Latest / The Fourcast / Will Donald Trump be an ‘authoritarian’ in power? | The American Fourcast
Transcript
- 0:00We are going to see a Trump who is unleashed in this
- 0:03administration, who has fewer wise advisors around him, who
- 0:07has a deep sense of vengeance and who has a court majority
- 0:10basically, that will probably aid and abet his decisions.
- 0:14The Democrats have to look reality in the face this time
- 0:17and recognize that this is the result that Americans wanted and
- 0:23they need to offer something more appealing to the American
- 0:26people if they want to win election.
- 0:27In his about victory speech, he spent a good chunk of time
- 0:31talking about Elon Musk and his SpaceX rocket ship, so I think
- 0:34he's going to begin to reward those people who he saw as his
- 0:38supporters. Is he an authoritarian?
- 0:41Is that what America's Got now as a president?
- 0:49Well, welcome to this latest edition of The American
- 0:52Forecaster with me, my two guests, Molly Ball from The Wall
- 0:55Street Journal, Christine Amber from The Atlantic.
- 0:57Thanks, both of you for making this time.
- 1:00Did you get any sleep, Christine?
- 1:02I actually did get a little bit of sleep.
- 1:04I'm awake this morning and it seems that Donald Trump will be
- 1:07our next president. These are words, Molly, that
- 1:11most people that I spoke to, even if they were going to vote
- 1:14for him, never thought they would actually be uttering on
- 1:17Wednesday morning. Which is odd because you know,
- 1:21this is not that shocking of a result.
- 1:23If you were following the polls and believing what they said,
- 1:27you know it, it was always likely that one or the other of
- 1:31these two candidates would sweep all of the swing states by a
- 1:34narrow margin. And that is indeed what Donald
- 1:37Trump appears to have done. And that is very much in line
- 1:41with what the polls were telling us going into the election where
- 1:45the candidates were basically tied within the margin of error
- 1:48in all of the swing states. Did you expect him to win the
- 1:51popular vote, Molly? I try not to have expectations
- 1:55or make predictions about politics, but again, that that
- 1:57is a result that is basically in line with what the polls were
- 2:00telling us, which was that this was a a, a close race within the
- 2:03margin of error. Christine, what really surprised
- 2:05me is that as the exit polls, you know, emerged overnight, one
- 2:08of the biggest concerns in a whole number of swing states was
- 2:11the issue of democracy. And I kind of interpreted that
- 2:15to mean a vote against Donald Trump for Kamala Harris.
- 2:19It turns out I was wrong. Yeah, No, I think that was a
- 2:22result that surprised a lot of people.
- 2:24And I think we'll have woken many people up.
- 2:27You know, yes, the concern for democracy was was great on, you
- 2:31know, the liberal side. On the democratic side, it was
- 2:34clearly the idea that Donald Trump was an autocrat, a
- 2:37fascist. That was the message.
- 2:40But I think many commentators forgot to think about the other
- 2:44side who were also hearing this message about democracy.
- 2:48You know, when Joe Rogan endorsed Donald Trump the day
- 2:52before the election in conversation with Elon Musk,
- 2:55their conversation centered around how if Kamala Harris was
- 2:58elected president, there would be no more elections.
- 3:01They were accusing the other side of communism, socialism, of
- 3:05destroying the American state. So there were concerns about
- 3:08democracy on on the Republican side, too.
- 3:12Were they well founded? I mean, we'll see.
- 3:14But democracy can mean very different things to different
- 3:18people. And I just want to under score
- 3:20that because, you know, we don't want to read too much into exit
- 3:22polls, but I'm looking right now at the CNN exit poll.
- 3:27And they asked, they asked the voters how, how, how threatened.
- 3:32Do you believe democracy in the United States is secure or
- 3:35threatened? A plurality of voters, 38%, said
- 3:38democracy in the US is very threatened.
- 3:40Trump won those voters 50 to 48%.
