Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Brad Edwards And His Affidavit In Support Of Epstein Related Transparency By The DOJ (Part 6)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up everyone, and welcome to another episode of the
- 0:02Epstein Chronicles. In this episode, we're going to pick up
- 0:05where we left off with the Brad Edwards CVR A
- 0:09Affid David. Another illustration of where the crime fraud misconduct
- 0:13exception could potentially apply is with regard to information that
- 0:17the government possesses that Matthew Minchell has a personal or
- 0:21business relationship with defending Jeffrey Epstein. This could potentially show
- 0:25misconduct by Menchell, and it also potentially a motive to
- 0:29violate the victim's rights. Has explained previously, the government's Privileged
- 0:33Log has numerous entries showing that Menchell was substantially and
- 0:37personally involved in making decisions related to the Epstein prosecution.
- 0:42Of the first Privilege log with regard to box number
- 0:46three P zero one one nine two three two P
- 0:50zero one one nine sixty six, the victims have information
- 0:53suggesting that immediately after leaving the employment with the US
- 0:57Attorney's Office, Menchell was associated with Epstein, can trolled entities
- 1:01or had some business relationship with them. The documents that
- 1:04the government possess showing a personal or business relationship between
- 1:08one of its prosecutors and the man who was charged
- 1:11with prosecuting should be produced. The government has admitted that
- 1:16its internal affairs component, the Office of Professional Responsibility, has
- 1:20collected information about possible improper behavior during the investigation of
- 1:24the Epstein matter. Government answers to RFA twenty two. The
- 1:29fact that the government's own investigating agencies have collected such
- 1:33information demonstrates that there is a prima fossee case of
- 1:37improper behavior which is enough to trigger the crime fraud misconduct.
- 1:41Exception to various privileges, factual materials not privileged. As noted
- 1:47in the accompanying legal memorandum, factual materials are generally not
- 1:51covered by the privileges at issue in the case, many
- 1:54of the material to which the government is asserting privilege
- 1:57are factual materials ver of the attorney client privilege. The
- 2:02government has asserted attorney client privilege regarding many documents. Yet
- 2:06with regard to most of these assertions, it's impossible to
- 2:09determine who is the attorney, who is the client, whether
- 2:12professional legal services are being rendered, and whether the communications
- 2:16were confidential to those involved in the delivery of legal services. Accordingly,
- 2:22it's very difficult for me to respond to many of
- 2:25the assertions of attorney client privilege, and in any event,
- 2:28the government has failed to carry its burden of showing
- 2:31that privilege applies. An illustration of documents at to which
- 2:36attorney client privilege appears to have been improperly asserted or
- 2:40inadequately described is found on page seven of the first
- 2:43privilege Log with regard to supplemental box number three. The
- 2:47entry for these twenty two pages of documents reads file
- 2:51folder entitled information Package Drafts, containing several descriptions. To see
- 2:56how the attorney client privilege applies to these documents, I
- 3:01could provide many other illustrations of the problem. The government's
- 3:04attorney client privilege claim directly covers situations where it was
- 3:08in a fiduciary relationship with the victims and therefore is
- 3:11limited in now asserting privilege. For example, page three of
- 3:16the supplemental Privilege Log contains an entry concerning a costa
- 3:21containing drafts of eleven thirty seven letters from Acosta to
- 3:26ken Starr and from j. Slowman to Jay Lefkowitz, performance
- 3:29and victim notification with handwritten notes and edits by Marie Villafauna.
- 3:35This information goes very directly to the issue involved in
- 3:38the case, as it goes directly to victim notification, Yet
- 3:41the government has asserted an attorney client privilege to prevent
- 3:45the victims from learning what's in these documents. The fiduciary
- 3:49exception to the attorney client privilege applies in this situation
- 3:53and limits the government's ability to invoke a privilege. This
- 3:57also appears to be shared communication between the government and
- 4:00Epstein's attorneys, and it's unclear how the attorney client privilege
- 4:04could ethically apply to such documents. As One example of
- 4:08why the victims have established a compelling need for material
- 4:11described in the preceding paragraph is the fact that the
- 4:14court has indicated that it will be considering an estoppel
- 4:18argument raised by the government as a defense in the case.
- 4:22The Court has noted that this argument implicates a fact sensitive,
- 4:25equitable defense which must be considered in the historical, factual
- 4:29context of the entire interface between Epstein, the relevant prosecutorial authorities,
- 4:35and the offense victims, including an assessment of the allegation
- 4:39of a deliberate conspiracy between Epstein and federal prosecutors to
- 4:43keep the victims in the dark. On the pendency of
- 4:47negotiation between Epstein and federal authorities until well after the
- 4:51fact and presentation of the non prosecution agreement to them
- 4:55was completed. The materials to which the government is asserting
- 4:59attorney client privilege go directly to that interface between the victims,
- 5:03the government, and Epstein. The victims have a compelling need
- 5:07for the information, and the fiduciary exception to the attorney
- 5:10client privilege applies to permit the court to provide these
- 5:13documents to the victims. The government has not explained any
- 5:17harm that would come from releasing the documents covered by
- 5:19attorney client privilege to the victims. If the government raises
- 5:23any such harm, I respectfully request an opportunity to provide
- 5:27additional information on that alleged arm deliberative process privilege. Some
- 5:33of the correspondents that is being withheld by the government
- 5:36under the deliberative process privilege concerns an investigation that the
- 5:39Justice Department's Office of Professional Responsibility opened with regard to
- 5:44the Epstein case. This investigation was undertaken at the request
- 5:48of the victims in the case. On December tenth, twenty ten,
- 5:51CO Council Professor Paul Cassel of the University of Utah
- 5:55College of Law and I met with US Attorney for
- 5:58the Southern District of Florida guarding this case in the
- 6:01US Attorney's office in Miami, Florida. On that date, Professor
- 6:06Cassell presented a letter to the US Attorney, Mister Ferrer,
- 6:10asking him to personally investigate what happened during the Epstein
- 6:13prosecution and how the victims were treated during that investigation
- 6:17based on the privileged log that has been provided as
- 6:20well as subsequent correspondence sent to Professor Cassell, That request
- 6:24for investigation was turned over to OPR in Washington. The
- 6:28ultimate outcome of the OPR investigation is unclear. What is
- 6:32clear is that many documents are being withheld about that investigation,
- 6:36documents that would go to the central issue in the case.
