Latest / Serial Killer Documentary Show / Serial Killer Documentary - The Case Against Bryan Kohberger
Transcript
- 0:04Speaker 1: The forward stab of a knife, but no weapon has
- 0:07Speaker 1: been located.
- 0:08Speaker 2: The true crime story that sent shock waves across the country.
- 0:12Speaker 3: All of us are shaking for murders, and then the
- 0:15Speaker 3: guys just running around on Lewis is all unnerving the victims.
- 0:21Speaker 2: For college students.
- 0:23Speaker 1: Ethan, Xana Madison and Kaylee, I mis a smile.
- 0:28Speaker 4: She was so giving, positive and fun and lover and
- 0:31Speaker 4: miss her so much.
- 0:32Speaker 2: Now a PhD criminology student accused of the murders.
- 0:39Speaker 1: Detectives arrested twenty eight year old Brian Christopher Colberger.
- 0:45Speaker 2: Hello, I know it, so I y'all know.
- 0:47Speaker 5: Today every inquiring mind wants to know why? Why would
- 0:51Speaker 5: Brian Coberger do this?
- 0:52Speaker 6: The master some healthy is a and or imprisonment for life?
- 0:56Speaker 7: Do you understand?
- 0:57Speaker 8: Yes?
- 0:58Speaker 9: Plus the evidence on that night Sheath was DNA likely
- 1:03Speaker 9: left there by the killer.
- 1:05Speaker 10: Including those twelve times when he's hanging around this house,
- 1:09Speaker 10: you better have a pretty good reason for this.
- 1:11Speaker 11: Guess what the defendant, the suspect, the accuse, what does
- 1:16Speaker 11: he drive a white alunchroom.
- 1:19Speaker 5: The way that we have been convicting Coburger is absolutely
- 1:23Speaker 5: appalling and disgusting.
- 1:25Speaker 12: I want all the evidence out, I want it to
- 1:27Speaker 12: be clear.
- 1:28Speaker 2: If I'm the parent of one of these four kids,
- 1:30Speaker 2: he is the boogeyman.
- 1:53Speaker 12: I try not to think too much about any of
- 1:55Speaker 12: the darker.
- 1:56Speaker 13: Side of the aspects. I just try to stay positive.
- 1:58Speaker 12: There'll be days where I have to focus on the negativity,
- 2:01Speaker 12: but today's not one of them. I missed her smile,
- 2:09Speaker 12: and then she was so giving when she came home.
- 2:13Speaker 13: She was always giving me.
- 2:14Speaker 12: A hug, always making sure she got a hug before
- 2:17Speaker 12: she left the house, just the simple things. These girls
- 2:22Speaker 12: were born fourteen days apart. We loved them both so much.
- 2:26Speaker 12: It was a great, great story, and I'm sad that
- 2:29Speaker 12: it ended and we lost them both at the same time.
- 2:35Speaker 12: I'll never see this car as mine.
- 2:39Speaker 13: She paid for it. She felt like this was a
- 2:41Speaker 13: super cute car.
- 2:43Speaker 9: It was emotional writing with Steve in Kaylee's car on
- 2:47Speaker 9: her birthday. We saw that vehicle at that home each day.
- 2:51Speaker 9: Inside the crime scene tape, Kaylee and her friends Madison Mugan,
- 2:56Speaker 9: Santa Cernodle, and Ethan Chapin were stabbed to debt at
- 3:00Speaker 9: the University of Idaho, and that car was part of
- 3:04Speaker 9: the reason Kaylee was in town that weekend of the murders.
- 3:10Speaker 12: When she bought her car, she was she wasn't her birthday,
- 3:13Speaker 12: but it was a gift that she gave herself because
- 3:16Speaker 12: she just got a new job. So I remember her
- 3:19Speaker 12: being super excited for that, and you know, showing Maddie
- 3:23Speaker 12: and driving down there and showing her friends off with it.
- 3:27Speaker 9: Those friends, Kayleie, Maddie, Xenna, Dylan Mortensen, and Bethany Funk
- 3:32Speaker 9: all lived together in the house on King Road, along
- 3:36Speaker 9: with Kaylee's dog, Murphy Murphy bed. There's a video of
- 3:42Speaker 9: all five of the girls together in the home, posted
- 3:45Speaker 9: just two weeks.
- 3:46Speaker 13: Before the murders.
- 3:47Speaker 9: They're laughing, making fun of each other, imitating each other.
- 3:51Speaker 13: Didn't even do their tours today comes skin do it?
- 3:54Speaker 9: You didn't get get out of here, You sure get.
- 3:56Speaker 14: Out of the.
- 3:58Speaker 12: If you look back at their moment, you can actually
- 4:01Speaker 12: see their whole lives. These girls really did do the
- 4:04Speaker 12: social media stuff.
- 4:06Speaker 2: Get down, get down, and these girls.
- 4:09Speaker 12: You know, they were everywhere, so people got a taste
- 4:12Speaker 12: and a look and a feel of who they really were.
- 4:14Speaker 13: I think people connected with that.
- 4:16Speaker 12: And then if you go back, you can see, like
- 4:18Speaker 12: I hate to say it, but like the last hours
- 4:20Speaker 12: of their lives.
- 4:22Speaker 9: Those last hours included two photos posted by Kaylee. On
- 4:26Speaker 9: one of them, she wrote, one lucky girl to be
- 4:28Speaker 9: surrounded by these people. According to investigators, that last night,
- 4:33Speaker 9: Ethan and Xanna go to a party at the Sigma
- 4:36Speaker 9: Kai House.
- 4:37Speaker 13: They're there till about one am.
- 4:39Speaker 9: That morning, Maddie and Kaylee go downtown downtown Moscow to
- 4:45Speaker 9: a bar called the Corner.
- 4:46Speaker 13: Club, and then about one thirty am they.
- 4:49Speaker 9: Walked to a food truck to grab a bike teat
- 4:52Speaker 9: and then what was it?
- 4:53Speaker 7: The show?
- 4:55Speaker 15: We and then click see rewards you go and quite.
- 5:02Speaker 2: Have enough one too?
- 5:03Speaker 13: Oh that's good, that's good ten dollars.
- 5:06Speaker 9: So about ten minutes later, the video shows Maddie reaching
- 5:11Speaker 9: to grab the food they ordered. Kaylee has her cell
- 5:14Speaker 9: phone up as if she's filming the moment. They're laughing
- 5:16Speaker 9: with each other until you see them run out of
- 5:20Speaker 9: the frame. By two am, all five girls and Ethan
- 5:24Speaker 9: Chapin were back at the house on King Rode. In
- 5:27Speaker 9: just over two hours, four of the six would be dead.