- 3:44So, and, and I think if you had been listening to Republican
- 3:47voters, if you've been listening to Trump voters over the last,
- 3:50over the course of this campaign, you would know, as
- 3:52Christine said, that they too harbored these deep concerns
- 3:55about the future of democracy. I mean, I spent quite a bit of
- 3:58time in Pennsylvania, as have most of us in the last few
- 4:01weeks. And it was so interesting going
- 4:03to, you know, a Trump event and the Harris event.
- 4:06And you ask them that open question, you know, what's the
- 4:08what's at stake for you in America?
- 4:10And you're right, Christine, both sides would say what's at
- 4:13stake is the future of democracy.
- 4:15And you think, hang on a minute. I thought that was the line the
- 4:17Democrats use, but actually turns out Republicans use that
- 4:20line as well. What about abortion?
- 4:22Because again, people assumed that reproductive rights, Roe V.
- 4:27Wade, being overturned by the Supreme Court would be something
- 4:30that would drive women to the polls in such huge numbers that
- 4:33there was no way that Trump could win.
- 4:35Obviously, Christine, that didn't happen.
- 4:37Yeah, obviously. I mean, I think Democrats banked
- 4:40on that as a really, really galvanizing issue.
- 4:44A lot of their ads spend focused on, you know, these these
- 4:47terrifying and sad stories of women whose lives were lost or
- 4:50who were irreparably harmed by not being able to get
- 4:52reproductive care. And while those were affecting,
- 4:56they did tend to be a heavily gendered message.
- 4:59And, you know, I think that they were messages that, while heart
- 5:03wrenching, didn't necessarily address what, again, the exit
- 5:06polls told us were the core concerns of voters, You know,
- 5:09this question of democracy and also, frankly, just the economy.
- 5:13As, you know, past politicians have said often, it's the
- 5:15economy, stupid. And maybe that is something that
- 5:17the Democrats should have spent more time on, simply because
- 5:20that was closer to hand for a wider swath of voters.
- 5:24Molly, I can't tell you how many podcasts I listened to where,
- 5:27you know, both men and women were saying, well, if you if you
- 5:30rely on men for your victory, you're in big trouble because
- 5:33you know, the Bros, the blokes never get off the sofa, you
- 5:35know, to actually do what they're supposed to be doing,
- 5:37which is cast a ballot. It turns out that they did, you
- 5:40know, and they could. And they are a force in
- 5:42politics. And one shouldn't be surprised
- 5:44by that. We saw what we usually see,
- 5:46which is a, a disproportionately female electorate, about 53% of
- 5:49the electorate was women and Harris won women, but while
- 5:53Trump won men by about equivalent margins to about 10
- 5:56point margins. So in fact this likely will not
- 5:58be a historic gender gap. It is about in line with what we
- 6:02have seen. So I, I think as, as Christine
- 6:04was saying, while while we did see a gender gap in these
- 6:08numbers, it was not as extreme as Democrats hoped, They were
- 6:11not able to really drive up either the turn out or the level
- 6:14of her support among women beyond where it would sort of
- 6:17naturally be in the course of of regular partisan politics.
- 6:21Christine, there are people who worked for Trump and described
- 6:26him as a fascist. Most importantly, John Kelly,
- 6:29his former chief of staff, like merely the, you know, the the
- 6:32the country's top soldier said this guy's dangerous.
- 6:35He's a wannabe dictator. Plenty of people on the campaign
- 6:38trail said it. You know, as you said earlier,
- 6:40the end of democracy was something that Democrats kind
- 6:43of, you know, baked into their campaign.
- 6:46Do you think that that language combined with the charges
- 6:51against him in the courts was overstepping the land?
- 6:55And actually, that was far more damaging to the Harris campaign
- 6:58in the end than the Trump campaign because people, many
- 7:01ordinary Americans, saw that, you know, it's just hysteria or
- 7:05in the case of the courts, an infringement on, you know,
- 7:08individual rights. You know, I'm not sure that the
- 7:11language was overstepping the line in in that many of those,
- 7:15you know, generals and former Trump employees were just
- 7:19repeating the words that he himself said.
