Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #48: Is Split Ticket Voting in US Elections Dead? Will it Make a Comeback?
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan political analysis.
- 0:06I am your host, Paul Raider.
- 0:07Hope you all had a great fourth of July weekend.
- 0:10Today's topic is split ticket voting.
- 0:14Is split ticket voting dead?
- 0:17How do we measure split ticket voting?
- 0:20What impacts our analysis of it?
- 0:22What does split ticket voting look like from a historical perspective, and how did it shape up
- 0:28in the twenty twenty four election?
- 0:30Is there any cause for concern about how potentially low it is?
- 0:34And will split ticketing make a comeback?
- 0:38All this and more on tap for today's episode.
- 0:41But first, I didn't realize just how difficult it would be to say split ticketing multiple
- 0:47times.
- 0:48But much has been made about the frequency with which voters vote straight party on their
- 0:53ballots, meaning they pick the same party for every partisan contest on the ballot because
- 0:58there's also some nonpartisan contest too in ballot measures.
- 1:01On the flip side is ticket splitting, meaning a voter picks a second party at some point on
- 1:07their ballot.
- 1:09And maybe they vote Republican for everything except one office, like a county commission
- 1:14where they choose a Democrat, or maybe they do it the opposite way where Democrat on
- 1:18everything except for a in one office.
- 1:21Maybe there are a bunch of offices that they both vote both Republican and Democrat on.
- 1:27Today, we explore not only data behind split ticketing, but the more descriptive aspects of
- 1:33how we study it and some of the philosophical implications behind it.
- 1:38Is split ticketing really on the decline as much as some political observers have said?
- 1:45And how different or similar is it two years past?
- 1:50What does it all mean?
- 1:51Let's find out.
- 1:52So a little bit more on the comparison between straight ticket voting and split ticket voting.
- 1:58Again, straight ticket voting just means you vote for the same party throughout the ballot.
- 2:03And as of October 2024, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures, six
- 2:09states have an option where you can choose a party without having to go all the way down the
- 2:14ballot.
- 2:15So at the top, there's a bubble you can say where I just want all the Republican candidates
- 2:20on the ballot or I want all the Democratic candidates on the ballot.
- 2:23And those states are Alabama, Kentucky, Indiana, Michigan, Oklahoma, and South
- 2:29Carolina.
- 2:30Although Indiana did abolish the practice for at large races only back in 2016.
- 2:35At large means they represent an entire geographical unit that otherwise would be
- 2:40districted.
- 2:41Like, for example, maybe county commission represents a district, but it's voted on at
- 2:46large, meaning the whole county votes on it even though they technically only represent one
- 2:50district.
- 2:52Now even in states where that simple option of voting Republican for everything or Democrat
- 2:57for everything, there are still plenty of voters that vote for just one party throughout
- 3:02other states.
- 3:04Now that straight ticket voting option, not straight ticket voting itself necessarily, that
- 3:10has declined in use over time.
- 3:13And NCSL shows 14 states have abolished it since 1994.
- 3:18And some examples are Georgia did it back in 1994.
- 3:21Illinois did it in 1997.
- 3:23Wisconsin in 2011.
- 3:25West Virginia in 2015.
- 3:27And then the latest was Utah in 2020.
- 3:31So just a few of the arguments real quick both for and against having that straight ticket
- 3:37voting option.
- 3:40Arguments in favor of the straight ticket voting option, so that is the ability to mark
- 3:45one bubble that counts for all members of that party on the ballot.
- 3:50A lot of people that argue in favor of that will say that many voters just do it anyway,
- 3:54voting straight party, so you might as well save them the time at the polls having to go
- 3:58down through these ballots because these ballots can be very long.
- 4:02Another argument they will use is that it mitigates the possibility of an error.
- 4:06So maybe you if you were gonna vote through the whole ballot, maybe you accidentally mark
- 4:10outside the bubbles, which, you know, if you've been to the ballot box, if you mark outside the
- 4:16bubbles, your choice for that office is invalidated.
- 4:20Or maybe you incorrectly mark a candidate.
- 4:22Some people still put, like, check marks or x marks in a bubble when they're supposed to fill
- 4:28it in.
- 4:28That still happens.
- 4:30Or maybe they forgot about a elect an election down the ballot.
- 4:34Like, there was a county commission that they forgot to mark a bubble for, and so their vote
- 4:39didn't count for that if they didn't have that straight ticket voting option.
- 4:43And then the, a third major argument is that it decreases voter fatigue, which is some voters
- 4:51just get tired of making choices on the ballot and will leave part of it blank.
- 4:56Maybe you filled out the first 10 contests, and you got to the eleventh, and you're like, I
- 5:01don't wanna freaking do this anymore.
- 5:03And then so you just turn it in.
- 5:04So straight ticket voters will say having that straight ticket voting option right up at the
- 5:10top to say, I just want all republicans.