- 5:38Speaker 1: Everybody here, my name is Chief James Fry with the
- 5:42Speaker 1: Moscow Police Department. I want to be reading from my
- 5:44Speaker 1: notes today because I want the information you received to
- 5:47Speaker 1: be extremely accurate the forward stab with a knife, but
- 5:51Speaker 1: no weapon has been located at this time. There was
- 5:54Speaker 1: no sign a forced entry into the residence. Based on
- 5:57Speaker 1: details of the scene, we believe this was an isolated,
- 6:01Speaker 1: targeted attack on our victims.
- 6:04Speaker 2: Right away, I think everyone knew there was going to
- 6:05Speaker 2: be a big story.
- 6:06Speaker 15: I mean, you've got four college students taken down at
- 6:10Speaker 15: once inside the same home, and the chief comes out
- 6:13Speaker 15: pretty quickly and says, listen, no forced entry here. This
- 6:18Speaker 15: was a targeted, isolated attack.
- 6:22Speaker 16: So most of us thought should be solved pretty quickly.
- 6:25Speaker 2: But that's not what happened here.
- 6:28Speaker 9: We did make sure we clarify, we have them restart
- 6:30Speaker 9: or restart this feed or. We arrived in Moscow just
- 6:33Speaker 9: days after the murders, and you could immediately since that
- 6:36Speaker 9: this was a community on edge, and you could understand
- 6:39Speaker 9: why four young people have been brutally murdered and nobody
- 6:43Speaker 9: knows why, and.
- 6:44Speaker 13: Nobody knows who's responsible.
- 6:46Speaker 9: I actually met a group of professors from the University
- 6:49Speaker 9: of Idaho. They were out for a bike ride and
- 6:51Speaker 9: they really summed up what the community was going through.
- 6:55Speaker 10: It has deeply affected all our students and our faculty
- 6:58Speaker 10: and our staff been just a struggle to get through
- 7:02Speaker 10: this last week.
- 7:03Speaker 9: So how hungry is this university, this town for answers?
- 7:09Speaker 2: Very much?
- 7:09Speaker 10: So the fact that there isn't an answer makes this
- 7:14Speaker 10: even worse.
- 7:15Speaker 2: You know, all of us are shaken.
- 7:17Speaker 3: I've heard from people all across the country talking about
- 7:20Speaker 3: this tragedy.
- 7:21Speaker 2: There's a small college town. We all know each other.
- 7:24Speaker 8: People in the community knew these students, So everybody's affected
- 7:28Speaker 8: one way or another.
- 7:29Speaker 2: And part of it is because we just don't know
- 7:31Speaker 2: anything yet.
- 7:33Speaker 9: We also met the prosecuting attorney, Bill Thompson, leaving details.
- 7:38Speaker 2: Nothing I can share.
- 7:39Speaker 13: How is the crime scene?
- 7:42Speaker 2: I can't talk about it. Everybody's working together. The investigation
- 7:46Speaker 2: is still active.
- 7:47Speaker 13: Absolutely how long they're going to stay here.
- 7:49Speaker 2: At the home as long as they need to.
- 7:52Speaker 9: I ended up sitting down with Bill Thompson in his office,
- 7:55Speaker 9: and remember they had not identified a suspect, and a
- 7:57Speaker 9: lot of people were wondering are they going.
- 8:00Speaker 13: To solve this?
- 8:01Speaker 9: And it was one of his answers to me that
- 8:04Speaker 9: made me think they know a lot more than what
- 8:06Speaker 9: they're saying. Would you feel safe having a child living
- 8:09Speaker 9: near or on campus?
- 8:12Speaker 17: I would, but I say that knowing that many people
- 8:17Speaker 17: would not, and I'm probably in a not probably, I'm
- 8:23Speaker 17: in a different situation because of the information and the
- 8:27Speaker 17: knowledge that I have of how the investigation is progressing.
- 8:31Speaker 2: Coming off. For weeks go by without.
- 8:33Speaker 3: An arrest, just your mind has to spend like, Okay,
- 8:37Speaker 3: what is going on?
- 8:38Speaker 1: You know?
- 8:39Speaker 18: Some people can commit grinds and there is no justice.
- 8:42Speaker 2: For that family with the families and public didn't know
- 8:45Speaker 2: about the investigation.
- 8:46Speaker 9: Partly under her body, partly under her comforter on her bed,
- 8:50Speaker 9: likely left there by the killer.
- 9:01Speaker 19: Moscow is a very typical university town. It has a
- 9:08Speaker 19: vibrant downtown with places to eat, places to drink, places
- 9:12Speaker 19: to gather.
- 9:13Speaker 14: There's not really much surrounding Moscow, rolling hills of just
- 9:17Speaker 14: wheat fields and various other farms.
- 9:20Speaker 13: Small town feel.
- 9:22Speaker 14: I think that's roughly twenty five thousand people, give or
- 9:25Speaker 14: take a couple thousand.
- 9:26Speaker 3: I think of North Idaho has a pretty oft themat
- 9:29Speaker 3: type of place, pretty safe place, very family friendly, and
- 9:32Speaker 3: to have four murders and then the guys just running
- 9:35Speaker 3: around on looses a little line nerving.
- 9:38Speaker 9: Weeks after the murders of Xana Cernodle, Ethan Chapin, Mattymgan.
- 9:43Speaker 13: And Kaylae Gonsalvez.
- 9:45Speaker 9: No arrest had been made, to the point that a
- 9:48Speaker 9: lot of the students there on campus had cleared out
- 9:50Speaker 9: because there was this fear among the community, and even
- 9:53Speaker 9: some of the victim's family members had fears that the
- 9:57Speaker 9: investigation was stalled.
- 10:00Speaker 18: I had a private investigators and different different things, and
- 10:04Speaker 18: that's why they told me to slow down. Stevie. You
- 10:06Speaker 18: know this thing. You know me as a father, it's
- 10:11Speaker 18: never fast enough, and I want to just charge a
- 10:13Speaker 18: head like probably just like a dumb ass.
- 10:17Speaker 2: But that's what I knew.
- 10:19Speaker 9: What the families and the public didn't know was that
- 10:22Speaker 9: the detectives had some significant evidence and leads, including DNA and.
- 10:29Speaker 13: A potential eyewitness.
- 10:32Speaker 9: At the time of the murders, according to investigators, Kaylee
- 10:35Speaker 9: and Maddie were on the third floor of the house
- 10:38Speaker 9: in Maddie's room. Kaylee's dog Murphy was across the hall
- 10:41Speaker 9: in Kaylee's room, Ethan and.
- 10:43Speaker 13: Xanna were a floor below.
- 10:45Speaker 9: Across from them was Dylan Mortenson, and on the first
- 10:49Speaker 9: floor was the Bethany Funk, who was.
- 10:50Speaker 13: In her room.
- 10:52Speaker 15: Dylan will be a key witness in all this because
- 10:54Speaker 15: she's on the same floor as two of the murders.
- 10:58Speaker 15: And she opens her door different times. Now, first couple
- 11:02Speaker 15: of times she really didn't see anything, but she was
- 11:04Speaker 15: hearing voices. Maybe he was the dog, maybe somebody was
- 11:09Speaker 15: crying or something.
