Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Paul and Kyle Back Together Again, Ford vs. Duffy, Dealers vs. the Economy
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, good morning. It is Friday, September 11th. We all know this date. Uh, I'm Paul Jay. Daily's Kyle Mountseret, the Automotive State of the Union.
- 0:10We haven't even been together on a call in the last couple of weeks, so I, I'm actually just trying to get recalibrated to what it looks like to see Kyle on a call. And it look- Well, how are you, man? [laughs] I'm good.
- 0:22I'm good. Thank you for asking. It's good. Uh- It's good. It's good to be back together.
- 0:26We've had a, we've, we've done podcasts every day, but never been together, and it's been the weirdest thing, but good as well, you know? So. It has been good.
- 0:33And I have to say this, we both have this natural light because neither of us are in our, our, you know, like normal spot. And, and you look like you've aged a little since I've seen you last.
- 0:42[laughs] Bro, I think I got, like, eight years on myself, uh, with this beard the way it's looking right now. The natural light, the camera sharpening. Yeah. I can't lose any more hair. Like, that's the thing.
- 0:49That's not good. [laughs] Your hair can definitely get grayer. [laughs] Oh, man, so- I saw a picture of myself.
- 0:53I was, I was, I was coaching soccer, and I don't wear a hat out there, and, uh, which is a weird thing, but I, like, saw the cut in the hair and I was like, "Whoa, that's the first time I ever saw that thing going away back there."
- 1:04So- Oh. [laughs]... we'll see. Who knows? Mayb- maybe I'll be, uh, maybe I'll join you as the, as the bald, uh- Join me. Yeah, yeah... bald, uh, ba- uh, on, on the podcast Yeah.
- 1:11Me, you, and Cirillo will just go for the- Done... for the real trio. Gotta stay together.
- 1:14[laughs] I posted a picture yesterday with me without a hat on, and, uh, I was like, "Oh, it's been a while since I posted one of those," but I'm going for, going for that tough guy look, you know what I mean? Wow.
- 1:23Like, I got a contrast. The tough guy. Dude, it was, it was strong. With the green overlay, it was strong. I, I'm jealous. It wasn't an overlay. That was actually a full natural picture. That was the light in there?
- 1:32Yo, that's cool. Yeah. That's dope. Yeah. Little Easter egg hiding in there. Yeah, that's what you get when you get kids that take artistic pictures. Like, I didn't pose for that. I was just going up the escalator.
- 1:40It's amazing. Some head by daughter's like, "Got one of you, Dad." [laughs] What a dream. What a dream. But, but so much has been going on in the last two weeks. So much. We have had so many guests on this show.
- 1:48We have a big drop coming next week on the 15th. Um, so I don't, I don't even know what to start, but I will tell you to pay attention because next week on Tuesday we are dropping the thing- Yes...
- 1:57we've been teasing for the last couple of weeks, which is our version of, like, how do we innovate, so do something we haven't done before? How do we do it in a way that brings people together and unifies the industry?
- 2:08And how do we do it in a way that pretty much anybody can be a part of it if you wanna be a part of it? So, um, we drop that on the 15th.
- 2:14We really sincerely hope that you will, you know, if you're able to be a part of what we're doing next.
- 2:20And, um, you know, if every, obviously everybody can't do everything, but, uh, you know, we hope you do everything you can. And it's, it's, that's all I'm gonna say. To be a part of the thing. I'm gonna stop talking.
- 2:29To be a part of the thing. I'm gonna stop talking. Let's go. Yeah. Yeah. 'Cause you're about to slip up. [laughs] I know, I know, I know. But let's, let's talk about- Speaking of slipping up- Oh, hit that segue.
- 2:36Is Nathan ready? Is Nathan ready? It's- Is Nathan ready? It's- Segway time... Segway time. [upbeat music] [laughs] I didn't know it was coming. I was not prepared for that.
