Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / Managing the Employee Who Always Says I Already Know That
Transcript
- Lucas: So you're in a one-on-one with a team member. You're walking through a new process, a tool update, or even just a best practice you want to share. And before you finish your second sentence, you hear it: 'Yeah, I already know that.' Luna: Oof. That one lands differently every time, doesn't it? Sometimes it feels like a dismissal, sometimes it's just… deflating. Lucas: Exactly. And if it happens a lot, it can really chip away at your willingness to give that person information or feedback. You start second-guessing yourself—do I really need to tell them this? But the deeper problem is, the phrase 'I already know that' often closes a door. It shuts down learning, collaboration, and sometimes even trust. Luna: And as a manager, you have to decide: is this a genuine confidence issue, a defense mechanism, or just a bad habit? The approach changes depending on which one it is. Lucas: Right. And let's be honest—none of us loves being told something we already know. But the frequency and the tone matter. I want to talk about one specific case that I think illustrates the problem really well. A senior developer at a mid-sized SaaS company I worked with—let's call him Mark—had this reflex down to an art form. Luna: What was the impact on the team? Lucas: It was subtle but corrosive. In stand-ups, when someone suggested an approach, Mark would say, 'Yeah, I already thought of that.' In code reviews, when a peer pointed out a potential edge case, Mark would say, 'I know, I was going to handle it later.' The team started to feel like they couldn't contribute anything new to him. And worse, Mark stopped being a collaborator—he became someone who just needed to be seen as the smartest person in the room. Luna: And that's a problem because the team stopped bringing ideas to him. They'd rather work around him than through him. Lucas: Exactly. And Mark was actually very talented. But his reflex was costing him influence and trust. So we had to figure out a way to address it without making him feel attacked. The first thing I did was to depersonalize the conversation. Luna: Meaning you didn't lead with 'You always say I already know that'? Lucas: Right. I framed it around team dynamics. In a one-on-one, I said something like, 'I've noticed that when we discuss new approaches in stand-ups, people sometimes hesitate to share ideas with you. I'm wondering if there's a pattern where you unintentionally shut down suggestions.' That's very different from 'You're a know-it-all.' Luna: That shifts the focus from his behavior to the team's experience. It's less accusatory. Lucas: Exactly. And Mark actually paused and said, 'I don't mean to do that. I'm just trying to show that I'm on top of things.' That was the opening we needed. From there, we could talk about how his need to signal competence was actually undermining it. Luna: If today's episode is giving you a new lens on a familiar situation, that's exactly the kind of practical takeaway we try to deliver every week. And the way we keep these conversations ad-free and focused is through listener support. If you found this useful, you can help by buying us a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Truly, every contribution lets us keep tackling these nuanced management challenges without any commercial breaks. Lucas: Yeah, and we really mean that—your support directly keeps this show running. So thanks for being part of it. Now, back to Mark. Once he acknowledged he was doing it, the next step was to give him a new script. Instead of 'I already know that,' I suggested he try saying, 'That's interesting—tell me more about your thinking.' Luna: That's a great reframe. It turns a dead end into an open door. Lucas: And it's honest. He doesn't have to pretend he doesn't know something. He just invites the other person to share their perspective. That alone changed the dynamic on his team. People started coming to him again. But there's a deeper layer here: the 'I already know that' reflex is often rooted in a fear of being seen as inexperienced or behind. Luna: Especially for senior folks. There's this unspoken pressure to always be ahead of the curve. Lucas: Right. So as a manager, you also need to create psychological safety for not knowing. If you, as the manager, occasionally say 'I don't know' or 'I learned something new today,' you model that it's okay to be a learner. That can gradually reduce the need for that defensive reflex. Luna: I've seen that work. I had a manager who would start meetings by saying, 'Here's something I didn't know last week.' It made it normal to admit gaps. Lucas: Exactly. So there are three concrete steps here. One: depersonalize the feedback by focusing on team impact. Two: give the person a new, constructive phrase to use instead. Three: model vulnerability yourself. Do that consistently, and the 'I already know that' reflex starts to fade. Luna: And what about when the person genuinely does know it? I mean, sometimes they really do already know. How do you handle that without creating friction? Lucas: Great question. If you're regularly telling someone things they already know, that's a feedback loop you need to examine. Maybe they need more challenging work. Or you need to trust their expertise more. But even then, a simple 'Got it, thanks for flagging' is a more collaborative response than 'I already know that.' So we can coach toward that, too. Luna: So it's not about assuming bad intent. It's about recognizing that the phrase itself—regardless of intent—has a negative effect on the relationship. Lucas: Exactly. And once you frame it that way, most people are willing to adjust. Mark did. Within a few weeks, his peers were giving him positive feedback. He felt more included, and the team felt more collaborative. It's a small change that can have a surprisingly big impact. Luna: Alright, so next time you hear 'I already know that,' pause. Depersonalize, offer a new script, and model not knowing. That's the three-step playbook. Lucas: And if you've got your own version of this challenge, we'd love to hear about it. You can reach us at the show's page. But for now, that's our time. Thanks for listening.