Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Meta Platforms: Valuation and Financial Analysis (July-2025)
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Deep Dive, your shortcut to being genuinely well
- 0:03informed. We try to add some surprising
- 0:05facts, maybe a bit of humor, keep you hooked.
- 0:08Today we're plunging into Meta Platforms Inc.
- 0:11You know, Facebook, a company that, well, it touches billions
- 0:14of lives every single day and it's been on a pretty dramatic
- 0:16financial roller coaster recently.
- 0:18So our mission today cut through the noise.
- 0:21We've got detailed financial research, expert analysis,
- 0:24really trying to uncover the most important Nuggets about
- 0:28Meta's business, its challenges and what it's actually worth.
- 0:31Yeah, and we're excited to really unpack the source
- 0:33material here. We'll be looking at Meta from
- 0:35well pretty much every angle. It's revenue engine, where the
- 0:38money comes from, the headwinds it's facing both short and long
- 0:41term, it's cost structure which is pretty unique, the leadership
- 0:44influence, huge factor there and crucially how top value
- 0:48investors actually approached Meta, especially during that big
- 0:51dip. We'll even try applying a Warren
- 0:53Buffett style intrinsic valuation, see where it stands
- 0:55today. We really encourage you as you
- 0:57listen, think critically, question the assumptions,
- 1:00consider different views with us, the complex company.
- 1:02OK, let's dig into it then. Meta Platforms, it's these
- 1:06massive platforms, Facebook, Instagram, Messenger, WhatsApp,
- 1:10they call it the family of apps. Plus they've got the Reality
- 1:12Labs division. That's all the virtual and
- 1:13augmented reality stuff. So what's the core business
- 1:17model? Where does like almost all the
- 1:19money really come from? What?
- 1:20What's immediately striking really, is the overwhelming
- 1:23dominance of advertising. It's almost unbelievable.
- 1:26In 2024, Meta reported total revenue of $164.5 billion and
- 1:32roughly 98% of that 90. 8% yeah 98.
- 1:34Percent over 100, $160 billion came directly from advertising.
- 1:38Only a tiny fraction, like one, 2%, comes from the places, you
- 1:41know, Reality Labs hardware sales, the Oculus, sorry, the
- 1:44Quest VR headsets or things like what's that?
- 1:47Business fees, Meta verified subscriptions, small stuff,
- 1:49relatively speaking. Just for context, Reality Labs
- 1:52revenue in 2024 was only about $2.15 billion.
- 1:55That's despite selling estimates, say maybe 20 million
- 1:58Quest headsets overtime. So OK, the money really pours in
- 2:01from ads. So who are metas actual
- 2:03customers then? And how do they make money off
- 2:05this huge user base if they're not charging us the users?
- 2:08Right, their primary customers are the advertisers.
- 2:11Millions of businesses, big ones, small ones, they all pay
- 2:14for AD exposure on the platforms.
- 2:15The end users, people like you scrolling through Facebook or
- 2:18Instagram. Generally we don't pay a fee,
- 2:21right? Which means user growth and
- 2:23engagement are absolutely critical.
- 2:24They're the fuel. They make the platform
- 2:26attractive to those advertisers. As of Q 4/20/24, the family of
- 2:30apps had get this 3.35 billion daily active people.
- 2:35Billion with AB billion. Billion and nearly 4 billion
- 2:39monthly active people. Facebook alone about 3A billion
- 2:42monthly active users by the end of 2023.
- 2:46Which if you stop and think about, it's.
- 2:47Like half the planet. It's roughly half the world
- 2:48population. This scale, this unprecedented
- 2:51scale, plus all the data they have on user demographics,
- 2:53behavior, that that's the bedrock, that's what lets them
- 2:55generate just enormous advertising revenue.
- 2:57They also have like over 200 million business pages, millions
- 3:00of active advertisers, and no single advertiser is more than a
- 3:03few percent of revenue. So it's diverse.
- 3:05OK, so even a giant like Meta faces challenges.
- 3:08What are some of the immediate short term headwinds they've
- 3:11been dealing with? What's kept them busy recently?
- 3:13Yeah, definitely On the short term side, one big one has been
- 3:17the cyclical nature of digital ad demand.
- 3:19We saw it late 2022, early 2023 ad revenue growth slowed down.
- 3:23Advertisers pulled back because of, you know, economic
- 3:26uncertainty. Foreign exchange swings can be a
- 3:28temporary issue too. A strong U.S. dollar hurts
- 3:31reported growth since so much revenue is overseas.
- 3:34Like in 2024, reported growth was 22%, but it was 23% if you
- 3:38adjust for currency. Seasonal add spending matters to
- 3:41AQ 4 is usually the strongest. And they definitely faced short
- 3:44term heat from Tik Tok's rapid rise.
- 3:46Oh yeah, that was huge. It hit engagement for a bit
- 3:49until Meta rolled out reels and fought back.