- 2:45[laughs] I know, I know, but he was frantically looking backstage. "Where's my button?"
- 2:49Okay, Ford, uh, CEO Jim Farley's pushing back hard [laughs] on Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy's claims that Ford is becoming too reliant on Chinese automotive companies. Wow. Yes.
- 3:00Unusual public dispute centering on Ford's CATL battery tech, overseas partnerships, and what Farley says are basic mischaracterizations of the company's strategy. Like, that's, it's pretty direct.
- 3:12Duffy accused Ford of actively intertwining its future with Chinese state-backed enterprises.
- 3:18He said American companies should out-innovate competitors rather than rely on them, which is easy to say when you don't have to out-innovate anybody. When you don't have to out-innovate, yeah.
- 3:27Far- Far- Farley said that Ford's Marshall, Michigan battery plant is owned and operated by Ford despite licensing some technology from CATL. Uh, the White House recently touted the project.
- 3:39Uh, we covered it when the White House was like, "This is great." Now, uh- Yeah... you know, Commerce, Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick praised Ford's domestic investments.
- 3:47Uh, so Ford also working with Geely overseas, uh, its Spanish plant building Geely vehicles for Europe. So there's a lot of things going on there.
- 3:54Duffy said Farley previously proposed a framework for US joint ventures with Chinese automakers, and Farley flatly denied it. Said, quote, "N-O," period. [laughs] Wild.
- 4:05He adding s- said Ford does not propose any framework described in the letter. So, I mean- Yeah... there's been a little spat...
- 4:12the, the really interesting, the, the part of this is wild is it's just right out in the open. The letter was right out in the open. It was a pretty scathing letter, although it was only, like a v- a very short thing.
- 4:23Um, but obviously as Jim Farley in a publicly traded company, he's gotta push back on that. There's a lot of tension when it comes to the Chinese.
- 4:30I had Michael Dunne on last week, and, you know, he's, he's putting out a lot of, like, warning signs, especially Stellantis in Europe.
- 4:37Um, you know, we look at the, the story about Ford partnering with Geely in its, in its Spanish plant.
- 4:42Look, when you're an international brand, you have to balance the, the, the fact that, like, yes, you're an American automaker, but you're dealing with in, uh, with everything internationally.
- 4:51An international playing field. I cannot imagine what that looks like, especially for a brand that's trying to stay relevant and getting squeezed out of so many countries.
- 4:58Um, so look, I, I, the, the battle, uh, the battle of the brains right now and the, and the PR teams has got to be, gotta be a wild one. Um- It's intense...
- 5:09but it seem, it, it seems like there's a little m- miscommunication on, on all fronts, which is typically the, the path. Yeah. You know? I mean, look, we hope they can come together.
- 5:15We c- hope there's more, you know, more communication is better in a situation like that. The fact that the letter was public meant that Farley's response had to be public as well.
- 5:23I'm very hopeful that they actually get in a room together, get on a call together, and don't just communicate via press releases- Come on, please... because that never helps anybody. Never.
- 5:31But I think they both have, I think they both have great intentions, and I think they need to communicate, so and hopefully we see some evidence of that.
- 5:38Because without a doubt, the US is relying on Ford to carry quite a load when it comes to innovation- For sure... in the auto market. We're relying on them for quite a bit. Speaking of relying on people for things. Stop.
- 5:48Yes. Segway time. [upbeat music] Can't get him twice Dealer sentiment slipped in the third quarter, even as US vehicles showed a bit of momentum.
- 5:57Cox Automotive said a- affordability pressure, lower margin vehicle demand, and broader economic uncertainty may be helping explain why dealers feel worse than the sales numbers suggest.
- 6:07Franchise dealers rated the current market at a 49, down from, from 53 last quarter, uh, and a year ago, their three-month outlook fell from 51 to, fr- uh, fell to 51 from 57 in Q2.
