Latest / Denver Post / Denver Post Sundays
Transcript
- 0:02Thank you for joining us for the Denver Post reading on Sunday read by Me Muna.
- 0:05With that, let's get started.
- 0:09Historic new funding launches Colorado into a post Tabor era.
- 0:13Amendment eighty seven Proposition N N remake Colorado's fiscal picture and set up a scramble on how to best use the money.
- 0:21By Robert Tan.
- 0:25For a generation, Colorado has hobbled the growth of government with some of the tightest legal shackles in the country.
- 0:30With a pair of votes to state, that era is over.
- 0:34Through Proposition NN and Amendment 87, approved by voters and backed by Democrats and Liberal groups, the state will see an influx of billions of dollars of new revenue after
- 0:44years of cuts.
- 0:45Taken together, they are the biggest change to state fiscal policy since 1992.
- 0:50When voters enshrine the taxpayers' Bill of Rights or Tabor into the state constitution.
- 0:56The state's flat income tax, where all taxpayers have the same rate, is gone, replaced with a system where the rich pay more.
- 1:03So is the cap on how much money the state could actually keep in flesh tax years.
- 1:07The money is tabbed for health care, childcare, and education, typically the state's biggest expenses.
- 1:15It also sets up a new debate for just how exactly lawmakers should spend that money and proves to voters that their trust was well placed.
- 1:22The language in the amendment specifies the money must be spent on those specific topics but gives broad leeway beyond that.
- 1:28The legislature will need to determine those parameters and work through internal struggles on who gets to set them, while working to avoid a freeding frenzy as Cent elect
- 1:37Emily Sorota, a Denver Democrat who sits on the legislature's joint budget committee, said.
- 1:44This is transformational, said Rep Lauren Garcia, Lorena Garcia, an Adams County Democrat who worked on the eighty seven campaign.
- 1:52This was a movement of the people saying that the tax policy that existed before is no longer working for us.
- 2:00The impact of that change will be swift.
- 2:02On Monday, state lawmakers were staring down another year of $1 billion plus budget cuts.
- 2:06Five days later, they were instead poised to return to the state capitol with spending authority that is unprecedented in recent state history.
- 2:14Taken together, 87NNN, plus another measure that sets aside funding for conservation and wildlife mitigation are estimated to bring in more than $2.6 billion in new spending next
- 2:24year.
- 2:28The new revenue does not fix all of the state's structural budgeting issues, nor will it fully meet the needs of the state's historically underfunded schools.
- 2:35But for the first time in years, voters have entrusted lawmakers with fresh tax dollars, giving newly elected Democratic supermajorities a freer hand in shaping or repairing the
- 2:44core systems that impact millions of Coloradans.
- 2:49The results were also something of a referendum on Tabor itself, or at least how it was how it has shaped the size and scale of state government for the past thirty four years.
- 2:59While conservatives have hailed Tabor as a check on big government, Democratic lawmakers and the liberal groups who backed eighty seven NNN have increasingly criticized it for
- 3:08imposing outdated austerity on a wealthy state with mounting needs.
- 3:14It was a recognition that there were some parts of Tabor that were really not working very well for working people in Colorado, said Chris de Gray Kennedy, president and CEO of the
- 3:23Bell Policy Center, the group that amended that placed Amendment 87 on the ballot.
- 3:29With its promise of taxpayer re rates, Tabor was once an elec electoral Goliath that withstood most of the reform proposals thrown against it.
- 3:37But recent federal tax cuts that primarily benefited the wealthiest Americans, coupled with mounting fiscal pressures on the state, emboldened lawmakers and liberal groups to
- 3:45take up the slingshot again.
- 3:51Billions unleashed for state society safety net systems education.
- 3:56Amid a historic democratic wave, Tabor emerged from Election Day bloody and weakened.
- 4:01Its core principle of requiring voter approval of tax increases remains intact along with a number of other provisions, but NN and 87 also landed direct shots against its key
- 4:11tenets of limited taxes and the state kicking back extra dollars to voters.
- 4:16Prop N N, which was placed on the ballot by Democratic lawmakers, will allow the state to keep money it would otherwise refund to taxpayers under tapor and spend it instead on K-12
- 4:25education and early childhood programs.
- 4:28That will pave the way for potentially billions of dollars for schools by the end of the next decade, though the annual amount will fluctuate based on state revenue.
- 4:37In twenty twenty seven, it means roughly fift five hundred million dollars more for schools and childcare.
- 4:44It's pretty historic, Kevin Vick.
- 4:46President of the Colorado Education Association, which spearheaded the measure, said, Over the course of the next ten years, there will be a dramatic shift in the amount of
- 4:53resources districts will have.
- 4:58Amendment 87 abolishes Tabor's requirement of a flat income tax currently set at 4.4%.