- 3:51And of course, broader economic stuff.
- 3:53High inflation, recession fears that makes advertisers trim
- 3:57budgets. We saw that impact in 2022
- 3:59clearly. And what about privacy changes,
- 4:01regulations? We hear so much about that with
- 4:02Meta. Have those been short term
- 4:04problems too? Absolutely.
- 4:05And pre substantial ones, Apple's app tracking
- 4:08transparency change back in 2021, that was a significant
- 4:11immediate hit. I remember that.
- 4:13Yeah, it hurt their ad targeting effectiveness.
- 4:15They spent quarters working to mitigate that.
- 4:17More recently, early 2023, the EU fined Meta over data privacy,
- 4:22demanded changes to add targeting consent and looking
- 4:25ahead, this is really current, Meta management specifically
- 4:28warned in Q12025, they said, complying with the new EU
- 4:32Digital Markets Act, which might force them to offer a
- 4:35subscription without personalized ads in Europe.
- 4:37That could materially impact European user experience in
- 4:40revenue as soon as Q 3/20/25. Wow.
- 4:43So that's not just a slap on the wrist.
- 4:44That's a potentially major business model shift in a huge
- 4:47market. Exactly.
- 4:48It's a very current, explicit short term risk.
- 4:50OK. So those are the immediate
- 4:52fires, but connecting this to the bigger picture, what about
- 4:55the deeper, more structural long term risks, the kind of things
- 4:58that could really erode their dominance over years?
- 5:00That's a crucial distinction. You're right, long term #1 is
- 5:03probably user growth saturation. I mean, with nearly half the
- 5:06world already using their platforms, where does future
- 5:09growth come from? It's limited, right?
- 5:11Facebook Score app has even seen usage flatten or decline in some
- 5:14mature markets. So Meta increasingly has to rely
- 5:17on getting more money per user or finding totally new product
- 5:20areas. Competition, changing consumer
- 5:22habits, that's another big long term risk.
- 5:25Meta dominates now, sure, but the landscape shifts fast we saw
- 5:28with TikTok. Definitely.
- 5:30If Meta doesn't keep innovating, keep engagement high, especially
- 5:33with younger users, advertisers could shift budgets permanently.
- 5:37And, you know, shifts in technology itself maybe towards
- 5:40more private messaging or decentralized social networks
- 5:43that could erode Meta's data advantage for ads.
- 5:45And regulation feels like it's always there for meta.
- 5:47Short term hits yes, but how much is a structural long term
- 5:51threat? Could it fundamentally change
- 5:52their global business? That really is the important
- 5:55question, isn't it? Regulatory and political risks
- 5:57are especially significant long term.
- 6:00They face ongoing antitrust scrutiny.
- 6:02The FTC case could theoretically lead to a breakup or limits on
- 6:06buying other companies. Governments everywhere are
- 6:09tightening rules on data protection, content moderation,
- 6:12EUSDMADSA. These could permanently restrict
- 6:16how they use data for personalized ads.
- 6:18And geopolitics matter too. Met is banned in China already.
- 6:22Similar moves by other countries could shrink their global reach
- 6:24significantly. So lots of external pressures?
- 6:27What about internal challenges? Strategic choices they've made
- 6:30that pose long term risks? Any self-inflicted wounds maybe?
- 6:33That's a critical point. Reputation and trust.
- 6:36That's a persistent long term challenge.
- 6:38Repeated controversies, Cambridge Analytic of
- 6:40misinformation battles, they lead to backlash from users,
- 6:43regulators. If they can't maintain user
- 6:44trust. You risk this slow blutive
- 6:46engagement over time, which hits the ad business.
- 6:49And lastly, maybe the biggest 1, the strategic pivot to the
- 6:53metaverse. It carries immense long term
- 6:55uncertainty. They are spending 10s of
- 6:57billions on this bet. Reality Labs lost $17.7 billion
- 7:01in 2024 alone. $17 billion lost in one division.
- 7:05Operating loss, yeah. And there's absolutely no
- 7:07guarantee it will pay off. If metaverse adoption doesn't
- 7:10take off, those huge investments could just permanently drag down
- 7:14the profitability of the core apps.
- 7:15So yeah, permanent headwinds, saturation, changing user taste
- 7:19regulation, and this big metaverse bet.
- 7:21OK, we get the massive revenue. Let's unpack the other side, the
- 7:23costs. How does Meta manage its
- 7:25finances on this scale? What's fixed?
- 7:27What's variable? Where's the really big spending
- 7:28happening, right? To understand Meta's engine, you
- 7:30need to look at costs and they have substantial fixed costs,
- 7:33especially R&D and capital investments.
- 7:35They spent over $35 billion on R&D in 2024.
- 7:39That's over 21% of their revenue.
- 7:41Wow, that's a huge chunk. A lot of that is fixed cost,
- 7:44maintaining current products, improving them, and developing
- 7:46new stuff like the ARVR hardware.