- 5:12I just want all democrats that will mitigate all those issues.
- 5:16On the flip side, people arguing against the straight ticket voting option will say that
- 5:22this allows extremists to get more easily elected instead of having to go through each of
- 5:27these races and say, oh, wait.
- 5:29That candidate is crazy.
- 5:30You're just letting people just mark a party and not even think about that possibility.
- 5:37Arguments against the straight ticket voting option.
- 5:39Another one is that it makes it even more difficult for third party candidates to win.
- 5:44And last week, we talked about roadblocks that third party candidates face to winning
- 5:50elections.
- 5:51And then a third big argument that people make against the straight ticket voting option is
- 5:58that it encourages voters to be less informed at the polls about their choices because they
- 6:03don't have to research them.
- 6:04They just think, oh, okay.
- 6:05Well, that's a republican.
- 6:06That's a democrat.
- 6:07I'm just gonna fill in the bubble.
- 6:09So I normally try to keep my opinions out as much as possible, certainly about parties and
- 6:17individuals and ideologies and all that.
- 6:19I'm not gonna tell you about that.
- 6:22I will tell you because I have a strong opinion.
- 6:26This, again, this is just my opinion on here.
- 6:28You are free to disagree with it if you want or to agree with it.
- 6:31My personal opinion about the straight ticket voting option is that it should not be allowed,
- 6:35but not even because of those arguments for before.
- 6:39My personal feeling is that you shouldn't be lazy about it.
- 6:42You should have to take the time to fill out each of those bubbles.
- 6:46And if there was a contest that somebody wasn't going to vote in, if they looked over the whole
- 6:51ballot, we should not be able to count their vote through just filling one bubble at the
- 6:56top.
- 6:56So if there was, like, a city council that somebody was voting for and you weren't gonna
- 7:02actually fill in that bubble because you maybe you were gonna get tired of voting on that
- 7:06ballot, If you fill out that bubble at the top, you don't even have to worry about that.
- 7:11But if you don't have that straight ticket voting option, then you have to go all the way
- 7:15down there.
- 7:15But if you weren't gonna go all the way down there, I don't think that itch having that
- 7:19straight ticket voting option should count for that election.
- 7:21I think you should have to take the time to fill out those bubbles.
- 7:25Again, you don't have to agree with that, but that's not a that's not a partisan or
- 7:30ideological thing.
- 7:31That's just something I feel particular about.
- 7:35But in any case, I digress.
- 7:37So even if you have ticket splitting or split ticketing, there are different levels to it.
- 7:44Any individual or geographical unit like a precinct could have voted for one party for
- 7:51every office except for one, like a school board, if the school board is partisan.
- 7:57A lot of school boards are not partisan.
- 7:59But just for the example, if it is a school board that is partisan, you maybe that's the
- 8:05one that you decided to vote Democrat on and everything else was Republican, or maybe you
- 8:09voted Republican on that one, but you voted Democrat on everything else.
- 8:13But then you can have another person or place that splits tickets for multiple offices as in,
- 8:19like, maybe five offices had a republican and five offices had a democrat that you voted for.
- 8:24So there's no real when when you do ticket splitting, it can get a little bit convoluted
- 8:32there.
- 8:32But speaking of which, when it comes to measuring split ticket voting, we can't look at
- 8:39specific ballots.
- 8:40We don't know which specific voters are doing the ticket splitting unless they tell you
- 8:46directly in, like, a poll, and they might be fibbing a bit with their answer.
- 8:49They might be saying, oh, yeah.
- 8:51I've I I split my ticket because they don't wanna seem like they're a hardheaded straight
- 8:56party voter, if if they feel like that's the socially desirable answer to not say they voted
- 9:01democrat on everything or republican on everything.
- 9:04Or if they're talking to other members of their party and they did split their ticket, maybe
- 9:09they're gonna say, oh, yeah.
- 9:10I totally voted for the the party in every case.
- 9:14So you can't necessarily say and I'm not saying that there's gonna be a lot of voters that do
- 9:19that, that a lot a lot of them are are lying about their choices.
- 9:23But I am saying that there can be a discrepancy between what people report and what they
- 9:29actually do.
- 9:32But in any case, you can't look at specific ballots.
- 9:35We do not have that access, and you certainly can't trade even if we could, you can't trace
- 9:39them back to a specific person.
- 9:42So you can't look exactly at how people split their tickets.
- 9:47So instead, we have to break down our voting results by geographical units.
- 9:53And, typically, you'll see it as states.
- 9:56So you might see how states voted for president and then how they voted for US senate.
- 10:03And then you might have it broken up by congressional and state legislative districts,
- 10:08counties, cities, precincts.
- 10:10Those are the typical units that you see.
- 10:14And in some places, in some states and some counties, that data is going to be more easily
- 10:19available than in others.
- 10:21It might be publicly available for download on some elections administrators websites And
- 10:28another places, it might only be available for a fee.