- 5:03It replaces that with a graduated rate that increases income tax rates on people and businesses earning more than $500,000 while cutting the rate or keeping it the same for
- 5:15everyone else, meaning the vast majority of Coloradans.
- 5:19It also exempts that new tax revenue from the state's revenue cap.
- 5:23The measure survived despite millions in outside spending and opposition from both the state's current and future governor.
- 5:30It is projected to generate more than two billion dollars in its first year.
- 5:34That provides immediate relief to what was shaping up to be another tough year.
- 5:40While the new funding is significant, it is not directionless.
- 5:4387's newly realized revenue must be directed into healthcare, education, and childcare.
- 5:51One of the biggest reasons why we chose these buckets is because healthcare and education specifically are two thirds of our budget, said Caroline Nutter, the policy manager of the
- 5:59Liberal Colorado Fiscal Institute, which also backed eighty seven.
- 6:03And those are really the places where we have faced the most cuts.
- 6:08Garcia said she wanted to direct some of the money to restore reductions is instituted last year.
- 6:17Beyond filling new or imminent gaps, DeGry Kennedy said the legislature should use the new money to expand or launch new services like childcare, which is currently a patchwork
- 6:26system of local and state programs.
- 6:29I think there would be a strong desire to make sure that there's a comprehensive program to make sure childcare is affordable for kids across Colorado, he said.
- 6:39Given that healthcare and education dominate the state's budget, the impact of eighty seven's new revenue will be far reaching.
- 6:44DeGry Kennedy said he expected to work closely on the measures implementation with Gov elect Phil Weiser.
- 6:53Weiser backed NN during the election season and lamented a cumulative ten billion dollars shortfall in education funding over the past fifteen years.
- 7:01But in a last minute rebuke, he criticized Amendment eighty seven for what he said was a lack of clarity about how its money would be spent.
- 7:09He also promised that if eighty seven passed, he would implement it effectively.
- 7:13Asked for comment after his supporters declared victory Thursday, Wiser's spokesman referred back to that pre election statement.
- 7:21On Thursday, the day 87 supporters declared victory, Kennedy said he had not spoken to Wiser.
- 7:26Michael Fields, the president of Advanced Colorado and a leading opponent to 87, declined to comment Thursday morning and did not respond to a text about 87 supporters' victory
- 7:35declaration.
- 7:39In a statement, Colorado Chamber of Commerce President and CEO Lauren Furman, a chief opponent of the measure, decrete the tax increase as crimping businesses' ability to hire,
- 7:50give workers raises and invest.
- 7:53But, she hoped, the money would mean the legislature would not pursue new fees on businesses.
- 8:01Small business owners work their entire lives to achieve the American dream, but this measure will penalize them for achieving that dream, Furman said.
- 8:10Despite the influx of new money, 87's passage will not solve all of the state's budget issues.
- 8:15Serious questions remain over how to fix entrenched budget issues, namely the surging cost of Medicaid, that could continue to hamper the state budget for years if left unchecked.
- 8:25The state budget was already buckling beneath the program's growth and additional cuts from the several
- 8:29From the federal government will soon kick in.
- 8:35eighty seven will provide breathing room to address those problems responsibly, lawmakers said, but it can't be the only fix.
- 8:42We still have to rein in the growth in Medicaid spending, said Sen Ju said Sen Judy Amabile, a bolder Democrat who sits on the legislature's joint budget committee, because
- 8:52otherwise in three or four years every penny of eighty seven will get absorbed by Medicaid.
- 9:01Money sets up new questions for lawmakers.
- 9:04The measure's passage marks a sea change.
- 9:06Not only does it entrust more money to lawmakers, but it also institutes a tax system that progressive reformers had long sought.
- 9:13It's kind of mind-breaking for me, said Scon Wat said Scott Wasserman, a veteran of the state's fiscal policy fights.
- 9:20He previously ran the Bell Policy Center, the group that backed 87.
- 9:25What that means is that for the first time in a really long time, the Colorado General Assembly has choices.
- 9:30And so now they actually have the financial ability to make choices they want to make.
- 9:38What exactly those choices are within the confines of 87 and NN's parameters or how they get made remains to be seen.
- 9:45Nutter and Garcia said the groups that BAX 87 will gather to decide next steps and set priorities.
- 9:51Garcia said she plans to run legislation to implement the measure early next year.
- 10:01Garcia cautioned that the legislature needed to validate voters' trust.
- 10:05She and others pointed out that the ballot measure requires annual reviews from the state auditor detailing how much money was collected under 87 and how it was spent.
- 10:18But she also said lawmakers needed to move quickly and make use of the large democratic majorities.
- 10:23She thought the money should be used to fill otherwise imminent Medicaid cuts and to potentially unwind reductions that were implemented in recent years.