- 7:48Then there's enormous fixed cost for infrastructure, data
- 7:51centers, servers, network gear. In 2024 their cash capital
- 7:55expenditures, actual cash spent on this stuff was $39.2 billion.
- 8:00That was way up as they invest heavily in AI data centers. 39
- 8:04billion on infrastructure. Yeah, mostly fixed.
- 8:06It provides capacity for growth and critically now for training
- 8:09these huge AI models. So massive upfront investment
- 8:12just to operate and build. What about costs that change
- 8:15more directly with usage, like when more people use Instagram?
- 8:18Good question. On the variable side, a key
- 8:21piece is cost of revenue. That was about $30.3 billion in
- 8:242024, around 18% of revenue. This includes things like data
- 8:27center operations, electricity, bandwidth, content, hosting,
- 8:31traffic acquisition cost, paying others to drive traffic.
- 8:34So every new user or more usage means more server load, more
- 8:38bandwidth costs. It also includes payments to
- 8:41content creators for reels which scales up user support content
- 8:45moderation. Those are also variable.
- 8:47They grow as activity grows. Sales and marketing can be semi
- 8:50variable, may be rising with new launches but it's a smaller part
- 8:53of the variable cost picture. That makes sense.
- 8:55And labor, they have 10s of thousands of employees, right?
- 8:57That must be significant. Absolutely significant.
- 8:59As of Q12025 they had around 76,800 employees.
- 9:04Compensation benefits, especially stock based
- 9:07compensation. It's a major expense line.
- 9:10Average pay per employee is high, often over $250,000 a year
- 9:14if you include stock. Quarter million per employee on
- 9:16average, yeah. Now, while that's largely fixed
- 9:18short term, Meta did. Those big layoffs in 2022-2023
- 9:22got about 21,000 people that showed they were willing to cut
- 9:25structural labor costs if needed.
- 9:26That was a big signal to investors about efficiency.
- 9:28Right, the year of efficiency. So putting it all together, what
- 9:31are the single biggest expenses for Meta right now?
- 9:33The ones really driving the numbers?
- 9:35The most significant costs are definitely R&D.
- 9:38And those infrastructure investments, particularly for
- 9:41AI, mean Reality Labs alone losing $17.7 billion
- 9:45operationally in 2024. That's not just R&D, it's a huge
- 9:49subsidy funded entirely by the profits from Facebook,
- 9:52Instagram, WhatsApp. That's a huge bet.
- 9:54It is and content infrastructure is the other massive driver.
- 9:57Especially with the push into AI.
- 9:59It needs immense computing power.
- 10:01Just look at Q12025. They raised their full year 2025
- 10:04capital spending guidance, again citing additional data center
- 10:07investments to support AI up to 60, four, $72 billion now. 64 to
- 10:12$72 billion in one year on CapEx.
- 10:15For 2025, yeah, that's the plan. It's a massive strategic bet on
- 10:19AI leadership. OK.
- 10:20So huge bets being placed. How has this whole cost
- 10:22structure affected their profitability, their margins
- 10:25overtime? Has it been stable or have there
- 10:27been big swings? If we connect this to the bigger
- 10:28picture, yeah, costs have generally trended up, but
- 10:30margins have definitely been cyclical.
- 10:32In the boom years, say 2016 to 2018, revenue grew much faster
- 10:35than costs. They had amazing operating
- 10:37margins, like 4550%. But then look at 2022.
- 10:41Revenue stalled basically flat, but cost kept rising.
- 10:44Expenses were still up 23% year over year.
- 10:47That crushed margins. Operating margin dropped to
- 10:50around 30%, Net margin down to 20%.
- 10:53But then by 2024, net profit margin bounced back strongly, up
- 10:57to about 38%. Management's year of efficiency
- 11:00pivot in 2023 show they can trim costs like the layoffs when
- 11:04revenue slows. So the long run strategy still
- 11:06involves heavy fixed investment in tech, keeping costs high.
- 11:10But they've shown they can be more disciplined now.
- 11:12The key take away? They seem to have this new found
- 11:14ability to toggle between investing hard and controlling
- 11:17costs when needed. OK, let's shift to the people
- 11:19running the show. Who's leading Meta and how do
- 11:22they manage this giant global entity well?
- 11:24It's famously led by the founder Mark Zuckerberg, CEO, Chairman
- 11:27of the board since what, 2004. And critically, he holds
- 11:30majority voting control through that dual class share structure
- 11:33that's central to understanding Meta.
- 11:35Right, the voting control. Other key execs Susan Lai is CFO
- 11:39Javier Alvan CEO Andrew Bos Bosworth the CTO heading up
- 11:44Reality Labs. Chris Cox is vital to chief
- 11:46product officer for the Core apps, but Zuckerberg's presence
- 11:49is huge. He's known to be very hands on
- 11:51setting the vision. Like the whole metaverse pivot.