- 10:32And then what hoops they have to jump through can differ, like, if there's some sort of info
- 10:36you have to provide, like, what you're doing this for, if it's for research purposes or
- 10:42reporting or anything like that.
- 10:45And then the further you break down those geographical units, the more elections that
- 10:49apply.
- 10:50So if you're talking about statewide elections like US senate, that can be also broken down
- 10:57into counties and precincts because all the counties and precincts are voting for that US
- 11:02senate candidate.
- 11:04But a mayor, obviously, can't be looked out through looked at through a statewide lens
- 11:09because that mayor is only for a county or only for a city.
- 11:14They only have a very small subset of that state that they are running for an election
- 11:20for.
- 11:20So you can't use a statewide lens for them.
- 11:23So more on those geographical units.
- 11:26States, normally, for statewide races like presidents, because, technically, presidents
- 11:31are statewide races because you have to win the electoral votes of each state or of all these
- 11:38states in order to get to two seventy to win the US presidency.
- 11:41US senate is always a statewide race.
- 11:44US house, if that state only has one US house rep, so those very sparsely populated states
- 11:51like Wyoming, for example, governor, which is statewide, a lot of other state executive
- 11:56offices like an attorney general.
- 11:58If your state votes on that, that is also gonna be statewide.
- 12:03Then you also have state legislative and congressional districts.
- 12:07So congressional districts, obviously, that US house rep can you can look at whether the
- 12:15ticket was split for them and then for the US senate because that US senate is going to be
- 12:20covering that congressional district as well.
- 12:24The county level, you can look at countywide races like some mayors because some counties do
- 12:28have mayors or a county commission.
- 12:32State legislative and congressional districts, if they cover whole counties, sometimes you'll
- 12:36see Congressional District one of whatever state might cover a whole county specifically
- 12:44or it might only cover part of that county, which can make split ticket analysis a little
- 12:49bit more convoluted and and difficult to do.
- 12:54There's also the city, so citywide races like some mayors or city councils.
- 13:00And then the most granular of all is precincts, and those precincts are how voters are divided
- 13:06into polling areas areas, excuse me, that they must go to on election day.
- 13:11So if you look at your voting ID or the sample ballot that you get in the mail, you will see,
- 13:19okay.
- 13:20This is my polling place right here.
- 13:23That's your precinct, and there'll be usually, like, a three digit number, like, one thirteen
- 13:28or three forty or something like that unless there's just that many precincts.
- 13:32And so and how each state does that, how each county does that, obviously, that's gonna
- 13:36differ considerably.
- 13:38But that's that's pretty much as granular as you can get those precincts.
- 13:43And then if you're looking at election results to see where these split ticketing occurrences
- 13:51are, there's this overall if you're if you're looking overall just simply at which way did
- 13:57this geographical unit go, you usually just do that by a solid coloring of red or blue, Red
- 14:03being Republican, blue being Democrat, or a different color like yellow is a lot you see a
- 14:09lot of times of a third party one somewhere.
- 14:12Or if it's for president and you have Nebraska and Maine, which can potentially split their
- 14:21electoral votes, they have a unique system where it's not winner take all.
- 14:25It's it's also splits up some electoral votes by congressional districts and which
- 14:31presidential candidate wins the most votes in those congressional districts.
- 14:35That might be purple.
- 14:38So those are usually solid colors just to show you, hey.
- 14:42This party won this county or this state.
- 14:47It's great for a quick analysis to see ultimately where candidates of the same party
- 14:52had similar or dissimilar success.
- 14:55If Donald Trump won x county, but well, I'll use my state for example.
- 15:03US senator Rick Scott, if he won those same counties, you can just see, okay, which of
- 15:08these counties are red because they're both Republican.
- 15:11However, this doesn't account for the granular details of percentages.
- 15:15So how much did these candidates win a county by or a state legislative district by?
- 15:23Then you can also look at it through the exact percentages of vote splits between candidates.
- 15:28So overall simple, where did this county or this other geographical unit go, and then the
- 15:34exact percentages of vote splits between candidates.
- 15:37And usually, that's done by different shades of red or blue.
- 15:41And so it'll be deeper or darker reds or blues if that party's candidate performed better
- 15:47there.
- 15:48So if a democrat wins, whatever county you wanna talk about, they won 60 to 40%, and then
- 15:55they won accounting right next to it by 80% to 20%.
- 16:01That county they won 80% of the vote in is going to be a deeper shade of blue.
- 16:06And these are this is great for diving into full details to see where these candidates
- 16:12should have improved relative to their party or just how well they did overall.
- 16:17However, this is very time consuming to do, and it's ultimately it's about winning places.
- 16:23Not necessarily if now, of course, if you lose a county and you're running for US senate,
- 16:29that's not necessarily gonna tank your your candidacy, but it'll probably make it a little
- 16:34bit more difficult, especially if it's a county that you were projected to win.