- 7:21But you, you have to wonder if Democrats maybe over relied on
- 7:27on that case. You know, they also have relied
- 7:29on it in the past. They've sort of been banging
- 7:31the, you know, Trump is bad for democracy, democracy is on the
- 7:36ballot, etcetera, drum for the past 2 elections and eventually
- 7:41it becomes a little bit of a boy who cried wolf situation, right?
- 7:44Trump was president. Contrary to, you know, some of
- 7:48the more extreme claims of the Democratic Party, America did
- 7:52not completely collapse. So saying that again just
- 7:56doesn't have quite the same punch as it might have if it
- 7:59were the first time. But let's be clear.
- 8:02I mean, you know, Trump as anyone as well as anyone else
- 8:05does. You know, we've all read the
- 8:06stuff. We all know what he did in his
- 8:08first administration. We remember those quotes on the
- 8:11campaign. Is he an authoritarian?
- 8:14Is that what America's Got now as a president?
- 8:18I mean, I think we're going to have to see whether he lives up
- 8:23to the statements that he made. You know, he's not actually
- 8:25famous for living up to what he has said he will do.
- 8:30That's not something Trump is known for.
- 8:32But I think we are going to see a Trump who is unleashed in this
- 8:36administration, who has fewer wise advisers around him, who
- 8:40has a deep sense of vengeance and who has a court majority
- 8:44basically, that will probably aid and abet his decisions.
- 8:49What that actually looks like day-to-day, we'll see.
- 8:51But I'm I'm not optimistic. Right, Molly, What about you?
- 8:56The Supreme Court has handed him any president, whatever they're
- 9:00called, extraordinary powers. Does that worry you?
- 9:03I think, you know, Trump has made very clear that he has
- 9:08little respect for the historic norms that have governed our
- 9:11politics or the institution. In fact, much of his his his
- 9:15sort of pitch to voters was that he viewed these institutions and
- 9:19as rotten and corrupt and promised to smash them.
- 9:22So I think there's very little doubt that he will, for example,
- 9:25fire the head of the FBI and the special counsel and make the
- 9:29criminal cases still standing against him go away.
- 9:32The Supreme Court, as Christine said, has helped clear the way
- 9:35for him to do that by establishing a, a broad right of
- 9:38immunity for him and for all presidents going forward.
- 9:42I think it's up to the scholars and, and, and, and the study,
- 9:46those who study semantics to decide what constitutes an
- 9:50authoritarian. But, but I think he certainly is
- 9:53poised to govern in a way that contradicts a lot of people's
- 9:57assumptions about what ought to be the guardrails on the
- 10:00presidency. And certainly he did that last
- 10:02time as well. And as Christine said there
- 10:04there will be far fewer restraints on him this time
- 10:06around. Let me ask this in a very
- 10:08delicate way, Christine. We've spoken a lot over the last
- 10:11few months and I remember your your criticism of Trump being
- 10:14quite trenchant. Is there a do I detect a hint of
- 10:18maybe self restraint in what you're saying to me this morning
- 10:21after his victory? You know, I wouldn't say that my
- 10:24criticism today is is less trenchant than it has been in
- 10:27the past. I think, you know, we're all
- 10:28waking up this morning to a new result.
- 10:32Results are still trickling in. Votes are still being counted.
- 10:36And until we have more information, I think it will be
- 10:39difficult to make conclusive statements about what the next
- 10:42administration will look like. And I do want to be respectful
- 10:45of the information that we have and not leap ahead of the fact.
- 10:49But we can make some, you know, assumptions or conjectures based
- 10:54on Trump's past behavior, based on past politics.
- 10:58That said, we're also seeing some of the expectations that we
- 11:01had for, you know, this election, for the next 4 years
- 11:04perhaps being upended. And I think we have to hold back
- 11:07until we see what's really going on.
- 11:09Just briefly on this point, I interviewed Fiona Hill a few
- 11:12months ago, who of course was, you know, Russia, the Russia
- 11:16expert both in the Bush administration, then the Obama
- 11:19administration, then the Trump administration.
- 11:21She was one of the star witnesses in the, you know, the,
- 11:24the, the Russia interference hearings on the Hill.