- 11:10Speaker 2: She wasn't quite clear what she heard.
- 11:12Speaker 8: But the third time she opens the door, she sees
- 11:16Speaker 8: this tall figure dressed in all dark colors, and she
- 11:22Speaker 8: noticed his bushy eyebrows.
- 11:24Speaker 2: And then this man walks right past her.
- 11:28Speaker 10: Imagine what it would be like to be a young
- 11:31Speaker 10: woman who opens the door and sees this man all
- 11:34Speaker 10: in black and all you really see are his eyebrows,
- 11:36Speaker 10: and he's tall, and he's big, and he just killed
- 11:39Speaker 10: four people with a knife. He walks right past you
- 11:44Speaker 10: and out the door. How close to death were you?
- 11:49Speaker 10: It gives me shivers to just think about what that is.
- 11:53Speaker 10: And that must just roll through her head every single day.
- 11:57Speaker 2: Yeah, that's gonna stick with a cherry.
- 12:00Speaker 9: According to investigators, Dylan described herself as being in quote
- 12:05Speaker 9: frozen shock when she saw a man inside her home
- 12:08Speaker 9: in the middle of the night. She was so scared
- 12:10Speaker 9: she walked herself in her bedroom. But the thing that
- 12:13Speaker 9: raised eyebrows is that nobody did anything about it if
- 12:16Speaker 9: that nine one one was not called until noon the
- 12:19Speaker 9: next day, about eight hours after the estimated time of
- 12:23Speaker 9: the murders.
- 12:24Speaker 20: Some people, when they're very frightened, they just shut down
- 12:28Speaker 20: and they tend to isolate and hide, and basically it's
- 12:32Speaker 20: a safety seeking safety response. If she had been drinking
- 12:37Speaker 20: or under the influence of something, she might have just
- 12:39Speaker 20: shut down because she really didn't know what to do.
- 12:42Speaker 9: The major piece of evidence that the public didn't know
- 12:45Speaker 9: about was a ninth sheep left behind, likely by the killer.
- 12:49Speaker 9: It was found partly under Madison Mogan's body, and the
- 12:52Speaker 9: comforter on her bed on the snap of that knife
- 12:56Speaker 9: sheet was DNA.
- 13:00Speaker 15: Investigators had DNA from the crime scene, and they took
- 13:03Speaker 15: the DNA and they ran it through the National Crime
- 13:06Speaker 15: Database and there were no hits, no matches, but the
- 13:09Speaker 15: DNA was still useful because you could eliminate potential suspects,
- 13:14Speaker 15: and there were a lot of them, not only ones
- 13:16Speaker 15: that law enforcement was looking at, but a whole bunch
- 13:19Speaker 15: that people online, all those true crime sluics that are
- 13:23Speaker 15: out there were looking at as well.
- 13:25Speaker 13: I'd made a video a few weeks ago.
- 13:27Speaker 9: Jeremy Reagan was included in that video, and a lot
- 13:29Speaker 9: of people since then have said that he seemed very
- 13:32Speaker 9: suspicious or he was the murderer.
- 13:36Speaker 14: My name is Jeremy Reagan, and I lived just a
- 13:38Speaker 14: couple of doors down from where the murders happened.
- 13:40Speaker 9: I first met Jeremy Reagan about a week after the murderers.
- 13:43Speaker 13: He was a neighbor of the girls on King Road.
- 13:46Speaker 9: Once people saw Jeremy on camera, many started to speculate
- 13:50Speaker 9: that he possibly was the killer. What was it like
- 13:54Speaker 9: to be accused of something.
- 13:56Speaker 13: So horrible offensive?
- 14:00Speaker 14: They watched my interview and they said, hey, he's kind
- 14:03Speaker 14: of weird.
- 14:04Speaker 2: It must be him.
- 14:05Speaker 14: And so then they dug into everything I ever did
- 14:08Speaker 14: on social media, stuff that my parents had posted about me,
- 14:11Speaker 14: taking everything super far out of context. For some people,
- 14:14Speaker 14: it was definitely worse than others. I know, the various
- 14:17Speaker 14: Jackson Jakes they got hammered.
- 14:21Speaker 2: Jack Decor and Jake Schreiger.
- 14:23Speaker 15: These two guys are the boyfriends of Caylee and Maddie.
- 14:27Speaker 15: As a matter of fact, Jack shared a dog, Murph,
- 14:31Speaker 15: with Kaylee.
- 14:31Speaker 2: So a lot of people are looking at them.
- 14:34Speaker 15: And investigators looked at him as well, but cleared them
- 14:37Speaker 15: so well.
- 14:37Speaker 11: In firstan says these guys are innocent, but the folks
- 14:41Speaker 11: online weren't convinced.
- 14:44Speaker 9: There was also Jack Showalter, who was at the food
- 14:47Speaker 9: truck when Maddie and Kaylee were there.
- 14:50Speaker 13: He became known as hoodie Guy.
- 14:53Speaker 9: So people were analyzing the food truck video and they
- 14:56Speaker 9: thought he looked quite suspicious.
- 15:00Speaker 1: There's been a lot of speculation in rumors where the
- 15:02Speaker 1: official source of information individuals who are being harassed in
- 15:05Speaker 1: this situation, how people need to be careful.
- 15:08Speaker 9: Another early focus of the investigation was video. Detectives gathered
- 15:13Speaker 9: recordings from homes, businesses all around the time of the
- 15:17Speaker 9: murders in that area, and one thing stood out. One
- 15:21Speaker 9: vehicle stood out. That was a white Hondai a Landra.
- 15:26Speaker 1: We're looking for that car because we believe through our
- 15:29Speaker 1: investigation that that car was in any area during the
- 15:32Speaker 1: time of the murders.
- 15:34Speaker 9: According to investigators, beginning at three point twenty nine am,
- 15:38Speaker 9: the white Lantra made three separate passes by the house
- 15:41Speaker 9: on King Road. Then at four oh four they say
- 15:45Speaker 9: it was back for a fourth time, stopping in front
- 15:48Speaker 9: of the house before traveling on to do a three
- 15:51Speaker 9: point term. It then drove past the house again and
- 15:56Speaker 9: out of the camera's view. At four twenty it was
- 15:59Speaker 9: back in view and leaving the area at a high
- 16:02Speaker 9: rate of speed.
- 16:03Speaker 15: So everyone's looking for this car this way to Launcher
- 16:06Speaker 15: And there's an officer, a campus police officer from Washington
- 16:10Speaker 15: State University across the state border, who decides to run
- 16:15Speaker 15: a list of all the white to lantras.
- 16:18Speaker 2: On campus, and he finds one.
- 16:20Speaker 15: It's registered to a guy named Brian Kohlberger.
- 16:24Speaker 9: They end up finding his car in the parking lot
- 16:27Speaker 9: of Coberger's campus apartment. When they run his name, they
- 16:31Speaker 9: find that he had been pulled over twice in the
- 16:34Speaker 9: months before the murders, once in.