- 16:39Both methods are great depending on what you are trying to do.
- 16:42Some people just want the basic data.
- 16:44Your typical consumer of media just wants to say, okay, which states went red?
- 16:49Which states went blue?
- 16:50Which counties went red?
- 16:51Which counties went blue?
- 16:53Which legislative districts went red or blue?
- 16:57And then some people want the full details like a campaigning organization.
- 17:01They're gonna need the full details for their own campaigns so that they know they can try to
- 17:07compare strategies to see, okay.
- 17:09This candidate did this thing, and this is how much of the vote they got in this county.
- 17:14Maybe our candidate needs to do that, or maybe our candidate needs to do something different,
- 17:18or does our candidate even have a chance at this county?
- 17:22Things like that.
- 17:23So really just depends on who your audience is.
- 17:26Both ways can be useful for studying split ticket voting.
- 17:31Of course, as always in politics and the study of politics, there are some factors that
- 17:37complicate and limit our split ticket analysis.
- 17:42Some places will see higher or lower frequencies in split ticket voting beyond just
- 17:47the simple who are people wanting to vote for.
- 17:51So some factors to look at is the timing of some elections.
- 17:54So some elections only happen in midterm years or only in presidential elections or only in
- 18:00odd numbered years or any non November month.
- 18:03So if you want to look at splits in presidential elections versus gubernatorial
- 18:11elections, most gubernatorial elections are governor only happen during midterm years, so
- 18:18you can't compare them a whole lot to the presidency.
- 18:23You you would have them split by two years, and that's not exactly a very comparable one to one
- 18:29ratio.
- 18:30Split ticketing, you're looking at the same year.
- 18:34And ticket splitting might fluctuate in midterms compared to presidential elections in
- 18:38some states anyways because not just because of the different contests on the ballot, like we
- 18:43said, most governors, they get elected in midterms, but also the different kinds of
- 18:49voters turning out.
- 18:51You can generally bet those people who show up in midterms, they're probably gonna show up in
- 18:56a presidential election.
- 18:58A lot of the people that show up at a presidential election aren't gonna show up in a
- 19:01midterm because a lot of them only care about the presidential election, or they don't even
- 19:06know that a midterm is going on, or they find it more difficult to find information.
- 19:11Presidential elections always have higher turnout rates by voters than midterm elections
- 19:18do.
- 19:18And then midterm elections compared to odd numbered years typically have higher turnout
- 19:25rates as well.
- 19:26But you and you don't really have a whole lot of odd numbered year elections.
- 19:30Most of those are gonna be at the local level.
- 19:34And then also some states, like, for example, many state senates, they only have half the
- 19:40chamber up for election in one year, and then two years later, the other half are up for
- 19:48election.
- 19:49And that you don't see that for a whole lot of other places.
- 19:54Another thing that complicates split ticket voting analysis is the number of elections on a
- 20:01ballot.
- 20:02So in a similar vein to what we were just talking about.
- 20:05Some election days have many more contests on the ballot than other days do just partially
- 20:10depending on which offices the term for their elected official is up.
- 20:19And some state and local areas just generally have more elections than others.
- 20:23For example, if we talk about state executives like governor, an attorney general and
- 20:27secretary of state, a state like North Carolina has a lot more of those to vote on than a place
- 20:35like Alaska.
- 20:36North Carolina has, like, 10 state executives to vote on, whereas Alaska only has governor
- 20:42and lieutenant governor.
- 20:43So and also North Carolina has a bigger state legislature, more US house representatives.
- 20:49So North Carolina is inherently going to have more opportunities for split ticket voting than
- 20:56a place like Alaska is going to because North Carolina has a lot more offices that are up for
- 21:02election.
- 21:04Another issue is that there's a lack of competition in some areas.
- 21:09Many races, especially local ones, will only have one candidate running flat out, not just
- 21:15one party running, just one candidate completely.
- 21:18They are not challenged in a primary.
- 21:20They are not challenged in a general election.
- 21:22And in some cases, if the election gets decided in the primary because only one party is
- 21:28running candidates, they might just cancel the general election outright and just say, okay.
- 21:34We're not gonna do this because nobody else filed for the seat except for this one person.
- 21:38Another factor complicating split ticket voting analysis is states that do not track voter
- 21:44party affiliation.
- 21:45Most states have the party affiliation of voters, but some states just register their
- 21:52voters, and that's it.
- 21:53And the way that this complicates split ticket analysis is that knowing how many Republicans
- 21:59and Democrats and third party and unaffiliated voters there are, it helps for estimating the
- 22:05likelihood of ticket splitting.
- 22:08For example, you assume that ticket splitting is gonna happen more in a place where
- 22:12Democratic and Republican voters are relatively even or possibly if there's a lot of
- 22:17independence in that district or in that state.