- 11:28And she said that if Trump gets re elected, she is afraid of
- 11:31getting a knock on the door one day of being hounded by Trump's
- 11:35administration. Do you think that's an
- 11:38unreasonable fear, Christine? You know, I actually don't it's
- 11:43it's interesting as you know, I was on the IDN doing commentary
- 11:46with a number of people, including Stormy Daniels, and
- 11:49she made an actual non joke that, you know, she was worried
- 11:55that in the next Trump administration she would be
- 11:58arrested again. She joked that she would be able
- 12:00to complete her set of four different mug shots.
- 12:03But she was very clear that she expected Trump to come after her
- 12:06if he had the power to win and come after more of his enemies.
- 12:08I don't actually think that that's an unfair to need to
- 12:11think at all. It's what he said he would do.
- 12:13And that, I think is the is the point is that this isn't some
- 12:16kind of, you know, liberal conjecture.
- 12:18This is a these are explicit promises that Trump has made.
- 12:21Now, maybe it's bluster, maybe he's not being serious.
- 12:24I think a lot of his supporters don't necessarily take all of
- 12:28his his many threats seriously. But he has said that, for
- 12:32example, he believes that Liz Cheney belongs in front of a
- 12:35military tribunal. He has said he plans to
- 12:38refashion the Justice Department into an instrument of of his
- 12:41will and prosecute his enemies. Many of his supporters have said
- 12:44that one of his and their regrets from his first
- 12:47presidency is that after promising to lock up Hillary
- 12:50Clinton, he didn't actually do it.
- 12:53So, so these are not why this is not wild speculation.
- 12:57This is based on the, you know, the reporting and on the things
- 13:00that Trump himself has promised. What are the three things you
- 13:03expect him to do as soon as he gets back into that White House?
- 13:07I think this idea of beginning to dismantle and weaponize the
- 13:10the Justice Department is going to be one of the first things
- 13:13that he does in parts that he can do away with any guardrails
- 13:17against him and any cases that are still lingering against him.
- 13:21I can see him installing kind of immediately some of his boosters
- 13:25and supporters. You know, even in his victory
- 13:28speech last night, apparently he spent a good chunk of time
- 13:31talking about Elon Musk and his SpaceX rocket ship.
- 13:35So I think he's going to begin to reward those people who he
- 13:39saw as his supporters. So that would be perhaps the
- 13:41flip side of weaponizing things against his enemies.
- 13:45And As for 1/3, I, I feel like we're going to see a real
- 13:52cleaning House of experts, frankly of long standing civil
- 13:59servants who may have worked for past administrations who Trump
- 14:01saw as contradicting him or not in favor of his policies and
- 14:06installing his friends. What about you, Molly?
- 14:10Three things he's going to do as soon as he gets in there.
- 14:13I think Christine's right about the Justice Department.
- 14:15That will absolutely be one of his top priorities, given how
- 14:18imperiled, you know, he has personally felt by these legal
- 14:21cases. He has promised to seal the
- 14:23border and deport unauthorized immigrants and Mass and his
- 14:28advisors and the people around him are quite serious about this
- 14:30and have drawn up plans for him to utilize executive authority
- 14:33to do that. He's promised a massive across
- 14:36the board tariffs. Many of the people around him
- 14:39and, and many of our readers on Wall Street, I believe that this
- 14:42is sort of an idle threat being used for leverage as a
- 14:45negotiating posture. And we will see if he's serious
- 14:48about it. But he has.
- 14:49He certainly says it in every single speech.
- 14:52And he has also promised that before he even takes office, he
- 14:55will have resolved the war in Ukraine.
- 14:59His critics believe that he intends to do that by brokering
- 15:04a deal that is favorable to Putin.
- 15:06We'll see what, if any, resolution he's able to bring to
- 15:09that, but that is certainly a top priority for him.
- 15:12You know, I think that Trump promises a return to
- 15:16instability. We're not sure what he's going
- 15:19to do. We're not sure what actions he's
- 15:21going to take. He does not necessarily act in a
- 15:25a reasonable or trackable or predictable manner.
