into confessing to something they didn't do because
- 35:16they were beaten so harshly at home in square or how many people died there we're just never gonna
- 35:21know because it's a black site that has no records maintained for everybody listening we're adding this
- 35:26in post-humously I guess I think the episode's dead once we've kind of recorded it right like
- 35:32that's how it works yeah I don't actually know yeah yeah I don't know it's an article I forgot to
- 35:37add in here this in fact has been condemned by the UN this surprise the hell out of me it's on the
- 35:44UN's website it's United Nations Human Rights Office of the High Commissioner posted on June 3rd
- 35:502024 United States UN experts urge action to address lives stolen by systemic racist police
- 35:56violence in Chicago UN experts today called for further action to remedy racialized police violence
- 36:02and misconduct within Chicago's law enforcement and criminal justice system against people of
- 36:07african and latino descent in the united states quote chicago has a long history of law enforcement
- 36:11officials reportedly using torture to extract confessions to serious crimes these heinous alleged
- 36:18human rights violations appear to a significant extent to be rooted in systemic racism and have
- 36:23disproportionately affected people of the african and latin american descent says the UN expert the
- 36:30expert stressed the devastating impact of these practices on individuals and communities quote
- 36:34many people of african and latin american descent some of whom were children at the time were reportedly
- 36:39arrested without reasonable cause and tortured to sign confessions to very serious crimes including
- 36:45homicide these confessions as well as broader systemic racism and police misconduct in Chicago's
- 36:50criminal justice system have reportedly resulted in many wrongful convictions and wrongful
- 36:54incarcerations of individuals often for extremely long periods of time without adequate access to
- 36:59health care including for older persons and survivors of torture lives have been stolen
- 37:05with a significant ripple effect within the community and quote they said chicago was taken
- 37:09steps to address the reported human rights violations including a public apology in the
- 37:13establishment of the torture inquiry and relief commission to acknowledge and remedy and prevent
- 37:17police torture and misconduct while welcoming these important initiatives the experts expressed
- 37:22concern the efforts to address abuse have been key snail and far too slow in implementation
- 37:28they expressed their concern that individuals affected remain incarcerated or unable to rebuild
- 37:32their lives due to systemic barriers to prevent their access to procedures to be established with
- 37:37innocence and access full redress and remedies the experts also expressed concerns that reports
- 37:43indicate that such alleged human rights violations have taken place largely with impunity quote the
- 37:49individuals implicated in these human rights violations have not been held accountable
- 37:53of just society must address these past wrongs and put in place all measures to prevent recurrence
- 37:59and quote the experts said the experts urge relevant federal state and local officials to
- 38:03take immediate and comprehensive action to fully address and remedy the situation in Chicago new
- 38:09and experts have been in contact with the government of the United States to address these allegations
- 38:13and clarify its obligations under an international law at the end of the article i found it's so
- 38:18crazy that usually when you see condemnation from the united nations it's not against a first world
- 38:25country excluding the whole debacle of israel we're just going to leave them out of this with that i
- 38:30don't know that i get my news from the united nations website but not only are these people
- 38:36well this seems like it's not a related thought but it is not only are these people being not held
- 38:42accountable but i mean this isn't just news that it's widely known it is on the united nations
- 38:49website but i didn't know about it it was the news i've never even heard of it until this journey
- 38:57to the fringe episode this could have been a fringy mini this week like later it happened in
- 39:03june this article on the u.n website yeah i would have taken it from a few years ago too yeah i'm
- 39:09no standards it's but i just wanted to add that because it's so mind-boggling like you don't think
- 39:15about the u.n condemning things in north america and yet here they are like this is terrible and
- 39:21needs to be addressed i do i also wonder what else are they condemning but i don't know because i'll
- 39:28never visit their website i don't even know what would bring me there in the first place to be on
- 39:33me sending you a website that's interesting yes anyhow back to the original episode i'm speechless
- 39:40all of this and you're right it did just progressively get worse not that the first one
- 39:45was good it didn't go good to worst it just went worse to worst but yeah these are systemic issues
- 39:52within law enforcement departments that show that there is something rotten with the entire situation
- 39:58that we have i think it's not just one-off individuals that have problems it is systemic yeah any one
- 40:04of these you can point to and say that there are major issues i know people are gonna point at the
- 40:08particular cities they take place in i'm going to tell you right now it's not just these ones you
- 40:12will find them anywhere and hell like i remember with the new york pd they threatened the previous
- 40:17mayor but with a doxing on his daughter just openly that's how it worked there's issues all over i
- 40:24mean these are just three things i'm sure there's a whole lot that we could be pulling up i was not
- 40:29expecting there to be gangs operating within i don't know what the technical term for it is the
- 40:36police generally well yeah and you got to assume that's not the only place where something like
- 40:41that's taking place even if it's not particularly named gangs that process that they talk about of
- 40:46covering up for each other and having this rate of passage which is violently attacking people
- 40:52no the whole thing has been a crazy ride as always i appreciate you enlightening me to this
- 40:57even if you don't want it it's just how kind of it works and i never want it yeah i have been
- 41:02taylor here with chelsea we are journey to the fringe thank you all for listening and we'll see
- 41:06you next week okay thank you for listening to journey to the fringe if you have liked what you
- 41:14have listened to please like share subscribe or follow depending on what venue you are listening to
- 41:21us through also please if possible leave a five star review as that really helps us in the algorithms
- 41:28should you wish to interact with us please check us out on your social media of choice i bet you
- 41:34we are there and if you really want to communicate with us and give us ideas for new episodes or
- 41:39tell us that we're wrong and terrible either way please send us an email at journey to the fringe
- 41:45at gmail.com for now i'll see you in the next episode