- 11:54That's pure Zuckerberg vision. That brings up that crucial
- 11:57point again. Zuckerberg has so much control.
- 11:59How does that actually play out in terms of governance,
- 12:01accountability to outside shareholders?
- 12:03Is it just his way or the highway?
- 12:04That's really the core tension, isn't it?
- 12:06Because of his voting control, he can essentially hire and fire
- 12:10board members, green light massive projects unilaterally.
- 12:13Now, management has an undeniable track record, right?
- 12:16Growing Facebook to billions, figuring out mobile
- 12:18monetization. They've achieved huge goals.
- 12:21But there have been stumbles, criticisms about transparency,
- 12:23the Cambridge Analytica scandal in 2018.
- 12:26Arguably, management wasn't fully upfront about the risks
- 12:29initially. Zuckerberg ended up testifying
- 12:31before Congress. Yes, he's visionary, but that
- 12:33control means public shareholders are basically along
- 12:35for his ride. And do they generally follow
- 12:38through on what they tell investors?
- 12:39Is their guidance reliable? In many cases, yeah, they have
- 12:42shown strong follow through. Zuckerberg promised efficiency
- 12:45in early 2023. The Year of efficiency I.
- 12:48Guess exactly. And operating margins jumped
- 12:50significantly that year, clear follow through.
- 12:53He committed to heavy spending on AI and reality lapse.
- 12:57The CapEx and R&D numbers absolutely confirm that.
- 13:00However, there have been allegations of downplaying
- 13:03negatives. Remember the Facebook papers
- 13:05leak suggesting executives maybe knew more about Instagrams
- 13:09impact on teens than they publicly stated?
- 13:11And while Meta discloses a lot of data, they did stop giving
- 13:14specific forward user guidance back in 2022, so analysts saw
- 13:18that as less transparency. What about financial alignment?
- 13:21Do they have skin in the game in a way that really aligns their
- 13:24interests with regular shareholders?
- 13:25Zuckerberg certainly does. He owned about 13% of the equity
- 13:28but controls roughly 61% of the voting power. 61% of the votes
- 13:32with 13% of the stock. Yep, that's the dual class
- 13:34structure. His stake is worth over $250
- 13:37billion. So yeah, his incentives are
- 13:39strongly aligned with the long term stock price.
- 13:42Other execs also get heavy stock compensation, tying their wealth
- 13:45to the share price. And we've seen management show
- 13:47confidence through big share buybacks, right, $44.5 billion
- 13:52from 2021, another $50 billion authorized in 2024.
- 13:55That suggests they think the stock is cheap sometimes.
- 13:59But the primary concern always comes back to this.
- 14:02Zuckerberg's absolute voting control means shareholders have
- 14:05very limited power to check his decisions.
- 14:07If his strategy, like the metaverse focus, differs from
- 14:09what outside investors want, he can and will pursue it anyway.
- 14:13Shareholder proposals like wanting an independent board
- 14:15chair or one share one vote. They get huge support from
- 14:17independent shareholders. 84% for one share, one vote in 2024
- 14:21from non insiders. 84% support. From the independent votes,
- 14:23yeah, but they always fail because Zuckerberg votes his
- 14:26majority stake against them. So leadership is visionary,
- 14:30financially aligned in terms of wealth, but investors rely
- 14:33totally on his judgement which so far has created tremendous
- 14:36value stocks compounded around 20% of years since IPO.
- 14:40But you are absolutely along for the ride with his long term
- 14:43bets. So Zuckerberg holds the keys.
- 14:45Who else owns big chunks of Meta?
- 14:47And even if their direct power is limited, do they have any
- 14:50influence at all? Right beyond Zuckerberg with his
- 14:5261% voting power via those Class B shares. 10 votes each,
- 14:56remember. Right, Class A gets one vote.
- 14:58Exactly. The biggest holders of the Class
- 15:00A common stock are the big index fund managers.
- 15:02Vanguard had about 8.8% of Class A as of Q12025.
- 15:07BlackRock had about 7.7%. Fidelity State Street, the usual
- 15:11suspects. Also interesting value funds
- 15:13like Dodge and Cox build up a big stake in 2022-2023, buying
- 15:17heavily during that price slump. So these huge institutions own
- 15:20billions in Meta stock, but you're saying their actual say
- 15:23is almost 0 because of Zuckerberg's votes?
- 15:25Is that really the whole story? No subtle influence.
- 15:27It's largely that stark in terms of direct power, yes, very
- 15:30limited due to Zuckerberg's control, but they do vote their
- 15:34Class A shares on shareholder proposals, board elections, and
- 15:38that distinction between the overall vote and the independent
- 15:41vote result is really telling. Like that 2024 proposal to ditch
- 15:44the dual class structure. Failed overall, obviously, but
- 15:48got 84% support from independent shareholders.