- 15:28And uncertainty in this way is, is dangerous for financial
- 15:33markets, for international stability, for our allies
- 15:37continuing to remain our allies and rely on us and allow them to
- 15:40allow us to rely on them. Many Americans are feeling a lot
- 15:44of fear today. And you know, we asked this
- 15:47question in our final Wall Street Journal poll a couple of
- 15:51weeks ago. 87% of voters said they believe that the country
- 15:56would sustain permanent damage if their candidate did not
- 15:59prevail. And 57% of Kamala Harris
- 16:01supporters said the principal emotion that they would feel if
- 16:04Trump were elected was fear. With with, with smaller
- 16:09percentages saying that, you know, the sort of milder
- 16:12reactions of anger or disappointment that I think are
- 16:15are relatively normal when your side loses an election.
- 16:18This was an election that inspired massive turn out.
- 16:21People felt the stakes were very high.
- 16:22Over and over again, voters told me that this did not feel like a
- 16:26normal election to them. It felt like a sort of hinge
- 16:29point in history with everything at stake.
- 16:31So it is certainly the case that a lot of people in this country
- 16:34are feeling a sense of fear today.
- 16:36There are people all, you know, all over the world who will be
- 16:40saying, and some of them told me there's no way America will
- 16:44elect a black woman as president.
- 16:46You know, they didn't elect Hillary Clinton.
- 16:47They're not going to do that with Kamala Harris.
- 16:49It's just not going to happen. The country will never do that.
- 16:52And I said, don't be ridiculous. You know, they had a black
- 16:54president before we had the Prime Minister of color in the
- 16:57UK. You know, you're completely
- 16:59underestimating this country. You know, it's diverse, it's
- 17:02versatile and it, you know, and it's prepared to do this.
- 17:05I guess I was wrong, Molly. What does it say about this
- 17:08country that it can't elect a female president, little at one
- 17:12of color? Well, it hasn't.
- 17:15I don't know that that means it can't.
- 17:17I think there were so many factors that went into this
- 17:20that, you know, it's impossible for anyone to say definitively
- 17:25that that was the reason. Look, I think the fundamental
- 17:29dynamic, the story of this election, which is the same
- 17:32story you could have told a year ago or even two years ago, was
- 17:35that this, that the electorate wanted change and the Democrats
- 17:38refused to give it to them. And over and over and over
- 17:41again, people told pollsters by overwhelming margins they
- 17:45believe the country was on the wrong track.
- 17:47They did not like the way the administration was managing
- 17:50immigration. They did not like the way the
- 17:52administration was managing the border, Sorry, the immigration
- 17:56and, and inflation, the economy. And over and over again, you
- 18:01know, the, the administration, which includes Kamala Harris and
- 18:04who, and Kamala Harris, who said that she would not have done
- 18:07anything differently than Joe Biden has done.
- 18:10And the Democrats answer was to sort of say, well, we're right.
- 18:12And you just have to hang on and, and, and believe or, or to
- 18:16blame Donald Trump for it, for the problems that were occurring
- 18:19on their watch. So I think, you know, it's,
- 18:23it's, it's fundamentally unknowable whether the I, I I
- 18:27would also note, though, that Donald Trump again, did not do
- 18:30any worse with women than he has done in the past and did much
- 18:35better with minorities, with black and Latino voters than he
- 18:39has done in the past. So the idea that that was the
- 18:43major obstacle for all of those voters, it it certainly could
- 18:47still be the case, but it requires you to believe that it
- 18:50was a lot of of black voters and Women Voters who harboured those
- 18:53sentiments. Is is this a mistake that we, we
- 18:56reporters, those of us with emotions and opinions make?
- 19:00That we think that demography is destiny and it just isn't always
- 19:06or maybe even sometimes. Yeah, that's a great question.
- 19:10I think that this election is going to cause a real reckoning
- 19:15in sort of the media and analytical class.
- 19:18I think that over the past several years, especially in
- 19:21this election, we saw evidence of, you know, some real great
- 19:25divergences from the past, new coalitions forming.