- 16:35Speaker 13: Moscow and once in Pullman.
- 16:38Speaker 9: Well, I am officer, lingus stops being audio and video recorded.
- 16:42Speaker 13: I was just slightly into the crosswalk. So yeah, we're
- 16:46Speaker 13: on from Pennsylvania.
- 16:48Speaker 2: We actually don't have LA crosswalks, so you can have
- 16:51Speaker 2: hear pecure kids slightly. Yeah, there's a little bit more
- 16:54Speaker 2: leeway as well. Like there are a few repris.
- 16:56Speaker 10: There's one white, there's another one with a certain Yeah,
- 17:01Speaker 10: march what you can actually kind a quick vehicle a
- 17:04Speaker 10: place or vehicle.
- 17:05Speaker 9: During the traffic stop in Moscow, Coburger gave the officer
- 17:09Speaker 9: his cell phone number.
- 17:11Speaker 10: Now, when you get a phone number, it changes everything
- 17:14Speaker 10: because you get access to it.
- 17:16Speaker 2: In a different way.
- 17:17Speaker 10: That's one more piece of evidence, one more piece of
- 17:20Speaker 10: the puzzle. Is it enough to see what the puzzle says?
- 17:23Speaker 10: Not necessarily, but you get closer.
- 17:26Speaker 9: According to investigators, Coburger's phone records showed that between two
- 17:30Speaker 9: twenty seven am and four to eight am the morning
- 17:33Speaker 9: of the murders, Coburger's phone was turned off or in
- 17:36Speaker 9: airplane mode or possibly out of battery, but it wasn't
- 17:39Speaker 9: connecting to any cell phone tower.
- 17:42Speaker 21: Sometimes it's not about evidence, it's about the lack of
- 17:45Speaker 21: evidence that actually matters. In this particular case, we had
- 17:49Speaker 21: a cell phone that was turned off for a very
- 17:52Speaker 21: specific window of time, during a window of time where
- 17:55Speaker 21: four people were murdered, and he is the singular suspect.
- 18:00Speaker 2: That means something.
- 18:02Speaker 9: Investigators say that when they looked back at Coburger's cell
- 18:06Speaker 9: phone records in the five months leading up to the murders,
- 18:09Speaker 9: that his phone was in the area of the girl's
- 18:12Speaker 9: home on twelve separate occasions.
- 18:15Speaker 10: This was not just something where he happened to be
- 18:18Speaker 10: in the region one time, and it's easily explainable. The
- 18:22Speaker 10: problem is is now you really have to be able
- 18:24Speaker 10: to explain that other dozen times the month before.
- 18:27Speaker 2: You better have a pretty good reason for this coming
- 18:31Speaker 2: up the arresting.
- 18:34Speaker 10: How are you doing?
- 18:36Speaker 2: How strong is the evidence against Brian Coburger.
- 18:39Speaker 18: Erie Daffidy that you just fight out that he was
- 18:42Speaker 18: talking to them, he was hunting them, He was just
- 18:45Speaker 18: a person looking for an opportunity.
- 18:49Speaker 10: Imagine what happens when you're finally able to get the
- 18:52Speaker 10: results of the DNA sample.
- 18:54Speaker 11: We've got this guy, We've got this god.
- 18:58Speaker 5: We don't know when and how this DNA got there.
- 19:02Speaker 6: I'm not at all worried about the DNA.
- 19:13Speaker 1: Last night, in injection with the Pennsylvania State Police, the
- 19:18Speaker 1: Federal Baro of Investigation detectives arrested twenty eight year old
- 19:22Speaker 1: Brian Christopher Coburger in Albrightsville, Pennsylvania on a warrant for
- 19:29Speaker 1: murders of ethan Zana Madison and Kayley.
- 19:37Speaker 2: Mister.
- 19:37Speaker 17: Coberger was taken into custody without incident.
- 19:41Speaker 15: The scene was turned over to the FBI Evidence Response
- 19:44Speaker 15: Team for processing.
- 19:45Speaker 22: According to a Monroe County, Pennsylvania Prosecutor. When SWAT arrived
- 19:49Speaker 22: at the family home of Brian Coburger, they found him
- 19:52Speaker 22: standing in his parents' kitchen at one thirty in the morning.
- 19:56Speaker 7: Coburger was found awake in the kitchen area, dressed in
- 20:01Speaker 7: shorts and a shirt and wearing latex medical type gloves
- 20:06Speaker 7: and apparently was taking his personal trash and putting it
- 20:09Speaker 7: into separate ziploc baggies.
- 20:11Speaker 9: The DNA found on the ninth sheath under Madison Morgan's
- 20:15Speaker 9: body was the piece of the puzzle investigators needed. Three
- 20:19Speaker 9: days before Coburger's arrest, detectives used trash from Coberger's parents'
- 20:25Speaker 9: home or a DNA sample that turned out to be
- 20:28Speaker 9: a match to the suspected killer's father.
- 20:33Speaker 10: Imagine what happens when you're finally able to get the
- 20:36Speaker 10: results of the DNA sample that you pull from the father.
- 20:40Speaker 10: You can just hear the champagne popping. Now, this is
- 20:44Speaker 10: a quad murder that has to be elation in that
- 20:48Speaker 10: squad room, in that war room, when they're sitting together
- 20:52Speaker 10: and they're looking at each.
- 20:53Speaker 2: Other and going, we got this guy, We've got this guy.
- 20:58Speaker 9: After Brian Coberger was taken into custody in Pennsylvania, he
- 21:03Speaker 9: met with an attorney who said publicly that Coburger told
- 21:06Speaker 9: him he believed that he would be exonerated.
- 21:09Speaker 13: He is very intelligent.
- 21:11Speaker 12: In my hour conversation with him, that comes off, I
- 21:14Speaker 12: can tell that, and he understands where we are right now?
- 21:19Speaker 22: What are you doing. Even though Brian Coberger wasn't fighting extradition,
- 21:24Speaker 22: he still had to appear in a Pennsylvania courtroom. I
- 21:28Speaker 22: was inside of that courtroom when he walked in and
- 21:31Speaker 22: everyone was able to see him for the first time.
- 21:35Speaker 22: His mother broke down into tears. The Coburger family, they
- 21:39Speaker 22: were sitting on the front row of that courtroom.
- 21:43Speaker 13: Team made sure to make.
- 21:44Speaker 22: That eye contact with them and he kept looking at them.
- 21:52Speaker 15: Big breaking news, folks, just moments ago. Here it is
- 21:55Speaker 15: the arrival of the accused chiller in Idaho.
- 22:00Speaker 9: It was quite a seed when Coburger arrived back in Idaho.
- 22:05Speaker 9: He was taken off the plane in Pullman and put
- 22:07Speaker 9: into a pickup truck, and then a caravan of law
- 22:10Speaker 9: enforcement vehicles drove him into the Leyton County Jail parking lot,
- 22:14Speaker 9: where media and even members of the public were outside
- 22:17Speaker 9: waiting for him.