- 15:50So basically everyone except Zuckerberg wanted it.
- 15:53Pretty much all the major outside holders, yeah.
- 15:55Same with proposals for an independent chair.
- 15:56More disclosures, lots of outside support.
- 15:59But they fail. So while their votes might feel
- 16:02symbolic against Zuckerberg's block, they do send a strong
- 16:06message to other investors, maybe subtly to management, to
- 16:10BlackRock Vanguard. They tend to vote for governance
- 16:12reforms based on their guidelines.
- 16:13It keeps the pressure on even if it doesn't force immediate
- 16:16change. So they're sending messages,
- 16:18even if symbolic. What topics do they focus on in
- 16:20these proposals besides governance?
- 16:22What does that tell us about their main concerns?
- 16:24Well, apart from the structure itself, recent hot topics often
- 16:28mirror broader societal concerns or risks to the business.
- 16:31Content moderation is a big one. Political advertising policies.
- 16:35For instance, at the 2023 meeting there was a proposal
- 16:37asking for an audit on anti-Semitism on the platform.
- 16:40It got about 46.8% of the independent vote.
- 16:42Nearly half the outside shareholder supported that.
- 16:45Yeah, indicating a large chunk wanted more accountability
- 16:47there, but the board controlled by Zuckerberg recommended voting
- 16:51against it and it failed. So, summing it up, voting power,
- 16:56overwhelmingly Zuckerberg's largest outside holders, mostly
- 16:59use their votes to push for reducing his control, without
- 17:02success so far. But they stay invested because,
- 17:05well, the financial performance has been compelling.
- 17:07Let's pivot to how Meta gives value back.
- 17:09We hear tons about their huge share buyback program.
- 17:12How big is it really and what's its signal?
- 17:14Oh, it's massive. Meta has become one of the
- 17:16absolute biggest repurchasers of its own stock.
- 17:18Early 2024, the board added another $50 billion
- 17:21authorization on top of what was already there. 50 billion more,
- 17:25yeah. Just in Q12025, they bought back
- 17:28$13.4 billion worth. In 2023, it was about $19.8
- 17:33billion net. It steadily shrinks the share
- 17:35count. That $50 billion authorization
- 17:38was a really strong signal of confidence from management and
- 17:40the board basically saying we think our stock is cheap.
- 17:43How does this compare historically?
- 17:44Have they always done this or is it more recent?
- 17:47It really ramped up significantly starting around
- 17:482017. 20/18/2021 was huge, $44.5 billion bought back another $28
- 17:54billion in 2022. Now, some might criticize the
- 17:56timing of those 2021-2022 buys, looking back at the prices then.
- 18:00Sure, hindsight is 2020. Exactly, but they kept buying
- 18:03even when the stock cratered to multi year lows.
- 18:05From 2017 through 2024, Meta returned over $116 billion
- 18:09through repurchases. 116 million.
- 18:11It's enormous, especially considering the only just
- 18:13started paying a small dividend 7 to $0.50 quarterly in early
- 18:172024. The net effect shares
- 18:20outstanding down roughly 12% between 2014 and 2023.
- 18:23That directly boosts earnings per share.
- 18:25And what's really fascinating is that commitment to keep buying
- 18:27even during the really trivial times.
- 18:29It shows deep long term confidence from the board for
- 18:33investors. Those buybacks in late 2022,
- 18:36early 2023, at really low prices, hugely accretive shares
- 18:40bought back around 100, a $150.00 in Q42022 are now worth
- 18:45well multiples of that with a stock around $720 now.
- 18:48Huge return on those buybacks. Absolutely.
- 18:50And with probably over $40 billion still authorized and
- 18:53generating over $50 billion in free cash flow a year, they have
- 18:56the firepower to keep going. It signals they don't see better
- 18:59uses for all that excess cash right now than just giving it
- 19:01back to shareholders. I remember that late 2022 period
- 19:03vividly. Meta stock just fell off a
- 19:05Cliff. Felt like panic.
- 19:06But for value investors, panic often spells opportunity, right?
- 19:09Who are the smart money folks who jumped in when everyone else
- 19:11was running away? That's great point and it raises
- 19:12that key question, how do the sophisticated players react?
- 19:16Well, late 2022 stock hits maybe $90.00.
- 19:20Several well known value firms significantly up their stakes.
- 19:23Dodge and Cox, famous for deep value, bought millions of
- 19:25shares, probably averaged in around 100 and 5200 dollars,
- 19:28then bought more below $150.00 bold.
- 19:31Move then. Very and they're still holding
- 19:33sitting on like 4X or 5X games. Met is still a big position for
- 19:37them. Over 5% of their main fund,
- 19:39First Eagle Investment Management, Artisan Partners.
- 19:42They also bought heavily during that downturn.
- 19:44Average costs likely low $100 to maybe 100 and 40s.