- 6:21Uh, the economy remained the dealers' biggest challenge at 54%, followed by interest rates at 39%. Consumer confidence was cited at 31%.
- 6:31Uh, the new vehicle sales environment scored a neutral 50, down from 53 last year, so really just a balance.
- 6:37Uh, or last quarter, but 58 a year ago, when obviously we saw shoppers rushing to buy EVs ahead of, uh, expiring tax credits.
- 6:46One Toyota dealer said, "I'm stuck with expensive new vehicles, whereas the cheaper, lower-trim models move much faster." Cox's Mark Strand noted the disconnect between sentiment and sales.
- 6:56They always feel a little bit worse post-spring bounce- Mm-hmm. 100%... but the market was actually picking up a little bit of momentum in Q3, which is good news.
- 7:04Just, like, get, get your rose-colored g- gos- glasses out, fam.
- 7:07I think, I think, you know, just if you, you follow the, the historical sentiment tracks over the last several quarters, you realize that dealers are just very resilient in general, and dealers are entrepreneurs, and entrepreneurs tend to be the optimistic type.
- 7:20So, um, we don't see any major swings here. It does, it... I wonder if you have dealer sentiment, uh, like, seasonally adjusted, if that's a number.
- 7:27It's not a real- [laughs] But seasonally adjusted dealers- Seasonally adjusted dealer sentiment. [laughs] No, you ask me questions after a good sales month, and I'm feeling pretty good about things, right?
- 7:33You have a bad- Yeah... month, a bunch of heat cases, sentiment's gonna go down. Same factors are at play.
- 7:39When we talked, uh, we would cover Jeff Dyke talking about EchoPark and Sonic's strategy on used cars, saying, "Hey, when used cars' average meets that middle part of what a, the, the 50% mark of what a used car costs, if you can hit that balance, the market's gonna rip."
- 7:53I think so much time and attention going into the used car market, used car acquisition, things like bolstering service through mobile service and other things.
- 8:02You know, the sentiment is just, you know, it's, it's, this just a reporting point, right? Absolutely. And I think that, that it's important to not put too much stock into what everyone's feeling.
- 8:12Again, everyone is only 900 dealers across the country, by the way. Yeah. The sentiment report is only about 900 dealers.
- 8:17And not just that, but, like, like I said, I actually mean, like, put your rose co- rose-colored glasses on. Like David Long says, "Make the market that you wanna make." There's so many dealers- That's right...
- 8:25that are wildly successful at breaking sales records, so why can't you? Don't look at it as doom and gloom. Uh, figure it out, and, and you're gonna be fine.
- 8:33You don't have to, uh, sit by the wayside and let the market demand, uh, you know, the market change the demand at your, i- in your local region. You know, one more thing 'cause our time's almost up here.
- 8:44Before you go, on Monday, we're gonna do a little recap of your time at the NCM Friends and Family event. Yes. But, but right now, you've been in the room with a bunch of dealers.
- 8:50What does the sentiment feel like across the dealers you've been in a room with over the last several days? Honestly, the sentiment is confused.
- 8:56There's so many conflicting ideas, especially in the, in the context of human versus AI, and a lot of dealers are going, "Okay, which way do I swing?
- 9:04What, what's the decisions that I need to make to make my store both efficient but also my people better?"
- 9:09Uh, and I'm still an advocate for train your people on the soft skills and let the, let the easy ones, uh, be handed to AI, but there's a lot of confusion in the room, and so I think dealers are trying to figure out what's the direction in which they're gonna take, um, and, and what's the path that they're gonna give their employees to be the most successful people, uh, in their career paths.
- 9:27I love that. Nathan, roll the outro music 'cause I know you're ready for it. Listen, whatever you've been doing this week, we hope you do what Kyle just said. Rose-colored glasses.
- 9:35Let's make the future we wanna make together. Keep the communication lines open, and pay attention. We got a next Tuesday. See you then.
- 9:47[upbeat music]