- 22:18Speaker 13: The next time we saw him would be in a courtroom.
- 22:21Speaker 9: The maximum penalty for that offense, if you plead guilty
- 22:25Speaker 9: or found guilty, is up to debt and or imprisonment
- 22:28Speaker 9: for life.
- 22:29Speaker 10: Do you understand yes.
- 22:31Speaker 9: Unlike in his Pennsylvania appearance where Coberger looked back to
- 22:35Speaker 9: see his family in the courtroom, he seemed to make
- 22:38Speaker 9: a point in Idaho not to do so, likely because
- 22:41Speaker 9: he knew the victims' families would be in the gallery.
- 22:45Speaker 18: I feel like he's scared to look at me in
- 22:47Speaker 18: the eyes and start to understand what's about to happen
- 22:51Speaker 18: to him. You know, he picked their own family.
- 22:54Speaker 15: So once the suspect of Pierce to court, prosecutors released.
- 22:57Speaker 16: The probable cause Affidavid, and this stuff filled with detail
- 23:01Speaker 16: after detail after detail, things we didn't know, eighteen pages worth,
- 23:06Speaker 16: And at that point the public got some answers, but
- 23:09Speaker 16: more importantly, the families finally got some answers.
- 23:14Speaker 18: He read Daffi David, and you just find out that
- 23:19Speaker 18: nobody understands exactly why. But he was talking them, he
- 23:23Speaker 18: was hunting them.
- 23:24Speaker 9: They Affadavid in this case lays out the evidence against
- 23:27Speaker 9: Brian Coburger. But there is a gag order here, so
- 23:29Speaker 9: we don't know everything the prosecution has.
- 23:32Speaker 13: But a lot of people think he's the guy.
- 23:34Speaker 9: He must be guilty, But there's a long way to go,
- 23:37Speaker 9: and a lot of people think that this case isn't
- 23:39Speaker 9: a slam dunk.
- 23:41Speaker 5: It's absolutely disgusting. This guy does not have a presumption
- 23:45Speaker 5: of NI says he has the assumption of guilt. I'm
- 23:49Speaker 5: Sarah Azari. I'm a criminal trial attorney in Los Angeles.
- 23:53Speaker 5: I'm currently a legal analyst for News Nation, and I
- 23:56Speaker 5: am the host of the Presumption podcast. You know, pre
- 24:00Speaker 5: trial convictions of high profile defendants in high profile cases,
- 24:04Speaker 5: it's nothing.
- 24:04Speaker 13: New, but Coburger is whole other level.
- 24:08Speaker 5: And I think not only we found him guilty of
- 24:12Speaker 5: slaying the four Idaho students, but we've decided that he's
- 24:15Speaker 5: going to get the death penalty.
- 24:17Speaker 9: The most significant piece of evidence for prosecutors is the
- 24:21Speaker 9: DNA of the defendant found on the knife sheath of
- 24:25Speaker 9: the alleged murer weapon located underneath victim Madison Mogan's body.
- 24:30Speaker 5: We don't know when and how this DNA got there.
- 24:35Speaker 2: So if Brian.
- 24:36Speaker 5: Cooberger is person a and he touches this knife sheath,
- 24:41Speaker 5: and then somehow this knife sheath is picked up by
- 24:44Speaker 5: somebody else. I mean he could touch it, he could
- 24:46Speaker 5: handle it, could be anything. And then that person then
- 24:50Speaker 5: somehow is in this King's road home. That is a
- 24:53Speaker 5: perfect explanation of how Coburger's DNA was on that knife sheath.
- 24:59Speaker 5: Is insufficient to place him in that home, let alone
- 25:03Speaker 5: to place the murder weapon in his hands. That's why
- 25:07Speaker 5: I'm not at all worried about the DNA.
- 25:11Speaker 23: I'm Tiffany Roy and I'm a forensic DNA expert. I
- 25:14Speaker 23: work privately in the area of forensic DNA and forensic biology.
- 25:19Speaker 23: I've been doing this work for seventeen years. DNA can
- 25:23Speaker 23: be transferred onto items that people have never contacted and
- 25:27Speaker 23: never touched, that can be found in rooms where people
- 25:30Speaker 23: have never set foot. He may never have touched that sheet,
- 25:33Speaker 23: and his DNA could have been transferred there by some
- 25:37Speaker 23: contact with another item or another person.
- 25:40Speaker 13: We can't tell how it got there. We can't tell
- 25:42Speaker 13: when it got.
- 25:43Speaker 15: There, or it could be there because he committed this
- 25:47Speaker 15: quadruple murder and took the lives of these four students,
- 25:51Speaker 15: and maybe when he was closing the snap, his thumb
- 25:53Speaker 15: touched it before he even showed up the murder scene,
- 25:56Speaker 15: and maybe that knife sheath got loose.
- 25:58Speaker 11: Because those girls were fighting for their lives.
- 26:01Speaker 15: Now you take that evidence in conjunction with all the
- 26:05Speaker 15: other evidence, including those phone records.
- 26:08Speaker 2: Wow.
- 26:09Speaker 9: Investigators believe that Coburger's cell phone was off or in
- 26:14Speaker 9: airplane mode around the estimated time of the murders because
- 26:18Speaker 9: he turned it off.
- 26:19Speaker 5: We've been saying it was off. His phone was off.
- 26:22Speaker 5: We don't know if it was off. It could have
- 26:24Speaker 5: been off, it could have been an airplane mode, or
- 26:27Speaker 5: it could have just simply not picked up signal during
- 26:30Speaker 5: that time. What's odd, of course, and what's problematic for
- 26:33Speaker 5: the defense, is that his phone did pick up signal
- 26:36Speaker 5: before the murders and after the murders.
- 26:39Speaker 15: Another significant coincidence for those who believe in coincidences I don't,
- 26:44Speaker 15: is that there's this white car that's driving around and
- 26:47Speaker 15: around at the time of the murders, close to the
- 26:50Speaker 15: scene of the murders, caught on video.
- 26:52Speaker 22: And guess what.
- 26:55Speaker 11: The defendant, the suspect, the accuse, what does he drive?
- 26:59Speaker 2: A white laundry.
- 27:01Speaker 5: The car is driving around, but then suddenly during the
- 27:03Speaker 5: window of the murders, we don't know where this car was,
- 27:07Speaker 5: We don't know where it was parked. We just know
- 27:09Speaker 5: nothing about the car identification of the Handai A Lantra
- 27:12Speaker 5: as like the suspect vehicle.
- 27:14Speaker 2: That's a problem.
- 27:15Speaker 9: Another part of the case against Brian Coburger is an
- 27:19Speaker 9: eyewitness account Dylan Morten's in one of the surviving roommates.
- 27:22Speaker 9: She told police that she saw a man around the
- 27:25Speaker 9: time of the murders, dressed in black ohsh eyebrows, wearing
- 27:29Speaker 9: a mask covering his nose and his mouth that walked
- 27:31Speaker 9: past her down the hallway.