- 19:47Their strategy is basically buy a fantastic business when it's
- 19:50on sale due to temporary fear. What about the really famous
- 19:53names? Buffett types?
- 19:54Did Berkshire buy Mehta? Berkshire itself?
- 19:56No. Buffett's generally avoid pure
- 19:58tech. Social media sticks to what he
- 20:00feels he deeply understands. But Ted Weschler, one of his key
- 20:02investment managers, did mention Mehta was incredibly cheap at
- 20:05its lows in early 2023. And Charlie Munger, Buffett's
- 20:08late partner, actually praised Mehta publicly around $200 in
- 20:12early 2022. Called it cheap even then.
- 20:14Interesting. So maybe not Buffett, but the
- 20:16circle around him saw value. Exactly.
- 20:18Lots of Buffett followers definitely bought in David
- 20:21Tempers. Appaloosa took a position late
- 20:222022 around $100, trimmed later as it rallied past $300.
- 20:27Dan Loeb's Third Point also got in around 100 and $130.00, then
- 20:31exited mid 2023 after a big quick game.
- 20:34Seth Klarman's Bowpost Group bought in 2022, likely low $100
- 20:38trimmed after it more than doubled.
- 20:40And interestingly, Michael Bury, the big short guy, he actually
- 20:43bought Meta in Q12022 around 200 two $120.00, but then he sold
- 20:47later in 2022 at a loss, missed the whole rebound.
- 20:50A rare missed time trade for him.
- 20:52Wow, even Bury doesn't get them all right.
- 20:54So where do these value investors stand now after this
- 20:56incredible rally? Still holding?
- 20:57Or do they cash out? Well, many who bought in that
- 20:59$91150 range have ridden it up multiple times over the shorter
- 21:03term players like Third Point Palooza, they largely took
- 21:05profits as the stock hit 253 hundred $400.00 locked in the
- 21:09gains. But the longer term value folks
- 21:11like Dodge and Cox, First Eagle, they're still holding very
- 21:15significant stakes, often three, 5% of their entire portfolios.
- 21:19They're continued holding even with Meta way up above $700.00
- 21:23now. It suggests they still don't see
- 21:25it as wildly overvalued relative to their estimate of its
- 21:28intrinsic worth. So they think they're still
- 21:29upside. Even now, it implies they see
- 21:31further potential return. Yeah, maybe they think intrinsic
- 21:33value is closer to $900 a $1000. Even these value investors, if
- 21:37you add them all up, probably own a meaningful chunk of the
- 21:39shares available to trade, maybe 1015%.
- 21:42That's often seen as a bullish long term sign.
- 21:44OK. So putting it all together, what
- 21:46does this mean for Meta's valuation today?
- 21:48If you try to use a Warren Buffett lens, estimate its
- 21:50intrinsic value. Does the current price offer any
- 21:53margin of safety for someone buying now?
- 21:55Right, the ultimate question how Buffett won't look at it.
- 21:58He focuses on owner earnings, basically free cash flow, SCF,
- 22:02the actual cash profit left after everything you project
- 22:04that FCF out discounted back to today using a required rate of
- 22:07return, maybe 10% for a stable quality company.
- 22:11And crucially, he wants a margin of safety buy at a significant
- 22:14discount, maybe 3050% to your calculated intrinsic value.
- 22:18OK, so let's try it. What's the starting point?
- 22:20Let's use metas 2024 FCF, roughly $50 billion.
- 22:24That's our baseline owner earnings.
- 22:25Now let's run a conservative scenario.
- 22:27Let's say SCF only grows 3% a year for 10 years, then just 2%
- 22:31forever after that, reflecting saturation regulation.
- 22:33Very low growth. Very low.
- 22:35If you discount that back at 10%, you get an intrinsic value
- 22:37of around $295 per share. 295, but the stocks at 700 and. $20
- 22:41Exactly. Under this very conservative
- 22:42view, the stock looks massively overvalued.
- 22:45It tells you the market is pricing in much better growth
- 22:47than 3%. OK, that's stark.
- 22:48What about a more moderate, maybe more realistic scenario?
- 22:51Let's. Try a moderate scenario.
- 22:53Assume 10% annual FCF growth for the next decade.
- 22:57That's more in line with what analysts expect for earnings
- 22:59growth given efficiency gains, monetization, then maybe a 2.5%
- 23:03terminal growth rate after that, still discounting at 10%.
- 23:07That calculation gives you an implied intrinsic value of about
- 23:09$630 per share. $630, OK, that's much closer to the $720 market
- 23:15price, but still below it. Right.
- 23:16So even in this more optimistic but still reasonably prudent
- 23:19scenario, the current price is slightly above that calculated
- 23:23intrinsic value. So where's the margin of safety
- 23:25Buffett talks about? Is there any for a new buyer
- 23:27today? That's the crucial point, isn't
- 23:29it? Where is the margin of safety
- 23:31with an intrinsic value around $630 in our moderate case, a 30%
- 23:35margin of safety means you want to buy below $440.