- 22:22Another potential complication is that one race that is nonpartisan in one state or local area
- 22:29may be partisan in another state.
- 22:32Some state level or county judges run-in partisan elections.
- 22:36Other ones run-in a nonpartisan election.
- 22:39Some of them are appointed.
- 22:41School boards are another case where where that could happen.
- 22:46You can include nonpartisan races in a split ticket analysis.
- 22:50So if I were to say, I can't think of the states off the top of my head that do partisan
- 22:55races for school board.
- 22:56But if state a had was voting on president and had partisan school board races, you can't
- 23:02really compare to state b if school board races are nonpartisan because they're not partisan.
- 23:10So you can't look at ticket splitting.
- 23:12And lastly, amongst split ticket voters, you can't really see just how much tickets were
- 23:18split since we can't look at individual voters to see how the ballots split.
- 23:22So our our ability to see who heavily or lightly split their ticket is very limited.
- 23:30You can look at the percentages for candidates across the board and see how much they
- 23:34differed, like for a Republican presidential candidate versus a Republican US senate
- 23:39candidate versus a US house candidate.
- 23:42But, again, you can't necessarily tell, like, how many voters heavily split their ticket.
- 23:51So in that regard, it's a little bit limited, but that that's okay.
- 23:56I mean, there's still a lot that we can get out of split ticket analysis even with these
- 24:01potential complications.
- 24:02It's just they are things to keep in mind.
- 24:05So for the historical data, we're gonna look at a couple of different analyses and highlight
- 24:09them.
- 24:10My own and one from Ballotpedia, the Encyclopedia of American Politics, which I've
- 24:17mentioned before.
- 24:18Full disclosure, I used to work for them, but I'll always vouch for them and the work that
- 24:22they do.
- 24:22And both of these have their own strengths.
- 24:24They do something a little bit different from each other, but they both get at the same basic
- 24:30idea as how much split ticket voting is there.
- 24:34So my analysis.
- 24:36My analysis looks at instances where states votes for president, US senate, and governor
- 24:42were not all the same party.
- 24:43So I'm only counting just if if that state in that year voted different parties for any of
- 24:53those elections.
- 24:55So if if a for example, here in South Dakota, there was no split ticket voting here.
- 25:00There was not a presidential election that year, but I was checking to see if the governor
- 25:04and US Senate split or couple of other states like Utah here in 2016.
- 25:11So you can see this if you're on YouTube, but if you're on another place like Spotify or
- 25:15Apple Podcast, I will try to describe this as best as possible.
- 25:19And I'm looking only from 1854 onwards since that's when elections became democratic versus
- 25:24republican.
- 25:26And then also, had a split from 1959 onwards since that is when we had or when we became 50
- 25:33states.
- 25:34So each state is a little bit more comparable in that regard.
- 25:37But I also included midterms where it was just a US senate and and or a governor because I
- 25:45wanted to not just compare presidential elections.
- 25:48I wanted to see, okay, in midterm elections or maybe an odd numbered years, was there a split
- 25:55ticket occurrence?
- 25:56So this is looking at every single year.
- 26:00And special elections that might have been in the same year, but possibly not on the same
- 26:05exact date as the regular elections, there might be a couple of those here.
- 26:09But as far as I know, not don't that's not the case for any of these.
- 26:13And in any case that those are very few of those cases anyways.
- 26:18So the exact results on average per state since 1854, there have been 12 to 13 instances of
- 26:26ticket splitting.
- 26:28And then since 1959, that number was closer to eight.
- 26:32Obviously, much less time in that regard.
- 26:35So the average times that you've seen ticket splitting is gonna be a lot less than if you
- 26:40count another extra hundred years.
- 26:44The lowest five states in terms of total ticket splitting instances, Hawaii had four years
- 26:53where they had ticket splitting.
- 26:55Mississippi also had four.
- 26:57Kentucky had five.
- 26:58Virginia had five, and Texas had seven.
- 27:02And for the highest five, actually six because there were two tied for five or for fifth
- 27:09place, excuse me, In terms of total splits or ticket splitting instances, Massachusetts had
- 27:1723 of those instances.
- 27:19North Dakota had 21.
- 27:21Minnesota had 20.
- 27:22Montana had 20.
- 27:24Maine had 19, and New Hampshire had 19 as well.
- 27:29And then if we take just splits from 1959 onwards, the lowest five, Kentucky,
- 27:36Mississippi, and Virginia were tied for first with three, and then Hawaii, New Jersey, Texas,
- 27:43and Utah were tied for fourth with four ticket splitting instances.
- 27:48And then on the high end, we have in terms of since 1959 again, the most ticket splitting
- 27:55instances was Vermont with 17.
- 27:58That was followed by New Hampshire with 14, Maine with 13, Montana with 13, and then
- 28:04Massachusetts, North Dakota, Rhode Island, Nevada, and Arkansas had 11.