- 27:34Speaker 5: And then we have Dylan, a surviving roommate, as she's
- 27:38Speaker 5: so afraid that she goes in her back in her
- 27:41Speaker 5: bedroom and locks herself up and then doesn't call nine
- 27:44Speaker 5: to one one.
- 27:45Speaker 13: For eight hours later. Okay, that is highly unusual.
- 27:50Speaker 5: We look to expected behavior, expected response, reasonable response. That
- 27:58Speaker 5: is what makes sense to jurors. Jurors are normal people,
- 28:01Speaker 5: so you tell them a story, it better makes sense, right,
- 28:05Speaker 5: and it doesn't make sense.
- 28:07Speaker 10: Credibility always matters with witnesses, and this witness comes across
- 28:12Speaker 10: as credible.
- 28:13Speaker 2: Is she flawed? Yes? Next the house on King Road,
- 28:19Speaker 2: No One the listeners hearing now and the type of
- 28:22Speaker 2: person capable of committing these murders, whoever.
- 28:25Speaker 20: Did this be a Coburger or someone else is a
- 28:28Speaker 20: sexual domination killer.
- 28:30Speaker 2: Plus Brian Coberger's defense.
- 28:33Speaker 10: If he says I was in this house before, that's
- 28:36Speaker 10: why my DNA is in this house all of a sudden,
- 28:40Speaker 10: you might have a completely different tribe.
- 28:50Speaker 1: Hey, guys, hooscope, turn the music down, turn the music down?
- 29:00Speaker 13: Hello, miss what's your name?
- 29:02Speaker 24: Dana?
- 29:03Speaker 13: And you live here?
- 29:04Speaker 7: Yeah, we've already talked to Maddie once and told her
- 29:06Speaker 7: the same thing.
- 29:07Speaker 9: The house at one one two two King Road, where
- 29:09Speaker 9: for University of Idaho students were murdered, was known as
- 29:13Speaker 9: a college party house going back before. Kayley, Maddie's, and
- 29:17Speaker 9: Dylan and Bethany all lived there. In the fall of
- 29:20Speaker 9: twenty twenty two, just a few months before the murders,
- 29:23Speaker 9: Moscow police responded to a noise complaint at the house
- 29:27Speaker 9: on multiple occasions.
- 29:28Speaker 15: And if I do have to come back here, three hundred.
- 29:31Speaker 10: Dollar tickets coming away, and only it's more expensive from there,
- 29:34Speaker 10: so right.
- 29:34Speaker 13: Fair, Yeah, that's hard.
- 29:35Speaker 9: There was even an incidence where there are people at
- 29:38Speaker 9: the house, but none of the roommates are even there.
- 29:43Speaker 2: How goes it?
- 29:43Speaker 24: Oh? Hi, how are you?
- 29:44Speaker 2: Who lives here?
- 29:46Speaker 15: We're not.
- 29:48Speaker 2: Who lives here?
- 29:50Speaker 13: We're just here for and ling point. So everyone here's trespassing.
- 29:53Speaker 25: Well, no one's here, trust passing, but no one, no
- 29:56Speaker 25: one that lives he's here right now? Sure that they're
- 29:59Speaker 25: just I have no clue.
- 30:00Speaker 15: They want no clue.
- 30:01Speaker 7: See, I just thrown a party in their house that
- 30:04Speaker 7: they were here at one point.
- 30:05Speaker 2: They're not here right now.
- 30:06Speaker 24: I just left and went over to some other parties.
- 30:09Speaker 13: And everyone is about another.
- 30:13Speaker 2: Who does live here? What are their names?
- 30:15Speaker 13: I am actually not sure.
- 30:17Speaker 9: Jeremy Reagan lived near the house on King Road for
- 30:19Speaker 9: a few years and saw a lot. Tell me about
- 30:23Speaker 9: the house, What do you know about the house?
- 30:25Speaker 14: So when I moved here my first year, that house
- 30:28Speaker 14: was not super bad, notorious for like students going in
- 30:32Speaker 14: and out partying all the time. My second year there
- 30:35Speaker 14: was a ton of people all the time, in and
- 30:38Speaker 14: out constantly. And then my third year, which is the
- 30:40Speaker 14: year that all this happened, it was much more similar
- 30:43Speaker 14: to the first year I was here. They did have
- 30:46Speaker 14: more stuff going on there, but they were definitely nowhere
- 30:49Speaker 14: near as loud as crazy as that second year that
- 30:51Speaker 14: I was here.
- 30:52Speaker 13: Does the fact that so many people were in and
- 30:55Speaker 13: out of this.
- 30:56Speaker 9: House back during to the case against Brian Coberger.
- 31:00Speaker 5: The fact that this King's Road house was a party
- 31:02Speaker 5: house is a huge, big deal because it expands the
- 31:05Speaker 5: universe of suspects. Who was there at the time the murders.
- 31:09Speaker 5: What was their connection to the victims? Who had access
- 31:12Speaker 5: to this home before? Did they have possible motive to kill?
- 31:17Speaker 5: For months, we've been calling this a party house, this
- 31:19Speaker 5: is a party venue.
- 31:20Speaker 10: One of the most important parts of this case is
- 31:23Speaker 10: that DNA and what we know is this is a
- 31:25Speaker 10: party house. We know that there were hundreds of kids
- 31:28Speaker 10: in this house. It could even have included him. And
- 31:32Speaker 10: the thing is is if he was in this house,
- 31:35Speaker 10: are you suggesting that these four know everybody who's been there.
- 31:38Speaker 2: I doubt that.
- 31:39Speaker 10: And as a result, if he says I was in
- 31:42Speaker 10: this house before, that's why my DNA is in this house.
- 31:46Speaker 2: Now we talk about that, and.
- 31:48Speaker 10: We talk about DNA transfer and all of a sudden,
- 31:51Speaker 10: all of a sudden, you might have a completely different trial.
- 31:55Speaker 15: It's not just that the defendant DNAs in the house.
- 31:59Speaker 15: It's on a knife which is found next to Maddie's body.
- 32:02Speaker 2: I'm a former prosecutor.
- 32:03Speaker 15: This is game over DNA, and it's not just any DNA,
- 32:08Speaker 15: it's single source DNA.
- 32:11Speaker 23: Single source DNA profile is the most informative type of
- 32:16Speaker 23: profile we can hope to get from a crime scene.
- 32:18Speaker 23: It's a lot of clear information and it's a lot
- 32:22Speaker 23: of very specific information. If you're looking for DNA from
- 32:26Speaker 23: a perpetrator, that's something that's related to a weapon, and
- 32:30Speaker 23: a weapon that could.
- 32:31Speaker 13: Have been used in the commission of this crime.
- 32:33Speaker 23: It would be a very rare event for anyone else
- 32:35Speaker 23: to match with a single source mail DNA profile, so
- 32:39Speaker 23: it's very strong evidence.