- 23:38A 50% margin of safety. You need a price below $350.00.
- 23:41Way below the current price. Way below the stocks low in late
- 23:452022, around $9000. That offered a huge margin of
- 23:49safety over 80%. But today's $720 price, it's far
- 23:53above those levels. It suggests no margin of safety,
- 23:56maybe even a slight premium to a reasonable intrinsic value
- 23:59estimate. Another way to look at it, if
- 24:01you assume the current price, $720 is the intrinsic value,
- 24:04what return does that imply? Solving for the discount rate,
- 24:07you get about 9.5% expected annual return, assuming our
- 24:10moderate gross plays out 9 1/2%, which is bad, but maybe not what
- 24:13a classic value investor often looking for 15% or more or that
- 24:16big safety margin wants. So bottom line, wonderful
- 24:19business undeniably, but it's $720, probably not a bargain by
- 24:23strict value standards anymore. The easy money for the multiple
- 24:26RE rating that's likely been made.
- 24:28Future returns depend much more on actual cash flow growth now.
- 24:31OK, let's bring this right up to the present moment Meta's latest
- 24:33quarterly results Q 1/20/25 reported April 30th.
- 24:36What were the key takeaways? How are things looking right
- 24:38now? Yeah, the.
- 24:39Q1 results were strong, definitely beat market
- 24:41expectations, continue that growth momentum we saw picking
- 24:44up revenue hit $42.31 billion, that's up 60% year over year or
- 24:4919% if you just for currency effects solid.
- 24:51Growth. What drove it?
- 24:53Driven by a healthy 5% increase in AD impressions, more Ads
- 24:56shown, and a 10% increase in the average price per AD.
- 24:59That suggests ad demand is improving and their targeting is
- 25:02getting better. Probably thanks to those AI
- 25:04driven recommendations. They're pushing hard.
- 25:06Net income was $16.64 billion, up a hefty 35% year over year.
- 25:11Diluted EPS was $6.43, peak consensus estimates by a good
- 25:16amount. 35% profit growth. Wow.
- 25:18Yeah. And their net profit margin
- 25:19expanded nicely to 39.3% shows revenue growth and those cost
- 25:23controls working together, total cost and expenses only up 9%
- 25:27year over year, much slower than revenue growth.
- 25:28That's operating leverage kicking in.
- 25:30Reality Labs losses continued around $4 billion for the
- 25:33quarter, but the core family of Apps profits easily swamp that.
- 25:36What about users still growing and what did they say about the
- 25:39next quarter? User engagement looked robust.
- 25:41Family daily active people hit 3.43 billion, up 6% year over
- 25:46year. Still growing the user base,
- 25:47especially in Asia Pacific. OK, for guidance, the CFO
- 25:50projected Q22025 revenue between 42.5 and $45.5 billion.
- 25:56Midpoint implies around 15% year over year growth that was ahead
- 26:00of what analytic less we're expecting.
- 26:01So continued strong growth expected.
- 26:03Yes, but they also again raised that 2025 capital expenditure
- 26:08guidance to 60, four, $72 billion for more AI
- 26:12infrastructure. That raises some eyebrows about
- 26:14spending levels, but it's also a strong signal they see huge
- 26:16returns from investing in AI right now.
- 26:19Also in Q1, they paid out their first ever dividend.
- 26:21That was 50 per share. I bought back another $13.4
- 26:24billion in stock, showcasing that massive cash generation.
- 26:27Any warnings or clouds on the horizon mentioned?
- 26:29Yes, definitely that EU regulation warning again, the
- 26:31Digital Markets Act management explicitly said it could lead to
- 26:34a materially worse user experience and have significant
- 26:36impact to European revenue as early as Q32025 if they have to
- 26:40make big changes like that no add subscription model.
- 26:42So that risk is looming large. It seems to be Zuckerberg also
- 26:46highlighted Meta AI, their assistant hitting almost 1
- 26:49billion monthly actives already huge AI adoption.
- 26:52So overall Q1 showed Meta firing on all cylinders near term,
- 26:56solid add growth, controlled costs, strong cash flow, but
- 27:00with that significant regulatory clouds specifically over Europe.
- 27:03OK, let's try to bring it all together now.
- 27:04We've looked at revenue, costs, risks, leadership, valuation.
- 27:08What is all this financial data? Tell us about Meadows overall
- 27:10health? Where is it really heading?
- 27:12What's the big picture story? The big picture story is one of
- 27:15a remarkably robust financial profile.
- 27:17It's got high profitability, strong historical growth and
- 27:20really a fortress balance sheet. Look at 2024 return on equity.
- 27:23How much profit from shareholder investment?
- 27:25Nearly 38% return on invested capital.
- 27:28How well they use all capital? Around 30.
- 27:29Percent. Those sound really high.