- 28:10Now if we want to look at it in decades, not necessarily by state, there were very few
- 28:15states that had ticket splitting instances in a given year in the second half of the eighteen
- 28:21hundreds.
- 28:21In fact, there's only two times it happened in the eighteen fifties, although again, that's
- 28:26when the Republican Party came into existence.
- 28:28So I didn't account for Whigs versus Democrats, for example, and also partly because there were
- 28:35fewer states in the union at that time.
- 28:38But it started to climb up a little bit through the nineteen hundreds, the nineteen teens, the
- 28:46nineteen twenties, nineteen thirties, and then it got up higher in the nineteen forties and
- 28:51nineteen fifties, and then really reached the high watermark in the sixties, seventies, and
- 28:56eighties, nineties, and February, the odds started to go back down a little bit.
- 29:02And then in the twenty tens, twenty teens, and the twenty twenties, it has come down a lot
- 29:10more.
- 29:10So split ticket voting by decade has steadily climbed up, up, up, up into the seventies and
- 29:18eighties thereabouts, sixties, seventies, and eighties, and has trended downward since then,
- 29:25especially dropping dramatically in the twenty tens and twenty twenties, at least so far.
- 29:30Maybe the rest of the decade will show something a little bit different.
- 29:34And now for ballot pedia's analysis, and they have a nifty little chart for you to look at
- 29:38here.
- 29:39They look at presidential elections only from 1916 to 2024, and they call these mixed party
- 29:45election outcomes.
- 29:47They take which party won that state for president and then sees if a different party or
- 29:53not won a US senate seat, a majority of the state's US house delegation, a state senate
- 29:59majority, or state house majority in that state, and they count each time that that
- 30:05occurred.
- 30:06Whereas my analysis was just looking to see if a split ticket voting instance occurred in that
- 30:12state in that year.
- 30:14Yes or no.
- 30:15This is looking at the specific times or the number of times rather that this has happened
- 30:21in in Ballipedia's analysis.
- 30:23So the general results is there's a general trend up and down trending upward from about
- 30:30the 1920s to the 1980s, then dropping off quite a bit in the nineties and early two thousands,
- 30:37and then really dropping off in the last ten, fifteen years.
- 30:44Almost every year here had 160 to 170 potential outcomes for mixed party results.
- 30:51For example, if that state had a US senate seat up in that year or if the US house delegation
- 30:58was not an even number so that you could win a majority of that US house delegation for a
- 31:04given state.
- 31:05So in 2024, what if a state voted for Donald Trump for president as a republican or if it
- 31:12voted for Kamala Harris as a democrat, These are all the instances where a US senate seat,
- 31:21majority of a US house delegation, majority of a state senate, or majority of a state house
- 31:25went the opposite direction.
- 31:27For the US house delegations, we mean for a specific state.
- 31:30So anytime I talk about a mixed party election outcome on this ballotpedia analysis, it's
- 31:36talking about anytime that the party that won a state for the US presidency, how that state
- 31:42differed in how it voted for US senate, US house majority delegation, state senate
- 31:48majority, state house majority.
- 31:50Those are always compared to which party won that state for president.
- 31:54So when it comes to US senate, there were the lowest or excuse me, the fewest instances of
- 32:03mixed party election outcomes was zero in 2016.
- 32:07On the high end, there were 17 mixed party election outcomes for US senate in 1972, 1984,
- 32:15and 1988.
- 32:16When it comes to US house delegation majorities, On the low end, there was one mixed
- 32:23party outcome in 1920 and '9 and 2024.
- 32:27And on the high end, there were 28 mixed party outcomes in 1984 for The US House.
- 32:36For state senate majorities, there were two mixed party election outcomes in 1920 and 2024.
- 32:44And on the high end, there were 24 mixed party election outcomes for state senate majorities
- 32:50in 1984.
- 32:54And then lastly, for state house majorities, there were two mixed party election outcomes in
- 33:021924, 2016, and 2024.
- 33:07And on the high end, there were 28 mixed party election outcomes for state house majorities in
- 33:131984.
- 33:14Now finally, percentage total here where the percentage of total possibilities that there
- 33:20could have been a mixed party election outcome, how many times was there a mixed party election
- 33:26outcome?
- 33:26And that's counting all the instances for US senate, US house, state senate majorities, and
- 33:33state house majorities.
- 33:35And in 1920 was the lowest percentage of mixed party election outcomes with 4.3.
- 33:44And on the high end, 1984, where there was 58.4% of the time that there could have been a
- 33:51mixed party election outcome, there was a mixed party election outcome.
- 33:55Now as for which states had the fewest and most mixed party election outcomes for that whole
- 34:05time frame of 1916 to 2024, the top five states mixed party election outcomes from 1916 to
- 34:132024.
- 34:14Oklahoma had 43.
- 34:18Florida had 42.
- 34:19Tennessee had 40.