- 10:32I don't believe voters are passing Amendment eighty seven to simply maintain the status quo, said Sorota, one of the Democratic Budget Committee members.
- 10:39Sheanne Amberbile said the legisl legislature needed to study how the new measures interact with each other and ensure the money is used as efficiently as possible.
- 10:49I absolutely think our childcare system is broken, and the funding from NN can be a huge source of support for families struggling to find childcare right now, Sorota said.
- 10:58Emabile said she wanted the legislature to plan for the future and identify a handful of large key priorities rather than diluting 87's impact by piecemealing the money out across
- 11:07scores of new programs.
- 11:13What I'm hearing from legislate from legislators is that we get we got these supermajorities and people expect us to deliver, Emma Bow said.
- 11:21So we might all have different ideas of how to go about that.
- 11:24But I think everybody is in agreement that we want to deliver for the people in Colorado.
- 11:30Rep Rick Taggart, a Grand Junction Republican and fellow joint budget committee member, said it would be critical that lawmakers establish clear guidelines for how the money can
- 11:39be spent.
- 11:40And not add more and not stretch the definition of what K-12 is or stretch the definition of healthcare.
- 11:45He said, We've got to be very careful in that legislation.
- 11:48And I know those are going to be difficult discussions and difficult debates.
- 11:56Sorota said the money should help immediately.
- 11:58Even as bigger decisions still have to be made, forecasters and predicted lawmakers would need to cut some $500 million just to cover spending overages this year.
- 12:0887 does give us some breathing room, Sorota said, lamenting the roller coaster of cuts lawmakers had endured in recent years that often fell on the backs of Medicaid patients
- 12:17and Colorado's most vulnerable residents.
- 12:20It doesn't mean the work stops, the work has to continue.
- 12:23But it doesn't mean we have to do such draconian things immediately.
- 12:26But she also emphasized that those decisions should be made by the legislature, especially given Weiser's last minute announcement that he didn't support the measure.
- 12:34He will still have a say as governor, but she noted that lawmakers control the purse.
- 12:42As someone who has served in the legislature for eight years and four years on the budget committee, two of which were excruciating to put mildly, I'm acutely aware of the fiscal
- 12:50challenges Colorado is in, Sorota said.
- 12:53I'm not sure I could say the name of Gov ElectWiser.
- 12:55I'm not sure I could say the same of Gov ElectWiser and the choices that were about to come before him.
- 13:03N provides a steady, if uneven, stream of school funding.
- 13:08Unlike 87, Prop N N's full impact may not be realized for years.
- 13:12That's because the amount of money it raises for schools by lifting the table imposed spending cap is subject to MIRID economic factors, which will vary by year.
- 13:25Under NN, the state will be able to keep about $500 million in new money for education and childhood programs next year.
- 13:32This could eventually grow civilians over the next 10 years, projections show, though that may shift depending on economic conditions.
- 13:42Still, educators aren't treating the new funding as a cure all as a cure-all.
- 13:46Independent studies commissioned by the legislature show that the state would need to spend between $3.5 and $4.1, $3.5 billion and $4.1 billion more annually to adequately
- 13:57fund its public K-12 system.
- 14:00It will also mean an end to Tabor refunds for the foreseeable future.
- 14:03Essentially, in years where the economy does well and state revenue exceeds the Tabor surplus.
- 14:09That money will now go to schools rather than back into taxpayers' pockets.
- 14:16NN is a major win for Democrats and liberal groups, who for years have repeatedly tried to amend Tabor or inject more education funding, largely without success.
- 14:25Conservatives have also often pointed to some of these defeats as proof that Tabor refunds were deeply popular.
- 14:33Vic, the Colorado Education Association president, attributed NN's success to its laser-focused message on education.
- 14:40An issue he says resonates with communities across Colorado who've seen upheaval from teachers driven out by high costs and strained resources.
- 14:50The measure's primary focus will be increasing teacher pay, for which Colorado ranks near the bottom nationally.
- 14:56It will also provide more funding to higher educators and increase the number of career and technical courses available to students.
- 15:03Like 87, the money will be tracked through public auditing.
- 15:07For 20 years, education has been in a mindset of only how can we make things work with fewer resources, Vix said.
- 15:13This now gives us an opportunity to actually really imagine and dream.
- 15:18A little bit about how we can effectively build and improve with new resources coming in.
- 15:26This article begins with an image captioned Denver, Colorado, November fifth.
- 15:31Amendment eighty seven supporters declare victory for major rewrite of Colorado's tax code, affecting all taxpayers at La Raza Park in Denver, Colorado, on Thursday, november
- 15:41fifth, twenty twenty six.
- 15:46Thanks for joining us for the Sunday Denver post.
- 15:48Have a great day.