- 32:41Speaker 2: Brian Coberger.
- 32:44Speaker 9: After graduating from the Sales University in the spring of
- 32:47Speaker 9: twenty twenty two, Brian Coberger was accepted into the Criminology
- 32:51Speaker 9: PhD program at Washington State University. At the time of
- 32:55Speaker 9: the Idaho student murderers, Coburger was a teaching assistant and
- 32:59Speaker 9: if you have this dudent and it's came forward to
- 33:00Speaker 9: say they noticed a difference in his behavior after the murders.
- 33:05Speaker 1: No reason to connect him to that at the time,
- 33:08Speaker 1: but definitely around then.
- 33:12Speaker 13: He started grading everybody just one hundreds. He seemed preoccupied,
- 33:15Speaker 13: is what I would have said. At the time.
- 33:17Speaker 1: He would come in, be there for ten minutes, leave,
- 33:20Speaker 1: not say much.
- 33:21Speaker 13: So he didn't really do.
- 33:23Speaker 4: That much, but you could tell there was some off
- 33:27Speaker 4: about him.
- 33:29Speaker 9: What's still unclear is the prosecution's theory as to why
- 33:32Speaker 9: you would want to kill these young people and what,
- 33:35Speaker 9: if any, was the connection.
- 33:37Speaker 5: Motive is not an element of crime or murder, but
- 33:40Speaker 5: of course every inquiring mind wants to know why why
- 33:44Speaker 5: would Brian Koberger do this to four innocent victims college students.
- 33:49Speaker 5: Could the state go to trial without motive, absolutely, but
- 33:52Speaker 5: I bet they won't. And the problem here is that
- 33:55Speaker 5: we don't even have a connection to these victims.
- 33:58Speaker 13: Forget about motive.
- 34:01Speaker 9: Steve Gonsalvez, Kaylee's father, believes there's a good chance the
- 34:04Speaker 9: murderer was tracking Kaylee and or her best friend, Maddie.
- 34:08Speaker 2: I'd be a.
- 34:09Speaker 18: Little bit surprised that there wasn't a clear touch point
- 34:13Speaker 18: that would suggest that he was interested in one or
- 34:17Speaker 18: two of the people more than he was the others.
- 34:21Speaker 13: An Instagram account that was taken down shortly after Coburger's
- 34:25Speaker 13: arrest with the username of Brian Coberger was following several
- 34:29Speaker 13: members of the Coburger family. The account also followed Madison Mogan.
- 34:36Speaker 4: I'm Benjamin Mogan. I'm Madison Mogan's father.
- 34:40Speaker 9: I first met Matti Mugan's father, Ben at the Mad
- 34:43Speaker 9: Greek Restaurant a few weeks after the murders. Maddie and
- 34:47Speaker 9: Xana both worked there. It's a popular restaurant in downtown Moscow.
- 34:51Speaker 9: Tell me about what a beautiful person she was.
- 34:53Speaker 2: She was so great she was.
- 34:56Speaker 4: She lit up every room she come in, and she
- 35:00Speaker 4: it was just so positive and fun and we just
- 35:04Speaker 4: love her and miss.
- 35:04Speaker 2: Her so much.
- 35:05Speaker 13: The Mad Greek Restaurant.
- 35:07Speaker 9: It's also one of the first places that comes up
- 35:10Speaker 9: if you search for vegan food in Moscow. We know
- 35:13Speaker 9: Brian Koberger claims to be a vegan because he asked
- 35:16Speaker 9: for a vegan meal plan at the jail.
- 35:19Speaker 15: So maybe he did see Maddie and Xana at the
- 35:23Speaker 15: Mad Greek and sort of became obsessed with them. But
- 35:27Speaker 15: prosecutors made a point and their probable cause affidavit they
- 35:31Speaker 15: went into detail about this Reddit post that the defendant
- 35:35Speaker 15: allegedly made.
- 35:38Speaker 2: Calling out to criminals to provide.
- 35:40Speaker 15: Him with the reason why they chose their victims and
- 35:44Speaker 15: committed their crimes. Now I understand he studies this well,
- 35:47Speaker 15: but this.
- 35:48Speaker 2: Is still a little strange.
- 35:50Speaker 10: Sounds like he's looking for the reasons why people do
- 35:54Speaker 10: the things that they do, maybe to answer the question
- 35:58Speaker 10: for himself, maybe to explained for him why he's motivated
- 36:03Speaker 10: in the way that he is.
- 36:04Speaker 2: Are you trying to figure out who you are? Or
- 36:06Speaker 2: are you trying to figure out who they are?
- 36:08Speaker 10: And in this particular case, I think the prosecutors are
- 36:12Speaker 10: going to say, yeah, this was about him trying to
- 36:14Speaker 10: figure out who he is, because we can tell you
- 36:16Speaker 10: who he is.
- 36:17Speaker 2: He's this guy.
- 36:22Speaker 13: I am Shaban Scott.
- 36:24Speaker 20: I am a psychotherapist from Portland, Oregon.
- 36:29Speaker 9: So what are your thoughts about this Reddit post?
- 36:32Speaker 20: I see a theme with him for years in his
- 36:37Speaker 20: online writings of going back and trying to make sense
- 36:42Speaker 20: out of himself, and I think he was in that
- 36:46Speaker 20: category of I'm studying all this because I want to
- 36:49Speaker 20: understand myself, and so I think that was driving his research.
- 36:54Speaker 20: There's also, in a rather perverse way, perhaps an attempt
- 36:59Speaker 20: to develop up some sense of camaraderie with other people
- 37:03Speaker 20: and to get a sense of maybe I'm really not
- 37:05Speaker 20: the only one who has these thoughts and feelings and experiences.
- 37:10Speaker 13: What do his.
- 37:12Speaker 9: Studies tell you about Brian Coburger.
- 37:14Speaker 20: It's not that unusual for sadistic killers to study criminology.
- 37:20Speaker 20: We think of the BTK killer in Kansas the Golden
- 37:23Speaker 20: State killer in California both had criminology degrees, and the
- 37:28Speaker 20: California killer did go on to become a law enforcement officers,
- 37:31Speaker 20: and there have been quite a few others. So I
- 37:34Speaker 20: think there are three reasons people study criminology. The first
- 37:38Speaker 20: is because they're altruistic and they really want to make
- 37:41Speaker 20: the world a safer place, so they have good motivations.
- 37:45Speaker 20: The second reason is because they're absolutely fascinated by the
- 37:48Speaker 20: criminal mind, which can be a fine reason, but the
- 37:52Speaker 20: dark side of that is they're trying to figure themselves out.
- 37:56Speaker 20: And the third reason is because they have a plan
- 38:00Speaker 20: to commit crimes and they're studying police tactics and procedures
- 38:04Speaker 20: so that they.
- 38:05Speaker 13: Can become a better criminal.
- 38:06Speaker 20: And if Coburger is the killer, I think those second
- 38:10Speaker 20: two reasons would be at.