- 34:21Oregon had 39, and Nevada had 38.
- 34:25And then on the low end, the five the states with the five fewest times that there were
- 34:30mixed party election outcomes from 1916 to 2024, Nebraska with six, and that's partly
- 34:36because it only has a state senate.
- 34:39There is no state house in Nebraska, and, also, that state senate is nonpartisan.
- 34:44So there's inherently much fewer opportunities for mixed party election outcomes and split
- 34:50ticket voting in Nebraska than there is in most other states.
- 34:56So Nebraska was the fewest with six mixed party election outcomes from 1916 to 2024.
- 35:02Utah was next with seven.
- 35:05Alabama was next with eight, Maryland was next with nine, and then Mississippi at fifth with
- 35:1310.
- 35:13So what are the big takeaways overall with split ticket voting from both of those
- 35:18analyses?
- 35:18The differences being I used governorships and every year from 1854 to the present, so that's
- 35:26including odd numbered years and midterm elections.
- 35:28Ballotpedia used majorities of US house delegations, state house majorities, and state
- 35:34senate majorities, and only presidential election years.
- 35:37Both of them have their own strengths.
- 35:39And, also, I'm just counting if there was a split ticket occurrence at all in a year, not
- 35:45counting the number of times that a ticket was split.
- 35:48And Ballipedia has counted the number of times within a year that a party won the presidency,
- 35:52but a different party won something else that they were measuring.
- 35:56But despite the differences, the analyses more or less find the same general trend in that
- 36:02there was very little ticket splitting in the very early nineteen hundreds, started to climb
- 36:06up a little bit in the nineteen twenties and the nineteen forties, climbing up again in the
- 36:10nineteen fifties and nineteen sixties, and the highest marks in the seventies and eighties or
- 36:15maybe even the sixties as well dropped down quite a bit in the nineteen nineties and
- 36:19February and then really dropped off afterwards to the low rates of split ticket voting that we
- 36:25see today.
- 36:28Speaking of today, let's look at the twenty twenty four election specifically using my
- 36:32analysis and Ballipedias.
- 36:34Again, quick recap.
- 36:36Mine is seeing if there was a split at all in a year between presidential US senate and vote,
- 36:42the governor vote in a state.
- 36:44Ballipedia is looking at which offices out of the US senate, US house delegation majority,
- 36:50state house majority, and state senate majority differed from the presidential vote.
- 36:55Whichever analyses you use, whether it's mine or Ballipedias or another one, you're gonna
- 36:59find little ticket splitting in 2024, at least compared to previous years, most previous
- 37:05years.
- 37:07In my analysis, there were seven states where there was a split ticket occurrence between
- 37:11president, US senate, and or governor.
- 37:15Those were Arizona, Michigan, Nevada, New Hampshire, North Carolina, Vermont, and
- 37:21Wisconsin.
- 37:22In Arizona, Michigan, Nevada, and Wisconsin's case, they voted Democratic for US Senate and
- 37:28then Republican for president.
- 37:31In New Hampshire, it was a Republican for governor and a Democrat for president.
- 37:35North Carolina was a democrat for governor and republican for president.
- 37:39And then in Vermont, it was republican for governor, independent for US senate, and
- 37:43democrat for president.
- 37:46And then in Ballipedia's analysis, there were five states where there was a split ticket for
- 37:51president and at least one of those other offices they looked at, US senate, US house
- 37:57delegation majority, state house majority, and state senate majority.
- 38:00And those five states were Arizona, Michigan, Nevada, New Hampshire, and Wisconsin.
- 38:06And in Nevada, that led with four mixed party outcomes where it voted Republican for
- 38:11president, but Democratic for US senate, US house delegation majority, state house
- 38:17majority, state senate majority.
- 38:19New Hampshire had two mixed party election outcomes, democrat for president, republican
- 38:25for state house, and state senate majority.
- 38:28And in Arizona, Michigan, and Wisconsin, there was one mixed party outcome where they voted
- 38:32republican for president, but then Democrat for US Senate.
- 38:37So anyway you cut it, split ticket voting has gone down quite a bit in the past ten to
- 38:45fifteen years.
- 38:45The high watermarks were the sixties, seventies, eighties, that that general time
- 38:51frame, and then really coming down a lot since then.
- 38:57So that leads us to talking about the future of split ticket voting.
- 39:03And here, I wanna be careful and not say voting straight party is inherently wrong.
- 39:09I'm I try to keep my opinions out as much as possible.
- 39:13It's not the whole voting straight party that I think is a problem.
- 39:19And it's not because of what I personally think or don't think about the parties or
- 39:23independence or anything like that.
- 39:25It's about my concerns about tribalism, groupthink, staying within our silos, and never
- 39:32entertaining other possibilities, never branching out.
- 39:35We can't grow personally or collectively if we don't at least hear what other people have to
- 39:41say or think about how to do things in a different way and at least say, okay, maybe
- 39:47I'll do something a little bit different.