- 6:39Approximately three hoole pages of privileged log, Pages twelve through
- 6:44fourteen of the supplemental log relate to the OPR investigation
- 6:48of how the Epstein case was handled and how the
- 6:50victims were treated. A deliberative process privilege can only be
- 6:55asserted with regard to the process of reaching a decision,
- 6:59not the ultimate disay decision itself. The government here has
- 7:02apparently asserted a deliberative process claim over not only the
- 7:06OPR process, but also over the OPR decision. It's not
- 7:11clear which document embodies the final OPR decision, or, given
- 7:14the inadequacies of the government's log, whether that final decision
- 7:18has been produced. Given the limited description of the document
- 7:22that have been provided, it appears that the OPR decision
- 7:25may be reflected in a document found on page thirteen
- 7:29of the supplemental log. The description there reads draft letter
- 7:34marked confidential to be opened by addresses only Robin c
- 7:38Ashton to a Fredo Ferrar, with a handwritten correction. No
- 7:43dates provided regarding the letter, nor is there any indication
- 7:46as to whether the letter was or was not circulated
- 7:49to other persons. It is also noteworthy that this letter
- 7:52is described as a draft letter. Nowhere in the privileged
- 7:55log is the final version of that letter indicated, raising
- 7:58questions about what was draft and what was final. If
- 8:02this is the final embodiment of the opr's conclusions, then
- 8:05this letter would not be protected by process of privilege
- 8:08because the deliberations would have come to an end. It's
- 8:12also worth noting that because OPR is an agency that
- 8:15investigates misconduct by federal prosecutors, it would not be providing
- 8:20attorney client advice to prosecutors, and its documents would not
- 8:24be attorney client privileged with regard to, for example, the
- 8:27US Attorney's Office for the Southern District of Florida. The
- 8:31fact that OPR has investigated many of the exact claims
- 8:34raised by Jane do one and two and were able
- 8:36to gather documents unobstructed by the government in order to
- 8:40reach its conclusion likely means that production of the OPR
- 8:43file to the victims in this case could significantly shortcut
- 8:47this discovery process and the litigation. Additionally, if OPR needed
- 8:52the documents to investigate and make findings regarding the victim's claims,
- 8:56then logically the victims share that need and have no
- 8:59other mis means through which to obtain the documents. The
- 9:03government has not explained any harm that would come from
- 9:06releasing the documents covered by the process of privilege to
- 9:09the victims. If the government raises any such harm, I
- 9:13respectfully request an opportunity to provide additional information on that
- 9:17alleged harm. Investigative privilege. The investigative privilege is a qualified
- 9:23privilege which balances the need of a particular litigate for
- 9:26access to information against any public interest in non disclosure.
- 9:31That balancing process is ordinarily made with reference to factors
- 9:34discussed and Frankhauser vers Rizzo on the facts of this
- 9:39case favor way in favor of disclosing the information the
- 9:43victims have requested. With regard to factor one, the extent
- 9:47to which disclosure will thwart governmental process by discouraging citizens
- 9:51from giving the government information I presented for victims of
- 9:55Epstein's sex offenses in federal court Change No. Number one,
- 9:58Change No. Number two, and a victim I will refer
- 10:01to as SR and MJ and other victims of Jeffrey
- 10:06Epstein's abuse as well. If further information is disclosed about
- 10:10the case, that will not discourage them from providing information,
- 10:14but rather will encourage them. I have also talked personally
- 10:18the attorneys for a number of other victims in the case.
- 10:21I have been told that many of these victims hope
- 10:23that Jang Do one and Jane Do two are successful
- 10:26in their case. With regard to factor number two, the
- 10:30impact upon persons who have given information of having their
- 10:33identities disclosed. Jang Do one and Jane Do two are
- 10:36not asking for information that would identify any particular victim accordingly,
- 10:41there will be no effect on other victims. Additionally, I'm
- 10:44aware of the true names of many of Epstein's victims,
- 10:47and that information has not been disseminated to the public
- 10:50where those individual victims did not wish for their identities
- 10:54to be disseminated. All right, we're going to wrap up
- 10:57this episode right here, and in the next episode dealing
- 10:59with the topic, we're gonna pick up where we left off.
- 11:02All of the information that goes with this episode can
- 11:05be found in the description box.