- 19:29You couldn't take for granted necessarily the beliefs of black
- 19:32voters or female voters or male voters.
- 19:36And it does feel like the media didn't catch up in time.
- 19:39We saw some these shifts happening and assumed, well,
- 19:42Latinos will be mad at this or obviously black people will
- 19:45support a black candidate and that's just not necessarily the
- 19:48case anymore. So I think we have a lot of hard
- 19:51thinking to do ahead of us. If I could just defend the media
- 19:54for a moment, I think actually, you know, all of these phenomena
- 19:57were covered extensively in the media.
- 20:00It was the Democrats who said this isn't really happening.
- 20:03And despite the fact that hundreds of polls showed these
- 20:06shifts and and all kinds of anecdotal evidence was making
- 20:09clear that it was really happening, it was the Harris
- 20:11campaign and the Democrats who said over and over and over
- 20:14again, this isn't real and they got their comeuppance.
- 20:18That is the point. I'll take that defense of the
- 20:20media. Kristin, you first.
- 20:22What's going to happen to the Democratic Party now?
- 20:25Clearly the knives are already out, right?
- 20:27There's a lot of licking of wounds.
- 20:28There's a lot of blaming that's going on.
- 20:30What's going to happen to the party?
- 20:32Yeah, the knives are out. I'm wondering if we're going to
- 20:34see the fissures that were already visible in the party
- 20:37grow even deeper and see some real battling battling it out.
- 20:42You know, there were Democratic moderates.
- 20:44There were sort of the the party knows best.
- 20:46The the let's move forward with Joe Biden and then Kamala Harris
- 20:50wing of the party. There was also also a huge left
- 20:53resistance within the party who wanted to push back against the
- 20:58Biden policies on Israel, Gaza, which potentially lost Kamala
- 21:04Harris, a a lot of votes in a key swing state in Michigan.
- 21:08There were leftists who wanted much more attention paid to
- 21:14family care issues, worker care issues, yes, even stronger
- 21:18brands of feminism and sort of gender questions than the
- 21:22Democratic Party came or gave. And I, I don't know if there
- 21:28will be visible splits, if there will be new parties or new
- 21:32groups formed, but I think there is going to be a lot of internal
- 21:35anger. And I'm I'm interested to see
- 21:38where that goes and how that's translated into policy and
- 21:41statements moving forward. Molly, the the Democrats used to
- 21:45love to point to the Republicans and say, you have become, you
- 21:48know, the hostage to Donald Trump.
- 21:50It's, you know, it's a corporate takeover, you know, and you are
- 21:53now Trump's creatures. Well, that may be the case, but
- 21:56but that creatures also won an election, you know, with a
- 21:59resounding majority. The Democrats are far more
- 22:02divided, perhaps, than people gave them credit for at the
- 22:04time. You know, after Hillary Clinton
- 22:07lost, the Democrats, you know, went into resistance mode and
- 22:12spent the next four years freaking out constantly over
- 22:17Donald Trump. But it was possible for them to
- 22:18see him as a sort of freak accident, an aberration.
- 22:21He had not won the popular vote. He no one had expected him to
- 22:24win. So there and and and and the
- 22:26election was extremely close. So you could blame any number of
- 22:30sort of exogenous factors for this freak occurrence.
- 22:33That's not the case anymore. This election has delivered a
- 22:36mandate to Donald Trump as as you said, he has won the popular
- 22:40vote. He has won all of these swing
- 22:42states by by slim but healthy margins.
- 22:46And, and so I think the Democrats have to look reality
- 22:49in the face this time and recognize that this is the
- 22:53result that Americans wanted and they need to offer something
- 22:57more appealing to the American people if they want to win
- 22:59election. Indeed, I think Joe Biden
- 23:02described the first Trump administration as an apparent
- 23:05moment in American history. It turns out it wasn't.
- 23:08To both of you, Molly Ball of the Wall Street Journal,
- 23:11Christine Ember of The Atlantic, thank you very much for taking
- 23:14part in the American Forecast. Have a good day.
- 23:18Get some sleep.