- 39:49So not if if you come to the conclusion on your own that I need to vote straight party because
- 39:56I think all these candidates are are for this party are better than you do you.
- 40:02I just have a concern about just voting for them because they're that party.
- 40:08I think that is a problem.
- 40:11But it's not doesn't matter if it's democrat or republican or for independents.
- 40:16Just voting independent doesn't inherently make things better either.
- 40:21Try to look beyond what's that affiliation is.
- 40:25So split ticket voting is not dead, but it is concerning how infrequent it has become, and
- 40:31especially during Donald Trump's terms in office and even between his terms in office.
- 40:37By some measures, split ticket voting has not been this low in a century, and it's become
- 40:44increasingly common to see if you look at geographical maps of voting along Democratic
- 40:50and Republican lines for different offices, They look quite similar in a lot of cases.
- 40:57Like, if you look at a lot of US senate voting maps compared to the presidential voting map,
- 41:02there is a lot of similarities there.
- 41:04There's a lot of similarities in how the counties vote and in how the state legislative
- 41:09districts vote.
- 41:09But split ticketing is still there, and it's it's still going to exist somewhere.
- 41:15It it it has to.
- 41:16There's just it's too diverse of a country that we have here where it's all going to be one
- 41:24party the exact same way across all of these elections.
- 41:29Some precincts and counties and states are just going to demonstrate that.
- 41:32Sometimes you won't really notice it with the states, but you will still see it with some
- 41:37precincts and counties.
- 41:39And in some odd numbered years, sure, there will be often very little tickets splitting,
- 41:44but that's because there's also much fewer offices that are up for election then.
- 41:50And so midterms and presidential elections will have the bulk of ticket splitting, but some
- 41:54ticket splitting analyses don't use odd numbered years anyways.
- 41:58They just look at midterms and presidential elections if they even look at midterms.
- 42:04The more appropriate question is not if ticket splitting still exists because it does still
- 42:09exist, but it's more if and when split ticket voting will start to go back up.
- 42:15Will unaffiliated voters become a more potent force in swinging elections toward multiple
- 42:20party paths?
- 42:21Some independents split their tickets.
- 42:25Some still vote for one party like you would expect from maybe some strongly affiliated
- 42:33Republicans and Democrats.
- 42:36Will third parties become more competitive and refer I'll refer again to my previous episode
- 42:42that I had, which was about third party competitiveness and whether there's a realistic
- 42:47chance of them becoming more strongly competitive in the near future.
- 42:52And, also, regardless of that, the Democratic and Republican parties are remarkably adaptive.
- 43:01I mean, they've they've been around for a hundred seventy.
- 43:05Well, the Republican Party's been around for a hundred seventy years.
- 43:08Democratic Party has actually been around since almost since the founding of this country.
- 43:13But the parties are remarkably adaptive to this ever changing political landscape as a whole.
- 43:19One may be a little slower to adapt to the times, but eventually they do.
- 43:25And then the other one starts to fall behind, and it kind of goes in in a in a cycle.
- 43:30It's done that several different times.
- 43:32So in short, I think ticket splitting will definitively go back up eventually.
- 43:38I mean, it can't go much further down than it has now, but it might take a couple elections.
- 43:44It might not be till after Donald Trump leaves office Given how unified Republicans have been
- 43:50for him and Democrats have been against him, might take a little while for that ticket
- 43:55splitting to pick back up again.
- 43:57But at some point, party realignments are going to happen again, and party realignments refer
- 44:02to fluctuations in which demographics make up which party.
- 44:06So racial lines, religious lines, gender lines, for example.
- 44:12If that party realignment hasn't happened now, some people say that Donald Trump has realigned
- 44:17the parties.
- 44:18That's that's a topic for another episode.
- 44:21But in any case, ticket splitting might take a little bit to come back up, but I think it will
- 44:30at some point.
- 44:32So is Ticketsplain dead?
- 44:34No.
- 44:35But, hopefully, it will start to go back up at least a little bit in the near future, if only
- 44:42just because we don't want too much tribalism and groupthink going on, but we shall see.
- 44:52But that's gonna do it for today's episode of the podcast.
- 44:55As always, thank you so much for listening.
- 44:57Please like, comment, subscribe, and share the podcast.
- 45:02Links in the show notes, my Facebook, Paul Raider author and speaker, my LinkedIn profile,
- 45:08my medium.com profile where I post about local science from time to time, including for these
- 45:14episodes.
- 45:16My matchmaker FM profile if you want to potentially be a guest on this podcast or have
- 45:21me as a guest on your podcast, and my educational email course about how we can more
- 45:28effectively depolarize American politics, and my email,
- 45:33PaulRaiderwritesasinwriting@Gmail.com.
- 45:39And that is gonna do it.
- 45:41So as always, thank you again, and until next time.
- 45:45Take care.