- 27:31They're extraordinary for a company this size.
- 27:33It screams wide mode business. Significant pricing power.
- 27:36Strong network effects in digital ads.
- 27:39Meta consistently turns a big chunk of revenue into actual
- 27:43profit. Net margins lately around 3040%.
- 27:46That 2022 dip in margins was definitely concerning at the
- 27:49time, but the fast rebound suggests it was more of a
- 27:51temporary blip, not a fundamental crack.
- 27:54And growth, how fast are they growing now compared to the
- 27:56past? Is it still hyper growth?
- 27:58Or more mature. That's the key shift, isn't it?
- 28:00The era of like 4050% annual growth?
- 28:02That's almost certainly over just too big now.
- 28:05Low double digits, maybe high single digits.
- 28:06That seems more realistic going forward given saturation
- 28:09competition. That 2022 revenue decline was
- 28:12the outlier. They pivoted quickly, wheels
- 28:15monetization cost cuts to get back to healthy growth and
- 28:18starting that small dividend. Now it underlines the maturity.
- 28:21They're generating more cash than they can realistically
- 28:24reinvest internally at super high rates, so they're giving
- 28:26some back. Makes sense?
- 28:28From a valuation angle, that PE ratio around 24 now tells you
- 28:32how much the market values each dollar of earnings.
- 28:35It's definitely not the screaming bargain it was in 2022
- 28:38when the PE was maybe 14. Right.
- 28:39We covered that. But 24 is arguably reasonable
- 28:42for a company growing earnings in the mid teens.
- 28:44The big jump for the market just re rating the stock higher,
- 28:47that's largely done. Future returns really depend on
- 28:49them delivering that actual earnings growth plus the buyback
- 28:52boost. If they grow EPS around 15% a
- 28:54year, keep buying back stock, maybe you see high teens.
- 28:57Total returns still quite attractive for a giant company.
- 29:00And financially, how stable are they?
- 29:01Could they handle another big economic downturn?
- 29:04Oh, absolutely. Rock solid on the balance sheet,
- 29:06around $70 billion in cash, only about $30 billion in debt.
- 29:09So they've net cash of roughly $40 billion. 40 billion net
- 29:13cash, yeah. Debt ratios are tiny, Castle
- 29:15easily covers interest, zero financial risk from leverage.
- 29:19They can easily fund those huge CapEx plans internally.
- 29:22Even the 60, four, $72 billion guided for 2025 AI spending.
- 29:26Current ratio around 2.7. Plenty of liquidity for short
- 29:29term needs. And that 2022 to 2024 swing
- 29:32really showed management can toggle right between invest hard
- 29:35for growth and harvest efficiency.
- 29:38The 2023 year of efficiency proved the cost base is
- 29:41flexible, reassured investors they won't just spend endlessly
- 29:44without results. So the financial picture, it's a
- 29:46cash generating behemoth, wide margins, prudent Capital
- 29:49Management. Now growth is inexplosive, but
- 29:51it's healthy and they're rewarding shareholders.
- 29:53Financially met as high quality, economically strong.
- 29:56The main caution for new investors?
- 29:57A lot of the strength is now reflected in the stock price, so
- 30:00temper your expectations for future returns.
- 30:01Think earnings growth, not another massive multiple leap.
- 30:04OK, as we wrap up this deep dive on Meta Platforms, it's clear
- 30:07it's incredibly complex, hugely influential, undeniably
- 30:10powerful. From ad dominance to these huge
- 30:12bets on the metaverse and AI, navigating intense regulation,
- 30:16managing enormous costs, it's a fascinating modern tech story.
- 30:19What's the one final thought or insight that really stands out
- 30:22to you from digging into all this?
- 30:24My final thought for you to chew on is this.
- 30:26The numbers show this incredibly resilient cash machine and
- 30:29navigated major headwinds came back strong.
- 30:31Now it's pouring vast sums into AI, which seems to be working,
- 30:35boosting the core ad business and also into that long term
- 30:39much more uncertain metaverse vision.
- 30:41So the fundamental question looking ahead is will these
- 30:44massive investments, especially in AI and the metaverse, truly
- 30:47unlock new, sustained, maybe even exponential growth?
- 30:51Growth at the market isn't fully pricing in today.
- 30:54Could today's price look like a bargain again in hindsight?
- 30:56Or conversely, will the heavy spending, particularly Reality
- 31:00Labs bleeding billions, become a permanent anchor dragging down
- 31:04the amazing profitability of the core apps if those new ventures
- 31:07just don't reach scale or profitability in the next few
- 31:09years? It's this really profound
- 31:10tensions, balance between future potential and current reality,
- 31:13and honestly it remains to be seen how it plays out.
- 31:16A great point to end on. Thank you for joining us on this
- 31:18deep dive. We hope you feel much more
- 31:19informed about the intricate world of Meta Platforms and what
- 31:22really makes it tick.