- 38:11Speaker 13: Clay whoever did this be a.
- 38:14Speaker 20: Coburger or someone else is a sexual domination killer, and
- 38:19Speaker 20: this is someone that's created a sadistic theatrical production based
- 38:25Speaker 20: on fantasies that he's had for many years now. The
- 38:28Speaker 20: fantasies serve to meet his emotional needs, to express rage
- 38:32Speaker 20: at women and to have a sense of godlike power
- 38:36Speaker 20: because others vulnerability makes him feel invincible and their deaths
- 38:40Speaker 20: make him feel like a god.
- 38:43Speaker 2: Coming up the legal battle ahead as prosecutors seek the
- 38:47Speaker 2: death penalty.
- 38:48Speaker 5: To have a full defense, he absolutely needs to know
- 38:52Speaker 5: that this investigation against against him was one hundred percent
- 38:57Speaker 5: according to protocol.
- 38:58Speaker 2: Plus remember the victims through all this.
- 39:02Speaker 24: I hope we can all look through that dark tunnel
- 39:06Speaker 24: and see the light and follow that light, and I
- 39:10Speaker 24: pray that we have justice someday.
- 39:19Speaker 9: Since his arrest in December twenty twenty two, Brian Coberger
- 39:22Speaker 9: has made a number of court appearances and his defense
- 39:25Speaker 9: team has filed a number of motions challenging everything from
- 39:29Speaker 9: the grand jury indictment against him to how the investigators
- 39:33Speaker 9: processed the DNA found at the crime scene.
- 39:35Speaker 15: They didn't get a hit for the DNA that was
- 39:38Speaker 15: found at the crime scene with the national database, so
- 39:41Speaker 15: they moved to a public database, one of those genealogy databases,
- 39:44Speaker 15: and they got a hit and it was for the
- 39:46Speaker 15: suspect's father. But now the defense is taken a closer
- 39:51Speaker 15: look at that, saying, well, wait a minute, wait a minute,
- 39:53Speaker 15: we want to know and we want to see exactly
- 39:55Speaker 15: how you tested all of this DNA to get that result.
- 39:59Speaker 23: What's going on on a Brian Colberger's case that's very
- 40:01Speaker 23: concerning is the government does not want to turn over
- 40:05Speaker 23: in discovery what all was searched, what databases were searched,
- 40:10Speaker 23: and what records were obtained.
- 40:12Speaker 5: When you're talking about a defendant's right to a fair
- 40:15Speaker 5: trial and his due process and his sixth Amendment to
- 40:21Speaker 5: you to have a full defense, he absolutely needs to
- 40:25Speaker 5: know that this investigation against against him was one hundred
- 40:29Speaker 5: percent according to protocol and that there was integrity in
- 40:33Speaker 5: this investigation.
- 40:34Speaker 15: The defendant apparently has an alibi, now a little strange here.
- 40:39Speaker 15: They say his attorneys that he likes to go out
- 40:41Speaker 15: at night and in the early morning hours and sort
- 40:43Speaker 15: of drive around and that's what he was doing at
- 40:46Speaker 15: the time of the murders.
- 40:48Speaker 2: Goodness done it.
- 40:50Speaker 5: Colberger's alibi is that he wasn't at the crime scene,
- 40:53Speaker 5: but instead he was driving around alone. That statement of
- 40:57Speaker 5: his alibi doesn't tell us obviously, exactly what you know, timey,
- 41:02Speaker 5: he was driving, where he was driving to and from
- 41:06Speaker 5: and why. I mean, we don't have any of those details.
- 41:08Speaker 5: He's not saying something that's completely inconsistent with the evidence.
- 41:12Speaker 9: The defense is also claiming that cameras should not be
- 41:15Speaker 9: allowed inside the courtroom, claiming Coburger's every move is being
- 41:19Speaker 9: analyzed in a way that's prejudicial. Kaylee's father, Steve can
- 41:23Speaker 9: Solve This has.
- 41:24Speaker 13: Some thoughts on that.
- 41:26Speaker 12: If you're not a personal person and you give off
- 41:29Speaker 12: weird advice, yeah, you probably don't want nobody to actually
- 41:32Speaker 12: see the truth and see who.
- 41:33Speaker 13: You are and read you for who how you.
- 41:36Speaker 12: Behathe You can't hide the truth, man. Just I'm so
- 41:40Speaker 12: tired of the secretive and all that stuff.
- 41:43Speaker 13: Just I want this stuff to be out.
- 41:44Speaker 2: In the open.
- 41:45Speaker 12: I want all the evidence out.
- 41:47Speaker 13: I want it to be clear.
- 41:48Speaker 12: I want the community to look at that evidence and
- 41:51Speaker 12: miss Taylor.
- 41:52Speaker 1: Is mister Coberger prepared to plead to be starved this No,
- 41:57Speaker 1: we don't understand.
- 41:58Speaker 13: This side of a plea of not guilty.
- 42:01Speaker 9: Wasn't dirt for Brian Coburger after he chose to stand
- 42:04Speaker 9: silent at his arraignment. His trial is expected to begin
- 42:08Speaker 9: sometime in twenty twenty four.
- 42:14Speaker 13: Kayleie, you will never be forgotten.
- 42:16Speaker 24: You will love by for you every day, with your
- 42:18Speaker 24: mentality in our mind.
- 42:19Speaker 13: We love you so much.
- 42:21Speaker 5: She embodied her on Sunshine, and that's when her skies
- 42:24Speaker 5: became limitless.
- 42:26Speaker 13: I sent too much, my brother, Amilia Jeke.
- 42:32Speaker 12: Most important is love, like it's the only thing. You
- 42:35Speaker 12: know how nothing even matters except love and human connections.
- 42:41Speaker 12: You know, I'm not a big drinker, but maybe I
- 42:42Speaker 12: should have something.
- 42:45Speaker 13: Ain't a big drinker.
- 42:46Speaker 25: I was lucky enough to be able to explore life
- 42:49Speaker 25: with Maddie. Maddie was the best spreading love.
- 42:53Speaker 2: Distance makes the hut.
- 42:55Speaker 25: No, it was the funniest person I knew and maybe
- 42:59Speaker 25: laugh every time I spent time with her.
- 43:04Speaker 13: Sanna, you will not be forgotten.
- 43:06Speaker 9: You have impacted so many lives, and I've given people
- 43:08Speaker 9: so much love.
- 43:10Speaker 25: Oh Ethan was always someone you could count on to
- 43:18Speaker 25: make you smile and cheer up your mood. And I
- 43:22Speaker 25: feel so lucky, so I've shared so many great memories
- 43:25Speaker 25: with him.
- 43:28Speaker 2: To night we steal the sweet love of min.
- 43:35Speaker 24: Through all this, I hope we can all look through
- 43:38Speaker 24: that dark tunnel and see the light and follow that light.
- 43:44Speaker 24: And I pray that we have justice someday